Make Fremen allied revival grants cancelable

Bind the original Fremen/ally/turn grant before Karama allowance or prevention.
A prevented grant leaves intrinsic free rates and prior payments intact. Permit
late grants under the explicit provisional Recruits current-rate policy, with
shared controls, minimal bot support and native public chronology evidence.
Complete rules and browser/deployed acceptance remain open.

docs/CURRENT_STATUS.md

@@ -16,6 +16,25 @@ open mode gates.
 
 
 ## Current checkpoint and work
+**Fremen allied free revival — 24 October. Prototyped / Partial.**
+The original owner/ally/turn grant now resolves Karama before commitment.
+Prevention provisionally denies only that grant for the current Revival;
+intrinsic rates, Recruits and completed returns/payments stay intact. A later
+Recruits grant now uses the same current-rate calculation and actual free-use
+ledger as the opposite order, with no refund or retroactive reclassification.
+Persistent controls and minimal bots share the projected permission.
+[Source, selected timing and proof](FREMEN_REVIVAL_GRANT.md).
+
+Disjoint helper/source/controls lanes and bounded review pass **14 files305/305**,
+types/lint/build, twelve actual control/gameplay/GameTable SSR journeys into
+Shipment, and sixteen existing-profile paths (80 accepted proposals).
+Genuine75–77 Basic/92–94 Advanced action sources earn Tanks in an actual battle
+and form the alliance at a real Nexus. Feedback repairs guidance expectations,
+two exhaustive kind registries and a fixture response label. No full-mode,
+strategy, comprehensive/browser/deployed certificate or saved-room/D1/reset/
+restart/deployment operation. The next mapped native candidate is Advanced
+Bene Gesserit advisor preparation timing before the first shipment.
+
 **CHOAM Charity funding — 24 October. Prototyped / Partial.**
 CHOAM's own eligible poverty claim now uses the Spice Bank; E2 names other
 factions as its payees. After legal intervening spending, the selected preview

