Record source-reviewed 1860-frame HD development pack

docs/hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md

@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
 # HD coordinator checkpoint — 12 October 2026
 
-The reviewed external development pack contains **1,844 original picture frames in 797 complete sequences**. Root has copied the exact **1,148-frame / 421-sequence** handoff into shared Linux/Windows runtime data. Root completed and validated both final Stage2 Linux/Windows archives at this exact snapshot; the previous **800-frame / 340-sequence** archives and `964ba93` assembly are historical. Root owns runtime data, binaries, libraries and archives; coordinator owns external development registration and this metadata. Bundled originals and approved runtime art are tracked under this repository's data/. Working originals, prompts, job candidates and review evidence remain external under ../data/.
+The reviewed external development pack contains **1,860 original picture frames in 798 complete sequences**. Root has copied the exact **1,148-frame / 421-sequence** handoff into shared Linux/Windows runtime data. Root completed and validated both final Stage2 Linux/Windows archives at this exact snapshot; the previous **800-frame / 340-sequence** archives and `964ba93` assembly are historical. Root owns runtime data, binaries, libraries and archives; coordinator owns external development registration and this metadata. Bundled originals and approved runtime art are tracked under this repository's data/. Working originals, prompts, job candidates and review evidence remain external under ../data/.
 
 ## Verified development coverage
 
@@ -12,11 +12,11 @@ The reviewed external development pack contains **1,844 original picture frames
 | Player and enemy projectiles | 45 / 51 |
 | Explosions and effects | 219 / 281 |
 | Equipment and pickups | 47 / 47 |
-| Terrain | 992 / 4,535 |
+| Terrain | 1,008 / 4,535 |
 | Menus, portraits, HUD and other pictures | 77 / 150 |
-| Total | 1,844 / 5,753 |
+| Total | 1,860 / 5,753 |
 
-All 6,449 catalog entries and 5,753 pictures were audited with zero HD source/hash/canvas/ID errors. **3,909 pictures still await registration**. Current ledger counts are 1824 registered, 20 render-reachable, 2685 candidates, 616 in-progress and 608 missing. Candidate status is neither artistic approval nor live occurrence. Unused/destroyed targets remain required; 303 AGX delta frames and four bitmap fonts retain separate policies.
+All 6,449 catalog entries and 5,753 pictures were audited with zero HD source/hash/canvas/ID errors. **3,893 pictures still await registration**. Current ledger counts are 1840 registered, 20 render-reachable, 2742 candidates, 559 in-progress and 592 missing. Candidate status is neither artistic approval nor live occurrence. Unused/destroyed targets remain required; 303 AGX delta frames and four bitmap fonts retain separate policies.
 
 ## Historical Stage2 API 1,148 output proof
 
@@ -115,20 +115,21 @@ Phase35 comprises complete PLATOON2/6, DMOON/7, TARG1G4/11 and TARG2G4/11. All f
 
 ## Durable owners and outstanding holds
 
-All ongoing independent scopes keep the original 1465 authority: Terrain1/192, Terrain2/80, Terrain3/96, Set4/256. Current counts 288/224/176/304 are not silently substituted.
+All ongoing independent scopes keep the original 1465 authority: Terrain1/192, Terrain2/80, Terrain3/96, Set4/256. Current registered counts 288/224/192/304 are not silently substituted. The 1860 handoff cutoff is immutable; later peer closures belong to subsequent receipts.
 
