Resume storm traversal after surviving advisor conversion

Preserve current-sector losses and original Fremen casualty priority before the mandatory BG counter. Bind public sector facts to a private continuation and resume only the remaining storm once.
2026-10-24 21:19:18 +11:00
1 parent 9959f1b347
commit d66b594770
@@ -1,5 +1,84 @@
 # Mandatory advisor conversions

+## Storm casualties before remaining traversal — 24 October 2026
+
+**Prototyped / Partial.** Compose the supplied Advanced source's physical17
+group-flip counter with physical28 E's mandatory conversion when alone. A storm
+can destroy the last outsider in one sector while advisors survive in another
+sector of the same exposed territory. Capture the surviving group after the
+actual sector's losses, before settlement can erase its advisor stance.
+Advisors destroyed in that same sector leave no conversion opportunity.
+
+Under the 14 October recommended-policy authority, the selected priority is
+after all current-sector casualties, including original Fremen allocation
+choices, and before the next sector or final storm completion. This composition
+is provisional, not a new combined publisher timing ruling. Initial CHOAM and
+Fremen protection retain their original priority. Hold an already-alone group
+through another territory's Fremen choice; an empty pending queue alone does
+not mean the last popped casualty choice is answered.
+
+The phase0 public receipt contains exactly a fresh event, starting sector,
+distance, traversed count and current sector. Bind the exact surviving physical
+group to that occurrence. The private parent separately records whether all
+current-sector choices are ready and the unchanged original traversal/source
+cursor. Never project that cursor, a private forecast, protection state or
+Fremen pending keys into the response or Karama source selection.
+
+Karama prevents only the BG conversion. The completed losses and spent card
+stay committed, with the existing provisional continuously-alone hold. Consume
+the parent before resuming the original traversal once, without replaying the
+current sector. Remaining sectors can still destroy the surviving group,
+whether it converted or remained advisors. Ecological Storm completion,
+final position/order and the next phase's forecast keep their original place.
+
+[Native fixture](../tests/fixture-advisor-storm-flip.ts) starts a public Advanced
+BG/Atreides/Emperor table with original base33, no Fremen or optional module.
+Actual setup places BG's original counter in empty Oh Gap10; it initially
+becomes a fighter. Actual first Storm dials2/3 move from1 to6. Atreides later
+pays2 to ship one original reserve into Oh Gap9, and BG accepts the resulting
+Intrusion and original advisor-flip response to become peaceful. Original
+starting Karama remains in Atreides' hand.
+
+Actual first Mentat readiness draws the original turn-two Storm Card. Scoped
+entropy selects only the original six-card shuffle, revealing3 or4 with its
+native source signature and logged card face. No played force, phase, wallet,
+hand, Tanks, stance or forecast is installed. Stop before the final real Storm
+Ready. A three-sector traversal kills Atreides9 while BG10 survives; a
+four-sector traversal must pause at9 and then destroy BG10 after the counter.
+The same-sector variant earns the same Intrusion at9, then both forces die
+without manufacturing a conversion.
+
+[Engine cases](../tests/advisor-storm-flip-engine.test.ts) cover both responses
+for ending/continuing traversal, same-sector destruction, source mismatch and
+all four existing legal profiles. The separately labelled controlled regression
+in [storm/worm cancellation](../tests/storm-worm-cancellation.test.ts) checks
+both outcomes after a real mixed Fremen casualty choice; its conserved placement
+is not a native setup journey. Frozen **17 files220/220**, types/lint/build,
+five native Storm/response/GameTable SSR journeys and eight existing-profile
+paths pass. All five genuine sources take48 original actions. Ending traversal
+finishes9 with BG10 alive; continuing traversal resumes from9 to10 and destroys
+that counter after either conversion outcome. Atreides loses one force once;
+same-sector placement loses both without offering a conversion. The original
+Karama is spent once only when used. Standard controls render; this is not a
+new callback/browser/mobile/deployed certificate.
+
+Initial220/220 passes; typecheck then catches an empty-array assertion narrowing
+the native fixture's readiness array to never[]. An equivalent length assertion
+repairs only the fixture. Final frozen220/220, types/lint/build and runtime pass
+without changing rule mechanics or weakening checks. Private proof and native
+HTML are in
+`/home/quintine/.local/share/dune/checkpoints/20261024-advisor-storm-flips/`.
+`frozen-integrated-2/report.json` binds tree
+`3efca2d3ef25d0090bc1c992411c4bbda0cf55265019306fed5761a4745221f9`,
+2745 files on base `9959f1b347f1e0e5bc96c2468cc6cfd97d13d4f3`.
+Prose/reference checkpoint overlays are separately reviewed and hashed after
+proof. No saved-room/D1, reset, restart or deployment operation was performed.
+
+Broader Fremen/CHOAM/Jubba/Ecological Storm/Homeworld/Nexus combinations with
+this conversion, special Ambassador/Discovery relocation and matching-group
+interpretations remain open. These prototypes do not certify complete modes,
+callbacks/browser/deployed behavior or final assurance.
+
 ## Completed Face Dance replacement — 24 October 2026

