Compose Semuta recovery with physical Shrine card roles

docs/CURRENT_STATUS.md

@@ -29,6 +29,24 @@ optional skill bands, combinations and public expansion starts remain open.
 Rules implementation continues; comprehensive assurance and administration
 remain deferred until all rules are implemented.
 
+**Semuta connects both physical Shrine roles — 16 October.**
+Fresh private `semuta --discoveries` setup retains original Richese/CHOAM,
+optional Ix, unused Tech3+/Advanced Strongholds and original Discovery7/8.
+Truthtrance spent as Karama is recoverable before the same original effect;
+Karama spent as Truthtrance is recoverable after its single definite answer.
+Neither changes its printed face. Emperor revival does not repeat; original
+price provenance and normal-auction physical identity remain.
+
+Affected six-file57/57, eight controlled runtime paths and32 legal policy
+probes pass. Two controlled390px journeys recover both faces; actual Guild
+shipment then pays bank3 for three counters, while the reverse path retains
+one yes answer. Width/scroll390; no application/browser error after isolated
+host setup repair. No saved room, human server, D1, deployment or public gate
+changed. Skills/Homeworld/Nexus/E3 composition and final assurance remain
+separate. [Source and exact evidence](SEMUTA_SOURCE_UPDATE_20260907.md#shrine-physical-role-costs--16-october-2026).
+Final types/lint and private CLI help pass; current source links and55
+Semuta evidence paths resolve. No build or broad assurance run in this slice.
+
 **Semuta preserves native BG conversion and the separate counter cost — 16 October.**
 Physical Worthless recovery now precedes the same native conversion counter,
 not its effect. The card stays Worthless in its new faction. A later printed

docs/DISCOVERY_PROTOTYPE.md

@@ -904,6 +904,13 @@ conversion was fabricated.
   authorizes Truthtrance as Karama or Karama as Truthtrance in the existing effect
   paths. Cards retain their physical identity and custody. A committed converted
   Truthtrance retains its use receipt through departure, answering and discard.
+  Fresh private `semuta --discoveries` setup now connects both physical-role
+  discards: recover used Truthtrance without replacing its original Karama
+  effect, or recover used Karama after one committed definite Truthtrance
+  answer. Original CHOAM/optional Ix setup, unused Tech3+/Advanced Strongholds
+  remain; Skills/Homeworlds/Nexus/E3 and public starts stay outside this entry.
+  [Scoped controlled proof](SEMUTA_SOURCE_UPDATE_20260907.md#shrine-physical-role-costs--16-october-2026)
+  is not natural draw/entry or complete-module acceptance.
   This does not implement missing special powers or resolve their pending rules.
 
 Great Maker vote/ride, Discovery token/discard, next-turn entry, station and carried

docs/IMPLEMENTATION_STATUS.md

@@ -1,5 +1,28 @@
 # Dune implementation status
 
+## 16 October 2026 — Semuta connects physical Shrine-role costs
+
+Fresh private `semuta --discoveries` composes original Richese/CHOAM and
+optional Ix Discovery setup, with original unused Tech3+/Advanced Strongholds.
+Live profile validation now retains this admitted composition. Existing
+Karama continuations accept entitled physical Truthtrance; original auction
+resumption retains that physical face rather than a printed-Karama flag.
+Existing clean Truthtrance disposal accepts committed Shrine-source Karama.
+Claim/pass preserves original effects, one recorded answer and post-revival
+Emperor timing, with no manufactured card or repeated effect.
+
+Eight new cases; affected six-file57/57. Eight controlled runtime paths and32
+legal policy probes pass. Two controlled390px actual-table journeys recover
+both faces; original Guild delivery pays bank3 for three forces and the
+reverse path retains one yes answer. Native setup precedes explicitly
+controlled Shrine placement/occupation/acquisition; this is not natural
+Discovery draw/entry or full-game evidence. No human server, D1, saved room,
+deployment or public start gate changed. Existing Skills/Homeworld/Nexus/E3
+and final-assurance boundaries remain.
+[Canonical source and proof](SEMUTA_SOURCE_UPDATE_20260907.md#shrine-physical-role-costs--16-october-2026).
+Final types/lint and actual private CLI help pass. Current source links and55
+Semuta evidence paths resolve; no production build or broad assurance run.
+
 ## 16 October 2026 — Semuta retains native BG role, conversion and counter costs
 
