Record 1748 reviewed original HD development snapshot

docs/hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md

@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
 # HD coordinator checkpoint — 12 October 2026
 
-The reviewed external development pack contains **1,652 original picture frames in605 complete sequences**. Root has copied the exact **1,148-frame / 421-sequence** handoff into shared Linux/Windows runtime data. Root completed and validated both final Stage2 Linux/Windows archives at this exact snapshot; the previous **800-frame / 340-sequence** archives and `964ba93` assembly are historical. Root owns runtime data, binaries, libraries and archives; coordinator owns external development registration and this metadata. Bundled originals and approved runtime art are tracked under this repository's data/. Working originals, prompts, job candidates and review evidence remain external under ../data/.
+The reviewed external development pack contains **1,748 original picture frames in701 complete sequences**. Root has copied the exact **1,148-frame / 421-sequence** handoff into shared Linux/Windows runtime data. Root completed and validated both final Stage2 Linux/Windows archives at this exact snapshot; the previous **800-frame / 340-sequence** archives and `964ba93` assembly are historical. Root owns runtime data, binaries, libraries and archives; coordinator owns external development registration and this metadata. Bundled originals and approved runtime art are tracked under this repository's data/. Working originals, prompts, job candidates and review evidence remain external under ../data/.
 
 ## Verified development coverage
 
@@ -12,11 +12,11 @@ The reviewed external development pack contains **1,652 original picture frames
 | Player and enemy projectiles | 45 / 51 |
 | Explosions and effects | 219 / 281 |
 | Equipment and pickups | 47 / 47 |
-| Terrain | 800 / 4,535 |
+| Terrain | 896 / 4,535 |
 | Menus, portraits, HUD and other pictures | 77 / 150 |
-| Total | 1,652 / 5,753 |
+| Total | 1,748 / 5,753 |
 
-All6,449 catalog entries and5,753 pictures were audited with zero HD source/hash/canvas/ID errors. **4,101 pictures still await registration**. The current ledger contains1632 registered,20 render-reachable,2778 candidates,683 in-progress and640 missing pictures. Candidate status establishes neither artistic approval nor a live occurrence. Unused/destroyed targets remain required;303 native AGX delta frames and four bitmap fonts retain separate preservation policies.
+All6,449 catalog entries and5,753 pictures were audited with zero HD source/hash/canvas/ID errors. **4,005 pictures still await registration**. Current ledger counts are1728 registered,20 render-reachable,2705 candidates,676 in-progress and624 missing. Candidate status is neither artistic approval nor a live occurrence. Unused/destroyed targets remain required;303 AGX delta frames and four bitmap fonts have separate preservation policies.
 
 ## Historical Stage2 API 1,148 output proof
 
@@ -115,22 +115,21 @@ Phase35 comprises complete PLATOON2/6, DMOON/7, TARG1G4/11 and TARG2G4/11. All f
 
 ## Durable owners and outstanding holds
 
-All current independent reviews keep the previously frozen multi-set1465 authority: Terrain1/192, Terrain2/80, Terrain3/96 and Set4/256. Ongoing cohorts do not silently upgrade to the new208/112/176/304 admissions.
+Ongoing independent scopes preserve the exact original1465 context authority: Terrain1/192, Terrain2/80, Terrain3/96, Set4/256. Current admissions240/176/176/304 are not silently substituted.
 
