Compose native Discovery skills and repair hidden trainer participation

docs/CURRENT_STATUS.md

@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
 # Current development status
 
-Updated 5 October 2026. **The full twelve-faction goal is unfinished. Basic
+Updated 6 October 2026. **The full twelve-faction goal is unfinished. Basic
 is playable and the six classic factions have a user-authorized Advanced preview.
 Expansion starts and full rules/publication acceptance remain gated.**
 
@@ -17,6 +17,37 @@ open mode gates.
 
 ## Current checkpoint and work
 
+**Native Leader Skills / Discovery — bounded Development Verified:**
+fresh supported native Basic/Advanced family predicates retain original
+decks, starting hands/offers/all14, Discovery7/8, optional Tech3+ and Advanced
+Strongholds2+. Typed entry/range/rescue/Cyborg/Face Dance, native stash/
+invoice/green marker and trained Moritani death/assassination/own revival use
+original handlers. Native Ecaz mandatory owner-labelled coalition remains.
+Other overlays/previews, pending rulings, public starts and conversion stay gated.
+
+Affected107 pass. Actual programmes observe rescue3/three Tanks/one Cyborg
+substitution, six-counter invoice5→receiver3/bank2, and five real native
+leader deaths followed by turn4 Revival/printed5 debit/optional replacement.
+Three genuine hidden-Smuggler stalls had legal human plans; the policy now
+uses authoritative projected capability, not full-state rules on player views.
+Failing-before/passing-after trainer regression covers all four policies.
+
+All31 genuine six-seat samples complete after three unchanged capture resumes:
+30,874 accepted/30,874 attempts/815 JSON across f2ec1d69 and corrected14d66863
+trees. Resumes add989/387/783 no-rejection actions; they do not reconstruct the
+prior random stream. Earlier duplicate-name runs remain incomplete/un-counted;
+new names include full roster/expansions while old profiles/seeds stay unchanged.
+
+Human 6NNTCFM2v12 moves one ordinary/one Cyborg into Shrine free, preserving
+natural Bureaucrat and HMS6. 5NLWDL68v14 keeps native Killer Medic: actual
+Stash5→6→5 through new Karama disposal without payment. MYPGMSW6 human
+Master Bewt revealv10 kills its naturally trained Guild Bureaucrat, returns
+that skill and pays10→13; winner cleanupv11 and ten original actions reach
+v12/Mentat with retired cost and one private replacement. All390px refresh,
+original starting hands/offers preserved, explicit staging and tabs released.
+[Canonical native evidence](DISCOVERY_PROTOTYPE.md#native-leader-skills-composition--6-october-2026).
+No full-faction, natural-every-effect, assurance or deployed acceptance claim.
+
 **Discovery / original Strongholds — bounded Development Verified:**
 fresh original Discovery and separate classic Skills/Discovery preserve
 Advanced Strongholds2–6, optional Tech3–6, original setup/held claims,

docs/DISCOVERY_PROTOTYPE.md

@@ -35,6 +35,84 @@ node --import tsx tools/start-prototype.ts --profile discovery --db PATH --room
 It preserves all seats and other rooms, requires the current version and refuses
 to redeal a started game. The default `ix` profile remains available.
 