docs/FREMEN_REVIVAL_GRANT.md

@@ -0,0 +1,110 @@
+# Fremen allied free revival
+
+## Source and selected timing — 24 October 2026
+
+The base publisher rulebook physical p16 gives the Fremen ally three free
+revivals; ordinary force limits and special-force rules remain independent.
+The November2020 publisher FAQ p7 permits a Karama to stop an alliance ability
+for one use. The native permission therefore needs a response before its
+benefit is committed, rather than an uncancelable direct addition to the
+permission list. The exact digital declaration point and prevention duration
+below are implementation policy, not a Fremen-specific worked FAQ.
+[Official base rules](https://www.gf9games.com/dunegame/wp-content/uploads/Dune-Rulebook.pdf),
+[official FAQ](https://www.gf9games.com/dune/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Dune-FAQ-Nov-2020.pdf).
+
+The existing optional Fremen grant action now binds the current native owner,
+mutual ally and turn during Revival. It opens the existing Karama response.
+All-pass commits the original grant once; prevention leaves it uncommitted and
+blocks that Fremen-to-current-ally opportunity for this Revival turn. It never
+sets general free-revival prevention. The recipient keeps its intrinsic free
+rate, Recruits, prior payments and completed returns. A later native Revival
+opening resets this denial through the existing phase rules. The user’s
+14 October choose-recommended authority selects this scope; no new question
+or claim of publisher confirmation is implied.
+
+Publisher E3 physical pp11/16 says Recruits doubles current free rates, with
+the ordinary total raised to seven. Under the same explicit current-rate
+prototype policy, a grant accepted after Recruits uses the same current
+calculation as a grant accepted before it. Recruits doubles the current granted rate, including applicable bonuses,
+before caps; without other bonuses, three becomes six. It replaces the native ordinary rate,
+not an additional six-force gift. Actual prior free usage consumes this rate;
+all prior returns consume the total cap. The already selected late-paid policy
+retains prices/classifications and supplies no refund or retroactive relabeling.
+No direct combined late-grant ruling was found in the bounded primary search.
+[Official E3](https://www.gf9games.com/dune/wp-content/uploads/EcazMoritani-Rulebook-LOWRES.pdf),
+[existing Recruits interpretation](RECRUITS_RULES.md).
+
+Original source passages were freshly checked through the publisher's indexed
+rulebooks and FAQ. No new edition, community rule or unrelated faction/module
+permission is adopted. This composition is provisional; complete rules/modes
+and final acceptance remain unfinished.
+
+## Connected implementation
+
+`game/fremen-revival-grant.ts` validates the original relationship and source,
+blocks repeated/prevented grants and checks known prior free usage before an
+active Recruits rate change. Native `game/revival.ts` remains the only owner of
+force quotes, intrinsic/granted rates, paid prices, total and elite caps,
+Homeworld additions and separate free prevention. A grant never moves counters.
+
+The engine opens `fremenRevivalGrant`, validates that same source on allow and
+before cancellation-card cost, then commits or marks the optional
+`revivalRules.fremenGrantBlocked` recipient list. New responses retain their
+source in the existing cancellation-context/purpose protocols. Completed grants
+have no new response or implicit undo. Unknown old grants are not converted into
+new pending windows. A pending native return or priority transaction must finish
+before a new grant can be declared; no accepted invoice is silently repriced.
+
+The public owner-only projection contains recipient identity, granted status
+and a generic blocked reason, without private wallets/Tanks or numeric usage.
+`components/fremen-revival-grant.tsx` provides the real persistent table action,
+status and provisional guidance. The normal response panel names the offered
+grant. Existing minimal bots consume that same legal projection and ordinary
+response/return controls, with no strategy or strength changes.
+
+## Verification and remaining work
+
+Frozen proof passes **14 affected offline files305/305**, types/lint and build.
+Twelve actual grant/Recruits/return callback and full GameTable SSR journeys
+reach native Shipment. Sixteen existing-profile native and Recruits paths
+accept80 legal grant/response/return proposals through their own views, with
+no strategy refinement or difficulty calibration. Focused engine cases also
+reach the next actual Revival and verify the denied grant becomes available.
+
+The genuine three-seat public Fremen/Atreides/Emperor source selects only
+original scalar order, three unopened Treachery positions, two ordinary Spice
+positions and a later unopened worm. Native Fremen setup puts ten at Tabr;
+Atreides pays six to invade with six real reserves. Both seal native unarmed
+plans; Fremen dials six and wins, producing six actual Tank counters for each.
+The next turn's real worm/Nexus permits an actual proposal and accepted alliance.
+Native controls reach second Revival:75–77 Basic or92–94 Advanced source actions.
+Optional Recruits is selected before setup and originally dealt; optional prior
+Atreides returns are actually two free and one paid for two spice. No played
+phase, wallet, army, alliance, grant/denial or payment receipt is installed.
+
+The twelve journeys cover ordinary allow/cancel, both Recruits/grant orders,
+prevention retaining intrinsic doubled returns and the actual prior-paid branch.
+Original force/card quantities and prior payment/usage remain intact. Existing
+related cases retain La La La, native/World limits, other revival and source/
+purpose behavior. First feedback passes304/305, exposing an old text assertion
+after review corrected bonus/cancellation wording. Targeted guidance feedback
+then passes. The next union passes305/305; types identify two exhaustive kind
+registries and one test's invented response label. The final frozen batch passes
+all steps after those corrections. Bounded review finds no concrete blocker;
+this is not comprehensive rules or privacy/persistence review.
+
+Private evidence:
+`/home/quintine/.local/share/dune/checkpoints/20261024-fremen-revival-grant/`,
+including `frozen-integrated-3/report.json`, `runtime-smoke.json`, HTML and feedback.
+Verified base `d63efccb55723c8ff33d9ec0d9daf037d0bd66ca`, source tree
+`62f9b1817cbe890828d2c1aa9c1563fd492e5d05fd923dc3881aefcf468e5034`
+(2699 nonignored files, identical before/after checks). Only checkpoint
+prose, reference strings and evidence paths follow proof; delivery records that
+reviewed overlay and pushed revision. The supplied PDF stays untracked.
+
+Framework aliases/CSS stubs mean callback/gameplay/SSR evidence, not visual
+browser or deployed acceptance. Full modes, all combinations, broader native
+Karama/optional nesting and comprehensive rules/recovery/privacy/custody
+assurance remain unfinished. Exact timing/prevention scope and late-grant
+rate composition remain provisional. No server, saved-room/D1/reset/restart
+or deployment operation occurs here.

docs/IMPLEMENTATION_STATUS.md

@@ -1,5 +1,31 @@
 # Dune implementation status
 
+## 24 October 2026 — Fremen allied revival response and late Recruits
+
+Replace direct permission commitment with an original owner/ally/turn-bound
+Karama response. Before-cost and allow/deny checks share the focused quote.
+All-pass grants once; prevention marks only the current Revival grant and
+retains intrinsic free rates, Recruits and history. The existing phase opening
+clears that denial. A successful later Recruits grant uses current rates and
+actual free usage without refunding prior paid returns. Timing/duration and
+late-rate symmetry remain explicit provisional choices. Persistent controls,
+response names, source/purpose registries and minimal bots are connected.
+
+Frozen14-file305/305, types/lint/build, twelve actual control/gameplay/GameTable
+SSR journeys into Shipment and sixteen existing-profile paths/80 accepted
+proposals pass. Genuine public classic setup, paid six-counter invasion, native
+battle losses and a second-turn worm/Nexus alliance supply75–77 Basic or92–94
+Advanced source actions. Recruits is originally dealt; optional prior return is
+actually two free/one paid. No played phase, army, wallet or alliance is assigned.
+Feedback corrects a stale guidance assertion, two exhaustive response tables
+and a synthetic response label. Bounded review corrects bonus-order wording;
+existing arithmetic already doubles applicable bonuses before caps.
+
+[Source, exact evidence and limits](FREMEN_REVIVAL_GRANT.md)
+retain complete rules/modes, wider combinations and comprehensive/browser/
+deployed acceptance. No strategy/calibration or saved-room/D1/reset/restart/
+deployment operation. Private proof:20261024-fremen-revival-grant/frozen-integrated-3.
+
 ## 24 October 2026 — CHOAM Charity self-claims and shortfall funding
 
