Compose native Stone and Reinforcements without a physical-token bonus

docs/CURRENT_STATUS.md

@@ -29,46 +29,38 @@ optional skill bands, combinations and public expansion starts remain open.
 Rules implementation continues; comprehensive assurance and administration
 remain deferred until all rules are implemented.
 
-**Same-plan Harass / Reinforcements — 16 October.** Both slot orders now follow
-the existing original-reserve-cost-before-return order under explicit
-choose-recommended interpretation. Future returns cannot fund deficient reserves
-or replace the original normal/elite quote. Original score-only +2, fixed Ecaz
-commitment, variable ally losses, all-outcome reserve cost and Traitor-canceled
-Harass remain separate; both physical cards discard once.
+**Independent Ecaz battle-card interaction wave — 16 October.**
+- Richese-family Harass/Stone uses visibly provisional post-withdrawal counts,
+  including own/opposing/copied Stone and Traitor-canceled returns.
+- Same-plan Harass/Reinforcements pays the original typed reserve quote before
+  any return; future returns cannot fund or change it.
+- In the existing native Advanced Occupy envelope, Reinforcements composes
+  with original or Mirror-copied Stone. Its +2 normal score adds no physical
+  undialed tokens, but the original own-reserve cost still pays.
 
-Affected eleven-file134/134, types/lint and build pass. Six new behavioral
-regressions, eight fresh Node policy programs/all four profiles with16 accepted
-continuation actions and a real390px typed-cost journey pass. Original2-normal/
-1-elite reserve payment survives the later4-normal return; owner finishes
-reserves4/Tanks16/elite Tanks5/spice29, both cards discarded and collection open.
-No root overflow or browser/application error. Current parse/policy anchor and38
-topic evidence paths resolve; all ten facets remain Partial.
-[Policy and scoped proof](REINFORCEMENTS_RUNTIME.md#combined-utility-plan--16-october-2026).
-Stone/Reinforcements, other profile/module limits and final assurance remain
-separate. No human server, saved room, D1, deployment or public gate changed.
+Original fixed Ecaz commitment, variable ally casualties, support, Traitor
+precedence and mandatory utility-card disposal stay separate. The earlier
+questions remain unanswered; explicit product interpretations are not publisher
+rulings. No state field, new profile or public start is added.
 
+Latest affected sixteen-file167/167, types/lint and build pass. Eight fresh
+Node programs/all four profiles cover both leads/original or Mirror attacks
+with36 accepted continuation actions. The corrected390px native-control journey
+starts within hand capacity: physical5-vs4 wins, Ecaz reserves15→12/Tanks6,
+Guild Tanks1, original support9→8, Ecaz2/Guild3 remain. Reinforcements discards
+once; Stone retention clears battle/decision into collection, without overflow
+or browser/application error. An overfull initial fixture was corrected by
+returning unselected cards to the conserved deck; that initial hand is not
+legal-hand evidence.
 
-**Harass / Stone Burner interaction — 16 October.** Richese-family Harass now
-uses visibly provisional post-withdrawal physical comparison under the standing
-choose-recommended priority; the earlier source question remains unanswered.
-Same-plan, opposing and Mirror-resolved Stone preserve Traitor precedence,
-original support and mandatory disposal. Active Occupy removes only its
-actual card user's fixed or variable undialed pool, preserving the original
-mandatory Ecaz commitment. Public preflight considers possible fixed withdrawal
-without reading hidden cards. No persisted game field is added.
-
-Affected thirteen-file161/161, types/lint and build pass. Eight same-plan
-policy programs/all four profiles accept24 continuation actions. Two actual
-390px native-control journeys prove Basic winner reversal and Advanced typed
-return/support/leader-death/bounty through retention and collection. No root
-overflow or application/browser error in the corrected host's journeys.
-Original Richese lot and shared-preparation fixture drivers were corrected;
-incidental collection-wallet expectations were removed. Current guide parse,
-policy anchor and33 evidence paths resolve; both topics' five facets stay
-Partial. [Policy and scoped proof](HARASS_WITHDRAW_RUNTIME.md#provisional-stone-burner-timing--16-october-2026).
-Ix/Poison Tooth, Reinforcements/Stone and own
-concealed No-Field Harass and other module gates remain. No human server,
-saved room, D1, deployment or public gate changed; final assurance stays due.
+Current parse/composition anchor and23 topic paths resolve; all ten relevant
+facets remain Partial. Exact policies and earlier bounded human/policy proof:
+[Harass/Stone](HARASS_WITHDRAW_RUNTIME.md#provisional-stone-burner-timing--16-october-2026),
+[Harass/Reinforcements](REINFORCEMENTS_RUNTIME.md#combined-utility-plan--16-october-2026),
+[Reinforcements/Stone](REINFORCEMENTS_RUNTIME.md#native-stone-composition--16-october-2026).
+Ix/Poison Tooth, own concealed No-Field Harass and other profile/module limits
+remain. No human server, saved room, D1, deployment or new assurance campaign
+changed; final assurance follows all rules.
 