 Added `bgKaramaCostDiscard` for the actual Worthless disposal before native

docs/RULE_DECISIONS.md

@@ -677,6 +677,7 @@ dedicated retrieved worked FAQs. [Contract and remaining limits](HOMEWORLD_OCCUP
 | Semuta on shipment-price activation | Claim/decline of the exact printed activation cost creates the same original half-normal bank-paid grant once. Physical recovery does not change its beneficiary/creator. Under the selected nonduplication extension to provisional stop refunds, a claimed cost is not refundable even if the new holder rediscarded it; Guild may use that same card for its actual stop without returning it to the former owner. Unclaimed refunds remain. This is product composition, not a publisher worked example. | [Source, policy and scoped proof](SEMUTA_SOURCE_UPDATE_20260907.md#shipment-price-cost-and-claimed-card-refund--16-october-2026) |
 | Semuta on printed native special costs | Preserve each native disposal point and original intent. Most printed costs precede their effect; native Emperor's completed revival precedes its cost disposal and is not repeated. CHOAM's selected hand cards form a separate private simultaneous batch after one earned credit; one fresh other-player card may be selected after commitment, never the earlier activation. Existing once-use, joint costs, native permission/typed custody and E3 entry gates remain unchanged. This composes the printed Semuta rule with existing native order, not a new publisher timing FAQ. | [Source/stages and original versus controlled proof](SEMUTA_SOURCE_UPDATE_20260907.md#printed-native-special-costs-and-choam-cashout--16-october-2026) |
 | Semuta on native BG conversion/counter costs | The played Worthless is fresh before the original native conversion response; recovery keeps its physical role and cannot bypass that counter. A later printed cancellation is a separate fresh cost and still denies the same conversion. Original four-use opportunity/incoming reservations and older passed history remain. Allowed converted prices retain claimed-cost provenance after real rediscard under the existing nonduplication policy. Kull remains before conversion/discard; Shrine/E3 scope stays separate. | [Native role/source and scoped proof](SEMUTA_SOURCE_UPDATE_20260907.md#native-bg-worthless-and-conversion-counter-costs--16-october-2026) |
+| Semuta on Shrine physical-role costs | Fresh private Richese/CHOAM/optional Ix Discovery setup composes the existing Shrine role and Semuta rules. An entitled Truthtrance used as Karama retains its physical face through the original price, cancellation, auction or special-cost continuation. Karama committed as Truthtrance is fresh after its single definite answer; recovery never repeats that answer. Emperor revival retains its original post-effect disposal. This is component composition, not a new publisher timing FAQ; Skills/Homeworld/Nexus/E3 and public gates remain separate. | [Source, controlled evidence and limits](SEMUTA_SOURCE_UPDATE_20260907.md#shrine-physical-role-costs--16-october-2026) |
 | Purchased price with immune Junction | Keep the original offered half/full tariff and normal payees; no quarter price or bank-only overlay. Under the standing choose-recommendation instruction, accepting this source with a purchased grant requires explicit acknowledgment that it ends unused, with no card refund. Consume only upon actual delivery, not failed, stale, unfunded or deferred acceptance; the ordinary purchased route remains available. This is a conservative product composition, not a publisher worked example. | [Source immunity and selected choice](JUNCTION_TRANSPORT_RULES.md#purchased-price-and-immune-offer--15-october-2026), [original versus controlled proof](JUNCTION_TRANSPORT_RUNTIME.md#purchased-price-source-choice--15-october-2026) |
 | Deferred shipment arrival | Quote unsupported ordinary arrivals before saving Guild interception. A validated legacy ordinary declaration may return unspent on the typed arrival error; corrupted declarations and special parent/card receipts are not silently cleared. This repairs continuation without deciding simultaneous reaction priority. | [Reproduction and bounded recovery](DEFERRED_SHIPMENT_ARRIVAL.md) |
 | Native Ambassador own-arrival continuation | Under the standing choose-recommended-option instruction, reuse committed entry after its own Guild income, BG Intrusion and accompaniment controls. Existing callbacks put a legitimate accompanying BG fighter child before the deferred original entrant; each sees the then-live token, so declining the child preserves a later original offer and consuming it does not recreate a token. Advisors remain exempt. This child-first/live-token composition is provisional, not a located publisher priority ruling. Actual busy controls, unsupported paired/module guards and separate native rate-window admission remain distinct. | [Native original-action evidence and boundary](DEFERRED_SHIPMENT_ARRIVAL.md#native-own-arrival-continuations--15-october-2026) |

docs/SEMUTA_DISCARD_CONTINUATIONS.md

@@ -2,6 +2,28 @@
 
 Read-only engine audit, 2026-09-07. Read the complete `docs/SEMUTA_DRUG_ENGINE_AUDIT.md`, then inspected every current `discard(...)` call, direct Treachery-discard mutation and `draw(g)` caller in `game/engine.ts`, plus the Truthtrance discard callback and pure Box/Distrans results. Names below are integration anchors; approximate current lines are navigation aids only. This report adopts no additional source ruling and changes no project file.
 