 Make the ordinary poverty claim effective for CHOAM itself using the bank,

docs/RECRUITS_RULES.md

@@ -17,6 +17,13 @@ provisional, not a new FAQ or resolution of all later-rate questions. See the
 [native contract](RECRUITS_RUNTIME.md#classic-homeworld-composition--16-october-2026).
 
 
+**Native grant follow-up — 24 October 2026:** the earlier direct-commit and
+later-grant absence claims below are superseded by the source-bound
+[Fremen grant protocol](FREMEN_REVIVAL_GRANT.md). The existing optional action
+now offers Karama before commitment; current-Recruits rate symmetry and denial
+of that grant for this Revival are explicit prototype choices. This does not
+settle unrelated timing/combination questions or certify full modes.
+
 ## Primary evidence
 
 | Source                                                                                                                                   | Relevant verified rule                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           |

docs/RECRUITS_RUNTIME.md

@@ -6,6 +6,19 @@ Advanced faction setup. All three physical cards are present exactly once.
 Recruits, bounded Reinforcements and Harass & Withdraw have connected controls,
 AI and saved continuation; full interactions and publication remain gated.
 
+## Native Fremen grant after play — 24 October 2026
+
+The earlier later-grant guard is replaced by the symmetric current-rate
+prototype: an original Fremen allied grant may be declared after Recruits.
+Its native Karama window settles before permission is committed. Prevention
+blocks only that grant for this Revival; it does not erase intrinsic free
+allowance, Recruits or earlier returns/payments. A successful late grant uses
+the same current3→6 calculation as a grant preceding play, with actual prior
+free usage deducted, no refund, and ordinary/native total and typed limits.
+The exact response scope and later-rate composition remain provisional under
+14 October, not a new publisher combined ruling.
+[Source, controls and bounded evidence](FREMEN_REVIVAL_GRANT.md).
+
 ## Original Skills/phase composition — 17 October 2026
 
 Supported classic, selected E1/E2 and standalone/paired E3 all14/card profiles
@@ -30,7 +43,7 @@ user ruling or a newly retrieved publisher answer.
 Thus Atreides' actual two-free/one-paid return retains its two-spice payment
 and three total returns; after Recruits it may take two additional free
 forces under the seven total cap. Missing or inconsistent free-use ledgers,
-pending declarations, later rate changes and same-turn replay remain guarded.
+pending declarations, unrelated later rate changes and same-turn replay remain guarded.
 The owned before-play panel and public active panel name this interpretation.
 
 Basic/Advanced before/after native smokes use a genuinely dealt card, an
@@ -113,7 +126,7 @@ source review. No newly retrieved late-paid ruling is claimed.
 
 The scope permits activation before returns or after consistently recorded
 free/paid normal returns, once priority windows and transactions finish.
-Unknown legacy usage, later Fremen grants, same-turn replay after recovery
+Unknown legacy usage, unrelated late-rate changes, same-turn replay after recovery
 and other optional modules remain guarded, apart from clean classic Homeworlds
 above or the separate clean classic/Ix/CHOAM
 [Tech/Advanced Stronghold composition](ECAZ_TREACHERY_RULES.md#original-phase-module-composition--16-october-2026).

docs/RULE_DECISIONS.md

@@ -1,5 +1,17 @@
 # Rule decision index
 
+## Fremen allied revival response and later Recruits grant — 24 October 2026
+
+Compose the base Fremen allied free rate with the general FAQ's cancelable
+alliance use. Before committing the original owner/mutual-ally/turn grant,
+resolve the native Karama window. Under the 14 October recommended policy,
+prevention denies only this grant for current Revival, retaining intrinsic
+free rates, Recruits and completed history. An allowed later Recruits grant
+uses the same current rate and recorded free usage as the opposite order;
+prior paid returns keep their prices without refund. Exact response duration
+and late-rate symmetry are provisional, not a direct publisher worked ruling.
+[Source, implementation and limits](FREMEN_REVIVAL_GRANT.md#source-and-selected-timing--24-october-2026).
+
 ## CHOAM self-claim and provisional shortfall funding — 24 October 2026
 
 E2 p7 names other factions as CHOAM's payees; the ordinary poverty rule leaves