 **Prototyped / Partial.** Compose the same supplied
@@ -16,6 +16,30 @@ open mode gates.


 ## Current checkpoint and work
+**Advisor conversion during storm traversal — 24 October. Prototyped / Partial.**
+Current-sector losses now capture surviving alone advisors before the original
+traversal continues. Retain them through unresolved Fremen casualty choices;
+an empty pending queue alone does not mean ready. The selected post-casualty,
+pre-next-sector priority is explicitly provisional. Original protection remains
+earlier; final storm bookkeeping remains later. Public sector evidence omits
+forecasts/protection/private continuation. Prevent only conversion and consume
+the private parent before the original traversal resumes once.
+[Source and native routes](ADVISOR_AUTOMATIC_FLIPS.md#storm-casualties-before-remaining-traversal--24-october-2026).
+
+Disjoint helper/native-fixture lanes, bounded continuation review and root
+integration pass **17 files220/220**, types/lint/build, five native Storm/response/
+GameTable SSR journeys and eight legal existing-profile paths. Genuine48-action
+public Advanced BG/Atreides/Emperor sources earn original base33, actual first
+dials2/3, paid shipment/Intrusion and native turn-two Storm Cards3/4. Both
+responses preserve Atreides' sector9 loss. Ending9 leaves BG10 alive; continuing
+through10 then destroys it after either response. Same-sector destruction leaves
+no conversion. A controlled mixed-Fremen case preserves original casualty
+priority. Type feedback repairs only an empty-array fixture assertion. Wider
+Fremen/CHOAM/Jubba/Ecological Storm/Homeworld/Nexus combinations, special
+relocation and matching-group interpretation stay open. No AI refinement,
+comprehensive/browser/deployed assurance or saved-room/D1/reset/restart/deployment
+operation.
+
 **Advisor conversion after Face Dance — 24 October. Prototyped / Partial.**
 Completed replacement now captures surviving alone advisors at remote board
 sources and zero-replacement targets. Original army return, replacement, leader
@@ -40,8 +64,8 @@ Homeworld/Nexus combinations with this counter remain open. No AI refinement,
 comprehensive/browser/deployed assurance or saved-room/D1/reset/restart/deployment
 operation.

-Next conversion work includes sector-specific storm losses and special
-Ambassador/Discovery relocation. Matching-group interpretation and complete
+Next conversion work includes special Ambassador/Discovery relocation.
+Matching-group interpretation and complete
 Advanced/mode acceptance remain unfinished.

