From 9d3b15b8d600bf97f3ad698ca62df41a46176be0 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: raptorreplica Date: Sun, 11 Oct 2026 18:50:32 +1100 Subject: [PATCH] Checkpoint 1,037 independently reviewed development HD frames --- docs/hd-art.md | 29 +- docs/hd-backlog.md | 31 +- docs/hd-completion.json | 39524 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++- docs/hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md | 71 +- 4 files changed, 38920 insertions(+), 735 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/hd-art.md b/docs/hd-art.md index b1302abc..9d998e0c 100644 --- a/docs/hd-art.md +++ b/docs/hd-art.md @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ The Rust Options screen includes **HD art**. It starts disabled. Enable it to use reviewed artwork from the selected data directory's `hd/hd.json`; each missing or rejected frame keeps the selected original / 2x / 3x / 4x crisp treatment. The bundled runtime uses `data/`, while development artwork and review jobs live under `../data/`. The scale setting still determines the indexed rendering resolution, and the HD toggle can be changed while paused. HD art is presentation only: simulation, collision sizes, banking positions and save content IDs stay unchanged. -The development base-game pack currently supplies **929 reviewed replacement frames in 377 complete sequences**. These include all twenty-one light, dark and firing-flash player poses, 223 boss frames, complete vehicle families, ground defenses and opening bunkers, all forty-seven equipment and pickup pictures, projectile and effect animations, eleven HUD picture glyphs, nine pilot portraits, both title logos, three standalone opening cards and 256 canonical terrain tiles. The tracked Linux/Windows playable snapshots contain the separately frozen 800 reviewed frames, copied by the root assembler and committed at `964ba93`. Later development approvals remain separate from this runtime checkpoint. The complete catalog backlog and generation status are listed in [hd-backlog.md](hd-backlog.md). +The development base-game pack currently supplies **1,037 reviewed replacement frames in 396 complete sequences**. These include all twenty-one light, dark and firing-flash player poses, 232 boss frames, complete vehicle families, ground defenses and opening bunkers, all forty-seven equipment and pickup pictures, projectile and effect animations, eleven HUD picture glyphs, nine pilot portraits, four difficulty portraits, both title logos, three standalone opening cards and 320 canonical terrain tiles. The tracked Linux/Windows playable snapshots contain the separately frozen 800 reviewed frames, copied by the root assembler and committed at `964ba93`. Later development approvals remain separate from this runtime checkpoint. The complete catalog backlog and generation status are listed in [hd-backlog.md](hd-backlog.md). | Reviewed artwork | Original asset IDs | Supplied / complete frames | | --- | --- | ---: | @@ -30,7 +30,11 @@ The development base-game pack currently supplies **929 reviewed replacement fra | TANK02 tread phases | `0x200cc`–`0x200cd` | 2 / 2 | | Additional source-bound craft | `0x2009e`, `0x30049` | 2 / 2 | | Fine-metal third-campaign craft | `0x3004c`, `0x3004f`, `0x30055`, `0x3005c`, `0x30065`, `0x30068`, `0x3006b`, `0x3006e`, `0x30073` | 9 / 9 | +| Additional third-campaign hull and pod craft | `0x3008f`, `0x30092`, `0x30095`, `0x30098` | 4 / 4 | +| Third-campaign tread, slat and fork families | `0x30074`–`0x30077`, `0x30080`–`0x30088`, `0x3008b`–`0x3008c` | 15 / 15 | | Corrected third-campaign boss | `0x30044` | 1 / 1 | +| Restored asymmetric hull and lower-bridge bosses | `0x10310`, `0x200a3` | 2 / 2 | +| Restored EBOSS6 opening phases | `0x400ac`–`0x400b2` | 7 / 7 | | First-mission industrial boss `SHIP10G1_PIC` | `0x10306` | 1 / 1 | | Industrial bosses `SHIP12G1_PIC`, `SHIP17G1_PIC` | `0x10308`, `0x1030f` | 2 / 2 | | Industrial boss `SHIP11G1_PIC` | `0x10307` | 1 / 1 | @@ -88,6 +92,7 @@ The development base-game pack currently supplies **929 reviewed replacement fra | Plasma projectile picture | `0x10251` | 1 / 1 | | Energy ring | `0x101ae`–`0x101b9` | 12 / 12 | | Blue sparks | `0x1019c`–`0x101a4` | 9 / 9 | +| Orange sparks | `0x101a5`–`0x101ad` | 9 / 9 | | Death-ray hits | `0x101f1`–`0x101f4` | 4 / 4 | | Lightning growth/retraction | `0x1018e`–`0x1019b` | 14 / 14 | | Platoon fragments | `0x10213`–`0x1021c` | 10 / 10 | @@ -115,6 +120,8 @@ The development base-game pack currently supplies **929 reviewed replacement fra | Cyan-symbol and blank red buttons | `0x10121`–`0x10124` | 4 / 4 | | Buoy blink phases | `0x10162`–`0x10163` | 2 / 2 | | Alternate cursor and repeating menu texture | `0x50019`, `0x10019` | 2 / 2 | +| Difficulty portraits | `0x1001a`–`0x1001d` | 4 / 4 | +| Large repeating metal texture and side trims | `0x10018`, `0x50005`–`0x50006` | 3 / 3 | | Canonical terrain set 1, first shard | `0x10360`–`0x1036f` | 16 / 16 | | Canonical terrain set 2, corrected first shard | `0x2010d`–`0x2011c` | 16 / 16 | | Canonical industrial terrain, first two shards | `0x300ed`–`0x3010c` | 32 / 32 | @@ -124,15 +131,17 @@ The development base-game pack currently supplies **929 reviewed replacement fra | Agricultural ground and vegetation | `0x2011d`–`0x2013c` | 32 / 32 | | Fourth-campaign machinery and soil | `0x400d5`–`0x400f4` | 32 / 32 | | Fourth-campaign damaged structures and controls | `0x400f5`–`0x40114` | 32 / 32 | +| Fourth-campaign radar, damage and controls | `0x40115`–`0x40134` | 32 / 32 | +| Fourth-campaign cracked soil and rock terrain | `0x40135`–`0x40154` | 32 / 32 | | Source shoreline, fences and rocks | `0x103f0`–`0x103ff` | 16 / 16 | Every registered frame passed the exact original source hash, logical canvas, aspect, visible alpha and path checks. Complete contact sheets were inspected at source size and the 4× presentation size; per-frame geometry metrics and review evidence remain with each family. Their logical collision sizes are unchanged. Small contours and interpreted metal detail differ. Missing artwork keeps the crisp original fallback. HD remains an opt-in preview while the remaining catalog and game screenshots are reviewed. An actual Rust `HdAssets::sprite` pass also checked all registered frames at scales 1–4 with the game palette: every output has the expected dimensions and visible pixels, and the pack reports no diagnostics. Complete 4× source/HD sheets from that runtime path were reviewed for readable projectiles, equipment alignment, banking progression and energy-ring timing stages. These sprite checks complement live gameplay captures and do not establish full-game visual completion. -The current 929-frame development snapshot passed 3,716 actual scale checks. All 4,645 original and rendered PPMs are byte-identical to independently accepted references, with both source-age guards clear and the tested immutable library pinned by SHA and original build time. All 846 ordinary sources introduce no reserved palette labels; 80 sources retain legitimate gameplay classes, and the three opening cards use their authentic static palettes. Historical smaller-pack proofs, including the packaged 800-frame snapshot, remain separate. +The current 1,037-frame development snapshot passed 4,148 actual scale checks. All 5,185 original and rendered PPMs are byte-identical to independently accepted references, with both source-age guards clear and the tested immutable library pinned by SHA and original build time. All 952 ordinary sources introduce no reserved palette labels; 82 sources retain legitimate gameplay classes, and the three opening cards use their authentic static palettes. Historical smaller-pack proofs, including the packaged 800-frame snapshot, remain separate. -The 189 additional boss frames passed complete source/1×/4× and native 2×/3× review across 56 full families. Opaque component panels, weapon apertures and source phases remain recognizable; fine material detail and minor contour interpretations are disclosed per family. These gallery decisions do not certify complete assembled-boss joins or native encounter placement. The shortened paired bottom feet in `0x200a2`, lost painted wing/strut cells in `0x30045`, Mole's missing initial blink, selected contracted hulls and the final EBOSS6 white-plate substitution remain held and are excluded. +The 189 additional boss frames passed complete source/1×/4× and native 2×/3× review across 56 full families. Opaque component panels, weapon apertures and source phases remain recognizable; fine material detail and minor contour interpretations are disclosed per family. These gallery decisions do not certify complete assembled-boss joins or native encounter placement. The shortened paired bottom feet in `0x200a2`, lost painted wing/strut cells in `0x30045`, Mole's missing initial blink, other contracted hulls remain held and are excluded. The later repaired asymmetric hull, lower bridge and complete EBOSS6 phases are reviewed separately below. The six corrected dinosaur poses preserve every native source occupied cell, bound and centroid, including the formerly lost dorsal, belly and tail points. They contain new painted detail at higher scales. The restored `0x10345` fighter retains its fork teeth and lower rails; ten very dark outer corner/foot cells remain an accepted contour interpretation. TANK01 has stable hull landmarks and distinct tread phases; three or four external corner cells per pose round inward at 1× while every source cell retains occupancy at 2×–4×. Minor stationary surface shading variance is disclosed. @@ -242,10 +251,22 @@ Inspect every source frame before generating its replacement. Request the same o Keep image-generation prompts and provenance alongside the artwork. Never overwrite original catalog assets. The loader deliberately accepts partial coverage so a reviewed sprite can be previewed before the complete pack is ready, while preserving per-frame fallback. -The 129-frame development addition has complete independent source/all-scale family review and coordinator inspection of every 42 source/native1/HD4 pages on eight unresampled boards. All 645 current PPMs match those accepted outputs exactly. Set4's next thirty-two tiles were checked with 70 native contexts, 719 joins and 27 states; the isolated 64-tile pack has 21 unique damage pairs with both HD partners and four fallback partners. The sixteen shoreline/fence/rock tiles passed all 83 current boards and 1,960 scale composition cases, with no declared damaged partners. Fine material and original-fallback density differences remain disclosed. +The earlier 129-frame development addition has complete independent source/all-scale family review and coordinator inspection of every 42 source/native1/HD4 pages on eight unresampled boards. All 645 current PPMs match those accepted outputs exactly. Set4's next thirty-two tiles were checked with 70 native contexts, 719 joins and 27 states; the isolated 64-tile pack has 21 unique damage pairs with both HD partners and four fallback partners. The sixteen shoreline/fence/rock tiles passed all 83 current boards and 1,960 scale composition cases, with no declared damaged partners. Fine material and original-fallback density differences remain disclosed. Power and Impact retain their native phase masks and repaired source arms. Shield's independent actual patterned `Canvas::shade` proof preserves the original world center, deep holes and outside background, and is invariant to occupied mask RGB. Its higher-scale ring edges are smoother and the final 4× mask has 2,303 pixels against 2,304 source-expanded pixels. Smoke's matching mask has no demonstrated visible HD enhancement and remains held because every actual shaded output is byte-identical to its nearest-neighbor original. MediumAir's matte grain avoids the rejected ivory glints; exact peripheral source-cell losses remain disclosed. The final lower-left yellow cue is visibly stronger than the source, accepted with a 37% fall in complete penultimate-to-final intensity. SmallGround's first four tiny phases have stronger source-cell edge emphasis at higher scales, especially `0x10280`; review accepts their warm solid-core particle appearance, while recording tiny warm/brown losses and two adjacent tail additions. Both complete animation families retain source bounds, negative spaces and phase progression. LargeAir remains held for persistent painted ray and fading-ring losses. The new nine craft singles retain source arrays, machinery, forks, deck sections and dark hull backing, with precise small contour interpretations in their peer records. The alternate cursor retains all sixteen gold cells, thirty-six near-black cells and the nine-cell central hole, with warmer native gold shading accepted. Repeating texture connectors retain their source macro layout. Buoys retain exact native blink252/253 centers and the source's cyan/water240–244 palette classes; high-scale fringe and downward contour differences are accepted explicitly. BUTTON1–4 retains exact cyan glyph cells and the blank red panel. These are source-bound gallery approvals, without a new custom-menu or live Host reachability claim. + +The next 108 development frames were admitted in two exact batches: 50 frames in eight families, then 58 in eleven. The coordinator inspected every 35 complete source/native1/HD4 pages on ten unresampled boards; all 540 source and scaled PPMs match independently accepted references. The complete 1,037-frame rerender also matches every earlier reference. Original fallback detail density, low-scale contours and material interpretations remain documented rather than implied pixel-exactness. + +The next radar cohort preserves the authentic nine-cell circular assembly, mast, lower controls and index252 lamp at all four scales. Its 70 native contexts, 709 joins and 17 declared states produce 3,316 current composition checks. Nine damaged radar partners retain original fallback. The following cracked-ground cohort preserves branch routing, source rock counts and positions, and shallow divots. Corrected 40138 excludes the rejected foreign fissure; fine gravel and deeper crack contrast are accepted. Those two ground families declare no state partners, and their twelve unused IDs stay gallery-only. + +The four later tank families preserve distinct tread/slat/fork phases and stationary architecture. Every source cell survives at scales3–4; small native/2x contour loss and quantified stationary shading variance are accepted explicitly. The four later craft singles retain hulls, pods, forks and dark backing. One RGB4 upper-post corner in30098 rounds away at native1x and remains at2–4; its252/253 lamps retain exact1/4/9/16 coverage. + +The two repaired boss hulls retain their original asymmetric machinery and connected source structure. Boss10310's right disc, curved skirt and feet are continuous; its three remaining4x losses are two RGB4 corners and one isolated painted-gray rim cell(60,46), accepted after actual contour inspection. Boss200a3's y35 bridges and central dark body are fully restored, with remaining outer contour interpretations disclosed. The complete seven-phase EBOSS6 now retains final pale rectangular plates, horizontal central grille, narrow left slats and crossed lower floor pattern. The first six bindings and24 outputs remain unchanged. Fine final grain, rail pitch and frame-width differences are accepted rather than described as byte-stationary. Each former held main is preserved under its SHA before exact sibling promotion. + +Orange sparks preserve source warm rays, separated fragments and brown fade. Stronger outlined cell edges in101ab/ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; adjacent additions and three faint alpha16/17/19 crop specks in101a8 are accepted disclosures, with all meaningful alpha32 artwork retained. Difficulty portraits retain defining faces, glasses, visor, cigar and skull. Warmer painting and a shallow same-region helmet-tab interpretation are accepted, without an exact-hardware claim. TEXTURE10018 and both side trims retain authentic connectors, opposing rails and eight readable burgundy slots through repeated contexts. Stronger grain/edge contrast and threshold-sensitive brown highlights are accepted visual shading, without an exact red-RGB or zero-seam guarantee. + +LargeAir's newer v9 still remains held: repaired first/late pairs improve the earlier missing rays and rims, but middle101eb loses a connected seven-cell inner lip and101ec loses its five-cell upper shoulder, visibly changing source structure. Terrain10406 also remains held for interpreting organic ground as rigid rectangular slabs. Neither technical decoding nor opaque coverage admits those drafts. diff --git a/docs/hd-backlog.md b/docs/hd-backlog.md index 8ddec449..0a829623 100644 --- a/docs/hd-backlog.md +++ b/docs/hd-backlog.md @@ -1,17 +1,17 @@ # Original artwork HD backlog -The checked catalog contains **5,753 standalone picture frames**. The active local HD pack supplies **929**; **4,824** have no registered HD replacement. These counts include unnamed graphics outside `sprites/`. Scale2x/3x/4x filtering is crisp scaling, not a newly authored HD replacement. Authored mod SD/HD art is separate from this original-catalog audit. +The checked catalog contains **5,753 standalone picture frames**. The active local HD pack supplies **1,037**; **4,716** have no registered HD replacement. These counts include unnamed graphics outside `sprites/`. Scale2x/3x/4x filtering is crisp scaling, not a newly authored HD replacement. Authored mod SD/HD art is separate from this original-catalog audit. | Category | Picture frames | Registered HD | Missing HD | Declared sequences / terrain sets | | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | | Player banking | 21 | 21 | 0 | 3 | -| Bosses | 249 | 223 | 26 | 79 | -| Enemies and ground objects | 419 | 129 | 290 | 183 | +| Bosses | 249 | 232 | 17 | 79 | +| Enemies and ground objects | 419 | 148 | 271 | 183 | | Player and enemy projectiles | 51 | 45 | 6 | 18 | -| Explosions and effects | 281 | 155 | 126 | 25 | +| Explosions and effects | 281 | 164 | 117 | 25 | | Equipment and pickups | 47 | 47 | 0 | 23 | -| Terrain | 4,535 | 256 | 4,279 | 4 | -| Menus, portraits, HUD and other pictures | 150 | 53 | 97 | mixed static / animated | +| Terrain | 4,535 | 320 | 4,215 | 4 | +| Menus, portraits, HUD and other pictures | 150 | 60 | 90 | mixed static / animated | ## Registered pack and generation jobs @@ -396,6 +396,25 @@ Only registered frames passing canvas, source-hash, PNG and alpha checks count a | STEXTURE_PIC | `0x10019` | 1 / 1 | | EAGLE1G3_PIC | `0x30073` | 1 / 1 | | Small ground blast padded replacement v6 | `0x1027d` | 35 / 35 | +| Terrain set4 shard5 | `0x40115` | 16 / 16 | +| Terrain set4 shard6 | `0x40125` | 16 / 16 | +| TANK01G3_PIC | `0x30074` | 4 / 4 | +| TANK04G3_PIC | `0x30080` | 5 / 5 | +| TANK05G3_PIC | `0x30085` | 4 / 4 | +| TANK07G3_PIC | `0x3008b` | 2 / 2 | +| TEXTURE_PIC | `0x10018` | 1 / 1 | +| SIDETEXL_PIC / SIDETEXR_PIC | `0x50005` | 2 / 2 | +| Orange sparks padded replacement v3 | `0x101a5` | 9 / 9 | +| CDIF1_PIC / CDIF2_PIC / CDIF3_PIC / CDIF4_PIC | `0x1001a` | 4 / 4 | +| TANK10G3_PIC | `0x3008f` | 1 / 1 | +| TANK13G3_PIC | `0x30092` | 1 / 1 | +| DSHP03G3_PIC | `0x30095` | 1 / 1 | +| DSHP06G3_PIC | `0x30098` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain set4 shard7 | `0x40135` | 16 / 16 | +| Terrain set4 shard8 | `0x40145` | 16 / 16 | +| SHIP18G1_PIC faithful HD candidate | `0x10310` | 1 / 1 | +| SHIP12G2_PIC faithful HD candidate | `0x200a3` | 1 / 1 | +| EBOSS6_PIC faithful HD candidate | `0x400ac` | 7 / 7 | | Generation job | Status | | --- | --- | diff --git a/docs/hd-completion.json b/docs/hd-completion.json index 04671df0..aeca1fd9 100644 --- a/docs/hd-completion.json +++ b/docs/hd-completion.json @@ -19,11 +19,11 @@ ], "stage_contract": "Every generated candidate stays distinct from review, registration and render reachability. Original-only fallback is temporary for every required picture. Native cinematics/fonts have explicit preservation exceptions, not HD claims.", "picture_status_counts": { - "registered": 909, - "missing": 2135, - "candidate": 1589, - "inprogress": 1100, - "renderreachable": 20 + "registered": 1017, + "missing": 1975, + "inprogress": 1084, + "renderreachable": 20, + "candidate": 1657 }, "assets": { "10001": { @@ -4438,7 +4438,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10018", "family_id": "interface-other-10018-10018", "job_id": "interface-other-10018-10018", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_dark_player", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -4450,6 +4450,56 @@ "manifest": "jobs/interface-other-10018-10018/candidate.json", "sha256": "75fcc61b042e0f32ddc74908ebea40157cf2673b1968133e1e1f53f10600601e", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "75fcc61b042e0f32ddc74908ebea40157cf2673b1968133e1e1f53f10600601e", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a802f786dbb0ab01b14d7ad46344bd391bacacf6090a7f175f57b822f68d7da9", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:31.405721+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/interface-other-10018-10018/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"Original upper square housing and stepped circular inset keep their placement, left narrow recess and diagonal lower-right relief. The lower-left plate retains its three upper notch/recess runs and irregular partial corner plates continue at the original edges.\", \"Dark connecting channels and stepped diagonal/rectilinear lines keep the source arrangement. All4096 near-black or colored source cells remain occupied; there are no added alpha holes or palette240\\u2013255 classes at any actual scale.\", \"New scuffed/pitted gray-metal grain, scratches, fine bevel highlights and brown-rust patches are stronger than the flat subdued source. This higher contrast is explicitly accepted as coherent continuous material at2\\u20134 and legible original regions at1x; it is not RGB-identical preservation.\", \"Complete source and actual1\\u20134 three-by-three repeats plus full raw and native seam crops preserve macro channel continuity. No outer frame, seam-spanning gap, restored destroyed object or new bolt/light/sign was found. Fine grain changes across tile edges and authored structural edge transitions remain visible; no zero-seam metric is claimed.\"] [\"This is one static opaque texture, not an animation. Opacity/IoU are trivial coverage checks; internal source landmarks and full repeat-context visual inspection decide art fidelity.\", \"Independent edge-component means reproduce the author diagnostics: original V/H2.8958/2.3385, HD4 V/H6.7734/7.2773. These describe stronger micro-shading and do not establish or refute seam correctness on their own.\", \"Galeries and exact loading establish artwork fidelity only; the coordinator owns global admission and runtime-route completion.\"] {} All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-texture10018-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 516f010e03d4d4a040e9ef6ddcc09e80e767ad26882977191dd6129438407690", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "10018" + ], + "sha256": "c1bbbf25cf0ba68f456fe39cda8431c6ceb184eed1decf25ddb4a9d107d9c340", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10018-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6f29997c619f0a3d1eea38db3895dce789b7fedc3637e298dd6bf58196025b64", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-texture10018-independent-review/runtime/10018-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10018-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2f867375fe3a36b4c11d956d40482a751e761908ef1fd2f645e75038812f3c39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-texture10018-independent-review/runtime/10018-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10018-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "dcecdc2391b2051dcc671202f2b067f9f02211f1862e08980fa50c0174460cc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-texture10018-independent-review/runtime/10018-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10018-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5775f67a35184730ab584c010ccb65ede32ccf50d81a07d818c7be2615551c66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-texture10018-independent-review/runtime/10018-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10018-original.ppm", + "sha256": "91a7898d80d429d9c11a68b08a29d3eeaeb7ed8a1547589afcdd26adae45c9ea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-texture10018-independent-review/runtime/10018-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "10019": { @@ -4554,7 +4604,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1001a", "family_id": "interface-other-1001a-1001d", "job_id": "interface-other-1001a-1001d", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_dark_player", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -4566,6 +4616,134 @@ "manifest": "jobs/interface-other-1001a-1001d/candidate.json", "sha256": "2a66b6cd0e4ff3188cb2c48398200e3e8bc47ca29b7e809804f5b9114bda87e0", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "2a66b6cd0e4ff3188cb2c48398200e3e8bc47ca29b7e809804f5b9114bda87e0", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "5a5bdfdaed5303653c4515a6bd0847a4cb2980de82202e5fed306068fec99295", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.307246+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/interface-other-1001a-1001d/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"All four remasters intensify warm skin/hair or pale bone/metal highlights and change local shadows. Their classic subject/pose/identifying features and mechanical framing remain; exact original color-region masks and RGB identity are not claimed.\", \"The green helmet central mark is visibly more dimensional than the sparse original highlight. Its shallow raised-tab/underside-seam interpretation is accepted after independent source/native1\\u20134/fullraw inspection and is not certified as original hardware.\", \"Fine painted teeth, strands, skin, collars, visor reflections and skull pits are new authored detail; four static selection portraits are not an animation or moving-expression set.\"] [\"Approved: red-haired grinning pilot retains source head placement, broad ears, long nose, rectangular black clear-glass frames with cyan/pale lens highlights, teeth band and cropped dark collar. Source left shade/right highlight direction remains. New painted strands, individually shaded teeth and brighter warm skin accents are accepted fine detail, not exact original skin/hair RGB or feature-cell equality.\", \"Approved: unglassed red-haired pilot preserves source grin, teal eye locations, orange brows, long nose and face framing. Larger-scale blue-teal eye/pupil detail and warm cheek/forehead paint interpret the original sparse eye pixels without new glasses, beard, clothing or changed pose. Source directional shadows, ear positions and overall head/collar location remain identifiable.\", \"Approved with explicitly accepted material interpretation: original rounded green helmet, broad nearly-black visor, nose/grin and original lower-left lit cigar tip retain their placement and color identities. Helmet original central pale mark now reads as a shallow raised horizontal tab with thin dark shadow/seam and the existing vertical groove; this is not unchanged hardware or a pixel-exact flat highlight. It occupies the original central highlight/stripe region, adds no emblem/pin/strap or new silhouette, and remains restrained at actual native1\\u20134. The full source/1x/4x feature focus binds this judgment. Helmet right pale reflection, dark lens footprint and tiny tip remain recognizable.\", \"Approved: hooded ivory/ochre skull retains dark sockets with original paired red markers, pale stepped nasal/cheek/teeth geometry, black open mouth and asymmetric dark-left/pale-right hood. New painted bone pitting and hood-metal flecks are accepted inside the authentic framing; the square eye markers and mouth gap remain distinct at every actual scale. The more detailed hood and bone are material interpretation rather than exact palette RGB preservation.\"] [\"These are four different static difficulty faces encoded as consecutive lookup frames; no animation-phase or expression interpolation claim.\", \"Opaque maskIoU1 is trivial. Each576-cell canvas remains occupied at every scale, but face/feature/material fidelity was decided from all complete original/raw/native views.\", \"No exact source skin/hair/bone masks, glasses hardware area or micro-shading equality is claimed; accepted interpretations are explicit.\", \"Coordinator owns admission and runtime-route ledger; unrelated HANGP and boss200a2 holds and earlier reviewer proofs stay unchanged.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 6920ad1ca0eaa64940419615bdb3936fe9d453b329e38bd47900bdcd3171f7af", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "1001a", + "1001b", + "1001c", + "1001d" + ], + "sha256": "b5251d952d74525fd15104ea06e6ca3af0c093081a10ef7ad4c395474db1ee2c", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "1001a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "82e929475b351e805bbd2430d12c2c7a0ceddcdf3de9b132b143122d4d5db8b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a46bd8e7477a65eb038cdf5ecc55db287fee5cbde2639374b5769357c28184b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "79d7dacaaf9b8dd41eddd516b174d5f39b501e86abef95fee93afe88c2f996b6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4ced6913388fe690a779582955b3e06e2643c328f3f3eb5e402303ec65a08088", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dfdf61159d817956d22a9d824f0b5c247322eb155c2e0e7237be8e390a2fddf4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5d9c334bc313b51219510964c87e1acf9a68153a03283ad800c10494e8f8b5bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e2bf6fb19c10dd3405c545c75dc294c7ea4406228d4c3600a1acc089fa4fe16c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "55ddcc73f085583b575aea396bbd2abb335a763a0d93abdfebd6597d52de6e74", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d58212e049f4556293c8d8e640ee743b894a94a1f0f7f0c1ec16424b037339a7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ef4ee35f9f3b9b823821fc9d5c4867e4e907c389ecc12f42fd976dec147f60e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa1cd89f13ecbe52ceed3fb3cda7d49db2dde1a9dd99ef6abe219849518730d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "65b0eb2384dac5dfd6c521ad956eaa8e5d06eac363eb011eb0a5b0326c015769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b59e1263c609e5c62403fb01c5579df41c2f6002bf5ca10883e1d2d952867d6b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c085778cec6f39af3bd5b07a48d3679657112f0ff5512d09c2a70ace0d2766ee", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ae3a0b271a9a4e1ecace75908d989b8165ba9c6efbb0026b83ea662bee2150fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "99fe168d275f1185683cc5d2f60ab48d410ba368db10b705c50b693cc5b2e431", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7f2514cc13097772c27e0698369ca063d0b6ccfbec8b2920027f9a1850416df6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db1aeddab2054cdff5b199a9f4576efb62ed96dba527779ec11901403f5c38df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5d998df596d0c7c350337a9c7141dccd9ca5ae3afa9dd725983a77d6e3b18631", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ffe9b1ec1490ffe60a81ca611bbc3e90ea7119259db4cbbf48b83ab4dd4269a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001d-hd-4.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "1001b": { @@ -4587,7 +4765,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1001b", "family_id": "interface-other-1001a-1001d", "job_id": "interface-other-1001a-1001d", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_dark_player", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -4599,6 +4777,134 @@ "manifest": "jobs/interface-other-1001a-1001d/candidate.json", "sha256": "2a66b6cd0e4ff3188cb2c48398200e3e8bc47ca29b7e809804f5b9114bda87e0", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "2a66b6cd0e4ff3188cb2c48398200e3e8bc47ca29b7e809804f5b9114bda87e0", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "5a5bdfdaed5303653c4515a6bd0847a4cb2980de82202e5fed306068fec99295", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.307246+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/interface-other-1001a-1001d/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"All four remasters intensify warm skin/hair or pale bone/metal highlights and change local shadows. Their classic subject/pose/identifying features and mechanical framing remain; exact original color-region masks and RGB identity are not claimed.\", \"The green helmet central mark is visibly more dimensional than the sparse original highlight. Its shallow raised-tab/underside-seam interpretation is accepted after independent source/native1\\u20134/fullraw inspection and is not certified as original hardware.\", \"Fine painted teeth, strands, skin, collars, visor reflections and skull pits are new authored detail; four static selection portraits are not an animation or moving-expression set.\"] [\"Approved: red-haired grinning pilot retains source head placement, broad ears, long nose, rectangular black clear-glass frames with cyan/pale lens highlights, teeth band and cropped dark collar. Source left shade/right highlight direction remains. New painted strands, individually shaded teeth and brighter warm skin accents are accepted fine detail, not exact original skin/hair RGB or feature-cell equality.\", \"Approved: unglassed red-haired pilot preserves source grin, teal eye locations, orange brows, long nose and face framing. Larger-scale blue-teal eye/pupil detail and warm cheek/forehead paint interpret the original sparse eye pixels without new glasses, beard, clothing or changed pose. Source directional shadows, ear positions and overall head/collar location remain identifiable.\", \"Approved with explicitly accepted material interpretation: original rounded green helmet, broad nearly-black visor, nose/grin and original lower-left lit cigar tip retain their placement and color identities. Helmet original central pale mark now reads as a shallow raised horizontal tab with thin dark shadow/seam and the existing vertical groove; this is not unchanged hardware or a pixel-exact flat highlight. It occupies the original central highlight/stripe region, adds no emblem/pin/strap or new silhouette, and remains restrained at actual native1\\u20134. The full source/1x/4x feature focus binds this judgment. Helmet right pale reflection, dark lens footprint and tiny tip remain recognizable.\", \"Approved: hooded ivory/ochre skull retains dark sockets with original paired red markers, pale stepped nasal/cheek/teeth geometry, black open mouth and asymmetric dark-left/pale-right hood. New painted bone pitting and hood-metal flecks are accepted inside the authentic framing; the square eye markers and mouth gap remain distinct at every actual scale. The more detailed hood and bone are material interpretation rather than exact palette RGB preservation.\"] [\"These are four different static difficulty faces encoded as consecutive lookup frames; no animation-phase or expression interpolation claim.\", \"Opaque maskIoU1 is trivial. Each576-cell canvas remains occupied at every scale, but face/feature/material fidelity was decided from all complete original/raw/native views.\", \"No exact source skin/hair/bone masks, glasses hardware area or micro-shading equality is claimed; accepted interpretations are explicit.\", \"Coordinator owns admission and runtime-route ledger; unrelated HANGP and boss200a2 holds and earlier reviewer proofs stay unchanged.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 6920ad1ca0eaa64940419615bdb3936fe9d453b329e38bd47900bdcd3171f7af", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "1001a", + "1001b", + "1001c", + "1001d" + ], + "sha256": "b5251d952d74525fd15104ea06e6ca3af0c093081a10ef7ad4c395474db1ee2c", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "1001a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "82e929475b351e805bbd2430d12c2c7a0ceddcdf3de9b132b143122d4d5db8b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a46bd8e7477a65eb038cdf5ecc55db287fee5cbde2639374b5769357c28184b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "79d7dacaaf9b8dd41eddd516b174d5f39b501e86abef95fee93afe88c2f996b6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4ced6913388fe690a779582955b3e06e2643c328f3f3eb5e402303ec65a08088", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dfdf61159d817956d22a9d824f0b5c247322eb155c2e0e7237be8e390a2fddf4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5d9c334bc313b51219510964c87e1acf9a68153a03283ad800c10494e8f8b5bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e2bf6fb19c10dd3405c545c75dc294c7ea4406228d4c3600a1acc089fa4fe16c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "55ddcc73f085583b575aea396bbd2abb335a763a0d93abdfebd6597d52de6e74", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d58212e049f4556293c8d8e640ee743b894a94a1f0f7f0c1ec16424b037339a7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ef4ee35f9f3b9b823821fc9d5c4867e4e907c389ecc12f42fd976dec147f60e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa1cd89f13ecbe52ceed3fb3cda7d49db2dde1a9dd99ef6abe219849518730d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "65b0eb2384dac5dfd6c521ad956eaa8e5d06eac363eb011eb0a5b0326c015769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b59e1263c609e5c62403fb01c5579df41c2f6002bf5ca10883e1d2d952867d6b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c085778cec6f39af3bd5b07a48d3679657112f0ff5512d09c2a70ace0d2766ee", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ae3a0b271a9a4e1ecace75908d989b8165ba9c6efbb0026b83ea662bee2150fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "99fe168d275f1185683cc5d2f60ab48d410ba368db10b705c50b693cc5b2e431", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7f2514cc13097772c27e0698369ca063d0b6ccfbec8b2920027f9a1850416df6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db1aeddab2054cdff5b199a9f4576efb62ed96dba527779ec11901403f5c38df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5d998df596d0c7c350337a9c7141dccd9ca5ae3afa9dd725983a77d6e3b18631", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ffe9b1ec1490ffe60a81ca611bbc3e90ea7119259db4cbbf48b83ab4dd4269a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001d-hd-4.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "1001c": { @@ -4620,7 +4926,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1001c", "family_id": "interface-other-1001a-1001d", "job_id": "interface-other-1001a-1001d", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_dark_player", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -4632,6 +4938,134 @@ "manifest": "jobs/interface-other-1001a-1001d/candidate.json", "sha256": "2a66b6cd0e4ff3188cb2c48398200e3e8bc47ca29b7e809804f5b9114bda87e0", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "2a66b6cd0e4ff3188cb2c48398200e3e8bc47ca29b7e809804f5b9114bda87e0", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "5a5bdfdaed5303653c4515a6bd0847a4cb2980de82202e5fed306068fec99295", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.307246+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/interface-other-1001a-1001d/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"All four remasters intensify warm skin/hair or pale bone/metal highlights and change local shadows. Their classic subject/pose/identifying features and mechanical framing remain; exact original color-region masks and RGB identity are not claimed.\", \"The green helmet central mark is visibly more dimensional than the sparse original highlight. Its shallow raised-tab/underside-seam interpretation is accepted after independent source/native1\\u20134/fullraw inspection and is not certified as original hardware.\", \"Fine painted teeth, strands, skin, collars, visor reflections and skull pits are new authored detail; four static selection portraits are not an animation or moving-expression set.\"] [\"Approved: red-haired grinning pilot retains source head placement, broad ears, long nose, rectangular black clear-glass frames with cyan/pale lens highlights, teeth band and cropped dark collar. Source left shade/right highlight direction remains. New painted strands, individually shaded teeth and brighter warm skin accents are accepted fine detail, not exact original skin/hair RGB or feature-cell equality.\", \"Approved: unglassed red-haired pilot preserves source grin, teal eye locations, orange brows, long nose and face framing. Larger-scale blue-teal eye/pupil detail and warm cheek/forehead paint interpret the original sparse eye pixels without new glasses, beard, clothing or changed pose. Source directional shadows, ear positions and overall head/collar location remain identifiable.\", \"Approved with explicitly accepted material interpretation: original rounded green helmet, broad nearly-black visor, nose/grin and original lower-left lit cigar tip retain their placement and color identities. Helmet original central pale mark now reads as a shallow raised horizontal tab with thin dark shadow/seam and the existing vertical groove; this is not unchanged hardware or a pixel-exact flat highlight. It occupies the original central highlight/stripe region, adds no emblem/pin/strap or new silhouette, and remains restrained at actual native1\\u20134. The full source/1x/4x feature focus binds this judgment. Helmet right pale reflection, dark lens footprint and tiny tip remain recognizable.\", \"Approved: hooded ivory/ochre skull retains dark sockets with original paired red markers, pale stepped nasal/cheek/teeth geometry, black open mouth and asymmetric dark-left/pale-right hood. New painted bone pitting and hood-metal flecks are accepted inside the authentic framing; the square eye markers and mouth gap remain distinct at every actual scale. The more detailed hood and bone are material interpretation rather than exact palette RGB preservation.\"] [\"These are four different static difficulty faces encoded as consecutive lookup frames; no animation-phase or expression interpolation claim.\", \"Opaque maskIoU1 is trivial. Each576-cell canvas remains occupied at every scale, but face/feature/material fidelity was decided from all complete original/raw/native views.\", \"No exact source skin/hair/bone masks, glasses hardware area or micro-shading equality is claimed; accepted interpretations are explicit.\", \"Coordinator owns admission and runtime-route ledger; unrelated HANGP and boss200a2 holds and earlier reviewer proofs stay unchanged.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 6920ad1ca0eaa64940419615bdb3936fe9d453b329e38bd47900bdcd3171f7af", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "1001a", + "1001b", + "1001c", + "1001d" + ], + "sha256": "b5251d952d74525fd15104ea06e6ca3af0c093081a10ef7ad4c395474db1ee2c", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "1001a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "82e929475b351e805bbd2430d12c2c7a0ceddcdf3de9b132b143122d4d5db8b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a46bd8e7477a65eb038cdf5ecc55db287fee5cbde2639374b5769357c28184b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "79d7dacaaf9b8dd41eddd516b174d5f39b501e86abef95fee93afe88c2f996b6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4ced6913388fe690a779582955b3e06e2643c328f3f3eb5e402303ec65a08088", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dfdf61159d817956d22a9d824f0b5c247322eb155c2e0e7237be8e390a2fddf4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5d9c334bc313b51219510964c87e1acf9a68153a03283ad800c10494e8f8b5bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e2bf6fb19c10dd3405c545c75dc294c7ea4406228d4c3600a1acc089fa4fe16c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "55ddcc73f085583b575aea396bbd2abb335a763a0d93abdfebd6597d52de6e74", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d58212e049f4556293c8d8e640ee743b894a94a1f0f7f0c1ec16424b037339a7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ef4ee35f9f3b9b823821fc9d5c4867e4e907c389ecc12f42fd976dec147f60e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa1cd89f13ecbe52ceed3fb3cda7d49db2dde1a9dd99ef6abe219849518730d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "65b0eb2384dac5dfd6c521ad956eaa8e5d06eac363eb011eb0a5b0326c015769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b59e1263c609e5c62403fb01c5579df41c2f6002bf5ca10883e1d2d952867d6b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c085778cec6f39af3bd5b07a48d3679657112f0ff5512d09c2a70ace0d2766ee", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ae3a0b271a9a4e1ecace75908d989b8165ba9c6efbb0026b83ea662bee2150fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "99fe168d275f1185683cc5d2f60ab48d410ba368db10b705c50b693cc5b2e431", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7f2514cc13097772c27e0698369ca063d0b6ccfbec8b2920027f9a1850416df6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db1aeddab2054cdff5b199a9f4576efb62ed96dba527779ec11901403f5c38df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5d998df596d0c7c350337a9c7141dccd9ca5ae3afa9dd725983a77d6e3b18631", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ffe9b1ec1490ffe60a81ca611bbc3e90ea7119259db4cbbf48b83ab4dd4269a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001d-hd-4.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "1001d": { @@ -4653,7 +5087,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1001d", "family_id": "interface-other-1001a-1001d", "job_id": "interface-other-1001a-1001d", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_dark_player", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -4665,6 +5099,134 @@ "manifest": "jobs/interface-other-1001a-1001d/candidate.json", "sha256": "2a66b6cd0e4ff3188cb2c48398200e3e8bc47ca29b7e809804f5b9114bda87e0", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "2a66b6cd0e4ff3188cb2c48398200e3e8bc47ca29b7e809804f5b9114bda87e0", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "5a5bdfdaed5303653c4515a6bd0847a4cb2980de82202e5fed306068fec99295", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.307246+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/interface-other-1001a-1001d/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"All four remasters intensify warm skin/hair or pale bone/metal highlights and change local shadows. Their classic subject/pose/identifying features and mechanical framing remain; exact original color-region masks and RGB identity are not claimed.\", \"The green helmet central mark is visibly more dimensional than the sparse original highlight. Its shallow raised-tab/underside-seam interpretation is accepted after independent source/native1\\u20134/fullraw inspection and is not certified as original hardware.\", \"Fine painted teeth, strands, skin, collars, visor reflections and skull pits are new authored detail; four static selection portraits are not an animation or moving-expression set.\"] [\"Approved: red-haired grinning pilot retains source head placement, broad ears, long nose, rectangular black clear-glass frames with cyan/pale lens highlights, teeth band and cropped dark collar. Source left shade/right highlight direction remains. New painted strands, individually shaded teeth and brighter warm skin accents are accepted fine detail, not exact original skin/hair RGB or feature-cell equality.\", \"Approved: unglassed red-haired pilot preserves source grin, teal eye locations, orange brows, long nose and face framing. Larger-scale blue-teal eye/pupil detail and warm cheek/forehead paint interpret the original sparse eye pixels without new glasses, beard, clothing or changed pose. Source directional shadows, ear positions and overall head/collar location remain identifiable.\", \"Approved with explicitly accepted material interpretation: original rounded green helmet, broad nearly-black visor, nose/grin and original lower-left lit cigar tip retain their placement and color identities. Helmet original central pale mark now reads as a shallow raised horizontal tab with thin dark shadow/seam and the existing vertical groove; this is not unchanged hardware or a pixel-exact flat highlight. It occupies the original central highlight/stripe region, adds no emblem/pin/strap or new silhouette, and remains restrained at actual native1\\u20134. The full source/1x/4x feature focus binds this judgment. Helmet right pale reflection, dark lens footprint and tiny tip remain recognizable.\", \"Approved: hooded ivory/ochre skull retains dark sockets with original paired red markers, pale stepped nasal/cheek/teeth geometry, black open mouth and asymmetric dark-left/pale-right hood. New painted bone pitting and hood-metal flecks are accepted inside the authentic framing; the square eye markers and mouth gap remain distinct at every actual scale. The more detailed hood and bone are material interpretation rather than exact palette RGB preservation.\"] [\"These are four different static difficulty faces encoded as consecutive lookup frames; no animation-phase or expression interpolation claim.\", \"Opaque maskIoU1 is trivial. Each576-cell canvas remains occupied at every scale, but face/feature/material fidelity was decided from all complete original/raw/native views.\", \"No exact source skin/hair/bone masks, glasses hardware area or micro-shading equality is claimed; accepted interpretations are explicit.\", \"Coordinator owns admission and runtime-route ledger; unrelated HANGP and boss200a2 holds and earlier reviewer proofs stay unchanged.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 6920ad1ca0eaa64940419615bdb3936fe9d453b329e38bd47900bdcd3171f7af", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "1001a", + "1001b", + "1001c", + "1001d" + ], + "sha256": "b5251d952d74525fd15104ea06e6ca3af0c093081a10ef7ad4c395474db1ee2c", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "1001a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "82e929475b351e805bbd2430d12c2c7a0ceddcdf3de9b132b143122d4d5db8b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a46bd8e7477a65eb038cdf5ecc55db287fee5cbde2639374b5769357c28184b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "79d7dacaaf9b8dd41eddd516b174d5f39b501e86abef95fee93afe88c2f996b6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4ced6913388fe690a779582955b3e06e2643c328f3f3eb5e402303ec65a08088", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dfdf61159d817956d22a9d824f0b5c247322eb155c2e0e7237be8e390a2fddf4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5d9c334bc313b51219510964c87e1acf9a68153a03283ad800c10494e8f8b5bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e2bf6fb19c10dd3405c545c75dc294c7ea4406228d4c3600a1acc089fa4fe16c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "55ddcc73f085583b575aea396bbd2abb335a763a0d93abdfebd6597d52de6e74", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d58212e049f4556293c8d8e640ee743b894a94a1f0f7f0c1ec16424b037339a7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ef4ee35f9f3b9b823821fc9d5c4867e4e907c389ecc12f42fd976dec147f60e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa1cd89f13ecbe52ceed3fb3cda7d49db2dde1a9dd99ef6abe219849518730d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "65b0eb2384dac5dfd6c521ad956eaa8e5d06eac363eb011eb0a5b0326c015769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b59e1263c609e5c62403fb01c5579df41c2f6002bf5ca10883e1d2d952867d6b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c085778cec6f39af3bd5b07a48d3679657112f0ff5512d09c2a70ace0d2766ee", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ae3a0b271a9a4e1ecace75908d989b8165ba9c6efbb0026b83ea662bee2150fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "99fe168d275f1185683cc5d2f60ab48d410ba368db10b705c50b693cc5b2e431", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7f2514cc13097772c27e0698369ca063d0b6ccfbec8b2920027f9a1850416df6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db1aeddab2054cdff5b199a9f4576efb62ed96dba527779ec11901403f5c38df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5d998df596d0c7c350337a9c7141dccd9ca5ae3afa9dd725983a77d6e3b18631", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1001d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ffe9b1ec1490ffe60a81ca611bbc3e90ea7119259db4cbbf48b83ab4dd4269a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-difficulty-portraits-independent-review/runtime/1001d-hd-4.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "1001e": { @@ -16323,7 +16885,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101a5", "family_id": "effects-101a5-101ad", "job_id": "effects-101a5-101ad", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -16335,6 +16897,278 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101a5-101ad/candidate.json", "sha256": "9a84f7a47741d47b66cd6f34fce68e02f67ab8ba25b3b08a01d0841f277c05a1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "9a84f7a47741d47b66cd6f34fce68e02f67ab8ba25b3b08a01d0841f277c05a1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a893793764dd179f56949452b6b3c6aaa6f7ba95234f5c761e0c733b51178c70", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.243014+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101a5-101ad/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"All nine authentic original Catalog sources, the unchanged genuine v3 raw atlas, fresh actual Rust scales 1\\u20134, every native 2\\u20133 comparison and the complete ordered static fade sequence were independently inspected. Every padded generator reference is the authentic decoded source plus disclosed transparent padding. The 16\\u00d716 logical canvases, origins and native occupied extrema are retained.\", \"The first frame remains the source narrow nine-cell warm patch. Particle locations, disconnected sparse fragments and development into the wider burst remain source-aligned. No whole occupied source cell is absent at any of the four scales; partial high-scale edge coverage is documented per frame instead of being described as exact silhouettes. Fine matte orange/rust grain is visibly authored in the actual 3\\u00d7 and 4\\u00d7 results; all 36 actual HD outputs differ from original nearest-neighbor RGB pixels.\", \"Stronger outlined source-cell edges occur at 4\\u00d7, particularly 101ab and 101ad. They are conspicuous in diagnostic magnification and remain a local style difference at the actual 64\\u00d764 canvas size. At that actual presentation size the fragments still read as warm orange/brown sparks, not metallic tiled panels, luminous ivory veins or a different object. This exact emphasis is accepted as a disclosed material caveat, based on inspected current pixels rather than native IoU alone.\", \"Native occupancy changes are 9\\u21929, 26\\u219227, 45\\u219247, 41\\u219242, 28\\u219229, 17\\u219220, 18\\u219219, 22\\u219222 and 11\\u219213 across 101a5\\u2013101ad. The three added 101aa cells lie at (2,7), (6,9), (4,15); the two added 101ad cells lie at (5,14), (12,14). The annotated comparisons place them beside existing fragments or in a local body gap, without an independent new particle or changed native bounds. These adjacent expansions, including the lower native IoU of the sparsest late phases, are explicitly accepted and remain documented.\", \"The raw and actual outputs preserve the warm orange/rust-to-dim-brown phase character. They do not introduce white or ivory veins, halos, new rays or an artificial final bright burst. The source itself is not strictly monotonic: 101ab briefly has more light than 101aa. Actual occupied mean brightness is mostly slightly lower, but larger fine edge coverage increases logical-area-normalized total luminance in most later phases; this difference is retained, not called identical brightness. Final 101ad occupied mean luma is 48.7 versus source 60.9, while normalized total is 945.9 versus 670.4. The actual full-size final frame still reads as dim brown sparse fragments.\", \"All selected square source-aspect crops retain every raw pixel with alpha at least 32, 64, 128 and 255 within its own atlas cell. The 101a8 crop alone excludes three faint fringe specks with alpha 17, 16 and 19 at atlas coordinates (295,686), (295,687), (295,688); the exact RGBA values are bound below. This is a disclosed low-opacity crop-margin caveat, not a false zero-alpha\\u226516 claim. The actual indexed loader uses a 128 cutoff after resizing. No meaningful opaque source-aligned contour is cut, and no raw pixels, crop metadata or shader were changed for this review.\", \"Actual indexed original and HD palette counts contain no reserved indices 240\\u2013255. All occupied-source palette-class and forced-index checks pass. Authenticated original binary/RGBA/palette/INDEX bytes, exact frame/crop bindings and immutable library/probe identities are bound. The raw is byte-identical to the original builtin imagegen file; prompt, preparation, references, generation attempts and provenance are separately hashed.\", \"Both runtime freshness guards were false at the actual render invocation, and the indexed invocation recorded an unchanged source snapshot. Our current immutable library is 0ec6137e0e3261e813b2b863cd96c04da55e07cdf29b5c10b1d112e20f0a3daf. All 45 PPMs, nine originals plus 36 actual scales 1\\u20134, are byte-identical to the frozen owner proof using 409b38ea7760734201caf6dfbdd1d08c77ed903c18d7d7450dcd964b1a81fc39. This establishes current output continuity without pretending that the owner proof used our newer library.\", \"Historical v1 held_brightness and v2 held_raw_geometry_brightness remain unchanged and held as their historical versions. The independent approval applies only to the exact submitted v3 candidate and its unchanged raw/bindings. Every one of the 141 frozen author files was verified unchanged at closure. The earlier accepted MediumAir13 and SmallGround35 report hashes were verified unchanged.\", \"This is source/material/crop/palette/loader and complete static phase presentation approval only. No live Host occurrence, effect cadence, compositor timing, live palette fade, final 1080p SDL scene, simulation, collision or RNG behavior was exercised or inferred. Production admission is exclusively the HD coordinator\\u2019s decision and remains separate from the closed 800-frame checkpoint.\"] \"No Host, live timing, reachability, compositor, palette-fade or 1080p acceptance claim. A future engine change requires current output continuity proof separately.\" [{\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 686], \"RGBA\": [120, 60, 15, 17]}, {\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 687], \"RGBA\": [127, 63, 15, 16]}, {\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 688], \"RGBA\": [120, 67, 13, 19]}] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/independent-review.json, SHA256 9eccf362c3030701ed66d9f5cafc800c417641ac9c3cc8c2c3180630c8d9187c", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101a5", + "101a6", + "101a7", + "101a8" + ], + "sha256": "0d03279051ab2742dbf22368ce2213743f10db8795662c979a3f0e8481d1894d", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101a9", + "101aa", + "101ab", + "101ac" + ], + "sha256": "f9ea76b45d46711d9ca433b8e6cdc7c441e5507e636c388d2f40edbc5bdae033", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ad" + ], + "sha256": "150630e51d745e2b1af7226c28f11ba6a1c71e4bfd83bed0c42a0372475403ff", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101a5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0814c4019a4abc0a70e35d4ff15a205015055cebae968b85765fa951ded4d4fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cb6c60be80d483c171ecbb6b924ebc411134343c0a9615d4303e5e4c42c8c8f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "76bc2033132cf13cbbe2c8d7c1a44c81596c196287e3882c258ab19cda879466", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "947e90d905ac58798fdbb93523483a4c7ecefc1b20a857b39834d731b3a1766c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b62ddde5fe31a72112683a3bee45ea58384c50ee95b44a418ba54eb78f1361dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "751043c9bdf21414a00f712b26bccd2c1ed51d533ee3c09f64e5ca96229d75f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b24d51f5113cce9f08168e13c60688c3ebbfa645f140bfb11bf94727e6a2fc06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ad3354c19d7bfa3d533efd656f377f5b7b04beb25c17572af68cf2e5426f45d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5647e851bae4d375e45fbd2d407ba591a3a8a9510eef30542982dc372210dd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eaa858087535efb28717f573d16104fc6e16b38d4f04060b4e92ed2f45a793b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c5abe050d44059c272da0bfcdf11191034a6b920eec9b699c716512baf6e18d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b7b4fbbf3ee582ec6afee56bb732886dcc743f731a10b95a49e73a404d70c51a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1232f9b9c2105c73b243dfdf96f148e722e171672c0426ed8946d05add88fcf4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ef74a7d86dcf335ef163680cdde22edff1d05a9f0b13e2f5ee01e966ea6c274", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0a99e38cc58bf02a45d5c966e5d45f7f66446875f5d4eb719bce424bd2d943d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d2d2f5de5603297b2f21f05bdd89f655c98b597315f8920f39cff1dc4de43341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "82d2793a721aae8efda5d37a132ddd2e0f533af54776059f37776e1d4342ef93", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a68199be50cef1592115a161febc9a7adc7ecba060d7dcde4333f67ee67c71e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "22f4e78d12cbfdaf4dfe47722aecb991e53d8fc5d2b08d8e8b68639b71b512fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39669071ac802ad6323f1153ba78f1b9899f7180471217146be3dea4fb4cbdcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7534837245eab1316ff0b9fc8a7f66bdb1940c3e68a0b5a5979e817c600fd815", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2f68e67347216fd1b4596a0856386e62df75f72b44b83f3db4b5c558d61cb323", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "abcb99f8a77e6041351d0481cd5cf048a6c8faa818f605e29e5ed53713a9299d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "246f653cb975094ac1be085528c0f8a811cc38f7403ff993e6a2694539033c69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8a463405eecdae5954dfec86fdf59d119f4242b6848aebeb890aa547fffa0ec6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "367e917da7cf5034bf89e37d59ec59dc9c977d488ed813782ceb80c5ab1656c1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d1c963203e8901479cec6b2534fd1cfa2afe70d57438b335078c8148619084d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6dc6a854736b065e78f1d77567a58bcbd5142f5105092794b3b3580da3344cac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4058f39c3a06f31d3a3cecd6827c7fb6a5efa7b86e2541fb19fbb151f934d026", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bb7e8ffdf0f2a3138784534ce20231b45d98e0a5732c836bcc02c0a546c66934", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e190e1089192b1ea824aba7c25842cfafaf1f83d00461e0cb8a23d736ab6235b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "50255049acdebbee4917bfc9787cb79db54088853fe08beab04331a797b59974", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9b13226dafbc76229fb6bd60ed702433308c16e038c7a40e8a70eab660884a34", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "110158f6fc9fa87bad18727e2089a621979c8a4aa6103d2f69f73e502def4d9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa0a27e7ed7d7347aa3767dc9824be5cf14f7f6103db2af8cfa35d24b67c2837", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3c79854593cb1bd811f02dfb376a879357265787edf2ba1bd23b376e2ecdb9bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c76c6d1246bd18a22296d621e726b3454b4117941ec250fdc943e79fb247c69c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb8ef3ccf5ddd0c769b56bad3851eb8e07c13589a879ede64443b3f7431aa044", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a42484d4748505f7c56f521145cab11a74ab42abd12a7c50bbabf44391745a55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9dac55e6ab8fd5ebae29bd64acfd3662175f0df65673bb8301fb7829703e9ff8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8e953f7cbe098fa150300c58d5c00ae94ce0dc7c8c39294305a5e6b478850e41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dff718058528cf477ca0a53116e0042f93ebff44351bfdc3e7d30c5b11217e9c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17ffb3e9b3888b05175ee3e35cdf4be9fbff8a52c0ae90cf8aba8838dfdb73fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "70599b40d0306a114a2431065047f7b1658514a5d2307d08c57e8516fe265cbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bb62feab87345b9736844381e6d9d06244ecc9f80141d66e568db8b4ab9074d9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101a6": { @@ -16356,7 +17190,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101a6", "family_id": "effects-101a5-101ad", "job_id": "effects-101a5-101ad", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -16368,6 +17202,278 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101a5-101ad/candidate.json", "sha256": "9a84f7a47741d47b66cd6f34fce68e02f67ab8ba25b3b08a01d0841f277c05a1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "9a84f7a47741d47b66cd6f34fce68e02f67ab8ba25b3b08a01d0841f277c05a1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a893793764dd179f56949452b6b3c6aaa6f7ba95234f5c761e0c733b51178c70", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.243014+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101a5-101ad/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"All nine authentic original Catalog sources, the unchanged genuine v3 raw atlas, fresh actual Rust scales 1\\u20134, every native 2\\u20133 comparison and the complete ordered static fade sequence were independently inspected. Every padded generator reference is the authentic decoded source plus disclosed transparent padding. The 16\\u00d716 logical canvases, origins and native occupied extrema are retained.\", \"The first frame remains the source narrow nine-cell warm patch. Particle locations, disconnected sparse fragments and development into the wider burst remain source-aligned. No whole occupied source cell is absent at any of the four scales; partial high-scale edge coverage is documented per frame instead of being described as exact silhouettes. Fine matte orange/rust grain is visibly authored in the actual 3\\u00d7 and 4\\u00d7 results; all 36 actual HD outputs differ from original nearest-neighbor RGB pixels.\", \"Stronger outlined source-cell edges occur at 4\\u00d7, particularly 101ab and 101ad. They are conspicuous in diagnostic magnification and remain a local style difference at the actual 64\\u00d764 canvas size. At that actual presentation size the fragments still read as warm orange/brown sparks, not metallic tiled panels, luminous ivory veins or a different object. This exact emphasis is accepted as a disclosed material caveat, based on inspected current pixels rather than native IoU alone.\", \"Native occupancy changes are 9\\u21929, 26\\u219227, 45\\u219247, 41\\u219242, 28\\u219229, 17\\u219220, 18\\u219219, 22\\u219222 and 11\\u219213 across 101a5\\u2013101ad. The three added 101aa cells lie at (2,7), (6,9), (4,15); the two added 101ad cells lie at (5,14), (12,14). The annotated comparisons place them beside existing fragments or in a local body gap, without an independent new particle or changed native bounds. These adjacent expansions, including the lower native IoU of the sparsest late phases, are explicitly accepted and remain documented.\", \"The raw and actual outputs preserve the warm orange/rust-to-dim-brown phase character. They do not introduce white or ivory veins, halos, new rays or an artificial final bright burst. The source itself is not strictly monotonic: 101ab briefly has more light than 101aa. Actual occupied mean brightness is mostly slightly lower, but larger fine edge coverage increases logical-area-normalized total luminance in most later phases; this difference is retained, not called identical brightness. Final 101ad occupied mean luma is 48.7 versus source 60.9, while normalized total is 945.9 versus 670.4. The actual full-size final frame still reads as dim brown sparse fragments.\", \"All selected square source-aspect crops retain every raw pixel with alpha at least 32, 64, 128 and 255 within its own atlas cell. The 101a8 crop alone excludes three faint fringe specks with alpha 17, 16 and 19 at atlas coordinates (295,686), (295,687), (295,688); the exact RGBA values are bound below. This is a disclosed low-opacity crop-margin caveat, not a false zero-alpha\\u226516 claim. The actual indexed loader uses a 128 cutoff after resizing. No meaningful opaque source-aligned contour is cut, and no raw pixels, crop metadata or shader were changed for this review.\", \"Actual indexed original and HD palette counts contain no reserved indices 240\\u2013255. All occupied-source palette-class and forced-index checks pass. Authenticated original binary/RGBA/palette/INDEX bytes, exact frame/crop bindings and immutable library/probe identities are bound. The raw is byte-identical to the original builtin imagegen file; prompt, preparation, references, generation attempts and provenance are separately hashed.\", \"Both runtime freshness guards were false at the actual render invocation, and the indexed invocation recorded an unchanged source snapshot. Our current immutable library is 0ec6137e0e3261e813b2b863cd96c04da55e07cdf29b5c10b1d112e20f0a3daf. All 45 PPMs, nine originals plus 36 actual scales 1\\u20134, are byte-identical to the frozen owner proof using 409b38ea7760734201caf6dfbdd1d08c77ed903c18d7d7450dcd964b1a81fc39. This establishes current output continuity without pretending that the owner proof used our newer library.\", \"Historical v1 held_brightness and v2 held_raw_geometry_brightness remain unchanged and held as their historical versions. The independent approval applies only to the exact submitted v3 candidate and its unchanged raw/bindings. Every one of the 141 frozen author files was verified unchanged at closure. The earlier accepted MediumAir13 and SmallGround35 report hashes were verified unchanged.\", \"This is source/material/crop/palette/loader and complete static phase presentation approval only. No live Host occurrence, effect cadence, compositor timing, live palette fade, final 1080p SDL scene, simulation, collision or RNG behavior was exercised or inferred. Production admission is exclusively the HD coordinator\\u2019s decision and remains separate from the closed 800-frame checkpoint.\"] \"No Host, live timing, reachability, compositor, palette-fade or 1080p acceptance claim. A future engine change requires current output continuity proof separately.\" [{\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 686], \"RGBA\": [120, 60, 15, 17]}, {\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 687], \"RGBA\": [127, 63, 15, 16]}, {\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 688], \"RGBA\": [120, 67, 13, 19]}] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/independent-review.json, SHA256 9eccf362c3030701ed66d9f5cafc800c417641ac9c3cc8c2c3180630c8d9187c", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101a5", + "101a6", + "101a7", + "101a8" + ], + "sha256": "0d03279051ab2742dbf22368ce2213743f10db8795662c979a3f0e8481d1894d", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101a9", + "101aa", + "101ab", + "101ac" + ], + "sha256": "f9ea76b45d46711d9ca433b8e6cdc7c441e5507e636c388d2f40edbc5bdae033", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ad" + ], + "sha256": "150630e51d745e2b1af7226c28f11ba6a1c71e4bfd83bed0c42a0372475403ff", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101a5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0814c4019a4abc0a70e35d4ff15a205015055cebae968b85765fa951ded4d4fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cb6c60be80d483c171ecbb6b924ebc411134343c0a9615d4303e5e4c42c8c8f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "76bc2033132cf13cbbe2c8d7c1a44c81596c196287e3882c258ab19cda879466", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "947e90d905ac58798fdbb93523483a4c7ecefc1b20a857b39834d731b3a1766c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b62ddde5fe31a72112683a3bee45ea58384c50ee95b44a418ba54eb78f1361dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "751043c9bdf21414a00f712b26bccd2c1ed51d533ee3c09f64e5ca96229d75f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b24d51f5113cce9f08168e13c60688c3ebbfa645f140bfb11bf94727e6a2fc06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ad3354c19d7bfa3d533efd656f377f5b7b04beb25c17572af68cf2e5426f45d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5647e851bae4d375e45fbd2d407ba591a3a8a9510eef30542982dc372210dd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eaa858087535efb28717f573d16104fc6e16b38d4f04060b4e92ed2f45a793b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c5abe050d44059c272da0bfcdf11191034a6b920eec9b699c716512baf6e18d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b7b4fbbf3ee582ec6afee56bb732886dcc743f731a10b95a49e73a404d70c51a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1232f9b9c2105c73b243dfdf96f148e722e171672c0426ed8946d05add88fcf4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ef74a7d86dcf335ef163680cdde22edff1d05a9f0b13e2f5ee01e966ea6c274", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0a99e38cc58bf02a45d5c966e5d45f7f66446875f5d4eb719bce424bd2d943d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d2d2f5de5603297b2f21f05bdd89f655c98b597315f8920f39cff1dc4de43341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "82d2793a721aae8efda5d37a132ddd2e0f533af54776059f37776e1d4342ef93", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a68199be50cef1592115a161febc9a7adc7ecba060d7dcde4333f67ee67c71e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "22f4e78d12cbfdaf4dfe47722aecb991e53d8fc5d2b08d8e8b68639b71b512fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39669071ac802ad6323f1153ba78f1b9899f7180471217146be3dea4fb4cbdcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7534837245eab1316ff0b9fc8a7f66bdb1940c3e68a0b5a5979e817c600fd815", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2f68e67347216fd1b4596a0856386e62df75f72b44b83f3db4b5c558d61cb323", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "abcb99f8a77e6041351d0481cd5cf048a6c8faa818f605e29e5ed53713a9299d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "246f653cb975094ac1be085528c0f8a811cc38f7403ff993e6a2694539033c69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8a463405eecdae5954dfec86fdf59d119f4242b6848aebeb890aa547fffa0ec6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "367e917da7cf5034bf89e37d59ec59dc9c977d488ed813782ceb80c5ab1656c1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d1c963203e8901479cec6b2534fd1cfa2afe70d57438b335078c8148619084d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6dc6a854736b065e78f1d77567a58bcbd5142f5105092794b3b3580da3344cac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4058f39c3a06f31d3a3cecd6827c7fb6a5efa7b86e2541fb19fbb151f934d026", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bb7e8ffdf0f2a3138784534ce20231b45d98e0a5732c836bcc02c0a546c66934", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e190e1089192b1ea824aba7c25842cfafaf1f83d00461e0cb8a23d736ab6235b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "50255049acdebbee4917bfc9787cb79db54088853fe08beab04331a797b59974", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9b13226dafbc76229fb6bd60ed702433308c16e038c7a40e8a70eab660884a34", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "110158f6fc9fa87bad18727e2089a621979c8a4aa6103d2f69f73e502def4d9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa0a27e7ed7d7347aa3767dc9824be5cf14f7f6103db2af8cfa35d24b67c2837", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3c79854593cb1bd811f02dfb376a879357265787edf2ba1bd23b376e2ecdb9bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c76c6d1246bd18a22296d621e726b3454b4117941ec250fdc943e79fb247c69c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb8ef3ccf5ddd0c769b56bad3851eb8e07c13589a879ede64443b3f7431aa044", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a42484d4748505f7c56f521145cab11a74ab42abd12a7c50bbabf44391745a55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9dac55e6ab8fd5ebae29bd64acfd3662175f0df65673bb8301fb7829703e9ff8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8e953f7cbe098fa150300c58d5c00ae94ce0dc7c8c39294305a5e6b478850e41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dff718058528cf477ca0a53116e0042f93ebff44351bfdc3e7d30c5b11217e9c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17ffb3e9b3888b05175ee3e35cdf4be9fbff8a52c0ae90cf8aba8838dfdb73fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "70599b40d0306a114a2431065047f7b1658514a5d2307d08c57e8516fe265cbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bb62feab87345b9736844381e6d9d06244ecc9f80141d66e568db8b4ab9074d9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101a7": { @@ -16389,7 +17495,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101a7", "family_id": "effects-101a5-101ad", "job_id": "effects-101a5-101ad", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -16401,6 +17507,278 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101a5-101ad/candidate.json", "sha256": "9a84f7a47741d47b66cd6f34fce68e02f67ab8ba25b3b08a01d0841f277c05a1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "9a84f7a47741d47b66cd6f34fce68e02f67ab8ba25b3b08a01d0841f277c05a1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a893793764dd179f56949452b6b3c6aaa6f7ba95234f5c761e0c733b51178c70", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.243014+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101a5-101ad/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"All nine authentic original Catalog sources, the unchanged genuine v3 raw atlas, fresh actual Rust scales 1\\u20134, every native 2\\u20133 comparison and the complete ordered static fade sequence were independently inspected. Every padded generator reference is the authentic decoded source plus disclosed transparent padding. The 16\\u00d716 logical canvases, origins and native occupied extrema are retained.\", \"The first frame remains the source narrow nine-cell warm patch. Particle locations, disconnected sparse fragments and development into the wider burst remain source-aligned. No whole occupied source cell is absent at any of the four scales; partial high-scale edge coverage is documented per frame instead of being described as exact silhouettes. Fine matte orange/rust grain is visibly authored in the actual 3\\u00d7 and 4\\u00d7 results; all 36 actual HD outputs differ from original nearest-neighbor RGB pixels.\", \"Stronger outlined source-cell edges occur at 4\\u00d7, particularly 101ab and 101ad. They are conspicuous in diagnostic magnification and remain a local style difference at the actual 64\\u00d764 canvas size. At that actual presentation size the fragments still read as warm orange/brown sparks, not metallic tiled panels, luminous ivory veins or a different object. This exact emphasis is accepted as a disclosed material caveat, based on inspected current pixels rather than native IoU alone.\", \"Native occupancy changes are 9\\u21929, 26\\u219227, 45\\u219247, 41\\u219242, 28\\u219229, 17\\u219220, 18\\u219219, 22\\u219222 and 11\\u219213 across 101a5\\u2013101ad. The three added 101aa cells lie at (2,7), (6,9), (4,15); the two added 101ad cells lie at (5,14), (12,14). The annotated comparisons place them beside existing fragments or in a local body gap, without an independent new particle or changed native bounds. These adjacent expansions, including the lower native IoU of the sparsest late phases, are explicitly accepted and remain documented.\", \"The raw and actual outputs preserve the warm orange/rust-to-dim-brown phase character. They do not introduce white or ivory veins, halos, new rays or an artificial final bright burst. The source itself is not strictly monotonic: 101ab briefly has more light than 101aa. Actual occupied mean brightness is mostly slightly lower, but larger fine edge coverage increases logical-area-normalized total luminance in most later phases; this difference is retained, not called identical brightness. Final 101ad occupied mean luma is 48.7 versus source 60.9, while normalized total is 945.9 versus 670.4. The actual full-size final frame still reads as dim brown sparse fragments.\", \"All selected square source-aspect crops retain every raw pixel with alpha at least 32, 64, 128 and 255 within its own atlas cell. The 101a8 crop alone excludes three faint fringe specks with alpha 17, 16 and 19 at atlas coordinates (295,686), (295,687), (295,688); the exact RGBA values are bound below. This is a disclosed low-opacity crop-margin caveat, not a false zero-alpha\\u226516 claim. The actual indexed loader uses a 128 cutoff after resizing. No meaningful opaque source-aligned contour is cut, and no raw pixels, crop metadata or shader were changed for this review.\", \"Actual indexed original and HD palette counts contain no reserved indices 240\\u2013255. All occupied-source palette-class and forced-index checks pass. Authenticated original binary/RGBA/palette/INDEX bytes, exact frame/crop bindings and immutable library/probe identities are bound. The raw is byte-identical to the original builtin imagegen file; prompt, preparation, references, generation attempts and provenance are separately hashed.\", \"Both runtime freshness guards were false at the actual render invocation, and the indexed invocation recorded an unchanged source snapshot. Our current immutable library is 0ec6137e0e3261e813b2b863cd96c04da55e07cdf29b5c10b1d112e20f0a3daf. All 45 PPMs, nine originals plus 36 actual scales 1\\u20134, are byte-identical to the frozen owner proof using 409b38ea7760734201caf6dfbdd1d08c77ed903c18d7d7450dcd964b1a81fc39. This establishes current output continuity without pretending that the owner proof used our newer library.\", \"Historical v1 held_brightness and v2 held_raw_geometry_brightness remain unchanged and held as their historical versions. The independent approval applies only to the exact submitted v3 candidate and its unchanged raw/bindings. Every one of the 141 frozen author files was verified unchanged at closure. The earlier accepted MediumAir13 and SmallGround35 report hashes were verified unchanged.\", \"This is source/material/crop/palette/loader and complete static phase presentation approval only. No live Host occurrence, effect cadence, compositor timing, live palette fade, final 1080p SDL scene, simulation, collision or RNG behavior was exercised or inferred. Production admission is exclusively the HD coordinator\\u2019s decision and remains separate from the closed 800-frame checkpoint.\"] \"No Host, live timing, reachability, compositor, palette-fade or 1080p acceptance claim. A future engine change requires current output continuity proof separately.\" [{\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 686], \"RGBA\": [120, 60, 15, 17]}, {\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 687], \"RGBA\": [127, 63, 15, 16]}, {\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 688], \"RGBA\": [120, 67, 13, 19]}] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/independent-review.json, SHA256 9eccf362c3030701ed66d9f5cafc800c417641ac9c3cc8c2c3180630c8d9187c", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101a5", + "101a6", + "101a7", + "101a8" + ], + "sha256": "0d03279051ab2742dbf22368ce2213743f10db8795662c979a3f0e8481d1894d", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101a9", + "101aa", + "101ab", + "101ac" + ], + "sha256": "f9ea76b45d46711d9ca433b8e6cdc7c441e5507e636c388d2f40edbc5bdae033", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ad" + ], + "sha256": "150630e51d745e2b1af7226c28f11ba6a1c71e4bfd83bed0c42a0372475403ff", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101a5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0814c4019a4abc0a70e35d4ff15a205015055cebae968b85765fa951ded4d4fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cb6c60be80d483c171ecbb6b924ebc411134343c0a9615d4303e5e4c42c8c8f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "76bc2033132cf13cbbe2c8d7c1a44c81596c196287e3882c258ab19cda879466", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "947e90d905ac58798fdbb93523483a4c7ecefc1b20a857b39834d731b3a1766c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b62ddde5fe31a72112683a3bee45ea58384c50ee95b44a418ba54eb78f1361dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "751043c9bdf21414a00f712b26bccd2c1ed51d533ee3c09f64e5ca96229d75f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b24d51f5113cce9f08168e13c60688c3ebbfa645f140bfb11bf94727e6a2fc06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ad3354c19d7bfa3d533efd656f377f5b7b04beb25c17572af68cf2e5426f45d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5647e851bae4d375e45fbd2d407ba591a3a8a9510eef30542982dc372210dd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eaa858087535efb28717f573d16104fc6e16b38d4f04060b4e92ed2f45a793b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c5abe050d44059c272da0bfcdf11191034a6b920eec9b699c716512baf6e18d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b7b4fbbf3ee582ec6afee56bb732886dcc743f731a10b95a49e73a404d70c51a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1232f9b9c2105c73b243dfdf96f148e722e171672c0426ed8946d05add88fcf4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ef74a7d86dcf335ef163680cdde22edff1d05a9f0b13e2f5ee01e966ea6c274", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0a99e38cc58bf02a45d5c966e5d45f7f66446875f5d4eb719bce424bd2d943d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d2d2f5de5603297b2f21f05bdd89f655c98b597315f8920f39cff1dc4de43341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "82d2793a721aae8efda5d37a132ddd2e0f533af54776059f37776e1d4342ef93", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a68199be50cef1592115a161febc9a7adc7ecba060d7dcde4333f67ee67c71e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "22f4e78d12cbfdaf4dfe47722aecb991e53d8fc5d2b08d8e8b68639b71b512fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39669071ac802ad6323f1153ba78f1b9899f7180471217146be3dea4fb4cbdcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7534837245eab1316ff0b9fc8a7f66bdb1940c3e68a0b5a5979e817c600fd815", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2f68e67347216fd1b4596a0856386e62df75f72b44b83f3db4b5c558d61cb323", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "abcb99f8a77e6041351d0481cd5cf048a6c8faa818f605e29e5ed53713a9299d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "246f653cb975094ac1be085528c0f8a811cc38f7403ff993e6a2694539033c69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8a463405eecdae5954dfec86fdf59d119f4242b6848aebeb890aa547fffa0ec6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "367e917da7cf5034bf89e37d59ec59dc9c977d488ed813782ceb80c5ab1656c1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d1c963203e8901479cec6b2534fd1cfa2afe70d57438b335078c8148619084d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6dc6a854736b065e78f1d77567a58bcbd5142f5105092794b3b3580da3344cac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4058f39c3a06f31d3a3cecd6827c7fb6a5efa7b86e2541fb19fbb151f934d026", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bb7e8ffdf0f2a3138784534ce20231b45d98e0a5732c836bcc02c0a546c66934", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e190e1089192b1ea824aba7c25842cfafaf1f83d00461e0cb8a23d736ab6235b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "50255049acdebbee4917bfc9787cb79db54088853fe08beab04331a797b59974", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9b13226dafbc76229fb6bd60ed702433308c16e038c7a40e8a70eab660884a34", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "110158f6fc9fa87bad18727e2089a621979c8a4aa6103d2f69f73e502def4d9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa0a27e7ed7d7347aa3767dc9824be5cf14f7f6103db2af8cfa35d24b67c2837", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3c79854593cb1bd811f02dfb376a879357265787edf2ba1bd23b376e2ecdb9bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c76c6d1246bd18a22296d621e726b3454b4117941ec250fdc943e79fb247c69c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb8ef3ccf5ddd0c769b56bad3851eb8e07c13589a879ede64443b3f7431aa044", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a42484d4748505f7c56f521145cab11a74ab42abd12a7c50bbabf44391745a55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9dac55e6ab8fd5ebae29bd64acfd3662175f0df65673bb8301fb7829703e9ff8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8e953f7cbe098fa150300c58d5c00ae94ce0dc7c8c39294305a5e6b478850e41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dff718058528cf477ca0a53116e0042f93ebff44351bfdc3e7d30c5b11217e9c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17ffb3e9b3888b05175ee3e35cdf4be9fbff8a52c0ae90cf8aba8838dfdb73fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "70599b40d0306a114a2431065047f7b1658514a5d2307d08c57e8516fe265cbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bb62feab87345b9736844381e6d9d06244ecc9f80141d66e568db8b4ab9074d9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101a8": { @@ -16422,7 +17800,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101a8", "family_id": "effects-101a5-101ad", "job_id": "effects-101a5-101ad", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -16434,6 +17812,278 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101a5-101ad/candidate.json", "sha256": "9a84f7a47741d47b66cd6f34fce68e02f67ab8ba25b3b08a01d0841f277c05a1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "9a84f7a47741d47b66cd6f34fce68e02f67ab8ba25b3b08a01d0841f277c05a1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a893793764dd179f56949452b6b3c6aaa6f7ba95234f5c761e0c733b51178c70", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.243014+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101a5-101ad/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"All nine authentic original Catalog sources, the unchanged genuine v3 raw atlas, fresh actual Rust scales 1\\u20134, every native 2\\u20133 comparison and the complete ordered static fade sequence were independently inspected. Every padded generator reference is the authentic decoded source plus disclosed transparent padding. The 16\\u00d716 logical canvases, origins and native occupied extrema are retained.\", \"The first frame remains the source narrow nine-cell warm patch. Particle locations, disconnected sparse fragments and development into the wider burst remain source-aligned. No whole occupied source cell is absent at any of the four scales; partial high-scale edge coverage is documented per frame instead of being described as exact silhouettes. Fine matte orange/rust grain is visibly authored in the actual 3\\u00d7 and 4\\u00d7 results; all 36 actual HD outputs differ from original nearest-neighbor RGB pixels.\", \"Stronger outlined source-cell edges occur at 4\\u00d7, particularly 101ab and 101ad. They are conspicuous in diagnostic magnification and remain a local style difference at the actual 64\\u00d764 canvas size. At that actual presentation size the fragments still read as warm orange/brown sparks, not metallic tiled panels, luminous ivory veins or a different object. This exact emphasis is accepted as a disclosed material caveat, based on inspected current pixels rather than native IoU alone.\", \"Native occupancy changes are 9\\u21929, 26\\u219227, 45\\u219247, 41\\u219242, 28\\u219229, 17\\u219220, 18\\u219219, 22\\u219222 and 11\\u219213 across 101a5\\u2013101ad. The three added 101aa cells lie at (2,7), (6,9), (4,15); the two added 101ad cells lie at (5,14), (12,14). The annotated comparisons place them beside existing fragments or in a local body gap, without an independent new particle or changed native bounds. These adjacent expansions, including the lower native IoU of the sparsest late phases, are explicitly accepted and remain documented.\", \"The raw and actual outputs preserve the warm orange/rust-to-dim-brown phase character. They do not introduce white or ivory veins, halos, new rays or an artificial final bright burst. The source itself is not strictly monotonic: 101ab briefly has more light than 101aa. Actual occupied mean brightness is mostly slightly lower, but larger fine edge coverage increases logical-area-normalized total luminance in most later phases; this difference is retained, not called identical brightness. Final 101ad occupied mean luma is 48.7 versus source 60.9, while normalized total is 945.9 versus 670.4. The actual full-size final frame still reads as dim brown sparse fragments.\", \"All selected square source-aspect crops retain every raw pixel with alpha at least 32, 64, 128 and 255 within its own atlas cell. The 101a8 crop alone excludes three faint fringe specks with alpha 17, 16 and 19 at atlas coordinates (295,686), (295,687), (295,688); the exact RGBA values are bound below. This is a disclosed low-opacity crop-margin caveat, not a false zero-alpha\\u226516 claim. The actual indexed loader uses a 128 cutoff after resizing. No meaningful opaque source-aligned contour is cut, and no raw pixels, crop metadata or shader were changed for this review.\", \"Actual indexed original and HD palette counts contain no reserved indices 240\\u2013255. All occupied-source palette-class and forced-index checks pass. Authenticated original binary/RGBA/palette/INDEX bytes, exact frame/crop bindings and immutable library/probe identities are bound. The raw is byte-identical to the original builtin imagegen file; prompt, preparation, references, generation attempts and provenance are separately hashed.\", \"Both runtime freshness guards were false at the actual render invocation, and the indexed invocation recorded an unchanged source snapshot. Our current immutable library is 0ec6137e0e3261e813b2b863cd96c04da55e07cdf29b5c10b1d112e20f0a3daf. All 45 PPMs, nine originals plus 36 actual scales 1\\u20134, are byte-identical to the frozen owner proof using 409b38ea7760734201caf6dfbdd1d08c77ed903c18d7d7450dcd964b1a81fc39. This establishes current output continuity without pretending that the owner proof used our newer library.\", \"Historical v1 held_brightness and v2 held_raw_geometry_brightness remain unchanged and held as their historical versions. The independent approval applies only to the exact submitted v3 candidate and its unchanged raw/bindings. Every one of the 141 frozen author files was verified unchanged at closure. The earlier accepted MediumAir13 and SmallGround35 report hashes were verified unchanged.\", \"This is source/material/crop/palette/loader and complete static phase presentation approval only. No live Host occurrence, effect cadence, compositor timing, live palette fade, final 1080p SDL scene, simulation, collision or RNG behavior was exercised or inferred. Production admission is exclusively the HD coordinator\\u2019s decision and remains separate from the closed 800-frame checkpoint.\"] \"No Host, live timing, reachability, compositor, palette-fade or 1080p acceptance claim. A future engine change requires current output continuity proof separately.\" [{\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 686], \"RGBA\": [120, 60, 15, 17]}, {\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 687], \"RGBA\": [127, 63, 15, 16]}, {\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 688], \"RGBA\": [120, 67, 13, 19]}] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/independent-review.json, SHA256 9eccf362c3030701ed66d9f5cafc800c417641ac9c3cc8c2c3180630c8d9187c", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101a5", + "101a6", + "101a7", + "101a8" + ], + "sha256": "0d03279051ab2742dbf22368ce2213743f10db8795662c979a3f0e8481d1894d", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101a9", + "101aa", + "101ab", + "101ac" + ], + "sha256": "f9ea76b45d46711d9ca433b8e6cdc7c441e5507e636c388d2f40edbc5bdae033", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ad" + ], + "sha256": "150630e51d745e2b1af7226c28f11ba6a1c71e4bfd83bed0c42a0372475403ff", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101a5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0814c4019a4abc0a70e35d4ff15a205015055cebae968b85765fa951ded4d4fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cb6c60be80d483c171ecbb6b924ebc411134343c0a9615d4303e5e4c42c8c8f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "76bc2033132cf13cbbe2c8d7c1a44c81596c196287e3882c258ab19cda879466", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "947e90d905ac58798fdbb93523483a4c7ecefc1b20a857b39834d731b3a1766c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b62ddde5fe31a72112683a3bee45ea58384c50ee95b44a418ba54eb78f1361dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "751043c9bdf21414a00f712b26bccd2c1ed51d533ee3c09f64e5ca96229d75f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b24d51f5113cce9f08168e13c60688c3ebbfa645f140bfb11bf94727e6a2fc06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ad3354c19d7bfa3d533efd656f377f5b7b04beb25c17572af68cf2e5426f45d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5647e851bae4d375e45fbd2d407ba591a3a8a9510eef30542982dc372210dd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eaa858087535efb28717f573d16104fc6e16b38d4f04060b4e92ed2f45a793b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c5abe050d44059c272da0bfcdf11191034a6b920eec9b699c716512baf6e18d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b7b4fbbf3ee582ec6afee56bb732886dcc743f731a10b95a49e73a404d70c51a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1232f9b9c2105c73b243dfdf96f148e722e171672c0426ed8946d05add88fcf4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ef74a7d86dcf335ef163680cdde22edff1d05a9f0b13e2f5ee01e966ea6c274", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0a99e38cc58bf02a45d5c966e5d45f7f66446875f5d4eb719bce424bd2d943d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d2d2f5de5603297b2f21f05bdd89f655c98b597315f8920f39cff1dc4de43341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "82d2793a721aae8efda5d37a132ddd2e0f533af54776059f37776e1d4342ef93", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a68199be50cef1592115a161febc9a7adc7ecba060d7dcde4333f67ee67c71e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "22f4e78d12cbfdaf4dfe47722aecb991e53d8fc5d2b08d8e8b68639b71b512fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39669071ac802ad6323f1153ba78f1b9899f7180471217146be3dea4fb4cbdcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7534837245eab1316ff0b9fc8a7f66bdb1940c3e68a0b5a5979e817c600fd815", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2f68e67347216fd1b4596a0856386e62df75f72b44b83f3db4b5c558d61cb323", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "abcb99f8a77e6041351d0481cd5cf048a6c8faa818f605e29e5ed53713a9299d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "246f653cb975094ac1be085528c0f8a811cc38f7403ff993e6a2694539033c69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8a463405eecdae5954dfec86fdf59d119f4242b6848aebeb890aa547fffa0ec6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "367e917da7cf5034bf89e37d59ec59dc9c977d488ed813782ceb80c5ab1656c1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d1c963203e8901479cec6b2534fd1cfa2afe70d57438b335078c8148619084d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6dc6a854736b065e78f1d77567a58bcbd5142f5105092794b3b3580da3344cac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4058f39c3a06f31d3a3cecd6827c7fb6a5efa7b86e2541fb19fbb151f934d026", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bb7e8ffdf0f2a3138784534ce20231b45d98e0a5732c836bcc02c0a546c66934", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e190e1089192b1ea824aba7c25842cfafaf1f83d00461e0cb8a23d736ab6235b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "50255049acdebbee4917bfc9787cb79db54088853fe08beab04331a797b59974", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9b13226dafbc76229fb6bd60ed702433308c16e038c7a40e8a70eab660884a34", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "110158f6fc9fa87bad18727e2089a621979c8a4aa6103d2f69f73e502def4d9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa0a27e7ed7d7347aa3767dc9824be5cf14f7f6103db2af8cfa35d24b67c2837", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3c79854593cb1bd811f02dfb376a879357265787edf2ba1bd23b376e2ecdb9bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c76c6d1246bd18a22296d621e726b3454b4117941ec250fdc943e79fb247c69c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb8ef3ccf5ddd0c769b56bad3851eb8e07c13589a879ede64443b3f7431aa044", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a42484d4748505f7c56f521145cab11a74ab42abd12a7c50bbabf44391745a55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9dac55e6ab8fd5ebae29bd64acfd3662175f0df65673bb8301fb7829703e9ff8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8e953f7cbe098fa150300c58d5c00ae94ce0dc7c8c39294305a5e6b478850e41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dff718058528cf477ca0a53116e0042f93ebff44351bfdc3e7d30c5b11217e9c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17ffb3e9b3888b05175ee3e35cdf4be9fbff8a52c0ae90cf8aba8838dfdb73fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "70599b40d0306a114a2431065047f7b1658514a5d2307d08c57e8516fe265cbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bb62feab87345b9736844381e6d9d06244ecc9f80141d66e568db8b4ab9074d9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101a9": { @@ -16455,7 +18105,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101a9", "family_id": "effects-101a5-101ad", "job_id": "effects-101a5-101ad", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -16467,6 +18117,278 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101a5-101ad/candidate.json", "sha256": "9a84f7a47741d47b66cd6f34fce68e02f67ab8ba25b3b08a01d0841f277c05a1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "9a84f7a47741d47b66cd6f34fce68e02f67ab8ba25b3b08a01d0841f277c05a1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a893793764dd179f56949452b6b3c6aaa6f7ba95234f5c761e0c733b51178c70", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.243014+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101a5-101ad/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"All nine authentic original Catalog sources, the unchanged genuine v3 raw atlas, fresh actual Rust scales 1\\u20134, every native 2\\u20133 comparison and the complete ordered static fade sequence were independently inspected. Every padded generator reference is the authentic decoded source plus disclosed transparent padding. The 16\\u00d716 logical canvases, origins and native occupied extrema are retained.\", \"The first frame remains the source narrow nine-cell warm patch. Particle locations, disconnected sparse fragments and development into the wider burst remain source-aligned. No whole occupied source cell is absent at any of the four scales; partial high-scale edge coverage is documented per frame instead of being described as exact silhouettes. Fine matte orange/rust grain is visibly authored in the actual 3\\u00d7 and 4\\u00d7 results; all 36 actual HD outputs differ from original nearest-neighbor RGB pixels.\", \"Stronger outlined source-cell edges occur at 4\\u00d7, particularly 101ab and 101ad. They are conspicuous in diagnostic magnification and remain a local style difference at the actual 64\\u00d764 canvas size. At that actual presentation size the fragments still read as warm orange/brown sparks, not metallic tiled panels, luminous ivory veins or a different object. This exact emphasis is accepted as a disclosed material caveat, based on inspected current pixels rather than native IoU alone.\", \"Native occupancy changes are 9\\u21929, 26\\u219227, 45\\u219247, 41\\u219242, 28\\u219229, 17\\u219220, 18\\u219219, 22\\u219222 and 11\\u219213 across 101a5\\u2013101ad. The three added 101aa cells lie at (2,7), (6,9), (4,15); the two added 101ad cells lie at (5,14), (12,14). The annotated comparisons place them beside existing fragments or in a local body gap, without an independent new particle or changed native bounds. These adjacent expansions, including the lower native IoU of the sparsest late phases, are explicitly accepted and remain documented.\", \"The raw and actual outputs preserve the warm orange/rust-to-dim-brown phase character. They do not introduce white or ivory veins, halos, new rays or an artificial final bright burst. The source itself is not strictly monotonic: 101ab briefly has more light than 101aa. Actual occupied mean brightness is mostly slightly lower, but larger fine edge coverage increases logical-area-normalized total luminance in most later phases; this difference is retained, not called identical brightness. Final 101ad occupied mean luma is 48.7 versus source 60.9, while normalized total is 945.9 versus 670.4. The actual full-size final frame still reads as dim brown sparse fragments.\", \"All selected square source-aspect crops retain every raw pixel with alpha at least 32, 64, 128 and 255 within its own atlas cell. The 101a8 crop alone excludes three faint fringe specks with alpha 17, 16 and 19 at atlas coordinates (295,686), (295,687), (295,688); the exact RGBA values are bound below. This is a disclosed low-opacity crop-margin caveat, not a false zero-alpha\\u226516 claim. The actual indexed loader uses a 128 cutoff after resizing. No meaningful opaque source-aligned contour is cut, and no raw pixels, crop metadata or shader were changed for this review.\", \"Actual indexed original and HD palette counts contain no reserved indices 240\\u2013255. All occupied-source palette-class and forced-index checks pass. Authenticated original binary/RGBA/palette/INDEX bytes, exact frame/crop bindings and immutable library/probe identities are bound. The raw is byte-identical to the original builtin imagegen file; prompt, preparation, references, generation attempts and provenance are separately hashed.\", \"Both runtime freshness guards were false at the actual render invocation, and the indexed invocation recorded an unchanged source snapshot. Our current immutable library is 0ec6137e0e3261e813b2b863cd96c04da55e07cdf29b5c10b1d112e20f0a3daf. All 45 PPMs, nine originals plus 36 actual scales 1\\u20134, are byte-identical to the frozen owner proof using 409b38ea7760734201caf6dfbdd1d08c77ed903c18d7d7450dcd964b1a81fc39. This establishes current output continuity without pretending that the owner proof used our newer library.\", \"Historical v1 held_brightness and v2 held_raw_geometry_brightness remain unchanged and held as their historical versions. The independent approval applies only to the exact submitted v3 candidate and its unchanged raw/bindings. Every one of the 141 frozen author files was verified unchanged at closure. The earlier accepted MediumAir13 and SmallGround35 report hashes were verified unchanged.\", \"This is source/material/crop/palette/loader and complete static phase presentation approval only. No live Host occurrence, effect cadence, compositor timing, live palette fade, final 1080p SDL scene, simulation, collision or RNG behavior was exercised or inferred. Production admission is exclusively the HD coordinator\\u2019s decision and remains separate from the closed 800-frame checkpoint.\"] \"No Host, live timing, reachability, compositor, palette-fade or 1080p acceptance claim. A future engine change requires current output continuity proof separately.\" [{\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 686], \"RGBA\": [120, 60, 15, 17]}, {\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 687], \"RGBA\": [127, 63, 15, 16]}, {\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 688], \"RGBA\": [120, 67, 13, 19]}] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/independent-review.json, SHA256 9eccf362c3030701ed66d9f5cafc800c417641ac9c3cc8c2c3180630c8d9187c", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101a5", + "101a6", + "101a7", + "101a8" + ], + "sha256": "0d03279051ab2742dbf22368ce2213743f10db8795662c979a3f0e8481d1894d", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101a9", + "101aa", + "101ab", + "101ac" + ], + "sha256": "f9ea76b45d46711d9ca433b8e6cdc7c441e5507e636c388d2f40edbc5bdae033", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ad" + ], + "sha256": "150630e51d745e2b1af7226c28f11ba6a1c71e4bfd83bed0c42a0372475403ff", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101a5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0814c4019a4abc0a70e35d4ff15a205015055cebae968b85765fa951ded4d4fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cb6c60be80d483c171ecbb6b924ebc411134343c0a9615d4303e5e4c42c8c8f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "76bc2033132cf13cbbe2c8d7c1a44c81596c196287e3882c258ab19cda879466", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "947e90d905ac58798fdbb93523483a4c7ecefc1b20a857b39834d731b3a1766c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b62ddde5fe31a72112683a3bee45ea58384c50ee95b44a418ba54eb78f1361dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "751043c9bdf21414a00f712b26bccd2c1ed51d533ee3c09f64e5ca96229d75f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b24d51f5113cce9f08168e13c60688c3ebbfa645f140bfb11bf94727e6a2fc06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ad3354c19d7bfa3d533efd656f377f5b7b04beb25c17572af68cf2e5426f45d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5647e851bae4d375e45fbd2d407ba591a3a8a9510eef30542982dc372210dd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eaa858087535efb28717f573d16104fc6e16b38d4f04060b4e92ed2f45a793b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c5abe050d44059c272da0bfcdf11191034a6b920eec9b699c716512baf6e18d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b7b4fbbf3ee582ec6afee56bb732886dcc743f731a10b95a49e73a404d70c51a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1232f9b9c2105c73b243dfdf96f148e722e171672c0426ed8946d05add88fcf4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ef74a7d86dcf335ef163680cdde22edff1d05a9f0b13e2f5ee01e966ea6c274", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0a99e38cc58bf02a45d5c966e5d45f7f66446875f5d4eb719bce424bd2d943d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d2d2f5de5603297b2f21f05bdd89f655c98b597315f8920f39cff1dc4de43341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "82d2793a721aae8efda5d37a132ddd2e0f533af54776059f37776e1d4342ef93", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a68199be50cef1592115a161febc9a7adc7ecba060d7dcde4333f67ee67c71e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "22f4e78d12cbfdaf4dfe47722aecb991e53d8fc5d2b08d8e8b68639b71b512fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39669071ac802ad6323f1153ba78f1b9899f7180471217146be3dea4fb4cbdcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7534837245eab1316ff0b9fc8a7f66bdb1940c3e68a0b5a5979e817c600fd815", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2f68e67347216fd1b4596a0856386e62df75f72b44b83f3db4b5c558d61cb323", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "abcb99f8a77e6041351d0481cd5cf048a6c8faa818f605e29e5ed53713a9299d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "246f653cb975094ac1be085528c0f8a811cc38f7403ff993e6a2694539033c69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8a463405eecdae5954dfec86fdf59d119f4242b6848aebeb890aa547fffa0ec6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "367e917da7cf5034bf89e37d59ec59dc9c977d488ed813782ceb80c5ab1656c1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d1c963203e8901479cec6b2534fd1cfa2afe70d57438b335078c8148619084d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6dc6a854736b065e78f1d77567a58bcbd5142f5105092794b3b3580da3344cac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4058f39c3a06f31d3a3cecd6827c7fb6a5efa7b86e2541fb19fbb151f934d026", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bb7e8ffdf0f2a3138784534ce20231b45d98e0a5732c836bcc02c0a546c66934", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e190e1089192b1ea824aba7c25842cfafaf1f83d00461e0cb8a23d736ab6235b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "50255049acdebbee4917bfc9787cb79db54088853fe08beab04331a797b59974", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9b13226dafbc76229fb6bd60ed702433308c16e038c7a40e8a70eab660884a34", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "110158f6fc9fa87bad18727e2089a621979c8a4aa6103d2f69f73e502def4d9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa0a27e7ed7d7347aa3767dc9824be5cf14f7f6103db2af8cfa35d24b67c2837", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3c79854593cb1bd811f02dfb376a879357265787edf2ba1bd23b376e2ecdb9bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c76c6d1246bd18a22296d621e726b3454b4117941ec250fdc943e79fb247c69c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb8ef3ccf5ddd0c769b56bad3851eb8e07c13589a879ede64443b3f7431aa044", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a42484d4748505f7c56f521145cab11a74ab42abd12a7c50bbabf44391745a55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9dac55e6ab8fd5ebae29bd64acfd3662175f0df65673bb8301fb7829703e9ff8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8e953f7cbe098fa150300c58d5c00ae94ce0dc7c8c39294305a5e6b478850e41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dff718058528cf477ca0a53116e0042f93ebff44351bfdc3e7d30c5b11217e9c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17ffb3e9b3888b05175ee3e35cdf4be9fbff8a52c0ae90cf8aba8838dfdb73fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "70599b40d0306a114a2431065047f7b1658514a5d2307d08c57e8516fe265cbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bb62feab87345b9736844381e6d9d06244ecc9f80141d66e568db8b4ab9074d9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101aa": { @@ -16488,7 +18410,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101aa", "family_id": "effects-101a5-101ad", "job_id": "effects-101a5-101ad", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -16500,6 +18422,278 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101a5-101ad/candidate.json", "sha256": "9a84f7a47741d47b66cd6f34fce68e02f67ab8ba25b3b08a01d0841f277c05a1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "9a84f7a47741d47b66cd6f34fce68e02f67ab8ba25b3b08a01d0841f277c05a1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a893793764dd179f56949452b6b3c6aaa6f7ba95234f5c761e0c733b51178c70", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.243014+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101a5-101ad/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"All nine authentic original Catalog sources, the unchanged genuine v3 raw atlas, fresh actual Rust scales 1\\u20134, every native 2\\u20133 comparison and the complete ordered static fade sequence were independently inspected. Every padded generator reference is the authentic decoded source plus disclosed transparent padding. The 16\\u00d716 logical canvases, origins and native occupied extrema are retained.\", \"The first frame remains the source narrow nine-cell warm patch. Particle locations, disconnected sparse fragments and development into the wider burst remain source-aligned. No whole occupied source cell is absent at any of the four scales; partial high-scale edge coverage is documented per frame instead of being described as exact silhouettes. Fine matte orange/rust grain is visibly authored in the actual 3\\u00d7 and 4\\u00d7 results; all 36 actual HD outputs differ from original nearest-neighbor RGB pixels.\", \"Stronger outlined source-cell edges occur at 4\\u00d7, particularly 101ab and 101ad. They are conspicuous in diagnostic magnification and remain a local style difference at the actual 64\\u00d764 canvas size. At that actual presentation size the fragments still read as warm orange/brown sparks, not metallic tiled panels, luminous ivory veins or a different object. This exact emphasis is accepted as a disclosed material caveat, based on inspected current pixels rather than native IoU alone.\", \"Native occupancy changes are 9\\u21929, 26\\u219227, 45\\u219247, 41\\u219242, 28\\u219229, 17\\u219220, 18\\u219219, 22\\u219222 and 11\\u219213 across 101a5\\u2013101ad. The three added 101aa cells lie at (2,7), (6,9), (4,15); the two added 101ad cells lie at (5,14), (12,14). The annotated comparisons place them beside existing fragments or in a local body gap, without an independent new particle or changed native bounds. These adjacent expansions, including the lower native IoU of the sparsest late phases, are explicitly accepted and remain documented.\", \"The raw and actual outputs preserve the warm orange/rust-to-dim-brown phase character. They do not introduce white or ivory veins, halos, new rays or an artificial final bright burst. The source itself is not strictly monotonic: 101ab briefly has more light than 101aa. Actual occupied mean brightness is mostly slightly lower, but larger fine edge coverage increases logical-area-normalized total luminance in most later phases; this difference is retained, not called identical brightness. Final 101ad occupied mean luma is 48.7 versus source 60.9, while normalized total is 945.9 versus 670.4. The actual full-size final frame still reads as dim brown sparse fragments.\", \"All selected square source-aspect crops retain every raw pixel with alpha at least 32, 64, 128 and 255 within its own atlas cell. The 101a8 crop alone excludes three faint fringe specks with alpha 17, 16 and 19 at atlas coordinates (295,686), (295,687), (295,688); the exact RGBA values are bound below. This is a disclosed low-opacity crop-margin caveat, not a false zero-alpha\\u226516 claim. The actual indexed loader uses a 128 cutoff after resizing. No meaningful opaque source-aligned contour is cut, and no raw pixels, crop metadata or shader were changed for this review.\", \"Actual indexed original and HD palette counts contain no reserved indices 240\\u2013255. All occupied-source palette-class and forced-index checks pass. Authenticated original binary/RGBA/palette/INDEX bytes, exact frame/crop bindings and immutable library/probe identities are bound. The raw is byte-identical to the original builtin imagegen file; prompt, preparation, references, generation attempts and provenance are separately hashed.\", \"Both runtime freshness guards were false at the actual render invocation, and the indexed invocation recorded an unchanged source snapshot. Our current immutable library is 0ec6137e0e3261e813b2b863cd96c04da55e07cdf29b5c10b1d112e20f0a3daf. All 45 PPMs, nine originals plus 36 actual scales 1\\u20134, are byte-identical to the frozen owner proof using 409b38ea7760734201caf6dfbdd1d08c77ed903c18d7d7450dcd964b1a81fc39. This establishes current output continuity without pretending that the owner proof used our newer library.\", \"Historical v1 held_brightness and v2 held_raw_geometry_brightness remain unchanged and held as their historical versions. The independent approval applies only to the exact submitted v3 candidate and its unchanged raw/bindings. Every one of the 141 frozen author files was verified unchanged at closure. The earlier accepted MediumAir13 and SmallGround35 report hashes were verified unchanged.\", \"This is source/material/crop/palette/loader and complete static phase presentation approval only. No live Host occurrence, effect cadence, compositor timing, live palette fade, final 1080p SDL scene, simulation, collision or RNG behavior was exercised or inferred. Production admission is exclusively the HD coordinator\\u2019s decision and remains separate from the closed 800-frame checkpoint.\"] \"No Host, live timing, reachability, compositor, palette-fade or 1080p acceptance claim. A future engine change requires current output continuity proof separately.\" [{\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 686], \"RGBA\": [120, 60, 15, 17]}, {\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 687], \"RGBA\": [127, 63, 15, 16]}, {\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 688], \"RGBA\": [120, 67, 13, 19]}] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/independent-review.json, SHA256 9eccf362c3030701ed66d9f5cafc800c417641ac9c3cc8c2c3180630c8d9187c", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101a5", + "101a6", + "101a7", + "101a8" + ], + "sha256": "0d03279051ab2742dbf22368ce2213743f10db8795662c979a3f0e8481d1894d", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101a9", + "101aa", + "101ab", + "101ac" + ], + "sha256": "f9ea76b45d46711d9ca433b8e6cdc7c441e5507e636c388d2f40edbc5bdae033", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ad" + ], + "sha256": "150630e51d745e2b1af7226c28f11ba6a1c71e4bfd83bed0c42a0372475403ff", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101a5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0814c4019a4abc0a70e35d4ff15a205015055cebae968b85765fa951ded4d4fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cb6c60be80d483c171ecbb6b924ebc411134343c0a9615d4303e5e4c42c8c8f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "76bc2033132cf13cbbe2c8d7c1a44c81596c196287e3882c258ab19cda879466", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "947e90d905ac58798fdbb93523483a4c7ecefc1b20a857b39834d731b3a1766c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b62ddde5fe31a72112683a3bee45ea58384c50ee95b44a418ba54eb78f1361dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "751043c9bdf21414a00f712b26bccd2c1ed51d533ee3c09f64e5ca96229d75f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b24d51f5113cce9f08168e13c60688c3ebbfa645f140bfb11bf94727e6a2fc06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ad3354c19d7bfa3d533efd656f377f5b7b04beb25c17572af68cf2e5426f45d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5647e851bae4d375e45fbd2d407ba591a3a8a9510eef30542982dc372210dd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eaa858087535efb28717f573d16104fc6e16b38d4f04060b4e92ed2f45a793b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c5abe050d44059c272da0bfcdf11191034a6b920eec9b699c716512baf6e18d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b7b4fbbf3ee582ec6afee56bb732886dcc743f731a10b95a49e73a404d70c51a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1232f9b9c2105c73b243dfdf96f148e722e171672c0426ed8946d05add88fcf4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ef74a7d86dcf335ef163680cdde22edff1d05a9f0b13e2f5ee01e966ea6c274", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0a99e38cc58bf02a45d5c966e5d45f7f66446875f5d4eb719bce424bd2d943d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d2d2f5de5603297b2f21f05bdd89f655c98b597315f8920f39cff1dc4de43341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "82d2793a721aae8efda5d37a132ddd2e0f533af54776059f37776e1d4342ef93", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a68199be50cef1592115a161febc9a7adc7ecba060d7dcde4333f67ee67c71e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "22f4e78d12cbfdaf4dfe47722aecb991e53d8fc5d2b08d8e8b68639b71b512fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39669071ac802ad6323f1153ba78f1b9899f7180471217146be3dea4fb4cbdcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7534837245eab1316ff0b9fc8a7f66bdb1940c3e68a0b5a5979e817c600fd815", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2f68e67347216fd1b4596a0856386e62df75f72b44b83f3db4b5c558d61cb323", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "abcb99f8a77e6041351d0481cd5cf048a6c8faa818f605e29e5ed53713a9299d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "246f653cb975094ac1be085528c0f8a811cc38f7403ff993e6a2694539033c69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8a463405eecdae5954dfec86fdf59d119f4242b6848aebeb890aa547fffa0ec6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "367e917da7cf5034bf89e37d59ec59dc9c977d488ed813782ceb80c5ab1656c1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d1c963203e8901479cec6b2534fd1cfa2afe70d57438b335078c8148619084d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6dc6a854736b065e78f1d77567a58bcbd5142f5105092794b3b3580da3344cac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4058f39c3a06f31d3a3cecd6827c7fb6a5efa7b86e2541fb19fbb151f934d026", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bb7e8ffdf0f2a3138784534ce20231b45d98e0a5732c836bcc02c0a546c66934", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e190e1089192b1ea824aba7c25842cfafaf1f83d00461e0cb8a23d736ab6235b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "50255049acdebbee4917bfc9787cb79db54088853fe08beab04331a797b59974", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9b13226dafbc76229fb6bd60ed702433308c16e038c7a40e8a70eab660884a34", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "110158f6fc9fa87bad18727e2089a621979c8a4aa6103d2f69f73e502def4d9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa0a27e7ed7d7347aa3767dc9824be5cf14f7f6103db2af8cfa35d24b67c2837", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3c79854593cb1bd811f02dfb376a879357265787edf2ba1bd23b376e2ecdb9bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c76c6d1246bd18a22296d621e726b3454b4117941ec250fdc943e79fb247c69c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb8ef3ccf5ddd0c769b56bad3851eb8e07c13589a879ede64443b3f7431aa044", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a42484d4748505f7c56f521145cab11a74ab42abd12a7c50bbabf44391745a55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9dac55e6ab8fd5ebae29bd64acfd3662175f0df65673bb8301fb7829703e9ff8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8e953f7cbe098fa150300c58d5c00ae94ce0dc7c8c39294305a5e6b478850e41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dff718058528cf477ca0a53116e0042f93ebff44351bfdc3e7d30c5b11217e9c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17ffb3e9b3888b05175ee3e35cdf4be9fbff8a52c0ae90cf8aba8838dfdb73fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "70599b40d0306a114a2431065047f7b1658514a5d2307d08c57e8516fe265cbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bb62feab87345b9736844381e6d9d06244ecc9f80141d66e568db8b4ab9074d9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101ab": { @@ -16521,7 +18715,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101ab", "family_id": "effects-101a5-101ad", "job_id": "effects-101a5-101ad", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -16533,6 +18727,278 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101a5-101ad/candidate.json", "sha256": "9a84f7a47741d47b66cd6f34fce68e02f67ab8ba25b3b08a01d0841f277c05a1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "9a84f7a47741d47b66cd6f34fce68e02f67ab8ba25b3b08a01d0841f277c05a1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a893793764dd179f56949452b6b3c6aaa6f7ba95234f5c761e0c733b51178c70", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.243014+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101a5-101ad/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"All nine authentic original Catalog sources, the unchanged genuine v3 raw atlas, fresh actual Rust scales 1\\u20134, every native 2\\u20133 comparison and the complete ordered static fade sequence were independently inspected. Every padded generator reference is the authentic decoded source plus disclosed transparent padding. The 16\\u00d716 logical canvases, origins and native occupied extrema are retained.\", \"The first frame remains the source narrow nine-cell warm patch. Particle locations, disconnected sparse fragments and development into the wider burst remain source-aligned. No whole occupied source cell is absent at any of the four scales; partial high-scale edge coverage is documented per frame instead of being described as exact silhouettes. Fine matte orange/rust grain is visibly authored in the actual 3\\u00d7 and 4\\u00d7 results; all 36 actual HD outputs differ from original nearest-neighbor RGB pixels.\", \"Stronger outlined source-cell edges occur at 4\\u00d7, particularly 101ab and 101ad. They are conspicuous in diagnostic magnification and remain a local style difference at the actual 64\\u00d764 canvas size. At that actual presentation size the fragments still read as warm orange/brown sparks, not metallic tiled panels, luminous ivory veins or a different object. This exact emphasis is accepted as a disclosed material caveat, based on inspected current pixels rather than native IoU alone.\", \"Native occupancy changes are 9\\u21929, 26\\u219227, 45\\u219247, 41\\u219242, 28\\u219229, 17\\u219220, 18\\u219219, 22\\u219222 and 11\\u219213 across 101a5\\u2013101ad. The three added 101aa cells lie at (2,7), (6,9), (4,15); the two added 101ad cells lie at (5,14), (12,14). The annotated comparisons place them beside existing fragments or in a local body gap, without an independent new particle or changed native bounds. These adjacent expansions, including the lower native IoU of the sparsest late phases, are explicitly accepted and remain documented.\", \"The raw and actual outputs preserve the warm orange/rust-to-dim-brown phase character. They do not introduce white or ivory veins, halos, new rays or an artificial final bright burst. The source itself is not strictly monotonic: 101ab briefly has more light than 101aa. Actual occupied mean brightness is mostly slightly lower, but larger fine edge coverage increases logical-area-normalized total luminance in most later phases; this difference is retained, not called identical brightness. Final 101ad occupied mean luma is 48.7 versus source 60.9, while normalized total is 945.9 versus 670.4. The actual full-size final frame still reads as dim brown sparse fragments.\", \"All selected square source-aspect crops retain every raw pixel with alpha at least 32, 64, 128 and 255 within its own atlas cell. The 101a8 crop alone excludes three faint fringe specks with alpha 17, 16 and 19 at atlas coordinates (295,686), (295,687), (295,688); the exact RGBA values are bound below. This is a disclosed low-opacity crop-margin caveat, not a false zero-alpha\\u226516 claim. The actual indexed loader uses a 128 cutoff after resizing. No meaningful opaque source-aligned contour is cut, and no raw pixels, crop metadata or shader were changed for this review.\", \"Actual indexed original and HD palette counts contain no reserved indices 240\\u2013255. All occupied-source palette-class and forced-index checks pass. Authenticated original binary/RGBA/palette/INDEX bytes, exact frame/crop bindings and immutable library/probe identities are bound. The raw is byte-identical to the original builtin imagegen file; prompt, preparation, references, generation attempts and provenance are separately hashed.\", \"Both runtime freshness guards were false at the actual render invocation, and the indexed invocation recorded an unchanged source snapshot. Our current immutable library is 0ec6137e0e3261e813b2b863cd96c04da55e07cdf29b5c10b1d112e20f0a3daf. All 45 PPMs, nine originals plus 36 actual scales 1\\u20134, are byte-identical to the frozen owner proof using 409b38ea7760734201caf6dfbdd1d08c77ed903c18d7d7450dcd964b1a81fc39. This establishes current output continuity without pretending that the owner proof used our newer library.\", \"Historical v1 held_brightness and v2 held_raw_geometry_brightness remain unchanged and held as their historical versions. The independent approval applies only to the exact submitted v3 candidate and its unchanged raw/bindings. Every one of the 141 frozen author files was verified unchanged at closure. The earlier accepted MediumAir13 and SmallGround35 report hashes were verified unchanged.\", \"This is source/material/crop/palette/loader and complete static phase presentation approval only. No live Host occurrence, effect cadence, compositor timing, live palette fade, final 1080p SDL scene, simulation, collision or RNG behavior was exercised or inferred. Production admission is exclusively the HD coordinator\\u2019s decision and remains separate from the closed 800-frame checkpoint.\"] \"No Host, live timing, reachability, compositor, palette-fade or 1080p acceptance claim. A future engine change requires current output continuity proof separately.\" [{\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 686], \"RGBA\": [120, 60, 15, 17]}, {\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 687], \"RGBA\": [127, 63, 15, 16]}, {\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 688], \"RGBA\": [120, 67, 13, 19]}] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/independent-review.json, SHA256 9eccf362c3030701ed66d9f5cafc800c417641ac9c3cc8c2c3180630c8d9187c", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101a5", + "101a6", + "101a7", + "101a8" + ], + "sha256": "0d03279051ab2742dbf22368ce2213743f10db8795662c979a3f0e8481d1894d", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101a9", + "101aa", + "101ab", + "101ac" + ], + "sha256": "f9ea76b45d46711d9ca433b8e6cdc7c441e5507e636c388d2f40edbc5bdae033", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ad" + ], + "sha256": "150630e51d745e2b1af7226c28f11ba6a1c71e4bfd83bed0c42a0372475403ff", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101a5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0814c4019a4abc0a70e35d4ff15a205015055cebae968b85765fa951ded4d4fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cb6c60be80d483c171ecbb6b924ebc411134343c0a9615d4303e5e4c42c8c8f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "76bc2033132cf13cbbe2c8d7c1a44c81596c196287e3882c258ab19cda879466", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "947e90d905ac58798fdbb93523483a4c7ecefc1b20a857b39834d731b3a1766c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b62ddde5fe31a72112683a3bee45ea58384c50ee95b44a418ba54eb78f1361dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "751043c9bdf21414a00f712b26bccd2c1ed51d533ee3c09f64e5ca96229d75f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b24d51f5113cce9f08168e13c60688c3ebbfa645f140bfb11bf94727e6a2fc06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ad3354c19d7bfa3d533efd656f377f5b7b04beb25c17572af68cf2e5426f45d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5647e851bae4d375e45fbd2d407ba591a3a8a9510eef30542982dc372210dd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eaa858087535efb28717f573d16104fc6e16b38d4f04060b4e92ed2f45a793b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c5abe050d44059c272da0bfcdf11191034a6b920eec9b699c716512baf6e18d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b7b4fbbf3ee582ec6afee56bb732886dcc743f731a10b95a49e73a404d70c51a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1232f9b9c2105c73b243dfdf96f148e722e171672c0426ed8946d05add88fcf4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ef74a7d86dcf335ef163680cdde22edff1d05a9f0b13e2f5ee01e966ea6c274", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0a99e38cc58bf02a45d5c966e5d45f7f66446875f5d4eb719bce424bd2d943d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d2d2f5de5603297b2f21f05bdd89f655c98b597315f8920f39cff1dc4de43341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "82d2793a721aae8efda5d37a132ddd2e0f533af54776059f37776e1d4342ef93", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a68199be50cef1592115a161febc9a7adc7ecba060d7dcde4333f67ee67c71e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "22f4e78d12cbfdaf4dfe47722aecb991e53d8fc5d2b08d8e8b68639b71b512fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39669071ac802ad6323f1153ba78f1b9899f7180471217146be3dea4fb4cbdcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7534837245eab1316ff0b9fc8a7f66bdb1940c3e68a0b5a5979e817c600fd815", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2f68e67347216fd1b4596a0856386e62df75f72b44b83f3db4b5c558d61cb323", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "abcb99f8a77e6041351d0481cd5cf048a6c8faa818f605e29e5ed53713a9299d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "246f653cb975094ac1be085528c0f8a811cc38f7403ff993e6a2694539033c69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8a463405eecdae5954dfec86fdf59d119f4242b6848aebeb890aa547fffa0ec6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "367e917da7cf5034bf89e37d59ec59dc9c977d488ed813782ceb80c5ab1656c1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d1c963203e8901479cec6b2534fd1cfa2afe70d57438b335078c8148619084d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6dc6a854736b065e78f1d77567a58bcbd5142f5105092794b3b3580da3344cac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4058f39c3a06f31d3a3cecd6827c7fb6a5efa7b86e2541fb19fbb151f934d026", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bb7e8ffdf0f2a3138784534ce20231b45d98e0a5732c836bcc02c0a546c66934", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e190e1089192b1ea824aba7c25842cfafaf1f83d00461e0cb8a23d736ab6235b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "50255049acdebbee4917bfc9787cb79db54088853fe08beab04331a797b59974", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9b13226dafbc76229fb6bd60ed702433308c16e038c7a40e8a70eab660884a34", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "110158f6fc9fa87bad18727e2089a621979c8a4aa6103d2f69f73e502def4d9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa0a27e7ed7d7347aa3767dc9824be5cf14f7f6103db2af8cfa35d24b67c2837", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3c79854593cb1bd811f02dfb376a879357265787edf2ba1bd23b376e2ecdb9bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c76c6d1246bd18a22296d621e726b3454b4117941ec250fdc943e79fb247c69c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb8ef3ccf5ddd0c769b56bad3851eb8e07c13589a879ede64443b3f7431aa044", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a42484d4748505f7c56f521145cab11a74ab42abd12a7c50bbabf44391745a55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9dac55e6ab8fd5ebae29bd64acfd3662175f0df65673bb8301fb7829703e9ff8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8e953f7cbe098fa150300c58d5c00ae94ce0dc7c8c39294305a5e6b478850e41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dff718058528cf477ca0a53116e0042f93ebff44351bfdc3e7d30c5b11217e9c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17ffb3e9b3888b05175ee3e35cdf4be9fbff8a52c0ae90cf8aba8838dfdb73fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "70599b40d0306a114a2431065047f7b1658514a5d2307d08c57e8516fe265cbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bb62feab87345b9736844381e6d9d06244ecc9f80141d66e568db8b4ab9074d9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101ac": { @@ -16554,7 +19020,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101ac", "family_id": "effects-101a5-101ad", "job_id": "effects-101a5-101ad", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -16566,6 +19032,278 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101a5-101ad/candidate.json", "sha256": "9a84f7a47741d47b66cd6f34fce68e02f67ab8ba25b3b08a01d0841f277c05a1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "9a84f7a47741d47b66cd6f34fce68e02f67ab8ba25b3b08a01d0841f277c05a1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a893793764dd179f56949452b6b3c6aaa6f7ba95234f5c761e0c733b51178c70", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.243014+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101a5-101ad/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"All nine authentic original Catalog sources, the unchanged genuine v3 raw atlas, fresh actual Rust scales 1\\u20134, every native 2\\u20133 comparison and the complete ordered static fade sequence were independently inspected. Every padded generator reference is the authentic decoded source plus disclosed transparent padding. The 16\\u00d716 logical canvases, origins and native occupied extrema are retained.\", \"The first frame remains the source narrow nine-cell warm patch. Particle locations, disconnected sparse fragments and development into the wider burst remain source-aligned. No whole occupied source cell is absent at any of the four scales; partial high-scale edge coverage is documented per frame instead of being described as exact silhouettes. Fine matte orange/rust grain is visibly authored in the actual 3\\u00d7 and 4\\u00d7 results; all 36 actual HD outputs differ from original nearest-neighbor RGB pixels.\", \"Stronger outlined source-cell edges occur at 4\\u00d7, particularly 101ab and 101ad. They are conspicuous in diagnostic magnification and remain a local style difference at the actual 64\\u00d764 canvas size. At that actual presentation size the fragments still read as warm orange/brown sparks, not metallic tiled panels, luminous ivory veins or a different object. This exact emphasis is accepted as a disclosed material caveat, based on inspected current pixels rather than native IoU alone.\", \"Native occupancy changes are 9\\u21929, 26\\u219227, 45\\u219247, 41\\u219242, 28\\u219229, 17\\u219220, 18\\u219219, 22\\u219222 and 11\\u219213 across 101a5\\u2013101ad. The three added 101aa cells lie at (2,7), (6,9), (4,15); the two added 101ad cells lie at (5,14), (12,14). The annotated comparisons place them beside existing fragments or in a local body gap, without an independent new particle or changed native bounds. These adjacent expansions, including the lower native IoU of the sparsest late phases, are explicitly accepted and remain documented.\", \"The raw and actual outputs preserve the warm orange/rust-to-dim-brown phase character. They do not introduce white or ivory veins, halos, new rays or an artificial final bright burst. The source itself is not strictly monotonic: 101ab briefly has more light than 101aa. Actual occupied mean brightness is mostly slightly lower, but larger fine edge coverage increases logical-area-normalized total luminance in most later phases; this difference is retained, not called identical brightness. Final 101ad occupied mean luma is 48.7 versus source 60.9, while normalized total is 945.9 versus 670.4. The actual full-size final frame still reads as dim brown sparse fragments.\", \"All selected square source-aspect crops retain every raw pixel with alpha at least 32, 64, 128 and 255 within its own atlas cell. The 101a8 crop alone excludes three faint fringe specks with alpha 17, 16 and 19 at atlas coordinates (295,686), (295,687), (295,688); the exact RGBA values are bound below. This is a disclosed low-opacity crop-margin caveat, not a false zero-alpha\\u226516 claim. The actual indexed loader uses a 128 cutoff after resizing. No meaningful opaque source-aligned contour is cut, and no raw pixels, crop metadata or shader were changed for this review.\", \"Actual indexed original and HD palette counts contain no reserved indices 240\\u2013255. All occupied-source palette-class and forced-index checks pass. Authenticated original binary/RGBA/palette/INDEX bytes, exact frame/crop bindings and immutable library/probe identities are bound. The raw is byte-identical to the original builtin imagegen file; prompt, preparation, references, generation attempts and provenance are separately hashed.\", \"Both runtime freshness guards were false at the actual render invocation, and the indexed invocation recorded an unchanged source snapshot. Our current immutable library is 0ec6137e0e3261e813b2b863cd96c04da55e07cdf29b5c10b1d112e20f0a3daf. All 45 PPMs, nine originals plus 36 actual scales 1\\u20134, are byte-identical to the frozen owner proof using 409b38ea7760734201caf6dfbdd1d08c77ed903c18d7d7450dcd964b1a81fc39. This establishes current output continuity without pretending that the owner proof used our newer library.\", \"Historical v1 held_brightness and v2 held_raw_geometry_brightness remain unchanged and held as their historical versions. The independent approval applies only to the exact submitted v3 candidate and its unchanged raw/bindings. Every one of the 141 frozen author files was verified unchanged at closure. The earlier accepted MediumAir13 and SmallGround35 report hashes were verified unchanged.\", \"This is source/material/crop/palette/loader and complete static phase presentation approval only. No live Host occurrence, effect cadence, compositor timing, live palette fade, final 1080p SDL scene, simulation, collision or RNG behavior was exercised or inferred. Production admission is exclusively the HD coordinator\\u2019s decision and remains separate from the closed 800-frame checkpoint.\"] \"No Host, live timing, reachability, compositor, palette-fade or 1080p acceptance claim. A future engine change requires current output continuity proof separately.\" [{\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 686], \"RGBA\": [120, 60, 15, 17]}, {\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 687], \"RGBA\": [127, 63, 15, 16]}, {\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 688], \"RGBA\": [120, 67, 13, 19]}] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/independent-review.json, SHA256 9eccf362c3030701ed66d9f5cafc800c417641ac9c3cc8c2c3180630c8d9187c", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101a5", + "101a6", + "101a7", + "101a8" + ], + "sha256": "0d03279051ab2742dbf22368ce2213743f10db8795662c979a3f0e8481d1894d", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101a9", + "101aa", + "101ab", + "101ac" + ], + "sha256": "f9ea76b45d46711d9ca433b8e6cdc7c441e5507e636c388d2f40edbc5bdae033", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ad" + ], + "sha256": "150630e51d745e2b1af7226c28f11ba6a1c71e4bfd83bed0c42a0372475403ff", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101a5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0814c4019a4abc0a70e35d4ff15a205015055cebae968b85765fa951ded4d4fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cb6c60be80d483c171ecbb6b924ebc411134343c0a9615d4303e5e4c42c8c8f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "76bc2033132cf13cbbe2c8d7c1a44c81596c196287e3882c258ab19cda879466", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "947e90d905ac58798fdbb93523483a4c7ecefc1b20a857b39834d731b3a1766c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b62ddde5fe31a72112683a3bee45ea58384c50ee95b44a418ba54eb78f1361dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "751043c9bdf21414a00f712b26bccd2c1ed51d533ee3c09f64e5ca96229d75f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b24d51f5113cce9f08168e13c60688c3ebbfa645f140bfb11bf94727e6a2fc06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ad3354c19d7bfa3d533efd656f377f5b7b04beb25c17572af68cf2e5426f45d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5647e851bae4d375e45fbd2d407ba591a3a8a9510eef30542982dc372210dd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eaa858087535efb28717f573d16104fc6e16b38d4f04060b4e92ed2f45a793b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c5abe050d44059c272da0bfcdf11191034a6b920eec9b699c716512baf6e18d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b7b4fbbf3ee582ec6afee56bb732886dcc743f731a10b95a49e73a404d70c51a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1232f9b9c2105c73b243dfdf96f148e722e171672c0426ed8946d05add88fcf4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ef74a7d86dcf335ef163680cdde22edff1d05a9f0b13e2f5ee01e966ea6c274", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0a99e38cc58bf02a45d5c966e5d45f7f66446875f5d4eb719bce424bd2d943d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d2d2f5de5603297b2f21f05bdd89f655c98b597315f8920f39cff1dc4de43341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "82d2793a721aae8efda5d37a132ddd2e0f533af54776059f37776e1d4342ef93", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a68199be50cef1592115a161febc9a7adc7ecba060d7dcde4333f67ee67c71e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "22f4e78d12cbfdaf4dfe47722aecb991e53d8fc5d2b08d8e8b68639b71b512fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39669071ac802ad6323f1153ba78f1b9899f7180471217146be3dea4fb4cbdcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7534837245eab1316ff0b9fc8a7f66bdb1940c3e68a0b5a5979e817c600fd815", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2f68e67347216fd1b4596a0856386e62df75f72b44b83f3db4b5c558d61cb323", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "abcb99f8a77e6041351d0481cd5cf048a6c8faa818f605e29e5ed53713a9299d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "246f653cb975094ac1be085528c0f8a811cc38f7403ff993e6a2694539033c69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8a463405eecdae5954dfec86fdf59d119f4242b6848aebeb890aa547fffa0ec6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "367e917da7cf5034bf89e37d59ec59dc9c977d488ed813782ceb80c5ab1656c1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d1c963203e8901479cec6b2534fd1cfa2afe70d57438b335078c8148619084d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6dc6a854736b065e78f1d77567a58bcbd5142f5105092794b3b3580da3344cac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4058f39c3a06f31d3a3cecd6827c7fb6a5efa7b86e2541fb19fbb151f934d026", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bb7e8ffdf0f2a3138784534ce20231b45d98e0a5732c836bcc02c0a546c66934", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e190e1089192b1ea824aba7c25842cfafaf1f83d00461e0cb8a23d736ab6235b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "50255049acdebbee4917bfc9787cb79db54088853fe08beab04331a797b59974", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9b13226dafbc76229fb6bd60ed702433308c16e038c7a40e8a70eab660884a34", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "110158f6fc9fa87bad18727e2089a621979c8a4aa6103d2f69f73e502def4d9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa0a27e7ed7d7347aa3767dc9824be5cf14f7f6103db2af8cfa35d24b67c2837", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3c79854593cb1bd811f02dfb376a879357265787edf2ba1bd23b376e2ecdb9bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c76c6d1246bd18a22296d621e726b3454b4117941ec250fdc943e79fb247c69c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb8ef3ccf5ddd0c769b56bad3851eb8e07c13589a879ede64443b3f7431aa044", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a42484d4748505f7c56f521145cab11a74ab42abd12a7c50bbabf44391745a55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9dac55e6ab8fd5ebae29bd64acfd3662175f0df65673bb8301fb7829703e9ff8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8e953f7cbe098fa150300c58d5c00ae94ce0dc7c8c39294305a5e6b478850e41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dff718058528cf477ca0a53116e0042f93ebff44351bfdc3e7d30c5b11217e9c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17ffb3e9b3888b05175ee3e35cdf4be9fbff8a52c0ae90cf8aba8838dfdb73fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "70599b40d0306a114a2431065047f7b1658514a5d2307d08c57e8516fe265cbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bb62feab87345b9736844381e6d9d06244ecc9f80141d66e568db8b4ab9074d9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101ad": { @@ -16587,7 +19325,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101ad", "family_id": "effects-101a5-101ad", "job_id": "effects-101a5-101ad", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -16599,6 +19337,278 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101a5-101ad/candidate.json", "sha256": "9a84f7a47741d47b66cd6f34fce68e02f67ab8ba25b3b08a01d0841f277c05a1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "9a84f7a47741d47b66cd6f34fce68e02f67ab8ba25b3b08a01d0841f277c05a1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a893793764dd179f56949452b6b3c6aaa6f7ba95234f5c761e0c733b51178c70", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.243014+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101a5-101ad/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"All nine authentic original Catalog sources, the unchanged genuine v3 raw atlas, fresh actual Rust scales 1\\u20134, every native 2\\u20133 comparison and the complete ordered static fade sequence were independently inspected. Every padded generator reference is the authentic decoded source plus disclosed transparent padding. The 16\\u00d716 logical canvases, origins and native occupied extrema are retained.\", \"The first frame remains the source narrow nine-cell warm patch. Particle locations, disconnected sparse fragments and development into the wider burst remain source-aligned. No whole occupied source cell is absent at any of the four scales; partial high-scale edge coverage is documented per frame instead of being described as exact silhouettes. Fine matte orange/rust grain is visibly authored in the actual 3\\u00d7 and 4\\u00d7 results; all 36 actual HD outputs differ from original nearest-neighbor RGB pixels.\", \"Stronger outlined source-cell edges occur at 4\\u00d7, particularly 101ab and 101ad. They are conspicuous in diagnostic magnification and remain a local style difference at the actual 64\\u00d764 canvas size. At that actual presentation size the fragments still read as warm orange/brown sparks, not metallic tiled panels, luminous ivory veins or a different object. This exact emphasis is accepted as a disclosed material caveat, based on inspected current pixels rather than native IoU alone.\", \"Native occupancy changes are 9\\u21929, 26\\u219227, 45\\u219247, 41\\u219242, 28\\u219229, 17\\u219220, 18\\u219219, 22\\u219222 and 11\\u219213 across 101a5\\u2013101ad. The three added 101aa cells lie at (2,7), (6,9), (4,15); the two added 101ad cells lie at (5,14), (12,14). The annotated comparisons place them beside existing fragments or in a local body gap, without an independent new particle or changed native bounds. These adjacent expansions, including the lower native IoU of the sparsest late phases, are explicitly accepted and remain documented.\", \"The raw and actual outputs preserve the warm orange/rust-to-dim-brown phase character. They do not introduce white or ivory veins, halos, new rays or an artificial final bright burst. The source itself is not strictly monotonic: 101ab briefly has more light than 101aa. Actual occupied mean brightness is mostly slightly lower, but larger fine edge coverage increases logical-area-normalized total luminance in most later phases; this difference is retained, not called identical brightness. Final 101ad occupied mean luma is 48.7 versus source 60.9, while normalized total is 945.9 versus 670.4. The actual full-size final frame still reads as dim brown sparse fragments.\", \"All selected square source-aspect crops retain every raw pixel with alpha at least 32, 64, 128 and 255 within its own atlas cell. The 101a8 crop alone excludes three faint fringe specks with alpha 17, 16 and 19 at atlas coordinates (295,686), (295,687), (295,688); the exact RGBA values are bound below. This is a disclosed low-opacity crop-margin caveat, not a false zero-alpha\\u226516 claim. The actual indexed loader uses a 128 cutoff after resizing. No meaningful opaque source-aligned contour is cut, and no raw pixels, crop metadata or shader were changed for this review.\", \"Actual indexed original and HD palette counts contain no reserved indices 240\\u2013255. All occupied-source palette-class and forced-index checks pass. Authenticated original binary/RGBA/palette/INDEX bytes, exact frame/crop bindings and immutable library/probe identities are bound. The raw is byte-identical to the original builtin imagegen file; prompt, preparation, references, generation attempts and provenance are separately hashed.\", \"Both runtime freshness guards were false at the actual render invocation, and the indexed invocation recorded an unchanged source snapshot. Our current immutable library is 0ec6137e0e3261e813b2b863cd96c04da55e07cdf29b5c10b1d112e20f0a3daf. All 45 PPMs, nine originals plus 36 actual scales 1\\u20134, are byte-identical to the frozen owner proof using 409b38ea7760734201caf6dfbdd1d08c77ed903c18d7d7450dcd964b1a81fc39. This establishes current output continuity without pretending that the owner proof used our newer library.\", \"Historical v1 held_brightness and v2 held_raw_geometry_brightness remain unchanged and held as their historical versions. The independent approval applies only to the exact submitted v3 candidate and its unchanged raw/bindings. Every one of the 141 frozen author files was verified unchanged at closure. The earlier accepted MediumAir13 and SmallGround35 report hashes were verified unchanged.\", \"This is source/material/crop/palette/loader and complete static phase presentation approval only. No live Host occurrence, effect cadence, compositor timing, live palette fade, final 1080p SDL scene, simulation, collision or RNG behavior was exercised or inferred. Production admission is exclusively the HD coordinator\\u2019s decision and remains separate from the closed 800-frame checkpoint.\"] \"No Host, live timing, reachability, compositor, palette-fade or 1080p acceptance claim. A future engine change requires current output continuity proof separately.