-- hd_full_review closed corrected3014c approval, three worm advice scopes, Terrain3 original14/15 approvals and two HELP approvals. It closed Set4 original17v4 as whole-held solely401df desaturated earth, then exclusively reviews original22's two well-fleck repairs as a different peer.
-- iron_coast_3 approved Terrain3 original9/10,16/17 and18/19 with detailed material/state limits. It now reviews late originals37/38 using authentic sources, whole raws and864 genuine cases; all other late drafts remain original fallback.
-- iron_coast_5 approved Terrain2 original8/12/14/15, held original9's water/rib materials and original13's coarse201d6 water, and explicitly superseded its prior six-green job5 acceptance with a material hold. It next reserves original16/17.
-- windows_persistence approved original10, the genuine201b8 hardware sibling, continuous-grass job6v5 and complete classic menu8. It held the earlier green checker and smooth2018d pipe repair; it now exclusively reviews job5's six-green complete sibling. Prior45 gallery regeneration changed only mtimes, and that additive incident remains preserved.
-- iron_coast_2 approved complete Set4 originals18–21 and25/26; original17 atlas edges and22 missing interior gray flecks remain held. It next reserves29/30. iron_coast_6 closed the three damaged singles and Set4 original24 approval/23 atlas-top hold; it now reviews27/28.
-- terrain_capture_fixture approved10450/80/90; it preserved historical10460/70 approvals but explicitly clarified fourteen enlarged-cellular material failures. Whole10460/70 are coordinator-held. It now exclusively reviews frozen104a0.
-- campaign_release_review preserves every accepted/held raw and candidate, author-frozen original43 and later correction history. Only401df warm earth,40237 source-absent atlas line and4022d/40230 well cues have separate exact-source correction reservations; no partial-family admission.
-- hd_terrain_set_1 has208 admitted targets. Frozen104a0 is peer-ready; nine10460 and five10470 fine-material corrections use two early plain-ground/fence probes before the remaining targets. Existing source geometry/colors and other bindings stay fixed.
-- hd_terrain_set_2 has112 admitted targets and90 proposal families/1,437 IDs. Grassv5/hardwarev4 independent approvals, pipe-ribv4 and201d6-waterv3 ready siblings, and job5 peer review remain outside1652. Final2069f/a0 green loss stays hard-held; no blind repeat.
-- Terrain3 middle has128 admitted original targets, including the matching-identity corrected6 sibling without extra coverage. Original14–19 independent approvals await coordinator review; original20 is author-held and production continues from21.301ae remains missing/no-retry. Late37–68 proposes506 distinct targets with514 genuine raws and433 gallery pages, all held pending independent judgment; current actual dependency/source pins are complete and historical omissions/retractions stay preserved.
-- hd_dark_player keeps capped worm-material failures, opaque framing/aspect holds and prepared first-source scene plans separate. MKS/SDL opening ownership and the integer-rounded full-opaque aspect policy remain parent decisions. Two HELP approvals await coordinator review; no extra worm/opaque correction is submitted.
-- hd_enemies_01 preserves all rotor/lamp/tab failures and service refusal history. campaign_integration preserves approved Flare/Sparkle/LargeAir and holds Ground42 decay grain, Person ivory resampling and unchanged shaded smoke. No raw-color, mask, crop or renderer compensation stands in for genuine art.
+- hd_full_review approved corrected Set4 original17 warm-earth-v5,22 well-fleck-v2 and23 brown-edge-v2; these remain future-only. It now exclusively reviews whole corrected10460 then10470 material siblings as a different peer. Historical coarse-material holds and all inputs remain unchanged.
+- iron_coast_2 approved complete Set4 original31/32 and35/36 and now reviews39/40; iron_coast_6 approved33/34 and now reviews37/38. All new holds/qualified approvals are complete-family decisions; later shared quarters remain provenance/original fallback.
+- iron_coast_3 approved Terrain3 original14–19 and late37–40; these remain future-only. It now reviews late41/42 after full owner snapshots. Original late37–68 is proposal-complete506targets/514raws, not admitted by production coverage.
+- iron_coast_5 approved Terrain2 original14–16,18/19 and21. Original17 coarse water was repaired in a separate now-approved sibling. Original20 remains whole-held for six dark water atlas-divider edges20241/43/45/47/49/4b; an early one-water method check precedes the separate six-source correction. It now reviews originals22/23.
+- windows_persistence approved the four corrected64-frame cohort now registered in1748 and the later original17 three-water sibling, outside1748.2018d pipe-ribv4 remains whole-held: all17 fourth-band cells become cyan water at native1. No further blind pipe attempt is reserved.
+- terrain_capture_fixture completed10480/90/104a0 approvals;104a0 remains future-only. Final2069f v3 advice is KEEP HELD: genuine source interleaved green/checker footprints became physical outlined stone paving and native green merges into olive/gray. Full13/206a0 remains held; no fourthf/a0 request.
+- hd_terrain_set_1 has240 registered pictures. New10460/70 complete material siblings are frozen for the different peer; disjoint104b0 may record partial_source_pass with contexts pending, but every complete-family case must be inspected before freeze. There is no partial acceptance.
+- hd_terrain_set_2 has176 registered targets and90 proposal families/1,437 IDs. Exact plantedv2/grassv5/hardwarev4/D6finewaterv3 sibling bytes were promoted with old mains SHA-preserved. Unregistered original25 quality probes stay partial held; smaller atlas divider failure is retained and source-single trials remain bounded. Final13 green/paving stays held.
+- Terrain3 middle has128 own registered targets. Original14–19 peer approvals remain pending coordinator review;20/21 are author-held. Original22 production continues;301ae stays missing/no-retry. Source/raw/proof bytes in all peer freezes remain immutable.
+- campaign_release_review preserves source/raw/history throughout author-frozen original44 and ongoing45. Source-contour-only repairs402a1/402ab are separate whole16 siblings; no crop/pixel compensation. All current39/40 and37/38 author/shared-parent freezes remain exact.
+- Dark-player worm caps, original opaque-scene aspect/border failures, rotor/lamp/tab failures and service refusal history remain held. RITE/LEFT plans and MKS/SDL/opaque policy questions remain separate; no extra worm/opaque execution is implied.
 