-- Corrected 10460/10470 complete 32 are registered in 1844 with exact accepted sibling promotion and preserved historical material holds. Terrain1 artist continues disjoint 104d0; fixture reviews frozen 104c0, including genuineCFv2 and foreign original 104b1/1048a state fallback. Complete104b0 is independently approved and awaits coordinator review.
-- hd_full_review closed Terrain3 middle 20/21 complete 32 and Set4 corrected 40 complete 16 qualified approvals. It now reviews middle 22/23 under new full freezes, preserving author angular/faceted/raised-remnant and faint-mark disclosures. Middle owner has 128 own registered targets; 301ae remains missing/no-retry.
-- iron_coast_3 closed Terrain3 late 43/44 complete 32 qualified approval and now reviews 45/46. All prior 41/42 and bounded30380 successor holds remain literal: upper channels and first lower lip are too high/deep/tall. The one-request correction is exhausted; no second call is reserved.
-- iron_coast_2 closed Set4 original 45 complete 16 qualified approval. Originals41/42 remain whole-held for six/four low-scale lavender/ember/network cues. Author early 57 route is legible, but60 method variants retain dim/orange native yellow markers; methods and remaining eight calls stay gated, with no loader/palette/RGB compensation.
-- iron_coast_6 closed Set4 original 44 complete 16 approval and original 43 whole hold on 40382 opaque near-black raw right border with allscale rendered boundary darkening. A separate genuine 40382 source-only complete sibling is reserved after the early 41/42 methods; other 15 and recovery history stay exact.
-- windows_persistence preserved the complete 30380 successor HOLD and now reviews frozen Terrain2 original 20 six-water-rule successor. Coordinator early 20249 method inspected full raw/source/current1–4 and genuine repeated contexts/pairs; it is method advice only, with no whole-family approval.
-- iron_coast_5 closed Terrain2 original 24/26 approvals and original 27 whole hold on five coarse installation/wreck mosaics. It now reviews 28/29 under literal 80. Original27 five-only corrections are reserved behind earlier22/23 hardware/edge/diagonal/mosaic work; intact/damaged probes precede the remaining three.
-- Fixture closed Terrain2 original 25 v5 whole hold on 20303/20307 microscopic square soil/water mosaics despite valid macro/checker geometry and softened native 3–4. A separate two-source correction is reserved after earlier work; other 14 and all failed atlas/prompt history remain frozen. Final2069f v3 advice stays KEEP HELD for physical paving emphasis and muted green distinction; no additional f/a0 call is reserved.
-- Terrain2 artist has 224 registered targets,90 proposal families/1,437 IDs. Accepted parents and all selected art/proofs remain frozen; current peer80 authority is literal. Missing-prompt original 12 and native 1-erased fourth2018d metal band remain separate provenance/art blockers.
-- Set4 author original 46 remains partial5/11 unsubmitted and excluded from complete-family review. All frozen current40/43/44/45 and prior contour/warm-earth histories stay exact. Dark-player worm caps, opaque framing, rotor/lamp/tab/shop failures and service refusal history remain held; unexecuted RITE/LEFT plans and opening-card policy questions imply no generation.
+- Terrain1 corrected 10460/10470 are registered in 1844 with accepted siblings and preserved historical holds. Complete 104b0/104c0 are independently approved and await coordinator review. Fixture closed 104d0 complete16 after the 1860 cutoff, retaining all source/state/raw evidence and the official derived job exception. Artist continues disjoint 104e0 source preparation.