\" [{\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 686], \"RGBA\": [120, 60, 15, 17]}, {\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 687], \"RGBA\": [127, 63, 15, 16]}, {\"atlas_coordinate\": [295, 688], \"RGBA\": [120, 67, 13, 19]}] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/independent-review.json, SHA256 9eccf362c3030701ed66d9f5cafc800c417641ac9c3cc8c2c3180630c8d9187c", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101a5", + "101a6", + "101a7", + "101a8" + ], + "sha256": "0d03279051ab2742dbf22368ce2213743f10db8795662c979a3f0e8481d1894d", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101a9", + "101aa", + "101ab", + "101ac" + ], + "sha256": "f9ea76b45d46711d9ca433b8e6cdc7c441e5507e636c388d2f40edbc5bdae033", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ad" + ], + "sha256": "150630e51d745e2b1af7226c28f11ba6a1c71e4bfd83bed0c42a0372475403ff", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101a5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0814c4019a4abc0a70e35d4ff15a205015055cebae968b85765fa951ded4d4fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cb6c60be80d483c171ecbb6b924ebc411134343c0a9615d4303e5e4c42c8c8f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "76bc2033132cf13cbbe2c8d7c1a44c81596c196287e3882c258ab19cda879466", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "947e90d905ac58798fdbb93523483a4c7ecefc1b20a857b39834d731b3a1766c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b62ddde5fe31a72112683a3bee45ea58384c50ee95b44a418ba54eb78f1361dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "751043c9bdf21414a00f712b26bccd2c1ed51d533ee3c09f64e5ca96229d75f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b24d51f5113cce9f08168e13c60688c3ebbfa645f140bfb11bf94727e6a2fc06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ad3354c19d7bfa3d533efd656f377f5b7b04beb25c17572af68cf2e5426f45d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5647e851bae4d375e45fbd2d407ba591a3a8a9510eef30542982dc372210dd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eaa858087535efb28717f573d16104fc6e16b38d4f04060b4e92ed2f45a793b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c5abe050d44059c272da0bfcdf11191034a6b920eec9b699c716512baf6e18d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b7b4fbbf3ee582ec6afee56bb732886dcc743f731a10b95a49e73a404d70c51a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1232f9b9c2105c73b243dfdf96f148e722e171672c0426ed8946d05add88fcf4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ef74a7d86dcf335ef163680cdde22edff1d05a9f0b13e2f5ee01e966ea6c274", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0a99e38cc58bf02a45d5c966e5d45f7f66446875f5d4eb719bce424bd2d943d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d2d2f5de5603297b2f21f05bdd89f655c98b597315f8920f39cff1dc4de43341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "82d2793a721aae8efda5d37a132ddd2e0f533af54776059f37776e1d4342ef93", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a68199be50cef1592115a161febc9a7adc7ecba060d7dcde4333f67ee67c71e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "22f4e78d12cbfdaf4dfe47722aecb991e53d8fc5d2b08d8e8b68639b71b512fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39669071ac802ad6323f1153ba78f1b9899f7180471217146be3dea4fb4cbdcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7534837245eab1316ff0b9fc8a7f66bdb1940c3e68a0b5a5979e817c600fd815", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2f68e67347216fd1b4596a0856386e62df75f72b44b83f3db4b5c558d61cb323", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "abcb99f8a77e6041351d0481cd5cf048a6c8faa818f605e29e5ed53713a9299d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "246f653cb975094ac1be085528c0f8a811cc38f7403ff993e6a2694539033c69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101a9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8a463405eecdae5954dfec86fdf59d119f4242b6848aebeb890aa547fffa0ec6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101a9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "367e917da7cf5034bf89e37d59ec59dc9c977d488ed813782ceb80c5ab1656c1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d1c963203e8901479cec6b2534fd1cfa2afe70d57438b335078c8148619084d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6dc6a854736b065e78f1d77567a58bcbd5142f5105092794b3b3580da3344cac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4058f39c3a06f31d3a3cecd6827c7fb6a5efa7b86e2541fb19fbb151f934d026", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101aa-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bb7e8ffdf0f2a3138784534ce20231b45d98e0a5732c836bcc02c0a546c66934", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101aa-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e190e1089192b1ea824aba7c25842cfafaf1f83d00461e0cb8a23d736ab6235b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "50255049acdebbee4917bfc9787cb79db54088853fe08beab04331a797b59974", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9b13226dafbc76229fb6bd60ed702433308c16e038c7a40e8a70eab660884a34", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "110158f6fc9fa87bad18727e2089a621979c8a4aa6103d2f69f73e502def4d9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ab-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa0a27e7ed7d7347aa3767dc9824be5cf14f7f6103db2af8cfa35d24b67c2837", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ab-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3c79854593cb1bd811f02dfb376a879357265787edf2ba1bd23b376e2ecdb9bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c76c6d1246bd18a22296d621e726b3454b4117941ec250fdc943e79fb247c69c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb8ef3ccf5ddd0c769b56bad3851eb8e07c13589a879ede64443b3f7431aa044", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a42484d4748505f7c56f521145cab11a74ab42abd12a7c50bbabf44391745a55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ac-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9dac55e6ab8fd5ebae29bd64acfd3662175f0df65673bb8301fb7829703e9ff8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ac-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8e953f7cbe098fa150300c58d5c00ae94ce0dc7c8c39294305a5e6b478850e41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dff718058528cf477ca0a53116e0042f93ebff44351bfdc3e7d30c5b11217e9c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17ffb3e9b3888b05175ee3e35cdf4be9fbff8a52c0ae90cf8aba8838dfdb73fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "70599b40d0306a114a2431065047f7b1658514a5d2307d08c57e8516fe265cbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ad-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bb62feab87345b9736844381e6d9d06244ecc9f80141d66e568db8b4ab9074d9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/independent-orange9-iron-coast6/runtime/101ad-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101ae": { @@ -23767,7 +26777,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", - "sha256": "2c369afed088d42bcbfb8985454209716f3cbe24e38cd4f1e3ce55d3fda23a9b", + "sha256": "83dd5f820727b5fb1237169205df6a3e30c1ae2776a8611c5983e1086c78ed3a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -23800,7 +26810,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", - "sha256": "2c369afed088d42bcbfb8985454209716f3cbe24e38cd4f1e3ce55d3fda23a9b", + "sha256": "83dd5f820727b5fb1237169205df6a3e30c1ae2776a8611c5983e1086c78ed3a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -23833,7 +26843,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", - "sha256": "2c369afed088d42bcbfb8985454209716f3cbe24e38cd4f1e3ce55d3fda23a9b", + "sha256": "83dd5f820727b5fb1237169205df6a3e30c1ae2776a8611c5983e1086c78ed3a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -23866,7 +26876,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", - "sha256": "2c369afed088d42bcbfb8985454209716f3cbe24e38cd4f1e3ce55d3fda23a9b", + "sha256": "83dd5f820727b5fb1237169205df6a3e30c1ae2776a8611c5983e1086c78ed3a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -23899,7 +26909,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", - "sha256": "2c369afed088d42bcbfb8985454209716f3cbe24e38cd4f1e3ce55d3fda23a9b", + "sha256": "83dd5f820727b5fb1237169205df6a3e30c1ae2776a8611c5983e1086c78ed3a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -23932,7 +26942,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", - "sha256": "2c369afed088d42bcbfb8985454209716f3cbe24e38cd4f1e3ce55d3fda23a9b", + "sha256": "83dd5f820727b5fb1237169205df6a3e30c1ae2776a8611c5983e1086c78ed3a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -23965,7 +26975,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", - "sha256": "2c369afed088d42bcbfb8985454209716f3cbe24e38cd4f1e3ce55d3fda23a9b", + "sha256": "83dd5f820727b5fb1237169205df6a3e30c1ae2776a8611c5983e1086c78ed3a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -23998,7 +27008,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", - "sha256": "2c369afed088d42bcbfb8985454209716f3cbe24e38cd4f1e3ce55d3fda23a9b", + "sha256": "83dd5f820727b5fb1237169205df6a3e30c1ae2776a8611c5983e1086c78ed3a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -24031,7 +27041,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", - "sha256": "2c369afed088d42bcbfb8985454209716f3cbe24e38cd4f1e3ce55d3fda23a9b", + "sha256": "83dd5f820727b5fb1237169205df6a3e30c1ae2776a8611c5983e1086c78ed3a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -24064,7 +27074,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", - "sha256": "2c369afed088d42bcbfb8985454209716f3cbe24e38cd4f1e3ce55d3fda23a9b", + "sha256": "83dd5f820727b5fb1237169205df6a3e30c1ae2776a8611c5983e1086c78ed3a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -24097,7 +27107,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", - "sha256": "2c369afed088d42bcbfb8985454209716f3cbe24e38cd4f1e3ce55d3fda23a9b", + "sha256": "83dd5f820727b5fb1237169205df6a3e30c1ae2776a8611c5983e1086c78ed3a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -24130,7 +27140,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", - "sha256": "2c369afed088d42bcbfb8985454209716f3cbe24e38cd4f1e3ce55d3fda23a9b", + "sha256": "83dd5f820727b5fb1237169205df6a3e30c1ae2776a8611c5983e1086c78ed3a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -33769,7 +36779,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -33802,7 +36812,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -33835,7 +36845,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -33868,7 +36878,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -33901,7 +36911,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -33934,7 +36944,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -33967,7 +36977,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34000,7 +37010,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34033,7 +37043,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34066,7 +37076,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34099,7 +37109,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34132,7 +37142,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34165,7 +37175,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34198,7 +37208,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34231,7 +37241,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34264,7 +37274,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34297,7 +37307,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34330,7 +37340,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34363,7 +37373,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34396,7 +37406,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34429,7 +37439,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34462,7 +37472,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34495,7 +37505,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34528,7 +37538,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34561,7 +37571,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34594,7 +37604,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0b3681546ffa5e83836821d4e74e0e6bf43aa442893866d962707ac04729043e", + "sha256": "58dd542368337ea0324bd42e5a7006208aa66157058c8376df2abc3c397a1ee9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34627,7 +37637,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "338563f9782d6e1e67fc0564ac880ca4a35ba17cbaae831fbb22159ca84b651d", + "sha256": "ab2efd8f47b07b1d2d2fd0b136126085c8d0b2e9e68124e0793d41f4e2565c21", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34660,7 +37670,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "338563f9782d6e1e67fc0564ac880ca4a35ba17cbaae831fbb22159ca84b651d", + "sha256": "ab2efd8f47b07b1d2d2fd0b136126085c8d0b2e9e68124e0793d41f4e2565c21", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34693,7 +37703,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "338563f9782d6e1e67fc0564ac880ca4a35ba17cbaae831fbb22159ca84b651d", + "sha256": "ab2efd8f47b07b1d2d2fd0b136126085c8d0b2e9e68124e0793d41f4e2565c21", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34726,7 +37736,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "338563f9782d6e1e67fc0564ac880ca4a35ba17cbaae831fbb22159ca84b651d", + "sha256": "ab2efd8f47b07b1d2d2fd0b136126085c8d0b2e9e68124e0793d41f4e2565c21", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34759,7 +37769,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "338563f9782d6e1e67fc0564ac880ca4a35ba17cbaae831fbb22159ca84b651d", + "sha256": "ab2efd8f47b07b1d2d2fd0b136126085c8d0b2e9e68124e0793d41f4e2565c21", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34792,7 +37802,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "338563f9782d6e1e67fc0564ac880ca4a35ba17cbaae831fbb22159ca84b651d", + "sha256": "ab2efd8f47b07b1d2d2fd0b136126085c8d0b2e9e68124e0793d41f4e2565c21", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34825,7 +37835,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "338563f9782d6e1e67fc0564ac880ca4a35ba17cbaae831fbb22159ca84b651d", + "sha256": "ab2efd8f47b07b1d2d2fd0b136126085c8d0b2e9e68124e0793d41f4e2565c21", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34858,7 +37868,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "338563f9782d6e1e67fc0564ac880ca4a35ba17cbaae831fbb22159ca84b651d", + "sha256": "ab2efd8f47b07b1d2d2fd0b136126085c8d0b2e9e68124e0793d41f4e2565c21", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34891,7 +37901,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "338563f9782d6e1e67fc0564ac880ca4a35ba17cbaae831fbb22159ca84b651d", + "sha256": "ab2efd8f47b07b1d2d2fd0b136126085c8d0b2e9e68124e0793d41f4e2565c21", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34924,7 +37934,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "338563f9782d6e1e67fc0564ac880ca4a35ba17cbaae831fbb22159ca84b651d", + "sha256": "ab2efd8f47b07b1d2d2fd0b136126085c8d0b2e9e68124e0793d41f4e2565c21", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34957,7 +37967,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "338563f9782d6e1e67fc0564ac880ca4a35ba17cbaae831fbb22159ca84b651d", + "sha256": "ab2efd8f47b07b1d2d2fd0b136126085c8d0b2e9e68124e0793d41f4e2565c21", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -34990,7 +38000,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "338563f9782d6e1e67fc0564ac880ca4a35ba17cbaae831fbb22159ca84b651d", + "sha256": "ab2efd8f47b07b1d2d2fd0b136126085c8d0b2e9e68124e0793d41f4e2565c21", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -35023,7 +38033,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "338563f9782d6e1e67fc0564ac880ca4a35ba17cbaae831fbb22159ca84b651d", + "sha256": "ab2efd8f47b07b1d2d2fd0b136126085c8d0b2e9e68124e0793d41f4e2565c21", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -35056,7 +38066,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "338563f9782d6e1e67fc0564ac880ca4a35ba17cbaae831fbb22159ca84b651d", + "sha256": "ab2efd8f47b07b1d2d2fd0b136126085c8d0b2e9e68124e0793d41f4e2565c21", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -35089,7 +38099,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "338563f9782d6e1e67fc0564ac880ca4a35ba17cbaae831fbb22159ca84b651d", + "sha256": "ab2efd8f47b07b1d2d2fd0b136126085c8d0b2e9e68124e0793d41f4e2565c21", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -35122,7 +38132,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "338563f9782d6e1e67fc0564ac880ca4a35ba17cbaae831fbb22159ca84b651d", + "sha256": "ab2efd8f47b07b1d2d2fd0b136126085c8d0b2e9e68124e0793d41f4e2565c21", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -35155,7 +38165,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "338563f9782d6e1e67fc0564ac880ca4a35ba17cbaae831fbb22159ca84b651d", + "sha256": "ab2efd8f47b07b1d2d2fd0b136126085c8d0b2e9e68124e0793d41f4e2565c21", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -76755,7 +79765,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10310", "family_id": "bosses-10310-10310", "job_id": "bosses-10310-10310", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_3", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -76765,8 +79775,68 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/bosses-10310-10310/candidate.json", - "sha256": "a22f8d8737bf1c81b201b39419065a147dc1af6f56171d0c7133a4ec4cba28e9", + "sha256": "ca153766ba0e567d2f0400d0df55532d70c34721d3ce17acb82ba727ded9aa66", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "ca153766ba0e567d2f0400d0df55532d70c34721d3ce17acb82ba727ded9aa66", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "03324962cd8466aebc9eb428521e58d76dd469bbe6240e9bddd75be3ade97de2", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.930767+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/bosses-10310-10310/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"family\": \"bosses-10310-10310\", \"decision\": \"approve\", \"scope\": \"Exact v4 candidate, source-faithful HD artwork gallery at scales1\\u20134; no whole-boss assembly claim.\", \"geometry\": \"Broad asymmetric upper elliptical plating, twin centers, opaque dark connecting machinery, side silver/brown housings, circular right upper rim, curved lower skirt and complete cylindrical feet remain recognizable and continuous. Native2/3 retain the same mass and part placement. Authored occupation of black interior is preserved; black is never treated as transparent by the audit.\", \"isolated_contour_judgment\": \"At4x, exactly three wholly missing source cells: dark RGB4 corners(22,7),(28,54), and a gray RGB113 rim edge cell(60,46). Independently viewed the marked source/HD2/3/4 close-up; gray cell is one outward stair on a smooth arc, with connected curved plating continuing immediately inward. Accept this isolated curved-edge interpretation. It does not create a rim gap, amputate a housing or flatten the skirt/foot. The author named critical boxes exclude this cell; the broader independent box includes it, so zero named-region loss is not presented as whole-contour identity.\", \"remaining_differences\": \"Source-cell misses at1/2/3/4 are98/30/22/3. Scale3 loses18 source-dark edge cells on x0; scale1 thins the top rim and foot edge. Actual native images remain coherent silhouettes, but low-scale contours are not pixel-identical. Subpixel coverage of many curved boundary cells remains below half their source-cell area. More segmented metal grain, bolts and vents are an HD interpretation.\", \"named_critical_boxes\": \"Right disc[51,1,64,20], lower-right skirt[50,48,61,56], foot[62,46,79,51] have zero wholly missing occupied source cells at2/3/4; no half-area guarantee.\", \"candidate_sha256\": \"ca153766ba0e567d2f0400d0df55532d70c34721d3ce17acb82ba727ded9aa66\", \"frame_bindings_sha256\": \"03324962cd8466aebc9eb428521e58d76dd469bbe6240e9bddd75be3ade97de2\"} [\"Independent artwork and actual immutable HdAssets::load/sprite gallery review only. No live Host whole-boss assembly/reachability/timing, gameplay hitbox/economy or boss behavior claim.\", \"No art/source/candidate/raw/schema/global/production/Git writes, generation or promotion. Evidence only under isolated reference directory. Coordinator owns any admission.\", \"Crops preserve every raw alpha>=16and32pixel. 10310 crop excludes192and200a3crop2072low-alpha1\\u201315exterior gutter pixels; do not claim all input pixels displayed. Entire raw files are unchanged and match original builtin generator output exactly.\", \"Existing held300a8\\u2013ab/200ba/300a0 and old400v2/atlas final remain outside approval. Source-class/straight-alpha policies unchanged.\", \"Source masks, occupied-black fidelity and reserved-index counts are diagnostics; geometry/material decisions above were made from actual source/raw/runtime visual inspection.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 89652063ab9dda20291516e213612346c1a7163723ad70061271980bd373361b", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/author-review-complete.json", + "sha256": "f095712da51d9a5ad76657a4f77797f319b0e3a599af7535ee881a3c04e8bf64" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "10310" + ], + "sha256": "df62ed3aa415cec4d2783213eae7c1cc9abaf8d170d0490ff69eacc20e713712", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10310-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3d3db3d3f99cb2e762fd099c0b1b7f20d6e57be925e5b854e2aed80bbe38ecbe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-10310-10310/runtime/10310-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10310-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b844ef6fe2d09a2066b6da26d4e082bea1dd4d745626e93a7b5ab8aa12f01d8d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-10310-10310/runtime/10310-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10310-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a63b86d0b6e642776a1583ad55e7d01c23e4012d74c7cfcea4f563cb648cea61", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-10310-10310/runtime/10310-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10310-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ced950081704b5baf82217b6b83047f72dff2d84a393c29ddbfe590103adf6d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-10310-10310/runtime/10310-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10310-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c01fbec7c410153138a48303640d8e57b19ade0aeca7645316a930a0f666bf11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-10310-10310/runtime/10310-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": { + "old_held_candidate": "jobs/bosses-10310-10310/held-main-before-coordinator-promotion-a22f8d8737bf1c81.json", + "old_held_sha256": "a22f8d8737bf1c81b201b39419065a147dc1af6f56171d0c7133a4ec4cba28e9", + "approved_sibling": "jobs/bosses-10310-10310/candidate-iron-coast-3-peer-v4.json", + "exact_bytes_promoted": true + } } }, "10311": { @@ -133346,7 +136416,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10410", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -133357,6 +136427,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6a1001508d2dd9da57a401ae10eec5e0d59d9cefca849a99e8fb1f9c37a95fbe", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "10411": { @@ -133378,7 +136453,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10411", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -133389,6 +136464,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6a1001508d2dd9da57a401ae10eec5e0d59d9cefca849a99e8fb1f9c37a95fbe", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "10412": { @@ -133410,7 +136490,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10412", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -133421,6 +136501,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6a1001508d2dd9da57a401ae10eec5e0d59d9cefca849a99e8fb1f9c37a95fbe", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "10413": { @@ -133442,7 +136527,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10413", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -133453,6 +136538,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6a1001508d2dd9da57a401ae10eec5e0d59d9cefca849a99e8fb1f9c37a95fbe", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "10414": { @@ -133474,7 +136564,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10414", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -133485,6 +136575,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6a1001508d2dd9da57a401ae10eec5e0d59d9cefca849a99e8fb1f9c37a95fbe", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "10415": { @@ -133506,7 +136601,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10415", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -133517,6 +136612,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6a1001508d2dd9da57a401ae10eec5e0d59d9cefca849a99e8fb1f9c37a95fbe", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "10416": { @@ -133538,7 +136638,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10416", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -133549,6 +136649,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6a1001508d2dd9da57a401ae10eec5e0d59d9cefca849a99e8fb1f9c37a95fbe", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "10417": { @@ -133570,7 +136675,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10417", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -133581,6 +136686,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6a1001508d2dd9da57a401ae10eec5e0d59d9cefca849a99e8fb1f9c37a95fbe", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "10418": { @@ -133602,7 +136712,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10418", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -133613,6 +136723,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6a1001508d2dd9da57a401ae10eec5e0d59d9cefca849a99e8fb1f9c37a95fbe", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "10419": { @@ -133634,7 +136749,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10419", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -133645,6 +136760,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6a1001508d2dd9da57a401ae10eec5e0d59d9cefca849a99e8fb1f9c37a95fbe", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "1041a": { @@ -133666,7 +136786,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1041a", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -133677,6 +136797,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6a1001508d2dd9da57a401ae10eec5e0d59d9cefca849a99e8fb1f9c37a95fbe", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "1041b": { @@ -133698,7 +136823,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1041b", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -133709,6 +136834,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6a1001508d2dd9da57a401ae10eec5e0d59d9cefca849a99e8fb1f9c37a95fbe", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "1041c": { @@ -133730,7 +136860,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1041c", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -133741,6 +136871,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6a1001508d2dd9da57a401ae10eec5e0d59d9cefca849a99e8fb1f9c37a95fbe", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "1041d": { @@ -133762,7 +136897,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1041d", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -133773,6 +136908,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6a1001508d2dd9da57a401ae10eec5e0d59d9cefca849a99e8fb1f9c37a95fbe", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "1041e": { @@ -133794,7 +136934,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1041e", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -133805,6 +136945,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6a1001508d2dd9da57a401ae10eec5e0d59d9cefca849a99e8fb1f9c37a95fbe", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "1041f": { @@ -133826,7 +136971,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1041f", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -133837,6 +136982,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6a1001508d2dd9da57a401ae10eec5e0d59d9cefca849a99e8fb1f9c37a95fbe", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "10420": { @@ -160690,7 +163840,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "200a3", "family_id": "bosses-200a3-200a3", "job_id": "bosses-200a3-200a3", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_3", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -160700,8 +163850,68 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/bosses-200a3-200a3/candidate.json", - "sha256": "69e4e10058d184d8d2ee8785fdb597930e5a65ca8dbea9a72da3e747f70d6f69", + "sha256": "032d4ec12eaf91887416ea55d71042c26d8937a9a61ae622af12d54abc1b1144", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "032d4ec12eaf91887416ea55d71042c26d8937a9a61ae622af12d54abc1b1144", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "da8fddc18ce5c562257056bc2087a42b689cc2b7f4dad8d0690270c69cf280d4", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.988535+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/bosses-200a3-200a3/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"family\": \"bosses-200a3-200a3\", \"decision\": \"approve\", \"scope\": \"Exact v4 candidate, source-faithful HD artwork gallery at scales1\\u20134; no whole-boss assembly claim.\", \"geometry\": \"Four upper stalks, paired circular copper/cyan fronts, occupied dark connecting mass, central cyan crossbar, paired lower joins and stepped tips retain the source layout. Both logical y35 joining bridges(leftx20\\u201331,rightx39\\u201349) and center x35y36 have full actual occupancy at all four scales; no lower floating or disconnected mass remains. Logical72\\u00d740canvas/origin0 unchanged.\", \"isolated_contour_judgment\": \"Exactly17 wholly missing source cells at2/3/4: upper stalk outline/corner cells with gray up toRGB48, source-dark lower tip outlines, and a single gray RGB93/89/89 tip cell(18,37). Original and actual native2/3 plus marked lower-tip2/3/4 detail were visually inspected. The isolated gray tip is a one-cell bevel interpretation; the stepped fork/tip remains present beside it, rather than a removed appendage. Accept.\", \"remaining_differences\": \"HD occupies logical rightmost column where source maxx is70: source bounds71\\u00d740 versusHD logical bounds72\\u00d740, within exact immutable logical canvas. This small contour expansion and17 missing cells mean mask geometry is approximate. Count at1x28. Source black interiors remain occupied. Surface rivets, finer vents and rounded bevels are interpreted HD detail, while muted cyan/copper/dark palette character is retained.\", \"candidate_sha256\": \"032d4ec12eaf91887416ea55d71042c26d8937a9a61ae622af12d54abc1b1144\", \"frame_bindings_sha256\": \"da8fddc18ce5c562257056bc2087a42b689cc2b7f4dad8d0690270c69cf280d4\"} [\"Independent artwork and actual immutable HdAssets::load/sprite gallery review only. No live Host whole-boss assembly/reachability/timing, gameplay hitbox/economy or boss behavior claim.\", \"No art/source/candidate/raw/schema/global/production/Git writes, generation or promotion. Evidence only under isolated reference directory. Coordinator owns any admission.\", \"Crops preserve every raw alpha>=16and32pixel. 10310 crop excludes192and200a3crop2072low-alpha1\\u201315exterior gutter pixels; do not claim all input pixels displayed. Entire raw files are unchanged and match original builtin generator output exactly.\", \"Existing held300a8\\u2013ab/200ba/300a0 and old400v2/atlas final remain outside approval. Source-class/straight-alpha policies unchanged.\", \"Source masks, occupied-black fidelity and reserved-index counts are diagnostics; geometry/material decisions above were made from actual source/raw/runtime visual inspection.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 89652063ab9dda20291516e213612346c1a7163723ad70061271980bd373361b", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/author-review-complete.json", + "sha256": "f095712da51d9a5ad76657a4f77797f319b0e3a599af7535ee881a3c04e8bf64" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "200a3" + ], + "sha256": "a671ceb354d6320216036fd66c05d53981fc12f8501acc0d82b1eb07f9465196", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "200a3-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "095cd89c4d818e9fe58868a2c5409c3f5d99c4d98f15d3e4ed0083b645a8a723", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-200a3-200a3/runtime/200a3-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "200a3-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "901cbe6aa7198a8f107409230bf6ca1795694113fc813061a3c62253aa5da717", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-200a3-200a3/runtime/200a3-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "200a3-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bc6aae74387b18e8ed334c4520647f8e79bf14fa379c10c2482498eb58571782", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-200a3-200a3/runtime/200a3-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "200a3-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3cb5b8cf7a0a28368f7eceea38aed90634e4acc3d0617723e17250593e6a041d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-200a3-200a3/runtime/200a3-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "200a3-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a0fe366139603bb23f7cbd80afa0decc25da594eea145a075192affd50a0238e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-200a3-200a3/runtime/200a3-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": { + "old_held_candidate": "jobs/bosses-200a3-200a3/held-main-before-coordinator-promotion-69e4e10058d184d8.json", + "old_held_sha256": "69e4e10058d184d8d2ee8785fdb597930e5a65ca8dbea9a72da3e747f70d6f69", + "approved_sibling": "jobs/bosses-200a3-200a3/candidate-iron-coast-3-peer-v4.json", + "exact_bytes_promoted": true + } } }, "200a4": { @@ -202112,7 +205322,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2030d-2031c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "ceac559efbf41445f42db605dc9a6c92dd897584f542a5a4b03c127de2fac09e", + "sha256": "52ab5955a9e743ea3b6f87ffa6ec545d77e1e0a3647d125548ecd278a233332c", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -202149,7 +205359,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2030d-2031c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "ceac559efbf41445f42db605dc9a6c92dd897584f542a5a4b03c127de2fac09e", + "sha256": "52ab5955a9e743ea3b6f87ffa6ec545d77e1e0a3647d125548ecd278a233332c", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -202186,7 +205396,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2030d-2031c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "ceac559efbf41445f42db605dc9a6c92dd897584f542a5a4b03c127de2fac09e", + "sha256": "52ab5955a9e743ea3b6f87ffa6ec545d77e1e0a3647d125548ecd278a233332c", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -202223,7 +205433,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2030d-2031c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "ceac559efbf41445f42db605dc9a6c92dd897584f542a5a4b03c127de2fac09e", + "sha256": "52ab5955a9e743ea3b6f87ffa6ec545d77e1e0a3647d125548ecd278a233332c", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -202260,7 +205470,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2030d-2031c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "ceac559efbf41445f42db605dc9a6c92dd897584f542a5a4b03c127de2fac09e", + "sha256": "52ab5955a9e743ea3b6f87ffa6ec545d77e1e0a3647d125548ecd278a233332c", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -202297,7 +205507,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2030d-2031c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "ceac559efbf41445f42db605dc9a6c92dd897584f542a5a4b03c127de2fac09e", + "sha256": "52ab5955a9e743ea3b6f87ffa6ec545d77e1e0a3647d125548ecd278a233332c", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -202334,7 +205544,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2030d-2031c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "ceac559efbf41445f42db605dc9a6c92dd897584f542a5a4b03c127de2fac09e", + "sha256": "52ab5955a9e743ea3b6f87ffa6ec545d77e1e0a3647d125548ecd278a233332c", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -202371,7 +205581,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2030d-2031c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "ceac559efbf41445f42db605dc9a6c92dd897584f542a5a4b03c127de2fac09e", + "sha256": "52ab5955a9e743ea3b6f87ffa6ec545d77e1e0a3647d125548ecd278a233332c", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -202408,7 +205618,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2030d-2031c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "ceac559efbf41445f42db605dc9a6c92dd897584f542a5a4b03c127de2fac09e", + "sha256": "52ab5955a9e743ea3b6f87ffa6ec545d77e1e0a3647d125548ecd278a233332c", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -202445,7 +205655,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2030d-2031c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "ceac559efbf41445f42db605dc9a6c92dd897584f542a5a4b03c127de2fac09e", + "sha256": "52ab5955a9e743ea3b6f87ffa6ec545d77e1e0a3647d125548ecd278a233332c", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -202482,7 +205692,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2030d-2031c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "ceac559efbf41445f42db605dc9a6c92dd897584f542a5a4b03c127de2fac09e", + "sha256": "52ab5955a9e743ea3b6f87ffa6ec545d77e1e0a3647d125548ecd278a233332c", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -202519,7 +205729,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2030d-2031c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "ceac559efbf41445f42db605dc9a6c92dd897584f542a5a4b03c127de2fac09e", + "sha256": "52ab5955a9e743ea3b6f87ffa6ec545d77e1e0a3647d125548ecd278a233332c", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -202556,7 +205766,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2030d-2031c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "ceac559efbf41445f42db605dc9a6c92dd897584f542a5a4b03c127de2fac09e", + "sha256": "52ab5955a9e743ea3b6f87ffa6ec545d77e1e0a3647d125548ecd278a233332c", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -202593,7 +205803,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2030d-2031c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "ceac559efbf41445f42db605dc9a6c92dd897584f542a5a4b03c127de2fac09e", + "sha256": "52ab5955a9e743ea3b6f87ffa6ec545d77e1e0a3647d125548ecd278a233332c", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -202630,7 +205840,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2030d-2031c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "ceac559efbf41445f42db605dc9a6c92dd897584f542a5a4b03c127de2fac09e", + "sha256": "52ab5955a9e743ea3b6f87ffa6ec545d77e1e0a3647d125548ecd278a233332c", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -202667,7 +205877,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2030d-2031c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "ceac559efbf41445f42db605dc9a6c92dd897584f542a5a4b03c127de2fac09e", + "sha256": "52ab5955a9e743ea3b6f87ffa6ec545d77e1e0a3647d125548ecd278a233332c", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -202690,7 +205900,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2031d", "family_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", "job_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202701,6 +205911,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2031d-2032c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "411b15a873abfc42739c8d9e872e6c797e24b588bd4b9c0901b0f1bc42689d50", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2031e": { @@ -202722,7 +205937,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2031e", "family_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", "job_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202733,6 +205948,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2031d-2032c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "411b15a873abfc42739c8d9e872e6c797e24b588bd4b9c0901b0f1bc42689d50", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2031f": { @@ -202754,7 +205974,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2031f", "family_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", "job_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202765,6 +205985,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2031d-2032c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "411b15a873abfc42739c8d9e872e6c797e24b588bd4b9c0901b0f1bc42689d50", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20320": { @@ -202786,7 +206011,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20320", "family_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", "job_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -202797,6 +206022,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2031d-2032c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "411b15a873abfc42739c8d9e872e6c797e24b588bd4b9c0901b0f1bc42689d50", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20321": { @@ -202818,7 +206048,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20321", "family_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", "job_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202829,6 +206059,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2031d-2032c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "411b15a873abfc42739c8d9e872e6c797e24b588bd4b9c0901b0f1bc42689d50", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20322": { @@ -202850,7 +206085,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20322", "family_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", "job_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -202861,6 +206096,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2031d-2032c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "411b15a873abfc42739c8d9e872e6c797e24b588bd4b9c0901b0f1bc42689d50", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20323": { @@ -202882,7 +206122,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20323", "family_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", "job_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202893,6 +206133,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2031d-2032c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "411b15a873abfc42739c8d9e872e6c797e24b588bd4b9c0901b0f1bc42689d50", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20324": { @@ -202914,7 +206159,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20324", "family_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", "job_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202925,6 +206170,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2031d-2032c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "411b15a873abfc42739c8d9e872e6c797e24b588bd4b9c0901b0f1bc42689d50", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20325": { @@ -202946,7 +206196,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20325", "family_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", "job_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202957,6 +206207,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2031d-2032c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "411b15a873abfc42739c8d9e872e6c797e24b588bd4b9c0901b0f1bc42689d50", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20326": { @@ -202978,7 +206233,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20326", "family_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", "job_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202989,6 +206244,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2031d-2032c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "411b15a873abfc42739c8d9e872e6c797e24b588bd4b9c0901b0f1bc42689d50", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20327": { @@ -203010,7 +206270,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20327", "family_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", "job_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -203021,6 +206281,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2031d-2032c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "411b15a873abfc42739c8d9e872e6c797e24b588bd4b9c0901b0f1bc42689d50", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20328": { @@ -203042,7 +206307,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20328", "family_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", "job_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203053,6 +206318,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2031d-2032c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "411b15a873abfc42739c8d9e872e6c797e24b588bd4b9c0901b0f1bc42689d50", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20329": { @@ -203074,7 +206344,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20329", "family_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", "job_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203085,6 +206355,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2031d-2032c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "411b15a873abfc42739c8d9e872e6c797e24b588bd4b9c0901b0f1bc42689d50", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2032a": { @@ -203106,7 +206381,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2032a", "family_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", "job_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203117,6 +206392,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2031d-2032c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "411b15a873abfc42739c8d9e872e6c797e24b588bd4b9c0901b0f1bc42689d50", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2032b": { @@ -203138,7 +206418,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2032b", "family_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", "job_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203149,6 +206429,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2031d-2032c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "411b15a873abfc42739c8d9e872e6c797e24b588bd4b9c0901b0f1bc42689d50", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2032c": { @@ -203170,7 +206455,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2032c", "family_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", "job_id": "terrain-2031d-2032c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203181,6 +206466,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2031d-2032c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "411b15a873abfc42739c8d9e872e6c797e24b588bd4b9c0901b0f1bc42689d50", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2032d": { @@ -203202,7 +206492,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2032d", "family_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", "job_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203213,6 +206503,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2032d-2033c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "ddbc832f249d345dbb36d53579dbed9e9d7e2522af0070da6953a3b92f3536e5", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2032e": { @@ -203234,7 +206529,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2032e", "family_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", "job_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203245,6 +206540,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2032d-2033c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "ddbc832f249d345dbb36d53579dbed9e9d7e2522af0070da6953a3b92f3536e5", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2032f": { @@ -203266,7 +206566,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2032f", "family_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", "job_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203277,6 +206577,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2032d-2033c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "ddbc832f249d345dbb36d53579dbed9e9d7e2522af0070da6953a3b92f3536e5", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20330": { @@ -203298,7 +206603,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20330", "family_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", "job_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203309,6 +206614,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2032d-2033c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "ddbc832f249d345dbb36d53579dbed9e9d7e2522af0070da6953a3b92f3536e5", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20331": { @@ -203330,7 +206640,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20331", "family_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", "job_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203341,6 +206651,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2032d-2033c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "ddbc832f249d345dbb36d53579dbed9e9d7e2522af0070da6953a3b92f3536e5", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20332": { @@ -203362,7 +206677,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20332", "family_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", "job_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203373,6 +206688,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2032d-2033c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "ddbc832f249d345dbb36d53579dbed9e9d7e2522af0070da6953a3b92f3536e5", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20333": { @@ -203394,7 +206714,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20333", "family_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", "job_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203405,6 +206725,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2032d-2033c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "ddbc832f249d345dbb36d53579dbed9e9d7e2522af0070da6953a3b92f3536e5", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20334": { @@ -203426,7 +206751,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20334", "family_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", "job_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203437,6 +206762,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2032d-2033c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "ddbc832f249d345dbb36d53579dbed9e9d7e2522af0070da6953a3b92f3536e5", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20335": { @@ -203458,7 +206788,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20335", "family_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", "job_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203469,6 +206799,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2032d-2033c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "ddbc832f249d345dbb36d53579dbed9e9d7e2522af0070da6953a3b92f3536e5", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20336": { @@ -203490,7 +206825,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20336", "family_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", "job_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203501,6 +206836,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2032d-2033c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "ddbc832f249d345dbb36d53579dbed9e9d7e2522af0070da6953a3b92f3536e5", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20337": { @@ -203522,7 +206862,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20337", "family_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", "job_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203533,6 +206873,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2032d-2033c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "ddbc832f249d345dbb36d53579dbed9e9d7e2522af0070da6953a3b92f3536e5", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20338": { @@ -203554,7 +206899,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20338", "family_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", "job_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203565,6 +206910,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2032d-2033c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "ddbc832f249d345dbb36d53579dbed9e9d7e2522af0070da6953a3b92f3536e5", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20339": { @@ -203586,7 +206936,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20339", "family_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", "job_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203597,6 +206947,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2032d-2033c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "ddbc832f249d345dbb36d53579dbed9e9d7e2522af0070da6953a3b92f3536e5", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2033a": { @@ -203618,7 +206973,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2033a", "family_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", "job_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203629,6 +206984,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2032d-2033c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "ddbc832f249d345dbb36d53579dbed9e9d7e2522af0070da6953a3b92f3536e5", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2033b": { @@ -203650,7 +207010,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2033b", "family_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", "job_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203661,6 +207021,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2032d-2033c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "ddbc832f249d345dbb36d53579dbed9e9d7e2522af0070da6953a3b92f3536e5", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2033c": { @@ -203682,7 +207047,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2033c", "family_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", "job_id": "terrain-2032d-2033c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -203693,6 +207058,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2032d-2033c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "ddbc832f249d345dbb36d53579dbed9e9d7e2522af0070da6953a3b92f3536e5", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2033d": { @@ -203714,7 +207084,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2033d", "family_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", "job_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203725,6 +207095,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2033d-2034c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "21d9448483c93bdb6a1e4436022e6e4220c5b069ec068a1ac76075b6dae26d6e", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2033e": { @@ -203746,7 +207121,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2033e", "family_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", "job_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203757,6 +207132,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2033d-2034c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "21d9448483c93bdb6a1e4436022e6e4220c5b069ec068a1ac76075b6dae26d6e", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2033f": { @@ -203778,7 +207158,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2033f", "family_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", "job_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -203789,6 +207169,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2033d-2034c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "21d9448483c93bdb6a1e4436022e6e4220c5b069ec068a1ac76075b6dae26d6e", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20340": { @@ -203810,7 +207195,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20340", "family_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", "job_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -203821,6 +207206,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2033d-2034c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "21d9448483c93bdb6a1e4436022e6e4220c5b069ec068a1ac76075b6dae26d6e", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20341": { @@ -203842,7 +207232,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20341", "family_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", "job_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203853,6 +207243,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2033d-2034c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "21d9448483c93bdb6a1e4436022e6e4220c5b069ec068a1ac76075b6dae26d6e", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20342": { @@ -203874,7 +207269,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20342", "family_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", "job_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203885,6 +207280,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2033d-2034c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "21d9448483c93bdb6a1e4436022e6e4220c5b069ec068a1ac76075b6dae26d6e", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20343": { @@ -203906,7 +207306,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20343", "family_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", "job_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203917,6 +207317,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2033d-2034c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "21d9448483c93bdb6a1e4436022e6e4220c5b069ec068a1ac76075b6dae26d6e", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20344": { @@ -203938,7 +207343,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20344", "family_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", "job_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203949,6 +207354,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2033d-2034c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "21d9448483c93bdb6a1e4436022e6e4220c5b069ec068a1ac76075b6dae26d6e", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20345": { @@ -203970,7 +207380,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20345", "family_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", "job_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -203981,6 +207391,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2033d-2034c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "21d9448483c93bdb6a1e4436022e6e4220c5b069ec068a1ac76075b6dae26d6e", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20346": { @@ -204002,7 +207417,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20346", "family_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", "job_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -204013,6 +207428,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2033d-2034c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "21d9448483c93bdb6a1e4436022e6e4220c5b069ec068a1ac76075b6dae26d6e", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20347": { @@ -204034,7 +207454,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20347", "family_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", "job_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -204045,6 +207465,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2033d-2034c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "21d9448483c93bdb6a1e4436022e6e4220c5b069ec068a1ac76075b6dae26d6e", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20348": { @@ -204066,7 +207491,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20348", "family_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", "job_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -204077,6 +207502,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2033d-2034c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "21d9448483c93bdb6a1e4436022e6e4220c5b069ec068a1ac76075b6dae26d6e", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20349": { @@ -204098,7 +207528,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20349", "family_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", "job_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -204109,6 +207539,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2033d-2034c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "21d9448483c93bdb6a1e4436022e6e4220c5b069ec068a1ac76075b6dae26d6e", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2034a": { @@ -204130,7 +207565,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2034a", "family_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", "job_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -204141,6 +207576,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2033d-2034c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "21d9448483c93bdb6a1e4436022e6e4220c5b069ec068a1ac76075b6dae26d6e", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2034b": { @@ -204162,7 +207602,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2034b", "family_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", "job_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -204173,6 +207613,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2033d-2034c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "21d9448483c93bdb6a1e4436022e6e4220c5b069ec068a1ac76075b6dae26d6e", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2034c": { @@ -204194,7 +207639,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2034c", "family_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", "job_id": "terrain-2033d-2034c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -204205,6 +207650,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2033d-2034c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "21d9448483c93bdb6a1e4436022e6e4220c5b069ec068a1ac76075b6dae26d6e", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2034d": { @@ -204226,8 +207676,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2034d", "family_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", "job_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -204237,6 +207687,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2034d-2035c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "650dd6af8ce463295db00c9d39ae29e1af225e83ab17619dcb2c049358b5fe4d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2034e": { @@ -204258,8 +207713,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2034e", "family_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", "job_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -204269,6 +207724,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2034d-2035c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "650dd6af8ce463295db00c9d39ae29e1af225e83ab17619dcb2c049358b5fe4d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2034f": { @@ -204290,8 +207750,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2034f", "family_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", "job_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -204301,6 +207761,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2034d-2035c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "650dd6af8ce463295db00c9d39ae29e1af225e83ab17619dcb2c049358b5fe4d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20350": { @@ -204322,8 +207787,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20350", "family_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", "job_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -204333,6 +207798,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2034d-2035c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "650dd6af8ce463295db00c9d39ae29e1af225e83ab17619dcb2c049358b5fe4d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20351": { @@ -204354,8 +207824,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20351", "family_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", "job_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -204365,6 +207835,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2034d-2035c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "650dd6af8ce463295db00c9d39ae29e1af225e83ab17619dcb2c049358b5fe4d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20352": { @@ -204386,8 +207861,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20352", "family_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", "job_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -204397,6 +207872,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2034d-2035c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "650dd6af8ce463295db00c9d39ae29e1af225e83ab17619dcb2c049358b5fe4d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20353": { @@ -204418,8 +207898,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20353", "family_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", "job_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -204429,6 +207909,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2034d-2035c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "650dd6af8ce463295db00c9d39ae29e1af225e83ab17619dcb2c049358b5fe4d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20354": { @@ -204450,8 +207935,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20354", "family_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", "job_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -204461,6 +207946,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2034d-2035c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "650dd6af8ce463295db00c9d39ae29e1af225e83ab17619dcb2c049358b5fe4d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20355": { @@ -204482,8 +207972,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20355", "family_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", "job_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -204493,6 +207983,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2034d-2035c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "650dd6af8ce463295db00c9d39ae29e1af225e83ab17619dcb2c049358b5fe4d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20356": { @@ -204514,8 +208009,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20356", "family_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", "job_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -204525,6 +208020,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2034d-2035c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "650dd6af8ce463295db00c9d39ae29e1af225e83ab17619dcb2c049358b5fe4d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20357": { @@ -204546,8 +208046,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20357", "family_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", "job_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -204557,6 +208057,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2034d-2035c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "650dd6af8ce463295db00c9d39ae29e1af225e83ab17619dcb2c049358b5fe4d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20358": { @@ -204578,8 +208083,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20358", "family_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", "job_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -204589,6 +208094,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2034d-2035c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "650dd6af8ce463295db00c9d39ae29e1af225e83ab17619dcb2c049358b5fe4d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20359": { @@ -204610,8 +208120,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20359", "family_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", "job_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -204621,6 +208131,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2034d-2035c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "650dd6af8ce463295db00c9d39ae29e1af225e83ab17619dcb2c049358b5fe4d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2035a": { @@ -204642,8 +208157,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2035a", "family_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", "job_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -204653,6 +208168,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2034d-2035c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "650dd6af8ce463295db00c9d39ae29e1af225e83ab17619dcb2c049358b5fe4d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2035b": { @@ -204674,8 +208194,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2035b", "family_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", "job_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -204685,6 +208205,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2034d-2035c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "650dd6af8ce463295db00c9d39ae29e1af225e83ab17619dcb2c049358b5fe4d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2035c": { @@ -204706,8 +208231,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2035c", "family_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", "job_id": "terrain-2034d-2035c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -204717,6 +208242,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2034d-2035c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "650dd6af8ce463295db00c9d39ae29e1af225e83ab17619dcb2c049358b5fe4d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2035d": { @@ -204738,8 +208268,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2035d", "family_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", "job_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -204749,6 +208279,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2035d-2036c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "c414e2366dd648865d7c60ab3ebd45399bfd3103b4359793d9207ea79f3e15e3", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2035e": { @@ -204770,8 +208305,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2035e", "family_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", "job_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -204781,6 +208316,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2035d-2036c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "c414e2366dd648865d7c60ab3ebd45399bfd3103b4359793d9207ea79f3e15e3", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2035f": { @@ -204802,8 +208342,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2035f", "family_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", "job_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -204813,6 +208353,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2035d-2036c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "c414e2366dd648865d7c60ab3ebd45399bfd3103b4359793d9207ea79f3e15e3", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20360": { @@ -204834,8 +208379,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20360", "family_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", "job_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -204845,6 +208390,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2035d-2036c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "c414e2366dd648865d7c60ab3ebd45399bfd3103b4359793d9207ea79f3e15e3", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20361": { @@ -204866,8 +208416,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20361", "family_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", "job_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -204877,6 +208427,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2035d-2036c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "c414e2366dd648865d7c60ab3ebd45399bfd3103b4359793d9207ea79f3e15e3", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20362": { @@ -204898,8 +208453,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20362", "family_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", "job_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -204909,6 +208464,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2035d-2036c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "c414e2366dd648865d7c60ab3ebd45399bfd3103b4359793d9207ea79f3e15e3", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20363": { @@ -204930,8 +208490,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20363", "family_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", "job_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -204941,6 +208501,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2035d-2036c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "c414e2366dd648865d7c60ab3ebd45399bfd3103b4359793d9207ea79f3e15e3", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20364": { @@ -204962,8 +208527,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20364", "family_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", "job_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -204973,6 +208538,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2035d-2036c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "c414e2366dd648865d7c60ab3ebd45399bfd3103b4359793d9207ea79f3e15e3", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20365": { @@ -204994,8 +208564,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20365", "family_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", "job_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205005,6 +208575,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2035d-2036c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "c414e2366dd648865d7c60ab3ebd45399bfd3103b4359793d9207ea79f3e15e3", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20366": { @@ -205026,8 +208601,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20366", "family_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", "job_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205037,6 +208612,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2035d-2036c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "c414e2366dd648865d7c60ab3ebd45399bfd3103b4359793d9207ea79f3e15e3", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20367": { @@ -205058,8 +208638,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20367", "family_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", "job_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205069,6 +208649,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2035d-2036c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "c414e2366dd648865d7c60ab3ebd45399bfd3103b4359793d9207ea79f3e15e3", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20368": { @@ -205090,8 +208675,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20368", "family_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", "job_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -205101,6 +208686,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2035d-2036c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "c414e2366dd648865d7c60ab3ebd45399bfd3103b4359793d9207ea79f3e15e3", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "20369": { @@ -205122,8 +208712,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20369", "family_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", "job_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -205133,6 +208723,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2035d-2036c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "c414e2366dd648865d7c60ab3ebd45399bfd3103b4359793d9207ea79f3e15e3", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2036a": { @@ -205154,8 +208749,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2036a", "family_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", "job_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205165,6 +208760,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2035d-2036c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "c414e2366dd648865d7c60ab3ebd45399bfd3103b4359793d9207ea79f3e15e3", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2036b": { @@ -205186,8 +208786,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2036b", "family_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", "job_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205197,6 +208797,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2035d-2036c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "c414e2366dd648865d7c60ab3ebd45399bfd3103b4359793d9207ea79f3e15e3", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2036c": { @@ -205218,8 +208823,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2036c", "family_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", "job_id": "terrain-2035d-2036c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205229,6 +208834,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2035d-2036c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "c414e2366dd648865d7c60ab3ebd45399bfd3103b4359793d9207ea79f3e15e3", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2036d": { @@ -205250,8 +208860,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2036d", "family_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", "job_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205282,8 +208892,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2036e", "family_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", "job_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205314,8 +208924,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2036f", "family_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", "job_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -205346,8 +208956,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20370", "family_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", "job_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -205378,8 +208988,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20371", "family_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", "job_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205410,8 +209020,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20372", "family_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", "job_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205442,8 +209052,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20373", "family_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", "job_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205474,8 +209084,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20374", "family_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", "job_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205506,8 +209116,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20375", "family_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", "job_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205538,8 +209148,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20376", "family_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", "job_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205570,8 +209180,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20377", "family_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", "job_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205602,8 +209212,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20378", "family_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", "job_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205634,8 +209244,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20379", "family_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", "job_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205666,8 +209276,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2037a", "family_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", "job_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205698,8 +209308,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2037b", "family_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", "job_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205730,8 +209340,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2037c", "family_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", "job_id": "terrain-2036d-2037c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205762,8 +209372,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2037d", "family_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", "job_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205794,8 +209404,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2037e", "family_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", "job_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205826,8 +209436,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2037f", "family_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", "job_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205858,8 +209468,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20380", "family_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", "job_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205890,8 +209500,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20381", "family_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", "job_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205922,8 +209532,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20382", "family_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", "job_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205954,8 +209564,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20383", "family_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", "job_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -205986,8 +209596,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20384", "family_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", "job_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206018,8 +209628,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20385", "family_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", "job_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206050,8 +209660,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20386", "family_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", "job_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206082,8 +209692,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20387", "family_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", "job_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206114,8 +209724,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20388", "family_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", "job_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206146,8 +209756,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20389", "family_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", "job_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206178,8 +209788,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2038a", "family_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", "job_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -206210,8 +209820,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2038b", "family_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", "job_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -206242,8 +209852,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2038c", "family_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", "job_id": "terrain-2037d-2038c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206274,8 +209884,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2038d", "family_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", "job_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206306,8 +209916,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2038e", "family_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", "job_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206338,8 +209948,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2038f", "family_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", "job_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206370,8 +209980,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20390", "family_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", "job_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206402,8 +210012,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20391", "family_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", "job_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206434,8 +210044,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20392", "family_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", "job_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206466,8 +210076,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20393", "family_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", "job_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206498,8 +210108,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20394", "family_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", "job_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206530,8 +210140,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20395", "family_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", "job_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206562,8 +210172,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20396", "family_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", "job_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206594,8 +210204,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20397", "family_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", "job_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -206626,8 +210236,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20398", "family_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", "job_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -206658,8 +210268,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20395", "family_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", "job_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -206690,8 +210300,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2039a", "family_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", "job_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206722,8 +210332,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2039b", "family_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", "job_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206754,8 +210364,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2039c", "family_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", "job_id": "terrain-2038d-2039c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206786,8 +210396,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2039d", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -206818,8 +210428,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2039e", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206850,8 +210460,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2039f", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -206882,8 +210492,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203a0", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206914,8 +210524,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203a1", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -206946,8 +210556,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203a2", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -206978,8 +210588,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203a3", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -207010,8 +210620,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203a4", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -207042,8 +210652,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203a5", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -207074,8 +210684,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203a6", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -207106,8 +210716,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20395", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -207138,8 +210748,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203a8", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -207170,8 +210780,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203a9", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -207202,8 +210812,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203aa", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -207234,8 +210844,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203ab", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -207266,8 +210876,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203ac", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -239995,7 +243605,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30074", "family_id": "enemies-30074-30077", "job_id": "enemies-30074-30077", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -240007,6 +243617,143 @@ "manifest": "jobs/enemies-30074-30077/candidate.json", "sha256": "9eb74fb9566b3ef05a4dc3234298cf9ee5d307d9836bd2c119bab9ef4f44a97d", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "9eb74fb9566b3ef05a4dc3234298cf9ee5d307d9836bd2c119bab9ef4f44a97d", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "c3a24732ba842cfe229a258db66fdd50a289fc1d29efe679428618201b32a0af", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:31.010556+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/enemies-30074-30077/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"Original gray/teal body retains asymmetric left dark/right pale material, central ladder and framed dark aperture. Upper/lower tread rows5/28 retain four distinct original phases. Authored metal grain, seams and rivets remain readable at1\\u20134.\", \"No source cell is entirely missing at any scale. Later native phases each add one peripheral contour cell, disclosed; bounds stay original. Original stationary rows6\\u201327 have264/333/333 changed native shades, only4/5/4 above32-channel delta. Logical mean source-stationary color changes >=32 at4\\u00d7 occupy4/6/3 of543 cells; no component movement seen.\"] {\"source_phase_differences\": [{\"asset\": \"30074\", \"changed_cells\": 0, \"changed_rows\": {}, \"changes\": []}, {\"asset\": \"30075\", \"changed_cells\": 48, \"changed_rows\": {\"5\": 24, \"28\": 24}, \"changes\": [[4, 5, 20, 27], [5, 5, 23, 20], [6, 5, 31, 23], [7, 5, 27, 31], [8, 5, 20, 27], [9, 5, 23, 20], [10, 5, 31, 23], [11, 5, 27, 31], [12, 5, 20, 27], [13, 5, 23, 20], [14, 5, 31, 23], [15, 5, 27, 31], [16, 5, 20, 27], [17, 5, 23, 20], [18, 5, 31, 23], [19, 5, 27, 31], [20, 5, 20, 27], [21, 5, 23, 20], [22, 5, 31, 23], [23, 5, 27, 31], [24, 5, 20, 27], [25, 5, 23, 20], [26, 5, 31, 23], [27, 5, 27, 31], [4, 28, 23, 30], [5, 28, 26, 23], [6, 28, 31, 26], [7, 28, 30, 31], [8, 28, 23, 30], [9, 28, 26, 23], [10, 28, 31, 26], [11, 28, 30, 31], [12, 28, 23, 30], [13, 28, 26, 23], [14, 28, 31, 26], [15, 28, 30, 31], [16, 28, 23, 30], [17, 28, 26, 23], [18, 28, 31, 26], [19, 28, 30, 31], [20, 28, 23, 30], [21, 28, 26, 23], [22, 28, 31, 26], [23, 28, 30, 31], [24, 28, 23, 30], [25, 28, 26, 23], [26, 28, 31, 26], [27, 28, 30, 31]]}, {\"asset\": \"30076\", \"changed_cells\": 48, \"changed_rows\": {\"5\": 24, \"28\": 24}, \"changes\": [[4, 5, 20, 31], [5, 5, 23, 27], [6, 5, 31, 20], [7, 5, 27, 23], [8, 5, 20, 31], [9, 5, 23, 27], [10, 5, 31, 20], [11, 5, 27, 23], [12, 5, 20, 31], [13, 5, 23, 27], [14, 5, 31, 20], [15, 5, 27, 23], [16, 5, 20, 31], [17, 5, 23, 27], [18, 5, 31, 20], [19, 5, 27, 23], [20, 5, 20, 31], [21, 5, 23, 27], [22, 5, 31, 20], [23, 5, 27, 23], [24, 5, 20, 31], [25, 5, 23, 27], [26, 5, 31, 20], [27, 5, 27, 23], [4, 28, 23, 31], [5, 28, 26, 30], [6, 28, 31, 23], [7, 28, 30, 26], [8, 28, 23, 31], [9, 28, 26, 30], [10, 28, 31, 23], [11, 28, 30, 26], [12, 28, 23, 31], [13, 28, 26, 30], [14, 28, 31, 23], [15, 28, 30, 26], [16, 28, 23, 31], [17, 28, 26, 30], [18, 28, 31, 23], [19, 28, 30, 26], [20, 28, 23, 31], [21, 28, 26, 30], [22, 28, 31, 23], [23, 28, 30, 26], [24, 28, 23, 31], [25, 28, 26, 30], [26, 28, 31, 23], [27, 28, 30, 26]]}, {\"asset\": \"30077\", \"changed_cells\": 48, \"changed_rows\": {\"5\": 24, \"28\": 24}, \"changes\": [[4, 5, 20, 27], [5, 5, 23, 31], [6, 5, 31, 27], [7, 5, 27, 20], [8, 5, 20, 23], [9, 5, 23, 31], [10, 5, 31, 27], [11, 5, 27, 20], [12, 5, 20, 23], [13, 5, 23, 31], [14, 5, 31, 27], [15, 5, 27, 20], [16, 5, 20, 23], [17, 5, 23, 31], [18, 5, 31, 27], [19, 5, 27, 20], [20, 5, 20, 23], [21, 5, 23, 31], [22, 5, 31, 27], [23, 5, 27, 20], [24, 5, 20, 23], [25, 5, 23, 31], [26, 5, 31, 27], [27, 5, 27, 20], [4, 28, 23, 30], [5, 28, 26, 31], [6, 28, 31, 30], [7, 28, 30, 23], [8, 28, 23, 26], [9, 28, 26, 31], [10, 28, 31, 30], [11, 28, 30, 23], [12, 28, 23, 26], [13, 28, 26, 31], [14, 28, 31, 30], [15, 28, 30, 23], [16, 28, 23, 26], [17, 28, 26, 31], [18, 28, 31, 30], [19, 28, 30, 23], [20, 28, 23, 26], [21, 28, 26, 31], [22, 28, 31, 30], [23, 28, 30, 23], [24, 28, 23, 26], [25, 28, 26, 31], [26, 28, 31, 30], [27, 28, 30, 23]]}], \"all_phase_source_stationary_occupied_cells\": 543, \"independent_row_based_metrics_match_worker\": true, \"row_based_metrics\": [{\"asset\": \"30075\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 264, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 4, \"max_channel_difference\": 93}, {\"asset\": \"30076\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 333, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 5, \"max_channel_difference\": 93}, {\"asset\": \"30077\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 333, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 4, \"max_channel_difference\": 85}], \"all_source_stationary_comparisons\": [{\"asset\": \"30075\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 263, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 543, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 7, 37.0, [97.0, 97.0, 97.0], [60.0, 60.0, 60.0]], [10, 8, 48.0, [4.0, 65.0, 73.0], [52.0, 52.0, 52.0]], [9, 24, 44.0, [4.0, 56.0, 65.0], [48.0, 48.0, 48.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1342, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 2172, \"opacity_changes\": [[56, 12, 9, 256], [57, 12, 11, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 6, 45.25, [106.5, 105.25, 105.25], [61.25, 60.25, 60.25]], [28, 6, 67.0, [178.5, 176.5, 176.5], [111.5, 114.5, 119.5]], [8, 7, 43.5, [65.5, 64.5, 64.5], [22.0, 40.0, 44.0]], [12, 7, 44.0, [92.0, 90.0, 90.0], [48.0, 48.0, 48.0]], [8, 8, 37.5, [62.5, 61.5, 61.5], [25.0, 39.0, 43.0]], [12, 8, 38.5, [88.75, 88.75, 88.75], [50.25, 50.25, 50.25]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 6}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3230, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4887, \"opacity_changes\": [[9, 18, 21, 256], [10, 18, 19, 256], [11, 18, 20, 256], [7, 72, 29, 256], [6, 82, 256, 27]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 6, 40.3333, [104.66666666666667, 104.11111111111111, 104.11111111111111], [64.33333333333333, 64.33333333333333, 64.33333333333333]], [8, 7, 36.6667, [62.44444444444444, 63.77777777777778, 64.66666666666667], [25.77777777777778, 41.333333333333336, 44.22222222222222]], [12, 7, 45.6667, [93.0, 92.11111111111111, 92.11111111111111], [47.333333333333336, 47.333333333333336, 47.333333333333336]], [12, 8, 35.7778, [88.55555555555556, 88.11111111111111, 88.11111111111111], [52.77777777777778, 52.77777777777778, 52.77777777777778]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 6020, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 8688, \"opacity_changes\": [[12, 24, 22, 256], [15, 24, 22, 256], [111, 24, 256, 22], [8, 28, 24, 256], [9, 28, 27, 256], [16, 44, 256, 30], [16, 45, 256, 29], [16, 47, 256, 28], [111, 44, 256, 27], [111, 45, 256, 18], [111, 53, 256, 13], [112, 93, 9, 256], [113, 93, 10, 256], [114, 93, 8, 256], [8, 97, 26, 256], [9, 97, 28, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 6, 40.8125, [104.0625, 103.3125, 103.3125], [63.25, 63.0, 63.0]], [8, 7, 33.75, [59.25, 64.75, 66.25], [25.5, 41.0, 44.125]], [12, 7, 46.3125, [94.3125, 92.75, 92.75], [48.0, 47.75, 47.75]], [12, 8, 33.75, [89.75, 89.25, 89.25], [56.0, 55.75, 55.75]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}]}, {\"asset\": \"30076\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 332, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 543, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[11, 7, 36.0, [105.0, 105.0, 105.0], [69.0, 69.0, 69.0]], [13, 8, 33.0, [60.0, 60.0, 60.0], [93.0, 89.0, 89.0]], [17, 8, 33.0, [85.0, 85.0, 85.0], [52.0, 52.0, 52.0]], [10, 9, 48.0, [52.0, 52.0, 52.0], [4.0, 56.0, 65.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1640, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 2172, \"opacity_changes\": [[56, 12, 9, 256], [57, 12, 11, 256], [5, 21, 30, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[17, 6, 32.0, [107.5, 107.5, 107.5], [76.75, 75.5, 75.5]], [28, 6, 61.0, [178.5, 176.5, 176.5], [117.5, 119.5, 124.5]], [13, 7, 33.25, [72.75, 71.75, 71.75], [105.0, 105.0, 105.0]], [13, 8, 32.75, [66.25, 66.25, 66.25], [99.0, 99.0, 99.0]], [25, 26, 32.25, [84.75, 83.5, 83.5], [52.5, 80.75, 85.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 5}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3785, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4887, \"opacity_changes\": [[9, 18, 21, 256], [11, 18, 20, 256], [83, 18, 19, 256], [12, 33, 29, 256], [12, 34, 27, 256], [12, 35, 27, 256], [7, 72, 29, 256], [6, 82, 256, 28]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[11, 7, 32.1111, [91.66666666666667, 90.33333333333333, 90.33333333333333], [59.55555555555556, 59.55555555555556, 59.55555555555556]], [13, 7, 36.7778, [70.0, 70.0, 70.0], [106.77777777777777, 106.77777777777777, 106.77777777777777]], [13, 8, 38.0, [66.22222222222223, 66.22222222222223, 66.22222222222223], [104.22222222222223, 103.33333333333333, 103.33333333333333]], [18, 11, 33.8889, [138.33333333333334, 151.88888888888889, 154.66666666666666], [172.22222222222223, 171.33333333333334, 171.33333333333334]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 6934, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 8688, \"opacity_changes\": [[12, 24, 22, 256], [15, 24, 22, 256], [16, 24, 28, 256], [10, 42, 29, 256], [16, 46, 27, 256], [111, 44, 256, 27], [111, 45, 256, 20], [111, 53, 256, 13], [18, 93, 26, 256], [112, 93, 9, 256], [113, 93, 10, 256], [114, 93, 8, 256], [10, 96, 29, 256], [8, 97, 26, 256], [9, 97, 28, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 7, 37.75, [71.25, 70.75, 70.75], [108.75, 108.5, 108.5]], [17, 7, 32.3125, [96.375, 95.0625, 95.0625], [64.0625, 63.8125, 63.8125]], [13, 8, 36.75, [69.125, 69.125, 69.125], [105.875, 105.125, 105.125]], [17, 8, 32.6875, [93.9375, 93.1875, 93.1875], [61.25, 61.0, 61.0]], [18, 10, 34.0625, [151.0, 165.5625, 167.5625], [185.0625, 182.5625, 182.5625]], [18, 11, 37.375, [134.25, 150.0, 152.25], [171.625, 169.625, 169.625]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 6}]}, {\"asset\": \"30077\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 332, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 543, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 7, 41.0, [97.0, 97.0, 97.0], [138.0, 134.0, 134.0]], [17, 9, 57.0, [130.0, 121.0, 142.0], [73.0, 142.0, 150.0]], [9, 24, 44.0, [4.0, 56.0, 65.0], [48.0, 48.0, 48.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1579, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 2172, \"opacity_changes\": [[56, 12, 9, 256], [57, 12, 11, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[28, 6, 61.0, [178.5, 176.5, 176.5], [117.5, 119.5, 124.5]], [13, 7, 35.25, [72.75, 71.75, 71.75], [107.0, 107.0, 107.0]], [13, 8, 35.75, [66.25, 66.25, 66.25], [102.0, 102.0, 102.0]], [17, 14, 32.75, [157.0, 155.0, 155.0], [124.25, 123.25, 123.25]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3723, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4887, \"opacity_changes\": [[9, 18, 21, 256], [10, 18, 19, 256], [11, 18, 20, 256], [12, 34, 27, 256], [7, 72, 29, 256], [6, 82, 256, 27]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 7, 37.8889, [70.0, 70.0, 70.0], [107.88888888888889, 105.88888888888889, 105.88888888888889]], [13, 8, 39.7778, [66.22222222222223, 66.22222222222223, 66.22222222222223], [106.0, 105.11111111111111, 105.11111111111111]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 2}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 6805, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 8688, \"opacity_changes\": [[12, 24, 22, 256], [15, 24, 22, 256], [10, 42, 29, 256], [16, 44, 256, 29], [16, 46, 27, 256], [111, 44, 256, 27], [111, 45, 256, 21], [111, 53, 256, 13], [18, 93, 26, 256], [112, 93, 9, 256], [113, 93, 10, 256], [114, 93, 8, 256], [10, 96, 29, 256], [8, 97, 26, 256], [9, 97, 28, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 6, 32.0, [75.25, 74.5, 74.5], [107.25, 106.5, 106.5]], [13, 7, 38.1875, [71.25, 70.75, 70.75], [109.4375, 108.0625, 108.0625]], [13, 8, 38.75, [69.125, 69.125, 69.125], [107.875, 106.8125, 106.8125]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}]}]} [\"Isolated actual Catalog/HdAssets source-bound sprite raster and artistic approval only. No new Host enemy occurrence, animation timing, terrain blend, gameplay, simulation-neutrality or fullscreen capture.\", \"Broader game-source freshness flag is true due to unrelated menu/game edits; relevant assets/hd loader source is current.\", \"Complete shared family scale, origin and all rawalpha>=16/>=32 crop retention independently verified. Palette classes, forced indices and all240\\u2013255counts pass; these numeric checks do not substitute for the completed artistic review.\", \"Original/source and newly authored stationary body shading are not byte identical; localized variations and native/2\\u00d7 contour smoothing are deliberately disclosed.\", \"Global registration and bundled pack snapshot remain coordinator-owned; no source/candidate/raw/global/Git edits by reviewer.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/independent-review.json, SHA256 f6c62881aa1b2c8f035cd588b6d4e11b8b543af4a03a6a56616613afe6be7839", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/inputs/enemies-30074-30077/runtime-review/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "4726f3da5a9f766a3116ddaaaae89a026c71e496816f536d544084541083812c" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "26ce2f190978e8c78b69c05c2c1e50e4c0faa6716b81f5c0da237c01e576ac6d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "30074", + "30075", + "30076", + "30077" + ], + "sha256": "b1b1b4f02c5341345bbb152748480a856dc54e1a18d4c32eeba2c7b1b1bd7860", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "30074-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4430eabcff3d19800acdd200fe09540ab411154b707fe1bdc2c232786237aa6a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30074-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30074-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0a844f2a3a332d05fa6f64bea2c098059e5dd56fd6c408f1be93498abc157f30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30074-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30074-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c429937330350f210aa3c0d1871f3af4607e2ae9675d19a5c7de102c2d49a5a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30074-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30074-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ba034b46eec6606ac83234e7e34daeddc9611c4121b5ae9541504885f24823e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30074-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30074-original.ppm", + "sha256": "91ecf064fc1a1bc2288e5ee14197c2ae8f28f72ef214269c009aecb56bbe40f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30074-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30075-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fc6e45e74adf75c5f54177f448809e9e89a3729eec59a0858f51d71546a6ae89", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30075-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30075-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b8133927f1f4683cbcccf6ee4b1324ae2a096fd99de2f06bbc2d8138ec18b72c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30075-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30075-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c56f120209ffe8607301d88088c9eb104b9e02c201303ee1a0938d8869b285ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30075-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30075-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "62493b07f34d8e1f09a6630ebfad610f01593c8c221f391426d3d06ff6a09ff3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30075-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30075-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2ca7d4baa576f0992bfdcedf9bfb09c66a708c2d8bd6864b200661708a5ec1bd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30075-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30076-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "dbb499347ff5edb324b240abd8c721b1a66d5a6132d4f50c5eb0246e370fdce1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30076-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30076-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6d9cb52e6155183515e5cf468425ebf0653faaece9eed84661cef25c3884cef7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30076-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30076-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e2678a2c24e3b6178206fa257d988dbed2edb176729d49b81e2d3ee6a68feecb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30076-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30076-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dda990d6e96583460bd49cc3cf03eb2997e8d85687a2b0775460ec3fb984605b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30076-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30076-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a1237841d9cc1405762056737132f5b1b46c79d3ab9e1c7e9233922e593cd9eb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30076-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30077-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "627d28a5350c9c4cc286c469a21fc29a57b8c11ce64d8b6fc56b0c21543f60f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30077-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30077-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dfdd6eb5c687e0e18237005ea8fc248ebb660d962550eaf0b0a47bf2120eb3fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30077-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30077-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "abb4cbbcd637f4814f71ecad942ff7a4649d34f14896ad8fc5636e8f38210303", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30077-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30077-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eb61d8277392d954991fd25caa315753de80673700d2dace1b2cc1faa425d541", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30077-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30077-original.ppm", + "sha256": "40b127321aa22ab03c00262bbc9aa352e1520f5cc5172368a855a4295f1d83be", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30077-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30075": { @@ -240028,7 +243775,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30075", "family_id": "enemies-30074-30077", "job_id": "enemies-30074-30077", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -240040,6 +243787,143 @@ "manifest": "jobs/enemies-30074-30077/candidate.json", "sha256": "9eb74fb9566b3ef05a4dc3234298cf9ee5d307d9836bd2c119bab9ef4f44a97d", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "9eb74fb9566b3ef05a4dc3234298cf9ee5d307d9836bd2c119bab9ef4f44a97d", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "c3a24732ba842cfe229a258db66fdd50a289fc1d29efe679428618201b32a0af", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:31.010556+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/enemies-30074-30077/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"Original gray/teal body retains asymmetric left dark/right pale material, central ladder and framed dark aperture. Upper/lower tread rows5/28 retain four distinct original phases. Authored metal grain, seams and rivets remain readable at1\\u20134.\", \"No source cell is entirely missing at any scale. Later native phases each add one peripheral contour cell, disclosed; bounds stay original. Original stationary rows6\\u201327 have264/333/333 changed native shades, only4/5/4 above32-channel delta. Logical mean source-stationary color changes >=32 at4\\u00d7 occupy4/6/3 of543 cells; no component movement seen.\"] {\"source_phase_differences\": [{\"asset\": \"30074\", \"changed_cells\": 0, \"changed_rows\": {}, \"changes\": []}, {\"asset\": \"30075\", \"changed_cells\": 48, \"changed_rows\": {\"5\": 24, \"28\": 24}, \"changes\": [[4, 5, 20, 27], [5, 5, 23, 20], [6, 5, 31, 23], [7, 5, 27, 31], [8, 5, 20, 27], [9, 5, 23, 20], [10, 5, 31, 23], [11, 5, 27, 31], [12, 5, 20, 27], [13, 5, 23, 20], [14, 5, 31, 23], [15, 5, 27, 31], [16, 5, 20, 27], [17, 5, 23, 20], [18, 5, 31, 23], [19, 5, 27, 31], [20, 5, 20, 27], [21, 5, 23, 20], [22, 5, 31, 23], [23, 5, 27, 31], [24, 5, 20, 27], [25, 5, 23, 20], [26, 5, 31, 23], [27, 5, 27, 31], [4, 28, 23, 30], [5, 28, 26, 23], [6, 28, 31, 26], [7, 28, 30, 31], [8, 28, 23, 30], [9, 28, 26, 23], [10, 28, 31, 26], [11, 28, 30, 31], [12, 28, 23, 30], [13, 28, 26, 23], [14, 28, 31, 26], [15, 28, 30, 31], [16, 28, 23, 30], [17, 28, 26, 23], [18, 28, 31, 26], [19, 28, 30, 31], [20, 28, 23, 30], [21, 28, 26, 23], [22, 28, 31, 26], [23, 28, 30, 31], [24, 28, 23, 30], [25, 28, 26, 23], [26, 28, 31, 26], [27, 28, 30, 31]]}, {\"asset\": \"30076\", \"changed_cells\": 48, \"changed_rows\": {\"5\": 24, \"28\": 24}, \"changes\": [[4, 5, 20, 31], [5, 5, 23, 27], [6, 5, 31, 20], [7, 5, 27, 23], [8, 5, 20, 31], [9, 5, 23, 27], [10, 5, 31, 20], [11, 5, 27, 23], [12, 5, 20, 31], [13, 5, 23, 27], [14, 5, 31, 20], [15, 5, 27, 23], [16, 5, 20, 31], [17, 5, 23, 27], [18, 5, 31, 20], [19, 5, 27, 23], [20, 5, 20, 31], [21, 5, 23, 27], [22, 5, 31, 20], [23, 5, 27, 23], [24, 5, 20, 31], [25, 5, 23, 27], [26, 5, 31, 20], [27, 5, 27, 23], [4, 28, 23, 31], [5, 28, 26, 30], [6, 28, 31, 23], [7, 28, 30, 26], [8, 28, 23, 31], [9, 28, 26, 30], [10, 28, 31, 23], [11, 28, 30, 26], [12, 28, 23, 31], [13, 28, 26, 30], [14, 28, 31, 23], [15, 28, 30, 26], [16, 28, 23, 31], [17, 28, 26, 30], [18, 28, 31, 23], [19, 28, 30, 26], [20, 28, 23, 31], [21, 28, 26, 30], [22, 28, 31, 23], [23, 28, 30, 26], [24, 28, 23, 31], [25, 28, 26, 30], [26, 28, 31, 23], [27, 28, 30, 26]]}, {\"asset\": \"30077\", \"changed_cells\": 48, \"changed_rows\": {\"5\": 24, \"28\": 24}, \"changes\": [[4, 5, 20, 27], [5, 5, 23, 31], [6, 5, 31, 27], [7, 5, 27, 20], [8, 5, 20, 23], [9, 5, 23, 31], [10, 5, 31, 27], [11, 5, 27, 20], [12, 5, 20, 23], [13, 5, 23, 31], [14, 5, 31, 27], [15, 5, 27, 20], [16, 5, 20, 23], [17, 5, 23, 31], [18, 5, 31, 27], [19, 5, 27, 20], [20, 5, 20, 23], [21, 5, 23, 31], [22, 5, 31, 27], [23, 5, 27, 20], [24, 5, 20, 23], [25, 5, 23, 31], [26, 5, 31, 27], [27, 5, 27, 20], [4, 28, 23, 30], [5, 28, 26, 31], [6, 28, 31, 30], [7, 28, 30, 23], [8, 28, 23, 26], [9, 28, 26, 31], [10, 28, 31, 30], [11, 28, 30, 23], [12, 28, 23, 26], [13, 28, 26, 31], [14, 28, 31, 30], [15, 28, 30, 23], [16, 28, 23, 26], [17, 28, 26, 31], [18, 28, 31, 30], [19, 28, 30, 23], [20, 28, 23, 26], [21, 28, 26, 31], [22, 28, 31, 30], [23, 28, 30, 23], [24, 28, 23, 26], [25, 28, 26, 31], [26, 28, 31, 30], [27, 28, 30, 23]]}], \"all_phase_source_stationary_occupied_cells\": 543, \"independent_row_based_metrics_match_worker\": true, \"row_based_metrics\": [{\"asset\": \"30075\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 264, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 4, \"max_channel_difference\": 93}, {\"asset\": \"30076\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 333, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 5, \"max_channel_difference\": 93}, {\"asset\": \"30077\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 333, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 4, \"max_channel_difference\": 85}], \"all_source_stationary_comparisons\": [{\"asset\": \"30075\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 263, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 543, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 7, 37.0, [97.0, 97.0, 97.0], [60.0, 60.0, 60.0]], [10, 8, 48.0, [4.0, 65.0, 73.0], [52.0, 52.0, 52.0]], [9, 24, 44.0, [4.0, 56.0, 65.0], [48.0, 48.0, 48.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1342, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 2172, \"opacity_changes\": [[56, 12, 9, 256], [57, 12, 11, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 6, 45.25, [106.5, 105.25, 105.25], [61.25, 60.25, 60.25]], [28, 6, 67.0, [178.5, 176.5, 176.5], [111.5, 114.5, 119.5]], [8, 7, 43.5, [65.5, 64.5, 64.5], [22.0, 40.0, 44.0]], [12, 7, 44.0, [92.0, 90.0, 90.0], [48.0, 48.0, 48.0]], [8, 8, 37.5, [62.5, 61.5, 61.5], [25.0, 39.0, 43.0]], [12, 8, 38.5, [88.75, 88.75, 88.75], [50.25, 50.25, 50.25]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 6}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3230, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4887, \"opacity_changes\": [[9, 18, 21, 256], [10, 18, 19, 256], [11, 18, 20, 256], [7, 72, 29, 256], [6, 82, 256, 27]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 6, 40.3333, [104.66666666666667, 104.11111111111111, 104.11111111111111], [64.33333333333333, 64.33333333333333, 64.33333333333333]], [8, 7, 36.6667, [62.44444444444444, 63.77777777777778, 64.66666666666667], [25.77777777777778, 41.333333333333336, 44.22222222222222]], [12, 7, 45.6667, [93.0, 92.11111111111111, 92.11111111111111], [47.333333333333336, 47.333333333333336, 47.333333333333336]], [12, 8, 35.7778, [88.55555555555556, 88.11111111111111, 88.11111111111111], [52.77777777777778, 52.77777777777778, 52.77777777777778]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 6020, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 8688, \"opacity_changes\": [[12, 24, 22, 256], [15, 24, 22, 256], [111, 24, 256, 22], [8, 28, 24, 256], [9, 28, 27, 256], [16, 44, 256, 30], [16, 45, 256, 29], [16, 47, 256, 28], [111, 44, 256, 27], [111, 45, 256, 18], [111, 53, 256, 13], [112, 93, 9, 256], [113, 93, 10, 256], [114, 93, 8, 256], [8, 97, 26, 256], [9, 97, 28, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 6, 40.8125, [104.0625, 103.3125, 103.3125], [63.25, 63.0, 63.0]], [8, 7, 33.75, [59.25, 64.75, 66.25], [25.5, 41.0, 44.125]], [12, 7, 46.3125, [94.3125, 92.75, 92.75], [48.0, 47.75, 47.75]], [12, 8, 33.75, [89.75, 89.25, 89.25], [56.0, 55.75, 55.75]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}]}, {\"asset\": \"30076\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 332, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 543, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[11, 7, 36.0, [105.0, 105.0, 105.0], [69.0, 69.0, 69.0]], [13, 8, 33.0, [60.0, 60.0, 60.0], [93.0, 89.0, 89.0]], [17, 8, 33.0, [85.0, 85.0, 85.0], [52.0, 52.0, 52.0]], [10, 9, 48.0, [52.0, 52.0, 52.0], [4.0, 56.0, 65.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1640, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 2172, \"opacity_changes\": [[56, 12, 9, 256], [57, 12, 11, 256], [5, 21, 30, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[17, 6, 32.0, [107.5, 107.5, 107.5], [76.75, 75.5, 75.5]], [28, 6, 61.0, [178.5, 176.5, 176.5], [117.5, 119.5, 124.5]], [13, 7, 33.25, [72.75, 71.75, 71.75], [105.0, 105.0, 105.0]], [13, 8, 32.75, [66.25, 66.25, 66.25], [99.0, 99.0, 99.0]], [25, 26, 32.25, [84.75, 83.5, 83.5], [52.5, 80.75, 85.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 5}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3785, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4887, \"opacity_changes\": [[9, 18, 21, 256], [11, 18, 20, 256], [83, 18, 19, 256], [12, 33, 29, 256], [12, 34, 27, 256], [12, 35, 27, 256], [7, 72, 29, 256], [6, 82, 256, 28]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[11, 7, 32.1111, [91.66666666666667, 90.33333333333333, 90.33333333333333], [59.55555555555556, 59.55555555555556, 59.55555555555556]], [13, 7, 36.7778, [70.0, 70.0, 70.0], [106.77777777777777, 106.77777777777777, 106.77777777777777]], [13, 8, 38.0, [66.22222222222223, 66.22222222222223, 66.22222222222223], [104.22222222222223, 103.33333333333333, 103.33333333333333]], [18, 11, 33.8889, [138.33333333333334, 151.88888888888889, 154.66666666666666], [172.22222222222223, 171.33333333333334, 171.33333333333334]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 6934, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 8688, \"opacity_changes\": [[12, 24, 22, 256], [15, 24, 22, 256], [16, 24, 28, 256], [10, 42, 29, 256], [16, 46, 27, 256], [111, 44, 256, 27], [111, 45, 256, 20], [111, 53, 256, 13], [18, 93, 26, 256], [112, 93, 9, 256], [113, 93, 10, 256], [114, 93, 8, 256], [10, 96, 29, 256], [8, 97, 26, 256], [9, 97, 28, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 7, 37.75, [71.25, 70.75, 70.75], [108.75, 108.5, 108.5]], [17, 7, 32.3125, [96.375, 95.0625, 95.0625], [64.0625, 63.8125, 63.8125]], [13, 8, 36.75, [69.125, 69.125, 69.125], [105.875, 105.125, 105.125]], [17, 8, 32.6875, [93.9375, 93.1875, 93.1875], [61.25, 61.0, 61.0]], [18, 10, 34.0625, [151.0, 165.5625, 167.5625], [185.0625, 182.5625, 182.5625]], [18, 11, 37.375, [134.25, 150.0, 152.25], [171.625, 169.625, 169.625]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 6}]}, {\"asset\": \"30077\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 332, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 543, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 7, 41.0, [97.0, 97.0, 97.0], [138.0, 134.0, 134.0]], [17, 9, 57.0, [130.0, 121.0, 142.0], [73.0, 142.0, 150.0]], [9, 24, 44.0, [4.0, 56.0, 65.0], [48.0, 48.0, 48.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1579, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 2172, \"opacity_changes\": [[56, 12, 9, 256], [57, 12, 11, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[28, 6, 61.0, [178.5, 176.5, 176.5], [117.5, 119.5, 124.5]], [13, 7, 35.25, [72.75, 71.75, 71.75], [107.0, 107.0, 107.0]], [13, 8, 35.75, [66.25, 66.25, 66.25], [102.0, 102.0, 102.0]], [17, 14, 32.75, [157.0, 155.0, 155.0], [124.25, 123.25, 123.25]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3723, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4887, \"opacity_changes\": [[9, 18, 21, 256], [10, 18, 19, 256], [11, 18, 20, 256], [12, 34, 27, 256], [7, 72, 29, 256], [6, 82, 256, 27]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 7, 37.8889, [70.0, 70.0, 70.0], [107.88888888888889, 105.88888888888889, 105.88888888888889]], [13, 8, 39.7778, [66.22222222222223, 66.22222222222223, 66.22222222222223], [106.0, 105.11111111111111, 105.11111111111111]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 2}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 6805, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 8688, \"opacity_changes\": [[12, 24, 22, 256], [15, 24, 22, 256], [10, 42, 29, 256], [16, 44, 256, 29], [16, 46, 27, 256], [111, 44, 256, 27], [111, 45, 256, 21], [111, 53, 256, 13], [18, 93, 26, 256], [112, 93, 9, 256], [113, 93, 10, 256], [114, 93, 8, 256], [10, 96, 29, 256], [8, 97, 26, 256], [9, 97, 28, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 6, 32.0, [75.25, 74.5, 74.5], [107.25, 106.5, 106.5]], [13, 7, 38.1875, [71.25, 70.75, 70.75], [109.4375, 108.0625, 108.0625]], [13, 8, 38.75, [69.125, 69.125, 69.125], [107.875, 106.8125, 106.8125]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}]}]} [\"Isolated actual Catalog/HdAssets source-bound sprite raster and artistic approval only. No new Host enemy occurrence, animation timing, terrain blend, gameplay, simulation-neutrality or fullscreen capture.\", \"Broader game-source freshness flag is true due to unrelated menu/game edits; relevant assets/hd loader source is current.\", \"Complete shared family scale, origin and all rawalpha>=16/>=32 crop retention independently verified. Palette classes, forced indices and all240\\u2013255counts pass; these numeric checks do not substitute for the completed artistic review.\", \"Original/source and newly authored stationary body shading are not byte identical; localized variations and native/2\\u00d7 contour smoothing are deliberately disclosed.\", \"Global registration and bundled pack snapshot remain coordinator-owned; no source/candidate/raw/global/Git edits by reviewer.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/independent-review.json, SHA256 f6c62881aa1b2c8f035cd588b6d4e11b8b543af4a03a6a56616613afe6be7839", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/inputs/enemies-30074-30077/runtime-review/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "4726f3da5a9f766a3116ddaaaae89a026c71e496816f536d544084541083812c" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "26ce2f190978e8c78b69c05c2c1e50e4c0faa6716b81f5c0da237c01e576ac6d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "30074", + "30075", + "30076", + "30077" + ], + "sha256": "b1b1b4f02c5341345bbb152748480a856dc54e1a18d4c32eeba2c7b1b1bd7860", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "30074-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4430eabcff3d19800acdd200fe09540ab411154b707fe1bdc2c232786237aa6a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30074-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30074-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0a844f2a3a332d05fa6f64bea2c098059e5dd56fd6c408f1be93498abc157f30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30074-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30074-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c429937330350f210aa3c0d1871f3af4607e2ae9675d19a5c7de102c2d49a5a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30074-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30074-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ba034b46eec6606ac83234e7e34daeddc9611c4121b5ae9541504885f24823e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30074-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30074-original.ppm", + "sha256": "91ecf064fc1a1bc2288e5ee14197c2ae8f28f72ef214269c009aecb56bbe40f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30074-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30075-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fc6e45e74adf75c5f54177f448809e9e89a3729eec59a0858f51d71546a6ae89", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30075-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30075-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b8133927f1f4683cbcccf6ee4b1324ae2a096fd99de2f06bbc2d8138ec18b72c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30075-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30075-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c56f120209ffe8607301d88088c9eb104b9e02c201303ee1a0938d8869b285ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30075-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30075-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "62493b07f34d8e1f09a6630ebfad610f01593c8c221f391426d3d06ff6a09ff3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30075-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30075-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2ca7d4baa576f0992bfdcedf9bfb09c66a708c2d8bd6864b200661708a5ec1bd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30075-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30076-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "dbb499347ff5edb324b240abd8c721b1a66d5a6132d4f50c5eb0246e370fdce1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30076-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30076-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6d9cb52e6155183515e5cf468425ebf0653faaece9eed84661cef25c3884cef7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30076-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30076-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e2678a2c24e3b6178206fa257d988dbed2edb176729d49b81e2d3ee6a68feecb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30076-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30076-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dda990d6e96583460bd49cc3cf03eb2997e8d85687a2b0775460ec3fb984605b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30076-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30076-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a1237841d9cc1405762056737132f5b1b46c79d3ab9e1c7e9233922e593cd9eb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30076-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30077-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "627d28a5350c9c4cc286c469a21fc29a57b8c11ce64d8b6fc56b0c21543f60f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30077-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30077-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dfdd6eb5c687e0e18237005ea8fc248ebb660d962550eaf0b0a47bf2120eb3fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30077-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30077-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "abb4cbbcd637f4814f71ecad942ff7a4649d34f14896ad8fc5636e8f38210303", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30077-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30077-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eb61d8277392d954991fd25caa315753de80673700d2dace1b2cc1faa425d541", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30077-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30077-original.ppm", + "sha256": "40b127321aa22ab03c00262bbc9aa352e1520f5cc5172368a855a4295f1d83be", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30077-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30076": { @@ -240061,7 +243945,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30076", "family_id": "enemies-30074-30077", "job_id": "enemies-30074-30077", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -240073,6 +243957,143 @@ "manifest": "jobs/enemies-30074-30077/candidate.json", "sha256": "9eb74fb9566b3ef05a4dc3234298cf9ee5d307d9836bd2c119bab9ef4f44a97d", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "9eb74fb9566b3ef05a4dc3234298cf9ee5d307d9836bd2c119bab9ef4f44a97d", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "c3a24732ba842cfe229a258db66fdd50a289fc1d29efe679428618201b32a0af", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:31.010556+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/enemies-30074-30077/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"Original gray/teal body retains asymmetric left dark/right pale material, central ladder and framed dark aperture. Upper/lower tread rows5/28 retain four distinct original phases. Authored metal grain, seams and rivets remain readable at1\\u20134.\", \"No source cell is entirely missing at any scale. Later native phases each add one peripheral contour cell, disclosed; bounds stay original. Original stationary rows6\\u201327 have264/333/333 changed native shades, only4/5/4 above32-channel delta. Logical mean source-stationary color changes >=32 at4\\u00d7 occupy4/6/3 of543 cells; no component movement seen.\"] {\"source_phase_differences\": [{\"asset\": \"30074\", \"changed_cells\": 0, \"changed_rows\": {}, \"changes\": []}, {\"asset\": \"30075\", \"changed_cells\": 48, \"changed_rows\": {\"5\": 24, \"28\": 24}, \"changes\": [[4, 5, 20, 27], [5, 5, 23, 20], [6, 5, 31, 23], [7, 5, 27, 31], [8, 5, 20, 27], [9, 5, 23, 20], [10, 5, 31, 23], [11, 5, 27, 31], [12, 5, 20, 27], [13, 5, 23, 20], [14, 5, 31, 23], [15, 5, 27, 31], [16, 5, 20, 27], [17, 5, 23, 20], [18, 5, 31, 23], [19, 5, 27, 31], [20, 5, 20, 27], [21, 5, 23, 20], [22, 5, 31, 23], [23, 5, 27, 31], [24, 5, 20, 27], [25, 5, 23, 20], [26, 5, 31, 23], [27, 5, 27, 31], [4, 28, 23, 30], [5, 28, 26, 23], [6, 28, 31, 26], [7, 28, 30, 31], [8, 28, 23, 30], [9, 28, 26, 23], [10, 28, 31, 26], [11, 28, 30, 31], [12, 28, 23, 30], [13, 28, 26, 23], [14, 28, 31, 26], [15, 28, 30, 31], [16, 28, 23, 30], [17, 28, 26, 23], [18, 28, 31, 26], [19, 28, 30, 31], [20, 28, 23, 30], [21, 28, 26, 23], [22, 28, 31, 26], [23, 28, 30, 31], [24, 28, 23, 30], [25, 28, 26, 23], [26, 28, 31, 26], [27, 28, 30, 31]]}, {\"asset\": \"30076\", \"changed_cells\": 48, \"changed_rows\": {\"5\": 24, \"28\": 24}, \"changes\": [[4, 5, 20, 31], [5, 5, 23, 27], [6, 5, 31, 20], [7, 5, 27, 23], [8, 5, 20, 31], [9, 5, 23, 27], [10, 5, 31, 20], [11, 5, 27, 23], [12, 5, 20, 31], [13, 5, 23, 27], [14, 5, 31, 20], [15, 5, 27, 23], [16, 5, 20, 31], [17, 5, 23, 27], [18, 5, 31, 20], [19, 5, 27, 23], [20, 5, 20, 31], [21, 5, 23, 27], [22, 5, 31, 20], [23, 5, 27, 23], [24, 5, 20, 31], [25, 5, 23, 27], [26, 5, 31, 20], [27, 5, 27, 23], [4, 28, 23, 31], [5, 28, 26, 30], [6, 28, 31, 23], [7, 28, 30, 26], [8, 28, 23, 31], [9, 28, 26, 30], [10, 28, 31, 23], [11, 28, 30, 26], [12, 28, 23, 31], [13, 28, 26, 30], [14, 28, 31, 23], [15, 28, 30, 26], [16, 28, 23, 31], [17, 28, 26, 30], [18, 28, 31, 23], [19, 28, 30, 26], [20, 28, 23, 31], [21, 28, 26, 30], [22, 28, 31, 23], [23, 28, 30, 26], [24, 28, 23, 31], [25, 28, 26, 30], [26, 28, 31, 23], [27, 28, 30, 26]]}, {\"asset\": \"30077\", \"changed_cells\": 48, \"changed_rows\": {\"5\": 24, \"28\": 24}, \"changes\": [[4, 5, 20, 27], [5, 5, 23, 31], [6, 5, 31, 27], [7, 5, 27, 20], [8, 5, 20, 23], [9, 5, 23, 31], [10, 5, 31, 27], [11, 5, 27, 20], [12, 5, 20, 23], [13, 5, 23, 31], [14, 5, 31, 27], [15, 5, 27, 20], [16, 5, 20, 23], [17, 5, 23, 31], [18, 5, 31, 27], [19, 5, 27, 20], [20, 5, 20, 23], [21, 5, 23, 31], [22, 5, 31, 27], [23, 5, 27, 20], [24, 5, 20, 23], [25, 5, 23, 31], [26, 5, 31, 27], [27, 5, 27, 20], [4, 28, 23, 30], [5, 28, 26, 31], [6, 28, 31, 30], [7, 28, 30, 23], [8, 28, 23, 26], [9, 28, 26, 31], [10, 28, 31, 30], [11, 28, 30, 23], [12, 28, 23, 26], [13, 28, 26, 31], [14, 28, 31, 30], [15, 28, 30, 23], [16, 28, 23, 26], [17, 28, 26, 31], [18, 28, 31, 30], [19, 28, 30, 23], [20, 28, 23, 26], [21, 28, 26, 31], [22, 28, 31, 30], [23, 28, 30, 23], [24, 28, 23, 26], [25, 28, 26, 31], [26, 28, 31, 30], [27, 28, 30, 23]]}], \"all_phase_source_stationary_occupied_cells\": 543, \"independent_row_based_metrics_match_worker\": true, \"row_based_metrics\": [{\"asset\": \"30075\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 264, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 4, \"max_channel_difference\": 93}, {\"asset\": \"30076\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 333, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 5, \"max_channel_difference\": 93}, {\"asset\": \"30077\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 333, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 4, \"max_channel_difference\": 85}], \"all_source_stationary_comparisons\": [{\"asset\": \"30075\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 263, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 543, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 7, 37.0, [97.0, 97.0, 97.0], [60.0, 60.0, 60.0]], [10, 8, 48.0, [4.0, 65.0, 73.0], [52.0, 52.0, 52.0]], [9, 24, 44.0, [4.0, 56.0, 65.0], [48.0, 48.0, 48.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1342, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 2172, \"opacity_changes\": [[56, 12, 9, 256], [57, 12, 11, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 6, 45.25, [106.5, 105.25, 105.25], [61.25, 60.25, 60.25]], [28, 6, 67.0, [178.5, 176.5, 176.5], [111.5, 114.5, 119.5]], [8, 7, 43.5, [65.5, 64.5, 64.5], [22.0, 40.0, 44.0]], [12, 7, 44.0, [92.0, 90.0, 90.0], [48.0, 48.0, 48.0]], [8, 8, 37.5, [62.5, 61.5, 61.5], [25.0, 39.0, 43.0]], [12, 8, 38.5, [88.75, 88.75, 88.75], [50.25, 50.25, 50.25]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 6}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3230, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4887, \"opacity_changes\": [[9, 18, 21, 256], [10, 18, 19, 256], [11, 18, 20, 256], [7, 72, 29, 256], [6, 82, 256, 27]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 6, 40.3333, [104.66666666666667, 104.11111111111111, 104.11111111111111], [64.33333333333333, 64.33333333333333, 64.33333333333333]], [8, 7, 36.6667, [62.44444444444444, 63.77777777777778, 64.66666666666667], [25.77777777777778, 41.333333333333336, 44.22222222222222]], [12, 7, 45.6667, [93.0, 92.11111111111111, 92.11111111111111], [47.333333333333336, 47.333333333333336, 47.333333333333336]], [12, 8, 35.7778, [88.55555555555556, 88.11111111111111, 88.11111111111111], [52.77777777777778, 52.77777777777778, 52.77777777777778]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 6020, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 8688, \"opacity_changes\": [[12, 24, 22, 256], [15, 24, 22, 256], [111, 24, 256, 22], [8, 28, 24, 256], [9, 28, 27, 256], [16, 44, 256, 30], [16, 45, 256, 29], [16, 47, 256, 28], [111, 44, 256, 27], [111, 45, 256, 18], [111, 53, 256, 13], [112, 93, 9, 256], [113, 93, 10, 256], [114, 93, 8, 256], [8, 97, 26, 256], [9, 97, 28, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 6, 40.8125, [104.0625, 103.3125, 103.3125], [63.25, 63.0, 63.0]], [8, 7, 33.75, [59.25, 64.75, 66.25], [25.5, 41.0, 44.125]], [12, 7, 46.3125, [94.3125, 92.75, 92.75], [48.0, 47.75, 47.75]], [12, 8, 33.75, [89.75, 89.25, 89.25], [56.0, 55.75, 55.75]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}]}, {\"asset\": \"30076\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 332, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 543, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[11, 7, 36.0, [105.0, 105.0, 105.0], [69.0, 69.0, 69.0]], [13, 8, 33.0, [60.0, 60.0, 60.0], [93.0, 89.0, 89.0]], [17, 8, 33.0, [85.0, 85.0, 85.0], [52.0, 52.0, 52.0]], [10, 9, 48.0, [52.0, 52.0, 52.0], [4.0, 56.0, 65.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1640, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 2172, \"opacity_changes\": [[56, 12, 9, 256], [57, 12, 11, 256], [5, 21, 30, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[17, 6, 32.0, [107.5, 107.5, 107.5], [76.75, 75.5, 75.5]], [28, 6, 61.0, [178.5, 176.5, 176.5], [117.5, 119.5, 124.5]], [13, 7, 33.25, [72.75, 71.75, 71.75], [105.0, 105.0, 105.0]], [13, 8, 32.75, [66.25, 66.25, 66.25], [99.0, 99.0, 99.0]], [25, 26, 32.25, [84.75, 83.5, 83.5], [52.5, 80.75, 85.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 5}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3785, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4887, \"opacity_changes\": [[9, 18, 21, 256], [11, 18, 20, 256], [83, 18, 19, 256], [12, 33, 29, 256], [12, 34, 27, 256], [12, 35, 27, 256], [7, 72, 29, 256], [6, 82, 256, 28]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[11, 7, 32.1111, [91.66666666666667, 90.33333333333333, 90.33333333333333], [59.55555555555556, 59.55555555555556, 59.55555555555556]], [13, 7, 36.7778, [70.0, 70.0, 70.0], [106.77777777777777, 106.77777777777777, 106.77777777777777]], [13, 8, 38.0, [66.22222222222223, 66.22222222222223, 66.22222222222223], [104.22222222222223, 103.33333333333333, 103.33333333333333]], [18, 11, 33.8889, [138.33333333333334, 151.88888888888889, 154.66666666666666], [172.22222222222223, 171.33333333333334, 171.33333333333334]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 6934, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 8688, \"opacity_changes\": [[12, 24, 22, 256], [15, 24, 22, 256], [16, 24, 28, 256], [10, 42, 29, 256], [16, 46, 27, 256], [111, 44, 256, 27], [111, 45, 256, 20], [111, 53, 256, 13], [18, 93, 26, 256], [112, 93, 9, 256], [113, 93, 10, 256], [114, 93, 8, 256], [10, 96, 29, 256], [8, 97, 26, 256], [9, 97, 28, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 7, 37.75, [71.25, 70.75, 70.75], [108.75, 108.5, 108.5]], [17, 7, 32.3125, [96.375, 95.0625, 95.0625], [64.0625, 63.8125, 63.8125]], [13, 8, 36.75, [69.125, 69.125, 69.125], [105.875, 105.125, 105.125]], [17, 8, 32.6875, [93.9375, 93.1875, 93.1875], [61.25, 61.0, 61.0]], [18, 10, 34.0625, [151.0, 165.5625, 167.5625], [185.0625, 182.5625, 182.5625]], [18, 11, 37.375, [134.25, 150.0, 152.25], [171.625, 169.625, 169.625]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 6}]}, {\"asset\": \"30077\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 332, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 543, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 7, 41.0, [97.0, 97.0, 97.0], [138.0, 134.0, 134.0]], [17, 9, 57.0, [130.0, 121.0, 142.0], [73.0, 142.0, 150.0]], [9, 24, 44.0, [4.0, 56.0, 65.0], [48.0, 48.0, 48.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1579, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 2172, \"opacity_changes\": [[56, 12, 9, 256], [57, 12, 11, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[28, 6, 61.0, [178.5, 176.5, 176.5], [117.5, 119.5, 124.5]], [13, 7, 35.25, [72.75, 71.75, 71.75], [107.0, 107.0, 107.0]], [13, 8, 35.75, [66.25, 66.25, 66.25], [102.0, 102.0, 102.0]], [17, 14, 32.75, [157.0, 155.0, 155.0], [124.25, 123.25, 123.25]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3723, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4887, \"opacity_changes\": [[9, 18, 21, 256], [10, 18, 19, 256], [11, 18, 20, 256], [12, 34, 27, 256], [7, 72, 29, 256], [6, 82, 256, 27]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 7, 37.8889, [70.0, 70.0, 70.0], [107.88888888888889, 105.88888888888889, 105.88888888888889]], [13, 8, 39.7778, [66.22222222222223, 66.22222222222223, 66.22222222222223], [106.0, 105.11111111111111, 105.11111111111111]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 2}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 6805, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 8688, \"opacity_changes\": [[12, 24, 22, 256], [15, 24, 22, 256], [10, 42, 29, 256], [16, 44, 256, 29], [16, 46, 27, 256], [111, 44, 256, 27], [111, 45, 256, 21], [111, 53, 256, 13], [18, 93, 26, 256], [112, 93, 9, 256], [113, 93, 10, 256], [114, 93, 8, 256], [10, 96, 29, 256], [8, 97, 26, 256], [9, 97, 28, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 6, 32.0, [75.25, 74.5, 74.5], [107.25, 106.5, 106.5]], [13, 7, 38.1875, [71.25, 70.75, 70.75], [109.4375, 108.0625, 108.0625]], [13, 8, 38.75, [69.125, 69.125, 69.125], [107.875, 106.8125, 106.8125]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}]}]} [\"Isolated actual Catalog/HdAssets source-bound sprite raster and artistic approval only. No new Host enemy occurrence, animation timing, terrain blend, gameplay, simulation-neutrality or fullscreen capture.\", \"Broader game-source freshness flag is true due to unrelated menu/game edits; relevant assets/hd loader source is current.\", \"Complete shared family scale, origin and all rawalpha>=16/>=32 crop retention independently verified. Palette classes, forced indices and all240\\u2013255counts pass; these numeric checks do not substitute for the completed artistic review.\", \"Original/source and newly authored stationary body shading are not byte identical; localized variations and native/2\\u00d7 contour smoothing are deliberately disclosed.\", \"Global registration and bundled pack snapshot remain coordinator-owned; no source/candidate/raw/global/Git edits by reviewer.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/independent-review.json, SHA256 f6c62881aa1b2c8f035cd588b6d4e11b8b543af4a03a6a56616613afe6be7839", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/inputs/enemies-30074-30077/runtime-review/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "4726f3da5a9f766a3116ddaaaae89a026c71e496816f536d544084541083812c" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "26ce2f190978e8c78b69c05c2c1e50e4c0faa6716b81f5c0da237c01e576ac6d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "30074", + "30075", + "30076", + "30077" + ], + "sha256": "b1b1b4f02c5341345bbb152748480a856dc54e1a18d4c32eeba2c7b1b1bd7860", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "30074-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4430eabcff3d19800acdd200fe09540ab411154b707fe1bdc2c232786237aa6a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30074-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30074-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0a844f2a3a332d05fa6f64bea2c098059e5dd56fd6c408f1be93498abc157f30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30074-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30074-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c429937330350f210aa3c0d1871f3af4607e2ae9675d19a5c7de102c2d49a5a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30074-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30074-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ba034b46eec6606ac83234e7e34daeddc9611c4121b5ae9541504885f24823e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30074-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30074-original.ppm", + "sha256": "91ecf064fc1a1bc2288e5ee14197c2ae8f28f72ef214269c009aecb56bbe40f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30074-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30075-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fc6e45e74adf75c5f54177f448809e9e89a3729eec59a0858f51d71546a6ae89", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30075-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30075-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b8133927f1f4683cbcccf6ee4b1324ae2a096fd99de2f06bbc2d8138ec18b72c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30075-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30075-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c56f120209ffe8607301d88088c9eb104b9e02c201303ee1a0938d8869b285ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30075-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30075-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "62493b07f34d8e1f09a6630ebfad610f01593c8c221f391426d3d06ff6a09ff3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30075-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30075-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2ca7d4baa576f0992bfdcedf9bfb09c66a708c2d8bd6864b200661708a5ec1bd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30075-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30076-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "dbb499347ff5edb324b240abd8c721b1a66d5a6132d4f50c5eb0246e370fdce1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30076-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30076-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6d9cb52e6155183515e5cf468425ebf0653faaece9eed84661cef25c3884cef7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30076-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30076-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e2678a2c24e3b6178206fa257d988dbed2edb176729d49b81e2d3ee6a68feecb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30076-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30076-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dda990d6e96583460bd49cc3cf03eb2997e8d85687a2b0775460ec3fb984605b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30076-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30076-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a1237841d9cc1405762056737132f5b1b46c79d3ab9e1c7e9233922e593cd9eb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30076-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30077-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "627d28a5350c9c4cc286c469a21fc29a57b8c11ce64d8b6fc56b0c21543f60f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30077-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30077-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dfdd6eb5c687e0e18237005ea8fc248ebb660d962550eaf0b0a47bf2120eb3fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30077-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30077-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "abb4cbbcd637f4814f71ecad942ff7a4649d34f14896ad8fc5636e8f38210303", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30077-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30077-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eb61d8277392d954991fd25caa315753de80673700d2dace1b2cc1faa425d541", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30077-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30077-original.ppm", + "sha256": "40b127321aa22ab03c00262bbc9aa352e1520f5cc5172368a855a4295f1d83be", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30077-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30077": { @@ -240094,7 +244115,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30077", "family_id": "enemies-30074-30077", "job_id": "enemies-30074-30077", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -240106,6 +244127,143 @@ "manifest": "jobs/enemies-30074-30077/candidate.json", "sha256": "9eb74fb9566b3ef05a4dc3234298cf9ee5d307d9836bd2c119bab9ef4f44a97d", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "9eb74fb9566b3ef05a4dc3234298cf9ee5d307d9836bd2c119bab9ef4f44a97d", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "c3a24732ba842cfe229a258db66fdd50a289fc1d29efe679428618201b32a0af", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:31.010556+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/enemies-30074-30077/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"Original gray/teal body retains asymmetric left dark/right pale material, central ladder and framed dark aperture. Upper/lower tread rows5/28 retain four distinct original phases. Authored metal grain, seams and rivets remain readable at1\\u20134.\", \"No source cell is entirely missing at any scale. Later native phases each add one peripheral contour cell, disclosed; bounds stay original. Original stationary rows6\\u201327 have264/333/333 changed native shades, only4/5/4 above32-channel delta. Logical mean source-stationary color changes >=32 at4\\u00d7 occupy4/6/3 of543 cells; no component movement seen.\"] {\"source_phase_differences\": [{\"asset\": \"30074\", \"changed_cells\": 0, \"changed_rows\": {}, \"changes\": []}, {\"asset\": \"30075\", \"changed_cells\": 48, \"changed_rows\": {\"5\": 24, \"28\": 24}, \"changes\": [[4, 5, 20, 27], [5, 5, 23, 20], [6, 5, 31, 23], [7, 5, 27, 31], [8, 5, 20, 27], [9, 5, 23, 20], [10, 5, 31, 23], [11, 5, 27, 31], [12, 5, 20, 27], [13, 5, 23, 20], [14, 5, 31, 23], [15, 5, 27, 31], [16, 5, 20, 27], [17, 5, 23, 20], [18, 5, 31, 23], [19, 5, 27, 31], [20, 5, 20, 27], [21, 5, 23, 20], [22, 5, 31, 23], [23, 5, 27, 31], [24, 5, 20, 27], [25, 5, 23, 20], [26, 5, 31, 23], [27, 5, 27, 31], [4, 28, 23, 30], [5, 28, 26, 23], [6, 28, 31, 26], [7, 28, 30, 31], [8, 28, 23, 30], [9, 28, 26, 23], [10, 28, 31, 26], [11, 28, 30, 31], [12, 28, 23, 30], [13, 28, 26, 23], [14, 28, 31, 26], [15, 28, 30, 31], [16, 28, 23, 30], [17, 28, 26, 23], [18, 28, 31, 26], [19, 28, 30, 31], [20, 28, 23, 30], [21, 28, 26, 23], [22, 28, 31, 26], [23, 28, 30, 31], [24, 28, 23, 30], [25, 28, 26, 23], [26, 28, 31, 26], [27, 28, 30, 31]]}, {\"asset\": \"30076\", \"changed_cells\": 48, \"changed_rows\": {\"5\": 24, \"28\": 24}, \"changes\": [[4, 5, 20, 31], [5, 5, 23, 27], [6, 5, 31, 20], [7, 5, 27, 23], [8, 5, 20, 31], [9, 5, 23, 27], [10, 5, 31, 20], [11, 5, 27, 23], [12, 5, 20, 31], [13, 5, 23, 27], [14, 5, 31, 20], [15, 5, 27, 23], [16, 5, 20, 31], [17, 5, 23, 27], [18, 5, 31, 20], [19, 5, 27, 23], [20, 5, 20, 31], [21, 5, 23, 27], [22, 5, 31, 20], [23, 5, 27, 23], [24, 5, 20, 31], [25, 5, 23, 27], [26, 5, 31, 20], [27, 5, 27, 23], [4, 28, 23, 31], [5, 28, 26, 30], [6, 28, 31, 23], [7, 28, 30, 26], [8, 28, 23, 31], [9, 28, 26, 30], [10, 28, 31, 23], [11, 28, 30, 26], [12, 28, 23, 31], [13, 28, 26, 30], [14, 28, 31, 23], [15, 28, 30, 26], [16, 28, 23, 31], [17, 28, 26, 30], [18, 28, 31, 23], [19, 28, 30, 26], [20, 28, 23, 31], [21, 28, 26, 30], [22, 28, 31, 23], [23, 28, 30, 26], [24, 28, 23, 31], [25, 28, 26, 30], [26, 28, 31, 23], [27, 28, 30, 26]]}, {\"asset\": \"30077\", \"changed_cells\": 48, \"changed_rows\": {\"5\": 24, \"28\": 24}, \"changes\": [[4, 5, 20, 27], [5, 5, 23, 31], [6, 5, 31, 27], [7, 5, 27, 20], [8, 5, 20, 23], [9, 5, 23, 31], [10, 5, 31, 27], [11, 5, 27, 20], [12, 5, 20, 23], [13, 5, 23, 31], [14, 5, 31, 27], [15, 5, 27, 20], [16, 5, 20, 23], [17, 5, 23, 31], [18, 5, 31, 27], [19, 5, 27, 20], [20, 5, 20, 23], [21, 5, 23, 31], [22, 5, 31, 27], [23, 5, 27, 20], [24, 5, 20, 23], [25, 5, 23, 31], [26, 5, 31, 27], [27, 5, 27, 20], [4, 28, 23, 30], [5, 28, 26, 31], [6, 28, 31, 30], [7, 28, 30, 23], [8, 28, 23, 26], [9, 28, 26, 31], [10, 28, 31, 30], [11, 28, 30, 23], [12, 28, 23, 26], [13, 28, 26, 31], [14, 28, 31, 30], [15, 28, 30, 23], [16, 28, 23, 26], [17, 28, 26, 31], [18, 28, 31, 30], [19, 28, 30, 23], [20, 28, 23, 26], [21, 28, 26, 31], [22, 28, 31, 30], [23, 28, 30, 23], [24, 28, 23, 26], [25, 28, 26, 31], [26, 28, 31, 30], [27, 28, 30, 23]]}], \"all_phase_source_stationary_occupied_cells\": 543, \"independent_row_based_metrics_match_worker\": true, \"row_based_metrics\": [{\"asset\": \"30075\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 264, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 4, \"max_channel_difference\": 93}, {\"asset\": \"30076\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 333, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 5, \"max_channel_difference\": 93}, {\"asset\": \"30077\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 333, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 4, \"max_channel_difference\": 85}], \"all_source_stationary_comparisons\": [{\"asset\": \"30075\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 263, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 543, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 7, 37.0, [97.0, 97.0, 97.0], [60.0, 60.0, 60.0]], [10, 8, 48.0, [4.0, 65.0, 73.0], [52.0, 52.0, 52.0]], [9, 24, 44.0, [4.0, 56.0, 65.0], [48.0, 48.0, 48.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1342, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 2172, \"opacity_changes\": [[56, 12, 9, 256], [57, 12, 11, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 6, 45.25, [106.5, 105.25, 105.25], [61.25, 60.25, 60.25]], [28, 6, 67.0, [178.5, 176.5, 176.5], [111.5, 114.5, 119.5]], [8, 7, 43.5, [65.5, 64.5, 64.5], [22.0, 40.0, 44.0]], [12, 7, 44.0, [92.0, 90.0, 90.0], [48.0, 48.0, 48.0]], [8, 8, 37.5, [62.5, 61.5, 61.5], [25.0, 39.0, 43.0]], [12, 8, 38.5, [88.75, 88.75, 88.75], [50.25, 50.25, 50.25]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 6}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3230, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4887, \"opacity_changes\": [[9, 18, 21, 256], [10, 18, 19, 256], [11, 18, 20, 256], [7, 72, 29, 256], [6, 82, 256, 27]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 6, 40.3333, [104.66666666666667, 104.11111111111111, 104.11111111111111], [64.33333333333333, 64.33333333333333, 64.33333333333333]], [8, 7, 36.6667, [62.44444444444444, 63.77777777777778, 64.66666666666667], [25.77777777777778, 41.333333333333336, 44.22222222222222]], [12, 7, 45.6667, [93.0, 92.11111111111111, 92.11111111111111], [47.333333333333336, 47.333333333333336, 47.333333333333336]], [12, 8, 35.7778, [88.55555555555556, 88.11111111111111, 88.11111111111111], [52.77777777777778, 52.77777777777778, 52.77777777777778]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 6020, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 8688, \"opacity_changes\": [[12, 24, 22, 256], [15, 24, 22, 256], [111, 24, 256, 22], [8, 28, 24, 256], [9, 28, 27, 256], [16, 44, 256, 30], [16, 45, 256, 29], [16, 47, 256, 28], [111, 44, 256, 27], [111, 45, 256, 18], [111, 53, 256, 13], [112, 93, 9, 256], [113, 93, 10, 256], [114, 93, 8, 256], [8, 97, 26, 256], [9, 97, 28, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 6, 40.8125, [104.0625, 103.3125, 103.3125], [63.25, 63.0, 63.0]], [8, 7, 33.75, [59.25, 64.75, 66.25], [25.5, 41.0, 44.125]], [12, 7, 46.3125, [94.3125, 92.75, 92.75], [48.0, 47.75, 47.75]], [12, 8, 33.75, [89.75, 89.25, 89.25], [56.0, 55.75, 55.75]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}]}, {\"asset\": \"30076\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 332, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 543, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[11, 7, 36.0, [105.0, 105.0, 105.0], [69.0, 69.0, 69.0]], [13, 8, 33.0, [60.0, 60.0, 60.0], [93.0, 89.0, 89.0]], [17, 8, 33.0, [85.0, 85.0, 85.0], [52.0, 52.0, 52.0]], [10, 9, 48.0, [52.0, 52.0, 52.0], [4.0, 56.0, 65.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1640, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 2172, \"opacity_changes\": [[56, 12, 9, 256], [57, 12, 11, 256], [5, 21, 30, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[17, 6, 32.0, [107.5, 107.5, 107.5], [76.75, 75.5, 75.5]], [28, 6, 61.0, [178.5, 176.5, 176.5], [117.5, 119.5, 124.5]], [13, 7, 33.25, [72.75, 71.75, 71.75], [105.0, 105.0, 105.0]], [13, 8, 32.75, [66.25, 66.25, 66.25], [99.0, 99.0, 99.0]], [25, 26, 32.25, [84.75, 83.5, 83.5], [52.5, 80.75, 85.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 5}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3785, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4887, \"opacity_changes\": [[9, 18, 21, 256], [11, 18, 20, 256], [83, 18, 19, 256], [12, 33, 29, 256], [12, 34, 27, 256], [12, 35, 27, 256], [7, 72, 29, 256], [6, 82, 256, 28]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[11, 7, 32.1111, [91.66666666666667, 90.33333333333333, 90.33333333333333], [59.55555555555556, 59.55555555555556, 59.55555555555556]], [13, 7, 36.7778, [70.0, 70.0, 70.0], [106.77777777777777, 106.77777777777777, 106.77777777777777]], [13, 8, 38.0, [66.22222222222223, 66.22222222222223, 66.22222222222223], [104.22222222222223, 103.33333333333333, 103.33333333333333]], [18, 11, 33.8889, [138.33333333333334, 151.88888888888889, 154.66666666666666], [172.22222222222223, 171.33333333333334, 171.33333333333334]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 6934, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 8688, \"opacity_changes\": [[12, 24, 22, 256], [15, 24, 22, 256], [16, 24, 28, 256], [10, 42, 29, 256], [16, 46, 27, 256], [111, 44, 256, 27], [111, 45, 256, 20], [111, 53, 256, 13], [18, 93, 26, 256], [112, 93, 9, 256], [113, 93, 10, 256], [114, 93, 8, 256], [10, 96, 29, 256], [8, 97, 26, 256], [9, 97, 28, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 7, 37.75, [71.25, 70.75, 70.75], [108.75, 108.5, 108.5]], [17, 7, 32.3125, [96.375, 95.0625, 95.0625], [64.0625, 63.8125, 63.8125]], [13, 8, 36.75, [69.125, 69.125, 69.125], [105.875, 105.125, 105.125]], [17, 8, 32.6875, [93.9375, 93.1875, 93.1875], [61.25, 61.0, 61.0]], [18, 10, 34.0625, [151.0, 165.5625, 167.5625], [185.0625, 182.5625, 182.5625]], [18, 11, 37.375, [134.25, 150.0, 152.25], [171.625, 169.625, 169.625]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 6}]}, {\"asset\": \"30077\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 332, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 543, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 7, 41.0, [97.0, 97.0, 97.0], [138.0, 134.0, 134.0]], [17, 9, 57.0, [130.0, 121.0, 142.0], [73.0, 142.0, 150.0]], [9, 24, 44.0, [4.0, 56.0, 65.0], [48.0, 48.0, 48.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1579, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 2172, \"opacity_changes\": [[56, 12, 9, 256], [57, 12, 11, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[28, 6, 61.0, [178.5, 176.5, 176.5], [117.5, 119.5, 124.5]], [13, 7, 35.25, [72.75, 71.75, 71.75], [107.0, 107.0, 107.0]], [13, 8, 35.75, [66.25, 66.25, 66.25], [102.0, 102.0, 102.0]], [17, 14, 32.75, [157.0, 155.0, 155.0], [124.25, 123.25, 123.25]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3723, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4887, \"opacity_changes\": [[9, 18, 21, 256], [10, 18, 19, 256], [11, 18, 20, 256], [12, 34, 27, 256], [7, 72, 29, 256], [6, 82, 256, 27]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 7, 37.8889, [70.0, 70.0, 70.0], [107.88888888888889, 105.88888888888889, 105.88888888888889]], [13, 8, 39.7778, [66.22222222222223, 66.22222222222223, 66.22222222222223], [106.0, 105.11111111111111, 105.11111111111111]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 2}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 6805, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 8688, \"opacity_changes\": [[12, 24, 22, 256], [15, 24, 22, 256], [10, 42, 29, 256], [16, 44, 256, 29], [16, 46, 27, 256], [111, 44, 256, 27], [111, 45, 256, 21], [111, 53, 256, 13], [18, 93, 26, 256], [112, 93, 9, 256], [113, 93, 10, 256], [114, 93, 8, 256], [10, 96, 29, 256], [8, 97, 26, 256], [9, 97, 28, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 6, 32.0, [75.25, 74.5, 74.5], [107.25, 106.5, 106.5]], [13, 7, 38.1875, [71.25, 70.75, 70.75], [109.4375, 108.0625, 108.0625]], [13, 8, 38.75, [69.125, 69.125, 69.125], [107.875, 106.8125, 106.8125]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}]}]} [\"Isolated actual Catalog/HdAssets source-bound sprite raster and artistic approval only. No new Host enemy occurrence, animation timing, terrain blend, gameplay, simulation-neutrality or fullscreen capture.\", \"Broader game-source freshness flag is true due to unrelated menu/game edits; relevant assets/hd loader source is current.\", \"Complete shared family scale, origin and all rawalpha>=16/>=32 crop retention independently verified. Palette classes, forced indices and all240\\u2013255counts pass; these numeric checks do not substitute for the completed artistic review.\", \"Original/source and newly authored stationary body shading are not byte identical; localized variations and native/2\\u00d7 contour smoothing are deliberately disclosed.\", \"Global registration and bundled pack snapshot remain coordinator-owned; no source/candidate/raw/global/Git edits by reviewer.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/independent-review.json, SHA256 f6c62881aa1b2c8f035cd588b6d4e11b8b543af4a03a6a56616613afe6be7839", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/inputs/enemies-30074-30077/runtime-review/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "4726f3da5a9f766a3116ddaaaae89a026c71e496816f536d544084541083812c" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "26ce2f190978e8c78b69c05c2c1e50e4c0faa6716b81f5c0da237c01e576ac6d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "30074", + "30075", + "30076", + "30077" + ], + "sha256": "b1b1b4f02c5341345bbb152748480a856dc54e1a18d4c32eeba2c7b1b1bd7860", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "30074-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4430eabcff3d19800acdd200fe09540ab411154b707fe1bdc2c232786237aa6a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30074-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30074-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0a844f2a3a332d05fa6f64bea2c098059e5dd56fd6c408f1be93498abc157f30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30074-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30074-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c429937330350f210aa3c0d1871f3af4607e2ae9675d19a5c7de102c2d49a5a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30074-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30074-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ba034b46eec6606ac83234e7e34daeddc9611c4121b5ae9541504885f24823e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30074-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30074-original.ppm", + "sha256": "91ecf064fc1a1bc2288e5ee14197c2ae8f28f72ef214269c009aecb56bbe40f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30074-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30075-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fc6e45e74adf75c5f54177f448809e9e89a3729eec59a0858f51d71546a6ae89", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30075-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30075-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b8133927f1f4683cbcccf6ee4b1324ae2a096fd99de2f06bbc2d8138ec18b72c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30075-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30075-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c56f120209ffe8607301d88088c9eb104b9e02c201303ee1a0938d8869b285ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30075-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30075-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "62493b07f34d8e1f09a6630ebfad610f01593c8c221f391426d3d06ff6a09ff3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30075-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30075-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2ca7d4baa576f0992bfdcedf9bfb09c66a708c2d8bd6864b200661708a5ec1bd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30075-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30076-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "dbb499347ff5edb324b240abd8c721b1a66d5a6132d4f50c5eb0246e370fdce1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30076-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30076-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6d9cb52e6155183515e5cf468425ebf0653faaece9eed84661cef25c3884cef7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30076-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30076-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e2678a2c24e3b6178206fa257d988dbed2edb176729d49b81e2d3ee6a68feecb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30076-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30076-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dda990d6e96583460bd49cc3cf03eb2997e8d85687a2b0775460ec3fb984605b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30076-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30076-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a1237841d9cc1405762056737132f5b1b46c79d3ab9e1c7e9233922e593cd9eb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30076-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30077-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "627d28a5350c9c4cc286c469a21fc29a57b8c11ce64d8b6fc56b0c21543f60f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30077-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30077-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dfdd6eb5c687e0e18237005ea8fc248ebb660d962550eaf0b0a47bf2120eb3fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30077-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30077-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "abb4cbbcd637f4814f71ecad942ff7a4649d34f14896ad8fc5636e8f38210303", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30077-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30077-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eb61d8277392d954991fd25caa315753de80673700d2dace1b2cc1faa425d541", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30077-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30077-original.ppm", + "sha256": "40b127321aa22ab03c00262bbc9aa352e1520f5cc5172368a855a4295f1d83be", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30077-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30078": { @@ -240391,7 +244549,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30080", "family_id": "enemies-30080-30084", "job_id": "enemies-30080-30084", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -240403,6 +244561,176 @@ "manifest": "jobs/enemies-30080-30084/candidate.json", "sha256": "1ace4e117a41b4a2790441b94331eb05bc7d66eb711100a0db325d068726758e", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1ace4e117a41b4a2790441b94331eb05bc7d66eb711100a0db325d068726758e", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "7ef5d4f694e62bab8fa8fd3254ccc6cfd56ca21f4f030a9db231b5e1d7d340df", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:31.125025+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/enemies-30080-30084/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"Four copper slats preserve original five-stage horizontal highlight/recess progression; outer gray tread/bar positions and lower split legs/aperture remain aligned. Fine bronze grain and pale bevels are slightly brighter than the source. Dark source bands become opaque recessed faces, not transparent holes.\", \"Native1 loses only source black contour cell(3,27) in all five frames;2\\u00d7 also loses it only30082/30083. Every source cell survives3\\u20134. Stationary lower rows20\\u201330 retain architecture with89/124/126/128 changed native shades,0/0/4/3 >=32-channel delta.