+## Native Leader Skills composition — 6 October 2026
+
+Fresh explicit `leader-skills --discoveries` now preserves original native
+family decks, all14 training, Discovery7/8 and each existing native Basic/
+Advanced roster predicate. Original Tech needs3+; Strongholds requires Advanced.
+Standalone Ecaz OR Moritani retains its Duke/assassination/Harkonnen exclusions.
+No Nexus/Homeworlds/independent variants, Banker/Mentat or unrelated preview,
+public start or played-save conversion is admitted.
+
+The original native module predicates validate one Discovery envelope, not
+copies of game/configuration objects. Ordinary skill quotes, Planetologist,
+Suk/Rihani/Sandmaster, native invoices and Bureaucrat consume those predicates.
+Original native starting hands and already offered training are authoritative;
+some original E2/E3 constructors have dealt their one starting card before
+training. Human programmes preserve that original unassigned setup rather
+than redealing or demanding empty hands. No assigned/played setup is accepted.
+
+Actual typed entry, paid nested routes, green components, rescue before real
+Cyborg Tank substitution, cleanup/Tech before matching Face Dance, CHOAM5→6→5
+Stash, native invoice5→receiver3/bank2, physical marker0/3/5 caps and mandatory
+green cleanup compose existing handlers. Moritani nested assassination kills
+the actual unused trained disc, returns its exact skill once, pays printed3
+and receives one private actual Mentat replacement. Five original battles
+kill all five native Moritani discs; original next Revival pays printed5
+and opens optional replacement. No death, clock, wallet or earned receipt is
+assigned to reach it.
+
+### Native skill runtime evidence
+
+The affected native/Smuggler union passes **107 cases**. Original rule programmes
+observe three rescue survivors/three Tanks/one genuine Cyborg loss eligible
+for substitution, the six-counter5-spice invoice with receiver3/bank2, and
+five actual native disc deaths followed by turn4 Revival, printed5 debit,
+four remaining dead discs and the private replacement decision.
+
+Three genuine games stalled with a hidden Smuggler trainer after the opposing
+plan. Actual human zero-support plans were legal, but bots incorrectly ran
+full-state module predicates on partial player views. The authoritative battle
+projection now supplies `smugglerCollectionSupported`; all four policies use
+that quote while keeping the existing modified-strength/multiple-pile guards.
+A real trainer-plan regression fails before repair and passes afterward.
+The original captures resume at seeds20265473/20265497/20265501 and complete
+989/387/783 more accepted actions without rejection and26/10/21 JSON.
+
+All31 original six-seat samples now complete: nineteen Basic/Advanced native
+Skills/Discovery/Tech and twelve Advanced four-module games. Combined original
+and repaired continuations total30,874 accepted/30,874 attempts/815 JSON.
+Initial reports bind unchanged
+`f2ec1d696e1a5572abcb43a9e529b07cdf8e56dc7694f4c3c9f34cad3acd3958`;
+the three corrected resumes bind unchanged
+`14d6686355ebff299369e8c62f5b498e2194574b7a4eb69fc1ce5d9ff42668ea`.
+This spans two trees; resume does not reconstruct the earlier stream.
+Early duplicate scenario-name runs remain incomplete and are not counted:
+native names now include the full original roster/selected expansion list,
+without changing earlier profiles/defaults or new4400–4700 ordinal bands.
+
+Actual **6NNTCFM2** original CLIv10 keeps natural Ixian Bureaucrat training.
+Conserved original Shrine/counter positions and original first-Mentat claim
+reachv11 entry. Human one-ordinary/one-Cyborg entry **v12** leaves Shrine2/
+one Cyborg, one parent counter, unchanged spice/reserves and actual HMS6.
+Actual **5NLWDL68** original CLIv10 keeps starting hands and natural CHOAM
+Killer Medic. Explicit conserved native five-card capacity precedes Collection;
+human inspectv12/revealv13 draws six, then human actual new Karama discard
+**v14** restores five without price or training loss.
+Actual **MYPGMSW6** original CLIv8 keeps native training and produced Cistern
+after-loss opportunityv9. Human Master Bewt reveal **v10** spends the actual
+Traitor, kills the Guild's naturally trained Bureaucrat, returns that skill
+and pays10→13. Human winner cleanupv11 retains original Tech; ten original
+actions finish the separate conflict/Collection and actual **v12/Mentat**
+retires the cost and produces one private replacement. Native assassination
+profile admission was repaired after its independent Discovery-first branch
+rejected the real original setup. All three refresh at390px; tabs released.
+
+Conserved positions, original token/card lotteries and original offers remain
+explicit. Controlled deterministic programmes are not natural card histories;
+passing samples do not prove natural use of every effect, complete factions,
+full combination assurance, privacy/recovery certification or deployment.
+
 ## Classic Nexus composition — 5 October 2026
 