+- Terrain3 middle original19 is newly registered in 1860. Originals14–18 remain whole-held for ten finish components across 80 frames. Middle owner has 144 own registered targets and is preparing only genuine char 301c3 / green 301ec method probes before the other eight; final siblings need complete author context QA and a different peer. 301ae remains missing/no-retry.
+- hd_full_review closed middle 20/21, 22/23 and 24 qualified complete-family approvals. Middle 25 is reserved for exclusive review after its complete owner freeze, including raised 30272/30273 material concerns and official 1860 derived-only job epoch accounting. No peer approval is an admission.
+- iron_coast_3 closed late 45/46 and 47/48 approvals before the frozen cutoff, and 49/50 approvals afterward. Every old late closure remains frozen. Whole 42 and the bounded 30380 successor remain held for upper channels and first lower lip too high/deep/tall. The one-request correction is exhausted; no second call is reserved.
+- iron_coast_5 closed Terrain2 original 28/29 qualified approval. Original 30 holds 20352–20355 retained black atlas-divider columns; all original 31 remains held for flat square material. Original 32 whole hold and 33 qualified16 approval closed after 1860, with exact divider/recess/finish diagnostics preserved. Literal original 34/35 preparation uses explicit ranges and owner freeze, never filtered queue offsets.
+- Terrain2 original 22/23 requests remain gated. Early 20263 restores broad gray/lime hardware but native cyan notches become gray; an additive raw/sampling explanation preserves the initial geometry caution. Early 2025e edge advice is useful with denser/redder gravel qualifications; preparatory 2026b restores the source diagonal but is not family approval. Named 93/275/276 artifact freezes remain exact, with no further request inferred.
+- Terrain2 original 25 v5 stays whole-held on 20303/20307 microscopic square material; original 27 stays held on five installation/wreck mosaics. Their future bounded corrections remain behind earlier gates. Final 2069f v3 physical paving/green distinction and native1-erased fourth 2018d metal band remain separate holds, with no extra request reserved.
+- windows_persistence closed Terrain2 original 20 complete16 six-water-rule successor approval before the cutoff and Set4 corrected 43 complete16 afterward. Historical held mains, other unchanged bindings and source/raw/proof bytes remain frozen; coordinator admission is separate.
+- Set4 original 46 independently approved after full source/current/context review. Author continues disjoint original 47. Whole 41/42 low-scale lavender/ember/network holds remain; early 57 is viable but 60 v3/v4/v5 retain orange/dim native yellow. Bounded advice shows final reduction mixing even authentic source-colored calibration; no unsupported prompt retry or remaining eight corrections are authorized.
+- Original 12 actual historical prompt/request evidence is recovered additively outside its frozen parent. The candidate's wrong saved-prompt locator remains unchanged; exact invocation source-image byte pin is unavailable. Independent narrow history verification and parent policy are required before any locator update or admission. Historical missing-prompt reports remain literal.
+- Dark-player worm caps, opaque framing, rotor/lamp/tab/shop failures and service refusal history remain held. Prepared RITE/LEFT and opaque scene plans or opening-card questions imply no generation.
 