\"] {\"source_phase_differences\": [{\"asset\": \"30080\", \"changed_cells\": 0, \"changed_rows\": {}, \"changes\": []}, {\"asset\": \"30081\", \"changed_cells\": 207, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 13, \"2\": 11, \"3\": 8, \"4\": 7, \"5\": 8, \"6\": 7, \"7\": 10, \"8\": 10, \"9\": 10, \"10\": 13, \"11\": 14, \"12\": 17, \"13\": 12, \"14\": 11, \"15\": 14, \"16\": 15, \"17\": 13, \"18\": 6, \"19\": 8}, \"changes\": [[9, 1, 186, 187], [10, 1, 183, 185], [11, 1, 181, 179], [14, 1, 186, 187], [15, 1, 183, 185], [18, 1, 187, 188], [19, 1, 184, 186], [20, 1, 179, 185], [21, 1, 180, 181], [23, 1, 187, 188], [24, 1, 183, 187], [25, 1, 179, 187], [26, 1, 180, 183], [9, 2, 195, 194], [11, 2, 186, 183], [13, 2, 197, 196], [15, 2, 192, 194], [18, 2, 196, 197], [19, 2, 193, 195], [21, 2, 184, 185], [23, 2, 196, 197], [24, 2, 194, 195], [25, 2, 190, 193], [26, 2, 181, 186], [8, 3, 197, 196], [9, 3, 197, 194], [10, 3, 194, 193], [11, 3, 187, 184], [19, 3, 195, 197], [21, 3, 183, 184], [24, 3, 195, 196], [26, 3, 183, 186], [9, 4, 197, 196], [10, 4, 195, 194], [14, 4, 197, 196], [19, 4, 196, 197], [21, 4, 185, 186], [24, 4, 196, 197], [26, 4, 185, 187], [9, 5, 197, 196], [10, 5, 197, 194], [11, 5, 188, 187], [14, 5, 197, 196], [16, 5, 187, 186], [21, 5, 186, 187], [25, 5, 194, 196], [27, 5, 199, 200], [10, 6, 197, 196], [11, 6, 188, 187], [13, 6, 198, 197], [14, 6, 197, 196], [16, 6, 188, 187], [20, 6, 196, 195], [26, 6, 186, 187], [8, 7, 197, 198], [10, 7, 197, 196], [11, 7, 188, 186], [12, 7, 203, 202], [13, 7, 198, 197], [15, 7, 196, 195], [17, 7, 203, 202], [20, 7, 197, 195], [22, 7, 202, 203], [25, 7, 197, 196], [8, 8, 198, 197], [9, 8, 197, 198], [11, 8, 188, 187], [12, 8, 203, 202], [13, 8, 198, 197], [14, 8, 198, 197], [15, 8, 197, 195], [17, 8, 203, 202], [20, 8, 197, 195], [22, 8, 202, 204], [8, 9, 198, 197], [9, 9, 198, 197], [12, 9, 203, 202], [15, 9, 198, 195], [18, 9, 198, 197], [20, 9, 197, 196], [21, 9, 189, 188], [22, 9, 202, 204], [24, 9, 199, 197], [26, 9, 189, 188], [7, 10, 204, 205], [9, 10, 198, 197], [11, 10, 189, 188], [12, 10, 203, 202], [14, 10, 199, 197], [15, 10, 198, 196], [18, 10, 198, 197], [19, 10, 198, 197], [21, 10, 189, 188], [22, 10, 202, 204], [23, 10, 198, 197], [24, 10, 199, 197], [26, 10, 189, 188], [8, 11, 199, 197], [9, 11, 198, 197], [11, 11, 190, 188], [12, 11, 203, 204], [14, 11, 198, 197], [15, 11, 198, 197], [17, 11, 203, 204], [18, 11, 198, 197], [19, 11, 198, 197], [20, 11, 198, 197], [21, 11, 189, 188], [22, 11, 202, 204], [23, 11, 199, 197], [26, 11, 189, 188], [7, 12, 204, 205], [8, 12, 199, 198], [9, 12, 198, 197], [10, 12, 199, 198], [11, 12, 190, 189], [12, 12, 204, 205], [13, 12, 199, 198], [15, 12, 198, 197], [16, 12, 190, 188], [17, 12, 203, 205], [19, 12, 198, 197], [20, 12, 198, 197], [21, 12, 189, 188], [22, 12, 203, 205], [23, 12, 199, 197], [24, 12, 198, 197], [26, 12, 190, 188], [8, 13, 202, 201], [9, 13, 202, 201], [10, 13, 202, 201], [13, 13, 202, 201], [14, 13, 201, 202], [15, 13, 201, 200], [16, 13, 194, 191], [20, 13, 201, 200], [21, 13, 195, 192], [23, 13, 201, 202], [25, 13, 201, 200], [26, 13, 193, 191], [8, 14, 200, 198], [9, 14, 199, 198], [10, 14, 199, 198], [11, 14, 192, 190], [14, 14, 199, 200], [16, 14, 192, 188], [18, 14, 200, 198], [21, 14, 193, 189], [22, 14, 204, 205], [25, 14, 198, 197], [26, 14, 191, 188], [6, 15, 207, 79], [8, 15, 202, 200], [9, 15, 201, 199], [10, 15, 201, 198], [11, 15, 193, 190], [13, 15, 201, 199], [14, 15, 199, 200], [16, 15, 192, 188], [18, 15, 201, 200], [19, 15, 200, 199], [21, 15, 193, 189], [22, 15, 203, 205], [24, 15, 200, 199], [26, 15, 191, 188], [6, 16, 79, 207], [8, 16, 206, 204], [9, 16, 205, 204], [10, 16, 204, 203], [11, 16, 195, 193], [13, 16, 205, 203], [14, 16, 204, 203], [16, 16, 196, 191], [17, 16, 207, 206], [18, 16, 204, 203], [19, 16, 204, 203], [21, 16, 196, 192], [23, 16, 205, 204], [24, 16, 205, 203], [26, 16, 197, 195], [5, 17, 207, 47], [6, 17, 207, 47], [12, 17, 79, 207], [13, 17, 47, 207], [14, 17, 47, 207], [18, 17, 206, 207], [19, 17, 206, 207], [20, 17, 206, 207], [21, 17, 205, 207], [23, 17, 206, 207], [24, 17, 204, 207], [25, 17, 205, 207], [26, 17, 195, 207], [11, 18, 206, 47], [14, 18, 206, 204], [15, 18, 206, 47], [16, 18, 206, 47], [20, 18, 204, 200], [24, 18, 202, 197], [12, 19, 206, 205], [16, 19, 205, 203], [18, 19, 47, 206], [19, 19, 206, 204], [20, 19, 205, 202], [21, 19, 205, 203], [22, 19, 205, 202], [23, 19, 205, 197]]}, {\"asset\": \"30082\", \"changed_cells\": 299, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 20, \"2\": 17, \"3\": 14, \"4\": 14, \"5\": 11, \"6\": 13, \"7\": 12, \"8\": 13, \"9\": 14, \"10\": 14, \"11\": 19, \"12\": 15, \"13\": 20, \"14\": 19, \"15\": 20, \"16\": 18, \"17\": 19, \"18\": 9, \"19\": 18}, \"changes\": [[7, 1, 195, 200], [8, 1, 188, 189], [9, 1, 186, 189], [10, 1, 183, 188], [11, 1, 181, 184], [12, 1, 195, 198], [13, 1, 188, 190], [14, 1, 186, 187], [15, 1, 183, 189], [16, 1, 181, 183], [17, 1, 195, 198], [18, 1, 187, 189], [19, 1, 184, 189], [20, 1, 179, 189], [21, 1, 180, 184], [22, 1, 195, 197], [23, 1, 187, 190], [24, 1, 183, 187], [25, 1, 179, 187], [26, 1, 180, 183], [7, 2, 202, 205], [8, 2, 196, 197], [9, 2, 195, 197], [10, 2, 193, 195], [11, 2, 186, 187], [12, 2, 202, 204], [13, 2, 197, 198], [15, 2, 192, 196], [17, 2, 202, 204], [18, 2, 196, 197], [19, 2, 193, 196], [20, 2, 193, 196], [21, 2, 184, 188], [23, 2, 196, 199], [24, 2, 194, 195], [25, 2, 190, 194], [26, 2, 181, 187], [7, 3, 202, 205], [9, 3, 197, 196], [11, 3, 187, 185], [12, 3, 202, 204], [13, 3, 197, 198], [14, 3, 196, 194], [15, 3, 194, 196], [16, 3, 186, 182], [17, 3, 202, 203], [21, 3, 183, 188], [22, 3, 202, 199], [23, 3, 197, 198], [24, 3, 195, 197], [25, 3, 194, 195], [7, 4, 202, 204], [9, 4, 197, 195], [10, 4, 195, 193], [11, 4, 186, 182], [12, 4, 202, 204], [13, 4, 197, 198], [14, 4, 197, 195], [15, 4, 195, 196], [16, 4, 186, 182], [21, 4, 185, 187], [22, 4, 202, 201], [24, 4, 196, 197], [25, 4, 195, 196], [26, 4, 185, 182], [7, 5, 202, 204], [9, 5, 197, 196], [10, 5, 197, 193], [11, 5, 188, 181], [12, 5, 202, 203], [16, 5, 187, 181], [20, 5, 195, 194], [22, 5, 202, 201], [25, 5, 194, 196], [26, 5, 187, 181], [27, 5, 199, 200], [7, 6, 202, 204], [9, 6, 197, 196], [10, 6, 197, 194], [11, 6, 188, 183], [12, 6, 202, 203], [13, 6, 198, 199], [15, 6, 196, 194], [16, 6, 188, 180], [20, 6, 196, 194], [21, 6, 187, 184], [22, 6, 202, 201], [25, 6, 196, 197], [26, 6, 186, 181], [7, 7, 202, 203], [9, 7, 197, 196], [10, 7, 197, 194], [11, 7, 188, 186], [12, 7, 203, 202], [15, 7, 196, 195], [16, 7, 188, 182], [20, 7, 197, 194], [21, 7, 188, 185], [22, 7, 202, 200], [25, 7, 197, 196], [26, 7, 187, 184], [8, 8, 198, 197], [9, 8, 197, 196], [10, 8, 197, 194], [13, 8, 198, 197], [14, 8, 198, 197], [15, 8, 197, 195], [16, 8, 188, 185], [17, 8, 203, 204], [20, 8, 197, 195], [21, 8, 188, 186], [22, 8, 202, 200], [25, 8, 197, 196], [26, 8, 188, 185], [7, 9, 203, 205], [8, 9, 198, 197], [9, 9, 198, 197], [10, 9, 198, 195], [12, 9, 203, 204], [13, 9, 198, 197], [15, 9, 198, 196], [16, 9, 188, 184], [17, 9, 203, 205], [18, 9, 198, 197], [20, 9, 197, 195], [21, 9, 189, 188], [24, 9, 199, 197], [26, 9, 189, 185], [7, 10, 204, 205], [9, 10, 198, 197], [10, 10, 198, 196], [11, 10, 189, 188], [14, 10, 199, 197], [15, 10, 198, 197], [16, 10, 188, 186], [17, 10, 203, 205], [19, 10, 198, 197], [20, 10, 197, 196], [21, 10, 189, 187], [22, 10, 202, 203], [24, 10, 199, 197], [26, 10, 189, 186], [7, 11, 205, 207], [8, 11, 199, 202], [9, 11, 198, 200], [10, 11, 198, 199], [11, 11, 190, 191], [12, 11, 203, 206], [13, 11, 199, 201], [14, 11, 198, 200], [15, 11, 198, 200], [16, 11, 188, 190], [17, 11, 203, 207], [18, 11, 198, 202], [19, 11, 198, 200], [20, 11, 198, 199], [21, 11, 189, 190], [22, 11, 202, 207], [23, 11, 199, 201], [24, 11, 197, 200], [25, 11, 197, 200], [9, 12, 198, 197], [10, 12, 199, 196], [11, 12, 190, 188], [12, 12, 204, 203], [14, 12, 198, 197], [15, 12, 198, 197], [16, 12, 190, 188], [17, 12, 203, 204], [18, 12, 198, 199], [19, 12, 198, 197], [20, 12, 198, 196], [21, 12, 189, 187], [22, 12, 203, 204], [24, 12, 198, 197], [26, 12, 190, 187], [7, 13, 207, 205], [8, 13, 202, 199], [9, 13, 202, 199], [10, 13, 202, 196], [11, 13, 193, 187], [12, 13, 207, 203], [13, 13, 202, 199], [14, 13, 201, 198], [15, 13, 201, 197], [16, 13, 194, 188], [17, 13, 207, 204], [18, 13, 202, 200], [19, 13, 201, 198], [20, 13, 201, 197], [21, 13, 195, 187], [22, 13, 207, 203], [23, 13, 201, 200], [24, 13, 201, 197], [25, 13, 201, 197], [26, 13, 193, 188], [6, 14, 207, 79], [8, 14, 200, 203], [9, 14, 199, 204], [10, 14, 199, 202], [11, 14, 192, 191], [13, 14, 199, 202], [14, 14, 199, 203], [15, 14, 198, 203], [16, 14, 192, 191], [17, 14, 205, 206], [18, 14, 200, 203], [19, 14, 199, 203], [20, 14, 198, 202], [21, 14, 193, 191], [22, 14, 204, 206], [23, 14, 200, 204], [24, 14, 198, 203], [25, 14, 198, 202], [26, 14, 191, 195], [7, 15, 206, 207], [8, 15, 202, 239], [9, 15, 201, 31], [10, 15, 201, 239], [11, 15, 193, 207], [12, 15, 206, 207], [13, 15, 201, 239], [14, 15, 199, 31], [15, 15, 198, 239], [16, 15, 192, 207], [17, 15, 205, 207], [18, 15, 201, 239], [19, 15, 200, 31], [20, 15, 198, 239], [21, 15, 193, 207], [22, 15, 203, 207], [23, 15, 200, 239], [24, 15, 200, 31], [25, 15, 198, 239], [26, 15, 191, 207], [6, 16, 79, 207], [7, 16, 206, 207], [8, 16, 206, 239], [9, 16, 205, 31], [10, 16, 204, 239], [11, 16, 195, 207], [13, 16, 205, 239], [14, 16, 204, 31], [15, 16, 204, 239], [16, 16, 196, 207], [18, 16, 204, 239], [19, 16, 204, 31], [20, 16, 204, 239], [21, 16, 196, 207], [23, 16, 205, 239], [24, 16, 205, 31], [25, 16, 203, 239], [26, 16, 197, 207], [5, 17, 207, 47], [6, 17, 207, 47], [8, 17, 207, 47], [9, 17, 207, 47], [10, 17, 207, 47], [12, 17, 79, 47], [14, 17, 47, 206], [15, 17, 207, 205], [16, 17, 207, 205], [17, 17, 207, 205], [18, 17, 206, 204], [19, 17, 206, 204], [20, 17, 206, 197], [21, 17, 205, 193], [22, 17, 207, 202], [23, 17, 206, 202], [24, 17, 204, 191], [25, 17, 205, 198], [26, 17, 195, 192], [13, 18, 205, 203], [14, 18, 206, 201], [18, 18, 205, 202], [19, 18, 205, 202], [20, 18, 204, 194], [21, 18, 205, 202], [22, 18, 205, 202], [23, 18, 205, 197], [24, 18, 202, 190], [5, 19, 206, 204], [6, 19, 201, 196], [8, 19, 206, 205], [9, 19, 206, 204], [10, 19, 205, 203], [11, 19, 204, 200], [12, 19, 206, 203], [13, 19, 204, 201], [14, 19, 205, 202], [15, 19, 205, 202], [16, 19, 205, 199], [17, 19, 47, 206], [18, 19, 47, 205], [19, 19, 206, 201], [20, 19, 205, 197], [21, 19, 205, 199], [22, 19, 205, 197], [23, 19, 205, 197]]}, {\"asset\": \"30083\", \"changed_cells\": 335, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 20, \"2\": 19, \"3\": 17, \"4\": 15, \"5\": 13, \"6\": 13, \"7\": 18, \"8\": 19, \"9\": 19, \"10\": 18, \"11\": 17, \"12\": 19, \"13\": 19, \"14\": 19, \"15\": 21, \"16\": 19, \"17\": 20, \"18\": 12, \"19\": 18}, \"changes\": [[7, 1, 195, 203], [8, 1, 188, 190], [9, 1, 186, 190], [10, 1, 183, 188], [11, 1, 181, 185], [12, 1, 195, 202], [13, 1, 188, 190], [14, 1, 186, 190], [15, 1, 183, 190], [16, 1, 181, 185], [17, 1, 195, 203], [18, 1, 187, 191], [19, 1, 184, 190], [20, 1, 179, 190], [21, 1, 180, 185], [22, 1, 195, 201], [23, 1, 187, 192], [24, 1, 183, 190], [25, 1, 179, 190], [26, 1, 180, 185], [7, 2, 202, 206], [8, 2, 196, 197], [9, 2, 195, 197], [10, 2, 193, 195], [11, 2, 186, 188], [12, 2, 202, 205], [14, 2, 194, 196], [15, 2, 192, 197], [16, 2, 185, 188], [17, 2, 202, 205], [18, 2, 196, 197], [19, 2, 193, 197], [20, 2, 193, 197], [21, 2, 184, 188], [22, 2, 202, 205], [23, 2, 196, 199], [24, 2, 194, 197], [25, 2, 190, 197], [26, 2, 181, 187], [7, 3, 202, 206], [8, 3, 197, 196], [10, 3, 194, 196], [11, 3, 187, 186], [12, 3, 202, 205], [14, 3, 196, 195], [15, 3, 194, 197], [16, 3, 186, 187], [17, 3, 202, 205], [19, 3, 195, 197], [20, 3, 194, 196], [21, 3, 183, 189], [22, 3, 202, 205], [23, 3, 197, 199], [24, 3, 195, 197], [25, 3, 194, 197], [26, 3, 183, 187], [7, 4, 202, 206], [10, 4, 195, 196], [11, 4, 186, 184], [12, 4, 202, 204], [14, 4, 197, 196], [15, 4, 195, 197], [16, 4, 186, 185], [17, 4, 202, 205], [19, 4, 196, 197], [20, 4, 194, 195], [21, 4, 185, 189], [22, 4, 202, 205], [23, 4, 197, 198], [25, 4, 195, 196], [26, 4, 185, 187], [7, 5, 202, 206], [10, 5, 197, 194], [11, 5, 188, 185], [12, 5, 202, 203], [14, 5, 197, 195], [16, 5, 187, 184], [17, 5, 202, 205], [21, 5, 186, 187], [22, 5, 202, 203], [23, 5, 197, 198], [25, 5, 194, 196], [26, 5, 187, 188], [27, 5, 199, 200], [7, 6, 202, 205], [10, 6, 197, 194], [11, 6, 188, 183], [13, 6, 198, 197], [14, 6, 197, 196], [15, 6, 196, 195], [16, 6, 188, 185], [17, 6, 202, 203], [20, 6, 196, 195], [21, 6, 187, 184], [22, 6, 202, 203], [23, 6, 197, 198], [25, 6, 196, 195], [7, 7, 202, 203], [9, 7, 197, 196], [10, 7, 197, 193], [11, 7, 188, 180], [12, 7, 203, 202], [13, 7, 198, 197], [14, 7, 197, 196], [15, 7, 196, 194], [16, 7, 188, 181], [17, 7, 203, 202], [19, 7, 197, 196], [20, 7, 197, 193], [21, 7, 188, 184], [22, 7, 202, 203], [23, 7, 197, 198], [24, 7, 197, 196], [25, 7, 197, 195], [26, 7, 187, 183], [7, 8, 203, 202], [8, 8, 198, 197], [9, 8, 197, 196], [10, 8, 197, 194], [11, 8, 188, 180], [12, 8, 203, 200], [13, 8, 198, 197], [14, 8, 198, 196], [15, 8, 197, 194], [16, 8, 188, 182], [17, 8, 203, 202], [19, 8, 197, 195], [20, 8, 197, 193], [21, 8, 188, 183], [22, 8, 202, 203], [23, 8, 197, 198], [24, 8, 197, 195], [25, 8, 197, 196], [26, 8, 188, 183], [7, 9, 203, 206], [8, 9, 198, 200], [9, 9, 198, 199], [10, 9, 198, 196], [11, 9, 188, 185], [12, 9, 203, 204], [13, 9, 198, 200], [14, 9, 197, 199], [15, 9, 198, 197], [16, 9, 188, 184], [17, 9, 203, 206], [18, 9, 198, 200], [19, 9, 197, 198], [21, 9, 189, 186], [22, 9, 202, 206], [23, 9, 197, 200], [24, 9, 199, 198], [25, 9, 197, 198], [26, 9, 189, 184], [8, 10, 198, 197], [9, 10, 198, 196], [10, 10, 198, 195], [11, 10, 189, 185], [13, 10, 198, 197], [14, 10, 199, 196], [15, 10, 198, 195], [16, 10, 188, 184], [17, 10, 203, 204], [18, 10, 198, 197], [19, 10, 198, 196], [20, 10, 197, 195], [21, 10, 189, 188], [22, 10, 202, 204], [23, 10, 198, 197], [24, 10, 199, 195], [25, 10, 197, 196], [26, 10, 189, 182], [7, 11, 205, 204], [8, 11, 199, 198], [9, 11, 198, 196], [10, 11, 198, 196], [11, 11, 190, 186], [12, 11, 203, 204], [13, 11, 199, 197], [14, 11, 198, 197], [15, 11, 198, 196], [17, 11, 203, 204], [19, 11, 198, 197], [20, 11, 198, 196], [21, 11, 189, 187], [22, 11, 202, 204], [23, 11, 199, 197], [24, 11, 197, 196], [26, 11, 189, 184], [7, 12, 204, 206], [8, 12, 199, 203], [9, 12, 198, 200], [10, 12, 199, 202], [12, 12, 204, 207], [13, 12, 199, 204], [14, 12, 198, 202], [15, 12, 198, 202], [16, 12, 190, 191], [17, 12, 203, 206], [18, 12, 198, 203], [19, 12, 198, 202], [20, 12, 198, 202], [21, 12, 189, 190], [22, 12, 203, 207], [23, 12, 199, 204], [24, 12, 198, 202], [25, 12, 197, 202], [26, 12, 190, 195], [8, 13, 202, 239], [9, 13, 202, 31], [10, 13, 202, 238], [11, 13, 193, 207], [12, 13, 207, 206], [13, 13, 202, 239], [14, 13, 201, 31], [15, 13, 201, 238], [16, 13, 194, 207], [17, 13, 207, 206], [18, 13, 202, 239], [19, 13, 201, 31], [20, 13, 201, 238], [21, 13, 195, 207], [22, 13, 207, 206], [23, 13, 201, 239], [24, 13, 201, 31], [25, 13, 201, 238], [26, 13, 193, 205], [7, 14, 206, 207], [8, 14, 200, 31], [9, 14, 199, 31], [10, 14, 199, 31], [11, 14, 192, 207], [13, 14, 199, 31], [14, 14, 199, 31], [15, 14, 198, 31], [16, 14, 192, 207], [17, 14, 205, 206], [18, 14, 200, 31], [19, 14, 199, 31], [20, 14, 198, 31], [21, 14, 193, 207], [22, 14, 204, 206], [23, 14, 200, 31], [24, 14, 198, 31], [25, 14, 198, 31], [26, 14, 191, 206], [6, 15, 207, 79], [7, 15, 206, 207], [8, 15, 202, 239], [9, 15, 201, 31], [10, 15, 201, 239], [11, 15, 193, 207], [12, 15, 206, 207], [13, 15, 201, 239], [14, 15, 199, 31], [15, 15, 198, 239], [16, 15, 192, 207], [17, 15, 205, 207], [18, 15, 201, 239], [19, 15, 200, 31], [20, 15, 198, 239], [21, 15, 193, 207], [22, 15, 203, 207], [23, 15, 200, 239], [24, 15, 200, 31], [25, 15, 198, 239], [26, 15, 191, 206], [6, 16, 79, 207], [7, 16, 206, 207], [8, 16, 206, 207], [9, 16, 205, 207], [10, 16, 204, 207], [11, 16, 195, 207], [12, 16, 207, 79], [13, 16, 205, 206], [14, 16, 204, 206], [16, 16, 196, 204], [17, 16, 207, 200], [18, 16, 204, 197], [19, 16, 204, 193], [20, 16, 204, 191], [21, 16, 196, 186], [22, 16, 207, 197], [23, 16, 205, 197], [24, 16, 205, 194], [25, 16, 203, 198], [5, 17, 207, 47], [6, 17, 207, 47], [8, 17, 207, 47], [9, 17, 207, 47], [10, 17, 207, 47], [12, 17, 79, 47], [13, 17, 47, 206], [14, 17, 47, 204], [15, 17, 207, 203], [16, 17, 207, 202], [17, 17, 207, 202], [18, 17, 206, 196], [19, 17, 206, 194], [20, 17, 206, 191], [21, 17, 205, 186], [22, 17, 207, 197], [23, 17, 206, 197], [24, 17, 204, 191], [25, 17, 205, 198], [26, 17, 195, 192], [13, 18, 205, 203], [14, 18, 206, 201], [15, 18, 206, 204], [16, 18, 206, 205], [17, 18, 47, 206], [18, 18, 205, 197], [19, 18, 205, 197], [20, 18, 204, 187], [21, 18, 205, 197], [22, 18, 205, 197], [23, 18, 205, 197], [24, 18, 202, 190], [5, 19, 206, 204], [6, 19, 201, 196], [8, 19, 206, 205], [9, 19, 206, 204], [10, 19, 205, 203], [11, 19, 204, 200], [12, 19, 206, 203], [13, 19, 204, 201], [14, 19, 205, 202], [15, 19, 205, 202], [16, 19, 205, 199], [17, 19, 47, 206], [18, 19, 47, 205], [19, 19, 206, 201], [20, 19, 205, 197], [21, 19, 205, 199], [22, 19, 205, 197], [23, 19, 205, 197]]}, {\"asset\": \"30084\", \"changed_cells\": 339, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 20, \"2\": 20, \"3\": 19, \"4\": 17, \"5\": 13, \"6\": 12, \"7\": 12, \"8\": 19, \"9\": 16, \"10\": 18, \"11\": 20, \"12\": 20, \"13\": 20, \"14\": 20, \"15\": 21, \"16\": 19, \"17\": 20, \"18\": 15, \"19\": 18}, \"changes\": [[7, 1, 195, 206], [8, 1, 188, 193], [9, 1, 186, 191], [10, 1, 183, 191], [11, 1, 181, 186], [12, 1, 195, 205], [13, 1, 188, 194], [14, 1, 186, 191], [15, 1, 183, 191], [16, 1, 181, 187], [17, 1, 195, 204], [18, 1, 187, 194], [19, 1, 184, 192], [20, 1, 179, 191], [21, 1, 180, 186], [22, 1, 195, 206], [23, 1, 187, 194], [24, 1, 183, 192], [25, 1, 179, 191], [26, 1, 180, 186], [7, 2, 202, 206], [8, 2, 196, 200], [9, 2, 195, 197], [10, 2, 193, 197], [11, 2, 186, 188], [12, 2, 202, 206], [13, 2, 197, 201], [14, 2, 194, 197], [15, 2, 192, 197], [16, 2, 185, 189], [17, 2, 202, 206], [18, 2, 196, 201], [19, 2, 193, 197], [20, 2, 193, 197], [21, 2, 184, 188], [22, 2, 202, 206], [23, 2, 196, 199], [24, 2, 194, 198], [25, 2, 190, 197], [26, 2, 181, 188], [7, 3, 202, 206], [8, 3, 197, 199], [10, 3, 194, 197], [11, 3, 187, 188], [12, 3, 202, 206], [13, 3, 197, 200], [14, 3, 196, 197], [15, 3, 194, 197], [16, 3, 186, 189], [17, 3, 202, 206], [18, 3, 197, 199], [19, 3, 195, 197], [20, 3, 194, 197], [21, 3, 183, 188], [22, 3, 202, 206], [23, 3, 197, 199], [24, 3, 195, 198], [25, 3, 194, 197], [26, 3, 183, 187], [7, 4, 202, 205], [8, 4, 197, 198], [10, 4, 195, 197], [11, 4, 186, 187], [12, 4, 202, 206], [15, 4, 195, 197], [16, 4, 186, 188], [17, 4, 202, 206], [18, 4, 197, 198], [19, 4, 196, 197], [20, 4, 194, 197], [21, 4, 185, 186], [22, 4, 202, 205], [23, 4, 197, 199], [24, 4, 196, 198], [25, 4, 195, 197], [26, 4, 185, 186], [7, 5, 202, 204], [11, 5, 188, 186], [12, 5, 202, 206], [15, 5, 196, 197], [16, 5, 187, 188], [17, 5, 202, 204], [20, 5, 195, 197], [21, 5, 186, 184], [22, 5, 202, 205], [23, 5, 197, 198], [25, 5, 194, 196], [26, 5, 187, 186], [27, 5, 199, 200], [7, 6, 202, 203], [11, 6, 188, 186], [12, 6, 202, 205], [13, 6, 198, 197], [15, 6, 196, 197], [16, 6, 188, 186], [17, 6, 202, 204], [21, 6, 187, 184], [22, 6, 202, 205], [23, 6, 197, 198], [25, 6, 196, 195], [26, 6, 186, 185], [7, 7, 202, 203], [10, 7, 197, 196], [11, 7, 188, 185], [13, 7, 198, 197], [15, 7, 196, 197], [16, 7, 188, 185], [20, 7, 197, 196], [21, 7, 188, 182], [22, 7, 202, 203], [23, 7, 197, 198], [25, 7, 197, 194], [26, 7, 187, 182], [7, 8, 203, 205], [8, 8, 198, 200], [9, 8, 197, 200], [10, 8, 197, 198], [11, 8, 188, 186], [12, 8, 203, 206], [13, 8, 198, 200], [14, 8, 198, 200], [15, 8, 197, 198], [16, 8, 188, 186], [17, 8, 203, 206], [18, 8, 197, 200], [19, 8, 197, 200], [20, 8, 197, 198], [21, 8, 188, 183], [22, 8, 202, 205], [23, 8, 197, 200], [24, 8, 197, 200], [25, 8, 197, 195], [7, 9, 203, 202], [8, 9, 198, 197], [9, 9, 198, 197], [10, 9, 198, 194], [11, 9, 188, 180], [12, 9, 203, 202], [13, 9, 198, 197], [14, 9, 197, 196], [15, 9, 198, 195], [16, 9, 188, 180], [18, 9, 198, 197], [20, 9, 197, 191], [21, 9, 189, 179], [24, 9, 199, 195], [25, 9, 197, 191], [26, 9, 189, 182], [7, 10, 204, 202], [8, 10, 198, 197], [9, 10, 198, 196], [10, 10, 198, 192], [11, 10, 189, 176], [12, 10, 203, 202], [13, 10, 198, 197], [14, 10, 199, 195], [15, 10, 198, 192], [16, 10, 188, 179], [18, 10, 198, 196], [19, 10, 198, 193], [20, 10, 197, 189], [21, 10, 189, 178], [23, 10, 198, 196], [24, 10, 199, 191], [25, 10, 197, 189], [26, 10, 189, 181], [7, 11, 205, 204], [8, 11, 199, 200], [9, 11, 198, 195], [10, 11, 198, 191], [11, 11, 190, 183], [12, 11, 203, 205], [13, 11, 199, 201], [14, 11, 198, 195], [15, 11, 198, 191], [16, 11, 188, 183], [17, 11, 203, 205], [18, 11, 198, 199], [19, 11, 198, 197], [20, 11, 198, 193], [21, 11, 189, 185], [22, 11, 202, 205], [24, 11, 197, 193], [25, 11, 197, 194], [26, 11, 189, 190], [27, 11, 199, 198], [7, 12, 204, 206], [8, 12, 199, 238], [9, 12, 198, 31], [10, 12, 199, 237], [11, 12, 190, 205], [12, 12, 204, 206], [13, 12, 199, 238], [14, 12, 198, 31], [15, 12, 198, 237], [16, 12, 190, 203], [17, 12, 203, 206], [18, 12, 198, 238], [19, 12, 198, 31], [20, 12, 198, 237], [21, 12, 189, 204], [22, 12, 203, 206], [23, 12, 199, 238], [24, 12, 198, 31], [25, 12, 197, 237], [26, 12, 190, 205], [7, 13, 207, 206], [8, 13, 202, 31], [9, 13, 202, 31], [10, 13, 202, 31], [11, 13, 193, 205], [12, 13, 207, 206], [13, 13, 202, 31], [14, 13, 201, 31], [15, 13, 201, 31], [16, 13, 194, 205], [17, 13, 207, 206], [18, 13, 202, 31], [19, 13, 201, 31], [20, 13, 201, 31], [21, 13, 195, 205], [22, 13, 207, 206], [23, 13, 201, 31], [24, 13, 201, 31], [25, 13, 201, 31], [26, 13, 193, 205], [7, 14, 206, 207], [8, 14, 200, 238], [9, 14, 199, 31], [10, 14, 199, 237], [11, 14, 192, 206], [12, 14, 206, 207], [13, 14, 199, 238], [14, 14, 199, 31], [15, 14, 198, 237], [16, 14, 192, 206], [17, 14, 205, 207], [18, 14, 200, 238], [19, 14, 199, 31], [20, 14, 198, 237], [21, 14, 193, 206], [22, 14, 204, 207], [23, 14, 200, 238], [24, 14, 198, 31], [25, 14, 198, 237], [26, 14, 191, 206], [6, 15, 207, 79], [7, 15, 206, 207], [8, 15, 202, 207], [9, 15, 201, 206], [10, 15, 201, 206], [11, 15, 193, 206], [12, 15, 206, 207], [13, 15, 201, 207], [14, 15, 199, 206], [15, 15, 198, 206], [16, 15, 192, 206], [17, 15, 205, 207], [18, 15, 201, 207], [19, 15, 200, 206], [20, 15, 198, 206], [21, 15, 193, 206], [22, 15, 203, 207], [23, 15, 200, 207], [24, 15, 200, 206], [25, 15, 198, 206], [26, 15, 191, 206], [6, 16, 79, 207], [7, 16, 206, 207], [8, 16, 206, 207], [9, 16, 205, 207], [10, 16, 204, 207], [11, 16, 195, 207], [12, 16, 207, 79], [13, 16, 205, 206], [14, 16, 204, 206], [16, 16, 196, 204], [17, 16, 207, 200], [18, 16, 204, 197], [19, 16, 204, 193], [20, 16, 204, 191], [21, 16, 196, 186], [22, 16, 207, 197], [23, 16, 205, 197], [24, 16, 205, 194], [25, 16, 203, 198], [5, 17, 207, 47], [6, 17, 207, 47], [8, 17, 207, 47], [9, 17, 207, 47], [10, 17, 207, 47], [12, 17, 79, 47], [13, 17, 47, 204], [14, 17, 47, 200], [15, 17, 207, 199], [16, 17, 207, 197], [17, 17, 207, 197], [18, 17, 206, 196], [19, 17, 206, 194], [20, 17, 206, 191], [21, 17, 205, 186], [22, 17, 207, 197], [23, 17, 206, 197], [24, 17, 204, 191], [25, 17, 205, 198], [26, 17, 195, 192], [9, 18, 47, 206], [10, 18, 47, 206], [11, 18, 206, 204], [13, 18, 205, 199], [14, 18, 206, 196], [15, 18, 206, 204], [16, 18, 206, 205], [17, 18, 47, 206], [18, 18, 205, 197], [19, 18, 205, 197], [20, 18, 204, 187], [21, 18, 205, 197], [22, 18, 205, 197], [23, 18, 205, 197], [24, 18, 202, 190], [5, 19, 206, 204], [6, 19, 201, 196], [8, 19, 206, 205], [9, 19, 206, 204], [10, 19, 205, 203], [11, 19, 204, 200], [12, 19, 206, 203], [13, 19, 204, 201], [14, 19, 205, 202], [15, 19, 205, 202], [16, 19, 205, 199], [17, 19, 47, 206], [18, 19, 47, 205], [19, 19, 206, 201], [20, 19, 205, 197], [21, 19, 205, 199], [22, 19, 205, 197], [23, 19, 205, 197]]}], \"all_phase_source_stationary_occupied_cells\": 341, \"independent_row_based_metrics_match_worker\": true, \"row_based_metrics\": [{\"asset\": \"30081\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 89, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 0, \"max_channel_difference\": 20}, {\"asset\": \"30082\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 124, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 0, \"max_channel_difference\": 28}, {\"asset\": \"30083\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 126, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 4, \"max_channel_difference\": 33}, {\"asset\": \"30084\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 128, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 3, \"max_channel_difference\": 33}], \"all_source_stationary_comparisons\": [{\"asset\": \"30081\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 133, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 341, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 624, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1364, \"opacity_changes\": [[6, 53, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1638, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 3069, \"opacity_changes\": [[9, 19, 29, 256], [9, 31, 30, 256], [9, 43, 30, 256], [9, 55, 30, 256], [86, 55, 256, 28], [9, 67, 30, 256], [86, 67, 256, 28], [13, 89, 0, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2885, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 5456, \"opacity_changes\": [[111, 10, 235, 256], [12, 25, 29, 256], [12, 26, 29, 256], [12, 41, 29, 256], [12, 42, 29, 256], [12, 57, 29, 256], [12, 58, 29, 256], [12, 73, 29, 256], [12, 74, 29, 256], [12, 89, 29, 256], [115, 89, 256, 28], [13, 107, 31, 256], [115, 105, 256, 30], [15, 109, 31, 256], [42, 112, 256, 239], [42, 113, 256, 239], [42, 114, 256, 239], [42, 115, 256, 239], [17, 118, 31, 256], [21, 122, 31, 256], [21, 123, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}]}, {\"asset\": \"30082\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 187, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 341, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 842, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1364, \"opacity_changes\": [[6, 53, 31, 256], [23, 53, 256, 30], [7, 54, 31, 256], [41, 55, 31, 256], [42, 58, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1962, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 3069, \"opacity_changes\": [[86, 9, 256, 237], [9, 79, 0, 256], [60, 79, 31, 256], [60, 80, 31, 256], [60, 81, 31, 256], [60, 82, 31, 256], [62, 83, 239, 256], [13, 89, 0, 256], [63, 87, 31, 256], [15, 91, 31, 256], [67, 92, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3485, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 5456, \"opacity_changes\": [[110, 8, 256, 237], [110, 9, 256, 237], [12, 25, 29, 256], [12, 26, 29, 256], [12, 41, 29, 256], [12, 42, 29, 256], [115, 40, 29, 256], [12, 73, 29, 256], [12, 90, 256, 29], [13, 107, 31, 256], [80, 105, 31, 256], [80, 106, 31, 256], [80, 107, 31, 256], [115, 105, 256, 30], [14, 108, 0, 256], [15, 109, 31, 256], [80, 108, 31, 256], [80, 109, 31, 256], [81, 110, 31, 256], [83, 111, 239, 256], [111, 110, 256, 30], [111, 111, 256, 30], [42, 112, 256, 239], [42, 113, 256, 30], [42, 114, 256, 31], [42, 115, 256, 31], [111, 112, 256, 30], [111, 113, 256, 30], [111, 114, 256, 30], [111, 115, 256, 31], [16, 117, 0, 256], [17, 118, 31, 256], [18, 119, 0, 256], [19, 119, 0, 256], [39, 119, 239, 256], [84, 116, 0, 256], [85, 117, 31, 256], [86, 119, 30, 256], [87, 119, 31, 256], [107, 119, 30, 256], [21, 122, 31, 256], [21, 123, 31, 256], [88, 121, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}]}, {\"asset\": \"30083\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 191, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 341, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 20, 33.0, [117.0, 69.0, 56.0], [150.0, 101.0, 85.0]], [15, 22, 32.0, [93.0, 48.0, 40.0], [125.0, 77.0, 65.0]], [16, 22, 32.0, [93.0, 48.0, 40.0], [125.0, 77.0, 65.0]], [9, 23, 33.0, [48.0, 32.0, 28.0], [81.0, 36.0, 32.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 789, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1364, \"opacity_changes\": [[6, 53, 31, 256], [7, 54, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[15, 21, 36.5, [44.5, 22.0, 19.0], [8.0, 6.0, 5.0]], [16, 21, 40.5, [46.5, 24.0, 20.0], [6.0, 4.0, 3.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 2}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1792, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 3069, \"opacity_changes\": [[86, 19, 256, 28], [86, 31, 256, 28], [86, 44, 29, 256], [86, 55, 256, 29], [86, 56, 29, 256], [86, 67, 256, 28], [35, 78, 30, 256], [86, 79, 256, 30], [32, 83, 239, 256], [60, 82, 31, 256], [62, 83, 239, 256], [83, 86, 239, 256], [13, 89, 0, 256], [29, 89, 239, 256], [80, 89, 31, 256], [15, 91, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[15, 21, 36.3333, [39.888888888888886, 23.88888888888889, 19.666666666666668], [3.5555555555555554, 3.5555555555555554, 3.5555555555555554]], [16, 21, 39.2222, [43.22222222222222, 27.88888888888889, 23.0], [4.0, 3.111111111111111, 2.6666666666666665]], [15, 22, 34.4444, [98.11111111111111, 66.44444444444444, 56.22222222222222], [132.55555555555554, 85.44444444444444, 71.44444444444444]], [16, 22, 32.1111, [100.55555555555556, 65.55555555555556, 55.22222222222222], [132.66666666666666, 85.44444444444444, 71.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3169, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 5456, \"opacity_changes\": [[24, 4, 238, 256], [25, 4, 237, 256], [26, 4, 237, 256], [27, 4, 237, 256], [111, 10, 235, 256], [115, 25, 256, 28], [115, 41, 256, 28], [115, 43, 29, 256], [115, 59, 30, 256], [115, 73, 256, 29], [115, 75, 30, 256], [115, 89, 256, 29], [13, 107, 31, 256], [47, 104, 31, 256], [115, 105, 256, 31], [81, 110, 31, 256], [83, 111, 239, 256], [16, 117, 0, 256], [18, 119, 0, 256], [38, 119, 239, 256], [39, 119, 239, 256], [85, 117, 31, 256], [86, 119, 30, 256], [87, 119, 31, 256], [107, 119, 30, 256], [21, 122, 31, 256], [21, 123, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[15, 21, 38.25, [40.25, 26.5, 21.75], [2.0, 2.0, 2.0]], [16, 21, 39.75, [41.75, 28.5, 24.0], [2.0, 2.0, 2.0]], [15, 22, 35.5625, [98.25, 62.25, 51.6875], [133.8125, 86.75, 71.125]], [16, 22, 36.3125, [99.5, 64.6875, 53.25], [135.8125, 88.5, 72.9375]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}]}, {\"asset\": \"30084\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 203, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 341, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 20, 33.0, [117.0, 69.0, 56.0], [150.0, 101.0, 85.0]], [15, 22, 32.0, [93.0, 48.0, 40.0], [125.0, 77.0, 65.0]], [16, 22, 32.0, [93.0, 48.0, 40.0], [125.0, 77.0, 65.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 907, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1364, \"opacity_changes\": [[57, 53, 256, 31]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 18, 32.5, [61.5, 27.0, 23.0], [94.0, 49.25, 42.25]], [15, 21, 36.5, [44.5, 22.0, 19.0], [8.0, 6.0, 5.0]], [16, 21, 42.5, [46.5, 24.0, 20.0], [4.0, 4.0, 4.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2077, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 3069, \"opacity_changes\": [[18, 3, 238, 256], [19, 3, 206, 256], [20, 3, 204, 256], [86, 19, 256, 30], [86, 31, 256, 31], [86, 43, 256, 0], [86, 55, 256, 0], [86, 67, 256, 0], [9, 80, 256, 0], [86, 79, 256, 0], [86, 80, 256, 30], [9, 81, 256, 31], [10, 81, 256, 31], [11, 82, 256, 31], [11, 83, 256, 31], [32, 83, 239, 256], [60, 82, 31, 256], [12, 88, 256, 0], [29, 89, 239, 256], [67, 92, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 18, 32.5556, [58.111111111111114, 24.88888888888889, 21.333333333333332], [90.66666666666667, 46.0, 39.666666666666664]], [15, 21, 37.2222, [39.888888888888886, 23.88888888888889, 19.666666666666668], [2.6666666666666665, 2.6666666666666665, 2.6666666666666665]], [16, 21, 41.0, [43.22222222222222, 27.88888888888889, 23.0], [2.2222222222222223, 2.2222222222222223, 2.2222222222222223]], [15, 22, 37.7778, [98.11111111111111, 66.44444444444444, 56.22222222222222], [135.88888888888889, 88.55555555555556, 73.55555555555556]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3747, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 5456, \"opacity_changes\": [[24, 4, 238, 256], [25, 4, 237, 256], [26, 4, 237, 256], [27, 4, 237, 256], [110, 9, 256, 27], [111, 10, 235, 256], [115, 25, 256, 30], [115, 26, 256, 30], [115, 41, 256, 31], [115, 42, 256, 31], [115, 57, 256, 0], [115, 58, 256, 0], [115, 73, 256, 0], [115, 74, 256, 0], [12, 90, 256, 0], [115, 89, 256, 0], [115, 90, 256, 0], [12, 106, 256, 0], [12, 107, 256, 0], [115, 105, 256, 0], [115, 106, 256, 0], [114, 107, 256, 0], [12, 108, 256, 0], [13, 108, 256, 0], [15, 110, 256, 0], [15, 111, 256, 0], [42, 111, 239, 256], [81, 110, 31, 256], [111, 110, 256, 239], [111, 111, 256, 239], [111, 112, 256, 239], [111, 113, 256, 239], [111, 114, 256, 30], [111, 115, 256, 30], [38, 119, 239, 256], [39, 119, 239, 256], [86, 119, 30, 256], [35, 123, 0, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[15, 21, 38.25, [40.25, 26.5, 21.75], [2.0, 2.0, 2.0]], [16, 21, 39.75, [41.75, 28.5, 24.0], [2.0, 2.0, 2.0]], [15, 22, 34.8125, [98.25, 62.25, 51.6875], [133.0625, 86.75, 71.0625]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}]}]} [\"Isolated actual Catalog/HdAssets source-bound sprite raster and artistic approval only. No new Host enemy occurrence, animation timing, terrain blend, gameplay, simulation-neutrality or fullscreen capture.\", \"Broader game-source freshness flag is true due to unrelated menu/game edits; relevant assets/hd loader source is current.\", \"Complete shared family scale, origin and all rawalpha>=16/>=32 crop retention independently verified. Palette classes, forced indices and all240\\u2013255counts pass; these numeric checks do not substitute for the completed artistic review.\", \"Original/source and newly authored stationary body shading are not byte identical; localized variations and native/2\\u00d7 contour smoothing are deliberately disclosed.\", \"Global registration and bundled pack snapshot remain coordinator-owned; no source/candidate/raw/global/Git edits by reviewer.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/independent-review.json, SHA256 f6c62881aa1b2c8f035cd588b6d4e11b8b543af4a03a6a56616613afe6be7839", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/inputs/enemies-30080-30084/runtime-review/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "68bdf75fcfc9e36e5803e81af307e91c46a72ab88666febfe1291401e8a7cedc" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "26ce2f190978e8c78b69c05c2c1e50e4c0faa6716b81f5c0da237c01e576ac6d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "30080", + "30081", + "30082", + "30083" + ], + "sha256": "87a471ee7483c597619bcafa1a41f41f84681e3942a30262e568a743a977eeb1", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30084" + ], + "sha256": "cdd16f1f605cfe46e24c3bbcffb4ff43587a552b9e8cf13271897e273e17af71", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "30080-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fd536ad9aac9e344e6fe4331f433898abbb167c69ffa94aec9806ad694368e28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30080-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "079b87081e39873b5be9faffe14dce4d027bf00ef7cfc8fd9cdd93c3cedeee01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30080-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b22cd16a11c9ea3efb035b80bc7b3dc3447f8ae7a24d621e9f7185cfe139b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30080-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3026bb9ff8b4f4f313ca7fef0f19a6fdc94edf6f79eb64ca0746332484079269", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30080-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3e1e6ae5ef3819f4bc82778766e1195e67b334749eb22b0b950a353cb7680d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bc6d145991040b69c3b1c20ad055094df2fe9360b28e57a1def1b4f3576ad52", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1ed74c04f89cbfe0fa1c2ed506fa99036eeca0707bad34e212e280dec92c9501", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d959fbbda4ef1bb1a3e75799357d61aa00d11a23d42d917f773e2a10efd9d445", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e678bac84f7983a2834d980ba471739612290201c967ed3f845f3eb7d0971168", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e6f1cc73de3209d87af4b3130d44b011218627d4296eb259290a276b92002f5b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cb1c7a13bdc40f1eccf2e2a3fcba9ff79eaa51a142b5e4b7d6515a7b3a791f4d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "25cea435d141ec8d9a453ad33bf3a9397c5ba4b57a5329921e7de79d3e176d1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "746b84803b2db47a4fae7952ec8cda086a5e9c49e889fd0cc03837baef8e7b03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fad8a48e3b868a0203a5cbc218c707937c0ee7a5ab6694adcce600b04fd8c6f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ace88f16d8d9b49fb9ac34e04137466bb67e8d9e1b160143ad1d305a509f6c86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "32ebaab7e521884d8354069450aa20094c4ca483a59c7c21b898bacf4fe92338", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b25da63039cb7ddece4861d2a226a120f6d340b6677c68ded58ad6a246c212fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "86b26559707c319eb729080b46de9880aa6555d0f8effe44fcd5cce2de1abe77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "28e6c46d40117ab5632eb95e8cf342e8f566f4a881dabc787cd0dda1b48521fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3a5d7a92757bdc7b81278a3f38a27823432b2bdb3cd2e12be800560a3bc46a06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7e56ddacfb74d930186bafe4a0ad431a07ef43e6a2ef94c50c9de12b406394df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "674eae95c1902c100ac9366782d1e930b06068b501ae38088b89bbca6c23e90f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "080847674391cb7141f23910600c4cd61659d4727766afd1e2e8745c724a59d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc9b5f686a39f45aa4f001ad675b64d547f6e866866052466436a6c4c0fa2739", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d017c6f503fa8a58ccb5a52c0dc76c79f71436e906b88d0bc5ed234867738eec", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30081": { @@ -240424,7 +244752,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30081", "family_id": "enemies-30080-30084", "job_id": "enemies-30080-30084", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -240436,6 +244764,176 @@ "manifest": "jobs/enemies-30080-30084/candidate.json", "sha256": "1ace4e117a41b4a2790441b94331eb05bc7d66eb711100a0db325d068726758e", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1ace4e117a41b4a2790441b94331eb05bc7d66eb711100a0db325d068726758e", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "7ef5d4f694e62bab8fa8fd3254ccc6cfd56ca21f4f030a9db231b5e1d7d340df", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:31.125025+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/enemies-30080-30084/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"Four copper slats preserve original five-stage horizontal highlight/recess progression; outer gray tread/bar positions and lower split legs/aperture remain aligned. Fine bronze grain and pale bevels are slightly brighter than the source. Dark source bands become opaque recessed faces, not transparent holes.\", \"Native1 loses only source black contour cell(3,27) in all five frames;2\\u00d7 also loses it only30082/30083. Every source cell survives3\\u20134. Stationary lower rows20\\u201330 retain architecture with89/124/126/128 changed native shades,0/0/4/3 >=32-channel delta.\"] {\"source_phase_differences\": [{\"asset\": \"30080\", \"changed_cells\": 0, \"changed_rows\": {}, \"changes\": []}, {\"asset\": \"30081\", \"changed_cells\": 207, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 13, \"2\": 11, \"3\": 8, \"4\": 7, \"5\": 8, \"6\": 7, \"7\": 10, \"8\": 10, \"9\": 10, \"10\": 13, \"11\": 14, \"12\": 17, \"13\": 12, \"14\": 11, \"15\": 14, \"16\": 15, \"17\": 13, \"18\": 6, \"19\": 8}, \"changes\": [[9, 1, 186, 187], [10, 1, 183, 185], [11, 1, 181, 179], [14, 1, 186, 187], [15, 1, 183, 185], [18, 1, 187, 188], [19, 1, 184, 186], [20, 1, 179, 185], [21, 1, 180, 181], [23, 1, 187, 188], [24, 1, 183, 187], [25, 1, 179, 187], [26, 1, 180, 183], [9, 2, 195, 194], [11, 2, 186, 183], [13, 2, 197, 196], [15, 2, 192, 194], [18, 2, 196, 197], [19, 2, 193, 195], [21, 2, 184, 185], [23, 2, 196, 197], [24, 2, 194, 195], [25, 2, 190, 193], [26, 2, 181, 186], [8, 3, 197, 196], [9, 3, 197, 194], [10, 3, 194, 193], [11, 3, 187, 184], [19, 3, 195, 197], [21, 3, 183, 184], [24, 3, 195, 196], [26, 3, 183, 186], [9, 4, 197, 196], [10, 4, 195, 194], [14, 4, 197, 196], [19, 4, 196, 197], [21, 4, 185, 186], [24, 4, 196, 197], [26, 4, 185, 187], [9, 5, 197, 196], [10, 5, 197, 194], [11, 5, 188, 187], [14, 5, 197, 196], [16, 5, 187, 186], [21, 5, 186, 187], [25, 5, 194, 196], [27, 5, 199, 200], [10, 6, 197, 196], [11, 6, 188, 187], [13, 6, 198, 197], [14, 6, 197, 196], [16, 6, 188, 187], [20, 6, 196, 195], [26, 6, 186, 187], [8, 7, 197, 198], [10, 7, 197, 196], [11, 7, 188, 186], [12, 7, 203, 202], [13, 7, 198, 197], [15, 7, 196, 195], [17, 7, 203, 202], [20, 7, 197, 195], [22, 7, 202, 203], [25, 7, 197, 196], [8, 8, 198, 197], [9, 8, 197, 198], [11, 8, 188, 187], [12, 8, 203, 202], [13, 8, 198, 197], [14, 8, 198, 197], [15, 8, 197, 195], [17, 8, 203, 202], [20, 8, 197, 195], [22, 8, 202, 204], [8, 9, 198, 197], [9, 9, 198, 197], [12, 9, 203, 202], [15, 9, 198, 195], [18, 9, 198, 197], [20, 9, 197, 196], [21, 9, 189, 188], [22, 9, 202, 204], [24, 9, 199, 197], [26, 9, 189, 188], [7, 10, 204, 205], [9, 10, 198, 197], [11, 10, 189, 188], [12, 10, 203, 202], [14, 10, 199, 197], [15, 10, 198, 196], [18, 10, 198, 197], [19, 10, 198, 197], [21, 10, 189, 188], [22, 10, 202, 204], [23, 10, 198, 197], [24, 10, 199, 197], [26, 10, 189, 188], [8, 11, 199, 197], [9, 11, 198, 197], [11, 11, 190, 188], [12, 11, 203, 204], [14, 11, 198, 197], [15, 11, 198, 197], [17, 11, 203, 204], [18, 11, 198, 197], [19, 11, 198, 197], [20, 11, 198, 197], [21, 11, 189, 188], [22, 11, 202, 204], [23, 11, 199, 197], [26, 11, 189, 188], [7, 12, 204, 205], [8, 12, 199, 198], [9, 12, 198, 197], [10, 12, 199, 198], [11, 12, 190, 189], [12, 12, 204, 205], [13, 12, 199, 198], [15, 12, 198, 197], [16, 12, 190, 188], [17, 12, 203, 205], [19, 12, 198, 197], [20, 12, 198, 197], [21, 12, 189, 188], [22, 12, 203, 205], [23, 12, 199, 197], [24, 12, 198, 197], [26, 12, 190, 188], [8, 13, 202, 201], [9, 13, 202, 201], [10, 13, 202, 201], [13, 13, 202, 201], [14, 13, 201, 202], [15, 13, 201, 200], [16, 13, 194, 191], [20, 13, 201, 200], [21, 13, 195, 192], [23, 13, 201, 202], [25, 13, 201, 200], [26, 13, 193, 191], [8, 14, 200, 198], [9, 14, 199, 198], [10, 14, 199, 198], [11, 14, 192, 190], [14, 14, 199, 200], [16, 14, 192, 188], [18, 14, 200, 198], [21, 14, 193, 189], [22, 14, 204, 205], [25, 14, 198, 197], [26, 14, 191, 188], [6, 15, 207, 79], [8, 15, 202, 200], [9, 15, 201, 199], [10, 15, 201, 198], [11, 15, 193, 190], [13, 15, 201, 199], [14, 15, 199, 200], [16, 15, 192, 188], [18, 15, 201, 200], [19, 15, 200, 199], [21, 15, 193, 189], [22, 15, 203, 205], [24, 15, 200, 199], [26, 15, 191, 188], [6, 16, 79, 207], [8, 16, 206, 204], [9, 16, 205, 204], [10, 16, 204, 203], [11, 16, 195, 193], [13, 16, 205, 203], [14, 16, 204, 203], [16, 16, 196, 191], [17, 16, 207, 206], [18, 16, 204, 203], [19, 16, 204, 203], [21, 16, 196, 192], [23, 16, 205, 204], [24, 16, 205, 203], [26, 16, 197, 195], [5, 17, 207, 47], [6, 17, 207, 47], [12, 17, 79, 207], [13, 17, 47, 207], [14, 17, 47, 207], [18, 17, 206, 207], [19, 17, 206, 207], [20, 17, 206, 207], [21, 17, 205, 207], [23, 17, 206, 207], [24, 17, 204, 207], [25, 17, 205, 207], [26, 17, 195, 207], [11, 18, 206, 47], [14, 18, 206, 204], [15, 18, 206, 47], [16, 18, 206, 47], [20, 18, 204, 200], [24, 18, 202, 197], [12, 19, 206, 205], [16, 19, 205, 203], [18, 19, 47, 206], [19, 19, 206, 204], [20, 19, 205, 202], [21, 19, 205, 203], [22, 19, 205, 202], [23, 19, 205, 197]]}, {\"asset\": \"30082\", \"changed_cells\": 299, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 20, \"2\": 17, \"3\": 14, \"4\": 14, \"5\": 11, \"6\": 13, \"7\": 12, \"8\": 13, \"9\": 14, \"10\": 14, \"11\": 19, \"12\": 15, \"13\": 20, \"14\": 19, \"15\": 20, \"16\": 18, \"17\": 19, \"18\": 9, \"19\": 18}, \"changes\": [[7, 1, 195, 200], [8, 1, 188, 189], [9, 1, 186, 189], [10, 1, 183, 188], [11, 1, 181, 184], [12, 1, 195, 198], [13, 1, 188, 190], [14, 1, 186, 187], [15, 1, 183, 189], [16, 1, 181, 183], [17, 1, 195, 198], [18, 1, 187, 189], [19, 1, 184, 189], [20, 1, 179, 189], [21, 1, 180, 184], [22, 1, 195, 197], [23, 1, 187, 190], [24, 1, 183, 187], [25, 1, 179, 187], [26, 1, 180, 183], [7, 2, 202, 205], [8, 2, 196, 197], [9, 2, 195, 197], [10, 2, 193, 195], [11, 2, 186, 187], [12, 2, 202, 204], [13, 2, 197, 198], [15, 2, 192, 196], [17, 2, 202, 204], [18, 2, 196, 197], [19, 2, 193, 196], [20, 2, 193, 196], [21, 2, 184, 188], [23, 2, 196, 199], [24, 2, 194, 195], [25, 2, 190, 194], [26, 2, 181, 187], [7, 3, 202, 205], [9, 3, 197, 196], [11, 3, 187, 185], [12, 3, 202, 204], [13, 3, 197, 198], [14, 3, 196, 194], [15, 3, 194, 196], [16, 3, 186, 182], [17, 3, 202, 203], [21, 3, 183, 188], [22, 3, 202, 199], [23, 3, 197, 198], [24, 3, 195, 197], [25, 3, 194, 195], [7, 4, 202, 204], [9, 4, 197, 195], [10, 4, 195, 193], [11, 4, 186, 182], [12, 4, 202, 204], [13, 4, 197, 198], [14, 4, 197, 195], [15, 4, 195, 196], [16, 4, 186, 182], [21, 4, 185, 187], [22, 4, 202, 201], [24, 4, 196, 197], [25, 4, 195, 196], [26, 4, 185, 182], [7, 5, 202, 204], [9, 5, 197, 196], [10, 5, 197, 193], [11, 5, 188, 181], [12, 5, 202, 203], [16, 5, 187, 181], [20, 5, 195, 194], [22, 5, 202, 201], [25, 5, 194, 196], [26, 5, 187, 181], [27, 5, 199, 200], [7, 6, 202, 204], [9, 6, 197, 196], [10, 6, 197, 194], [11, 6, 188, 183], [12, 6, 202, 203], [13, 6, 198, 199], [15, 6, 196, 194], [16, 6, 188, 180], [20, 6, 196, 194], [21, 6, 187, 184], [22, 6, 202, 201], [25, 6, 196, 197], [26, 6, 186, 181], [7, 7, 202, 203], [9, 7, 197, 196], [10, 7, 197, 194], [11, 7, 188, 186], [12, 7, 203, 202], [15, 7, 196, 195], [16, 7, 188, 182], [20, 7, 197, 194], [21, 7, 188, 185], [22, 7, 202, 200], [25, 7, 197, 196], [26, 7, 187, 184], [8, 8, 198, 197], [9, 8, 197, 196], [10, 8, 197, 194], [13, 8, 198, 197], [14, 8, 198, 197], [15, 8, 197, 195], [16, 8, 188, 185], [17, 8, 203, 204], [20, 8, 197, 195], [21, 8, 188, 186], [22, 8, 202, 200], [25, 8, 197, 196], [26, 8, 188, 185], [7, 9, 203, 205], [8, 9, 198, 197], [9, 9, 198, 197], [10, 9, 198, 195], [12, 9, 203, 204], [13, 9, 198, 197], [15, 9, 198, 196], [16, 9, 188, 184], [17, 9, 203, 205], [18, 9, 198, 197], [20, 9, 197, 195], [21, 9, 189, 188], [24, 9, 199, 197], [26, 9, 189, 185], [7, 10, 204, 205], [9, 10, 198, 197], [10, 10, 198, 196], [11, 10, 189, 188], [14, 10, 199, 197], [15, 10, 198, 197], [16, 10, 188, 186], [17, 10, 203, 205], [19, 10, 198, 197], [20, 10, 197, 196], [21, 10, 189, 187], [22, 10, 202, 203], [24, 10, 199, 197], [26, 10, 189, 186], [7, 11, 205, 207], [8, 11, 199, 202], [9, 11, 198, 200], [10, 11, 198, 199], [11, 11, 190, 191], [12, 11, 203, 206], [13, 11, 199, 201], [14, 11, 198, 200], [15, 11, 198, 200], [16, 11, 188, 190], [17, 11, 203, 207], [18, 11, 198, 202], [19, 11, 198, 200], [20, 11, 198, 199], [21, 11, 189, 190], [22, 11, 202, 207], [23, 11, 199, 201], [24, 11, 197, 200], [25, 11, 197, 200], [9, 12, 198, 197], [10, 12, 199, 196], [11, 12, 190, 188], [12, 12, 204, 203], [14, 12, 198, 197], [15, 12, 198, 197], [16, 12, 190, 188], [17, 12, 203, 204], [18, 12, 198, 199], [19, 12, 198, 197], [20, 12, 198, 196], [21, 12, 189, 187], [22, 12, 203, 204], [24, 12, 198, 197], [26, 12, 190, 187], [7, 13, 207, 205], [8, 13, 202, 199], [9, 13, 202, 199], [10, 13, 202, 196], [11, 13, 193, 187], [12, 13, 207, 203], [13, 13, 202, 199], [14, 13, 201, 198], [15, 13, 201, 197], [16, 13, 194, 188], [17, 13, 207, 204], [18, 13, 202, 200], [19, 13, 201, 198], [20, 13, 201, 197], [21, 13, 195, 187], [22, 13, 207, 203], [23, 13, 201, 200], [24, 13, 201, 197], [25, 13, 201, 197], [26, 13, 193, 188], [6, 14, 207, 79], [8, 14, 200, 203], [9, 14, 199, 204], [10, 14, 199, 202], [11, 14, 192, 191], [13, 14, 199, 202], [14, 14, 199, 203], [15, 14, 198, 203], [16, 14, 192, 191], [17, 14, 205, 206], [18, 14, 200, 203], [19, 14, 199, 203], [20, 14, 198, 202], [21, 14, 193, 191], [22, 14, 204, 206], [23, 14, 200, 204], [24, 14, 198, 203], [25, 14, 198, 202], [26, 14, 191, 195], [7, 15, 206, 207], [8, 15, 202, 239], [9, 15, 201, 31], [10, 15, 201, 239], [11, 15, 193, 207], [12, 15, 206, 207], [13, 15, 201, 239], [14, 15, 199, 31], [15, 15, 198, 239], [16, 15, 192, 207], [17, 15, 205, 207], [18, 15, 201, 239], [19, 15, 200, 31], [20, 15, 198, 239], [21, 15, 193, 207], [22, 15, 203, 207], [23, 15, 200, 239], [24, 15, 200, 31], [25, 15, 198, 239], [26, 15, 191, 207], [6, 16, 79, 207], [7, 16, 206, 207], [8, 16, 206, 239], [9, 16, 205, 31], [10, 16, 204, 239], [11, 16, 195, 207], [13, 16, 205, 239], [14, 16, 204, 31], [15, 16, 204, 239], [16, 16, 196, 207], [18, 16, 204, 239], [19, 16, 204, 31], [20, 16, 204, 239], [21, 16, 196, 207], [23, 16, 205, 239], [24, 16, 205, 31], [25, 16, 203, 239], [26, 16, 197, 207], [5, 17, 207, 47], [6, 17, 207, 47], [8, 17, 207, 47], [9, 17, 207, 47], [10, 17, 207, 47], [12, 17, 79, 47], [14, 17, 47, 206], [15, 17, 207, 205], [16, 17, 207, 205], [17, 17, 207, 205], [18, 17, 206, 204], [19, 17, 206, 204], [20, 17, 206, 197], [21, 17, 205, 193], [22, 17, 207, 202], [23, 17, 206, 202], [24, 17, 204, 191], [25, 17, 205, 198], [26, 17, 195, 192], [13, 18, 205, 203], [14, 18, 206, 201], [18, 18, 205, 202], [19, 18, 205, 202], [20, 18, 204, 194], [21, 18, 205, 202], [22, 18, 205, 202], [23, 18, 205, 197], [24, 18, 202, 190], [5, 19, 206, 204], [6, 19, 201, 196], [8, 19, 206, 205], [9, 19, 206, 204], [10, 19, 205, 203], [11, 19, 204, 200], [12, 19, 206, 203], [13, 19, 204, 201], [14, 19, 205, 202], [15, 19, 205, 202], [16, 19, 205, 199], [17, 19, 47, 206], [18, 19, 47, 205], [19, 19, 206, 201], [20, 19, 205, 197], [21, 19, 205, 199], [22, 19, 205, 197], [23, 19, 205, 197]]}, {\"asset\": \"30083\", \"changed_cells\": 335, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 20, \"2\": 19, \"3\": 17, \"4\": 15, \"5\": 13, \"6\": 13, \"7\": 18, \"8\": 19, \"9\": 19, \"10\": 18, \"11\": 17, \"12\": 19, \"13\": 19, \"14\": 19, \"15\": 21, \"16\": 19, \"17\": 20, \"18\": 12, \"19\": 18}, \"changes\": [[7, 1, 195, 203], [8, 1, 188, 190], [9, 1, 186, 190], [10, 1, 183, 188], [11, 1, 181, 185], [12, 1, 195, 202], [13, 1, 188, 190], [14, 1, 186, 190], [15, 1, 183, 190], [16, 1, 181, 185], [17, 1, 195, 203], [18, 1, 187, 191], [19, 1, 184, 190], [20, 1, 179, 190], [21, 1, 180, 185], [22, 1, 195, 201], [23, 1, 187, 192], [24, 1, 183, 190], [25, 1, 179, 190], [26, 1, 180, 185], [7, 2, 202, 206], [8, 2, 196, 197], [9, 2, 195, 197], [10, 2, 193, 195], [11, 2, 186, 188], [12, 2, 202, 205], [14, 2, 194, 196], [15, 2, 192, 197], [16, 2, 185, 188], [17, 2, 202, 205], [18, 2, 196, 197], [19, 2, 193, 197], [20, 2, 193, 197], [21, 2, 184, 188], [22, 2, 202, 205], [23, 2, 196, 199], [24, 2, 194, 197], [25, 2, 190, 197], [26, 2, 181, 187], [7, 3, 202, 206], [8, 3, 197, 196], [10, 3, 194, 196], [11, 3, 187, 186], [12, 3, 202, 205], [14, 3, 196, 195], [15, 3, 194, 197], [16, 3, 186, 187], [17, 3, 202, 205], [19, 3, 195, 197], [20, 3, 194, 196], [21, 3, 183, 189], [22, 3, 202, 205], [23, 3, 197, 199], [24, 3, 195, 197], [25, 3, 194, 197], [26, 3, 183, 187], [7, 4, 202, 206], [10, 4, 195, 196], [11, 4, 186, 184], [12, 4, 202, 204], [14, 4, 197, 196], [15, 4, 195, 197], [16, 4, 186, 185], [17, 4, 202, 205], [19, 4, 196, 197], [20, 4, 194, 195], [21, 4, 185, 189], [22, 4, 202, 205], [23, 4, 197, 198], [25, 4, 195, 196], [26, 4, 185, 187], [7, 5, 202, 206], [10, 5, 197, 194], [11, 5, 188, 185], [12, 5, 202, 203], [14, 5, 197, 195], [16, 5, 187, 184], [17, 5, 202, 205], [21, 5, 186, 187], [22, 5, 202, 203], [23, 5, 197, 198], [25, 5, 194, 196], [26, 5, 187, 188], [27, 5, 199, 200], [7, 6, 202, 205], [10, 6, 197, 194], [11, 6, 188, 183], [13, 6, 198, 197], [14, 6, 197, 196], [15, 6, 196, 195], [16, 6, 188, 185], [17, 6, 202, 203], [20, 6, 196, 195], [21, 6, 187, 184], [22, 6, 202, 203], [23, 6, 197, 198], [25, 6, 196, 195], [7, 7, 202, 203], [9, 7, 197, 196], [10, 7, 197, 193], [11, 7, 188, 180], [12, 7, 203, 202], [13, 7, 198, 197], [14, 7, 197, 196], [15, 7, 196, 194], [16, 7, 188, 181], [17, 7, 203, 202], [19, 7, 197, 196], [20, 7, 197, 193], [21, 7, 188, 184], [22, 7, 202, 203], [23, 7, 197, 198], [24, 7, 197, 196], [25, 7, 197, 195], [26, 7, 187, 183], [7, 8, 203, 202], [8, 8, 198, 197], [9, 8, 197, 196], [10, 8, 197, 194], [11, 8, 188, 180], [12, 8, 203, 200], [13, 8, 198, 197], [14, 8, 198, 196], [15, 8, 197, 194], [16, 8, 188, 182], [17, 8, 203, 202], [19, 8, 197, 195], [20, 8, 197, 193], [21, 8, 188, 183], [22, 8, 202, 203], [23, 8, 197, 198], [24, 8, 197, 195], [25, 8, 197, 196], [26, 8, 188, 183], [7, 9, 203, 206], [8, 9, 198, 200], [9, 9, 198, 199], [10, 9, 198, 196], [11, 9, 188, 185], [12, 9, 203, 204], [13, 9, 198, 200], [14, 9, 197, 199], [15, 9, 198, 197], [16, 9, 188, 184], [17, 9, 203, 206], [18, 9, 198, 200], [19, 9, 197, 198], [21, 9, 189, 186], [22, 9, 202, 206], [23, 9, 197, 200], [24, 9, 199, 198], [25, 9, 197, 198], [26, 9, 189, 184], [8, 10, 198, 197], [9, 10, 198, 196], [10, 10, 198, 195], [11, 10, 189, 185], [13, 10, 198, 197], [14, 10, 199, 196], [15, 10, 198, 195], [16, 10, 188, 184], [17, 10, 203, 204], [18, 10, 198, 197], [19, 10, 198, 196], [20, 10, 197, 195], [21, 10, 189, 188], [22, 10, 202, 204], [23, 10, 198, 197], [24, 10, 199, 195], [25, 10, 197, 196], [26, 10, 189, 182], [7, 11, 205, 204], [8, 11, 199, 198], [9, 11, 198, 196], [10, 11, 198, 196], [11, 11, 190, 186], [12, 11, 203, 204], [13, 11, 199, 197], [14, 11, 198, 197], [15, 11, 198, 196], [17, 11, 203, 204], [19, 11, 198, 197], [20, 11, 198, 196], [21, 11, 189, 187], [22, 11, 202, 204], [23, 11, 199, 197], [24, 11, 197, 196], [26, 11, 189, 184], [7, 12, 204, 206], [8, 12, 199, 203], [9, 12, 198, 200], [10, 12, 199, 202], [12, 12, 204, 207], [13, 12, 199, 204], [14, 12, 198, 202], [15, 12, 198, 202], [16, 12, 190, 191], [17, 12, 203, 206], [18, 12, 198, 203], [19, 12, 198, 202], [20, 12, 198, 202], [21, 12, 189, 190], [22, 12, 203, 207], [23, 12, 199, 204], [24, 12, 198, 202], [25, 12, 197, 202], [26, 12, 190, 195], [8, 13, 202, 239], [9, 13, 202, 31], [10, 13, 202, 238], [11, 13, 193, 207], [12, 13, 207, 206], [13, 13, 202, 239], [14, 13, 201, 31], [15, 13, 201, 238], [16, 13, 194, 207], [17, 13, 207, 206], [18, 13, 202, 239], [19, 13, 201, 31], [20, 13, 201, 238], [21, 13, 195, 207], [22, 13, 207, 206], [23, 13, 201, 239], [24, 13, 201, 31], [25, 13, 201, 238], [26, 13, 193, 205], [7, 14, 206, 207], [8, 14, 200, 31], [9, 14, 199, 31], [10, 14, 199, 31], [11, 14, 192, 207], [13, 14, 199, 31], [14, 14, 199, 31], [15, 14, 198, 31], [16, 14, 192, 207], [17, 14, 205, 206], [18, 14, 200, 31], [19, 14, 199, 31], [20, 14, 198, 31], [21, 14, 193, 207], [22, 14, 204, 206], [23, 14, 200, 31], [24, 14, 198, 31], [25, 14, 198, 31], [26, 14, 191, 206], [6, 15, 207, 79], [7, 15, 206, 207], [8, 15, 202, 239], [9, 15, 201, 31], [10, 15, 201, 239], [11, 15, 193, 207], [12, 15, 206, 207], [13, 15, 201, 239], [14, 15, 199, 31], [15, 15, 198, 239], [16, 15, 192, 207], [17, 15, 205, 207], [18, 15, 201, 239], [19, 15, 200, 31], [20, 15, 198, 239], [21, 15, 193, 207], [22, 15, 203, 207], [23, 15, 200, 239], [24, 15, 200, 31], [25, 15, 198, 239], [26, 15, 191, 206], [6, 16, 79, 207], [7, 16, 206, 207], [8, 16, 206, 207], [9, 16, 205, 207], [10, 16, 204, 207], [11, 16, 195, 207], [12, 16, 207, 79], [13, 16, 205, 206], [14, 16, 204, 206], [16, 16, 196, 204], [17, 16, 207, 200], [18, 16, 204, 197], [19, 16, 204, 193], [20, 16, 204, 191], [21, 16, 196, 186], [22, 16, 207, 197], [23, 16, 205, 197], [24, 16, 205, 194], [25, 16, 203, 198], [5, 17, 207, 47], [6, 17, 207, 47], [8, 17, 207, 47], [9, 17, 207, 47], [10, 17, 207, 47], [12, 17, 79, 47], [13, 17, 47, 206], [14, 17, 47, 204], [15, 17, 207, 203], [16, 17, 207, 202], [17, 17, 207, 202], [18, 17, 206, 196], [19, 17, 206, 194], [20, 17, 206, 191], [21, 17, 205, 186], [22, 17, 207, 197], [23, 17, 206, 197], [24, 17, 204, 191], [25, 17, 205, 198], [26, 17, 195, 192], [13, 18, 205, 203], [14, 18, 206, 201], [15, 18, 206, 204], [16, 18, 206, 205], [17, 18, 47, 206], [18, 18, 205, 197], [19, 18, 205, 197], [20, 18, 204, 187], [21, 18, 205, 197], [22, 18, 205, 197], [23, 18, 205, 197], [24, 18, 202, 190], [5, 19, 206, 204], [6, 19, 201, 196], [8, 19, 206, 205], [9, 19, 206, 204], [10, 19, 205, 203], [11, 19, 204, 200], [12, 19, 206, 203], [13, 19, 204, 201], [14, 19, 205, 202], [15, 19, 205, 202], [16, 19, 205, 199], [17, 19, 47, 206], [18, 19, 47, 205], [19, 19, 206, 201], [20, 19, 205, 197], [21, 19, 205, 199], [22, 19, 205, 197], [23, 19, 205, 197]]}, {\"asset\": \"30084\", \"changed_cells\": 339, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 20, \"2\": 20, \"3\": 19, \"4\": 17, \"5\": 13, \"6\": 12, \"7\": 12, \"8\": 19, \"9\": 16, \"10\": 18, \"11\": 20, \"12\": 20, \"13\": 20, \"14\": 20, \"15\": 21, \"16\": 19, \"17\": 20, \"18\": 15, \"19\": 18}, \"changes\": [[7, 1, 195, 206], [8, 1, 188, 193], [9, 1, 186, 191], [10, 1, 183, 191], [11, 1, 181, 186], [12, 1, 195, 205], [13, 1, 188, 194], [14, 1, 186, 191], [15, 1, 183, 191], [16, 1, 181, 187], [17, 1, 195, 204], [18, 1, 187, 194], [19, 1, 184, 192], [20, 1, 179, 191], [21, 1, 180, 186], [22, 1, 195, 206], [23, 1, 187, 194], [24, 1, 183, 192], [25, 1, 179, 191], [26, 1, 180, 186], [7, 2, 202, 206], [8, 2, 196, 200], [9, 2, 195, 197], [10, 2, 193, 197], [11, 2, 186, 188], [12, 2, 202, 206], [13, 2, 197, 201], [14, 2, 194, 197], [15, 2, 192, 197], [16, 2, 185, 189], [17, 2, 202, 206], [18, 2, 196, 201], [19, 2, 193, 197], [20, 2, 193, 197], [21, 2, 184, 188], [22, 2, 202, 206], [23, 2, 196, 199], [24, 2, 194, 198], [25, 2, 190, 197], [26, 2, 181, 188], [7, 3, 202, 206], [8, 3, 197, 199], [10, 3, 194, 197], [11, 3, 187, 188], [12, 3, 202, 206], [13, 3, 197, 200], [14, 3, 196, 197], [15, 3, 194, 197], [16, 3, 186, 189], [17, 3, 202, 206], [18, 3, 197, 199], [19, 3, 195, 197], [20, 3, 194, 197], [21, 3, 183, 188], [22, 3, 202, 206], [23, 3, 197, 199], [24, 3, 195, 198], [25, 3, 194, 197], [26, 3, 183, 187], [7, 4, 202, 205], [8, 4, 197, 198], [10, 4, 195, 197], [11, 4, 186, 187], [12, 4, 202, 206], [15, 4, 195, 197], [16, 4, 186, 188], [17, 4, 202, 206], [18, 4, 197, 198], [19, 4, 196, 197], [20, 4, 194, 197], [21, 4, 185, 186], [22, 4, 202, 205], [23, 4, 197, 199], [24, 4, 196, 198], [25, 4, 195, 197], [26, 4, 185, 186], [7, 5, 202, 204], [11, 5, 188, 186], [12, 5, 202, 206], [15, 5, 196, 197], [16, 5, 187, 188], [17, 5, 202, 204], [20, 5, 195, 197], [21, 5, 186, 184], [22, 5, 202, 205], [23, 5, 197, 198], [25, 5, 194, 196], [26, 5, 187, 186], [27, 5, 199, 200], [7, 6, 202, 203], [11, 6, 188, 186], [12, 6, 202, 205], [13, 6, 198, 197], [15, 6, 196, 197], [16, 6, 188, 186], [17, 6, 202, 204], [21, 6, 187, 184], [22, 6, 202, 205], [23, 6, 197, 198], [25, 6, 196, 195], [26, 6, 186, 185], [7, 7, 202, 203], [10, 7, 197, 196], [11, 7, 188, 185], [13, 7, 198, 197], [15, 7, 196, 197], [16, 7, 188, 185], [20, 7, 197, 196], [21, 7, 188, 182], [22, 7, 202, 203], [23, 7, 197, 198], [25, 7, 197, 194], [26, 7, 187, 182], [7, 8, 203, 205], [8, 8, 198, 200], [9, 8, 197, 200], [10, 8, 197, 198], [11, 8, 188, 186], [12, 8, 203, 206], [13, 8, 198, 200], [14, 8, 198, 200], [15, 8, 197, 198], [16, 8, 188, 186], [17, 8, 203, 206], [18, 8, 197, 200], [19, 8, 197, 200], [20, 8, 197, 198], [21, 8, 188, 183], [22, 8, 202, 205], [23, 8, 197, 200], [24, 8, 197, 200], [25, 8, 197, 195], [7, 9, 203, 202], [8, 9, 198, 197], [9, 9, 198, 197], [10, 9, 198, 194], [11, 9, 188, 180], [12, 9, 203, 202], [13, 9, 198, 197], [14, 9, 197, 196], [15, 9, 198, 195], [16, 9, 188, 180], [18, 9, 198, 197], [20, 9, 197, 191], [21, 9, 189, 179], [24, 9, 199, 195], [25, 9, 197, 191], [26, 9, 189, 182], [7, 10, 204, 202], [8, 10, 198, 197], [9, 10, 198, 196], [10, 10, 198, 192], [11, 10, 189, 176], [12, 10, 203, 202], [13, 10, 198, 197], [14, 10, 199, 195], [15, 10, 198, 192], [16, 10, 188, 179], [18, 10, 198, 196], [19, 10, 198, 193], [20, 10, 197, 189], [21, 10, 189, 178], [23, 10, 198, 196], [24, 10, 199, 191], [25, 10, 197, 189], [26, 10, 189, 181], [7, 11, 205, 204], [8, 11, 199, 200], [9, 11, 198, 195], [10, 11, 198, 191], [11, 11, 190, 183], [12, 11, 203, 205], [13, 11, 199, 201], [14, 11, 198, 195], [15, 11, 198, 191], [16, 11, 188, 183], [17, 11, 203, 205], [18, 11, 198, 199], [19, 11, 198, 197], [20, 11, 198, 193], [21, 11, 189, 185], [22, 11, 202, 205], [24, 11, 197, 193], [25, 11, 197, 194], [26, 11, 189, 190], [27, 11, 199, 198], [7, 12, 204, 206], [8, 12, 199, 238], [9, 12, 198, 31], [10, 12, 199, 237], [11, 12, 190, 205], [12, 12, 204, 206], [13, 12, 199, 238], [14, 12, 198, 31], [15, 12, 198, 237], [16, 12, 190, 203], [17, 12, 203, 206], [18, 12, 198, 238], [19, 12, 198, 31], [20, 12, 198, 237], [21, 12, 189, 204], [22, 12, 203, 206], [23, 12, 199, 238], [24, 12, 198, 31], [25, 12, 197, 237], [26, 12, 190, 205], [7, 13, 207, 206], [8, 13, 202, 31], [9, 13, 202, 31], [10, 13, 202, 31], [11, 13, 193, 205], [12, 13, 207, 206], [13, 13, 202, 31], [14, 13, 201, 31], [15, 13, 201, 31], [16, 13, 194, 205], [17, 13, 207, 206], [18, 13, 202, 31], [19, 13, 201, 31], [20, 13, 201, 31], [21, 13, 195, 205], [22, 13, 207, 206], [23, 13, 201, 31], [24, 13, 201, 31], [25, 13, 201, 31], [26, 13, 193, 205], [7, 14, 206, 207], [8, 14, 200, 238], [9, 14, 199, 31], [10, 14, 199, 237], [11, 14, 192, 206], [12, 14, 206, 207], [13, 14, 199, 238], [14, 14, 199, 31], [15, 14, 198, 237], [16, 14, 192, 206], [17, 14, 205, 207], [18, 14, 200, 238], [19, 14, 199, 31], [20, 14, 198, 237], [21, 14, 193, 206], [22, 14, 204, 207], [23, 14, 200, 238], [24, 14, 198, 31], [25, 14, 198, 237], [26, 14, 191, 206], [6, 15, 207, 79], [7, 15, 206, 207], [8, 15, 202, 207], [9, 15, 201, 206], [10, 15, 201, 206], [11, 15, 193, 206], [12, 15, 206, 207], [13, 15, 201, 207], [14, 15, 199, 206], [15, 15, 198, 206], [16, 15, 192, 206], [17, 15, 205, 207], [18, 15, 201, 207], [19, 15, 200, 206], [20, 15, 198, 206], [21, 15, 193, 206], [22, 15, 203, 207], [23, 15, 200, 207], [24, 15, 200, 206], [25, 15, 198, 206], [26, 15, 191, 206], [6, 16, 79, 207], [7, 16, 206, 207], [8, 16, 206, 207], [9, 16, 205, 207], [10, 16, 204, 207], [11, 16, 195, 207], [12, 16, 207, 79], [13, 16, 205, 206], [14, 16, 204, 206], [16, 16, 196, 204], [17, 16, 207, 200], [18, 16, 204, 197], [19, 16, 204, 193], [20, 16, 204, 191], [21, 16, 196, 186], [22, 16, 207, 197], [23, 16, 205, 197], [24, 16, 205, 194], [25, 16, 203, 198], [5, 17, 207, 47], [6, 17, 207, 47], [8, 17, 207, 47], [9, 17, 207, 47], [10, 17, 207, 47], [12, 17, 79, 47], [13, 17, 47, 204], [14, 17, 47, 200], [15, 17, 207, 199], [16, 17, 207, 197], [17, 17, 207, 197], [18, 17, 206, 196], [19, 17, 206, 194], [20, 17, 206, 191], [21, 17, 205, 186], [22, 17, 207, 197], [23, 17, 206, 197], [24, 17, 204, 191], [25, 17, 205, 198], [26, 17, 195, 192], [9, 18, 47, 206], [10, 18, 47, 206], [11, 18, 206, 204], [13, 18, 205, 199], [14, 18, 206, 196], [15, 18, 206, 204], [16, 18, 206, 205], [17, 18, 47, 206], [18, 18, 205, 197], [19, 18, 205, 197], [20, 18, 204, 187], [21, 18, 205, 197], [22, 18, 205, 197], [23, 18, 205, 197], [24, 18, 202, 190], [5, 19, 206, 204], [6, 19, 201, 196], [8, 19, 206, 205], [9, 19, 206, 204], [10, 19, 205, 203], [11, 19, 204, 200], [12, 19, 206, 203], [13, 19, 204, 201], [14, 19, 205, 202], [15, 19, 205, 202], [16, 19, 205, 199], [17, 19, 47, 206], [18, 19, 47, 205], [19, 19, 206, 201], [20, 19, 205, 197], [21, 19, 205, 199], [22, 19, 205, 197], [23, 19, 205, 197]]}], \"all_phase_source_stationary_occupied_cells\": 341, \"independent_row_based_metrics_match_worker\": true, \"row_based_metrics\": [{\"asset\": \"30081\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 89, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 0, \"max_channel_difference\": 20}, {\"asset\": \"30082\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 124, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 0, \"max_channel_difference\": 28}, {\"asset\": \"30083\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 126, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 4, \"max_channel_difference\": 33}, {\"asset\": \"30084\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 128, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 3, \"max_channel_difference\": 33}], \"all_source_stationary_comparisons\": [{\"asset\": \"30081\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 133, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 341, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 624, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1364, \"opacity_changes\": [[6, 53, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1638, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 3069, \"opacity_changes\": [[9, 19, 29, 256], [9, 31, 30, 256], [9, 43, 30, 256], [9, 55, 30, 256], [86, 55, 256, 28], [9, 67, 30, 256], [86, 67, 256, 28], [13, 89, 0, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2885, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 5456, \"opacity_changes\": [[111, 10, 235, 256], [12, 25, 29, 256], [12, 26, 29, 256], [12, 41, 29, 256], [12, 42, 29, 256], [12, 57, 29, 256], [12, 58, 29, 256], [12, 73, 29, 256], [12, 74, 29, 256], [12, 89, 29, 256], [115, 89, 256, 28], [13, 107, 31, 256], [115, 105, 256, 30], [15, 109, 31, 256], [42, 112, 256, 239], [42, 113, 256, 239], [42, 114, 256, 239], [42, 115, 256, 239], [17, 118, 31, 256], [21, 122, 31, 256], [21, 123, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}]}, {\"asset\": \"30082\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 187, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 341, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 842, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1364, \"opacity_changes\": [[6, 53, 31, 256], [23, 53, 256, 30], [7, 54, 31, 256], [41, 55, 31, 256], [42, 58, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1962, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 3069, \"opacity_changes\": [[86, 9, 256, 237], [9, 79, 0, 256], [60, 79, 31, 256], [60, 80, 31, 256], [60, 81, 31, 256], [60, 82, 31, 256], [62, 83, 239, 256], [13, 89, 0, 256], [63, 87, 31, 256], [15, 91, 31, 256], [67, 92, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3485, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 5456, \"opacity_changes\": [[110, 8, 256, 237], [110, 9, 256, 237], [12, 25, 29, 256], [12, 26, 29, 256], [12, 41, 29, 256], [12, 42, 29, 256], [115, 40, 29, 256], [12, 73, 29, 256], [12, 90, 256, 29], [13, 107, 31, 256], [80, 105, 31, 256], [80, 106, 31, 256], [80, 107, 31, 256], [115, 105, 256, 30], [14, 108, 0, 256], [15, 109, 31, 256], [80, 108, 31, 256], [80, 109, 31, 256], [81, 110, 31, 256], [83, 111, 239, 256], [111, 110, 256, 30], [111, 111, 256, 30], [42, 112, 256, 239], [42, 113, 256, 30], [42, 114, 256, 31], [42, 115, 256, 31], [111, 112, 256, 30], [111, 113, 256, 30], [111, 114, 256, 30], [111, 115, 256, 31], [16, 117, 0, 256], [17, 118, 31, 256], [18, 119, 0, 256], [19, 119, 0, 256], [39, 119, 239, 256], [84, 116, 0, 256], [85, 117, 31, 256], [86, 119, 30, 256], [87, 119, 31, 256], [107, 119, 30, 256], [21, 122, 31, 256], [21, 123, 31, 256], [88, 121, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}]}, {\"asset\": \"30083\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 191, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 341, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 20, 33.0, [117.0, 69.0, 56.0], [150.0, 101.0, 85.0]], [15, 22, 32.0, [93.0, 48.0, 40.0], [125.0, 77.0, 65.0]], [16, 22, 32.0, [93.0, 48.0, 40.0], [125.0, 77.0, 65.0]], [9, 23, 33.0, [48.0, 32.0, 28.0], [81.0, 36.0, 32.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 789, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1364, \"opacity_changes\": [[6, 53, 31, 256], [7, 54, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[15, 21, 36.5, [44.5, 22.0, 19.0], [8.0, 6.0, 5.0]], [16, 21, 40.5, [46.5, 24.0, 20.0], [6.0, 4.0, 3.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 2}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1792, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 3069, \"opacity_changes\": [[86, 19, 256, 28], [86, 31, 256, 28], [86, 44, 29, 256], [86, 55, 256, 29], [86, 56, 29, 256], [86, 67, 256, 28], [35, 78, 30, 256], [86, 79, 256, 30], [32, 83, 239, 256], [60, 82, 31, 256], [62, 83, 239, 256], [83, 86, 239, 256], [13, 89, 0, 256], [29, 89, 239, 256], [80, 89, 31, 256], [15, 91, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[15, 21, 36.3333, [39.888888888888886, 23.88888888888889, 19.666666666666668], [3.5555555555555554, 3.5555555555555554, 3.5555555555555554]], [16, 21, 39.2222, [43.22222222222222, 27.88888888888889, 23.0], [4.0, 3.111111111111111, 2.6666666666666665]], [15, 22, 34.4444, [98.11111111111111, 66.44444444444444, 56.22222222222222], [132.55555555555554, 85.44444444444444, 71.44444444444444]], [16, 22, 32.1111, [100.55555555555556, 65.55555555555556, 55.22222222222222], [132.66666666666666, 85.44444444444444, 71.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3169, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 5456, \"opacity_changes\": [[24, 4, 238, 256], [25, 4, 237, 256], [26, 4, 237, 256], [27, 4, 237, 256], [111, 10, 235, 256], [115, 25, 256, 28], [115, 41, 256, 28], [115, 43, 29, 256], [115, 59, 30, 256], [115, 73, 256, 29], [115, 75, 30, 256], [115, 89, 256, 29], [13, 107, 31, 256], [47, 104, 31, 256], [115, 105, 256, 31], [81, 110, 31, 256], [83, 111, 239, 256], [16, 117, 0, 256], [18, 119, 0, 256], [38, 119, 239, 256], [39, 119, 239, 256], [85, 117, 31, 256], [86, 119, 30, 256], [87, 119, 31, 256], [107, 119, 30, 256], [21, 122, 31, 256], [21, 123, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[15, 21, 38.25, [40.25, 26.5, 21.75], [2.0, 2.0, 2.0]], [16, 21, 39.75, [41.75, 28.5, 24.0], [2.0, 2.0, 2.0]], [15, 22, 35.5625, [98.25, 62.25, 51.6875], [133.8125, 86.75, 71.125]], [16, 22, 36.3125, [99.5, 64.6875, 53.25], [135.8125, 88.5, 72.9375]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}]}, {\"asset\": \"30084\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 203, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 341, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 20, 33.0, [117.0, 69.0, 56.0], [150.0, 101.0, 85.0]], [15, 22, 32.0, [93.0, 48.0, 40.0], [125.0, 77.0, 65.0]], [16, 22, 32.0, [93.0, 48.0, 40.0], [125.0, 77.0, 65.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 907, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1364, \"opacity_changes\": [[57, 53, 256, 31]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 18, 32.5, [61.5, 27.0, 23.0], [94.0, 49.25, 42.25]], [15, 21, 36.5, [44.5, 22.0, 19.0], [8.0, 6.0, 5.0]], [16, 21, 42.5, [46.5, 24.0, 20.0], [4.0, 4.0, 4.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2077, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 3069, \"opacity_changes\": [[18, 3, 238, 256], [19, 3, 206, 256], [20, 3, 204, 256], [86, 19, 256, 30], [86, 31, 256, 31], [86, 43, 256, 0], [86, 55, 256, 0], [86, 67, 256, 0], [9, 80, 256, 0], [86, 79, 256, 0], [86, 80, 256, 30], [9, 81, 256, 31], [10, 81, 256, 31], [11, 82, 256, 31], [11, 83, 256, 31], [32, 83, 239, 256], [60, 82, 31, 256], [12, 88, 256, 0], [29, 89, 239, 256], [67, 92, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 18, 32.5556, [58.111111111111114, 24.88888888888889, 21.333333333333332], [90.66666666666667, 46.0, 39.666666666666664]], [15, 21, 37.2222, [39.888888888888886, 23.88888888888889, 19.666666666666668], [2.6666666666666665, 2.6666666666666665, 2.6666666666666665]], [16, 21, 41.0, [43.22222222222222, 27.88888888888889, 23.0], [2.2222222222222223, 2.2222222222222223, 2.2222222222222223]], [15, 22, 37.7778, [98.11111111111111, 66.44444444444444, 56.22222222222222], [135.88888888888889, 88.55555555555556, 73.55555555555556]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3747, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 5456, \"opacity_changes\": [[24, 4, 238, 256], [25, 4, 237, 256], [26, 4, 237, 256], [27, 4, 237, 256], [110, 9, 256, 27], [111, 10, 235, 256], [115, 25, 256, 30], [115, 26, 256, 30], [115, 41, 256, 31], [115, 42, 256, 31], [115, 57, 256, 0], [115, 58, 256, 0], [115, 73, 256, 0], [115, 74, 256, 0], [12, 90, 256, 0], [115, 89, 256, 0], [115, 90, 256, 0], [12, 106, 256, 0], [12, 107, 256, 0], [115, 105, 256, 0], [115, 106, 256, 0], [114, 107, 256, 0], [12, 108, 256, 0], [13, 108, 256, 0], [15, 110, 256, 0], [15, 111, 256, 0], [42, 111, 239, 256], [81, 110, 31, 256], [111, 110, 256, 239], [111, 111, 256, 239], [111, 112, 256, 239], [111, 113, 256, 239], [111, 114, 256, 30], [111, 115, 256, 30], [38, 119, 239, 256], [39, 119, 239, 256], [86, 119, 30, 256], [35, 123, 0, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[15, 21, 38.25, [40.25, 26.5, 21.75], [2.0, 2.0, 2.0]], [16, 21, 39.75, [41.75, 28.5, 24.0], [2.0, 2.0, 2.0]], [15, 22, 34.8125, [98.25, 62.25, 51.6875], [133.0625, 86.75, 71.0625]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}]}]} [\"Isolated actual Catalog/HdAssets source-bound sprite raster and artistic approval only. No new Host enemy occurrence, animation timing, terrain blend, gameplay, simulation-neutrality or fullscreen capture.\", \"Broader game-source freshness flag is true due to unrelated menu/game edits; relevant assets/hd loader source is current.\", \"Complete shared family scale, origin and all rawalpha>=16/>=32 crop retention independently verified. Palette classes, forced indices and all240\\u2013255counts pass; these numeric checks do not substitute for the completed artistic review.\", \"Original/source and newly authored stationary body shading are not byte identical; localized variations and native/2\\u00d7 contour smoothing are deliberately disclosed.\", \"Global registration and bundled pack snapshot remain coordinator-owned; no source/candidate/raw/global/Git edits by reviewer.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/independent-review.json, SHA256 f6c62881aa1b2c8f035cd588b6d4e11b8b543af4a03a6a56616613afe6be7839", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/inputs/enemies-30080-30084/runtime-review/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "68bdf75fcfc9e36e5803e81af307e91c46a72ab88666febfe1291401e8a7cedc" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "26ce2f190978e8c78b69c05c2c1e50e4c0faa6716b81f5c0da237c01e576ac6d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "30080", + "30081", + "30082", + "30083" + ], + "sha256": "87a471ee7483c597619bcafa1a41f41f84681e3942a30262e568a743a977eeb1", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30084" + ], + "sha256": "cdd16f1f605cfe46e24c3bbcffb4ff43587a552b9e8cf13271897e273e17af71", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "30080-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fd536ad9aac9e344e6fe4331f433898abbb167c69ffa94aec9806ad694368e28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30080-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "079b87081e39873b5be9faffe14dce4d027bf00ef7cfc8fd9cdd93c3cedeee01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30080-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b22cd16a11c9ea3efb035b80bc7b3dc3447f8ae7a24d621e9f7185cfe139b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30080-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3026bb9ff8b4f4f313ca7fef0f19a6fdc94edf6f79eb64ca0746332484079269", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30080-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3e1e6ae5ef3819f4bc82778766e1195e67b334749eb22b0b950a353cb7680d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bc6d145991040b69c3b1c20ad055094df2fe9360b28e57a1def1b4f3576ad52", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1ed74c04f89cbfe0fa1c2ed506fa99036eeca0707bad34e212e280dec92c9501", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d959fbbda4ef1bb1a3e75799357d61aa00d11a23d42d917f773e2a10efd9d445", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e678bac84f7983a2834d980ba471739612290201c967ed3f845f3eb7d0971168", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e6f1cc73de3209d87af4b3130d44b011218627d4296eb259290a276b92002f5b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cb1c7a13bdc40f1eccf2e2a3fcba9ff79eaa51a142b5e4b7d6515a7b3a791f4d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "25cea435d141ec8d9a453ad33bf3a9397c5ba4b57a5329921e7de79d3e176d1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "746b84803b2db47a4fae7952ec8cda086a5e9c49e889fd0cc03837baef8e7b03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fad8a48e3b868a0203a5cbc218c707937c0ee7a5ab6694adcce600b04fd8c6f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ace88f16d8d9b49fb9ac34e04137466bb67e8d9e1b160143ad1d305a509f6c86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "32ebaab7e521884d8354069450aa20094c4ca483a59c7c21b898bacf4fe92338", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b25da63039cb7ddece4861d2a226a120f6d340b6677c68ded58ad6a246c212fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "86b26559707c319eb729080b46de9880aa6555d0f8effe44fcd5cce2de1abe77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "28e6c46d40117ab5632eb95e8cf342e8f566f4a881dabc787cd0dda1b48521fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3a5d7a92757bdc7b81278a3f38a27823432b2bdb3cd2e12be800560a3bc46a06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7e56ddacfb74d930186bafe4a0ad431a07ef43e6a2ef94c50c9de12b406394df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "674eae95c1902c100ac9366782d1e930b06068b501ae38088b89bbca6c23e90f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "080847674391cb7141f23910600c4cd61659d4727766afd1e2e8745c724a59d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc9b5f686a39f45aa4f001ad675b64d547f6e866866052466436a6c4c0fa2739", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d017c6f503fa8a58ccb5a52c0dc76c79f71436e906b88d0bc5ed234867738eec", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30082": { @@ -240457,7 +244955,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30082", "family_id": "enemies-30080-30084", "job_id": "enemies-30080-30084", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -240469,6 +244967,176 @@ "manifest": "jobs/enemies-30080-30084/candidate.json", "sha256": "1ace4e117a41b4a2790441b94331eb05bc7d66eb711100a0db325d068726758e", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1ace4e117a41b4a2790441b94331eb05bc7d66eb711100a0db325d068726758e", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "7ef5d4f694e62bab8fa8fd3254ccc6cfd56ca21f4f030a9db231b5e1d7d340df", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:31.125025+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/enemies-30080-30084/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"Four copper slats preserve original five-stage horizontal highlight/recess progression; outer gray tread/bar positions and lower split legs/aperture remain aligned. Fine bronze grain and pale bevels are slightly brighter than the source. Dark source bands become opaque recessed faces, not transparent holes.\", \"Native1 loses only source black contour cell(3,27) in all five frames;2\\u00d7 also loses it only30082/30083. Every source cell survives3\\u20134. Stationary lower rows20\\u201330 retain architecture with89/124/126/128 changed native shades,0/0/4/3 >=32-channel delta.\"] {\"source_phase_differences\": [{\"asset\": \"30080\", \"changed_cells\": 0, \"changed_rows\": {}, \"changes\": []}, {\"asset\": \"30081\", \"changed_cells\": 207, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 13, \"2\": 11, \"3\": 8, \"4\": 7, \"5\": 8, \"6\": 7, \"7\": 10, \"8\": 10, \"9\": 10, \"10\": 13, \"11\": 14, \"12\": 17, \"13\": 12, \"14\": 11, \"15\": 14, \"16\": 15, \"17\": 13, \"18\": 6, \"19\": 8}, \"changes\": [[9, 1, 186, 187], [10, 1, 183, 185], [11, 1, 181, 179], [14, 1, 186, 187], [15, 1, 183, 185], [18, 1, 187, 188], [19, 1, 184, 186], [20, 1, 179, 185], [21, 1, 180, 181], [23, 1, 187, 188], [24, 1, 183, 187], [25, 1, 179, 187], [26, 1, 180, 183], [9, 2, 195, 194], [11, 2, 186, 183], [13, 2, 197, 196], [15, 2, 192, 194], [18, 2, 196, 197], [19, 2, 193, 195], [21, 2, 184, 185], [23, 2, 196, 197], [24, 2, 194, 195], [25, 2, 190, 193], [26, 2, 181, 186], [8, 3, 197, 196], [9, 3, 197, 194], [10, 3, 194, 193], [11, 3, 187, 184], [19, 3, 195, 197], [21, 3, 183, 184], [24, 3, 195, 196], [26, 3, 183, 186], [9, 4, 197, 196], [10, 4, 195, 194], [14, 4, 197, 196], [19, 4, 196, 197], [21, 4, 185, 186], [24, 4, 196, 197], [26, 4, 185, 187], [9, 5, 197, 196], [10, 5, 197, 194], [11, 5, 188, 187], [14, 5, 197, 196], [16, 5, 187, 186], [21, 5, 186, 187], [25, 5, 194, 196], [27, 5, 199, 200], [10, 6, 197, 196], [11, 6, 188, 187], [13, 6, 198, 197], [14, 6, 197, 196], [16, 6, 188, 187], [20, 6, 196, 195], [26, 6, 186, 187], [8, 7, 197, 198], [10, 7, 197, 196], [11, 7, 188, 186], [12, 7, 203, 202], [13, 7, 198, 197], [15, 7, 196, 195], [17, 7, 203, 202], [20, 7, 197, 195], [22, 7, 202, 203], [25, 7, 197, 196], [8, 8, 198, 197], [9, 8, 197, 198], [11, 8, 188, 187], [12, 8, 203, 202], [13, 8, 198, 197], [14, 8, 198, 197], [15, 8, 197, 195], [17, 8, 203, 202], [20, 8, 197, 195], [22, 8, 202, 204], [8, 9, 198, 197], [9, 9, 198, 197], [12, 9, 203, 202], [15, 9, 198, 195], [18, 9, 198, 197], [20, 9, 197, 196], [21, 9, 189, 188], [22, 9, 202, 204], [24, 9, 199, 197], [26, 9, 189, 188], [7, 10, 204, 205], [9, 10, 198, 197], [11, 10, 189, 188], [12, 10, 203, 202], [14, 10, 199, 197], [15, 10, 198, 196], [18, 10, 198, 197], [19, 10, 198, 197], [21, 10, 189, 188], [22, 10, 202, 204], [23, 10, 198, 197], [24, 10, 199, 197], [26, 10, 189, 188], [8, 11, 199, 197], [9, 11, 198, 197], [11, 11, 190, 188], [12, 11, 203, 204], [14, 11, 198, 197], [15, 11, 198, 197], [17, 11, 203, 204], [18, 11, 198, 197], [19, 11, 198, 197], [20, 11, 198, 197], [21, 11, 189, 188], [22, 11, 202, 204], [23, 11, 199, 197], [26, 11, 189, 188], [7, 12, 204, 205], [8, 12, 199, 198], [9, 12, 198, 197], [10, 12, 199, 198], [11, 12, 190, 189], [12, 12, 204, 205], [13, 12, 199, 198], [15, 12, 198, 197], [16, 12, 190, 188], [17, 12, 203, 205], [19, 12, 198, 197], [20, 12, 198, 197], [21, 12, 189, 188], [22, 12, 203, 205], [23, 12, 199, 197], [24, 12, 198, 197], [26, 12, 190, 188], [8, 13, 202, 201], [9, 13, 202, 201], [10, 13, 202, 201], [13, 13, 202, 201], [14, 13, 201, 202], [15, 13, 201, 200], [16, 13, 194, 191], [20, 13, 201, 200], [21, 13, 195, 192], [23, 13, 201, 202], [25, 13, 201, 200], [26, 13, 193, 191], [8, 14, 200, 198], [9, 14, 199, 198], [10, 14, 199, 198], [11, 14, 192, 190], [14, 14, 199, 200], [16, 14, 192, 188], [18, 14, 200, 198], [21, 14, 193, 189], [22, 14, 204, 205], [25, 14, 198, 197], [26, 14, 191, 188], [6, 15, 207, 79], [8, 15, 202, 200], [9, 15, 201, 199], [10, 15, 201, 198], [11, 15, 193, 190], [13, 15, 201, 199], [14, 15, 199, 200], [16, 15, 192, 188], [18, 15, 201, 200], [19, 15, 200, 199], [21, 15, 193, 189], [22, 15, 203, 205], [24, 15, 200, 199], [26, 15, 191, 188], [6, 16, 79, 207], [8, 16, 206, 204], [9, 16, 205, 204], [10, 16, 204, 203], [11, 16, 195, 193], [13, 16, 205, 203], [14, 16, 204, 203], [16, 16, 196, 191], [17, 16, 207, 206], [18, 16, 204, 203], [19, 16, 204, 203], [21, 16, 196, 192], [23, 16, 205, 204], [24, 16, 205, 203], [26, 16, 197, 195], [5, 17, 207, 47], [6, 17, 207, 47], [12, 17, 79, 207], [13, 17, 47, 207], [14, 17, 47, 207], [18, 17, 206, 207], [19, 17, 206, 207], [20, 17, 206, 207], [21, 17, 205, 207], [23, 17, 206, 207], [24, 17, 204, 207], [25, 17, 205, 207], [26, 17, 195, 207], [11, 18, 206, 47], [14, 18, 206, 204], [15, 18, 206, 47], [16, 18, 206, 47], [20, 18, 204, 200], [24, 18, 202, 197], [12, 19, 206, 205], [16, 19, 205, 203], [18, 19, 47, 206], [19, 19, 206, 204], [20, 19, 205, 202], [21, 19, 205, 203], [22, 19, 205, 202], [23, 19, 205, 197]]}, {\"asset\": \"30082\", \"changed_cells\": 299, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 20, \"2\": 17, \"3\": 14, \"4\": 14, \"5\": 11, \"6\": 13, \"7\": 12, \"8\": 13, \"9\": 14, \"10\": 14, \"11\": 19, \"12\": 15, \"13\": 20, \"14\": 19, \"15\": 20, \"16\": 18, \"17\": 19, \"18\": 9, \"19\": 18}, \"changes\": [[7, 1, 195, 200], [8, 1, 188, 189], [9, 1, 186, 189], [10, 1, 183, 188], [11, 1, 181, 184], [12, 1, 195, 198], [13, 1, 188, 190], [14, 1, 186, 187], [15, 1, 183, 189], [16, 1, 181, 183], [17, 1, 195, 198], [18, 1, 187, 189], [19, 1, 184, 189], [20, 1, 179, 189], [21, 1, 180, 184], [22, 1, 195, 197], [23, 1, 187, 190], [24, 1, 183, 187], [25, 1, 179, 187], [26, 1, 180, 183], [7, 2, 202, 205], [8, 2, 196, 197], [9, 2, 195, 197], [10, 2, 193, 195], [11, 2, 186, 187], [12, 2, 202, 204], [13, 2, 197, 198], [15, 2, 192, 196], [17, 2, 202, 204], [18, 2, 196, 197], [19, 2, 193, 196], [20, 2, 193, 196], [21, 2, 184, 188], [23, 2, 196, 199], [24, 2, 194, 195], [25, 2, 190, 194], [26, 2, 181, 187], [7, 3, 202, 205], [9, 3, 197, 196], [11, 3, 187, 185], [12, 3, 202, 204], [13, 3, 197, 198], [14, 3, 196, 194], [15, 3, 194, 196], [16, 3, 186, 182], [17, 3, 202, 203], [21, 3, 183, 188], [22, 3, 202, 199], [23, 3, 197, 198], [24, 3, 195, 197], [25, 3, 194, 195], [7, 4, 202, 204], [9, 4, 197, 195], [10, 4, 195, 193], [11, 4, 186, 182], [12, 4, 202, 204], [13, 4, 197, 198], [14, 4, 197, 195], [15, 4, 195, 196], [16, 4, 186, 182], [21, 4, 185, 187], [22, 4, 202, 201], [24, 4, 196, 197], [25, 4, 195, 196], [26, 4, 185, 182], [7, 5, 202, 204], [9, 5, 197, 196], [10, 5, 197, 193], [11, 5, 188, 181], [12, 5, 202, 203], [16, 5, 187, 181], [20, 5, 195, 194], [22, 5, 202, 201], [25, 5, 194, 196], [26, 5, 187, 181], [27, 5, 199, 200], [7, 6, 202, 204], [9, 6, 197, 196], [10, 6, 197, 194], [11, 6, 188, 183], [12, 6, 202, 203], [13, 6, 198, 199], [15, 6, 196, 194], [16, 6, 188, 180], [20, 6, 196, 194], [21, 6, 187, 184], [22, 6, 202, 201], [25, 6, 196, 197], [26, 6, 186, 181], [7, 7, 202, 203], [9, 7, 197, 196], [10, 7, 197, 194], [11, 7, 188, 186], [12, 7, 203, 202], [15, 7, 196, 195], [16, 7, 188, 182], [20, 7, 197, 194], [21, 7, 188, 185], [22, 7, 202, 200], [25, 7, 197, 196], [26, 7, 187, 184], [8, 8, 198, 197], [9, 8, 197, 196], [10, 8, 197, 194], [13, 8, 198, 197], [14, 8, 198, 197], [15, 8, 197, 195], [16, 8, 188, 185], [17, 8, 203, 204], [20, 8, 197, 195], [21, 8, 188, 186], [22, 8, 202, 200], [25, 8, 197, 196], [26, 8, 188, 185], [7, 9, 203, 205], [8, 9, 198, 197], [9, 9, 198, 197], [10, 9, 198, 195], [12, 9, 203, 204], [13, 9, 198, 197], [15, 9, 198, 196], [16, 9, 188, 184], [17, 9, 203, 205], [18, 9, 198, 197], [20, 9, 197, 195], [21, 9, 189, 188], [24, 9, 199, 197], [26, 9, 189, 185], [7, 10, 204, 205], [9, 10, 198, 197], [10, 10, 198, 196], [11, 10, 189, 188], [14, 10, 199, 197], [15, 10, 198, 197], [16, 10, 188, 186], [17, 10, 203, 205], [19, 10, 198, 197], [20, 10, 197, 196], [21, 10, 189, 187], [22, 10, 202, 203], [24, 10, 199, 197], [26, 10, 189, 186], [7, 11, 205, 207], [8, 11, 199, 202], [9, 11, 198, 200], [10, 11, 198, 199], [11, 11, 190, 191], [12, 11, 203, 206], [13, 11, 199, 201], [14, 11, 198, 200], [15, 11, 198, 200], [16, 11, 188, 190], [17, 11, 203, 207], [18, 11, 198, 202], [19, 11, 198, 200], [20, 11, 198, 199], [21, 11, 189, 190], [22, 11, 202, 207], [23, 11, 199, 201], [24, 11, 197, 200], [25, 11, 197, 200], [9, 12, 198, 197], [10, 12, 199, 196], [11, 12, 190, 188], [12, 12, 204, 203], [14, 12, 198, 197], [15, 12, 198, 197], [16, 12, 190, 188], [17, 12, 203, 204], [18, 12, 198, 199], [19, 12, 198, 197], [20, 12, 198, 196], [21, 12, 189, 187], [22, 12, 203, 204], [24, 12, 198, 197], [26, 12, 190, 187], [7, 13, 207, 205], [8, 13, 202, 199], [9, 13, 202, 199], [10, 13, 202, 196], [11, 13, 193, 187], [12, 13, 207, 203], [13, 13, 202, 199], [14, 13, 201, 198], [15, 13, 201, 197], [16, 13, 194, 188], [17, 13, 207, 204], [18, 13, 202, 200], [19, 13, 201, 198], [20, 13, 201, 197], [21, 13, 195, 187], [22, 13, 207, 203], [23, 13, 201, 200], [24, 13, 201, 197], [25, 13, 201, 197], [26, 13, 193, 188], [6, 14, 207, 79], [8, 14, 200, 203], [9, 14, 199, 204], [10, 14, 199, 202], [11, 14, 192, 191], [13, 14, 199, 202], [14, 14, 199, 203], [15, 14, 198, 203], [16, 14, 192, 191], [17, 14, 205, 206], [18, 14, 200, 203], [19, 14, 199, 203], [20, 14, 198, 202], [21, 14, 193, 191], [22, 14, 204, 206], [23, 14, 200, 204], [24, 14, 198, 203], [25, 14, 198, 202], [26, 14, 191, 195], [7, 15, 206, 207], [8, 15, 202, 239], [9, 15, 201, 31], [10, 15, 201, 239], [11, 15, 193, 207], [12, 15, 206, 207], [13, 15, 201, 239], [14, 15, 199, 31], [15, 15, 198, 239], [16, 15, 192, 207], [17, 15, 205, 207], [18, 15, 201, 239], [19, 15, 200, 31], [20, 15, 198, 239], [21, 15, 193, 207], [22, 15, 203, 207], [23, 15, 200, 239], [24, 15, 200, 31], [25, 15, 198, 239], [26, 15, 191, 207], [6, 16, 79, 207], [7, 16, 206, 207], [8, 16, 206, 239], [9, 16, 205, 31], [10, 16, 204, 239], [11, 16, 195, 207], [13, 16, 205, 239], [14, 16, 204, 31], [15, 16, 204, 239], [16, 16, 196, 207], [18, 16, 204, 239], [19, 16, 204, 31], [20, 16, 204, 239], [21, 16, 196, 207], [23, 16, 205, 239], [24, 16, 205, 31], [25, 16, 203, 239], [26, 16, 197, 207], [5, 17, 207, 47], [6, 17, 207, 47], [8, 17, 207, 47], [9, 17, 207, 47], [10, 17, 207, 47], [12, 17, 79, 47], [14, 17, 47, 206], [15, 17, 207, 205], [16, 17, 207, 205], [17, 17, 207, 205], [18, 17, 206, 204], [19, 17, 206, 204], [20, 17, 206, 197], [21, 17, 205, 193], [22, 17, 207, 202], [23, 17, 206, 202], [24, 17, 204, 191], [25, 17, 205, 198], [26, 17, 195, 192], [13, 18, 205, 203], [14, 18, 206, 201], [18, 18, 205, 202], [19, 18, 205, 202], [20, 18, 204, 194], [21, 18, 205, 202], [22, 18, 205, 202], [23, 18, 205, 197], [24, 18, 202, 190], [5, 19, 206, 204], [6, 19, 201, 196], [8, 19, 206, 205], [9, 19, 206, 204], [10, 19, 205, 203], [11, 19, 204, 200], [12, 19, 206, 203], [13, 19, 204, 201], [14, 19, 205, 202], [15, 19, 205, 202], [16, 19, 205, 199], [17, 19, 47, 206], [18, 19, 47, 205], [19, 19, 206, 201], [20, 19, 205, 197], [21, 19, 205, 199], [22, 19, 205, 197], [23, 19, 205, 197]]}, {\"asset\": \"30083\", \"changed_cells\": 335, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 20, \"2\": 19, \"3\": 17, \"4\": 15, \"5\": 13, \"6\": 13, \"7\": 18, \"8\": 19, \"9\": 19, \"10\": 18, \"11\": 17, \"12\": 19, \"13\": 19, \"14\": 19, \"15\": 21, \"16\": 19, \"17\": 20, \"18\": 12, \"19\": 18}, \"changes\": [[7, 1, 195, 203], [8, 1, 188, 190], [9, 1, 186, 190], [10, 1, 183, 188], [11, 1, 181, 185], [12, 1, 195, 202], [13, 1, 188, 190], [14, 1, 186, 190], [15, 1, 183, 190], [16, 1, 181, 185], [17, 1, 195, 203], [18, 1, 187, 191], [19, 1, 184, 190], [20, 1, 179, 190], [21, 1, 180, 185], [22, 1, 195, 201], [23, 1, 187, 192], [24, 1, 183, 190], [25, 1, 179, 190], [26, 1, 180, 185], [7, 2, 202, 206], [8, 2, 196, 197], [9, 2, 195, 197], [10, 2, 193, 195], [11, 2, 186, 188], [12, 2, 202, 205], [14, 2, 194, 196], [15, 2, 192, 197], [16, 2, 185, 188], [17, 2, 202, 205], [18, 2, 196, 197], [19, 2, 193, 197], [20, 2, 193, 197], [21, 2, 184, 188], [22, 2, 202, 205], [23, 2, 196, 199], [24, 2, 194, 197], [25, 2, 190, 197], [26, 2, 181, 187], [7, 3, 202, 206], [8, 3, 197, 196], [10, 3, 194, 196], [11, 3, 187, 186], [12, 3, 202, 205], [14, 3, 196, 195], [15, 3, 194, 197], [16, 3, 186, 187], [17, 3, 202, 205], [19, 3, 195, 197], [20, 3, 194, 196], [21, 3, 183, 189], [22, 3, 202, 205], [23, 3, 197, 199], [24, 3, 195, 197], [25, 3, 194, 197], [26, 3, 183, 187], [7, 4, 202, 206], [10, 4, 195, 196], [11, 4, 186, 184], [12, 4, 202, 204], [14, 4, 197, 196], [15, 4, 195, 197], [16, 4, 186, 185], [17, 4, 202, 205], [19, 4, 196, 197], [20, 4, 194, 195], [21, 4, 185, 189], [22, 4, 202, 205], [23, 4, 197, 198], [25, 4, 195, 196], [26, 4, 185, 187], [7, 5, 202, 206], [10, 5, 197, 194], [11, 5, 188, 185], [12, 5, 202, 203], [14, 5, 197, 195], [16, 5, 187, 184], [17, 5, 202, 205], [21, 5, 186, 187], [22, 5, 202, 203], [23, 5, 197, 198], [25, 5, 194, 196], [26, 5, 187, 188], [27, 5, 199, 200], [7, 6, 202, 205], [10, 6, 197, 194], [11, 6, 188, 183], [13, 6, 198, 197], [14, 6, 197, 196], [15, 6, 196, 195], [16, 6, 188, 185], [17, 6, 202, 203], [20, 6, 196, 195], [21, 6, 187, 184], [22, 6, 202, 203], [23, 6, 197, 198], [25, 6, 196, 195], [7, 7, 202, 203], [9, 7, 197, 196], [10, 7, 197, 193], [11, 7, 188, 180], [12, 7, 203, 202], [13, 7, 198, 197], [14, 7, 197, 196], [15, 7, 196, 194], [16, 7, 188, 181], [17, 7, 203, 202], [19, 7, 197, 196], [20, 7, 197, 193], [21, 7, 188, 184], [22, 7, 202, 203], [23, 7, 197, 198], [24, 7, 197, 196], [25, 7, 197, 195], [26, 7, 187, 183], [7, 8, 203, 202], [8, 8, 198, 197], [9, 8, 197, 196], [10, 8, 197, 194], [11, 8, 188, 180], [12, 8, 203, 200], [13, 8, 198, 197], [14, 8, 198, 196], [15, 8, 197, 194], [16, 8, 188, 182], [17, 8, 203, 202], [19, 8, 197, 195], [20, 8, 197, 193], [21, 8, 188, 183], [22, 8, 202, 203], [23, 8, 197, 198], [24, 8, 197, 195], [25, 8, 197, 196], [26, 8, 188, 183], [7, 9, 203, 206], [8, 9, 198, 200], [9, 9, 198, 199], [10, 9, 198, 196], [11, 9, 188, 185], [12, 9, 203, 204], [13, 9, 198, 200], [14, 9, 197, 199], [15, 9, 198, 197], [16, 9, 188, 184], [17, 9, 203, 206], [18, 9, 198, 200], [19, 9, 197, 198], [21, 9, 189, 186], [22, 9, 202, 206], [23, 9, 197, 200], [24, 9, 199, 198], [25, 9, 197, 198], [26, 9, 189, 184], [8, 10, 198, 197], [9, 10, 198, 196], [10, 10, 198, 195], [11, 10, 189, 185], [13, 10, 198, 197], [14, 10, 199, 196], [15, 10, 198, 195], [16, 10, 188, 184], [17, 10, 203, 204], [18, 10, 198, 197], [19, 10, 198, 196], [20, 10, 197, 195], [21, 10, 189, 188], [22, 10, 202, 204], [23, 10, 198, 197], [24, 10, 199, 195], [25, 10, 197, 196], [26, 10, 189, 182], [7, 11, 205, 204], [8, 11, 199, 198], [9, 11, 198, 196], [10, 11, 198, 196], [11, 11, 190, 186], [12, 11, 203, 204], [13, 11, 199, 197], [14, 11, 198, 197], [15, 11, 198, 196], [17, 11, 203, 204], [19, 11, 198, 197], [20, 11, 198, 196], [21, 11, 189, 187], [22, 11, 202, 204], [23, 11, 199, 197], [24, 11, 197, 196], [26, 11, 189, 184], [7, 12, 204, 206], [8, 12, 199, 203], [9, 12, 198, 200], [10, 12, 199, 202], [12, 12, 204, 207], [13, 12, 199, 204], [14, 12, 198, 202], [15, 12, 198, 202], [16, 12, 190, 191], [17, 12, 203, 206], [18, 12, 198, 203], [19, 12, 198, 202], [20, 12, 198, 202], [21, 12, 189, 190], [22, 12, 203, 207], [23, 12, 199, 204], [24, 12, 198, 202], [25, 12, 197, 202], [26, 12, 190, 195], [8, 13, 202, 239], [9, 13, 202, 31], [10, 13, 202, 238], [11, 13, 193, 207], [12, 13, 207, 206], [13, 13, 202, 239], [14, 13, 201, 31], [15, 13, 201, 238], [16, 13, 194, 207], [17, 13, 207, 206], [18, 13, 202, 239], [19, 13, 201, 31], [20, 13, 201, 238], [21, 13, 195, 207], [22, 13, 207, 206], [23, 13, 201, 239], [24, 13, 201, 31], [25, 13, 201, 238], [26, 13, 193, 205], [7, 14, 206, 207], [8, 14, 200, 31], [9, 14, 199, 31], [10, 14, 199, 31], [11, 14, 192, 207], [13, 14, 199, 31], [14, 14, 199, 31], [15, 14, 198, 31], [16, 14, 192, 207], [17, 14, 205, 206], [18, 14, 200, 31], [19, 14, 199, 31], [20, 14, 198, 31], [21, 14, 193, 207], [22, 14, 204, 206], [23, 14, 200, 31], [24, 14, 198, 31], [25, 14, 198, 31], [26, 14, 191, 206], [6, 15, 207, 79], [7, 15, 206, 207], [8, 15, 202, 239], [9, 15, 201, 31], [10, 15, 201, 239], [11, 15, 193, 207], [12, 15, 206, 207], [13, 15, 201, 239], [14, 15, 199, 31], [15, 15, 198, 239], [16, 15, 192, 207], [17, 15, 205, 207], [18, 15, 201, 239], [19, 15, 200, 31], [20, 15, 198, 239], [21, 15, 193, 207], [22, 15, 203, 207], [23, 15, 200, 239], [24, 15, 200, 31], [25, 15, 198, 239], [26, 15, 191, 206], [6, 16, 79, 207], [7, 16, 206, 207], [8, 16, 206, 207], [9, 16, 205, 207], [10, 16, 204, 207], [11, 16, 195, 207], [12, 16, 207, 79], [13, 16, 205, 206], [14, 16, 204, 206], [16, 16, 196, 204], [17, 16, 207, 200], [18, 16, 204, 197], [19, 16, 204, 193], [20, 16, 204, 191], [21, 16, 196, 186], [22, 16, 207, 197], [23, 16, 205, 197], [24, 16, 205, 194], [25, 16, 203, 198], [5, 17, 207, 47], [6, 17, 207, 47], [8, 17, 207, 47], [9, 17, 207, 47], [10, 17, 207, 47], [12, 17, 79, 47], [13, 17, 47, 206], [14, 17, 47, 204], [15, 17, 207, 203], [16, 17, 207, 202], [17, 17, 207, 202], [18, 17, 206, 196], [19, 17, 206, 194], [20, 17, 206, 191], [21, 17, 205, 186], [22, 17, 207, 197], [23, 17, 206, 197], [24, 17, 204, 191], [25, 17, 205, 198], [26, 17, 195, 192], [13, 18, 205, 203], [14, 18, 206, 201], [15, 18, 206, 204], [16, 18, 206, 205], [17, 18, 47, 206], [18, 18, 205, 197], [19, 18, 205, 197], [20, 18, 204, 187], [21, 18, 205, 197], [22, 18, 205, 197], [23, 18, 205, 197], [24, 18, 202, 190], [5, 19, 206, 204], [6, 19, 201, 196], [8, 19, 206, 205], [9, 19, 206, 204], [10, 19, 205, 203], [11, 19, 204, 200], [12, 19, 206, 203], [13, 19, 204, 201], [14, 19, 205, 202], [15, 19, 205, 202], [16, 19, 205, 199], [17, 19, 47, 206], [18, 19, 47, 205], [19, 19, 206, 201], [20, 19, 205, 197], [21, 19, 205, 199], [22, 19, 205, 197], [23, 19, 205, 197]]}, {\"asset\": \"30084\", \"changed_cells\": 339, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 20, \"2\": 20, \"3\": 19, \"4\": 17, \"5\": 13, \"6\": 12, \"7\": 12, \"8\": 19, \"9\": 16, \"10\": 18, \"11\": 20, \"12\": 20, \"13\": 20, \"14\": 20, \"15\": 21, \"16\": 19, \"17\": 20, \"18\": 15, \"19\": 18}, \"changes\": [[7, 1, 195, 206], [8, 1, 188, 193], [9, 1, 186, 191], [10, 1, 183, 191], [11, 1, 181, 186], [12, 1, 195, 205], [13, 1, 188, 194], [14, 1, 186, 191], [15, 1, 183, 191], [16, 1, 181, 187], [17, 1, 195, 204], [18, 1, 187, 194], [19, 1, 184, 192], [20, 1, 179, 191], [21, 1, 180, 186], [22, 1, 195, 206], [23, 1, 187, 194], [24, 1, 183, 192], [25, 1, 179, 191], [26, 1, 180, 186], [7, 2, 202, 206], [8, 2, 196, 200], [9, 2, 195, 197], [10, 2, 193, 197], [11, 2, 186, 188], [12, 2, 202, 206], [13, 2, 197, 201], [14, 2, 194, 197], [15, 2, 192, 197], [16, 2, 185, 189], [17, 2, 202, 206], [18, 2, 196, 201], [19, 2, 193, 197], [20, 2, 193, 197], [21, 2, 184, 188], [22, 2, 202, 206], [23, 2, 196, 199], [24, 2, 194, 198], [25, 2, 190, 197], [26, 2, 181, 188], [7, 3, 202, 206], [8, 3, 197, 199], [10, 3, 194, 197], [11, 3, 187, 188], [12, 3, 202, 206], [13, 3, 197, 200], [14, 3, 196, 197], [15, 3, 194, 197], [16, 3, 186, 189], [17, 3, 202, 206], [18, 3, 197, 199], [19, 3, 195, 197], [20, 3, 194, 197], [21, 3, 183, 188], [22, 3, 202, 206], [23, 3, 197, 199], [24, 3, 195, 198], [25, 3, 194, 197], [26, 3, 183, 187], [7, 4, 202, 205], [8, 4, 197, 198], [10, 4, 195, 197], [11, 4, 186, 187], [12, 4, 202, 206], [15, 4, 195, 197], [16, 4, 186, 188], [17, 4, 202, 206], [18, 4, 197, 198], [19, 4, 196, 197], [20, 4, 194, 197], [21, 4, 185, 186], [22, 4, 202, 205], [23, 4, 197, 199], [24, 4, 196, 198], [25, 4, 195, 197], [26, 4, 185, 186], [7, 5, 202, 204], [11, 5, 188, 186], [12, 5, 202, 206], [15, 5, 196, 197], [16, 5, 187, 188], [17, 5, 202, 204], [20, 5, 195, 197], [21, 5, 186, 184], [22, 5, 202, 205], [23, 5, 197, 198], [25, 5, 194, 196], [26, 5, 187, 186], [27, 5, 199, 200], [7, 6, 202, 203], [11, 6, 188, 186], [12, 6, 202, 205], [13, 6, 198, 197], [15, 6, 196, 197], [16, 6, 188, 186], [17, 6, 202, 204], [21, 6, 187, 184], [22, 6, 202, 205], [23, 6, 197, 198], [25, 6, 196, 195], [26, 6, 186, 185], [7, 7, 202, 203], [10, 7, 197, 196], [11, 7, 188, 185], [13, 7, 198, 197], [15, 7, 196, 197], [16, 7, 188, 185], [20, 7, 197, 196], [21, 7, 188, 182], [22, 7, 202, 203], [23, 7, 197, 198], [25, 7, 197, 194], [26, 7, 187, 182], [7, 8, 203, 205], [8, 8, 198, 200], [9, 8, 197, 200], [10, 8, 197, 198], [11, 8, 188, 186], [12, 8, 203, 206], [13, 8, 198, 200], [14, 8, 198, 200], [15, 8, 197, 198], [16, 8, 188, 186], [17, 8, 203, 206], [18, 8, 197, 200], [19, 8, 197, 200], [20, 8, 197, 198], [21, 8, 188, 183], [22, 8, 202, 205], [23, 8, 197, 200], [24, 8, 197, 200], [25, 8, 197, 195], [7, 9, 203, 202], [8, 9, 198, 197], [9, 9, 198, 197], [10, 9, 198, 194], [11, 9, 188, 180], [12, 9, 203, 202], [13, 9, 198, 197], [14, 9, 197, 196], [15, 9, 198, 195], [16, 9, 188, 180], [18, 9, 198, 197], [20, 9, 197, 191], [21, 9, 189, 179], [24, 9, 199, 195], [25, 9, 197, 191], [26, 9, 189, 182], [7, 10, 204, 202], [8, 10, 198, 197], [9, 10, 198, 196], [10, 10, 198, 192], [11, 10, 189, 176], [12, 10, 203, 202], [13, 10, 198, 197], [14, 10, 199, 195], [15, 10, 198, 192], [16, 10, 188, 179], [18, 10, 198, 196], [19, 10, 198, 193], [20, 10, 197, 189], [21, 10, 189, 178], [23, 10, 198, 196], [24, 10, 199, 191], [25, 10, 197, 189], [26, 10, 189, 181], [7, 11, 205, 204], [8, 11, 199, 200], [9, 11, 198, 195], [10, 11, 198, 191], [11, 11, 190, 183], [12, 11, 203, 205], [13, 11, 199, 201], [14, 11, 198, 195], [15, 11, 198, 191], [16, 11, 188, 183], [17, 11, 203, 205], [18, 11, 198, 199], [19, 11, 198, 197], [20, 11, 198, 193], [21, 11, 189, 185], [22, 11, 202, 205], [24, 11, 197, 193], [25, 11, 197, 194], [26, 11, 189, 190], [27, 11, 199, 198], [7, 12, 204, 206], [8, 12, 199, 238], [9, 12, 198, 31], [10, 12, 199, 237], [11, 12, 190, 205], [12, 12, 204, 206], [13, 12, 199, 238], [14, 12, 198, 31], [15, 12, 198, 237], [16, 12, 190, 203], [17, 12, 203, 206], [18, 12, 198, 238], [19, 12, 198, 31], [20, 12, 198, 237], [21, 12, 189, 204], [22, 12, 203, 206], [23, 12, 199, 238], [24, 12, 198, 31], [25, 12, 197, 237], [26, 12, 190, 205], [7, 13, 207, 206], [8, 13, 202, 31], [9, 13, 202, 31], [10, 13, 202, 31], [11, 13, 193, 205], [12, 13, 207, 206], [13, 13, 202, 31], [14, 13, 201, 31], [15, 13, 201, 31], [16, 13, 194, 205], [17, 13, 207, 206], [18, 13, 202, 31], [19, 13, 201, 31], [20, 13, 201, 31], [21, 13, 195, 205], [22, 13, 207, 206], [23, 13, 201, 31], [24, 13, 201, 31], [25, 13, 201, 31], [26, 13, 193, 205], [7, 14, 206, 207], [8, 14, 200, 238], [9, 14, 199, 31], [10, 14, 199, 237], [11, 14, 192, 206], [12, 14, 206, 207], [13, 14, 199, 238], [14, 14, 199, 31], [15, 14, 198, 237], [16, 14, 192, 206], [17, 14, 205, 207], [18, 14, 200, 238], [19, 14, 199, 31], [20, 14, 198, 237], [21, 14, 193, 206], [22, 14, 204, 207], [23, 14, 200, 238], [24, 14, 198, 31], [25, 14, 198, 237], [26, 14, 191, 206], [6, 15, 207, 79], [7, 15, 206, 207], [8, 15, 202, 207], [9, 15, 201, 206], [10, 15, 201, 206], [11, 15, 193, 206], [12, 15, 206, 207], [13, 15, 201, 207], [14, 15, 199, 206], [15, 15, 198, 206], [16, 15, 192, 206], [17, 15, 205, 207], [18, 15, 201, 207], [19, 15, 200, 206], [20, 15, 198, 206], [21, 15, 193, 206], [22, 15, 203, 207], [23, 15, 200, 207], [24, 15, 200, 206], [25, 15, 198, 206], [26, 15, 191, 206], [6, 16, 79, 207], [7, 16, 206, 207], [8, 16, 206, 207], [9, 16, 205, 207], [10, 16, 204, 207], [11, 16, 195, 207], [12, 16, 207, 79], [13, 16, 205, 206], [14, 16, 204, 206], [16, 16, 196, 204], [17, 16, 207, 200], [18, 16, 204, 197], [19, 16, 204, 193], [20, 16, 204, 191], [21, 16, 196, 186], [22, 16, 207, 197], [23, 16, 205, 197], [24, 16, 205, 194], [25, 16, 203, 198], [5, 17, 207, 47], [6, 17, 207, 47], [8, 17, 207, 47], [9, 17, 207, 47], [10, 17, 207, 47], [12, 17, 79, 47], [13, 17, 47, 204], [14, 17, 47, 200], [15, 17, 207, 199], [16, 17, 207, 197], [17, 17, 207, 197], [18, 17, 206, 196], [19, 17, 206, 194], [20, 17, 206, 191], [21, 17, 205, 186], [22, 17, 207, 197], [23, 17, 206, 197], [24, 17, 204, 191], [25, 17, 205, 198], [26, 17, 195, 192], [9, 18, 47, 206], [10, 18, 47, 206], [11, 18, 206, 204], [13, 18, 205, 199], [14, 18, 206, 196], [15, 18, 206, 204], [16, 18, 206, 205], [17, 18, 47, 206], [18, 18, 205, 197], [19, 18, 205, 197], [20, 18, 204, 187], [21, 18, 205, 197], [22, 18, 205, 197], [23, 18, 205, 197], [24, 18, 202, 190], [5, 19, 206, 204], [6, 19, 201, 196], [8, 19, 206, 205], [9, 19, 206, 204], [10, 19, 205, 203], [11, 19, 204, 200], [12, 19, 206, 203], [13, 19, 204, 201], [14, 19, 205, 202], [15, 19, 205, 202], [16, 19, 205, 199], [17, 19, 47, 206], [18, 19, 47, 205], [19, 19, 206, 201], [20, 19, 205, 197], [21, 19, 205, 199], [22, 19, 205, 197], [23, 19, 205, 197]]}], \"all_phase_source_stationary_occupied_cells\": 341, \"independent_row_based_metrics_match_worker\": true, \"row_based_metrics\": [{\"asset\": \"30081\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 89, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 0, \"max_channel_difference\": 20}, {\"asset\": \"30082\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 124, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 0, \"max_channel_difference\": 28}, {\"asset\": \"30083\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 126, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 4, \"max_channel_difference\": 33}, {\"asset\": \"30084\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 128, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 3, \"max_channel_difference\": 33}], \"all_source_stationary_comparisons\": [{\"asset\": \"30081\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 133, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 341, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 624, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1364, \"opacity_changes\": [[6, 53, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1638, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 3069, \"opacity_changes\": [[9, 19, 29, 256], [9, 31, 30, 256], [9, 43, 30, 256], [9, 55, 30, 256], [86, 55, 256, 28], [9, 67, 30, 256], [86, 67, 256, 28], [13, 89, 0, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2885, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 5456, \"opacity_changes\": [[111, 10, 235, 256], [12, 25, 29, 256], [12, 26, 29, 256], [12, 41, 29, 256], [12, 42, 29, 256], [12, 57, 29, 256], [12, 58, 29, 256], [12, 73, 29, 256], [12, 74, 29, 256], [12, 89, 29, 256], [115, 89, 256, 28], [13, 107, 31, 256], [115, 105, 256, 30], [15, 109, 31, 256], [42, 112, 256, 239], [42, 113, 256, 239], [42, 114, 256, 239], [42, 115, 256, 239], [17, 118, 31, 256], [21, 122, 31, 256], [21, 123, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}]}, {\"asset\": \"30082\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 187, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 341, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 842, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1364, \"opacity_changes\": [[6, 53, 31, 256], [23, 53, 256, 30], [7, 54, 31, 256], [41, 55, 31, 256], [42, 58, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1962, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 3069, \"opacity_changes\": [[86, 9, 256, 237], [9, 79, 0, 256], [60, 79, 31, 256], [60, 80, 31, 256], [60, 81, 31, 256], [60, 82, 31, 256], [62, 83, 239, 256], [13, 89, 0, 256], [63, 87, 31, 256], [15, 91, 31, 256], [67, 92, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3485, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 5456, \"opacity_changes\": [[110, 8, 256, 237], [110, 9, 256, 237], [12, 25, 29, 256], [12, 26, 29, 256], [12, 41, 29, 256], [12, 42, 29, 256], [115, 40, 29, 256], [12, 73, 29, 256], [12, 90, 256, 29], [13, 107, 31, 256], [80, 105, 31, 256], [80, 106, 31, 256], [80, 107, 31, 256], [115, 105, 256, 30], [14, 108, 0, 256], [15, 109, 31, 256], [80, 108, 31, 256], [80, 109, 31, 256], [81, 110, 31, 256], [83, 111, 239, 256], [111, 110, 256, 30], [111, 111, 256, 30], [42, 112, 256, 239], [42, 113, 256, 30], [42, 114, 256, 31], [42, 115, 256, 31], [111, 112, 256, 30], [111, 113, 256, 30], [111, 114, 256, 30], [111, 115, 256, 31], [16, 117, 0, 256], [17, 118, 31, 256], [18, 119, 0, 256], [19, 119, 0, 256], [39, 119, 239, 256], [84, 116, 0, 256], [85, 117, 31, 256], [86, 119, 30, 256], [87, 119, 31, 256], [107, 119, 30, 256], [21, 122, 31, 256], [21, 123, 31, 256], [88, 121, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}]}, {\"asset\": \"30083\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 191, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 341, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 20, 33.0, [117.0, 69.0, 56.0], [150.0, 101.0, 85.0]], [15, 22, 32.0, [93.0, 48.0, 40.0], [125.0, 77.0, 65.0]], [16, 22, 32.0, [93.0, 48.0, 40.0], [125.0, 77.0, 65.0]], [9, 23, 33.0, [48.0, 32.0, 28.0], [81.0, 36.0, 32.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 789, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1364, \"opacity_changes\": [[6, 53, 31, 256], [7, 54, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[15, 21, 36.5, [44.5, 22.0, 19.0], [8.0, 6.0, 5.0]], [16, 21, 40.5, [46.5, 24.0, 20.0], [6.0, 4.0, 3.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 2}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1792, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 3069, \"opacity_changes\": [[86, 19, 256, 28], [86, 31, 256, 28], [86, 44, 29, 256], [86, 55, 256, 29], [86, 56, 29, 256], [86, 67, 256, 28], [35, 78, 30, 256], [86, 79, 256, 30], [32, 83, 239, 256], [60, 82, 31, 256], [62, 83, 239, 256], [83, 86, 239, 256], [13, 89, 0, 256], [29, 89, 239, 256], [80, 89, 31, 256], [15, 91, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[15, 21, 36.3333, [39.888888888888886, 23.88888888888889, 19.666666666666668], [3.5555555555555554, 3.5555555555555554, 3.5555555555555554]], [16, 21, 39.2222, [43.22222222222222, 27.88888888888889, 23.0], [4.0, 3.111111111111111, 2.6666666666666665]], [15, 22, 34.4444, [98.11111111111111, 66.44444444444444, 56.22222222222222], [132.55555555555554, 85.44444444444444, 71.44444444444444]], [16, 22, 32.1111, [100.55555555555556, 65.55555555555556, 55.22222222222222], [132.66666666666666, 85.44444444444444, 71.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3169, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 5456, \"opacity_changes\": [[24, 4, 238, 256], [25, 4, 237, 256], [26, 4, 237, 256], [27, 4, 237, 256], [111, 10, 235, 256], [115, 25, 256, 28], [115, 41, 256, 28], [115, 43, 29, 256], [115, 59, 30, 256], [115, 73, 256, 29], [115, 75, 30, 256], [115, 89, 256, 29], [13, 107, 31, 256], [47, 104, 31, 256], [115, 105, 256, 31], [81, 110, 31, 256], [83, 111, 239, 256], [16, 117, 0, 256], [18, 119, 0, 256], [38, 119, 239, 256], [39, 119, 239, 256], [85, 117, 31, 256], [86, 119, 30, 256], [87, 119, 31, 256], [107, 119, 30, 256], [21, 122, 31, 256], [21, 123, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[15, 21, 38.25, [40.25, 26.5, 21.75], [2.0, 2.0, 2.0]], [16, 21, 39.75, [41.75, 28.5, 24.0], [2.0, 2.0, 2.0]], [15, 22, 35.5625, [98.25, 62.25, 51.6875], [133.8125, 86.75, 71.125]], [16, 22, 36.3125, [99.5, 64.6875, 53.25], [135.8125, 88.5, 72.9375]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}]}, {\"asset\": \"30084\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 203, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 341, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 20, 33.0, [117.0, 69.0, 56.0], [150.0, 101.0, 85.0]], [15, 22, 32.0, [93.0, 48.0, 40.0], [125.0, 77.0, 65.0]], [16, 22, 32.0, [93.0, 48.0, 40.0], [125.0, 77.0, 65.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 907, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1364, \"opacity_changes\": [[57, 53, 256, 31]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 18, 32.5, [61.5, 27.0, 23.0], [94.0, 49.25, 42.25]], [15, 21, 36.5, [44.5, 22.0, 19.0], [8.0, 6.0, 5.0]], [16, 21, 42.5, [46.5, 24.0, 20.0], [4.0, 4.0, 4.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2077, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 3069, \"opacity_changes\": [[18, 3, 238, 256], [19, 3, 206, 256], [20, 3, 204, 256], [86, 19, 256, 30], [86, 31, 256, 31], [86, 43, 256, 0], [86, 55, 256, 0], [86, 67, 256, 0], [9, 80, 256, 0], [86, 79, 256, 0], [86, 80, 256, 30], [9, 81, 256, 31], [10, 81, 256, 31], [11, 82, 256, 31], [11, 83, 256, 31], [32, 83, 239, 256], [60, 82, 31, 256], [12, 88, 256, 0], [29, 89, 239, 256], [67, 92, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 18, 32.5556, [58.111111111111114, 24.88888888888889, 21.333333333333332], [90.66666666666667, 46.0, 39.666666666666664]], [15, 21, 37.2222, [39.888888888888886, 23.88888888888889, 19.666666666666668], [2.6666666666666665, 2.6666666666666665, 2.6666666666666665]], [16, 21, 41.0, [43.22222222222222, 27.88888888888889, 23.0], [2.2222222222222223, 2.2222222222222223, 2.2222222222222223]], [15, 22, 37.7778, [98.11111111111111, 66.44444444444444, 56.22222222222222], [135.88888888888889, 88.55555555555556, 73.55555555555556]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3747, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 5456, \"opacity_changes\": [[24, 4, 238, 256], [25, 4, 237, 256], [26, 4, 237, 256], [27, 4, 237, 256], [110, 9, 256, 27], [111, 10, 235, 256], [115, 25, 256, 30], [115, 26, 256, 30], [115, 41, 256, 31], [115, 42, 256, 31], [115, 57, 256, 0], [115, 58, 256, 0], [115, 73, 256, 0], [115, 74, 256, 0], [12, 90, 256, 0], [115, 89, 256, 0], [115, 90, 256, 0], [12, 106, 256, 0], [12, 107, 256, 0], [115, 105, 256, 0], [115, 106, 256, 0], [114, 107, 256, 0], [12, 108, 256, 0], [13, 108, 256, 0], [15, 110, 256, 0], [15, 111, 256, 0], [42, 111, 239, 256], [81, 110, 31, 256], [111, 110, 256, 239], [111, 111, 256, 239], [111, 112, 256, 239], [111, 113, 256, 239], [111, 114, 256, 30], [111, 115, 256, 30], [38, 119, 239, 256], [39, 119, 239, 256], [86, 119, 30, 256], [35, 123, 0, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[15, 21, 38.25, [40.25, 26.5, 21.75], [2.0, 2.0, 2.0]], [16, 21, 39.75, [41.75, 28.5, 24.0], [2.0, 2.0, 2.0]], [15, 22, 34.8125, [98.25, 62.25, 51.6875], [133.0625, 86.75, 71.0625]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}]}]} [\"Isolated actual Catalog/HdAssets source-bound sprite raster and artistic approval only. No new Host enemy occurrence, animation timing, terrain blend, gameplay, simulation-neutrality or fullscreen capture.\", \"Broader game-source freshness flag is true due to unrelated menu/game edits; relevant assets/hd loader source is current.\", \"Complete shared family scale, origin and all rawalpha>=16/>=32 crop retention independently verified. Palette classes, forced indices and all240\\u2013255counts pass; these numeric checks do not substitute for the completed artistic review.\", \"Original/source and newly authored stationary body shading are not byte identical; localized variations and native/2\\u00d7 contour smoothing are deliberately disclosed.\", \"Global registration and bundled pack snapshot remain coordinator-owned; no source/candidate/raw/global/Git edits by reviewer.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/independent-review.json, SHA256 f6c62881aa1b2c8f035cd588b6d4e11b8b543af4a03a6a56616613afe6be7839", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/inputs/enemies-30080-30084/runtime-review/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "68bdf75fcfc9e36e5803e81af307e91c46a72ab88666febfe1291401e8a7cedc" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "26ce2f190978e8c78b69c05c2c1e50e4c0faa6716b81f5c0da237c01e576ac6d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "30080", + "30081", + "30082", + "30083" + ], + "sha256": "87a471ee7483c597619bcafa1a41f41f84681e3942a30262e568a743a977eeb1", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30084" + ], + "sha256": "cdd16f1f605cfe46e24c3bbcffb4ff43587a552b9e8cf13271897e273e17af71", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "30080-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fd536ad9aac9e344e6fe4331f433898abbb167c69ffa94aec9806ad694368e28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30080-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "079b87081e39873b5be9faffe14dce4d027bf00ef7cfc8fd9cdd93c3cedeee01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30080-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b22cd16a11c9ea3efb035b80bc7b3dc3447f8ae7a24d621e9f7185cfe139b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30080-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3026bb9ff8b4f4f313ca7fef0f19a6fdc94edf6f79eb64ca0746332484079269", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30080-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3e1e6ae5ef3819f4bc82778766e1195e67b334749eb22b0b950a353cb7680d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bc6d145991040b69c3b1c20ad055094df2fe9360b28e57a1def1b4f3576ad52", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1ed74c04f89cbfe0fa1c2ed506fa99036eeca0707bad34e212e280dec92c9501", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d959fbbda4ef1bb1a3e75799357d61aa00d11a23d42d917f773e2a10efd9d445", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e678bac84f7983a2834d980ba471739612290201c967ed3f845f3eb7d0971168", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e6f1cc73de3209d87af4b3130d44b011218627d4296eb259290a276b92002f5b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cb1c7a13bdc40f1eccf2e2a3fcba9ff79eaa51a142b5e4b7d6515a7b3a791f4d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "25cea435d141ec8d9a453ad33bf3a9397c5ba4b57a5329921e7de79d3e176d1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "746b84803b2db47a4fae7952ec8cda086a5e9c49e889fd0cc03837baef8e7b03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fad8a48e3b868a0203a5cbc218c707937c0ee7a5ab6694adcce600b04fd8c6f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ace88f16d8d9b49fb9ac34e04137466bb67e8d9e1b160143ad1d305a509f6c86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "32ebaab7e521884d8354069450aa20094c4ca483a59c7c21b898bacf4fe92338", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b25da63039cb7ddece4861d2a226a120f6d340b6677c68ded58ad6a246c212fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "86b26559707c319eb729080b46de9880aa6555d0f8effe44fcd5cce2de1abe77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "28e6c46d40117ab5632eb95e8cf342e8f566f4a881dabc787cd0dda1b48521fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3a5d7a92757bdc7b81278a3f38a27823432b2bdb3cd2e12be800560a3bc46a06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7e56ddacfb74d930186bafe4a0ad431a07ef43e6a2ef94c50c9de12b406394df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "674eae95c1902c100ac9366782d1e930b06068b501ae38088b89bbca6c23e90f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "080847674391cb7141f23910600c4cd61659d4727766afd1e2e8745c724a59d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc9b5f686a39f45aa4f001ad675b64d547f6e866866052466436a6c4c0fa2739", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d017c6f503fa8a58ccb5a52c0dc76c79f71436e906b88d0bc5ed234867738eec", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30083": { @@ -240490,7 +245158,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30083", "family_id": "enemies-30080-30084", "job_id": "enemies-30080-30084", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -240502,6 +245170,176 @@ "manifest": "jobs/enemies-30080-30084/candidate.json", "sha256": "1ace4e117a41b4a2790441b94331eb05bc7d66eb711100a0db325d068726758e", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1ace4e117a41b4a2790441b94331eb05bc7d66eb711100a0db325d068726758e", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "7ef5d4f694e62bab8fa8fd3254ccc6cfd56ca21f4f030a9db231b5e1d7d340df", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:31.125025+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/enemies-30080-30084/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"Four copper slats preserve original five-stage horizontal highlight/recess progression; outer gray tread/bar positions and lower split legs/aperture remain aligned. Fine bronze grain and pale bevels are slightly brighter than the source. Dark source bands become opaque recessed faces, not transparent holes.\", \"Native1 loses only source black contour cell(3,27) in all five frames;2\\u00d7 also loses it only30082/30083. Every source cell survives3\\u20134. Stationary lower rows20\\u201330 retain architecture with89/124/126/128 changed native shades,0/0/4/3 >=32-channel delta.\"] {\"source_phase_differences\": [{\"asset\": \"30080\", \"changed_cells\": 0, \"changed_rows\": {}, \"changes\": []}, {\"asset\": \"30081\", \"changed_cells\": 207, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 13, \"2\": 11, \"3\": 8, \"4\": 7, \"5\": 8, \"6\": 7, \"7\": 10, \"8\": 10, \"9\": 10, \"10\": 13, \"11\": 14, \"12\": 17, \"13\": 12, \"14\": 11, \"15\": 14, \"16\": 15, \"17\": 13, \"18\": 6, \"19\": 8}, \"changes\": [[9, 1, 186, 187], [10, 1, 183, 185], [11, 1, 181, 179], [14, 1, 186, 187], [15, 1, 183, 185], [18, 1, 187, 188], [19, 1, 184, 186], [20, 1, 179, 185], [21, 1, 180, 181], [23, 1, 187, 188], [24, 1, 183, 187], [25, 1, 179, 187], [26, 1, 180, 183], [9, 2, 195, 194], [11, 2, 186, 183], [13, 2, 197, 196], [15, 2, 192, 194], [18, 2, 196, 197], [19, 2, 193, 195], [21, 2, 184, 185], [23, 2, 196, 197], [24, 2, 194, 195], [25, 2, 190, 193], [26, 2, 181, 186], [8, 3, 197, 196], [9, 3, 197, 194], [10, 3, 194, 193], [11, 3, 187, 184], [19, 3, 195, 197], [21, 3, 183, 184], [24, 3, 195, 196], [26, 3, 183, 186], [9, 4, 197, 196], [10, 4, 195, 194], [14, 4, 197, 196], [19, 4, 196, 197], [21, 4, 185, 186], [24, 4, 196, 197], [26, 4, 185, 187], [9, 5, 197, 196], [10, 5, 197, 194], [11, 5, 188, 187], [14, 5, 197, 196], [16, 5, 187, 186], [21, 5, 186, 187], [25, 5, 194, 196], [27, 5, 199, 200], [10, 6, 197, 196], [11, 6, 188, 187], [13, 6, 198, 197], [14, 6, 197, 196], [16, 6, 188, 187], [20, 6, 196, 195], [26, 6, 186, 187], [8, 7, 197, 198], [10, 7, 197, 196], [11, 7, 188, 186], [12, 7, 203, 202], [13, 7, 198, 197], [15, 7, 196, 195], [17, 7, 203, 202], [20, 7, 197, 195], [22, 7, 202, 203], [25, 7, 197, 196], [8, 8, 198, 197], [9, 8, 197, 198], [11, 8, 188, 187], [12, 8, 203, 202], [13, 8, 198, 197], [14, 8, 198, 197], [15, 8, 197, 195], [17, 8, 203, 202], [20, 8, 197, 195], [22, 8, 202, 204], [8, 9, 198, 197], [9, 9, 198, 197], [12, 9, 203, 202], [15, 9, 198, 195], [18, 9, 198, 197], [20, 9, 197, 196], [21, 9, 189, 188], [22, 9, 202, 204], [24, 9, 199, 197], [26, 9, 189, 188], [7, 10, 204, 205], [9, 10, 198, 197], [11, 10, 189, 188], [12, 10, 203, 202], [14, 10, 199, 197], [15, 10, 198, 196], [18, 10, 198, 197], [19, 10, 198, 197], [21, 10, 189, 188], [22, 10, 202, 204], [23, 10, 198, 197], [24, 10, 199, 197], [26, 10, 189, 188], [8, 11, 199, 197], [9, 11, 198, 197], [11, 11, 190, 188], [12, 11, 203, 204], [14, 11, 198, 197], [15, 11, 198, 197], [17, 11, 203, 204], [18, 11, 198, 197], [19, 11, 198, 197], [20, 11, 198, 197], [21, 11, 189, 188], [22, 11, 202, 204], [23, 11, 199, 197], [26, 11, 189, 188], [7, 12, 204, 205], [8, 12, 199, 198], [9, 12, 198, 197], [10, 12, 199, 198], [11, 12, 190, 189], [12, 12, 204, 205], [13, 12, 199, 198], [15, 12, 198, 197], [16, 12, 190, 188], [17, 12, 203, 205], [19, 12, 198, 197], [20, 12, 198, 197], [21, 12, 189, 188], [22, 12, 203, 205], [23, 12, 199, 197], [24, 12, 198, 197], [26, 12, 190, 188], [8, 13, 202, 201], [9, 13, 202, 201], [10, 13, 202, 201], [13, 13, 202, 201], [14, 13, 201, 202], [15, 13, 201, 200], [16, 13, 194, 191], [20, 13, 201, 200], [21, 13, 195, 192], [23, 13, 201, 202], [25, 13, 201, 200], [26, 13, 193, 191], [8, 14, 200, 198], [9, 14, 199, 198], [10, 14, 199, 198], [11, 14, 192, 190], [14, 14, 199, 200], [16, 14, 192, 188], [18, 14, 200, 198], [21, 14, 193, 189], [22, 14, 204, 205], [25, 14, 198, 197], [26, 14, 191, 188], [6, 15, 207, 79], [8, 15, 202, 200], [9, 15, 201, 199], [10, 15, 201, 198], [11, 15, 193, 190], [13, 15, 201, 199], [14, 15, 199, 200], [16, 15, 192, 188], [18, 15, 201, 200], [19, 15, 200, 199], [21, 15, 193, 189], [22, 15, 203, 205], [24, 15, 200, 199], [26, 15, 191, 188], [6, 16, 79, 207], [8, 16, 206, 204], [9, 16, 205, 204], [10, 16, 204, 203], [11, 16, 195, 193], [13, 16, 205, 203], [14, 16, 204, 203], [16, 16, 196, 191], [17, 16, 207, 206], [18, 16, 204, 203], [19, 16, 204, 203], [21, 16, 196, 192], [23, 16, 205, 204], [24, 16, 205, 203], [26, 16, 197, 195], [5, 17, 207, 47], [6, 17, 207, 47], [12, 17, 79, 207], [13, 17, 47, 207], [14, 17, 47, 207], [18, 17, 206, 207], [19, 17, 206, 207], [20, 17, 206, 207], [21, 17, 205, 207], [23, 17, 206, 207], [24, 17, 204, 207], [25, 17, 205, 207], [26, 17, 195, 207], [11, 18, 206, 47], [14, 18, 206, 204], [15, 18, 206, 47], [16, 18, 206, 47], [20, 18, 204, 200], [24, 18, 202, 197], [12, 19, 206, 205], [16, 19, 205, 203], [18, 19, 47, 206], [19, 19, 206, 204], [20, 19, 205, 202], [21, 19, 205, 203], [22, 19, 205, 202], [23, 19, 205, 197]]}, {\"asset\": \"30082\", \"changed_cells\": 299, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 20, \"2\": 17, \"3\": 14, \"4\": 14, \"5\": 11, \"6\": 13, \"7\": 12, \"8\": 13, \"9\": 14, \"10\": 14, \"11\": 19, \"12\": 15, \"13\": 20, \"14\": 19, \"15\": 20, \"16\": 18, \"17\": 19, \"18\": 9, \"19\": 18}, \"changes\": [[7, 1, 195, 200], [8, 1, 188, 189], [9, 1, 186, 189], [10, 1, 183, 188], [11, 1, 181, 184], [12, 1, 195, 198], [13, 1, 188, 190], [14, 1, 186, 187], [15, 1, 183, 189], [16, 1, 181, 183], [17, 1, 195, 198], [18, 1, 187, 189], [19, 1, 184, 189], [20, 1, 179, 189], [21, 1, 180, 184], [22, 1, 195, 197], [23, 1, 187, 190], [24, 1, 183, 187], [25, 1, 179, 187], [26, 1, 180, 183], [7, 2, 202, 205], [8, 2, 196, 197], [9, 2, 195, 197], [10, 2, 193, 195], [11, 2, 186, 187], [12, 2, 202, 204], [13, 2, 197, 198], [15, 2, 192, 196], [17, 2, 202, 204], [18, 2, 196, 197], [19, 2, 193, 196], [20, 2, 193, 196], [21, 2, 184, 188], [23, 2, 196, 199], [24, 2, 194, 195], [25, 2, 190, 194], [26, 2, 181, 187], [7, 3, 202, 205], [9, 3, 197, 196], [11, 3, 187, 185], [12, 3, 202, 204], [13, 3, 197, 198], [14, 3, 196, 194], [15, 3, 194, 196], [16, 3, 186, 182], [17, 3, 202, 203], [21, 3, 183, 188], [22, 3, 202, 199], [23, 3, 197, 198], [24, 3, 195, 197], [25, 3, 194, 195], [7, 4, 202, 204], [9, 4, 197, 195], [10, 4, 195, 193], [11, 4, 186, 182], [12, 4, 202, 204], [13, 4, 197, 198], [14, 4, 197, 195], [15, 4, 195, 196], [16, 4, 186, 182], [21, 4, 185, 187], [22, 4, 202, 201], [24, 4, 196, 197], [25, 4, 195, 196], [26, 4, 185, 182], [7, 5, 202, 204], [9, 5, 197, 196], [10, 5, 197, 193], [11, 5, 188, 181], [12, 5, 202, 203], [16, 5, 187, 181], [20, 5, 195, 194], [22, 5, 202, 201], [25, 5, 194, 196], [26, 5, 187, 181], [27, 5, 199, 200], [7, 6, 202, 204], [9, 6, 197, 196], [10, 6, 197, 194], [11, 6, 188, 183], [12, 6, 202, 203], [13, 6, 198, 199], [15, 6, 196, 194], [16, 6, 188, 180], [20, 6, 196, 194], [21, 6, 187, 184], [22, 6, 202, 201], [25, 6, 196, 197], [26, 6, 186, 181], [7, 7, 202, 203], [9, 7, 197, 196], [10, 7, 197, 194], [11, 7, 188, 186], [12, 7, 203, 202], [15, 7, 196, 195], [16, 7, 188, 182], [20, 7, 197, 194], [21, 7, 188, 185], [22, 7, 202, 200], [25, 7, 197, 196], [26, 7, 187, 184], [8, 8, 198, 197], [9, 8, 197, 196], [10, 8, 197, 194], [13, 8, 198, 197], [14, 8, 198, 197], [15, 8, 197, 195], [16, 8, 188, 185], [17, 8, 203, 204], [20, 8, 197, 195], [21, 8, 188, 186], [22, 8, 202, 200], [25, 8, 197, 196], [26, 8, 188, 185], [7, 9, 203, 205], [8, 9, 198, 197], [9, 9, 198, 197], [10, 9, 198, 195], [12, 9, 203, 204], [13, 9, 198, 197], [15, 9, 198, 196], [16, 9, 188, 184], [17, 9, 203, 205], [18, 9, 198, 197], [20, 9, 197, 195], [21, 9, 189, 188], [24, 9, 199, 197], [26, 9, 189, 185], [7, 10, 204, 205], [9, 10, 198, 197], [10, 10, 198, 196], [11, 10, 189, 188], [14, 10, 199, 197], [15, 10, 198, 197], [16, 10, 188, 186], [17, 10, 203, 205], [19, 10, 198, 197], [20, 10, 197, 196], [21, 10, 189, 187], [22, 10, 202, 203], [24, 10, 199, 197], [26, 10, 189, 186], [7, 11, 205, 207], [8, 11, 199, 202], [9, 11, 198, 200], [10, 11, 198, 199], [11, 11, 190, 191], [12, 11, 203, 206], [13, 11, 199, 201], [14, 11, 198, 200], [15, 11, 198, 200], [16, 11, 188, 190], [17, 11, 203, 207], [18, 11, 198, 202], [19, 11, 198, 200], [20, 11, 198, 199], [21, 11, 189, 190], [22, 11, 202, 207], [23, 11, 199, 201], [24, 11, 197, 200], [25, 11, 197, 200], [9, 12, 198, 197], [10, 12, 199, 196], [11, 12, 190, 188], [12, 12, 204, 203], [14, 12, 198, 197], [15, 12, 198, 197], [16, 12, 190, 188], [17, 12, 203, 204], [18, 12, 198, 199], [19, 12, 198, 197], [20, 12, 198, 196], [21, 12, 189, 187], [22, 12, 203, 204], [24, 12, 198, 197], [26, 12, 190, 187], [7, 13, 207, 205], [8, 13, 202, 199], [9, 13, 202, 199], [10, 13, 202, 196], [11, 13, 193, 187], [12, 13, 207, 203], [13, 13, 202, 199], [14, 13, 201, 198], [15, 13, 201, 197], [16, 13, 194, 188], [17, 13, 207, 204], [18, 13, 202, 200], [19, 13, 201, 198], [20, 13, 201, 197], [21, 13, 195, 187], [22, 13, 207, 203], [23, 13, 201, 200], [24, 13, 201, 197], [25, 13, 201, 197], [26, 13, 193, 188], [6, 14, 207, 79], [8, 14, 200, 203], [9, 14, 199, 204], [10, 14, 199, 202], [11, 14, 192, 191], [13, 14, 199, 202], [14, 14, 199, 203], [15, 14, 198, 203], [16, 14, 192, 191], [17, 14, 205, 206], [18, 14, 200, 203], [19, 14, 199, 203], [20, 14, 198, 202], [21, 14, 193, 191], [22, 14, 204, 206], [23, 14, 200, 204], [24, 14, 198, 203], [25, 14, 198, 202], [26, 14, 191, 195], [7, 15, 206, 207], [8, 15, 202, 239], [9, 15, 201, 31], [10, 15, 201, 239], [11, 15, 193, 207], [12, 15, 206, 207], [13, 15, 201, 239], [14, 15, 199, 31], [15, 15, 198, 239], [16, 15, 192, 207], [17, 15, 205, 207], [18, 15, 201, 239], [19, 15, 200, 31], [20, 15, 198, 239], [21, 15, 193, 207], [22, 15, 203, 207], [23, 15, 200, 239], [24, 15, 200, 31], [25, 15, 198, 239], [26, 15, 191, 207], [6, 16, 79, 207], [7, 16, 206, 207], [8, 16, 206, 239], [9, 16, 205, 31], [10, 16, 204, 239], [11, 16, 195, 207], [13, 16, 205, 239], [14, 16, 204, 31], [15, 16, 204, 239], [16, 16, 196, 207], [18, 16, 204, 239], [19, 16, 204, 31], [20, 16, 204, 239], [21, 16, 196, 207], [23, 16, 205, 239], [24, 16, 205, 31], [25, 16, 203, 239], [26, 16, 197, 207], [5, 17, 207, 47], [6, 17, 207, 47], [8, 17, 207, 47], [9, 17, 207, 47], [10, 17, 207, 47], [12, 17, 79, 47], [14, 17, 47, 206], [15, 17, 207, 205], [16, 17, 207, 205], [17, 17, 207, 205], [18, 17, 206, 204], [19, 17, 206, 204], [20, 17, 206, 197], [21, 17, 205, 193], [22, 17, 207, 202], [23, 17, 206, 202], [24, 17, 204, 191], [25, 17, 205, 198], [26, 17, 195, 192], [13, 18, 205, 203], [14, 18, 206, 201], [18, 18, 205, 202], [19, 18, 205, 202], [20, 18, 204, 194], [21, 18, 205, 202], [22, 18, 205, 202], [23, 18, 205, 197], [24, 18, 202, 190], [5, 19, 206, 204], [6, 19, 201, 196], [8, 19, 206, 205], [9, 19, 206, 204], [10, 19, 205, 203], [11, 19, 204, 200], [12, 19, 206, 203], [13, 19, 204, 201], [14, 19, 205, 202], [15, 19, 205, 202], [16, 19, 205, 199], [17, 19, 47, 206], [18, 19, 47, 205], [19, 19, 206, 201], [20, 19, 205, 197], [21, 19, 205, 199], [22, 19, 205, 197], [23, 19, 205, 197]]}, {\"asset\": \"30083\", \"changed_cells\": 335, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 20, \"2\": 19, \"3\": 17, \"4\": 15, \"5\": 13, \"6\": 13, \"7\": 18, \"8\": 19, \"9\": 19, \"10\": 18, \"11\": 17, \"12\": 19, \"13\": 19, \"14\": 19, \"15\": 21, \"16\": 19, \"17\": 20, \"18\": 12, \"19\": 18}, \"changes\": [[7, 1, 195, 203], [8, 1, 188, 190], [9, 1, 186, 190], [10, 1, 183, 188], [11, 1, 181, 185], [12, 1, 195, 202], [13, 1, 188, 190], [14, 1, 186, 190], [15, 1, 183, 190], [16, 1, 181, 185], [17, 1, 195, 203], [18, 1, 187, 191], [19, 1, 184, 190], [20, 1, 179, 190], [21, 1, 180, 185], [22, 1, 195, 201], [23, 1, 187, 192], [24, 1, 183, 190], [25, 1, 179, 190], [26, 1, 180, 185], [7, 2, 202, 206], [8, 2, 196, 197], [9, 2, 195, 197], [10, 2, 193, 195], [11, 2, 186, 188], [12, 2, 202, 205], [14, 2, 194, 196], [15, 2, 192, 197], [16, 2, 185, 188], [17, 2, 202, 205], [18, 2, 196, 197], [19, 2, 193, 197], [20, 2, 193, 197], [21, 2, 184, 188], [22, 2, 202, 205], [23, 2, 196, 199], [24, 2, 194, 197], [25, 2, 190, 197], [26, 2, 181, 187], [7, 3, 202, 206], [8, 3, 197, 196], [10, 3, 194, 196], [11, 3, 187, 186], [12, 3, 202, 205], [14, 3, 196, 195], [15, 3, 194, 197], [16, 3, 186, 187], [17, 3, 202, 205], [19, 3, 195, 197], [20, 3, 194, 196], [21, 3, 183, 189], [22, 3, 202, 205], [23, 3, 197, 199], [24, 3, 195, 197], [25, 3, 194, 197], [26, 3, 183, 187], [7, 4, 202, 206], [10, 4, 195, 196], [11, 4, 186, 184], [12, 4, 202, 204], [14, 4, 197, 196], [15, 4, 195, 197], [16, 4, 186, 185], [17, 4, 202, 205], [19, 4, 196, 197], [20, 4, 194, 195], [21, 4, 185, 189], [22, 4, 202, 205], [23, 4, 197, 198], [25, 4, 195, 196], [26, 4, 185, 187], [7, 5, 202, 206], [10, 5, 197, 194], [11, 5, 188, 185], [12, 5, 202, 203], [14, 5, 197, 195], [16, 5, 187, 184], [17, 5, 202, 205], [21, 5, 186, 187], [22, 5, 202, 203], [23, 5, 197, 198], [25, 5, 194, 196], [26, 5, 187, 188], [27, 5, 199, 200], [7, 6, 202, 205], [10, 6, 197, 194], [11, 6, 188, 183], [13, 6, 198, 197], [14, 6, 197, 196], [15, 6, 196, 195], [16, 6, 188, 185], [17, 6, 202, 203], [20, 6, 196, 195], [21, 6, 187, 184], [22, 6, 202, 203], [23, 6, 197, 198], [25, 6, 196, 195], [7, 7, 202, 203], [9, 7, 197, 196], [10, 7, 197, 193], [11, 7, 188, 180], [12, 7, 203, 202], [13, 7, 198, 197], [14, 7, 197, 196], [15, 7, 196, 194], [16, 7, 188, 181], [17, 7, 203, 202], [19, 7, 197, 196], [20, 7, 197, 193], [21, 7, 188, 184], [22, 7, 202, 203], [23, 7, 197, 198], [24, 7, 197, 196], [25, 7, 197, 195], [26, 7, 187, 183], [7, 8, 203, 202], [8, 8, 198, 197], [9, 8, 197, 196], [10, 8, 197, 194], [11, 8, 188, 180], [12, 8, 203, 200], [13, 8, 198, 197], [14, 8, 198, 196], [15, 8, 197, 194], [16, 8, 188, 182], [17, 8, 203, 202], [19, 8, 197, 195], [20, 8, 197, 193], [21, 8, 188, 183], [22, 8, 202, 203], [23, 8, 197, 198], [24, 8, 197, 195], [25, 8, 197, 196], [26, 8, 188, 183], [7, 9, 203, 206], [8, 9, 198, 200], [9, 9, 198, 199], [10, 9, 198, 196], [11, 9, 188, 185], [12, 9, 203, 204], [13, 9, 198, 200], [14, 9, 197, 199], [15, 9, 198, 197], [16, 9, 188, 184], [17, 9, 203, 206], [18, 9, 198, 200], [19, 9, 197, 198], [21, 9, 189, 186], [22, 9, 202, 206], [23, 9, 197, 200], [24, 9, 199, 198], [25, 9, 197, 198], [26, 9, 189, 184], [8, 10, 198, 197], [9, 10, 198, 196], [10, 10, 198, 195], [11, 10, 189, 185], [13, 10, 198, 197], [14, 10, 199, 196], [15, 10, 198, 195], [16, 10, 188, 184], [17, 10, 203, 204], [18, 10, 198, 197], [19, 10, 198, 196], [20, 10, 197, 195], [21, 10, 189, 188], [22, 10, 202, 204], [23, 10, 198, 197], [24, 10, 199, 195], [25, 10, 197, 196], [26, 10, 189, 182], [7, 11, 205, 204], [8, 11, 199, 198], [9, 11, 198, 196], [10, 11, 198, 196], [11, 11, 190, 186], [12, 11, 203, 204], [13, 11, 199, 197], [14, 11, 198, 197], [15, 11, 198, 196], [17, 11, 203, 204], [19, 11, 198, 197], [20, 11, 198, 196], [21, 11, 189, 187], [22, 11, 202, 204], [23, 11, 199, 197], [24, 11, 197, 196], [26, 11, 189, 184], [7, 12, 204, 206], [8, 12, 199, 203], [9, 12, 198, 200], [10, 12, 199, 202], [12, 12, 204, 207], [13, 12, 199, 204], [14, 12, 198, 202], [15, 12, 198, 202], [16, 12, 190, 191], [17, 12, 203, 206], [18, 12, 198, 203], [19, 12, 198, 202], [20, 12, 198, 202], [21, 12, 189, 190], [22, 12, 203, 207], [23, 12, 199, 204], [24, 12, 198, 202], [25, 12, 197, 202], [26, 12, 190, 195], [8, 13, 202, 239], [9, 13, 202, 31], [10, 13, 202, 238], [11, 13, 193, 207], [12, 13, 207, 206], [13, 13, 202, 239], [14, 13, 201, 31], [15, 13, 201, 238], [16, 13, 194, 207], [17, 13, 207, 206], [18, 13, 202, 239], [19, 13, 201, 31], [20, 13, 201, 238], [21, 13, 195, 207], [22, 13, 207, 206], [23, 13, 201, 239], [24, 13, 201, 31], [25, 13, 201, 238], [26, 13, 193, 205], [7, 14, 206, 207], [8, 14, 200, 31], [9, 14, 199, 31], [10, 14, 199, 31], [11, 14, 192, 207], [13, 14, 199, 31], [14, 14, 199, 31], [15, 14, 198, 31], [16, 14, 192, 207], [17, 14, 205, 206], [18, 14, 200, 31], [19, 14, 199, 31], [20, 14, 198, 31], [21, 14, 193, 207], [22, 14, 204, 206], [23, 14, 200, 31], [24, 14, 198, 31], [25, 14, 198, 31], [26, 14, 191, 206], [6, 15, 207, 79], [7, 15, 206, 207], [8, 15, 202, 239], [9, 15, 201, 31], [10, 15, 201, 239], [11, 15, 193, 207], [12, 15, 206, 207], [13, 15, 201, 239], [14, 15, 199, 31], [15, 15, 198, 239], [16, 15, 192, 207], [17, 15, 205, 207], [18, 15, 201, 239], [19, 15, 200, 31], [20, 15, 198, 239], [21, 15, 193, 207], [22, 15, 203, 207], [23, 15, 200, 239], [24, 15, 200, 31], [25, 15, 198, 239], [26, 15, 191, 206], [6, 16, 79, 207], [7, 16, 206, 207], [8, 16, 206, 207], [9, 16, 205, 207], [10, 16, 204, 207], [11, 16, 195, 207], [12, 16, 207, 79], [13, 16, 205, 206], [14, 16, 204, 206], [16, 16, 196, 204], [17, 16, 207, 200], [18, 16, 204, 197], [19, 16, 204, 193], [20, 16, 204, 191], [21, 16, 196, 186], [22, 16, 207, 197], [23, 16, 205, 197], [24, 16, 205, 194], [25, 16, 203, 198], [5, 17, 207, 47], [6, 17, 207, 47], [8, 17, 207, 47], [9, 17, 207, 47], [10, 17, 207, 47], [12, 17, 79, 47], [13, 17, 47, 206], [14, 17, 47, 204], [15, 17, 207, 203], [16, 17, 207, 202], [17, 17, 207, 202], [18, 17, 206, 196], [19, 17, 206, 194], [20, 17, 206, 191], [21, 17, 205, 186], [22, 17, 207, 197], [23, 17, 206, 197], [24, 17, 204, 191], [25, 17, 205, 198], [26, 17, 195, 192], [13, 18, 205, 203], [14, 18, 206, 201], [15, 18, 206, 204], [16, 18, 206, 205], [17, 18, 47, 206], [18, 18, 205, 197], [19, 18, 205, 197], [20, 18, 204, 187], [21, 18, 205, 197], [22, 18, 205, 197], [23, 18, 205, 197], [24, 18, 202, 190], [5, 19, 206, 204], [6, 19, 201, 196], [8, 19, 206, 205], [9, 19, 206, 204], [10, 19, 205, 203], [11, 19, 204, 200], [12, 19, 206, 203], [13, 19, 204, 201], [14, 19, 205, 202], [15, 19, 205, 202], [16, 19, 205, 199], [17, 19, 47, 206], [18, 19, 47, 205], [19, 19, 206, 201], [20, 19, 205, 197], [21, 19, 205, 199], [22, 19, 205, 197], [23, 19, 205, 197]]}, {\"asset\": \"30084\", \"changed_cells\": 339, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 20, \"2\": 20, \"3\": 19, \"4\": 17, \"5\": 13, \"6\": 12, \"7\": 12, \"8\": 19, \"9\": 16, \"10\": 18, \"11\": 20, \"12\": 20, \"13\": 20, \"14\": 20, \"15\": 21, \"16\": 19, \"17\": 20, \"18\": 15, \"19\": 18}, \"changes\": [[7, 1, 195, 206], [8, 1, 188, 193], [9, 1, 186, 191], [10, 1, 183, 191], [11, 1, 181, 186], [12, 1, 195, 205], [13, 1, 188, 194], [14, 1, 186, 191], [15, 1, 183, 191], [16, 1, 181, 187], [17, 1, 195, 204], [18, 1, 187, 194], [19, 1, 184, 192], [20, 1, 179, 191], [21, 1, 180, 186], [22, 1, 195, 206], [23, 1, 187, 194], [24, 1, 183, 192], [25, 1, 179, 191], [26, 1, 180, 186], [7, 2, 202, 206], [8, 2, 196, 200], [9, 2, 195, 197], [10, 2, 193, 197], [11, 2, 186, 188], [12, 2, 202, 206], [13, 2, 197, 201], [14, 2, 194, 197], [15, 2, 192, 197], [16, 2, 185, 189], [17, 2, 202, 206], [18, 2, 196, 201], [19, 2, 193, 197], [20, 2, 193, 197], [21, 2, 184, 188], [22, 2, 202, 206], [23, 2, 196, 199], [24, 2, 194, 198], [25, 2, 190, 197], [26, 2, 181, 188], [7, 3, 202, 206], [8, 3, 197, 199], [10, 3, 194, 197], [11, 3, 187, 188], [12, 3, 202, 206], [13, 3, 197, 200], [14, 3, 196, 197], [15, 3, 194, 197], [16, 3, 186, 189], [17, 3, 202, 206], [18, 3, 197, 199], [19, 3, 195, 197], [20, 3, 194, 197], [21, 3, 183, 188], [22, 3, 202, 206], [23, 3, 197, 199], [24, 3, 195, 198], [25, 3, 194, 197], [26, 3, 183, 187], [7, 4, 202, 205], [8, 4, 197, 198], [10, 4, 195, 197], [11, 4, 186, 187], [12, 4, 202, 206], [15, 4, 195, 197], [16, 4, 186, 188], [17, 4, 202, 206], [18, 4, 197, 198], [19, 4, 196, 197], [20, 4, 194, 197], [21, 4, 185, 186], [22, 4, 202, 205], [23, 4, 197, 199], [24, 4, 196, 198], [25, 4, 195, 197], [26, 4, 185, 186], [7, 5, 202, 204], [11, 5, 188, 186], [12, 5, 202, 206], [15, 5, 196, 197], [16, 5, 187, 188], [17, 5, 202, 204], [20, 5, 195, 197], [21, 5, 186, 184], [22, 5, 202, 205], [23, 5, 197, 198], [25, 5, 194, 196], [26, 5, 187, 186], [27, 5, 199, 200], [7, 6, 202, 203], [11, 6, 188, 186], [12, 6, 202, 205], [13, 6, 198, 197], [15, 6, 196, 197], [16, 6, 188, 186], [17, 6, 202, 204], [21, 6, 187, 184], [22, 6, 202, 205], [23, 6, 197, 198], [25, 6, 196, 195], [26, 6, 186, 185], [7, 7, 202, 203], [10, 7, 197, 196], [11, 7, 188, 185], [13, 7, 198, 197], [15, 7, 196, 197], [16, 7, 188, 185], [20, 7, 197, 196], [21, 7, 188, 182], [22, 7, 202, 203], [23, 7, 197, 198], [25, 7, 197, 194], [26, 7, 187, 182], [7, 8, 203, 205], [8, 8, 198, 200], [9, 8, 197, 200], [10, 8, 197, 198], [11, 8, 188, 186], [12, 8, 203, 206], [13, 8, 198, 200], [14, 8, 198, 200], [15, 8, 197, 198], [16, 8, 188, 186], [17, 8, 203, 206], [18, 8, 197, 200], [19, 8, 197, 200], [20, 8, 197, 198], [21, 8, 188, 183], [22, 8, 202, 205], [23, 8, 197, 200], [24, 8, 197, 200], [25, 8, 197, 195], [7, 9, 203, 202], [8, 9, 198, 197], [9, 9, 198, 197], [10, 9, 198, 194], [11, 9, 188, 180], [12, 9, 203, 202], [13, 9, 198, 197], [14, 9, 197, 196], [15, 9, 198, 195], [16, 9, 188, 180], [18, 9, 198, 197], [20, 9, 197, 191], [21, 9, 189, 179], [24, 9, 199, 195], [25, 9, 197, 191], [26, 9, 189, 182], [7, 10, 204, 202], [8, 10, 198, 197], [9, 10, 198, 196], [10, 10, 198, 192], [11, 10, 189, 176], [12, 10, 203, 202], [13, 10, 198, 197], [14, 10, 199, 195], [15, 10, 198, 192], [16, 10, 188, 179], [18, 10, 198, 196], [19, 10, 198, 193], [20, 10, 197, 189], [21, 10, 189, 178], [23, 10, 198, 196], [24, 10, 199, 191], [25, 10, 197, 189], [26, 10, 189, 181], [7, 11, 205, 204], [8, 11, 199, 200], [9, 11, 198, 195], [10, 11, 198, 191], [11, 11, 190, 183], [12, 11, 203, 205], [13, 11, 199, 201], [14, 11, 198, 195], [15, 11, 198, 191], [16, 11, 188, 183], [17, 11, 203, 205], [18, 11, 198, 199], [19, 11, 198, 197], [20, 11, 198, 193], [21, 11, 189, 185], [22, 11, 202, 205], [24, 11, 197, 193], [25, 11, 197, 194], [26, 11, 189, 190], [27, 11, 199, 198], [7, 12, 204, 206], [8, 12, 199, 238], [9, 12, 198, 31], [10, 12, 199, 237], [11, 12, 190, 205], [12, 12, 204, 206], [13, 12, 199, 238], [14, 12, 198, 31], [15, 12, 198, 237], [16, 12, 190, 203], [17, 12, 203, 206], [18, 12, 198, 238], [19, 12, 198, 31], [20, 12, 198, 237], [21, 12, 189, 204], [22, 12, 203, 206], [23, 12, 199, 238], [24, 12, 198, 31], [25, 12, 197, 237], [26, 12, 190, 205], [7, 13, 207, 206], [8, 13, 202, 31], [9, 13, 202, 31], [10, 13, 202, 31], [11, 13, 193, 205], [12, 13, 207, 206], [13, 13, 202, 31], [14, 13, 201, 31], [15, 13, 201, 31], [16, 13, 194, 205], [17, 13, 207, 206], [18, 13, 202, 31], [19, 13, 201, 31], [20, 13, 201, 31], [21, 13, 195, 205], [22, 13, 207, 206], [23, 13, 201, 31], [24, 13, 201, 31], [25, 13, 201, 31], [26, 13, 193, 205], [7, 14, 206, 207], [8, 14, 200, 238], [9, 14, 199, 31], [10, 14, 199, 237], [11, 14, 192, 206], [12, 14, 206, 207], [13, 14, 199, 238], [14, 14, 199, 31], [15, 14, 198, 237], [16, 14, 192, 206], [17, 14, 205, 207], [18, 14, 200, 238], [19, 14, 199, 31], [20, 14, 198, 237], [21, 14, 193, 206], [22, 14, 204, 207], [23, 14, 200, 238], [24, 14, 198, 31], [25, 14, 198, 237], [26, 14, 191, 206], [6, 15, 207, 79], [7, 15, 206, 207], [8, 15, 202, 207], [9, 15, 201, 206], [10, 15, 201, 206], [11, 15, 193, 206], [12, 15, 206, 207], [13, 15, 201, 207], [14, 15, 199, 206], [15, 15, 198, 206], [16, 15, 192, 206], [17, 15, 205, 207], [18, 15, 201, 207], [19, 15, 200, 206], [20, 15, 198, 206], [21, 15, 193, 206], [22, 15, 203, 207], [23, 15, 200, 207], [24, 15, 200, 206], [25, 15, 198, 206], [26, 15, 191, 206], [6, 16, 79, 207], [7, 16, 206, 207], [8, 16, 206, 207], [9, 16, 205, 207], [10, 16, 204, 207], [11, 16, 195, 207], [12, 16, 207, 79], [13, 16, 205, 206], [14, 16, 204, 206], [16, 16, 196, 204], [17, 16, 207, 200], [18, 16, 204, 197], [19, 16, 204, 193], [20, 16, 204, 191], [21, 16, 196, 186], [22, 16, 207, 197], [23, 16, 205, 197], [24, 16, 205, 194], [25, 16, 203, 198], [5, 17, 207, 47], [6, 17, 207, 47], [8, 17, 207, 47], [9, 17, 207, 47], [10, 17, 207, 47], [12, 17, 79, 47], [13, 17, 47, 204], [14, 17, 47, 200], [15, 17, 207, 199], [16, 17, 207, 197], [17, 17, 207, 197], [18, 17, 206, 196], [19, 17, 206, 194], [20, 17, 206, 191], [21, 17, 205, 186], [22, 17, 207, 197], [23, 17, 206, 197], [24, 17, 204, 191], [25, 17, 205, 198], [26, 17, 195, 192], [9, 18, 47, 206], [10, 18, 47, 206], [11, 18, 206, 204], [13, 18, 205, 199], [14, 18, 206, 196], [15, 18, 206, 204], [16, 18, 206, 205], [17, 18, 47, 206], [18, 18, 205, 197], [19, 18, 205, 197], [20, 18, 204, 187], [21, 18, 205, 197], [22, 18, 205, 197], [23, 18, 205, 197], [24, 18, 202, 190], [5, 19, 206, 204], [6, 19, 201, 196], [8, 19, 206, 205], [9, 19, 206, 204], [10, 19, 205, 203], [11, 19, 204, 200], [12, 19, 206, 203], [13, 19, 204, 201], [14, 19, 205, 202], [15, 19, 205, 202], [16, 19, 205, 199], [17, 19, 47, 206], [18, 19, 47, 205], [19, 19, 206, 201], [20, 19, 205, 197], [21, 19, 205, 199], [22, 19, 205, 197], [23, 19, 205, 197]]}], \"all_phase_source_stationary_occupied_cells\": 341, \"independent_row_based_metrics_match_worker\": true, \"row_based_metrics\": [{\"asset\": \"30081\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 89, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 0, \"max_channel_difference\": 20}, {\"asset\": \"30082\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 124, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 0, \"max_channel_difference\": 28}, {\"asset\": \"30083\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 126, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 4, \"max_channel_difference\": 33}, {\"asset\": \"30084\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 128, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 3, \"max_channel_difference\": 33}], \"all_source_stationary_comparisons\": [{\"asset\": \"30081\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 133, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 341, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 624, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1364, \"opacity_changes\": [[6, 53, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1638, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 3069, \"opacity_changes\": [[9, 19, 29, 256], [9, 31, 30, 256], [9, 43, 30, 256], [9, 55, 30, 256], [86, 55, 256, 28], [9, 67, 30, 256], [86, 67, 256, 28], [13, 89, 0, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2885, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 5456, \"opacity_changes\": [[111, 10, 235, 256], [12, 25, 29, 256], [12, 26, 29, 256], [12, 41, 29, 256], [12, 42, 29, 256], [12, 57, 29, 256], [12, 58, 29, 256], [12, 73, 29, 256], [12, 74, 29, 256], [12, 89, 29, 256], [115, 89, 256, 28], [13, 107, 31, 256], [115, 105, 256, 30], [15, 109, 31, 256], [42, 112, 256, 239], [42, 113, 256, 239], [42, 114, 256, 239], [42, 115, 256, 239], [17, 118, 31, 256], [21, 122, 31, 256], [21, 123, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}]}, {\"asset\": \"30082\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 187, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 341, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 842, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1364, \"opacity_changes\": [[6, 53, 31, 256], [23, 53, 256, 30], [7, 54, 31, 256], [41, 55, 31, 256], [42, 58, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1962, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 3069, \"opacity_changes\": [[86, 9, 256, 237], [9, 79, 0, 256], [60, 79, 31, 256], [60, 80, 31, 256], [60, 81, 31, 256], [60, 82, 31, 256], [62, 83, 239, 256], [13, 89, 0, 256], [63, 87, 31, 256], [15, 91, 31, 256], [67, 92, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3485, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 5456, \"opacity_changes\": [[110, 8, 256, 237], [110, 9, 256, 237], [12, 25, 29, 256], [12, 26, 29, 256], [12, 41, 29, 256], [12, 42, 29, 256], [115, 40, 29, 256], [12, 73, 29, 256], [12, 90, 256, 29], [13, 107, 31, 256], [80, 105, 31, 256], [80, 106, 31, 256], [80, 107, 31, 256], [115, 105, 256, 30], [14, 108, 0, 256], [15, 109, 31, 256], [80, 108, 31, 256], [80, 109, 31, 256], [81, 110, 31, 256], [83, 111, 239, 256], [111, 110, 256, 30], [111, 111, 256, 30], [42, 112, 256, 239], [42, 113, 256, 30], [42, 114, 256, 31], [42, 115, 256, 31], [111, 112, 256, 30], [111, 113, 256, 30], [111, 114, 256, 30], [111, 115, 256, 31], [16, 117, 0, 256], [17, 118, 31, 256], [18, 119, 0, 256], [19, 119, 0, 256], [39, 119, 239, 256], [84, 116, 0, 256], [85, 117, 31, 256], [86, 119, 30, 256], [87, 119, 31, 256], [107, 119, 30, 256], [21, 122, 31, 256], [21, 123, 31, 256], [88, 121, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}]}, {\"asset\": \"30083\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 191, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 341, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 20, 33.0, [117.0, 69.0, 56.0], [150.0, 101.0, 85.0]], [15, 22, 32.0, [93.0, 48.0, 40.0], [125.0, 77.0, 65.0]], [16, 22, 32.0, [93.0, 48.0, 40.0], [125.0, 77.0, 65.0]], [9, 23, 33.0, [48.0, 32.0, 28.0], [81.0, 36.0, 32.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 789, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1364, \"opacity_changes\": [[6, 53, 31, 256], [7, 54, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[15, 21, 36.5, [44.5, 22.0, 19.0], [8.0, 6.0, 5.0]], [16, 21, 40.5, [46.5, 24.0, 20.0], [6.0, 4.0, 3.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 2}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1792, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 3069, \"opacity_changes\": [[86, 19, 256, 28], [86, 31, 256, 28], [86, 44, 29, 256], [86, 55, 256, 29], [86, 56, 29, 256], [86, 67, 256, 28], [35, 78, 30, 256], [86, 79, 256, 30], [32, 83, 239, 256], [60, 82, 31, 256], [62, 83, 239, 256], [83, 86, 239, 256], [13, 89, 0, 256], [29, 89, 239, 256], [80, 89, 31, 256], [15, 91, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[15, 21, 36.3333, [39.888888888888886, 23.88888888888889, 19.666666666666668], [3.5555555555555554, 3.5555555555555554, 3.5555555555555554]], [16, 21, 39.2222, [43.22222222222222, 27.88888888888889, 23.0], [4.0, 3.111111111111111, 2.6666666666666665]], [15, 22, 34.4444, [98.11111111111111, 66.44444444444444, 56.22222222222222], [132.55555555555554, 85.44444444444444, 71.44444444444444]], [16, 22, 32.1111, [100.55555555555556, 65.55555555555556, 55.22222222222222], [132.66666666666666, 85.44444444444444, 71.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3169, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 5456, \"opacity_changes\": [[24, 4, 238, 256], [25, 4, 237, 256], [26, 4, 237, 256], [27, 4, 237, 256], [111, 10, 235, 256], [115, 25, 256, 28], [115, 41, 256, 28], [115, 43, 29, 256], [115, 59, 30, 256], [115, 73, 256, 29], [115, 75, 30, 256], [115, 89, 256, 29], [13, 107, 31, 256], [47, 104, 31, 256], [115, 105, 256, 31], [81, 110, 31, 256], [83, 111, 239, 256], [16, 117, 0, 256], [18, 119, 0, 256], [38, 119, 239, 256], [39, 119, 239, 256], [85, 117, 31, 256], [86, 119, 30, 256], [87, 119, 31, 256], [107, 119, 30, 256], [21, 122, 31, 256], [21, 123, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[15, 21, 38.25, [40.25, 26.5, 21.75], [2.0, 2.0, 2.0]], [16, 21, 39.75, [41.75, 28.5, 24.0], [2.0, 2.0, 2.0]], [15, 22, 35.5625, [98.25, 62.25, 51.6875], [133.8125, 86.75, 71.125]], [16, 22, 36.3125, [99.5, 64.6875, 53.25], [135.8125, 88.5, 72.9375]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}]}, {\"asset\": \"30084\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 203, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 341, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 20, 33.0, [117.0, 69.0, 56.0], [150.0, 101.0, 85.0]], [15, 22, 32.0, [93.0, 48.0, 40.0], [125.0, 77.0, 65.0]], [16, 22, 32.0, [93.0, 48.0, 40.0], [125.0, 77.0, 65.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 907, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1364, \"opacity_changes\": [[57, 53, 256, 31]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 18, 32.5, [61.5, 27.0, 23.0], [94.0, 49.25, 42.25]], [15, 21, 36.5, [44.5, 22.0, 19.0], [8.0, 6.0, 5.0]], [16, 21, 42.5, [46.5, 24.0, 20.0], [4.0, 4.0, 4.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2077, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 3069, \"opacity_changes\": [[18, 3, 238, 256], [19, 3, 206, 256], [20, 3, 204, 256], [86, 19, 256, 30], [86, 31, 256, 31], [86, 43, 256, 0], [86, 55, 256, 0], [86, 67, 256, 0], [9, 80, 256, 0], [86, 79, 256, 0], [86, 80, 256, 30], [9, 81, 256, 31], [10, 81, 256, 31], [11, 82, 256, 31], [11, 83, 256, 31], [32, 83, 239, 256], [60, 82, 31, 256], [12, 88, 256, 0], [29, 89, 239, 256], [67, 92, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 18, 32.5556, [58.111111111111114, 24.88888888888889, 21.333333333333332], [90.66666666666667, 46.0, 39.666666666666664]], [15, 21, 37.2222, [39.888888888888886, 23.88888888888889, 19.666666666666668], [2.6666666666666665, 2.6666666666666665, 2.6666666666666665]], [16, 21, 41.0, [43.22222222222222, 27.88888888888889, 23.0], [2.2222222222222223, 2.2222222222222223, 2.2222222222222223]], [15, 22, 37.7778, [98.11111111111111, 66.44444444444444, 56.22222222222222], [135.88888888888889, 88.55555555555556, 73.55555555555556]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3747, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 5456, \"opacity_changes\": [[24, 4, 238, 256], [25, 4, 237, 256], [26, 4, 237, 256], [27, 4, 237, 256], [110, 9, 256, 27], [111, 10, 235, 256], [115, 25, 256, 30], [115, 26, 256, 30], [115, 41, 256, 31], [115, 42, 256, 31], [115, 57, 256, 0], [115, 58, 256, 0], [115, 73, 256, 0], [115, 74, 256, 0], [12, 90, 256, 0], [115, 89, 256, 0], [115, 90, 256, 0], [12, 106, 256, 0], [12, 107, 256, 0], [115, 105, 256, 0], [115, 106, 256, 0], [114, 107, 256, 0], [12, 108, 256, 0], [13, 108, 256, 0], [15, 110, 256, 0], [15, 111, 256, 0], [42, 111, 239, 256], [81, 110, 31, 256], [111, 110, 256, 239], [111, 111, 256, 239], [111, 112, 256, 239], [111, 113, 256, 239], [111, 114, 256, 30], [111, 115, 256, 30], [38, 119, 239, 256], [39, 119, 239, 256], [86, 119, 30, 256], [35, 123, 0, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[15, 21, 38.25, [40.25, 26.5, 21.75], [2.0, 2.0, 2.0]], [16, 21, 39.75, [41.75, 28.5, 24.0], [2.0, 2.0, 2.0]], [15, 22, 34.8125, [98.25, 62.25, 51.6875], [133.0625, 86.75, 71.0625]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}]}]} [\"Isolated actual Catalog/HdAssets source-bound sprite raster and artistic approval only. No new Host enemy occurrence, animation timing, terrain blend, gameplay, simulation-neutrality or fullscreen capture.\", \"Broader game-source freshness flag is true due to unrelated menu/game edits; relevant assets/hd loader source is current.\", \"Complete shared family scale, origin and all rawalpha>=16/>=32 crop retention independently verified. Palette classes, forced indices and all240\\u2013255counts pass; these numeric checks do not substitute for the completed artistic review.\", \"Original/source and newly authored stationary body shading are not byte identical; localized variations and native/2\\u00d7 contour smoothing are deliberately disclosed.\", \"Global registration and bundled pack snapshot remain coordinator-owned; no source/candidate/raw/global/Git edits by reviewer.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/independent-review.json, SHA256 f6c62881aa1b2c8f035cd588b6d4e11b8b543af4a03a6a56616613afe6be7839", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/inputs/enemies-30080-30084/runtime-review/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "68bdf75fcfc9e36e5803e81af307e91c46a72ab88666febfe1291401e8a7cedc" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "26ce2f190978e8c78b69c05c2c1e50e4c0faa6716b81f5c0da237c01e576ac6d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "30080", + "30081", + "30082", + "30083" + ], + "sha256": "87a471ee7483c597619bcafa1a41f41f84681e3942a30262e568a743a977eeb1", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30084" + ], + "sha256": "cdd16f1f605cfe46e24c3bbcffb4ff43587a552b9e8cf13271897e273e17af71", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "30080-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fd536ad9aac9e344e6fe4331f433898abbb167c69ffa94aec9806ad694368e28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30080-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "079b87081e39873b5be9faffe14dce4d027bf00ef7cfc8fd9cdd93c3cedeee01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30080-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b22cd16a11c9ea3efb035b80bc7b3dc3447f8ae7a24d621e9f7185cfe139b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30080-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3026bb9ff8b4f4f313ca7fef0f19a6fdc94edf6f79eb64ca0746332484079269", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30080-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3e1e6ae5ef3819f4bc82778766e1195e67b334749eb22b0b950a353cb7680d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bc6d145991040b69c3b1c20ad055094df2fe9360b28e57a1def1b4f3576ad52", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1ed74c04f89cbfe0fa1c2ed506fa99036eeca0707bad34e212e280dec92c9501", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d959fbbda4ef1bb1a3e75799357d61aa00d11a23d42d917f773e2a10efd9d445", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e678bac84f7983a2834d980ba471739612290201c967ed3f845f3eb7d0971168", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e6f1cc73de3209d87af4b3130d44b011218627d4296eb259290a276b92002f5b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cb1c7a13bdc40f1eccf2e2a3fcba9ff79eaa51a142b5e4b7d6515a7b3a791f4d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "25cea435d141ec8d9a453ad33bf3a9397c5ba4b57a5329921e7de79d3e176d1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "746b84803b2db47a4fae7952ec8cda086a5e9c49e889fd0cc03837baef8e7b03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fad8a48e3b868a0203a5cbc218c707937c0ee7a5ab6694adcce600b04fd8c6f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ace88f16d8d9b49fb9ac34e04137466bb67e8d9e1b160143ad1d305a509f6c86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "32ebaab7e521884d8354069450aa20094c4ca483a59c7c21b898bacf4fe92338", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b25da63039cb7ddece4861d2a226a120f6d340b6677c68ded58ad6a246c212fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "86b26559707c319eb729080b46de9880aa6555d0f8effe44fcd5cce2de1abe77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "28e6c46d40117ab5632eb95e8cf342e8f566f4a881dabc787cd0dda1b48521fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3a5d7a92757bdc7b81278a3f38a27823432b2bdb3cd2e12be800560a3bc46a06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7e56ddacfb74d930186bafe4a0ad431a07ef43e6a2ef94c50c9de12b406394df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "674eae95c1902c100ac9366782d1e930b06068b501ae38088b89bbca6c23e90f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "080847674391cb7141f23910600c4cd61659d4727766afd1e2e8745c724a59d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc9b5f686a39f45aa4f001ad675b64d547f6e866866052466436a6c4c0fa2739", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d017c6f503fa8a58ccb5a52c0dc76c79f71436e906b88d0bc5ed234867738eec", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30084": { @@ -240523,7 +245361,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30084", "family_id": "enemies-30080-30084", "job_id": "enemies-30080-30084", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -240535,6 +245373,176 @@ "manifest": "jobs/enemies-30080-30084/candidate.json", "sha256": "1ace4e117a41b4a2790441b94331eb05bc7d66eb711100a0db325d068726758e", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1ace4e117a41b4a2790441b94331eb05bc7d66eb711100a0db325d068726758e", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "7ef5d4f694e62bab8fa8fd3254ccc6cfd56ca21f4f030a9db231b5e1d7d340df", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:31.125025+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/enemies-30080-30084/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"Four copper slats preserve original five-stage horizontal highlight/recess progression; outer gray tread/bar positions and lower split legs/aperture remain aligned. Fine bronze grain and pale bevels are slightly brighter than the source. Dark source bands become opaque recessed faces, not transparent holes.\", \"Native1 loses only source black contour cell(3,27) in all five frames;2\\u00d7 also loses it only30082/30083. Every source cell survives3\\u20134. Stationary lower rows20\\u201330 retain architecture with89/124/126/128 changed native shades,0/0/4/3 >=32-channel delta.\"] {\"source_phase_differences\": [{\"asset\": \"30080\", \"changed_cells\": 0, \"changed_rows\": {}, \"changes\": []}, {\"asset\": \"30081\", \"changed_cells\": 207, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 13, \"2\": 11, \"3\": 8, \"4\": 7, \"5\": 8, \"6\": 7, \"7\": 10, \"8\": 10, \"9\": 10, \"10\": 13, \"11\": 14, \"12\": 17, \"13\": 12, \"14\": 11, \"15\": 14, \"16\": 15, \"17\": 13, \"18\": 6, \"19\": 8}, \"changes\": [[9, 1, 186, 187], [10, 1, 183, 185], [11, 1, 181, 179], [14, 1, 186, 187], [15, 1, 183, 185], [18, 1, 187, 188], [19, 1, 184, 186], [20, 1, 179, 185], [21, 1, 180, 181], [23, 1, 187, 188], [24, 1, 183, 187], [25, 1, 179, 187], [26, 1, 180, 183], [9, 2, 195, 194], [11, 2, 186, 183], [13, 2, 197, 196], [15, 2, 192, 194], [18, 2, 196, 197], [19, 2, 193, 195], [21, 2, 184, 185], [23, 2, 196, 197], [24, 2, 194, 195], [25, 2, 190, 193], [26, 2, 181, 186], [8, 3, 197, 196], [9, 3, 197, 194], [10, 3, 194, 193], [11, 3, 187, 184], [19, 3, 195, 197], [21, 3, 183, 184], [24, 3, 195, 196], [26, 3, 183, 186], [9, 4, 197, 196], [10, 4, 195, 194], [14, 4, 197, 196], [19, 4, 196, 197], [21, 4, 185, 186], [24, 4, 196, 197], [26, 4, 185, 187], [9, 5, 197, 196], [10, 5, 197, 194], [11, 5, 188, 187], [14, 5, 197, 196], [16, 5, 187, 186], [21, 5, 186, 187], [25, 5, 194, 196], [27, 5, 199, 200], [10, 6, 197, 196], [11, 6, 188, 187], [13, 6, 198, 197], [14, 6, 197, 196], [16, 6, 188, 187], [20, 6, 196, 195], [26, 6, 186, 187], [8, 7, 197, 198], [10, 7, 197, 196], [11, 7, 188, 186], [12, 7, 203, 202], [13, 7, 198, 197], [15, 7, 196, 195], [17, 7, 203, 202], [20, 7, 197, 195], [22, 7, 202, 203], [25, 7, 197, 196], [8, 8, 198, 197], [9, 8, 197, 198], [11, 8, 188, 187], [12, 8, 203, 202], [13, 8, 198, 197], [14, 8, 198, 197], [15, 8, 197, 195], [17, 8, 203, 202], [20, 8, 197, 195], [22, 8, 202, 204], [8, 9, 198, 197], [9, 9, 198, 197], [12, 9, 203, 202], [15, 9, 198, 195], [18, 9, 198, 197], [20, 9, 197, 196], [21, 9, 189, 188], [22, 9, 202, 204], [24, 9, 199, 197], [26, 9, 189, 188], [7, 10, 204, 205], [9, 10, 198, 197], [11, 10, 189, 188], [12, 10, 203, 202], [14, 10, 199, 197], [15, 10, 198, 196], [18, 10, 198, 197], [19, 10, 198, 197], [21, 10, 189, 188], [22, 10, 202, 204], [23, 10, 198, 197], [24, 10, 199, 197], [26, 10, 189, 188], [8, 11, 199, 197], [9, 11, 198, 197], [11, 11, 190, 188], [12, 11, 203, 204], [14, 11, 198, 197], [15, 11, 198, 197], [17, 11, 203, 204], [18, 11, 198, 197], [19, 11, 198, 197], [20, 11, 198, 197], [21, 11, 189, 188], [22, 11, 202, 204], [23, 11, 199, 197], [26, 11, 189, 188], [7, 12, 204, 205], [8, 12, 199, 198], [9, 12, 198, 197], [10, 12, 199, 198], [11, 12, 190, 189], [12, 12, 204, 205], [13, 12, 199, 198], [15, 12, 198, 197], [16, 12, 190, 188], [17, 12, 203, 205], [19, 12, 198, 197], [20, 12, 198, 197], [21, 12, 189, 188], [22, 12, 203, 205], [23, 12, 199, 197], [24, 12, 198, 197], [26, 12, 190, 188], [8, 13, 202, 201], [9, 13, 202, 201], [10, 13, 202, 201], [13, 13, 202, 201], [14, 13, 201, 202], [15, 13, 201, 200], [16, 13, 194, 191], [20, 13, 201, 200], [21, 13, 195, 192], [23, 13, 201, 202], [25, 13, 201, 200], [26, 13, 193, 191], [8, 14, 200, 198], [9, 14, 199, 198], [10, 14, 199, 198], [11, 14, 192, 190], [14, 14, 199, 200], [16, 14, 192, 188], [18, 14, 200, 198], [21, 14, 193, 189], [22, 14, 204, 205], [25, 14, 198, 197], [26, 14, 191, 188], [6, 15, 207, 79], [8, 15, 202, 200], [9, 15, 201, 199], [10, 15, 201, 198], [11, 15, 193, 190], [13, 15, 201, 199], [14, 15, 199, 200], [16, 15, 192, 188], [18, 15, 201, 200], [19, 15, 200, 199], [21, 15, 193, 189], [22, 15, 203, 205], [24, 15, 200, 199], [26, 15, 191, 188], [6, 16, 79, 207], [8, 16, 206, 204], [9, 16, 205, 204], [10, 16, 204, 203], [11, 16, 195, 193], [13, 16, 205, 203], [14, 16, 204, 203], [16, 16, 196, 191], [17, 16, 207, 206], [18, 16, 204, 203], [19, 16, 204, 203], [21, 16, 196, 192], [23, 16, 205, 204], [24, 16, 205, 203], [26, 16, 197, 195], [5, 17, 207, 47], [6, 17, 207, 47], [12, 17, 79, 207], [13, 17, 47, 207], [14, 17, 47, 207], [18, 17, 206, 207], [19, 17, 206, 207], [20, 17, 206, 207], [21, 17, 205, 207], [23, 17, 206, 207], [24, 17, 204, 207], [25, 17, 205, 207], [26, 17, 195, 207], [11, 18, 206, 47], [14, 18, 206, 204], [15, 18, 206, 47], [16, 18, 206, 47], [20, 18, 204, 200], [24, 18, 202, 197], [12, 19, 206, 205], [16, 19, 205, 203], [18, 19, 47, 206], [19, 19, 206, 204], [20, 19, 205, 202], [21, 19, 205, 203], [22, 19, 205, 202], [23, 19, 205, 197]]}, {\"asset\": \"30082\", \"changed_cells\": 299, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 20, \"2\": 17, \"3\": 14, \"4\": 14, \"5\": 11, \"6\": 13, \"7\": 12, \"8\": 13, \"9\": 14, \"10\": 14, \"11\": 19, \"12\": 15, \"13\": 20, \"14\": 19, \"15\": 20, \"16\": 18, \"17\": 19, \"18\": 9, \"19\": 18}, \"changes\": [[7, 1, 195, 200], [8, 1, 188, 189], [9, 1, 186, 189], [10, 1, 183, 188], [11, 1, 181, 184], [12, 1, 195, 198], [13, 1, 188, 190], [14, 1, 186, 187], [15, 1, 183, 189], [16, 1, 181, 183], [17, 1, 195, 198], [18, 1, 187, 189], [19, 1, 184, 189], [20, 1, 179, 189], [21, 1, 180, 184], [22, 1, 195, 197], [23, 1, 187, 190], [24, 1, 183, 187], [25, 1, 179, 187], [26, 1, 180, 183], [7, 2, 202, 205], [8, 2, 196, 197], [9, 2, 195, 197], [10, 2, 193, 195], [11, 2, 186, 187], [12, 2, 202, 204], [13, 2, 197, 198], [15, 2, 192, 196], [17, 2, 202, 204], [18, 2, 196, 197], [19, 2, 193, 196], [20, 2, 193, 196], [21, 2, 184, 188], [23, 2, 196, 199], [24, 2, 194, 195], [25, 2, 190, 194], [26, 2, 181, 187], [7, 3, 202, 205], [9, 3, 197, 196], [11, 3, 187, 185], [12, 3, 202, 204], [13, 3, 197, 198], [14, 3, 196, 194], [15, 3, 194, 196], [16, 3, 186, 182], [17, 3, 202, 203], [21, 3, 183, 188], [22, 3, 202, 199], [23, 3, 197, 198], [24, 3, 195, 197], [25, 3, 194, 195], [7, 4, 202, 204], [9, 4, 197, 195], [10, 4, 195, 193], [11, 4, 186, 182], [12, 4, 202, 204], [13, 4, 197, 198], [14, 4, 197, 195], [15, 4, 195, 196], [16, 4, 186, 182], [21, 4, 185, 187], [22, 4, 202, 201], [24, 4, 196, 197], [25, 4, 195, 196], [26, 4, 185, 182], [7, 5, 202, 204], [9, 5, 197, 196], [10, 5, 197, 193], [11, 5, 188, 181], [12, 5, 202, 203], [16, 5, 187, 181], [20, 5, 195, 194], [22, 5, 202, 201], [25, 5, 194, 196], [26, 5, 187, 181], [27, 5, 199, 200], [7, 6, 202, 204], [9, 6, 197, 196], [10, 6, 197, 194], [11, 6, 188, 183], [12, 6, 202, 203], [13, 6, 198, 199], [15, 6, 196, 194], [16, 6, 188, 180], [20, 6, 196, 194], [21, 6, 187, 184], [22, 6, 202, 201], [25, 6, 196, 197], [26, 6, 186, 181], [7, 7, 202, 203], [9, 7, 197, 196], [10, 7, 197, 194], [11, 7, 188, 186], [12, 7, 203, 202], [15, 7, 196, 195], [16, 7, 188, 182], [20, 7, 197, 194], [21, 7, 188, 185], [22, 7, 202, 200], [25, 7, 197, 196], [26, 7, 187, 184], [8, 8, 198, 197], [9, 8, 197, 196], [10, 8, 197, 194], [13, 8, 198, 197], [14, 8, 198, 197], [15, 8, 197, 195], [16, 8, 188, 185], [17, 8, 203, 204], [20, 8, 197, 195], [21, 8, 188, 186], [22, 8, 202, 200], [25, 8, 197, 196], [26, 8, 188, 185], [7, 9, 203, 205], [8, 9, 198, 197], [9, 9, 198, 197], [10, 9, 198, 195], [12, 9, 203, 204], [13, 9, 198, 197], [15, 9, 198, 196], [16, 9, 188, 184], [17, 9, 203, 205], [18, 9, 198, 197], [20, 9, 197, 195], [21, 9, 189, 188], [24, 9, 199, 197], [26, 9, 189, 185], [7, 10, 204, 205], [9, 10, 198, 197], [10, 10, 198, 196], [11, 10, 189, 188], [14, 10, 199, 197], [15, 10, 198, 197], [16, 10, 188, 186], [17, 10, 203, 205], [19, 10, 198, 197], [20, 10, 197, 196], [21, 10, 189, 187], [22, 10, 202, 203], [24, 10, 199, 197], [26, 10, 189, 186], [7, 11, 205, 207], [8, 11, 199, 202], [9, 11, 198, 200], [10, 11, 198, 199], [11, 11, 190, 191], [12, 11, 203, 206], [13, 11, 199, 201], [14, 11, 198, 200], [15, 11, 198, 200], [16, 11, 188, 190], [17, 11, 203, 207], [18, 11, 198, 202], [19, 11, 198, 200], [20, 11, 198, 199], [21, 11, 189, 190], [22, 11, 202, 207], [23, 11, 199, 201], [24, 11, 197, 200], [25, 11, 197, 200], [9, 12, 198, 197], [10, 12, 199, 196], [11, 12, 190, 188], [12, 12, 204, 203], [14, 12, 198, 197], [15, 12, 198, 197], [16, 12, 190, 188], [17, 12, 203, 204], [18, 12, 198, 199], [19, 12, 198, 197], [20, 12, 198, 196], [21, 12, 189, 187], [22, 12, 203, 204], [24, 12, 198, 197], [26, 12, 190, 187], [7, 13, 207, 205], [8, 13, 202, 199], [9, 13, 202, 199], [10, 13, 202, 196], [11, 13, 193, 187], [12, 13, 207, 203], [13, 13, 202, 199], [14, 13, 201, 198], [15, 13, 201, 197], [16, 13, 194, 188], [17, 13, 207, 204], [18, 13, 202, 200], [19, 13, 201, 198], [20, 13, 201, 197], [21, 13, 195, 187], [22, 13, 207, 203], [23, 13, 201, 200], [24, 13, 201, 197], [25, 13, 201, 197], [26, 13, 193, 188], [6, 14, 207, 79], [8, 14, 200, 203], [9, 14, 199, 204], [10, 14, 199, 202], [11, 14, 192, 191], [13, 14, 199, 202], [14, 14, 199, 203], [15, 14, 198, 203], [16, 14, 192, 191], [17, 14, 205, 206], [18, 14, 200, 203], [19, 14, 199, 203], [20, 14, 198, 202], [21, 14, 193, 191], [22, 14, 204, 206], [23, 14, 200, 204], [24, 14, 198, 203], [25, 14, 198, 202], [26, 14, 191, 195], [7, 15, 206, 207], [8, 15, 202, 239], [9, 15, 201, 31], [10, 15, 201, 239], [11, 15, 193, 207], [12, 15, 206, 207], [13, 15, 201, 239], [14, 15, 199, 31], [15, 15, 198, 239], [16, 15, 192, 207], [17, 15, 205, 207], [18, 15, 201, 239], [19, 15, 200, 31], [20, 15, 198, 239], [21, 15, 193, 207], [22, 15, 203, 207], [23, 15, 200, 239], [24, 15, 200, 31], [25, 15, 198, 239], [26, 15, 191, 207], [6, 16, 79, 207], [7, 16, 206, 207], [8, 16, 206, 239], [9, 16, 205, 31], [10, 16, 204, 239], [11, 16, 195, 207], [13, 16, 205, 239], [14, 16, 204, 31], [15, 16, 204, 239], [16, 16, 196, 207], [18, 16, 204, 239], [19, 16, 204, 31], [20, 16, 204, 239], [21, 16, 196, 207], [23, 16, 205, 239], [24, 16, 205, 31], [25, 16, 203, 239], [26, 16, 197, 207], [5, 17, 207, 47], [6, 17, 207, 47], [8, 17, 207, 47], [9, 17, 207, 47], [10, 17, 207, 47], [12, 17, 79, 47], [14, 17, 47, 206], [15, 17, 207, 205], [16, 17, 207, 205], [17, 17, 207, 205], [18, 17, 206, 204], [19, 17, 206, 204], [20, 17, 206, 197], [21, 17, 205, 193], [22, 17, 207, 202], [23, 17, 206, 202], [24, 17, 204, 191], [25, 17, 205, 198], [26, 17, 195, 192], [13, 18, 205, 203], [14, 18, 206, 201], [18, 18, 205, 202], [19, 18, 205, 202], [20, 18, 204, 194], [21, 18, 205, 202], [22, 18, 205, 202], [23, 18, 205, 197], [24, 18, 202, 190], [5, 19, 206, 204], [6, 19, 201, 196], [8, 19, 206, 205], [9, 19, 206, 204], [10, 19, 205, 203], [11, 19, 204, 200], [12, 19, 206, 203], [13, 19, 204, 201], [14, 19, 205, 202], [15, 19, 205, 202], [16, 19, 205, 199], [17, 19, 47, 206], [18, 19, 47, 205], [19, 19, 206, 201], [20, 19, 205, 197], [21, 19, 205, 199], [22, 19, 205, 197], [23, 19, 205, 197]]}, {\"asset\": \"30083\", \"changed_cells\": 335, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 20, \"2\": 19, \"3\": 17, \"4\": 15, \"5\": 13, \"6\": 13, \"7\": 18, \"8\": 19, \"9\": 19, \"10\": 18, \"11\": 17, \"12\": 19, \"13\": 19, \"14\": 19, \"15\": 21, \"16\": 19, \"17\": 20, \"18\": 12, \"19\": 18}, \"changes\": [[7, 1, 195, 203], [8, 1, 188, 190], [9, 1, 186, 190], [10, 1, 183, 188], [11, 1, 181, 185], [12, 1, 195, 202], [13, 1, 188, 190], [14, 1, 186, 190], [15, 1, 183, 190], [16, 1, 181, 185], [17, 1, 195, 203], [18, 1, 187, 191], [19, 1, 184, 190], [20, 1, 179, 190], [21, 1, 180, 185], [22, 1, 195, 201], [23, 1, 187, 192], [24, 1, 183, 190], [25, 1, 179, 190], [26, 1, 180, 185], [7, 2, 202, 206], [8, 2, 196, 197], [9, 2, 195, 197], [10, 2, 193, 195], [11, 2, 186, 188], [12, 2, 202, 205], [14, 2, 194, 196], [15, 2, 192, 197], [16, 2, 185, 188], [17, 2, 202, 205], [18, 2, 196, 197], [19, 2, 193, 197], [20, 2, 193, 197], [21, 2, 184, 188], [22, 2, 202, 205], [23, 2, 196, 199], [24, 2, 194, 197], [25, 2, 190, 197], [26, 2, 181, 187], [7, 3, 202, 206], [8, 3, 197, 196], [10, 3, 194, 196], [11, 3, 187, 186], [12, 3, 202, 205], [14, 3, 196, 195], [15, 3, 194, 197], [16, 3, 186, 187], [17, 3, 202, 205], [19, 3, 195, 197], [20, 3, 194, 196], [21, 3, 183, 189], [22, 3, 202, 205], [23, 3, 197, 199], [24, 3, 195, 197], [25, 3, 194, 197], [26, 3, 183, 187], [7, 4, 202, 206], [10, 4, 195, 196], [11, 4, 186, 184], [12, 4, 202, 204], [14, 4, 197, 196], [15, 4, 195, 197], [16, 4, 186, 185], [17, 4, 202, 205], [19, 4, 196, 197], [20, 4, 194, 195], [21, 4, 185, 189], [22, 4, 202, 205], [23, 4, 197, 198], [25, 4, 195, 196], [26, 4, 185, 187], [7, 5, 202, 206], [10, 5, 197, 194], [11, 5, 188, 185], [12, 5, 202, 203], [14, 5, 197, 195], [16, 5, 187, 184], [17, 5, 202, 205], [21, 5, 186, 187], [22, 5, 202, 203], [23, 5, 197, 198], [25, 5, 194, 196], [26, 5, 187, 188], [27, 5, 199, 200], [7, 6, 202, 205], [10, 6, 197, 194], [11, 6, 188, 183], [13, 6, 198, 197], [14, 6, 197, 196], [15, 6, 196, 195], [16, 6, 188, 185], [17, 6, 202, 203], [20, 6, 196, 195], [21, 6, 187, 184], [22, 6, 202, 203], [23, 6, 197, 198], [25, 6, 196, 195], [7, 7, 202, 203], [9, 7, 197, 196], [10, 7, 197, 193], [11, 7, 188, 180], [12, 7, 203, 202], [13, 7, 198, 197], [14, 7, 197, 196], [15, 7, 196, 194], [16, 7, 188, 181], [17, 7, 203, 202], [19, 7, 197, 196], [20, 7, 197, 193], [21, 7, 188, 184], [22, 7, 202, 203], [23, 7, 197, 198], [24, 7, 197, 196], [25, 7, 197, 195], [26, 7, 187, 183], [7, 8, 203, 202], [8, 8, 198, 197], [9, 8, 197, 196], [10, 8, 197, 194], [11, 8, 188, 180], [12, 8, 203, 200], [13, 8, 198, 197], [14, 8, 198, 196], [15, 8, 197, 194], [16, 8, 188, 182], [17, 8, 203, 202], [19, 8, 197, 195], [20, 8, 197, 193], [21, 8, 188, 183], [22, 8, 202, 203], [23, 8, 197, 198], [24, 8, 197, 195], [25, 8, 197, 196], [26, 8, 188, 183], [7, 9, 203, 206], [8, 9, 198, 200], [9, 9, 198, 199], [10, 9, 198, 196], [11, 9, 188, 185], [12, 9, 203, 204], [13, 9, 198, 200], [14, 9, 197, 199], [15, 9, 198, 197], [16, 9, 188, 184], [17, 9, 203, 206], [18, 9, 198, 200], [19, 9, 197, 198], [21, 9, 189, 186], [22, 9, 202, 206], [23, 9, 197, 200], [24, 9, 199, 198], [25, 9, 197, 198], [26, 9, 189, 184], [8, 10, 198, 197], [9, 10, 198, 196], [10, 10, 198, 195], [11, 10, 189, 185], [13, 10, 198, 197], [14, 10, 199, 196], [15, 10, 198, 195], [16, 10, 188, 184], [17, 10, 203, 204], [18, 10, 198, 197], [19, 10, 198, 196], [20, 10, 197, 195], [21, 10, 189, 188], [22, 10, 202, 204], [23, 10, 198, 197], [24, 10, 199, 195], [25, 10, 197, 196], [26, 10, 189, 182], [7, 11, 205, 204], [8, 11, 199, 198], [9, 11, 198, 196], [10, 11, 198, 196], [11, 11, 190, 186], [12, 11, 203, 204], [13, 11, 199, 197], [14, 11, 198, 197], [15, 11, 198, 196], [17, 11, 203, 204], [19, 11, 198, 197], [20, 11, 198, 196], [21, 11, 189, 187], [22, 11, 202, 204], [23, 11, 199, 197], [24, 11, 197, 196], [26, 11, 189, 184], [7, 12, 204, 206], [8, 12, 199, 203], [9, 12, 198, 200], [10, 12, 199, 202], [12, 12, 204, 207], [13, 12, 199, 204], [14, 12, 198, 202], [15, 12, 198, 202], [16, 12, 190, 191], [17, 12, 203, 206], [18, 12, 198, 203], [19, 12, 198, 202], [20, 12, 198, 202], [21, 12, 189, 190], [22, 12, 203, 207], [23, 12, 199, 204], [24, 12, 198, 202], [25, 12, 197, 202], [26, 12, 190, 195], [8, 13, 202, 239], [9, 13, 202, 31], [10, 13, 202, 238], [11, 13, 193, 207], [12, 13, 207, 206], [13, 13, 202, 239], [14, 13, 201, 31], [15, 13, 201, 238], [16, 13, 194, 207], [17, 13, 207, 206], [18, 13, 202, 239], [19, 13, 201, 31], [20, 13, 201, 238], [21, 13, 195, 207], [22, 13, 207, 206], [23, 13, 201, 239], [24, 13, 201, 31], [25, 13, 201, 238], [26, 13, 193, 205], [7, 14, 206, 207], [8, 14, 200, 31], [9, 14, 199, 31], [10, 14, 199, 31], [11, 14, 192, 207], [13, 14, 199, 31], [14, 14, 199, 31], [15, 14, 198, 31], [16, 14, 192, 207], [17, 14, 205, 206], [18, 14, 200, 31], [19, 14, 199, 31], [20, 14, 198, 31], [21, 14, 193, 207], [22, 14, 204, 206], [23, 14, 200, 31], [24, 14, 198, 31], [25, 14, 198, 31], [26, 14, 191, 206], [6, 15, 207, 79], [7, 15, 206, 207], [8, 15, 202, 239], [9, 15, 201, 31], [10, 15, 201, 239], [11, 15, 193, 207], [12, 15, 206, 207], [13, 15, 201, 239], [14, 15, 199, 31], [15, 15, 198, 239], [16, 15, 192, 207], [17, 15, 205, 207], [18, 15, 201, 239], [19, 15, 200, 31], [20, 15, 198, 239], [21, 15, 193, 207], [22, 15, 203, 207], [23, 15, 200, 239], [24, 15, 200, 31], [25, 15, 198, 239], [26, 15, 191, 206], [6, 16, 79, 207], [7, 16, 206, 207], [8, 16, 206, 207], [9, 16, 205, 207], [10, 16, 204, 207], [11, 16, 195, 207], [12, 16, 207, 79], [13, 16, 205, 206], [14, 16, 204, 206], [16, 16, 196, 204], [17, 16, 207, 200], [18, 16, 204, 197], [19, 16, 204, 193], [20, 16, 204, 191], [21, 16, 196, 186], [22, 16, 207, 197], [23, 16, 205, 197], [24, 16, 205, 194], [25, 16, 203, 198], [5, 17, 207, 47], [6, 17, 207, 47], [8, 17, 207, 47], [9, 17, 207, 47], [10, 17, 207, 47], [12, 17, 79, 47], [13, 17, 47, 206], [14, 17, 47, 204], [15, 17, 207, 203], [16, 17, 207, 202], [17, 17, 207, 202], [18, 17, 206, 196], [19, 17, 206, 194], [20, 17, 206, 191], [21, 17, 205, 186], [22, 17, 207, 197], [23, 17, 206, 197], [24, 17, 204, 191], [25, 17, 205, 198], [26, 17, 195, 192], [13, 18, 205, 203], [14, 18, 206, 201], [15, 18, 206, 204], [16, 18, 206, 205], [17, 18, 47, 206], [18, 18, 205, 197], [19, 18, 205, 197], [20, 18, 204, 187], [21, 18, 205, 197], [22, 18, 205, 197], [23, 18, 205, 197], [24, 18, 202, 190], [5, 19, 206, 204], [6, 19, 201, 196], [8, 19, 206, 205], [9, 19, 206, 204], [10, 19, 205, 203], [11, 19, 204, 200], [12, 19, 206, 203], [13, 19, 204, 201], [14, 19, 205, 202], [15, 19, 205, 202], [16, 19, 205, 199], [17, 19, 47, 206], [18, 19, 47, 205], [19, 19, 206, 201], [20, 19, 205, 197], [21, 19, 205, 199], [22, 19, 205, 197], [23, 19, 205, 197]]}, {\"asset\": \"30084\", \"changed_cells\": 339, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 20, \"2\": 20, \"3\": 19, \"4\": 17, \"5\": 13, \"6\": 12, \"7\": 12, \"8\": 19, \"9\": 16, \"10\": 18, \"11\": 20, \"12\": 20, \"13\": 20, \"14\": 20, \"15\": 21, \"16\": 19, \"17\": 20, \"18\": 15, \"19\": 18}, \"changes\": [[7, 1, 195, 206], [8, 1, 188, 193], [9, 1, 186, 191], [10, 1, 183, 191], [11, 1, 181, 186], [12, 1, 195, 205], [13, 1, 188, 194], [14, 1, 186, 191], [15, 1, 183, 191], [16, 1, 181, 187], [17, 1, 195, 204], [18, 1, 187, 194], [19, 1, 184, 192], [20, 1, 179, 191], [21, 1, 180, 186], [22, 1, 195, 206], [23, 1, 187, 194], [24, 1, 183, 192], [25, 1, 179, 191], [26, 1, 180, 186], [7, 2, 202, 206], [8, 2, 196, 200], [9, 2, 195, 197], [10, 2, 193, 197], [11, 2, 186, 188], [12, 2, 202, 206], [13, 2, 197, 201], [14, 2, 194, 197], [15, 2, 192, 197], [16, 2, 185, 189], [17, 2, 202, 206], [18, 2, 196, 201], [19, 2, 193, 197], [20, 2, 193, 197], [21, 2, 184, 188], [22, 2, 202, 206], [23, 2, 196, 199], [24, 2, 194, 198], [25, 2, 190, 197], [26, 2, 181, 188], [7, 3, 202, 206], [8, 3, 197, 199], [10, 3, 194, 197], [11, 3, 187, 188], [12, 3, 202, 206], [13, 3, 197, 200], [14, 3, 196, 197], [15, 3, 194, 197], [16, 3, 186, 189], [17, 3, 202, 206], [18, 3, 197, 199], [19, 3, 195, 197], [20, 3, 194, 197], [21, 3, 183, 188], [22, 3, 202, 206], [23, 3, 197, 199], [24, 3, 195, 198], [25, 3, 194, 197], [26, 3, 183, 187], [7, 4, 202, 205], [8, 4, 197, 198], [10, 4, 195, 197], [11, 4, 186, 187], [12, 4, 202, 206], [15, 4, 195, 197], [16, 4, 186, 188], [17, 4, 202, 206], [18, 4, 197, 198], [19, 4, 196, 197], [20, 4, 194, 197], [21, 4, 185, 186], [22, 4, 202, 205], [23, 4, 197, 199], [24, 4, 196, 198], [25, 4, 195, 197], [26, 4, 185, 186], [7, 5, 202, 204], [11, 5, 188, 186], [12, 5, 202, 206], [15, 5, 196, 197], [16, 5, 187, 188], [17, 5, 202, 204], [20, 5, 195, 197], [21, 5, 186, 184], [22, 5, 202, 205], [23, 5, 197, 198], [25, 5, 194, 196], [26, 5, 187, 186], [27, 5, 199, 200], [7, 6, 202, 203], [11, 6, 188, 186], [12, 6, 202, 205], [13, 6, 198, 197], [15, 6, 196, 197], [16, 6, 188, 186], [17, 6, 202, 204], [21, 6, 187, 184], [22, 6, 202, 205], [23, 6, 197, 198], [25, 6, 196, 195], [26, 6, 186, 185], [7, 7, 202, 203], [10, 7, 197, 196], [11, 7, 188, 185], [13, 7, 198, 197], [15, 7, 196, 197], [16, 7, 188, 185], [20, 7, 197, 196], [21, 7, 188, 182], [22, 7, 202, 203], [23, 7, 197, 198], [25, 7, 197, 194], [26, 7, 187, 182], [7, 8, 203, 205], [8, 8, 198, 200], [9, 8, 197, 200], [10, 8, 197, 198], [11, 8, 188, 186], [12, 8, 203, 206], [13, 8, 198, 200], [14, 8, 198, 200], [15, 8, 197, 198], [16, 8, 188, 186], [17, 8, 203, 206], [18, 8, 197, 200], [19, 8, 197, 200], [20, 8, 197, 198], [21, 8, 188, 183], [22, 8, 202, 205], [23, 8, 197, 200], [24, 8, 197, 200], [25, 8, 197, 195], [7, 9, 203, 202], [8, 9, 198, 197], [9, 9, 198, 197], [10, 9, 198, 194], [11, 9, 188, 180], [12, 9, 203, 202], [13, 9, 198, 197], [14, 9, 197, 196], [15, 9, 198, 195], [16, 9, 188, 180], [18, 9, 198, 197], [20, 9, 197, 191], [21, 9, 189, 179], [24, 9, 199, 195], [25, 9, 197, 191], [26, 9, 189, 182], [7, 10, 204, 202], [8, 10, 198, 197], [9, 10, 198, 196], [10, 10, 198, 192], [11, 10, 189, 176], [12, 10, 203, 202], [13, 10, 198, 197], [14, 10, 199, 195], [15, 10, 198, 192], [16, 10, 188, 179], [18, 10, 198, 196], [19, 10, 198, 193], [20, 10, 197, 189], [21, 10, 189, 178], [23, 10, 198, 196], [24, 10, 199, 191], [25, 10, 197, 189], [26, 10, 189, 181], [7, 11, 205, 204], [8, 11, 199, 200], [9, 11, 198, 195], [10, 11, 198, 191], [11, 11, 190, 183], [12, 11, 203, 205], [13, 11, 199, 201], [14, 11, 198, 195], [15, 11, 198, 191], [16, 11, 188, 183], [17, 11, 203, 205], [18, 11, 198, 199], [19, 11, 198, 197], [20, 11, 198, 193], [21, 11, 189, 185], [22, 11, 202, 205], [24, 11, 197, 193], [25, 11, 197, 194], [26, 11, 189, 190], [27, 11, 199, 198], [7, 12, 204, 206], [8, 12, 199, 238], [9, 12, 198, 31], [10, 12, 199, 237], [11, 12, 190, 205], [12, 12, 204, 206], [13, 12, 199, 238], [14, 12, 198, 31], [15, 12, 198, 237], [16, 12, 190, 203], [17, 12, 203, 206], [18, 12, 198, 238], [19, 12, 198, 31], [20, 12, 198, 237], [21, 12, 189, 204], [22, 12, 203, 206], [23, 12, 199, 238], [24, 12, 198, 31], [25, 12, 197, 237], [26, 12, 190, 205], [7, 13, 207, 206], [8, 13, 202, 31], [9, 13, 202, 31], [10, 13, 202, 31], [11, 13, 193, 205], [12, 13, 207, 206], [13, 13, 202, 31], [14, 13, 201, 31], [15, 13, 201, 31], [16, 13, 194, 205], [17, 13, 207, 206], [18, 13, 202, 31], [19, 13, 201, 31], [20, 13, 201, 31], [21, 13, 195, 205], [22, 13, 207, 206], [23, 13, 201, 31], [24, 13, 201, 31], [25, 13, 201, 31], [26, 13, 193, 205], [7, 14, 206, 207], [8, 14, 200, 238], [9, 14, 199, 31], [10, 14, 199, 237], [11, 14, 192, 206], [12, 14, 206, 207], [13, 14, 199, 238], [14, 14, 199, 31], [15, 14, 198, 237], [16, 14, 192, 206], [17, 14, 205, 207], [18, 14, 200, 238], [19, 14, 199, 31], [20, 14, 198, 237], [21, 14, 193, 206], [22, 14, 204, 207], [23, 14, 200, 238], [24, 14, 198, 31], [25, 14, 198, 237], [26, 14, 191, 206], [6, 15, 207, 79], [7, 15, 206, 207], [8, 15, 202, 207], [9, 15, 201, 206], [10, 15, 201, 206], [11, 15, 193, 206], [12, 15, 206, 207], [13, 15, 201, 207], [14, 15, 199, 206], [15, 15, 198, 206], [16, 15, 192, 206], [17, 15, 205, 207], [18, 15, 201, 207], [19, 15, 200, 206], [20, 15, 198, 206], [21, 15, 193, 206], [22, 15, 203, 207], [23, 15, 200, 207], [24, 15, 200, 206], [25, 15, 198, 206], [26, 15, 191, 206], [6, 16, 79, 207], [7, 16, 206, 207], [8, 16, 206, 207], [9, 16, 205, 207], [10, 16, 204, 207], [11, 16, 195, 207], [12, 16, 207, 79], [13, 16, 205, 206], [14, 16, 204, 206], [16, 16, 196, 204], [17, 16, 207, 200], [18, 16, 204, 197], [19, 16, 204, 193], [20, 16, 204, 191], [21, 16, 196, 186], [22, 16, 207, 197], [23, 16, 205, 197], [24, 16, 205, 194], [25, 16, 203, 198], [5, 17, 207, 47], [6, 17, 207, 47], [8, 17, 207, 47], [9, 17, 207, 47], [10, 17, 207, 47], [12, 17, 79, 47], [13, 17, 47, 204], [14, 17, 47, 200], [15, 17, 207, 199], [16, 17, 207, 197], [17, 17, 207, 197], [18, 17, 206, 196], [19, 17, 206, 194], [20, 17, 206, 191], [21, 17, 205, 186], [22, 17, 207, 197], [23, 17, 206, 197], [24, 17, 204, 191], [25, 17, 205, 198], [26, 17, 195, 192], [9, 18, 47, 206], [10, 18, 47, 206], [11, 18, 206, 204], [13, 18, 205, 199], [14, 18, 206, 196], [15, 18, 206, 204], [16, 18, 206, 205], [17, 18, 47, 206], [18, 18, 205, 197], [19, 18, 205, 197], [20, 18, 204, 187], [21, 18, 205, 197], [22, 18, 205, 197], [23, 18, 205, 197], [24, 18, 202, 190], [5, 19, 206, 204], [6, 19, 201, 196], [8, 19, 206, 205], [9, 19, 206, 204], [10, 19, 205, 203], [11, 19, 204, 200], [12, 19, 206, 203], [13, 19, 204, 201], [14, 19, 205, 202], [15, 19, 205, 202], [16, 19, 205, 199], [17, 19, 47, 206], [18, 19, 47, 205], [19, 19, 206, 201], [20, 19, 205, 197], [21, 19, 205, 199], [22, 19, 205, 197], [23, 19, 205, 197]]}], \"all_phase_source_stationary_occupied_cells\": 341, \"independent_row_based_metrics_match_worker\": true, \"row_based_metrics\": [{\"asset\": \"30081\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 89, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 0, \"max_channel_difference\": 20}, {\"asset\": \"30082\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 124, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 0, \"max_channel_difference\": 28}, {\"asset\": \"30083\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 126, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 4, \"max_channel_difference\": 33}, {\"asset\": \"30084\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 128, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 3, \"max_channel_difference\": 33}], \"all_source_stationary_comparisons\": [{\"asset\": \"30081\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 133, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 341, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 624, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1364, \"opacity_changes\": [[6, 53, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1638, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 3069, \"opacity_changes\": [[9, 19, 29, 256], [9, 31, 30, 256], [9, 43, 30, 256], [9, 55, 30, 256], [86, 55, 256, 28], [9, 67, 30, 256], [86, 67, 256, 28], [13, 89, 0, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2885, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 5456, \"opacity_changes\": [[111, 10, 235, 256], [12, 25, 29, 256], [12, 26, 29, 256], [12, 41, 29, 256], [12, 42, 29, 256], [12, 57, 29, 256], [12, 58, 29, 256], [12, 73, 29, 256], [12, 74, 29, 256], [12, 89, 29, 256], [115, 89, 256, 28], [13, 107, 31, 256], [115, 105, 256, 30], [15, 109, 31, 256], [42, 112, 256, 239], [42, 113, 256, 239], [42, 114, 256, 239], [42, 115, 256, 239], [17, 118, 31, 256], [21, 122, 31, 256], [21, 123, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}]}, {\"asset\": \"30082\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 187, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 341, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 842, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1364, \"opacity_changes\": [[6, 53, 31, 256], [23, 53, 256, 30], [7, 54, 31, 256], [41, 55, 31, 256], [42, 58, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1962, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 3069, \"opacity_changes\": [[86, 9, 256, 237], [9, 79, 0, 256], [60, 79, 31, 256], [60, 80, 31, 256], [60, 81, 31, 256], [60, 82, 31, 256], [62, 83, 239, 256], [13, 89, 0, 256], [63, 87, 31, 256], [15, 91, 31, 256], [67, 92, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3485, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 5456, \"opacity_changes\": [[110, 8, 256, 237], [110, 9, 256, 237], [12, 25, 29, 256], [12, 26, 29, 256], [12, 41, 29, 256], [12, 42, 29, 256], [115, 40, 29, 256], [12, 73, 29, 256], [12, 90, 256, 29], [13, 107, 31, 256], [80, 105, 31, 256], [80, 106, 31, 256], [80, 107, 31, 256], [115, 105, 256, 30], [14, 108, 0, 256], [15, 109, 31, 256], [80, 108, 31, 256], [80, 109, 31, 256], [81, 110, 31, 256], [83, 111, 239, 256], [111, 110, 256, 30], [111, 111, 256, 30], [42, 112, 256, 239], [42, 113, 256, 30], [42, 114, 256, 31], [42, 115, 256, 31], [111, 112, 256, 30], [111, 113, 256, 30], [111, 114, 256, 30], [111, 115, 256, 31], [16, 117, 0, 256], [17, 118, 31, 256], [18, 119, 0, 256], [19, 119, 0, 256], [39, 119, 239, 256], [84, 116, 0, 256], [85, 117, 31, 256], [86, 119, 30, 256], [87, 119, 31, 256], [107, 119, 30, 256], [21, 122, 31, 256], [21, 123, 31, 256], [88, 121, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}]}, {\"asset\": \"30083\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 191, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 341, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 20, 33.0, [117.0, 69.0, 56.0], [150.0, 101.0, 85.0]], [15, 22, 32.0, [93.0, 48.0, 40.0], [125.0, 77.0, 65.0]], [16, 22, 32.0, [93.0, 48.0, 40.0], [125.0, 77.0, 65.0]], [9, 23, 33.0, [48.0, 32.0, 28.0], [81.0, 36.0, 32.