 Fresh local `nexus --discoveries` composes classic/base33/all12 Nexus with the

docs/IMPLEMENTATION_STATUS.md

@@ -1,5 +1,42 @@
 # Dune implementation status
 
+## 6 October 2026 — Original native Leader Skills and Discovery
+
+One exact Discovery envelope feeds existing native family/roster predicates
+and original all14 setup/starting hands, optional Tech3+/Advanced Strongholds2+.
+No game/config copies in rule quotes; no public gate or save conversion.
+Typed entry/range/rescue before Cyborg substitution, original cleanup/Tech
+before Face Dance, CHOAM stash/invoice/Bureaucrat/green marker, and trained
+Moritani nested death/assassination/private replacement/own revival compose
+existing sources. Actual native E2/E3 printed starting hands are preserved.
+
+Affected107 pass. Actual programmes observe rescue3/three Tanks/one real
+Cyborg loss, six-counter5 fee/receiver3/bank2, and five original battle deaths
+then turn4 native printed5 revival/optional replacement. Original chronology,
+support-unit and separate-conflict fixture corrections remove copied math,
+nonce/default assumptions rather than pinning implementation artifacts.
+
+Three genuine hidden-Smuggler captures had legal human zero-support plans
+but no bot candidate. Engine projects canonical support; bots stop recomputing
+full-state module predicates on partial views. The real trainer-plan regression
+fails before/passes after and keeps modified-strength/multi-pile guards.
+Original seeds20265473/20265497/20265501 resume unchanged, adding989/387/783
+accepted/no rejected actions and26/10/21 JSON on14d66863 tree.
+All31 six-seat samples finish30,874/30,874/815 JSON including those resumes;
+initial f2ec1d69 tree evidence is separate, not one frozen-tree/every-effect
+claim. Earlier filename collisions are retained but un-counted; full original
+rosters/expansions now distinguish new samples, without changing old names/seeds.
+
+Actual 6NNTCFM2 original CLIv10, natural Bureaucrat/free typed Shrinev12;
+5NLWDL68 original CLIv10, natural Killer Medic/Stash inspect12/reveal13/
+new-card disposal14 restores5 with no payment; MYPGMSW6 original CLIv8,
+real nested after-loss target9/human Master Bewt10 returns Guild Bureaucrat,
+printed10→13, winner cleanup11 and original Mentat12 retires one actual cost/
+draws one private replacement. Original hands/offers remain authoritative,
+conserved positions explicit,390px refresh/tabs closed.
+[Canonical native contract](DISCOVERY_PROTOTYPE.md#native-leader-skills-composition--6-october-2026).
+Full modes, assurance, strategic AI and protected live deployment remain open.
+
 ## 5 October 2026 — Original Discovery Strongholds and mandatory Ecaz repair
 
 Fresh original Discovery classic/E1/E2/standalone E3 and separate classic

docs/LEADER_SKILLS_RUNTIME.md

@@ -5,6 +5,27 @@ Normal mode starts and publication remain gated. The [source contract](LEADER_SK
 contains all fourteen physical cards; the [capture interpretation](LEADER_SKILLS_CAPTURE.md)
 records the fresh publisher/designer search requested by the user.
 