 **Ixian Nexus purchased-card interaction wave — 16 October.**
 Purchased-card replacement now composes:

docs/ECAZ_OCCUPY_RULES.md

@@ -252,8 +252,11 @@ is unchanged and remains explicitly not a publisher ruling. Both slots and
 opposing holders work. Same-plan Harass/Reinforcements now follows the
 [provisional original-reserve-cost-first policy](REINFORCEMENTS_RUNTIME.md#combined-utility-plan--16-october-2026),
 preserving actual card-user ownership and original fixed losses.
-Reinforcements with Stone/optional modules and Basic/unprofiled co-side
-card battles remain guarded.
+Original or copied Stone now composes with same-plan/opposing Reinforcements
+under the [physical-token contract](REINFORCEMENTS_RUNTIME.md#native-stone-composition--16-october-2026).
+Its +2 normal score adds no undialed counters; original reserve cost and fixed
+versus variable on-board losses stay separate. Other optional modules and
+Basic/unprofiled co-side card battles remain guarded.
 
 Native/pure67 cases, relevant284-case batch and27 actual native-program
 cases pass, including all four legal policies. Two natural captured games

docs/IMPLEMENTATION_STATUS.md

@@ -1,5 +1,33 @@
 # Dune implementation status
 
+## 16 October 2026 — Native Occupy Stone and Reinforcements
+
+Removed the same-plan/opposing Stone rejection while keeping existing mode
+eligibility. Original/copy Stone compares physical undialed counters, not +2
+normal score; the reserve fee still pays its original own typed quote under the
+existing provisional all-outcome policy. Fixed Ecaz and variable ally losses,
+mode choices, Traitor precedence and physical Stone/Mirror retention stay.
+No profile/state-field/public-start widening.
+
+Sixteen-file167/167, types/lint and build pass (module-register/large-chunk/
+Unknown-route warnings). Pure/native cases cover physical victory despite +2,
+same/opposing costs, typed reserves, both leads, copied kill and Traitor override.
+Eight fresh Node programs/all four profiles accept36 continuation actions.
+
+The first native fixture held five cards after adding Reinforcements. Corrected
+by returning unselected physical hands to the conserved deck before lead choice,
+then enforcing four-card capacity. Repeated actual390px controls start at three
+cards, seal dial4/support1, choose ignore and decline all three native votes:
+physical5-vs4 wins; Ecaz reserves15→12/Tanks6/support9→8, Guild Tanks1,
+Ecaz2/Guild3 remain. Reinforcements discards once, Stone retains, battle/decision
+clear into collection. No corrected-journey overflow/browser/application error;
+the overfull initial hand is not accepted legal-hand evidence.
+
+Current parse/anchor and23 topic paths resolve; all ten facets remain Partial.
+Owned hosts/scripts removed. No human server, D1, saved room, deployment or
+broad/HTTP/recovery assurance campaign changed.
+[Composition and scoped proof](REINFORCEMENTS_RUNTIME.md#native-stone-composition--16-october-2026).
+
 ## 16 October 2026 — Same-plan Harass and Reinforcements
 
 Connected both physical slot orders without adding a new settlement mechanism

docs/REINFORCEMENTS_RUNTIME.md

@@ -11,7 +11,8 @@ nor a defense: Prescience of a category receives **None**, while the physical
 slot stays occupied and hidden until reveal. A named-card inspection still
 fixes the exact card. Harass & Withdraw may share the plan under the
 [provisional original-cost-first policy](#combined-utility-plan--16-october-2026).
-Stone Burner, Homeworld and other optional-module combinations remain gated.
+Original or copied Stone Burner composes in the existing native Advanced Occupy
+envelope; Homeworld, other profile and optional-module boundaries remain.
 