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 789, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1364, \"opacity_changes\": [[6, 53, 31, 256], [7, 54, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[15, 21, 36.5, [44.5, 22.0, 19.0], [8.0, 6.0, 5.0]], [16, 21, 40.5, [46.5, 24.0, 20.0], [6.0, 4.0, 3.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 2}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1792, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 3069, \"opacity_changes\": [[86, 19, 256, 28], [86, 31, 256, 28], [86, 44, 29, 256], [86, 55, 256, 29], [86, 56, 29, 256], [86, 67, 256, 28], [35, 78, 30, 256], [86, 79, 256, 30], [32, 83, 239, 256], [60, 82, 31, 256], [62, 83, 239, 256], [83, 86, 239, 256], [13, 89, 0, 256], [29, 89, 239, 256], [80, 89, 31, 256], [15, 91, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[15, 21, 36.3333, [39.888888888888886, 23.88888888888889, 19.666666666666668], [3.5555555555555554, 3.5555555555555554, 3.5555555555555554]], [16, 21, 39.2222, [43.22222222222222, 27.88888888888889, 23.0], [4.0, 3.111111111111111, 2.6666666666666665]], [15, 22, 34.4444, [98.11111111111111, 66.44444444444444, 56.22222222222222], [132.55555555555554, 85.44444444444444, 71.44444444444444]], [16, 22, 32.1111, [100.55555555555556, 65.55555555555556, 55.22222222222222], [132.66666666666666, 85.44444444444444, 71.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3169, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 5456, \"opacity_changes\": [[24, 4, 238, 256], [25, 4, 237, 256], [26, 4, 237, 256], [27, 4, 237, 256], [111, 10, 235, 256], [115, 25, 256, 28], [115, 41, 256, 28], [115, 43, 29, 256], [115, 59, 30, 256], [115, 73, 256, 29], [115, 75, 30, 256], [115, 89, 256, 29], [13, 107, 31, 256], [47, 104, 31, 256], [115, 105, 256, 31], [81, 110, 31, 256], [83, 111, 239, 256], [16, 117, 0, 256], [18, 119, 0, 256], [38, 119, 239, 256], [39, 119, 239, 256], [85, 117, 31, 256], [86, 119, 30, 256], [87, 119, 31, 256], [107, 119, 30, 256], [21, 122, 31, 256], [21, 123, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[15, 21, 38.25, [40.25, 26.5, 21.75], [2.0, 2.0, 2.0]], [16, 21, 39.75, [41.75, 28.5, 24.0], [2.0, 2.0, 2.0]], [15, 22, 35.5625, [98.25, 62.25, 51.6875], [133.8125, 86.75, 71.125]], [16, 22, 36.3125, [99.5, 64.6875, 53.25], [135.8125, 88.5, 72.9375]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}]}, {\"asset\": \"30084\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 203, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 341, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 20, 33.0, [117.0, 69.0, 56.0], [150.0, 101.0, 85.0]], [15, 22, 32.0, [93.0, 48.0, 40.0], [125.0, 77.0, 65.0]], [16, 22, 32.0, [93.0, 48.0, 40.0], [125.0, 77.0, 65.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 907, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1364, \"opacity_changes\": [[57, 53, 256, 31]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 18, 32.5, [61.5, 27.0, 23.0], [94.0, 49.25, 42.25]], [15, 21, 36.5, [44.5, 22.0, 19.0], [8.0, 6.0, 5.0]], [16, 21, 42.5, [46.5, 24.0, 20.0], [4.0, 4.0, 4.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2077, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 3069, \"opacity_changes\": [[18, 3, 238, 256], [19, 3, 206, 256], [20, 3, 204, 256], [86, 19, 256, 30], [86, 31, 256, 31], [86, 43, 256, 0], [86, 55, 256, 0], [86, 67, 256, 0], [9, 80, 256, 0], [86, 79, 256, 0], [86, 80, 256, 30], [9, 81, 256, 31], [10, 81, 256, 31], [11, 82, 256, 31], [11, 83, 256, 31], [32, 83, 239, 256], [60, 82, 31, 256], [12, 88, 256, 0], [29, 89, 239, 256], [67, 92, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[12, 18, 32.5556, [58.111111111111114, 24.88888888888889, 21.333333333333332], [90.66666666666667, 46.0, 39.666666666666664]], [15, 21, 37.2222, [39.888888888888886, 23.88888888888889, 19.666666666666668], [2.6666666666666665, 2.6666666666666665, 2.6666666666666665]], [16, 21, 41.0, [43.22222222222222, 27.88888888888889, 23.0], [2.2222222222222223, 2.2222222222222223, 2.2222222222222223]], [15, 22, 37.7778, [98.11111111111111, 66.44444444444444, 56.22222222222222], [135.88888888888889, 88.55555555555556, 73.55555555555556]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 4}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 3747, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 5456, \"opacity_changes\": [[24, 4, 238, 256], [25, 4, 237, 256], [26, 4, 237, 256], [27, 4, 237, 256], [110, 9, 256, 27], [111, 10, 235, 256], [115, 25, 256, 30], [115, 26, 256, 30], [115, 41, 256, 31], [115, 42, 256, 31], [115, 57, 256, 0], [115, 58, 256, 0], [115, 73, 256, 0], [115, 74, 256, 0], [12, 90, 256, 0], [115, 89, 256, 0], [115, 90, 256, 0], [12, 106, 256, 0], [12, 107, 256, 0], [115, 105, 256, 0], [115, 106, 256, 0], [114, 107, 256, 0], [12, 108, 256, 0], [13, 108, 256, 0], [15, 110, 256, 0], [15, 111, 256, 0], [42, 111, 239, 256], [81, 110, 31, 256], [111, 110, 256, 239], [111, 111, 256, 239], [111, 112, 256, 239], [111, 113, 256, 239], [111, 114, 256, 30], [111, 115, 256, 30], [38, 119, 239, 256], [39, 119, 239, 256], [86, 119, 30, 256], [35, 123, 0, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[15, 21, 38.25, [40.25, 26.5, 21.75], [2.0, 2.0, 2.0]], [16, 21, 39.75, [41.75, 28.5, 24.0], [2.0, 2.0, 2.0]], [15, 22, 34.8125, [98.25, 62.25, 51.6875], [133.0625, 86.75, 71.0625]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}]}]} [\"Isolated actual Catalog/HdAssets source-bound sprite raster and artistic approval only. No new Host enemy occurrence, animation timing, terrain blend, gameplay, simulation-neutrality or fullscreen capture.\", \"Broader game-source freshness flag is true due to unrelated menu/game edits; relevant assets/hd loader source is current.\", \"Complete shared family scale, origin and all rawalpha>=16/>=32 crop retention independently verified. Palette classes, forced indices and all240\\u2013255counts pass; these numeric checks do not substitute for the completed artistic review.\", \"Original/source and newly authored stationary body shading are not byte identical; localized variations and native/2\\u00d7 contour smoothing are deliberately disclosed.\", \"Global registration and bundled pack snapshot remain coordinator-owned; no source/candidate/raw/global/Git edits by reviewer.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/independent-review.json, SHA256 f6c62881aa1b2c8f035cd588b6d4e11b8b543af4a03a6a56616613afe6be7839", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/inputs/enemies-30080-30084/runtime-review/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "68bdf75fcfc9e36e5803e81af307e91c46a72ab88666febfe1291401e8a7cedc" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "26ce2f190978e8c78b69c05c2c1e50e4c0faa6716b81f5c0da237c01e576ac6d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "30080", + "30081", + "30082", + "30083" + ], + "sha256": "87a471ee7483c597619bcafa1a41f41f84681e3942a30262e568a743a977eeb1", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30084" + ], + "sha256": "cdd16f1f605cfe46e24c3bbcffb4ff43587a552b9e8cf13271897e273e17af71", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "30080-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fd536ad9aac9e344e6fe4331f433898abbb167c69ffa94aec9806ad694368e28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30080-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "079b87081e39873b5be9faffe14dce4d027bf00ef7cfc8fd9cdd93c3cedeee01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30080-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b22cd16a11c9ea3efb035b80bc7b3dc3447f8ae7a24d621e9f7185cfe139b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30080-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3026bb9ff8b4f4f313ca7fef0f19a6fdc94edf6f79eb64ca0746332484079269", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30080-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3e1e6ae5ef3819f4bc82778766e1195e67b334749eb22b0b950a353cb7680d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30080-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bc6d145991040b69c3b1c20ad055094df2fe9360b28e57a1def1b4f3576ad52", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1ed74c04f89cbfe0fa1c2ed506fa99036eeca0707bad34e212e280dec92c9501", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d959fbbda4ef1bb1a3e75799357d61aa00d11a23d42d917f773e2a10efd9d445", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e678bac84f7983a2834d980ba471739612290201c967ed3f845f3eb7d0971168", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30081-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e6f1cc73de3209d87af4b3130d44b011218627d4296eb259290a276b92002f5b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30081-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cb1c7a13bdc40f1eccf2e2a3fcba9ff79eaa51a142b5e4b7d6515a7b3a791f4d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "25cea435d141ec8d9a453ad33bf3a9397c5ba4b57a5329921e7de79d3e176d1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "746b84803b2db47a4fae7952ec8cda086a5e9c49e889fd0cc03837baef8e7b03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fad8a48e3b868a0203a5cbc218c707937c0ee7a5ab6694adcce600b04fd8c6f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30082-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ace88f16d8d9b49fb9ac34e04137466bb67e8d9e1b160143ad1d305a509f6c86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30082-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "32ebaab7e521884d8354069450aa20094c4ca483a59c7c21b898bacf4fe92338", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b25da63039cb7ddece4861d2a226a120f6d340b6677c68ded58ad6a246c212fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "86b26559707c319eb729080b46de9880aa6555d0f8effe44fcd5cce2de1abe77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "28e6c46d40117ab5632eb95e8cf342e8f566f4a881dabc787cd0dda1b48521fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30083-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3a5d7a92757bdc7b81278a3f38a27823432b2bdb3cd2e12be800560a3bc46a06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30083-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7e56ddacfb74d930186bafe4a0ad431a07ef43e6a2ef94c50c9de12b406394df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "674eae95c1902c100ac9366782d1e930b06068b501ae38088b89bbca6c23e90f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "080847674391cb7141f23910600c4cd61659d4727766afd1e2e8745c724a59d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc9b5f686a39f45aa4f001ad675b64d547f6e866866052466436a6c4c0fa2739", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30084-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d017c6f503fa8a58ccb5a52c0dc76c79f71436e906b88d0bc5ed234867738eec", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30084-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30085": { @@ -240556,7 +245564,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30085", "family_id": "enemies-30085-30088", "job_id": "enemies-30085-30088", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -240568,6 +245576,143 @@ "manifest": "jobs/enemies-30085-30088/candidate.json", "sha256": "fb0785c9c88080cbee4602e784892ad29a71cdedbb2ded6f579e901e7c3db4dc", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "fb0785c9c88080cbee4602e784892ad29a71cdedbb2ded6f579e901e7c3db4dc", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "8dc37a284e0a31c76454230b0c34449340a1ce720d44077df3eb6b49a66ac625", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:31.246083+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/enemies-30085-30088/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"Bronze/gray tracked body, upper bridge, side pods, framed center and two pale forks remain source-aligned. Original phase0 forks extend to occupied row29; later phases end row28. Original changing fork colors/lengths and side shading remain distinct at all scales.\", \"Native1 loses3/4/2/4 source contour cells;2\\u00d7 loses only(21,28) in30087/30088. All survive3\\u20134. These are localized boundary smoothing, not clipped crop content or missing major limbs. Upper stationary rows3\\u201316 have171/167/167 shade differences,0/1/1 >=32 delta; source phase3 own tiny row6 color change is preserved as ordinary palette material.\"] {\"source_phase_differences\": [{\"asset\": \"30085\", \"changed_cells\": 0, \"changed_rows\": {}, \"changes\": []}, {\"asset\": \"30086\", \"changed_cells\": 81, \"changed_rows\": {\"17\": 6, \"18\": 5, \"19\": 6, \"20\": 6, \"21\": 6, \"22\": 6, \"23\": 6, \"24\": 6, \"25\": 6, \"26\": 6, \"27\": 8, \"28\": 8, \"29\": 6}, \"changes\": [[11, 17, 230, 233], [12, 17, 219, 10], [13, 17, 212, 6], [18, 17, 228, 229], [19, 17, 219, 217], [20, 17, 213, 4], [11, 18, 233, 230], [12, 18, 11, 217], [13, 18, 7, 211], [18, 18, 231, 228], [20, 18, 212, 211], [11, 19, 21, 232], [12, 19, 11, 226], [13, 19, 5, 218], [18, 19, 227, 234], [19, 19, 218, 228], [20, 19, 212, 216], [11, 20, 233, 223], [12, 20, 10, 178], [13, 20, 6, 210], [18, 20, 229, 224], [19, 20, 217, 208], [20, 20, 4, 210], [11, 21, 230, 227], [12, 21, 217, 219], [13, 21, 211, 178], [18, 21, 228, 221], [19, 21, 217, 218], [20, 21, 211, 214], [11, 22, 232, 229], [12, 22, 226, 214], [13, 22, 218, 178], [18, 22, 234, 224], [19, 22, 228, 218], [20, 22, 216, 210], [11, 23, 223, 218], [12, 23, 178, 208], [13, 23, 210, 211], [18, 23, 224, 223], [19, 23, 208, 215], [20, 23, 210, 211], [11, 24, 227, 222], [12, 24, 219, 31], [13, 24, 178, 212], [18, 24, 221, 225], [19, 24, 218, 31], [20, 24, 214, 211], [11, 25, 229, 219], [12, 25, 214, 218], [13, 25, 178, 214], [18, 25, 224, 222], [19, 25, 218, 216], [20, 25, 210, 216], [11, 26, 218, 31], [12, 26, 208, 31], [13, 26, 211, 256], [18, 26, 223, 31], [19, 26, 215, 31], [20, 26, 211, 31], [10, 27, 31, 256], [11, 27, 222, 256], [12, 27, 31, 256], [13, 27, 212, 256], [17, 27, 31, 256], [18, 27, 225, 256], [19, 27, 31, 256], [20, 27, 211, 31], [10, 28, 31, 256], [11, 28, 219, 256], [12, 28, 218, 256], [13, 28, 214, 256], [17, 28, 31, 256], [18, 28, 222, 256], [19, 28, 216, 256], [20, 28, 216, 256], [10, 29, 31, 256], [11, 29, 31, 256], [12, 29, 31, 256], [17, 29, 31, 256], [18, 29, 31, 256], [19, 29, 31, 256]]}, {\"asset\": \"30087\", \"changed_cells\": 74, \"changed_rows\": {\"17\": 6, \"18\": 4, \"19\": 6, \"20\": 6, \"21\": 6, \"22\": 6, \"23\": 4, \"24\": 6, \"25\": 6, \"26\": 6, \"27\": 4, \"28\": 8, \"29\": 6}, \"changes\": [[11, 17, 230, 21], [12, 17, 219, 11], [13, 17, 212, 5], [18, 17, 228, 227], [19, 17, 219, 218], [20, 17, 213, 212], [12, 18, 11, 10], [13, 18, 7, 6], [18, 18, 231, 229], [20, 18, 212, 4], [11, 19, 21, 230], [12, 19, 11, 217], [13, 19, 5, 211], [18, 19, 227, 228], [19, 19, 218, 217], [20, 19, 212, 211], [11, 20, 233, 232], [12, 20, 10, 226], [13, 20, 6, 218], [18, 20, 229, 234], [19, 20, 217, 228], [20, 20, 4, 216], [11, 21, 230, 223], [12, 21, 217, 178], [13, 21, 211, 210], [18, 21, 228, 224], [19, 21, 217, 208], [20, 21, 211, 210], [11, 22, 232, 227], [12, 22, 226, 219], [13, 22, 218, 178], [18, 22, 234, 221], [19, 22, 228, 218], [20, 22, 216, 214], [11, 23, 223, 229], [12, 23, 178, 214], [13, 23, 210, 178], [19, 23, 208, 218], [11, 24, 227, 218], [12, 24, 219, 208], [13, 24, 178, 211], [18, 24, 221, 223], [19, 24, 218, 215], [20, 24, 214, 211], [11, 25, 229, 222], [12, 25, 214, 31], [13, 25, 178, 212], [18, 25, 224, 225], [19, 25, 218, 31], [20, 25, 210, 211], [11, 26, 218, 219], [12, 26, 208, 218], [13, 26, 211, 214], [18, 26, 223, 222], [19, 26, 215, 216], [20, 26, 211, 216], [11, 27, 222, 31], [13, 27, 212, 256], [18, 27, 225, 31], [20, 27, 211, 31], [10, 28, 31, 256], [11, 28, 219, 256], [12, 28, 218, 256], [13, 28, 214, 256], [17, 28, 31, 256], [18, 28, 222, 256], [19, 28, 216, 256], [20, 28, 216, 256], [10, 29, 31, 256], [11, 29, 31, 256], [12, 29, 31, 256], [17, 29, 31, 256], [18, 29, 31, 256], [19, 29, 31, 256]]}, {\"asset\": \"30088\", \"changed_cells\": 73, \"changed_rows\": {\"6\": 1, \"17\": 6, \"18\": 4, \"19\": 6, \"20\": 5, \"21\": 6, \"22\": 6, \"23\": 6, \"24\": 4, \"25\": 6, \"26\": 5, \"27\": 6, \"28\": 6, \"29\": 6}, \"changes\": [[9, 6, 234, 229], [11, 17, 230, 233], [12, 17, 219, 11], [13, 17, 212, 7], [18, 17, 228, 231], [19, 17, 219, 217], [20, 17, 213, 212], [11, 18, 233, 21], [13, 18, 7, 5], [18, 18, 231, 227], [19, 18, 217, 218], [11, 19, 21, 233], [12, 19, 11, 10], [13, 19, 5, 6], [18, 19, 227, 229], [19, 19, 218, 217], [20, 19, 212, 4], [11, 20, 233, 230], [12, 20, 10, 217], [13, 20, 6, 211], [18, 20, 229, 228], [20, 20, 4, 211], [11, 21, 230, 232], [12, 21, 217, 226], [13, 21, 211, 218], [18, 21, 228, 234], [19, 21, 217, 228], [20, 21, 211, 216], [11, 22, 232, 223], [12, 22, 226, 178], [13, 22, 218, 210], [18, 22, 234, 224], [19, 22, 228, 208], [20, 22, 216, 210], [11, 23, 223, 227], [12, 23, 178, 219], [13, 23, 210, 178], [18, 23, 224, 221], [19, 23, 208, 218], [20, 23, 210, 214], [11, 24, 227, 229], [12, 24, 219, 214], [18, 24, 221, 224], [20, 24, 214, 210], [11, 25, 229, 218], [12, 25, 214, 208], [13, 25, 178, 211], [18, 25, 224, 223], [19, 25, 218, 215], [20, 25, 210, 211], [11, 26, 218, 222], [12, 26, 208, 31], [13, 26, 211, 212], [18, 26, 223, 225], [19, 26, 215, 31], [11, 27, 222, 219], [12, 27, 31, 218], [13, 27, 212, 214], [18, 27, 225, 222], [19, 27, 31, 216], [20, 27, 211, 216], [11, 28, 219, 31], [12, 28, 218, 31], [13, 28, 214, 256], [18, 28, 222, 31], [19, 28, 216, 31], [20, 28, 216, 256], [10, 29, 31, 256], [11, 29, 31, 256], [12, 29, 31, 256], [17, 29, 31, 256], [18, 29, 31, 256], [19, 29, 31, 256]]}], \"all_phase_source_stationary_occupied_cells\": 485, \"independent_row_based_metrics_match_worker\": true, \"row_based_metrics\": [{\"asset\": \"30086\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 171, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 0, \"max_channel_difference\": 28}, {\"asset\": \"30087\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 167, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 1, \"max_channel_difference\": 36}, {\"asset\": \"30088\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 167, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 1, \"max_channel_difference\": 32}], \"all_source_stationary_comparisons\": [{\"asset\": \"30086\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 255, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 485, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[10, 24, 33.0, [56.0, 40.0, 36.0], [89.0, 69.0, 56.0]], [10, 26, 49.0, [65.0, 48.0, 40.0], [16.0, 16.0, 16.0]], [17, 26, 65.0, [81.0, 60.0, 52.0], [16.0, 16.0, 16.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1223, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1940, \"opacity_changes\": [[12, 6, 234, 256], [13, 6, 232, 256], [14, 6, 230, 256], [15, 6, 20, 256], [16, 6, 229, 256], [17, 6, 233, 256], [44, 6, 231, 256], [45, 6, 229, 256], [46, 6, 230, 256], [47, 6, 231, 256], [48, 6, 231, 256], [49, 6, 232, 256], [50, 6, 236, 256], [21, 8, 23, 256], [22, 8, 22, 256], [23, 8, 21, 256], [24, 8, 22, 256], [26, 8, 21, 256], [27, 8, 20, 256], [28, 8, 22, 256], [29, 8, 20, 256], [30, 8, 22, 256], [31, 8, 24, 256], [32, 8, 235, 256], [38, 8, 232, 256], [39, 8, 232, 256], [40, 8, 230, 256], [41, 8, 229, 256], [52, 8, 233, 256], [34, 48, 28, 256], [34, 49, 27, 256], [34, 50, 237, 256], [34, 51, 237, 256], [34, 52, 27, 256], [34, 53, 26, 256], [11, 57, 256, 31], [12, 57, 256, 0], [13, 57, 256, 0], [14, 57, 256, 0], [15, 57, 256, 0], [44, 57, 256, 0], [45, 57, 256, 0], [46, 57, 256, 0], [47, 57, 256, 0], [48, 57, 256, 0]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[6, 3, 32.75, [104.5, 84.5, 72.5], [71.75, 65.5, 62.5]], [7, 3, 44.5, [126.5, 107.5, 92.75], [82.0, 75.5, 71.5]], [8, 3, 44.5, [129.5, 100.25, 83.5], [85.0, 78.75, 74.5]], [22, 3, 45.5, [127.5, 101.0, 85.5], [82.0, 75.5, 71.5]], [23, 3, 44.5, [125.5, 101.25, 84.5], [81.0, 74.5, 69.5]], [24, 3, 37.0, [107.5, 86.5, 73.5], [70.5, 64.5, 61.5]], [11, 4, 35.5, [113.5, 112.5, 112.5], [78.0, 80.75, 85.75]], [13, 4, 35.0, [105.5, 103.0, 103.0], [70.5, 74.5, 79.5]], [19, 4, 41.0, [141.0, 115.0, 99.0], [100.0, 85.0, 78.5]], [20, 4, 41.5, [127.5, 108.5, 91.75], [86.0, 80.75, 75.5]], [10, 26, 52.75, [67.75, 57.5, 49.5], [15.0, 11.0, 10.0]], [17, 26, 58.5, [77.5, 67.5, 59.5], [19.0, 23.0, 28.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 12}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2901, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4365, \"opacity_changes\": [[29, 12, 235, 256], [78, 12, 234, 256], [79, 13, 234, 256], [51, 72, 28, 256], [52, 80, 237, 256], [29, 81, 0, 256], [29, 82, 29, 256], [17, 86, 256, 30], [18, 86, 256, 31], [19, 86, 256, 31], [20, 86, 256, 31], [21, 86, 256, 31], [22, 86, 256, 31], [23, 86, 256, 31], [26, 85, 30, 256], [24, 86, 256, 31], [67, 86, 256, 31], [68, 86, 256, 31], [69, 86, 256, 31], [70, 86, 256, 31], [71, 86, 256, 31], [72, 86, 256, 31], [73, 86, 256, 31], [74, 86, 256, 31]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[10, 26, 57.2222, [72.88888888888889, 58.77777777777778, 50.333333333333336], [15.666666666666666, 12.555555555555555, 10.666666666666666]], [17, 26, 56.5556, [76.22222222222223, 66.88888888888889, 61.44444444444444], [19.666666666666668, 21.333333333333332, 24.88888888888889]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 2}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 5245, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 7760, \"opacity_changes\": [[36, 13, 229, 256], [38, 15, 233, 256], [102, 13, 238, 256], [40, 17, 20, 256], [42, 17, 20, 256], [43, 17, 18, 256], [48, 17, 19, 256], [49, 17, 19, 256], [50, 17, 19, 256], [56, 17, 20, 256], [57, 17, 20, 256], [58, 17, 19, 256], [59, 17, 19, 256], [60, 17, 19, 256], [61, 17, 20, 256], [64, 17, 233, 256], [65, 17, 233, 256], [66, 17, 233, 256], [67, 17, 232, 256], [68, 17, 230, 256], [69, 17, 229, 256], [70, 17, 232, 256], [71, 17, 234, 256], [72, 17, 233, 256], [73, 17, 232, 256], [74, 17, 232, 256], [82, 17, 229, 256], [84, 16, 235, 256], [104, 16, 235, 256], [105, 17, 232, 256], [16, 20, 30, 256], [107, 20, 28, 256], [68, 96, 235, 256], [69, 106, 0, 256], [69, 107, 0, 256], [17, 110, 256, 31], [39, 108, 0, 256], [39, 109, 31, 256], [38, 110, 256, 30], [37, 111, 29, 256], [20, 113, 256, 0], [89, 115, 256, 30], [90, 115, 256, 31], [91, 115, 256, 31]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[10, 26, 54.1875, [70.625, 58.875, 50.125], [16.4375, 12.5625, 10.5625]], [17, 26, 53.1875, [72.75, 62.1875, 56.4375], [19.5625, 19.8125, 22.3125]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 2}]}, {\"asset\": \"30087\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 235, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 485, \"opacity_changes\": [[26, 4, 256, 235]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[26, 4, 36.0, [20.0, 28.0, 38.0], [56.0, 40.0, 36.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1097, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1940, \"opacity_changes\": [[21, 8, 23, 256], [22, 8, 22, 256], [23, 8, 21, 256], [24, 8, 22, 256], [26, 8, 21, 256], [27, 8, 20, 256], [28, 8, 22, 256], [29, 8, 20, 256], [30, 8, 22, 256], [31, 8, 24, 256], [32, 8, 235, 256], [38, 8, 232, 256], [39, 8, 232, 256], [41, 8, 229, 256], [34, 48, 28, 256], [42, 55, 27, 256], [43, 56, 29, 256], [45, 57, 256, 31], [49, 57, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 4, 32.75, [105.5, 103.0, 103.0], [72.75, 75.5, 80.5]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2664, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4365, \"opacity_changes\": [[77, 10, 256, 237], [42, 71, 30, 256], [43, 71, 30, 256], [44, 71, 31, 256], [45, 71, 31, 256], [46, 71, 0, 256], [47, 71, 0, 256], [48, 71, 0, 256], [49, 71, 0, 256], [50, 71, 31, 256], [51, 72, 28, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[10, 23, 32.3333, [68.22222222222223, 58.333333333333336, 50.22222222222222], [35.888888888888886, 29.22222222222222, 25.11111111111111]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 4873, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 7760, \"opacity_changes\": [[103, 14, 256, 28], [39, 16, 256, 233], [84, 16, 235, 256], [106, 18, 256, 235], [56, 95, 0, 256], [57, 95, 0, 256], [58, 95, 0, 256], [59, 95, 0, 256], [60, 95, 0, 256], [61, 95, 0, 256], [62, 95, 0, 256], [63, 95, 0, 256], [64, 95, 0, 256], [65, 95, 0, 256], [66, 95, 0, 256], [67, 95, 0, 256], [68, 95, 0, 256], [68, 96, 235, 256], [37, 111, 29, 256], [84, 110, 29, 256], [85, 111, 27, 256], [21, 114, 0, 256], [86, 112, 30, 256], [87, 113, 30, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[10, 23, 33.8125, [69.0625, 56.75, 48.25], [35.25, 30.25, 26.75]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}]}, {\"asset\": \"30088\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 240, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 485, \"opacity_changes\": [[26, 4, 256, 236]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[26, 4, 32.0, [20.0, 28.0, 38.0], [52.0, 36.0, 32.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1126, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1940, \"opacity_changes\": [[21, 8, 23, 256], [22, 8, 22, 256], [23, 8, 21, 256], [24, 8, 22, 256], [26, 8, 21, 256], [27, 8, 20, 256], [30, 8, 22, 256], [31, 8, 24, 256], [32, 8, 235, 256], [38, 8, 232, 256], [39, 8, 232, 256], [40, 8, 230, 256], [41, 8, 229, 256], [53, 9, 256, 237], [34, 48, 28, 256], [34, 49, 27, 256], [34, 50, 237, 256], [34, 51, 237, 256], [34, 52, 27, 256], [34, 53, 26, 256], [42, 55, 27, 256], [43, 56, 29, 256], [49, 57, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[20, 4, 32.5, [127.5, 108.5, 91.75], [95.0, 91.0, 83.75]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2721, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4365, \"opacity_changes\": [[77, 10, 256, 237], [42, 71, 30, 256], [43, 71, 30, 256], [44, 71, 31, 256], [45, 71, 31, 256], [46, 71, 0, 256], [47, 71, 0, 256], [48, 71, 0, 256], [49, 71, 0, 256], [50, 71, 31, 256], [51, 71, 0, 256], [51, 72, 28, 256], [26, 85, 30, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 4960, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 7760, \"opacity_changes\": [[103, 14, 256, 28], [39, 16, 256, 236], [84, 16, 235, 256], [106, 18, 256, 236], [56, 95, 0, 256], [57, 95, 0, 256], [58, 95, 0, 256], [59, 95, 0, 256], [60, 95, 0, 256], [61, 95, 0, 256], [62, 95, 0, 256], [63, 95, 0, 256], [64, 95, 0, 256], [65, 95, 0, 256], [66, 95, 0, 256], [67, 95, 0, 256], [68, 95, 0, 256], [68, 96, 235, 256], [16, 108, 31, 256], [37, 111, 29, 256], [84, 110, 29, 256], [85, 111, 27, 256], [21, 114, 0, 256], [86, 112, 30, 256], [87, 113, 30, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}]}]} [\"Isolated actual Catalog/HdAssets source-bound sprite raster and artistic approval only. No new Host enemy occurrence, animation timing, terrain blend, gameplay, simulation-neutrality or fullscreen capture.\", \"Broader game-source freshness flag is true due to unrelated menu/game edits; relevant assets/hd loader source is current.\", \"Complete shared family scale, origin and all rawalpha>=16/>=32 crop retention independently verified. Palette classes, forced indices and all240\\u2013255counts pass; these numeric checks do not substitute for the completed artistic review.\", \"Original/source and newly authored stationary body shading are not byte identical; localized variations and native/2\\u00d7 contour smoothing are deliberately disclosed.\", \"Global registration and bundled pack snapshot remain coordinator-owned; no source/candidate/raw/global/Git edits by reviewer.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/independent-review.json, SHA256 f6c62881aa1b2c8f035cd588b6d4e11b8b543af4a03a6a56616613afe6be7839", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/inputs/enemies-30085-30088/runtime-review/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "680d5b7bdc22824d830466af4958734e85c7cc15256161f589b1eada1e9122a0" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "26ce2f190978e8c78b69c05c2c1e50e4c0faa6716b81f5c0da237c01e576ac6d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "30085", + "30086", + "30087", + "30088" + ], + "sha256": "6098ddc1718247e3ae78bf0189bfaf3ab0db23ca7f1fd6d17716576a640b9d67", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "30085-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b352fa2d84df8be85d3453226900c7dc3dd9e2a72368d51f97eddd9aeddbcd54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30085-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30085-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "994adf7b3315fa81b0102285dcc0dd92e2f3c7be99f3d5735fc64b84fffbf117", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30085-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30085-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "94ba0bede4b97116ea13ad73265bbf4d6525ac69a2072acd1a6694619acd7280", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30085-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30085-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "554be3d8138d0d9dd150f362a9e2778323a29665beacae6082d5939b46f30052", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30085-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30085-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6becde0e6286c18a3fe5b424c1b1ab1b6b55930f9e839326815a845a5409997f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30085-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30086-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3acd58213d25a8d450f9921bd27861edbb8acbf0ca1b476e7e9f8a7734ddbf01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30086-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30086-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6e721c34dcfc96b30f2bc92ff193cf23c1f38ab6eeea10617fc031f0fd00e210", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30086-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30086-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "644fd117f85d575d1cb1dc0336370c77ae0084f163cddd57075d28a20618ba08", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30086-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30086-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3a06b1fb65d6a6a76dcb86fad4159c313f323b060e27931de3c8190309a2683a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30086-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30086-original.ppm", + "sha256": "dfc125281c939aa7aa67c0f34391a4dd71140a7a582ad7a45c466e9498cba837", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30086-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30087-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c3b6ec8e0ef6a40ef4ac8764c7e8204e208a425644da042ed2b4335e61b6482c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30087-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30087-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf80e486b5b6b0d567590c40305716f934b6b2a6ee5a79d56dfc7c5da8fc3489", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30087-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30087-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "11de9ccf9b6ec25d19f0433d7672c3a7275995f088ce05b7dce1978a5207777e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30087-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30087-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c6e29f25375319520c2f7c91c12a1bf42a105b0f346d02e0f6d38cb620703c9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30087-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30087-original.ppm", + "sha256": "897f8e60171aa2447717815f8a44adc75901f3228ae8446248e0c46305226882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30087-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30088-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91eed83cb809069a38f809e441b3ea5891bef0be6e96ad5bb51c19331aa5726b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30088-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30088-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4aff80d63540eaac05f9eb3a2299ad1ef2ea53c828b608d7831f0702ec0c94ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30088-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30088-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ebd585d2efed2d53a8c7e13bd77a5f6686d81dc3d32674cdf38baf7958ff7e31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30088-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30088-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fe104624901259eb5ec2fe1cc1cf1a44f4bcee9300ec5f3f86534e29b7001ca4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30088-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30088-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2f5768643e5f0c624b0dbf138139ef301f6b23276b678f71e14b5dcd29eab987", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30088-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30086": { @@ -240589,7 +245734,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30086", "family_id": "enemies-30085-30088", "job_id": "enemies-30085-30088", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -240601,6 +245746,143 @@ "manifest": "jobs/enemies-30085-30088/candidate.json", "sha256": "fb0785c9c88080cbee4602e784892ad29a71cdedbb2ded6f579e901e7c3db4dc", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "fb0785c9c88080cbee4602e784892ad29a71cdedbb2ded6f579e901e7c3db4dc", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "8dc37a284e0a31c76454230b0c34449340a1ce720d44077df3eb6b49a66ac625", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:31.246083+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/enemies-30085-30088/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"Bronze/gray tracked body, upper bridge, side pods, framed center and two pale forks remain source-aligned. Original phase0 forks extend to occupied row29; later phases end row28. Original changing fork colors/lengths and side shading remain distinct at all scales.\", \"Native1 loses3/4/2/4 source contour cells;2\\u00d7 loses only(21,28) in30087/30088. All survive3\\u20134. These are localized boundary smoothing, not clipped crop content or missing major limbs. Upper stationary rows3\\u201316 have171/167/167 shade differences,0/1/1 >=32 delta; source phase3 own tiny row6 color change is preserved as ordinary palette material.\"] {\"source_phase_differences\": [{\"asset\": \"30085\", \"changed_cells\": 0, \"changed_rows\": {}, \"changes\": []}, {\"asset\": \"30086\", \"changed_cells\": 81, \"changed_rows\": {\"17\": 6, \"18\": 5, \"19\": 6, \"20\": 6, \"21\": 6, \"22\": 6, \"23\": 6, \"24\": 6, \"25\": 6, \"26\": 6, \"27\": 8, \"28\": 8, \"29\": 6}, \"changes\": [[11, 17, 230, 233], [12, 17, 219, 10], [13, 17, 212, 6], [18, 17, 228, 229], [19, 17, 219, 217], [20, 17, 213, 4], [11, 18, 233, 230], [12, 18, 11, 217], [13, 18, 7, 211], [18, 18, 231, 228], [20, 18, 212, 211], [11, 19, 21, 232], [12, 19, 11, 226], [13, 19, 5, 218], [18, 19, 227, 234], [19, 19, 218, 228], [20, 19, 212, 216], [11, 20, 233, 223], [12, 20, 10, 178], [13, 20, 6, 210], [18, 20, 229, 224], [19, 20, 217, 208], [20, 20, 4, 210], [11, 21, 230, 227], [12, 21, 217, 219], [13, 21, 211, 178], [18, 21, 228, 221], [19, 21, 217, 218], [20, 21, 211, 214], [11, 22, 232, 229], [12, 22, 226, 214], [13, 22, 218, 178], [18, 22, 234, 224], [19, 22, 228, 218], [20, 22, 216, 210], [11, 23, 223, 218], [12, 23, 178, 208], [13, 23, 210, 211], [18, 23, 224, 223], [19, 23, 208, 215], [20, 23, 210, 211], [11, 24, 227, 222], [12, 24, 219, 31], [13, 24, 178, 212], [18, 24, 221, 225], [19, 24, 218, 31], [20, 24, 214, 211], [11, 25, 229, 219], [12, 25, 214, 218], [13, 25, 178, 214], [18, 25, 224, 222], [19, 25, 218, 216], [20, 25, 210, 216], [11, 26, 218, 31], [12, 26, 208, 31], [13, 26, 211, 256], [18, 26, 223, 31], [19, 26, 215, 31], [20, 26, 211, 31], [10, 27, 31, 256], [11, 27, 222, 256], [12, 27, 31, 256], [13, 27, 212, 256], [17, 27, 31, 256], [18, 27, 225, 256], [19, 27, 31, 256], [20, 27, 211, 31], [10, 28, 31, 256], [11, 28, 219, 256], [12, 28, 218, 256], [13, 28, 214, 256], [17, 28, 31, 256], [18, 28, 222, 256], [19, 28, 216, 256], [20, 28, 216, 256], [10, 29, 31, 256], [11, 29, 31, 256], [12, 29, 31, 256], [17, 29, 31, 256], [18, 29, 31, 256], [19, 29, 31, 256]]}, {\"asset\": \"30087\", \"changed_cells\": 74, \"changed_rows\": {\"17\": 6, \"18\": 4, \"19\": 6, \"20\": 6, \"21\": 6, \"22\": 6, \"23\": 4, \"24\": 6, \"25\": 6, \"26\": 6, \"27\": 4, \"28\": 8, \"29\": 6}, \"changes\": [[11, 17, 230, 21], [12, 17, 219, 11], [13, 17, 212, 5], [18, 17, 228, 227], [19, 17, 219, 218], [20, 17, 213, 212], [12, 18, 11, 10], [13, 18, 7, 6], [18, 18, 231, 229], [20, 18, 212, 4], [11, 19, 21, 230], [12, 19, 11, 217], [13, 19, 5, 211], [18, 19, 227, 228], [19, 19, 218, 217], [20, 19, 212, 211], [11, 20, 233, 232], [12, 20, 10, 226], [13, 20, 6, 218], [18, 20, 229, 234], [19, 20, 217, 228], [20, 20, 4, 216], [11, 21, 230, 223], [12, 21, 217, 178], [13, 21, 211, 210], [18, 21, 228, 224], [19, 21, 217, 208], [20, 21, 211, 210], [11, 22, 232, 227], [12, 22, 226, 219], [13, 22, 218, 178], [18, 22, 234, 221], [19, 22, 228, 218], [20, 22, 216, 214], [11, 23, 223, 229], [12, 23, 178, 214], [13, 23, 210, 178], [19, 23, 208, 218], [11, 24, 227, 218], [12, 24, 219, 208], [13, 24, 178, 211], [18, 24, 221, 223], [19, 24, 218, 215], [20, 24, 214, 211], [11, 25, 229, 222], [12, 25, 214, 31], [13, 25, 178, 212], [18, 25, 224, 225], [19, 25, 218, 31], [20, 25, 210, 211], [11, 26, 218, 219], [12, 26, 208, 218], [13, 26, 211, 214], [18, 26, 223, 222], [19, 26, 215, 216], [20, 26, 211, 216], [11, 27, 222, 31], [13, 27, 212, 256], [18, 27, 225, 31], [20, 27, 211, 31], [10, 28, 31, 256], [11, 28, 219, 256], [12, 28, 218, 256], [13, 28, 214, 256], [17, 28, 31, 256], [18, 28, 222, 256], [19, 28, 216, 256], [20, 28, 216, 256], [10, 29, 31, 256], [11, 29, 31, 256], [12, 29, 31, 256], [17, 29, 31, 256], [18, 29, 31, 256], [19, 29, 31, 256]]}, {\"asset\": \"30088\", \"changed_cells\": 73, \"changed_rows\": {\"6\": 1, \"17\": 6, \"18\": 4, \"19\": 6, \"20\": 5, \"21\": 6, \"22\": 6, \"23\": 6, \"24\": 4, \"25\": 6, \"26\": 5, \"27\": 6, \"28\": 6, \"29\": 6}, \"changes\": [[9, 6, 234, 229], [11, 17, 230, 233], [12, 17, 219, 11], [13, 17, 212, 7], [18, 17, 228, 231], [19, 17, 219, 217], [20, 17, 213, 212], [11, 18, 233, 21], [13, 18, 7, 5], [18, 18, 231, 227], [19, 18, 217, 218], [11, 19, 21, 233], [12, 19, 11, 10], [13, 19, 5, 6], [18, 19, 227, 229], [19, 19, 218, 217], [20, 19, 212, 4], [11, 20, 233, 230], [12, 20, 10, 217], [13, 20, 6, 211], [18, 20, 229, 228], [20, 20, 4, 211], [11, 21, 230, 232], [12, 21, 217, 226], [13, 21, 211, 218], [18, 21, 228, 234], [19, 21, 217, 228], [20, 21, 211, 216], [11, 22, 232, 223], [12, 22, 226, 178], [13, 22, 218, 210], [18, 22, 234, 224], [19, 22, 228, 208], [20, 22, 216, 210], [11, 23, 223, 227], [12, 23, 178, 219], [13, 23, 210, 178], [18, 23, 224, 221], [19, 23, 208, 218], [20, 23, 210, 214], [11, 24, 227, 229], [12, 24, 219, 214], [18, 24, 221, 224], [20, 24, 214, 210], [11, 25, 229, 218], [12, 25, 214, 208], [13, 25, 178, 211], [18, 25, 224, 223], [19, 25, 218, 215], [20, 25, 210, 211], [11, 26, 218, 222], [12, 26, 208, 31], [13, 26, 211, 212], [18, 26, 223, 225], [19, 26, 215, 31], [11, 27, 222, 219], [12, 27, 31, 218], [13, 27, 212, 214], [18, 27, 225, 222], [19, 27, 31, 216], [20, 27, 211, 216], [11, 28, 219, 31], [12, 28, 218, 31], [13, 28, 214, 256], [18, 28, 222, 31], [19, 28, 216, 31], [20, 28, 216, 256], [10, 29, 31, 256], [11, 29, 31, 256], [12, 29, 31, 256], [17, 29, 31, 256], [18, 29, 31, 256], [19, 29, 31, 256]]}], \"all_phase_source_stationary_occupied_cells\": 485, \"independent_row_based_metrics_match_worker\": true, \"row_based_metrics\": [{\"asset\": \"30086\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 171, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 0, \"max_channel_difference\": 28}, {\"asset\": \"30087\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 167, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 1, \"max_channel_difference\": 36}, {\"asset\": \"30088\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 167, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 1, \"max_channel_difference\": 32}], \"all_source_stationary_comparisons\": [{\"asset\": \"30086\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 255, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 485, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[10, 24, 33.0, [56.0, 40.0, 36.0], [89.0, 69.0, 56.0]], [10, 26, 49.0, [65.0, 48.0, 40.0], [16.0, 16.0, 16.0]], [17, 26, 65.0, [81.0, 60.0, 52.0], [16.0, 16.0, 16.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1223, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1940, \"opacity_changes\": [[12, 6, 234, 256], [13, 6, 232, 256], [14, 6, 230, 256], [15, 6, 20, 256], [16, 6, 229, 256], [17, 6, 233, 256], [44, 6, 231, 256], [45, 6, 229, 256], [46, 6, 230, 256], [47, 6, 231, 256], [48, 6, 231, 256], [49, 6, 232, 256], [50, 6, 236, 256], [21, 8, 23, 256], [22, 8, 22, 256], [23, 8, 21, 256], [24, 8, 22, 256], [26, 8, 21, 256], [27, 8, 20, 256], [28, 8, 22, 256], [29, 8, 20, 256], [30, 8, 22, 256], [31, 8, 24, 256], [32, 8, 235, 256], [38, 8, 232, 256], [39, 8, 232, 256], [40, 8, 230, 256], [41, 8, 229, 256], [52, 8, 233, 256], [34, 48, 28, 256], [34, 49, 27, 256], [34, 50, 237, 256], [34, 51, 237, 256], [34, 52, 27, 256], [34, 53, 26, 256], [11, 57, 256, 31], [12, 57, 256, 0], [13, 57, 256, 0], [14, 57, 256, 0], [15, 57, 256, 0], [44, 57, 256, 0], [45, 57, 256, 0], [46, 57, 256, 0], [47, 57, 256, 0], [48, 57, 256, 0]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[6, 3, 32.75, [104.5, 84.5, 72.5], [71.75, 65.5, 62.5]], [7, 3, 44.5, [126.5, 107.5, 92.75], [82.0, 75.5, 71.5]], [8, 3, 44.5, [129.5, 100.25, 83.5], [85.0, 78.75, 74.5]], [22, 3, 45.5, [127.5, 101.0, 85.5], [82.0, 75.5, 71.5]], [23, 3, 44.5, [125.5, 101.25, 84.5], [81.0, 74.5, 69.5]], [24, 3, 37.0, [107.5, 86.5, 73.5], [70.5, 64.5, 61.5]], [11, 4, 35.5, [113.5, 112.5, 112.5], [78.0, 80.75, 85.75]], [13, 4, 35.0, [105.5, 103.0, 103.0], [70.5, 74.5, 79.5]], [19, 4, 41.0, [141.0, 115.0, 99.0], [100.0, 85.0, 78.5]], [20, 4, 41.5, [127.5, 108.5, 91.75], [86.0, 80.75, 75.5]], [10, 26, 52.75, [67.75, 57.5, 49.5], [15.0, 11.0, 10.0]], [17, 26, 58.5, [77.5, 67.5, 59.5], [19.0, 23.0, 28.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 12}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2901, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4365, \"opacity_changes\": [[29, 12, 235, 256], [78, 12, 234, 256], [79, 13, 234, 256], [51, 72, 28, 256], [52, 80, 237, 256], [29, 81, 0, 256], [29, 82, 29, 256], [17, 86, 256, 30], [18, 86, 256, 31], [19, 86, 256, 31], [20, 86, 256, 31], [21, 86, 256, 31], [22, 86, 256, 31], [23, 86, 256, 31], [26, 85, 30, 256], [24, 86, 256, 31], [67, 86, 256, 31], [68, 86, 256, 31], [69, 86, 256, 31], [70, 86, 256, 31], [71, 86, 256, 31], [72, 86, 256, 31], [73, 86, 256, 31], [74, 86, 256, 31]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[10, 26, 57.2222, [72.88888888888889, 58.77777777777778, 50.333333333333336], [15.666666666666666, 12.555555555555555, 10.666666666666666]], [17, 26, 56.5556, [76.22222222222223, 66.88888888888889, 61.44444444444444], [19.666666666666668, 21.333333333333332, 24.88888888888889]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 2}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 5245, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 7760, \"opacity_changes\": [[36, 13, 229, 256], [38, 15, 233, 256], [102, 13, 238, 256], [40, 17, 20, 256], [42, 17, 20, 256], [43, 17, 18, 256], [48, 17, 19, 256], [49, 17, 19, 256], [50, 17, 19, 256], [56, 17, 20, 256], [57, 17, 20, 256], [58, 17, 19, 256], [59, 17, 19, 256], [60, 17, 19, 256], [61, 17, 20, 256], [64, 17, 233, 256], [65, 17, 233, 256], [66, 17, 233, 256], [67, 17, 232, 256], [68, 17, 230, 256], [69, 17, 229, 256], [70, 17, 232, 256], [71, 17, 234, 256], [72, 17, 233, 256], [73, 17, 232, 256], [74, 17, 232, 256], [82, 17, 229, 256], [84, 16, 235, 256], [104, 16, 235, 256], [105, 17, 232, 256], [16, 20, 30, 256], [107, 20, 28, 256], [68, 96, 235, 256], [69, 106, 0, 256], [69, 107, 0, 256], [17, 110, 256, 31], [39, 108, 0, 256], [39, 109, 31, 256], [38, 110, 256, 30], [37, 111, 29, 256], [20, 113, 256, 0], [89, 115, 256, 30], [90, 115, 256, 31], [91, 115, 256, 31]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[10, 26, 54.1875, [70.625, 58.875, 50.125], [16.4375, 12.5625, 10.5625]], [17, 26, 53.1875, [72.75, 62.1875, 56.4375], [19.5625, 19.8125, 22.3125]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 2}]}, {\"asset\": \"30087\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 235, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 485, \"opacity_changes\": [[26, 4, 256, 235]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[26, 4, 36.0, [20.0, 28.0, 38.0], [56.0, 40.0, 36.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1097, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1940, \"opacity_changes\": [[21, 8, 23, 256], [22, 8, 22, 256], [23, 8, 21, 256], [24, 8, 22, 256], [26, 8, 21, 256], [27, 8, 20, 256], [28, 8, 22, 256], [29, 8, 20, 256], [30, 8, 22, 256], [31, 8, 24, 256], [32, 8, 235, 256], [38, 8, 232, 256], [39, 8, 232, 256], [41, 8, 229, 256], [34, 48, 28, 256], [42, 55, 27, 256], [43, 56, 29, 256], [45, 57, 256, 31], [49, 57, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 4, 32.75, [105.5, 103.0, 103.0], [72.75, 75.5, 80.5]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2664, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4365, \"opacity_changes\": [[77, 10, 256, 237], [42, 71, 30, 256], [43, 71, 30, 256], [44, 71, 31, 256], [45, 71, 31, 256], [46, 71, 0, 256], [47, 71, 0, 256], [48, 71, 0, 256], [49, 71, 0, 256], [50, 71, 31, 256], [51, 72, 28, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[10, 23, 32.3333, [68.22222222222223, 58.333333333333336, 50.22222222222222], [35.888888888888886, 29.22222222222222, 25.11111111111111]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 4873, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 7760, \"opacity_changes\": [[103, 14, 256, 28], [39, 16, 256, 233], [84, 16, 235, 256], [106, 18, 256, 235], [56, 95, 0, 256], [57, 95, 0, 256], [58, 95, 0, 256], [59, 95, 0, 256], [60, 95, 0, 256], [61, 95, 0, 256], [62, 95, 0, 256], [63, 95, 0, 256], [64, 95, 0, 256], [65, 95, 0, 256], [66, 95, 0, 256], [67, 95, 0, 256], [68, 95, 0, 256], [68, 96, 235, 256], [37, 111, 29, 256], [84, 110, 29, 256], [85, 111, 27, 256], [21, 114, 0, 256], [86, 112, 30, 256], [87, 113, 30, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[10, 23, 33.8125, [69.0625, 56.75, 48.25], [35.25, 30.25, 26.75]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}]}, {\"asset\": \"30088\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 240, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 485, \"opacity_changes\": [[26, 4, 256, 236]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[26, 4, 32.0, [20.0, 28.0, 38.0], [52.0, 36.0, 32.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1126, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1940, \"opacity_changes\": [[21, 8, 23, 256], [22, 8, 22, 256], [23, 8, 21, 256], [24, 8, 22, 256], [26, 8, 21, 256], [27, 8, 20, 256], [30, 8, 22, 256], [31, 8, 24, 256], [32, 8, 235, 256], [38, 8, 232, 256], [39, 8, 232, 256], [40, 8, 230, 256], [41, 8, 229, 256], [53, 9, 256, 237], [34, 48, 28, 256], [34, 49, 27, 256], [34, 50, 237, 256], [34, 51, 237, 256], [34, 52, 27, 256], [34, 53, 26, 256], [42, 55, 27, 256], [43, 56, 29, 256], [49, 57, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[20, 4, 32.5, [127.5, 108.5, 91.75], [95.0, 91.0, 83.75]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2721, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4365, \"opacity_changes\": [[77, 10, 256, 237], [42, 71, 30, 256], [43, 71, 30, 256], [44, 71, 31, 256], [45, 71, 31, 256], [46, 71, 0, 256], [47, 71, 0, 256], [48, 71, 0, 256], [49, 71, 0, 256], [50, 71, 31, 256], [51, 71, 0, 256], [51, 72, 28, 256], [26, 85, 30, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 4960, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 7760, \"opacity_changes\": [[103, 14, 256, 28], [39, 16, 256, 236], [84, 16, 235, 256], [106, 18, 256, 236], [56, 95, 0, 256], [57, 95, 0, 256], [58, 95, 0, 256], [59, 95, 0, 256], [60, 95, 0, 256], [61, 95, 0, 256], [62, 95, 0, 256], [63, 95, 0, 256], [64, 95, 0, 256], [65, 95, 0, 256], [66, 95, 0, 256], [67, 95, 0, 256], [68, 95, 0, 256], [68, 96, 235, 256], [16, 108, 31, 256], [37, 111, 29, 256], [84, 110, 29, 256], [85, 111, 27, 256], [21, 114, 0, 256], [86, 112, 30, 256], [87, 113, 30, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}]}]} [\"Isolated actual Catalog/HdAssets source-bound sprite raster and artistic approval only. No new Host enemy occurrence, animation timing, terrain blend, gameplay, simulation-neutrality or fullscreen capture.\", \"Broader game-source freshness flag is true due to unrelated menu/game edits; relevant assets/hd loader source is current.\", \"Complete shared family scale, origin and all rawalpha>=16/>=32 crop retention independently verified. Palette classes, forced indices and all240\\u2013255counts pass; these numeric checks do not substitute for the completed artistic review.\", \"Original/source and newly authored stationary body shading are not byte identical; localized variations and native/2\\u00d7 contour smoothing are deliberately disclosed.\", \"Global registration and bundled pack snapshot remain coordinator-owned; no source/candidate/raw/global/Git edits by reviewer.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/independent-review.json, SHA256 f6c62881aa1b2c8f035cd588b6d4e11b8b543af4a03a6a56616613afe6be7839", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/inputs/enemies-30085-30088/runtime-review/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "680d5b7bdc22824d830466af4958734e85c7cc15256161f589b1eada1e9122a0" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "26ce2f190978e8c78b69c05c2c1e50e4c0faa6716b81f5c0da237c01e576ac6d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "30085", + "30086", + "30087", + "30088" + ], + "sha256": "6098ddc1718247e3ae78bf0189bfaf3ab0db23ca7f1fd6d17716576a640b9d67", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "30085-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b352fa2d84df8be85d3453226900c7dc3dd9e2a72368d51f97eddd9aeddbcd54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30085-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30085-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "994adf7b3315fa81b0102285dcc0dd92e2f3c7be99f3d5735fc64b84fffbf117", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30085-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30085-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "94ba0bede4b97116ea13ad73265bbf4d6525ac69a2072acd1a6694619acd7280", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30085-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30085-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "554be3d8138d0d9dd150f362a9e2778323a29665beacae6082d5939b46f30052", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30085-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30085-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6becde0e6286c18a3fe5b424c1b1ab1b6b55930f9e839326815a845a5409997f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30085-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30086-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3acd58213d25a8d450f9921bd27861edbb8acbf0ca1b476e7e9f8a7734ddbf01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30086-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30086-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6e721c34dcfc96b30f2bc92ff193cf23c1f38ab6eeea10617fc031f0fd00e210", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30086-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30086-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "644fd117f85d575d1cb1dc0336370c77ae0084f163cddd57075d28a20618ba08", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30086-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30086-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3a06b1fb65d6a6a76dcb86fad4159c313f323b060e27931de3c8190309a2683a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30086-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30086-original.ppm", + "sha256": "dfc125281c939aa7aa67c0f34391a4dd71140a7a582ad7a45c466e9498cba837", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30086-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30087-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c3b6ec8e0ef6a40ef4ac8764c7e8204e208a425644da042ed2b4335e61b6482c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30087-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30087-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf80e486b5b6b0d567590c40305716f934b6b2a6ee5a79d56dfc7c5da8fc3489", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30087-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30087-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "11de9ccf9b6ec25d19f0433d7672c3a7275995f088ce05b7dce1978a5207777e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30087-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30087-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c6e29f25375319520c2f7c91c12a1bf42a105b0f346d02e0f6d38cb620703c9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30087-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30087-original.ppm", + "sha256": "897f8e60171aa2447717815f8a44adc75901f3228ae8446248e0c46305226882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30087-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30088-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91eed83cb809069a38f809e441b3ea5891bef0be6e96ad5bb51c19331aa5726b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30088-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30088-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4aff80d63540eaac05f9eb3a2299ad1ef2ea53c828b608d7831f0702ec0c94ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30088-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30088-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ebd585d2efed2d53a8c7e13bd77a5f6686d81dc3d32674cdf38baf7958ff7e31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30088-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30088-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fe104624901259eb5ec2fe1cc1cf1a44f4bcee9300ec5f3f86534e29b7001ca4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30088-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30088-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2f5768643e5f0c624b0dbf138139ef301f6b23276b678f71e14b5dcd29eab987", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30088-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30087": { @@ -240622,7 +245904,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30087", "family_id": "enemies-30085-30088", "job_id": "enemies-30085-30088", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -240634,6 +245916,143 @@ "manifest": "jobs/enemies-30085-30088/candidate.json", "sha256": "fb0785c9c88080cbee4602e784892ad29a71cdedbb2ded6f579e901e7c3db4dc", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "fb0785c9c88080cbee4602e784892ad29a71cdedbb2ded6f579e901e7c3db4dc", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "8dc37a284e0a31c76454230b0c34449340a1ce720d44077df3eb6b49a66ac625", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:31.246083+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/enemies-30085-30088/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"Bronze/gray tracked body, upper bridge, side pods, framed center and two pale forks remain source-aligned. Original phase0 forks extend to occupied row29; later phases end row28. Original changing fork colors/lengths and side shading remain distinct at all scales.\", \"Native1 loses3/4/2/4 source contour cells;2\\u00d7 loses only(21,28) in30087/30088. All survive3\\u20134. These are localized boundary smoothing, not clipped crop content or missing major limbs. Upper stationary rows3\\u201316 have171/167/167 shade differences,0/1/1 >=32 delta; source phase3 own tiny row6 color change is preserved as ordinary palette material.\"] {\"source_phase_differences\": [{\"asset\": \"30085\", \"changed_cells\": 0, \"changed_rows\": {}, \"changes\": []}, {\"asset\": \"30086\", \"changed_cells\": 81, \"changed_rows\": {\"17\": 6, \"18\": 5, \"19\": 6, \"20\": 6, \"21\": 6, \"22\": 6, \"23\": 6, \"24\": 6, \"25\": 6, \"26\": 6, \"27\": 8, \"28\": 8, \"29\": 6}, \"changes\": [[11, 17, 230, 233], [12, 17, 219, 10], [13, 17, 212, 6], [18, 17, 228, 229], [19, 17, 219, 217], [20, 17, 213, 4], [11, 18, 233, 230], [12, 18, 11, 217], [13, 18, 7, 211], [18, 18, 231, 228], [20, 18, 212, 211], [11, 19, 21, 232], [12, 19, 11, 226], [13, 19, 5, 218], [18, 19, 227, 234], [19, 19, 218, 228], [20, 19, 212, 216], [11, 20, 233, 223], [12, 20, 10, 178], [13, 20, 6, 210], [18, 20, 229, 224], [19, 20, 217, 208], [20, 20, 4, 210], [11, 21, 230, 227], [12, 21, 217, 219], [13, 21, 211, 178], [18, 21, 228, 221], [19, 21, 217, 218], [20, 21, 211, 214], [11, 22, 232, 229], [12, 22, 226, 214], [13, 22, 218, 178], [18, 22, 234, 224], [19, 22, 228, 218], [20, 22, 216, 210], [11, 23, 223, 218], [12, 23, 178, 208], [13, 23, 210, 211], [18, 23, 224, 223], [19, 23, 208, 215], [20, 23, 210, 211], [11, 24, 227, 222], [12, 24, 219, 31], [13, 24, 178, 212], [18, 24, 221, 225], [19, 24, 218, 31], [20, 24, 214, 211], [11, 25, 229, 219], [12, 25, 214, 218], [13, 25, 178, 214], [18, 25, 224, 222], [19, 25, 218, 216], [20, 25, 210, 216], [11, 26, 218, 31], [12, 26, 208, 31], [13, 26, 211, 256], [18, 26, 223, 31], [19, 26, 215, 31], [20, 26, 211, 31], [10, 27, 31, 256], [11, 27, 222, 256], [12, 27, 31, 256], [13, 27, 212, 256], [17, 27, 31, 256], [18, 27, 225, 256], [19, 27, 31, 256], [20, 27, 211, 31], [10, 28, 31, 256], [11, 28, 219, 256], [12, 28, 218, 256], [13, 28, 214, 256], [17, 28, 31, 256], [18, 28, 222, 256], [19, 28, 216, 256], [20, 28, 216, 256], [10, 29, 31, 256], [11, 29, 31, 256], [12, 29, 31, 256], [17, 29, 31, 256], [18, 29, 31, 256], [19, 29, 31, 256]]}, {\"asset\": \"30087\", \"changed_cells\": 74, \"changed_rows\": {\"17\": 6, \"18\": 4, \"19\": 6, \"20\": 6, \"21\": 6, \"22\": 6, \"23\": 4, \"24\": 6, \"25\": 6, \"26\": 6, \"27\": 4, \"28\": 8, \"29\": 6}, \"changes\": [[11, 17, 230, 21], [12, 17, 219, 11], [13, 17, 212, 5], [18, 17, 228, 227], [19, 17, 219, 218], [20, 17, 213, 212], [12, 18, 11, 10], [13, 18, 7, 6], [18, 18, 231, 229], [20, 18, 212, 4], [11, 19, 21, 230], [12, 19, 11, 217], [13, 19, 5, 211], [18, 19, 227, 228], [19, 19, 218, 217], [20, 19, 212, 211], [11, 20, 233, 232], [12, 20, 10, 226], [13, 20, 6, 218], [18, 20, 229, 234], [19, 20, 217, 228], [20, 20, 4, 216], [11, 21, 230, 223], [12, 21, 217, 178], [13, 21, 211, 210], [18, 21, 228, 224], [19, 21, 217, 208], [20, 21, 211, 210], [11, 22, 232, 227], [12, 22, 226, 219], [13, 22, 218, 178], [18, 22, 234, 221], [19, 22, 228, 218], [20, 22, 216, 214], [11, 23, 223, 229], [12, 23, 178, 214], [13, 23, 210, 178], [19, 23, 208, 218], [11, 24, 227, 218], [12, 24, 219, 208], [13, 24, 178, 211], [18, 24, 221, 223], [19, 24, 218, 215], [20, 24, 214, 211], [11, 25, 229, 222], [12, 25, 214, 31], [13, 25, 178, 212], [18, 25, 224, 225], [19, 25, 218, 31], [20, 25, 210, 211], [11, 26, 218, 219], [12, 26, 208, 218], [13, 26, 211, 214], [18, 26, 223, 222], [19, 26, 215, 216], [20, 26, 211, 216], [11, 27, 222, 31], [13, 27, 212, 256], [18, 27, 225, 31], [20, 27, 211, 31], [10, 28, 31, 256], [11, 28, 219, 256], [12, 28, 218, 256], [13, 28, 214, 256], [17, 28, 31, 256], [18, 28, 222, 256], [19, 28, 216, 256], [20, 28, 216, 256], [10, 29, 31, 256], [11, 29, 31, 256], [12, 29, 31, 256], [17, 29, 31, 256], [18, 29, 31, 256], [19, 29, 31, 256]]}, {\"asset\": \"30088\", \"changed_cells\": 73, \"changed_rows\": {\"6\": 1, \"17\": 6, \"18\": 4, \"19\": 6, \"20\": 5, \"21\": 6, \"22\": 6, \"23\": 6, \"24\": 4, \"25\": 6, \"26\": 5, \"27\": 6, \"28\": 6, \"29\": 6}, \"changes\": [[9, 6, 234, 229], [11, 17, 230, 233], [12, 17, 219, 11], [13, 17, 212, 7], [18, 17, 228, 231], [19, 17, 219, 217], [20, 17, 213, 212], [11, 18, 233, 21], [13, 18, 7, 5], [18, 18, 231, 227], [19, 18, 217, 218], [11, 19, 21, 233], [12, 19, 11, 10], [13, 19, 5, 6], [18, 19, 227, 229], [19, 19, 218, 217], [20, 19, 212, 4], [11, 20, 233, 230], [12, 20, 10, 217], [13, 20, 6, 211], [18, 20, 229, 228], [20, 20, 4, 211], [11, 21, 230, 232], [12, 21, 217, 226], [13, 21, 211, 218], [18, 21, 228, 234], [19, 21, 217, 228], [20, 21, 211, 216], [11, 22, 232, 223], [12, 22, 226, 178], [13, 22, 218, 210], [18, 22, 234, 224], [19, 22, 228, 208], [20, 22, 216, 210], [11, 23, 223, 227], [12, 23, 178, 219], [13, 23, 210, 178], [18, 23, 224, 221], [19, 23, 208, 218], [20, 23, 210, 214], [11, 24, 227, 229], [12, 24, 219, 214], [18, 24, 221, 224], [20, 24, 214, 210], [11, 25, 229, 218], [12, 25, 214, 208], [13, 25, 178, 211], [18, 25, 224, 223], [19, 25, 218, 215], [20, 25, 210, 211], [11, 26, 218, 222], [12, 26, 208, 31], [13, 26, 211, 212], [18, 26, 223, 225], [19, 26, 215, 31], [11, 27, 222, 219], [12, 27, 31, 218], [13, 27, 212, 214], [18, 27, 225, 222], [19, 27, 31, 216], [20, 27, 211, 216], [11, 28, 219, 31], [12, 28, 218, 31], [13, 28, 214, 256], [18, 28, 222, 31], [19, 28, 216, 31], [20, 28, 216, 256], [10, 29, 31, 256], [11, 29, 31, 256], [12, 29, 31, 256], [17, 29, 31, 256], [18, 29, 31, 256], [19, 29, 31, 256]]}], \"all_phase_source_stationary_occupied_cells\": 485, \"independent_row_based_metrics_match_worker\": true, \"row_based_metrics\": [{\"asset\": \"30086\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 171, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 0, \"max_channel_difference\": 28}, {\"asset\": \"30087\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 167, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 1, \"max_channel_difference\": 36}, {\"asset\": \"30088\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 167, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 1, \"max_channel_difference\": 32}], \"all_source_stationary_comparisons\": [{\"asset\": \"30086\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 255, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 485, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[10, 24, 33.0, [56.0, 40.0, 36.0], [89.0, 69.0, 56.0]], [10, 26, 49.0, [65.0, 48.0, 40.0], [16.0, 16.0, 16.0]], [17, 26, 65.0, [81.0, 60.0, 52.0], [16.0, 16.0, 16.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1223, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1940, \"opacity_changes\": [[12, 6, 234, 256], [13, 6, 232, 256], [14, 6, 230, 256], [15, 6, 20, 256], [16, 6, 229, 256], [17, 6, 233, 256], [44, 6, 231, 256], [45, 6, 229, 256], [46, 6, 230, 256], [47, 6, 231, 256], [48, 6, 231, 256], [49, 6, 232, 256], [50, 6, 236, 256], [21, 8, 23, 256], [22, 8, 22, 256], [23, 8, 21, 256], [24, 8, 22, 256], [26, 8, 21, 256], [27, 8, 20, 256], [28, 8, 22, 256], [29, 8, 20, 256], [30, 8, 22, 256], [31, 8, 24, 256], [32, 8, 235, 256], [38, 8, 232, 256], [39, 8, 232, 256], [40, 8, 230, 256], [41, 8, 229, 256], [52, 8, 233, 256], [34, 48, 28, 256], [34, 49, 27, 256], [34, 50, 237, 256], [34, 51, 237, 256], [34, 52, 27, 256], [34, 53, 26, 256], [11, 57, 256, 31], [12, 57, 256, 0], [13, 57, 256, 0], [14, 57, 256, 0], [15, 57, 256, 0], [44, 57, 256, 0], [45, 57, 256, 0], [46, 57, 256, 0], [47, 57, 256, 0], [48, 57, 256, 0]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[6, 3, 32.75, [104.5, 84.5, 72.5], [71.75, 65.5, 62.5]], [7, 3, 44.5, [126.5, 107.5, 92.75], [82.0, 75.5, 71.5]], [8, 3, 44.5, [129.5, 100.25, 83.5], [85.0, 78.75, 74.5]], [22, 3, 45.5, [127.5, 101.0, 85.5], [82.0, 75.5, 71.5]], [23, 3, 44.5, [125.5, 101.25, 84.5], [81.0, 74.5, 69.5]], [24, 3, 37.0, [107.5, 86.5, 73.5], [70.5, 64.5, 61.5]], [11, 4, 35.5, [113.5, 112.5, 112.5], [78.0, 80.75, 85.75]], [13, 4, 35.0, [105.5, 103.0, 103.0], [70.5, 74.5, 79.5]], [19, 4, 41.0, [141.0, 115.0, 99.0], [100.0, 85.0, 78.5]], [20, 4, 41.5, [127.5, 108.5, 91.75], [86.0, 80.75, 75.5]], [10, 26, 52.75, [67.75, 57.5, 49.5], [15.0, 11.0, 10.0]], [17, 26, 58.5, [77.5, 67.5, 59.5], [19.0, 23.0, 28.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 12}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2901, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4365, \"opacity_changes\": [[29, 12, 235, 256], [78, 12, 234, 256], [79, 13, 234, 256], [51, 72, 28, 256], [52, 80, 237, 256], [29, 81, 0, 256], [29, 82, 29, 256], [17, 86, 256, 30], [18, 86, 256, 31], [19, 86, 256, 31], [20, 86, 256, 31], [21, 86, 256, 31], [22, 86, 256, 31], [23, 86, 256, 31], [26, 85, 30, 256], [24, 86, 256, 31], [67, 86, 256, 31], [68, 86, 256, 31], [69, 86, 256, 31], [70, 86, 256, 31], [71, 86, 256, 31], [72, 86, 256, 31], [73, 86, 256, 31], [74, 86, 256, 31]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[10, 26, 57.2222, [72.88888888888889, 58.77777777777778, 50.333333333333336], [15.666666666666666, 12.555555555555555, 10.666666666666666]], [17, 26, 56.5556, [76.22222222222223, 66.88888888888889, 61.44444444444444], [19.666666666666668, 21.333333333333332, 24.88888888888889]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 2}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 5245, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 7760, \"opacity_changes\": [[36, 13, 229, 256], [38, 15, 233, 256], [102, 13, 238, 256], [40, 17, 20, 256], [42, 17, 20, 256], [43, 17, 18, 256], [48, 17, 19, 256], [49, 17, 19, 256], [50, 17, 19, 256], [56, 17, 20, 256], [57, 17, 20, 256], [58, 17, 19, 256], [59, 17, 19, 256], [60, 17, 19, 256], [61, 17, 20, 256], [64, 17, 233, 256], [65, 17, 233, 256], [66, 17, 233, 256], [67, 17, 232, 256], [68, 17, 230, 256], [69, 17, 229, 256], [70, 17, 232, 256], [71, 17, 234, 256], [72, 17, 233, 256], [73, 17, 232, 256], [74, 17, 232, 256], [82, 17, 229, 256], [84, 16, 235, 256], [104, 16, 235, 256], [105, 17, 232, 256], [16, 20, 30, 256], [107, 20, 28, 256], [68, 96, 235, 256], [69, 106, 0, 256], [69, 107, 0, 256], [17, 110, 256, 31], [39, 108, 0, 256], [39, 109, 31, 256], [38, 110, 256, 30], [37, 111, 29, 256], [20, 113, 256, 0], [89, 115, 256, 30], [90, 115, 256, 31], [91, 115, 256, 31]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[10, 26, 54.1875, [70.625, 58.875, 50.125], [16.4375, 12.5625, 10.5625]], [17, 26, 53.1875, [72.75, 62.1875, 56.4375], [19.5625, 19.8125, 22.3125]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 2}]}, {\"asset\": \"30087\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 235, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 485, \"opacity_changes\": [[26, 4, 256, 235]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[26, 4, 36.0, [20.0, 28.0, 38.0], [56.0, 40.0, 36.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1097, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1940, \"opacity_changes\": [[21, 8, 23, 256], [22, 8, 22, 256], [23, 8, 21, 256], [24, 8, 22, 256], [26, 8, 21, 256], [27, 8, 20, 256], [28, 8, 22, 256], [29, 8, 20, 256], [30, 8, 22, 256], [31, 8, 24, 256], [32, 8, 235, 256], [38, 8, 232, 256], [39, 8, 232, 256], [41, 8, 229, 256], [34, 48, 28, 256], [42, 55, 27, 256], [43, 56, 29, 256], [45, 57, 256, 31], [49, 57, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 4, 32.75, [105.5, 103.0, 103.0], [72.75, 75.5, 80.5]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2664, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4365, \"opacity_changes\": [[77, 10, 256, 237], [42, 71, 30, 256], [43, 71, 30, 256], [44, 71, 31, 256], [45, 71, 31, 256], [46, 71, 0, 256], [47, 71, 0, 256], [48, 71, 0, 256], [49, 71, 0, 256], [50, 71, 31, 256], [51, 72, 28, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[10, 23, 32.3333, [68.22222222222223, 58.333333333333336, 50.22222222222222], [35.888888888888886, 29.22222222222222, 25.11111111111111]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 4873, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 7760, \"opacity_changes\": [[103, 14, 256, 28], [39, 16, 256, 233], [84, 16, 235, 256], [106, 18, 256, 235], [56, 95, 0, 256], [57, 95, 0, 256], [58, 95, 0, 256], [59, 95, 0, 256], [60, 95, 0, 256], [61, 95, 0, 256], [62, 95, 0, 256], [63, 95, 0, 256], [64, 95, 0, 256], [65, 95, 0, 256], [66, 95, 0, 256], [67, 95, 0, 256], [68, 95, 0, 256], [68, 96, 235, 256], [37, 111, 29, 256], [84, 110, 29, 256], [85, 111, 27, 256], [21, 114, 0, 256], [86, 112, 30, 256], [87, 113, 30, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[10, 23, 33.8125, [69.0625, 56.75, 48.25], [35.25, 30.25, 26.75]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}]}, {\"asset\": \"30088\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 240, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 485, \"opacity_changes\": [[26, 4, 256, 236]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[26, 4, 32.0, [20.0, 28.0, 38.0], [52.0, 36.0, 32.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1126, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1940, \"opacity_changes\": [[21, 8, 23, 256], [22, 8, 22, 256], [23, 8, 21, 256], [24, 8, 22, 256], [26, 8, 21, 256], [27, 8, 20, 256], [30, 8, 22, 256], [31, 8, 24, 256], [32, 8, 235, 256], [38, 8, 232, 256], [39, 8, 232, 256], [40, 8, 230, 256], [41, 8, 229, 256], [53, 9, 256, 237], [34, 48, 28, 256], [34, 49, 27, 256], [34, 50, 237, 256], [34, 51, 237, 256], [34, 52, 27, 256], [34, 53, 26, 256], [42, 55, 27, 256], [43, 56, 29, 256], [49, 57, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[20, 4, 32.5, [127.5, 108.5, 91.75], [95.0, 91.0, 83.75]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2721, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4365, \"opacity_changes\": [[77, 10, 256, 237], [42, 71, 30, 256], [43, 71, 30, 256], [44, 71, 31, 256], [45, 71, 31, 256], [46, 71, 0, 256], [47, 71, 0, 256], [48, 71, 0, 256], [49, 71, 0, 256], [50, 71, 31, 256], [51, 71, 0, 256], [51, 72, 28, 256], [26, 85, 30, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 4960, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 7760, \"opacity_changes\": [[103, 14, 256, 28], [39, 16, 256, 236], [84, 16, 235, 256], [106, 18, 256, 236], [56, 95, 0, 256], [57, 95, 0, 256], [58, 95, 0, 256], [59, 95, 0, 256], [60, 95, 0, 256], [61, 95, 0, 256], [62, 95, 0, 256], [63, 95, 0, 256], [64, 95, 0, 256], [65, 95, 0, 256], [66, 95, 0, 256], [67, 95, 0, 256], [68, 95, 0, 256], [68, 96, 235, 256], [16, 108, 31, 256], [37, 111, 29, 256], [84, 110, 29, 256], [85, 111, 27, 256], [21, 114, 0, 256], [86, 112, 30, 256], [87, 113, 30, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}]}]} [\"Isolated actual Catalog/HdAssets source-bound sprite raster and artistic approval only. No new Host enemy occurrence, animation timing, terrain blend, gameplay, simulation-neutrality or fullscreen capture.\", \"Broader game-source freshness flag is true due to unrelated menu/game edits; relevant assets/hd loader source is current.\", \"Complete shared family scale, origin and all rawalpha>=16/>=32 crop retention independently verified. Palette classes, forced indices and all240\\u2013255counts pass; these numeric checks do not substitute for the completed artistic review.\", \"Original/source and newly authored stationary body shading are not byte identical; localized variations and native/2\\u00d7 contour smoothing are deliberately disclosed.\", \"Global registration and bundled pack snapshot remain coordinator-owned; no source/candidate/raw/global/Git edits by reviewer.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/independent-review.json, SHA256 f6c62881aa1b2c8f035cd588b6d4e11b8b543af4a03a6a56616613afe6be7839", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/inputs/enemies-30085-30088/runtime-review/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "680d5b7bdc22824d830466af4958734e85c7cc15256161f589b1eada1e9122a0" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "26ce2f190978e8c78b69c05c2c1e50e4c0faa6716b81f5c0da237c01e576ac6d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "30085", + "30086", + "30087", + "30088" + ], + "sha256": "6098ddc1718247e3ae78bf0189bfaf3ab0db23ca7f1fd6d17716576a640b9d67", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "30085-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b352fa2d84df8be85d3453226900c7dc3dd9e2a72368d51f97eddd9aeddbcd54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30085-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30085-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "994adf7b3315fa81b0102285dcc0dd92e2f3c7be99f3d5735fc64b84fffbf117", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30085-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30085-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "94ba0bede4b97116ea13ad73265bbf4d6525ac69a2072acd1a6694619acd7280", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30085-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30085-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "554be3d8138d0d9dd150f362a9e2778323a29665beacae6082d5939b46f30052", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30085-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30085-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6becde0e6286c18a3fe5b424c1b1ab1b6b55930f9e839326815a845a5409997f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30085-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30086-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3acd58213d25a8d450f9921bd27861edbb8acbf0ca1b476e7e9f8a7734ddbf01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30086-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30086-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6e721c34dcfc96b30f2bc92ff193cf23c1f38ab6eeea10617fc031f0fd00e210", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30086-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30086-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "644fd117f85d575d1cb1dc0336370c77ae0084f163cddd57075d28a20618ba08", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30086-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30086-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3a06b1fb65d6a6a76dcb86fad4159c313f323b060e27931de3c8190309a2683a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30086-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30086-original.ppm", + "sha256": "dfc125281c939aa7aa67c0f34391a4dd71140a7a582ad7a45c466e9498cba837", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30086-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30087-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c3b6ec8e0ef6a40ef4ac8764c7e8204e208a425644da042ed2b4335e61b6482c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30087-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30087-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf80e486b5b6b0d567590c40305716f934b6b2a6ee5a79d56dfc7c5da8fc3489", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30087-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30087-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "11de9ccf9b6ec25d19f0433d7672c3a7275995f088ce05b7dce1978a5207777e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30087-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30087-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c6e29f25375319520c2f7c91c12a1bf42a105b0f346d02e0f6d38cb620703c9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30087-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30087-original.ppm", + "sha256": "897f8e60171aa2447717815f8a44adc75901f3228ae8446248e0c46305226882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30087-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30088-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91eed83cb809069a38f809e441b3ea5891bef0be6e96ad5bb51c19331aa5726b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30088-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30088-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4aff80d63540eaac05f9eb3a2299ad1ef2ea53c828b608d7831f0702ec0c94ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30088-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30088-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ebd585d2efed2d53a8c7e13bd77a5f6686d81dc3d32674cdf38baf7958ff7e31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30088-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30088-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fe104624901259eb5ec2fe1cc1cf1a44f4bcee9300ec5f3f86534e29b7001ca4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30088-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30088-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2f5768643e5f0c624b0dbf138139ef301f6b23276b678f71e14b5dcd29eab987", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30088-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30088": { @@ -240655,7 +246074,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30088", "family_id": "enemies-30085-30088", "job_id": "enemies-30085-30088", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -240667,6 +246086,143 @@ "manifest": "jobs/enemies-30085-30088/candidate.json", "sha256": "fb0785c9c88080cbee4602e784892ad29a71cdedbb2ded6f579e901e7c3db4dc", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "fb0785c9c88080cbee4602e784892ad29a71cdedbb2ded6f579e901e7c3db4dc", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "8dc37a284e0a31c76454230b0c34449340a1ce720d44077df3eb6b49a66ac625", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:31.246083+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/enemies-30085-30088/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"Bronze/gray tracked body, upper bridge, side pods, framed center and two pale forks remain source-aligned. Original phase0 forks extend to occupied row29; later phases end row28. Original changing fork colors/lengths and side shading remain distinct at all scales.\", \"Native1 loses3/4/2/4 source contour cells;2\\u00d7 loses only(21,28) in30087/30088. All survive3\\u20134. These are localized boundary smoothing, not clipped crop content or missing major limbs. Upper stationary rows3\\u201316 have171/167/167 shade differences,0/1/1 >=32 delta; source phase3 own tiny row6 color change is preserved as ordinary palette material.\"] {\"source_phase_differences\": [{\"asset\": \"30085\", \"changed_cells\": 0, \"changed_rows\": {}, \"changes\": []}, {\"asset\": \"30086\", \"changed_cells\": 81, \"changed_rows\": {\"17\": 6, \"18\": 5, \"19\": 6, \"20\": 6, \"21\": 6, \"22\": 6, \"23\": 6, \"24\": 6, \"25\": 6, \"26\": 6, \"27\": 8, \"28\": 8, \"29\": 6}, \"changes\": [[11, 17, 230, 233], [12, 17, 219, 10], [13, 17, 212, 6], [18, 17, 228, 229], [19, 17, 219, 217], [20, 17, 213, 4], [11, 18, 233, 230], [12, 18, 11, 217], [13, 18, 7, 211], [18, 18, 231, 228], [20, 18, 212, 211], [11, 19, 21, 232], [12, 19, 11, 226], [13, 19, 5, 218], [18, 19, 227, 234], [19, 19, 218, 228], [20, 19, 212, 216], [11, 20, 233, 223], [12, 20, 10, 178], [13, 20, 6, 210], [18, 20, 229, 224], [19, 20, 217, 208], [20, 20, 4, 210], [11, 21, 230, 227], [12, 21, 217, 219], [13, 21, 211, 178], [18, 21, 228, 221], [19, 21, 217, 218], [20, 21, 211, 214], [11, 22, 232, 229], [12, 22, 226, 214], [13, 22, 218, 178], [18, 22, 234, 224], [19, 22, 228, 218], [20, 22, 216, 210], [11, 23, 223, 218], [12, 23, 178, 208], [13, 23, 210, 211], [18, 23, 224, 223], [19, 23, 208, 215], [20, 23, 210, 211], [11, 24, 227, 222], [12, 24, 219, 31], [13, 24, 178, 212], [18, 24, 221, 225], [19, 24, 218, 31], [20, 24, 214, 211], [11, 25, 229, 219], [12, 25, 214, 218], [13, 25, 178, 214], [18, 25, 224, 222], [19, 25, 218, 216], [20, 25, 210, 216], [11, 26, 218, 31], [12, 26, 208, 31], [13, 26, 211, 256], [18, 26, 223, 31], [19, 26, 215, 31], [20, 26, 211, 31], [10, 27, 31, 256], [11, 27, 222, 256], [12, 27, 31, 256], [13, 27, 212, 256], [17, 27, 31, 256], [18, 27, 225, 256], [19, 27, 31, 256], [20, 27, 211, 31], [10, 28, 31, 256], [11, 28, 219, 256], [12, 28, 218, 256], [13, 28, 214, 256], [17, 28, 31, 256], [18, 28, 222, 256], [19, 28, 216, 256], [20, 28, 216, 256], [10, 29, 31, 256], [11, 29, 31, 256], [12, 29, 31, 256], [17, 29, 31, 256], [18, 29, 31, 256], [19, 29, 31, 256]]}, {\"asset\": \"30087\", \"changed_cells\": 74, \"changed_rows\": {\"17\": 6, \"18\": 4, \"19\": 6, \"20\": 6, \"21\": 6, \"22\": 6, \"23\": 4, \"24\": 6, \"25\": 6, \"26\": 6, \"27\": 4, \"28\": 8, \"29\": 6}, \"changes\": [[11, 17, 230, 21], [12, 17, 219, 11], [13, 17, 212, 5], [18, 17, 228, 227], [19, 17, 219, 218], [20, 17, 213, 212], [12, 18, 11, 10], [13, 18, 7, 6], [18, 18, 231, 229], [20, 18, 212, 4], [11, 19, 21, 230], [12, 19, 11, 217], [13, 19, 5, 211], [18, 19, 227, 228], [19, 19, 218, 217], [20, 19, 212, 211], [11, 20, 233, 232], [12, 20, 10, 226], [13, 20, 6, 218], [18, 20, 229, 234], [19, 20, 217, 228], [20, 20, 4, 216], [11, 21, 230, 223], [12, 21, 217, 178], [13, 21, 211, 210], [18, 21, 228, 224], [19, 21, 217, 208], [20, 21, 211, 210], [11, 22, 232, 227], [12, 22, 226, 219], [13, 22, 218, 178], [18, 22, 234, 221], [19, 22, 228, 218], [20, 22, 216, 214], [11, 23, 223, 229], [12, 23, 178, 214], [13, 23, 210, 178], [19, 23, 208, 218], [11, 24, 227, 218], [12, 24, 219, 208], [13, 24, 178, 211], [18, 24, 221, 223], [19, 24, 218, 215], [20, 24, 214, 211], [11, 25, 229, 222], [12, 25, 214, 31], [13, 25, 178, 212], [18, 25, 224, 225], [19, 25, 218, 31], [20, 25, 210, 211], [11, 26, 218, 219], [12, 26, 208, 218], [13, 26, 211, 214], [18, 26, 223, 222], [19, 26, 215, 216], [20, 26, 211, 216], [11, 27, 222, 31], [13, 27, 212, 256], [18, 27, 225, 31], [20, 27, 211, 31], [10, 28, 31, 256], [11, 28, 219, 256], [12, 28, 218, 256], [13, 28, 214, 256], [17, 28, 31, 256], [18, 28, 222, 256], [19, 28, 216, 256], [20, 28, 216, 256], [10, 29, 31, 256], [11, 29, 31, 256], [12, 29, 31, 256], [17, 29, 31, 256], [18, 29, 31, 256], [19, 29, 31, 256]]}, {\"asset\": \"30088\", \"changed_cells\": 73, \"changed_rows\": {\"6\": 1, \"17\": 6, \"18\": 4, \"19\": 6, \"20\": 5, \"21\": 6, \"22\": 6, \"23\": 6, \"24\": 4, \"25\": 6, \"26\": 5, \"27\": 6, \"28\": 6, \"29\": 6}, \"changes\": [[9, 6, 234, 229], [11, 17, 230, 233], [12, 17, 219, 11], [13, 17, 212, 7], [18, 17, 228, 231], [19, 17, 219, 217], [20, 17, 213, 212], [11, 18, 233, 21], [13, 18, 7, 5], [18, 18, 231, 227], [19, 18, 217, 218], [11, 19, 21, 233], [12, 19, 11, 10], [13, 19, 5, 6], [18, 19, 227, 229], [19, 19, 218, 217], [20, 19, 212, 4], [11, 20, 233, 230], [12, 20, 10, 217], [13, 20, 6, 211], [18, 20, 229, 228], [20, 20, 4, 211], [11, 21, 230, 232], [12, 21, 217, 226], [13, 21, 211, 218], [18, 21, 228, 234], [19, 21, 217, 228], [20, 21, 211, 216], [11, 22, 232, 223], [12, 22, 226, 178], [13, 22, 218, 210], [18, 22, 234, 224], [19, 22, 228, 208], [20, 22, 216, 210], [11, 23, 223, 227], [12, 23, 178, 219], [13, 23, 210, 178], [18, 23, 224, 221], [19, 23, 208, 218], [20, 23, 210, 214], [11, 24, 227, 229], [12, 24, 219, 214], [18, 24, 221, 224], [20, 24, 214, 210], [11, 25, 229, 218], [12, 25, 214, 208], [13, 25, 178, 211], [18, 25, 224, 223], [19, 25, 218, 215], [20, 25, 210, 211], [11, 26, 218, 222], [12, 26, 208, 31], [13, 26, 211, 212], [18, 26, 223, 225], [19, 26, 215, 31], [11, 27, 222, 219], [12, 27, 31, 218], [13, 27, 212, 214], [18, 27, 225, 222], [19, 27, 31, 216], [20, 27, 211, 216], [11, 28, 219, 31], [12, 28, 218, 31], [13, 28, 214, 256], [18, 28, 222, 31], [19, 28, 216, 31], [20, 28, 216, 256], [10, 29, 31, 256], [11, 29, 31, 256], [12, 29, 31, 256], [17, 29, 31, 256], [18, 29, 31, 256], [19, 29, 31, 256]]}], \"all_phase_source_stationary_occupied_cells\": 485, \"independent_row_based_metrics_match_worker\": true, \"row_based_metrics\": [{\"asset\": \"30086\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 171, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 0, \"max_channel_difference\": 28}, {\"asset\": \"30087\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 167, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 1, \"max_channel_difference\": 36}, {\"asset\": \"30088\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 167, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 1, \"max_channel_difference\": 32}], \"all_source_stationary_comparisons\": [{\"asset\": \"30086\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 255, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 485, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[10, 24, 33.0, [56.0, 40.0, 36.0], [89.0, 69.0, 56.0]], [10, 26, 49.0, [65.0, 48.0, 40.0], [16.0, 16.0, 16.0]], [17, 26, 65.0, [81.0, 60.0, 52.0], [16.0, 16.0, 16.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 3}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1223, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1940, \"opacity_changes\": [[12, 6, 234, 256], [13, 6, 232, 256], [14, 6, 230, 256], [15, 6, 20, 256], [16, 6, 229, 256], [17, 6, 233, 256], [44, 6, 231, 256], [45, 6, 229, 256], [46, 6, 230, 256], [47, 6, 231, 256], [48, 6, 231, 256], [49, 6, 232, 256], [50, 6, 236, 256], [21, 8, 23, 256], [22, 8, 22, 256], [23, 8, 21, 256], [24, 8, 22, 256], [26, 8, 21, 256], [27, 8, 20, 256], [28, 8, 22, 256], [29, 8, 20, 256], [30, 8, 22, 256], [31, 8, 24, 256], [32, 8, 235, 256], [38, 8, 232, 256], [39, 8, 232, 256], [40, 8, 230, 256], [41, 8, 229, 256], [52, 8, 233, 256], [34, 48, 28, 256], [34, 49, 27, 256], [34, 50, 237, 256], [34, 51, 237, 256], [34, 52, 27, 256], [34, 53, 26, 256], [11, 57, 256, 31], [12, 57, 256, 0], [13, 57, 256, 0], [14, 57, 256, 0], [15, 57, 256, 0], [44, 57, 256, 0], [45, 57, 256, 0], [46, 57, 256, 0], [47, 57, 256, 0], [48, 57, 256, 0]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[6, 3, 32.75, [104.5, 84.5, 72.5], [71.75, 65.5, 62.5]], [7, 3, 44.5, [126.5, 107.5, 92.75], [82.0, 75.5, 71.5]], [8, 3, 44.5, [129.5, 100.25, 83.5], [85.0, 78.75, 74.5]], [22, 3, 45.5, [127.5, 101.0, 85.5], [82.0, 75.5, 71.5]], [23, 3, 44.5, [125.5, 101.25, 84.5], [81.0, 74.5, 69.5]], [24, 3, 37.0, [107.5, 86.5, 73.5], [70.5, 64.5, 61.5]], [11, 4, 35.5, [113.5, 112.5, 112.5], [78.0, 80.75, 85.75]], [13, 4, 35.0, [105.5, 103.0, 103.0], [70.5, 74.5, 79.5]], [19, 4, 41.0, [141.0, 115.0, 99.0], [100.0, 85.0, 78.5]], [20, 4, 41.5, [127.5, 108.5, 91.75], [86.0, 80.75, 75.5]], [10, 26, 52.75, [67.75, 57.5, 49.5], [15.0, 11.0, 10.0]], [17, 26, 58.5, [77.5, 67.5, 59.5], [19.0, 23.0, 28.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 12}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2901, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4365, \"opacity_changes\": [[29, 12, 235, 256], [78, 12, 234, 256], [79, 13, 234, 256], [51, 72, 28, 256], [52, 80, 237, 256], [29, 81, 0, 256], [29, 82, 29, 256], [17, 86, 256, 30], [18, 86, 256, 31], [19, 86, 256, 31], [20, 86, 256, 31], [21, 86, 256, 31], [22, 86, 256, 31], [23, 86, 256, 31], [26, 85, 30, 256], [24, 86, 256, 31], [67, 86, 256, 31], [68, 86, 256, 31], [69, 86, 256, 31], [70, 86, 256, 31], [71, 86, 256, 31], [72, 86, 256, 31], [73, 86, 256, 31], [74, 86, 256, 31]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[10, 26, 57.2222, [72.88888888888889, 58.77777777777778, 50.333333333333336], [15.666666666666666, 12.555555555555555, 10.666666666666666]], [17, 26, 56.5556, [76.22222222222223, 66.88888888888889, 61.44444444444444], [19.666666666666668, 21.333333333333332, 24.88888888888889]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 2}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 5245, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 7760, \"opacity_changes\": [[36, 13, 229, 256], [38, 15, 233, 256], [102, 13, 238, 256], [40, 17, 20, 256], [42, 17, 20, 256], [43, 17, 18, 256], [48, 17, 19, 256], [49, 17, 19, 256], [50, 17, 19, 256], [56, 17, 20, 256], [57, 17, 20, 256], [58, 17, 19, 256], [59, 17, 19, 256], [60, 17, 19, 256], [61, 17, 20, 256], [64, 17, 233, 256], [65, 17, 233, 256], [66, 17, 233, 256], [67, 17, 232, 256], [68, 17, 230, 256], [69, 17, 229, 256], [70, 17, 232, 256], [71, 17, 234, 256], [72, 17, 233, 256], [73, 17, 232, 256], [74, 17, 232, 256], [82, 17, 229, 256], [84, 16, 235, 256], [104, 16, 235, 256], [105, 17, 232, 256], [16, 20, 30, 256], [107, 20, 28, 256], [68, 96, 235, 256], [69, 106, 0, 256], [69, 107, 0, 256], [17, 110, 256, 31], [39, 108, 0, 256], [39, 109, 31, 256], [38, 110, 256, 30], [37, 111, 29, 256], [20, 113, 256, 0], [89, 115, 256, 30], [90, 115, 256, 31], [91, 115, 256, 31]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[10, 26, 54.1875, [70.625, 58.875, 50.125], [16.4375, 12.5625, 10.5625]], [17, 26, 53.1875, [72.75, 62.1875, 56.4375], [19.5625, 19.8125, 22.3125]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 2}]}, {\"asset\": \"30087\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 235, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 485, \"opacity_changes\": [[26, 4, 256, 235]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[26, 4, 36.0, [20.0, 28.0, 38.0], [56.0, 40.0, 36.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1097, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1940, \"opacity_changes\": [[21, 8, 23, 256], [22, 8, 22, 256], [23, 8, 21, 256], [24, 8, 22, 256], [26, 8, 21, 256], [27, 8, 20, 256], [28, 8, 22, 256], [29, 8, 20, 256], [30, 8, 22, 256], [31, 8, 24, 256], [32, 8, 235, 256], [38, 8, 232, 256], [39, 8, 232, 256], [41, 8, 229, 256], [34, 48, 28, 256], [42, 55, 27, 256], [43, 56, 29, 256], [45, 57, 256, 31], [49, 57, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[13, 4, 32.75, [105.5, 103.0, 103.0], [72.75, 75.5, 80.5]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2664, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4365, \"opacity_changes\": [[77, 10, 256, 237], [42, 71, 30, 256], [43, 71, 30, 256], [44, 71, 31, 256], [45, 71, 31, 256], [46, 71, 0, 256], [47, 71, 0, 256], [48, 71, 0, 256], [49, 71, 0, 256], [50, 71, 31, 256], [51, 72, 28, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[10, 23, 32.3333, [68.22222222222223, 58.333333333333336, 50.22222222222222], [35.888888888888886, 29.22222222222222, 25.11111111111111]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 4873, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 7760, \"opacity_changes\": [[103, 14, 256, 28], [39, 16, 256, 233], [84, 16, 235, 256], [106, 18, 256, 235], [56, 95, 0, 256], [57, 95, 0, 256], [58, 95, 0, 256], [59, 95, 0, 256], [60, 95, 0, 256], [61, 95, 0, 256], [62, 95, 0, 256], [63, 95, 0, 256], [64, 95, 0, 256], [65, 95, 0, 256], [66, 95, 0, 256], [67, 95, 0, 256], [68, 95, 0, 256], [68, 96, 235, 256], [37, 111, 29, 256], [84, 110, 29, 256], [85, 111, 27, 256], [21, 114, 0, 256], [86, 112, 30, 256], [87, 113, 30, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[10, 23, 33.8125, [69.0625, 56.75, 48.25], [35.25, 30.25, 26.75]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}]}, {\"asset\": \"30088\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 240, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 485, \"opacity_changes\": [[26, 4, 256, 236]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[26, 4, 32.0, [20.0, 28.0, 38.0], [52.0, 36.0, 32.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1126, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1940, \"opacity_changes\": [[21, 8, 23, 256], [22, 8, 22, 256], [23, 8, 21, 256], [24, 8, 22, 256], [26, 8, 21, 256], [27, 8, 20, 256], [30, 8, 22, 256], [31, 8, 24, 256], [32, 8, 235, 256], [38, 8, 232, 256], [39, 8, 232, 256], [40, 8, 230, 256], [41, 8, 229, 256], [53, 9, 256, 237], [34, 48, 28, 256], [34, 49, 27, 256], [34, 50, 237, 256], [34, 51, 237, 256], [34, 52, 27, 256], [34, 53, 26, 256], [42, 55, 27, 256], [43, 56, 29, 256], [49, 57, 31, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[20, 4, 32.5, [127.5, 108.5, 91.75], [95.0, 91.0, 83.75]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 1}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 2721, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4365, \"opacity_changes\": [[77, 10, 256, 237], [42, 71, 30, 256], [43, 71, 30, 256], [44, 71, 31, 256], [45, 71, 31, 256], [46, 71, 0, 256], [47, 71, 0, 256], [48, 71, 0, 256], [49, 71, 0, 256], [50, 71, 31, 256], [51, 71, 0, 256], [51, 72, 28, 256], [26, 85, 30, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 4960, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 7760, \"opacity_changes\": [[103, 14, 256, 28], [39, 16, 256, 236], [84, 16, 235, 256], [106, 18, 256, 236], [56, 95, 0, 256], [57, 95, 0, 256], [58, 95, 0, 256], [59, 95, 0, 256], [60, 95, 0, 256], [61, 95, 0, 256], [62, 95, 0, 256], [63, 95, 0, 256], [64, 95, 0, 256], [65, 95, 0, 256], [66, 95, 0, 256], [67, 95, 0, 256], [68, 95, 0, 256], [68, 96, 235, 256], [16, 108, 31, 256], [37, 111, 29, 256], [84, 110, 29, 256], [85, 111, 27, 256], [21, 114, 0, 256], [86, 112, 30, 256], [87, 113, 30, 256]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}]}]} [\"Isolated actual Catalog/HdAssets source-bound sprite raster and artistic approval only. No new Host enemy occurrence, animation timing, terrain blend, gameplay, simulation-neutrality or fullscreen capture.\", \"Broader game-source freshness flag is true due to unrelated menu/game edits; relevant assets/hd loader source is current.\", \"Complete shared family scale, origin and all rawalpha>=16/>=32 crop retention independently verified. Palette classes, forced indices and all240\\u2013255counts pass; these numeric checks do not substitute for the completed artistic review.\", \"Original/source and newly authored stationary body shading are not byte identical; localized variations and native/2\\u00d7 contour smoothing are deliberately disclosed.\", \"Global registration and bundled pack snapshot remain coordinator-owned; no source/candidate/raw/global/Git edits by reviewer.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/independent-review.json, SHA256 f6c62881aa1b2c8f035cd588b6d4e11b8b543af4a03a6a56616613afe6be7839", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/inputs/enemies-30085-30088/runtime-review/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "680d5b7bdc22824d830466af4958734e85c7cc15256161f589b1eada1e9122a0" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "26ce2f190978e8c78b69c05c2c1e50e4c0faa6716b81f5c0da237c01e576ac6d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "30085", + "30086", + "30087", + "30088" + ], + "sha256": "6098ddc1718247e3ae78bf0189bfaf3ab0db23ca7f1fd6d17716576a640b9d67", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "30085-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b352fa2d84df8be85d3453226900c7dc3dd9e2a72368d51f97eddd9aeddbcd54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30085-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30085-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "994adf7b3315fa81b0102285dcc0dd92e2f3c7be99f3d5735fc64b84fffbf117", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30085-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30085-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "94ba0bede4b97116ea13ad73265bbf4d6525ac69a2072acd1a6694619acd7280", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30085-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30085-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "554be3d8138d0d9dd150f362a9e2778323a29665beacae6082d5939b46f30052", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30085-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30085-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6becde0e6286c18a3fe5b424c1b1ab1b6b55930f9e839326815a845a5409997f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30085-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30086-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3acd58213d25a8d450f9921bd27861edbb8acbf0ca1b476e7e9f8a7734ddbf01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30086-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30086-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6e721c34dcfc96b30f2bc92ff193cf23c1f38ab6eeea10617fc031f0fd00e210", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30086-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30086-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "644fd117f85d575d1cb1dc0336370c77ae0084f163cddd57075d28a20618ba08", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30086-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30086-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3a06b1fb65d6a6a76dcb86fad4159c313f323b060e27931de3c8190309a2683a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30086-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30086-original.ppm", + "sha256": "dfc125281c939aa7aa67c0f34391a4dd71140a7a582ad7a45c466e9498cba837", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30086-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30087-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c3b6ec8e0ef6a40ef4ac8764c7e8204e208a425644da042ed2b4335e61b6482c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30087-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30087-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf80e486b5b6b0d567590c40305716f934b6b2a6ee5a79d56dfc7c5da8fc3489", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30087-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30087-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "11de9ccf9b6ec25d19f0433d7672c3a7275995f088ce05b7dce1978a5207777e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30087-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30087-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c6e29f25375319520c2f7c91c12a1bf42a105b0f346d02e0f6d38cb620703c9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30087-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30087-original.ppm", + "sha256": "897f8e60171aa2447717815f8a44adc75901f3228ae8446248e0c46305226882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30087-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30088-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91eed83cb809069a38f809e441b3ea5891bef0be6e96ad5bb51c19331aa5726b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30088-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30088-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4aff80d63540eaac05f9eb3a2299ad1ef2ea53c828b608d7831f0702ec0c94ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30088-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30088-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ebd585d2efed2d53a8c7e13bd77a5f6686d81dc3d32674cdf38baf7958ff7e31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30088-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30088-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fe104624901259eb5ec2fe1cc1cf1a44f4bcee9300ec5f3f86534e29b7001ca4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30088-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30088-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2f5768643e5f0c624b0dbf138139ef301f6b23276b678f71e14b5dcd29eab987", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/30088-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30089": { @@ -240754,7 +246310,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "3008b", "family_id": "enemies-3008b-3008c", "job_id": "enemies-3008b-3008c", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -240766,6 +246322,91 @@ "manifest": "jobs/enemies-3008b-3008c/candidate.json", "sha256": "05e1ca21fd8f7d7b02459175b03d963235f2b0eb86612276fffb52e4305ebfe1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "05e1ca21fd8f7d7b02459175b03d963235f2b0eb86612276fffb52e4305ebfe1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a5a6a88cc205b9c748c367fb020f27ffc9f0855c570a22280d804b7fffcccbd9", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:31.326401+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/enemies-3008b-3008c/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"Horizontal red tracked body retains its dark aperture, tall dark slot, four gray right rake bars and original pale marks; two original tread patterns on rows1/13 remain distinct. Newly authored paint grain and fine seams remain coherent.\", \"Both native1 outputs lose only original black boundary cell(1,14), present2\\u20134. Stationary body rows2\\u201312 differ in51 native shades,8 >=32-channel delta, concentrated along tread-adjacent upper border; none of275 original-stationary logical block means differ >=32 at4\\u00d7. No aperture/rake/mark displacement seen.\"] {\"source_phase_differences\": [{\"asset\": \"3008b\", \"changed_cells\": 0, \"changed_rows\": {}, \"changes\": []}, {\"asset\": \"3008c\", \"changed_cells\": 36, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 18, \"13\": 18}, \"changes\": [[2, 1, 28, 26], [3, 1, 26, 28], [4, 1, 28, 25], [5, 1, 25, 28], [6, 1, 28, 23], [7, 1, 23, 28], [8, 1, 28, 25], [9, 1, 25, 28], [10, 1, 28, 26], [12, 1, 28, 26], [13, 1, 26, 28], [14, 1, 28, 25], [15, 1, 25, 28], [16, 1, 28, 23], [17, 1, 23, 28], [18, 1, 28, 25], [19, 1, 25, 28], [20, 1, 28, 26], [2, 13, 31, 30], [3, 13, 29, 31], [4, 13, 31, 28], [5, 13, 28, 31], [6, 13, 31, 26], [7, 13, 26, 31], [8, 13, 31, 28], [9, 13, 28, 31], [10, 13, 31, 29], [12, 13, 31, 30], [13, 13, 29, 31], [14, 13, 31, 28], [15, 13, 28, 31], [16, 13, 31, 26], [17, 13, 26, 31], [18, 13, 31, 28], [19, 13, 28, 31], [20, 13, 31, 29]]}], \"all_phase_source_stationary_occupied_cells\": 275, \"independent_row_based_metrics_match_worker\": true, \"row_based_metrics\": [{\"asset\": \"3008c\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 51, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 8, \"max_channel_difference\": 53}], \"all_source_stationary_comparisons\": [{\"asset\": \"3008c\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 68, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 275, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[3, 2, 40.0, [101.0, 52.0, 44.0], [109.0, 12.0, 24.0]], [5, 2, 40.0, [101.0, 52.0, 44.0], [109.0, 12.0, 24.0]], [7, 2, 45.0, [117.0, 69.0, 56.0], [138.0, 24.0, 36.0]], [9, 2, 45.0, [125.0, 77.0, 65.0], [150.0, 32.0, 40.0]], [15, 2, 53.0, [125.0, 77.0, 65.0], [138.0, 24.0, 36.0]], [16, 2, 45.0, [138.0, 24.0, 36.0], [117.0, 69.0, 56.0]], [19, 2, 45.0, [117.0, 69.0, 56.0], [138.0, 24.0, 36.0]], [20, 2, 49.0, [166.0, 40.0, 48.0], [138.0, 89.0, 73.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 8}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 267, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1100, \"opacity_changes\": [[22, 4, 256, 204]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 703, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 2475, \"opacity_changes\": [[33, 6, 256, 239], [33, 42, 256, 31]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1286, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4400, \"opacity_changes\": [[44, 8, 256, 30]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}]}]} [\"Isolated actual Catalog/HdAssets source-bound sprite raster and artistic approval only. No new Host enemy occurrence, animation timing, terrain blend, gameplay, simulation-neutrality or fullscreen capture.\", \"Broader game-source freshness flag is true due to unrelated menu/game edits; relevant assets/hd loader source is current.\", \"Complete shared family scale, origin and all rawalpha>=16/>=32 crop retention independently verified. Palette classes, forced indices and all240\\u2013255counts pass; these numeric checks do not substitute for the completed artistic review.\", \"Original/source and newly authored stationary body shading are not byte identical; localized variations and native/2\\u00d7 contour smoothing are deliberately disclosed.\", \"Global registration and bundled pack snapshot remain coordinator-owned; no source/candidate/raw/global/Git edits by reviewer.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/independent-review.json, SHA256 f6c62881aa1b2c8f035cd588b6d4e11b8b543af4a03a6a56616613afe6be7839", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/inputs/enemies-3008b-3008c/runtime-review/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "d4f118284185a63b43fa696e60b418ba7e67466b7d030a88451d4228e1733563" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "26ce2f190978e8c78b69c05c2c1e50e4c0faa6716b81f5c0da237c01e576ac6d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "3008b", + "3008c" + ], + "sha256": "b8b076ff8ea287da415f887df836ac029f63cbd5f1c8a8ea10d81ff98c1a2acb", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "3008b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "43256f022f105e8ccadbe21da7cafe7d8f485b9682686037dd6d05de17dcf2bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/3008b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bd9e4f664706f32ed8cf9caef24e63312f6f076fcd9af3109eed10672e7b4eff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/3008b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e18d6891e02966edfa43106b8386697d34041f34befef8f30456588d7d5211b6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/3008b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "926522268b7af70e00546b030831772f39de284a94bf70e64e7d241c5b5bf6b5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/3008b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ce0b8a754f7098969f9845939d14c0fb524963083ed71ef8b57155c3638871d9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/3008b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0f2a5ccdb9563e6322268b44b0bb7eb6f5d8cbe943a472539e799a42ca199726", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/3008c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "aac0c7ab62450f91c1bca37348cb9220248a9085fb0c81c3bab43d534cf6a2f3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/3008c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "954e7ccfd2c5c1b2cc2af6fca02c3b1c7b65c223f6f64b9a2fd3711ec41e132f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/3008c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ca90e25de12362dcc589cf63cab242cae54802dcd0fcaa3caadc76d5dc5aecf1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/3008c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "675bc6e8172c820af523ab8dbd4585fb05a3fd6df82d84c72668c8fe949e8f17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/3008c-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "3008c": { @@ -240787,7 +246428,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "3008c", "family_id": "enemies-3008b-3008c", "job_id": "enemies-3008b-3008c", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -240799,6 +246440,91 @@ "manifest": "jobs/enemies-3008b-3008c/candidate.json", "sha256": "05e1ca21fd8f7d7b02459175b03d963235f2b0eb86612276fffb52e4305ebfe1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "05e1ca21fd8f7d7b02459175b03d963235f2b0eb86612276fffb52e4305ebfe1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a5a6a88cc205b9c748c367fb020f27ffc9f0855c570a22280d804b7fffcccbd9", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:31.326401+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/enemies-3008b-3008c/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"Horizontal red tracked body retains its dark aperture, tall dark slot, four gray right rake bars and original pale marks; two original tread patterns on rows1/13 remain distinct. Newly authored paint grain and fine seams remain coherent.\", \"Both native1 outputs lose only original black boundary cell(1,14), present2\\u20134. Stationary body rows2\\u201312 differ in51 native shades,8 >=32-channel delta, concentrated along tread-adjacent upper border; none of275 original-stationary logical block means differ >=32 at4\\u00d7. No aperture/rake/mark displacement seen.\"] {\"source_phase_differences\": [{\"asset\": \"3008b\", \"changed_cells\": 0, \"changed_rows\": {}, \"changes\": []}, {\"asset\": \"3008c\", \"changed_cells\": 36, \"changed_rows\": {\"1\": 18, \"13\": 18}, \"changes\": [[2, 1, 28, 26], [3, 1, 26, 28], [4, 1, 28, 25], [5, 1, 25, 28], [6, 1, 28, 23], [7, 1, 23, 28], [8, 1, 28, 25], [9, 1, 25, 28], [10, 1, 28, 26], [12, 1, 28, 26], [13, 1, 26, 28], [14, 1, 28, 25], [15, 1, 25, 28], [16, 1, 28, 23], [17, 1, 23, 28], [18, 1, 28, 25], [19, 1, 25, 28], [20, 1, 28, 26], [2, 13, 31, 30], [3, 13, 29, 31], [4, 13, 31, 28], [5, 13, 28, 31], [6, 13, 31, 26], [7, 13, 26, 31], [8, 13, 31, 28], [9, 13, 28, 31], [10, 13, 31, 29], [12, 13, 31, 30], [13, 13, 29, 31], [14, 13, 31, 28], [15, 13, 28, 31], [16, 13, 31, 26], [17, 13, 26, 31], [18, 13, 31, 28], [19, 13, 28, 31], [20, 13, 31, 29]]}], \"all_phase_source_stationary_occupied_cells\": 275, \"independent_row_based_metrics_match_worker\": true, \"row_based_metrics\": [{\"asset\": \"3008c\", \"native_changed_stationary_cells\": 51, \"at_least32_channel_difference_cells\": 8, \"max_channel_difference\": 53}], \"all_source_stationary_comparisons\": [{\"asset\": \"3008c\", \"scales\": [{\"scale\": 1, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 68, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 275, \"opacity_changes\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [[3, 2, 40.0, [101.0, 52.0, 44.0], [109.0, 12.0, 24.0]], [5, 2, 40.0, [101.0, 52.0, 44.0], [109.0, 12.0, 24.0]], [7, 2, 45.0, [117.0, 69.0, 56.0], [138.0, 24.0, 36.0]], [9, 2, 45.0, [125.0, 77.0, 65.0], [150.0, 32.0, 40.0]], [15, 2, 53.0, [125.0, 77.0, 65.0], [138.0, 24.0, 36.0]], [16, 2, 45.0, [138.0, 24.0, 36.0], [117.0, 69.0, 56.0]], [19, 2, 45.0, [117.0, 69.0, 56.0], [138.0, 24.0, 36.0]], [20, 2, 49.0, [166.0, 40.0, 48.0], [138.0, 89.0, 73.0]]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 8}, {\"scale\": 2, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 267, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 1100, \"opacity_changes\": [[22, 4, 256, 204]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 3, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 703, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 2475, \"opacity_changes\": [[33, 6, 256, 239], [33, 42, 256, 31]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}, {\"scale\": 4, \"changed_indexed_subpixels\": 1286, \"stable_source_subpixel_count\": 4400, \"opacity_changes\": [[44, 8, 256, 30]], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_or_more\": [], \"logical_mean_rgb_changed_32_count\": 0}]}]} [\"Isolated actual Catalog/HdAssets source-bound sprite raster and artistic approval only. No new Host enemy occurrence, animation timing, terrain blend, gameplay, simulation-neutrality or fullscreen capture.\", \"Broader game-source freshness flag is true due to unrelated menu/game edits; relevant assets/hd loader source is current.\", \"Complete shared family scale, origin and all rawalpha>=16/>=32 crop retention independently verified. Palette classes, forced indices and all240\\u2013255counts pass; these numeric checks do not substitute for the completed artistic review.\", \"Original/source and newly authored stationary body shading are not byte identical; localized variations and native/2\\u00d7 contour smoothing are deliberately disclosed.\", \"Global registration and bundled pack snapshot remain coordinator-owned; no source/candidate/raw/global/Git edits by reviewer.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/independent-review.json, SHA256 f6c62881aa1b2c8f035cd588b6d4e11b8b543af4a03a6a56616613afe6be7839", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/inputs/enemies-3008b-3008c/runtime-review/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "d4f118284185a63b43fa696e60b418ba7e67466b7d030a88451d4228e1733563" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/runtime-qa.json", + "sha256": "26ce2f190978e8c78b69c05c2c1e50e4c0faa6716b81f5c0da237c01e576ac6d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "3008b", + "3008c" + ], + "sha256": "b8b076ff8ea287da415f887df836ac029f63cbd5f1c8a8ea10d81ff98c1a2acb", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "3008b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "43256f022f105e8ccadbe21da7cafe7d8f485b9682686037dd6d05de17dcf2bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/3008b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bd9e4f664706f32ed8cf9caef24e63312f6f076fcd9af3109eed10672e7b4eff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/3008b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e18d6891e02966edfa43106b8386697d34041f34befef8f30456588d7d5211b6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/3008b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "926522268b7af70e00546b030831772f39de284a94bf70e64e7d241c5b5bf6b5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/3008b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ce0b8a754f7098969f9845939d14c0fb524963083ed71ef8b57155c3638871d9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/3008b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0f2a5ccdb9563e6322268b44b0bb7eb6f5d8cbe943a472539e799a42ca199726", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/3008c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "aac0c7ab62450f91c1bca37348cb9220248a9085fb0c81c3bab43d534cf6a2f3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/3008c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "954e7ccfd2c5c1b2cc2af6fca02c3b1c7b65c223f6f64b9a2fd3711ec41e132f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/3008c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ca90e25de12362dcc589cf63cab242cae54802dcd0fcaa3caadc76d5dc5aecf1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/3008c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "675bc6e8172c820af523ab8dbd4585fb05a3fd6df82d84c72668c8fe949e8f17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/runtime/3008c-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "3008d": { @@ -240886,7 +246612,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "3008f", "family_id": "enemies-3008f-3008f", "job_id": "enemies-3008f-3008f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -240898,6 +246624,61 @@ "manifest": "jobs/enemies-3008f-3008f/candidate.json", "sha256": "8f3e122fc0c8adec5328dc7c29279493d794eab653fe956ad060862b6cc99704", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "8f3e122fc0c8adec5328dc7c29279493d794eab653fe956ad060862b6cc99704", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "222050a1cd2369116117870fd3c351fdfcaa3461132084c1265f29c46c391563", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.378891+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/enemies-3008f-3008f/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"The original upright 40\\u00d740 red/orange TANK10 layout remains readable: four raised warm top tips, eight black opaque machinery apertures in two rows, broad outer rails/legs and the true lower-center transparent notch. All 1332 source occupied cells and all 50 source RGB4 backing cells survive at every render scale.\", \"New metal surface grain, wear, small fasteners, framed apertures and sharper gold/red bevels add genuine HD detail. Highlights are locally brighter and the lower side recesses resolve more strongly as rimmed machinery. These material differences remain inside the source structure and are accepted after viewing raw, native 2\\u00d7/3\\u00d7 and terrain contexts.\", \"Native alpha mask is exact; higher-scale partial edge cells 11/49/74 and missing subpixels 11/114/254 versus added subpixels 4/22/49 are disclosed. No whole original cell is lost and no reserved palette index is added.\", \"Untouched built-in output and workspace raw bytes match. The exact-aspect metadata crop preserves every raw alpha\\u226516 sample, original logical canvas and [0,0] origin. No artwork pixels were edited.\", \"Approval is limited to this exact complete single-frame proposal and source/hash-bound native gallery/compositor proof. No production registration or live gameplay claim is made.\"] \"Isolated ignored reference review only; no art/source/candidate/global manifest/ledger/Git/promotion edits. Earlier SHIP35 and LargeAir12 holds and DeathRayPower/buoy/EAGLE approvals remain frozen.\" All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/3008f/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 2a5e0348f8e02193f514de783442fb6e71d3b15b39c444513c93ed5d72d1666b", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/review-index.json", + "sha256": "99210b5ee9ceb0a7cccfa1acdd475134a229e72b4cd360a35dfbcf6993d35da6" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "3008f" + ], + "sha256": "2e56c7cb1eb1be377abeb203c061e626074c27c0ad0ff6d818c5a9833accdd65", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "3008f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f9e11d6cc17ddc4df18ca80e2c4c773086ebcbd2dc9fdac6ad0710676bc41d73", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/3008f/runtime/3008f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "897824037c4f526516f6a73b26718fab0a91f58890ff396854ccfdd8e8239025", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/3008f/runtime/3008f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7edbf3851c79b058a12d0b998e7429b1f1bcee3481faf10312b9f8af7f083753", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/3008f/runtime/3008f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e3e56ce6824ae82f22f4667c61ea6e4453fb9649b3d18cd497556c26cdf4d92a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/3008f/runtime/3008f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3008f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8b80c700127a4b231b33818625b44b396b7d9afba2a2fd79a296b75c2bc42c01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/3008f/runtime/3008f-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30090": { @@ -240985,7 +246766,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30092", "family_id": "enemies-30092-30092", "job_id": "enemies-30092-30092", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -240997,6 +246778,61 @@ "manifest": "jobs/enemies-30092-30092/candidate.json", "sha256": "e97cb85d7db6d3ba34dfbf4b57061a76117708e2e2e12b4e5e14c10f140b3247", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e97cb85d7db6d3ba34dfbf4b57061a76117708e2e2e12b4e5e14c10f140b3247", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d780baee03ad3d1bc5eddbf00d9e70e2d6c50ee682b57ed90dfd52dacb299c37", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.433455+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/enemies-30092-30092/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"The original 40\\u00d740 brown/copper TANK13 upper arch/head, long side inset panels, two pale vertical inner supports and separated lower legs remain in the source positions. Every one of the 1092 occupied original cells survives all scales, including ten RGB4 cells; native transparency is exact.\", \"Fine seams, rivets, brighter warm bevels and two tiny dark marks on the occupied upper head are newly authored surface detail. Those marks are dark paint/recess material, not transparent holes. Source-black samples become warmer and lighter on average, about RGB(28.66,17.55,15.61) at 4\\u00d7, but the backing and architecture remain visually coherent. These differences are explicitly accepted.\", \"Higher-scale partial edge cells 4/29/31 and missing subpixels 4/71/104 versus added subpixels 0/26/43 are disclosed; no complete source logical cell disappears and no reserved palette index is introduced.\", \"Untouched built-in output and workspace raw bytes match. The exact-aspect metadata crop preserves every raw alpha\\u226516 sample, original logical canvas and [0,0] origin. No artwork pixels were edited.\", \"Approval is limited to this exact complete single-frame proposal and source/hash-bound native gallery/compositor proof. No production registration or live gameplay claim is made.\"] \"Isolated ignored reference review only; no art/source/candidate/global manifest/ledger/Git/promotion edits. Earlier SHIP35 and LargeAir12 holds and DeathRayPower/buoy/EAGLE approvals remain frozen.\" All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/30092/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 fe94568050f00448b9a05f7f8cd6ff196abe15b8c37c67f67c665da8254078be", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/review-index.json", + "sha256": "99210b5ee9ceb0a7cccfa1acdd475134a229e72b4cd360a35dfbcf6993d35da6" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "30092" + ], + "sha256": "44e01778ecfb497a040f619ef336c370e7e2acaeba8ca2c0dd153554c6bd0d7a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "30092-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3d3e837b32a4fb1920e99fb91281231e3d4f2847cb9603bfcbff1b0d7cc98bff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/30092/runtime/30092-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30092-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4010c5eb4f74f18b9de47e182f7c4262edcb2571871a0cb65c81920dff14a803", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/30092/runtime/30092-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30092-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "af79aa201c5a038ed6b89bdb1c3192d5a64ec9080dd1ad23be2e9d7828733118", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/30092/runtime/30092-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30092-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b520691cc85347c870d4676afe1ae425e66bf51d1f0c9d27a5e4f6cab3e9894a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/30092/runtime/30092-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30092-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d10bd4f5334a18b86fea22e86d7a30b76ba6419f386561b84025f92a642d736d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/30092/runtime/30092-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30093": { @@ -241084,7 +246920,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30095", "family_id": "enemies-30095-30095", "job_id": "enemies-30095-30095", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -241096,6 +246932,61 @@ "manifest": "jobs/enemies-30095-30095/candidate.json", "sha256": "b65c7bc88fbf2ccbdf1cc9af151f6c98cb21f33f46b27c85c5d86d5318857b18", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "b65c7bc88fbf2ccbdf1cc9af151f6c98cb21f33f46b27c85c5d86d5318857b18", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d777bb89d84c73a274c660c521d4f2c7027e37c575e8ea74135e49c063a9e2dd", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.487113+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/enemies-30095-30095/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"The extremely dark 32\\u00d732 DSHP03 stepped backing remains opaque over terrain, with its asymmetric long lower-left gray rail, central rectangular structures, dark right extension and true lower notch. All 612 occupied source cells survive all scales, including all 286 RGB4 backing cells; native transparency is exact.\", \"New small seams, fasteners and quiet worn gray metal texture lighten some original black samples. Mean RGB remains approximately (9.96,9.96,9.96) at 4\\u00d7, with localized edge/detail highlights up to channel 93. The source dark body still reads as a continuous surface rather than empty background, and those material differences are accepted.\", \"Higher-scale partial edge cells 5/9/10 and missing subpixels 7/25/35 versus added subpixels 19/72/97 are boundary sample differences, not whole-source-cell losses. The source has no blink lamps, and the output introduces no reserved palette index.\", \"Untouched built-in output and workspace raw bytes match. The exact-aspect metadata crop preserves every raw alpha\\u226516 sample, original logical canvas and [0,0] origin. No artwork pixels were edited.\", \"Approval is limited to this exact complete single-frame proposal and source/hash-bound native gallery/compositor proof. No production registration or live gameplay claim is made.\"] \"Isolated ignored reference review only; no art/source/candidate/global manifest/ledger/Git/promotion edits. Earlier SHIP35 and LargeAir12 holds and DeathRayPower/buoy/EAGLE approvals remain frozen.\" All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/30095/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 d596f2d7a2bc083ce71e8bac5715ac78a3dbf145620d5ed9cb7a1377625d897c", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/review-index.json", + "sha256": "99210b5ee9ceb0a7cccfa1acdd475134a229e72b4cd360a35dfbcf6993d35da6" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "30095" + ], + "sha256": "7fd2812e1f0a324270df5e22b7a1022d96ada245671d441d73bb1347a23192f5", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "30095-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f8bf1fc63a8e04d55aed7edf853dfb152140ce7c63cfeca4cb4a30f29b8125a9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/30095/runtime/30095-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30095-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "75a09fa64098121579b25b6daa129ae015197cf1203dca04412a37ddeafc7361", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/30095/runtime/30095-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30095-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3fc16ea744386facff7a58d244abcc714164d08f030ef5e55afee698164ad839", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/30095/runtime/30095-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30095-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0e256f4a337519ef37ddd6ff57a89af8e08decd31964b13d3a73199429374413", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/30095/runtime/30095-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30095-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0041bfe20110c545297bd378cd6c7ed3d476b6ab5f4fd84295feecb2ae183546", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/30095/runtime/30095-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30096": { @@ -241183,7 +247074,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30098", "family_id": "enemies-30098-30098", "job_id": "enemies-30098-30098", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -241195,6 +247086,61 @@ "manifest": "jobs/enemies-30098-30098/candidate.json", "sha256": "b0ca606cde128416889fde6a81b6d0cc912c9d009ded6614d352b3afb8d8a5e6", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "b0ca606cde128416889fde6a81b6d0cc912c9d009ded6614d352b3afb8d8a5e6", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "feadd52844b9ec53b9820dd8d1976ceb56dfe64ef3a6e8576fe0e0c89e6e9ec0", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.541181+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/enemies-30098-30098/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [\"The original 40\\u00d732 DSHP06 dark structural backing, three upper raised structures, two lower round/rimmed pods, center nose, original alpha cutouts and bilateral white glints remain recognizable. Added grilles, seams, rivets and sharper metal facets are accepted HD detail. The rounded source pods have a more clearly faceted rim and brighter local bevels, which is disclosed rather than claimed color-identical.\", \"Source green index253 at (1,17) and red index252 at (39,17) have exact source-derived footprints at every render scale: each has 1/4/9/16 indexed pixels. No new reserved cells or palette-class failures occur. Source/base, red-off, green-off and both-off diagnostic palette states were viewed at source and all four HD scales.\", \"One genuine source RGB4/index31 corner cell (24,4) is transparent at native 1\\u00d7; this changes occupied coverage from 714 to713 and native mask IoU to713/714. Detailed source/native/context inspection identifies it as the outer upper-post corner, with the adjacent post structure and original occupied bounds intact. It survives 2\\u00d7, 3\\u00d7 and4\\u00d7. This single low-scale corner rounding is accepted explicitly; this approval does not claim an exact 1\\u00d7 outline or zero dark-cell loss.\", \"All 714 occupied source cells, including all272 RGB4 cells, survive 2\\u00d7\\u20134\\u00d7. Partial edge cells 15/30/47 and missing subpixels19/86/197 versus added subpixels2/9/39 at those scales are disclosed. The remaining native backing stays occupied and visually continuous over authentic terrain.\", \"Untouched built-in output and workspace raw bytes match. The exact-aspect metadata crop preserves every raw alpha\\u226516 sample, original logical canvas and [0,0] origin. No artwork pixels were edited.\", \"Approval is limited to this exact complete single-frame proposal and source/hash-bound native gallery/compositor proof. No production registration or live gameplay claim is made.\"] \"Isolated ignored reference review only; no art/source/candidate/global manifest/ledger/Git/promotion edits. Earlier SHIP35 and LargeAir12 holds and DeathRayPower/buoy/EAGLE approvals remain frozen.\" All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/30098/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 f0a2b3828b2f5daf401602be0c44c02fd908b4239cebcf25f01e5b02d6e49cf5", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/review-index.json", + "sha256": "99210b5ee9ceb0a7cccfa1acdd475134a229e72b4cd360a35dfbcf6993d35da6" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "30098" + ], + "sha256": "4cd74fa7ca5eab82e5cba0937518457f758a6468ac35c13066ace1eaeab5fc3d", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "30098-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "98619a8acba211fbb884ae31a63b8fb34844912828d9d7114f892b5e32356467", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/30098/runtime/30098-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30098-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c5ef515c644e34a5687cf350006d94f780cfee15406d32b89b168e5207ca69da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/30098/runtime/30098-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30098-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "23ed5d345897bc976c59f19ed046a309b9f8b83d5aa0ea801277c629b22be85c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/30098/runtime/30098-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30098-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "adda6ffb0efa815cb6049424d7f555178985f0c9c6ad10144cf3a222be5ffa30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/30098/runtime/30098-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30098-original.ppm", + "sha256": "578a34da7b572d9eaa4749f2366c10d9e427e0f15b0752efde2da9cb2e98467f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/enemy-singles-3/30098/runtime/30098-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30099": { @@ -241348,7 +247294,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/enemies-3009d-3009d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "66f756fd6fd72bd0d99c0a9bab9c36798a7d1e989cd2385908cecfbce8710e55", + "sha256": "8ed65947539723f8a8eccaf074fa35bd7affc74bdcf2c85de080e9221fac6422", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -241808,7 +247754,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/enemies-300ac-300ac/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0cf013628da4b6c559fa9eca5fff60912549812845d7a8cda82aa4c7d02fa3a1", + "sha256": "bac9554fb1c6a0878f5250dc98ecb3d0407880d48fe1b87f258022833e374167", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -249920,7 +255866,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "3019d", "family_id": "terrain-3019d-301ac", "job_id": "terrain-3019d-301ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -249931,6 +255877,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3019d-301ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "d2bc6e616e3c43668981efe3a5566c099ffefc42cc897880b39c897b13b98543", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "3019e": { @@ -249952,7 +255903,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "3019e", "family_id": "terrain-3019d-301ac", "job_id": "terrain-3019d-301ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -249963,6 +255914,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3019d-301ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "d2bc6e616e3c43668981efe3a5566c099ffefc42cc897880b39c897b13b98543", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "3019f": { @@ -249984,7 +255940,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "3019f", "family_id": "terrain-3019d-301ac", "job_id": "terrain-3019d-301ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -249995,6 +255951,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3019d-301ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "d2bc6e616e3c43668981efe3a5566c099ffefc42cc897880b39c897b13b98543", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "301a0": { @@ -250016,7 +255977,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "301a0", "family_id": "terrain-3019d-301ac", "job_id": "terrain-3019d-301ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -250027,6 +255988,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3019d-301ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "d2bc6e616e3c43668981efe3a5566c099ffefc42cc897880b39c897b13b98543", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "301a1": { @@ -250048,7 +256014,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "301a1", "family_id": "terrain-3019d-301ac", "job_id": "terrain-3019d-301ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -250059,6 +256025,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3019d-301ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "d2bc6e616e3c43668981efe3a5566c099ffefc42cc897880b39c897b13b98543", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "301a2": { @@ -250080,7 +256051,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "301a2", "family_id": "terrain-3019d-301ac", "job_id": "terrain-3019d-301ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -250091,6 +256062,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3019d-301ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "d2bc6e616e3c43668981efe3a5566c099ffefc42cc897880b39c897b13b98543", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "301a3": { @@ -250112,7 +256088,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "301a3", "family_id": "terrain-3019d-301ac", "job_id": "terrain-3019d-301ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -250123,6 +256099,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3019d-301ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "d2bc6e616e3c43668981efe3a5566c099ffefc42cc897880b39c897b13b98543", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "301a4": { @@ -250144,7 +256125,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "301a4", "family_id": "terrain-3019d-301ac", "job_id": "terrain-3019d-301ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -250155,6 +256136,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3019d-301ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "d2bc6e616e3c43668981efe3a5566c099ffefc42cc897880b39c897b13b98543", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "301a5": { @@ -268640,7 +274626,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303cd", "family_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", "job_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -268651,6 +274637,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303cd-303dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "0dec4fcd65615704be0140d642b3683b4b1f1c2b0d788e182d5f89abfdb3fb69", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303ce": { @@ -268672,7 +274663,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303ce", "family_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", "job_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -268683,6 +274674,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303cd-303dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "0dec4fcd65615704be0140d642b3683b4b1f1c2b0d788e182d5f89abfdb3fb69", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303cf": { @@ -268704,7 +274700,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303cf", "family_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", "job_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -268715,6 +274711,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303cd-303dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "0dec4fcd65615704be0140d642b3683b4b1f1c2b0d788e182d5f89abfdb3fb69", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303d0": { @@ -268736,7 +274737,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303d0", "family_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", "job_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -268747,6 +274748,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303cd-303dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "0dec4fcd65615704be0140d642b3683b4b1f1c2b0d788e182d5f89abfdb3fb69", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303d1": { @@ -268768,7 +274774,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303d1", "family_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", "job_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -268779,6 +274785,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303cd-303dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "0dec4fcd65615704be0140d642b3683b4b1f1c2b0d788e182d5f89abfdb3fb69", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303d2": { @@ -268800,7 +274811,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303d2", "family_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", "job_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -268811,6 +274822,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303cd-303dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "0dec4fcd65615704be0140d642b3683b4b1f1c2b0d788e182d5f89abfdb3fb69", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303d3": { @@ -268832,7 +274848,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303d3", "family_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", "job_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -268843,6 +274859,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303cd-303dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "0dec4fcd65615704be0140d642b3683b4b1f1c2b0d788e182d5f89abfdb3fb69", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303d4": { @@ -268864,7 +274885,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303d4", "family_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", "job_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -268875,6 +274896,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303cd-303dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "0dec4fcd65615704be0140d642b3683b4b1f1c2b0d788e182d5f89abfdb3fb69", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303d5": { @@ -268896,7 +274922,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303d5", "family_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", "job_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -268907,6 +274933,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303cd-303dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "0dec4fcd65615704be0140d642b3683b4b1f1c2b0d788e182d5f89abfdb3fb69", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303d6": { @@ -268928,7 +274959,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303d6", "family_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", "job_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -268939,6 +274970,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303cd-303dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "0dec4fcd65615704be0140d642b3683b4b1f1c2b0d788e182d5f89abfdb3fb69", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303d7": { @@ -268960,7 +274996,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303d7", "family_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", "job_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -268971,6 +275007,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303cd-303dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "0dec4fcd65615704be0140d642b3683b4b1f1c2b0d788e182d5f89abfdb3fb69", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303d8": { @@ -268992,7 +275033,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303d8", "family_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", "job_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -269003,6 +275044,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303cd-303dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "0dec4fcd65615704be0140d642b3683b4b1f1c2b0d788e182d5f89abfdb3fb69", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303d9": { @@ -269024,7 +275070,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303d9", "family_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", "job_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -269035,6 +275081,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303cd-303dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "0dec4fcd65615704be0140d642b3683b4b1f1c2b0d788e182d5f89abfdb3fb69", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303da": { @@ -269056,7 +275107,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303da", "family_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", "job_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -269067,6 +275118,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303cd-303dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "0dec4fcd65615704be0140d642b3683b4b1f1c2b0d788e182d5f89abfdb3fb69", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303db": { @@ -269088,7 +275144,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303db", "family_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", "job_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -269099,6 +275155,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303cd-303dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "0dec4fcd65615704be0140d642b3683b4b1f1c2b0d788e182d5f89abfdb3fb69", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303dc": { @@ -269120,7 +275181,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303dc", "family_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", "job_id": "terrain-303cd-303dc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -269131,6 +275192,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303cd-303dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "0dec4fcd65615704be0140d642b3683b4b1f1c2b0d788e182d5f89abfdb3fb69", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303dd": { @@ -269664,8 +275730,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303ed", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -269696,8 +275762,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303ee", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -269728,8 +275794,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303ef", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -269760,8 +275826,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303f0", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -269792,8 +275858,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303f1", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -269824,8 +275890,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303f2", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -269856,8 +275922,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303f3", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -269888,8 +275954,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303f4", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -269920,8 +275986,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303f5", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -269952,8 +276018,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303f6", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -269984,8 +276050,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303f7", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -270016,8 +276082,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303f8", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -270048,8 +276114,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303f9", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -270080,8 +276146,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303fa", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -270112,8 +276178,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303fb", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -270144,8 +276210,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303fc", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -279712,13 +285778,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40006", "family_id": "enemies-40006-40010", "job_id": "enemies-40006-40010", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40006-40010/candidate.json", + "sha256": "a9be6033f2257ca0cbbd39f051f5a4451dba941dddc46894989aea8d52276725", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40007": { @@ -279740,13 +285811,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40007", "family_id": "enemies-40006-40010", "job_id": "enemies-40006-40010", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40006-40010/candidate.json", + "sha256": "a9be6033f2257ca0cbbd39f051f5a4451dba941dddc46894989aea8d52276725", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40008": { @@ -279768,13 +285844,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40008", "family_id": "enemies-40006-40010", "job_id": "enemies-40006-40010", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40006-40010/candidate.json", + "sha256": "a9be6033f2257ca0cbbd39f051f5a4451dba941dddc46894989aea8d52276725", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40009": { @@ -279796,13 +285877,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40009", "family_id": "enemies-40006-40010", "job_id": "enemies-40006-40010", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40006-40010/candidate.json", + "sha256": "a9be6033f2257ca0cbbd39f051f5a4451dba941dddc46894989aea8d52276725", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4000a": { @@ -279824,13 +285910,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4000a", "family_id": "enemies-40006-40010", "job_id": "enemies-40006-40010", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40006-40010/candidate.json", + "sha256": "a9be6033f2257ca0cbbd39f051f5a4451dba941dddc46894989aea8d52276725", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4000b": { @@ -279852,13 +285943,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4000b", "family_id": "enemies-40006-40010", "job_id": "enemies-40006-40010", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40006-40010/candidate.json", + "sha256": "a9be6033f2257ca0cbbd39f051f5a4451dba941dddc46894989aea8d52276725", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4000c": { @@ -279880,13 +285976,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4000c", "family_id": "enemies-40006-40010", "job_id": "enemies-40006-40010", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40006-40010/candidate.json", + "sha256": "a9be6033f2257ca0cbbd39f051f5a4451dba941dddc46894989aea8d52276725", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4000d": { @@ -279908,13 +286009,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4000d", "family_id": "enemies-40006-40010", "job_id": "enemies-40006-40010", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40006-40010/candidate.json", + "sha256": "a9be6033f2257ca0cbbd39f051f5a4451dba941dddc46894989aea8d52276725", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4000e": { @@ -279936,13 +286042,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4000e", "family_id": "enemies-40006-40010", "job_id": "enemies-40006-40010", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40006-40010/candidate.json", + "sha256": "a9be6033f2257ca0cbbd39f051f5a4451dba941dddc46894989aea8d52276725", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4000f": { @@ -279964,13 +286075,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4000f", "family_id": "enemies-40006-40010", "job_id": "enemies-40006-40010", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40006-40010/candidate.json", + "sha256": "a9be6033f2257ca0cbbd39f051f5a4451dba941dddc46894989aea8d52276725", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40010": { @@ -279992,13 +286108,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40010", "family_id": "enemies-40006-40010", "job_id": "enemies-40006-40010", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40006-40010/candidate.json", + "sha256": "a9be6033f2257ca0cbbd39f051f5a4451dba941dddc46894989aea8d52276725", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40011": { @@ -280020,13 +286141,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40006", "family_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", "job_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40011-4001b/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6c7fc1b33e7ab4ab712ea45df4a8e46fff9d57e09d90d20f516580af04ee8f88", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40012": { @@ -280048,13 +286174,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40012", "family_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", "job_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40011-4001b/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6c7fc1b33e7ab4ab712ea45df4a8e46fff9d57e09d90d20f516580af04ee8f88", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40013": { @@ -280076,13 +286207,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40013", "family_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", "job_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40011-4001b/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6c7fc1b33e7ab4ab712ea45df4a8e46fff9d57e09d90d20f516580af04ee8f88", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40014": { @@ -280104,13 +286240,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40014", "family_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", "job_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40011-4001b/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6c7fc1b33e7ab4ab712ea45df4a8e46fff9d57e09d90d20f516580af04ee8f88", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40015": { @@ -280132,13 +286273,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40015", "family_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", "job_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40011-4001b/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6c7fc1b33e7ab4ab712ea45df4a8e46fff9d57e09d90d20f516580af04ee8f88", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40016": { @@ -280160,13 +286306,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40016", "family_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", "job_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40011-4001b/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6c7fc1b33e7ab4ab712ea45df4a8e46fff9d57e09d90d20f516580af04ee8f88", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40017": { @@ -280188,13 +286339,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40017", "family_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", "job_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40011-4001b/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6c7fc1b33e7ab4ab712ea45df4a8e46fff9d57e09d90d20f516580af04ee8f88", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40018": { @@ -280216,13 +286372,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40018", "family_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", "job_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40011-4001b/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6c7fc1b33e7ab4ab712ea45df4a8e46fff9d57e09d90d20f516580af04ee8f88", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40019": { @@ -280244,13 +286405,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40019", "family_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", "job_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40011-4001b/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6c7fc1b33e7ab4ab712ea45df4a8e46fff9d57e09d90d20f516580af04ee8f88", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4001a": { @@ -280272,13 +286438,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4001a", "family_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", "job_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40011-4001b/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6c7fc1b33e7ab4ab712ea45df4a8e46fff9d57e09d90d20f516580af04ee8f88", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4001b": { @@ -280300,13 +286471,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4001b", "family_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", "job_id": "enemies-40011-4001b", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40011-4001b/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6c7fc1b33e7ab4ab712ea45df4a8e46fff9d57e09d90d20f516580af04ee8f88", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4001c": { @@ -295120,13 +301296,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4006e", "family_id": "enemies-4006e-4006e", "job_id": "enemies-4006e-4006e", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-4006e-4006e/candidate.json", + "sha256": "ae810d617704048645b48a8445837f2902e6381a6487db60fe1df7557b47e7f7", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4006f": { @@ -295938,13 +302119,18 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40088", "family_id": "enemies-40088-40088", "job_id": "enemies-40088-40088", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { "availability": "unverified", "evidence": [] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40088-40088/candidate.json", + "sha256": "da9700e956771494e03ca922ccf57e929e15eda5b4fa9e11b8cee0a171e4e709", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40089": { @@ -304139,7 +310325,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "400ac", "family_id": "bosses-400ac-400b2", "job_id": "bosses-400ac-400b2", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_3", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -304149,8 +310335,231 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/candidate.json", - "sha256": "7ac77d44e6a1a750045ada766e6c117b947b6d6e764b0b43c3c102509b971b9c", + "sha256": "02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "7ef14266c0d8ddd6a6c5b1a505ae1c58d392ac06eaa683079a8c69daa8b4c586", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:38.049262+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"family\": \"bosses-400ac-400b2\", \"decision\": \"approve\", \"scope\": \"Exact complete seven-frame v3 sibling, all firstsix unchanged; full phase gallery1\\u20134, native2/3, final-frame correction. No live boss assembly or timing claim.