+## Original native Discovery composition — 6 October 2026
+
+Fresh native `leader-skills --discoveries` composes each already-supported
+Basic/Advanced native family predicate, original decks/hands/offers/all14 and
+Discovery7/8, optional original Tech3+ and Advanced Strongholds2+.
+E1 typed entry/range/rescue/Cyborg/Face Dance, E2 stash/invoice/green marker
+and E3 trained death/assassination/own revival use original consumers.
+Actual offered training and printed starting hands are not replaced.
+The same supported live Ecaz profile keeps mandatory owner-labelled coalition
+battles; shared Duke assignments and Basic odd-force rounding remain guarded.
+Nexus/HW/variants/Banker/Mentat previews/public starts/save conversion stay
+separate. This does not certify all fourteen effects or complete native factions.
+
+[The Discovery contract](DISCOVERY_PROTOTYPE.md#native-leader-skills-composition--6-october-2026)
+records affected107, actual producer programmes and three original human
+390px paths. Thirty-one genuine six-seat samples complete after three actual
+hidden-Smuggler policy captures are repaired/resumed:30,874 accepted/no
+rejection/815 JSON across two frozen trees, not one unstaged every-effect proof.
+Original Native starting-hand order, source-local held effects and physical
+reward/skill-return ordering remain; comprehensive assurance stays deferred.
+
 **2 October normal Banker checkpoint:** the separate fresh local `banker-income`
 profile connects actual final-bank payment legs, one physical Banker phase
 grant and automatic current Mentat collection. The full deck14

docs/RULE_DECISIONS.md

@@ -238,6 +238,7 @@ dedicated retrieved worked FAQs. [Contract and remaining limits](HOMEWORLD_OCCUP
 | Paired E1/E2 Nexus / Leader Skills | Fresh both Ixians+Tleilaxu OR CHOAM+Richese plus classics, one original family deck/all14 Skills/all12 Nexus, Basic/Advanced2..6, explicit original skill entry. Actual native setup/offers/closing draws remain. Full unsupported Suboids compose typed Suk rescue before equal actual Tank substitution; Face Dance follows original winner outcomes, kills/returns the winning trainer skill once without another bounty, and partial Cunning retains ordinary Mentat rights. Richese pair uses its original signed two-token frame/one invoice/native response/Guild continuation, not single-marker skill proof; CHOAM printed fuel/Planetologist physical route remain separate. No other overlays, companion/mixed-plan/new ruling/public starts or retrofit. | [Scope, sources and bounded evidence](NEXUS_CARD_RULES.md#paired-e1e2-nexus-and-leader-skills-composition--4-october-2026), [Skill runtime](LEADER_SKILLS_RUNTIME.md#paired-e1e2-nexus-composition--4-october-2026) |
 | Classic Nexus / Discovery / original components | Fresh classic/base33/all12/Discovery7/8 Basic/Advanced2–6, original Tech3+/Advanced Strongholds2+, explicit `nexus --discoveries`. Original worm/vote/typed ride, next-turn entry, end-Mentat held custody and end-Spice closing draw after a Nexus and settled alliance remain. Extra/ordinary revival ledgers and borrowed Guild nested payment preserve native identity and physical outcomes. Skills/native/HW/variants/previews and unresolved mixed-module Fremen Betrayal remain gated; no new universal interruption priority. | [Composition contract and bounded evidence](DISCOVERY_PROTOTYPE.md#classic-nexus-composition--5-october-2026), [Nexus source contract](NEXUS_CARD_RULES.md#classic-discovery--original-tech-and-strongholds--5-october-2026) |
 | Discovery / original Advanced Strongholds | Fresh original Discovery classic/selected E1/E2/standalone E3 and separate classic all14 Skills entry retain Strongholds6 Advanced2–6, optional Tech3–6 and original end-Mentat claims. Named held benefits or actual HMS copy do not inherit into nested locations; Jacurutu creates no seventh card. Live supported Ecaz Discovery feeds mandatory original coalition lead/armies/payment/aftermath rather than skipping legal battle. Native typed/marker, trained rescue and winner Tech retain their sources. Basic Strongholds, native Discovery Skills, HW/variants/previews/pending rules/public starts/save conversion remain separate. | [Bounded contract and original programmes](DISCOVERY_PROTOTYPE.md#original-advanced-stronghold-composition--5-october-2026), [mandatory Ecaz repair](ECAZ_OCCUPY_RULES.md#original-live-discovery-coalition--5-october-2026) |
