Resume native Guild cancellation after Semuta cost recovery

docs/CURRENT_STATUS.md

@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
 # Current development status
 
-Updated 15 October 2026. **The full twelve-faction goal is unfinished. Basic
+Updated 16 October 2026. **The full twelve-faction goal is unfinished. Basic
 is playable and the six classic factions have a user-authorized Advanced preview.
 Expansion starts and full rules/publication acceptance remain gated.**
 
@@ -29,6 +29,26 @@ optional skill bands, combinations and public expansion starts remain open.
 Rules implementation continues; comprehensive assurance and administration
 remain deferred until all rules are implemented.
 
+**Semuta recovers native Guild cancellation costs — 16 October.**
+Printed permission/rate costs now offer the exact public Karama while the
+original reserve, cross/return or typed Homeworld parent stays unpaid.
+Claim/pass applies the same native cancellation once: no restored route,
+retained discount, invented funding or repeated shipment. Original paid
+cache/normal auctions provide both physical cards without played-state staging.
+
+Affected thirteen-file158/158 and32 original-action runtime/policy paths pass,
+including both modes and all four profiles for both native families.
+Four actual390px cancellation/continuation journeys prove reserve full4,
+denied cross plus ordinary1, typed full2 all-seat decline, and unfunded2/full4
+then one-force full2. No overflow, browser error or application exception.
+One transient stale-node tool error was followed by fresh evidence, not replay.
+No worker/D1/real room, human server, deployment or public gate changed.
+Shipment-price activation disposal/refund binding remains separate.
+[Canonical source and scoped proof](SEMUTA_SOURCE_UPDATE_20260907.md#native-guild-permission-and-rate-costs--16-october-2026).
+Final types/lint and production build pass with existing warnings; the
+twelve new cases pass again after fixture-only type narrowing. Current
+source links and all five still-partial Semuta facets resolve.
+
 **Native Guild rate with Richese Secret Ally — 15 October.**
 The original unpaid counter now preserves one billed counter and all five
 physical forces: sand1→2, not ten. Unfunded full2 keeps forces/spice and the

docs/IMPLEMENTATION_STATUS.md

@@ -1,5 +1,57 @@
 # Dune implementation status
 
+## 16 October 2026 — Semuta retains native Guild permission/rate cancellation
+
+Added the dedicated `karamaShipmentDiscard` family using the existing
+neutral all-seat Semuta offer, original private claimant choice and native
+Karama completion. Original unpaid reserve, cross/return and typed Homeworld
+frames persist through cost recovery or decline, bound to the exact response,
+physical group, approved payment, allowance and independent price source.
+Recovering Karama does not undo permission denial or native repricing,
+finance an unfunded group, mutate typed sources or repeat shipment.
+Existing original-opportunity/no-debt policies are unchanged.
+
+Original setup selects only conserved undealt lottery/deck order. Actual
+Guild public cache purchase pays1 for Semuta; actual Emperor normal auction
+pays1 for the original physical Karama. Original native turns and optional
+outgoing bribes follow as actions; no played hands, wallets, armies, phases
+or decisions are staged.
+
+Affected thirteen-file **158/158** passes, including twelve new behavior
+cases. Thirty-two original-action runtime/policy paths pass: six rate routes,
+four permission routes, claim/decline, unaffordable release, both modes and
+all four original profiles for both native families. No tuning/calibration.
+Two additional explicitly controlled second-card acquisition probes exercise
+actual cross/typed permission cancellation and claim with an independent
+price active; both preserve its original grant. They do not certify the
+separate unfinished shipment-price activation discard producer.
+
+Four actual styled390×844 GameTable cancellation/continuation journeys begin
+at those original-action unpaid responses. Reserve-rate claim pays full4
+for two real counters and retains the recovered cost card. Cross-permission
+claim leaves original five-counter source/spice4 unchanged and still denies
+that route; a new ordinary1 then leaves Guild3. Typed world all-seat decline
+keeps Semuta held and delivers two native counters for full2 once. Poor2
+cannot finance original full4 even after cost recovery, but a new one-force
+full2 shipment remains legal. Original turn completion is observed.
+Viewport/scroll width390, no browser error or application exception.
+One transient stale-node tool error after successful cancellation was
+resolved with fresh authoritative state/accessibility without replay.
+
+Only an owned memory-only host started/stopped. No worker, D1, authenticated
+saved room, human server, deployed revision or gate was exercised or changed.
+Outside-Git source/API/table proof and four initial scenes remain under
+`/tmp/dune-semuta-guild-native-*20261016*`. Shipment-price activation disposal
+and provisional special-stop refund binding remain separate. The full goal
+and final assurance remain unfinished.
+[Source/runtime checkpoint](SEMUTA_SOURCE_UPDATE_20260907.md#native-guild-permission-and-rate-costs--16-october-2026),
+[continuation contract](SEMUTA_DISCARD_CONTINUATIONS.md#native-guild-cancellation-cost-family--16-october-2026).
+Final `npm run check:quick` and production build pass with existing
+module-register, large-chunk and Unknown-route warnings. The twelve new
+cases pass again after a fixture-only captured-reaction narrowing repair.
+Six current local links and51 evidence paths resolve; all five Semuta
+facets stay Partial, without recovery/deployed or complete-mode claims.
+
 ## 15 October 2026 — Native Guild price counter retains Richese one-counter source
 