\", \"geometry\": \"Every source/HD frame preserves32\\u00d732whole occupied canvas and origin0. The sliding textured panel reveals the same dark/red machinery and pale rectangular right plates. Final phase keeps both pale rectangular plates instead of the held atlas rounded cap. Source-stable central panel is again a framed horizontal narrow-slat grille, not diagonal sheet material. Bottom floor now has short crossed diamond/herringbone topology, matching the earlier six frames instead of the held parallel-streak interpretation. Left bright/dark narrow slats and rail remain distinct.\", \"stationary_material_judgment\": \"Independently confirmed source central42/42cells and floor63/63cells identical across400b0,b1,b2. All three actualHD4regions and full nineframe/allscale galleries inspected. Final-grille frame slightly wider, floor repeat slightly finer/brighter, left rail grain/bolt pattern different. Fine texture does change rather than remaining byte-stationary: central only45/672 and floor93/1008 HD4pixels identical acrosslastthree. Accept these disclosed grain/pitch/frame-width variations because horizontal grille and crossing-floor topology are stable and no coarse-block substitution, material reorientation, or rounded plate replacement remains. No pixel-perfect animation material invariance claimed.\", \"first_six_preservation\": \"Exact six target bindings and six sequence bindings equal original frozen candidate; all24HD1\\u20134PPM bytes independently equal prior independent review corpus and currentauthor. Untouched firstsix atlas exactly equals recovered builtin PNG SHA fed3c49a6c1b281ab752d3efe30e2a29ba6842550d50189c89abc7f37cbfc1f7. Heldv2 inputs remain frozen.\", \"candidate_sha256\": \"02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b\", \"frame_bindings_sha256\": \"7ef14266c0d8ddd6a6c5b1a505ae1c58d392ac06eaa683079a8c69daa8b4c586\"} [\"Independent artwork and actual immutable HdAssets::load/sprite gallery review only. No live Host whole-boss assembly/reachability/timing, gameplay hitbox/economy or boss behavior claim.\", \"No art/source/candidate/raw/schema/global/production/Git writes, generation or promotion. Evidence only under isolated reference directory. Coordinator owns any admission.\", \"Crops preserve every raw alpha>=16and32pixel. 10310 crop excludes192and200a3crop2072low-alpha1\\u201315exterior gutter pixels; do not claim all input pixels displayed. Entire raw files are unchanged and match original builtin generator output exactly.\", \"Existing held300a8\\u2013ab/200ba/300a0 and old400v2/atlas final remain outside approval. Source-class/straight-alpha policies unchanged.\", \"Source masks, occupied-black fidelity and reserved-index counts are diagnostics; geometry/material decisions above were made from actual source/raw/runtime visual inspection.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 89652063ab9dda20291516e213612346c1a7163723ad70061271980bd373361b", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/author-review-complete.json", + "sha256": "f095712da51d9a5ad76657a4f77797f319b0e3a599af7535ee881a3c04e8bf64" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "400ac", + "400ad", + "400ae", + "400af" + ], + "sha256": "3fdc0752402efb53b0f45c249695953d5f85375ddc694c8b0a84d29f5ac1f7a1", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "400b0", + "400b1", + "400b2" + ], + "sha256": "78e3ec4c3048d8d7e029677b291f068e8acbbafa163542d87795ca568986fcf0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "400ac-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "99bf5dc19ee0b033195ac203d85b5a5f5132e771596aecc42949321602f8da2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "45773c8254ee64e2d67bbddbb1647a4ee38ec48f97f030e5bff1339ab08298c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9f11146e67778801b7bda06487fc9a3aca3a7aaa25ece9f721fcd4b42c9ff46e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9d5bca741347cda74f9e97e840470a56427950d724d3dba927bfecb43d8c99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52453fd92a1173569e3239f27710c176128eadf481ec8dea54c55ec17a1b702c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d42d1e6b1647799804f632e48090af203ff964891d72ffdaed868cff3cffc0e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c09fc82040d0da24d2f071c01439b8367d1dcc35be13df6e25c8eaa8130570d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f7d694a4a65cbe597a56532caec01ead68029ffe894df6614cc99a9038235890", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3aae84663408855bd3e6d2d9fd105d67fb230d6c2bdcc6bc50cfcc82a0974fe8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-original.ppm", + "sha256": "394f079943a1fa7ddb8d091280526d9c53d47b61371129720fc786c4726141b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1549b2cc2031d3eec908854fa6ba170d336e330dbce2676c97fee7e6cb6af6ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ca2cb3e743af674415e4a1fe6700ed486d0a2fcf3e4919aed331fdf07d5dd70", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ae8cd16bfb3172db601eec124d6bb6b0cea12bd40cd51e8e32c6f7e05cf2b8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bce99c3ec5cf096764ca4f97336278236ebf4cb71fa8ec6ad043b46de97291c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-original.ppm", + "sha256": "652f30c7efdeba05b7c666448c11bff14e583a8b1db5d7fb4550ca2a29b056d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e71eb5a150a7f3ad30fbdc6e06e06d0aba7635a0993bdbca518f6a5c59f8c44e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ed60ae4428718bdc336ed576b23a6888d37c38aeded8b90ce6387c71c0427508", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "abd2ce5fba0c7eb82752f572e6ce518570e69c51e669ade60923ccd1b6c93444", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "53199e6ed8409746fdeba36efd02fc203e4fb9e0b7e4a2a32cb647a69ca1ce6d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b41e262a0567d85f19e2f3676c854b867d85f4d4ef0f5c3e60412e0bbd790c5b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4027ea32c1bf92824c70aef5ff06083f96000608c119b7b9a31e84b6adbd621e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6584946ef1eea844056d7646a846fb2b561d924d1ccd786215389b524773d92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3315946dfb356a5995145a93dee364c864b91bf4d315383d816be1994d7fbf01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "de876a6b51110b1bb204d9762377a6ca9dbcd4524159014b235223938d737bbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f8243a6a33174a8b3e625ada45d86c8dca0931a477df40242069637b09aca327", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54ea061d8690918efad37687181043c8a5d0e11eee821c41d4ed7257ef21264b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "82194e05f7fb97bf40d768315d397b4da52bb65c04db74cd4df3723c328fee29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ca202cba244fbc88f7928841951ac464d3d6cb7869a4d8505329dc007ae70b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3a56d45a86e0a031be54d90da7e0edab63e1caf500b46cb51dd14140ae172992", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3284d6762eda92c9fcbe2a6b232028235b1a46cf35cd4a65fb1edafee6a090e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a3c37d108033424e8729dd9a30ea200f8afa68231aa004f4bee3011f2f2de93b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e1611940e97c1b120dea66acc4c11c41bd7e9000e72584f5a12d428ead4ec1ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0bbd60e3ffd2261be4c64af5ac3c76b98cf799d2320d022b7df2d0ba79614982", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d3da5f7854eb7278f860d14226ae50af54611a6957c27e8664d593b21b81cfd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b053ad1d43f650f9628d40cf86cd895b458925f1b05131bce9d7677075fe3d52", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": { + "old_held_candidate": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/held-main-before-coordinator-promotion-7ac77d44e6a1a750.json", + "old_held_sha256": "7ac77d44e6a1a750045ada766e6c117b947b6d6e764b0b43c3c102509b971b9c", + "approved_sibling": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/candidate-iron-coast-3-peer-v3.json", + "exact_bytes_promoted": true + } } }, "400ad": { @@ -304172,7 +310581,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "400ad", "family_id": "bosses-400ac-400b2", "job_id": "bosses-400ac-400b2", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_3", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -304182,8 +310591,231 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/candidate.json", - "sha256": "7ac77d44e6a1a750045ada766e6c117b947b6d6e764b0b43c3c102509b971b9c", + "sha256": "02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "7ef14266c0d8ddd6a6c5b1a505ae1c58d392ac06eaa683079a8c69daa8b4c586", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:38.049262+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"family\": \"bosses-400ac-400b2\", \"decision\": \"approve\", \"scope\": \"Exact complete seven-frame v3 sibling, all firstsix unchanged; full phase gallery1\\u20134, native2/3, final-frame correction. No live boss assembly or timing claim.\", \"geometry\": \"Every source/HD frame preserves32\\u00d732whole occupied canvas and origin0. The sliding textured panel reveals the same dark/red machinery and pale rectangular right plates. Final phase keeps both pale rectangular plates instead of the held atlas rounded cap. Source-stable central panel is again a framed horizontal narrow-slat grille, not diagonal sheet material. Bottom floor now has short crossed diamond/herringbone topology, matching the earlier six frames instead of the held parallel-streak interpretation. Left bright/dark narrow slats and rail remain distinct.\", \"stationary_material_judgment\": \"Independently confirmed source central42/42cells and floor63/63cells identical across400b0,b1,b2. All three actualHD4regions and full nineframe/allscale galleries inspected. Final-grille frame slightly wider, floor repeat slightly finer/brighter, left rail grain/bolt pattern different. Fine texture does change rather than remaining byte-stationary: central only45/672 and floor93/1008 HD4pixels identical acrosslastthree. Accept these disclosed grain/pitch/frame-width variations because horizontal grille and crossing-floor topology are stable and no coarse-block substitution, material reorientation, or rounded plate replacement remains. No pixel-perfect animation material invariance claimed.\", \"first_six_preservation\": \"Exact six target bindings and six sequence bindings equal original frozen candidate; all24HD1\\u20134PPM bytes independently equal prior independent review corpus and currentauthor. Untouched firstsix atlas exactly equals recovered builtin PNG SHA fed3c49a6c1b281ab752d3efe30e2a29ba6842550d50189c89abc7f37cbfc1f7. Heldv2 inputs remain frozen.\", \"candidate_sha256\": \"02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b\", \"frame_bindings_sha256\": \"7ef14266c0d8ddd6a6c5b1a505ae1c58d392ac06eaa683079a8c69daa8b4c586\"} [\"Independent artwork and actual immutable HdAssets::load/sprite gallery review only. No live Host whole-boss assembly/reachability/timing, gameplay hitbox/economy or boss behavior claim.\", \"No art/source/candidate/raw/schema/global/production/Git writes, generation or promotion. Evidence only under isolated reference directory. Coordinator owns any admission.\", \"Crops preserve every raw alpha>=16and32pixel. 10310 crop excludes192and200a3crop2072low-alpha1\\u201315exterior gutter pixels; do not claim all input pixels displayed. Entire raw files are unchanged and match original builtin generator output exactly.\", \"Existing held300a8\\u2013ab/200ba/300a0 and old400v2/atlas final remain outside approval. Source-class/straight-alpha policies unchanged.\", \"Source masks, occupied-black fidelity and reserved-index counts are diagnostics; geometry/material decisions above were made from actual source/raw/runtime visual inspection.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 89652063ab9dda20291516e213612346c1a7163723ad70061271980bd373361b", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/author-review-complete.json", + "sha256": "f095712da51d9a5ad76657a4f77797f319b0e3a599af7535ee881a3c04e8bf64" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "400ac", + "400ad", + "400ae", + "400af" + ], + "sha256": "3fdc0752402efb53b0f45c249695953d5f85375ddc694c8b0a84d29f5ac1f7a1", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "400b0", + "400b1", + "400b2" + ], + "sha256": "78e3ec4c3048d8d7e029677b291f068e8acbbafa163542d87795ca568986fcf0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "400ac-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "99bf5dc19ee0b033195ac203d85b5a5f5132e771596aecc42949321602f8da2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "45773c8254ee64e2d67bbddbb1647a4ee38ec48f97f030e5bff1339ab08298c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9f11146e67778801b7bda06487fc9a3aca3a7aaa25ece9f721fcd4b42c9ff46e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9d5bca741347cda74f9e97e840470a56427950d724d3dba927bfecb43d8c99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52453fd92a1173569e3239f27710c176128eadf481ec8dea54c55ec17a1b702c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d42d1e6b1647799804f632e48090af203ff964891d72ffdaed868cff3cffc0e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c09fc82040d0da24d2f071c01439b8367d1dcc35be13df6e25c8eaa8130570d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f7d694a4a65cbe597a56532caec01ead68029ffe894df6614cc99a9038235890", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3aae84663408855bd3e6d2d9fd105d67fb230d6c2bdcc6bc50cfcc82a0974fe8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-original.ppm", + "sha256": "394f079943a1fa7ddb8d091280526d9c53d47b61371129720fc786c4726141b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1549b2cc2031d3eec908854fa6ba170d336e330dbce2676c97fee7e6cb6af6ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ca2cb3e743af674415e4a1fe6700ed486d0a2fcf3e4919aed331fdf07d5dd70", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ae8cd16bfb3172db601eec124d6bb6b0cea12bd40cd51e8e32c6f7e05cf2b8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bce99c3ec5cf096764ca4f97336278236ebf4cb71fa8ec6ad043b46de97291c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-original.ppm", + "sha256": "652f30c7efdeba05b7c666448c11bff14e583a8b1db5d7fb4550ca2a29b056d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e71eb5a150a7f3ad30fbdc6e06e06d0aba7635a0993bdbca518f6a5c59f8c44e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ed60ae4428718bdc336ed576b23a6888d37c38aeded8b90ce6387c71c0427508", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "abd2ce5fba0c7eb82752f572e6ce518570e69c51e669ade60923ccd1b6c93444", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "53199e6ed8409746fdeba36efd02fc203e4fb9e0b7e4a2a32cb647a69ca1ce6d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b41e262a0567d85f19e2f3676c854b867d85f4d4ef0f5c3e60412e0bbd790c5b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4027ea32c1bf92824c70aef5ff06083f96000608c119b7b9a31e84b6adbd621e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6584946ef1eea844056d7646a846fb2b561d924d1ccd786215389b524773d92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3315946dfb356a5995145a93dee364c864b91bf4d315383d816be1994d7fbf01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "de876a6b51110b1bb204d9762377a6ca9dbcd4524159014b235223938d737bbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f8243a6a33174a8b3e625ada45d86c8dca0931a477df40242069637b09aca327", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54ea061d8690918efad37687181043c8a5d0e11eee821c41d4ed7257ef21264b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "82194e05f7fb97bf40d768315d397b4da52bb65c04db74cd4df3723c328fee29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ca202cba244fbc88f7928841951ac464d3d6cb7869a4d8505329dc007ae70b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3a56d45a86e0a031be54d90da7e0edab63e1caf500b46cb51dd14140ae172992", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3284d6762eda92c9fcbe2a6b232028235b1a46cf35cd4a65fb1edafee6a090e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a3c37d108033424e8729dd9a30ea200f8afa68231aa004f4bee3011f2f2de93b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e1611940e97c1b120dea66acc4c11c41bd7e9000e72584f5a12d428ead4ec1ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0bbd60e3ffd2261be4c64af5ac3c76b98cf799d2320d022b7df2d0ba79614982", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d3da5f7854eb7278f860d14226ae50af54611a6957c27e8664d593b21b81cfd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b053ad1d43f650f9628d40cf86cd895b458925f1b05131bce9d7677075fe3d52", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": { + "old_held_candidate": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/held-main-before-coordinator-promotion-7ac77d44e6a1a750.json", + "old_held_sha256": "7ac77d44e6a1a750045ada766e6c117b947b6d6e764b0b43c3c102509b971b9c", + "approved_sibling": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/candidate-iron-coast-3-peer-v3.json", + "exact_bytes_promoted": true + } } }, "400ae": { @@ -304205,7 +310837,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "400ae", "family_id": "bosses-400ac-400b2", "job_id": "bosses-400ac-400b2", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_3", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -304215,8 +310847,231 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/candidate.json", - "sha256": "7ac77d44e6a1a750045ada766e6c117b947b6d6e764b0b43c3c102509b971b9c", + "sha256": "02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "7ef14266c0d8ddd6a6c5b1a505ae1c58d392ac06eaa683079a8c69daa8b4c586", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:38.049262+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"family\": \"bosses-400ac-400b2\", \"decision\": \"approve\", \"scope\": \"Exact complete seven-frame v3 sibling, all firstsix unchanged; full phase gallery1\\u20134, native2/3, final-frame correction. No live boss assembly or timing claim.\", \"geometry\": \"Every source/HD frame preserves32\\u00d732whole occupied canvas and origin0. The sliding textured panel reveals the same dark/red machinery and pale rectangular right plates. Final phase keeps both pale rectangular plates instead of the held atlas rounded cap. Source-stable central panel is again a framed horizontal narrow-slat grille, not diagonal sheet material. Bottom floor now has short crossed diamond/herringbone topology, matching the earlier six frames instead of the held parallel-streak interpretation. Left bright/dark narrow slats and rail remain distinct.\", \"stationary_material_judgment\": \"Independently confirmed source central42/42cells and floor63/63cells identical across400b0,b1,b2. All three actualHD4regions and full nineframe/allscale galleries inspected. Final-grille frame slightly wider, floor repeat slightly finer/brighter, left rail grain/bolt pattern different. Fine texture does change rather than remaining byte-stationary: central only45/672 and floor93/1008 HD4pixels identical acrosslastthree. Accept these disclosed grain/pitch/frame-width variations because horizontal grille and crossing-floor topology are stable and no coarse-block substitution, material reorientation, or rounded plate replacement remains. No pixel-perfect animation material invariance claimed.\", \"first_six_preservation\": \"Exact six target bindings and six sequence bindings equal original frozen candidate; all24HD1\\u20134PPM bytes independently equal prior independent review corpus and currentauthor. Untouched firstsix atlas exactly equals recovered builtin PNG SHA fed3c49a6c1b281ab752d3efe30e2a29ba6842550d50189c89abc7f37cbfc1f7. Heldv2 inputs remain frozen.\", \"candidate_sha256\": \"02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b\", \"frame_bindings_sha256\": \"7ef14266c0d8ddd6a6c5b1a505ae1c58d392ac06eaa683079a8c69daa8b4c586\"} [\"Independent artwork and actual immutable HdAssets::load/sprite gallery review only. No live Host whole-boss assembly/reachability/timing, gameplay hitbox/economy or boss behavior claim.\", \"No art/source/candidate/raw/schema/global/production/Git writes, generation or promotion. Evidence only under isolated reference directory. Coordinator owns any admission.\", \"Crops preserve every raw alpha>=16and32pixel. 10310 crop excludes192and200a3crop2072low-alpha1\\u201315exterior gutter pixels; do not claim all input pixels displayed. Entire raw files are unchanged and match original builtin generator output exactly.\", \"Existing held300a8\\u2013ab/200ba/300a0 and old400v2/atlas final remain outside approval. Source-class/straight-alpha policies unchanged.\", \"Source masks, occupied-black fidelity and reserved-index counts are diagnostics; geometry/material decisions above were made from actual source/raw/runtime visual inspection.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 89652063ab9dda20291516e213612346c1a7163723ad70061271980bd373361b", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/author-review-complete.json", + "sha256": "f095712da51d9a5ad76657a4f77797f319b0e3a599af7535ee881a3c04e8bf64" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "400ac", + "400ad", + "400ae", + "400af" + ], + "sha256": "3fdc0752402efb53b0f45c249695953d5f85375ddc694c8b0a84d29f5ac1f7a1", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "400b0", + "400b1", + "400b2" + ], + "sha256": "78e3ec4c3048d8d7e029677b291f068e8acbbafa163542d87795ca568986fcf0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "400ac-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "99bf5dc19ee0b033195ac203d85b5a5f5132e771596aecc42949321602f8da2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "45773c8254ee64e2d67bbddbb1647a4ee38ec48f97f030e5bff1339ab08298c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9f11146e67778801b7bda06487fc9a3aca3a7aaa25ece9f721fcd4b42c9ff46e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9d5bca741347cda74f9e97e840470a56427950d724d3dba927bfecb43d8c99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52453fd92a1173569e3239f27710c176128eadf481ec8dea54c55ec17a1b702c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d42d1e6b1647799804f632e48090af203ff964891d72ffdaed868cff3cffc0e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c09fc82040d0da24d2f071c01439b8367d1dcc35be13df6e25c8eaa8130570d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f7d694a4a65cbe597a56532caec01ead68029ffe894df6614cc99a9038235890", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3aae84663408855bd3e6d2d9fd105d67fb230d6c2bdcc6bc50cfcc82a0974fe8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-original.ppm", + "sha256": "394f079943a1fa7ddb8d091280526d9c53d47b61371129720fc786c4726141b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1549b2cc2031d3eec908854fa6ba170d336e330dbce2676c97fee7e6cb6af6ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ca2cb3e743af674415e4a1fe6700ed486d0a2fcf3e4919aed331fdf07d5dd70", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ae8cd16bfb3172db601eec124d6bb6b0cea12bd40cd51e8e32c6f7e05cf2b8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bce99c3ec5cf096764ca4f97336278236ebf4cb71fa8ec6ad043b46de97291c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-original.ppm", + "sha256": "652f30c7efdeba05b7c666448c11bff14e583a8b1db5d7fb4550ca2a29b056d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e71eb5a150a7f3ad30fbdc6e06e06d0aba7635a0993bdbca518f6a5c59f8c44e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ed60ae4428718bdc336ed576b23a6888d37c38aeded8b90ce6387c71c0427508", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "abd2ce5fba0c7eb82752f572e6ce518570e69c51e669ade60923ccd1b6c93444", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "53199e6ed8409746fdeba36efd02fc203e4fb9e0b7e4a2a32cb647a69ca1ce6d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b41e262a0567d85f19e2f3676c854b867d85f4d4ef0f5c3e60412e0bbd790c5b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4027ea32c1bf92824c70aef5ff06083f96000608c119b7b9a31e84b6adbd621e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6584946ef1eea844056d7646a846fb2b561d924d1ccd786215389b524773d92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3315946dfb356a5995145a93dee364c864b91bf4d315383d816be1994d7fbf01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "de876a6b51110b1bb204d9762377a6ca9dbcd4524159014b235223938d737bbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f8243a6a33174a8b3e625ada45d86c8dca0931a477df40242069637b09aca327", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54ea061d8690918efad37687181043c8a5d0e11eee821c41d4ed7257ef21264b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "82194e05f7fb97bf40d768315d397b4da52bb65c04db74cd4df3723c328fee29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ca202cba244fbc88f7928841951ac464d3d6cb7869a4d8505329dc007ae70b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3a56d45a86e0a031be54d90da7e0edab63e1caf500b46cb51dd14140ae172992", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3284d6762eda92c9fcbe2a6b232028235b1a46cf35cd4a65fb1edafee6a090e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a3c37d108033424e8729dd9a30ea200f8afa68231aa004f4bee3011f2f2de93b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e1611940e97c1b120dea66acc4c11c41bd7e9000e72584f5a12d428ead4ec1ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0bbd60e3ffd2261be4c64af5ac3c76b98cf799d2320d022b7df2d0ba79614982", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d3da5f7854eb7278f860d14226ae50af54611a6957c27e8664d593b21b81cfd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b053ad1d43f650f9628d40cf86cd895b458925f1b05131bce9d7677075fe3d52", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": { + "old_held_candidate": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/held-main-before-coordinator-promotion-7ac77d44e6a1a750.json", + "old_held_sha256": "7ac77d44e6a1a750045ada766e6c117b947b6d6e764b0b43c3c102509b971b9c", + "approved_sibling": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/candidate-iron-coast-3-peer-v3.json", + "exact_bytes_promoted": true + } } }, "400af": { @@ -304238,7 +311093,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "400af", "family_id": "bosses-400ac-400b2", "job_id": "bosses-400ac-400b2", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_3", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -304248,8 +311103,231 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/candidate.json", - "sha256": "7ac77d44e6a1a750045ada766e6c117b947b6d6e764b0b43c3c102509b971b9c", + "sha256": "02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "7ef14266c0d8ddd6a6c5b1a505ae1c58d392ac06eaa683079a8c69daa8b4c586", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:38.049262+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"family\": \"bosses-400ac-400b2\", \"decision\": \"approve\", \"scope\": \"Exact complete seven-frame v3 sibling, all firstsix unchanged; full phase gallery1\\u20134, native2/3, final-frame correction. No live boss assembly or timing claim.\", \"geometry\": \"Every source/HD frame preserves32\\u00d732whole occupied canvas and origin0. The sliding textured panel reveals the same dark/red machinery and pale rectangular right plates. Final phase keeps both pale rectangular plates instead of the held atlas rounded cap. Source-stable central panel is again a framed horizontal narrow-slat grille, not diagonal sheet material. Bottom floor now has short crossed diamond/herringbone topology, matching the earlier six frames instead of the held parallel-streak interpretation. Left bright/dark narrow slats and rail remain distinct.\", \"stationary_material_judgment\": \"Independently confirmed source central42/42cells and floor63/63cells identical across400b0,b1,b2. All three actualHD4regions and full nineframe/allscale galleries inspected. Final-grille frame slightly wider, floor repeat slightly finer/brighter, left rail grain/bolt pattern different. Fine texture does change rather than remaining byte-stationary: central only45/672 and floor93/1008 HD4pixels identical acrosslastthree. Accept these disclosed grain/pitch/frame-width variations because horizontal grille and crossing-floor topology are stable and no coarse-block substitution, material reorientation, or rounded plate replacement remains. No pixel-perfect animation material invariance claimed.\", \"first_six_preservation\": \"Exact six target bindings and six sequence bindings equal original frozen candidate; all24HD1\\u20134PPM bytes independently equal prior independent review corpus and currentauthor. Untouched firstsix atlas exactly equals recovered builtin PNG SHA fed3c49a6c1b281ab752d3efe30e2a29ba6842550d50189c89abc7f37cbfc1f7. Heldv2 inputs remain frozen.\", \"candidate_sha256\": \"02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b\", \"frame_bindings_sha256\": \"7ef14266c0d8ddd6a6c5b1a505ae1c58d392ac06eaa683079a8c69daa8b4c586\"} [\"Independent artwork and actual immutable HdAssets::load/sprite gallery review only. No live Host whole-boss assembly/reachability/timing, gameplay hitbox/economy or boss behavior claim.\", \"No art/source/candidate/raw/schema/global/production/Git writes, generation or promotion. Evidence only under isolated reference directory. Coordinator owns any admission.\", \"Crops preserve every raw alpha>=16and32pixel. 10310 crop excludes192and200a3crop2072low-alpha1\\u201315exterior gutter pixels; do not claim all input pixels displayed. Entire raw files are unchanged and match original builtin generator output exactly.\", \"Existing held300a8\\u2013ab/200ba/300a0 and old400v2/atlas final remain outside approval. Source-class/straight-alpha policies unchanged.\", \"Source masks, occupied-black fidelity and reserved-index counts are diagnostics; geometry/material decisions above were made from actual source/raw/runtime visual inspection.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 89652063ab9dda20291516e213612346c1a7163723ad70061271980bd373361b", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/author-review-complete.json", + "sha256": "f095712da51d9a5ad76657a4f77797f319b0e3a599af7535ee881a3c04e8bf64" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "400ac", + "400ad", + "400ae", + "400af" + ], + "sha256": "3fdc0752402efb53b0f45c249695953d5f85375ddc694c8b0a84d29f5ac1f7a1", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "400b0", + "400b1", + "400b2" + ], + "sha256": "78e3ec4c3048d8d7e029677b291f068e8acbbafa163542d87795ca568986fcf0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "400ac-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "99bf5dc19ee0b033195ac203d85b5a5f5132e771596aecc42949321602f8da2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "45773c8254ee64e2d67bbddbb1647a4ee38ec48f97f030e5bff1339ab08298c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9f11146e67778801b7bda06487fc9a3aca3a7aaa25ece9f721fcd4b42c9ff46e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9d5bca741347cda74f9e97e840470a56427950d724d3dba927bfecb43d8c99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52453fd92a1173569e3239f27710c176128eadf481ec8dea54c55ec17a1b702c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d42d1e6b1647799804f632e48090af203ff964891d72ffdaed868cff3cffc0e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c09fc82040d0da24d2f071c01439b8367d1dcc35be13df6e25c8eaa8130570d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f7d694a4a65cbe597a56532caec01ead68029ffe894df6614cc99a9038235890", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3aae84663408855bd3e6d2d9fd105d67fb230d6c2bdcc6bc50cfcc82a0974fe8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-original.ppm", + "sha256": "394f079943a1fa7ddb8d091280526d9c53d47b61371129720fc786c4726141b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1549b2cc2031d3eec908854fa6ba170d336e330dbce2676c97fee7e6cb6af6ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ca2cb3e743af674415e4a1fe6700ed486d0a2fcf3e4919aed331fdf07d5dd70", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ae8cd16bfb3172db601eec124d6bb6b0cea12bd40cd51e8e32c6f7e05cf2b8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bce99c3ec5cf096764ca4f97336278236ebf4cb71fa8ec6ad043b46de97291c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-original.ppm", + "sha256": "652f30c7efdeba05b7c666448c11bff14e583a8b1db5d7fb4550ca2a29b056d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e71eb5a150a7f3ad30fbdc6e06e06d0aba7635a0993bdbca518f6a5c59f8c44e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ed60ae4428718bdc336ed576b23a6888d37c38aeded8b90ce6387c71c0427508", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "abd2ce5fba0c7eb82752f572e6ce518570e69c51e669ade60923ccd1b6c93444", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "53199e6ed8409746fdeba36efd02fc203e4fb9e0b7e4a2a32cb647a69ca1ce6d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b41e262a0567d85f19e2f3676c854b867d85f4d4ef0f5c3e60412e0bbd790c5b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4027ea32c1bf92824c70aef5ff06083f96000608c119b7b9a31e84b6adbd621e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6584946ef1eea844056d7646a846fb2b561d924d1ccd786215389b524773d92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3315946dfb356a5995145a93dee364c864b91bf4d315383d816be1994d7fbf01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "de876a6b51110b1bb204d9762377a6ca9dbcd4524159014b235223938d737bbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f8243a6a33174a8b3e625ada45d86c8dca0931a477df40242069637b09aca327", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54ea061d8690918efad37687181043c8a5d0e11eee821c41d4ed7257ef21264b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "82194e05f7fb97bf40d768315d397b4da52bb65c04db74cd4df3723c328fee29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ca202cba244fbc88f7928841951ac464d3d6cb7869a4d8505329dc007ae70b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3a56d45a86e0a031be54d90da7e0edab63e1caf500b46cb51dd14140ae172992", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3284d6762eda92c9fcbe2a6b232028235b1a46cf35cd4a65fb1edafee6a090e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a3c37d108033424e8729dd9a30ea200f8afa68231aa004f4bee3011f2f2de93b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e1611940e97c1b120dea66acc4c11c41bd7e9000e72584f5a12d428ead4ec1ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0bbd60e3ffd2261be4c64af5ac3c76b98cf799d2320d022b7df2d0ba79614982", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d3da5f7854eb7278f860d14226ae50af54611a6957c27e8664d593b21b81cfd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b053ad1d43f650f9628d40cf86cd895b458925f1b05131bce9d7677075fe3d52", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": { + "old_held_candidate": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/held-main-before-coordinator-promotion-7ac77d44e6a1a750.json", + "old_held_sha256": "7ac77d44e6a1a750045ada766e6c117b947b6d6e764b0b43c3c102509b971b9c", + "approved_sibling": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/candidate-iron-coast-3-peer-v3.json", + "exact_bytes_promoted": true + } } }, "400b0": { @@ -304271,7 +311349,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "400b0", "family_id": "bosses-400ac-400b2", "job_id": "bosses-400ac-400b2", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_3", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -304281,8 +311359,231 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/candidate.json", - "sha256": "7ac77d44e6a1a750045ada766e6c117b947b6d6e764b0b43c3c102509b971b9c", + "sha256": "02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "7ef14266c0d8ddd6a6c5b1a505ae1c58d392ac06eaa683079a8c69daa8b4c586", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:38.049262+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"family\": \"bosses-400ac-400b2\", \"decision\": \"approve\", \"scope\": \"Exact complete seven-frame v3 sibling, all firstsix unchanged; full phase gallery1\\u20134, native2/3, final-frame correction. No live boss assembly or timing claim.\", \"geometry\": \"Every source/HD frame preserves32\\u00d732whole occupied canvas and origin0. The sliding textured panel reveals the same dark/red machinery and pale rectangular right plates. Final phase keeps both pale rectangular plates instead of the held atlas rounded cap. Source-stable central panel is again a framed horizontal narrow-slat grille, not diagonal sheet material. Bottom floor now has short crossed diamond/herringbone topology, matching the earlier six frames instead of the held parallel-streak interpretation. Left bright/dark narrow slats and rail remain distinct.\", \"stationary_material_judgment\": \"Independently confirmed source central42/42cells and floor63/63cells identical across400b0,b1,b2. All three actualHD4regions and full nineframe/allscale galleries inspected. Final-grille frame slightly wider, floor repeat slightly finer/brighter, left rail grain/bolt pattern different. Fine texture does change rather than remaining byte-stationary: central only45/672 and floor93/1008 HD4pixels identical acrosslastthree. Accept these disclosed grain/pitch/frame-width variations because horizontal grille and crossing-floor topology are stable and no coarse-block substitution, material reorientation, or rounded plate replacement remains. No pixel-perfect animation material invariance claimed.\", \"first_six_preservation\": \"Exact six target bindings and six sequence bindings equal original frozen candidate; all24HD1\\u20134PPM bytes independently equal prior independent review corpus and currentauthor. Untouched firstsix atlas exactly equals recovered builtin PNG SHA fed3c49a6c1b281ab752d3efe30e2a29ba6842550d50189c89abc7f37cbfc1f7. Heldv2 inputs remain frozen.\", \"candidate_sha256\": \"02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b\", \"frame_bindings_sha256\": \"7ef14266c0d8ddd6a6c5b1a505ae1c58d392ac06eaa683079a8c69daa8b4c586\"} [\"Independent artwork and actual immutable HdAssets::load/sprite gallery review only. No live Host whole-boss assembly/reachability/timing, gameplay hitbox/economy or boss behavior claim.\", \"No art/source/candidate/raw/schema/global/production/Git writes, generation or promotion. Evidence only under isolated reference directory. Coordinator owns any admission.\", \"Crops preserve every raw alpha>=16and32pixel. 10310 crop excludes192and200a3crop2072low-alpha1\\u201315exterior gutter pixels; do not claim all input pixels displayed. Entire raw files are unchanged and match original builtin generator output exactly.\", \"Existing held300a8\\u2013ab/200ba/300a0 and old400v2/atlas final remain outside approval. Source-class/straight-alpha policies unchanged.\", \"Source masks, occupied-black fidelity and reserved-index counts are diagnostics; geometry/material decisions above were made from actual source/raw/runtime visual inspection.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 89652063ab9dda20291516e213612346c1a7163723ad70061271980bd373361b", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/author-review-complete.json", + "sha256": "f095712da51d9a5ad76657a4f77797f319b0e3a599af7535ee881a3c04e8bf64" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "400ac", + "400ad", + "400ae", + "400af" + ], + "sha256": "3fdc0752402efb53b0f45c249695953d5f85375ddc694c8b0a84d29f5ac1f7a1", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "400b0", + "400b1", + "400b2" + ], + "sha256": "78e3ec4c3048d8d7e029677b291f068e8acbbafa163542d87795ca568986fcf0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "400ac-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "99bf5dc19ee0b033195ac203d85b5a5f5132e771596aecc42949321602f8da2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "45773c8254ee64e2d67bbddbb1647a4ee38ec48f97f030e5bff1339ab08298c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9f11146e67778801b7bda06487fc9a3aca3a7aaa25ece9f721fcd4b42c9ff46e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9d5bca741347cda74f9e97e840470a56427950d724d3dba927bfecb43d8c99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52453fd92a1173569e3239f27710c176128eadf481ec8dea54c55ec17a1b702c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d42d1e6b1647799804f632e48090af203ff964891d72ffdaed868cff3cffc0e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c09fc82040d0da24d2f071c01439b8367d1dcc35be13df6e25c8eaa8130570d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f7d694a4a65cbe597a56532caec01ead68029ffe894df6614cc99a9038235890", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3aae84663408855bd3e6d2d9fd105d67fb230d6c2bdcc6bc50cfcc82a0974fe8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-original.ppm", + "sha256": "394f079943a1fa7ddb8d091280526d9c53d47b61371129720fc786c4726141b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1549b2cc2031d3eec908854fa6ba170d336e330dbce2676c97fee7e6cb6af6ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ca2cb3e743af674415e4a1fe6700ed486d0a2fcf3e4919aed331fdf07d5dd70", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ae8cd16bfb3172db601eec124d6bb6b0cea12bd40cd51e8e32c6f7e05cf2b8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bce99c3ec5cf096764ca4f97336278236ebf4cb71fa8ec6ad043b46de97291c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-original.ppm", + "sha256": "652f30c7efdeba05b7c666448c11bff14e583a8b1db5d7fb4550ca2a29b056d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e71eb5a150a7f3ad30fbdc6e06e06d0aba7635a0993bdbca518f6a5c59f8c44e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ed60ae4428718bdc336ed576b23a6888d37c38aeded8b90ce6387c71c0427508", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "abd2ce5fba0c7eb82752f572e6ce518570e69c51e669ade60923ccd1b6c93444", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "53199e6ed8409746fdeba36efd02fc203e4fb9e0b7e4a2a32cb647a69ca1ce6d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b41e262a0567d85f19e2f3676c854b867d85f4d4ef0f5c3e60412e0bbd790c5b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4027ea32c1bf92824c70aef5ff06083f96000608c119b7b9a31e84b6adbd621e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6584946ef1eea844056d7646a846fb2b561d924d1ccd786215389b524773d92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3315946dfb356a5995145a93dee364c864b91bf4d315383d816be1994d7fbf01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "de876a6b51110b1bb204d9762377a6ca9dbcd4524159014b235223938d737bbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f8243a6a33174a8b3e625ada45d86c8dca0931a477df40242069637b09aca327", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54ea061d8690918efad37687181043c8a5d0e11eee821c41d4ed7257ef21264b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "82194e05f7fb97bf40d768315d397b4da52bb65c04db74cd4df3723c328fee29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ca202cba244fbc88f7928841951ac464d3d6cb7869a4d8505329dc007ae70b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3a56d45a86e0a031be54d90da7e0edab63e1caf500b46cb51dd14140ae172992", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3284d6762eda92c9fcbe2a6b232028235b1a46cf35cd4a65fb1edafee6a090e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a3c37d108033424e8729dd9a30ea200f8afa68231aa004f4bee3011f2f2de93b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e1611940e97c1b120dea66acc4c11c41bd7e9000e72584f5a12d428ead4ec1ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0bbd60e3ffd2261be4c64af5ac3c76b98cf799d2320d022b7df2d0ba79614982", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d3da5f7854eb7278f860d14226ae50af54611a6957c27e8664d593b21b81cfd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b053ad1d43f650f9628d40cf86cd895b458925f1b05131bce9d7677075fe3d52", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": { + "old_held_candidate": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/held-main-before-coordinator-promotion-7ac77d44e6a1a750.json", + "old_held_sha256": "7ac77d44e6a1a750045ada766e6c117b947b6d6e764b0b43c3c102509b971b9c", + "approved_sibling": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/candidate-iron-coast-3-peer-v3.json", + "exact_bytes_promoted": true + } } }, "400b1": { @@ -304304,7 +311605,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "400b1", "family_id": "bosses-400ac-400b2", "job_id": "bosses-400ac-400b2", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_3", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -304314,8 +311615,231 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/candidate.json", - "sha256": "7ac77d44e6a1a750045ada766e6c117b947b6d6e764b0b43c3c102509b971b9c", + "sha256": "02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "7ef14266c0d8ddd6a6c5b1a505ae1c58d392ac06eaa683079a8c69daa8b4c586", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:38.049262+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"family\": \"bosses-400ac-400b2\", \"decision\": \"approve\", \"scope\": \"Exact complete seven-frame v3 sibling, all firstsix unchanged; full phase gallery1\\u20134, native2/3, final-frame correction. No live boss assembly or timing claim.\", \"geometry\": \"Every source/HD frame preserves32\\u00d732whole occupied canvas and origin0. The sliding textured panel reveals the same dark/red machinery and pale rectangular right plates. Final phase keeps both pale rectangular plates instead of the held atlas rounded cap. Source-stable central panel is again a framed horizontal narrow-slat grille, not diagonal sheet material. Bottom floor now has short crossed diamond/herringbone topology, matching the earlier six frames instead of the held parallel-streak interpretation. Left bright/dark narrow slats and rail remain distinct.\", \"stationary_material_judgment\": \"Independently confirmed source central42/42cells and floor63/63cells identical across400b0,b1,b2. All three actualHD4regions and full nineframe/allscale galleries inspected. Final-grille frame slightly wider, floor repeat slightly finer/brighter, left rail grain/bolt pattern different. Fine texture does change rather than remaining byte-stationary: central only45/672 and floor93/1008 HD4pixels identical acrosslastthree. Accept these disclosed grain/pitch/frame-width variations because horizontal grille and crossing-floor topology are stable and no coarse-block substitution, material reorientation, or rounded plate replacement remains. No pixel-perfect animation material invariance claimed.\", \"first_six_preservation\": \"Exact six target bindings and six sequence bindings equal original frozen candidate; all24HD1\\u20134PPM bytes independently equal prior independent review corpus and currentauthor. Untouched firstsix atlas exactly equals recovered builtin PNG SHA fed3c49a6c1b281ab752d3efe30e2a29ba6842550d50189c89abc7f37cbfc1f7. Heldv2 inputs remain frozen.\", \"candidate_sha256\": \"02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b\", \"frame_bindings_sha256\": \"7ef14266c0d8ddd6a6c5b1a505ae1c58d392ac06eaa683079a8c69daa8b4c586\"} [\"Independent artwork and actual immutable HdAssets::load/sprite gallery review only. No live Host whole-boss assembly/reachability/timing, gameplay hitbox/economy or boss behavior claim.\", \"No art/source/candidate/raw/schema/global/production/Git writes, generation or promotion. Evidence only under isolated reference directory. Coordinator owns any admission.\", \"Crops preserve every raw alpha>=16and32pixel. 10310 crop excludes192and200a3crop2072low-alpha1\\u201315exterior gutter pixels; do not claim all input pixels displayed. Entire raw files are unchanged and match original builtin generator output exactly.\", \"Existing held300a8\\u2013ab/200ba/300a0 and old400v2/atlas final remain outside approval. Source-class/straight-alpha policies unchanged.\", \"Source masks, occupied-black fidelity and reserved-index counts are diagnostics; geometry/material decisions above were made from actual source/raw/runtime visual inspection.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 89652063ab9dda20291516e213612346c1a7163723ad70061271980bd373361b", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/author-review-complete.json", + "sha256": "f095712da51d9a5ad76657a4f77797f319b0e3a599af7535ee881a3c04e8bf64" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "400ac", + "400ad", + "400ae", + "400af" + ], + "sha256": "3fdc0752402efb53b0f45c249695953d5f85375ddc694c8b0a84d29f5ac1f7a1", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "400b0", + "400b1", + "400b2" + ], + "sha256": "78e3ec4c3048d8d7e029677b291f068e8acbbafa163542d87795ca568986fcf0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "400ac-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "99bf5dc19ee0b033195ac203d85b5a5f5132e771596aecc42949321602f8da2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "45773c8254ee64e2d67bbddbb1647a4ee38ec48f97f030e5bff1339ab08298c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9f11146e67778801b7bda06487fc9a3aca3a7aaa25ece9f721fcd4b42c9ff46e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9d5bca741347cda74f9e97e840470a56427950d724d3dba927bfecb43d8c99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52453fd92a1173569e3239f27710c176128eadf481ec8dea54c55ec17a1b702c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d42d1e6b1647799804f632e48090af203ff964891d72ffdaed868cff3cffc0e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c09fc82040d0da24d2f071c01439b8367d1dcc35be13df6e25c8eaa8130570d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f7d694a4a65cbe597a56532caec01ead68029ffe894df6614cc99a9038235890", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3aae84663408855bd3e6d2d9fd105d67fb230d6c2bdcc6bc50cfcc82a0974fe8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-original.ppm", + "sha256": "394f079943a1fa7ddb8d091280526d9c53d47b61371129720fc786c4726141b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1549b2cc2031d3eec908854fa6ba170d336e330dbce2676c97fee7e6cb6af6ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ca2cb3e743af674415e4a1fe6700ed486d0a2fcf3e4919aed331fdf07d5dd70", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ae8cd16bfb3172db601eec124d6bb6b0cea12bd40cd51e8e32c6f7e05cf2b8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bce99c3ec5cf096764ca4f97336278236ebf4cb71fa8ec6ad043b46de97291c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-original.ppm", + "sha256": "652f30c7efdeba05b7c666448c11bff14e583a8b1db5d7fb4550ca2a29b056d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e71eb5a150a7f3ad30fbdc6e06e06d0aba7635a0993bdbca518f6a5c59f8c44e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ed60ae4428718bdc336ed576b23a6888d37c38aeded8b90ce6387c71c0427508", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "abd2ce5fba0c7eb82752f572e6ce518570e69c51e669ade60923ccd1b6c93444", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "53199e6ed8409746fdeba36efd02fc203e4fb9e0b7e4a2a32cb647a69ca1ce6d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b41e262a0567d85f19e2f3676c854b867d85f4d4ef0f5c3e60412e0bbd790c5b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4027ea32c1bf92824c70aef5ff06083f96000608c119b7b9a31e84b6adbd621e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6584946ef1eea844056d7646a846fb2b561d924d1ccd786215389b524773d92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3315946dfb356a5995145a93dee364c864b91bf4d315383d816be1994d7fbf01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "de876a6b51110b1bb204d9762377a6ca9dbcd4524159014b235223938d737bbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f8243a6a33174a8b3e625ada45d86c8dca0931a477df40242069637b09aca327", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54ea061d8690918efad37687181043c8a5d0e11eee821c41d4ed7257ef21264b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "82194e05f7fb97bf40d768315d397b4da52bb65c04db74cd4df3723c328fee29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ca202cba244fbc88f7928841951ac464d3d6cb7869a4d8505329dc007ae70b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3a56d45a86e0a031be54d90da7e0edab63e1caf500b46cb51dd14140ae172992", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3284d6762eda92c9fcbe2a6b232028235b1a46cf35cd4a65fb1edafee6a090e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a3c37d108033424e8729dd9a30ea200f8afa68231aa004f4bee3011f2f2de93b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e1611940e97c1b120dea66acc4c11c41bd7e9000e72584f5a12d428ead4ec1ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0bbd60e3ffd2261be4c64af5ac3c76b98cf799d2320d022b7df2d0ba79614982", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d3da5f7854eb7278f860d14226ae50af54611a6957c27e8664d593b21b81cfd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b053ad1d43f650f9628d40cf86cd895b458925f1b05131bce9d7677075fe3d52", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": { + "old_held_candidate": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/held-main-before-coordinator-promotion-7ac77d44e6a1a750.json", + "old_held_sha256": "7ac77d44e6a1a750045ada766e6c117b947b6d6e764b0b43c3c102509b971b9c", + "approved_sibling": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/candidate-iron-coast-3-peer-v3.json", + "exact_bytes_promoted": true + } } }, "400b2": { @@ -304337,7 +311861,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "400b2", "family_id": "bosses-400ac-400b2", "job_id": "bosses-400ac-400b2", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_3", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -304347,8 +311871,231 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/candidate.json", - "sha256": "7ac77d44e6a1a750045ada766e6c117b947b6d6e764b0b43c3c102509b971b9c", + "sha256": "02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "7ef14266c0d8ddd6a6c5b1a505ae1c58d392ac06eaa683079a8c69daa8b4c586", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:38.049262+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"family\": \"bosses-400ac-400b2\", \"decision\": \"approve\", \"scope\": \"Exact complete seven-frame v3 sibling, all firstsix unchanged; full phase gallery1\\u20134, native2/3, final-frame correction. No live boss assembly or timing claim.\", \"geometry\": \"Every source/HD frame preserves32\\u00d732whole occupied canvas and origin0. The sliding textured panel reveals the same dark/red machinery and pale rectangular right plates. Final phase keeps both pale rectangular plates instead of the held atlas rounded cap. Source-stable central panel is again a framed horizontal narrow-slat grille, not diagonal sheet material. Bottom floor now has short crossed diamond/herringbone topology, matching the earlier six frames instead of the held parallel-streak interpretation. Left bright/dark narrow slats and rail remain distinct.\", \"stationary_material_judgment\": \"Independently confirmed source central42/42cells and floor63/63cells identical across400b0,b1,b2. All three actualHD4regions and full nineframe/allscale galleries inspected. Final-grille frame slightly wider, floor repeat slightly finer/brighter, left rail grain/bolt pattern different. Fine texture does change rather than remaining byte-stationary: central only45/672 and floor93/1008 HD4pixels identical acrosslastthree. Accept these disclosed grain/pitch/frame-width variations because horizontal grille and crossing-floor topology are stable and no coarse-block substitution, material reorientation, or rounded plate replacement remains. No pixel-perfect animation material invariance claimed.\", \"first_six_preservation\": \"Exact six target bindings and six sequence bindings equal original frozen candidate; all24HD1\\u20134PPM bytes independently equal prior independent review corpus and currentauthor. Untouched firstsix atlas exactly equals recovered builtin PNG SHA fed3c49a6c1b281ab752d3efe30e2a29ba6842550d50189c89abc7f37cbfc1f7. Heldv2 inputs remain frozen.\", \"candidate_sha256\": \"02a55d1b9a98358df73ea8ba7751e4371187ad76052ca2fb9ce3b3cadd880e1b\", \"frame_bindings_sha256\": \"7ef14266c0d8ddd6a6c5b1a505ae1c58d392ac06eaa683079a8c69daa8b4c586\"} [\"Independent artwork and actual immutable HdAssets::load/sprite gallery review only. No live Host whole-boss assembly/reachability/timing, gameplay hitbox/economy or boss behavior claim.\", \"No art/source/candidate/raw/schema/global/production/Git writes, generation or promotion. Evidence only under isolated reference directory. Coordinator owns any admission.\", \"Crops preserve every raw alpha>=16and32pixel. 10310 crop excludes192and200a3crop2072low-alpha1\\u201315exterior gutter pixels; do not claim all input pixels displayed. Entire raw files are unchanged and match original builtin generator output exactly.\", \"Existing held300a8\\u2013ab/200ba/300a0 and old400v2/atlas final remain outside approval. Source-class/straight-alpha policies unchanged.\", \"Source masks, occupied-black fidelity and reserved-index counts are diagnostics; geometry/material decisions above were made from actual source/raw/runtime visual inspection.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 89652063ab9dda20291516e213612346c1a7163723ad70061271980bd373361b", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/author-review-complete.json", + "sha256": "f095712da51d9a5ad76657a4f77797f319b0e3a599af7535ee881a3c04e8bf64" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "400ac", + "400ad", + "400ae", + "400af" + ], + "sha256": "3fdc0752402efb53b0f45c249695953d5f85375ddc694c8b0a84d29f5ac1f7a1", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "400b0", + "400b1", + "400b2" + ], + "sha256": "78e3ec4c3048d8d7e029677b291f068e8acbbafa163542d87795ca568986fcf0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "400ac-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "99bf5dc19ee0b033195ac203d85b5a5f5132e771596aecc42949321602f8da2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "45773c8254ee64e2d67bbddbb1647a4ee38ec48f97f030e5bff1339ab08298c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9f11146e67778801b7bda06487fc9a3aca3a7aaa25ece9f721fcd4b42c9ff46e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9d5bca741347cda74f9e97e840470a56427950d724d3dba927bfecb43d8c99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ac-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52453fd92a1173569e3239f27710c176128eadf481ec8dea54c55ec17a1b702c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ac-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d42d1e6b1647799804f632e48090af203ff964891d72ffdaed868cff3cffc0e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c09fc82040d0da24d2f071c01439b8367d1dcc35be13df6e25c8eaa8130570d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f7d694a4a65cbe597a56532caec01ead68029ffe894df6614cc99a9038235890", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3aae84663408855bd3e6d2d9fd105d67fb230d6c2bdcc6bc50cfcc82a0974fe8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ad-original.ppm", + "sha256": "394f079943a1fa7ddb8d091280526d9c53d47b61371129720fc786c4726141b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ad-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1549b2cc2031d3eec908854fa6ba170d336e330dbce2676c97fee7e6cb6af6ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ca2cb3e743af674415e4a1fe6700ed486d0a2fcf3e4919aed331fdf07d5dd70", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ae8cd16bfb3172db601eec124d6bb6b0cea12bd40cd51e8e32c6f7e05cf2b8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bce99c3ec5cf096764ca4f97336278236ebf4cb71fa8ec6ad043b46de97291c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400ae-original.ppm", + "sha256": "652f30c7efdeba05b7c666448c11bff14e583a8b1db5d7fb4550ca2a29b056d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400ae-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e71eb5a150a7f3ad30fbdc6e06e06d0aba7635a0993bdbca518f6a5c59f8c44e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ed60ae4428718bdc336ed576b23a6888d37c38aeded8b90ce6387c71c0427508", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "abd2ce5fba0c7eb82752f572e6ce518570e69c51e669ade60923ccd1b6c93444", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "53199e6ed8409746fdeba36efd02fc203e4fb9e0b7e4a2a32cb647a69ca1ce6d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400af-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b41e262a0567d85f19e2f3676c854b867d85f4d4ef0f5c3e60412e0bbd790c5b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400af-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4027ea32c1bf92824c70aef5ff06083f96000608c119b7b9a31e84b6adbd621e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6584946ef1eea844056d7646a846fb2b561d924d1ccd786215389b524773d92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3315946dfb356a5995145a93dee364c864b91bf4d315383d816be1994d7fbf01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "de876a6b51110b1bb204d9762377a6ca9dbcd4524159014b235223938d737bbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b0-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f8243a6a33174a8b3e625ada45d86c8dca0931a477df40242069637b09aca327", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b0-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54ea061d8690918efad37687181043c8a5d0e11eee821c41d4ed7257ef21264b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "82194e05f7fb97bf40d768315d397b4da52bb65c04db74cd4df3723c328fee29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ca202cba244fbc88f7928841951ac464d3d6cb7869a4d8505329dc007ae70b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3a56d45a86e0a031be54d90da7e0edab63e1caf500b46cb51dd14140ae172992", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b1-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3284d6762eda92c9fcbe2a6b232028235b1a46cf35cd4a65fb1edafee6a090e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b1-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a3c37d108033424e8729dd9a30ea200f8afa68231aa004f4bee3011f2f2de93b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e1611940e97c1b120dea66acc4c11c41bd7e9000e72584f5a12d428ead4ec1ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0bbd60e3ffd2261be4c64af5ac3c76b98cf799d2320d022b7df2d0ba79614982", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d3da5f7854eb7278f860d14226ae50af54611a6957c27e8664d593b21b81cfd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "400b2-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b053ad1d43f650f9628d40cf86cd895b458925f1b05131bce9d7677075fe3d52", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-local-fixture-review/bosses-400ac-400b2/runtime/400b2-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": { + "old_held_candidate": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/held-main-before-coordinator-promotion-7ac77d44e6a1a750.json", + "old_held_sha256": "7ac77d44e6a1a750045ada766e6c117b947b6d6e764b0b43c3c102509b971b9c", + "approved_sibling": "jobs/bosses-400ac-400b2/candidate-iron-coast-3-peer-v3.json", + "exact_bytes_promoted": true + } } }, "400b3": { @@ -344558,7 +352305,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40115", "family_id": "terrain-40115-40124", "job_id": "terrain-40115-40124", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -344574,6 +352321,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/candidate.json", "sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eea8c9dace9deb784646fb82f50ab21c3a97bb8e3874d63e1a7d11a1640fb99b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.545085+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"radar\": \"Complete genuine9-cell dish independently located twice in actual checked original Registry mission base:sector_3_wave_4 at row0/col0 and row0/col6. Full assembly1\\u20134 preserves ovoid dish, vertical double rails, horizontal beam, diagonal feed arm pointing lower-left, dark left foot/light right foot, bottom support with red source indicator and down-left ground shadow. All source cell crossings remain continuous; bottom-right40125 comes from second family exact literal crop. Modest facet/rivet/round-hub interpretation is accepted as newly authored detail, with source pose and key landmarks retained.\", \"source_indicator\": \"40124 original single index252 pixel remains exactly1/4/9/16 pixels at scales1/2/3/4. Other new31 tiles have no source dynamic indices, and proposed outputs add none. All compose probes preserve water/fire/single-index palette classes per pixel.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 586d3484558a98a0b48fa2f4b5436af681e85f1a6df6e463b7570c37000d80cc", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40115", + "40116", + "40117", + "40118" + ], + "sha256": "0591a7c752304b489096270b5d2a0b8e621594923b085fdb5a862e14e3225ac2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40119", + "4011a", + "4011b", + "4011c" + ], + "sha256": "da9615e1c2f75e40701c1651cbe53dc38ae7e042b3991938bced6a50e58e9aef", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4011d", + "4011e", + "4011f", + "40120" + ], + "sha256": "8bfbf337ef8847e703c331b872536de05b98948daf471333be9a0a590ff82b3a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40121", + "40122", + "40123", + "40124" + ], + "sha256": "c96258e857361c4996e85dd68a91d7e26c2a38abb1423cb37a519fc57acf3649", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40115-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "81f55f7b76d786bd9967935c30621f87ade4d25286411a022d6d19cda179a87f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db81d7396b38ccfe3207c94073d4215bb5ecae6d7089fc9cd677226977502ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "02ab0db2fad9f9b805b8a0c5e7a6ff1ac21f66aa3d7a129380213f0e56758ff1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc75189e56d6006fa415ed1b26d1543eeee301a623e9a0c745b6d1599ddf6d74", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108de4b5b90a0d4e9a1bb50d2802b500529d0751bd8f74070a31e699b31d02f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bdd322052e50366f686b11ff2dbea2ba169ee86f402bf615b8808ced24674a2e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b50e31f20e6d42025ad8d11862c638418eaa27a95d5972b1e8213070920da03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9a05fef741623c0008ffdd3fbee4357f50f1f43e275f05f65bc115376f952d9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cff578bf5bcc42a48665e288ace0067cf819505acdbb4b4eb47ebab7fce86348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2305e5a91dde4daac3bbcd3753363b1e7873305a8f60bea716ab50a26046eb66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "93e9a2b912ee31c3dbb538e739d5c1deffe2e3ff1b8ff18b01f0cadc8a100769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "157ae2f62916bba51c72138c4f71daceb863256fb4a591c1242f48bef69e7237", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f474433675ca4ca8ac9b25bb470528d9bc6a2f7620873126c204a05d03555553", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a416496d2ffd0ea5e2aac18b4a27c325f79a7c04b43d1b747fc0b24d399749c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9903a18e644f92402afd31b90ff5f33055cf3d8a752204849ac3c557dc90b104", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b849a505d7220afe638b17feb07b28c066a1966166520f4a7b09446c77388f08", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3a12a7d24c56ce771b950fc137295488723b73c8227d5ed092c0a3eac9045b04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d70722dae2e2c470a6ff06d95db19f446c4e5ee188c1811e546e0c28550ae2ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ab755a61b4f29404eae0fc69db6c6daf47f862812c75b8288ddd865594387a8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-original.ppm", + "sha256": "74982df2c178379136049377e64734fc85658e4215b2d0f3add38acd49e92f3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "84bac11cc0d40a51bf48a3dcc84393a2c0a216adde666251fa744b474ac4af6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "451b5925cf64b2d76ce3c1921de3974848fabfda2e215f76830824b31509fa5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c1802cee33337b3ee96e498fb186d08406edc0b9bd76c5ed5770152bee47105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8d6826dbf12e07d533c79794a08c907df51c21a2fc93f7e7e7ec87dee7964a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cacf909ef0797cea2a5528e4466d3463db1c77bbf5a76bcc6434f3e72a6ca51e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2af9ac17f5e80769dc1cfb402e9da093e313b0c072e09abe78a5015e7d16c4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "650f5a9f04911bd5404b60c2de8f406e12cd1f78b45460b342fe3fcee6a625c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "50fad51965e60a64c4f88fdf79f3cb88f582cbcd136a29588c9f19748722c7fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0dc4f45ab5a62e7318c045bcfb77db665c2bce52a4f7d194b3a53693ae83b022", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8efcee76d4ad364bd3665ae090415151348e0ebfce7eaf3f65cad73433bfdbae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4f5536bb63d024365ac1f7cfeb46382ef3c83fa098d573d5a4a3297485c9f105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3c4c28ee1b20ab662d3db1c0d98a6106ead652819998b5197a79363f5a655035", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "48960b86fc04528391963c1bf4eb2cc1372b5e6d95cdb59240504fd794cefb2c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7de3b05cef98dffe4cf7c1eb08ed7048f7291485875d95c43644d3575f2a7464", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250cf8c478790b5eb9ff2cf7cec80e420a6c95506f747ed2da71600951cdff42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "578259c1668e3ba3a9c05d8260f2e3fe8c53ac245211b706edf15694483fa2bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "056c806b021a80b965a8e9d9454ccbe44517abb57c3fdcac35a449c3a928794e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "adef5a9dd838fb78f921d8e1f73adbee19fa0720efc24f949260d3aba6cf0782", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a2dcc700b719f25fac3e69d7943ee7716112e2f2fc7d4a58224778a4bf79bb31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de1f27549ff452e116aacff012b18655c3fbe46642da5502d3c03f80dbb35825", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cad580274feb2c96666516169ea6491ca23436ca351fffc0a6cfa22fedb7ab85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6a4a4cb3192dea3c54995948f985fc0433c5d2d8bc4e189656406dffa0da575", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b1ea0593f03a28049fdd749f01302955562c0c7fa74f626ed990443c04e5a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b58259013db82b50398ab16bfb8f96654f858a96b23f7a381a977a845314e2d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4881eabaa4994249c0b2b675e55437c0f35d7794ba403fb617252016a571a012", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1854fabf39cc4522d771c076e69a428e14c37dcf035967da354aeb3815ed19fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "effe172b2a5e805f2e044420120e42fda45a359341ffd221a67b037517a7a9f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "582ab949c8eeca6ed80e96f78fec992b9d71fda17ebc4eaccc265c948b4606c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "730c1daf6de9b496850fd42556323d38a542ecf6c01833b9eef1369db8863ad8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "789cc80d4fd3714071537c958d4ef807e6ad23f1ea64da549c4a39a14cf4898f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "781ef1854ab07423ba4bf0ab3e7ee925cb58d0c5f8344d0df3c93e88a4741896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26c6a4a506895b59affff539c1f0e578571db2b6001df8fe9872d601f6d95829", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82a7963c214eb0dd3b2f180e0df7aa044db2882bf5d3d8bfe230341684fe5856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5e16ec3be0f2ccc7c28e95bddcb79757ac2c4d776d078d2b104f9a197a5b9aa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "185bbd6ca8d00a5fe097cb38366344da24853ba5905f8cca78434cfa35d19f98", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a4d9574ad43cdee2244bea882a02b480e3039a50c96fc156d81ca10cb472649e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e7bbaf31fbf98e083b5855d1624b323c8e5cde929cb13c0dd971988ac1e34d46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5384ce41d9b99477ffc601954064f8e92aaacbfaa8e04a40b933c1d1139101d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "75f0fa97b7fdb2b56811cb6ca967864a0da344111db9127e346ddd3b726b00af", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9cc70ce409af7feaf4cd45178775e9d267eff8775f6d7e43e168c89dd3ab4347", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "17a90d4602d94ce73604588843eacbfbe2e8636c1fcc0c8aaea293f0dca18c28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d89e7c1b41f23bf421e0cd0d2970f39e94e15972809cd5da09ccbf9c97b105d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1ec5e09d42b79ac2dd22915d37027fdae9e02ef9abb74340314eda4c65e47ce3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dbee004989c2b9caa4394e2039b054d2ba9df4af40b2be962f36d6b6b78ee3be", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "aec387334e29e8b1f8013a357e5d4ec6d8922c3dbe9099e63961769c0ca84939", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d21d6933bd94eb169fa629389643ef375cb72739f19e1cc81d11cecbb59ee20", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "253c832e1f4f69b79c5c1f7e02986cf81d47b20647c832828f8ac561a7b797c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "326148bdef19c436a2eb07180fc25bc7ecf70058c9cc5c61104a164bef2afdf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f85ed8035add441def60d92992f3b458ad65d1df1b3f1934ae9c5c564e998d4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05aaf983932b5d288145e7c2028b219375246636d0a3f8dbde24d771002352d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1a404f9dde85acab25e040b39f94a1199d01646e78e221f70eeb6ff67548d72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26cba078e1604d3f9a2b3cc26ea99bf42ba62c7e049cf2d46a5ecd05b60a7fc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fed3e579f88263c02ab856dc1fe0c68105d949a328e2b874e804ec3abbf8bfe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b76706cd499da75a46176a5dc3a83c5516e53a11ab18e28a2c82e806b2b15204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e87c3d8c9c63d0f0caee3e5650132a334ca1a70ac6d6fa41675750797d9ecb6e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a5c304e2cf0a67eb5601f2ae7049a1289c7aa8a867df2bb58ba7121f845ef3ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "64bdb88f558231e706b9eec9179cdf4d022139af2085a169aac2639023562d7f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "af0cb612d62934c3c22c456cbdc4c33c9f11092bc41321eaf25790cadc64a4da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0c79ec3f4b05788af4c21a84e8e27ac0d3fae8b46b1299a3a364aaa4f61b6c6c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d6d2064ddbbd48570b44bad5d7aaf7698dbf8fb89ed5b535724bb387615e950", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40116": { @@ -344595,7 +352812,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40116", "family_id": "terrain-40115-40124", "job_id": "terrain-40115-40124", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -344611,6 +352828,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/candidate.json", "sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eea8c9dace9deb784646fb82f50ab21c3a97bb8e3874d63e1a7d11a1640fb99b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.545085+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"radar\": \"Complete genuine9-cell dish independently located twice in actual checked original Registry mission base:sector_3_wave_4 at row0/col0 and row0/col6. Full assembly1\\u20134 preserves ovoid dish, vertical double rails, horizontal beam, diagonal feed arm pointing lower-left, dark left foot/light right foot, bottom support with red source indicator and down-left ground shadow. All source cell crossings remain continuous; bottom-right40125 comes from second family exact literal crop. Modest facet/rivet/round-hub interpretation is accepted as newly authored detail, with source pose and key landmarks retained.\", \"source_indicator\": \"40124 original single index252 pixel remains exactly1/4/9/16 pixels at scales1/2/3/4. Other new31 tiles have no source dynamic indices, and proposed outputs add none. All compose probes preserve water/fire/single-index palette classes per pixel.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 586d3484558a98a0b48fa2f4b5436af681e85f1a6df6e463b7570c37000d80cc", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40115", + "40116", + "40117", + "40118" + ], + "sha256": "0591a7c752304b489096270b5d2a0b8e621594923b085fdb5a862e14e3225ac2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40119", + "4011a", + "4011b", + "4011c" + ], + "sha256": "da9615e1c2f75e40701c1651cbe53dc38ae7e042b3991938bced6a50e58e9aef", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4011d", + "4011e", + "4011f", + "40120" + ], + "sha256": "8bfbf337ef8847e703c331b872536de05b98948daf471333be9a0a590ff82b3a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40121", + "40122", + "40123", + "40124" + ], + "sha256": "c96258e857361c4996e85dd68a91d7e26c2a38abb1423cb37a519fc57acf3649", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40115-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "81f55f7b76d786bd9967935c30621f87ade4d25286411a022d6d19cda179a87f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db81d7396b38ccfe3207c94073d4215bb5ecae6d7089fc9cd677226977502ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "02ab0db2fad9f9b805b8a0c5e7a6ff1ac21f66aa3d7a129380213f0e56758ff1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc75189e56d6006fa415ed1b26d1543eeee301a623e9a0c745b6d1599ddf6d74", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108de4b5b90a0d4e9a1bb50d2802b500529d0751bd8f74070a31e699b31d02f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bdd322052e50366f686b11ff2dbea2ba169ee86f402bf615b8808ced24674a2e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b50e31f20e6d42025ad8d11862c638418eaa27a95d5972b1e8213070920da03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9a05fef741623c0008ffdd3fbee4357f50f1f43e275f05f65bc115376f952d9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cff578bf5bcc42a48665e288ace0067cf819505acdbb4b4eb47ebab7fce86348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2305e5a91dde4daac3bbcd3753363b1e7873305a8f60bea716ab50a26046eb66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "93e9a2b912ee31c3dbb538e739d5c1deffe2e3ff1b8ff18b01f0cadc8a100769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "157ae2f62916bba51c72138c4f71daceb863256fb4a591c1242f48bef69e7237", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f474433675ca4ca8ac9b25bb470528d9bc6a2f7620873126c204a05d03555553", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a416496d2ffd0ea5e2aac18b4a27c325f79a7c04b43d1b747fc0b24d399749c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9903a18e644f92402afd31b90ff5f33055cf3d8a752204849ac3c557dc90b104", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b849a505d7220afe638b17feb07b28c066a1966166520f4a7b09446c77388f08", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3a12a7d24c56ce771b950fc137295488723b73c8227d5ed092c0a3eac9045b04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d70722dae2e2c470a6ff06d95db19f446c4e5ee188c1811e546e0c28550ae2ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ab755a61b4f29404eae0fc69db6c6daf47f862812c75b8288ddd865594387a8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-original.ppm", + "sha256": "74982df2c178379136049377e64734fc85658e4215b2d0f3add38acd49e92f3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "84bac11cc0d40a51bf48a3dcc84393a2c0a216adde666251fa744b474ac4af6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "451b5925cf64b2d76ce3c1921de3974848fabfda2e215f76830824b31509fa5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c1802cee33337b3ee96e498fb186d08406edc0b9bd76c5ed5770152bee47105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8d6826dbf12e07d533c79794a08c907df51c21a2fc93f7e7e7ec87dee7964a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cacf909ef0797cea2a5528e4466d3463db1c77bbf5a76bcc6434f3e72a6ca51e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2af9ac17f5e80769dc1cfb402e9da093e313b0c072e09abe78a5015e7d16c4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "650f5a9f04911bd5404b60c2de8f406e12cd1f78b45460b342fe3fcee6a625c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "50fad51965e60a64c4f88fdf79f3cb88f582cbcd136a29588c9f19748722c7fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0dc4f45ab5a62e7318c045bcfb77db665c2bce52a4f7d194b3a53693ae83b022", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8efcee76d4ad364bd3665ae090415151348e0ebfce7eaf3f65cad73433bfdbae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4f5536bb63d024365ac1f7cfeb46382ef3c83fa098d573d5a4a3297485c9f105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3c4c28ee1b20ab662d3db1c0d98a6106ead652819998b5197a79363f5a655035", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "48960b86fc04528391963c1bf4eb2cc1372b5e6d95cdb59240504fd794cefb2c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7de3b05cef98dffe4cf7c1eb08ed7048f7291485875d95c43644d3575f2a7464", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250cf8c478790b5eb9ff2cf7cec80e420a6c95506f747ed2da71600951cdff42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "578259c1668e3ba3a9c05d8260f2e3fe8c53ac245211b706edf15694483fa2bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "056c806b021a80b965a8e9d9454ccbe44517abb57c3fdcac35a449c3a928794e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "adef5a9dd838fb78f921d8e1f73adbee19fa0720efc24f949260d3aba6cf0782", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a2dcc700b719f25fac3e69d7943ee7716112e2f2fc7d4a58224778a4bf79bb31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de1f27549ff452e116aacff012b18655c3fbe46642da5502d3c03f80dbb35825", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cad580274feb2c96666516169ea6491ca23436ca351fffc0a6cfa22fedb7ab85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6a4a4cb3192dea3c54995948f985fc0433c5d2d8bc4e189656406dffa0da575", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b1ea0593f03a28049fdd749f01302955562c0c7fa74f626ed990443c04e5a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b58259013db82b50398ab16bfb8f96654f858a96b23f7a381a977a845314e2d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4881eabaa4994249c0b2b675e55437c0f35d7794ba403fb617252016a571a012", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1854fabf39cc4522d771c076e69a428e14c37dcf035967da354aeb3815ed19fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "effe172b2a5e805f2e044420120e42fda45a359341ffd221a67b037517a7a9f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "582ab949c8eeca6ed80e96f78fec992b9d71fda17ebc4eaccc265c948b4606c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "730c1daf6de9b496850fd42556323d38a542ecf6c01833b9eef1369db8863ad8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "789cc80d4fd3714071537c958d4ef807e6ad23f1ea64da549c4a39a14cf4898f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "781ef1854ab07423ba4bf0ab3e7ee925cb58d0c5f8344d0df3c93e88a4741896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26c6a4a506895b59affff539c1f0e578571db2b6001df8fe9872d601f6d95829", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82a7963c214eb0dd3b2f180e0df7aa044db2882bf5d3d8bfe230341684fe5856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5e16ec3be0f2ccc7c28e95bddcb79757ac2c4d776d078d2b104f9a197a5b9aa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "185bbd6ca8d00a5fe097cb38366344da24853ba5905f8cca78434cfa35d19f98", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a4d9574ad43cdee2244bea882a02b480e3039a50c96fc156d81ca10cb472649e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e7bbaf31fbf98e083b5855d1624b323c8e5cde929cb13c0dd971988ac1e34d46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5384ce41d9b99477ffc601954064f8e92aaacbfaa8e04a40b933c1d1139101d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "75f0fa97b7fdb2b56811cb6ca967864a0da344111db9127e346ddd3b726b00af", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9cc70ce409af7feaf4cd45178775e9d267eff8775f6d7e43e168c89dd3ab4347", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "17a90d4602d94ce73604588843eacbfbe2e8636c1fcc0c8aaea293f0dca18c28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d89e7c1b41f23bf421e0cd0d2970f39e94e15972809cd5da09ccbf9c97b105d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1ec5e09d42b79ac2dd22915d37027fdae9e02ef9abb74340314eda4c65e47ce3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dbee004989c2b9caa4394e2039b054d2ba9df4af40b2be962f36d6b6b78ee3be", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "aec387334e29e8b1f8013a357e5d4ec6d8922c3dbe9099e63961769c0ca84939", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d21d6933bd94eb169fa629389643ef375cb72739f19e1cc81d11cecbb59ee20", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "253c832e1f4f69b79c5c1f7e02986cf81d47b20647c832828f8ac561a7b797c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "326148bdef19c436a2eb07180fc25bc7ecf70058c9cc5c61104a164bef2afdf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f85ed8035add441def60d92992f3b458ad65d1df1b3f1934ae9c5c564e998d4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05aaf983932b5d288145e7c2028b219375246636d0a3f8dbde24d771002352d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1a404f9dde85acab25e040b39f94a1199d01646e78e221f70eeb6ff67548d72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26cba078e1604d3f9a2b3cc26ea99bf42ba62c7e049cf2d46a5ecd05b60a7fc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fed3e579f88263c02ab856dc1fe0c68105d949a328e2b874e804ec3abbf8bfe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b76706cd499da75a46176a5dc3a83c5516e53a11ab18e28a2c82e806b2b15204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e87c3d8c9c63d0f0caee3e5650132a334ca1a70ac6d6fa41675750797d9ecb6e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a5c304e2cf0a67eb5601f2ae7049a1289c7aa8a867df2bb58ba7121f845ef3ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "64bdb88f558231e706b9eec9179cdf4d022139af2085a169aac2639023562d7f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "af0cb612d62934c3c22c456cbdc4c33c9f11092bc41321eaf25790cadc64a4da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0c79ec3f4b05788af4c21a84e8e27ac0d3fae8b46b1299a3a364aaa4f61b6c6c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d6d2064ddbbd48570b44bad5d7aaf7698dbf8fb89ed5b535724bb387615e950", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40117": { @@ -344632,7 +353319,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40117", "family_id": "terrain-40115-40124", "job_id": "terrain-40115-40124", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -344648,6 +353335,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/candidate.json", "sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eea8c9dace9deb784646fb82f50ab21c3a97bb8e3874d63e1a7d11a1640fb99b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.545085+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"radar\": \"Complete genuine9-cell dish independently located twice in actual checked original Registry mission base:sector_3_wave_4 at row0/col0 and row0/col6. Full assembly1\\u20134 preserves ovoid dish, vertical double rails, horizontal beam, diagonal feed arm pointing lower-left, dark left foot/light right foot, bottom support with red source indicator and down-left ground shadow. All source cell crossings remain continuous; bottom-right40125 comes from second family exact literal crop. Modest facet/rivet/round-hub interpretation is accepted as newly authored detail, with source pose and key landmarks retained.\", \"source_indicator\": \"40124 original single index252 pixel remains exactly1/4/9/16 pixels at scales1/2/3/4. Other new31 tiles have no source dynamic indices, and proposed outputs add none. All compose probes preserve water/fire/single-index palette classes per pixel.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 586d3484558a98a0b48fa2f4b5436af681e85f1a6df6e463b7570c37000d80cc", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40115", + "40116", + "40117", + "40118" + ], + "sha256": "0591a7c752304b489096270b5d2a0b8e621594923b085fdb5a862e14e3225ac2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40119", + "4011a", + "4011b", + "4011c" + ], + "sha256": "da9615e1c2f75e40701c1651cbe53dc38ae7e042b3991938bced6a50e58e9aef", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4011d", + "4011e", + "4011f", + "40120" + ], + "sha256": "8bfbf337ef8847e703c331b872536de05b98948daf471333be9a0a590ff82b3a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40121", + "40122", + "40123", + "40124" + ], + "sha256": "c96258e857361c4996e85dd68a91d7e26c2a38abb1423cb37a519fc57acf3649", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40115-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "81f55f7b76d786bd9967935c30621f87ade4d25286411a022d6d19cda179a87f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db81d7396b38ccfe3207c94073d4215bb5ecae6d7089fc9cd677226977502ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "02ab0db2fad9f9b805b8a0c5e7a6ff1ac21f66aa3d7a129380213f0e56758ff1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc75189e56d6006fa415ed1b26d1543eeee301a623e9a0c745b6d1599ddf6d74", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108de4b5b90a0d4e9a1bb50d2802b500529d0751bd8f74070a31e699b31d02f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bdd322052e50366f686b11ff2dbea2ba169ee86f402bf615b8808ced24674a2e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b50e31f20e6d42025ad8d11862c638418eaa27a95d5972b1e8213070920da03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9a05fef741623c0008ffdd3fbee4357f50f1f43e275f05f65bc115376f952d9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cff578bf5bcc42a48665e288ace0067cf819505acdbb4b4eb47ebab7fce86348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2305e5a91dde4daac3bbcd3753363b1e7873305a8f60bea716ab50a26046eb66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "93e9a2b912ee31c3dbb538e739d5c1deffe2e3ff1b8ff18b01f0cadc8a100769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "157ae2f62916bba51c72138c4f71daceb863256fb4a591c1242f48bef69e7237", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f474433675ca4ca8ac9b25bb470528d9bc6a2f7620873126c204a05d03555553", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a416496d2ffd0ea5e2aac18b4a27c325f79a7c04b43d1b747fc0b24d399749c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9903a18e644f92402afd31b90ff5f33055cf3d8a752204849ac3c557dc90b104", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b849a505d7220afe638b17feb07b28c066a1966166520f4a7b09446c77388f08", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3a12a7d24c56ce771b950fc137295488723b73c8227d5ed092c0a3eac9045b04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d70722dae2e2c470a6ff06d95db19f446c4e5ee188c1811e546e0c28550ae2ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ab755a61b4f29404eae0fc69db6c6daf47f862812c75b8288ddd865594387a8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-original.ppm", + "sha256": "74982df2c178379136049377e64734fc85658e4215b2d0f3add38acd49e92f3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "84bac11cc0d40a51bf48a3dcc84393a2c0a216adde666251fa744b474ac4af6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "451b5925cf64b2d76ce3c1921de3974848fabfda2e215f76830824b31509fa5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c1802cee33337b3ee96e498fb186d08406edc0b9bd76c5ed5770152bee47105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8d6826dbf12e07d533c79794a08c907df51c21a2fc93f7e7e7ec87dee7964a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cacf909ef0797cea2a5528e4466d3463db1c77bbf5a76bcc6434f3e72a6ca51e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2af9ac17f5e80769dc1cfb402e9da093e313b0c072e09abe78a5015e7d16c4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "650f5a9f04911bd5404b60c2de8f406e12cd1f78b45460b342fe3fcee6a625c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "50fad51965e60a64c4f88fdf79f3cb88f582cbcd136a29588c9f19748722c7fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0dc4f45ab5a62e7318c045bcfb77db665c2bce52a4f7d194b3a53693ae83b022", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8efcee76d4ad364bd3665ae090415151348e0ebfce7eaf3f65cad73433bfdbae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4f5536bb63d024365ac1f7cfeb46382ef3c83fa098d573d5a4a3297485c9f105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3c4c28ee1b20ab662d3db1c0d98a6106ead652819998b5197a79363f5a655035", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "48960b86fc04528391963c1bf4eb2cc1372b5e6d95cdb59240504fd794cefb2c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7de3b05cef98dffe4cf7c1eb08ed7048f7291485875d95c43644d3575f2a7464", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250cf8c478790b5eb9ff2cf7cec80e420a6c95506f747ed2da71600951cdff42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "578259c1668e3ba3a9c05d8260f2e3fe8c53ac245211b706edf15694483fa2bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "056c806b021a80b965a8e9d9454ccbe44517abb57c3fdcac35a449c3a928794e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "adef5a9dd838fb78f921d8e1f73adbee19fa0720efc24f949260d3aba6cf0782", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a2dcc700b719f25fac3e69d7943ee7716112e2f2fc7d4a58224778a4bf79bb31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de1f27549ff452e116aacff012b18655c3fbe46642da5502d3c03f80dbb35825", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cad580274feb2c96666516169ea6491ca23436ca351fffc0a6cfa22fedb7ab85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6a4a4cb3192dea3c54995948f985fc0433c5d2d8bc4e189656406dffa0da575", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b1ea0593f03a28049fdd749f01302955562c0c7fa74f626ed990443c04e5a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b58259013db82b50398ab16bfb8f96654f858a96b23f7a381a977a845314e2d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4881eabaa4994249c0b2b675e55437c0f35d7794ba403fb617252016a571a012", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1854fabf39cc4522d771c076e69a428e14c37dcf035967da354aeb3815ed19fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "effe172b2a5e805f2e044420120e42fda45a359341ffd221a67b037517a7a9f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "582ab949c8eeca6ed80e96f78fec992b9d71fda17ebc4eaccc265c948b4606c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "730c1daf6de9b496850fd42556323d38a542ecf6c01833b9eef1369db8863ad8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "789cc80d4fd3714071537c958d4ef807e6ad23f1ea64da549c4a39a14cf4898f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "781ef1854ab07423ba4bf0ab3e7ee925cb58d0c5f8344d0df3c93e88a4741896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26c6a4a506895b59affff539c1f0e578571db2b6001df8fe9872d601f6d95829", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82a7963c214eb0dd3b2f180e0df7aa044db2882bf5d3d8bfe230341684fe5856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5e16ec3be0f2ccc7c28e95bddcb79757ac2c4d776d078d2b104f9a197a5b9aa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "185bbd6ca8d00a5fe097cb38366344da24853ba5905f8cca78434cfa35d19f98", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a4d9574ad43cdee2244bea882a02b480e3039a50c96fc156d81ca10cb472649e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e7bbaf31fbf98e083b5855d1624b323c8e5cde929cb13c0dd971988ac1e34d46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5384ce41d9b99477ffc601954064f8e92aaacbfaa8e04a40b933c1d1139101d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "75f0fa97b7fdb2b56811cb6ca967864a0da344111db9127e346ddd3b726b00af", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9cc70ce409af7feaf4cd45178775e9d267eff8775f6d7e43e168c89dd3ab4347", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "17a90d4602d94ce73604588843eacbfbe2e8636c1fcc0c8aaea293f0dca18c28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d89e7c1b41f23bf421e0cd0d2970f39e94e15972809cd5da09ccbf9c97b105d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1ec5e09d42b79ac2dd22915d37027fdae9e02ef9abb74340314eda4c65e47ce3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dbee004989c2b9caa4394e2039b054d2ba9df4af40b2be962f36d6b6b78ee3be", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "aec387334e29e8b1f8013a357e5d4ec6d8922c3dbe9099e63961769c0ca84939", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d21d6933bd94eb169fa629389643ef375cb72739f19e1cc81d11cecbb59ee20", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "253c832e1f4f69b79c5c1f7e02986cf81d47b20647c832828f8ac561a7b797c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "326148bdef19c436a2eb07180fc25bc7ecf70058c9cc5c61104a164bef2afdf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f85ed8035add441def60d92992f3b458ad65d1df1b3f1934ae9c5c564e998d4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05aaf983932b5d288145e7c2028b219375246636d0a3f8dbde24d771002352d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1a404f9dde85acab25e040b39f94a1199d01646e78e221f70eeb6ff67548d72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26cba078e1604d3f9a2b3cc26ea99bf42ba62c7e049cf2d46a5ecd05b60a7fc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fed3e579f88263c02ab856dc1fe0c68105d949a328e2b874e804ec3abbf8bfe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b76706cd499da75a46176a5dc3a83c5516e53a11ab18e28a2c82e806b2b15204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e87c3d8c9c63d0f0caee3e5650132a334ca1a70ac6d6fa41675750797d9ecb6e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a5c304e2cf0a67eb5601f2ae7049a1289c7aa8a867df2bb58ba7121f845ef3ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "64bdb88f558231e706b9eec9179cdf4d022139af2085a169aac2639023562d7f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "af0cb612d62934c3c22c456cbdc4c33c9f11092bc41321eaf25790cadc64a4da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0c79ec3f4b05788af4c21a84e8e27ac0d3fae8b46b1299a3a364aaa4f61b6c6c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d6d2064ddbbd48570b44bad5d7aaf7698dbf8fb89ed5b535724bb387615e950", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40118": { @@ -344669,7 +353826,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40118", "family_id": "terrain-40115-40124", "job_id": "terrain-40115-40124", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -344685,6 +353842,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/candidate.json", "sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eea8c9dace9deb784646fb82f50ab21c3a97bb8e3874d63e1a7d11a1640fb99b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.545085+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"radar\": \"Complete genuine9-cell dish independently located twice in actual checked original Registry mission base:sector_3_wave_4 at row0/col0 and row0/col6. Full assembly1\\u20134 preserves ovoid dish, vertical double rails, horizontal beam, diagonal feed arm pointing lower-left, dark left foot/light right foot, bottom support with red source indicator and down-left ground shadow. All source cell crossings remain continuous; bottom-right40125 comes from second family exact literal crop. Modest facet/rivet/round-hub interpretation is accepted as newly authored detail, with source pose and key landmarks retained.\", \"source_indicator\": \"40124 original single index252 pixel remains exactly1/4/9/16 pixels at scales1/2/3/4. Other new31 tiles have no source dynamic indices, and proposed outputs add none. All compose probes preserve water/fire/single-index palette classes per pixel.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 586d3484558a98a0b48fa2f4b5436af681e85f1a6df6e463b7570c37000d80cc", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40115", + "40116", + "40117", + "40118" + ], + "sha256": "0591a7c752304b489096270b5d2a0b8e621594923b085fdb5a862e14e3225ac2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40119", + "4011a", + "4011b", + "4011c" + ], + "sha256": "da9615e1c2f75e40701c1651cbe53dc38ae7e042b3991938bced6a50e58e9aef", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4011d", + "4011e", + "4011f", + "40120" + ], + "sha256": "8bfbf337ef8847e703c331b872536de05b98948daf471333be9a0a590ff82b3a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40121", + "40122", + "40123", + "40124" + ], + "sha256": "c96258e857361c4996e85dd68a91d7e26c2a38abb1423cb37a519fc57acf3649", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40115-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "81f55f7b76d786bd9967935c30621f87ade4d25286411a022d6d19cda179a87f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db81d7396b38ccfe3207c94073d4215bb5ecae6d7089fc9cd677226977502ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "02ab0db2fad9f9b805b8a0c5e7a6ff1ac21f66aa3d7a129380213f0e56758ff1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc75189e56d6006fa415ed1b26d1543eeee301a623e9a0c745b6d1599ddf6d74", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108de4b5b90a0d4e9a1bb50d2802b500529d0751bd8f74070a31e699b31d02f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bdd322052e50366f686b11ff2dbea2ba169ee86f402bf615b8808ced24674a2e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b50e31f20e6d42025ad8d11862c638418eaa27a95d5972b1e8213070920da03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9a05fef741623c0008ffdd3fbee4357f50f1f43e275f05f65bc115376f952d9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cff578bf5bcc42a48665e288ace0067cf819505acdbb4b4eb47ebab7fce86348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2305e5a91dde4daac3bbcd3753363b1e7873305a8f60bea716ab50a26046eb66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "93e9a2b912ee31c3dbb538e739d5c1deffe2e3ff1b8ff18b01f0cadc8a100769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "157ae2f62916bba51c72138c4f71daceb863256fb4a591c1242f48bef69e7237", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f474433675ca4ca8ac9b25bb470528d9bc6a2f7620873126c204a05d03555553", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a416496d2ffd0ea5e2aac18b4a27c325f79a7c04b43d1b747fc0b24d399749c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9903a18e644f92402afd31b90ff5f33055cf3d8a752204849ac3c557dc90b104", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b849a505d7220afe638b17feb07b28c066a1966166520f4a7b09446c77388f08", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3a12a7d24c56ce771b950fc137295488723b73c8227d5ed092c0a3eac9045b04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d70722dae2e2c470a6ff06d95db19f446c4e5ee188c1811e546e0c28550ae2ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ab755a61b4f29404eae0fc69db6c6daf47f862812c75b8288ddd865594387a8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-original.ppm", + "sha256": "74982df2c178379136049377e64734fc85658e4215b2d0f3add38acd49e92f3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "84bac11cc0d40a51bf48a3dcc84393a2c0a216adde666251fa744b474ac4af6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "451b5925cf64b2d76ce3c1921de3974848fabfda2e215f76830824b31509fa5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c1802cee33337b3ee96e498fb186d08406edc0b9bd76c5ed5770152bee47105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8d6826dbf12e07d533c79794a08c907df51c21a2fc93f7e7e7ec87dee7964a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cacf909ef0797cea2a5528e4466d3463db1c77bbf5a76bcc6434f3e72a6ca51e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2af9ac17f5e80769dc1cfb402e9da093e313b0c072e09abe78a5015e7d16c4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "650f5a9f04911bd5404b60c2de8f406e12cd1f78b45460b342fe3fcee6a625c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "50fad51965e60a64c4f88fdf79f3cb88f582cbcd136a29588c9f19748722c7fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0dc4f45ab5a62e7318c045bcfb77db665c2bce52a4f7d194b3a53693ae83b022", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8efcee76d4ad364bd3665ae090415151348e0ebfce7eaf3f65cad73433bfdbae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4f5536bb63d024365ac1f7cfeb46382ef3c83fa098d573d5a4a3297485c9f105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3c4c28ee1b20ab662d3db1c0d98a6106ead652819998b5197a79363f5a655035", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "48960b86fc04528391963c1bf4eb2cc1372b5e6d95cdb59240504fd794cefb2c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7de3b05cef98dffe4cf7c1eb08ed7048f7291485875d95c43644d3575f2a7464", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250cf8c478790b5eb9ff2cf7cec80e420a6c95506f747ed2da71600951cdff42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "578259c1668e3ba3a9c05d8260f2e3fe8c53ac245211b706edf15694483fa2bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "056c806b021a80b965a8e9d9454ccbe44517abb57c3fdcac35a449c3a928794e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "adef5a9dd838fb78f921d8e1f73adbee19fa0720efc24f949260d3aba6cf0782", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a2dcc700b719f25fac3e69d7943ee7716112e2f2fc7d4a58224778a4bf79bb31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de1f27549ff452e116aacff012b18655c3fbe46642da5502d3c03f80dbb35825", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cad580274feb2c96666516169ea6491ca23436ca351fffc0a6cfa22fedb7ab85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6a4a4cb3192dea3c54995948f985fc0433c5d2d8bc4e189656406dffa0da575", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b1ea0593f03a28049fdd749f01302955562c0c7fa74f626ed990443c04e5a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b58259013db82b50398ab16bfb8f96654f858a96b23f7a381a977a845314e2d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4881eabaa4994249c0b2b675e55437c0f35d7794ba403fb617252016a571a012", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1854fabf39cc4522d771c076e69a428e14c37dcf035967da354aeb3815ed19fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "effe172b2a5e805f2e044420120e42fda45a359341ffd221a67b037517a7a9f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "582ab949c8eeca6ed80e96f78fec992b9d71fda17ebc4eaccc265c948b4606c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "730c1daf6de9b496850fd42556323d38a542ecf6c01833b9eef1369db8863ad8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "789cc80d4fd3714071537c958d4ef807e6ad23f1ea64da549c4a39a14cf4898f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "781ef1854ab07423ba4bf0ab3e7ee925cb58d0c5f8344d0df3c93e88a4741896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26c6a4a506895b59affff539c1f0e578571db2b6001df8fe9872d601f6d95829", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82a7963c214eb0dd3b2f180e0df7aa044db2882bf5d3d8bfe230341684fe5856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5e16ec3be0f2ccc7c28e95bddcb79757ac2c4d776d078d2b104f9a197a5b9aa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "185bbd6ca8d00a5fe097cb38366344da24853ba5905f8cca78434cfa35d19f98", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a4d9574ad43cdee2244bea882a02b480e3039a50c96fc156d81ca10cb472649e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e7bbaf31fbf98e083b5855d1624b323c8e5cde929cb13c0dd971988ac1e34d46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5384ce41d9b99477ffc601954064f8e92aaacbfaa8e04a40b933c1d1139101d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "75f0fa97b7fdb2b56811cb6ca967864a0da344111db9127e346ddd3b726b00af", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9cc70ce409af7feaf4cd45178775e9d267eff8775f6d7e43e168c89dd3ab4347", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "17a90d4602d94ce73604588843eacbfbe2e8636c1fcc0c8aaea293f0dca18c28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d89e7c1b41f23bf421e0cd0d2970f39e94e15972809cd5da09ccbf9c97b105d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1ec5e09d42b79ac2dd22915d37027fdae9e02ef9abb74340314eda4c65e47ce3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dbee004989c2b9caa4394e2039b054d2ba9df4af40b2be962f36d6b6b78ee3be", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "aec387334e29e8b1f8013a357e5d4ec6d8922c3dbe9099e63961769c0ca84939", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d21d6933bd94eb169fa629389643ef375cb72739f19e1cc81d11cecbb59ee20", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "253c832e1f4f69b79c5c1f7e02986cf81d47b20647c832828f8ac561a7b797c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "326148bdef19c436a2eb07180fc25bc7ecf70058c9cc5c61104a164bef2afdf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f85ed8035add441def60d92992f3b458ad65d1df1b3f1934ae9c5c564e998d4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05aaf983932b5d288145e7c2028b219375246636d0a3f8dbde24d771002352d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1a404f9dde85acab25e040b39f94a1199d01646e78e221f70eeb6ff67548d72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26cba078e1604d3f9a2b3cc26ea99bf42ba62c7e049cf2d46a5ecd05b60a7fc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fed3e579f88263c02ab856dc1fe0c68105d949a328e2b874e804ec3abbf8bfe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b76706cd499da75a46176a5dc3a83c5516e53a11ab18e28a2c82e806b2b15204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e87c3d8c9c63d0f0caee3e5650132a334ca1a70ac6d6fa41675750797d9ecb6e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a5c304e2cf0a67eb5601f2ae7049a1289c7aa8a867df2bb58ba7121f845ef3ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "64bdb88f558231e706b9eec9179cdf4d022139af2085a169aac2639023562d7f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "af0cb612d62934c3c22c456cbdc4c33c9f11092bc41321eaf25790cadc64a4da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0c79ec3f4b05788af4c21a84e8e27ac0d3fae8b46b1299a3a364aaa4f61b6c6c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d6d2064ddbbd48570b44bad5d7aaf7698dbf8fb89ed5b535724bb387615e950", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40119": { @@ -344706,7 +354333,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40119", "family_id": "terrain-40115-40124", "job_id": "terrain-40115-40124", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -344722,6 +354349,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/candidate.json", "sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eea8c9dace9deb784646fb82f50ab21c3a97bb8e3874d63e1a7d11a1640fb99b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.545085+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"radar\": \"Complete genuine9-cell dish independently located twice in actual checked original Registry mission base:sector_3_wave_4 at row0/col0 and row0/col6. Full assembly1\\u20134 preserves ovoid dish, vertical double rails, horizontal beam, diagonal feed arm pointing lower-left, dark left foot/light right foot, bottom support with red source indicator and down-left ground shadow. All source cell crossings remain continuous; bottom-right40125 comes from second family exact literal crop. Modest facet/rivet/round-hub interpretation is accepted as newly authored detail, with source pose and key landmarks retained.\", \"source_indicator\": \"40124 original single index252 pixel remains exactly1/4/9/16 pixels at scales1/2/3/4. Other new31 tiles have no source dynamic indices, and proposed outputs add none. All compose probes preserve water/fire/single-index palette classes per pixel.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 586d3484558a98a0b48fa2f4b5436af681e85f1a6df6e463b7570c37000d80cc", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40115", + "40116", + "40117", + "40118" + ], + "sha256": "0591a7c752304b489096270b5d2a0b8e621594923b085fdb5a862e14e3225ac2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40119", + "4011a", + "4011b", + "4011c" + ], + "sha256": "da9615e1c2f75e40701c1651cbe53dc38ae7e042b3991938bced6a50e58e9aef", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4011d", + "4011e", + "4011f", + "40120" + ], + "sha256": "8bfbf337ef8847e703c331b872536de05b98948daf471333be9a0a590ff82b3a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40121", + "40122", + "40123", + "40124" + ], + "sha256": "c96258e857361c4996e85dd68a91d7e26c2a38abb1423cb37a519fc57acf3649", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40115-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "81f55f7b76d786bd9967935c30621f87ade4d25286411a022d6d19cda179a87f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db81d7396b38ccfe3207c94073d4215bb5ecae6d7089fc9cd677226977502ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "02ab0db2fad9f9b805b8a0c5e7a6ff1ac21f66aa3d7a129380213f0e56758ff1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc75189e56d6006fa415ed1b26d1543eeee301a623e9a0c745b6d1599ddf6d74", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108de4b5b90a0d4e9a1bb50d2802b500529d0751bd8f74070a31e699b31d02f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bdd322052e50366f686b11ff2dbea2ba169ee86f402bf615b8808ced24674a2e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b50e31f20e6d42025ad8d11862c638418eaa27a95d5972b1e8213070920da03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9a05fef741623c0008ffdd3fbee4357f50f1f43e275f05f65bc115376f952d9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cff578bf5bcc42a48665e288ace0067cf819505acdbb4b4eb47ebab7fce86348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2305e5a91dde4daac3bbcd3753363b1e7873305a8f60bea716ab50a26046eb66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "93e9a2b912ee31c3dbb538e739d5c1deffe2e3ff1b8ff18b01f0cadc8a100769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "157ae2f62916bba51c72138c4f71daceb863256fb4a591c1242f48bef69e7237", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f474433675ca4ca8ac9b25bb470528d9bc6a2f7620873126c204a05d03555553", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a416496d2ffd0ea5e2aac18b4a27c325f79a7c04b43d1b747fc0b24d399749c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9903a18e644f92402afd31b90ff5f33055cf3d8a752204849ac3c557dc90b104", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b849a505d7220afe638b17feb07b28c066a1966166520f4a7b09446c77388f08", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3a12a7d24c56ce771b950fc137295488723b73c8227d5ed092c0a3eac9045b04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d70722dae2e2c470a6ff06d95db19f446c4e5ee188c1811e546e0c28550ae2ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ab755a61b4f29404eae0fc69db6c6daf47f862812c75b8288ddd865594387a8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-original.ppm", + "sha256": "74982df2c178379136049377e64734fc85658e4215b2d0f3add38acd49e92f3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "84bac11cc0d40a51bf48a3dcc84393a2c0a216adde666251fa744b474ac4af6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "451b5925cf64b2d76ce3c1921de3974848fabfda2e215f76830824b31509fa5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c1802cee33337b3ee96e498fb186d08406edc0b9bd76c5ed5770152bee47105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8d6826dbf12e07d533c79794a08c907df51c21a2fc93f7e7e7ec87dee7964a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cacf909ef0797cea2a5528e4466d3463db1c77bbf5a76bcc6434f3e72a6ca51e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2af9ac17f5e80769dc1cfb402e9da093e313b0c072e09abe78a5015e7d16c4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "650f5a9f04911bd5404b60c2de8f406e12cd1f78b45460b342fe3fcee6a625c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "50fad51965e60a64c4f88fdf79f3cb88f582cbcd136a29588c9f19748722c7fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0dc4f45ab5a62e7318c045bcfb77db665c2bce52a4f7d194b3a53693ae83b022", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8efcee76d4ad364bd3665ae090415151348e0ebfce7eaf3f65cad73433bfdbae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4f5536bb63d024365ac1f7cfeb46382ef3c83fa098d573d5a4a3297485c9f105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3c4c28ee1b20ab662d3db1c0d98a6106ead652819998b5197a79363f5a655035", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "48960b86fc04528391963c1bf4eb2cc1372b5e6d95cdb59240504fd794cefb2c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7de3b05cef98dffe4cf7c1eb08ed7048f7291485875d95c43644d3575f2a7464", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250cf8c478790b5eb9ff2cf7cec80e420a6c95506f747ed2da71600951cdff42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "578259c1668e3ba3a9c05d8260f2e3fe8c53ac245211b706edf15694483fa2bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "056c806b021a80b965a8e9d9454ccbe44517abb57c3fdcac35a449c3a928794e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "adef5a9dd838fb78f921d8e1f73adbee19fa0720efc24f949260d3aba6cf0782", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a2dcc700b719f25fac3e69d7943ee7716112e2f2fc7d4a58224778a4bf79bb31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de1f27549ff452e116aacff012b18655c3fbe46642da5502d3c03f80dbb35825", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cad580274feb2c96666516169ea6491ca23436ca351fffc0a6cfa22fedb7ab85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6a4a4cb3192dea3c54995948f985fc0433c5d2d8bc4e189656406dffa0da575", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b1ea0593f03a28049fdd749f01302955562c0c7fa74f626ed990443c04e5a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b58259013db82b50398ab16bfb8f96654f858a96b23f7a381a977a845314e2d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4881eabaa4994249c0b2b675e55437c0f35d7794ba403fb617252016a571a012", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1854fabf39cc4522d771c076e69a428e14c37dcf035967da354aeb3815ed19fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "effe172b2a5e805f2e044420120e42fda45a359341ffd221a67b037517a7a9f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "582ab949c8eeca6ed80e96f78fec992b9d71fda17ebc4eaccc265c948b4606c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "730c1daf6de9b496850fd42556323d38a542ecf6c01833b9eef1369db8863ad8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "789cc80d4fd3714071537c958d4ef807e6ad23f1ea64da549c4a39a14cf4898f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "781ef1854ab07423ba4bf0ab3e7ee925cb58d0c5f8344d0df3c93e88a4741896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26c6a4a506895b59affff539c1f0e578571db2b6001df8fe9872d601f6d95829", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82a7963c214eb0dd3b2f180e0df7aa044db2882bf5d3d8bfe230341684fe5856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5e16ec3be0f2ccc7c28e95bddcb79757ac2c4d776d078d2b104f9a197a5b9aa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "185bbd6ca8d00a5fe097cb38366344da24853ba5905f8cca78434cfa35d19f98", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a4d9574ad43cdee2244bea882a02b480e3039a50c96fc156d81ca10cb472649e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e7bbaf31fbf98e083b5855d1624b323c8e5cde929cb13c0dd971988ac1e34d46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5384ce41d9b99477ffc601954064f8e92aaacbfaa8e04a40b933c1d1139101d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "75f0fa97b7fdb2b56811cb6ca967864a0da344111db9127e346ddd3b726b00af", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9cc70ce409af7feaf4cd45178775e9d267eff8775f6d7e43e168c89dd3ab4347", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "17a90d4602d94ce73604588843eacbfbe2e8636c1fcc0c8aaea293f0dca18c28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d89e7c1b41f23bf421e0cd0d2970f39e94e15972809cd5da09ccbf9c97b105d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1ec5e09d42b79ac2dd22915d37027fdae9e02ef9abb74340314eda4c65e47ce3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dbee004989c2b9caa4394e2039b054d2ba9df4af40b2be962f36d6b6b78ee3be", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "aec387334e29e8b1f8013a357e5d4ec6d8922c3dbe9099e63961769c0ca84939", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d21d6933bd94eb169fa629389643ef375cb72739f19e1cc81d11cecbb59ee20", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "253c832e1f4f69b79c5c1f7e02986cf81d47b20647c832828f8ac561a7b797c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "326148bdef19c436a2eb07180fc25bc7ecf70058c9cc5c61104a164bef2afdf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f85ed8035add441def60d92992f3b458ad65d1df1b3f1934ae9c5c564e998d4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05aaf983932b5d288145e7c2028b219375246636d0a3f8dbde24d771002352d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1a404f9dde85acab25e040b39f94a1199d01646e78e221f70eeb6ff67548d72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26cba078e1604d3f9a2b3cc26ea99bf42ba62c7e049cf2d46a5ecd05b60a7fc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fed3e579f88263c02ab856dc1fe0c68105d949a328e2b874e804ec3abbf8bfe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b76706cd499da75a46176a5dc3a83c5516e53a11ab18e28a2c82e806b2b15204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e87c3d8c9c63d0f0caee3e5650132a334ca1a70ac6d6fa41675750797d9ecb6e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a5c304e2cf0a67eb5601f2ae7049a1289c7aa8a867df2bb58ba7121f845ef3ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "64bdb88f558231e706b9eec9179cdf4d022139af2085a169aac2639023562d7f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "af0cb612d62934c3c22c456cbdc4c33c9f11092bc41321eaf25790cadc64a4da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0c79ec3f4b05788af4c21a84e8e27ac0d3fae8b46b1299a3a364aaa4f61b6c6c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d6d2064ddbbd48570b44bad5d7aaf7698dbf8fb89ed5b535724bb387615e950", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4011a": { @@ -344743,7 +354840,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4011a", "family_id": "terrain-40115-40124", "job_id": "terrain-40115-40124", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -344759,6 +354856,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/candidate.json", "sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eea8c9dace9deb784646fb82f50ab21c3a97bb8e3874d63e1a7d11a1640fb99b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.545085+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"radar\": \"Complete genuine9-cell dish independently located twice in actual checked original Registry mission base:sector_3_wave_4 at row0/col0 and row0/col6. Full assembly1\\u20134 preserves ovoid dish, vertical double rails, horizontal beam, diagonal feed arm pointing lower-left, dark left foot/light right foot, bottom support with red source indicator and down-left ground shadow. All source cell crossings remain continuous; bottom-right40125 comes from second family exact literal crop. Modest facet/rivet/round-hub interpretation is accepted as newly authored detail, with source pose and key landmarks retained.\", \"source_indicator\": \"40124 original single index252 pixel remains exactly1/4/9/16 pixels at scales1/2/3/4. Other new31 tiles have no source dynamic indices, and proposed outputs add none. All compose probes preserve water/fire/single-index palette classes per pixel.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 586d3484558a98a0b48fa2f4b5436af681e85f1a6df6e463b7570c37000d80cc", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40115", + "40116", + "40117", + "40118" + ], + "sha256": "0591a7c752304b489096270b5d2a0b8e621594923b085fdb5a862e14e3225ac2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40119", + "4011a", + "4011b", + "4011c" + ], + "sha256": "da9615e1c2f75e40701c1651cbe53dc38ae7e042b3991938bced6a50e58e9aef", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4011d", + "4011e", + "4011f", + "40120" + ], + "sha256": "8bfbf337ef8847e703c331b872536de05b98948daf471333be9a0a590ff82b3a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40121", + "40122", + "40123", + "40124" + ], + "sha256": "c96258e857361c4996e85dd68a91d7e26c2a38abb1423cb37a519fc57acf3649", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40115-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "81f55f7b76d786bd9967935c30621f87ade4d25286411a022d6d19cda179a87f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db81d7396b38ccfe3207c94073d4215bb5ecae6d7089fc9cd677226977502ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "02ab0db2fad9f9b805b8a0c5e7a6ff1ac21f66aa3d7a129380213f0e56758ff1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc75189e56d6006fa415ed1b26d1543eeee301a623e9a0c745b6d1599ddf6d74", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108de4b5b90a0d4e9a1bb50d2802b500529d0751bd8f74070a31e699b31d02f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bdd322052e50366f686b11ff2dbea2ba169ee86f402bf615b8808ced24674a2e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b50e31f20e6d42025ad8d11862c638418eaa27a95d5972b1e8213070920da03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9a05fef741623c0008ffdd3fbee4357f50f1f43e275f05f65bc115376f952d9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cff578bf5bcc42a48665e288ace0067cf819505acdbb4b4eb47ebab7fce86348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2305e5a91dde4daac3bbcd3753363b1e7873305a8f60bea716ab50a26046eb66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "93e9a2b912ee31c3dbb538e739d5c1deffe2e3ff1b8ff18b01f0cadc8a100769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "157ae2f62916bba51c72138c4f71daceb863256fb4a591c1242f48bef69e7237", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f474433675ca4ca8ac9b25bb470528d9bc6a2f7620873126c204a05d03555553", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a416496d2ffd0ea5e2aac18b4a27c325f79a7c04b43d1b747fc0b24d399749c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9903a18e644f92402afd31b90ff5f33055cf3d8a752204849ac3c557dc90b104", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b849a505d7220afe638b17feb07b28c066a1966166520f4a7b09446c77388f08", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3a12a7d24c56ce771b950fc137295488723b73c8227d5ed092c0a3eac9045b04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d70722dae2e2c470a6ff06d95db19f446c4e5ee188c1811e546e0c28550ae2ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ab755a61b4f29404eae0fc69db6c6daf47f862812c75b8288ddd865594387a8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-original.ppm", + "sha256": "74982df2c178379136049377e64734fc85658e4215b2d0f3add38acd49e92f3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "84bac11cc0d40a51bf48a3dcc84393a2c0a216adde666251fa744b474ac4af6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "451b5925cf64b2d76ce3c1921de3974848fabfda2e215f76830824b31509fa5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c1802cee33337b3ee96e498fb186d08406edc0b9bd76c5ed5770152bee47105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8d6826dbf12e07d533c79794a08c907df51c21a2fc93f7e7e7ec87dee7964a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cacf909ef0797cea2a5528e4466d3463db1c77bbf5a76bcc6434f3e72a6ca51e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2af9ac17f5e80769dc1cfb402e9da093e313b0c072e09abe78a5015e7d16c4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "650f5a9f04911bd5404b60c2de8f406e12cd1f78b45460b342fe3fcee6a625c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "50fad51965e60a64c4f88fdf79f3cb88f582cbcd136a29588c9f19748722c7fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0dc4f45ab5a62e7318c045bcfb77db665c2bce52a4f7d194b3a53693ae83b022", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8efcee76d4ad364bd3665ae090415151348e0ebfce7eaf3f65cad73433bfdbae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4f5536bb63d024365ac1f7cfeb46382ef3c83fa098d573d5a4a3297485c9f105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3c4c28ee1b20ab662d3db1c0d98a6106ead652819998b5197a79363f5a655035", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "48960b86fc04528391963c1bf4eb2cc1372b5e6d95cdb59240504fd794cefb2c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7de3b05cef98dffe4cf7c1eb08ed7048f7291485875d95c43644d3575f2a7464", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250cf8c478790b5eb9ff2cf7cec80e420a6c95506f747ed2da71600951cdff42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "578259c1668e3ba3a9c05d8260f2e3fe8c53ac245211b706edf15694483fa2bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "056c806b021a80b965a8e9d9454ccbe44517abb57c3fdcac35a449c3a928794e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "adef5a9dd838fb78f921d8e1f73adbee19fa0720efc24f949260d3aba6cf0782", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a2dcc700b719f25fac3e69d7943ee7716112e2f2fc7d4a58224778a4bf79bb31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de1f27549ff452e116aacff012b18655c3fbe46642da5502d3c03f80dbb35825", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cad580274feb2c96666516169ea6491ca23436ca351fffc0a6cfa22fedb7ab85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6a4a4cb3192dea3c54995948f985fc0433c5d2d8bc4e189656406dffa0da575", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b1ea0593f03a28049fdd749f01302955562c0c7fa74f626ed990443c04e5a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b58259013db82b50398ab16bfb8f96654f858a96b23f7a381a977a845314e2d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4881eabaa4994249c0b2b675e55437c0f35d7794ba403fb617252016a571a012", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1854fabf39cc4522d771c076e69a428e14c37dcf035967da354aeb3815ed19fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "effe172b2a5e805f2e044420120e42fda45a359341ffd221a67b037517a7a9f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "582ab949c8eeca6ed80e96f78fec992b9d71fda17ebc4eaccc265c948b4606c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "730c1daf6de9b496850fd42556323d38a542ecf6c01833b9eef1369db8863ad8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "789cc80d4fd3714071537c958d4ef807e6ad23f1ea64da549c4a39a14cf4898f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "781ef1854ab07423ba4bf0ab3e7ee925cb58d0c5f8344d0df3c93e88a4741896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26c6a4a506895b59affff539c1f0e578571db2b6001df8fe9872d601f6d95829", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82a7963c214eb0dd3b2f180e0df7aa044db2882bf5d3d8bfe230341684fe5856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5e16ec3be0f2ccc7c28e95bddcb79757ac2c4d776d078d2b104f9a197a5b9aa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "185bbd6ca8d00a5fe097cb38366344da24853ba5905f8cca78434cfa35d19f98", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a4d9574ad43cdee2244bea882a02b480e3039a50c96fc156d81ca10cb472649e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e7bbaf31fbf98e083b5855d1624b323c8e5cde929cb13c0dd971988ac1e34d46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5384ce41d9b99477ffc601954064f8e92aaacbfaa8e04a40b933c1d1139101d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "75f0fa97b7fdb2b56811cb6ca967864a0da344111db9127e346ddd3b726b00af", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9cc70ce409af7feaf4cd45178775e9d267eff8775f6d7e43e168c89dd3ab4347", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "17a90d4602d94ce73604588843eacbfbe2e8636c1fcc0c8aaea293f0dca18c28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d89e7c1b41f23bf421e0cd0d2970f39e94e15972809cd5da09ccbf9c97b105d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1ec5e09d42b79ac2dd22915d37027fdae9e02ef9abb74340314eda4c65e47ce3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dbee004989c2b9caa4394e2039b054d2ba9df4af40b2be962f36d6b6b78ee3be", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "aec387334e29e8b1f8013a357e5d4ec6d8922c3dbe9099e63961769c0ca84939", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d21d6933bd94eb169fa629389643ef375cb72739f19e1cc81d11cecbb59ee20", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "253c832e1f4f69b79c5c1f7e02986cf81d47b20647c832828f8ac561a7b797c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "326148bdef19c436a2eb07180fc25bc7ecf70058c9cc5c61104a164bef2afdf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f85ed8035add441def60d92992f3b458ad65d1df1b3f1934ae9c5c564e998d4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05aaf983932b5d288145e7c2028b219375246636d0a3f8dbde24d771002352d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1a404f9dde85acab25e040b39f94a1199d01646e78e221f70eeb6ff67548d72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26cba078e1604d3f9a2b3cc26ea99bf42ba62c7e049cf2d46a5ecd05b60a7fc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fed3e579f88263c02ab856dc1fe0c68105d949a328e2b874e804ec3abbf8bfe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b76706cd499da75a46176a5dc3a83c5516e53a11ab18e28a2c82e806b2b15204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e87c3d8c9c63d0f0caee3e5650132a334ca1a70ac6d6fa41675750797d9ecb6e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a5c304e2cf0a67eb5601f2ae7049a1289c7aa8a867df2bb58ba7121f845ef3ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "64bdb88f558231e706b9eec9179cdf4d022139af2085a169aac2639023562d7f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "af0cb612d62934c3c22c456cbdc4c33c9f11092bc41321eaf25790cadc64a4da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0c79ec3f4b05788af4c21a84e8e27ac0d3fae8b46b1299a3a364aaa4f61b6c6c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d6d2064ddbbd48570b44bad5d7aaf7698dbf8fb89ed5b535724bb387615e950", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4011b": { @@ -344780,7 +355347,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4011b", "family_id": "terrain-40115-40124", "job_id": "terrain-40115-40124", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -344796,6 +355363,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/candidate.json", "sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eea8c9dace9deb784646fb82f50ab21c3a97bb8e3874d63e1a7d11a1640fb99b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.545085+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"radar\": \"Complete genuine9-cell dish independently located twice in actual checked original Registry mission base:sector_3_wave_4 at row0/col0 and row0/col6. Full assembly1\\u20134 preserves ovoid dish, vertical double rails, horizontal beam, diagonal feed arm pointing lower-left, dark left foot/light right foot, bottom support with red source indicator and down-left ground shadow. All source cell crossings remain continuous; bottom-right40125 comes from second family exact literal crop. Modest facet/rivet/round-hub interpretation is accepted as newly authored detail, with source pose and key landmarks retained.\", \"source_indicator\": \"40124 original single index252 pixel remains exactly1/4/9/16 pixels at scales1/2/3/4. Other new31 tiles have no source dynamic indices, and proposed outputs add none. All compose probes preserve water/fire/single-index palette classes per pixel.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 586d3484558a98a0b48fa2f4b5436af681e85f1a6df6e463b7570c37000d80cc", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40115", + "40116", + "40117", + "40118" + ], + "sha256": "0591a7c752304b489096270b5d2a0b8e621594923b085fdb5a862e14e3225ac2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40119", + "4011a", + "4011b", + "4011c" + ], + "sha256": "da9615e1c2f75e40701c1651cbe53dc38ae7e042b3991938bced6a50e58e9aef", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4011d", + "4011e", + "4011f", + "40120" + ], + "sha256": "8bfbf337ef8847e703c331b872536de05b98948daf471333be9a0a590ff82b3a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40121", + "40122", + "40123", + "40124" + ], + "sha256": "c96258e857361c4996e85dd68a91d7e26c2a38abb1423cb37a519fc57acf3649", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40115-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "81f55f7b76d786bd9967935c30621f87ade4d25286411a022d6d19cda179a87f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db81d7396b38ccfe3207c94073d4215bb5ecae6d7089fc9cd677226977502ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "02ab0db2fad9f9b805b8a0c5e7a6ff1ac21f66aa3d7a129380213f0e56758ff1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc75189e56d6006fa415ed1b26d1543eeee301a623e9a0c745b6d1599ddf6d74", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108de4b5b90a0d4e9a1bb50d2802b500529d0751bd8f74070a31e699b31d02f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bdd322052e50366f686b11ff2dbea2ba169ee86f402bf615b8808ced24674a2e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b50e31f20e6d42025ad8d11862c638418eaa27a95d5972b1e8213070920da03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9a05fef741623c0008ffdd3fbee4357f50f1f43e275f05f65bc115376f952d9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cff578bf5bcc42a48665e288ace0067cf819505acdbb4b4eb47ebab7fce86348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2305e5a91dde4daac3bbcd3753363b1e7873305a8f60bea716ab50a26046eb66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "93e9a2b912ee31c3dbb538e739d5c1deffe2e3ff1b8ff18b01f0cadc8a100769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "157ae2f62916bba51c72138c4f71daceb863256fb4a591c1242f48bef69e7237", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f474433675ca4ca8ac9b25bb470528d9bc6a2f7620873126c204a05d03555553", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a416496d2ffd0ea5e2aac18b4a27c325f79a7c04b43d1b747fc0b24d399749c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9903a18e644f92402afd31b90ff5f33055cf3d8a752204849ac3c557dc90b104", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b849a505d7220afe638b17feb07b28c066a1966166520f4a7b09446c77388f08", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3a12a7d24c56ce771b950fc137295488723b73c8227d5ed092c0a3eac9045b04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d70722dae2e2c470a6ff06d95db19f446c4e5ee188c1811e546e0c28550ae2ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ab755a61b4f29404eae0fc69db6c6daf47f862812c75b8288ddd865594387a8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-original.ppm", + "sha256": "74982df2c178379136049377e64734fc85658e4215b2d0f3add38acd49e92f3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "84bac11cc0d40a51bf48a3dcc84393a2c0a216adde666251fa744b474ac4af6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "451b5925cf64b2d76ce3c1921de3974848fabfda2e215f76830824b31509fa5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c1802cee33337b3ee96e498fb186d08406edc0b9bd76c5ed5770152bee47105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8d6826dbf12e07d533c79794a08c907df51c21a2fc93f7e7e7ec87dee7964a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cacf909ef0797cea2a5528e4466d3463db1c77bbf5a76bcc6434f3e72a6ca51e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2af9ac17f5e80769dc1cfb402e9da093e313b0c072e09abe78a5015e7d16c4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "650f5a9f04911bd5404b60c2de8f406e12cd1f78b45460b342fe3fcee6a625c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "50fad51965e60a64c4f88fdf79f3cb88f582cbcd136a29588c9f19748722c7fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0dc4f45ab5a62e7318c045bcfb77db665c2bce52a4f7d194b3a53693ae83b022", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8efcee76d4ad364bd3665ae090415151348e0ebfce7eaf3f65cad73433bfdbae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4f5536bb63d024365ac1f7cfeb46382ef3c83fa098d573d5a4a3297485c9f105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3c4c28ee1b20ab662d3db1c0d98a6106ead652819998b5197a79363f5a655035", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "48960b86fc04528391963c1bf4eb2cc1372b5e6d95cdb59240504fd794cefb2c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7de3b05cef98dffe4cf7c1eb08ed7048f7291485875d95c43644d3575f2a7464", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250cf8c478790b5eb9ff2cf7cec80e420a6c95506f747ed2da71600951cdff42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "578259c1668e3ba3a9c05d8260f2e3fe8c53ac245211b706edf15694483fa2bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "056c806b021a80b965a8e9d9454ccbe44517abb57c3fdcac35a449c3a928794e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "adef5a9dd838fb78f921d8e1f73adbee19fa0720efc24f949260d3aba6cf0782", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a2dcc700b719f25fac3e69d7943ee7716112e2f2fc7d4a58224778a4bf79bb31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de1f27549ff452e116aacff012b18655c3fbe46642da5502d3c03f80dbb35825", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cad580274feb2c96666516169ea6491ca23436ca351fffc0a6cfa22fedb7ab85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6a4a4cb3192dea3c54995948f985fc0433c5d2d8bc4e189656406dffa0da575", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b1ea0593f03a28049fdd749f01302955562c0c7fa74f626ed990443c04e5a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b58259013db82b50398ab16bfb8f96654f858a96b23f7a381a977a845314e2d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4881eabaa4994249c0b2b675e55437c0f35d7794ba403fb617252016a571a012", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1854fabf39cc4522d771c076e69a428e14c37dcf035967da354aeb3815ed19fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "effe172b2a5e805f2e044420120e42fda45a359341ffd221a67b037517a7a9f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "582ab949c8eeca6ed80e96f78fec992b9d71fda17ebc4eaccc265c948b4606c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "730c1daf6de9b496850fd42556323d38a542ecf6c01833b9eef1369db8863ad8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "789cc80d4fd3714071537c958d4ef807e6ad23f1ea64da549c4a39a14cf4898f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "781ef1854ab07423ba4bf0ab3e7ee925cb58d0c5f8344d0df3c93e88a4741896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26c6a4a506895b59affff539c1f0e578571db2b6001df8fe9872d601f6d95829", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82a7963c214eb0dd3b2f180e0df7aa044db2882bf5d3d8bfe230341684fe5856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5e16ec3be0f2ccc7c28e95bddcb79757ac2c4d776d078d2b104f9a197a5b9aa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "185bbd6ca8d00a5fe097cb38366344da24853ba5905f8cca78434cfa35d19f98", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a4d9574ad43cdee2244bea882a02b480e3039a50c96fc156d81ca10cb472649e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e7bbaf31fbf98e083b5855d1624b323c8e5cde929cb13c0dd971988ac1e34d46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5384ce41d9b99477ffc601954064f8e92aaacbfaa8e04a40b933c1d1139101d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "75f0fa97b7fdb2b56811cb6ca967864a0da344111db9127e346ddd3b726b00af", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9cc70ce409af7feaf4cd45178775e9d267eff8775f6d7e43e168c89dd3ab4347", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "17a90d4602d94ce73604588843eacbfbe2e8636c1fcc0c8aaea293f0dca18c28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d89e7c1b41f23bf421e0cd0d2970f39e94e15972809cd5da09ccbf9c97b105d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1ec5e09d42b79ac2dd22915d37027fdae9e02ef9abb74340314eda4c65e47ce3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dbee004989c2b9caa4394e2039b054d2ba9df4af40b2be962f36d6b6b78ee3be", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "aec387334e29e8b1f8013a357e5d4ec6d8922c3dbe9099e63961769c0ca84939", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d21d6933bd94eb169fa629389643ef375cb72739f19e1cc81d11cecbb59ee20", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "253c832e1f4f69b79c5c1f7e02986cf81d47b20647c832828f8ac561a7b797c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "326148bdef19c436a2eb07180fc25bc7ecf70058c9cc5c61104a164bef2afdf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f85ed8035add441def60d92992f3b458ad65d1df1b3f1934ae9c5c564e998d4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05aaf983932b5d288145e7c2028b219375246636d0a3f8dbde24d771002352d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1a404f9dde85acab25e040b39f94a1199d01646e78e221f70eeb6ff67548d72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26cba078e1604d3f9a2b3cc26ea99bf42ba62c7e049cf2d46a5ecd05b60a7fc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fed3e579f88263c02ab856dc1fe0c68105d949a328e2b874e804ec3abbf8bfe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b76706cd499da75a46176a5dc3a83c5516e53a11ab18e28a2c82e806b2b15204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e87c3d8c9c63d0f0caee3e5650132a334ca1a70ac6d6fa41675750797d9ecb6e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a5c304e2cf0a67eb5601f2ae7049a1289c7aa8a867df2bb58ba7121f845ef3ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "64bdb88f558231e706b9eec9179cdf4d022139af2085a169aac2639023562d7f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "af0cb612d62934c3c22c456cbdc4c33c9f11092bc41321eaf25790cadc64a4da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0c79ec3f4b05788af4c21a84e8e27ac0d3fae8b46b1299a3a364aaa4f61b6c6c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d6d2064ddbbd48570b44bad5d7aaf7698dbf8fb89ed5b535724bb387615e950", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4011c": { @@ -344817,7 +355854,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4011c", "family_id": "terrain-40115-40124", "job_id": "terrain-40115-40124", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -344833,6 +355870,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/candidate.json", "sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eea8c9dace9deb784646fb82f50ab21c3a97bb8e3874d63e1a7d11a1640fb99b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.545085+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"radar\": \"Complete genuine9-cell dish independently located twice in actual checked original Registry mission base:sector_3_wave_4 at row0/col0 and row0/col6. Full assembly1\\u20134 preserves ovoid dish, vertical double rails, horizontal beam, diagonal feed arm pointing lower-left, dark left foot/light right foot, bottom support with red source indicator and down-left ground shadow. All source cell crossings remain continuous; bottom-right40125 comes from second family exact literal crop. Modest facet/rivet/round-hub interpretation is accepted as newly authored detail, with source pose and key landmarks retained.\", \"source_indicator\": \"40124 original single index252 pixel remains exactly1/4/9/16 pixels at scales1/2/3/4. Other new31 tiles have no source dynamic indices, and proposed outputs add none. All compose probes preserve water/fire/single-index palette classes per pixel.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 586d3484558a98a0b48fa2f4b5436af681e85f1a6df6e463b7570c37000d80cc", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40115", + "40116", + "40117", + "40118" + ], + "sha256": "0591a7c752304b489096270b5d2a0b8e621594923b085fdb5a862e14e3225ac2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40119", + "4011a", + "4011b", + "4011c" + ], + "sha256": "da9615e1c2f75e40701c1651cbe53dc38ae7e042b3991938bced6a50e58e9aef", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4011d", + "4011e", + "4011f", + "40120" + ], + "sha256": "8bfbf337ef8847e703c331b872536de05b98948daf471333be9a0a590ff82b3a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40121", + "40122", + "40123", + "40124" + ], + "sha256": "c96258e857361c4996e85dd68a91d7e26c2a38abb1423cb37a519fc57acf3649", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40115-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "81f55f7b76d786bd9967935c30621f87ade4d25286411a022d6d19cda179a87f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db81d7396b38ccfe3207c94073d4215bb5ecae6d7089fc9cd677226977502ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "02ab0db2fad9f9b805b8a0c5e7a6ff1ac21f66aa3d7a129380213f0e56758ff1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc75189e56d6006fa415ed1b26d1543eeee301a623e9a0c745b6d1599ddf6d74", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108de4b5b90a0d4e9a1bb50d2802b500529d0751bd8f74070a31e699b31d02f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bdd322052e50366f686b11ff2dbea2ba169ee86f402bf615b8808ced24674a2e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b50e31f20e6d42025ad8d11862c638418eaa27a95d5972b1e8213070920da03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9a05fef741623c0008ffdd3fbee4357f50f1f43e275f05f65bc115376f952d9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cff578bf5bcc42a48665e288ace0067cf819505acdbb4b4eb47ebab7fce86348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2305e5a91dde4daac3bbcd3753363b1e7873305a8f60bea716ab50a26046eb66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "93e9a2b912ee31c3dbb538e739d5c1deffe2e3ff1b8ff18b01f0cadc8a100769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "157ae2f62916bba51c72138c4f71daceb863256fb4a591c1242f48bef69e7237", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f474433675ca4ca8ac9b25bb470528d9bc6a2f7620873126c204a05d03555553", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a416496d2ffd0ea5e2aac18b4a27c325f79a7c04b43d1b747fc0b24d399749c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9903a18e644f92402afd31b90ff5f33055cf3d8a752204849ac3c557dc90b104", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b849a505d7220afe638b17feb07b28c066a1966166520f4a7b09446c77388f08", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3a12a7d24c56ce771b950fc137295488723b73c8227d5ed092c0a3eac9045b04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d70722dae2e2c470a6ff06d95db19f446c4e5ee188c1811e546e0c28550ae2ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ab755a61b4f29404eae0fc69db6c6daf47f862812c75b8288ddd865594387a8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-original.ppm", + "sha256": "74982df2c178379136049377e64734fc85658e4215b2d0f3add38acd49e92f3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "84bac11cc0d40a51bf48a3dcc84393a2c0a216adde666251fa744b474ac4af6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "451b5925cf64b2d76ce3c1921de3974848fabfda2e215f76830824b31509fa5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c1802cee33337b3ee96e498fb186d08406edc0b9bd76c5ed5770152bee47105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8d6826dbf12e07d533c79794a08c907df51c21a2fc93f7e7e7ec87dee7964a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cacf909ef0797cea2a5528e4466d3463db1c77bbf5a76bcc6434f3e72a6ca51e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2af9ac17f5e80769dc1cfb402e9da093e313b0c072e09abe78a5015e7d16c4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "650f5a9f04911bd5404b60c2de8f406e12cd1f78b45460b342fe3fcee6a625c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "50fad51965e60a64c4f88fdf79f3cb88f582cbcd136a29588c9f19748722c7fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0dc4f45ab5a62e7318c045bcfb77db665c2bce52a4f7d194b3a53693ae83b022", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8efcee76d4ad364bd3665ae090415151348e0ebfce7eaf3f65cad73433bfdbae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4f5536bb63d024365ac1f7cfeb46382ef3c83fa098d573d5a4a3297485c9f105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3c4c28ee1b20ab662d3db1c0d98a6106ead652819998b5197a79363f5a655035", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "48960b86fc04528391963c1bf4eb2cc1372b5e6d95cdb59240504fd794cefb2c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7de3b05cef98dffe4cf7c1eb08ed7048f7291485875d95c43644d3575f2a7464", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250cf8c478790b5eb9ff2cf7cec80e420a6c95506f747ed2da71600951cdff42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "578259c1668e3ba3a9c05d8260f2e3fe8c53ac245211b706edf15694483fa2bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "056c806b021a80b965a8e9d9454ccbe44517abb57c3fdcac35a449c3a928794e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "adef5a9dd838fb78f921d8e1f73adbee19fa0720efc24f949260d3aba6cf0782", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a2dcc700b719f25fac3e69d7943ee7716112e2f2fc7d4a58224778a4bf79bb31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de1f27549ff452e116aacff012b18655c3fbe46642da5502d3c03f80dbb35825", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cad580274feb2c96666516169ea6491ca23436ca351fffc0a6cfa22fedb7ab85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6a4a4cb3192dea3c54995948f985fc0433c5d2d8bc4e189656406dffa0da575", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b1ea0593f03a28049fdd749f01302955562c0c7fa74f626ed990443c04e5a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b58259013db82b50398ab16bfb8f96654f858a96b23f7a381a977a845314e2d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4881eabaa4994249c0b2b675e55437c0f35d7794ba403fb617252016a571a012", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1854fabf39cc4522d771c076e69a428e14c37dcf035967da354aeb3815ed19fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "effe172b2a5e805f2e044420120e42fda45a359341ffd221a67b037517a7a9f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "582ab949c8eeca6ed80e96f78fec992b9d71fda17ebc4eaccc265c948b4606c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "730c1daf6de9b496850fd42556323d38a542ecf6c01833b9eef1369db8863ad8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "789cc80d4fd3714071537c958d4ef807e6ad23f1ea64da549c4a39a14cf4898f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "781ef1854ab07423ba4bf0ab3e7ee925cb58d0c5f8344d0df3c93e88a4741896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26c6a4a506895b59affff539c1f0e578571db2b6001df8fe9872d601f6d95829", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82a7963c214eb0dd3b2f180e0df7aa044db2882bf5d3d8bfe230341684fe5856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5e16ec3be0f2ccc7c28e95bddcb79757ac2c4d776d078d2b104f9a197a5b9aa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "185bbd6ca8d00a5fe097cb38366344da24853ba5905f8cca78434cfa35d19f98", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a4d9574ad43cdee2244bea882a02b480e3039a50c96fc156d81ca10cb472649e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e7bbaf31fbf98e083b5855d1624b323c8e5cde929cb13c0dd971988ac1e34d46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5384ce41d9b99477ffc601954064f8e92aaacbfaa8e04a40b933c1d1139101d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "75f0fa97b7fdb2b56811cb6ca967864a0da344111db9127e346ddd3b726b00af", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9cc70ce409af7feaf4cd45178775e9d267eff8775f6d7e43e168c89dd3ab4347", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "17a90d4602d94ce73604588843eacbfbe2e8636c1fcc0c8aaea293f0dca18c28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d89e7c1b41f23bf421e0cd0d2970f39e94e15972809cd5da09ccbf9c97b105d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1ec5e09d42b79ac2dd22915d37027fdae9e02ef9abb74340314eda4c65e47ce3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dbee004989c2b9caa4394e2039b054d2ba9df4af40b2be962f36d6b6b78ee3be", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "aec387334e29e8b1f8013a357e5d4ec6d8922c3dbe9099e63961769c0ca84939", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d21d6933bd94eb169fa629389643ef375cb72739f19e1cc81d11cecbb59ee20", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "253c832e1f4f69b79c5c1f7e02986cf81d47b20647c832828f8ac561a7b797c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "326148bdef19c436a2eb07180fc25bc7ecf70058c9cc5c61104a164bef2afdf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f85ed8035add441def60d92992f3b458ad65d1df1b3f1934ae9c5c564e998d4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05aaf983932b5d288145e7c2028b219375246636d0a3f8dbde24d771002352d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1a404f9dde85acab25e040b39f94a1199d01646e78e221f70eeb6ff67548d72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26cba078e1604d3f9a2b3cc26ea99bf42ba62c7e049cf2d46a5ecd05b60a7fc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fed3e579f88263c02ab856dc1fe0c68105d949a328e2b874e804ec3abbf8bfe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b76706cd499da75a46176a5dc3a83c5516e53a11ab18e28a2c82e806b2b15204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e87c3d8c9c63d0f0caee3e5650132a334ca1a70ac6d6fa41675750797d9ecb6e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a5c304e2cf0a67eb5601f2ae7049a1289c7aa8a867df2bb58ba7121f845ef3ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "64bdb88f558231e706b9eec9179cdf4d022139af2085a169aac2639023562d7f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "af0cb612d62934c3c22c456cbdc4c33c9f11092bc41321eaf25790cadc64a4da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0c79ec3f4b05788af4c21a84e8e27ac0d3fae8b46b1299a3a364aaa4f61b6c6c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d6d2064ddbbd48570b44bad5d7aaf7698dbf8fb89ed5b535724bb387615e950", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4011d": { @@ -344854,7 +356361,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4011d", "family_id": "terrain-40115-40124", "job_id": "terrain-40115-40124", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -344870,6 +356377,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/candidate.json", "sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eea8c9dace9deb784646fb82f50ab21c3a97bb8e3874d63e1a7d11a1640fb99b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.545085+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"radar\": \"Complete genuine9-cell dish independently located twice in actual checked original Registry mission base:sector_3_wave_4 at row0/col0 and row0/col6. Full assembly1\\u20134 preserves ovoid dish, vertical double rails, horizontal beam, diagonal feed arm pointing lower-left, dark left foot/light right foot, bottom support with red source indicator and down-left ground shadow. All source cell crossings remain continuous; bottom-right40125 comes from second family exact literal crop. Modest facet/rivet/round-hub interpretation is accepted as newly authored detail, with source pose and key landmarks retained.\", \"source_indicator\": \"40124 original single index252 pixel remains exactly1/4/9/16 pixels at scales1/2/3/4. Other new31 tiles have no source dynamic indices, and proposed outputs add none. All compose probes preserve water/fire/single-index palette classes per pixel.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 586d3484558a98a0b48fa2f4b5436af681e85f1a6df6e463b7570c37000d80cc", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40115", + "40116", + "40117", + "40118" + ], + "sha256": "0591a7c752304b489096270b5d2a0b8e621594923b085fdb5a862e14e3225ac2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40119", + "4011a", + "4011b", + "4011c" + ], + "sha256": "da9615e1c2f75e40701c1651cbe53dc38ae7e042b3991938bced6a50e58e9aef", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4011d", + "4011e", + "4011f", + "40120" + ], + "sha256": "8bfbf337ef8847e703c331b872536de05b98948daf471333be9a0a590ff82b3a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40121", + "40122", + "40123", + "40124" + ], + "sha256": "c96258e857361c4996e85dd68a91d7e26c2a38abb1423cb37a519fc57acf3649", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40115-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "81f55f7b76d786bd9967935c30621f87ade4d25286411a022d6d19cda179a87f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db81d7396b38ccfe3207c94073d4215bb5ecae6d7089fc9cd677226977502ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "02ab0db2fad9f9b805b8a0c5e7a6ff1ac21f66aa3d7a129380213f0e56758ff1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc75189e56d6006fa415ed1b26d1543eeee301a623e9a0c745b6d1599ddf6d74", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108de4b5b90a0d4e9a1bb50d2802b500529d0751bd8f74070a31e699b31d02f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bdd322052e50366f686b11ff2dbea2ba169ee86f402bf615b8808ced24674a2e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b50e31f20e6d42025ad8d11862c638418eaa27a95d5972b1e8213070920da03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9a05fef741623c0008ffdd3fbee4357f50f1f43e275f05f65bc115376f952d9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cff578bf5bcc42a48665e288ace0067cf819505acdbb4b4eb47ebab7fce86348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2305e5a91dde4daac3bbcd3753363b1e7873305a8f60bea716ab50a26046eb66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "93e9a2b912ee31c3dbb538e739d5c1deffe2e3ff1b8ff18b01f0cadc8a100769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "157ae2f62916bba51c72138c4f71daceb863256fb4a591c1242f48bef69e7237", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f474433675ca4ca8ac9b25bb470528d9bc6a2f7620873126c204a05d03555553", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a416496d2ffd0ea5e2aac18b4a27c325f79a7c04b43d1b747fc0b24d399749c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9903a18e644f92402afd31b90ff5f33055cf3d8a752204849ac3c557dc90b104", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b849a505d7220afe638b17feb07b28c066a1966166520f4a7b09446c77388f08", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3a12a7d24c56ce771b950fc137295488723b73c8227d5ed092c0a3eac9045b04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d70722dae2e2c470a6ff06d95db19f446c4e5ee188c1811e546e0c28550ae2ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ab755a61b4f29404eae0fc69db6c6daf47f862812c75b8288ddd865594387a8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-original.ppm", + "sha256": "74982df2c178379136049377e64734fc85658e4215b2d0f3add38acd49e92f3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "84bac11cc0d40a51bf48a3dcc84393a2c0a216adde666251fa744b474ac4af6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "451b5925cf64b2d76ce3c1921de3974848fabfda2e215f76830824b31509fa5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c1802cee33337b3ee96e498fb186d08406edc0b9bd76c5ed5770152bee47105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8d6826dbf12e07d533c79794a08c907df51c21a2fc93f7e7e7ec87dee7964a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cacf909ef0797cea2a5528e4466d3463db1c77bbf5a76bcc6434f3e72a6ca51e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2af9ac17f5e80769dc1cfb402e9da093e313b0c072e09abe78a5015e7d16c4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "650f5a9f04911bd5404b60c2de8f406e12cd1f78b45460b342fe3fcee6a625c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "50fad51965e60a64c4f88fdf79f3cb88f582cbcd136a29588c9f19748722c7fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0dc4f45ab5a62e7318c045bcfb77db665c2bce52a4f7d194b3a53693ae83b022", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8efcee76d4ad364bd3665ae090415151348e0ebfce7eaf3f65cad73433bfdbae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4f5536bb63d024365ac1f7cfeb46382ef3c83fa098d573d5a4a3297485c9f105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3c4c28ee1b20ab662d3db1c0d98a6106ead652819998b5197a79363f5a655035", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "48960b86fc04528391963c1bf4eb2cc1372b5e6d95cdb59240504fd794cefb2c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7de3b05cef98dffe4cf7c1eb08ed7048f7291485875d95c43644d3575f2a7464", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250cf8c478790b5eb9ff2cf7cec80e420a6c95506f747ed2da71600951cdff42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "578259c1668e3ba3a9c05d8260f2e3fe8c53ac245211b706edf15694483fa2bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "056c806b021a80b965a8e9d9454ccbe44517abb57c3fdcac35a449c3a928794e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "adef5a9dd838fb78f921d8e1f73adbee19fa0720efc24f949260d3aba6cf0782", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a2dcc700b719f25fac3e69d7943ee7716112e2f2fc7d4a58224778a4bf79bb31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de1f27549ff452e116aacff012b18655c3fbe46642da5502d3c03f80dbb35825", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cad580274feb2c96666516169ea6491ca23436ca351fffc0a6cfa22fedb7ab85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6a4a4cb3192dea3c54995948f985fc0433c5d2d8bc4e189656406dffa0da575", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b1ea0593f03a28049fdd749f01302955562c0c7fa74f626ed990443c04e5a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b58259013db82b50398ab16bfb8f96654f858a96b23f7a381a977a845314e2d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4881eabaa4994249c0b2b675e55437c0f35d7794ba403fb617252016a571a012", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1854fabf39cc4522d771c076e69a428e14c37dcf035967da354aeb3815ed19fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "effe172b2a5e805f2e044420120e42fda45a359341ffd221a67b037517a7a9f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "582ab949c8eeca6ed80e96f78fec992b9d71fda17ebc4eaccc265c948b4606c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "730c1daf6de9b496850fd42556323d38a542ecf6c01833b9eef1369db8863ad8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "789cc80d4fd3714071537c958d4ef807e6ad23f1ea64da549c4a39a14cf4898f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "781ef1854ab07423ba4bf0ab3e7ee925cb58d0c5f8344d0df3c93e88a4741896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26c6a4a506895b59affff539c1f0e578571db2b6001df8fe9872d601f6d95829", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82a7963c214eb0dd3b2f180e0df7aa044db2882bf5d3d8bfe230341684fe5856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5e16ec3be0f2ccc7c28e95bddcb79757ac2c4d776d078d2b104f9a197a5b9aa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "185bbd6ca8d00a5fe097cb38366344da24853ba5905f8cca78434cfa35d19f98", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a4d9574ad43cdee2244bea882a02b480e3039a50c96fc156d81ca10cb472649e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e7bbaf31fbf98e083b5855d1624b323c8e5cde929cb13c0dd971988ac1e34d46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5384ce41d9b99477ffc601954064f8e92aaacbfaa8e04a40b933c1d1139101d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "75f0fa97b7fdb2b56811cb6ca967864a0da344111db9127e346ddd3b726b00af", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9cc70ce409af7feaf4cd45178775e9d267eff8775f6d7e43e168c89dd3ab4347", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "17a90d4602d94ce73604588843eacbfbe2e8636c1fcc0c8aaea293f0dca18c28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d89e7c1b41f23bf421e0cd0d2970f39e94e15972809cd5da09ccbf9c97b105d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1ec5e09d42b79ac2dd22915d37027fdae9e02ef9abb74340314eda4c65e47ce3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dbee004989c2b9caa4394e2039b054d2ba9df4af40b2be962f36d6b6b78ee3be", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "aec387334e29e8b1f8013a357e5d4ec6d8922c3dbe9099e63961769c0ca84939", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d21d6933bd94eb169fa629389643ef375cb72739f19e1cc81d11cecbb59ee20", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "253c832e1f4f69b79c5c1f7e02986cf81d47b20647c832828f8ac561a7b797c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "326148bdef19c436a2eb07180fc25bc7ecf70058c9cc5c61104a164bef2afdf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f85ed8035add441def60d92992f3b458ad65d1df1b3f1934ae9c5c564e998d4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05aaf983932b5d288145e7c2028b219375246636d0a3f8dbde24d771002352d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1a404f9dde85acab25e040b39f94a1199d01646e78e221f70eeb6ff67548d72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26cba078e1604d3f9a2b3cc26ea99bf42ba62c7e049cf2d46a5ecd05b60a7fc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fed3e579f88263c02ab856dc1fe0c68105d949a328e2b874e804ec3abbf8bfe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b76706cd499da75a46176a5dc3a83c5516e53a11ab18e28a2c82e806b2b15204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e87c3d8c9c63d0f0caee3e5650132a334ca1a70ac6d6fa41675750797d9ecb6e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a5c304e2cf0a67eb5601f2ae7049a1289c7aa8a867df2bb58ba7121f845ef3ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "64bdb88f558231e706b9eec9179cdf4d022139af2085a169aac2639023562d7f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "af0cb612d62934c3c22c456cbdc4c33c9f11092bc41321eaf25790cadc64a4da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0c79ec3f4b05788af4c21a84e8e27ac0d3fae8b46b1299a3a364aaa4f61b6c6c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d6d2064ddbbd48570b44bad5d7aaf7698dbf8fb89ed5b535724bb387615e950", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4011e": { @@ -344891,7 +356868,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4011e", "family_id": "terrain-40115-40124", "job_id": "terrain-40115-40124", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -344907,6 +356884,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/candidate.json", "sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eea8c9dace9deb784646fb82f50ab21c3a97bb8e3874d63e1a7d11a1640fb99b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.545085+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"radar\": \"Complete genuine9-cell dish independently located twice in actual checked original Registry mission base:sector_3_wave_4 at row0/col0 and row0/col6. Full assembly1\\u20134 preserves ovoid dish, vertical double rails, horizontal beam, diagonal feed arm pointing lower-left, dark left foot/light right foot, bottom support with red source indicator and down-left ground shadow. All source cell crossings remain continuous; bottom-right40125 comes from second family exact literal crop. Modest facet/rivet/round-hub interpretation is accepted as newly authored detail, with source pose and key landmarks retained.