-The exact registered terrain totals are208/112/176/304,800 overall. The next274 independent approved pictures are outside1652 and require coordinator source/raw/material/current-output review; sixteen original12 targets also have a missing saved-prompt provenance gap requiring parent policy. Their acceptance is not readiness or registration. No catalog-complete or universal seamlessness claim is made.
+The1748 pending snapshot records546 unique independently approved unregistered pictures, all requiring coordinator complete-source/raw/material/current-output review. Sixteen original12 pictures also have a missing saved-prompt provenance gap requiring parent policy. No generic5753 completion or universal seamlessness claim is made.
 
 ## Startup PNG source epoch and current continuity
 
@@ -174,3 +173,14 @@ Whole10460/10470 remain unregistered. Additive fixture clarification SHAs `f9ee0
 Bookkeeping receipt `e807e545bd51dbc379433f571cba466f050e23947b735fd7763c4c6c759d85e8` checks all698 job source/context contracts and preserves720 original/interim metadata files. Thirty-six final payload changes affect derived status/count/owner/review only. A queue refresh accidentally began before audit completion and read old1465; its entire interim state is saved, then one sequential refresh against completed1652 produced1632 registered plus20 reachable,2778 candidates,683 in-progress and640 missing. Byte-identical rewritten job files also changed mtimes, explicitly disclosed to active reviewers. A separate closure assertion mistakenly expected635 sequences; it failed before closure writes and was corrected to605 (the excluded32 targets were standalone sequences). Both exact failed-attempt histories are retained; neither affected art, registration bindings or runtime pixels. Audit SHA `3a90095a51fdfd0748c1ec51cf60c18a42a1812feddc4b243319d4d89b6586c1` reports1652/4101/zero errors; ledger SHA `22b6ee44bee7c7f0392590a0fb4277ee555fec9391d4fbced31b997b3f0b9588` retains all5753 required targets.
 