 Removed the explicit Richese Secret Ally exclusion from native rate

docs/RULE_DECISIONS.md

@@ -672,6 +672,7 @@ dedicated retrieved worked FAQs. [Contract and remaining limits](HOMEWORLD_OCCUP
 | Guild native rate Karama | Native prices follow original source rather than blanket module flags. Independent Smuggler counters stay free; own/allied No-Field bills one marker, never materialized value. A supplier’s whole-fee1 approval cannot silently become2: release and obtain a new full-price offer/consent. Typed native World/cross/return retains original sources and approved split; deferred Betrayal retains full-price authority until delivery. Earlier bank-only allied-loan, no-debt withdrawal and return policies remain provisional. | [Current composition and proof](GUILD_RATE_KARAMA_RULES.md#permission-purchase-and-allied-marker-composition--15-october-2026) |
 | Guild rate with Richese Secret Ally | A native Guild holder retains the Nexus source's one-counter bill for up to five real forces. Native cancellation changes sand1→2, not the actual physical count or absent Richese advantage. Independently purchased prices remain separate. Under selected existing no-debt/spent-card composition, unaffordable full2 ends the declared Nexus effect without refund/reusable coupon but preserves the ordinary full-price shipment. A still-held card instead remains available with the correct full quote. This is not a publisher worked timing example. | [Source and explicit policy](NEXUS_RICHESE_RULES.md#native-guild-rate-composition--15-october-2026), [original-action runtime and controls](NEXUS_RICHESE_RUNTIME.md#native-guild-rate-followup--15-october-2026) |
 | Guild native transport permission | A distinct unpaid cross/return response precedes rate/payment. Under the standing choose-recommendation instruction, the provisional denied scope is that original shipment opportunity, preventing immediate redeclaration while preserving a legal different shipment/movement. Signed Cunning second opportunity is distinct; common World-to-foreign-World and immune Junction permissions are not canceled by analogy. Selected special-stop→permission→rate order is product composition, not a new publisher timing FAQ. | [Policy, source and genuine/controlled evidence](GUILD_RATE_KARAMA_RULES.md#permission-purchase-and-allied-marker-composition--15-october-2026) |
+| Semuta on native Guild cancellation costs | A printed permission/rate cancellation cost is a fresh public discard while its original reserve, cross/return or typed Homeworld parent remains unpaid. Claim/all-seat decline restores and applies that same cancellation once. Recovering the cost cannot restore denied transport, keep the native discount, finance an unfunded group or replay shipment. Existing denial/affordability policy is unchanged; shipment-price activation disposal and special-stop refund remain separate. | [Printed-source continuation and scoped proof](SEMUTA_SOURCE_UPDATE_20260907.md#native-guild-permission-and-rate-costs--16-october-2026) |
 | Purchased Karama typed price | Supplied authorized Advanced PDF physical16 says any player’s Force Shipment may be half normal, paid to bank. Original typed routes use that independent tariff without new route rights or Nexus stacking; the entire approved invoice is bank-only. Completion consumes only the original grant. Special-stop uses existing provisional card-return parity, refunding the exact original physical card to its owner. Immune Junction uses the separate source choice below, not this card tariff. | [Connected typed routes and source distinction](GUILD_HOMEWORLD_TRANSPORT_RULES.md#separate-permission-and-purchased-price--15-october-2026) |
 | Purchased price with immune Junction | Keep the original offered half/full tariff and normal payees; no quarter price or bank-only overlay. Under the standing choose-recommendation instruction, accepting this source with a purchased grant requires explicit acknowledgment that it ends unused, with no card refund. Consume only upon actual delivery, not failed, stale, unfunded or deferred acceptance; the ordinary purchased route remains available. This is a conservative product composition, not a publisher worked example. | [Source immunity and selected choice](JUNCTION_TRANSPORT_RULES.md#purchased-price-and-immune-offer--15-october-2026), [original versus controlled proof](JUNCTION_TRANSPORT_RUNTIME.md#purchased-price-source-choice--15-october-2026) |
 | Deferred shipment arrival | Quote unsupported ordinary arrivals before saving Guild interception. A validated legacy ordinary declaration may return unspent on the typed arrival error; corrupted declarations and special parent/card receipts are not silently cleared. This repairs continuation without deciding simultaneous reaction priority. | [Reproduction and bounded recovery](DEFERRED_SHIPMENT_ARRIVAL.md) |