\", \"source_indicator\": \"40124 original single index252 pixel remains exactly1/4/9/16 pixels at scales1/2/3/4. Other new31 tiles have no source dynamic indices, and proposed outputs add none. All compose probes preserve water/fire/single-index palette classes per pixel.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 586d3484558a98a0b48fa2f4b5436af681e85f1a6df6e463b7570c37000d80cc", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40115", + "40116", + "40117", + "40118" + ], + "sha256": "0591a7c752304b489096270b5d2a0b8e621594923b085fdb5a862e14e3225ac2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40119", + "4011a", + "4011b", + "4011c" + ], + "sha256": "da9615e1c2f75e40701c1651cbe53dc38ae7e042b3991938bced6a50e58e9aef", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4011d", + "4011e", + "4011f", + "40120" + ], + "sha256": "8bfbf337ef8847e703c331b872536de05b98948daf471333be9a0a590ff82b3a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40121", + "40122", + "40123", + "40124" + ], + "sha256": "c96258e857361c4996e85dd68a91d7e26c2a38abb1423cb37a519fc57acf3649", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40115-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "81f55f7b76d786bd9967935c30621f87ade4d25286411a022d6d19cda179a87f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db81d7396b38ccfe3207c94073d4215bb5ecae6d7089fc9cd677226977502ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "02ab0db2fad9f9b805b8a0c5e7a6ff1ac21f66aa3d7a129380213f0e56758ff1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc75189e56d6006fa415ed1b26d1543eeee301a623e9a0c745b6d1599ddf6d74", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108de4b5b90a0d4e9a1bb50d2802b500529d0751bd8f74070a31e699b31d02f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bdd322052e50366f686b11ff2dbea2ba169ee86f402bf615b8808ced24674a2e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b50e31f20e6d42025ad8d11862c638418eaa27a95d5972b1e8213070920da03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9a05fef741623c0008ffdd3fbee4357f50f1f43e275f05f65bc115376f952d9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cff578bf5bcc42a48665e288ace0067cf819505acdbb4b4eb47ebab7fce86348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2305e5a91dde4daac3bbcd3753363b1e7873305a8f60bea716ab50a26046eb66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "93e9a2b912ee31c3dbb538e739d5c1deffe2e3ff1b8ff18b01f0cadc8a100769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "157ae2f62916bba51c72138c4f71daceb863256fb4a591c1242f48bef69e7237", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f474433675ca4ca8ac9b25bb470528d9bc6a2f7620873126c204a05d03555553", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a416496d2ffd0ea5e2aac18b4a27c325f79a7c04b43d1b747fc0b24d399749c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9903a18e644f92402afd31b90ff5f33055cf3d8a752204849ac3c557dc90b104", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b849a505d7220afe638b17feb07b28c066a1966166520f4a7b09446c77388f08", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3a12a7d24c56ce771b950fc137295488723b73c8227d5ed092c0a3eac9045b04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d70722dae2e2c470a6ff06d95db19f446c4e5ee188c1811e546e0c28550ae2ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ab755a61b4f29404eae0fc69db6c6daf47f862812c75b8288ddd865594387a8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-original.ppm", + "sha256": "74982df2c178379136049377e64734fc85658e4215b2d0f3add38acd49e92f3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "84bac11cc0d40a51bf48a3dcc84393a2c0a216adde666251fa744b474ac4af6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "451b5925cf64b2d76ce3c1921de3974848fabfda2e215f76830824b31509fa5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c1802cee33337b3ee96e498fb186d08406edc0b9bd76c5ed5770152bee47105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8d6826dbf12e07d533c79794a08c907df51c21a2fc93f7e7e7ec87dee7964a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cacf909ef0797cea2a5528e4466d3463db1c77bbf5a76bcc6434f3e72a6ca51e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2af9ac17f5e80769dc1cfb402e9da093e313b0c072e09abe78a5015e7d16c4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "650f5a9f04911bd5404b60c2de8f406e12cd1f78b45460b342fe3fcee6a625c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "50fad51965e60a64c4f88fdf79f3cb88f582cbcd136a29588c9f19748722c7fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0dc4f45ab5a62e7318c045bcfb77db665c2bce52a4f7d194b3a53693ae83b022", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8efcee76d4ad364bd3665ae090415151348e0ebfce7eaf3f65cad73433bfdbae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4f5536bb63d024365ac1f7cfeb46382ef3c83fa098d573d5a4a3297485c9f105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3c4c28ee1b20ab662d3db1c0d98a6106ead652819998b5197a79363f5a655035", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "48960b86fc04528391963c1bf4eb2cc1372b5e6d95cdb59240504fd794cefb2c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7de3b05cef98dffe4cf7c1eb08ed7048f7291485875d95c43644d3575f2a7464", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250cf8c478790b5eb9ff2cf7cec80e420a6c95506f747ed2da71600951cdff42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "578259c1668e3ba3a9c05d8260f2e3fe8c53ac245211b706edf15694483fa2bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "056c806b021a80b965a8e9d9454ccbe44517abb57c3fdcac35a449c3a928794e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "adef5a9dd838fb78f921d8e1f73adbee19fa0720efc24f949260d3aba6cf0782", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a2dcc700b719f25fac3e69d7943ee7716112e2f2fc7d4a58224778a4bf79bb31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de1f27549ff452e116aacff012b18655c3fbe46642da5502d3c03f80dbb35825", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cad580274feb2c96666516169ea6491ca23436ca351fffc0a6cfa22fedb7ab85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6a4a4cb3192dea3c54995948f985fc0433c5d2d8bc4e189656406dffa0da575", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b1ea0593f03a28049fdd749f01302955562c0c7fa74f626ed990443c04e5a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b58259013db82b50398ab16bfb8f96654f858a96b23f7a381a977a845314e2d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4881eabaa4994249c0b2b675e55437c0f35d7794ba403fb617252016a571a012", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1854fabf39cc4522d771c076e69a428e14c37dcf035967da354aeb3815ed19fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "effe172b2a5e805f2e044420120e42fda45a359341ffd221a67b037517a7a9f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "582ab949c8eeca6ed80e96f78fec992b9d71fda17ebc4eaccc265c948b4606c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "730c1daf6de9b496850fd42556323d38a542ecf6c01833b9eef1369db8863ad8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "789cc80d4fd3714071537c958d4ef807e6ad23f1ea64da549c4a39a14cf4898f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "781ef1854ab07423ba4bf0ab3e7ee925cb58d0c5f8344d0df3c93e88a4741896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26c6a4a506895b59affff539c1f0e578571db2b6001df8fe9872d601f6d95829", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82a7963c214eb0dd3b2f180e0df7aa044db2882bf5d3d8bfe230341684fe5856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5e16ec3be0f2ccc7c28e95bddcb79757ac2c4d776d078d2b104f9a197a5b9aa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "185bbd6ca8d00a5fe097cb38366344da24853ba5905f8cca78434cfa35d19f98", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a4d9574ad43cdee2244bea882a02b480e3039a50c96fc156d81ca10cb472649e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e7bbaf31fbf98e083b5855d1624b323c8e5cde929cb13c0dd971988ac1e34d46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5384ce41d9b99477ffc601954064f8e92aaacbfaa8e04a40b933c1d1139101d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "75f0fa97b7fdb2b56811cb6ca967864a0da344111db9127e346ddd3b726b00af", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9cc70ce409af7feaf4cd45178775e9d267eff8775f6d7e43e168c89dd3ab4347", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "17a90d4602d94ce73604588843eacbfbe2e8636c1fcc0c8aaea293f0dca18c28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d89e7c1b41f23bf421e0cd0d2970f39e94e15972809cd5da09ccbf9c97b105d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1ec5e09d42b79ac2dd22915d37027fdae9e02ef9abb74340314eda4c65e47ce3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dbee004989c2b9caa4394e2039b054d2ba9df4af40b2be962f36d6b6b78ee3be", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "aec387334e29e8b1f8013a357e5d4ec6d8922c3dbe9099e63961769c0ca84939", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d21d6933bd94eb169fa629389643ef375cb72739f19e1cc81d11cecbb59ee20", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "253c832e1f4f69b79c5c1f7e02986cf81d47b20647c832828f8ac561a7b797c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "326148bdef19c436a2eb07180fc25bc7ecf70058c9cc5c61104a164bef2afdf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f85ed8035add441def60d92992f3b458ad65d1df1b3f1934ae9c5c564e998d4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05aaf983932b5d288145e7c2028b219375246636d0a3f8dbde24d771002352d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1a404f9dde85acab25e040b39f94a1199d01646e78e221f70eeb6ff67548d72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26cba078e1604d3f9a2b3cc26ea99bf42ba62c7e049cf2d46a5ecd05b60a7fc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fed3e579f88263c02ab856dc1fe0c68105d949a328e2b874e804ec3abbf8bfe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b76706cd499da75a46176a5dc3a83c5516e53a11ab18e28a2c82e806b2b15204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e87c3d8c9c63d0f0caee3e5650132a334ca1a70ac6d6fa41675750797d9ecb6e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a5c304e2cf0a67eb5601f2ae7049a1289c7aa8a867df2bb58ba7121f845ef3ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "64bdb88f558231e706b9eec9179cdf4d022139af2085a169aac2639023562d7f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "af0cb612d62934c3c22c456cbdc4c33c9f11092bc41321eaf25790cadc64a4da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0c79ec3f4b05788af4c21a84e8e27ac0d3fae8b46b1299a3a364aaa4f61b6c6c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d6d2064ddbbd48570b44bad5d7aaf7698dbf8fb89ed5b535724bb387615e950", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4011f": { @@ -344928,7 +357375,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4011f", "family_id": "terrain-40115-40124", "job_id": "terrain-40115-40124", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -344944,6 +357391,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/candidate.json", "sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eea8c9dace9deb784646fb82f50ab21c3a97bb8e3874d63e1a7d11a1640fb99b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.545085+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"radar\": \"Complete genuine9-cell dish independently located twice in actual checked original Registry mission base:sector_3_wave_4 at row0/col0 and row0/col6. Full assembly1\\u20134 preserves ovoid dish, vertical double rails, horizontal beam, diagonal feed arm pointing lower-left, dark left foot/light right foot, bottom support with red source indicator and down-left ground shadow. All source cell crossings remain continuous; bottom-right40125 comes from second family exact literal crop. Modest facet/rivet/round-hub interpretation is accepted as newly authored detail, with source pose and key landmarks retained.\", \"source_indicator\": \"40124 original single index252 pixel remains exactly1/4/9/16 pixels at scales1/2/3/4. Other new31 tiles have no source dynamic indices, and proposed outputs add none. All compose probes preserve water/fire/single-index palette classes per pixel.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 586d3484558a98a0b48fa2f4b5436af681e85f1a6df6e463b7570c37000d80cc", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40115", + "40116", + "40117", + "40118" + ], + "sha256": "0591a7c752304b489096270b5d2a0b8e621594923b085fdb5a862e14e3225ac2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40119", + "4011a", + "4011b", + "4011c" + ], + "sha256": "da9615e1c2f75e40701c1651cbe53dc38ae7e042b3991938bced6a50e58e9aef", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4011d", + "4011e", + "4011f", + "40120" + ], + "sha256": "8bfbf337ef8847e703c331b872536de05b98948daf471333be9a0a590ff82b3a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40121", + "40122", + "40123", + "40124" + ], + "sha256": "c96258e857361c4996e85dd68a91d7e26c2a38abb1423cb37a519fc57acf3649", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40115-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "81f55f7b76d786bd9967935c30621f87ade4d25286411a022d6d19cda179a87f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db81d7396b38ccfe3207c94073d4215bb5ecae6d7089fc9cd677226977502ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "02ab0db2fad9f9b805b8a0c5e7a6ff1ac21f66aa3d7a129380213f0e56758ff1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc75189e56d6006fa415ed1b26d1543eeee301a623e9a0c745b6d1599ddf6d74", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108de4b5b90a0d4e9a1bb50d2802b500529d0751bd8f74070a31e699b31d02f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bdd322052e50366f686b11ff2dbea2ba169ee86f402bf615b8808ced24674a2e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b50e31f20e6d42025ad8d11862c638418eaa27a95d5972b1e8213070920da03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9a05fef741623c0008ffdd3fbee4357f50f1f43e275f05f65bc115376f952d9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cff578bf5bcc42a48665e288ace0067cf819505acdbb4b4eb47ebab7fce86348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2305e5a91dde4daac3bbcd3753363b1e7873305a8f60bea716ab50a26046eb66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "93e9a2b912ee31c3dbb538e739d5c1deffe2e3ff1b8ff18b01f0cadc8a100769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "157ae2f62916bba51c72138c4f71daceb863256fb4a591c1242f48bef69e7237", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f474433675ca4ca8ac9b25bb470528d9bc6a2f7620873126c204a05d03555553", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a416496d2ffd0ea5e2aac18b4a27c325f79a7c04b43d1b747fc0b24d399749c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9903a18e644f92402afd31b90ff5f33055cf3d8a752204849ac3c557dc90b104", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b849a505d7220afe638b17feb07b28c066a1966166520f4a7b09446c77388f08", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3a12a7d24c56ce771b950fc137295488723b73c8227d5ed092c0a3eac9045b04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d70722dae2e2c470a6ff06d95db19f446c4e5ee188c1811e546e0c28550ae2ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ab755a61b4f29404eae0fc69db6c6daf47f862812c75b8288ddd865594387a8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-original.ppm", + "sha256": "74982df2c178379136049377e64734fc85658e4215b2d0f3add38acd49e92f3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "84bac11cc0d40a51bf48a3dcc84393a2c0a216adde666251fa744b474ac4af6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "451b5925cf64b2d76ce3c1921de3974848fabfda2e215f76830824b31509fa5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c1802cee33337b3ee96e498fb186d08406edc0b9bd76c5ed5770152bee47105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8d6826dbf12e07d533c79794a08c907df51c21a2fc93f7e7e7ec87dee7964a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cacf909ef0797cea2a5528e4466d3463db1c77bbf5a76bcc6434f3e72a6ca51e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2af9ac17f5e80769dc1cfb402e9da093e313b0c072e09abe78a5015e7d16c4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "650f5a9f04911bd5404b60c2de8f406e12cd1f78b45460b342fe3fcee6a625c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "50fad51965e60a64c4f88fdf79f3cb88f582cbcd136a29588c9f19748722c7fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0dc4f45ab5a62e7318c045bcfb77db665c2bce52a4f7d194b3a53693ae83b022", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8efcee76d4ad364bd3665ae090415151348e0ebfce7eaf3f65cad73433bfdbae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4f5536bb63d024365ac1f7cfeb46382ef3c83fa098d573d5a4a3297485c9f105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3c4c28ee1b20ab662d3db1c0d98a6106ead652819998b5197a79363f5a655035", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "48960b86fc04528391963c1bf4eb2cc1372b5e6d95cdb59240504fd794cefb2c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7de3b05cef98dffe4cf7c1eb08ed7048f7291485875d95c43644d3575f2a7464", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250cf8c478790b5eb9ff2cf7cec80e420a6c95506f747ed2da71600951cdff42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "578259c1668e3ba3a9c05d8260f2e3fe8c53ac245211b706edf15694483fa2bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "056c806b021a80b965a8e9d9454ccbe44517abb57c3fdcac35a449c3a928794e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "adef5a9dd838fb78f921d8e1f73adbee19fa0720efc24f949260d3aba6cf0782", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a2dcc700b719f25fac3e69d7943ee7716112e2f2fc7d4a58224778a4bf79bb31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de1f27549ff452e116aacff012b18655c3fbe46642da5502d3c03f80dbb35825", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cad580274feb2c96666516169ea6491ca23436ca351fffc0a6cfa22fedb7ab85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6a4a4cb3192dea3c54995948f985fc0433c5d2d8bc4e189656406dffa0da575", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b1ea0593f03a28049fdd749f01302955562c0c7fa74f626ed990443c04e5a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b58259013db82b50398ab16bfb8f96654f858a96b23f7a381a977a845314e2d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4881eabaa4994249c0b2b675e55437c0f35d7794ba403fb617252016a571a012", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1854fabf39cc4522d771c076e69a428e14c37dcf035967da354aeb3815ed19fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "effe172b2a5e805f2e044420120e42fda45a359341ffd221a67b037517a7a9f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "582ab949c8eeca6ed80e96f78fec992b9d71fda17ebc4eaccc265c948b4606c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "730c1daf6de9b496850fd42556323d38a542ecf6c01833b9eef1369db8863ad8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "789cc80d4fd3714071537c958d4ef807e6ad23f1ea64da549c4a39a14cf4898f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "781ef1854ab07423ba4bf0ab3e7ee925cb58d0c5f8344d0df3c93e88a4741896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26c6a4a506895b59affff539c1f0e578571db2b6001df8fe9872d601f6d95829", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82a7963c214eb0dd3b2f180e0df7aa044db2882bf5d3d8bfe230341684fe5856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5e16ec3be0f2ccc7c28e95bddcb79757ac2c4d776d078d2b104f9a197a5b9aa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "185bbd6ca8d00a5fe097cb38366344da24853ba5905f8cca78434cfa35d19f98", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a4d9574ad43cdee2244bea882a02b480e3039a50c96fc156d81ca10cb472649e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e7bbaf31fbf98e083b5855d1624b323c8e5cde929cb13c0dd971988ac1e34d46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5384ce41d9b99477ffc601954064f8e92aaacbfaa8e04a40b933c1d1139101d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "75f0fa97b7fdb2b56811cb6ca967864a0da344111db9127e346ddd3b726b00af", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9cc70ce409af7feaf4cd45178775e9d267eff8775f6d7e43e168c89dd3ab4347", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "17a90d4602d94ce73604588843eacbfbe2e8636c1fcc0c8aaea293f0dca18c28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d89e7c1b41f23bf421e0cd0d2970f39e94e15972809cd5da09ccbf9c97b105d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1ec5e09d42b79ac2dd22915d37027fdae9e02ef9abb74340314eda4c65e47ce3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dbee004989c2b9caa4394e2039b054d2ba9df4af40b2be962f36d6b6b78ee3be", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "aec387334e29e8b1f8013a357e5d4ec6d8922c3dbe9099e63961769c0ca84939", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d21d6933bd94eb169fa629389643ef375cb72739f19e1cc81d11cecbb59ee20", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "253c832e1f4f69b79c5c1f7e02986cf81d47b20647c832828f8ac561a7b797c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "326148bdef19c436a2eb07180fc25bc7ecf70058c9cc5c61104a164bef2afdf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f85ed8035add441def60d92992f3b458ad65d1df1b3f1934ae9c5c564e998d4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05aaf983932b5d288145e7c2028b219375246636d0a3f8dbde24d771002352d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1a404f9dde85acab25e040b39f94a1199d01646e78e221f70eeb6ff67548d72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26cba078e1604d3f9a2b3cc26ea99bf42ba62c7e049cf2d46a5ecd05b60a7fc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fed3e579f88263c02ab856dc1fe0c68105d949a328e2b874e804ec3abbf8bfe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b76706cd499da75a46176a5dc3a83c5516e53a11ab18e28a2c82e806b2b15204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e87c3d8c9c63d0f0caee3e5650132a334ca1a70ac6d6fa41675750797d9ecb6e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a5c304e2cf0a67eb5601f2ae7049a1289c7aa8a867df2bb58ba7121f845ef3ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "64bdb88f558231e706b9eec9179cdf4d022139af2085a169aac2639023562d7f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "af0cb612d62934c3c22c456cbdc4c33c9f11092bc41321eaf25790cadc64a4da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0c79ec3f4b05788af4c21a84e8e27ac0d3fae8b46b1299a3a364aaa4f61b6c6c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d6d2064ddbbd48570b44bad5d7aaf7698dbf8fb89ed5b535724bb387615e950", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40120": { @@ -344965,7 +357882,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40120", "family_id": "terrain-40115-40124", "job_id": "terrain-40115-40124", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -344981,6 +357898,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/candidate.json", "sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eea8c9dace9deb784646fb82f50ab21c3a97bb8e3874d63e1a7d11a1640fb99b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.545085+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"radar\": \"Complete genuine9-cell dish independently located twice in actual checked original Registry mission base:sector_3_wave_4 at row0/col0 and row0/col6. Full assembly1\\u20134 preserves ovoid dish, vertical double rails, horizontal beam, diagonal feed arm pointing lower-left, dark left foot/light right foot, bottom support with red source indicator and down-left ground shadow. All source cell crossings remain continuous; bottom-right40125 comes from second family exact literal crop. Modest facet/rivet/round-hub interpretation is accepted as newly authored detail, with source pose and key landmarks retained.\", \"source_indicator\": \"40124 original single index252 pixel remains exactly1/4/9/16 pixels at scales1/2/3/4. Other new31 tiles have no source dynamic indices, and proposed outputs add none. All compose probes preserve water/fire/single-index palette classes per pixel.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 586d3484558a98a0b48fa2f4b5436af681e85f1a6df6e463b7570c37000d80cc", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40115", + "40116", + "40117", + "40118" + ], + "sha256": "0591a7c752304b489096270b5d2a0b8e621594923b085fdb5a862e14e3225ac2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40119", + "4011a", + "4011b", + "4011c" + ], + "sha256": "da9615e1c2f75e40701c1651cbe53dc38ae7e042b3991938bced6a50e58e9aef", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4011d", + "4011e", + "4011f", + "40120" + ], + "sha256": "8bfbf337ef8847e703c331b872536de05b98948daf471333be9a0a590ff82b3a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40121", + "40122", + "40123", + "40124" + ], + "sha256": "c96258e857361c4996e85dd68a91d7e26c2a38abb1423cb37a519fc57acf3649", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40115-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "81f55f7b76d786bd9967935c30621f87ade4d25286411a022d6d19cda179a87f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db81d7396b38ccfe3207c94073d4215bb5ecae6d7089fc9cd677226977502ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "02ab0db2fad9f9b805b8a0c5e7a6ff1ac21f66aa3d7a129380213f0e56758ff1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc75189e56d6006fa415ed1b26d1543eeee301a623e9a0c745b6d1599ddf6d74", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108de4b5b90a0d4e9a1bb50d2802b500529d0751bd8f74070a31e699b31d02f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bdd322052e50366f686b11ff2dbea2ba169ee86f402bf615b8808ced24674a2e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b50e31f20e6d42025ad8d11862c638418eaa27a95d5972b1e8213070920da03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9a05fef741623c0008ffdd3fbee4357f50f1f43e275f05f65bc115376f952d9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cff578bf5bcc42a48665e288ace0067cf819505acdbb4b4eb47ebab7fce86348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2305e5a91dde4daac3bbcd3753363b1e7873305a8f60bea716ab50a26046eb66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "93e9a2b912ee31c3dbb538e739d5c1deffe2e3ff1b8ff18b01f0cadc8a100769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "157ae2f62916bba51c72138c4f71daceb863256fb4a591c1242f48bef69e7237", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f474433675ca4ca8ac9b25bb470528d9bc6a2f7620873126c204a05d03555553", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a416496d2ffd0ea5e2aac18b4a27c325f79a7c04b43d1b747fc0b24d399749c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9903a18e644f92402afd31b90ff5f33055cf3d8a752204849ac3c557dc90b104", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b849a505d7220afe638b17feb07b28c066a1966166520f4a7b09446c77388f08", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3a12a7d24c56ce771b950fc137295488723b73c8227d5ed092c0a3eac9045b04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d70722dae2e2c470a6ff06d95db19f446c4e5ee188c1811e546e0c28550ae2ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ab755a61b4f29404eae0fc69db6c6daf47f862812c75b8288ddd865594387a8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-original.ppm", + "sha256": "74982df2c178379136049377e64734fc85658e4215b2d0f3add38acd49e92f3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "84bac11cc0d40a51bf48a3dcc84393a2c0a216adde666251fa744b474ac4af6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "451b5925cf64b2d76ce3c1921de3974848fabfda2e215f76830824b31509fa5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c1802cee33337b3ee96e498fb186d08406edc0b9bd76c5ed5770152bee47105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8d6826dbf12e07d533c79794a08c907df51c21a2fc93f7e7e7ec87dee7964a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cacf909ef0797cea2a5528e4466d3463db1c77bbf5a76bcc6434f3e72a6ca51e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2af9ac17f5e80769dc1cfb402e9da093e313b0c072e09abe78a5015e7d16c4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "650f5a9f04911bd5404b60c2de8f406e12cd1f78b45460b342fe3fcee6a625c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "50fad51965e60a64c4f88fdf79f3cb88f582cbcd136a29588c9f19748722c7fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0dc4f45ab5a62e7318c045bcfb77db665c2bce52a4f7d194b3a53693ae83b022", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8efcee76d4ad364bd3665ae090415151348e0ebfce7eaf3f65cad73433bfdbae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4f5536bb63d024365ac1f7cfeb46382ef3c83fa098d573d5a4a3297485c9f105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3c4c28ee1b20ab662d3db1c0d98a6106ead652819998b5197a79363f5a655035", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "48960b86fc04528391963c1bf4eb2cc1372b5e6d95cdb59240504fd794cefb2c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7de3b05cef98dffe4cf7c1eb08ed7048f7291485875d95c43644d3575f2a7464", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250cf8c478790b5eb9ff2cf7cec80e420a6c95506f747ed2da71600951cdff42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "578259c1668e3ba3a9c05d8260f2e3fe8c53ac245211b706edf15694483fa2bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "056c806b021a80b965a8e9d9454ccbe44517abb57c3fdcac35a449c3a928794e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "adef5a9dd838fb78f921d8e1f73adbee19fa0720efc24f949260d3aba6cf0782", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a2dcc700b719f25fac3e69d7943ee7716112e2f2fc7d4a58224778a4bf79bb31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de1f27549ff452e116aacff012b18655c3fbe46642da5502d3c03f80dbb35825", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cad580274feb2c96666516169ea6491ca23436ca351fffc0a6cfa22fedb7ab85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6a4a4cb3192dea3c54995948f985fc0433c5d2d8bc4e189656406dffa0da575", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b1ea0593f03a28049fdd749f01302955562c0c7fa74f626ed990443c04e5a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b58259013db82b50398ab16bfb8f96654f858a96b23f7a381a977a845314e2d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4881eabaa4994249c0b2b675e55437c0f35d7794ba403fb617252016a571a012", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1854fabf39cc4522d771c076e69a428e14c37dcf035967da354aeb3815ed19fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "effe172b2a5e805f2e044420120e42fda45a359341ffd221a67b037517a7a9f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "582ab949c8eeca6ed80e96f78fec992b9d71fda17ebc4eaccc265c948b4606c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "730c1daf6de9b496850fd42556323d38a542ecf6c01833b9eef1369db8863ad8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "789cc80d4fd3714071537c958d4ef807e6ad23f1ea64da549c4a39a14cf4898f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "781ef1854ab07423ba4bf0ab3e7ee925cb58d0c5f8344d0df3c93e88a4741896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26c6a4a506895b59affff539c1f0e578571db2b6001df8fe9872d601f6d95829", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82a7963c214eb0dd3b2f180e0df7aa044db2882bf5d3d8bfe230341684fe5856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5e16ec3be0f2ccc7c28e95bddcb79757ac2c4d776d078d2b104f9a197a5b9aa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "185bbd6ca8d00a5fe097cb38366344da24853ba5905f8cca78434cfa35d19f98", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a4d9574ad43cdee2244bea882a02b480e3039a50c96fc156d81ca10cb472649e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e7bbaf31fbf98e083b5855d1624b323c8e5cde929cb13c0dd971988ac1e34d46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5384ce41d9b99477ffc601954064f8e92aaacbfaa8e04a40b933c1d1139101d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "75f0fa97b7fdb2b56811cb6ca967864a0da344111db9127e346ddd3b726b00af", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9cc70ce409af7feaf4cd45178775e9d267eff8775f6d7e43e168c89dd3ab4347", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "17a90d4602d94ce73604588843eacbfbe2e8636c1fcc0c8aaea293f0dca18c28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d89e7c1b41f23bf421e0cd0d2970f39e94e15972809cd5da09ccbf9c97b105d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1ec5e09d42b79ac2dd22915d37027fdae9e02ef9abb74340314eda4c65e47ce3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dbee004989c2b9caa4394e2039b054d2ba9df4af40b2be962f36d6b6b78ee3be", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "aec387334e29e8b1f8013a357e5d4ec6d8922c3dbe9099e63961769c0ca84939", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d21d6933bd94eb169fa629389643ef375cb72739f19e1cc81d11cecbb59ee20", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "253c832e1f4f69b79c5c1f7e02986cf81d47b20647c832828f8ac561a7b797c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "326148bdef19c436a2eb07180fc25bc7ecf70058c9cc5c61104a164bef2afdf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f85ed8035add441def60d92992f3b458ad65d1df1b3f1934ae9c5c564e998d4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05aaf983932b5d288145e7c2028b219375246636d0a3f8dbde24d771002352d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1a404f9dde85acab25e040b39f94a1199d01646e78e221f70eeb6ff67548d72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26cba078e1604d3f9a2b3cc26ea99bf42ba62c7e049cf2d46a5ecd05b60a7fc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fed3e579f88263c02ab856dc1fe0c68105d949a328e2b874e804ec3abbf8bfe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b76706cd499da75a46176a5dc3a83c5516e53a11ab18e28a2c82e806b2b15204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e87c3d8c9c63d0f0caee3e5650132a334ca1a70ac6d6fa41675750797d9ecb6e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a5c304e2cf0a67eb5601f2ae7049a1289c7aa8a867df2bb58ba7121f845ef3ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "64bdb88f558231e706b9eec9179cdf4d022139af2085a169aac2639023562d7f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "af0cb612d62934c3c22c456cbdc4c33c9f11092bc41321eaf25790cadc64a4da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0c79ec3f4b05788af4c21a84e8e27ac0d3fae8b46b1299a3a364aaa4f61b6c6c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d6d2064ddbbd48570b44bad5d7aaf7698dbf8fb89ed5b535724bb387615e950", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40121": { @@ -345002,7 +358389,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40121", "family_id": "terrain-40115-40124", "job_id": "terrain-40115-40124", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345018,6 +358405,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/candidate.json", "sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eea8c9dace9deb784646fb82f50ab21c3a97bb8e3874d63e1a7d11a1640fb99b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.545085+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"radar\": \"Complete genuine9-cell dish independently located twice in actual checked original Registry mission base:sector_3_wave_4 at row0/col0 and row0/col6. Full assembly1\\u20134 preserves ovoid dish, vertical double rails, horizontal beam, diagonal feed arm pointing lower-left, dark left foot/light right foot, bottom support with red source indicator and down-left ground shadow. All source cell crossings remain continuous; bottom-right40125 comes from second family exact literal crop. Modest facet/rivet/round-hub interpretation is accepted as newly authored detail, with source pose and key landmarks retained.\", \"source_indicator\": \"40124 original single index252 pixel remains exactly1/4/9/16 pixels at scales1/2/3/4. Other new31 tiles have no source dynamic indices, and proposed outputs add none. All compose probes preserve water/fire/single-index palette classes per pixel.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 586d3484558a98a0b48fa2f4b5436af681e85f1a6df6e463b7570c37000d80cc", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40115", + "40116", + "40117", + "40118" + ], + "sha256": "0591a7c752304b489096270b5d2a0b8e621594923b085fdb5a862e14e3225ac2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40119", + "4011a", + "4011b", + "4011c" + ], + "sha256": "da9615e1c2f75e40701c1651cbe53dc38ae7e042b3991938bced6a50e58e9aef", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4011d", + "4011e", + "4011f", + "40120" + ], + "sha256": "8bfbf337ef8847e703c331b872536de05b98948daf471333be9a0a590ff82b3a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40121", + "40122", + "40123", + "40124" + ], + "sha256": "c96258e857361c4996e85dd68a91d7e26c2a38abb1423cb37a519fc57acf3649", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40115-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "81f55f7b76d786bd9967935c30621f87ade4d25286411a022d6d19cda179a87f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db81d7396b38ccfe3207c94073d4215bb5ecae6d7089fc9cd677226977502ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "02ab0db2fad9f9b805b8a0c5e7a6ff1ac21f66aa3d7a129380213f0e56758ff1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc75189e56d6006fa415ed1b26d1543eeee301a623e9a0c745b6d1599ddf6d74", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108de4b5b90a0d4e9a1bb50d2802b500529d0751bd8f74070a31e699b31d02f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bdd322052e50366f686b11ff2dbea2ba169ee86f402bf615b8808ced24674a2e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b50e31f20e6d42025ad8d11862c638418eaa27a95d5972b1e8213070920da03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9a05fef741623c0008ffdd3fbee4357f50f1f43e275f05f65bc115376f952d9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cff578bf5bcc42a48665e288ace0067cf819505acdbb4b4eb47ebab7fce86348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2305e5a91dde4daac3bbcd3753363b1e7873305a8f60bea716ab50a26046eb66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "93e9a2b912ee31c3dbb538e739d5c1deffe2e3ff1b8ff18b01f0cadc8a100769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "157ae2f62916bba51c72138c4f71daceb863256fb4a591c1242f48bef69e7237", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f474433675ca4ca8ac9b25bb470528d9bc6a2f7620873126c204a05d03555553", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a416496d2ffd0ea5e2aac18b4a27c325f79a7c04b43d1b747fc0b24d399749c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9903a18e644f92402afd31b90ff5f33055cf3d8a752204849ac3c557dc90b104", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b849a505d7220afe638b17feb07b28c066a1966166520f4a7b09446c77388f08", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3a12a7d24c56ce771b950fc137295488723b73c8227d5ed092c0a3eac9045b04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d70722dae2e2c470a6ff06d95db19f446c4e5ee188c1811e546e0c28550ae2ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ab755a61b4f29404eae0fc69db6c6daf47f862812c75b8288ddd865594387a8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-original.ppm", + "sha256": "74982df2c178379136049377e64734fc85658e4215b2d0f3add38acd49e92f3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "84bac11cc0d40a51bf48a3dcc84393a2c0a216adde666251fa744b474ac4af6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "451b5925cf64b2d76ce3c1921de3974848fabfda2e215f76830824b31509fa5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c1802cee33337b3ee96e498fb186d08406edc0b9bd76c5ed5770152bee47105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8d6826dbf12e07d533c79794a08c907df51c21a2fc93f7e7e7ec87dee7964a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cacf909ef0797cea2a5528e4466d3463db1c77bbf5a76bcc6434f3e72a6ca51e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2af9ac17f5e80769dc1cfb402e9da093e313b0c072e09abe78a5015e7d16c4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "650f5a9f04911bd5404b60c2de8f406e12cd1f78b45460b342fe3fcee6a625c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "50fad51965e60a64c4f88fdf79f3cb88f582cbcd136a29588c9f19748722c7fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0dc4f45ab5a62e7318c045bcfb77db665c2bce52a4f7d194b3a53693ae83b022", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8efcee76d4ad364bd3665ae090415151348e0ebfce7eaf3f65cad73433bfdbae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4f5536bb63d024365ac1f7cfeb46382ef3c83fa098d573d5a4a3297485c9f105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3c4c28ee1b20ab662d3db1c0d98a6106ead652819998b5197a79363f5a655035", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "48960b86fc04528391963c1bf4eb2cc1372b5e6d95cdb59240504fd794cefb2c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7de3b05cef98dffe4cf7c1eb08ed7048f7291485875d95c43644d3575f2a7464", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250cf8c478790b5eb9ff2cf7cec80e420a6c95506f747ed2da71600951cdff42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "578259c1668e3ba3a9c05d8260f2e3fe8c53ac245211b706edf15694483fa2bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "056c806b021a80b965a8e9d9454ccbe44517abb57c3fdcac35a449c3a928794e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "adef5a9dd838fb78f921d8e1f73adbee19fa0720efc24f949260d3aba6cf0782", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a2dcc700b719f25fac3e69d7943ee7716112e2f2fc7d4a58224778a4bf79bb31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de1f27549ff452e116aacff012b18655c3fbe46642da5502d3c03f80dbb35825", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cad580274feb2c96666516169ea6491ca23436ca351fffc0a6cfa22fedb7ab85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6a4a4cb3192dea3c54995948f985fc0433c5d2d8bc4e189656406dffa0da575", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b1ea0593f03a28049fdd749f01302955562c0c7fa74f626ed990443c04e5a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b58259013db82b50398ab16bfb8f96654f858a96b23f7a381a977a845314e2d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4881eabaa4994249c0b2b675e55437c0f35d7794ba403fb617252016a571a012", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1854fabf39cc4522d771c076e69a428e14c37dcf035967da354aeb3815ed19fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "effe172b2a5e805f2e044420120e42fda45a359341ffd221a67b037517a7a9f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "582ab949c8eeca6ed80e96f78fec992b9d71fda17ebc4eaccc265c948b4606c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "730c1daf6de9b496850fd42556323d38a542ecf6c01833b9eef1369db8863ad8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "789cc80d4fd3714071537c958d4ef807e6ad23f1ea64da549c4a39a14cf4898f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "781ef1854ab07423ba4bf0ab3e7ee925cb58d0c5f8344d0df3c93e88a4741896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26c6a4a506895b59affff539c1f0e578571db2b6001df8fe9872d601f6d95829", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82a7963c214eb0dd3b2f180e0df7aa044db2882bf5d3d8bfe230341684fe5856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5e16ec3be0f2ccc7c28e95bddcb79757ac2c4d776d078d2b104f9a197a5b9aa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "185bbd6ca8d00a5fe097cb38366344da24853ba5905f8cca78434cfa35d19f98", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a4d9574ad43cdee2244bea882a02b480e3039a50c96fc156d81ca10cb472649e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e7bbaf31fbf98e083b5855d1624b323c8e5cde929cb13c0dd971988ac1e34d46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5384ce41d9b99477ffc601954064f8e92aaacbfaa8e04a40b933c1d1139101d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "75f0fa97b7fdb2b56811cb6ca967864a0da344111db9127e346ddd3b726b00af", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9cc70ce409af7feaf4cd45178775e9d267eff8775f6d7e43e168c89dd3ab4347", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "17a90d4602d94ce73604588843eacbfbe2e8636c1fcc0c8aaea293f0dca18c28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d89e7c1b41f23bf421e0cd0d2970f39e94e15972809cd5da09ccbf9c97b105d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1ec5e09d42b79ac2dd22915d37027fdae9e02ef9abb74340314eda4c65e47ce3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dbee004989c2b9caa4394e2039b054d2ba9df4af40b2be962f36d6b6b78ee3be", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "aec387334e29e8b1f8013a357e5d4ec6d8922c3dbe9099e63961769c0ca84939", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d21d6933bd94eb169fa629389643ef375cb72739f19e1cc81d11cecbb59ee20", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "253c832e1f4f69b79c5c1f7e02986cf81d47b20647c832828f8ac561a7b797c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "326148bdef19c436a2eb07180fc25bc7ecf70058c9cc5c61104a164bef2afdf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f85ed8035add441def60d92992f3b458ad65d1df1b3f1934ae9c5c564e998d4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05aaf983932b5d288145e7c2028b219375246636d0a3f8dbde24d771002352d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1a404f9dde85acab25e040b39f94a1199d01646e78e221f70eeb6ff67548d72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26cba078e1604d3f9a2b3cc26ea99bf42ba62c7e049cf2d46a5ecd05b60a7fc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fed3e579f88263c02ab856dc1fe0c68105d949a328e2b874e804ec3abbf8bfe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b76706cd499da75a46176a5dc3a83c5516e53a11ab18e28a2c82e806b2b15204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e87c3d8c9c63d0f0caee3e5650132a334ca1a70ac6d6fa41675750797d9ecb6e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a5c304e2cf0a67eb5601f2ae7049a1289c7aa8a867df2bb58ba7121f845ef3ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "64bdb88f558231e706b9eec9179cdf4d022139af2085a169aac2639023562d7f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "af0cb612d62934c3c22c456cbdc4c33c9f11092bc41321eaf25790cadc64a4da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0c79ec3f4b05788af4c21a84e8e27ac0d3fae8b46b1299a3a364aaa4f61b6c6c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d6d2064ddbbd48570b44bad5d7aaf7698dbf8fb89ed5b535724bb387615e950", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40122": { @@ -345039,7 +358896,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40122", "family_id": "terrain-40115-40124", "job_id": "terrain-40115-40124", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345055,6 +358912,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/candidate.json", "sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eea8c9dace9deb784646fb82f50ab21c3a97bb8e3874d63e1a7d11a1640fb99b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.545085+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"radar\": \"Complete genuine9-cell dish independently located twice in actual checked original Registry mission base:sector_3_wave_4 at row0/col0 and row0/col6. Full assembly1\\u20134 preserves ovoid dish, vertical double rails, horizontal beam, diagonal feed arm pointing lower-left, dark left foot/light right foot, bottom support with red source indicator and down-left ground shadow. All source cell crossings remain continuous; bottom-right40125 comes from second family exact literal crop. Modest facet/rivet/round-hub interpretation is accepted as newly authored detail, with source pose and key landmarks retained.\", \"source_indicator\": \"40124 original single index252 pixel remains exactly1/4/9/16 pixels at scales1/2/3/4. Other new31 tiles have no source dynamic indices, and proposed outputs add none. All compose probes preserve water/fire/single-index palette classes per pixel.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 586d3484558a98a0b48fa2f4b5436af681e85f1a6df6e463b7570c37000d80cc", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40115", + "40116", + "40117", + "40118" + ], + "sha256": "0591a7c752304b489096270b5d2a0b8e621594923b085fdb5a862e14e3225ac2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40119", + "4011a", + "4011b", + "4011c" + ], + "sha256": "da9615e1c2f75e40701c1651cbe53dc38ae7e042b3991938bced6a50e58e9aef", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4011d", + "4011e", + "4011f", + "40120" + ], + "sha256": "8bfbf337ef8847e703c331b872536de05b98948daf471333be9a0a590ff82b3a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40121", + "40122", + "40123", + "40124" + ], + "sha256": "c96258e857361c4996e85dd68a91d7e26c2a38abb1423cb37a519fc57acf3649", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40115-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "81f55f7b76d786bd9967935c30621f87ade4d25286411a022d6d19cda179a87f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db81d7396b38ccfe3207c94073d4215bb5ecae6d7089fc9cd677226977502ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "02ab0db2fad9f9b805b8a0c5e7a6ff1ac21f66aa3d7a129380213f0e56758ff1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc75189e56d6006fa415ed1b26d1543eeee301a623e9a0c745b6d1599ddf6d74", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108de4b5b90a0d4e9a1bb50d2802b500529d0751bd8f74070a31e699b31d02f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bdd322052e50366f686b11ff2dbea2ba169ee86f402bf615b8808ced24674a2e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b50e31f20e6d42025ad8d11862c638418eaa27a95d5972b1e8213070920da03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9a05fef741623c0008ffdd3fbee4357f50f1f43e275f05f65bc115376f952d9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cff578bf5bcc42a48665e288ace0067cf819505acdbb4b4eb47ebab7fce86348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2305e5a91dde4daac3bbcd3753363b1e7873305a8f60bea716ab50a26046eb66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "93e9a2b912ee31c3dbb538e739d5c1deffe2e3ff1b8ff18b01f0cadc8a100769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "157ae2f62916bba51c72138c4f71daceb863256fb4a591c1242f48bef69e7237", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f474433675ca4ca8ac9b25bb470528d9bc6a2f7620873126c204a05d03555553", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a416496d2ffd0ea5e2aac18b4a27c325f79a7c04b43d1b747fc0b24d399749c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9903a18e644f92402afd31b90ff5f33055cf3d8a752204849ac3c557dc90b104", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b849a505d7220afe638b17feb07b28c066a1966166520f4a7b09446c77388f08", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3a12a7d24c56ce771b950fc137295488723b73c8227d5ed092c0a3eac9045b04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d70722dae2e2c470a6ff06d95db19f446c4e5ee188c1811e546e0c28550ae2ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ab755a61b4f29404eae0fc69db6c6daf47f862812c75b8288ddd865594387a8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-original.ppm", + "sha256": "74982df2c178379136049377e64734fc85658e4215b2d0f3add38acd49e92f3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "84bac11cc0d40a51bf48a3dcc84393a2c0a216adde666251fa744b474ac4af6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "451b5925cf64b2d76ce3c1921de3974848fabfda2e215f76830824b31509fa5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c1802cee33337b3ee96e498fb186d08406edc0b9bd76c5ed5770152bee47105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8d6826dbf12e07d533c79794a08c907df51c21a2fc93f7e7e7ec87dee7964a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cacf909ef0797cea2a5528e4466d3463db1c77bbf5a76bcc6434f3e72a6ca51e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2af9ac17f5e80769dc1cfb402e9da093e313b0c072e09abe78a5015e7d16c4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "650f5a9f04911bd5404b60c2de8f406e12cd1f78b45460b342fe3fcee6a625c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "50fad51965e60a64c4f88fdf79f3cb88f582cbcd136a29588c9f19748722c7fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0dc4f45ab5a62e7318c045bcfb77db665c2bce52a4f7d194b3a53693ae83b022", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8efcee76d4ad364bd3665ae090415151348e0ebfce7eaf3f65cad73433bfdbae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4f5536bb63d024365ac1f7cfeb46382ef3c83fa098d573d5a4a3297485c9f105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3c4c28ee1b20ab662d3db1c0d98a6106ead652819998b5197a79363f5a655035", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "48960b86fc04528391963c1bf4eb2cc1372b5e6d95cdb59240504fd794cefb2c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7de3b05cef98dffe4cf7c1eb08ed7048f7291485875d95c43644d3575f2a7464", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250cf8c478790b5eb9ff2cf7cec80e420a6c95506f747ed2da71600951cdff42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "578259c1668e3ba3a9c05d8260f2e3fe8c53ac245211b706edf15694483fa2bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "056c806b021a80b965a8e9d9454ccbe44517abb57c3fdcac35a449c3a928794e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "adef5a9dd838fb78f921d8e1f73adbee19fa0720efc24f949260d3aba6cf0782", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a2dcc700b719f25fac3e69d7943ee7716112e2f2fc7d4a58224778a4bf79bb31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de1f27549ff452e116aacff012b18655c3fbe46642da5502d3c03f80dbb35825", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cad580274feb2c96666516169ea6491ca23436ca351fffc0a6cfa22fedb7ab85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6a4a4cb3192dea3c54995948f985fc0433c5d2d8bc4e189656406dffa0da575", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b1ea0593f03a28049fdd749f01302955562c0c7fa74f626ed990443c04e5a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b58259013db82b50398ab16bfb8f96654f858a96b23f7a381a977a845314e2d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4881eabaa4994249c0b2b675e55437c0f35d7794ba403fb617252016a571a012", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1854fabf39cc4522d771c076e69a428e14c37dcf035967da354aeb3815ed19fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "effe172b2a5e805f2e044420120e42fda45a359341ffd221a67b037517a7a9f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "582ab949c8eeca6ed80e96f78fec992b9d71fda17ebc4eaccc265c948b4606c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "730c1daf6de9b496850fd42556323d38a542ecf6c01833b9eef1369db8863ad8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "789cc80d4fd3714071537c958d4ef807e6ad23f1ea64da549c4a39a14cf4898f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "781ef1854ab07423ba4bf0ab3e7ee925cb58d0c5f8344d0df3c93e88a4741896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26c6a4a506895b59affff539c1f0e578571db2b6001df8fe9872d601f6d95829", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82a7963c214eb0dd3b2f180e0df7aa044db2882bf5d3d8bfe230341684fe5856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5e16ec3be0f2ccc7c28e95bddcb79757ac2c4d776d078d2b104f9a197a5b9aa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "185bbd6ca8d00a5fe097cb38366344da24853ba5905f8cca78434cfa35d19f98", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a4d9574ad43cdee2244bea882a02b480e3039a50c96fc156d81ca10cb472649e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e7bbaf31fbf98e083b5855d1624b323c8e5cde929cb13c0dd971988ac1e34d46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5384ce41d9b99477ffc601954064f8e92aaacbfaa8e04a40b933c1d1139101d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "75f0fa97b7fdb2b56811cb6ca967864a0da344111db9127e346ddd3b726b00af", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9cc70ce409af7feaf4cd45178775e9d267eff8775f6d7e43e168c89dd3ab4347", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "17a90d4602d94ce73604588843eacbfbe2e8636c1fcc0c8aaea293f0dca18c28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d89e7c1b41f23bf421e0cd0d2970f39e94e15972809cd5da09ccbf9c97b105d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1ec5e09d42b79ac2dd22915d37027fdae9e02ef9abb74340314eda4c65e47ce3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dbee004989c2b9caa4394e2039b054d2ba9df4af40b2be962f36d6b6b78ee3be", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "aec387334e29e8b1f8013a357e5d4ec6d8922c3dbe9099e63961769c0ca84939", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d21d6933bd94eb169fa629389643ef375cb72739f19e1cc81d11cecbb59ee20", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "253c832e1f4f69b79c5c1f7e02986cf81d47b20647c832828f8ac561a7b797c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "326148bdef19c436a2eb07180fc25bc7ecf70058c9cc5c61104a164bef2afdf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f85ed8035add441def60d92992f3b458ad65d1df1b3f1934ae9c5c564e998d4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05aaf983932b5d288145e7c2028b219375246636d0a3f8dbde24d771002352d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1a404f9dde85acab25e040b39f94a1199d01646e78e221f70eeb6ff67548d72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26cba078e1604d3f9a2b3cc26ea99bf42ba62c7e049cf2d46a5ecd05b60a7fc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fed3e579f88263c02ab856dc1fe0c68105d949a328e2b874e804ec3abbf8bfe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b76706cd499da75a46176a5dc3a83c5516e53a11ab18e28a2c82e806b2b15204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e87c3d8c9c63d0f0caee3e5650132a334ca1a70ac6d6fa41675750797d9ecb6e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a5c304e2cf0a67eb5601f2ae7049a1289c7aa8a867df2bb58ba7121f845ef3ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "64bdb88f558231e706b9eec9179cdf4d022139af2085a169aac2639023562d7f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "af0cb612d62934c3c22c456cbdc4c33c9f11092bc41321eaf25790cadc64a4da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0c79ec3f4b05788af4c21a84e8e27ac0d3fae8b46b1299a3a364aaa4f61b6c6c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d6d2064ddbbd48570b44bad5d7aaf7698dbf8fb89ed5b535724bb387615e950", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40123": { @@ -345076,7 +359403,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40123", "family_id": "terrain-40115-40124", "job_id": "terrain-40115-40124", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345092,6 +359419,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/candidate.json", "sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eea8c9dace9deb784646fb82f50ab21c3a97bb8e3874d63e1a7d11a1640fb99b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.545085+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"radar\": \"Complete genuine9-cell dish independently located twice in actual checked original Registry mission base:sector_3_wave_4 at row0/col0 and row0/col6. Full assembly1\\u20134 preserves ovoid dish, vertical double rails, horizontal beam, diagonal feed arm pointing lower-left, dark left foot/light right foot, bottom support with red source indicator and down-left ground shadow. All source cell crossings remain continuous; bottom-right40125 comes from second family exact literal crop. Modest facet/rivet/round-hub interpretation is accepted as newly authored detail, with source pose and key landmarks retained.\", \"source_indicator\": \"40124 original single index252 pixel remains exactly1/4/9/16 pixels at scales1/2/3/4. Other new31 tiles have no source dynamic indices, and proposed outputs add none. All compose probes preserve water/fire/single-index palette classes per pixel.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 586d3484558a98a0b48fa2f4b5436af681e85f1a6df6e463b7570c37000d80cc", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40115", + "40116", + "40117", + "40118" + ], + "sha256": "0591a7c752304b489096270b5d2a0b8e621594923b085fdb5a862e14e3225ac2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40119", + "4011a", + "4011b", + "4011c" + ], + "sha256": "da9615e1c2f75e40701c1651cbe53dc38ae7e042b3991938bced6a50e58e9aef", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4011d", + "4011e", + "4011f", + "40120" + ], + "sha256": "8bfbf337ef8847e703c331b872536de05b98948daf471333be9a0a590ff82b3a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40121", + "40122", + "40123", + "40124" + ], + "sha256": "c96258e857361c4996e85dd68a91d7e26c2a38abb1423cb37a519fc57acf3649", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40115-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "81f55f7b76d786bd9967935c30621f87ade4d25286411a022d6d19cda179a87f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db81d7396b38ccfe3207c94073d4215bb5ecae6d7089fc9cd677226977502ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "02ab0db2fad9f9b805b8a0c5e7a6ff1ac21f66aa3d7a129380213f0e56758ff1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc75189e56d6006fa415ed1b26d1543eeee301a623e9a0c745b6d1599ddf6d74", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108de4b5b90a0d4e9a1bb50d2802b500529d0751bd8f74070a31e699b31d02f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bdd322052e50366f686b11ff2dbea2ba169ee86f402bf615b8808ced24674a2e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b50e31f20e6d42025ad8d11862c638418eaa27a95d5972b1e8213070920da03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9a05fef741623c0008ffdd3fbee4357f50f1f43e275f05f65bc115376f952d9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cff578bf5bcc42a48665e288ace0067cf819505acdbb4b4eb47ebab7fce86348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2305e5a91dde4daac3bbcd3753363b1e7873305a8f60bea716ab50a26046eb66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "93e9a2b912ee31c3dbb538e739d5c1deffe2e3ff1b8ff18b01f0cadc8a100769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "157ae2f62916bba51c72138c4f71daceb863256fb4a591c1242f48bef69e7237", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f474433675ca4ca8ac9b25bb470528d9bc6a2f7620873126c204a05d03555553", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a416496d2ffd0ea5e2aac18b4a27c325f79a7c04b43d1b747fc0b24d399749c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9903a18e644f92402afd31b90ff5f33055cf3d8a752204849ac3c557dc90b104", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b849a505d7220afe638b17feb07b28c066a1966166520f4a7b09446c77388f08", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3a12a7d24c56ce771b950fc137295488723b73c8227d5ed092c0a3eac9045b04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d70722dae2e2c470a6ff06d95db19f446c4e5ee188c1811e546e0c28550ae2ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ab755a61b4f29404eae0fc69db6c6daf47f862812c75b8288ddd865594387a8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-original.ppm", + "sha256": "74982df2c178379136049377e64734fc85658e4215b2d0f3add38acd49e92f3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "84bac11cc0d40a51bf48a3dcc84393a2c0a216adde666251fa744b474ac4af6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "451b5925cf64b2d76ce3c1921de3974848fabfda2e215f76830824b31509fa5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c1802cee33337b3ee96e498fb186d08406edc0b9bd76c5ed5770152bee47105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8d6826dbf12e07d533c79794a08c907df51c21a2fc93f7e7e7ec87dee7964a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cacf909ef0797cea2a5528e4466d3463db1c77bbf5a76bcc6434f3e72a6ca51e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2af9ac17f5e80769dc1cfb402e9da093e313b0c072e09abe78a5015e7d16c4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "650f5a9f04911bd5404b60c2de8f406e12cd1f78b45460b342fe3fcee6a625c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "50fad51965e60a64c4f88fdf79f3cb88f582cbcd136a29588c9f19748722c7fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0dc4f45ab5a62e7318c045bcfb77db665c2bce52a4f7d194b3a53693ae83b022", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8efcee76d4ad364bd3665ae090415151348e0ebfce7eaf3f65cad73433bfdbae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4f5536bb63d024365ac1f7cfeb46382ef3c83fa098d573d5a4a3297485c9f105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3c4c28ee1b20ab662d3db1c0d98a6106ead652819998b5197a79363f5a655035", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "48960b86fc04528391963c1bf4eb2cc1372b5e6d95cdb59240504fd794cefb2c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7de3b05cef98dffe4cf7c1eb08ed7048f7291485875d95c43644d3575f2a7464", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250cf8c478790b5eb9ff2cf7cec80e420a6c95506f747ed2da71600951cdff42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "578259c1668e3ba3a9c05d8260f2e3fe8c53ac245211b706edf15694483fa2bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "056c806b021a80b965a8e9d9454ccbe44517abb57c3fdcac35a449c3a928794e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "adef5a9dd838fb78f921d8e1f73adbee19fa0720efc24f949260d3aba6cf0782", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a2dcc700b719f25fac3e69d7943ee7716112e2f2fc7d4a58224778a4bf79bb31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de1f27549ff452e116aacff012b18655c3fbe46642da5502d3c03f80dbb35825", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cad580274feb2c96666516169ea6491ca23436ca351fffc0a6cfa22fedb7ab85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6a4a4cb3192dea3c54995948f985fc0433c5d2d8bc4e189656406dffa0da575", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b1ea0593f03a28049fdd749f01302955562c0c7fa74f626ed990443c04e5a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b58259013db82b50398ab16bfb8f96654f858a96b23f7a381a977a845314e2d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4881eabaa4994249c0b2b675e55437c0f35d7794ba403fb617252016a571a012", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1854fabf39cc4522d771c076e69a428e14c37dcf035967da354aeb3815ed19fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "effe172b2a5e805f2e044420120e42fda45a359341ffd221a67b037517a7a9f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "582ab949c8eeca6ed80e96f78fec992b9d71fda17ebc4eaccc265c948b4606c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "730c1daf6de9b496850fd42556323d38a542ecf6c01833b9eef1369db8863ad8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "789cc80d4fd3714071537c958d4ef807e6ad23f1ea64da549c4a39a14cf4898f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "781ef1854ab07423ba4bf0ab3e7ee925cb58d0c5f8344d0df3c93e88a4741896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26c6a4a506895b59affff539c1f0e578571db2b6001df8fe9872d601f6d95829", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82a7963c214eb0dd3b2f180e0df7aa044db2882bf5d3d8bfe230341684fe5856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5e16ec3be0f2ccc7c28e95bddcb79757ac2c4d776d078d2b104f9a197a5b9aa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "185bbd6ca8d00a5fe097cb38366344da24853ba5905f8cca78434cfa35d19f98", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a4d9574ad43cdee2244bea882a02b480e3039a50c96fc156d81ca10cb472649e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e7bbaf31fbf98e083b5855d1624b323c8e5cde929cb13c0dd971988ac1e34d46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5384ce41d9b99477ffc601954064f8e92aaacbfaa8e04a40b933c1d1139101d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "75f0fa97b7fdb2b56811cb6ca967864a0da344111db9127e346ddd3b726b00af", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9cc70ce409af7feaf4cd45178775e9d267eff8775f6d7e43e168c89dd3ab4347", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "17a90d4602d94ce73604588843eacbfbe2e8636c1fcc0c8aaea293f0dca18c28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d89e7c1b41f23bf421e0cd0d2970f39e94e15972809cd5da09ccbf9c97b105d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1ec5e09d42b79ac2dd22915d37027fdae9e02ef9abb74340314eda4c65e47ce3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dbee004989c2b9caa4394e2039b054d2ba9df4af40b2be962f36d6b6b78ee3be", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "aec387334e29e8b1f8013a357e5d4ec6d8922c3dbe9099e63961769c0ca84939", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d21d6933bd94eb169fa629389643ef375cb72739f19e1cc81d11cecbb59ee20", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "253c832e1f4f69b79c5c1f7e02986cf81d47b20647c832828f8ac561a7b797c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "326148bdef19c436a2eb07180fc25bc7ecf70058c9cc5c61104a164bef2afdf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f85ed8035add441def60d92992f3b458ad65d1df1b3f1934ae9c5c564e998d4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05aaf983932b5d288145e7c2028b219375246636d0a3f8dbde24d771002352d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1a404f9dde85acab25e040b39f94a1199d01646e78e221f70eeb6ff67548d72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26cba078e1604d3f9a2b3cc26ea99bf42ba62c7e049cf2d46a5ecd05b60a7fc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fed3e579f88263c02ab856dc1fe0c68105d949a328e2b874e804ec3abbf8bfe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b76706cd499da75a46176a5dc3a83c5516e53a11ab18e28a2c82e806b2b15204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e87c3d8c9c63d0f0caee3e5650132a334ca1a70ac6d6fa41675750797d9ecb6e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a5c304e2cf0a67eb5601f2ae7049a1289c7aa8a867df2bb58ba7121f845ef3ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "64bdb88f558231e706b9eec9179cdf4d022139af2085a169aac2639023562d7f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "af0cb612d62934c3c22c456cbdc4c33c9f11092bc41321eaf25790cadc64a4da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0c79ec3f4b05788af4c21a84e8e27ac0d3fae8b46b1299a3a364aaa4f61b6c6c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d6d2064ddbbd48570b44bad5d7aaf7698dbf8fb89ed5b535724bb387615e950", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40124": { @@ -345113,7 +359910,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40124", "family_id": "terrain-40115-40124", "job_id": "terrain-40115-40124", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345129,6 +359926,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/candidate.json", "sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "5d3b23240f0868d2964c936846324ba6246744951825ee8589b89f20f4765651", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eea8c9dace9deb784646fb82f50ab21c3a97bb8e3874d63e1a7d11a1640fb99b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.545085+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40115-40124/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"radar\": \"Complete genuine9-cell dish independently located twice in actual checked original Registry mission base:sector_3_wave_4 at row0/col0 and row0/col6. Full assembly1\\u20134 preserves ovoid dish, vertical double rails, horizontal beam, diagonal feed arm pointing lower-left, dark left foot/light right foot, bottom support with red source indicator and down-left ground shadow. All source cell crossings remain continuous; bottom-right40125 comes from second family exact literal crop. Modest facet/rivet/round-hub interpretation is accepted as newly authored detail, with source pose and key landmarks retained.\", \"source_indicator\": \"40124 original single index252 pixel remains exactly1/4/9/16 pixels at scales1/2/3/4. Other new31 tiles have no source dynamic indices, and proposed outputs add none. All compose probes preserve water/fire/single-index palette classes per pixel.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 586d3484558a98a0b48fa2f4b5436af681e85f1a6df6e463b7570c37000d80cc", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40115", + "40116", + "40117", + "40118" + ], + "sha256": "0591a7c752304b489096270b5d2a0b8e621594923b085fdb5a862e14e3225ac2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40119", + "4011a", + "4011b", + "4011c" + ], + "sha256": "da9615e1c2f75e40701c1651cbe53dc38ae7e042b3991938bced6a50e58e9aef", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4011d", + "4011e", + "4011f", + "40120" + ], + "sha256": "8bfbf337ef8847e703c331b872536de05b98948daf471333be9a0a590ff82b3a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40121", + "40122", + "40123", + "40124" + ], + "sha256": "c96258e857361c4996e85dd68a91d7e26c2a38abb1423cb37a519fc57acf3649", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40115-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "81f55f7b76d786bd9967935c30621f87ade4d25286411a022d6d19cda179a87f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db81d7396b38ccfe3207c94073d4215bb5ecae6d7089fc9cd677226977502ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "02ab0db2fad9f9b805b8a0c5e7a6ff1ac21f66aa3d7a129380213f0e56758ff1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bc75189e56d6006fa415ed1b26d1543eeee301a623e9a0c745b6d1599ddf6d74", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40115-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108de4b5b90a0d4e9a1bb50d2802b500529d0751bd8f74070a31e699b31d02f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40115-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bdd322052e50366f686b11ff2dbea2ba169ee86f402bf615b8808ced24674a2e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b50e31f20e6d42025ad8d11862c638418eaa27a95d5972b1e8213070920da03", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9a05fef741623c0008ffdd3fbee4357f50f1f43e275f05f65bc115376f952d9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cff578bf5bcc42a48665e288ace0067cf819505acdbb4b4eb47ebab7fce86348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40116-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2305e5a91dde4daac3bbcd3753363b1e7873305a8f60bea716ab50a26046eb66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40116-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "93e9a2b912ee31c3dbb538e739d5c1deffe2e3ff1b8ff18b01f0cadc8a100769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "157ae2f62916bba51c72138c4f71daceb863256fb4a591c1242f48bef69e7237", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f474433675ca4ca8ac9b25bb470528d9bc6a2f7620873126c204a05d03555553", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a416496d2ffd0ea5e2aac18b4a27c325f79a7c04b43d1b747fc0b24d399749c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40117-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9903a18e644f92402afd31b90ff5f33055cf3d8a752204849ac3c557dc90b104", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40117-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b849a505d7220afe638b17feb07b28c066a1966166520f4a7b09446c77388f08", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3a12a7d24c56ce771b950fc137295488723b73c8227d5ed092c0a3eac9045b04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d70722dae2e2c470a6ff06d95db19f446c4e5ee188c1811e546e0c28550ae2ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ab755a61b4f29404eae0fc69db6c6daf47f862812c75b8288ddd865594387a8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40118-original.ppm", + "sha256": "74982df2c178379136049377e64734fc85658e4215b2d0f3add38acd49e92f3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40118-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "84bac11cc0d40a51bf48a3dcc84393a2c0a216adde666251fa744b474ac4af6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "451b5925cf64b2d76ce3c1921de3974848fabfda2e215f76830824b31509fa5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c1802cee33337b3ee96e498fb186d08406edc0b9bd76c5ed5770152bee47105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8d6826dbf12e07d533c79794a08c907df51c21a2fc93f7e7e7ec87dee7964a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40119-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cacf909ef0797cea2a5528e4466d3463db1c77bbf5a76bcc6434f3e72a6ca51e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40119-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2af9ac17f5e80769dc1cfb402e9da093e313b0c072e09abe78a5015e7d16c4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "650f5a9f04911bd5404b60c2de8f406e12cd1f78b45460b342fe3fcee6a625c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "50fad51965e60a64c4f88fdf79f3cb88f582cbcd136a29588c9f19748722c7fa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0dc4f45ab5a62e7318c045bcfb77db665c2bce52a4f7d194b3a53693ae83b022", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8efcee76d4ad364bd3665ae090415151348e0ebfce7eaf3f65cad73433bfdbae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4f5536bb63d024365ac1f7cfeb46382ef3c83fa098d573d5a4a3297485c9f105", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3c4c28ee1b20ab662d3db1c0d98a6106ead652819998b5197a79363f5a655035", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "48960b86fc04528391963c1bf4eb2cc1372b5e6d95cdb59240504fd794cefb2c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7de3b05cef98dffe4cf7c1eb08ed7048f7291485875d95c43644d3575f2a7464", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250cf8c478790b5eb9ff2cf7cec80e420a6c95506f747ed2da71600951cdff42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "578259c1668e3ba3a9c05d8260f2e3fe8c53ac245211b706edf15694483fa2bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "056c806b021a80b965a8e9d9454ccbe44517abb57c3fdcac35a449c3a928794e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "adef5a9dd838fb78f921d8e1f73adbee19fa0720efc24f949260d3aba6cf0782", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a2dcc700b719f25fac3e69d7943ee7716112e2f2fc7d4a58224778a4bf79bb31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de1f27549ff452e116aacff012b18655c3fbe46642da5502d3c03f80dbb35825", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cad580274feb2c96666516169ea6491ca23436ca351fffc0a6cfa22fedb7ab85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6a4a4cb3192dea3c54995948f985fc0433c5d2d8bc4e189656406dffa0da575", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b1ea0593f03a28049fdd749f01302955562c0c7fa74f626ed990443c04e5a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b58259013db82b50398ab16bfb8f96654f858a96b23f7a381a977a845314e2d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4881eabaa4994249c0b2b675e55437c0f35d7794ba403fb617252016a571a012", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1854fabf39cc4522d771c076e69a428e14c37dcf035967da354aeb3815ed19fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "effe172b2a5e805f2e044420120e42fda45a359341ffd221a67b037517a7a9f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "582ab949c8eeca6ed80e96f78fec992b9d71fda17ebc4eaccc265c948b4606c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "730c1daf6de9b496850fd42556323d38a542ecf6c01833b9eef1369db8863ad8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "789cc80d4fd3714071537c958d4ef807e6ad23f1ea64da549c4a39a14cf4898f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "781ef1854ab07423ba4bf0ab3e7ee925cb58d0c5f8344d0df3c93e88a4741896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26c6a4a506895b59affff539c1f0e578571db2b6001df8fe9872d601f6d95829", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82a7963c214eb0dd3b2f180e0df7aa044db2882bf5d3d8bfe230341684fe5856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5e16ec3be0f2ccc7c28e95bddcb79757ac2c4d776d078d2b104f9a197a5b9aa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "185bbd6ca8d00a5fe097cb38366344da24853ba5905f8cca78434cfa35d19f98", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/4011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a4d9574ad43cdee2244bea882a02b480e3039a50c96fc156d81ca10cb472649e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e7bbaf31fbf98e083b5855d1624b323c8e5cde929cb13c0dd971988ac1e34d46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5384ce41d9b99477ffc601954064f8e92aaacbfaa8e04a40b933c1d1139101d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "75f0fa97b7fdb2b56811cb6ca967864a0da344111db9127e346ddd3b726b00af", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9cc70ce409af7feaf4cd45178775e9d267eff8775f6d7e43e168c89dd3ab4347", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "17a90d4602d94ce73604588843eacbfbe2e8636c1fcc0c8aaea293f0dca18c28", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d89e7c1b41f23bf421e0cd0d2970f39e94e15972809cd5da09ccbf9c97b105d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1ec5e09d42b79ac2dd22915d37027fdae9e02ef9abb74340314eda4c65e47ce3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "dbee004989c2b9caa4394e2039b054d2ba9df4af40b2be962f36d6b6b78ee3be", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "aec387334e29e8b1f8013a357e5d4ec6d8922c3dbe9099e63961769c0ca84939", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d21d6933bd94eb169fa629389643ef375cb72739f19e1cc81d11cecbb59ee20", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "253c832e1f4f69b79c5c1f7e02986cf81d47b20647c832828f8ac561a7b797c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "326148bdef19c436a2eb07180fc25bc7ecf70058c9cc5c61104a164bef2afdf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f85ed8035add441def60d92992f3b458ad65d1df1b3f1934ae9c5c564e998d4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05aaf983932b5d288145e7c2028b219375246636d0a3f8dbde24d771002352d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1a404f9dde85acab25e040b39f94a1199d01646e78e221f70eeb6ff67548d72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26cba078e1604d3f9a2b3cc26ea99bf42ba62c7e049cf2d46a5ecd05b60a7fc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fed3e579f88263c02ab856dc1fe0c68105d949a328e2b874e804ec3abbf8bfe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b76706cd499da75a46176a5dc3a83c5516e53a11ab18e28a2c82e806b2b15204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e87c3d8c9c63d0f0caee3e5650132a334ca1a70ac6d6fa41675750797d9ecb6e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a5c304e2cf0a67eb5601f2ae7049a1289c7aa8a867df2bb58ba7121f845ef3ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "64bdb88f558231e706b9eec9179cdf4d022139af2085a169aac2639023562d7f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "af0cb612d62934c3c22c456cbdc4c33c9f11092bc41321eaf25790cadc64a4da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0c79ec3f4b05788af4c21a84e8e27ac0d3fae8b46b1299a3a364aaa4f61b6c6c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d6d2064ddbbd48570b44bad5d7aaf7698dbf8fb89ed5b535724bb387615e950", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40115-40124/runtime/40124-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40125": { @@ -345150,7 +360417,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40125", "family_id": "terrain-40125-40134", "job_id": "terrain-40125-40134", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345166,6 +360433,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/candidate.json", "sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d1c21018461c039b710ddc6f80de163756ccf01e4a8684fd87323e7dc6f95082", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.733706+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"ground_topography\": \"All five featureless ground variants stay ground; fissures4012e\\u201340131 retain source branching and edge directions; rock clusters40132\\u201340134 retain principal count/location, scale and brown identity. Shared ground atlas cells beyond40134 are outside approval scope; existing40138 rejection preserved.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 88b53b4b2f29bbddb668d5b2b90ed1dbc0e42d3e699f330a01d9e239a3778202", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40125", + "40126", + "40127", + "40128" + ], + "sha256": "ff046123d25c0950738c37fc1125c25b0978d294a0fe79486d96380e9975c5b9", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40129", + "4012a", + "4012b", + "4012c" + ], + "sha256": "cead42d6055c342a23a8fef2251a9972e57838e4d82e103f32899962618f8dbe", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4012d", + "4012e", + "4012f", + "40130" + ], + "sha256": "df7bd16455c07c6bdbf22be44c20980141a623f53f68aed43a97d6122ca000d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40131", + "40132", + "40133", + "40134" + ], + "sha256": "49d8e2721b003e276c18520130472f4ff30509c81f89ba8140f3952c4d1005d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "39b6a46b61ba95278d911b6a80012aa3bd0929a92fbffd43cb928355ec4bef75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c2f42ca88f187a4c55130e7118e0c72e70351ed81b397b9e7e6937535397928", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcd01e3c32f553247de716539710ede996e6ff258c71ed2ea4848f83099c9f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d7fc7ea76f896d0af4095302a2d8bf6a7dc6c0f878c3979053ad366b01584cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b34a2386d71dc6167d267750cd4c1d5a8f7014698ed9f10c46cd7b8e38c21f0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "71313fdc08fd481d9dcaedce2b68ad92c8cea851550f0ba85d4d59c568baca01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c0fcb9f037d549c501fb6516e8cc48a1cc7a4230c37dccbd29a8dd742211e8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b27a3c751273dc563d6d3874c7ec295a65698d2450d2ebae9a92327f0321a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e0b8730d2f291998138cebba411392b730e414102112c38042ba67931ba63e0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "894dc6b28a9adeeed0d863e0fb62fc1d2df28f7b0e2b02be4d721aaa1845647f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "753a6ae1e44c5e43aad89ed68058626342a184cd9ce9009bd0e5e5e1829e9b32", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b65356700fd03566f2f545d9c8dc76e14bef80a6c1d1899d108b759519163d41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a712a1a8cd4e77ef1a4ed71da8c714022a40734fc76d2296ae534149c7dbfb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "31535cec9b1f287c3b5c819bb92c5792fef6e34343366c1b01c758a2551dceb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3237e849259d1fa4bcf62314e98bdc4f4dc2300bd58093c4a4b26e933bcc72d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d1918f3ee5a45bec07e3d386301be6176087df231c6097d29df1b3f65c8615e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "368914f49681185268325652a9f0c61a0b7c59d0bf02d7fd96c90b12ab20f2e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fa8b00511a179327d40781192a981f023c3ae47accaa2b4c2b0487cc85005c97", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "11caeb65c4f04c97f74bbb15b38af1829bed2f1dd465c5804d05fd5356ce7df4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8cfb6dda870a9ae7d0dcac12e09fe385e6aa8fc78cdc383088b2281cb2d44f07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3555970e3f9e2176114f91a4e595c9dd2d848ccd9e46f2c1e5cca9c6200f2298", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bda78fe91e5ceaefe6ae733b70907fcfcbeb5ee8ae66fdc20e2c21103f91c3db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5d85da319cf6e0eb58ee07a136917c9c8c632102b8db1c9b716f6c6a02f8d3a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "667b08a09d94345808eac90f347e51859c5fbe74dd46fd2874a5a0ca87b364c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "dcba38c97e43dcc48320c5fe7e92a0718de7ff6bec63de2c2e4843f6d3b30048", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "804dc0ab5f297799e5717dc9f2aa873efae84f38e512c39d11ebca711ab89ccf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1aeb19f5ae7f55baef504fe8dac4eab7f2b69b61b1a3f8eaeda0b0fef6625072", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f209bd186972159a8019d3138669849376eed03cdfcd915017297205ceacb0d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d6aca5b373bc0d340b0692b99df38936e2c5ecefc7bda3f8a5eb2c73e66ba7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a8b36af129b2d2a631f8a452e5fcf617b7170a9a870205a086e36408e78e1931", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db1b8c298742dbeac2f63b162bfc6d8f7823b784267a689810bed908da320a27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "35a9bcf736d7c10010a8826da2892e238d30be12c161426d87eb877317641aa7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f2ce821f5d33511475772e51bd274c2b37259f4f3429f633fd651aac57ebd83d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4a1b5ed0e794f949c1c29a77b872fde1e0717186d932527e74327e1ee7747631", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52dcc5e7686e826e3181bb68610a962eb7dda62a261a28ba1de1bf9e5f43814c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6f09ead046c0cb0ea4314242d7fecccc5e154894508a33c8ad4a98b362415661", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26aa036da340fd20fd3bd6338113456a7eab81eb606baebe797f6a19ce57ae0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81e001aff228f78b841eb9811904706e35b166248cfc9c7b51b316c63afad887", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4e875c6b021628443495f967091e6a45edb96d8262e5eb3b798d295a4c62362b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30174f98ee63b0f65932816b480baa9e276cc6778d07637b096af7062c739888", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06189914280c66bb3fc98d184848d153dca72952d2c88d8398b2d9c6eb6d13d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "222387972a103fad9390604d4440ce827abf59fd4713bbdf6f8865f33e773ce0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5b692dac2331d4edd2a4751b312a3f6ab08a0e9592589d01d97b6b580c73d606", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f7b0982bc5f2e486520c714078525e7ea006fbb2c0e16ae0c89b0dcecb67401", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80eeb99c1ccc109d9f86371e093a4a5b3808da2b2c62eb50ab63cfd5d89bdf77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bccf61b4cb7cce8b5d144b88edbd2c7868306d91bf0237240f5d2ea419bd4428", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2374513de03d44405106824abf734517d878d5d10af5f5d54d148318664f15ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "92ba61fd81f030eb33d41a7b600baf5684a929790de069c4c0a6e32f18066de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b148a3f285ca3a37b414b3cc0fc0904301f615ece781953f9b5b29a689175806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3206b0490155d47cd32913533ad42c57222ba0714162121fc169f1e40e8405c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "18bb7647dad8ba4fc6fe500e70c2bb879e340e8babf08ed47e66b301b1c5f1c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c60718867c84d32ad512e3749bbf5cfbf2373c5e289314fbf4af08b98de0f8b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "eea762f538e5b1611022e242fdb6bdc18bba987af318e9c6faa2bbf6b47c5152", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1c48504d0b42df33c5de0779c424c34a36e774e074856281e4d3e5f1ef7d9b72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ec2999dff502882b5a2bfb8ea4c7de9f427c01c660d4abf9bbb220367f48bfe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0cf2880c8c1bcff497c2652c8ba32b2368806a687e846df39ca00bd04269f1bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6583d2e7217aae07c769f8cfa84bcc56426f287865b1409c681612ff4905857", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "850b6c9cbf66fde98152a049aa4ece56d9281a5e17fb2e915eb3443ab002c7c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "012346f5fa60e0fb2545cbad81929e12029a2c270d0ece8790eac56df540c140", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1a98f2b5f8c660ba1a29907cc6610006146be0dd76398da79c6cb49ce62cb8ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35fd28460f47e8471b9a3dd8a697aaf978b82be4336c4af69af38684baa1a075", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "44978fab3a43eaddaba266e1b71b640263a23256a873626e2444f553cd0c7fcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "876a8e70267f2b886e189c42aafe58364007ccf288eea862ff15da337fd562ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f19ca34caba18ca28967a7f581c2e6b2b4c89e0fad277b2dfb7e9a6d0a96a47d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab490c204065c976719bc6c7d629496fea98313031e8881eb48bf0ea19900b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "30ea3be2b19e035aa13f5c00f26ca4bfaadffb508d16d66c6250df7f123f9e0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "101158f62d925d76670a9a6b30de77f67f3b143b2eb2f511b59ccc69fa19e1ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2f293da4835a8b403ab2d3a3f7982321fdd9557778b6667fbec83173b97e49", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8a0def269b604915124b11a74a8e6e0fe9c43c916b4551a2d81412894119a28e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a86513a89ed2b7100538d7bc31e724e5dd7dd9371e8af886c07f971d7013f5d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "15d68049b62b5589f7c6fc0aadc57710e5ba0330d28743b352dc21e28903b29c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "38d8923d099ee90c13c820960b6c064f2cbea0312eebf34318ccd20ea895ccbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "99ad2762f3cfc3bc4762d53229a63468452c4fd18139f00118926526c64f3b3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "26cbe0ce5cd528a0a7e7174e44d46274dece5717095d56eea0da83255241b61a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-original.ppm", + "sha256": "928a6d1a802efadadc24db01def7b01cc963202a277bfae37421659da11b01ac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df6dc1a38be8f9594a1faf12e46039608b35df79bf0e0f1981ec63e0de442c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "209718e85a6a3bd19450282cf1b598dbb987f2b7dd0e5ea872ba59c50781fcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "01861bb5ac661535b523a01fb922fdf78d1a1d4f64afa2a7d02fbe0c37505024", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "95a31c3909011cf6a1ebfb0aaf19440e462c0abf2546e74e962a87e80b42610e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a93374608551ced9d3c5903900c2fc182fdaf94a648c5798d248cb95bc13cef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40126": { @@ -345187,7 +360924,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40126", "family_id": "terrain-40125-40134", "job_id": "terrain-40125-40134", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345203,6 +360940,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/candidate.json", "sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d1c21018461c039b710ddc6f80de163756ccf01e4a8684fd87323e7dc6f95082", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.733706+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"ground_topography\": \"All five featureless ground variants stay ground; fissures4012e\\u201340131 retain source branching and edge directions; rock clusters40132\\u201340134 retain principal count/location, scale and brown identity. Shared ground atlas cells beyond40134 are outside approval scope; existing40138 rejection preserved.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 88b53b4b2f29bbddb668d5b2b90ed1dbc0e42d3e699f330a01d9e239a3778202", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40125", + "40126", + "40127", + "40128" + ], + "sha256": "ff046123d25c0950738c37fc1125c25b0978d294a0fe79486d96380e9975c5b9", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40129", + "4012a", + "4012b", + "4012c" + ], + "sha256": "cead42d6055c342a23a8fef2251a9972e57838e4d82e103f32899962618f8dbe", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4012d", + "4012e", + "4012f", + "40130" + ], + "sha256": "df7bd16455c07c6bdbf22be44c20980141a623f53f68aed43a97d6122ca000d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40131", + "40132", + "40133", + "40134" + ], + "sha256": "49d8e2721b003e276c18520130472f4ff30509c81f89ba8140f3952c4d1005d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "39b6a46b61ba95278d911b6a80012aa3bd0929a92fbffd43cb928355ec4bef75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c2f42ca88f187a4c55130e7118e0c72e70351ed81b397b9e7e6937535397928", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcd01e3c32f553247de716539710ede996e6ff258c71ed2ea4848f83099c9f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d7fc7ea76f896d0af4095302a2d8bf6a7dc6c0f878c3979053ad366b01584cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b34a2386d71dc6167d267750cd4c1d5a8f7014698ed9f10c46cd7b8e38c21f0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "71313fdc08fd481d9dcaedce2b68ad92c8cea851550f0ba85d4d59c568baca01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c0fcb9f037d549c501fb6516e8cc48a1cc7a4230c37dccbd29a8dd742211e8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b27a3c751273dc563d6d3874c7ec295a65698d2450d2ebae9a92327f0321a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e0b8730d2f291998138cebba411392b730e414102112c38042ba67931ba63e0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "894dc6b28a9adeeed0d863e0fb62fc1d2df28f7b0e2b02be4d721aaa1845647f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "753a6ae1e44c5e43aad89ed68058626342a184cd9ce9009bd0e5e5e1829e9b32", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b65356700fd03566f2f545d9c8dc76e14bef80a6c1d1899d108b759519163d41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a712a1a8cd4e77ef1a4ed71da8c714022a40734fc76d2296ae534149c7dbfb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "31535cec9b1f287c3b5c819bb92c5792fef6e34343366c1b01c758a2551dceb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3237e849259d1fa4bcf62314e98bdc4f4dc2300bd58093c4a4b26e933bcc72d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d1918f3ee5a45bec07e3d386301be6176087df231c6097d29df1b3f65c8615e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "368914f49681185268325652a9f0c61a0b7c59d0bf02d7fd96c90b12ab20f2e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fa8b00511a179327d40781192a981f023c3ae47accaa2b4c2b0487cc85005c97", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "11caeb65c4f04c97f74bbb15b38af1829bed2f1dd465c5804d05fd5356ce7df4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8cfb6dda870a9ae7d0dcac12e09fe385e6aa8fc78cdc383088b2281cb2d44f07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3555970e3f9e2176114f91a4e595c9dd2d848ccd9e46f2c1e5cca9c6200f2298", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bda78fe91e5ceaefe6ae733b70907fcfcbeb5ee8ae66fdc20e2c21103f91c3db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5d85da319cf6e0eb58ee07a136917c9c8c632102b8db1c9b716f6c6a02f8d3a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "667b08a09d94345808eac90f347e51859c5fbe74dd46fd2874a5a0ca87b364c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "dcba38c97e43dcc48320c5fe7e92a0718de7ff6bec63de2c2e4843f6d3b30048", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "804dc0ab5f297799e5717dc9f2aa873efae84f38e512c39d11ebca711ab89ccf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1aeb19f5ae7f55baef504fe8dac4eab7f2b69b61b1a3f8eaeda0b0fef6625072", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f209bd186972159a8019d3138669849376eed03cdfcd915017297205ceacb0d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d6aca5b373bc0d340b0692b99df38936e2c5ecefc7bda3f8a5eb2c73e66ba7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a8b36af129b2d2a631f8a452e5fcf617b7170a9a870205a086e36408e78e1931", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db1b8c298742dbeac2f63b162bfc6d8f7823b784267a689810bed908da320a27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "35a9bcf736d7c10010a8826da2892e238d30be12c161426d87eb877317641aa7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f2ce821f5d33511475772e51bd274c2b37259f4f3429f633fd651aac57ebd83d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4a1b5ed0e794f949c1c29a77b872fde1e0717186d932527e74327e1ee7747631", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52dcc5e7686e826e3181bb68610a962eb7dda62a261a28ba1de1bf9e5f43814c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6f09ead046c0cb0ea4314242d7fecccc5e154894508a33c8ad4a98b362415661", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26aa036da340fd20fd3bd6338113456a7eab81eb606baebe797f6a19ce57ae0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81e001aff228f78b841eb9811904706e35b166248cfc9c7b51b316c63afad887", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4e875c6b021628443495f967091e6a45edb96d8262e5eb3b798d295a4c62362b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30174f98ee63b0f65932816b480baa9e276cc6778d07637b096af7062c739888", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06189914280c66bb3fc98d184848d153dca72952d2c88d8398b2d9c6eb6d13d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "222387972a103fad9390604d4440ce827abf59fd4713bbdf6f8865f33e773ce0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5b692dac2331d4edd2a4751b312a3f6ab08a0e9592589d01d97b6b580c73d606", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f7b0982bc5f2e486520c714078525e7ea006fbb2c0e16ae0c89b0dcecb67401", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80eeb99c1ccc109d9f86371e093a4a5b3808da2b2c62eb50ab63cfd5d89bdf77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bccf61b4cb7cce8b5d144b88edbd2c7868306d91bf0237240f5d2ea419bd4428", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2374513de03d44405106824abf734517d878d5d10af5f5d54d148318664f15ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "92ba61fd81f030eb33d41a7b600baf5684a929790de069c4c0a6e32f18066de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b148a3f285ca3a37b414b3cc0fc0904301f615ece781953f9b5b29a689175806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3206b0490155d47cd32913533ad42c57222ba0714162121fc169f1e40e8405c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "18bb7647dad8ba4fc6fe500e70c2bb879e340e8babf08ed47e66b301b1c5f1c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c60718867c84d32ad512e3749bbf5cfbf2373c5e289314fbf4af08b98de0f8b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "eea762f538e5b1611022e242fdb6bdc18bba987af318e9c6faa2bbf6b47c5152", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1c48504d0b42df33c5de0779c424c34a36e774e074856281e4d3e5f1ef7d9b72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ec2999dff502882b5a2bfb8ea4c7de9f427c01c660d4abf9bbb220367f48bfe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0cf2880c8c1bcff497c2652c8ba32b2368806a687e846df39ca00bd04269f1bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6583d2e7217aae07c769f8cfa84bcc56426f287865b1409c681612ff4905857", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "850b6c9cbf66fde98152a049aa4ece56d9281a5e17fb2e915eb3443ab002c7c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "012346f5fa60e0fb2545cbad81929e12029a2c270d0ece8790eac56df540c140", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1a98f2b5f8c660ba1a29907cc6610006146be0dd76398da79c6cb49ce62cb8ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35fd28460f47e8471b9a3dd8a697aaf978b82be4336c4af69af38684baa1a075", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "44978fab3a43eaddaba266e1b71b640263a23256a873626e2444f553cd0c7fcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "876a8e70267f2b886e189c42aafe58364007ccf288eea862ff15da337fd562ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f19ca34caba18ca28967a7f581c2e6b2b4c89e0fad277b2dfb7e9a6d0a96a47d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab490c204065c976719bc6c7d629496fea98313031e8881eb48bf0ea19900b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "30ea3be2b19e035aa13f5c00f26ca4bfaadffb508d16d66c6250df7f123f9e0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "101158f62d925d76670a9a6b30de77f67f3b143b2eb2f511b59ccc69fa19e1ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2f293da4835a8b403ab2d3a3f7982321fdd9557778b6667fbec83173b97e49", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8a0def269b604915124b11a74a8e6e0fe9c43c916b4551a2d81412894119a28e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a86513a89ed2b7100538d7bc31e724e5dd7dd9371e8af886c07f971d7013f5d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "15d68049b62b5589f7c6fc0aadc57710e5ba0330d28743b352dc21e28903b29c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "38d8923d099ee90c13c820960b6c064f2cbea0312eebf34318ccd20ea895ccbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "99ad2762f3cfc3bc4762d53229a63468452c4fd18139f00118926526c64f3b3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "26cbe0ce5cd528a0a7e7174e44d46274dece5717095d56eea0da83255241b61a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-original.ppm", + "sha256": "928a6d1a802efadadc24db01def7b01cc963202a277bfae37421659da11b01ac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df6dc1a38be8f9594a1faf12e46039608b35df79bf0e0f1981ec63e0de442c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "209718e85a6a3bd19450282cf1b598dbb987f2b7dd0e5ea872ba59c50781fcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "01861bb5ac661535b523a01fb922fdf78d1a1d4f64afa2a7d02fbe0c37505024", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "95a31c3909011cf6a1ebfb0aaf19440e462c0abf2546e74e962a87e80b42610e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a93374608551ced9d3c5903900c2fc182fdaf94a648c5798d248cb95bc13cef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40127": { @@ -345224,7 +361431,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40127", "family_id": "terrain-40125-40134", "job_id": "terrain-40125-40134", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345240,6 +361447,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/candidate.json", "sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d1c21018461c039b710ddc6f80de163756ccf01e4a8684fd87323e7dc6f95082", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.733706+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"ground_topography\": \"All five featureless ground variants stay ground; fissures4012e\\u201340131 retain source branching and edge directions; rock clusters40132\\u201340134 retain principal count/location, scale and brown identity. Shared ground atlas cells beyond40134 are outside approval scope; existing40138 rejection preserved.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 88b53b4b2f29bbddb668d5b2b90ed1dbc0e42d3e699f330a01d9e239a3778202", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40125", + "40126", + "40127", + "40128" + ], + "sha256": "ff046123d25c0950738c37fc1125c25b0978d294a0fe79486d96380e9975c5b9", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40129", + "4012a", + "4012b", + "4012c" + ], + "sha256": "cead42d6055c342a23a8fef2251a9972e57838e4d82e103f32899962618f8dbe", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4012d", + "4012e", + "4012f", + "40130" + ], + "sha256": "df7bd16455c07c6bdbf22be44c20980141a623f53f68aed43a97d6122ca000d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40131", + "40132", + "40133", + "40134" + ], + "sha256": "49d8e2721b003e276c18520130472f4ff30509c81f89ba8140f3952c4d1005d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "39b6a46b61ba95278d911b6a80012aa3bd0929a92fbffd43cb928355ec4bef75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c2f42ca88f187a4c55130e7118e0c72e70351ed81b397b9e7e6937535397928", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcd01e3c32f553247de716539710ede996e6ff258c71ed2ea4848f83099c9f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d7fc7ea76f896d0af4095302a2d8bf6a7dc6c0f878c3979053ad366b01584cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b34a2386d71dc6167d267750cd4c1d5a8f7014698ed9f10c46cd7b8e38c21f0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "71313fdc08fd481d9dcaedce2b68ad92c8cea851550f0ba85d4d59c568baca01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c0fcb9f037d549c501fb6516e8cc48a1cc7a4230c37dccbd29a8dd742211e8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b27a3c751273dc563d6d3874c7ec295a65698d2450d2ebae9a92327f0321a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e0b8730d2f291998138cebba411392b730e414102112c38042ba67931ba63e0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "894dc6b28a9adeeed0d863e0fb62fc1d2df28f7b0e2b02be4d721aaa1845647f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "753a6ae1e44c5e43aad89ed68058626342a184cd9ce9009bd0e5e5e1829e9b32", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b65356700fd03566f2f545d9c8dc76e14bef80a6c1d1899d108b759519163d41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a712a1a8cd4e77ef1a4ed71da8c714022a40734fc76d2296ae534149c7dbfb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "31535cec9b1f287c3b5c819bb92c5792fef6e34343366c1b01c758a2551dceb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3237e849259d1fa4bcf62314e98bdc4f4dc2300bd58093c4a4b26e933bcc72d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d1918f3ee5a45bec07e3d386301be6176087df231c6097d29df1b3f65c8615e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "368914f49681185268325652a9f0c61a0b7c59d0bf02d7fd96c90b12ab20f2e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fa8b00511a179327d40781192a981f023c3ae47accaa2b4c2b0487cc85005c97", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "11caeb65c4f04c97f74bbb15b38af1829bed2f1dd465c5804d05fd5356ce7df4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8cfb6dda870a9ae7d0dcac12e09fe385e6aa8fc78cdc383088b2281cb2d44f07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3555970e3f9e2176114f91a4e595c9dd2d848ccd9e46f2c1e5cca9c6200f2298", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bda78fe91e5ceaefe6ae733b70907fcfcbeb5ee8ae66fdc20e2c21103f91c3db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5d85da319cf6e0eb58ee07a136917c9c8c632102b8db1c9b716f6c6a02f8d3a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "667b08a09d94345808eac90f347e51859c5fbe74dd46fd2874a5a0ca87b364c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "dcba38c97e43dcc48320c5fe7e92a0718de7ff6bec63de2c2e4843f6d3b30048", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "804dc0ab5f297799e5717dc9f2aa873efae84f38e512c39d11ebca711ab89ccf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1aeb19f5ae7f55baef504fe8dac4eab7f2b69b61b1a3f8eaeda0b0fef6625072", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f209bd186972159a8019d3138669849376eed03cdfcd915017297205ceacb0d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d6aca5b373bc0d340b0692b99df38936e2c5ecefc7bda3f8a5eb2c73e66ba7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a8b36af129b2d2a631f8a452e5fcf617b7170a9a870205a086e36408e78e1931", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db1b8c298742dbeac2f63b162bfc6d8f7823b784267a689810bed908da320a27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "35a9bcf736d7c10010a8826da2892e238d30be12c161426d87eb877317641aa7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f2ce821f5d33511475772e51bd274c2b37259f4f3429f633fd651aac57ebd83d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4a1b5ed0e794f949c1c29a77b872fde1e0717186d932527e74327e1ee7747631", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52dcc5e7686e826e3181bb68610a962eb7dda62a261a28ba1de1bf9e5f43814c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6f09ead046c0cb0ea4314242d7fecccc5e154894508a33c8ad4a98b362415661", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26aa036da340fd20fd3bd6338113456a7eab81eb606baebe797f6a19ce57ae0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81e001aff228f78b841eb9811904706e35b166248cfc9c7b51b316c63afad887", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4e875c6b021628443495f967091e6a45edb96d8262e5eb3b798d295a4c62362b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30174f98ee63b0f65932816b480baa9e276cc6778d07637b096af7062c739888", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06189914280c66bb3fc98d184848d153dca72952d2c88d8398b2d9c6eb6d13d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "222387972a103fad9390604d4440ce827abf59fd4713bbdf6f8865f33e773ce0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5b692dac2331d4edd2a4751b312a3f6ab08a0e9592589d01d97b6b580c73d606", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f7b0982bc5f2e486520c714078525e7ea006fbb2c0e16ae0c89b0dcecb67401", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80eeb99c1ccc109d9f86371e093a4a5b3808da2b2c62eb50ab63cfd5d89bdf77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bccf61b4cb7cce8b5d144b88edbd2c7868306d91bf0237240f5d2ea419bd4428", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2374513de03d44405106824abf734517d878d5d10af5f5d54d148318664f15ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "92ba61fd81f030eb33d41a7b600baf5684a929790de069c4c0a6e32f18066de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b148a3f285ca3a37b414b3cc0fc0904301f615ece781953f9b5b29a689175806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3206b0490155d47cd32913533ad42c57222ba0714162121fc169f1e40e8405c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "18bb7647dad8ba4fc6fe500e70c2bb879e340e8babf08ed47e66b301b1c5f1c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c60718867c84d32ad512e3749bbf5cfbf2373c5e289314fbf4af08b98de0f8b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "eea762f538e5b1611022e242fdb6bdc18bba987af318e9c6faa2bbf6b47c5152", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1c48504d0b42df33c5de0779c424c34a36e774e074856281e4d3e5f1ef7d9b72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ec2999dff502882b5a2bfb8ea4c7de9f427c01c660d4abf9bbb220367f48bfe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0cf2880c8c1bcff497c2652c8ba32b2368806a687e846df39ca00bd04269f1bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6583d2e7217aae07c769f8cfa84bcc56426f287865b1409c681612ff4905857", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "850b6c9cbf66fde98152a049aa4ece56d9281a5e17fb2e915eb3443ab002c7c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "012346f5fa60e0fb2545cbad81929e12029a2c270d0ece8790eac56df540c140", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1a98f2b5f8c660ba1a29907cc6610006146be0dd76398da79c6cb49ce62cb8ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35fd28460f47e8471b9a3dd8a697aaf978b82be4336c4af69af38684baa1a075", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "44978fab3a43eaddaba266e1b71b640263a23256a873626e2444f553cd0c7fcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "876a8e70267f2b886e189c42aafe58364007ccf288eea862ff15da337fd562ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f19ca34caba18ca28967a7f581c2e6b2b4c89e0fad277b2dfb7e9a6d0a96a47d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab490c204065c976719bc6c7d629496fea98313031e8881eb48bf0ea19900b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "30ea3be2b19e035aa13f5c00f26ca4bfaadffb508d16d66c6250df7f123f9e0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "101158f62d925d76670a9a6b30de77f67f3b143b2eb2f511b59ccc69fa19e1ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2f293da4835a8b403ab2d3a3f7982321fdd9557778b6667fbec83173b97e49", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8a0def269b604915124b11a74a8e6e0fe9c43c916b4551a2d81412894119a28e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a86513a89ed2b7100538d7bc31e724e5dd7dd9371e8af886c07f971d7013f5d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "15d68049b62b5589f7c6fc0aadc57710e5ba0330d28743b352dc21e28903b29c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "38d8923d099ee90c13c820960b6c064f2cbea0312eebf34318ccd20ea895ccbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "99ad2762f3cfc3bc4762d53229a63468452c4fd18139f00118926526c64f3b3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "26cbe0ce5cd528a0a7e7174e44d46274dece5717095d56eea0da83255241b61a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-original.ppm", + "sha256": "928a6d1a802efadadc24db01def7b01cc963202a277bfae37421659da11b01ac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df6dc1a38be8f9594a1faf12e46039608b35df79bf0e0f1981ec63e0de442c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "209718e85a6a3bd19450282cf1b598dbb987f2b7dd0e5ea872ba59c50781fcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "01861bb5ac661535b523a01fb922fdf78d1a1d4f64afa2a7d02fbe0c37505024", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "95a31c3909011cf6a1ebfb0aaf19440e462c0abf2546e74e962a87e80b42610e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a93374608551ced9d3c5903900c2fc182fdaf94a648c5798d248cb95bc13cef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40128": { @@ -345261,7 +361938,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40128", "family_id": "terrain-40125-40134", "job_id": "terrain-40125-40134", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345277,6 +361954,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/candidate.json", "sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d1c21018461c039b710ddc6f80de163756ccf01e4a8684fd87323e7dc6f95082", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.733706+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"ground_topography\": \"All five featureless ground variants stay ground; fissures4012e\\u201340131 retain source branching and edge directions; rock clusters40132\\u201340134 retain principal count/location, scale and brown identity. Shared ground atlas cells beyond40134 are outside approval scope; existing40138 rejection preserved.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 88b53b4b2f29bbddb668d5b2b90ed1dbc0e42d3e699f330a01d9e239a3778202", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40125", + "40126", + "40127", + "40128" + ], + "sha256": "ff046123d25c0950738c37fc1125c25b0978d294a0fe79486d96380e9975c5b9", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40129", + "4012a", + "4012b", + "4012c" + ], + "sha256": "cead42d6055c342a23a8fef2251a9972e57838e4d82e103f32899962618f8dbe", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4012d", + "4012e", + "4012f", + "40130" + ], + "sha256": "df7bd16455c07c6bdbf22be44c20980141a623f53f68aed43a97d6122ca000d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40131", + "40132", + "40133", + "40134" + ], + "sha256": "49d8e2721b003e276c18520130472f4ff30509c81f89ba8140f3952c4d1005d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "39b6a46b61ba95278d911b6a80012aa3bd0929a92fbffd43cb928355ec4bef75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c2f42ca88f187a4c55130e7118e0c72e70351ed81b397b9e7e6937535397928", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcd01e3c32f553247de716539710ede996e6ff258c71ed2ea4848f83099c9f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d7fc7ea76f896d0af4095302a2d8bf6a7dc6c0f878c3979053ad366b01584cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b34a2386d71dc6167d267750cd4c1d5a8f7014698ed9f10c46cd7b8e38c21f0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "71313fdc08fd481d9dcaedce2b68ad92c8cea851550f0ba85d4d59c568baca01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c0fcb9f037d549c501fb6516e8cc48a1cc7a4230c37dccbd29a8dd742211e8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b27a3c751273dc563d6d3874c7ec295a65698d2450d2ebae9a92327f0321a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e0b8730d2f291998138cebba411392b730e414102112c38042ba67931ba63e0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "894dc6b28a9adeeed0d863e0fb62fc1d2df28f7b0e2b02be4d721aaa1845647f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "753a6ae1e44c5e43aad89ed68058626342a184cd9ce9009bd0e5e5e1829e9b32", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b65356700fd03566f2f545d9c8dc76e14bef80a6c1d1899d108b759519163d41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a712a1a8cd4e77ef1a4ed71da8c714022a40734fc76d2296ae534149c7dbfb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "31535cec9b1f287c3b5c819bb92c5792fef6e34343366c1b01c758a2551dceb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3237e849259d1fa4bcf62314e98bdc4f4dc2300bd58093c4a4b26e933bcc72d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d1918f3ee5a45bec07e3d386301be6176087df231c6097d29df1b3f65c8615e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "368914f49681185268325652a9f0c61a0b7c59d0bf02d7fd96c90b12ab20f2e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fa8b00511a179327d40781192a981f023c3ae47accaa2b4c2b0487cc85005c97", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "11caeb65c4f04c97f74bbb15b38af1829bed2f1dd465c5804d05fd5356ce7df4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8cfb6dda870a9ae7d0dcac12e09fe385e6aa8fc78cdc383088b2281cb2d44f07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3555970e3f9e2176114f91a4e595c9dd2d848ccd9e46f2c1e5cca9c6200f2298", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bda78fe91e5ceaefe6ae733b70907fcfcbeb5ee8ae66fdc20e2c21103f91c3db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5d85da319cf6e0eb58ee07a136917c9c8c632102b8db1c9b716f6c6a02f8d3a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "667b08a09d94345808eac90f347e51859c5fbe74dd46fd2874a5a0ca87b364c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "dcba38c97e43dcc48320c5fe7e92a0718de7ff6bec63de2c2e4843f6d3b30048", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "804dc0ab5f297799e5717dc9f2aa873efae84f38e512c39d11ebca711ab89ccf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1aeb19f5ae7f55baef504fe8dac4eab7f2b69b61b1a3f8eaeda0b0fef6625072", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f209bd186972159a8019d3138669849376eed03cdfcd915017297205ceacb0d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d6aca5b373bc0d340b0692b99df38936e2c5ecefc7bda3f8a5eb2c73e66ba7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a8b36af129b2d2a631f8a452e5fcf617b7170a9a870205a086e36408e78e1931", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db1b8c298742dbeac2f63b162bfc6d8f7823b784267a689810bed908da320a27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "35a9bcf736d7c10010a8826da2892e238d30be12c161426d87eb877317641aa7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f2ce821f5d33511475772e51bd274c2b37259f4f3429f633fd651aac57ebd83d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4a1b5ed0e794f949c1c29a77b872fde1e0717186d932527e74327e1ee7747631", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52dcc5e7686e826e3181bb68610a962eb7dda62a261a28ba1de1bf9e5f43814c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6f09ead046c0cb0ea4314242d7fecccc5e154894508a33c8ad4a98b362415661", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26aa036da340fd20fd3bd6338113456a7eab81eb606baebe797f6a19ce57ae0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81e001aff228f78b841eb9811904706e35b166248cfc9c7b51b316c63afad887", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4e875c6b021628443495f967091e6a45edb96d8262e5eb3b798d295a4c62362b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30174f98ee63b0f65932816b480baa9e276cc6778d07637b096af7062c739888", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06189914280c66bb3fc98d184848d153dca72952d2c88d8398b2d9c6eb6d13d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "222387972a103fad9390604d4440ce827abf59fd4713bbdf6f8865f33e773ce0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5b692dac2331d4edd2a4751b312a3f6ab08a0e9592589d01d97b6b580c73d606", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f7b0982bc5f2e486520c714078525e7ea006fbb2c0e16ae0c89b0dcecb67401", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80eeb99c1ccc109d9f86371e093a4a5b3808da2b2c62eb50ab63cfd5d89bdf77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bccf61b4cb7cce8b5d144b88edbd2c7868306d91bf0237240f5d2ea419bd4428", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2374513de03d44405106824abf734517d878d5d10af5f5d54d148318664f15ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "92ba61fd81f030eb33d41a7b600baf5684a929790de069c4c0a6e32f18066de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b148a3f285ca3a37b414b3cc0fc0904301f615ece781953f9b5b29a689175806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3206b0490155d47cd32913533ad42c57222ba0714162121fc169f1e40e8405c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "18bb7647dad8ba4fc6fe500e70c2bb879e340e8babf08ed47e66b301b1c5f1c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c60718867c84d32ad512e3749bbf5cfbf2373c5e289314fbf4af08b98de0f8b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "eea762f538e5b1611022e242fdb6bdc18bba987af318e9c6faa2bbf6b47c5152", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1c48504d0b42df33c5de0779c424c34a36e774e074856281e4d3e5f1ef7d9b72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ec2999dff502882b5a2bfb8ea4c7de9f427c01c660d4abf9bbb220367f48bfe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0cf2880c8c1bcff497c2652c8ba32b2368806a687e846df39ca00bd04269f1bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6583d2e7217aae07c769f8cfa84bcc56426f287865b1409c681612ff4905857", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "850b6c9cbf66fde98152a049aa4ece56d9281a5e17fb2e915eb3443ab002c7c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "012346f5fa60e0fb2545cbad81929e12029a2c270d0ece8790eac56df540c140", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1a98f2b5f8c660ba1a29907cc6610006146be0dd76398da79c6cb49ce62cb8ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35fd28460f47e8471b9a3dd8a697aaf978b82be4336c4af69af38684baa1a075", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "44978fab3a43eaddaba266e1b71b640263a23256a873626e2444f553cd0c7fcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "876a8e70267f2b886e189c42aafe58364007ccf288eea862ff15da337fd562ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f19ca34caba18ca28967a7f581c2e6b2b4c89e0fad277b2dfb7e9a6d0a96a47d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab490c204065c976719bc6c7d629496fea98313031e8881eb48bf0ea19900b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "30ea3be2b19e035aa13f5c00f26ca4bfaadffb508d16d66c6250df7f123f9e0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "101158f62d925d76670a9a6b30de77f67f3b143b2eb2f511b59ccc69fa19e1ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2f293da4835a8b403ab2d3a3f7982321fdd9557778b6667fbec83173b97e49", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8a0def269b604915124b11a74a8e6e0fe9c43c916b4551a2d81412894119a28e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a86513a89ed2b7100538d7bc31e724e5dd7dd9371e8af886c07f971d7013f5d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "15d68049b62b5589f7c6fc0aadc57710e5ba0330d28743b352dc21e28903b29c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "38d8923d099ee90c13c820960b6c064f2cbea0312eebf34318ccd20ea895ccbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "99ad2762f3cfc3bc4762d53229a63468452c4fd18139f00118926526c64f3b3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "26cbe0ce5cd528a0a7e7174e44d46274dece5717095d56eea0da83255241b61a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-original.ppm", + "sha256": "928a6d1a802efadadc24db01def7b01cc963202a277bfae37421659da11b01ac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df6dc1a38be8f9594a1faf12e46039608b35df79bf0e0f1981ec63e0de442c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "209718e85a6a3bd19450282cf1b598dbb987f2b7dd0e5ea872ba59c50781fcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "01861bb5ac661535b523a01fb922fdf78d1a1d4f64afa2a7d02fbe0c37505024", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "95a31c3909011cf6a1ebfb0aaf19440e462c0abf2546e74e962a87e80b42610e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a93374608551ced9d3c5903900c2fc182fdaf94a648c5798d248cb95bc13cef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40129": { @@ -345298,7 +362445,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40129", "family_id": "terrain-40125-40134", "job_id": "terrain-40125-40134", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345314,6 +362461,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/candidate.json", "sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d1c21018461c039b710ddc6f80de163756ccf01e4a8684fd87323e7dc6f95082", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.733706+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"ground_topography\": \"All five featureless ground variants stay ground; fissures4012e\\u201340131 retain source branching and edge directions; rock clusters40132\\u201340134 retain principal count/location, scale and brown identity. Shared ground atlas cells beyond40134 are outside approval scope; existing40138 rejection preserved.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 88b53b4b2f29bbddb668d5b2b90ed1dbc0e42d3e699f330a01d9e239a3778202", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40125", + "40126", + "40127", + "40128" + ], + "sha256": "ff046123d25c0950738c37fc1125c25b0978d294a0fe79486d96380e9975c5b9", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40129", + "4012a", + "4012b", + "4012c" + ], + "sha256": "cead42d6055c342a23a8fef2251a9972e57838e4d82e103f32899962618f8dbe", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4012d", + "4012e", + "4012f", + "40130" + ], + "sha256": "df7bd16455c07c6bdbf22be44c20980141a623f53f68aed43a97d6122ca000d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40131", + "40132", + "40133", + "40134" + ], + "sha256": "49d8e2721b003e276c18520130472f4ff30509c81f89ba8140f3952c4d1005d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "39b6a46b61ba95278d911b6a80012aa3bd0929a92fbffd43cb928355ec4bef75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c2f42ca88f187a4c55130e7118e0c72e70351ed81b397b9e7e6937535397928", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcd01e3c32f553247de716539710ede996e6ff258c71ed2ea4848f83099c9f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d7fc7ea76f896d0af4095302a2d8bf6a7dc6c0f878c3979053ad366b01584cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b34a2386d71dc6167d267750cd4c1d5a8f7014698ed9f10c46cd7b8e38c21f0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "71313fdc08fd481d9dcaedce2b68ad92c8cea851550f0ba85d4d59c568baca01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c0fcb9f037d549c501fb6516e8cc48a1cc7a4230c37dccbd29a8dd742211e8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b27a3c751273dc563d6d3874c7ec295a65698d2450d2ebae9a92327f0321a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e0b8730d2f291998138cebba411392b730e414102112c38042ba67931ba63e0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "894dc6b28a9adeeed0d863e0fb62fc1d2df28f7b0e2b02be4d721aaa1845647f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "753a6ae1e44c5e43aad89ed68058626342a184cd9ce9009bd0e5e5e1829e9b32", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b65356700fd03566f2f545d9c8dc76e14bef80a6c1d1899d108b759519163d41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a712a1a8cd4e77ef1a4ed71da8c714022a40734fc76d2296ae534149c7dbfb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "31535cec9b1f287c3b5c819bb92c5792fef6e34343366c1b01c758a2551dceb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3237e849259d1fa4bcf62314e98bdc4f4dc2300bd58093c4a4b26e933bcc72d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d1918f3ee5a45bec07e3d386301be6176087df231c6097d29df1b3f65c8615e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "368914f49681185268325652a9f0c61a0b7c59d0bf02d7fd96c90b12ab20f2e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fa8b00511a179327d40781192a981f023c3ae47accaa2b4c2b0487cc85005c97", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "11caeb65c4f04c97f74bbb15b38af1829bed2f1dd465c5804d05fd5356ce7df4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8cfb6dda870a9ae7d0dcac12e09fe385e6aa8fc78cdc383088b2281cb2d44f07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3555970e3f9e2176114f91a4e595c9dd2d848ccd9e46f2c1e5cca9c6200f2298", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bda78fe91e5ceaefe6ae733b70907fcfcbeb5ee8ae66fdc20e2c21103f91c3db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5d85da319cf6e0eb58ee07a136917c9c8c632102b8db1c9b716f6c6a02f8d3a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "667b08a09d94345808eac90f347e51859c5fbe74dd46fd2874a5a0ca87b364c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "dcba38c97e43dcc48320c5fe7e92a0718de7ff6bec63de2c2e4843f6d3b30048", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "804dc0ab5f297799e5717dc9f2aa873efae84f38e512c39d11ebca711ab89ccf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1aeb19f5ae7f55baef504fe8dac4eab7f2b69b61b1a3f8eaeda0b0fef6625072", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f209bd186972159a8019d3138669849376eed03cdfcd915017297205ceacb0d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d6aca5b373bc0d340b0692b99df38936e2c5ecefc7bda3f8a5eb2c73e66ba7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a8b36af129b2d2a631f8a452e5fcf617b7170a9a870205a086e36408e78e1931", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db1b8c298742dbeac2f63b162bfc6d8f7823b784267a689810bed908da320a27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "35a9bcf736d7c10010a8826da2892e238d30be12c161426d87eb877317641aa7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f2ce821f5d33511475772e51bd274c2b37259f4f3429f633fd651aac57ebd83d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4a1b5ed0e794f949c1c29a77b872fde1e0717186d932527e74327e1ee7747631", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52dcc5e7686e826e3181bb68610a962eb7dda62a261a28ba1de1bf9e5f43814c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6f09ead046c0cb0ea4314242d7fecccc5e154894508a33c8ad4a98b362415661", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26aa036da340fd20fd3bd6338113456a7eab81eb606baebe797f6a19ce57ae0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81e001aff228f78b841eb9811904706e35b166248cfc9c7b51b316c63afad887", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4e875c6b021628443495f967091e6a45edb96d8262e5eb3b798d295a4c62362b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30174f98ee63b0f65932816b480baa9e276cc6778d07637b096af7062c739888", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06189914280c66bb3fc98d184848d153dca72952d2c88d8398b2d9c6eb6d13d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "222387972a103fad9390604d4440ce827abf59fd4713bbdf6f8865f33e773ce0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5b692dac2331d4edd2a4751b312a3f6ab08a0e9592589d01d97b6b580c73d606", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f7b0982bc5f2e486520c714078525e7ea006fbb2c0e16ae0c89b0dcecb67401", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80eeb99c1ccc109d9f86371e093a4a5b3808da2b2c62eb50ab63cfd5d89bdf77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bccf61b4cb7cce8b5d144b88edbd2c7868306d91bf0237240f5d2ea419bd4428", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2374513de03d44405106824abf734517d878d5d10af5f5d54d148318664f15ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "92ba61fd81f030eb33d41a7b600baf5684a929790de069c4c0a6e32f18066de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b148a3f285ca3a37b414b3cc0fc0904301f615ece781953f9b5b29a689175806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3206b0490155d47cd32913533ad42c57222ba0714162121fc169f1e40e8405c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "18bb7647dad8ba4fc6fe500e70c2bb879e340e8babf08ed47e66b301b1c5f1c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c60718867c84d32ad512e3749bbf5cfbf2373c5e289314fbf4af08b98de0f8b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "eea762f538e5b1611022e242fdb6bdc18bba987af318e9c6faa2bbf6b47c5152", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1c48504d0b42df33c5de0779c424c34a36e774e074856281e4d3e5f1ef7d9b72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ec2999dff502882b5a2bfb8ea4c7de9f427c01c660d4abf9bbb220367f48bfe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0cf2880c8c1bcff497c2652c8ba32b2368806a687e846df39ca00bd04269f1bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6583d2e7217aae07c769f8cfa84bcc56426f287865b1409c681612ff4905857", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "850b6c9cbf66fde98152a049aa4ece56d9281a5e17fb2e915eb3443ab002c7c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "012346f5fa60e0fb2545cbad81929e12029a2c270d0ece8790eac56df540c140", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1a98f2b5f8c660ba1a29907cc6610006146be0dd76398da79c6cb49ce62cb8ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35fd28460f47e8471b9a3dd8a697aaf978b82be4336c4af69af38684baa1a075", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "44978fab3a43eaddaba266e1b71b640263a23256a873626e2444f553cd0c7fcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "876a8e70267f2b886e189c42aafe58364007ccf288eea862ff15da337fd562ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f19ca34caba18ca28967a7f581c2e6b2b4c89e0fad277b2dfb7e9a6d0a96a47d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab490c204065c976719bc6c7d629496fea98313031e8881eb48bf0ea19900b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "30ea3be2b19e035aa13f5c00f26ca4bfaadffb508d16d66c6250df7f123f9e0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "101158f62d925d76670a9a6b30de77f67f3b143b2eb2f511b59ccc69fa19e1ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2f293da4835a8b403ab2d3a3f7982321fdd9557778b6667fbec83173b97e49", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8a0def269b604915124b11a74a8e6e0fe9c43c916b4551a2d81412894119a28e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a86513a89ed2b7100538d7bc31e724e5dd7dd9371e8af886c07f971d7013f5d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "15d68049b62b5589f7c6fc0aadc57710e5ba0330d28743b352dc21e28903b29c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "38d8923d099ee90c13c820960b6c064f2cbea0312eebf34318ccd20ea895ccbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "99ad2762f3cfc3bc4762d53229a63468452c4fd18139f00118926526c64f3b3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "26cbe0ce5cd528a0a7e7174e44d46274dece5717095d56eea0da83255241b61a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-original.ppm", + "sha256": "928a6d1a802efadadc24db01def7b01cc963202a277bfae37421659da11b01ac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df6dc1a38be8f9594a1faf12e46039608b35df79bf0e0f1981ec63e0de442c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "209718e85a6a3bd19450282cf1b598dbb987f2b7dd0e5ea872ba59c50781fcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "01861bb5ac661535b523a01fb922fdf78d1a1d4f64afa2a7d02fbe0c37505024", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "95a31c3909011cf6a1ebfb0aaf19440e462c0abf2546e74e962a87e80b42610e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a93374608551ced9d3c5903900c2fc182fdaf94a648c5798d248cb95bc13cef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4012a": { @@ -345335,7 +362952,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4012a", "family_id": "terrain-40125-40134", "job_id": "terrain-40125-40134", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345351,6 +362968,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/candidate.json", "sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d1c21018461c039b710ddc6f80de163756ccf01e4a8684fd87323e7dc6f95082", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.733706+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"ground_topography\": \"All five featureless ground variants stay ground; fissures4012e\\u201340131 retain source branching and edge directions; rock clusters40132\\u201340134 retain principal count/location, scale and brown identity. Shared ground atlas cells beyond40134 are outside approval scope; existing40138 rejection preserved.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 88b53b4b2f29bbddb668d5b2b90ed1dbc0e42d3e699f330a01d9e239a3778202", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40125", + "40126", + "40127", + "40128" + ], + "sha256": "ff046123d25c0950738c37fc1125c25b0978d294a0fe79486d96380e9975c5b9", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40129", + "4012a", + "4012b", + "4012c" + ], + "sha256": "cead42d6055c342a23a8fef2251a9972e57838e4d82e103f32899962618f8dbe", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4012d", + "4012e", + "4012f", + "40130" + ], + "sha256": "df7bd16455c07c6bdbf22be44c20980141a623f53f68aed43a97d6122ca000d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40131", + "40132", + "40133", + "40134" + ], + "sha256": "49d8e2721b003e276c18520130472f4ff30509c81f89ba8140f3952c4d1005d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "39b6a46b61ba95278d911b6a80012aa3bd0929a92fbffd43cb928355ec4bef75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c2f42ca88f187a4c55130e7118e0c72e70351ed81b397b9e7e6937535397928", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcd01e3c32f553247de716539710ede996e6ff258c71ed2ea4848f83099c9f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d7fc7ea76f896d0af4095302a2d8bf6a7dc6c0f878c3979053ad366b01584cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b34a2386d71dc6167d267750cd4c1d5a8f7014698ed9f10c46cd7b8e38c21f0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "71313fdc08fd481d9dcaedce2b68ad92c8cea851550f0ba85d4d59c568baca01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c0fcb9f037d549c501fb6516e8cc48a1cc7a4230c37dccbd29a8dd742211e8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b27a3c751273dc563d6d3874c7ec295a65698d2450d2ebae9a92327f0321a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e0b8730d2f291998138cebba411392b730e414102112c38042ba67931ba63e0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "894dc6b28a9adeeed0d863e0fb62fc1d2df28f7b0e2b02be4d721aaa1845647f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "753a6ae1e44c5e43aad89ed68058626342a184cd9ce9009bd0e5e5e1829e9b32", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b65356700fd03566f2f545d9c8dc76e14bef80a6c1d1899d108b759519163d41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a712a1a8cd4e77ef1a4ed71da8c714022a40734fc76d2296ae534149c7dbfb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "31535cec9b1f287c3b5c819bb92c5792fef6e34343366c1b01c758a2551dceb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3237e849259d1fa4bcf62314e98bdc4f4dc2300bd58093c4a4b26e933bcc72d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d1918f3ee5a45bec07e3d386301be6176087df231c6097d29df1b3f65c8615e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "368914f49681185268325652a9f0c61a0b7c59d0bf02d7fd96c90b12ab20f2e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fa8b00511a179327d40781192a981f023c3ae47accaa2b4c2b0487cc85005c97", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "11caeb65c4f04c97f74bbb15b38af1829bed2f1dd465c5804d05fd5356ce7df4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8cfb6dda870a9ae7d0dcac12e09fe385e6aa8fc78cdc383088b2281cb2d44f07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3555970e3f9e2176114f91a4e595c9dd2d848ccd9e46f2c1e5cca9c6200f2298", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bda78fe91e5ceaefe6ae733b70907fcfcbeb5ee8ae66fdc20e2c21103f91c3db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5d85da319cf6e0eb58ee07a136917c9c8c632102b8db1c9b716f6c6a02f8d3a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "667b08a09d94345808eac90f347e51859c5fbe74dd46fd2874a5a0ca87b364c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "dcba38c97e43dcc48320c5fe7e92a0718de7ff6bec63de2c2e4843f6d3b30048", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "804dc0ab5f297799e5717dc9f2aa873efae84f38e512c39d11ebca711ab89ccf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1aeb19f5ae7f55baef504fe8dac4eab7f2b69b61b1a3f8eaeda0b0fef6625072", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f209bd186972159a8019d3138669849376eed03cdfcd915017297205ceacb0d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d6aca5b373bc0d340b0692b99df38936e2c5ecefc7bda3f8a5eb2c73e66ba7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a8b36af129b2d2a631f8a452e5fcf617b7170a9a870205a086e36408e78e1931", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db1b8c298742dbeac2f63b162bfc6d8f7823b784267a689810bed908da320a27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "35a9bcf736d7c10010a8826da2892e238d30be12c161426d87eb877317641aa7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f2ce821f5d33511475772e51bd274c2b37259f4f3429f633fd651aac57ebd83d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4a1b5ed0e794f949c1c29a77b872fde1e0717186d932527e74327e1ee7747631", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52dcc5e7686e826e3181bb68610a962eb7dda62a261a28ba1de1bf9e5f43814c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6f09ead046c0cb0ea4314242d7fecccc5e154894508a33c8ad4a98b362415661", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26aa036da340fd20fd3bd6338113456a7eab81eb606baebe797f6a19ce57ae0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81e001aff228f78b841eb9811904706e35b166248cfc9c7b51b316c63afad887", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4e875c6b021628443495f967091e6a45edb96d8262e5eb3b798d295a4c62362b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30174f98ee63b0f65932816b480baa9e276cc6778d07637b096af7062c739888", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06189914280c66bb3fc98d184848d153dca72952d2c88d8398b2d9c6eb6d13d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "222387972a103fad9390604d4440ce827abf59fd4713bbdf6f8865f33e773ce0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5b692dac2331d4edd2a4751b312a3f6ab08a0e9592589d01d97b6b580c73d606", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f7b0982bc5f2e486520c714078525e7ea006fbb2c0e16ae0c89b0dcecb67401", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80eeb99c1ccc109d9f86371e093a4a5b3808da2b2c62eb50ab63cfd5d89bdf77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bccf61b4cb7cce8b5d144b88edbd2c7868306d91bf0237240f5d2ea419bd4428", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2374513de03d44405106824abf734517d878d5d10af5f5d54d148318664f15ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "92ba61fd81f030eb33d41a7b600baf5684a929790de069c4c0a6e32f18066de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b148a3f285ca3a37b414b3cc0fc0904301f615ece781953f9b5b29a689175806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3206b0490155d47cd32913533ad42c57222ba0714162121fc169f1e40e8405c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "18bb7647dad8ba4fc6fe500e70c2bb879e340e8babf08ed47e66b301b1c5f1c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c60718867c84d32ad512e3749bbf5cfbf2373c5e289314fbf4af08b98de0f8b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "eea762f538e5b1611022e242fdb6bdc18bba987af318e9c6faa2bbf6b47c5152", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1c48504d0b42df33c5de0779c424c34a36e774e074856281e4d3e5f1ef7d9b72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ec2999dff502882b5a2bfb8ea4c7de9f427c01c660d4abf9bbb220367f48bfe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0cf2880c8c1bcff497c2652c8ba32b2368806a687e846df39ca00bd04269f1bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6583d2e7217aae07c769f8cfa84bcc56426f287865b1409c681612ff4905857", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "850b6c9cbf66fde98152a049aa4ece56d9281a5e17fb2e915eb3443ab002c7c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "012346f5fa60e0fb2545cbad81929e12029a2c270d0ece8790eac56df540c140", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1a98f2b5f8c660ba1a29907cc6610006146be0dd76398da79c6cb49ce62cb8ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35fd28460f47e8471b9a3dd8a697aaf978b82be4336c4af69af38684baa1a075", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "44978fab3a43eaddaba266e1b71b640263a23256a873626e2444f553cd0c7fcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "876a8e70267f2b886e189c42aafe58364007ccf288eea862ff15da337fd562ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f19ca34caba18ca28967a7f581c2e6b2b4c89e0fad277b2dfb7e9a6d0a96a47d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab490c204065c976719bc6c7d629496fea98313031e8881eb48bf0ea19900b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "30ea3be2b19e035aa13f5c00f26ca4bfaadffb508d16d66c6250df7f123f9e0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "101158f62d925d76670a9a6b30de77f67f3b143b2eb2f511b59ccc69fa19e1ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2f293da4835a8b403ab2d3a3f7982321fdd9557778b6667fbec83173b97e49", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8a0def269b604915124b11a74a8e6e0fe9c43c916b4551a2d81412894119a28e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a86513a89ed2b7100538d7bc31e724e5dd7dd9371e8af886c07f971d7013f5d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "15d68049b62b5589f7c6fc0aadc57710e5ba0330d28743b352dc21e28903b29c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "38d8923d099ee90c13c820960b6c064f2cbea0312eebf34318ccd20ea895ccbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "99ad2762f3cfc3bc4762d53229a63468452c4fd18139f00118926526c64f3b3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "26cbe0ce5cd528a0a7e7174e44d46274dece5717095d56eea0da83255241b61a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-original.ppm", + "sha256": "928a6d1a802efadadc24db01def7b01cc963202a277bfae37421659da11b01ac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df6dc1a38be8f9594a1faf12e46039608b35df79bf0e0f1981ec63e0de442c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "209718e85a6a3bd19450282cf1b598dbb987f2b7dd0e5ea872ba59c50781fcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "01861bb5ac661535b523a01fb922fdf78d1a1d4f64afa2a7d02fbe0c37505024", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "95a31c3909011cf6a1ebfb0aaf19440e462c0abf2546e74e962a87e80b42610e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a93374608551ced9d3c5903900c2fc182fdaf94a648c5798d248cb95bc13cef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4012b": { @@ -345372,7 +363459,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4012b", "family_id": "terrain-40125-40134", "job_id": "terrain-40125-40134", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345388,6 +363475,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/candidate.json", "sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d1c21018461c039b710ddc6f80de163756ccf01e4a8684fd87323e7dc6f95082", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.733706+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"ground_topography\": \"All five featureless ground variants stay ground; fissures4012e\\u201340131 retain source branching and edge directions; rock clusters40132\\u201340134 retain principal count/location, scale and brown identity. Shared ground atlas cells beyond40134 are outside approval scope; existing40138 rejection preserved.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 88b53b4b2f29bbddb668d5b2b90ed1dbc0e42d3e699f330a01d9e239a3778202", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40125", + "40126", + "40127", + "40128" + ], + "sha256": "ff046123d25c0950738c37fc1125c25b0978d294a0fe79486d96380e9975c5b9", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40129", + "4012a", + "4012b", + "4012c" + ], + "sha256": "cead42d6055c342a23a8fef2251a9972e57838e4d82e103f32899962618f8dbe", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4012d", + "4012e", + "4012f", + "40130" + ], + "sha256": "df7bd16455c07c6bdbf22be44c20980141a623f53f68aed43a97d6122ca000d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40131", + "40132", + "40133", + "40134" + ], + "sha256": "49d8e2721b003e276c18520130472f4ff30509c81f89ba8140f3952c4d1005d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "39b6a46b61ba95278d911b6a80012aa3bd0929a92fbffd43cb928355ec4bef75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c2f42ca88f187a4c55130e7118e0c72e70351ed81b397b9e7e6937535397928", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcd01e3c32f553247de716539710ede996e6ff258c71ed2ea4848f83099c9f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d7fc7ea76f896d0af4095302a2d8bf6a7dc6c0f878c3979053ad366b01584cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b34a2386d71dc6167d267750cd4c1d5a8f7014698ed9f10c46cd7b8e38c21f0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "71313fdc08fd481d9dcaedce2b68ad92c8cea851550f0ba85d4d59c568baca01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c0fcb9f037d549c501fb6516e8cc48a1cc7a4230c37dccbd29a8dd742211e8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b27a3c751273dc563d6d3874c7ec295a65698d2450d2ebae9a92327f0321a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e0b8730d2f291998138cebba411392b730e414102112c38042ba67931ba63e0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "894dc6b28a9adeeed0d863e0fb62fc1d2df28f7b0e2b02be4d721aaa1845647f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "753a6ae1e44c5e43aad89ed68058626342a184cd9ce9009bd0e5e5e1829e9b32", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b65356700fd03566f2f545d9c8dc76e14bef80a6c1d1899d108b759519163d41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a712a1a8cd4e77ef1a4ed71da8c714022a40734fc76d2296ae534149c7dbfb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "31535cec9b1f287c3b5c819bb92c5792fef6e34343366c1b01c758a2551dceb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3237e849259d1fa4bcf62314e98bdc4f4dc2300bd58093c4a4b26e933bcc72d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d1918f3ee5a45bec07e3d386301be6176087df231c6097d29df1b3f65c8615e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "368914f49681185268325652a9f0c61a0b7c59d0bf02d7fd96c90b12ab20f2e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fa8b00511a179327d40781192a981f023c3ae47accaa2b4c2b0487cc85005c97", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "11caeb65c4f04c97f74bbb15b38af1829bed2f1dd465c5804d05fd5356ce7df4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8cfb6dda870a9ae7d0dcac12e09fe385e6aa8fc78cdc383088b2281cb2d44f07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3555970e3f9e2176114f91a4e595c9dd2d848ccd9e46f2c1e5cca9c6200f2298", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bda78fe91e5ceaefe6ae733b70907fcfcbeb5ee8ae66fdc20e2c21103f91c3db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5d85da319cf6e0eb58ee07a136917c9c8c632102b8db1c9b716f6c6a02f8d3a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "667b08a09d94345808eac90f347e51859c5fbe74dd46fd2874a5a0ca87b364c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "dcba38c97e43dcc48320c5fe7e92a0718de7ff6bec63de2c2e4843f6d3b30048", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "804dc0ab5f297799e5717dc9f2aa873efae84f38e512c39d11ebca711ab89ccf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1aeb19f5ae7f55baef504fe8dac4eab7f2b69b61b1a3f8eaeda0b0fef6625072", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f209bd186972159a8019d3138669849376eed03cdfcd915017297205ceacb0d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d6aca5b373bc0d340b0692b99df38936e2c5ecefc7bda3f8a5eb2c73e66ba7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a8b36af129b2d2a631f8a452e5fcf617b7170a9a870205a086e36408e78e1931", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db1b8c298742dbeac2f63b162bfc6d8f7823b784267a689810bed908da320a27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "35a9bcf736d7c10010a8826da2892e238d30be12c161426d87eb877317641aa7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f2ce821f5d33511475772e51bd274c2b37259f4f3429f633fd651aac57ebd83d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4a1b5ed0e794f949c1c29a77b872fde1e0717186d932527e74327e1ee7747631", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52dcc5e7686e826e3181bb68610a962eb7dda62a261a28ba1de1bf9e5f43814c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6f09ead046c0cb0ea4314242d7fecccc5e154894508a33c8ad4a98b362415661", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26aa036da340fd20fd3bd6338113456a7eab81eb606baebe797f6a19ce57ae0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81e001aff228f78b841eb9811904706e35b166248cfc9c7b51b316c63afad887", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4e875c6b021628443495f967091e6a45edb96d8262e5eb3b798d295a4c62362b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30174f98ee63b0f65932816b480baa9e276cc6778d07637b096af7062c739888", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06189914280c66bb3fc98d184848d153dca72952d2c88d8398b2d9c6eb6d13d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "222387972a103fad9390604d4440ce827abf59fd4713bbdf6f8865f33e773ce0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5b692dac2331d4edd2a4751b312a3f6ab08a0e9592589d01d97b6b580c73d606", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f7b0982bc5f2e486520c714078525e7ea006fbb2c0e16ae0c89b0dcecb67401", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80eeb99c1ccc109d9f86371e093a4a5b3808da2b2c62eb50ab63cfd5d89bdf77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bccf61b4cb7cce8b5d144b88edbd2c7868306d91bf0237240f5d2ea419bd4428", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2374513de03d44405106824abf734517d878d5d10af5f5d54d148318664f15ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "92ba61fd81f030eb33d41a7b600baf5684a929790de069c4c0a6e32f18066de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b148a3f285ca3a37b414b3cc0fc0904301f615ece781953f9b5b29a689175806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3206b0490155d47cd32913533ad42c57222ba0714162121fc169f1e40e8405c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "18bb7647dad8ba4fc6fe500e70c2bb879e340e8babf08ed47e66b301b1c5f1c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c60718867c84d32ad512e3749bbf5cfbf2373c5e289314fbf4af08b98de0f8b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "eea762f538e5b1611022e242fdb6bdc18bba987af318e9c6faa2bbf6b47c5152", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1c48504d0b42df33c5de0779c424c34a36e774e074856281e4d3e5f1ef7d9b72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ec2999dff502882b5a2bfb8ea4c7de9f427c01c660d4abf9bbb220367f48bfe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0cf2880c8c1bcff497c2652c8ba32b2368806a687e846df39ca00bd04269f1bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6583d2e7217aae07c769f8cfa84bcc56426f287865b1409c681612ff4905857", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "850b6c9cbf66fde98152a049aa4ece56d9281a5e17fb2e915eb3443ab002c7c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "012346f5fa60e0fb2545cbad81929e12029a2c270d0ece8790eac56df540c140", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1a98f2b5f8c660ba1a29907cc6610006146be0dd76398da79c6cb49ce62cb8ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35fd28460f47e8471b9a3dd8a697aaf978b82be4336c4af69af38684baa1a075", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "44978fab3a43eaddaba266e1b71b640263a23256a873626e2444f553cd0c7fcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "876a8e70267f2b886e189c42aafe58364007ccf288eea862ff15da337fd562ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f19ca34caba18ca28967a7f581c2e6b2b4c89e0fad277b2dfb7e9a6d0a96a47d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab490c204065c976719bc6c7d629496fea98313031e8881eb48bf0ea19900b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "30ea3be2b19e035aa13f5c00f26ca4bfaadffb508d16d66c6250df7f123f9e0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "101158f62d925d76670a9a6b30de77f67f3b143b2eb2f511b59ccc69fa19e1ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2f293da4835a8b403ab2d3a3f7982321fdd9557778b6667fbec83173b97e49", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8a0def269b604915124b11a74a8e6e0fe9c43c916b4551a2d81412894119a28e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a86513a89ed2b7100538d7bc31e724e5dd7dd9371e8af886c07f971d7013f5d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "15d68049b62b5589f7c6fc0aadc57710e5ba0330d28743b352dc21e28903b29c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "38d8923d099ee90c13c820960b6c064f2cbea0312eebf34318ccd20ea895ccbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "99ad2762f3cfc3bc4762d53229a63468452c4fd18139f00118926526c64f3b3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "26cbe0ce5cd528a0a7e7174e44d46274dece5717095d56eea0da83255241b61a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-original.ppm", + "sha256": "928a6d1a802efadadc24db01def7b01cc963202a277bfae37421659da11b01ac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df6dc1a38be8f9594a1faf12e46039608b35df79bf0e0f1981ec63e0de442c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "209718e85a6a3bd19450282cf1b598dbb987f2b7dd0e5ea872ba59c50781fcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "01861bb5ac661535b523a01fb922fdf78d1a1d4f64afa2a7d02fbe0c37505024", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "95a31c3909011cf6a1ebfb0aaf19440e462c0abf2546e74e962a87e80b42610e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a93374608551ced9d3c5903900c2fc182fdaf94a648c5798d248cb95bc13cef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4012c": { @@ -345409,7 +363966,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4012c", "family_id": "terrain-40125-40134", "job_id": "terrain-40125-40134", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345425,6 +363982,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/candidate.json", "sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d1c21018461c039b710ddc6f80de163756ccf01e4a8684fd87323e7dc6f95082", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.733706+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"ground_topography\": \"All five featureless ground variants stay ground; fissures4012e\\u201340131 retain source branching and edge directions; rock clusters40132\\u201340134 retain principal count/location, scale and brown identity. Shared ground atlas cells beyond40134 are outside approval scope; existing40138 rejection preserved.