+| Native Leader Skills / Discovery | Original supported native Basic/Advanced family/roster predicates retain selected native decks/hands/all14 and Discovery7/8, optional Tech3+/Advanced Strongholds2+. Typed rescue precedes actual Cyborg substitution; original cleanup/Tech precedes Face Dance. Native stash/invoice/green marker and trained assassination/own revival keep physical sources. Actual starting hands/offers are authoritative. Hidden-Smuggler legal participation uses the engine's projected support quote, not private-state profile reconstruction. Native Ecaz owner-labelled coalition remains; no shared-Duke training, new ruling, other overlays/public starts or conversion. | [Bounded native contract and original runtime/human evidence](DISCOVERY_PROTOTYPE.md#native-leader-skills-composition--6-october-2026), [Smuggler capture repair](SMUGGLER_BATTLE.md#native-discovery-legal-participation--6-october-2026) |
 | Discoveries | Preserve seven sourced Spice Cards/eight tokens, faction peeks and Collection choices. Fresh classic/native E1/E2/standalone E3 may retain original Tech3..6; separate fresh classic all14 Skills/Discovery/Tech uses original training, entry, movement, stash, rescue/rewards and Bureaucrat invoices. Native setup, revealed-only No-Fields and Moritani source histories remain. Advanced Orgiz uses the supplied p24 territory-Collection trigger; Basic stays provisional per deposit. Only Jacurutu adds a stronghold. Contested/shared/mixed cases, other combinations and public starts remain unfinished. | [Component authority](DISCOVERY_COMPONENTS.md), [native composition](DISCOVERY_PROTOTYPE.md#native-setup-and-original-consumers--5-october-2026), [classic Skills/Advanced source cutover](DISCOVERY_PROTOTYPE.md#classic-leader-skills-and-advanced-orgiz--5-october-2026) |
 | Guild Secret Ally | One explicit Guild-priced ordinary shipment; borrowed prices/routes preserve native identity. Free Fremen reinforcement remains a separate choice. | [Route contract](NEXUS_GUILD_SECRET_ALLY_RULES.md), [verified runtime](NEXUS_GUILD_SECRET_ALLY_RUNTIME.md) |
 | Homeworld custody and mobility | Physical home/visitor groups, population thresholds, tariffs and transport permissions retain distinct sources; Homeworld immunity is not universal immunity. | [Homeworld rules](HOMEWORLD_RULES.md), [benefits](HOMEWORLD_BENEFITS_RULES.md), [mobility](HOMEWORLD_MOBILITY_RULES.md), [invasion](HOMEWORLD_INVASION_RULES.md), [Guild transport](GUILD_HOMEWORLD_TRANSPORT_RULES.md) |

docs/SMUGGLER_BATTLE.md

@@ -4,6 +4,19 @@
 the base-faction Leader Skills preview connect the lower Smuggler effect in Basic
 and Advanced games. Public module, mode and publication gates remain closed.
 
+## Native Discovery legal participation — 6 October 2026
+
+Three genuine native Skills/Discovery/Tech captures had legal hidden-trainer
+plans but no bot candidate: the policy recomputed full-state module admission
+against a player view that intentionally lacks private/internal configuration.
+The engine now projects `smugglerCollectionSupported` beside the existing
+saved battle format flag; bots use that authoritative rule result rather than
+reconstructing the module profile. Modified-strength and multiple-positive-pile
+guards still apply to each actual plan. No public mode or strategy tuning is
+added. A real trainer-plan regression fails before and passes after repair;
+all three original captures finish without rejection. Source trees/counts and
+limits are in the [native Discovery evidence](DISCOVERY_PROTOTYPE.md#native-skill-runtime-evidence).
+
 ## Rule and timing contract
 
 The [source follow-up](LEADER_SKILLS_RULES.md#20-september-smuggler-follow-up)