docs/SEMUTA_DISCARD_CONTINUATIONS.md

@@ -2,6 +2,29 @@
 
 Read-only engine audit, 2026-09-07. Read the complete `docs/SEMUTA_DRUG_ENGINE_AUDIT.md`, then inspected every current `discard(...)` call, direct Treachery-discard mutation and `draw(g)` caller in `game/engine.ts`, plus the Truthtrance discard callback and pure Box/Distrans results. Names below are integration anchors; approximate current lines are navigation aids only. This report adopts no additional source ruling and changes no project file.
 
+## Native Guild cancellation cost family — 16 October 2026
+
+`karamaShipmentDiscard` now suspends a printed cancellation cost for original
+native permission/rate responses. Pending reserve, cross/return or typed
+Homeworld frames remain in their own custody while the response is parked.
+Existing response collectors see that saved response; an admitted Semuta
+claim or all-seat decline restores it and finishes the cancellation once.
+
+Unlike the already-paid income family, no shipment payment or physical
+departure has happened. Recovering the cost cannot create a route, keep
+half price, finance the unfunded group or repeat a delivery. Signature and
+existing native validators bind the original group, approved split, source
+books, allowance and any independent price grant. Ordinary permission and
+affordability interpretations are unchanged.
+
+The [current source/runtime checkpoint](SEMUTA_SOURCE_UPDATE_20260907.md#native-guild-permission-and-rate-costs--16-october-2026)
+records158 affected cases,32 original runtime/policy paths and four actual
+mobile cancellation/continuation journeys. These are changed-rule proofs,
+not a new broad save/privacy/custody campaign or complete-mode acceptance.
+Shipment-price activation disposal and special-stop refund composition
+remain separate work.
+
+
 Update: the exchange producers, three battle producers, Sabotage, Robbery overflow and completed Nullentropy Box searches, Ornithopter escrow retirement, definite Truthtrance answers and the five ordinary completed-card effects below now have production automatic continuation frames; see [exchange checkpoint](TREACHERY_DISCARD_CONTINUATIONS.md), [battle checkpoint](BATTLE_DISCARD_CONTINUATIONS.md), [forced Terror checkpoint](TERROR_DISCARD_CONTINUATIONS.md), [Box checkpoint](BOX_DISCARD_CONTINUATIONS.md), [Ornithopter checkpoint](ORNITHOPTER_DISCARD_CONTINUATIONS.md), [Truthtrance checkpoint](TRUTHTRANCE_DISCARD_CONTINUATIONS.md) and [ordinary-card checkpoint](ORDINARY_CARD_DISCARD_CONTINUATIONS.md). The remaining table is an implementation inventory, not a claim that Semuta is active.
 