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 88b53b4b2f29bbddb668d5b2b90ed1dbc0e42d3e699f330a01d9e239a3778202", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40125", + "40126", + "40127", + "40128" + ], + "sha256": "ff046123d25c0950738c37fc1125c25b0978d294a0fe79486d96380e9975c5b9", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40129", + "4012a", + "4012b", + "4012c" + ], + "sha256": "cead42d6055c342a23a8fef2251a9972e57838e4d82e103f32899962618f8dbe", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4012d", + "4012e", + "4012f", + "40130" + ], + "sha256": "df7bd16455c07c6bdbf22be44c20980141a623f53f68aed43a97d6122ca000d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40131", + "40132", + "40133", + "40134" + ], + "sha256": "49d8e2721b003e276c18520130472f4ff30509c81f89ba8140f3952c4d1005d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "39b6a46b61ba95278d911b6a80012aa3bd0929a92fbffd43cb928355ec4bef75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c2f42ca88f187a4c55130e7118e0c72e70351ed81b397b9e7e6937535397928", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcd01e3c32f553247de716539710ede996e6ff258c71ed2ea4848f83099c9f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d7fc7ea76f896d0af4095302a2d8bf6a7dc6c0f878c3979053ad366b01584cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b34a2386d71dc6167d267750cd4c1d5a8f7014698ed9f10c46cd7b8e38c21f0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "71313fdc08fd481d9dcaedce2b68ad92c8cea851550f0ba85d4d59c568baca01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c0fcb9f037d549c501fb6516e8cc48a1cc7a4230c37dccbd29a8dd742211e8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b27a3c751273dc563d6d3874c7ec295a65698d2450d2ebae9a92327f0321a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e0b8730d2f291998138cebba411392b730e414102112c38042ba67931ba63e0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "894dc6b28a9adeeed0d863e0fb62fc1d2df28f7b0e2b02be4d721aaa1845647f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "753a6ae1e44c5e43aad89ed68058626342a184cd9ce9009bd0e5e5e1829e9b32", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b65356700fd03566f2f545d9c8dc76e14bef80a6c1d1899d108b759519163d41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a712a1a8cd4e77ef1a4ed71da8c714022a40734fc76d2296ae534149c7dbfb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "31535cec9b1f287c3b5c819bb92c5792fef6e34343366c1b01c758a2551dceb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3237e849259d1fa4bcf62314e98bdc4f4dc2300bd58093c4a4b26e933bcc72d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d1918f3ee5a45bec07e3d386301be6176087df231c6097d29df1b3f65c8615e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "368914f49681185268325652a9f0c61a0b7c59d0bf02d7fd96c90b12ab20f2e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fa8b00511a179327d40781192a981f023c3ae47accaa2b4c2b0487cc85005c97", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "11caeb65c4f04c97f74bbb15b38af1829bed2f1dd465c5804d05fd5356ce7df4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8cfb6dda870a9ae7d0dcac12e09fe385e6aa8fc78cdc383088b2281cb2d44f07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3555970e3f9e2176114f91a4e595c9dd2d848ccd9e46f2c1e5cca9c6200f2298", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bda78fe91e5ceaefe6ae733b70907fcfcbeb5ee8ae66fdc20e2c21103f91c3db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5d85da319cf6e0eb58ee07a136917c9c8c632102b8db1c9b716f6c6a02f8d3a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "667b08a09d94345808eac90f347e51859c5fbe74dd46fd2874a5a0ca87b364c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "dcba38c97e43dcc48320c5fe7e92a0718de7ff6bec63de2c2e4843f6d3b30048", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "804dc0ab5f297799e5717dc9f2aa873efae84f38e512c39d11ebca711ab89ccf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1aeb19f5ae7f55baef504fe8dac4eab7f2b69b61b1a3f8eaeda0b0fef6625072", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f209bd186972159a8019d3138669849376eed03cdfcd915017297205ceacb0d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d6aca5b373bc0d340b0692b99df38936e2c5ecefc7bda3f8a5eb2c73e66ba7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a8b36af129b2d2a631f8a452e5fcf617b7170a9a870205a086e36408e78e1931", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db1b8c298742dbeac2f63b162bfc6d8f7823b784267a689810bed908da320a27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "35a9bcf736d7c10010a8826da2892e238d30be12c161426d87eb877317641aa7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f2ce821f5d33511475772e51bd274c2b37259f4f3429f633fd651aac57ebd83d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4a1b5ed0e794f949c1c29a77b872fde1e0717186d932527e74327e1ee7747631", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52dcc5e7686e826e3181bb68610a962eb7dda62a261a28ba1de1bf9e5f43814c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6f09ead046c0cb0ea4314242d7fecccc5e154894508a33c8ad4a98b362415661", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26aa036da340fd20fd3bd6338113456a7eab81eb606baebe797f6a19ce57ae0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81e001aff228f78b841eb9811904706e35b166248cfc9c7b51b316c63afad887", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4e875c6b021628443495f967091e6a45edb96d8262e5eb3b798d295a4c62362b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30174f98ee63b0f65932816b480baa9e276cc6778d07637b096af7062c739888", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06189914280c66bb3fc98d184848d153dca72952d2c88d8398b2d9c6eb6d13d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "222387972a103fad9390604d4440ce827abf59fd4713bbdf6f8865f33e773ce0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5b692dac2331d4edd2a4751b312a3f6ab08a0e9592589d01d97b6b580c73d606", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f7b0982bc5f2e486520c714078525e7ea006fbb2c0e16ae0c89b0dcecb67401", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80eeb99c1ccc109d9f86371e093a4a5b3808da2b2c62eb50ab63cfd5d89bdf77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bccf61b4cb7cce8b5d144b88edbd2c7868306d91bf0237240f5d2ea419bd4428", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2374513de03d44405106824abf734517d878d5d10af5f5d54d148318664f15ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "92ba61fd81f030eb33d41a7b600baf5684a929790de069c4c0a6e32f18066de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b148a3f285ca3a37b414b3cc0fc0904301f615ece781953f9b5b29a689175806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3206b0490155d47cd32913533ad42c57222ba0714162121fc169f1e40e8405c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "18bb7647dad8ba4fc6fe500e70c2bb879e340e8babf08ed47e66b301b1c5f1c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c60718867c84d32ad512e3749bbf5cfbf2373c5e289314fbf4af08b98de0f8b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "eea762f538e5b1611022e242fdb6bdc18bba987af318e9c6faa2bbf6b47c5152", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1c48504d0b42df33c5de0779c424c34a36e774e074856281e4d3e5f1ef7d9b72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ec2999dff502882b5a2bfb8ea4c7de9f427c01c660d4abf9bbb220367f48bfe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0cf2880c8c1bcff497c2652c8ba32b2368806a687e846df39ca00bd04269f1bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6583d2e7217aae07c769f8cfa84bcc56426f287865b1409c681612ff4905857", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "850b6c9cbf66fde98152a049aa4ece56d9281a5e17fb2e915eb3443ab002c7c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "012346f5fa60e0fb2545cbad81929e12029a2c270d0ece8790eac56df540c140", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1a98f2b5f8c660ba1a29907cc6610006146be0dd76398da79c6cb49ce62cb8ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35fd28460f47e8471b9a3dd8a697aaf978b82be4336c4af69af38684baa1a075", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "44978fab3a43eaddaba266e1b71b640263a23256a873626e2444f553cd0c7fcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "876a8e70267f2b886e189c42aafe58364007ccf288eea862ff15da337fd562ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f19ca34caba18ca28967a7f581c2e6b2b4c89e0fad277b2dfb7e9a6d0a96a47d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab490c204065c976719bc6c7d629496fea98313031e8881eb48bf0ea19900b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "30ea3be2b19e035aa13f5c00f26ca4bfaadffb508d16d66c6250df7f123f9e0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "101158f62d925d76670a9a6b30de77f67f3b143b2eb2f511b59ccc69fa19e1ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2f293da4835a8b403ab2d3a3f7982321fdd9557778b6667fbec83173b97e49", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8a0def269b604915124b11a74a8e6e0fe9c43c916b4551a2d81412894119a28e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a86513a89ed2b7100538d7bc31e724e5dd7dd9371e8af886c07f971d7013f5d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "15d68049b62b5589f7c6fc0aadc57710e5ba0330d28743b352dc21e28903b29c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "38d8923d099ee90c13c820960b6c064f2cbea0312eebf34318ccd20ea895ccbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "99ad2762f3cfc3bc4762d53229a63468452c4fd18139f00118926526c64f3b3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "26cbe0ce5cd528a0a7e7174e44d46274dece5717095d56eea0da83255241b61a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-original.ppm", + "sha256": "928a6d1a802efadadc24db01def7b01cc963202a277bfae37421659da11b01ac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df6dc1a38be8f9594a1faf12e46039608b35df79bf0e0f1981ec63e0de442c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "209718e85a6a3bd19450282cf1b598dbb987f2b7dd0e5ea872ba59c50781fcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "01861bb5ac661535b523a01fb922fdf78d1a1d4f64afa2a7d02fbe0c37505024", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "95a31c3909011cf6a1ebfb0aaf19440e462c0abf2546e74e962a87e80b42610e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a93374608551ced9d3c5903900c2fc182fdaf94a648c5798d248cb95bc13cef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4012d": { @@ -345446,7 +364473,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4012d", "family_id": "terrain-40125-40134", "job_id": "terrain-40125-40134", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345462,6 +364489,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/candidate.json", "sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d1c21018461c039b710ddc6f80de163756ccf01e4a8684fd87323e7dc6f95082", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.733706+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"ground_topography\": \"All five featureless ground variants stay ground; fissures4012e\\u201340131 retain source branching and edge directions; rock clusters40132\\u201340134 retain principal count/location, scale and brown identity. Shared ground atlas cells beyond40134 are outside approval scope; existing40138 rejection preserved.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 88b53b4b2f29bbddb668d5b2b90ed1dbc0e42d3e699f330a01d9e239a3778202", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40125", + "40126", + "40127", + "40128" + ], + "sha256": "ff046123d25c0950738c37fc1125c25b0978d294a0fe79486d96380e9975c5b9", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40129", + "4012a", + "4012b", + "4012c" + ], + "sha256": "cead42d6055c342a23a8fef2251a9972e57838e4d82e103f32899962618f8dbe", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4012d", + "4012e", + "4012f", + "40130" + ], + "sha256": "df7bd16455c07c6bdbf22be44c20980141a623f53f68aed43a97d6122ca000d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40131", + "40132", + "40133", + "40134" + ], + "sha256": "49d8e2721b003e276c18520130472f4ff30509c81f89ba8140f3952c4d1005d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "39b6a46b61ba95278d911b6a80012aa3bd0929a92fbffd43cb928355ec4bef75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c2f42ca88f187a4c55130e7118e0c72e70351ed81b397b9e7e6937535397928", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcd01e3c32f553247de716539710ede996e6ff258c71ed2ea4848f83099c9f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d7fc7ea76f896d0af4095302a2d8bf6a7dc6c0f878c3979053ad366b01584cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b34a2386d71dc6167d267750cd4c1d5a8f7014698ed9f10c46cd7b8e38c21f0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "71313fdc08fd481d9dcaedce2b68ad92c8cea851550f0ba85d4d59c568baca01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c0fcb9f037d549c501fb6516e8cc48a1cc7a4230c37dccbd29a8dd742211e8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b27a3c751273dc563d6d3874c7ec295a65698d2450d2ebae9a92327f0321a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e0b8730d2f291998138cebba411392b730e414102112c38042ba67931ba63e0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "894dc6b28a9adeeed0d863e0fb62fc1d2df28f7b0e2b02be4d721aaa1845647f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "753a6ae1e44c5e43aad89ed68058626342a184cd9ce9009bd0e5e5e1829e9b32", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b65356700fd03566f2f545d9c8dc76e14bef80a6c1d1899d108b759519163d41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a712a1a8cd4e77ef1a4ed71da8c714022a40734fc76d2296ae534149c7dbfb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "31535cec9b1f287c3b5c819bb92c5792fef6e34343366c1b01c758a2551dceb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3237e849259d1fa4bcf62314e98bdc4f4dc2300bd58093c4a4b26e933bcc72d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d1918f3ee5a45bec07e3d386301be6176087df231c6097d29df1b3f65c8615e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "368914f49681185268325652a9f0c61a0b7c59d0bf02d7fd96c90b12ab20f2e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fa8b00511a179327d40781192a981f023c3ae47accaa2b4c2b0487cc85005c97", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "11caeb65c4f04c97f74bbb15b38af1829bed2f1dd465c5804d05fd5356ce7df4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8cfb6dda870a9ae7d0dcac12e09fe385e6aa8fc78cdc383088b2281cb2d44f07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3555970e3f9e2176114f91a4e595c9dd2d848ccd9e46f2c1e5cca9c6200f2298", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bda78fe91e5ceaefe6ae733b70907fcfcbeb5ee8ae66fdc20e2c21103f91c3db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5d85da319cf6e0eb58ee07a136917c9c8c632102b8db1c9b716f6c6a02f8d3a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "667b08a09d94345808eac90f347e51859c5fbe74dd46fd2874a5a0ca87b364c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "dcba38c97e43dcc48320c5fe7e92a0718de7ff6bec63de2c2e4843f6d3b30048", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "804dc0ab5f297799e5717dc9f2aa873efae84f38e512c39d11ebca711ab89ccf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1aeb19f5ae7f55baef504fe8dac4eab7f2b69b61b1a3f8eaeda0b0fef6625072", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f209bd186972159a8019d3138669849376eed03cdfcd915017297205ceacb0d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d6aca5b373bc0d340b0692b99df38936e2c5ecefc7bda3f8a5eb2c73e66ba7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a8b36af129b2d2a631f8a452e5fcf617b7170a9a870205a086e36408e78e1931", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db1b8c298742dbeac2f63b162bfc6d8f7823b784267a689810bed908da320a27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "35a9bcf736d7c10010a8826da2892e238d30be12c161426d87eb877317641aa7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f2ce821f5d33511475772e51bd274c2b37259f4f3429f633fd651aac57ebd83d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4a1b5ed0e794f949c1c29a77b872fde1e0717186d932527e74327e1ee7747631", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52dcc5e7686e826e3181bb68610a962eb7dda62a261a28ba1de1bf9e5f43814c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6f09ead046c0cb0ea4314242d7fecccc5e154894508a33c8ad4a98b362415661", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26aa036da340fd20fd3bd6338113456a7eab81eb606baebe797f6a19ce57ae0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81e001aff228f78b841eb9811904706e35b166248cfc9c7b51b316c63afad887", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4e875c6b021628443495f967091e6a45edb96d8262e5eb3b798d295a4c62362b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30174f98ee63b0f65932816b480baa9e276cc6778d07637b096af7062c739888", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06189914280c66bb3fc98d184848d153dca72952d2c88d8398b2d9c6eb6d13d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "222387972a103fad9390604d4440ce827abf59fd4713bbdf6f8865f33e773ce0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5b692dac2331d4edd2a4751b312a3f6ab08a0e9592589d01d97b6b580c73d606", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f7b0982bc5f2e486520c714078525e7ea006fbb2c0e16ae0c89b0dcecb67401", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80eeb99c1ccc109d9f86371e093a4a5b3808da2b2c62eb50ab63cfd5d89bdf77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bccf61b4cb7cce8b5d144b88edbd2c7868306d91bf0237240f5d2ea419bd4428", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2374513de03d44405106824abf734517d878d5d10af5f5d54d148318664f15ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "92ba61fd81f030eb33d41a7b600baf5684a929790de069c4c0a6e32f18066de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b148a3f285ca3a37b414b3cc0fc0904301f615ece781953f9b5b29a689175806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3206b0490155d47cd32913533ad42c57222ba0714162121fc169f1e40e8405c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "18bb7647dad8ba4fc6fe500e70c2bb879e340e8babf08ed47e66b301b1c5f1c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c60718867c84d32ad512e3749bbf5cfbf2373c5e289314fbf4af08b98de0f8b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "eea762f538e5b1611022e242fdb6bdc18bba987af318e9c6faa2bbf6b47c5152", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1c48504d0b42df33c5de0779c424c34a36e774e074856281e4d3e5f1ef7d9b72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ec2999dff502882b5a2bfb8ea4c7de9f427c01c660d4abf9bbb220367f48bfe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0cf2880c8c1bcff497c2652c8ba32b2368806a687e846df39ca00bd04269f1bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6583d2e7217aae07c769f8cfa84bcc56426f287865b1409c681612ff4905857", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "850b6c9cbf66fde98152a049aa4ece56d9281a5e17fb2e915eb3443ab002c7c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "012346f5fa60e0fb2545cbad81929e12029a2c270d0ece8790eac56df540c140", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1a98f2b5f8c660ba1a29907cc6610006146be0dd76398da79c6cb49ce62cb8ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35fd28460f47e8471b9a3dd8a697aaf978b82be4336c4af69af38684baa1a075", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "44978fab3a43eaddaba266e1b71b640263a23256a873626e2444f553cd0c7fcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "876a8e70267f2b886e189c42aafe58364007ccf288eea862ff15da337fd562ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f19ca34caba18ca28967a7f581c2e6b2b4c89e0fad277b2dfb7e9a6d0a96a47d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab490c204065c976719bc6c7d629496fea98313031e8881eb48bf0ea19900b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "30ea3be2b19e035aa13f5c00f26ca4bfaadffb508d16d66c6250df7f123f9e0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "101158f62d925d76670a9a6b30de77f67f3b143b2eb2f511b59ccc69fa19e1ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2f293da4835a8b403ab2d3a3f7982321fdd9557778b6667fbec83173b97e49", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8a0def269b604915124b11a74a8e6e0fe9c43c916b4551a2d81412894119a28e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a86513a89ed2b7100538d7bc31e724e5dd7dd9371e8af886c07f971d7013f5d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "15d68049b62b5589f7c6fc0aadc57710e5ba0330d28743b352dc21e28903b29c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "38d8923d099ee90c13c820960b6c064f2cbea0312eebf34318ccd20ea895ccbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "99ad2762f3cfc3bc4762d53229a63468452c4fd18139f00118926526c64f3b3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "26cbe0ce5cd528a0a7e7174e44d46274dece5717095d56eea0da83255241b61a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-original.ppm", + "sha256": "928a6d1a802efadadc24db01def7b01cc963202a277bfae37421659da11b01ac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df6dc1a38be8f9594a1faf12e46039608b35df79bf0e0f1981ec63e0de442c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "209718e85a6a3bd19450282cf1b598dbb987f2b7dd0e5ea872ba59c50781fcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "01861bb5ac661535b523a01fb922fdf78d1a1d4f64afa2a7d02fbe0c37505024", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "95a31c3909011cf6a1ebfb0aaf19440e462c0abf2546e74e962a87e80b42610e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a93374608551ced9d3c5903900c2fc182fdaf94a648c5798d248cb95bc13cef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4012e": { @@ -345483,7 +364980,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4012e", "family_id": "terrain-40125-40134", "job_id": "terrain-40125-40134", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345499,6 +364996,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/candidate.json", "sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d1c21018461c039b710ddc6f80de163756ccf01e4a8684fd87323e7dc6f95082", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.733706+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"ground_topography\": \"All five featureless ground variants stay ground; fissures4012e\\u201340131 retain source branching and edge directions; rock clusters40132\\u201340134 retain principal count/location, scale and brown identity. Shared ground atlas cells beyond40134 are outside approval scope; existing40138 rejection preserved.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 88b53b4b2f29bbddb668d5b2b90ed1dbc0e42d3e699f330a01d9e239a3778202", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40125", + "40126", + "40127", + "40128" + ], + "sha256": "ff046123d25c0950738c37fc1125c25b0978d294a0fe79486d96380e9975c5b9", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40129", + "4012a", + "4012b", + "4012c" + ], + "sha256": "cead42d6055c342a23a8fef2251a9972e57838e4d82e103f32899962618f8dbe", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4012d", + "4012e", + "4012f", + "40130" + ], + "sha256": "df7bd16455c07c6bdbf22be44c20980141a623f53f68aed43a97d6122ca000d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40131", + "40132", + "40133", + "40134" + ], + "sha256": "49d8e2721b003e276c18520130472f4ff30509c81f89ba8140f3952c4d1005d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "39b6a46b61ba95278d911b6a80012aa3bd0929a92fbffd43cb928355ec4bef75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c2f42ca88f187a4c55130e7118e0c72e70351ed81b397b9e7e6937535397928", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcd01e3c32f553247de716539710ede996e6ff258c71ed2ea4848f83099c9f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d7fc7ea76f896d0af4095302a2d8bf6a7dc6c0f878c3979053ad366b01584cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b34a2386d71dc6167d267750cd4c1d5a8f7014698ed9f10c46cd7b8e38c21f0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "71313fdc08fd481d9dcaedce2b68ad92c8cea851550f0ba85d4d59c568baca01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c0fcb9f037d549c501fb6516e8cc48a1cc7a4230c37dccbd29a8dd742211e8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b27a3c751273dc563d6d3874c7ec295a65698d2450d2ebae9a92327f0321a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e0b8730d2f291998138cebba411392b730e414102112c38042ba67931ba63e0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "894dc6b28a9adeeed0d863e0fb62fc1d2df28f7b0e2b02be4d721aaa1845647f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "753a6ae1e44c5e43aad89ed68058626342a184cd9ce9009bd0e5e5e1829e9b32", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b65356700fd03566f2f545d9c8dc76e14bef80a6c1d1899d108b759519163d41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a712a1a8cd4e77ef1a4ed71da8c714022a40734fc76d2296ae534149c7dbfb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "31535cec9b1f287c3b5c819bb92c5792fef6e34343366c1b01c758a2551dceb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3237e849259d1fa4bcf62314e98bdc4f4dc2300bd58093c4a4b26e933bcc72d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d1918f3ee5a45bec07e3d386301be6176087df231c6097d29df1b3f65c8615e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "368914f49681185268325652a9f0c61a0b7c59d0bf02d7fd96c90b12ab20f2e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fa8b00511a179327d40781192a981f023c3ae47accaa2b4c2b0487cc85005c97", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "11caeb65c4f04c97f74bbb15b38af1829bed2f1dd465c5804d05fd5356ce7df4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8cfb6dda870a9ae7d0dcac12e09fe385e6aa8fc78cdc383088b2281cb2d44f07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3555970e3f9e2176114f91a4e595c9dd2d848ccd9e46f2c1e5cca9c6200f2298", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bda78fe91e5ceaefe6ae733b70907fcfcbeb5ee8ae66fdc20e2c21103f91c3db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5d85da319cf6e0eb58ee07a136917c9c8c632102b8db1c9b716f6c6a02f8d3a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "667b08a09d94345808eac90f347e51859c5fbe74dd46fd2874a5a0ca87b364c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "dcba38c97e43dcc48320c5fe7e92a0718de7ff6bec63de2c2e4843f6d3b30048", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "804dc0ab5f297799e5717dc9f2aa873efae84f38e512c39d11ebca711ab89ccf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1aeb19f5ae7f55baef504fe8dac4eab7f2b69b61b1a3f8eaeda0b0fef6625072", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f209bd186972159a8019d3138669849376eed03cdfcd915017297205ceacb0d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d6aca5b373bc0d340b0692b99df38936e2c5ecefc7bda3f8a5eb2c73e66ba7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a8b36af129b2d2a631f8a452e5fcf617b7170a9a870205a086e36408e78e1931", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db1b8c298742dbeac2f63b162bfc6d8f7823b784267a689810bed908da320a27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "35a9bcf736d7c10010a8826da2892e238d30be12c161426d87eb877317641aa7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f2ce821f5d33511475772e51bd274c2b37259f4f3429f633fd651aac57ebd83d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4a1b5ed0e794f949c1c29a77b872fde1e0717186d932527e74327e1ee7747631", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52dcc5e7686e826e3181bb68610a962eb7dda62a261a28ba1de1bf9e5f43814c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6f09ead046c0cb0ea4314242d7fecccc5e154894508a33c8ad4a98b362415661", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26aa036da340fd20fd3bd6338113456a7eab81eb606baebe797f6a19ce57ae0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81e001aff228f78b841eb9811904706e35b166248cfc9c7b51b316c63afad887", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4e875c6b021628443495f967091e6a45edb96d8262e5eb3b798d295a4c62362b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30174f98ee63b0f65932816b480baa9e276cc6778d07637b096af7062c739888", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06189914280c66bb3fc98d184848d153dca72952d2c88d8398b2d9c6eb6d13d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "222387972a103fad9390604d4440ce827abf59fd4713bbdf6f8865f33e773ce0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5b692dac2331d4edd2a4751b312a3f6ab08a0e9592589d01d97b6b580c73d606", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f7b0982bc5f2e486520c714078525e7ea006fbb2c0e16ae0c89b0dcecb67401", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80eeb99c1ccc109d9f86371e093a4a5b3808da2b2c62eb50ab63cfd5d89bdf77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bccf61b4cb7cce8b5d144b88edbd2c7868306d91bf0237240f5d2ea419bd4428", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2374513de03d44405106824abf734517d878d5d10af5f5d54d148318664f15ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "92ba61fd81f030eb33d41a7b600baf5684a929790de069c4c0a6e32f18066de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b148a3f285ca3a37b414b3cc0fc0904301f615ece781953f9b5b29a689175806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3206b0490155d47cd32913533ad42c57222ba0714162121fc169f1e40e8405c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "18bb7647dad8ba4fc6fe500e70c2bb879e340e8babf08ed47e66b301b1c5f1c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c60718867c84d32ad512e3749bbf5cfbf2373c5e289314fbf4af08b98de0f8b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "eea762f538e5b1611022e242fdb6bdc18bba987af318e9c6faa2bbf6b47c5152", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1c48504d0b42df33c5de0779c424c34a36e774e074856281e4d3e5f1ef7d9b72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ec2999dff502882b5a2bfb8ea4c7de9f427c01c660d4abf9bbb220367f48bfe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0cf2880c8c1bcff497c2652c8ba32b2368806a687e846df39ca00bd04269f1bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6583d2e7217aae07c769f8cfa84bcc56426f287865b1409c681612ff4905857", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "850b6c9cbf66fde98152a049aa4ece56d9281a5e17fb2e915eb3443ab002c7c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "012346f5fa60e0fb2545cbad81929e12029a2c270d0ece8790eac56df540c140", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1a98f2b5f8c660ba1a29907cc6610006146be0dd76398da79c6cb49ce62cb8ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35fd28460f47e8471b9a3dd8a697aaf978b82be4336c4af69af38684baa1a075", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "44978fab3a43eaddaba266e1b71b640263a23256a873626e2444f553cd0c7fcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "876a8e70267f2b886e189c42aafe58364007ccf288eea862ff15da337fd562ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f19ca34caba18ca28967a7f581c2e6b2b4c89e0fad277b2dfb7e9a6d0a96a47d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab490c204065c976719bc6c7d629496fea98313031e8881eb48bf0ea19900b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "30ea3be2b19e035aa13f5c00f26ca4bfaadffb508d16d66c6250df7f123f9e0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "101158f62d925d76670a9a6b30de77f67f3b143b2eb2f511b59ccc69fa19e1ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2f293da4835a8b403ab2d3a3f7982321fdd9557778b6667fbec83173b97e49", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8a0def269b604915124b11a74a8e6e0fe9c43c916b4551a2d81412894119a28e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a86513a89ed2b7100538d7bc31e724e5dd7dd9371e8af886c07f971d7013f5d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "15d68049b62b5589f7c6fc0aadc57710e5ba0330d28743b352dc21e28903b29c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "38d8923d099ee90c13c820960b6c064f2cbea0312eebf34318ccd20ea895ccbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "99ad2762f3cfc3bc4762d53229a63468452c4fd18139f00118926526c64f3b3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "26cbe0ce5cd528a0a7e7174e44d46274dece5717095d56eea0da83255241b61a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-original.ppm", + "sha256": "928a6d1a802efadadc24db01def7b01cc963202a277bfae37421659da11b01ac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df6dc1a38be8f9594a1faf12e46039608b35df79bf0e0f1981ec63e0de442c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "209718e85a6a3bd19450282cf1b598dbb987f2b7dd0e5ea872ba59c50781fcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "01861bb5ac661535b523a01fb922fdf78d1a1d4f64afa2a7d02fbe0c37505024", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "95a31c3909011cf6a1ebfb0aaf19440e462c0abf2546e74e962a87e80b42610e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a93374608551ced9d3c5903900c2fc182fdaf94a648c5798d248cb95bc13cef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4012f": { @@ -345520,7 +365487,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4012f", "family_id": "terrain-40125-40134", "job_id": "terrain-40125-40134", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345536,6 +365503,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/candidate.json", "sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d1c21018461c039b710ddc6f80de163756ccf01e4a8684fd87323e7dc6f95082", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.733706+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"ground_topography\": \"All five featureless ground variants stay ground; fissures4012e\\u201340131 retain source branching and edge directions; rock clusters40132\\u201340134 retain principal count/location, scale and brown identity. Shared ground atlas cells beyond40134 are outside approval scope; existing40138 rejection preserved.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 88b53b4b2f29bbddb668d5b2b90ed1dbc0e42d3e699f330a01d9e239a3778202", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40125", + "40126", + "40127", + "40128" + ], + "sha256": "ff046123d25c0950738c37fc1125c25b0978d294a0fe79486d96380e9975c5b9", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40129", + "4012a", + "4012b", + "4012c" + ], + "sha256": "cead42d6055c342a23a8fef2251a9972e57838e4d82e103f32899962618f8dbe", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4012d", + "4012e", + "4012f", + "40130" + ], + "sha256": "df7bd16455c07c6bdbf22be44c20980141a623f53f68aed43a97d6122ca000d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40131", + "40132", + "40133", + "40134" + ], + "sha256": "49d8e2721b003e276c18520130472f4ff30509c81f89ba8140f3952c4d1005d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "39b6a46b61ba95278d911b6a80012aa3bd0929a92fbffd43cb928355ec4bef75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c2f42ca88f187a4c55130e7118e0c72e70351ed81b397b9e7e6937535397928", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcd01e3c32f553247de716539710ede996e6ff258c71ed2ea4848f83099c9f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d7fc7ea76f896d0af4095302a2d8bf6a7dc6c0f878c3979053ad366b01584cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b34a2386d71dc6167d267750cd4c1d5a8f7014698ed9f10c46cd7b8e38c21f0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "71313fdc08fd481d9dcaedce2b68ad92c8cea851550f0ba85d4d59c568baca01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c0fcb9f037d549c501fb6516e8cc48a1cc7a4230c37dccbd29a8dd742211e8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b27a3c751273dc563d6d3874c7ec295a65698d2450d2ebae9a92327f0321a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e0b8730d2f291998138cebba411392b730e414102112c38042ba67931ba63e0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "894dc6b28a9adeeed0d863e0fb62fc1d2df28f7b0e2b02be4d721aaa1845647f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "753a6ae1e44c5e43aad89ed68058626342a184cd9ce9009bd0e5e5e1829e9b32", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b65356700fd03566f2f545d9c8dc76e14bef80a6c1d1899d108b759519163d41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a712a1a8cd4e77ef1a4ed71da8c714022a40734fc76d2296ae534149c7dbfb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "31535cec9b1f287c3b5c819bb92c5792fef6e34343366c1b01c758a2551dceb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3237e849259d1fa4bcf62314e98bdc4f4dc2300bd58093c4a4b26e933bcc72d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d1918f3ee5a45bec07e3d386301be6176087df231c6097d29df1b3f65c8615e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "368914f49681185268325652a9f0c61a0b7c59d0bf02d7fd96c90b12ab20f2e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fa8b00511a179327d40781192a981f023c3ae47accaa2b4c2b0487cc85005c97", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "11caeb65c4f04c97f74bbb15b38af1829bed2f1dd465c5804d05fd5356ce7df4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8cfb6dda870a9ae7d0dcac12e09fe385e6aa8fc78cdc383088b2281cb2d44f07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3555970e3f9e2176114f91a4e595c9dd2d848ccd9e46f2c1e5cca9c6200f2298", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bda78fe91e5ceaefe6ae733b70907fcfcbeb5ee8ae66fdc20e2c21103f91c3db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5d85da319cf6e0eb58ee07a136917c9c8c632102b8db1c9b716f6c6a02f8d3a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "667b08a09d94345808eac90f347e51859c5fbe74dd46fd2874a5a0ca87b364c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "dcba38c97e43dcc48320c5fe7e92a0718de7ff6bec63de2c2e4843f6d3b30048", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "804dc0ab5f297799e5717dc9f2aa873efae84f38e512c39d11ebca711ab89ccf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1aeb19f5ae7f55baef504fe8dac4eab7f2b69b61b1a3f8eaeda0b0fef6625072", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f209bd186972159a8019d3138669849376eed03cdfcd915017297205ceacb0d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d6aca5b373bc0d340b0692b99df38936e2c5ecefc7bda3f8a5eb2c73e66ba7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a8b36af129b2d2a631f8a452e5fcf617b7170a9a870205a086e36408e78e1931", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db1b8c298742dbeac2f63b162bfc6d8f7823b784267a689810bed908da320a27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "35a9bcf736d7c10010a8826da2892e238d30be12c161426d87eb877317641aa7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f2ce821f5d33511475772e51bd274c2b37259f4f3429f633fd651aac57ebd83d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4a1b5ed0e794f949c1c29a77b872fde1e0717186d932527e74327e1ee7747631", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52dcc5e7686e826e3181bb68610a962eb7dda62a261a28ba1de1bf9e5f43814c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6f09ead046c0cb0ea4314242d7fecccc5e154894508a33c8ad4a98b362415661", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26aa036da340fd20fd3bd6338113456a7eab81eb606baebe797f6a19ce57ae0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81e001aff228f78b841eb9811904706e35b166248cfc9c7b51b316c63afad887", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4e875c6b021628443495f967091e6a45edb96d8262e5eb3b798d295a4c62362b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30174f98ee63b0f65932816b480baa9e276cc6778d07637b096af7062c739888", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06189914280c66bb3fc98d184848d153dca72952d2c88d8398b2d9c6eb6d13d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "222387972a103fad9390604d4440ce827abf59fd4713bbdf6f8865f33e773ce0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5b692dac2331d4edd2a4751b312a3f6ab08a0e9592589d01d97b6b580c73d606", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f7b0982bc5f2e486520c714078525e7ea006fbb2c0e16ae0c89b0dcecb67401", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80eeb99c1ccc109d9f86371e093a4a5b3808da2b2c62eb50ab63cfd5d89bdf77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bccf61b4cb7cce8b5d144b88edbd2c7868306d91bf0237240f5d2ea419bd4428", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2374513de03d44405106824abf734517d878d5d10af5f5d54d148318664f15ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "92ba61fd81f030eb33d41a7b600baf5684a929790de069c4c0a6e32f18066de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b148a3f285ca3a37b414b3cc0fc0904301f615ece781953f9b5b29a689175806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3206b0490155d47cd32913533ad42c57222ba0714162121fc169f1e40e8405c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "18bb7647dad8ba4fc6fe500e70c2bb879e340e8babf08ed47e66b301b1c5f1c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c60718867c84d32ad512e3749bbf5cfbf2373c5e289314fbf4af08b98de0f8b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "eea762f538e5b1611022e242fdb6bdc18bba987af318e9c6faa2bbf6b47c5152", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1c48504d0b42df33c5de0779c424c34a36e774e074856281e4d3e5f1ef7d9b72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ec2999dff502882b5a2bfb8ea4c7de9f427c01c660d4abf9bbb220367f48bfe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0cf2880c8c1bcff497c2652c8ba32b2368806a687e846df39ca00bd04269f1bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6583d2e7217aae07c769f8cfa84bcc56426f287865b1409c681612ff4905857", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "850b6c9cbf66fde98152a049aa4ece56d9281a5e17fb2e915eb3443ab002c7c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "012346f5fa60e0fb2545cbad81929e12029a2c270d0ece8790eac56df540c140", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1a98f2b5f8c660ba1a29907cc6610006146be0dd76398da79c6cb49ce62cb8ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35fd28460f47e8471b9a3dd8a697aaf978b82be4336c4af69af38684baa1a075", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "44978fab3a43eaddaba266e1b71b640263a23256a873626e2444f553cd0c7fcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "876a8e70267f2b886e189c42aafe58364007ccf288eea862ff15da337fd562ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f19ca34caba18ca28967a7f581c2e6b2b4c89e0fad277b2dfb7e9a6d0a96a47d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab490c204065c976719bc6c7d629496fea98313031e8881eb48bf0ea19900b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "30ea3be2b19e035aa13f5c00f26ca4bfaadffb508d16d66c6250df7f123f9e0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "101158f62d925d76670a9a6b30de77f67f3b143b2eb2f511b59ccc69fa19e1ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2f293da4835a8b403ab2d3a3f7982321fdd9557778b6667fbec83173b97e49", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8a0def269b604915124b11a74a8e6e0fe9c43c916b4551a2d81412894119a28e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a86513a89ed2b7100538d7bc31e724e5dd7dd9371e8af886c07f971d7013f5d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "15d68049b62b5589f7c6fc0aadc57710e5ba0330d28743b352dc21e28903b29c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "38d8923d099ee90c13c820960b6c064f2cbea0312eebf34318ccd20ea895ccbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "99ad2762f3cfc3bc4762d53229a63468452c4fd18139f00118926526c64f3b3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "26cbe0ce5cd528a0a7e7174e44d46274dece5717095d56eea0da83255241b61a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-original.ppm", + "sha256": "928a6d1a802efadadc24db01def7b01cc963202a277bfae37421659da11b01ac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df6dc1a38be8f9594a1faf12e46039608b35df79bf0e0f1981ec63e0de442c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "209718e85a6a3bd19450282cf1b598dbb987f2b7dd0e5ea872ba59c50781fcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "01861bb5ac661535b523a01fb922fdf78d1a1d4f64afa2a7d02fbe0c37505024", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "95a31c3909011cf6a1ebfb0aaf19440e462c0abf2546e74e962a87e80b42610e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a93374608551ced9d3c5903900c2fc182fdaf94a648c5798d248cb95bc13cef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40130": { @@ -345557,7 +365994,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40130", "family_id": "terrain-40125-40134", "job_id": "terrain-40125-40134", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345573,6 +366010,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/candidate.json", "sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d1c21018461c039b710ddc6f80de163756ccf01e4a8684fd87323e7dc6f95082", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.733706+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"ground_topography\": \"All five featureless ground variants stay ground; fissures4012e\\u201340131 retain source branching and edge directions; rock clusters40132\\u201340134 retain principal count/location, scale and brown identity. Shared ground atlas cells beyond40134 are outside approval scope; existing40138 rejection preserved.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 88b53b4b2f29bbddb668d5b2b90ed1dbc0e42d3e699f330a01d9e239a3778202", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40125", + "40126", + "40127", + "40128" + ], + "sha256": "ff046123d25c0950738c37fc1125c25b0978d294a0fe79486d96380e9975c5b9", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40129", + "4012a", + "4012b", + "4012c" + ], + "sha256": "cead42d6055c342a23a8fef2251a9972e57838e4d82e103f32899962618f8dbe", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4012d", + "4012e", + "4012f", + "40130" + ], + "sha256": "df7bd16455c07c6bdbf22be44c20980141a623f53f68aed43a97d6122ca000d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40131", + "40132", + "40133", + "40134" + ], + "sha256": "49d8e2721b003e276c18520130472f4ff30509c81f89ba8140f3952c4d1005d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "39b6a46b61ba95278d911b6a80012aa3bd0929a92fbffd43cb928355ec4bef75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c2f42ca88f187a4c55130e7118e0c72e70351ed81b397b9e7e6937535397928", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcd01e3c32f553247de716539710ede996e6ff258c71ed2ea4848f83099c9f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d7fc7ea76f896d0af4095302a2d8bf6a7dc6c0f878c3979053ad366b01584cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b34a2386d71dc6167d267750cd4c1d5a8f7014698ed9f10c46cd7b8e38c21f0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "71313fdc08fd481d9dcaedce2b68ad92c8cea851550f0ba85d4d59c568baca01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c0fcb9f037d549c501fb6516e8cc48a1cc7a4230c37dccbd29a8dd742211e8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b27a3c751273dc563d6d3874c7ec295a65698d2450d2ebae9a92327f0321a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e0b8730d2f291998138cebba411392b730e414102112c38042ba67931ba63e0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "894dc6b28a9adeeed0d863e0fb62fc1d2df28f7b0e2b02be4d721aaa1845647f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "753a6ae1e44c5e43aad89ed68058626342a184cd9ce9009bd0e5e5e1829e9b32", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b65356700fd03566f2f545d9c8dc76e14bef80a6c1d1899d108b759519163d41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a712a1a8cd4e77ef1a4ed71da8c714022a40734fc76d2296ae534149c7dbfb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "31535cec9b1f287c3b5c819bb92c5792fef6e34343366c1b01c758a2551dceb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3237e849259d1fa4bcf62314e98bdc4f4dc2300bd58093c4a4b26e933bcc72d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d1918f3ee5a45bec07e3d386301be6176087df231c6097d29df1b3f65c8615e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "368914f49681185268325652a9f0c61a0b7c59d0bf02d7fd96c90b12ab20f2e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fa8b00511a179327d40781192a981f023c3ae47accaa2b4c2b0487cc85005c97", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "11caeb65c4f04c97f74bbb15b38af1829bed2f1dd465c5804d05fd5356ce7df4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8cfb6dda870a9ae7d0dcac12e09fe385e6aa8fc78cdc383088b2281cb2d44f07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3555970e3f9e2176114f91a4e595c9dd2d848ccd9e46f2c1e5cca9c6200f2298", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bda78fe91e5ceaefe6ae733b70907fcfcbeb5ee8ae66fdc20e2c21103f91c3db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5d85da319cf6e0eb58ee07a136917c9c8c632102b8db1c9b716f6c6a02f8d3a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "667b08a09d94345808eac90f347e51859c5fbe74dd46fd2874a5a0ca87b364c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "dcba38c97e43dcc48320c5fe7e92a0718de7ff6bec63de2c2e4843f6d3b30048", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "804dc0ab5f297799e5717dc9f2aa873efae84f38e512c39d11ebca711ab89ccf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1aeb19f5ae7f55baef504fe8dac4eab7f2b69b61b1a3f8eaeda0b0fef6625072", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f209bd186972159a8019d3138669849376eed03cdfcd915017297205ceacb0d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d6aca5b373bc0d340b0692b99df38936e2c5ecefc7bda3f8a5eb2c73e66ba7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a8b36af129b2d2a631f8a452e5fcf617b7170a9a870205a086e36408e78e1931", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db1b8c298742dbeac2f63b162bfc6d8f7823b784267a689810bed908da320a27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "35a9bcf736d7c10010a8826da2892e238d30be12c161426d87eb877317641aa7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f2ce821f5d33511475772e51bd274c2b37259f4f3429f633fd651aac57ebd83d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4a1b5ed0e794f949c1c29a77b872fde1e0717186d932527e74327e1ee7747631", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52dcc5e7686e826e3181bb68610a962eb7dda62a261a28ba1de1bf9e5f43814c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6f09ead046c0cb0ea4314242d7fecccc5e154894508a33c8ad4a98b362415661", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26aa036da340fd20fd3bd6338113456a7eab81eb606baebe797f6a19ce57ae0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81e001aff228f78b841eb9811904706e35b166248cfc9c7b51b316c63afad887", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4e875c6b021628443495f967091e6a45edb96d8262e5eb3b798d295a4c62362b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30174f98ee63b0f65932816b480baa9e276cc6778d07637b096af7062c739888", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06189914280c66bb3fc98d184848d153dca72952d2c88d8398b2d9c6eb6d13d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "222387972a103fad9390604d4440ce827abf59fd4713bbdf6f8865f33e773ce0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5b692dac2331d4edd2a4751b312a3f6ab08a0e9592589d01d97b6b580c73d606", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f7b0982bc5f2e486520c714078525e7ea006fbb2c0e16ae0c89b0dcecb67401", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80eeb99c1ccc109d9f86371e093a4a5b3808da2b2c62eb50ab63cfd5d89bdf77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bccf61b4cb7cce8b5d144b88edbd2c7868306d91bf0237240f5d2ea419bd4428", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2374513de03d44405106824abf734517d878d5d10af5f5d54d148318664f15ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "92ba61fd81f030eb33d41a7b600baf5684a929790de069c4c0a6e32f18066de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b148a3f285ca3a37b414b3cc0fc0904301f615ece781953f9b5b29a689175806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3206b0490155d47cd32913533ad42c57222ba0714162121fc169f1e40e8405c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "18bb7647dad8ba4fc6fe500e70c2bb879e340e8babf08ed47e66b301b1c5f1c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c60718867c84d32ad512e3749bbf5cfbf2373c5e289314fbf4af08b98de0f8b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "eea762f538e5b1611022e242fdb6bdc18bba987af318e9c6faa2bbf6b47c5152", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1c48504d0b42df33c5de0779c424c34a36e774e074856281e4d3e5f1ef7d9b72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ec2999dff502882b5a2bfb8ea4c7de9f427c01c660d4abf9bbb220367f48bfe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0cf2880c8c1bcff497c2652c8ba32b2368806a687e846df39ca00bd04269f1bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6583d2e7217aae07c769f8cfa84bcc56426f287865b1409c681612ff4905857", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "850b6c9cbf66fde98152a049aa4ece56d9281a5e17fb2e915eb3443ab002c7c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "012346f5fa60e0fb2545cbad81929e12029a2c270d0ece8790eac56df540c140", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1a98f2b5f8c660ba1a29907cc6610006146be0dd76398da79c6cb49ce62cb8ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35fd28460f47e8471b9a3dd8a697aaf978b82be4336c4af69af38684baa1a075", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "44978fab3a43eaddaba266e1b71b640263a23256a873626e2444f553cd0c7fcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "876a8e70267f2b886e189c42aafe58364007ccf288eea862ff15da337fd562ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f19ca34caba18ca28967a7f581c2e6b2b4c89e0fad277b2dfb7e9a6d0a96a47d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab490c204065c976719bc6c7d629496fea98313031e8881eb48bf0ea19900b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "30ea3be2b19e035aa13f5c00f26ca4bfaadffb508d16d66c6250df7f123f9e0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "101158f62d925d76670a9a6b30de77f67f3b143b2eb2f511b59ccc69fa19e1ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2f293da4835a8b403ab2d3a3f7982321fdd9557778b6667fbec83173b97e49", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8a0def269b604915124b11a74a8e6e0fe9c43c916b4551a2d81412894119a28e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a86513a89ed2b7100538d7bc31e724e5dd7dd9371e8af886c07f971d7013f5d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "15d68049b62b5589f7c6fc0aadc57710e5ba0330d28743b352dc21e28903b29c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "38d8923d099ee90c13c820960b6c064f2cbea0312eebf34318ccd20ea895ccbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "99ad2762f3cfc3bc4762d53229a63468452c4fd18139f00118926526c64f3b3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "26cbe0ce5cd528a0a7e7174e44d46274dece5717095d56eea0da83255241b61a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-original.ppm", + "sha256": "928a6d1a802efadadc24db01def7b01cc963202a277bfae37421659da11b01ac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df6dc1a38be8f9594a1faf12e46039608b35df79bf0e0f1981ec63e0de442c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "209718e85a6a3bd19450282cf1b598dbb987f2b7dd0e5ea872ba59c50781fcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "01861bb5ac661535b523a01fb922fdf78d1a1d4f64afa2a7d02fbe0c37505024", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "95a31c3909011cf6a1ebfb0aaf19440e462c0abf2546e74e962a87e80b42610e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a93374608551ced9d3c5903900c2fc182fdaf94a648c5798d248cb95bc13cef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40131": { @@ -345594,7 +366501,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40131", "family_id": "terrain-40125-40134", "job_id": "terrain-40125-40134", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345610,6 +366517,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/candidate.json", "sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d1c21018461c039b710ddc6f80de163756ccf01e4a8684fd87323e7dc6f95082", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.733706+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"ground_topography\": \"All five featureless ground variants stay ground; fissures4012e\\u201340131 retain source branching and edge directions; rock clusters40132\\u201340134 retain principal count/location, scale and brown identity. Shared ground atlas cells beyond40134 are outside approval scope; existing40138 rejection preserved.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 88b53b4b2f29bbddb668d5b2b90ed1dbc0e42d3e699f330a01d9e239a3778202", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40125", + "40126", + "40127", + "40128" + ], + "sha256": "ff046123d25c0950738c37fc1125c25b0978d294a0fe79486d96380e9975c5b9", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40129", + "4012a", + "4012b", + "4012c" + ], + "sha256": "cead42d6055c342a23a8fef2251a9972e57838e4d82e103f32899962618f8dbe", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4012d", + "4012e", + "4012f", + "40130" + ], + "sha256": "df7bd16455c07c6bdbf22be44c20980141a623f53f68aed43a97d6122ca000d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40131", + "40132", + "40133", + "40134" + ], + "sha256": "49d8e2721b003e276c18520130472f4ff30509c81f89ba8140f3952c4d1005d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "39b6a46b61ba95278d911b6a80012aa3bd0929a92fbffd43cb928355ec4bef75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c2f42ca88f187a4c55130e7118e0c72e70351ed81b397b9e7e6937535397928", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcd01e3c32f553247de716539710ede996e6ff258c71ed2ea4848f83099c9f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d7fc7ea76f896d0af4095302a2d8bf6a7dc6c0f878c3979053ad366b01584cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b34a2386d71dc6167d267750cd4c1d5a8f7014698ed9f10c46cd7b8e38c21f0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "71313fdc08fd481d9dcaedce2b68ad92c8cea851550f0ba85d4d59c568baca01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c0fcb9f037d549c501fb6516e8cc48a1cc7a4230c37dccbd29a8dd742211e8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b27a3c751273dc563d6d3874c7ec295a65698d2450d2ebae9a92327f0321a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e0b8730d2f291998138cebba411392b730e414102112c38042ba67931ba63e0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "894dc6b28a9adeeed0d863e0fb62fc1d2df28f7b0e2b02be4d721aaa1845647f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "753a6ae1e44c5e43aad89ed68058626342a184cd9ce9009bd0e5e5e1829e9b32", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b65356700fd03566f2f545d9c8dc76e14bef80a6c1d1899d108b759519163d41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a712a1a8cd4e77ef1a4ed71da8c714022a40734fc76d2296ae534149c7dbfb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "31535cec9b1f287c3b5c819bb92c5792fef6e34343366c1b01c758a2551dceb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3237e849259d1fa4bcf62314e98bdc4f4dc2300bd58093c4a4b26e933bcc72d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d1918f3ee5a45bec07e3d386301be6176087df231c6097d29df1b3f65c8615e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "368914f49681185268325652a9f0c61a0b7c59d0bf02d7fd96c90b12ab20f2e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fa8b00511a179327d40781192a981f023c3ae47accaa2b4c2b0487cc85005c97", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "11caeb65c4f04c97f74bbb15b38af1829bed2f1dd465c5804d05fd5356ce7df4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8cfb6dda870a9ae7d0dcac12e09fe385e6aa8fc78cdc383088b2281cb2d44f07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3555970e3f9e2176114f91a4e595c9dd2d848ccd9e46f2c1e5cca9c6200f2298", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bda78fe91e5ceaefe6ae733b70907fcfcbeb5ee8ae66fdc20e2c21103f91c3db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5d85da319cf6e0eb58ee07a136917c9c8c632102b8db1c9b716f6c6a02f8d3a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "667b08a09d94345808eac90f347e51859c5fbe74dd46fd2874a5a0ca87b364c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "dcba38c97e43dcc48320c5fe7e92a0718de7ff6bec63de2c2e4843f6d3b30048", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "804dc0ab5f297799e5717dc9f2aa873efae84f38e512c39d11ebca711ab89ccf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1aeb19f5ae7f55baef504fe8dac4eab7f2b69b61b1a3f8eaeda0b0fef6625072", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f209bd186972159a8019d3138669849376eed03cdfcd915017297205ceacb0d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d6aca5b373bc0d340b0692b99df38936e2c5ecefc7bda3f8a5eb2c73e66ba7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a8b36af129b2d2a631f8a452e5fcf617b7170a9a870205a086e36408e78e1931", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db1b8c298742dbeac2f63b162bfc6d8f7823b784267a689810bed908da320a27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "35a9bcf736d7c10010a8826da2892e238d30be12c161426d87eb877317641aa7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f2ce821f5d33511475772e51bd274c2b37259f4f3429f633fd651aac57ebd83d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4a1b5ed0e794f949c1c29a77b872fde1e0717186d932527e74327e1ee7747631", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52dcc5e7686e826e3181bb68610a962eb7dda62a261a28ba1de1bf9e5f43814c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6f09ead046c0cb0ea4314242d7fecccc5e154894508a33c8ad4a98b362415661", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26aa036da340fd20fd3bd6338113456a7eab81eb606baebe797f6a19ce57ae0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81e001aff228f78b841eb9811904706e35b166248cfc9c7b51b316c63afad887", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4e875c6b021628443495f967091e6a45edb96d8262e5eb3b798d295a4c62362b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30174f98ee63b0f65932816b480baa9e276cc6778d07637b096af7062c739888", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06189914280c66bb3fc98d184848d153dca72952d2c88d8398b2d9c6eb6d13d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "222387972a103fad9390604d4440ce827abf59fd4713bbdf6f8865f33e773ce0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5b692dac2331d4edd2a4751b312a3f6ab08a0e9592589d01d97b6b580c73d606", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f7b0982bc5f2e486520c714078525e7ea006fbb2c0e16ae0c89b0dcecb67401", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80eeb99c1ccc109d9f86371e093a4a5b3808da2b2c62eb50ab63cfd5d89bdf77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bccf61b4cb7cce8b5d144b88edbd2c7868306d91bf0237240f5d2ea419bd4428", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2374513de03d44405106824abf734517d878d5d10af5f5d54d148318664f15ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "92ba61fd81f030eb33d41a7b600baf5684a929790de069c4c0a6e32f18066de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b148a3f285ca3a37b414b3cc0fc0904301f615ece781953f9b5b29a689175806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3206b0490155d47cd32913533ad42c57222ba0714162121fc169f1e40e8405c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "18bb7647dad8ba4fc6fe500e70c2bb879e340e8babf08ed47e66b301b1c5f1c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c60718867c84d32ad512e3749bbf5cfbf2373c5e289314fbf4af08b98de0f8b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "eea762f538e5b1611022e242fdb6bdc18bba987af318e9c6faa2bbf6b47c5152", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1c48504d0b42df33c5de0779c424c34a36e774e074856281e4d3e5f1ef7d9b72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ec2999dff502882b5a2bfb8ea4c7de9f427c01c660d4abf9bbb220367f48bfe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0cf2880c8c1bcff497c2652c8ba32b2368806a687e846df39ca00bd04269f1bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6583d2e7217aae07c769f8cfa84bcc56426f287865b1409c681612ff4905857", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "850b6c9cbf66fde98152a049aa4ece56d9281a5e17fb2e915eb3443ab002c7c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "012346f5fa60e0fb2545cbad81929e12029a2c270d0ece8790eac56df540c140", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1a98f2b5f8c660ba1a29907cc6610006146be0dd76398da79c6cb49ce62cb8ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35fd28460f47e8471b9a3dd8a697aaf978b82be4336c4af69af38684baa1a075", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "44978fab3a43eaddaba266e1b71b640263a23256a873626e2444f553cd0c7fcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "876a8e70267f2b886e189c42aafe58364007ccf288eea862ff15da337fd562ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f19ca34caba18ca28967a7f581c2e6b2b4c89e0fad277b2dfb7e9a6d0a96a47d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab490c204065c976719bc6c7d629496fea98313031e8881eb48bf0ea19900b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "30ea3be2b19e035aa13f5c00f26ca4bfaadffb508d16d66c6250df7f123f9e0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "101158f62d925d76670a9a6b30de77f67f3b143b2eb2f511b59ccc69fa19e1ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2f293da4835a8b403ab2d3a3f7982321fdd9557778b6667fbec83173b97e49", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8a0def269b604915124b11a74a8e6e0fe9c43c916b4551a2d81412894119a28e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a86513a89ed2b7100538d7bc31e724e5dd7dd9371e8af886c07f971d7013f5d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "15d68049b62b5589f7c6fc0aadc57710e5ba0330d28743b352dc21e28903b29c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "38d8923d099ee90c13c820960b6c064f2cbea0312eebf34318ccd20ea895ccbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "99ad2762f3cfc3bc4762d53229a63468452c4fd18139f00118926526c64f3b3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "26cbe0ce5cd528a0a7e7174e44d46274dece5717095d56eea0da83255241b61a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-original.ppm", + "sha256": "928a6d1a802efadadc24db01def7b01cc963202a277bfae37421659da11b01ac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df6dc1a38be8f9594a1faf12e46039608b35df79bf0e0f1981ec63e0de442c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "209718e85a6a3bd19450282cf1b598dbb987f2b7dd0e5ea872ba59c50781fcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "01861bb5ac661535b523a01fb922fdf78d1a1d4f64afa2a7d02fbe0c37505024", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "95a31c3909011cf6a1ebfb0aaf19440e462c0abf2546e74e962a87e80b42610e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a93374608551ced9d3c5903900c2fc182fdaf94a648c5798d248cb95bc13cef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40132": { @@ -345631,7 +367008,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40132", "family_id": "terrain-40125-40134", "job_id": "terrain-40125-40134", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345647,6 +367024,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/candidate.json", "sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d1c21018461c039b710ddc6f80de163756ccf01e4a8684fd87323e7dc6f95082", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.733706+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"ground_topography\": \"All five featureless ground variants stay ground; fissures4012e\\u201340131 retain source branching and edge directions; rock clusters40132\\u201340134 retain principal count/location, scale and brown identity. Shared ground atlas cells beyond40134 are outside approval scope; existing40138 rejection preserved.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 88b53b4b2f29bbddb668d5b2b90ed1dbc0e42d3e699f330a01d9e239a3778202", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40125", + "40126", + "40127", + "40128" + ], + "sha256": "ff046123d25c0950738c37fc1125c25b0978d294a0fe79486d96380e9975c5b9", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40129", + "4012a", + "4012b", + "4012c" + ], + "sha256": "cead42d6055c342a23a8fef2251a9972e57838e4d82e103f32899962618f8dbe", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4012d", + "4012e", + "4012f", + "40130" + ], + "sha256": "df7bd16455c07c6bdbf22be44c20980141a623f53f68aed43a97d6122ca000d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40131", + "40132", + "40133", + "40134" + ], + "sha256": "49d8e2721b003e276c18520130472f4ff30509c81f89ba8140f3952c4d1005d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "39b6a46b61ba95278d911b6a80012aa3bd0929a92fbffd43cb928355ec4bef75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c2f42ca88f187a4c55130e7118e0c72e70351ed81b397b9e7e6937535397928", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcd01e3c32f553247de716539710ede996e6ff258c71ed2ea4848f83099c9f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d7fc7ea76f896d0af4095302a2d8bf6a7dc6c0f878c3979053ad366b01584cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b34a2386d71dc6167d267750cd4c1d5a8f7014698ed9f10c46cd7b8e38c21f0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "71313fdc08fd481d9dcaedce2b68ad92c8cea851550f0ba85d4d59c568baca01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c0fcb9f037d549c501fb6516e8cc48a1cc7a4230c37dccbd29a8dd742211e8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b27a3c751273dc563d6d3874c7ec295a65698d2450d2ebae9a92327f0321a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e0b8730d2f291998138cebba411392b730e414102112c38042ba67931ba63e0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "894dc6b28a9adeeed0d863e0fb62fc1d2df28f7b0e2b02be4d721aaa1845647f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "753a6ae1e44c5e43aad89ed68058626342a184cd9ce9009bd0e5e5e1829e9b32", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b65356700fd03566f2f545d9c8dc76e14bef80a6c1d1899d108b759519163d41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a712a1a8cd4e77ef1a4ed71da8c714022a40734fc76d2296ae534149c7dbfb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "31535cec9b1f287c3b5c819bb92c5792fef6e34343366c1b01c758a2551dceb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3237e849259d1fa4bcf62314e98bdc4f4dc2300bd58093c4a4b26e933bcc72d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d1918f3ee5a45bec07e3d386301be6176087df231c6097d29df1b3f65c8615e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "368914f49681185268325652a9f0c61a0b7c59d0bf02d7fd96c90b12ab20f2e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fa8b00511a179327d40781192a981f023c3ae47accaa2b4c2b0487cc85005c97", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "11caeb65c4f04c97f74bbb15b38af1829bed2f1dd465c5804d05fd5356ce7df4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8cfb6dda870a9ae7d0dcac12e09fe385e6aa8fc78cdc383088b2281cb2d44f07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3555970e3f9e2176114f91a4e595c9dd2d848ccd9e46f2c1e5cca9c6200f2298", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bda78fe91e5ceaefe6ae733b70907fcfcbeb5ee8ae66fdc20e2c21103f91c3db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5d85da319cf6e0eb58ee07a136917c9c8c632102b8db1c9b716f6c6a02f8d3a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "667b08a09d94345808eac90f347e51859c5fbe74dd46fd2874a5a0ca87b364c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "dcba38c97e43dcc48320c5fe7e92a0718de7ff6bec63de2c2e4843f6d3b30048", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "804dc0ab5f297799e5717dc9f2aa873efae84f38e512c39d11ebca711ab89ccf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1aeb19f5ae7f55baef504fe8dac4eab7f2b69b61b1a3f8eaeda0b0fef6625072", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f209bd186972159a8019d3138669849376eed03cdfcd915017297205ceacb0d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d6aca5b373bc0d340b0692b99df38936e2c5ecefc7bda3f8a5eb2c73e66ba7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a8b36af129b2d2a631f8a452e5fcf617b7170a9a870205a086e36408e78e1931", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db1b8c298742dbeac2f63b162bfc6d8f7823b784267a689810bed908da320a27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "35a9bcf736d7c10010a8826da2892e238d30be12c161426d87eb877317641aa7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f2ce821f5d33511475772e51bd274c2b37259f4f3429f633fd651aac57ebd83d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4a1b5ed0e794f949c1c29a77b872fde1e0717186d932527e74327e1ee7747631", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52dcc5e7686e826e3181bb68610a962eb7dda62a261a28ba1de1bf9e5f43814c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6f09ead046c0cb0ea4314242d7fecccc5e154894508a33c8ad4a98b362415661", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26aa036da340fd20fd3bd6338113456a7eab81eb606baebe797f6a19ce57ae0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81e001aff228f78b841eb9811904706e35b166248cfc9c7b51b316c63afad887", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4e875c6b021628443495f967091e6a45edb96d8262e5eb3b798d295a4c62362b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30174f98ee63b0f65932816b480baa9e276cc6778d07637b096af7062c739888", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06189914280c66bb3fc98d184848d153dca72952d2c88d8398b2d9c6eb6d13d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "222387972a103fad9390604d4440ce827abf59fd4713bbdf6f8865f33e773ce0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5b692dac2331d4edd2a4751b312a3f6ab08a0e9592589d01d97b6b580c73d606", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f7b0982bc5f2e486520c714078525e7ea006fbb2c0e16ae0c89b0dcecb67401", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80eeb99c1ccc109d9f86371e093a4a5b3808da2b2c62eb50ab63cfd5d89bdf77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bccf61b4cb7cce8b5d144b88edbd2c7868306d91bf0237240f5d2ea419bd4428", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2374513de03d44405106824abf734517d878d5d10af5f5d54d148318664f15ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "92ba61fd81f030eb33d41a7b600baf5684a929790de069c4c0a6e32f18066de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b148a3f285ca3a37b414b3cc0fc0904301f615ece781953f9b5b29a689175806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3206b0490155d47cd32913533ad42c57222ba0714162121fc169f1e40e8405c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "18bb7647dad8ba4fc6fe500e70c2bb879e340e8babf08ed47e66b301b1c5f1c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c60718867c84d32ad512e3749bbf5cfbf2373c5e289314fbf4af08b98de0f8b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "eea762f538e5b1611022e242fdb6bdc18bba987af318e9c6faa2bbf6b47c5152", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1c48504d0b42df33c5de0779c424c34a36e774e074856281e4d3e5f1ef7d9b72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ec2999dff502882b5a2bfb8ea4c7de9f427c01c660d4abf9bbb220367f48bfe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0cf2880c8c1bcff497c2652c8ba32b2368806a687e846df39ca00bd04269f1bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6583d2e7217aae07c769f8cfa84bcc56426f287865b1409c681612ff4905857", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "850b6c9cbf66fde98152a049aa4ece56d9281a5e17fb2e915eb3443ab002c7c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "012346f5fa60e0fb2545cbad81929e12029a2c270d0ece8790eac56df540c140", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1a98f2b5f8c660ba1a29907cc6610006146be0dd76398da79c6cb49ce62cb8ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35fd28460f47e8471b9a3dd8a697aaf978b82be4336c4af69af38684baa1a075", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "44978fab3a43eaddaba266e1b71b640263a23256a873626e2444f553cd0c7fcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "876a8e70267f2b886e189c42aafe58364007ccf288eea862ff15da337fd562ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f19ca34caba18ca28967a7f581c2e6b2b4c89e0fad277b2dfb7e9a6d0a96a47d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab490c204065c976719bc6c7d629496fea98313031e8881eb48bf0ea19900b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "30ea3be2b19e035aa13f5c00f26ca4bfaadffb508d16d66c6250df7f123f9e0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "101158f62d925d76670a9a6b30de77f67f3b143b2eb2f511b59ccc69fa19e1ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2f293da4835a8b403ab2d3a3f7982321fdd9557778b6667fbec83173b97e49", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8a0def269b604915124b11a74a8e6e0fe9c43c916b4551a2d81412894119a28e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a86513a89ed2b7100538d7bc31e724e5dd7dd9371e8af886c07f971d7013f5d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "15d68049b62b5589f7c6fc0aadc57710e5ba0330d28743b352dc21e28903b29c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "38d8923d099ee90c13c820960b6c064f2cbea0312eebf34318ccd20ea895ccbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "99ad2762f3cfc3bc4762d53229a63468452c4fd18139f00118926526c64f3b3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "26cbe0ce5cd528a0a7e7174e44d46274dece5717095d56eea0da83255241b61a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-original.ppm", + "sha256": "928a6d1a802efadadc24db01def7b01cc963202a277bfae37421659da11b01ac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df6dc1a38be8f9594a1faf12e46039608b35df79bf0e0f1981ec63e0de442c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "209718e85a6a3bd19450282cf1b598dbb987f2b7dd0e5ea872ba59c50781fcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "01861bb5ac661535b523a01fb922fdf78d1a1d4f64afa2a7d02fbe0c37505024", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "95a31c3909011cf6a1ebfb0aaf19440e462c0abf2546e74e962a87e80b42610e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a93374608551ced9d3c5903900c2fc182fdaf94a648c5798d248cb95bc13cef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40133": { @@ -345668,7 +367515,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40133", "family_id": "terrain-40125-40134", "job_id": "terrain-40125-40134", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345684,6 +367531,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/candidate.json", "sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d1c21018461c039b710ddc6f80de163756ccf01e4a8684fd87323e7dc6f95082", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.733706+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"ground_topography\": \"All five featureless ground variants stay ground; fissures4012e\\u201340131 retain source branching and edge directions; rock clusters40132\\u201340134 retain principal count/location, scale and brown identity. Shared ground atlas cells beyond40134 are outside approval scope; existing40138 rejection preserved.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 88b53b4b2f29bbddb668d5b2b90ed1dbc0e42d3e699f330a01d9e239a3778202", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40125", + "40126", + "40127", + "40128" + ], + "sha256": "ff046123d25c0950738c37fc1125c25b0978d294a0fe79486d96380e9975c5b9", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40129", + "4012a", + "4012b", + "4012c" + ], + "sha256": "cead42d6055c342a23a8fef2251a9972e57838e4d82e103f32899962618f8dbe", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4012d", + "4012e", + "4012f", + "40130" + ], + "sha256": "df7bd16455c07c6bdbf22be44c20980141a623f53f68aed43a97d6122ca000d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40131", + "40132", + "40133", + "40134" + ], + "sha256": "49d8e2721b003e276c18520130472f4ff30509c81f89ba8140f3952c4d1005d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "39b6a46b61ba95278d911b6a80012aa3bd0929a92fbffd43cb928355ec4bef75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c2f42ca88f187a4c55130e7118e0c72e70351ed81b397b9e7e6937535397928", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcd01e3c32f553247de716539710ede996e6ff258c71ed2ea4848f83099c9f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d7fc7ea76f896d0af4095302a2d8bf6a7dc6c0f878c3979053ad366b01584cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b34a2386d71dc6167d267750cd4c1d5a8f7014698ed9f10c46cd7b8e38c21f0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "71313fdc08fd481d9dcaedce2b68ad92c8cea851550f0ba85d4d59c568baca01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c0fcb9f037d549c501fb6516e8cc48a1cc7a4230c37dccbd29a8dd742211e8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b27a3c751273dc563d6d3874c7ec295a65698d2450d2ebae9a92327f0321a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e0b8730d2f291998138cebba411392b730e414102112c38042ba67931ba63e0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "894dc6b28a9adeeed0d863e0fb62fc1d2df28f7b0e2b02be4d721aaa1845647f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "753a6ae1e44c5e43aad89ed68058626342a184cd9ce9009bd0e5e5e1829e9b32", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b65356700fd03566f2f545d9c8dc76e14bef80a6c1d1899d108b759519163d41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a712a1a8cd4e77ef1a4ed71da8c714022a40734fc76d2296ae534149c7dbfb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "31535cec9b1f287c3b5c819bb92c5792fef6e34343366c1b01c758a2551dceb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3237e849259d1fa4bcf62314e98bdc4f4dc2300bd58093c4a4b26e933bcc72d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d1918f3ee5a45bec07e3d386301be6176087df231c6097d29df1b3f65c8615e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "368914f49681185268325652a9f0c61a0b7c59d0bf02d7fd96c90b12ab20f2e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fa8b00511a179327d40781192a981f023c3ae47accaa2b4c2b0487cc85005c97", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "11caeb65c4f04c97f74bbb15b38af1829bed2f1dd465c5804d05fd5356ce7df4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8cfb6dda870a9ae7d0dcac12e09fe385e6aa8fc78cdc383088b2281cb2d44f07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3555970e3f9e2176114f91a4e595c9dd2d848ccd9e46f2c1e5cca9c6200f2298", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bda78fe91e5ceaefe6ae733b70907fcfcbeb5ee8ae66fdc20e2c21103f91c3db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5d85da319cf6e0eb58ee07a136917c9c8c632102b8db1c9b716f6c6a02f8d3a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "667b08a09d94345808eac90f347e51859c5fbe74dd46fd2874a5a0ca87b364c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "dcba38c97e43dcc48320c5fe7e92a0718de7ff6bec63de2c2e4843f6d3b30048", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "804dc0ab5f297799e5717dc9f2aa873efae84f38e512c39d11ebca711ab89ccf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1aeb19f5ae7f55baef504fe8dac4eab7f2b69b61b1a3f8eaeda0b0fef6625072", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f209bd186972159a8019d3138669849376eed03cdfcd915017297205ceacb0d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d6aca5b373bc0d340b0692b99df38936e2c5ecefc7bda3f8a5eb2c73e66ba7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a8b36af129b2d2a631f8a452e5fcf617b7170a9a870205a086e36408e78e1931", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db1b8c298742dbeac2f63b162bfc6d8f7823b784267a689810bed908da320a27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "35a9bcf736d7c10010a8826da2892e238d30be12c161426d87eb877317641aa7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f2ce821f5d33511475772e51bd274c2b37259f4f3429f633fd651aac57ebd83d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4a1b5ed0e794f949c1c29a77b872fde1e0717186d932527e74327e1ee7747631", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52dcc5e7686e826e3181bb68610a962eb7dda62a261a28ba1de1bf9e5f43814c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6f09ead046c0cb0ea4314242d7fecccc5e154894508a33c8ad4a98b362415661", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26aa036da340fd20fd3bd6338113456a7eab81eb606baebe797f6a19ce57ae0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81e001aff228f78b841eb9811904706e35b166248cfc9c7b51b316c63afad887", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4e875c6b021628443495f967091e6a45edb96d8262e5eb3b798d295a4c62362b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30174f98ee63b0f65932816b480baa9e276cc6778d07637b096af7062c739888", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06189914280c66bb3fc98d184848d153dca72952d2c88d8398b2d9c6eb6d13d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "222387972a103fad9390604d4440ce827abf59fd4713bbdf6f8865f33e773ce0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5b692dac2331d4edd2a4751b312a3f6ab08a0e9592589d01d97b6b580c73d606", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f7b0982bc5f2e486520c714078525e7ea006fbb2c0e16ae0c89b0dcecb67401", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80eeb99c1ccc109d9f86371e093a4a5b3808da2b2c62eb50ab63cfd5d89bdf77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bccf61b4cb7cce8b5d144b88edbd2c7868306d91bf0237240f5d2ea419bd4428", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2374513de03d44405106824abf734517d878d5d10af5f5d54d148318664f15ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "92ba61fd81f030eb33d41a7b600baf5684a929790de069c4c0a6e32f18066de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b148a3f285ca3a37b414b3cc0fc0904301f615ece781953f9b5b29a689175806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3206b0490155d47cd32913533ad42c57222ba0714162121fc169f1e40e8405c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "18bb7647dad8ba4fc6fe500e70c2bb879e340e8babf08ed47e66b301b1c5f1c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c60718867c84d32ad512e3749bbf5cfbf2373c5e289314fbf4af08b98de0f8b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "eea762f538e5b1611022e242fdb6bdc18bba987af318e9c6faa2bbf6b47c5152", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1c48504d0b42df33c5de0779c424c34a36e774e074856281e4d3e5f1ef7d9b72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ec2999dff502882b5a2bfb8ea4c7de9f427c01c660d4abf9bbb220367f48bfe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0cf2880c8c1bcff497c2652c8ba32b2368806a687e846df39ca00bd04269f1bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6583d2e7217aae07c769f8cfa84bcc56426f287865b1409c681612ff4905857", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "850b6c9cbf66fde98152a049aa4ece56d9281a5e17fb2e915eb3443ab002c7c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "012346f5fa60e0fb2545cbad81929e12029a2c270d0ece8790eac56df540c140", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1a98f2b5f8c660ba1a29907cc6610006146be0dd76398da79c6cb49ce62cb8ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35fd28460f47e8471b9a3dd8a697aaf978b82be4336c4af69af38684baa1a075", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "44978fab3a43eaddaba266e1b71b640263a23256a873626e2444f553cd0c7fcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "876a8e70267f2b886e189c42aafe58364007ccf288eea862ff15da337fd562ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f19ca34caba18ca28967a7f581c2e6b2b4c89e0fad277b2dfb7e9a6d0a96a47d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab490c204065c976719bc6c7d629496fea98313031e8881eb48bf0ea19900b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "30ea3be2b19e035aa13f5c00f26ca4bfaadffb508d16d66c6250df7f123f9e0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "101158f62d925d76670a9a6b30de77f67f3b143b2eb2f511b59ccc69fa19e1ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2f293da4835a8b403ab2d3a3f7982321fdd9557778b6667fbec83173b97e49", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8a0def269b604915124b11a74a8e6e0fe9c43c916b4551a2d81412894119a28e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a86513a89ed2b7100538d7bc31e724e5dd7dd9371e8af886c07f971d7013f5d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "15d68049b62b5589f7c6fc0aadc57710e5ba0330d28743b352dc21e28903b29c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "38d8923d099ee90c13c820960b6c064f2cbea0312eebf34318ccd20ea895ccbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "99ad2762f3cfc3bc4762d53229a63468452c4fd18139f00118926526c64f3b3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "26cbe0ce5cd528a0a7e7174e44d46274dece5717095d56eea0da83255241b61a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-original.ppm", + "sha256": "928a6d1a802efadadc24db01def7b01cc963202a277bfae37421659da11b01ac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df6dc1a38be8f9594a1faf12e46039608b35df79bf0e0f1981ec63e0de442c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "209718e85a6a3bd19450282cf1b598dbb987f2b7dd0e5ea872ba59c50781fcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "01861bb5ac661535b523a01fb922fdf78d1a1d4f64afa2a7d02fbe0c37505024", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "95a31c3909011cf6a1ebfb0aaf19440e462c0abf2546e74e962a87e80b42610e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a93374608551ced9d3c5903900c2fc182fdaf94a648c5798d248cb95bc13cef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40134": { @@ -345705,7 +368022,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40134", "family_id": "terrain-40125-40134", "job_id": "terrain-40125-40134", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345721,6 +368038,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/candidate.json", "sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e59e302c84410669046e7207ae2c9f75701a5ae7fa1143cfb5af210b955052a3", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d1c21018461c039b710ddc6f80de163756ccf01e4a8684fd87323e7dc6f95082", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:30.733706+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40125-40134/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"Every original32x32 canvas and origin0 preserved. Burned square control units retain surviving rims/connector directions; source five parallel pipe runs remain five; intact dark/light horizontal ends retain four inset panel positions. Charred vertical/horizontal remnants keep source soot footprint orientation. No foreign machinery strip or displaced structural boundary found.\", \"materials\": \"New metal detail and charred fragments remain within source machinery/damage regions. Brown granular soil is sharper and denser than original fallback; material patches remain visible in mixed scenes. This is disclosed stylistic contrast, not a structural defect or claim of a seamless fully remastered map.\", \"mask_limit\": \"All targets are opaque32x32, so alphaIoU1 proves coverage only. Verdict rests on authentic source landmarks, complete-scale images and native joins.\", \"holds\": [], \"ground_topography\": \"All five featureless ground variants stay ground; fissures4012e\\u201340131 retain source branching and edge directions; rock clusters40132\\u201340134 retain principal count/location, scale and brown identity. Shared ground atlas cells beyond40134 are outside approval scope; existing40138 rejection preserved.\"} [\"Fine HD soil grain is visibly sharper/denser against unchanged original fallback. No seamless/fullHD whole-map claim.\", \"Only exact32 target frames approved; sharedraw outside claimedcrops and prior rejected/withdrawn variants stay outside scope.\", \"Nine radar destroyed-state partners remain original fallback; no invented remastered damage art.\", \"Gallery-only40120 has no native occurrence, state partners or neighbors; no live placement claim.\", \"Actual immutable Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes only. No independent running SDL/live Host cache capture.\", \"Future newly remastered surrounding tile/state joins need independent review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 88b53b4b2f29bbddb668d5b2b90ed1dbc0e42d3e699f330a01d9e239a3778202", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "bc0d7a863c5e077c55b4de6702d48f390239f58eda34aaa0aed525ce21cb67c1" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "687c20b66019e6c07761faa59d57c298f15cd31fead1a6b08de5896c12a49f53" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40125", + "40126", + "40127", + "40128" + ], + "sha256": "ff046123d25c0950738c37fc1125c25b0978d294a0fe79486d96380e9975c5b9", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40129", + "4012a", + "4012b", + "4012c" + ], + "sha256": "cead42d6055c342a23a8fef2251a9972e57838e4d82e103f32899962618f8dbe", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4012d", + "4012e", + "4012f", + "40130" + ], + "sha256": "df7bd16455c07c6bdbf22be44c20980141a623f53f68aed43a97d6122ca000d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40131", + "40132", + "40133", + "40134" + ], + "sha256": "49d8e2721b003e276c18520130472f4ff30509c81f89ba8140f3952c4d1005d4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "39b6a46b61ba95278d911b6a80012aa3bd0929a92fbffd43cb928355ec4bef75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c2f42ca88f187a4c55130e7118e0c72e70351ed81b397b9e7e6937535397928", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcd01e3c32f553247de716539710ede996e6ff258c71ed2ea4848f83099c9f0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d7fc7ea76f896d0af4095302a2d8bf6a7dc6c0f878c3979053ad366b01584cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b34a2386d71dc6167d267750cd4c1d5a8f7014698ed9f10c46cd7b8e38c21f0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "71313fdc08fd481d9dcaedce2b68ad92c8cea851550f0ba85d4d59c568baca01", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6c0fcb9f037d549c501fb6516e8cc48a1cc7a4230c37dccbd29a8dd742211e8a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a2b27a3c751273dc563d6d3874c7ec295a65698d2450d2ebae9a92327f0321a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e0b8730d2f291998138cebba411392b730e414102112c38042ba67931ba63e0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "894dc6b28a9adeeed0d863e0fb62fc1d2df28f7b0e2b02be4d721aaa1845647f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "753a6ae1e44c5e43aad89ed68058626342a184cd9ce9009bd0e5e5e1829e9b32", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b65356700fd03566f2f545d9c8dc76e14bef80a6c1d1899d108b759519163d41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a712a1a8cd4e77ef1a4ed71da8c714022a40734fc76d2296ae534149c7dbfb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "31535cec9b1f287c3b5c819bb92c5792fef6e34343366c1b01c758a2551dceb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c3237e849259d1fa4bcf62314e98bdc4f4dc2300bd58093c4a4b26e933bcc72d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d1918f3ee5a45bec07e3d386301be6176087df231c6097d29df1b3f65c8615e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "368914f49681185268325652a9f0c61a0b7c59d0bf02d7fd96c90b12ab20f2e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fa8b00511a179327d40781192a981f023c3ae47accaa2b4c2b0487cc85005c97", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "11caeb65c4f04c97f74bbb15b38af1829bed2f1dd465c5804d05fd5356ce7df4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8cfb6dda870a9ae7d0dcac12e09fe385e6aa8fc78cdc383088b2281cb2d44f07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3555970e3f9e2176114f91a4e595c9dd2d848ccd9e46f2c1e5cca9c6200f2298", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bda78fe91e5ceaefe6ae733b70907fcfcbeb5ee8ae66fdc20e2c21103f91c3db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5d85da319cf6e0eb58ee07a136917c9c8c632102b8db1c9b716f6c6a02f8d3a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "667b08a09d94345808eac90f347e51859c5fbe74dd46fd2874a5a0ca87b364c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "dcba38c97e43dcc48320c5fe7e92a0718de7ff6bec63de2c2e4843f6d3b30048", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "804dc0ab5f297799e5717dc9f2aa873efae84f38e512c39d11ebca711ab89ccf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1aeb19f5ae7f55baef504fe8dac4eab7f2b69b61b1a3f8eaeda0b0fef6625072", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f209bd186972159a8019d3138669849376eed03cdfcd915017297205ceacb0d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d6aca5b373bc0d340b0692b99df38936e2c5ecefc7bda3f8a5eb2c73e66ba7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a8b36af129b2d2a631f8a452e5fcf617b7170a9a870205a086e36408e78e1931", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db1b8c298742dbeac2f63b162bfc6d8f7823b784267a689810bed908da320a27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "35a9bcf736d7c10010a8826da2892e238d30be12c161426d87eb877317641aa7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f2ce821f5d33511475772e51bd274c2b37259f4f3429f633fd651aac57ebd83d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4a1b5ed0e794f949c1c29a77b872fde1e0717186d932527e74327e1ee7747631", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52dcc5e7686e826e3181bb68610a962eb7dda62a261a28ba1de1bf9e5f43814c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6f09ead046c0cb0ea4314242d7fecccc5e154894508a33c8ad4a98b362415661", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26aa036da340fd20fd3bd6338113456a7eab81eb606baebe797f6a19ce57ae0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81e001aff228f78b841eb9811904706e35b166248cfc9c7b51b316c63afad887", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4e875c6b021628443495f967091e6a45edb96d8262e5eb3b798d295a4c62362b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30174f98ee63b0f65932816b480baa9e276cc6778d07637b096af7062c739888", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06189914280c66bb3fc98d184848d153dca72952d2c88d8398b2d9c6eb6d13d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "222387972a103fad9390604d4440ce827abf59fd4713bbdf6f8865f33e773ce0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5b692dac2331d4edd2a4751b312a3f6ab08a0e9592589d01d97b6b580c73d606", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f7b0982bc5f2e486520c714078525e7ea006fbb2c0e16ae0c89b0dcecb67401", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80eeb99c1ccc109d9f86371e093a4a5b3808da2b2c62eb50ab63cfd5d89bdf77", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bccf61b4cb7cce8b5d144b88edbd2c7868306d91bf0237240f5d2ea419bd4428", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2374513de03d44405106824abf734517d878d5d10af5f5d54d148318664f15ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "92ba61fd81f030eb33d41a7b600baf5684a929790de069c4c0a6e32f18066de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b148a3f285ca3a37b414b3cc0fc0904301f615ece781953f9b5b29a689175806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3206b0490155d47cd32913533ad42c57222ba0714162121fc169f1e40e8405c4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "18bb7647dad8ba4fc6fe500e70c2bb879e340e8babf08ed47e66b301b1c5f1c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c60718867c84d32ad512e3749bbf5cfbf2373c5e289314fbf4af08b98de0f8b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "eea762f538e5b1611022e242fdb6bdc18bba987af318e9c6faa2bbf6b47c5152", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1c48504d0b42df33c5de0779c424c34a36e774e074856281e4d3e5f1ef7d9b72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4012f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ec2999dff502882b5a2bfb8ea4c7de9f427c01c660d4abf9bbb220367f48bfe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/4012f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0cf2880c8c1bcff497c2652c8ba32b2368806a687e846df39ca00bd04269f1bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6583d2e7217aae07c769f8cfa84bcc56426f287865b1409c681612ff4905857", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "850b6c9cbf66fde98152a049aa4ece56d9281a5e17fb2e915eb3443ab002c7c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "012346f5fa60e0fb2545cbad81929e12029a2c270d0ece8790eac56df540c140", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40130-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1a98f2b5f8c660ba1a29907cc6610006146be0dd76398da79c6cb49ce62cb8ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40130-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35fd28460f47e8471b9a3dd8a697aaf978b82be4336c4af69af38684baa1a075", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "44978fab3a43eaddaba266e1b71b640263a23256a873626e2444f553cd0c7fcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "876a8e70267f2b886e189c42aafe58364007ccf288eea862ff15da337fd562ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f19ca34caba18ca28967a7f581c2e6b2b4c89e0fad277b2dfb7e9a6d0a96a47d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40131-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab490c204065c976719bc6c7d629496fea98313031e8881eb48bf0ea19900b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40131-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "30ea3be2b19e035aa13f5c00f26ca4bfaadffb508d16d66c6250df7f123f9e0b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "101158f62d925d76670a9a6b30de77f67f3b143b2eb2f511b59ccc69fa19e1ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2f293da4835a8b403ab2d3a3f7982321fdd9557778b6667fbec83173b97e49", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8a0def269b604915124b11a74a8e6e0fe9c43c916b4551a2d81412894119a28e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40132-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a86513a89ed2b7100538d7bc31e724e5dd7dd9371e8af886c07f971d7013f5d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40132-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "15d68049b62b5589f7c6fc0aadc57710e5ba0330d28743b352dc21e28903b29c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "38d8923d099ee90c13c820960b6c064f2cbea0312eebf34318ccd20ea895ccbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "99ad2762f3cfc3bc4762d53229a63468452c4fd18139f00118926526c64f3b3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "26cbe0ce5cd528a0a7e7174e44d46274dece5717095d56eea0da83255241b61a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40133-original.ppm", + "sha256": "928a6d1a802efadadc24db01def7b01cc963202a277bfae37421659da11b01ac", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40133-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df6dc1a38be8f9594a1faf12e46039608b35df79bf0e0f1981ec63e0de442c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "209718e85a6a3bd19450282cf1b598dbb987f2b7dd0e5ea872ba59c50781fcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "01861bb5ac661535b523a01fb922fdf78d1a1d4f64afa2a7d02fbe0c37505024", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "95a31c3909011cf6a1ebfb0aaf19440e462c0abf2546e74e962a87e80b42610e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40134-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a93374608551ced9d3c5903900c2fc182fdaf94a648c5798d248cb95bc13cef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-radar-two/terrain-40125-40134/runtime/40134-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40135": { @@ -345742,7 +368529,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40135", "family_id": "terrain-40135-40144", "job_id": "terrain-40135-40144", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345758,6 +368545,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/candidate.json", "sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "556a32bf29ebf9ee172059ea0f22d8f462e51ab53668ef1783d956a4a98a5ac2", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.605315+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40138 standalone v2 preserves its two principal stones and tiny lower-right pebble without the previously rejected foreign fissure. 4013e/4013f retain their upper/lower branch fan; 40143 has the source single tapered vertical fissure; 40144 retains descending diagonal plus short left vertical branch.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 ae25353c16e8b505b9825bbb95946c39443aed3ec07274c4af7ff08c9ff42c61", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40135", + "40136", + "40137", + "40138" + ], + "sha256": "0d2794e4d1fd5391cec77fc86aaee31352b715b8fbdb5e64f4dc04ca9b02960e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40139", + "4013a", + "4013b", + "4013c" + ], + "sha256": "e6b7707870477658cc3dfa49602a7fd3dfd814a7fb41b3c8ffd7921d6aed0fc3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4013d", + "4013e", + "4013f", + "40140" + ], + "sha256": "dc651cb770ee3076c2fa3641e5c2606f7e6e1f3078d0b1a66d52e094a2b42e02", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40141", + "40142", + "40143", + "40144" + ], + "sha256": "c85527d989aa2afe12dc3925b61dccf8c5c68b58c184afdba60794c86f23055f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40135-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "004c7ced4542320fc143bab031ac1e23c82ec35a376a4a0ce7d5f8d9766f06fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "163cc5d28931f94e78a13a266754a356a14738d4ffbd0244dd60e7e66ef1ed1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ff58b355e237f35c3b0117f786eb0c335f438874d7e4cd56600056ad0d2d7f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b4e67e4440e5bbf7d3a96e108c5e7e7b0a4fd9e66b288a3c7eff04164e61121", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-original.ppm", + "sha256": "323f994d88bdfc85b1fd5f0da8d016528d177f5f4ae161b8f4fd1d9c31e8f8cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6c90e04d053bc6503125178ea88149b0e70a201f7bbfaa74eba8514bae2c2294", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d77fd92e32e74f7e4bc758027018ffff86999cfe150ac295100bb5ddb5f31be9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "520b1a8d3da97ffee31cbf4cbda9c2201d705c38ff4e2b9f59c7b56b89bf4873", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7bf1a66c309e5e27f78ebd33a77741415e5dc07f17b7a66add9018a8a0168bb6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcf27e9fb33248fbfbde9b3a3dbd43531c7d41856691dea8687cb1bedefc7df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "881bac50fe4cb6b4cfdf6221cd6ae43c1c203898ab3b0976ae57aa98061d00a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afb7b208c7864b7dd9d543ff10a3807efadda0bb2fedfc7cb4de59fbc93e6ba0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3732affb156ce43a9324e9305eafe9eeac67ed1250e7dcaac80141da66930bb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b504983b79b46f8fb04dfb1ae53818761032fa018dc630d47dc0723ad3015eb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52824c1443b6fa23d968a974df44c8402ed07d4f68a1fe0082358b7bb99775bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a200bb1c9002fa1851c525bc49cf73166b939ce219bd1110f0cdfdb091bb1ba4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "88311946e1716061b3f5844b3c2c71c968455ef70f55eef0f5432e4c10c2c7e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5c94f60faca30e467836e1ec28685691d05f52f914c53ae1dbc1ac7fbbb39fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ad7c96a8bfd9e345a049fc56a2f7006de8a39b650b1141c515e52e6bc4c6d732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-original.ppm", + "sha256": "95f7ee0bb4adecf2b09fb558ec65fa7df02cddf5f4980a5d2f22b0fe705e1d4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f325abbbc67fbc6bbf965964203593b72b257bf54c953aa8c243dc9bbf6ee99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a0fb8d5371cccf257f7eb72bae410a48cb5e2e55448904b306258df6736d88a7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b096d1063c77318135dca09ddfc97312c867a2b62e346f78ede9229202c57d54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bfab1e8711551941d5a511ea2f60fdbb6fad28eb3da79e1f553c92100f0d076e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af6d624cf089b69f2945b3e4b7131e7904ad8c2ab4570376dbbc915460eaed63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "42114d7ec64dce9ce46638513723a9ca264c98a3dcb4bf0d4b75cf0f01c85b33", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf5ae14df8e29dedab8c2594c80944c7d214249ac01869b3868858856d6676cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8a32d0f3d3661a27822e10b17449df3fc97c79a5a6e11a62bca45d5fab3056e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f0080331f0ba1421094a37611b75ef5637363e8c89242e553650de1ec31ebb2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a5be54aa0de23afda041722ff131a34bf7915b663e805100edcbae670efcdfd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2c198b97d03a429ba59e2d44176d342ee2cb73f4900f446d71eec2ab2f9f0155", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d084ac2dc513a9d936e1f6a7ce10f3c0885182d82c30125477303dd9a617c9a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "46ba7b5aab5dd93f2b91f9cf2c05211a6eff53993a4033c3e7eb5cf428a59ab0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "64845979129dd4cf1d791595e235965c70e0c520dfb21fa230207d86aa8d8d59", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c87ff97d470deccfe7f98ea5661833cb545080cdcf6ec4089b1a39bc7e80fef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "83f01f7167a18a1cbf14fe3f8c59c58a3ee3c215f7f4aff3e3b1830312abe884", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26b3da57a60d2835a2d54f90bc221ce5aa12fe99681b916e6fea6862576e87c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b0071f55e5f0815c122b8aecaa11c124009135c797c1172b7ae9ef7b603d526a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7870a9ea2e2dd21bc0a990213366b71c4a1b6cc8bb48b073689c03fa8fa94349", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4cd396ea6f806e35904551d5a1c15b57f5f8f860ed6580bb398cfa8e554591c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f90187bd20fda2ebe115eb40fd3b3f0249e6716e9b817960e729b5952c243d7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7d2d8d558481d69e9a990435f11576c28cb14950496351cc4bdf6df21a3835ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "66ff0d1cca01b9e976dba42894d0ab81f3a44e4ec0779c8b43f96ee35137fc2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0274a70ab8bf872e0d54b7870e2770ddf9bedf5145c4e65d5662e474d3699b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1494db86c30901877b193e7089aac4bd67475735b32cbccdde8f816407c95966", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91c584fa7efdca2f0e92c2fb79a82e9e2b53e8801d6f37ebdb0d6852d0717d57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21b77e99354230542cbe8bc5fe27851b5403e3898f4f2475b206d61bf0a1c89c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1b6f9e2f110ff7ad0a50a6db64479a837dd6757916bc90fc5bad42ccb4b72e99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "171d40fb656c1f69ae4e2e876d67dfeed1760cbfbdb7c40d28dd54f134886e65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39641bdce92c245bfd56b3d02478f5c7f15f73ebaf9a0b878dd78bef2377e9cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bc3845c189111a7c4f59f748b584d3b654770c2461ef0ea40d626e6ed765470f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2eb33e9db08bfaba168470e598ab5922032422edc05641739469b7452fe5d867", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b3765358445d6015f17f8bb2b12d4b03d0d2232c5048161a81c28ea26dd62bc1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4deafeeb09ce2cf146b6efbaa7682f35da2c32c31877a70fffdbadfcf39466e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e4a93c5ed6e33642c0dbe6efc5f15b66e72283767528b5e90c8cb0651b84437d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ced9c9e73ebb4f47a73c748e98741d6cdbca7841849b7445df4a538d35ef359b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3fd3fcf1d6e6315e905c8a4b629655c4157062a3a4213036efa994eaf94236cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b216c2a1968322da29a2d58f4b932c361881c601e7cc81fba106a13153eae743", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "65582a4515c94a88105685b917fa7f882518df98b18679aa014e3ec85d91b856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8fa2d312960c480b2f1a266a02021b024eb749181b19e1b715ce8e768a42775c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0906f5b6044adfa4066460b1c0713fb14a5d5a91dd183f5293492c277bd7224d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ad6be231b3a1b74f9cefb78b24c2ea14f0fb756651270ac7809c525d674aa05a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4fffdf7afa76e0e5bb9e8593eb971047d7750fcec82a092de3e010c19b1abc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b33f135fd32ed8c07f1df27f2ed2da1af47e3ea9520189f08436cf26c3513300", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4b3912fcace2e318aba5b8a56c0700f3f5cf3005a427732a3cde62a2e9f61f3b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "75d578525b47cc1984eac90a83d97646b7223a2e1d5b241fedb6945ed3bafec1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b34cbd5a38c09891c450ef8efd873b5edbdc0a69ca3e9d5e59da1e7b8b7c35b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f758d90398932a0fb893f56c99a0970b8963622710618b5bde1614b30e35c71a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "19a4fd2ebc31c4ddbf8df49c20cb45deedfb9918e76b4c8f3d73b2859c353beb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80c8652187f91adf99c29ee87b76151cbc675893daffb44225700a0f6023c732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "720521030ed6596c8c901aab05e83cad8eeb63a912740b90c8589d7ccf5a4d31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f09810569751d1889a56e15348692a5c9940fd594f28c48e371d21b243efd5ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "054ad21644f0e3ff3d6ac7d0a65a62a96c3dd42748196b4ac0a1fa4b15c48080", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "04c4e8cb5fa0ceb4d2038e0896160080ed08d5cc482b07e6cb25b861a83984e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d4631c461a750ef27cd4e325dd10818c5665b395951c75d6d86328a878659a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bca5b1553df89212f42bcdfe2ba0d54f914f10f915cb2d39f5474bbdcee0b47", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c14795354a8e98d8101bbd7376945ccaeca83fd575c0e982854e9e3d994c7021", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1c7d396166040be2e95cb0186aab14e747cfde1f037fe1668cfb5f8a678a59f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "be3d2b93818c4b52b23c429086ca4748df43a7784828432ce0b7453f1c60e05b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0765e61a71b81fb5d4e1e5abdfa0ed1905e6d6b3197e941a1324a09fe656076a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40136": { @@ -345779,7 +369036,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40136", "family_id": "terrain-40135-40144", "job_id": "terrain-40135-40144", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345795,6 +369052,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/candidate.json", "sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "556a32bf29ebf9ee172059ea0f22d8f462e51ab53668ef1783d956a4a98a5ac2", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.605315+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40138 standalone v2 preserves its two principal stones and tiny lower-right pebble without the previously rejected foreign fissure. 4013e/4013f retain their upper/lower branch fan; 40143 has the source single tapered vertical fissure; 40144 retains descending diagonal plus short left vertical branch.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 ae25353c16e8b505b9825bbb95946c39443aed3ec07274c4af7ff08c9ff42c61", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40135", + "40136", + "40137", + "40138" + ], + "sha256": "0d2794e4d1fd5391cec77fc86aaee31352b715b8fbdb5e64f4dc04ca9b02960e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40139", + "4013a", + "4013b", + "4013c" + ], + "sha256": "e6b7707870477658cc3dfa49602a7fd3dfd814a7fb41b3c8ffd7921d6aed0fc3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4013d", + "4013e", + "4013f", + "40140" + ], + "sha256": "dc651cb770ee3076c2fa3641e5c2606f7e6e1f3078d0b1a66d52e094a2b42e02", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40141", + "40142", + "40143", + "40144" + ], + "sha256": "c85527d989aa2afe12dc3925b61dccf8c5c68b58c184afdba60794c86f23055f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40135-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "004c7ced4542320fc143bab031ac1e23c82ec35a376a4a0ce7d5f8d9766f06fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "163cc5d28931f94e78a13a266754a356a14738d4ffbd0244dd60e7e66ef1ed1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ff58b355e237f35c3b0117f786eb0c335f438874d7e4cd56600056ad0d2d7f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b4e67e4440e5bbf7d3a96e108c5e7e7b0a4fd9e66b288a3c7eff04164e61121", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-original.ppm", + "sha256": "323f994d88bdfc85b1fd5f0da8d016528d177f5f4ae161b8f4fd1d9c31e8f8cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6c90e04d053bc6503125178ea88149b0e70a201f7bbfaa74eba8514bae2c2294", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d77fd92e32e74f7e4bc758027018ffff86999cfe150ac295100bb5ddb5f31be9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "520b1a8d3da97ffee31cbf4cbda9c2201d705c38ff4e2b9f59c7b56b89bf4873", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7bf1a66c309e5e27f78ebd33a77741415e5dc07f17b7a66add9018a8a0168bb6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcf27e9fb33248fbfbde9b3a3dbd43531c7d41856691dea8687cb1bedefc7df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "881bac50fe4cb6b4cfdf6221cd6ae43c1c203898ab3b0976ae57aa98061d00a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afb7b208c7864b7dd9d543ff10a3807efadda0bb2fedfc7cb4de59fbc93e6ba0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3732affb156ce43a9324e9305eafe9eeac67ed1250e7dcaac80141da66930bb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b504983b79b46f8fb04dfb1ae53818761032fa018dc630d47dc0723ad3015eb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52824c1443b6fa23d968a974df44c8402ed07d4f68a1fe0082358b7bb99775bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a200bb1c9002fa1851c525bc49cf73166b939ce219bd1110f0cdfdb091bb1ba4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "88311946e1716061b3f5844b3c2c71c968455ef70f55eef0f5432e4c10c2c7e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5c94f60faca30e467836e1ec28685691d05f52f914c53ae1dbc1ac7fbbb39fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ad7c96a8bfd9e345a049fc56a2f7006de8a39b650b1141c515e52e6bc4c6d732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-original.ppm", + "sha256": "95f7ee0bb4adecf2b09fb558ec65fa7df02cddf5f4980a5d2f22b0fe705e1d4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f325abbbc67fbc6bbf965964203593b72b257bf54c953aa8c243dc9bbf6ee99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a0fb8d5371cccf257f7eb72bae410a48cb5e2e55448904b306258df6736d88a7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b096d1063c77318135dca09ddfc97312c867a2b62e346f78ede9229202c57d54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bfab1e8711551941d5a511ea2f60fdbb6fad28eb3da79e1f553c92100f0d076e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af6d624cf089b69f2945b3e4b7131e7904ad8c2ab4570376dbbc915460eaed63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "42114d7ec64dce9ce46638513723a9ca264c98a3dcb4bf0d4b75cf0f01c85b33", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf5ae14df8e29dedab8c2594c80944c7d214249ac01869b3868858856d6676cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8a32d0f3d3661a27822e10b17449df3fc97c79a5a6e11a62bca45d5fab3056e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f0080331f0ba1421094a37611b75ef5637363e8c89242e553650de1ec31ebb2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a5be54aa0de23afda041722ff131a34bf7915b663e805100edcbae670efcdfd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2c198b97d03a429ba59e2d44176d342ee2cb73f4900f446d71eec2ab2f9f0155", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d084ac2dc513a9d936e1f6a7ce10f3c0885182d82c30125477303dd9a617c9a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "46ba7b5aab5dd93f2b91f9cf2c05211a6eff53993a4033c3e7eb5cf428a59ab0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "64845979129dd4cf1d791595e235965c70e0c520dfb21fa230207d86aa8d8d59", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c87ff97d470deccfe7f98ea5661833cb545080cdcf6ec4089b1a39bc7e80fef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "83f01f7167a18a1cbf14fe3f8c59c58a3ee3c215f7f4aff3e3b1830312abe884", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26b3da57a60d2835a2d54f90bc221ce5aa12fe99681b916e6fea6862576e87c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b0071f55e5f0815c122b8aecaa11c124009135c797c1172b7ae9ef7b603d526a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7870a9ea2e2dd21bc0a990213366b71c4a1b6cc8bb48b073689c03fa8fa94349", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4cd396ea6f806e35904551d5a1c15b57f5f8f860ed6580bb398cfa8e554591c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f90187bd20fda2ebe115eb40fd3b3f0249e6716e9b817960e729b5952c243d7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7d2d8d558481d69e9a990435f11576c28cb14950496351cc4bdf6df21a3835ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "66ff0d1cca01b9e976dba42894d0ab81f3a44e4ec0779c8b43f96ee35137fc2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0274a70ab8bf872e0d54b7870e2770ddf9bedf5145c4e65d5662e474d3699b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1494db86c30901877b193e7089aac4bd67475735b32cbccdde8f816407c95966", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91c584fa7efdca2f0e92c2fb79a82e9e2b53e8801d6f37ebdb0d6852d0717d57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21b77e99354230542cbe8bc5fe27851b5403e3898f4f2475b206d61bf0a1c89c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1b6f9e2f110ff7ad0a50a6db64479a837dd6757916bc90fc5bad42ccb4b72e99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "171d40fb656c1f69ae4e2e876d67dfeed1760cbfbdb7c40d28dd54f134886e65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39641bdce92c245bfd56b3d02478f5c7f15f73ebaf9a0b878dd78bef2377e9cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bc3845c189111a7c4f59f748b584d3b654770c2461ef0ea40d626e6ed765470f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2eb33e9db08bfaba168470e598ab5922032422edc05641739469b7452fe5d867", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b3765358445d6015f17f8bb2b12d4b03d0d2232c5048161a81c28ea26dd62bc1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4deafeeb09ce2cf146b6efbaa7682f35da2c32c31877a70fffdbadfcf39466e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e4a93c5ed6e33642c0dbe6efc5f15b66e72283767528b5e90c8cb0651b84437d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ced9c9e73ebb4f47a73c748e98741d6cdbca7841849b7445df4a538d35ef359b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3fd3fcf1d6e6315e905c8a4b629655c4157062a3a4213036efa994eaf94236cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b216c2a1968322da29a2d58f4b932c361881c601e7cc81fba106a13153eae743", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "65582a4515c94a88105685b917fa7f882518df98b18679aa014e3ec85d91b856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8fa2d312960c480b2f1a266a02021b024eb749181b19e1b715ce8e768a42775c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0906f5b6044adfa4066460b1c0713fb14a5d5a91dd183f5293492c277bd7224d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ad6be231b3a1b74f9cefb78b24c2ea14f0fb756651270ac7809c525d674aa05a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4fffdf7afa76e0e5bb9e8593eb971047d7750fcec82a092de3e010c19b1abc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b33f135fd32ed8c07f1df27f2ed2da1af47e3ea9520189f08436cf26c3513300", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4b3912fcace2e318aba5b8a56c0700f3f5cf3005a427732a3cde62a2e9f61f3b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "75d578525b47cc1984eac90a83d97646b7223a2e1d5b241fedb6945ed3bafec1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b34cbd5a38c09891c450ef8efd873b5edbdc0a69ca3e9d5e59da1e7b8b7c35b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f758d90398932a0fb893f56c99a0970b8963622710618b5bde1614b30e35c71a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "19a4fd2ebc31c4ddbf8df49c20cb45deedfb9918e76b4c8f3d73b2859c353beb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80c8652187f91adf99c29ee87b76151cbc675893daffb44225700a0f6023c732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "720521030ed6596c8c901aab05e83cad8eeb63a912740b90c8589d7ccf5a4d31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f09810569751d1889a56e15348692a5c9940fd594f28c48e371d21b243efd5ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "054ad21644f0e3ff3d6ac7d0a65a62a96c3dd42748196b4ac0a1fa4b15c48080", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "04c4e8cb5fa0ceb4d2038e0896160080ed08d5cc482b07e6cb25b861a83984e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d4631c461a750ef27cd4e325dd10818c5665b395951c75d6d86328a878659a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bca5b1553df89212f42bcdfe2ba0d54f914f10f915cb2d39f5474bbdcee0b47", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c14795354a8e98d8101bbd7376945ccaeca83fd575c0e982854e9e3d994c7021", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1c7d396166040be2e95cb0186aab14e747cfde1f037fe1668cfb5f8a678a59f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "be3d2b93818c4b52b23c429086ca4748df43a7784828432ce0b7453f1c60e05b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0765e61a71b81fb5d4e1e5abdfa0ed1905e6d6b3197e941a1324a09fe656076a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40137": { @@ -345816,7 +369543,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40137", "family_id": "terrain-40135-40144", "job_id": "terrain-40135-40144", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345832,6 +369559,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/candidate.json", "sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "556a32bf29ebf9ee172059ea0f22d8f462e51ab53668ef1783d956a4a98a5ac2", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.605315+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40138 standalone v2 preserves its two principal stones and tiny lower-right pebble without the previously rejected foreign fissure. 4013e/4013f retain their upper/lower branch fan; 40143 has the source single tapered vertical fissure; 40144 retains descending diagonal plus short left vertical branch.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 ae25353c16e8b505b9825bbb95946c39443aed3ec07274c4af7ff08c9ff42c61", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40135", + "40136", + "40137", + "40138" + ], + "sha256": "0d2794e4d1fd5391cec77fc86aaee31352b715b8fbdb5e64f4dc04ca9b02960e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40139", + "4013a", + "4013b", + "4013c" + ], + "sha256": "e6b7707870477658cc3dfa49602a7fd3dfd814a7fb41b3c8ffd7921d6aed0fc3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4013d", + "4013e", + "4013f", + "40140" + ], + "sha256": "dc651cb770ee3076c2fa3641e5c2606f7e6e1f3078d0b1a66d52e094a2b42e02", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40141", + "40142", + "40143", + "40144" + ], + "sha256": "c85527d989aa2afe12dc3925b61dccf8c5c68b58c184afdba60794c86f23055f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40135-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "004c7ced4542320fc143bab031ac1e23c82ec35a376a4a0ce7d5f8d9766f06fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "163cc5d28931f94e78a13a266754a356a14738d4ffbd0244dd60e7e66ef1ed1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ff58b355e237f35c3b0117f786eb0c335f438874d7e4cd56600056ad0d2d7f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b4e67e4440e5bbf7d3a96e108c5e7e7b0a4fd9e66b288a3c7eff04164e61121", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-original.ppm", + "sha256": "323f994d88bdfc85b1fd5f0da8d016528d177f5f4ae161b8f4fd1d9c31e8f8cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6c90e04d053bc6503125178ea88149b0e70a201f7bbfaa74eba8514bae2c2294", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d77fd92e32e74f7e4bc758027018ffff86999cfe150ac295100bb5ddb5f31be9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "520b1a8d3da97ffee31cbf4cbda9c2201d705c38ff4e2b9f59c7b56b89bf4873", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7bf1a66c309e5e27f78ebd33a77741415e5dc07f17b7a66add9018a8a0168bb6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcf27e9fb33248fbfbde9b3a3dbd43531c7d41856691dea8687cb1bedefc7df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "881bac50fe4cb6b4cfdf6221cd6ae43c1c203898ab3b0976ae57aa98061d00a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afb7b208c7864b7dd9d543ff10a3807efadda0bb2fedfc7cb4de59fbc93e6ba0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3732affb156ce43a9324e9305eafe9eeac67ed1250e7dcaac80141da66930bb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b504983b79b46f8fb04dfb1ae53818761032fa018dc630d47dc0723ad3015eb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52824c1443b6fa23d968a974df44c8402ed07d4f68a1fe0082358b7bb99775bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a200bb1c9002fa1851c525bc49cf73166b939ce219bd1110f0cdfdb091bb1ba4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "88311946e1716061b3f5844b3c2c71c968455ef70f55eef0f5432e4c10c2c7e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5c94f60faca30e467836e1ec28685691d05f52f914c53ae1dbc1ac7fbbb39fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ad7c96a8bfd9e345a049fc56a2f7006de8a39b650b1141c515e52e6bc4c6d732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-original.ppm", + "sha256": "95f7ee0bb4adecf2b09fb558ec65fa7df02cddf5f4980a5d2f22b0fe705e1d4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f325abbbc67fbc6bbf965964203593b72b257bf54c953aa8c243dc9bbf6ee99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a0fb8d5371cccf257f7eb72bae410a48cb5e2e55448904b306258df6736d88a7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b096d1063c77318135dca09ddfc97312c867a2b62e346f78ede9229202c57d54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bfab1e8711551941d5a511ea2f60fdbb6fad28eb3da79e1f553c92100f0d076e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af6d624cf089b69f2945b3e4b7131e7904ad8c2ab4570376dbbc915460eaed63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "42114d7ec64dce9ce46638513723a9ca264c98a3dcb4bf0d4b75cf0f01c85b33", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf5ae14df8e29dedab8c2594c80944c7d214249ac01869b3868858856d6676cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8a32d0f3d3661a27822e10b17449df3fc97c79a5a6e11a62bca45d5fab3056e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f0080331f0ba1421094a37611b75ef5637363e8c89242e553650de1ec31ebb2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a5be54aa0de23afda041722ff131a34bf7915b663e805100edcbae670efcdfd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2c198b97d03a429ba59e2d44176d342ee2cb73f4900f446d71eec2ab2f9f0155", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d084ac2dc513a9d936e1f6a7ce10f3c0885182d82c30125477303dd9a617c9a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "46ba7b5aab5dd93f2b91f9cf2c05211a6eff53993a4033c3e7eb5cf428a59ab0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "64845979129dd4cf1d791595e235965c70e0c520dfb21fa230207d86aa8d8d59", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c87ff97d470deccfe7f98ea5661833cb545080cdcf6ec4089b1a39bc7e80fef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "83f01f7167a18a1cbf14fe3f8c59c58a3ee3c215f7f4aff3e3b1830312abe884", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26b3da57a60d2835a2d54f90bc221ce5aa12fe99681b916e6fea6862576e87c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b0071f55e5f0815c122b8aecaa11c124009135c797c1172b7ae9ef7b603d526a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7870a9ea2e2dd21bc0a990213366b71c4a1b6cc8bb48b073689c03fa8fa94349", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4cd396ea6f806e35904551d5a1c15b57f5f8f860ed6580bb398cfa8e554591c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f90187bd20fda2ebe115eb40fd3b3f0249e6716e9b817960e729b5952c243d7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7d2d8d558481d69e9a990435f11576c28cb14950496351cc4bdf6df21a3835ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "66ff0d1cca01b9e976dba42894d0ab81f3a44e4ec0779c8b43f96ee35137fc2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0274a70ab8bf872e0d54b7870e2770ddf9bedf5145c4e65d5662e474d3699b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1494db86c30901877b193e7089aac4bd67475735b32cbccdde8f816407c95966", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91c584fa7efdca2f0e92c2fb79a82e9e2b53e8801d6f37ebdb0d6852d0717d57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21b77e99354230542cbe8bc5fe27851b5403e3898f4f2475b206d61bf0a1c89c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1b6f9e2f110ff7ad0a50a6db64479a837dd6757916bc90fc5bad42ccb4b72e99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "171d40fb656c1f69ae4e2e876d67dfeed1760cbfbdb7c40d28dd54f134886e65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39641bdce92c245bfd56b3d02478f5c7f15f73ebaf9a0b878dd78bef2377e9cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bc3845c189111a7c4f59f748b584d3b654770c2461ef0ea40d626e6ed765470f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2eb33e9db08bfaba168470e598ab5922032422edc05641739469b7452fe5d867", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b3765358445d6015f17f8bb2b12d4b03d0d2232c5048161a81c28ea26dd62bc1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4deafeeb09ce2cf146b6efbaa7682f35da2c32c31877a70fffdbadfcf39466e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e4a93c5ed6e33642c0dbe6efc5f15b66e72283767528b5e90c8cb0651b84437d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ced9c9e73ebb4f47a73c748e98741d6cdbca7841849b7445df4a538d35ef359b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3fd3fcf1d6e6315e905c8a4b629655c4157062a3a4213036efa994eaf94236cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b216c2a1968322da29a2d58f4b932c361881c601e7cc81fba106a13153eae743", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "65582a4515c94a88105685b917fa7f882518df98b18679aa014e3ec85d91b856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8fa2d312960c480b2f1a266a02021b024eb749181b19e1b715ce8e768a42775c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0906f5b6044adfa4066460b1c0713fb14a5d5a91dd183f5293492c277bd7224d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ad6be231b3a1b74f9cefb78b24c2ea14f0fb756651270ac7809c525d674aa05a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4fffdf7afa76e0e5bb9e8593eb971047d7750fcec82a092de3e010c19b1abc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b33f135fd32ed8c07f1df27f2ed2da1af47e3ea9520189f08436cf26c3513300", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4b3912fcace2e318aba5b8a56c0700f3f5cf3005a427732a3cde62a2e9f61f3b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "75d578525b47cc1984eac90a83d97646b7223a2e1d5b241fedb6945ed3bafec1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b34cbd5a38c09891c450ef8efd873b5edbdc0a69ca3e9d5e59da1e7b8b7c35b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f758d90398932a0fb893f56c99a0970b8963622710618b5bde1614b30e35c71a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "19a4fd2ebc31c4ddbf8df49c20cb45deedfb9918e76b4c8f3d73b2859c353beb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80c8652187f91adf99c29ee87b76151cbc675893daffb44225700a0f6023c732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "720521030ed6596c8c901aab05e83cad8eeb63a912740b90c8589d7ccf5a4d31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f09810569751d1889a56e15348692a5c9940fd594f28c48e371d21b243efd5ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "054ad21644f0e3ff3d6ac7d0a65a62a96c3dd42748196b4ac0a1fa4b15c48080", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "04c4e8cb5fa0ceb4d2038e0896160080ed08d5cc482b07e6cb25b861a83984e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d4631c461a750ef27cd4e325dd10818c5665b395951c75d6d86328a878659a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bca5b1553df89212f42bcdfe2ba0d54f914f10f915cb2d39f5474bbdcee0b47", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c14795354a8e98d8101bbd7376945ccaeca83fd575c0e982854e9e3d994c7021", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1c7d396166040be2e95cb0186aab14e747cfde1f037fe1668cfb5f8a678a59f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "be3d2b93818c4b52b23c429086ca4748df43a7784828432ce0b7453f1c60e05b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0765e61a71b81fb5d4e1e5abdfa0ed1905e6d6b3197e941a1324a09fe656076a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40138": { @@ -345853,7 +370050,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40138", "family_id": "terrain-40135-40144", "job_id": "terrain-40135-40144", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -345869,6 +370066,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/candidate.json", "sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "556a32bf29ebf9ee172059ea0f22d8f462e51ab53668ef1783d956a4a98a5ac2", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.605315+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40138 standalone v2 preserves its two principal stones and tiny lower-right pebble without the previously rejected foreign fissure. 4013e/4013f retain their upper/lower branch fan; 40143 has the source single tapered vertical fissure; 40144 retains descending diagonal plus short left vertical branch.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 ae25353c16e8b505b9825bbb95946c39443aed3ec07274c4af7ff08c9ff42c61", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40135", + "40136", + "40137", + "40138" + ], + "sha256": "0d2794e4d1fd5391cec77fc86aaee31352b715b8fbdb5e64f4dc04ca9b02960e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40139", + "4013a", + "4013b", + "4013c" + ], + "sha256": "e6b7707870477658cc3dfa49602a7fd3dfd814a7fb41b3c8ffd7921d6aed0fc3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4013d", + "4013e", + "4013f", + "40140" + ], + "sha256": "dc651cb770ee3076c2fa3641e5c2606f7e6e1f3078d0b1a66d52e094a2b42e02", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40141", + "40142", + "40143", + "40144" + ], + "sha256": "c85527d989aa2afe12dc3925b61dccf8c5c68b58c184afdba60794c86f23055f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40135-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "004c7ced4542320fc143bab031ac1e23c82ec35a376a4a0ce7d5f8d9766f06fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "163cc5d28931f94e78a13a266754a356a14738d4ffbd0244dd60e7e66ef1ed1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ff58b355e237f35c3b0117f786eb0c335f438874d7e4cd56600056ad0d2d7f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b4e67e4440e5bbf7d3a96e108c5e7e7b0a4fd9e66b288a3c7eff04164e61121", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-original.ppm", + "sha256": "323f994d88bdfc85b1fd5f0da8d016528d177f5f4ae161b8f4fd1d9c31e8f8cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6c90e04d053bc6503125178ea88149b0e70a201f7bbfaa74eba8514bae2c2294", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d77fd92e32e74f7e4bc758027018ffff86999cfe150ac295100bb5ddb5f31be9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "520b1a8d3da97ffee31cbf4cbda9c2201d705c38ff4e2b9f59c7b56b89bf4873", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7bf1a66c309e5e27f78ebd33a77741415e5dc07f17b7a66add9018a8a0168bb6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcf27e9fb33248fbfbde9b3a3dbd43531c7d41856691dea8687cb1bedefc7df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "881bac50fe4cb6b4cfdf6221cd6ae43c1c203898ab3b0976ae57aa98061d00a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afb7b208c7864b7dd9d543ff10a3807efadda0bb2fedfc7cb4de59fbc93e6ba0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3732affb156ce43a9324e9305eafe9eeac67ed1250e7dcaac80141da66930bb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b504983b79b46f8fb04dfb1ae53818761032fa018dc630d47dc0723ad3015eb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52824c1443b6fa23d968a974df44c8402ed07d4f68a1fe0082358b7bb99775bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a200bb1c9002fa1851c525bc49cf73166b939ce219bd1110f0cdfdb091bb1ba4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "88311946e1716061b3f5844b3c2c71c968455ef70f55eef0f5432e4c10c2c7e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5c94f60faca30e467836e1ec28685691d05f52f914c53ae1dbc1ac7fbbb39fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ad7c96a8bfd9e345a049fc56a2f7006de8a39b650b1141c515e52e6bc4c6d732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-original.ppm", + "sha256": "95f7ee0bb4adecf2b09fb558ec65fa7df02cddf5f4980a5d2f22b0fe705e1d4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f325abbbc67fbc6bbf965964203593b72b257bf54c953aa8c243dc9bbf6ee99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a0fb8d5371cccf257f7eb72bae410a48cb5e2e55448904b306258df6736d88a7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b096d1063c77318135dca09ddfc97312c867a2b62e346f78ede9229202c57d54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bfab1e8711551941d5a511ea2f60fdbb6fad28eb3da79e1f553c92100f0d076e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af6d624cf089b69f2945b3e4b7131e7904ad8c2ab4570376dbbc915460eaed63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "42114d7ec64dce9ce46638513723a9ca264c98a3dcb4bf0d4b75cf0f01c85b33", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf5ae14df8e29dedab8c2594c80944c7d214249ac01869b3868858856d6676cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8a32d0f3d3661a27822e10b17449df3fc97c79a5a6e11a62bca45d5fab3056e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f0080331f0ba1421094a37611b75ef5637363e8c89242e553650de1ec31ebb2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a5be54aa0de23afda041722ff131a34bf7915b663e805100edcbae670efcdfd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2c198b97d03a429ba59e2d44176d342ee2cb73f4900f446d71eec2ab2f9f0155", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d084ac2dc513a9d936e1f6a7ce10f3c0885182d82c30125477303dd9a617c9a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "46ba7b5aab5dd93f2b91f9cf2c05211a6eff53993a4033c3e7eb5cf428a59ab0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "64845979129dd4cf1d791595e235965c70e0c520dfb21fa230207d86aa8d8d59", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c87ff97d470deccfe7f98ea5661833cb545080cdcf6ec4089b1a39bc7e80fef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "83f01f7167a18a1cbf14fe3f8c59c58a3ee3c215f7f4aff3e3b1830312abe884", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26b3da57a60d2835a2d54f90bc221ce5aa12fe99681b916e6fea6862576e87c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b0071f55e5f0815c122b8aecaa11c124009135c797c1172b7ae9ef7b603d526a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7870a9ea2e2dd21bc0a990213366b71c4a1b6cc8bb48b073689c03fa8fa94349", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4cd396ea6f806e35904551d5a1c15b57f5f8f860ed6580bb398cfa8e554591c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f90187bd20fda2ebe115eb40fd3b3f0249e6716e9b817960e729b5952c243d7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7d2d8d558481d69e9a990435f11576c28cb14950496351cc4bdf6df21a3835ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "66ff0d1cca01b9e976dba42894d0ab81f3a44e4ec0779c8b43f96ee35137fc2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0274a70ab8bf872e0d54b7870e2770ddf9bedf5145c4e65d5662e474d3699b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1494db86c30901877b193e7089aac4bd67475735b32cbccdde8f816407c95966", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91c584fa7efdca2f0e92c2fb79a82e9e2b53e8801d6f37ebdb0d6852d0717d57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21b77e99354230542cbe8bc5fe27851b5403e3898f4f2475b206d61bf0a1c89c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1b6f9e2f110ff7ad0a50a6db64479a837dd6757916bc90fc5bad42ccb4b72e99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "171d40fb656c1f69ae4e2e876d67dfeed1760cbfbdb7c40d28dd54f134886e65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39641bdce92c245bfd56b3d02478f5c7f15f73ebaf9a0b878dd78bef2377e9cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bc3845c189111a7c4f59f748b584d3b654770c2461ef0ea40d626e6ed765470f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2eb33e9db08bfaba168470e598ab5922032422edc05641739469b7452fe5d867", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b3765358445d6015f17f8bb2b12d4b03d0d2232c5048161a81c28ea26dd62bc1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4deafeeb09ce2cf146b6efbaa7682f35da2c32c31877a70fffdbadfcf39466e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e4a93c5ed6e33642c0dbe6efc5f15b66e72283767528b5e90c8cb0651b84437d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ced9c9e73ebb4f47a73c748e98741d6cdbca7841849b7445df4a538d35ef359b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3fd3fcf1d6e6315e905c8a4b629655c4157062a3a4213036efa994eaf94236cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b216c2a1968322da29a2d58f4b932c361881c601e7cc81fba106a13153eae743", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "65582a4515c94a88105685b917fa7f882518df98b18679aa014e3ec85d91b856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8fa2d312960c480b2f1a266a02021b024eb749181b19e1b715ce8e768a42775c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0906f5b6044adfa4066460b1c0713fb14a5d5a91dd183f5293492c277bd7224d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ad6be231b3a1b74f9cefb78b24c2ea14f0fb756651270ac7809c525d674aa05a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4fffdf7afa76e0e5bb9e8593eb971047d7750fcec82a092de3e010c19b1abc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b33f135fd32ed8c07f1df27f2ed2da1af47e3ea9520189f08436cf26c3513300", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4b3912fcace2e318aba5b8a56c0700f3f5cf3005a427732a3cde62a2e9f61f3b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "75d578525b47cc1984eac90a83d97646b7223a2e1d5b241fedb6945ed3bafec1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b34cbd5a38c09891c450ef8efd873b5edbdc0a69ca3e9d5e59da1e7b8b7c35b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f758d90398932a0fb893f56c99a0970b8963622710618b5bde1614b30e35c71a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "19a4fd2ebc31c4ddbf8df49c20cb45deedfb9918e76b4c8f3d73b2859c353beb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80c8652187f91adf99c29ee87b76151cbc675893daffb44225700a0f6023c732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "720521030ed6596c8c901aab05e83cad8eeb63a912740b90c8589d7ccf5a4d31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f09810569751d1889a56e15348692a5c9940fd594f28c48e371d21b243efd5ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "054ad21644f0e3ff3d6ac7d0a65a62a96c3dd42748196b4ac0a1fa4b15c48080", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "04c4e8cb5fa0ceb4d2038e0896160080ed08d5cc482b07e6cb25b861a83984e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d4631c461a750ef27cd4e325dd10818c5665b395951c75d6d86328a878659a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bca5b1553df89212f42bcdfe2ba0d54f914f10f915cb2d39f5474bbdcee0b47", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c14795354a8e98d8101bbd7376945ccaeca83fd575c0e982854e9e3d994c7021", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1c7d396166040be2e95cb0186aab14e747cfde1f037fe1668cfb5f8a678a59f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "be3d2b93818c4b52b23c429086ca4748df43a7784828432ce0b7453f1c60e05b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0765e61a71b81fb5d4e1e5abdfa0ed1905e6d6b3197e941a1324a09fe656076a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40139": { @@ -345890,7 +370557,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40139", "family_id": "terrain-40135-40144", "job_id": "terrain-40135-40144", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -345906,6 +370573,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/candidate.json", "sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "556a32bf29ebf9ee172059ea0f22d8f462e51ab53668ef1783d956a4a98a5ac2", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.605315+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40138 standalone v2 preserves its two principal stones and tiny lower-right pebble without the previously rejected foreign fissure. 4013e/4013f retain their upper/lower branch fan; 40143 has the source single tapered vertical fissure; 40144 retains descending diagonal plus short left vertical branch.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 ae25353c16e8b505b9825bbb95946c39443aed3ec07274c4af7ff08c9ff42c61", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40135", + "40136", + "40137", + "40138" + ], + "sha256": "0d2794e4d1fd5391cec77fc86aaee31352b715b8fbdb5e64f4dc04ca9b02960e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40139", + "4013a", + "4013b", + "4013c" + ], + "sha256": "e6b7707870477658cc3dfa49602a7fd3dfd814a7fb41b3c8ffd7921d6aed0fc3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4013d", + "4013e", + "4013f", + "40140" + ], + "sha256": "dc651cb770ee3076c2fa3641e5c2606f7e6e1f3078d0b1a66d52e094a2b42e02", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40141", + "40142", + "40143", + "40144" + ], + "sha256": "c85527d989aa2afe12dc3925b61dccf8c5c68b58c184afdba60794c86f23055f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40135-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "004c7ced4542320fc143bab031ac1e23c82ec35a376a4a0ce7d5f8d9766f06fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "163cc5d28931f94e78a13a266754a356a14738d4ffbd0244dd60e7e66ef1ed1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ff58b355e237f35c3b0117f786eb0c335f438874d7e4cd56600056ad0d2d7f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b4e67e4440e5bbf7d3a96e108c5e7e7b0a4fd9e66b288a3c7eff04164e61121", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-original.ppm", + "sha256": "323f994d88bdfc85b1fd5f0da8d016528d177f5f4ae161b8f4fd1d9c31e8f8cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6c90e04d053bc6503125178ea88149b0e70a201f7bbfaa74eba8514bae2c2294", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d77fd92e32e74f7e4bc758027018ffff86999cfe150ac295100bb5ddb5f31be9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "520b1a8d3da97ffee31cbf4cbda9c2201d705c38ff4e2b9f59c7b56b89bf4873", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7bf1a66c309e5e27f78ebd33a77741415e5dc07f17b7a66add9018a8a0168bb6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcf27e9fb33248fbfbde9b3a3dbd43531c7d41856691dea8687cb1bedefc7df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "881bac50fe4cb6b4cfdf6221cd6ae43c1c203898ab3b0976ae57aa98061d00a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afb7b208c7864b7dd9d543ff10a3807efadda0bb2fedfc7cb4de59fbc93e6ba0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3732affb156ce43a9324e9305eafe9eeac67ed1250e7dcaac80141da66930bb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b504983b79b46f8fb04dfb1ae53818761032fa018dc630d47dc0723ad3015eb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52824c1443b6fa23d968a974df44c8402ed07d4f68a1fe0082358b7bb99775bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a200bb1c9002fa1851c525bc49cf73166b939ce219bd1110f0cdfdb091bb1ba4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "88311946e1716061b3f5844b3c2c71c968455ef70f55eef0f5432e4c10c2c7e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5c94f60faca30e467836e1ec28685691d05f52f914c53ae1dbc1ac7fbbb39fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ad7c96a8bfd9e345a049fc56a2f7006de8a39b650b1141c515e52e6bc4c6d732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-original.ppm", + "sha256": "95f7ee0bb4adecf2b09fb558ec65fa7df02cddf5f4980a5d2f22b0fe705e1d4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f325abbbc67fbc6bbf965964203593b72b257bf54c953aa8c243dc9bbf6ee99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a0fb8d5371cccf257f7eb72bae410a48cb5e2e55448904b306258df6736d88a7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b096d1063c77318135dca09ddfc97312c867a2b62e346f78ede9229202c57d54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bfab1e8711551941d5a511ea2f60fdbb6fad28eb3da79e1f553c92100f0d076e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af6d624cf089b69f2945b3e4b7131e7904ad8c2ab4570376dbbc915460eaed63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "42114d7ec64dce9ce46638513723a9ca264c98a3dcb4bf0d4b75cf0f01c85b33", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf5ae14df8e29dedab8c2594c80944c7d214249ac01869b3868858856d6676cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8a32d0f3d3661a27822e10b17449df3fc97c79a5a6e11a62bca45d5fab3056e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f0080331f0ba1421094a37611b75ef5637363e8c89242e553650de1ec31ebb2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a5be54aa0de23afda041722ff131a34bf7915b663e805100edcbae670efcdfd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2c198b97d03a429ba59e2d44176d342ee2cb73f4900f446d71eec2ab2f9f0155", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d084ac2dc513a9d936e1f6a7ce10f3c0885182d82c30125477303dd9a617c9a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "46ba7b5aab5dd93f2b91f9cf2c05211a6eff53993a4033c3e7eb5cf428a59ab0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "64845979129dd4cf1d791595e235965c70e0c520dfb21fa230207d86aa8d8d59", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c87ff97d470deccfe7f98ea5661833cb545080cdcf6ec4089b1a39bc7e80fef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "83f01f7167a18a1cbf14fe3f8c59c58a3ee3c215f7f4aff3e3b1830312abe884", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26b3da57a60d2835a2d54f90bc221ce5aa12fe99681b916e6fea6862576e87c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b0071f55e5f0815c122b8aecaa11c124009135c797c1172b7ae9ef7b603d526a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7870a9ea2e2dd21bc0a990213366b71c4a1b6cc8bb48b073689c03fa8fa94349", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4cd396ea6f806e35904551d5a1c15b57f5f8f860ed6580bb398cfa8e554591c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f90187bd20fda2ebe115eb40fd3b3f0249e6716e9b817960e729b5952c243d7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7d2d8d558481d69e9a990435f11576c28cb14950496351cc4bdf6df21a3835ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "66ff0d1cca01b9e976dba42894d0ab81f3a44e4ec0779c8b43f96ee35137fc2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0274a70ab8bf872e0d54b7870e2770ddf9bedf5145c4e65d5662e474d3699b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1494db86c30901877b193e7089aac4bd67475735b32cbccdde8f816407c95966", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91c584fa7efdca2f0e92c2fb79a82e9e2b53e8801d6f37ebdb0d6852d0717d57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21b77e99354230542cbe8bc5fe27851b5403e3898f4f2475b206d61bf0a1c89c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1b6f9e2f110ff7ad0a50a6db64479a837dd6757916bc90fc5bad42ccb4b72e99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "171d40fb656c1f69ae4e2e876d67dfeed1760cbfbdb7c40d28dd54f134886e65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39641bdce92c245bfd56b3d02478f5c7f15f73ebaf9a0b878dd78bef2377e9cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bc3845c189111a7c4f59f748b584d3b654770c2461ef0ea40d626e6ed765470f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2eb33e9db08bfaba168470e598ab5922032422edc05641739469b7452fe5d867", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b3765358445d6015f17f8bb2b12d4b03d0d2232c5048161a81c28ea26dd62bc1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4deafeeb09ce2cf146b6efbaa7682f35da2c32c31877a70fffdbadfcf39466e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e4a93c5ed6e33642c0dbe6efc5f15b66e72283767528b5e90c8cb0651b84437d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ced9c9e73ebb4f47a73c748e98741d6cdbca7841849b7445df4a538d35ef359b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3fd3fcf1d6e6315e905c8a4b629655c4157062a3a4213036efa994eaf94236cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b216c2a1968322da29a2d58f4b932c361881c601e7cc81fba106a13153eae743", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "65582a4515c94a88105685b917fa7f882518df98b18679aa014e3ec85d91b856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8fa2d312960c480b2f1a266a02021b024eb749181b19e1b715ce8e768a42775c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0906f5b6044adfa4066460b1c0713fb14a5d5a91dd183f5293492c277bd7224d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ad6be231b3a1b74f9cefb78b24c2ea14f0fb756651270ac7809c525d674aa05a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4fffdf7afa76e0e5bb9e8593eb971047d7750fcec82a092de3e010c19b1abc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b33f135fd32ed8c07f1df27f2ed2da1af47e3ea9520189f08436cf26c3513300", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4b3912fcace2e318aba5b8a56c0700f3f5cf3005a427732a3cde62a2e9f61f3b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "75d578525b47cc1984eac90a83d97646b7223a2e1d5b241fedb6945ed3bafec1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b34cbd5a38c09891c450ef8efd873b5edbdc0a69ca3e9d5e59da1e7b8b7c35b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f758d90398932a0fb893f56c99a0970b8963622710618b5bde1614b30e35c71a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "19a4fd2ebc31c4ddbf8df49c20cb45deedfb9918e76b4c8f3d73b2859c353beb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80c8652187f91adf99c29ee87b76151cbc675893daffb44225700a0f6023c732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "720521030ed6596c8c901aab05e83cad8eeb63a912740b90c8589d7ccf5a4d31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f09810569751d1889a56e15348692a5c9940fd594f28c48e371d21b243efd5ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "054ad21644f0e3ff3d6ac7d0a65a62a96c3dd42748196b4ac0a1fa4b15c48080", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "04c4e8cb5fa0ceb4d2038e0896160080ed08d5cc482b07e6cb25b861a83984e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d4631c461a750ef27cd4e325dd10818c5665b395951c75d6d86328a878659a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bca5b1553df89212f42bcdfe2ba0d54f914f10f915cb2d39f5474bbdcee0b47", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c14795354a8e98d8101bbd7376945ccaeca83fd575c0e982854e9e3d994c7021", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1c7d396166040be2e95cb0186aab14e747cfde1f037fe1668cfb5f8a678a59f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "be3d2b93818c4b52b23c429086ca4748df43a7784828432ce0b7453f1c60e05b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0765e61a71b81fb5d4e1e5abdfa0ed1905e6d6b3197e941a1324a09fe656076a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4013a": { @@ -345927,7 +371064,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4013a", "family_id": "terrain-40135-40144", "job_id": "terrain-40135-40144", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -345943,6 +371080,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/candidate.json", "sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "556a32bf29ebf9ee172059ea0f22d8f462e51ab53668ef1783d956a4a98a5ac2", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.605315+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40138 standalone v2 preserves its two principal stones and tiny lower-right pebble without the previously rejected foreign fissure. 4013e/4013f retain their upper/lower branch fan; 40143 has the source single tapered vertical fissure; 40144 retains descending diagonal plus short left vertical branch.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 ae25353c16e8b505b9825bbb95946c39443aed3ec07274c4af7ff08c9ff42c61", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40135", + "40136", + "40137", + "40138" + ], + "sha256": "0d2794e4d1fd5391cec77fc86aaee31352b715b8fbdb5e64f4dc04ca9b02960e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40139", + "4013a", + "4013b", + "4013c" + ], + "sha256": "e6b7707870477658cc3dfa49602a7fd3dfd814a7fb41b3c8ffd7921d6aed0fc3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4013d", + "4013e", + "4013f", + "40140" + ], + "sha256": "dc651cb770ee3076c2fa3641e5c2606f7e6e1f3078d0b1a66d52e094a2b42e02", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40141", + "40142", + "40143", + "40144" + ], + "sha256": "c85527d989aa2afe12dc3925b61dccf8c5c68b58c184afdba60794c86f23055f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40135-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "004c7ced4542320fc143bab031ac1e23c82ec35a376a4a0ce7d5f8d9766f06fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "163cc5d28931f94e78a13a266754a356a14738d4ffbd0244dd60e7e66ef1ed1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ff58b355e237f35c3b0117f786eb0c335f438874d7e4cd56600056ad0d2d7f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b4e67e4440e5bbf7d3a96e108c5e7e7b0a4fd9e66b288a3c7eff04164e61121", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-original.ppm", + "sha256": "323f994d88bdfc85b1fd5f0da8d016528d177f5f4ae161b8f4fd1d9c31e8f8cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6c90e04d053bc6503125178ea88149b0e70a201f7bbfaa74eba8514bae2c2294", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d77fd92e32e74f7e4bc758027018ffff86999cfe150ac295100bb5ddb5f31be9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "520b1a8d3da97ffee31cbf4cbda9c2201d705c38ff4e2b9f59c7b56b89bf4873", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7bf1a66c309e5e27f78ebd33a77741415e5dc07f17b7a66add9018a8a0168bb6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcf27e9fb33248fbfbde9b3a3dbd43531c7d41856691dea8687cb1bedefc7df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "881bac50fe4cb6b4cfdf6221cd6ae43c1c203898ab3b0976ae57aa98061d00a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afb7b208c7864b7dd9d543ff10a3807efadda0bb2fedfc7cb4de59fbc93e6ba0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3732affb156ce43a9324e9305eafe9eeac67ed1250e7dcaac80141da66930bb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b504983b79b46f8fb04dfb1ae53818761032fa018dc630d47dc0723ad3015eb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52824c1443b6fa23d968a974df44c8402ed07d4f68a1fe0082358b7bb99775bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a200bb1c9002fa1851c525bc49cf73166b939ce219bd1110f0cdfdb091bb1ba4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "88311946e1716061b3f5844b3c2c71c968455ef70f55eef0f5432e4c10c2c7e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5c94f60faca30e467836e1ec28685691d05f52f914c53ae1dbc1ac7fbbb39fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ad7c96a8bfd9e345a049fc56a2f7006de8a39b650b1141c515e52e6bc4c6d732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-original.ppm", + "sha256": "95f7ee0bb4adecf2b09fb558ec65fa7df02cddf5f4980a5d2f22b0fe705e1d4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f325abbbc67fbc6bbf965964203593b72b257bf54c953aa8c243dc9bbf6ee99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a0fb8d5371cccf257f7eb72bae410a48cb5e2e55448904b306258df6736d88a7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b096d1063c77318135dca09ddfc97312c867a2b62e346f78ede9229202c57d54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bfab1e8711551941d5a511ea2f60fdbb6fad28eb3da79e1f553c92100f0d076e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af6d624cf089b69f2945b3e4b7131e7904ad8c2ab4570376dbbc915460eaed63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "42114d7ec64dce9ce46638513723a9ca264c98a3dcb4bf0d4b75cf0f01c85b33", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf5ae14df8e29dedab8c2594c80944c7d214249ac01869b3868858856d6676cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8a32d0f3d3661a27822e10b17449df3fc97c79a5a6e11a62bca45d5fab3056e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f0080331f0ba1421094a37611b75ef5637363e8c89242e553650de1ec31ebb2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a5be54aa0de23afda041722ff131a34bf7915b663e805100edcbae670efcdfd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2c198b97d03a429ba59e2d44176d342ee2cb73f4900f446d71eec2ab2f9f0155", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d084ac2dc513a9d936e1f6a7ce10f3c0885182d82c30125477303dd9a617c9a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "46ba7b5aab5dd93f2b91f9cf2c05211a6eff53993a4033c3e7eb5cf428a59ab0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "64845979129dd4cf1d791595e235965c70e0c520dfb21fa230207d86aa8d8d59", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c87ff97d470deccfe7f98ea5661833cb545080cdcf6ec4089b1a39bc7e80fef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "83f01f7167a18a1cbf14fe3f8c59c58a3ee3c215f7f4aff3e3b1830312abe884", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26b3da57a60d2835a2d54f90bc221ce5aa12fe99681b916e6fea6862576e87c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b0071f55e5f0815c122b8aecaa11c124009135c797c1172b7ae9ef7b603d526a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7870a9ea2e2dd21bc0a990213366b71c4a1b6cc8bb48b073689c03fa8fa94349", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4cd396ea6f806e35904551d5a1c15b57f5f8f860ed6580bb398cfa8e554591c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f90187bd20fda2ebe115eb40fd3b3f0249e6716e9b817960e729b5952c243d7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7d2d8d558481d69e9a990435f11576c28cb14950496351cc4bdf6df21a3835ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "66ff0d1cca01b9e976dba42894d0ab81f3a44e4ec0779c8b43f96ee35137fc2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0274a70ab8bf872e0d54b7870e2770ddf9bedf5145c4e65d5662e474d3699b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1494db86c30901877b193e7089aac4bd67475735b32cbccdde8f816407c95966", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91c584fa7efdca2f0e92c2fb79a82e9e2b53e8801d6f37ebdb0d6852d0717d57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21b77e99354230542cbe8bc5fe27851b5403e3898f4f2475b206d61bf0a1c89c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1b6f9e2f110ff7ad0a50a6db64479a837dd6757916bc90fc5bad42ccb4b72e99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "171d40fb656c1f69ae4e2e876d67dfeed1760cbfbdb7c40d28dd54f134886e65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39641bdce92c245bfd56b3d02478f5c7f15f73ebaf9a0b878dd78bef2377e9cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bc3845c189111a7c4f59f748b584d3b654770c2461ef0ea40d626e6ed765470f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2eb33e9db08bfaba168470e598ab5922032422edc05641739469b7452fe5d867", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b3765358445d6015f17f8bb2b12d4b03d0d2232c5048161a81c28ea26dd62bc1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4deafeeb09ce2cf146b6efbaa7682f35da2c32c31877a70fffdbadfcf39466e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e4a93c5ed6e33642c0dbe6efc5f15b66e72283767528b5e90c8cb0651b84437d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ced9c9e73ebb4f47a73c748e98741d6cdbca7841849b7445df4a538d35ef359b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3fd3fcf1d6e6315e905c8a4b629655c4157062a3a4213036efa994eaf94236cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b216c2a1968322da29a2d58f4b932c361881c601e7cc81fba106a13153eae743", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "65582a4515c94a88105685b917fa7f882518df98b18679aa014e3ec85d91b856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8fa2d312960c480b2f1a266a02021b024eb749181b19e1b715ce8e768a42775c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0906f5b6044adfa4066460b1c0713fb14a5d5a91dd183f5293492c277bd7224d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ad6be231b3a1b74f9cefb78b24c2ea14f0fb756651270ac7809c525d674aa05a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4fffdf7afa76e0e5bb9e8593eb971047d7750fcec82a092de3e010c19b1abc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b33f135fd32ed8c07f1df27f2ed2da1af47e3ea9520189f08436cf26c3513300", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4b3912fcace2e318aba5b8a56c0700f3f5cf3005a427732a3cde62a2e9f61f3b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "75d578525b47cc1984eac90a83d97646b7223a2e1d5b241fedb6945ed3bafec1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b34cbd5a38c09891c450ef8efd873b5edbdc0a69ca3e9d5e59da1e7b8b7c35b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f758d90398932a0fb893f56c99a0970b8963622710618b5bde1614b30e35c71a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "19a4fd2ebc31c4ddbf8df49c20cb45deedfb9918e76b4c8f3d73b2859c353beb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80c8652187f91adf99c29ee87b76151cbc675893daffb44225700a0f6023c732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "720521030ed6596c8c901aab05e83cad8eeb63a912740b90c8589d7ccf5a4d31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f09810569751d1889a56e15348692a5c9940fd594f28c48e371d21b243efd5ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "054ad21644f0e3ff3d6ac7d0a65a62a96c3dd42748196b4ac0a1fa4b15c48080", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "04c4e8cb5fa0ceb4d2038e0896160080ed08d5cc482b07e6cb25b861a83984e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d4631c461a750ef27cd4e325dd10818c5665b395951c75d6d86328a878659a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bca5b1553df89212f42bcdfe2ba0d54f914f10f915cb2d39f5474bbdcee0b47", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c14795354a8e98d8101bbd7376945ccaeca83fd575c0e982854e9e3d994c7021", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1c7d396166040be2e95cb0186aab14e747cfde1f037fe1668cfb5f8a678a59f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "be3d2b93818c4b52b23c429086ca4748df43a7784828432ce0b7453f1c60e05b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0765e61a71b81fb5d4e1e5abdfa0ed1905e6d6b3197e941a1324a09fe656076a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4013b": { @@ -345964,7 +371571,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4013b", "family_id": "terrain-40135-40144", "job_id": "terrain-40135-40144", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -345980,6 +371587,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/candidate.json", "sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "556a32bf29ebf9ee172059ea0f22d8f462e51ab53668ef1783d956a4a98a5ac2", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.605315+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40138 standalone v2 preserves its two principal stones and tiny lower-right pebble without the previously rejected foreign fissure. 