 The [combined-army follow-up](ECAZ_OCCUPY_RULES.md#independent-cards-with-combined-armies--2-october-2026)
 retains own-holder reserve cost and selected lead card/payment ownership.
@@ -45,7 +46,8 @@ provisional all-outcome policy.
 Both slot orders compose in the existing Basic/Advanced and selected Advanced
 Occupy envelopes. Only the card user's reserves and undialed forces change;
 original fixed Ecaz commitment and the other ally's pool stay separate.
-Stone/Reinforcements, Basic/unprofiled co-side and other module gates stay.
+Basic/unprofiled co-side and other module gates stay; Stone uses the
+[physical-token composition below](#native-stone-composition--16-october-2026).
 No persisted state or fresh/public profile is added.
 
 ### Scoped proof
@@ -74,3 +76,53 @@ HTTP, recovery/privacy/custody assurance campaign ran. Private proof artifacts
 remain outside Git; the owned source host and throwaway scripts were removed.
 
 
+## Native Stone composition — 16 October 2026
+
+Reinforcements now composes with same-plan or opposing Stone Burner, including
+a physical Mirror Weapon copying Stone. This uses the existing fresh native
+Advanced Occupy envelope with the independent Ecaz cards and actual Richese
+cache. No new profile, Basic Richese eligibility, public start or optional
+module is enabled.
+
+Stone still compares only physical undialed counters, including original
+fixed Ecaz and native variable ally contributions. Reinforcements adds no
+physical tokens, extra dial, support or on-board casualties; its +2 normal-score
+bonus is inactive for Stone comparison. Its original own-reserve cost still
+pays once under the existing provisional all-outcome policy. Original/copy
+kill-or-ignore modes and Traitor precedence remain unchanged. Reinforcements
+discards once; a winning physical Stone or Mirror keeps ordinary retention.
+
+The printed physical-token instruction and the existing score-only reserve
+card implementation are composed here. The reserve-payment question remains
+unanswered; no new publisher ruling or user answer is implied.
+
+### Scoped native Stone proof
+
+The affected sixteen-file offline union passes **167/167**, with types/lint
+and production build passing (module-register, large-chunk and Unknown-route
+warnings). New pure/native cases cover physical-token victory despite +2,
+same-plan/opposing cost, original elite reserves, fixed/variable card users,
+copied kill mode, Traitor precedence and physical retention.
+
+Eight fresh Node programs cover both lead roles and all four legal profiles,
+with original/Mirror attacks and36 accepted continuation actions. The native
+fixture initially exceeded hand capacity when a third selected card was added;
+it now returns unselected real hands to the conserved deck before lead choice
+and checks four-card limits. The actual390px journey was repeated on that
+corrected fixture, starting with only three held cards.
+
+Original total dial4/support1 compares five undialed coalition counters against
+four, never seven. All three native voters decline Traitor through actual
+controls. Ecaz pays reserves15→12 plus original fixed3 losses (Tanks6);
+Guild loses only variable1, leaving Ecaz2/Guild3 in the territory. Support
+costs Ecaz9→8. Reinforcements discards once; Stone is retained through its
+original choice, and battle/decision clear into collection. No root overflow,
+browser/application error or over-capacity hand occurs in the corrected journey.
+The earlier overfull fixture is not accepted evidence of a legal hand.
+
+Current reference parses; the composition anchor and23 evidence paths across
+both topics resolve, with all ten facets Partial. No human server, saved room,
+D1, deployment, public profile or new broad/HTTP/recovery/privacy/custody
+assurance campaign changed. Owned hosts/scripts are removed; private proof
+artifacts stay outside Git.
+

docs/RULE_DECISIONS.md

@@ -758,7 +758,7 @@ These are unresolved in the cited records. Do not infer an answer from elapsed t
 
