Resolve concealed No-Field losses in Discovery blows

This commit is contained in:
Quintine committed 2026-10-27 13:00:03 +11:00
1 parent 933a9c1379
commit 11e50e7f49
14 files changed
+587 -10

No files matched your search

+37
View File
@@ -20,6 +20,43 @@ open mode gates.
Keep identified Basic-function gaps ahead of Advanced and wider interactions.
Prototype labels and final acceptance gates remain.
**Discovery blow / No-Field — 27 October. Prototyped / Partial.**
An original Discovery blow now reveals an affected concealed marker through a
distinct `discoveryBlow` cause, materializes only available reserves and sends
the whole actual target group to Tanks.0 creates no counter. Original old-spice
removal, fresh six subject to storm and separate face-down token placement
continue. Dedicated preflight imports no Fremen/ally worm immunity. Separate
territory IDs remain outside the parent target. Forced reveal and nested-target
composition are explicitly provisional; no specific combined publisher ruling
is claimed. Existing Ready/Accept controls and minimal policies continue normally.
[Source and contract](DISCOVERY_PROTOTYPE.md#concealed-no-field-at-a-discovery-blow--27-october-2026).
Frozen **9-file union, 70/70**, types/lint/build and eight original-game
programmes pass. Public Basic/Advanced R/A/E+CHOAM-deck starts actually opt in
to Discoveries before readiness/start. Marker0/3/5 costs2 at WindPassNorth17
before the real turn2 Discovery; each mode's mixed case first ships physical1
on turn1, then marker5 on turn2 before the turn3 blow. Actual Emperor Polar1
survives. Native token placement remains at separate PlasticBasin13.
Runtime records24 GameTable SSR and8 actual Ready callbacks, with source/further
action arrays488/44. Other Ready/Accept and source controls use native packets.
There is no browser hydration/navigation or clicked-control claim for them.
No played hand, purse, army, phase, marker, event, spice, token placement or
casualty is installed. Controlled helper cases separately cover scarce/empty
reserves, elite validity, numeric capacity, Fremen and separate nested markers;
no depleted-supply or nested-source native journey is claimed.
The first union exposed an older genuine Homeworld Discovery driver's wrong
Charity actor; it now follows the actual ordered turn. Type feedback repaired
two test assertions without changing gameplay. Failed v1/v2 proof is preserved;
v3 reruns the frozen related source and runtime after repair.
Proof: `/home/quintine/.local/share/dune/checkpoints/20261027-discovery-no-field-blow-proof-v3/`;
journeys/HTML: adjacent `20261027-discovery-no-field-blow-runtime/run-v2/`.
Only a recorded three-document evidence overlay follows verification. Existing
server HTTP200, no restart or saved-game/database operation. Broader combinations,
complete modes and final rules/recovery/privacy/custody/browser/deployed
acceptance remain open.
**Concealed No-Field Guild transport — 27 October. Prototyped / Partial.**
Native reciprocal Guild allies can cross-ship their owned concealed Richese
marker alone or with same-origin counters. Original permission/rate responses,
+48
View File
@@ -5,6 +5,54 @@ partial rules coverage. It connects physical components, real actions, private
controls, AI choices and saved continuation. Normal public Discovery and
Advanced start gates, and the publication gate, remain closed.
## Concealed No-Field at a Discovery blow — 27 October 2026
Publisher E3 physical/printed12 and supplied Advanced physical23/printed21
destroy existing spice and forces in the Discovery card's printed territory.
The Fremen exception is part of Great Maker, not this effect. E2 FAQ10 and
supplied physical36/printed34 B count the concealed No-Field as one for all
effects, including0. The latter's mandatory revelation list does not explicitly
include Discovery. A targeted publisher/designer search found no combined ruling.
Under the standing recommended interpretation, reveal through the distinct
`discoveryBlow` cause, materialize no more than actual reserves, then destroy
all actual counters in the target.0 creates no invented casualty. This forced
reveal is provisional. Dedicated preflight validates every affected player;
Fremen, its ally and ordinary worm protection are not exempt. Original spice
removal, fresh six subject to storm, physical token type/supply and separate
placement destination continue once. Nested locations keep their separate
territory IDs (E3p13); this is the selected territorial composition, not a new
published immunity. No mode or module gate changes.
Existing Ready/Accept controls and minimal policies advance the normal phase.
The chronicle names the provisional destructive reveal and actual counters;
no extra confirmation or new player action is required. The pure model keeps
token history and reserve caps; the engine owns actual loss and placement.
[No-Field contract](RICHESE_NO_FIELD_RULES.md#discovery-spice-blow-destruction--27-october-2026).
### Scoped native evidence
Frozen9-file union70/70, types/lint/build and eight original programmes pass.
Public Basic/Advanced R/A/E+CHOAM starts opt Discoveries in before Ready/start.
Actual paid marker0/3/5 shipments precede the original later WindPassNorth17
Discovery. Mixed cases earn physical1 on turn1, then marker5 on turn2 before
the turn3 blow; all six actual counters die once. Original Emperor Polar1
survives. Original fresh6 and native face-down placement at separate
PlasticBasin13 follow; Spice Blow closes into Charity without another reveal.
Runtime records24 GameTable SSR and8 actual Ready callbacks; source/further
arrays488/44. Other controls use native packets directly. No played hand,
purse, force, phase, marker/event, spice, placement or casualty is installed.
Scarce reserves/typed capacity and nested markers are controlled supplements,
not native depleted/nested journeys. An old genuine Homeworld Discovery driver
now obeys current Charity order; two test assertions were repaired after type
feedback. Failed v1/v2 remains preserved; v3 uses one frozen source and then a