-This handoff cutoff records 738 unique independently approved unregistered pictures requiring coordinator full-source/raw/material/current-output review. Sixteen original 12 pictures additionally retain the missing saved-prompt gap requiring parent policy. There is no original 5753 completion or universal seamlessness claim.
+The immutable 1860 pending cutoff records 914 historically independent-approved unregistered pictures: 80 now whole-family coordinator material-held and 834 still pending coordinator review. Subsequent approvals are recorded as later evidence, without silently modifying the cutoff. No original 5753 completion, universal seamlessness, live Host, timing or UI-route claim follows.
 
 ## Startup PNG source epoch and current continuity
 
@@ -213,3 +214,18 @@ Manifest `23a51de8c951ad06c104af7dfc227a9a19117cc032bb5371772b5d8e7b9e39d4`, pro
 The frozen pending snapshot has **738 independently approved unregistered pictures** requiring coordinator review, including 16 original 12 pictures with a missing saved-prompt provenance gap. Source-rib, atlas-border, misplaced shallow panels, erased low-scale lavender/ember cues, square material, worm and opaque-scene holds remain separate. Registration does not establish catalog completion, seamless mixed maps, live Host, palette timing or UI-route coverage.
 
 Bookkeeping receipt `910d6514783b882fa6b9651f63277dbb05c94217149d0d0f1b38124e29d7e3d5` verifies all 698 job source/context contracts. Five actual derived job changes have exact before copies; all 693 byte-identical job payloads retain their mtimes. Status/count-only 104c0 and middle 23/active24 epochs are separately receipted for affected owners/reviewers. Official queue computation/locks/atomic writing were used, skipping identical writes. Current ledger counts are {'registered': 1824, 'inprogress': 616, 'renderreachable': 20, 'candidate': 2685, 'missing': 608}. No packaged copy/build/export was performed.
+
+
+## Closed 1860 outer development registration
+
+Batch 1860 adds **16 terrain pictures in one complete 16-frame sequence**, original Terrain3 family 19 (`3020d`–`3021c`), yielding **1,860 / 5,753 originals**, **798 complete sequences** and **1,008 terrain pictures**. Coordinator material review `13db31cf892cb67ba2ef25d843415d405d6cabe31167b3684429eb10945d12ff` records actual inspection of all 96 full selected raw canvases, 24 complete source/current 1–4 boards and 16 focused pages across original families 14–19. All 480 canonical source/scaled outputs match the frozen author bytes. The separately bound independent reports retain their exhaustive cardinal/native/state scope; no fresh coordinator invocation of every context is claimed.
+
+Only family 19 receives complete-family coordinator approval. Families 14–18 remain **whole-family held: 80 frames**, because exactly ten components retain dominant flat cellular or polygonal material: `301c3`, `301c8`, `301cc`, `301d1`, `301d4`, `301d7`, `301ec`, `301fc`, `301fd`, `30201`. Geometry and palette checks do not establish fine material. The provisional questions on `30202` and `30205` were resolved through physical raw/source/native comparisons as qualified irregular or directional aggregate. Historical author and peer judgments remain unchanged; acceptable individual components do not confer partial registration. Source-only char/green probes on `301c3` and `301ec` are reserved before the remaining eight corrections, with separate complete-family siblings and a different final peer.
+
+Full current Rust proof `f7fdb7f935152e70471addf693c3a5c1afe10b4e0534a7a28a02da848f8af3f0` compares all **9,300 source/scaled outputs** exactly: 9,220 prior 1844 outputs plus 80 new, including 7,440 scaled outputs. Every 1844 baseline binding remains exact. Actual immutable c0c3/compatible ba61 dependencies, both literal false age guards and all 18 recursive source SHA/size/mtime records are stable. The 117 combined contact pages are hash-bound, not described as freshly inspected. No candidate promotion was required; all source/raw/candidate/proof pixels remain unchanged. Finer grit, stronger relief, native1 softness and visible HD/original density and tone rectangles are accepted material qualifications.
+
+Manifest `4546c9c4887af721c4bfe7b0f5414df4cecca0727b4c97f02339d2f723b0de46`, provenance `732d33b02cd22f00f267576ac46dc3b3505ea2954dd05efa9229aa43bec43506`, approval `b742a0f6572c87a4deba7ed579cf5d9c64b59d7d5009bb05cc3b149736e89d07` and registration `290ac3082830e325cc47afe9991be7402c630980677f408068e9bd69d67fc3cc` bind the accepted family. Immutable private input ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-1860-20261012/pack/ contains 752 files / 1,648,893,441 bytes with distinct private inodes; handoff `fc3cf1667c33ff9b2990ce3a88c88a7a477893e0b9a7e42473a95508fbc5aaf0`. Every 1844 handoff payload and all 6,853 packaged runtime files remain exact. Released runtime stays **1,148 frames / 421 sequences with 45 accepted mods**; parent alone controls a later copy/build/export.
+
+The frozen 1860 pending cutoff has **914 historically independent-approved unregistered pictures**: **80 whole-family coordinator material-held** and **834 pending coordinator review**. Later peer closures are subsequent evidence, not additions silently attributed to this cutoff. Original12 actual historical prompt/request records were recovered additively; the incorrect candidate prompt locator and missing historical source-image byte pin remain explicit pending independent verification and parent policy, with no locator edit or admission. Source-rib, atlas-border, misplaced panel, low-scale lavender/ember, square-material, worm and opaque-scene holds remain separate. Registration does not establish catalog completion, seamless mixed maps, live Host, palette timing or UI-route coverage.
+
+Bookkeeping receipt `c91e6a5d497a795a3480dbcd3e648c0f985f26ef6864e45d98b41671a9ce71a9` verifies all 698 source/context contracts. Six actual derived job changes have exact beforecopies; all 692 byte-identical job payloads retain their mtimes. Original19 registration and 104d0/middle24/middle25/Set4 original46/47 status-count successors are separately receipted for affected owners and reviewers. Official queue computation, locks and atomic writing skipped identical files. Current ledger counts are {'registered': 1840, 'inprogress': 559, 'renderreachable': 20, 'candidate': 2742, 'missing': 592}. No packaged copy/build/export was performed.