 Immutable future handoff ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-1652-20261011/pack/ contains1,652 frames/605 sequences,636 files/1263053074 bytes with verified distinct inodes. Handoff SHA `2b89b62f0b673a2fbbff31441307af0fd6bfa9fe89fa33c893a7399acd801556` binds all pack/proof/source/audit/ledger/pending histories. All6,853 packaged bin/lib/data files remain byte-identical, inventory SHA `6fc0642c24cae2ba04bab30ab4cd0547d62c965421b1cb49026aa8a48d351653`; shared runtime remains1,148/421 and45 accepted Stage2 mods. No runtime copy/export, whole-map seam, live Host, palette-time or UI-route proof is inferred. Parent alone coordinates a later runtime snapshot.
+
+
+## Closed1748 outer development registration
+
+Batch1748 adds96 terrain pictures in six complete families, yielding1,748/5,753 originals in701 sequences and896 terrain pictures. Approval `fc2c4de1ba0263b39c90628f9194f9623e4774c37c2b90bf0a0be7569b5f1e46`, canonical registration `a39194c9e176a29a6283bb2b5e6e931e2046ff666cea04836b986c57c47e4937` and whole actual proof `c5e0a7a97a27f85e2200609be77bbb0f69ad76e046597a883e4728910028bae6` bind every accepted original/raw/candidate/peer judgment. All8,740 source/scaled outputs match:8,260 baseline plus480 new,6,992 scaled. Every1652 baseline frame remains exact. Actual c0c3/compatible ba61 dependencies, both literal false freshness flags and18 recursive source SHA/size/mtime pins remain stable. Current manifest `f74a3dc7a973258d9eb13896b39e78c957710f4ab999d87ffbe415ffbe6de274`, provenance `75c96e18cbb4ed2d0bb7d4783d455617b767f968430f3bc593cb7de9dda7176f`. The110 full-pack contact pages are hash-bound; actual coordinator visual authority is47 full raw canvases and24 complete source/native1–4 boards, plus separate peer full contexts/state proofs.
+
+10480/90 source rail/shore/building/one-wreck geometry is retained with fine continuous material, stronger relief, darker water and original-fallback islands qualified. Planted green row breaks/soil gaps are repaired;20161 continuous grass replaces the checker finish, with39→34 weaker native green samples and all39 green at higher scales qualified.201b8 restores nine broad gray tabbed bodies/square gold plates, native297/81 positions exact, brighter highscale bevel edges qualified.201d6 five3/3/2/3/3 source supports retain narrow center and authentic side stepping; fine water replaces coarse grid with one warm support sample becoming neutral gray and darker/dense cyan ripple differences qualified. Whole families are accepted; no exact RGB or highscale contour identity is claimed.
+
+Canonical registration required four exact approved sibling-byte promotions under their existing parent identities. B/batch-1748-approval-before retains old candidate/coordinator/job bytes in SHA-named copies; all explicit siblings/raw/source/crop/proof bytes remain exact.698 job source/context contracts are checked; only eight derived job payloads changed (six registered parents and two completed/current Terrain3 production jobs). Receipt `9c54e806d6190644920b041b224c7f2275bcf28102e15ea1535158e1ab283946` preserves every old byte. A private wrapper uses unmodified official queue computation/locks/writer but skips identical serialized writes, preserving all690 byte-identical job mtimes. Audit completed before queue derivation; current ledger1728registered+20reachable=1748,2705candidate,676inprogress,624missing. No prior metadata incident is overwritten.
+
+Immutable future input ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-1748-20261012/pack/ has683 files/1,417,761,478 bytes and private inodes; handoff `62fcbf7d286125c065ab374bad3fde39fb3812b62fa057d5ece5d4a3d936ddde`. All636 old1652 handoff files and all6,853 packaged bin/lib/data files remain exact, runtime inventory `6fc0642c24cae2ba04bab30ab4cd0547d62c965421b1cb49026aa8a48d351653`; shared runtime1,148/421 and45 Stage2 mods are unchanged. Parent alone coordinates later runtime copying/build/export. This closes an outer development batch, not the original5753 catalog, live Host, UI routes, palette timing, complete boss assemblies or invisible whole-map seams.