three-document evidence overlay. Existing server HTTP200 without restart or
saved-game/database operation. Browser hydration/navigation, deployed and final
full-mode/combined/recovery/privacy/custody acceptance remain open.
Proof: `/home/quintine/.local/share/dune/checkpoints/20261027-discovery-no-field-blow-proof-v3/`;
runtime: adjacent `20261027-discovery-no-field-blow-runtime/run-v2/`.
## Recommended physical dial and cumulative storm choices — 14 October 2026
Under the user's choose-recommended-option priority, the prototype now selects
+39
View File
@@ -1,5 +1,44 @@
# Dune implementation status
## 27 October 2026 — Discovery blow with concealed No-Field
**Discovery blow / No-Field — 27 October. Prototyped / Partial.**
An original Discovery blow now reveals an affected concealed marker through a
distinct `discoveryBlow` cause, materializes only available reserves and sends
the whole actual target group to Tanks.0 creates no counter. Original old-spice
removal, fresh six subject to storm and separate face-down token placement
continue. Dedicated preflight imports no Fremen/ally worm immunity. Separate
territory IDs remain outside the parent target. Forced reveal and nested-target
composition are explicitly provisional; no specific combined publisher ruling
is claimed. Existing Ready/Accept controls and minimal policies continue normally.
[Source and contract](DISCOVERY_PROTOTYPE.md#concealed-no-field-at-a-discovery-blow--27-october-2026).
Frozen **9-file union, 70/70**, types/lint/build and eight original-game
programmes pass. Public Basic/Advanced R/A/E+CHOAM-deck starts actually opt in
to Discoveries before readiness/start. Marker0/3/5 costs2 at WindPassNorth17
before the real turn2 Discovery; each mode's mixed case first ships physical1
on turn1, then marker5 on turn2 before the turn3 blow. Actual Emperor Polar1
survives. Native token placement remains at separate PlasticBasin13.
Runtime records24 GameTable SSR and8 actual Ready callbacks, with source/further
action arrays488/44. Other Ready/Accept and source controls use native packets.
There is no browser hydration/navigation or clicked-control claim for them.
No played hand, purse, army, phase, marker, event, spice, token placement or
casualty is installed. Controlled helper cases separately cover scarce/empty
reserves, elite validity, numeric capacity, Fremen and separate nested markers;
no depleted-supply or nested-source native journey is claimed.
The first union exposed an older genuine Homeworld Discovery driver's wrong
Charity actor; it now follows the actual ordered turn. Type feedback repaired
two test assertions without changing gameplay. Failed v1/v2 proof is preserved;
v3 reruns the frozen related source and runtime after repair.
Proof: `/home/quintine/.local/share/dune/checkpoints/20261027-discovery-no-field-blow-proof-v3/`;
journeys/HTML: adjacent `20261027-discovery-no-field-blow-runtime/run-v2/`.
Only a recorded three-document evidence overlay follows verification. Existing
server HTTP200, no restart or saved-game/database operation. Broader combinations,
complete modes and final rules/recovery/privacy/custody/browser/deployed
acceptance remain open.
## 27 October 2026 — Concealed No-Field Guild transport
**Concealed No-Field Guild transport — 27 October. Prototyped / Partial.**
+20
View File
@@ -2,6 +2,26 @@
Audit date: 2026-09-06. This document distinguishes the printed token lifecycle from engine integration and unresolved combinations. It does not certify Richese, Homeworlds, or any other gated game mode.
## Discovery spice-blow destruction — 27 October 2026
Publisher E3 physical/printed12 and supplied Advanced physical23/printed21
destroy existing spice and all forces in the printed Discovery-blow territory.
Compose the one-force rule (E2 FAQ10/supplied physical36 B) using a distinct
`discoveryBlow` cause: reveal, materialize only actual available reserves, then
send the whole affected physical group to Tanks.0 adds no counter. The native
sequence continues to fresh spice and original face-down token placement.
Discovery is absent from the explicit forced-reveal list. Targeted GF9/designer
search found no dedicated combined answer, so destructive revelation is an
explicit provisional interpretation under standing recommended-option authority.
Do not import ordinary worm protection for Fremen or its ally. Other territories,
including separately identified revealed nested locations, are outside the
printed parent target; this is territorial composition, not an additional
publisher Discovery-immunity ruling. Original storm exclusion for the fresh
spice and supply-type placement remain. Existing phase Ready/Accept controls
continue without an extra confirmation; history names the provisional reveal.
[Discovery source and scope](DISCOVERY_PROTOTYPE.md#concealed-no-field-at-a-discovery-blow--27-october-2026).
## Concealed Guild cross-shipment and Secret Ally return — 27 October 2026
The supplied Advanced source, physical36/printed34 B, and E2 FAQ printed10
+14
View File
@@ -1,5 +1,19 @@
# Rule decision index
## Discovery blow and concealed No-Field — 27 October 2026
Publisher E3physical/printed12 and supplied Advanced physical23/printed21
destroy old spice and all forces in the printed target. E2FAQ10/supplied
physical36 B's marker-as-one rule composes provisionally through the distinct
`discoveryBlow` reveal: cap materialization to actual reserves, then destroy
the actual whole group.0 invents no casualty. No Fremen/ally worm immunity is
borrowed. Original new-spice/storm/token placement follows. Separate nested
territory IDs stay outside the parent target; this is territorial composition,
not a new published immunity. Targeted GF9/designer search found no specific
combined ruling, and Discovery is not in the printed mandatory-reveal list.
Standing recommended-option authority selects this explicit provisional path.
[Contract](DISCOVERY_PROTOTYPE.md#concealed-no-field-at-a-discovery-blow--27-october-2026).
## Concealed No-Field Guild transport — 27 October 2026
Under the standing recommended-option policy, compose supplied Advanced