 30 September 2026 checkpoint: the explicit Semuta development preview

docs/SEMUTA_SOURCE_UPDATE_20260907.md

@@ -2,6 +2,58 @@
 
 7 September 2026. Read `docs/SEMUTA_DRUG_ENGINE_AUDIT.md` in full, inspected the physical card again, checked current capacity/recovery code, and freshly searched publisher sources. No project runtime edits.
 
+## Native Guild permission and rate costs — 16 October 2026
+
+Printed Karama cancellation of native `guildTransportPermission` or
+`guildRate` now offers its exact public cost through the existing neutral
+Semuta mechanism. This covers original reserve shipping, cross/return and
+typed Homeworld parents. The three physical parent frames remain unpaid
+while another player claims the cost or every seat declines.
+
+The dedicated `karamaShipmentDiscard` continuation binds the original
+response, source group, allowance, approved payment, native cancellation
+state, physical pools and independent purchased-price grant. Claim/pass
+restores that response and applies the original cancellation once. Recovering
+Karama neither restores denied transport nor removes the full-price invoice,
+finances an unfunded group, changes typed sources or repeats shipment.
+The existing permission-scope and no-debt policies are unchanged.
+
+Affected thirteen-file **158/158** passes, including twelve new behavior
+cases. Thirty-two original-action runtime/policy paths pass, including
+Basic/Advanced, six rate routes, four permission routes, unaffordable
+release and all four profiles for each native family. Original setup selects
+only undealt entropy/deck order; Guild buys Semuta in a real cache auction
+and Emperor buys the physical Karama in a real normal auction. No played
+hand, wallet, army, phase or response is assigned.
+Two additional **controlled** probes conserve a second physical card into
+Atreides custody, then actually activate its price and use the original
+cross/typed permission, cancellation and claim. Both retain that exact
+independent grant without payment or restoring native permission. They do
+not verify the separate shipment-price activation discard producer.
+Proof: `/tmp/dune-semuta-native-active-price-20261016.json`.
+
+Four actual styled390×844 GameTable journeys begin at those original-action
+unpaid responses: reserve-rate claim/full4, cross-permission claim then
+ordinary1, typed world-rate all-seat decline/full2, and poor2/full4 release
+then a new one-force full2 replacement. The recovered card remains held,
+not automatically replayed. Viewport/scroll width390, no browser error or
+application exception. One transient stale-node browser-tool error was
+followed by fresh authoritative state/accessibility, never action replay.
+
+Only an owned memory-only loopback host ran; no worker, D1, authenticated
+saved room, human server, deployment or mode gate was changed. Source/API/
+table proof and four initial scenes remain outside Git under
+`/tmp/dune-semuta-guild-native-*20261016*`.
+Shipment-price activation costs and their provisional special-stop refund
+binding remain separate; this does not certify complete Semuta/module play.
+[Continuation inventory](SEMUTA_DISCARD_CONTINUATIONS.md#native-guild-cancellation-cost-family--16-october-2026).
+Final types/lint and production build pass; existing module-register,
+large-chunk and Unknown-route warnings remain. The twelve new behavior
+cases pass again after the fixture-only TypeScript narrowing repair.
+Six current local links and51 Semuta evidence paths resolve; all five
+Semuta facets remain Partial. No final recovery or deployed claim is made.
+
+
 ## User-selected full-hand exchange — 30 September 2026
 
 The user selected **Allow exchange**: treat the acquisition and