+## Shrine physical-role stages — 16 October 2026
+
+Fresh private `semuta --discoveries` setup retains the original Discovery
+roster/modules; unsupported Skills/Homeworld/Nexus/E3 overlays stay excluded.
+The existing Karama cost continuations accept an entitled physical
+Truthtrance without changing its face. Auction and price resumption carry
+that committed physical card; claim/pass preserves the original owner,
+recipient, lot, payment and once-use. Emperor's post-revival disposal never
+repeats its completed revival.
+
+`truthtranceDiscard` also accepts the already-validated `source: shrine`
+receipt for physical Karama after one definite answer. No fresh occupancy
+check is imposed on that committed Truthtrance role; existing history,
+promise, parent signatures and clean-continuation restrictions remain.
+Semuta recovery changes custody, not the recorded answer or printed face.
+
+[Scoped evidence](SEMUTA_SOURCE_UPDATE_20260907.md#shrine-physical-role-costs--16-october-2026):
+57 affected cases, eight controlled runtime paths,32 legal policy probes and
+two controlled390px journeys. This is not original Discovery acquisition,
+full-combination or saved/deployed assurance.
+
+
 ## Native BG cost and counter stages — 16 October 2026
 
 The actual physical Worthless creates `bgKaramaCostDiscard` before the

docs/SEMUTA_SOURCE_UPDATE_20260907.md

@@ -2,6 +2,54 @@
 
 7 September 2026. Read `docs/SEMUTA_DRUG_ENGINE_AUDIT.md` in full, inspected the physical card again, checked current capacity/recovery code, and freshly searched publisher sources. No project runtime edits.
 
+## Shrine physical-role costs — 16 October 2026
+
+The private `semuta --discoveries` entry now composes original fresh Richese/
+CHOAM and optional Ix setup with Discovery's seven Spice Cards/eight tokens,
+Basic/Advanced2–6, optional unused Tech3+ and Advanced Strongholds. Skills,
+Homeworlds, Nexus and E3 overlays, played-save conversion and public starts
+remain excluded. Live admission uses the same Discovery roster contract.
+
+Existing [Shrine roles](DISCOVERY_PROTOTYPE.md#connected-behavior) and printed
+Semuta recovery compose without changing physical card identity. A current
+revealed-Shrine fighter may spend Truthtrance through the existing Karama
+price, cancellation, normal-auction purchase/payment and special-cost paths.
+The fresh cost retains that physical Truthtrance. Claim/pass resumes the
+original effect, not a BG conversion or a new source owned by the claimant.
+Native Emperor revival remains before its cost disposal and is never repeated.
+Auction continuation receives the committed physical card rather than
+manufacturing a printed-Karama flag.
+
+Conversely, Karama committed as Truthtrance retains its `source: shrine`
+receipt. Its completed definite answer now offers that physical Karama to
+Semuta under the existing clean Truthtrance continuation restrictions.
+Recovery does not ask again, append another answer or reclassify the card.
+This connects existing component rules; it claims no new publisher timing FAQ.
+
+Eight new behavior cases and the six-file affected union pass **57/57**.
+Eight runtime claim/pass paths and32 legal policy probes cover both roles,
+both modes and all four profiles. Fixtures use genuine ready/setup/first
+Movement, then **controlled Shrine placement, occupation and conserved hand
+acquisition**; auction/Revival tests explicitly stage their later clocks.
+These are not natural Discovery draw/entry or complete-game evidence.
+
+Two actual styled390×844 table journeys recover each physical face. The price
+journey then declares three Guild forces, uses its actual Allow shipment
+control and pays bank3: spice5→2, reserves15→12, Wind Pass14 gains3; the grant
+retires while Richese holds physical Truthtrance. The reverse journey keeps
+one yes answer while Richese holds physical Karama. Width/scroll390 and no
+browser/application errors after correcting isolated host setup. Only an
+owned memory-only loopback host ran; no human server, D1, saved room,
+deployment or public gate changed. Proof is outside Git:
+`/tmp/dune-shrine-runtime.json`, `/tmp/dune-shrine-ui-proof.json`.
+Full combinations, recovery/deployed assurance and all five Semuta facets
+remain Partial.
+Final `npm run check:quick` passes. The actual private CLI help runs and
+includes the new composition; five current source links and55 Semuta test
+evidence paths resolve. No production build, broad suite or HTTP assurance
+was run for this bounded rules slice.
+
+
 ## Native BG Worthless and conversion-counter costs — 16 October 2026
 
 `bgKaramaCostDiscard` offers the actual played **Worthless** before the native