 | Boundary | Still unresolved | Existing record |
 | --- | --- | --- |
-| Reinforcements cost | The earlier all-outcome versus sole-Traitor-winner question remains unanswered. The bounded prototype provisionally charges on every revealed outcome, chooses normal reserves first and counts the transfer as battle losses. Under standing choose-recommended, same-plan Harass composes by paying that original reserve quote before returns; future returns cannot fund or change it. Those are product interpretations, not publisher rulings or a numerical user answer. Stone/Reinforcements and other module gates remain. Eligibility never depends on concealed matching Traitors. | [Source review](ECAZ_TREACHERY_RULES.md#14-september-reinforcements-cost-review) · [Combined policy](REINFORCEMENTS_RUNTIME.md#combined-utility-plan--16-october-2026) |
+| Reinforcements cost | The earlier all-outcome versus sole-Traitor-winner question remains unanswered. The bounded prototype provisionally charges on every revealed outcome, chooses normal reserves first and counts the transfer as battle losses. Same-plan Harass pays the original quote before returns; future returns cannot fund or change it. Native Advanced Occupy Stone/Mirror composition keeps the fee but ignores +2 normal score in physical-token comparison. These are product interpretations, not a new publisher ruling or user answer. Other profile/module gates remain; eligibility never depends on concealed Traitors. | [Source review](ECAZ_TREACHERY_RULES.md#14-september-reinforcements-cost-review) · [Combined policy](REINFORCEMENTS_RUNTIME.md#combined-utility-plan--16-october-2026) · [Stone composition](REINFORCEMENTS_RUNTIME.md#native-stone-composition--16-october-2026) |
 | Harass / Stone Burner | The earlier question (keep gated or compare after withdrawal) remains unanswered. Under the standing 14 October choose-recommended instruction, the development prototype now provisionally compares undialed counters remaining after successful withdrawal. Opposing Traitor cancels the return; original fixed Occupy commitment stays. Public preflight considers possible fixed Ecaz withdrawal without reading hidden custody. Allocation ambiguity, Ix/Poison Tooth and other module boundaries remain. This is an implementation interpretation, not a publisher ruling or a user answer. | [Provisional timing](HARASS_WITHDRAW_RUNTIME.md#provisional-stone-burner-timing--16-october-2026) |
 | Recruits late accounting and rates | The earlier one/two-further-free question remains unanswered. The content-first prototype now preserves paid spice, deducts recorded actual free usage from the doubled rate and all returns from the total cap: two-free/one-paid Atreides can take two more free. This is visibly provisional, not a numerical user ruling. Unknown ledgers, pending repricing, late rate changes and same-turn replay remain guarded. | [Source alternatives](RECRUITS_RULES.md), [provisional runtime](RECRUITS_RUNTIME.md) |
 | Sapho remaining timing | First versus unspent Advanced Guild priority, partly completed combined turns, cyclic auction duration and later battle timing stay guarded. The existing pre-plan opportunity supports [early aggressor](SAPHO_AGGRESSOR.md). Prior questions remain unanswered. | [Source audit](JUICE_OF_SAPHO_SOURCE_UPDATE.md), [battle review](JUICE_OF_SAPHO_BATTLE_REVIEW.md) |

docs/STONE_BURNER_ENGINE_AUDIT.md

@@ -29,11 +29,21 @@ checks possible fixed Ecaz withdrawal without inspecting hidden cards.
 
 The earlier question remains unanswered. This is an interpretation selected
 under the standing choose-recommended priority, not newly retrieved publisher
-authority. Ix/Poison Tooth, Reinforcements/Stone, own concealed No-Field Harass
-and other module boundaries remain separate. The 6 September evidence above
+authority. Ix/Poison Tooth, own concealed No-Field Harass and other profile/
+module boundaries remain separate. The 6 September evidence above
 is historical; the current checkpoint has its own bounded proof.
 
 
+## Reinforcements composition — 16 October 2026
+
+Within the existing native Advanced Occupy envelope, same-plan/opposing
+Reinforcements and original/Mirror-copied Stone now share the
+[physical-token composition](REINFORCEMENTS_RUNTIME.md#native-stone-composition--16-october-2026).
+The original three-own-reserve fee pays once; +2 normal score adds no physical
+undialed tokens or support. Original fixed Ecaz commitment, variable ally losses,
+mode choices, Traitor precedence and physical Stone/Mirror retention stay.
+Other profile/module gates and the explicit reserve-cost interpretation remain.
+
 ## Primary evidence and exact effect
 
 The physical publisher face was visually read at `/tmp/dune-rules/choam-stone-reading.png`, enlarged from the [component photograph](https://cdn.anyfinder.eu/assets/QsUJtVktEC87xwK08oLlwnKyaozUWfuaLzG0LFEn67ENEEVgNrDGoITy3608Dqe7) linked by the [product gallery](https://www.tabletopfinder.eu/en/boardgame/32692/dune-choam-richese). Photograph provenance/hash are recorded in `RICHESE_ACQUISITION_RULES.md`. The visible publisher wording is the evidence; uploader printing/date remains unverified.