 **Advisor conversion after Homeworld/Junction transport — 24 October. Prototyped / Partial.**
@@ -1,5 +1,49 @@
 # Dune implementation status

+## 24 October 2026 — Advisor conversion between storm sectors
+
+Supplied physical17/28 E's counter now follows actual current-sector losses
+that leave surviving advisors alone elsewhere in the same territory. Original
+CHOAM/Fremen protection remains earlier. Preserve the group through unresolved
+Fremen casualty choices, including when the last pending item has already been
+popped. Under the 14 October authority, finishing all current-sector losses
+before conversion and remaining traversal is explicit provisional composition.
+
+A public five-field event/from/distance/traversed/sector receipt selects only
+current movement facts. The private parent separately binds readiness and the
+original traversal/source cursor. Forecasts, protection and private continuation
+stay out of the response and Karama source. Prevention changes only conversion;
+retain actual losses and the existing continuously-alone hold. Consume the
+parent before the next sector/final storm bookkeeping once. Later sectors can
+still destroy either stance; a group destroyed in the same sector cannot flip.
+
+Disjoint helper/native-fixture lanes, bounded timing review and root integration
+pass **17 files220/220**, types/lint/build, five native Storm/response/GameTable
+SSR journeys and eight existing-profile paths. Each source takes48 original
+public Advanced BG/Atreides/Emperor actions with base33, genuine first dials2/3,
+paid shipment2, actual Intrusion and native turn-two Storm Cards3/4. Ending9
+kills the last Atreides while BG10 survives. Continuing resumes9→10 after both
+response outcomes, killing BG once; same-sector9 kills both without conversion.
+Original Karama is spent once only when used. A separately labelled conserved
+controlled case checks original mixed-Fremen casualty priority in both outcomes.
+No played force, phase, wallet, hand, Tanks, stance or forecast is installed in
+the native sources.
+
+Initial220/220 passes; typecheck catches an empty-array fixture assertion's
+never[] narrowing. Its equivalent length assertion repairs only that fixture;
+final frozen220/220, quick, build and runtime pass without weakening rules or
+checks. Private proof and actual-source HTML:
+`/home/quintine/.local/share/dune/checkpoints/20261024-advisor-storm-flips/`.
+`frozen-integrated-2/report.json` binds tree
+`3efca2d3ef25d0090bc1c992411c4bbda0cf55265019306fed5761a4745221f9`,
+2745 files on base `9959f1b347f1e0e5bc96c2468cc6cfd97d13d4f3`.
+Prose/reference overlays are separately reviewed/hashed. Standard controls render;
+no new callback/browser/mobile/deployed or complete-mode claim. Broader
+Fremen/CHOAM/Jubba/Ecological Storm/Homeworld/Nexus combinations with this counter,
+special relocation, matching-group interpretation, comprehensive assurance and
+AI refinement remain due. No saved-room/D1, reset, restart or deployment operation.
+[Connected source and limits](ADVISOR_AUTOMATIC_FLIPS.md#storm-casualties-before-remaining-traversal--24-october-2026).
+
 ## 24 October 2026 — Advisor conversion after completed Face Dance

 Supplied physical17/28 E's counter now follows physical38 A's completed native
@@ -1,5 +1,20 @@
 # Rule decision index

+## Advisor conversion during storm traversal — 24 October 2026
+
+Compose supplied Advanced physical17/28 E with actual current-sector storm
+losses that leave advisors alive and alone elsewhere in the same territory.
+Under the 14 October authority, provisionally finish all current-sector losses,
+including Fremen allocation choices, before the conversion counter and remaining
+traversal. Protection keeps its original earlier priority. Hold surviving
+advisors through unresolved casualty choices; an empty queue is not sufficient.
+Cancel only conversion, preserving actual losses and the existing continuously-
+alone duration. A public five-field sector receipt omits forecasts, protection
+and private continuation. Consume its private parent before traversing the next
+sector or completing the storm once. Later sectors can still kill the group;
+same-sector destruction creates no conversion.
+[Source, continuation and limits](ADVISOR_AUTOMATIC_FLIPS.md#storm-casualties-before-remaining-traversal--24-october-2026).
+
 ## Advisor conversion after Face Dance — 24 October 2026

 Compose supplied Advanced physical17/28 E with physical38 A's completed