4013e/4013f retain their upper/lower branch fan; 40143 has the source single tapered vertical fissure; 40144 retains descending diagonal plus short left vertical branch.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 ae25353c16e8b505b9825bbb95946c39443aed3ec07274c4af7ff08c9ff42c61", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40135", + "40136", + "40137", + "40138" + ], + "sha256": "0d2794e4d1fd5391cec77fc86aaee31352b715b8fbdb5e64f4dc04ca9b02960e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40139", + "4013a", + "4013b", + "4013c" + ], + "sha256": "e6b7707870477658cc3dfa49602a7fd3dfd814a7fb41b3c8ffd7921d6aed0fc3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4013d", + "4013e", + "4013f", + "40140" + ], + "sha256": "dc651cb770ee3076c2fa3641e5c2606f7e6e1f3078d0b1a66d52e094a2b42e02", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40141", + "40142", + "40143", + "40144" + ], + "sha256": "c85527d989aa2afe12dc3925b61dccf8c5c68b58c184afdba60794c86f23055f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40135-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "004c7ced4542320fc143bab031ac1e23c82ec35a376a4a0ce7d5f8d9766f06fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "163cc5d28931f94e78a13a266754a356a14738d4ffbd0244dd60e7e66ef1ed1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ff58b355e237f35c3b0117f786eb0c335f438874d7e4cd56600056ad0d2d7f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b4e67e4440e5bbf7d3a96e108c5e7e7b0a4fd9e66b288a3c7eff04164e61121", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-original.ppm", + "sha256": "323f994d88bdfc85b1fd5f0da8d016528d177f5f4ae161b8f4fd1d9c31e8f8cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6c90e04d053bc6503125178ea88149b0e70a201f7bbfaa74eba8514bae2c2294", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d77fd92e32e74f7e4bc758027018ffff86999cfe150ac295100bb5ddb5f31be9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "520b1a8d3da97ffee31cbf4cbda9c2201d705c38ff4e2b9f59c7b56b89bf4873", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7bf1a66c309e5e27f78ebd33a77741415e5dc07f17b7a66add9018a8a0168bb6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcf27e9fb33248fbfbde9b3a3dbd43531c7d41856691dea8687cb1bedefc7df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "881bac50fe4cb6b4cfdf6221cd6ae43c1c203898ab3b0976ae57aa98061d00a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afb7b208c7864b7dd9d543ff10a3807efadda0bb2fedfc7cb4de59fbc93e6ba0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3732affb156ce43a9324e9305eafe9eeac67ed1250e7dcaac80141da66930bb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b504983b79b46f8fb04dfb1ae53818761032fa018dc630d47dc0723ad3015eb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52824c1443b6fa23d968a974df44c8402ed07d4f68a1fe0082358b7bb99775bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a200bb1c9002fa1851c525bc49cf73166b939ce219bd1110f0cdfdb091bb1ba4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "88311946e1716061b3f5844b3c2c71c968455ef70f55eef0f5432e4c10c2c7e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5c94f60faca30e467836e1ec28685691d05f52f914c53ae1dbc1ac7fbbb39fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ad7c96a8bfd9e345a049fc56a2f7006de8a39b650b1141c515e52e6bc4c6d732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-original.ppm", + "sha256": "95f7ee0bb4adecf2b09fb558ec65fa7df02cddf5f4980a5d2f22b0fe705e1d4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f325abbbc67fbc6bbf965964203593b72b257bf54c953aa8c243dc9bbf6ee99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a0fb8d5371cccf257f7eb72bae410a48cb5e2e55448904b306258df6736d88a7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b096d1063c77318135dca09ddfc97312c867a2b62e346f78ede9229202c57d54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bfab1e8711551941d5a511ea2f60fdbb6fad28eb3da79e1f553c92100f0d076e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af6d624cf089b69f2945b3e4b7131e7904ad8c2ab4570376dbbc915460eaed63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "42114d7ec64dce9ce46638513723a9ca264c98a3dcb4bf0d4b75cf0f01c85b33", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf5ae14df8e29dedab8c2594c80944c7d214249ac01869b3868858856d6676cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8a32d0f3d3661a27822e10b17449df3fc97c79a5a6e11a62bca45d5fab3056e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f0080331f0ba1421094a37611b75ef5637363e8c89242e553650de1ec31ebb2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a5be54aa0de23afda041722ff131a34bf7915b663e805100edcbae670efcdfd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2c198b97d03a429ba59e2d44176d342ee2cb73f4900f446d71eec2ab2f9f0155", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d084ac2dc513a9d936e1f6a7ce10f3c0885182d82c30125477303dd9a617c9a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "46ba7b5aab5dd93f2b91f9cf2c05211a6eff53993a4033c3e7eb5cf428a59ab0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "64845979129dd4cf1d791595e235965c70e0c520dfb21fa230207d86aa8d8d59", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c87ff97d470deccfe7f98ea5661833cb545080cdcf6ec4089b1a39bc7e80fef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "83f01f7167a18a1cbf14fe3f8c59c58a3ee3c215f7f4aff3e3b1830312abe884", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26b3da57a60d2835a2d54f90bc221ce5aa12fe99681b916e6fea6862576e87c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b0071f55e5f0815c122b8aecaa11c124009135c797c1172b7ae9ef7b603d526a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7870a9ea2e2dd21bc0a990213366b71c4a1b6cc8bb48b073689c03fa8fa94349", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4cd396ea6f806e35904551d5a1c15b57f5f8f860ed6580bb398cfa8e554591c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f90187bd20fda2ebe115eb40fd3b3f0249e6716e9b817960e729b5952c243d7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7d2d8d558481d69e9a990435f11576c28cb14950496351cc4bdf6df21a3835ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "66ff0d1cca01b9e976dba42894d0ab81f3a44e4ec0779c8b43f96ee35137fc2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0274a70ab8bf872e0d54b7870e2770ddf9bedf5145c4e65d5662e474d3699b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1494db86c30901877b193e7089aac4bd67475735b32cbccdde8f816407c95966", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91c584fa7efdca2f0e92c2fb79a82e9e2b53e8801d6f37ebdb0d6852d0717d57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21b77e99354230542cbe8bc5fe27851b5403e3898f4f2475b206d61bf0a1c89c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1b6f9e2f110ff7ad0a50a6db64479a837dd6757916bc90fc5bad42ccb4b72e99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "171d40fb656c1f69ae4e2e876d67dfeed1760cbfbdb7c40d28dd54f134886e65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39641bdce92c245bfd56b3d02478f5c7f15f73ebaf9a0b878dd78bef2377e9cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bc3845c189111a7c4f59f748b584d3b654770c2461ef0ea40d626e6ed765470f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2eb33e9db08bfaba168470e598ab5922032422edc05641739469b7452fe5d867", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b3765358445d6015f17f8bb2b12d4b03d0d2232c5048161a81c28ea26dd62bc1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4deafeeb09ce2cf146b6efbaa7682f35da2c32c31877a70fffdbadfcf39466e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e4a93c5ed6e33642c0dbe6efc5f15b66e72283767528b5e90c8cb0651b84437d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ced9c9e73ebb4f47a73c748e98741d6cdbca7841849b7445df4a538d35ef359b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3fd3fcf1d6e6315e905c8a4b629655c4157062a3a4213036efa994eaf94236cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b216c2a1968322da29a2d58f4b932c361881c601e7cc81fba106a13153eae743", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "65582a4515c94a88105685b917fa7f882518df98b18679aa014e3ec85d91b856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8fa2d312960c480b2f1a266a02021b024eb749181b19e1b715ce8e768a42775c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0906f5b6044adfa4066460b1c0713fb14a5d5a91dd183f5293492c277bd7224d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ad6be231b3a1b74f9cefb78b24c2ea14f0fb756651270ac7809c525d674aa05a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4fffdf7afa76e0e5bb9e8593eb971047d7750fcec82a092de3e010c19b1abc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b33f135fd32ed8c07f1df27f2ed2da1af47e3ea9520189f08436cf26c3513300", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4b3912fcace2e318aba5b8a56c0700f3f5cf3005a427732a3cde62a2e9f61f3b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "75d578525b47cc1984eac90a83d97646b7223a2e1d5b241fedb6945ed3bafec1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b34cbd5a38c09891c450ef8efd873b5edbdc0a69ca3e9d5e59da1e7b8b7c35b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f758d90398932a0fb893f56c99a0970b8963622710618b5bde1614b30e35c71a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "19a4fd2ebc31c4ddbf8df49c20cb45deedfb9918e76b4c8f3d73b2859c353beb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80c8652187f91adf99c29ee87b76151cbc675893daffb44225700a0f6023c732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "720521030ed6596c8c901aab05e83cad8eeb63a912740b90c8589d7ccf5a4d31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f09810569751d1889a56e15348692a5c9940fd594f28c48e371d21b243efd5ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "054ad21644f0e3ff3d6ac7d0a65a62a96c3dd42748196b4ac0a1fa4b15c48080", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "04c4e8cb5fa0ceb4d2038e0896160080ed08d5cc482b07e6cb25b861a83984e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d4631c461a750ef27cd4e325dd10818c5665b395951c75d6d86328a878659a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bca5b1553df89212f42bcdfe2ba0d54f914f10f915cb2d39f5474bbdcee0b47", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c14795354a8e98d8101bbd7376945ccaeca83fd575c0e982854e9e3d994c7021", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1c7d396166040be2e95cb0186aab14e747cfde1f037fe1668cfb5f8a678a59f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "be3d2b93818c4b52b23c429086ca4748df43a7784828432ce0b7453f1c60e05b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0765e61a71b81fb5d4e1e5abdfa0ed1905e6d6b3197e941a1324a09fe656076a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4013c": { @@ -346001,7 +372078,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4013c", "family_id": "terrain-40135-40144", "job_id": "terrain-40135-40144", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -346017,6 +372094,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/candidate.json", "sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "556a32bf29ebf9ee172059ea0f22d8f462e51ab53668ef1783d956a4a98a5ac2", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.605315+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40138 standalone v2 preserves its two principal stones and tiny lower-right pebble without the previously rejected foreign fissure. 4013e/4013f retain their upper/lower branch fan; 40143 has the source single tapered vertical fissure; 40144 retains descending diagonal plus short left vertical branch.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 ae25353c16e8b505b9825bbb95946c39443aed3ec07274c4af7ff08c9ff42c61", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40135", + "40136", + "40137", + "40138" + ], + "sha256": "0d2794e4d1fd5391cec77fc86aaee31352b715b8fbdb5e64f4dc04ca9b02960e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40139", + "4013a", + "4013b", + "4013c" + ], + "sha256": "e6b7707870477658cc3dfa49602a7fd3dfd814a7fb41b3c8ffd7921d6aed0fc3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4013d", + "4013e", + "4013f", + "40140" + ], + "sha256": "dc651cb770ee3076c2fa3641e5c2606f7e6e1f3078d0b1a66d52e094a2b42e02", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40141", + "40142", + "40143", + "40144" + ], + "sha256": "c85527d989aa2afe12dc3925b61dccf8c5c68b58c184afdba60794c86f23055f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40135-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "004c7ced4542320fc143bab031ac1e23c82ec35a376a4a0ce7d5f8d9766f06fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "163cc5d28931f94e78a13a266754a356a14738d4ffbd0244dd60e7e66ef1ed1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ff58b355e237f35c3b0117f786eb0c335f438874d7e4cd56600056ad0d2d7f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b4e67e4440e5bbf7d3a96e108c5e7e7b0a4fd9e66b288a3c7eff04164e61121", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-original.ppm", + "sha256": "323f994d88bdfc85b1fd5f0da8d016528d177f5f4ae161b8f4fd1d9c31e8f8cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6c90e04d053bc6503125178ea88149b0e70a201f7bbfaa74eba8514bae2c2294", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d77fd92e32e74f7e4bc758027018ffff86999cfe150ac295100bb5ddb5f31be9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "520b1a8d3da97ffee31cbf4cbda9c2201d705c38ff4e2b9f59c7b56b89bf4873", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7bf1a66c309e5e27f78ebd33a77741415e5dc07f17b7a66add9018a8a0168bb6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcf27e9fb33248fbfbde9b3a3dbd43531c7d41856691dea8687cb1bedefc7df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "881bac50fe4cb6b4cfdf6221cd6ae43c1c203898ab3b0976ae57aa98061d00a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afb7b208c7864b7dd9d543ff10a3807efadda0bb2fedfc7cb4de59fbc93e6ba0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3732affb156ce43a9324e9305eafe9eeac67ed1250e7dcaac80141da66930bb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b504983b79b46f8fb04dfb1ae53818761032fa018dc630d47dc0723ad3015eb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52824c1443b6fa23d968a974df44c8402ed07d4f68a1fe0082358b7bb99775bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a200bb1c9002fa1851c525bc49cf73166b939ce219bd1110f0cdfdb091bb1ba4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "88311946e1716061b3f5844b3c2c71c968455ef70f55eef0f5432e4c10c2c7e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5c94f60faca30e467836e1ec28685691d05f52f914c53ae1dbc1ac7fbbb39fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ad7c96a8bfd9e345a049fc56a2f7006de8a39b650b1141c515e52e6bc4c6d732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-original.ppm", + "sha256": "95f7ee0bb4adecf2b09fb558ec65fa7df02cddf5f4980a5d2f22b0fe705e1d4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f325abbbc67fbc6bbf965964203593b72b257bf54c953aa8c243dc9bbf6ee99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a0fb8d5371cccf257f7eb72bae410a48cb5e2e55448904b306258df6736d88a7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b096d1063c77318135dca09ddfc97312c867a2b62e346f78ede9229202c57d54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bfab1e8711551941d5a511ea2f60fdbb6fad28eb3da79e1f553c92100f0d076e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af6d624cf089b69f2945b3e4b7131e7904ad8c2ab4570376dbbc915460eaed63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "42114d7ec64dce9ce46638513723a9ca264c98a3dcb4bf0d4b75cf0f01c85b33", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf5ae14df8e29dedab8c2594c80944c7d214249ac01869b3868858856d6676cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8a32d0f3d3661a27822e10b17449df3fc97c79a5a6e11a62bca45d5fab3056e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f0080331f0ba1421094a37611b75ef5637363e8c89242e553650de1ec31ebb2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a5be54aa0de23afda041722ff131a34bf7915b663e805100edcbae670efcdfd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2c198b97d03a429ba59e2d44176d342ee2cb73f4900f446d71eec2ab2f9f0155", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d084ac2dc513a9d936e1f6a7ce10f3c0885182d82c30125477303dd9a617c9a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "46ba7b5aab5dd93f2b91f9cf2c05211a6eff53993a4033c3e7eb5cf428a59ab0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "64845979129dd4cf1d791595e235965c70e0c520dfb21fa230207d86aa8d8d59", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c87ff97d470deccfe7f98ea5661833cb545080cdcf6ec4089b1a39bc7e80fef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "83f01f7167a18a1cbf14fe3f8c59c58a3ee3c215f7f4aff3e3b1830312abe884", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26b3da57a60d2835a2d54f90bc221ce5aa12fe99681b916e6fea6862576e87c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b0071f55e5f0815c122b8aecaa11c124009135c797c1172b7ae9ef7b603d526a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7870a9ea2e2dd21bc0a990213366b71c4a1b6cc8bb48b073689c03fa8fa94349", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4cd396ea6f806e35904551d5a1c15b57f5f8f860ed6580bb398cfa8e554591c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f90187bd20fda2ebe115eb40fd3b3f0249e6716e9b817960e729b5952c243d7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7d2d8d558481d69e9a990435f11576c28cb14950496351cc4bdf6df21a3835ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "66ff0d1cca01b9e976dba42894d0ab81f3a44e4ec0779c8b43f96ee35137fc2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0274a70ab8bf872e0d54b7870e2770ddf9bedf5145c4e65d5662e474d3699b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1494db86c30901877b193e7089aac4bd67475735b32cbccdde8f816407c95966", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91c584fa7efdca2f0e92c2fb79a82e9e2b53e8801d6f37ebdb0d6852d0717d57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21b77e99354230542cbe8bc5fe27851b5403e3898f4f2475b206d61bf0a1c89c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1b6f9e2f110ff7ad0a50a6db64479a837dd6757916bc90fc5bad42ccb4b72e99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "171d40fb656c1f69ae4e2e876d67dfeed1760cbfbdb7c40d28dd54f134886e65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39641bdce92c245bfd56b3d02478f5c7f15f73ebaf9a0b878dd78bef2377e9cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bc3845c189111a7c4f59f748b584d3b654770c2461ef0ea40d626e6ed765470f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2eb33e9db08bfaba168470e598ab5922032422edc05641739469b7452fe5d867", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b3765358445d6015f17f8bb2b12d4b03d0d2232c5048161a81c28ea26dd62bc1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4deafeeb09ce2cf146b6efbaa7682f35da2c32c31877a70fffdbadfcf39466e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e4a93c5ed6e33642c0dbe6efc5f15b66e72283767528b5e90c8cb0651b84437d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ced9c9e73ebb4f47a73c748e98741d6cdbca7841849b7445df4a538d35ef359b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3fd3fcf1d6e6315e905c8a4b629655c4157062a3a4213036efa994eaf94236cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b216c2a1968322da29a2d58f4b932c361881c601e7cc81fba106a13153eae743", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "65582a4515c94a88105685b917fa7f882518df98b18679aa014e3ec85d91b856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8fa2d312960c480b2f1a266a02021b024eb749181b19e1b715ce8e768a42775c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0906f5b6044adfa4066460b1c0713fb14a5d5a91dd183f5293492c277bd7224d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ad6be231b3a1b74f9cefb78b24c2ea14f0fb756651270ac7809c525d674aa05a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4fffdf7afa76e0e5bb9e8593eb971047d7750fcec82a092de3e010c19b1abc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b33f135fd32ed8c07f1df27f2ed2da1af47e3ea9520189f08436cf26c3513300", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4b3912fcace2e318aba5b8a56c0700f3f5cf3005a427732a3cde62a2e9f61f3b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "75d578525b47cc1984eac90a83d97646b7223a2e1d5b241fedb6945ed3bafec1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b34cbd5a38c09891c450ef8efd873b5edbdc0a69ca3e9d5e59da1e7b8b7c35b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f758d90398932a0fb893f56c99a0970b8963622710618b5bde1614b30e35c71a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "19a4fd2ebc31c4ddbf8df49c20cb45deedfb9918e76b4c8f3d73b2859c353beb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80c8652187f91adf99c29ee87b76151cbc675893daffb44225700a0f6023c732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "720521030ed6596c8c901aab05e83cad8eeb63a912740b90c8589d7ccf5a4d31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f09810569751d1889a56e15348692a5c9940fd594f28c48e371d21b243efd5ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "054ad21644f0e3ff3d6ac7d0a65a62a96c3dd42748196b4ac0a1fa4b15c48080", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "04c4e8cb5fa0ceb4d2038e0896160080ed08d5cc482b07e6cb25b861a83984e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d4631c461a750ef27cd4e325dd10818c5665b395951c75d6d86328a878659a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bca5b1553df89212f42bcdfe2ba0d54f914f10f915cb2d39f5474bbdcee0b47", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c14795354a8e98d8101bbd7376945ccaeca83fd575c0e982854e9e3d994c7021", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1c7d396166040be2e95cb0186aab14e747cfde1f037fe1668cfb5f8a678a59f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "be3d2b93818c4b52b23c429086ca4748df43a7784828432ce0b7453f1c60e05b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0765e61a71b81fb5d4e1e5abdfa0ed1905e6d6b3197e941a1324a09fe656076a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4013d": { @@ -346038,7 +372585,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4013d", "family_id": "terrain-40135-40144", "job_id": "terrain-40135-40144", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -346054,6 +372601,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/candidate.json", "sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "556a32bf29ebf9ee172059ea0f22d8f462e51ab53668ef1783d956a4a98a5ac2", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.605315+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40138 standalone v2 preserves its two principal stones and tiny lower-right pebble without the previously rejected foreign fissure. 4013e/4013f retain their upper/lower branch fan; 40143 has the source single tapered vertical fissure; 40144 retains descending diagonal plus short left vertical branch.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 ae25353c16e8b505b9825bbb95946c39443aed3ec07274c4af7ff08c9ff42c61", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40135", + "40136", + "40137", + "40138" + ], + "sha256": "0d2794e4d1fd5391cec77fc86aaee31352b715b8fbdb5e64f4dc04ca9b02960e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40139", + "4013a", + "4013b", + "4013c" + ], + "sha256": "e6b7707870477658cc3dfa49602a7fd3dfd814a7fb41b3c8ffd7921d6aed0fc3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4013d", + "4013e", + "4013f", + "40140" + ], + "sha256": "dc651cb770ee3076c2fa3641e5c2606f7e6e1f3078d0b1a66d52e094a2b42e02", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40141", + "40142", + "40143", + "40144" + ], + "sha256": "c85527d989aa2afe12dc3925b61dccf8c5c68b58c184afdba60794c86f23055f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40135-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "004c7ced4542320fc143bab031ac1e23c82ec35a376a4a0ce7d5f8d9766f06fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "163cc5d28931f94e78a13a266754a356a14738d4ffbd0244dd60e7e66ef1ed1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ff58b355e237f35c3b0117f786eb0c335f438874d7e4cd56600056ad0d2d7f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b4e67e4440e5bbf7d3a96e108c5e7e7b0a4fd9e66b288a3c7eff04164e61121", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-original.ppm", + "sha256": "323f994d88bdfc85b1fd5f0da8d016528d177f5f4ae161b8f4fd1d9c31e8f8cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6c90e04d053bc6503125178ea88149b0e70a201f7bbfaa74eba8514bae2c2294", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d77fd92e32e74f7e4bc758027018ffff86999cfe150ac295100bb5ddb5f31be9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "520b1a8d3da97ffee31cbf4cbda9c2201d705c38ff4e2b9f59c7b56b89bf4873", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7bf1a66c309e5e27f78ebd33a77741415e5dc07f17b7a66add9018a8a0168bb6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcf27e9fb33248fbfbde9b3a3dbd43531c7d41856691dea8687cb1bedefc7df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "881bac50fe4cb6b4cfdf6221cd6ae43c1c203898ab3b0976ae57aa98061d00a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afb7b208c7864b7dd9d543ff10a3807efadda0bb2fedfc7cb4de59fbc93e6ba0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3732affb156ce43a9324e9305eafe9eeac67ed1250e7dcaac80141da66930bb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b504983b79b46f8fb04dfb1ae53818761032fa018dc630d47dc0723ad3015eb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52824c1443b6fa23d968a974df44c8402ed07d4f68a1fe0082358b7bb99775bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a200bb1c9002fa1851c525bc49cf73166b939ce219bd1110f0cdfdb091bb1ba4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "88311946e1716061b3f5844b3c2c71c968455ef70f55eef0f5432e4c10c2c7e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5c94f60faca30e467836e1ec28685691d05f52f914c53ae1dbc1ac7fbbb39fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ad7c96a8bfd9e345a049fc56a2f7006de8a39b650b1141c515e52e6bc4c6d732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-original.ppm", + "sha256": "95f7ee0bb4adecf2b09fb558ec65fa7df02cddf5f4980a5d2f22b0fe705e1d4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f325abbbc67fbc6bbf965964203593b72b257bf54c953aa8c243dc9bbf6ee99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a0fb8d5371cccf257f7eb72bae410a48cb5e2e55448904b306258df6736d88a7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b096d1063c77318135dca09ddfc97312c867a2b62e346f78ede9229202c57d54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bfab1e8711551941d5a511ea2f60fdbb6fad28eb3da79e1f553c92100f0d076e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af6d624cf089b69f2945b3e4b7131e7904ad8c2ab4570376dbbc915460eaed63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "42114d7ec64dce9ce46638513723a9ca264c98a3dcb4bf0d4b75cf0f01c85b33", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf5ae14df8e29dedab8c2594c80944c7d214249ac01869b3868858856d6676cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8a32d0f3d3661a27822e10b17449df3fc97c79a5a6e11a62bca45d5fab3056e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f0080331f0ba1421094a37611b75ef5637363e8c89242e553650de1ec31ebb2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a5be54aa0de23afda041722ff131a34bf7915b663e805100edcbae670efcdfd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2c198b97d03a429ba59e2d44176d342ee2cb73f4900f446d71eec2ab2f9f0155", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d084ac2dc513a9d936e1f6a7ce10f3c0885182d82c30125477303dd9a617c9a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "46ba7b5aab5dd93f2b91f9cf2c05211a6eff53993a4033c3e7eb5cf428a59ab0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "64845979129dd4cf1d791595e235965c70e0c520dfb21fa230207d86aa8d8d59", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c87ff97d470deccfe7f98ea5661833cb545080cdcf6ec4089b1a39bc7e80fef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "83f01f7167a18a1cbf14fe3f8c59c58a3ee3c215f7f4aff3e3b1830312abe884", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26b3da57a60d2835a2d54f90bc221ce5aa12fe99681b916e6fea6862576e87c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b0071f55e5f0815c122b8aecaa11c124009135c797c1172b7ae9ef7b603d526a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7870a9ea2e2dd21bc0a990213366b71c4a1b6cc8bb48b073689c03fa8fa94349", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4cd396ea6f806e35904551d5a1c15b57f5f8f860ed6580bb398cfa8e554591c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f90187bd20fda2ebe115eb40fd3b3f0249e6716e9b817960e729b5952c243d7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7d2d8d558481d69e9a990435f11576c28cb14950496351cc4bdf6df21a3835ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "66ff0d1cca01b9e976dba42894d0ab81f3a44e4ec0779c8b43f96ee35137fc2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0274a70ab8bf872e0d54b7870e2770ddf9bedf5145c4e65d5662e474d3699b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1494db86c30901877b193e7089aac4bd67475735b32cbccdde8f816407c95966", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91c584fa7efdca2f0e92c2fb79a82e9e2b53e8801d6f37ebdb0d6852d0717d57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21b77e99354230542cbe8bc5fe27851b5403e3898f4f2475b206d61bf0a1c89c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1b6f9e2f110ff7ad0a50a6db64479a837dd6757916bc90fc5bad42ccb4b72e99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "171d40fb656c1f69ae4e2e876d67dfeed1760cbfbdb7c40d28dd54f134886e65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39641bdce92c245bfd56b3d02478f5c7f15f73ebaf9a0b878dd78bef2377e9cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bc3845c189111a7c4f59f748b584d3b654770c2461ef0ea40d626e6ed765470f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2eb33e9db08bfaba168470e598ab5922032422edc05641739469b7452fe5d867", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b3765358445d6015f17f8bb2b12d4b03d0d2232c5048161a81c28ea26dd62bc1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4deafeeb09ce2cf146b6efbaa7682f35da2c32c31877a70fffdbadfcf39466e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e4a93c5ed6e33642c0dbe6efc5f15b66e72283767528b5e90c8cb0651b84437d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ced9c9e73ebb4f47a73c748e98741d6cdbca7841849b7445df4a538d35ef359b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3fd3fcf1d6e6315e905c8a4b629655c4157062a3a4213036efa994eaf94236cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b216c2a1968322da29a2d58f4b932c361881c601e7cc81fba106a13153eae743", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "65582a4515c94a88105685b917fa7f882518df98b18679aa014e3ec85d91b856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8fa2d312960c480b2f1a266a02021b024eb749181b19e1b715ce8e768a42775c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0906f5b6044adfa4066460b1c0713fb14a5d5a91dd183f5293492c277bd7224d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ad6be231b3a1b74f9cefb78b24c2ea14f0fb756651270ac7809c525d674aa05a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4fffdf7afa76e0e5bb9e8593eb971047d7750fcec82a092de3e010c19b1abc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b33f135fd32ed8c07f1df27f2ed2da1af47e3ea9520189f08436cf26c3513300", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4b3912fcace2e318aba5b8a56c0700f3f5cf3005a427732a3cde62a2e9f61f3b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "75d578525b47cc1984eac90a83d97646b7223a2e1d5b241fedb6945ed3bafec1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b34cbd5a38c09891c450ef8efd873b5edbdc0a69ca3e9d5e59da1e7b8b7c35b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f758d90398932a0fb893f56c99a0970b8963622710618b5bde1614b30e35c71a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "19a4fd2ebc31c4ddbf8df49c20cb45deedfb9918e76b4c8f3d73b2859c353beb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80c8652187f91adf99c29ee87b76151cbc675893daffb44225700a0f6023c732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "720521030ed6596c8c901aab05e83cad8eeb63a912740b90c8589d7ccf5a4d31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f09810569751d1889a56e15348692a5c9940fd594f28c48e371d21b243efd5ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "054ad21644f0e3ff3d6ac7d0a65a62a96c3dd42748196b4ac0a1fa4b15c48080", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "04c4e8cb5fa0ceb4d2038e0896160080ed08d5cc482b07e6cb25b861a83984e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d4631c461a750ef27cd4e325dd10818c5665b395951c75d6d86328a878659a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bca5b1553df89212f42bcdfe2ba0d54f914f10f915cb2d39f5474bbdcee0b47", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c14795354a8e98d8101bbd7376945ccaeca83fd575c0e982854e9e3d994c7021", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1c7d396166040be2e95cb0186aab14e747cfde1f037fe1668cfb5f8a678a59f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "be3d2b93818c4b52b23c429086ca4748df43a7784828432ce0b7453f1c60e05b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0765e61a71b81fb5d4e1e5abdfa0ed1905e6d6b3197e941a1324a09fe656076a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4013e": { @@ -346075,7 +373092,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4013e", "family_id": "terrain-40135-40144", "job_id": "terrain-40135-40144", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -346091,6 +373108,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/candidate.json", "sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "556a32bf29ebf9ee172059ea0f22d8f462e51ab53668ef1783d956a4a98a5ac2", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.605315+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40138 standalone v2 preserves its two principal stones and tiny lower-right pebble without the previously rejected foreign fissure. 4013e/4013f retain their upper/lower branch fan; 40143 has the source single tapered vertical fissure; 40144 retains descending diagonal plus short left vertical branch.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 ae25353c16e8b505b9825bbb95946c39443aed3ec07274c4af7ff08c9ff42c61", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40135", + "40136", + "40137", + "40138" + ], + "sha256": "0d2794e4d1fd5391cec77fc86aaee31352b715b8fbdb5e64f4dc04ca9b02960e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40139", + "4013a", + "4013b", + "4013c" + ], + "sha256": "e6b7707870477658cc3dfa49602a7fd3dfd814a7fb41b3c8ffd7921d6aed0fc3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4013d", + "4013e", + "4013f", + "40140" + ], + "sha256": "dc651cb770ee3076c2fa3641e5c2606f7e6e1f3078d0b1a66d52e094a2b42e02", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40141", + "40142", + "40143", + "40144" + ], + "sha256": "c85527d989aa2afe12dc3925b61dccf8c5c68b58c184afdba60794c86f23055f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40135-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "004c7ced4542320fc143bab031ac1e23c82ec35a376a4a0ce7d5f8d9766f06fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "163cc5d28931f94e78a13a266754a356a14738d4ffbd0244dd60e7e66ef1ed1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ff58b355e237f35c3b0117f786eb0c335f438874d7e4cd56600056ad0d2d7f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b4e67e4440e5bbf7d3a96e108c5e7e7b0a4fd9e66b288a3c7eff04164e61121", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-original.ppm", + "sha256": "323f994d88bdfc85b1fd5f0da8d016528d177f5f4ae161b8f4fd1d9c31e8f8cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6c90e04d053bc6503125178ea88149b0e70a201f7bbfaa74eba8514bae2c2294", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d77fd92e32e74f7e4bc758027018ffff86999cfe150ac295100bb5ddb5f31be9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "520b1a8d3da97ffee31cbf4cbda9c2201d705c38ff4e2b9f59c7b56b89bf4873", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7bf1a66c309e5e27f78ebd33a77741415e5dc07f17b7a66add9018a8a0168bb6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcf27e9fb33248fbfbde9b3a3dbd43531c7d41856691dea8687cb1bedefc7df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "881bac50fe4cb6b4cfdf6221cd6ae43c1c203898ab3b0976ae57aa98061d00a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afb7b208c7864b7dd9d543ff10a3807efadda0bb2fedfc7cb4de59fbc93e6ba0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3732affb156ce43a9324e9305eafe9eeac67ed1250e7dcaac80141da66930bb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b504983b79b46f8fb04dfb1ae53818761032fa018dc630d47dc0723ad3015eb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52824c1443b6fa23d968a974df44c8402ed07d4f68a1fe0082358b7bb99775bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a200bb1c9002fa1851c525bc49cf73166b939ce219bd1110f0cdfdb091bb1ba4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "88311946e1716061b3f5844b3c2c71c968455ef70f55eef0f5432e4c10c2c7e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5c94f60faca30e467836e1ec28685691d05f52f914c53ae1dbc1ac7fbbb39fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ad7c96a8bfd9e345a049fc56a2f7006de8a39b650b1141c515e52e6bc4c6d732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-original.ppm", + "sha256": "95f7ee0bb4adecf2b09fb558ec65fa7df02cddf5f4980a5d2f22b0fe705e1d4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f325abbbc67fbc6bbf965964203593b72b257bf54c953aa8c243dc9bbf6ee99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a0fb8d5371cccf257f7eb72bae410a48cb5e2e55448904b306258df6736d88a7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b096d1063c77318135dca09ddfc97312c867a2b62e346f78ede9229202c57d54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bfab1e8711551941d5a511ea2f60fdbb6fad28eb3da79e1f553c92100f0d076e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af6d624cf089b69f2945b3e4b7131e7904ad8c2ab4570376dbbc915460eaed63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "42114d7ec64dce9ce46638513723a9ca264c98a3dcb4bf0d4b75cf0f01c85b33", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf5ae14df8e29dedab8c2594c80944c7d214249ac01869b3868858856d6676cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8a32d0f3d3661a27822e10b17449df3fc97c79a5a6e11a62bca45d5fab3056e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f0080331f0ba1421094a37611b75ef5637363e8c89242e553650de1ec31ebb2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a5be54aa0de23afda041722ff131a34bf7915b663e805100edcbae670efcdfd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2c198b97d03a429ba59e2d44176d342ee2cb73f4900f446d71eec2ab2f9f0155", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d084ac2dc513a9d936e1f6a7ce10f3c0885182d82c30125477303dd9a617c9a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "46ba7b5aab5dd93f2b91f9cf2c05211a6eff53993a4033c3e7eb5cf428a59ab0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "64845979129dd4cf1d791595e235965c70e0c520dfb21fa230207d86aa8d8d59", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c87ff97d470deccfe7f98ea5661833cb545080cdcf6ec4089b1a39bc7e80fef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "83f01f7167a18a1cbf14fe3f8c59c58a3ee3c215f7f4aff3e3b1830312abe884", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26b3da57a60d2835a2d54f90bc221ce5aa12fe99681b916e6fea6862576e87c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b0071f55e5f0815c122b8aecaa11c124009135c797c1172b7ae9ef7b603d526a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7870a9ea2e2dd21bc0a990213366b71c4a1b6cc8bb48b073689c03fa8fa94349", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4cd396ea6f806e35904551d5a1c15b57f5f8f860ed6580bb398cfa8e554591c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f90187bd20fda2ebe115eb40fd3b3f0249e6716e9b817960e729b5952c243d7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7d2d8d558481d69e9a990435f11576c28cb14950496351cc4bdf6df21a3835ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "66ff0d1cca01b9e976dba42894d0ab81f3a44e4ec0779c8b43f96ee35137fc2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0274a70ab8bf872e0d54b7870e2770ddf9bedf5145c4e65d5662e474d3699b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1494db86c30901877b193e7089aac4bd67475735b32cbccdde8f816407c95966", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91c584fa7efdca2f0e92c2fb79a82e9e2b53e8801d6f37ebdb0d6852d0717d57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21b77e99354230542cbe8bc5fe27851b5403e3898f4f2475b206d61bf0a1c89c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1b6f9e2f110ff7ad0a50a6db64479a837dd6757916bc90fc5bad42ccb4b72e99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "171d40fb656c1f69ae4e2e876d67dfeed1760cbfbdb7c40d28dd54f134886e65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39641bdce92c245bfd56b3d02478f5c7f15f73ebaf9a0b878dd78bef2377e9cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bc3845c189111a7c4f59f748b584d3b654770c2461ef0ea40d626e6ed765470f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2eb33e9db08bfaba168470e598ab5922032422edc05641739469b7452fe5d867", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b3765358445d6015f17f8bb2b12d4b03d0d2232c5048161a81c28ea26dd62bc1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4deafeeb09ce2cf146b6efbaa7682f35da2c32c31877a70fffdbadfcf39466e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e4a93c5ed6e33642c0dbe6efc5f15b66e72283767528b5e90c8cb0651b84437d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ced9c9e73ebb4f47a73c748e98741d6cdbca7841849b7445df4a538d35ef359b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3fd3fcf1d6e6315e905c8a4b629655c4157062a3a4213036efa994eaf94236cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b216c2a1968322da29a2d58f4b932c361881c601e7cc81fba106a13153eae743", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "65582a4515c94a88105685b917fa7f882518df98b18679aa014e3ec85d91b856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8fa2d312960c480b2f1a266a02021b024eb749181b19e1b715ce8e768a42775c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0906f5b6044adfa4066460b1c0713fb14a5d5a91dd183f5293492c277bd7224d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ad6be231b3a1b74f9cefb78b24c2ea14f0fb756651270ac7809c525d674aa05a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4fffdf7afa76e0e5bb9e8593eb971047d7750fcec82a092de3e010c19b1abc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b33f135fd32ed8c07f1df27f2ed2da1af47e3ea9520189f08436cf26c3513300", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4b3912fcace2e318aba5b8a56c0700f3f5cf3005a427732a3cde62a2e9f61f3b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "75d578525b47cc1984eac90a83d97646b7223a2e1d5b241fedb6945ed3bafec1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b34cbd5a38c09891c450ef8efd873b5edbdc0a69ca3e9d5e59da1e7b8b7c35b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f758d90398932a0fb893f56c99a0970b8963622710618b5bde1614b30e35c71a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "19a4fd2ebc31c4ddbf8df49c20cb45deedfb9918e76b4c8f3d73b2859c353beb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80c8652187f91adf99c29ee87b76151cbc675893daffb44225700a0f6023c732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "720521030ed6596c8c901aab05e83cad8eeb63a912740b90c8589d7ccf5a4d31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f09810569751d1889a56e15348692a5c9940fd594f28c48e371d21b243efd5ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "054ad21644f0e3ff3d6ac7d0a65a62a96c3dd42748196b4ac0a1fa4b15c48080", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "04c4e8cb5fa0ceb4d2038e0896160080ed08d5cc482b07e6cb25b861a83984e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d4631c461a750ef27cd4e325dd10818c5665b395951c75d6d86328a878659a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bca5b1553df89212f42bcdfe2ba0d54f914f10f915cb2d39f5474bbdcee0b47", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c14795354a8e98d8101bbd7376945ccaeca83fd575c0e982854e9e3d994c7021", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1c7d396166040be2e95cb0186aab14e747cfde1f037fe1668cfb5f8a678a59f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "be3d2b93818c4b52b23c429086ca4748df43a7784828432ce0b7453f1c60e05b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0765e61a71b81fb5d4e1e5abdfa0ed1905e6d6b3197e941a1324a09fe656076a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4013f": { @@ -346112,7 +373599,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4013f", "family_id": "terrain-40135-40144", "job_id": "terrain-40135-40144", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -346128,6 +373615,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/candidate.json", "sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "556a32bf29ebf9ee172059ea0f22d8f462e51ab53668ef1783d956a4a98a5ac2", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.605315+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40138 standalone v2 preserves its two principal stones and tiny lower-right pebble without the previously rejected foreign fissure. 4013e/4013f retain their upper/lower branch fan; 40143 has the source single tapered vertical fissure; 40144 retains descending diagonal plus short left vertical branch.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 ae25353c16e8b505b9825bbb95946c39443aed3ec07274c4af7ff08c9ff42c61", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40135", + "40136", + "40137", + "40138" + ], + "sha256": "0d2794e4d1fd5391cec77fc86aaee31352b715b8fbdb5e64f4dc04ca9b02960e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40139", + "4013a", + "4013b", + "4013c" + ], + "sha256": "e6b7707870477658cc3dfa49602a7fd3dfd814a7fb41b3c8ffd7921d6aed0fc3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4013d", + "4013e", + "4013f", + "40140" + ], + "sha256": "dc651cb770ee3076c2fa3641e5c2606f7e6e1f3078d0b1a66d52e094a2b42e02", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40141", + "40142", + "40143", + "40144" + ], + "sha256": "c85527d989aa2afe12dc3925b61dccf8c5c68b58c184afdba60794c86f23055f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40135-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "004c7ced4542320fc143bab031ac1e23c82ec35a376a4a0ce7d5f8d9766f06fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "163cc5d28931f94e78a13a266754a356a14738d4ffbd0244dd60e7e66ef1ed1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ff58b355e237f35c3b0117f786eb0c335f438874d7e4cd56600056ad0d2d7f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b4e67e4440e5bbf7d3a96e108c5e7e7b0a4fd9e66b288a3c7eff04164e61121", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-original.ppm", + "sha256": "323f994d88bdfc85b1fd5f0da8d016528d177f5f4ae161b8f4fd1d9c31e8f8cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6c90e04d053bc6503125178ea88149b0e70a201f7bbfaa74eba8514bae2c2294", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d77fd92e32e74f7e4bc758027018ffff86999cfe150ac295100bb5ddb5f31be9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "520b1a8d3da97ffee31cbf4cbda9c2201d705c38ff4e2b9f59c7b56b89bf4873", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7bf1a66c309e5e27f78ebd33a77741415e5dc07f17b7a66add9018a8a0168bb6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcf27e9fb33248fbfbde9b3a3dbd43531c7d41856691dea8687cb1bedefc7df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "881bac50fe4cb6b4cfdf6221cd6ae43c1c203898ab3b0976ae57aa98061d00a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afb7b208c7864b7dd9d543ff10a3807efadda0bb2fedfc7cb4de59fbc93e6ba0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3732affb156ce43a9324e9305eafe9eeac67ed1250e7dcaac80141da66930bb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b504983b79b46f8fb04dfb1ae53818761032fa018dc630d47dc0723ad3015eb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52824c1443b6fa23d968a974df44c8402ed07d4f68a1fe0082358b7bb99775bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a200bb1c9002fa1851c525bc49cf73166b939ce219bd1110f0cdfdb091bb1ba4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "88311946e1716061b3f5844b3c2c71c968455ef70f55eef0f5432e4c10c2c7e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5c94f60faca30e467836e1ec28685691d05f52f914c53ae1dbc1ac7fbbb39fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ad7c96a8bfd9e345a049fc56a2f7006de8a39b650b1141c515e52e6bc4c6d732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-original.ppm", + "sha256": "95f7ee0bb4adecf2b09fb558ec65fa7df02cddf5f4980a5d2f22b0fe705e1d4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f325abbbc67fbc6bbf965964203593b72b257bf54c953aa8c243dc9bbf6ee99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a0fb8d5371cccf257f7eb72bae410a48cb5e2e55448904b306258df6736d88a7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b096d1063c77318135dca09ddfc97312c867a2b62e346f78ede9229202c57d54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bfab1e8711551941d5a511ea2f60fdbb6fad28eb3da79e1f553c92100f0d076e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af6d624cf089b69f2945b3e4b7131e7904ad8c2ab4570376dbbc915460eaed63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "42114d7ec64dce9ce46638513723a9ca264c98a3dcb4bf0d4b75cf0f01c85b33", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf5ae14df8e29dedab8c2594c80944c7d214249ac01869b3868858856d6676cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8a32d0f3d3661a27822e10b17449df3fc97c79a5a6e11a62bca45d5fab3056e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f0080331f0ba1421094a37611b75ef5637363e8c89242e553650de1ec31ebb2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a5be54aa0de23afda041722ff131a34bf7915b663e805100edcbae670efcdfd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2c198b97d03a429ba59e2d44176d342ee2cb73f4900f446d71eec2ab2f9f0155", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d084ac2dc513a9d936e1f6a7ce10f3c0885182d82c30125477303dd9a617c9a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "46ba7b5aab5dd93f2b91f9cf2c05211a6eff53993a4033c3e7eb5cf428a59ab0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "64845979129dd4cf1d791595e235965c70e0c520dfb21fa230207d86aa8d8d59", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c87ff97d470deccfe7f98ea5661833cb545080cdcf6ec4089b1a39bc7e80fef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "83f01f7167a18a1cbf14fe3f8c59c58a3ee3c215f7f4aff3e3b1830312abe884", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26b3da57a60d2835a2d54f90bc221ce5aa12fe99681b916e6fea6862576e87c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b0071f55e5f0815c122b8aecaa11c124009135c797c1172b7ae9ef7b603d526a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7870a9ea2e2dd21bc0a990213366b71c4a1b6cc8bb48b073689c03fa8fa94349", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4cd396ea6f806e35904551d5a1c15b57f5f8f860ed6580bb398cfa8e554591c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f90187bd20fda2ebe115eb40fd3b3f0249e6716e9b817960e729b5952c243d7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7d2d8d558481d69e9a990435f11576c28cb14950496351cc4bdf6df21a3835ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "66ff0d1cca01b9e976dba42894d0ab81f3a44e4ec0779c8b43f96ee35137fc2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0274a70ab8bf872e0d54b7870e2770ddf9bedf5145c4e65d5662e474d3699b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1494db86c30901877b193e7089aac4bd67475735b32cbccdde8f816407c95966", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91c584fa7efdca2f0e92c2fb79a82e9e2b53e8801d6f37ebdb0d6852d0717d57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21b77e99354230542cbe8bc5fe27851b5403e3898f4f2475b206d61bf0a1c89c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1b6f9e2f110ff7ad0a50a6db64479a837dd6757916bc90fc5bad42ccb4b72e99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "171d40fb656c1f69ae4e2e876d67dfeed1760cbfbdb7c40d28dd54f134886e65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39641bdce92c245bfd56b3d02478f5c7f15f73ebaf9a0b878dd78bef2377e9cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bc3845c189111a7c4f59f748b584d3b654770c2461ef0ea40d626e6ed765470f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2eb33e9db08bfaba168470e598ab5922032422edc05641739469b7452fe5d867", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b3765358445d6015f17f8bb2b12d4b03d0d2232c5048161a81c28ea26dd62bc1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4deafeeb09ce2cf146b6efbaa7682f35da2c32c31877a70fffdbadfcf39466e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e4a93c5ed6e33642c0dbe6efc5f15b66e72283767528b5e90c8cb0651b84437d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ced9c9e73ebb4f47a73c748e98741d6cdbca7841849b7445df4a538d35ef359b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3fd3fcf1d6e6315e905c8a4b629655c4157062a3a4213036efa994eaf94236cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b216c2a1968322da29a2d58f4b932c361881c601e7cc81fba106a13153eae743", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "65582a4515c94a88105685b917fa7f882518df98b18679aa014e3ec85d91b856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8fa2d312960c480b2f1a266a02021b024eb749181b19e1b715ce8e768a42775c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0906f5b6044adfa4066460b1c0713fb14a5d5a91dd183f5293492c277bd7224d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ad6be231b3a1b74f9cefb78b24c2ea14f0fb756651270ac7809c525d674aa05a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4fffdf7afa76e0e5bb9e8593eb971047d7750fcec82a092de3e010c19b1abc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b33f135fd32ed8c07f1df27f2ed2da1af47e3ea9520189f08436cf26c3513300", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4b3912fcace2e318aba5b8a56c0700f3f5cf3005a427732a3cde62a2e9f61f3b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "75d578525b47cc1984eac90a83d97646b7223a2e1d5b241fedb6945ed3bafec1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b34cbd5a38c09891c450ef8efd873b5edbdc0a69ca3e9d5e59da1e7b8b7c35b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f758d90398932a0fb893f56c99a0970b8963622710618b5bde1614b30e35c71a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "19a4fd2ebc31c4ddbf8df49c20cb45deedfb9918e76b4c8f3d73b2859c353beb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80c8652187f91adf99c29ee87b76151cbc675893daffb44225700a0f6023c732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "720521030ed6596c8c901aab05e83cad8eeb63a912740b90c8589d7ccf5a4d31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f09810569751d1889a56e15348692a5c9940fd594f28c48e371d21b243efd5ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "054ad21644f0e3ff3d6ac7d0a65a62a96c3dd42748196b4ac0a1fa4b15c48080", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "04c4e8cb5fa0ceb4d2038e0896160080ed08d5cc482b07e6cb25b861a83984e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d4631c461a750ef27cd4e325dd10818c5665b395951c75d6d86328a878659a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bca5b1553df89212f42bcdfe2ba0d54f914f10f915cb2d39f5474bbdcee0b47", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c14795354a8e98d8101bbd7376945ccaeca83fd575c0e982854e9e3d994c7021", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1c7d396166040be2e95cb0186aab14e747cfde1f037fe1668cfb5f8a678a59f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "be3d2b93818c4b52b23c429086ca4748df43a7784828432ce0b7453f1c60e05b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0765e61a71b81fb5d4e1e5abdfa0ed1905e6d6b3197e941a1324a09fe656076a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40140": { @@ -346149,7 +374106,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40140", "family_id": "terrain-40135-40144", "job_id": "terrain-40135-40144", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -346165,6 +374122,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/candidate.json", "sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "556a32bf29ebf9ee172059ea0f22d8f462e51ab53668ef1783d956a4a98a5ac2", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.605315+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40138 standalone v2 preserves its two principal stones and tiny lower-right pebble without the previously rejected foreign fissure. 4013e/4013f retain their upper/lower branch fan; 40143 has the source single tapered vertical fissure; 40144 retains descending diagonal plus short left vertical branch.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 ae25353c16e8b505b9825bbb95946c39443aed3ec07274c4af7ff08c9ff42c61", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40135", + "40136", + "40137", + "40138" + ], + "sha256": "0d2794e4d1fd5391cec77fc86aaee31352b715b8fbdb5e64f4dc04ca9b02960e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40139", + "4013a", + "4013b", + "4013c" + ], + "sha256": "e6b7707870477658cc3dfa49602a7fd3dfd814a7fb41b3c8ffd7921d6aed0fc3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4013d", + "4013e", + "4013f", + "40140" + ], + "sha256": "dc651cb770ee3076c2fa3641e5c2606f7e6e1f3078d0b1a66d52e094a2b42e02", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40141", + "40142", + "40143", + "40144" + ], + "sha256": "c85527d989aa2afe12dc3925b61dccf8c5c68b58c184afdba60794c86f23055f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40135-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "004c7ced4542320fc143bab031ac1e23c82ec35a376a4a0ce7d5f8d9766f06fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "163cc5d28931f94e78a13a266754a356a14738d4ffbd0244dd60e7e66ef1ed1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ff58b355e237f35c3b0117f786eb0c335f438874d7e4cd56600056ad0d2d7f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b4e67e4440e5bbf7d3a96e108c5e7e7b0a4fd9e66b288a3c7eff04164e61121", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-original.ppm", + "sha256": "323f994d88bdfc85b1fd5f0da8d016528d177f5f4ae161b8f4fd1d9c31e8f8cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6c90e04d053bc6503125178ea88149b0e70a201f7bbfaa74eba8514bae2c2294", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d77fd92e32e74f7e4bc758027018ffff86999cfe150ac295100bb5ddb5f31be9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "520b1a8d3da97ffee31cbf4cbda9c2201d705c38ff4e2b9f59c7b56b89bf4873", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7bf1a66c309e5e27f78ebd33a77741415e5dc07f17b7a66add9018a8a0168bb6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcf27e9fb33248fbfbde9b3a3dbd43531c7d41856691dea8687cb1bedefc7df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "881bac50fe4cb6b4cfdf6221cd6ae43c1c203898ab3b0976ae57aa98061d00a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afb7b208c7864b7dd9d543ff10a3807efadda0bb2fedfc7cb4de59fbc93e6ba0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3732affb156ce43a9324e9305eafe9eeac67ed1250e7dcaac80141da66930bb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b504983b79b46f8fb04dfb1ae53818761032fa018dc630d47dc0723ad3015eb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52824c1443b6fa23d968a974df44c8402ed07d4f68a1fe0082358b7bb99775bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a200bb1c9002fa1851c525bc49cf73166b939ce219bd1110f0cdfdb091bb1ba4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "88311946e1716061b3f5844b3c2c71c968455ef70f55eef0f5432e4c10c2c7e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5c94f60faca30e467836e1ec28685691d05f52f914c53ae1dbc1ac7fbbb39fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ad7c96a8bfd9e345a049fc56a2f7006de8a39b650b1141c515e52e6bc4c6d732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-original.ppm", + "sha256": "95f7ee0bb4adecf2b09fb558ec65fa7df02cddf5f4980a5d2f22b0fe705e1d4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f325abbbc67fbc6bbf965964203593b72b257bf54c953aa8c243dc9bbf6ee99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a0fb8d5371cccf257f7eb72bae410a48cb5e2e55448904b306258df6736d88a7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b096d1063c77318135dca09ddfc97312c867a2b62e346f78ede9229202c57d54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bfab1e8711551941d5a511ea2f60fdbb6fad28eb3da79e1f553c92100f0d076e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af6d624cf089b69f2945b3e4b7131e7904ad8c2ab4570376dbbc915460eaed63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "42114d7ec64dce9ce46638513723a9ca264c98a3dcb4bf0d4b75cf0f01c85b33", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf5ae14df8e29dedab8c2594c80944c7d214249ac01869b3868858856d6676cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8a32d0f3d3661a27822e10b17449df3fc97c79a5a6e11a62bca45d5fab3056e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f0080331f0ba1421094a37611b75ef5637363e8c89242e553650de1ec31ebb2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a5be54aa0de23afda041722ff131a34bf7915b663e805100edcbae670efcdfd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2c198b97d03a429ba59e2d44176d342ee2cb73f4900f446d71eec2ab2f9f0155", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d084ac2dc513a9d936e1f6a7ce10f3c0885182d82c30125477303dd9a617c9a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "46ba7b5aab5dd93f2b91f9cf2c05211a6eff53993a4033c3e7eb5cf428a59ab0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "64845979129dd4cf1d791595e235965c70e0c520dfb21fa230207d86aa8d8d59", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c87ff97d470deccfe7f98ea5661833cb545080cdcf6ec4089b1a39bc7e80fef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "83f01f7167a18a1cbf14fe3f8c59c58a3ee3c215f7f4aff3e3b1830312abe884", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26b3da57a60d2835a2d54f90bc221ce5aa12fe99681b916e6fea6862576e87c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b0071f55e5f0815c122b8aecaa11c124009135c797c1172b7ae9ef7b603d526a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7870a9ea2e2dd21bc0a990213366b71c4a1b6cc8bb48b073689c03fa8fa94349", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4cd396ea6f806e35904551d5a1c15b57f5f8f860ed6580bb398cfa8e554591c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f90187bd20fda2ebe115eb40fd3b3f0249e6716e9b817960e729b5952c243d7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7d2d8d558481d69e9a990435f11576c28cb14950496351cc4bdf6df21a3835ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "66ff0d1cca01b9e976dba42894d0ab81f3a44e4ec0779c8b43f96ee35137fc2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0274a70ab8bf872e0d54b7870e2770ddf9bedf5145c4e65d5662e474d3699b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1494db86c30901877b193e7089aac4bd67475735b32cbccdde8f816407c95966", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91c584fa7efdca2f0e92c2fb79a82e9e2b53e8801d6f37ebdb0d6852d0717d57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21b77e99354230542cbe8bc5fe27851b5403e3898f4f2475b206d61bf0a1c89c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1b6f9e2f110ff7ad0a50a6db64479a837dd6757916bc90fc5bad42ccb4b72e99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "171d40fb656c1f69ae4e2e876d67dfeed1760cbfbdb7c40d28dd54f134886e65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39641bdce92c245bfd56b3d02478f5c7f15f73ebaf9a0b878dd78bef2377e9cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bc3845c189111a7c4f59f748b584d3b654770c2461ef0ea40d626e6ed765470f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2eb33e9db08bfaba168470e598ab5922032422edc05641739469b7452fe5d867", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b3765358445d6015f17f8bb2b12d4b03d0d2232c5048161a81c28ea26dd62bc1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4deafeeb09ce2cf146b6efbaa7682f35da2c32c31877a70fffdbadfcf39466e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e4a93c5ed6e33642c0dbe6efc5f15b66e72283767528b5e90c8cb0651b84437d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ced9c9e73ebb4f47a73c748e98741d6cdbca7841849b7445df4a538d35ef359b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3fd3fcf1d6e6315e905c8a4b629655c4157062a3a4213036efa994eaf94236cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b216c2a1968322da29a2d58f4b932c361881c601e7cc81fba106a13153eae743", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "65582a4515c94a88105685b917fa7f882518df98b18679aa014e3ec85d91b856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8fa2d312960c480b2f1a266a02021b024eb749181b19e1b715ce8e768a42775c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0906f5b6044adfa4066460b1c0713fb14a5d5a91dd183f5293492c277bd7224d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ad6be231b3a1b74f9cefb78b24c2ea14f0fb756651270ac7809c525d674aa05a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4fffdf7afa76e0e5bb9e8593eb971047d7750fcec82a092de3e010c19b1abc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b33f135fd32ed8c07f1df27f2ed2da1af47e3ea9520189f08436cf26c3513300", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4b3912fcace2e318aba5b8a56c0700f3f5cf3005a427732a3cde62a2e9f61f3b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "75d578525b47cc1984eac90a83d97646b7223a2e1d5b241fedb6945ed3bafec1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b34cbd5a38c09891c450ef8efd873b5edbdc0a69ca3e9d5e59da1e7b8b7c35b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f758d90398932a0fb893f56c99a0970b8963622710618b5bde1614b30e35c71a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "19a4fd2ebc31c4ddbf8df49c20cb45deedfb9918e76b4c8f3d73b2859c353beb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80c8652187f91adf99c29ee87b76151cbc675893daffb44225700a0f6023c732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "720521030ed6596c8c901aab05e83cad8eeb63a912740b90c8589d7ccf5a4d31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f09810569751d1889a56e15348692a5c9940fd594f28c48e371d21b243efd5ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "054ad21644f0e3ff3d6ac7d0a65a62a96c3dd42748196b4ac0a1fa4b15c48080", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "04c4e8cb5fa0ceb4d2038e0896160080ed08d5cc482b07e6cb25b861a83984e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d4631c461a750ef27cd4e325dd10818c5665b395951c75d6d86328a878659a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bca5b1553df89212f42bcdfe2ba0d54f914f10f915cb2d39f5474bbdcee0b47", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c14795354a8e98d8101bbd7376945ccaeca83fd575c0e982854e9e3d994c7021", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1c7d396166040be2e95cb0186aab14e747cfde1f037fe1668cfb5f8a678a59f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "be3d2b93818c4b52b23c429086ca4748df43a7784828432ce0b7453f1c60e05b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0765e61a71b81fb5d4e1e5abdfa0ed1905e6d6b3197e941a1324a09fe656076a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40141": { @@ -346186,7 +374613,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40141", "family_id": "terrain-40135-40144", "job_id": "terrain-40135-40144", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -346202,6 +374629,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/candidate.json", "sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "556a32bf29ebf9ee172059ea0f22d8f462e51ab53668ef1783d956a4a98a5ac2", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.605315+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40138 standalone v2 preserves its two principal stones and tiny lower-right pebble without the previously rejected foreign fissure. 4013e/4013f retain their upper/lower branch fan; 40143 has the source single tapered vertical fissure; 40144 retains descending diagonal plus short left vertical branch.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 ae25353c16e8b505b9825bbb95946c39443aed3ec07274c4af7ff08c9ff42c61", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40135", + "40136", + "40137", + "40138" + ], + "sha256": "0d2794e4d1fd5391cec77fc86aaee31352b715b8fbdb5e64f4dc04ca9b02960e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40139", + "4013a", + "4013b", + "4013c" + ], + "sha256": "e6b7707870477658cc3dfa49602a7fd3dfd814a7fb41b3c8ffd7921d6aed0fc3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4013d", + "4013e", + "4013f", + "40140" + ], + "sha256": "dc651cb770ee3076c2fa3641e5c2606f7e6e1f3078d0b1a66d52e094a2b42e02", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40141", + "40142", + "40143", + "40144" + ], + "sha256": "c85527d989aa2afe12dc3925b61dccf8c5c68b58c184afdba60794c86f23055f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40135-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "004c7ced4542320fc143bab031ac1e23c82ec35a376a4a0ce7d5f8d9766f06fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "163cc5d28931f94e78a13a266754a356a14738d4ffbd0244dd60e7e66ef1ed1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ff58b355e237f35c3b0117f786eb0c335f438874d7e4cd56600056ad0d2d7f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b4e67e4440e5bbf7d3a96e108c5e7e7b0a4fd9e66b288a3c7eff04164e61121", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-original.ppm", + "sha256": "323f994d88bdfc85b1fd5f0da8d016528d177f5f4ae161b8f4fd1d9c31e8f8cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6c90e04d053bc6503125178ea88149b0e70a201f7bbfaa74eba8514bae2c2294", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d77fd92e32e74f7e4bc758027018ffff86999cfe150ac295100bb5ddb5f31be9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "520b1a8d3da97ffee31cbf4cbda9c2201d705c38ff4e2b9f59c7b56b89bf4873", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7bf1a66c309e5e27f78ebd33a77741415e5dc07f17b7a66add9018a8a0168bb6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcf27e9fb33248fbfbde9b3a3dbd43531c7d41856691dea8687cb1bedefc7df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "881bac50fe4cb6b4cfdf6221cd6ae43c1c203898ab3b0976ae57aa98061d00a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afb7b208c7864b7dd9d543ff10a3807efadda0bb2fedfc7cb4de59fbc93e6ba0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3732affb156ce43a9324e9305eafe9eeac67ed1250e7dcaac80141da66930bb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b504983b79b46f8fb04dfb1ae53818761032fa018dc630d47dc0723ad3015eb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52824c1443b6fa23d968a974df44c8402ed07d4f68a1fe0082358b7bb99775bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a200bb1c9002fa1851c525bc49cf73166b939ce219bd1110f0cdfdb091bb1ba4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "88311946e1716061b3f5844b3c2c71c968455ef70f55eef0f5432e4c10c2c7e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5c94f60faca30e467836e1ec28685691d05f52f914c53ae1dbc1ac7fbbb39fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ad7c96a8bfd9e345a049fc56a2f7006de8a39b650b1141c515e52e6bc4c6d732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-original.ppm", + "sha256": "95f7ee0bb4adecf2b09fb558ec65fa7df02cddf5f4980a5d2f22b0fe705e1d4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f325abbbc67fbc6bbf965964203593b72b257bf54c953aa8c243dc9bbf6ee99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a0fb8d5371cccf257f7eb72bae410a48cb5e2e55448904b306258df6736d88a7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b096d1063c77318135dca09ddfc97312c867a2b62e346f78ede9229202c57d54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bfab1e8711551941d5a511ea2f60fdbb6fad28eb3da79e1f553c92100f0d076e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af6d624cf089b69f2945b3e4b7131e7904ad8c2ab4570376dbbc915460eaed63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "42114d7ec64dce9ce46638513723a9ca264c98a3dcb4bf0d4b75cf0f01c85b33", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf5ae14df8e29dedab8c2594c80944c7d214249ac01869b3868858856d6676cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8a32d0f3d3661a27822e10b17449df3fc97c79a5a6e11a62bca45d5fab3056e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f0080331f0ba1421094a37611b75ef5637363e8c89242e553650de1ec31ebb2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a5be54aa0de23afda041722ff131a34bf7915b663e805100edcbae670efcdfd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2c198b97d03a429ba59e2d44176d342ee2cb73f4900f446d71eec2ab2f9f0155", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d084ac2dc513a9d936e1f6a7ce10f3c0885182d82c30125477303dd9a617c9a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "46ba7b5aab5dd93f2b91f9cf2c05211a6eff53993a4033c3e7eb5cf428a59ab0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "64845979129dd4cf1d791595e235965c70e0c520dfb21fa230207d86aa8d8d59", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c87ff97d470deccfe7f98ea5661833cb545080cdcf6ec4089b1a39bc7e80fef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "83f01f7167a18a1cbf14fe3f8c59c58a3ee3c215f7f4aff3e3b1830312abe884", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26b3da57a60d2835a2d54f90bc221ce5aa12fe99681b916e6fea6862576e87c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b0071f55e5f0815c122b8aecaa11c124009135c797c1172b7ae9ef7b603d526a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7870a9ea2e2dd21bc0a990213366b71c4a1b6cc8bb48b073689c03fa8fa94349", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4cd396ea6f806e35904551d5a1c15b57f5f8f860ed6580bb398cfa8e554591c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f90187bd20fda2ebe115eb40fd3b3f0249e6716e9b817960e729b5952c243d7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7d2d8d558481d69e9a990435f11576c28cb14950496351cc4bdf6df21a3835ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "66ff0d1cca01b9e976dba42894d0ab81f3a44e4ec0779c8b43f96ee35137fc2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0274a70ab8bf872e0d54b7870e2770ddf9bedf5145c4e65d5662e474d3699b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1494db86c30901877b193e7089aac4bd67475735b32cbccdde8f816407c95966", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91c584fa7efdca2f0e92c2fb79a82e9e2b53e8801d6f37ebdb0d6852d0717d57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21b77e99354230542cbe8bc5fe27851b5403e3898f4f2475b206d61bf0a1c89c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1b6f9e2f110ff7ad0a50a6db64479a837dd6757916bc90fc5bad42ccb4b72e99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "171d40fb656c1f69ae4e2e876d67dfeed1760cbfbdb7c40d28dd54f134886e65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39641bdce92c245bfd56b3d02478f5c7f15f73ebaf9a0b878dd78bef2377e9cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bc3845c189111a7c4f59f748b584d3b654770c2461ef0ea40d626e6ed765470f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2eb33e9db08bfaba168470e598ab5922032422edc05641739469b7452fe5d867", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b3765358445d6015f17f8bb2b12d4b03d0d2232c5048161a81c28ea26dd62bc1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4deafeeb09ce2cf146b6efbaa7682f35da2c32c31877a70fffdbadfcf39466e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e4a93c5ed6e33642c0dbe6efc5f15b66e72283767528b5e90c8cb0651b84437d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ced9c9e73ebb4f47a73c748e98741d6cdbca7841849b7445df4a538d35ef359b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3fd3fcf1d6e6315e905c8a4b629655c4157062a3a4213036efa994eaf94236cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b216c2a1968322da29a2d58f4b932c361881c601e7cc81fba106a13153eae743", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "65582a4515c94a88105685b917fa7f882518df98b18679aa014e3ec85d91b856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8fa2d312960c480b2f1a266a02021b024eb749181b19e1b715ce8e768a42775c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0906f5b6044adfa4066460b1c0713fb14a5d5a91dd183f5293492c277bd7224d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ad6be231b3a1b74f9cefb78b24c2ea14f0fb756651270ac7809c525d674aa05a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4fffdf7afa76e0e5bb9e8593eb971047d7750fcec82a092de3e010c19b1abc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b33f135fd32ed8c07f1df27f2ed2da1af47e3ea9520189f08436cf26c3513300", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4b3912fcace2e318aba5b8a56c0700f3f5cf3005a427732a3cde62a2e9f61f3b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "75d578525b47cc1984eac90a83d97646b7223a2e1d5b241fedb6945ed3bafec1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b34cbd5a38c09891c450ef8efd873b5edbdc0a69ca3e9d5e59da1e7b8b7c35b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f758d90398932a0fb893f56c99a0970b8963622710618b5bde1614b30e35c71a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "19a4fd2ebc31c4ddbf8df49c20cb45deedfb9918e76b4c8f3d73b2859c353beb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80c8652187f91adf99c29ee87b76151cbc675893daffb44225700a0f6023c732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "720521030ed6596c8c901aab05e83cad8eeb63a912740b90c8589d7ccf5a4d31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f09810569751d1889a56e15348692a5c9940fd594f28c48e371d21b243efd5ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "054ad21644f0e3ff3d6ac7d0a65a62a96c3dd42748196b4ac0a1fa4b15c48080", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "04c4e8cb5fa0ceb4d2038e0896160080ed08d5cc482b07e6cb25b861a83984e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d4631c461a750ef27cd4e325dd10818c5665b395951c75d6d86328a878659a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bca5b1553df89212f42bcdfe2ba0d54f914f10f915cb2d39f5474bbdcee0b47", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c14795354a8e98d8101bbd7376945ccaeca83fd575c0e982854e9e3d994c7021", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1c7d396166040be2e95cb0186aab14e747cfde1f037fe1668cfb5f8a678a59f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "be3d2b93818c4b52b23c429086ca4748df43a7784828432ce0b7453f1c60e05b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0765e61a71b81fb5d4e1e5abdfa0ed1905e6d6b3197e941a1324a09fe656076a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40142": { @@ -346223,7 +375120,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40142", "family_id": "terrain-40135-40144", "job_id": "terrain-40135-40144", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -346239,6 +375136,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/candidate.json", "sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "556a32bf29ebf9ee172059ea0f22d8f462e51ab53668ef1783d956a4a98a5ac2", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.605315+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40138 standalone v2 preserves its two principal stones and tiny lower-right pebble without the previously rejected foreign fissure. 4013e/4013f retain their upper/lower branch fan; 40143 has the source single tapered vertical fissure; 40144 retains descending diagonal plus short left vertical branch.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 ae25353c16e8b505b9825bbb95946c39443aed3ec07274c4af7ff08c9ff42c61", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40135", + "40136", + "40137", + "40138" + ], + "sha256": "0d2794e4d1fd5391cec77fc86aaee31352b715b8fbdb5e64f4dc04ca9b02960e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40139", + "4013a", + "4013b", + "4013c" + ], + "sha256": "e6b7707870477658cc3dfa49602a7fd3dfd814a7fb41b3c8ffd7921d6aed0fc3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4013d", + "4013e", + "4013f", + "40140" + ], + "sha256": "dc651cb770ee3076c2fa3641e5c2606f7e6e1f3078d0b1a66d52e094a2b42e02", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40141", + "40142", + "40143", + "40144" + ], + "sha256": "c85527d989aa2afe12dc3925b61dccf8c5c68b58c184afdba60794c86f23055f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40135-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "004c7ced4542320fc143bab031ac1e23c82ec35a376a4a0ce7d5f8d9766f06fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "163cc5d28931f94e78a13a266754a356a14738d4ffbd0244dd60e7e66ef1ed1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ff58b355e237f35c3b0117f786eb0c335f438874d7e4cd56600056ad0d2d7f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b4e67e4440e5bbf7d3a96e108c5e7e7b0a4fd9e66b288a3c7eff04164e61121", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-original.ppm", + "sha256": "323f994d88bdfc85b1fd5f0da8d016528d177f5f4ae161b8f4fd1d9c31e8f8cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6c90e04d053bc6503125178ea88149b0e70a201f7bbfaa74eba8514bae2c2294", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d77fd92e32e74f7e4bc758027018ffff86999cfe150ac295100bb5ddb5f31be9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "520b1a8d3da97ffee31cbf4cbda9c2201d705c38ff4e2b9f59c7b56b89bf4873", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7bf1a66c309e5e27f78ebd33a77741415e5dc07f17b7a66add9018a8a0168bb6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcf27e9fb33248fbfbde9b3a3dbd43531c7d41856691dea8687cb1bedefc7df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "881bac50fe4cb6b4cfdf6221cd6ae43c1c203898ab3b0976ae57aa98061d00a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afb7b208c7864b7dd9d543ff10a3807efadda0bb2fedfc7cb4de59fbc93e6ba0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3732affb156ce43a9324e9305eafe9eeac67ed1250e7dcaac80141da66930bb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b504983b79b46f8fb04dfb1ae53818761032fa018dc630d47dc0723ad3015eb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52824c1443b6fa23d968a974df44c8402ed07d4f68a1fe0082358b7bb99775bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a200bb1c9002fa1851c525bc49cf73166b939ce219bd1110f0cdfdb091bb1ba4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "88311946e1716061b3f5844b3c2c71c968455ef70f55eef0f5432e4c10c2c7e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5c94f60faca30e467836e1ec28685691d05f52f914c53ae1dbc1ac7fbbb39fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ad7c96a8bfd9e345a049fc56a2f7006de8a39b650b1141c515e52e6bc4c6d732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-original.ppm", + "sha256": "95f7ee0bb4adecf2b09fb558ec65fa7df02cddf5f4980a5d2f22b0fe705e1d4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f325abbbc67fbc6bbf965964203593b72b257bf54c953aa8c243dc9bbf6ee99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a0fb8d5371cccf257f7eb72bae410a48cb5e2e55448904b306258df6736d88a7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b096d1063c77318135dca09ddfc97312c867a2b62e346f78ede9229202c57d54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bfab1e8711551941d5a511ea2f60fdbb6fad28eb3da79e1f553c92100f0d076e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af6d624cf089b69f2945b3e4b7131e7904ad8c2ab4570376dbbc915460eaed63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "42114d7ec64dce9ce46638513723a9ca264c98a3dcb4bf0d4b75cf0f01c85b33", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf5ae14df8e29dedab8c2594c80944c7d214249ac01869b3868858856d6676cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8a32d0f3d3661a27822e10b17449df3fc97c79a5a6e11a62bca45d5fab3056e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f0080331f0ba1421094a37611b75ef5637363e8c89242e553650de1ec31ebb2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a5be54aa0de23afda041722ff131a34bf7915b663e805100edcbae670efcdfd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2c198b97d03a429ba59e2d44176d342ee2cb73f4900f446d71eec2ab2f9f0155", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d084ac2dc513a9d936e1f6a7ce10f3c0885182d82c30125477303dd9a617c9a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "46ba7b5aab5dd93f2b91f9cf2c05211a6eff53993a4033c3e7eb5cf428a59ab0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "64845979129dd4cf1d791595e235965c70e0c520dfb21fa230207d86aa8d8d59", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c87ff97d470deccfe7f98ea5661833cb545080cdcf6ec4089b1a39bc7e80fef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "83f01f7167a18a1cbf14fe3f8c59c58a3ee3c215f7f4aff3e3b1830312abe884", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26b3da57a60d2835a2d54f90bc221ce5aa12fe99681b916e6fea6862576e87c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b0071f55e5f0815c122b8aecaa11c124009135c797c1172b7ae9ef7b603d526a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7870a9ea2e2dd21bc0a990213366b71c4a1b6cc8bb48b073689c03fa8fa94349", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4cd396ea6f806e35904551d5a1c15b57f5f8f860ed6580bb398cfa8e554591c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f90187bd20fda2ebe115eb40fd3b3f0249e6716e9b817960e729b5952c243d7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7d2d8d558481d69e9a990435f11576c28cb14950496351cc4bdf6df21a3835ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "66ff0d1cca01b9e976dba42894d0ab81f3a44e4ec0779c8b43f96ee35137fc2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0274a70ab8bf872e0d54b7870e2770ddf9bedf5145c4e65d5662e474d3699b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1494db86c30901877b193e7089aac4bd67475735b32cbccdde8f816407c95966", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91c584fa7efdca2f0e92c2fb79a82e9e2b53e8801d6f37ebdb0d6852d0717d57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21b77e99354230542cbe8bc5fe27851b5403e3898f4f2475b206d61bf0a1c89c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1b6f9e2f110ff7ad0a50a6db64479a837dd6757916bc90fc5bad42ccb4b72e99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "171d40fb656c1f69ae4e2e876d67dfeed1760cbfbdb7c40d28dd54f134886e65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39641bdce92c245bfd56b3d02478f5c7f15f73ebaf9a0b878dd78bef2377e9cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bc3845c189111a7c4f59f748b584d3b654770c2461ef0ea40d626e6ed765470f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2eb33e9db08bfaba168470e598ab5922032422edc05641739469b7452fe5d867", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b3765358445d6015f17f8bb2b12d4b03d0d2232c5048161a81c28ea26dd62bc1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4deafeeb09ce2cf146b6efbaa7682f35da2c32c31877a70fffdbadfcf39466e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e4a93c5ed6e33642c0dbe6efc5f15b66e72283767528b5e90c8cb0651b84437d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ced9c9e73ebb4f47a73c748e98741d6cdbca7841849b7445df4a538d35ef359b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3fd3fcf1d6e6315e905c8a4b629655c4157062a3a4213036efa994eaf94236cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b216c2a1968322da29a2d58f4b932c361881c601e7cc81fba106a13153eae743", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "65582a4515c94a88105685b917fa7f882518df98b18679aa014e3ec85d91b856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8fa2d312960c480b2f1a266a02021b024eb749181b19e1b715ce8e768a42775c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0906f5b6044adfa4066460b1c0713fb14a5d5a91dd183f5293492c277bd7224d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ad6be231b3a1b74f9cefb78b24c2ea14f0fb756651270ac7809c525d674aa05a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4fffdf7afa76e0e5bb9e8593eb971047d7750fcec82a092de3e010c19b1abc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b33f135fd32ed8c07f1df27f2ed2da1af47e3ea9520189f08436cf26c3513300", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4b3912fcace2e318aba5b8a56c0700f3f5cf3005a427732a3cde62a2e9f61f3b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "75d578525b47cc1984eac90a83d97646b7223a2e1d5b241fedb6945ed3bafec1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b34cbd5a38c09891c450ef8efd873b5edbdc0a69ca3e9d5e59da1e7b8b7c35b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f758d90398932a0fb893f56c99a0970b8963622710618b5bde1614b30e35c71a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "19a4fd2ebc31c4ddbf8df49c20cb45deedfb9918e76b4c8f3d73b2859c353beb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80c8652187f91adf99c29ee87b76151cbc675893daffb44225700a0f6023c732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "720521030ed6596c8c901aab05e83cad8eeb63a912740b90c8589d7ccf5a4d31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f09810569751d1889a56e15348692a5c9940fd594f28c48e371d21b243efd5ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "054ad21644f0e3ff3d6ac7d0a65a62a96c3dd42748196b4ac0a1fa4b15c48080", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "04c4e8cb5fa0ceb4d2038e0896160080ed08d5cc482b07e6cb25b861a83984e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d4631c461a750ef27cd4e325dd10818c5665b395951c75d6d86328a878659a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bca5b1553df89212f42bcdfe2ba0d54f914f10f915cb2d39f5474bbdcee0b47", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c14795354a8e98d8101bbd7376945ccaeca83fd575c0e982854e9e3d994c7021", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1c7d396166040be2e95cb0186aab14e747cfde1f037fe1668cfb5f8a678a59f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "be3d2b93818c4b52b23c429086ca4748df43a7784828432ce0b7453f1c60e05b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0765e61a71b81fb5d4e1e5abdfa0ed1905e6d6b3197e941a1324a09fe656076a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40143": { @@ -346260,7 +375627,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40143", "family_id": "terrain-40135-40144", "job_id": "terrain-40135-40144", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -346276,6 +375643,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/candidate.json", "sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "556a32bf29ebf9ee172059ea0f22d8f462e51ab53668ef1783d956a4a98a5ac2", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.605315+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40138 standalone v2 preserves its two principal stones and tiny lower-right pebble without the previously rejected foreign fissure. 4013e/4013f retain their upper/lower branch fan; 40143 has the source single tapered vertical fissure; 40144 retains descending diagonal plus short left vertical branch.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 ae25353c16e8b505b9825bbb95946c39443aed3ec07274c4af7ff08c9ff42c61", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40135", + "40136", + "40137", + "40138" + ], + "sha256": "0d2794e4d1fd5391cec77fc86aaee31352b715b8fbdb5e64f4dc04ca9b02960e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40139", + "4013a", + "4013b", + "4013c" + ], + "sha256": "e6b7707870477658cc3dfa49602a7fd3dfd814a7fb41b3c8ffd7921d6aed0fc3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4013d", + "4013e", + "4013f", + "40140" + ], + "sha256": "dc651cb770ee3076c2fa3641e5c2606f7e6e1f3078d0b1a66d52e094a2b42e02", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40141", + "40142", + "40143", + "40144" + ], + "sha256": "c85527d989aa2afe12dc3925b61dccf8c5c68b58c184afdba60794c86f23055f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40135-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "004c7ced4542320fc143bab031ac1e23c82ec35a376a4a0ce7d5f8d9766f06fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "163cc5d28931f94e78a13a266754a356a14738d4ffbd0244dd60e7e66ef1ed1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ff58b355e237f35c3b0117f786eb0c335f438874d7e4cd56600056ad0d2d7f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b4e67e4440e5bbf7d3a96e108c5e7e7b0a4fd9e66b288a3c7eff04164e61121", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-original.ppm", + "sha256": "323f994d88bdfc85b1fd5f0da8d016528d177f5f4ae161b8f4fd1d9c31e8f8cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6c90e04d053bc6503125178ea88149b0e70a201f7bbfaa74eba8514bae2c2294", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d77fd92e32e74f7e4bc758027018ffff86999cfe150ac295100bb5ddb5f31be9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "520b1a8d3da97ffee31cbf4cbda9c2201d705c38ff4e2b9f59c7b56b89bf4873", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7bf1a66c309e5e27f78ebd33a77741415e5dc07f17b7a66add9018a8a0168bb6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcf27e9fb33248fbfbde9b3a3dbd43531c7d41856691dea8687cb1bedefc7df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "881bac50fe4cb6b4cfdf6221cd6ae43c1c203898ab3b0976ae57aa98061d00a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afb7b208c7864b7dd9d543ff10a3807efadda0bb2fedfc7cb4de59fbc93e6ba0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3732affb156ce43a9324e9305eafe9eeac67ed1250e7dcaac80141da66930bb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b504983b79b46f8fb04dfb1ae53818761032fa018dc630d47dc0723ad3015eb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52824c1443b6fa23d968a974df44c8402ed07d4f68a1fe0082358b7bb99775bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a200bb1c9002fa1851c525bc49cf73166b939ce219bd1110f0cdfdb091bb1ba4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "88311946e1716061b3f5844b3c2c71c968455ef70f55eef0f5432e4c10c2c7e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5c94f60faca30e467836e1ec28685691d05f52f914c53ae1dbc1ac7fbbb39fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ad7c96a8bfd9e345a049fc56a2f7006de8a39b650b1141c515e52e6bc4c6d732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-original.ppm", + "sha256": "95f7ee0bb4adecf2b09fb558ec65fa7df02cddf5f4980a5d2f22b0fe705e1d4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f325abbbc67fbc6bbf965964203593b72b257bf54c953aa8c243dc9bbf6ee99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a0fb8d5371cccf257f7eb72bae410a48cb5e2e55448904b306258df6736d88a7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b096d1063c77318135dca09ddfc97312c867a2b62e346f78ede9229202c57d54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bfab1e8711551941d5a511ea2f60fdbb6fad28eb3da79e1f553c92100f0d076e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af6d624cf089b69f2945b3e4b7131e7904ad8c2ab4570376dbbc915460eaed63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "42114d7ec64dce9ce46638513723a9ca264c98a3dcb4bf0d4b75cf0f01c85b33", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf5ae14df8e29dedab8c2594c80944c7d214249ac01869b3868858856d6676cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8a32d0f3d3661a27822e10b17449df3fc97c79a5a6e11a62bca45d5fab3056e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f0080331f0ba1421094a37611b75ef5637363e8c89242e553650de1ec31ebb2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a5be54aa0de23afda041722ff131a34bf7915b663e805100edcbae670efcdfd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2c198b97d03a429ba59e2d44176d342ee2cb73f4900f446d71eec2ab2f9f0155", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d084ac2dc513a9d936e1f6a7ce10f3c0885182d82c30125477303dd9a617c9a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "46ba7b5aab5dd93f2b91f9cf2c05211a6eff53993a4033c3e7eb5cf428a59ab0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "64845979129dd4cf1d791595e235965c70e0c520dfb21fa230207d86aa8d8d59", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c87ff97d470deccfe7f98ea5661833cb545080cdcf6ec4089b1a39bc7e80fef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "83f01f7167a18a1cbf14fe3f8c59c58a3ee3c215f7f4aff3e3b1830312abe884", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26b3da57a60d2835a2d54f90bc221ce5aa12fe99681b916e6fea6862576e87c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b0071f55e5f0815c122b8aecaa11c124009135c797c1172b7ae9ef7b603d526a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7870a9ea2e2dd21bc0a990213366b71c4a1b6cc8bb48b073689c03fa8fa94349", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4cd396ea6f806e35904551d5a1c15b57f5f8f860ed6580bb398cfa8e554591c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f90187bd20fda2ebe115eb40fd3b3f0249e6716e9b817960e729b5952c243d7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7d2d8d558481d69e9a990435f11576c28cb14950496351cc4bdf6df21a3835ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "66ff0d1cca01b9e976dba42894d0ab81f3a44e4ec0779c8b43f96ee35137fc2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0274a70ab8bf872e0d54b7870e2770ddf9bedf5145c4e65d5662e474d3699b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1494db86c30901877b193e7089aac4bd67475735b32cbccdde8f816407c95966", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91c584fa7efdca2f0e92c2fb79a82e9e2b53e8801d6f37ebdb0d6852d0717d57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21b77e99354230542cbe8bc5fe27851b5403e3898f4f2475b206d61bf0a1c89c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1b6f9e2f110ff7ad0a50a6db64479a837dd6757916bc90fc5bad42ccb4b72e99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "171d40fb656c1f69ae4e2e876d67dfeed1760cbfbdb7c40d28dd54f134886e65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39641bdce92c245bfd56b3d02478f5c7f15f73ebaf9a0b878dd78bef2377e9cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bc3845c189111a7c4f59f748b584d3b654770c2461ef0ea40d626e6ed765470f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2eb33e9db08bfaba168470e598ab5922032422edc05641739469b7452fe5d867", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b3765358445d6015f17f8bb2b12d4b03d0d2232c5048161a81c28ea26dd62bc1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4deafeeb09ce2cf146b6efbaa7682f35da2c32c31877a70fffdbadfcf39466e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e4a93c5ed6e33642c0dbe6efc5f15b66e72283767528b5e90c8cb0651b84437d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ced9c9e73ebb4f47a73c748e98741d6cdbca7841849b7445df4a538d35ef359b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3fd3fcf1d6e6315e905c8a4b629655c4157062a3a4213036efa994eaf94236cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b216c2a1968322da29a2d58f4b932c361881c601e7cc81fba106a13153eae743", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "65582a4515c94a88105685b917fa7f882518df98b18679aa014e3ec85d91b856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8fa2d312960c480b2f1a266a02021b024eb749181b19e1b715ce8e768a42775c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0906f5b6044adfa4066460b1c0713fb14a5d5a91dd183f5293492c277bd7224d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ad6be231b3a1b74f9cefb78b24c2ea14f0fb756651270ac7809c525d674aa05a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4fffdf7afa76e0e5bb9e8593eb971047d7750fcec82a092de3e010c19b1abc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b33f135fd32ed8c07f1df27f2ed2da1af47e3ea9520189f08436cf26c3513300", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4b3912fcace2e318aba5b8a56c0700f3f5cf3005a427732a3cde62a2e9f61f3b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "75d578525b47cc1984eac90a83d97646b7223a2e1d5b241fedb6945ed3bafec1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b34cbd5a38c09891c450ef8efd873b5edbdc0a69ca3e9d5e59da1e7b8b7c35b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f758d90398932a0fb893f56c99a0970b8963622710618b5bde1614b30e35c71a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "19a4fd2ebc31c4ddbf8df49c20cb45deedfb9918e76b4c8f3d73b2859c353beb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80c8652187f91adf99c29ee87b76151cbc675893daffb44225700a0f6023c732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "720521030ed6596c8c901aab05e83cad8eeb63a912740b90c8589d7ccf5a4d31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f09810569751d1889a56e15348692a5c9940fd594f28c48e371d21b243efd5ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "054ad21644f0e3ff3d6ac7d0a65a62a96c3dd42748196b4ac0a1fa4b15c48080", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "04c4e8cb5fa0ceb4d2038e0896160080ed08d5cc482b07e6cb25b861a83984e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d4631c461a750ef27cd4e325dd10818c5665b395951c75d6d86328a878659a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bca5b1553df89212f42bcdfe2ba0d54f914f10f915cb2d39f5474bbdcee0b47", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c14795354a8e98d8101bbd7376945ccaeca83fd575c0e982854e9e3d994c7021", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1c7d396166040be2e95cb0186aab14e747cfde1f037fe1668cfb5f8a678a59f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "be3d2b93818c4b52b23c429086ca4748df43a7784828432ce0b7453f1c60e05b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0765e61a71b81fb5d4e1e5abdfa0ed1905e6d6b3197e941a1324a09fe656076a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40144": { @@ -346297,7 +376134,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40144", "family_id": "terrain-40135-40144", "job_id": "terrain-40135-40144", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -346313,6 +376150,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/candidate.json", "sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "67f71ee3ec6e9030e2bb270122999542ac4f159fd8323229c73f9095472db4d7", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "556a32bf29ebf9ee172059ea0f22d8f462e51ab53668ef1783d956a4a98a5ac2", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.605315+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40135-40144/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40138 standalone v2 preserves its two principal stones and tiny lower-right pebble without the previously rejected foreign fissure. 4013e/4013f retain their upper/lower branch fan; 40143 has the source single tapered vertical fissure; 40144 retains descending diagonal plus short left vertical branch.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 ae25353c16e8b505b9825bbb95946c39443aed3ec07274c4af7ff08c9ff42c61", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40135", + "40136", + "40137", + "40138" + ], + "sha256": "0d2794e4d1fd5391cec77fc86aaee31352b715b8fbdb5e64f4dc04ca9b02960e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40139", + "4013a", + "4013b", + "4013c" + ], + "sha256": "e6b7707870477658cc3dfa49602a7fd3dfd814a7fb41b3c8ffd7921d6aed0fc3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4013d", + "4013e", + "4013f", + "40140" + ], + "sha256": "dc651cb770ee3076c2fa3641e5c2606f7e6e1f3078d0b1a66d52e094a2b42e02", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40141", + "40142", + "40143", + "40144" + ], + "sha256": "c85527d989aa2afe12dc3925b61dccf8c5c68b58c184afdba60794c86f23055f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40135-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "004c7ced4542320fc143bab031ac1e23c82ec35a376a4a0ce7d5f8d9766f06fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "163cc5d28931f94e78a13a266754a356a14738d4ffbd0244dd60e7e66ef1ed1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7ff58b355e237f35c3b0117f786eb0c335f438874d7e4cd56600056ad0d2d7f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b4e67e4440e5bbf7d3a96e108c5e7e7b0a4fd9e66b288a3c7eff04164e61121", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40135-original.ppm", + "sha256": "323f994d88bdfc85b1fd5f0da8d016528d177f5f4ae161b8f4fd1d9c31e8f8cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40135-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6c90e04d053bc6503125178ea88149b0e70a201f7bbfaa74eba8514bae2c2294", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d77fd92e32e74f7e4bc758027018ffff86999cfe150ac295100bb5ddb5f31be9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "520b1a8d3da97ffee31cbf4cbda9c2201d705c38ff4e2b9f59c7b56b89bf4873", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7bf1a66c309e5e27f78ebd33a77741415e5dc07f17b7a66add9018a8a0168bb6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40136-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9bcf27e9fb33248fbfbde9b3a3dbd43531c7d41856691dea8687cb1bedefc7df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40136-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "881bac50fe4cb6b4cfdf6221cd6ae43c1c203898ab3b0976ae57aa98061d00a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afb7b208c7864b7dd9d543ff10a3807efadda0bb2fedfc7cb4de59fbc93e6ba0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3732affb156ce43a9324e9305eafe9eeac67ed1250e7dcaac80141da66930bb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b504983b79b46f8fb04dfb1ae53818761032fa018dc630d47dc0723ad3015eb4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40137-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52824c1443b6fa23d968a974df44c8402ed07d4f68a1fe0082358b7bb99775bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40137-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a200bb1c9002fa1851c525bc49cf73166b939ce219bd1110f0cdfdb091bb1ba4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "88311946e1716061b3f5844b3c2c71c968455ef70f55eef0f5432e4c10c2c7e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d5c94f60faca30e467836e1ec28685691d05f52f914c53ae1dbc1ac7fbbb39fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ad7c96a8bfd9e345a049fc56a2f7006de8a39b650b1141c515e52e6bc4c6d732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40138-original.ppm", + "sha256": "95f7ee0bb4adecf2b09fb558ec65fa7df02cddf5f4980a5d2f22b0fe705e1d4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40138-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f325abbbc67fbc6bbf965964203593b72b257bf54c953aa8c243dc9bbf6ee99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a0fb8d5371cccf257f7eb72bae410a48cb5e2e55448904b306258df6736d88a7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b096d1063c77318135dca09ddfc97312c867a2b62e346f78ede9229202c57d54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "bfab1e8711551941d5a511ea2f60fdbb6fad28eb3da79e1f553c92100f0d076e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40139-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af6d624cf089b69f2945b3e4b7131e7904ad8c2ab4570376dbbc915460eaed63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40139-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "42114d7ec64dce9ce46638513723a9ca264c98a3dcb4bf0d4b75cf0f01c85b33", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf5ae14df8e29dedab8c2594c80944c7d214249ac01869b3868858856d6676cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8a32d0f3d3661a27822e10b17449df3fc97c79a5a6e11a62bca45d5fab3056e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f0080331f0ba1421094a37611b75ef5637363e8c89242e553650de1ec31ebb2a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a5be54aa0de23afda041722ff131a34bf7915b663e805100edcbae670efcdfd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2c198b97d03a429ba59e2d44176d342ee2cb73f4900f446d71eec2ab2f9f0155", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d084ac2dc513a9d936e1f6a7ce10f3c0885182d82c30125477303dd9a617c9a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "46ba7b5aab5dd93f2b91f9cf2c05211a6eff53993a4033c3e7eb5cf428a59ab0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "64845979129dd4cf1d791595e235965c70e0c520dfb21fa230207d86aa8d8d59", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c87ff97d470deccfe7f98ea5661833cb545080cdcf6ec4089b1a39bc7e80fef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "83f01f7167a18a1cbf14fe3f8c59c58a3ee3c215f7f4aff3e3b1830312abe884", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "26b3da57a60d2835a2d54f90bc221ce5aa12fe99681b916e6fea6862576e87c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b0071f55e5f0815c122b8aecaa11c124009135c797c1172b7ae9ef7b603d526a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7870a9ea2e2dd21bc0a990213366b71c4a1b6cc8bb48b073689c03fa8fa94349", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4cd396ea6f806e35904551d5a1c15b57f5f8f860ed6580bb398cfa8e554591c0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f90187bd20fda2ebe115eb40fd3b3f0249e6716e9b817960e729b5952c243d7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7d2d8d558481d69e9a990435f11576c28cb14950496351cc4bdf6df21a3835ae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "66ff0d1cca01b9e976dba42894d0ab81f3a44e4ec0779c8b43f96ee35137fc2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0274a70ab8bf872e0d54b7870e2770ddf9bedf5145c4e65d5662e474d3699b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1494db86c30901877b193e7089aac4bd67475735b32cbccdde8f816407c95966", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91c584fa7efdca2f0e92c2fb79a82e9e2b53e8801d6f37ebdb0d6852d0717d57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21b77e99354230542cbe8bc5fe27851b5403e3898f4f2475b206d61bf0a1c89c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1b6f9e2f110ff7ad0a50a6db64479a837dd6757916bc90fc5bad42ccb4b72e99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "171d40fb656c1f69ae4e2e876d67dfeed1760cbfbdb7c40d28dd54f134886e65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "39641bdce92c245bfd56b3d02478f5c7f15f73ebaf9a0b878dd78bef2377e9cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bc3845c189111a7c4f59f748b584d3b654770c2461ef0ea40d626e6ed765470f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2eb33e9db08bfaba168470e598ab5922032422edc05641739469b7452fe5d867", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b3765358445d6015f17f8bb2b12d4b03d0d2232c5048161a81c28ea26dd62bc1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4deafeeb09ce2cf146b6efbaa7682f35da2c32c31877a70fffdbadfcf39466e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4013f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e4a93c5ed6e33642c0dbe6efc5f15b66e72283767528b5e90c8cb0651b84437d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/4013f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ced9c9e73ebb4f47a73c748e98741d6cdbca7841849b7445df4a538d35ef359b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3fd3fcf1d6e6315e905c8a4b629655c4157062a3a4213036efa994eaf94236cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b216c2a1968322da29a2d58f4b932c361881c601e7cc81fba106a13153eae743", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "65582a4515c94a88105685b917fa7f882518df98b18679aa014e3ec85d91b856", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40140-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8fa2d312960c480b2f1a266a02021b024eb749181b19e1b715ce8e768a42775c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40140-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0906f5b6044adfa4066460b1c0713fb14a5d5a91dd183f5293492c277bd7224d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ad6be231b3a1b74f9cefb78b24c2ea14f0fb756651270ac7809c525d674aa05a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4fffdf7afa76e0e5bb9e8593eb971047d7750fcec82a092de3e010c19b1abc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b33f135fd32ed8c07f1df27f2ed2da1af47e3ea9520189f08436cf26c3513300", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40141-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4b3912fcace2e318aba5b8a56c0700f3f5cf3005a427732a3cde62a2e9f61f3b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40141-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "75d578525b47cc1984eac90a83d97646b7223a2e1d5b241fedb6945ed3bafec1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b34cbd5a38c09891c450ef8efd873b5edbdc0a69ca3e9d5e59da1e7b8b7c35b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f758d90398932a0fb893f56c99a0970b8963622710618b5bde1614b30e35c71a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "19a4fd2ebc31c4ddbf8df49c20cb45deedfb9918e76b4c8f3d73b2859c353beb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40142-original.ppm", + "sha256": "80c8652187f91adf99c29ee87b76151cbc675893daffb44225700a0f6023c732", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40142-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "720521030ed6596c8c901aab05e83cad8eeb63a912740b90c8589d7ccf5a4d31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f09810569751d1889a56e15348692a5c9940fd594f28c48e371d21b243efd5ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "054ad21644f0e3ff3d6ac7d0a65a62a96c3dd42748196b4ac0a1fa4b15c48080", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "04c4e8cb5fa0ceb4d2038e0896160080ed08d5cc482b07e6cb25b861a83984e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40143-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8d4631c461a750ef27cd4e325dd10818c5665b395951c75d6d86328a878659a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40143-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9bca5b1553df89212f42bcdfe2ba0d54f914f10f915cb2d39f5474bbdcee0b47", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c14795354a8e98d8101bbd7376945ccaeca83fd575c0e982854e9e3d994c7021", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1c7d396166040be2e95cb0186aab14e747cfde1f037fe1668cfb5f8a678a59f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "be3d2b93818c4b52b23c429086ca4748df43a7784828432ce0b7453f1c60e05b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40144-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0765e61a71b81fb5d4e1e5abdfa0ed1905e6d6b3197e941a1324a09fe656076a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40135-40144/runtime/40144-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40145": { @@ -346334,7 +376641,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40145", "family_id": "terrain-40145-40154", "job_id": "terrain-40145-40154", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -346350,6 +376657,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/candidate.json", "sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2344fd05aa5b7c66672308e99c535e5705923b8190304488208a0861cb927f2b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.766043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40145 retains its lower-left hollow cluster; 40146 retains the shallow central circular hollow; 40147 retains its two aligned depressions. Gallery-only40150/40151 retain occupied dark upper fissure backing. Native4014c/4014d/4014e/40153/40154 keep principal branching and star-junction placements.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 bb185aa389fce46555aea78a6a1683227216ecf2a5a8d635cc65f49b2a741eb1", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40145", + "40146", + "40147", + "40148" + ], + "sha256": "2118ba900c0c0e2423a8e70d6941c91a9f69f3f8fcbf9a1af901c40303c67bd7", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40149", + "4014a", + "4014b", + "4014c" + ], + "sha256": "0a5cbd63e0de911fc18a7edeaa007217dcfd9788adaede2c9d6c74f45364c145", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4014d", + "4014e", + "4014f", + "40150" + ], + "sha256": "2e7f0573e1d6ee9560ee01a5c3282fdd31c78192b96af3458b379c7467ccaced", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40151", + "40152", + "40153", + "40154" + ], + "sha256": "0b1b4ab14f02637594f12b6cc247190baa3994124dd0794558be10fd2d1bceba", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40145-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d3d70f233a01d7abd4f99f5785511bcb31dac038bed5413cabc5919cab4c3023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "712038c91c2f71c8ea7beb167c5d8f2c2287c84297778413a021b2041eae9089", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c8ed44987088709d60ea4601841a6fe03e0aee2836f0fe1271903777b35ac415", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3df2186222e743dbdf01202d15df6e757237e5286cab713aaa93204203bc757", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ff6a432d41188eb75be732b616e4cbac8c9351065cce8b23ebff926d09568d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2e2fd14c542ca7a499cdd111cb871297b91804b86caaad952806b0810ab0232f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6b9a0189815c49a13f07b5b2c9d2756c8819b5cf1130be813a40817bfd71c8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "183ccdaf00c2faa210d66cca9c0d55f20c106f8d1179d577a01d16b82c4fdf0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f7c11063e6718ea9664dac1c0a0dac3cdb091d1e67475a7b56eae5ebd3171aae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3ad735c66ba344d083c78394626f3093050b01fe339c8fcfce9184eca6b0904b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47cf688f58791501a4d9c72de1aae6c70fa0748434582dcaff023a062f07deb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "34344c20d4c890c4ed0e322140821675c54d72eb0c8f77a219373515340cb89b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2337cd2cb51b1bf08f1886a28b835d0efab680db6d70c85c5abd354454f86efd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f5a698a47610e48657fbf5f952737fb44f0c7bd30c3b51ed0150803d136cc7a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0ef70b37f1735ea91dc5b13aee07dbeab6f81f1928a9195be975055912986fbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37eeacd053883ac70308e1b076e84d75b70763e875a9941c29177c807cb0b378", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b0176ba6d6c12400f8c73cdb798130c06b93f672f70e0d73c7d631a0ead48ab4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "453ba7b0658ca37054dbef42d5ad8afe45b105fe2b15a7638bac7e4bbed7b89e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5b675158947fe902f96d22baa3b11bd401a695c6c3428034f4f190fdb03b872a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30f5fd28184fac4a0b21157bfc4ae306c73362822cc28f9ced29953ef9c2d02e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5751a4627be0ea4c5d4a635b401018e26e263c48a2dd9b28276bdb8281ac884b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "715c8d864841d54f0c39d895c19755d74da18d5857aa7d0862209c0d62b938bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6fee49860d4b68f0dcc2b03bc7703673aa90efc32aee96bc26d9b45fecd04eb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "35ee74f2d64f4bf2c295e9e75c87639165870593fba7f8a1463ed89d7b210c9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3edc9040b90398736e5a78a76d7c1952a08368305b4468444c75449806d00c9d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b7e34eac197540f8e3271bcdf73c137d0e9a0f8c8d1d9df41a8d68eb70d79646", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e86404d4d0bf397ad60e791edb18757e1659a0b188ba183e204317af46233710", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "607c10ed2b7ff31161c81db47927047fc4983c42c42135f7d6334dc852e8c208", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e638432b60f1eca0d66ee07b4f96c33e4e7d84e4c25c3331282173661598483", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "96c61d79de108b033f65d19d6c9599cb3cf191aafe50bbd5d0300efa3d690490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b4f67a2e1973d62a0e7ccd26295b0b973b776cecfc5149498e6a689eea7a690e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7346d5f88722c03895376cbc42f5961581e5c01dff245416e8661730bfc96a6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ff9e1ea59e6cdf8be1d2b00892fec9f7c69e1d49f7390d7c0e1be4f8008c29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36c37ee3a3539a991f457b0936fcb50d7ec2404c049e4eea9f79b52095c6424", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e186b4dc36b0c9ad581d57924014764f3abbe04d15def19024090213fe857d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0c452dca8986320b8a6fe724a9cf310f856dbfe84596f83e5508df8947af2a25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0fcc271ecc1b71ad4219976b58a976537849c70c584c485a2eb1298eb8fcecd6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7942f0600eb6386e8928fd6f4850910cfad42a983592ea20dc08aeff66876f4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "df4296686502f7cbee4de63946c5e7c130a1e9f38119b71bdb115c8096754f19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e9920c7eabf49a704c88367e5c30d3774bcb810019725189e307e7a3eee2b30c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9858fac0ccbe5f431c872256ea80eeceaac1796474443d86448adc9fdc668594", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "30e567de236a8d621adc4f8034447dfde50869ed6e80cc1444385a6790700905", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c58e51280ad84e332d145973d8c45630480c90d3d4803a1c855f89bbe91f1851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b95aa16bb1913d6689693d3861e833c986f94073176d470fea4e0f26049e4241", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e0d9c3855b0f1ddc258a1648ac62539f5bbd4f1a78ded6a032b1ba3bc5960fc8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "14c36f40ee716610c6a4408fd209cf8454ce57ae4fc097d9c7431b4a74e402b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a871534279e983547fcbdbfe789349d034abe113b41583a46a503f44e7996b4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf87cf24e0a27e5ab7fe118f654bdc2980fa5ae25032673d569dda9cf4705ea3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eacd52d9fc804f1c58108655cc294a9b7fdcbb2f992b12405fc1394ce27c4c09", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8e16e3e7a3d814d85d0c0e7b4b10468bf8f7bdf0316b36ec383a1104919e22c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d944d4863d7a8cb82695f4601d5ab2eb9afdf91738e7f41738198574b1cdeb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "32f046e795625f4021213a3aa5ccb940526bb31e6128c16c1ac0428f94e97dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "37b1f7657f226c5f62ee5acb752c470a27c98ccd688a99403eca51696bb764ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b734e84320c0b0d18b6f7c005626c457d2cc593784846c584a71d5f011070a39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa64abc2903dbf3f90ae4e8b2e41dee899943e1d254498a579970f5f23262355", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "872d16ded97babfc182fe0c0e495ed1708ee87134ef8d3110e605c960b18a70f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6183848a6b396e8d351368bde6fc0f3be7125ac080ae4b9519eec1d95b6f8adb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d94ecafbd7cc7909cda32fd1853832bc78e0f2f7dd54aeceafb02c34936f9b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e3aa51b24375334a6b28d727af48188e5c0daa706d55850431b92c2cf07baaf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-original.ppm", + "sha256": "576dd05985e677f2268476886d87ba016fcac4927169bed5b39365b771c5bde3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36a73df1a2bd68ca78a189af9a9fb17355a9cadcb65783e7df2cfefa529081b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c241429b850a5d20818c9dd78184696c1631c991f04429ecc4fdb9a92c3ca46b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d10d52afcc7c547b2eaab1eac2cc3be291ddc89c5c5d518dcc13b66416cb3976", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2c942d9c19cb1384d6fd34f3083e8051413b11aa71b09bba5ace9f81c965c3f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108b3c22271faa45aa5c43859198c22fbdb083c24c18a80288061283bae9d1a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "be701e99bc926803ffbab6595ef1ec66c9dc451f2f47d1017061c9f8462ee0f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf6a1e4712a233400c5687a34987ea8332704958440620223c07577082e4edfc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "162a24b500a597dadb139e01557548c8f5c81d30d5e4766fa467dc1a2f33b8d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13d6aed360f87778296c7ac376e28812b36b45ae79ca29c1e1f53c3907fb4544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-original.ppm", + "sha256": "50af887f191e4dd9150559986f04f668b982b10514a2100a1a99242123f5708c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6cbb570bba40b8dc55886984d4b8cd85e9f2bf3e655289e102b5745face5b16d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "134d706f1bdbab4ff33b723d052a85fd2517e39046f8e6340e3498adddaf91f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ab88687e43871ab0f5da01ae4b1405712ca2e05c975d0688bc4f8826c627fdd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a09bf32551e65e375f9c0882972e6ca620cc98cb9adb02b59f5249ce16df42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75e07f7a0716808fc84c6d10e91d2877fc505235cd9178517a49adae645aee5d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db19dd301625261e0e2236b0036c624ca1b019bb3949f6fb5acbf7d5df325be4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "09b5cdd83bcb56dde10e91697a84725dcc5751fca835cb4c3332ab7e27d1a572", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "55da754def7e5bc52d0b759d776376b5b318a6ee22d7592c1ed305e98911c9d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4cf8d944587c4d4f12134bcf94d11158ce37254b26e2155cd7e1368f753c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f256b1ae087ecd3a614d6240937d33a8b980e2c68faf30730aa5f41b0d57f513", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40146": { @@ -346371,7 +377148,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40146", "family_id": "terrain-40145-40154", "job_id": "terrain-40145-40154", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -346387,6 +377164,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/candidate.json", "sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2344fd05aa5b7c66672308e99c535e5705923b8190304488208a0861cb927f2b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.766043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40145 retains its lower-left hollow cluster; 40146 retains the shallow central circular hollow; 40147 retains its two aligned depressions. Gallery-only40150/40151 retain occupied dark upper fissure backing. Native4014c/4014d/4014e/40153/40154 keep principal branching and star-junction placements.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 bb185aa389fce46555aea78a6a1683227216ecf2a5a8d635cc65f49b2a741eb1", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40145", + "40146", + "40147", + "40148" + ], + "sha256": "2118ba900c0c0e2423a8e70d6941c91a9f69f3f8fcbf9a1af901c40303c67bd7", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40149", + "4014a", + "4014b", + "4014c" + ], + "sha256": "0a5cbd63e0de911fc18a7edeaa007217dcfd9788adaede2c9d6c74f45364c145", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4014d", + "4014e", + "4014f", + "40150" + ], + "sha256": "2e7f0573e1d6ee9560ee01a5c3282fdd31c78192b96af3458b379c7467ccaced", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40151", + "40152", + "40153", + "40154" + ], + "sha256": "0b1b4ab14f02637594f12b6cc247190baa3994124dd0794558be10fd2d1bceba", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40145-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d3d70f233a01d7abd4f99f5785511bcb31dac038bed5413cabc5919cab4c3023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "712038c91c2f71c8ea7beb167c5d8f2c2287c84297778413a021b2041eae9089", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c8ed44987088709d60ea4601841a6fe03e0aee2836f0fe1271903777b35ac415", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3df2186222e743dbdf01202d15df6e757237e5286cab713aaa93204203bc757", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ff6a432d41188eb75be732b616e4cbac8c9351065cce8b23ebff926d09568d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2e2fd14c542ca7a499cdd111cb871297b91804b86caaad952806b0810ab0232f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6b9a0189815c49a13f07b5b2c9d2756c8819b5cf1130be813a40817bfd71c8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "183ccdaf00c2faa210d66cca9c0d55f20c106f8d1179d577a01d16b82c4fdf0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f7c11063e6718ea9664dac1c0a0dac3cdb091d1e67475a7b56eae5ebd3171aae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3ad735c66ba344d083c78394626f3093050b01fe339c8fcfce9184eca6b0904b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47cf688f58791501a4d9c72de1aae6c70fa0748434582dcaff023a062f07deb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "34344c20d4c890c4ed0e322140821675c54d72eb0c8f77a219373515340cb89b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2337cd2cb51b1bf08f1886a28b835d0efab680db6d70c85c5abd354454f86efd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f5a698a47610e48657fbf5f952737fb44f0c7bd30c3b51ed0150803d136cc7a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0ef70b37f1735ea91dc5b13aee07dbeab6f81f1928a9195be975055912986fbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37eeacd053883ac70308e1b076e84d75b70763e875a9941c29177c807cb0b378", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b0176ba6d6c12400f8c73cdb798130c06b93f672f70e0d73c7d631a0ead48ab4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "453ba7b0658ca37054dbef42d5ad8afe45b105fe2b15a7638bac7e4bbed7b89e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5b675158947fe902f96d22baa3b11bd401a695c6c3428034f4f190fdb03b872a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30f5fd28184fac4a0b21157bfc4ae306c73362822cc28f9ced29953ef9c2d02e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5751a4627be0ea4c5d4a635b401018e26e263c48a2dd9b28276bdb8281ac884b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "715c8d864841d54f0c39d895c19755d74da18d5857aa7d0862209c0d62b938bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6fee49860d4b68f0dcc2b03bc7703673aa90efc32aee96bc26d9b45fecd04eb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "35ee74f2d64f4bf2c295e9e75c87639165870593fba7f8a1463ed89d7b210c9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3edc9040b90398736e5a78a76d7c1952a08368305b4468444c75449806d00c9d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b7e34eac197540f8e3271bcdf73c137d0e9a0f8c8d1d9df41a8d68eb70d79646", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e86404d4d0bf397ad60e791edb18757e1659a0b188ba183e204317af46233710", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "607c10ed2b7ff31161c81db47927047fc4983c42c42135f7d6334dc852e8c208", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e638432b60f1eca0d66ee07b4f96c33e4e7d84e4c25c3331282173661598483", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "96c61d79de108b033f65d19d6c9599cb3cf191aafe50bbd5d0300efa3d690490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b4f67a2e1973d62a0e7ccd26295b0b973b776cecfc5149498e6a689eea7a690e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7346d5f88722c03895376cbc42f5961581e5c01dff245416e8661730bfc96a6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ff9e1ea59e6cdf8be1d2b00892fec9f7c69e1d49f7390d7c0e1be4f8008c29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36c37ee3a3539a991f457b0936fcb50d7ec2404c049e4eea9f79b52095c6424", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e186b4dc36b0c9ad581d57924014764f3abbe04d15def19024090213fe857d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0c452dca8986320b8a6fe724a9cf310f856dbfe84596f83e5508df8947af2a25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0fcc271ecc1b71ad4219976b58a976537849c70c584c485a2eb1298eb8fcecd6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7942f0600eb6386e8928fd6f4850910cfad42a983592ea20dc08aeff66876f4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "df4296686502f7cbee4de63946c5e7c130a1e9f38119b71bdb115c8096754f19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e9920c7eabf49a704c88367e5c30d3774bcb810019725189e307e7a3eee2b30c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9858fac0ccbe5f431c872256ea80eeceaac1796474443d86448adc9fdc668594", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "30e567de236a8d621adc4f8034447dfde50869ed6e80cc1444385a6790700905", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c58e51280ad84e332d145973d8c45630480c90d3d4803a1c855f89bbe91f1851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b95aa16bb1913d6689693d3861e833c986f94073176d470fea4e0f26049e4241", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e0d9c3855b0f1ddc258a1648ac62539f5bbd4f1a78ded6a032b1ba3bc5960fc8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "14c36f40ee716610c6a4408fd209cf8454ce57ae4fc097d9c7431b4a74e402b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a871534279e983547fcbdbfe789349d034abe113b41583a46a503f44e7996b4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf87cf24e0a27e5ab7fe118f654bdc2980fa5ae25032673d569dda9cf4705ea3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eacd52d9fc804f1c58108655cc294a9b7fdcbb2f992b12405fc1394ce27c4c09", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8e16e3e7a3d814d85d0c0e7b4b10468bf8f7bdf0316b36ec383a1104919e22c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d944d4863d7a8cb82695f4601d5ab2eb9afdf91738e7f41738198574b1cdeb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "32f046e795625f4021213a3aa5ccb940526bb31e6128c16c1ac0428f94e97dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "37b1f7657f226c5f62ee5acb752c470a27c98ccd688a99403eca51696bb764ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b734e84320c0b0d18b6f7c005626c457d2cc593784846c584a71d5f011070a39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa64abc2903dbf3f90ae4e8b2e41dee899943e1d254498a579970f5f23262355", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "872d16ded97babfc182fe0c0e495ed1708ee87134ef8d3110e605c960b18a70f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6183848a6b396e8d351368bde6fc0f3be7125ac080ae4b9519eec1d95b6f8adb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d94ecafbd7cc7909cda32fd1853832bc78e0f2f7dd54aeceafb02c34936f9b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e3aa51b24375334a6b28d727af48188e5c0daa706d55850431b92c2cf07baaf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-original.ppm", + "sha256": "576dd05985e677f2268476886d87ba016fcac4927169bed5b39365b771c5bde3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36a73df1a2bd68ca78a189af9a9fb17355a9cadcb65783e7df2cfefa529081b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c241429b850a5d20818c9dd78184696c1631c991f04429ecc4fdb9a92c3ca46b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d10d52afcc7c547b2eaab1eac2cc3be291ddc89c5c5d518dcc13b66416cb3976", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2c942d9c19cb1384d6fd34f3083e8051413b11aa71b09bba5ace9f81c965c3f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108b3c22271faa45aa5c43859198c22fbdb083c24c18a80288061283bae9d1a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "be701e99bc926803ffbab6595ef1ec66c9dc451f2f47d1017061c9f8462ee0f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf6a1e4712a233400c5687a34987ea8332704958440620223c07577082e4edfc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "162a24b500a597dadb139e01557548c8f5c81d30d5e4766fa467dc1a2f33b8d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13d6aed360f87778296c7ac376e28812b36b45ae79ca29c1e1f53c3907fb4544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-original.ppm", + "sha256": "50af887f191e4dd9150559986f04f668b982b10514a2100a1a99242123f5708c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6cbb570bba40b8dc55886984d4b8cd85e9f2bf3e655289e102b5745face5b16d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "134d706f1bdbab4ff33b723d052a85fd2517e39046f8e6340e3498adddaf91f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ab88687e43871ab0f5da01ae4b1405712ca2e05c975d0688bc4f8826c627fdd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a09bf32551e65e375f9c0882972e6ca620cc98cb9adb02b59f5249ce16df42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75e07f7a0716808fc84c6d10e91d2877fc505235cd9178517a49adae645aee5d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db19dd301625261e0e2236b0036c624ca1b019bb3949f6fb5acbf7d5df325be4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "09b5cdd83bcb56dde10e91697a84725dcc5751fca835cb4c3332ab7e27d1a572", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "55da754def7e5bc52d0b759d776376b5b318a6ee22d7592c1ed305e98911c9d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4cf8d944587c4d4f12134bcf94d11158ce37254b26e2155cd7e1368f753c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f256b1ae087ecd3a614d6240937d33a8b980e2c68faf30730aa5f41b0d57f513", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40147": { @@ -346408,7 +377655,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40147", "family_id": "terrain-40145-40154", "job_id": "terrain-40145-40154", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -346424,6 +377671,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/candidate.json", "sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2344fd05aa5b7c66672308e99c535e5705923b8190304488208a0861cb927f2b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.766043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40145 retains its lower-left hollow cluster; 40146 retains the shallow central circular hollow; 40147 retains its two aligned depressions. Gallery-only40150/40151 retain occupied dark upper fissure backing. Native4014c/4014d/4014e/40153/40154 keep principal branching and star-junction placements.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 bb185aa389fce46555aea78a6a1683227216ecf2a5a8d635cc65f49b2a741eb1", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40145", + "40146", + "40147", + "40148" + ], + "sha256": "2118ba900c0c0e2423a8e70d6941c91a9f69f3f8fcbf9a1af901c40303c67bd7", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40149", + "4014a", + "4014b", + "4014c" + ], + "sha256": "0a5cbd63e0de911fc18a7edeaa007217dcfd9788adaede2c9d6c74f45364c145", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4014d", + "4014e", + "4014f", + "40150" + ], + "sha256": "2e7f0573e1d6ee9560ee01a5c3282fdd31c78192b96af3458b379c7467ccaced", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40151", + "40152", + "40153", + "40154" + ], + "sha256": "0b1b4ab14f02637594f12b6cc247190baa3994124dd0794558be10fd2d1bceba", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40145-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d3d70f233a01d7abd4f99f5785511bcb31dac038bed5413cabc5919cab4c3023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "712038c91c2f71c8ea7beb167c5d8f2c2287c84297778413a021b2041eae9089", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c8ed44987088709d60ea4601841a6fe03e0aee2836f0fe1271903777b35ac415", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3df2186222e743dbdf01202d15df6e757237e5286cab713aaa93204203bc757", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ff6a432d41188eb75be732b616e4cbac8c9351065cce8b23ebff926d09568d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2e2fd14c542ca7a499cdd111cb871297b91804b86caaad952806b0810ab0232f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6b9a0189815c49a13f07b5b2c9d2756c8819b5cf1130be813a40817bfd71c8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "183ccdaf00c2faa210d66cca9c0d55f20c106f8d1179d577a01d16b82c4fdf0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f7c11063e6718ea9664dac1c0a0dac3cdb091d1e67475a7b56eae5ebd3171aae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3ad735c66ba344d083c78394626f3093050b01fe339c8fcfce9184eca6b0904b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47cf688f58791501a4d9c72de1aae6c70fa0748434582dcaff023a062f07deb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "34344c20d4c890c4ed0e322140821675c54d72eb0c8f77a219373515340cb89b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2337cd2cb51b1bf08f1886a28b835d0efab680db6d70c85c5abd354454f86efd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f5a698a47610e48657fbf5f952737fb44f0c7bd30c3b51ed0150803d136cc7a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0ef70b37f1735ea91dc5b13aee07dbeab6f81f1928a9195be975055912986fbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37eeacd053883ac70308e1b076e84d75b70763e875a9941c29177c807cb0b378", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b0176ba6d6c12400f8c73cdb798130c06b93f672f70e0d73c7d631a0ead48ab4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "453ba7b0658ca37054dbef42d5ad8afe45b105fe2b15a7638bac7e4bbed7b89e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5b675158947fe902f96d22baa3b11bd401a695c6c3428034f4f190fdb03b872a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30f5fd28184fac4a0b21157bfc4ae306c73362822cc28f9ced29953ef9c2d02e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5751a4627be0ea4c5d4a635b401018e26e263c48a2dd9b28276bdb8281ac884b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "715c8d864841d54f0c39d895c19755d74da18d5857aa7d0862209c0d62b938bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6fee49860d4b68f0dcc2b03bc7703673aa90efc32aee96bc26d9b45fecd04eb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "35ee74f2d64f4bf2c295e9e75c87639165870593fba7f8a1463ed89d7b210c9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3edc9040b90398736e5a78a76d7c1952a08368305b4468444c75449806d00c9d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b7e34eac197540f8e3271bcdf73c137d0e9a0f8c8d1d9df41a8d68eb70d79646", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e86404d4d0bf397ad60e791edb18757e1659a0b188ba183e204317af46233710", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "607c10ed2b7ff31161c81db47927047fc4983c42c42135f7d6334dc852e8c208", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e638432b60f1eca0d66ee07b4f96c33e4e7d84e4c25c3331282173661598483", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "96c61d79de108b033f65d19d6c9599cb3cf191aafe50bbd5d0300efa3d690490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b4f67a2e1973d62a0e7ccd26295b0b973b776cecfc5149498e6a689eea7a690e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7346d5f88722c03895376cbc42f5961581e5c01dff245416e8661730bfc96a6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ff9e1ea59e6cdf8be1d2b00892fec9f7c69e1d49f7390d7c0e1be4f8008c29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36c37ee3a3539a991f457b0936fcb50d7ec2404c049e4eea9f79b52095c6424", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e186b4dc36b0c9ad581d57924014764f3abbe04d15def19024090213fe857d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0c452dca8986320b8a6fe724a9cf310f856dbfe84596f83e5508df8947af2a25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0fcc271ecc1b71ad4219976b58a976537849c70c584c485a2eb1298eb8fcecd6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7942f0600eb6386e8928fd6f4850910cfad42a983592ea20dc08aeff66876f4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "df4296686502f7cbee4de63946c5e7c130a1e9f38119b71bdb115c8096754f19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e9920c7eabf49a704c88367e5c30d3774bcb810019725189e307e7a3eee2b30c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9858fac0ccbe5f431c872256ea80eeceaac1796474443d86448adc9fdc668594", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "30e567de236a8d621adc4f8034447dfde50869ed6e80cc1444385a6790700905", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c58e51280ad84e332d145973d8c45630480c90d3d4803a1c855f89bbe91f1851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b95aa16bb1913d6689693d3861e833c986f94073176d470fea4e0f26049e4241", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e0d9c3855b0f1ddc258a1648ac62539f5bbd4f1a78ded6a032b1ba3bc5960fc8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "14c36f40ee716610c6a4408fd209cf8454ce57ae4fc097d9c7431b4a74e402b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a871534279e983547fcbdbfe789349d034abe113b41583a46a503f44e7996b4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf87cf24e0a27e5ab7fe118f654bdc2980fa5ae25032673d569dda9cf4705ea3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eacd52d9fc804f1c58108655cc294a9b7fdcbb2f992b12405fc1394ce27c4c09", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8e16e3e7a3d814d85d0c0e7b4b10468bf8f7bdf0316b36ec383a1104919e22c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d944d4863d7a8cb82695f4601d5ab2eb9afdf91738e7f41738198574b1cdeb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "32f046e795625f4021213a3aa5ccb940526bb31e6128c16c1ac0428f94e97dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "37b1f7657f226c5f62ee5acb752c470a27c98ccd688a99403eca51696bb764ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b734e84320c0b0d18b6f7c005626c457d2cc593784846c584a71d5f011070a39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa64abc2903dbf3f90ae4e8b2e41dee899943e1d254498a579970f5f23262355", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "872d16ded97babfc182fe0c0e495ed1708ee87134ef8d3110e605c960b18a70f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6183848a6b396e8d351368bde6fc0f3be7125ac080ae4b9519eec1d95b6f8adb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d94ecafbd7cc7909cda32fd1853832bc78e0f2f7dd54aeceafb02c34936f9b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e3aa51b24375334a6b28d727af48188e5c0daa706d55850431b92c2cf07baaf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-original.ppm", + "sha256": "576dd05985e677f2268476886d87ba016fcac4927169bed5b39365b771c5bde3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36a73df1a2bd68ca78a189af9a9fb17355a9cadcb65783e7df2cfefa529081b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c241429b850a5d20818c9dd78184696c1631c991f04429ecc4fdb9a92c3ca46b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d10d52afcc7c547b2eaab1eac2cc3be291ddc89c5c5d518dcc13b66416cb3976", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2c942d9c19cb1384d6fd34f3083e8051413b11aa71b09bba5ace9f81c965c3f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108b3c22271faa45aa5c43859198c22fbdb083c24c18a80288061283bae9d1a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "be701e99bc926803ffbab6595ef1ec66c9dc451f2f47d1017061c9f8462ee0f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf6a1e4712a233400c5687a34987ea8332704958440620223c07577082e4edfc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "162a24b500a597dadb139e01557548c8f5c81d30d5e4766fa467dc1a2f33b8d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13d6aed360f87778296c7ac376e28812b36b45ae79ca29c1e1f53c3907fb4544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-original.ppm", + "sha256": "50af887f191e4dd9150559986f04f668b982b10514a2100a1a99242123f5708c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6cbb570bba40b8dc55886984d4b8cd85e9f2bf3e655289e102b5745face5b16d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "134d706f1bdbab4ff33b723d052a85fd2517e39046f8e6340e3498adddaf91f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ab88687e43871ab0f5da01ae4b1405712ca2e05c975d0688bc4f8826c627fdd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a09bf32551e65e375f9c0882972e6ca620cc98cb9adb02b59f5249ce16df42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75e07f7a0716808fc84c6d10e91d2877fc505235cd9178517a49adae645aee5d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db19dd301625261e0e2236b0036c624ca1b019bb3949f6fb5acbf7d5df325be4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "09b5cdd83bcb56dde10e91697a84725dcc5751fca835cb4c3332ab7e27d1a572", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "55da754def7e5bc52d0b759d776376b5b318a6ee22d7592c1ed305e98911c9d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4cf8d944587c4d4f12134bcf94d11158ce37254b26e2155cd7e1368f753c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f256b1ae087ecd3a614d6240937d33a8b980e2c68faf30730aa5f41b0d57f513", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40148": { @@ -346445,7 +378162,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40148", "family_id": "terrain-40145-40154", "job_id": "terrain-40145-40154", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -346461,6 +378178,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/candidate.json", "sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2344fd05aa5b7c66672308e99c535e5705923b8190304488208a0861cb927f2b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.766043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40145 retains its lower-left hollow cluster; 40146 retains the shallow central circular hollow; 40147 retains its two aligned depressions. Gallery-only40150/40151 retain occupied dark upper fissure backing. Native4014c/4014d/4014e/40153/40154 keep principal branching and star-junction placements.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 bb185aa389fce46555aea78a6a1683227216ecf2a5a8d635cc65f49b2a741eb1", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40145", + "40146", + "40147", + "40148" + ], + "sha256": "2118ba900c0c0e2423a8e70d6941c91a9f69f3f8fcbf9a1af901c40303c67bd7", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40149", + "4014a", + "4014b", + "4014c" + ], + "sha256": "0a5cbd63e0de911fc18a7edeaa007217dcfd9788adaede2c9d6c74f45364c145", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4014d", + "4014e", + "4014f", + "40150" + ], + "sha256": "2e7f0573e1d6ee9560ee01a5c3282fdd31c78192b96af3458b379c7467ccaced", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40151", + "40152", + "40153", + "40154" + ], + "sha256": "0b1b4ab14f02637594f12b6cc247190baa3994124dd0794558be10fd2d1bceba", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40145-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d3d70f233a01d7abd4f99f5785511bcb31dac038bed5413cabc5919cab4c3023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "712038c91c2f71c8ea7beb167c5d8f2c2287c84297778413a021b2041eae9089", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c8ed44987088709d60ea4601841a6fe03e0aee2836f0fe1271903777b35ac415", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3df2186222e743dbdf01202d15df6e757237e5286cab713aaa93204203bc757", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ff6a432d41188eb75be732b616e4cbac8c9351065cce8b23ebff926d09568d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2e2fd14c542ca7a499cdd111cb871297b91804b86caaad952806b0810ab0232f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6b9a0189815c49a13f07b5b2c9d2756c8819b5cf1130be813a40817bfd71c8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "183ccdaf00c2faa210d66cca9c0d55f20c106f8d1179d577a01d16b82c4fdf0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f7c11063e6718ea9664dac1c0a0dac3cdb091d1e67475a7b56eae5ebd3171aae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3ad735c66ba344d083c78394626f3093050b01fe339c8fcfce9184eca6b0904b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47cf688f58791501a4d9c72de1aae6c70fa0748434582dcaff023a062f07deb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "34344c20d4c890c4ed0e322140821675c54d72eb0c8f77a219373515340cb89b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2337cd2cb51b1bf08f1886a28b835d0efab680db6d70c85c5abd354454f86efd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f5a698a47610e48657fbf5f952737fb44f0c7bd30c3b51ed0150803d136cc7a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0ef70b37f1735ea91dc5b13aee07dbeab6f81f1928a9195be975055912986fbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37eeacd053883ac70308e1b076e84d75b70763e875a9941c29177c807cb0b378", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b0176ba6d6c12400f8c73cdb798130c06b93f672f70e0d73c7d631a0ead48ab4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "453ba7b0658ca37054dbef42d5ad8afe45b105fe2b15a7638bac7e4bbed7b89e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5b675158947fe902f96d22baa3b11bd401a695c6c3428034f4f190fdb03b872a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30f5fd28184fac4a0b21157bfc4ae306c73362822cc28f9ced29953ef9c2d02e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5751a4627be0ea4c5d4a635b401018e26e263c48a2dd9b28276bdb8281ac884b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "715c8d864841d54f0c39d895c19755d74da18d5857aa7d0862209c0d62b938bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6fee49860d4b68f0dcc2b03bc7703673aa90efc32aee96bc26d9b45fecd04eb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "35ee74f2d64f4bf2c295e9e75c87639165870593fba7f8a1463ed89d7b210c9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3edc9040b90398736e5a78a76d7c1952a08368305b4468444c75449806d00c9d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b7e34eac197540f8e3271bcdf73c137d0e9a0f8c8d1d9df41a8d68eb70d79646", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e86404d4d0bf397ad60e791edb18757e1659a0b188ba183e204317af46233710", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "607c10ed2b7ff31161c81db47927047fc4983c42c42135f7d6334dc852e8c208", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e638432b60f1eca0d66ee07b4f96c33e4e7d84e4c25c3331282173661598483", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "96c61d79de108b033f65d19d6c9599cb3cf191aafe50bbd5d0300efa3d690490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b4f67a2e1973d62a0e7ccd26295b0b973b776cecfc5149498e6a689eea7a690e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7346d5f88722c03895376cbc42f5961581e5c01dff245416e8661730bfc96a6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ff9e1ea59e6cdf8be1d2b00892fec9f7c69e1d49f7390d7c0e1be4f8008c29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36c37ee3a3539a991f457b0936fcb50d7ec2404c049e4eea9f79b52095c6424", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e186b4dc36b0c9ad581d57924014764f3abbe04d15def19024090213fe857d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0c452dca8986320b8a6fe724a9cf310f856dbfe84596f83e5508df8947af2a25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0fcc271ecc1b71ad4219976b58a976537849c70c584c485a2eb1298eb8fcecd6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7942f0600eb6386e8928fd6f4850910cfad42a983592ea20dc08aeff66876f4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "df4296686502f7cbee4de63946c5e7c130a1e9f38119b71bdb115c8096754f19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e9920c7eabf49a704c88367e5c30d3774bcb810019725189e307e7a3eee2b30c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9858fac0ccbe5f431c872256ea80eeceaac1796474443d86448adc9fdc668594", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "30e567de236a8d621adc4f8034447dfde50869ed6e80cc1444385a6790700905", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c58e51280ad84e332d145973d8c45630480c90d3d4803a1c855f89bbe91f1851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b95aa16bb1913d6689693d3861e833c986f94073176d470fea4e0f26049e4241", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e0d9c3855b0f1ddc258a1648ac62539f5bbd4f1a78ded6a032b1ba3bc5960fc8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "14c36f40ee716610c6a4408fd209cf8454ce57ae4fc097d9c7431b4a74e402b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a871534279e983547fcbdbfe789349d034abe113b41583a46a503f44e7996b4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf87cf24e0a27e5ab7fe118f654bdc2980fa5ae25032673d569dda9cf4705ea3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eacd52d9fc804f1c58108655cc294a9b7fdcbb2f992b12405fc1394ce27c4c09", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8e16e3e7a3d814d85d0c0e7b4b10468bf8f7bdf0316b36ec383a1104919e22c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d944d4863d7a8cb82695f4601d5ab2eb9afdf91738e7f41738198574b1cdeb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "32f046e795625f4021213a3aa5ccb940526bb31e6128c16c1ac0428f94e97dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "37b1f7657f226c5f62ee5acb752c470a27c98ccd688a99403eca51696bb764ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b734e84320c0b0d18b6f7c005626c457d2cc593784846c584a71d5f011070a39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa64abc2903dbf3f90ae4e8b2e41dee899943e1d254498a579970f5f23262355", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "872d16ded97babfc182fe0c0e495ed1708ee87134ef8d3110e605c960b18a70f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6183848a6b396e8d351368bde6fc0f3be7125ac080ae4b9519eec1d95b6f8adb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d94ecafbd7cc7909cda32fd1853832bc78e0f2f7dd54aeceafb02c34936f9b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e3aa51b24375334a6b28d727af48188e5c0daa706d55850431b92c2cf07baaf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-original.ppm", + "sha256": "576dd05985e677f2268476886d87ba016fcac4927169bed5b39365b771c5bde3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36a73df1a2bd68ca78a189af9a9fb17355a9cadcb65783e7df2cfefa529081b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c241429b850a5d20818c9dd78184696c1631c991f04429ecc4fdb9a92c3ca46b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d10d52afcc7c547b2eaab1eac2cc3be291ddc89c5c5d518dcc13b66416cb3976", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2c942d9c19cb1384d6fd34f3083e8051413b11aa71b09bba5ace9f81c965c3f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108b3c22271faa45aa5c43859198c22fbdb083c24c18a80288061283bae9d1a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "be701e99bc926803ffbab6595ef1ec66c9dc451f2f47d1017061c9f8462ee0f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf6a1e4712a233400c5687a34987ea8332704958440620223c07577082e4edfc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "162a24b500a597dadb139e01557548c8f5c81d30d5e4766fa467dc1a2f33b8d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13d6aed360f87778296c7ac376e28812b36b45ae79ca29c1e1f53c3907fb4544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-original.ppm", + "sha256": "50af887f191e4dd9150559986f04f668b982b10514a2100a1a99242123f5708c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6cbb570bba40b8dc55886984d4b8cd85e9f2bf3e655289e102b5745face5b16d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "134d706f1bdbab4ff33b723d052a85fd2517e39046f8e6340e3498adddaf91f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ab88687e43871ab0f5da01ae4b1405712ca2e05c975d0688bc4f8826c627fdd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a09bf32551e65e375f9c0882972e6ca620cc98cb9adb02b59f5249ce16df42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75e07f7a0716808fc84c6d10e91d2877fc505235cd9178517a49adae645aee5d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db19dd301625261e0e2236b0036c624ca1b019bb3949f6fb5acbf7d5df325be4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "09b5cdd83bcb56dde10e91697a84725dcc5751fca835cb4c3332ab7e27d1a572", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "55da754def7e5bc52d0b759d776376b5b318a6ee22d7592c1ed305e98911c9d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4cf8d944587c4d4f12134bcf94d11158ce37254b26e2155cd7e1368f753c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f256b1ae087ecd3a614d6240937d33a8b980e2c68faf30730aa5f41b0d57f513", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40149": { @@ -346482,7 +378669,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40149", "family_id": "terrain-40145-40154", "job_id": "terrain-40145-40154", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -346498,6 +378685,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/candidate.json", "sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2344fd05aa5b7c66672308e99c535e5705923b8190304488208a0861cb927f2b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.766043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40145 retains its lower-left hollow cluster; 40146 retains the shallow central circular hollow; 40147 retains its two aligned depressions. Gallery-only40150/40151 retain occupied dark upper fissure backing. Native4014c/4014d/4014e/40153/40154 keep principal branching and star-junction placements.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 bb185aa389fce46555aea78a6a1683227216ecf2a5a8d635cc65f49b2a741eb1", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40145", + "40146", + "40147", + "40148" + ], + "sha256": "2118ba900c0c0e2423a8e70d6941c91a9f69f3f8fcbf9a1af901c40303c67bd7", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40149", + "4014a", + "4014b", + "4014c" + ], + "sha256": "0a5cbd63e0de911fc18a7edeaa007217dcfd9788adaede2c9d6c74f45364c145", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4014d", + "4014e", + "4014f", + "40150" + ], + "sha256": "2e7f0573e1d6ee9560ee01a5c3282fdd31c78192b96af3458b379c7467ccaced", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40151", + "40152", + "40153", + "40154" + ], + "sha256": "0b1b4ab14f02637594f12b6cc247190baa3994124dd0794558be10fd2d1bceba", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40145-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d3d70f233a01d7abd4f99f5785511bcb31dac038bed5413cabc5919cab4c3023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "712038c91c2f71c8ea7beb167c5d8f2c2287c84297778413a021b2041eae9089", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c8ed44987088709d60ea4601841a6fe03e0aee2836f0fe1271903777b35ac415", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3df2186222e743dbdf01202d15df6e757237e5286cab713aaa93204203bc757", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ff6a432d41188eb75be732b616e4cbac8c9351065cce8b23ebff926d09568d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2e2fd14c542ca7a499cdd111cb871297b91804b86caaad952806b0810ab0232f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6b9a0189815c49a13f07b5b2c9d2756c8819b5cf1130be813a40817bfd71c8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "183ccdaf00c2faa210d66cca9c0d55f20c106f8d1179d577a01d16b82c4fdf0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f7c11063e6718ea9664dac1c0a0dac3cdb091d1e67475a7b56eae5ebd3171aae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3ad735c66ba344d083c78394626f3093050b01fe339c8fcfce9184eca6b0904b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47cf688f58791501a4d9c72de1aae6c70fa0748434582dcaff023a062f07deb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "34344c20d4c890c4ed0e322140821675c54d72eb0c8f77a219373515340cb89b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2337cd2cb51b1bf08f1886a28b835d0efab680db6d70c85c5abd354454f86efd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f5a698a47610e48657fbf5f952737fb44f0c7bd30c3b51ed0150803d136cc7a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0ef70b37f1735ea91dc5b13aee07dbeab6f81f1928a9195be975055912986fbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37eeacd053883ac70308e1b076e84d75b70763e875a9941c29177c807cb0b378", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b0176ba6d6c12400f8c73cdb798130c06b93f672f70e0d73c7d631a0ead48ab4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "453ba7b0658ca37054dbef42d5ad8afe45b105fe2b15a7638bac7e4bbed7b89e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5b675158947fe902f96d22baa3b11bd401a695c6c3428034f4f190fdb03b872a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30f5fd28184fac4a0b21157bfc4ae306c73362822cc28f9ced29953ef9c2d02e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5751a4627be0ea4c5d4a635b401018e26e263c48a2dd9b28276bdb8281ac884b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "715c8d864841d54f0c39d895c19755d74da18d5857aa7d0862209c0d62b938bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6fee49860d4b68f0dcc2b03bc7703673aa90efc32aee96bc26d9b45fecd04eb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "35ee74f2d64f4bf2c295e9e75c87639165870593fba7f8a1463ed89d7b210c9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3edc9040b90398736e5a78a76d7c1952a08368305b4468444c75449806d00c9d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b7e34eac197540f8e3271bcdf73c137d0e9a0f8c8d1d9df41a8d68eb70d79646", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e86404d4d0bf397ad60e791edb18757e1659a0b188ba183e204317af46233710", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "607c10ed2b7ff31161c81db47927047fc4983c42c42135f7d6334dc852e8c208", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e638432b60f1eca0d66ee07b4f96c33e4e7d84e4c25c3331282173661598483", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "96c61d79de108b033f65d19d6c9599cb3cf191aafe50bbd5d0300efa3d690490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b4f67a2e1973d62a0e7ccd26295b0b973b776cecfc5149498e6a689eea7a690e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7346d5f88722c03895376cbc42f5961581e5c01dff245416e8661730bfc96a6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ff9e1ea59e6cdf8be1d2b00892fec9f7c69e1d49f7390d7c0e1be4f8008c29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36c37ee3a3539a991f457b0936fcb50d7ec2404c049e4eea9f79b52095c6424", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e186b4dc36b0c9ad581d57924014764f3abbe04d15def19024090213fe857d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0c452dca8986320b8a6fe724a9cf310f856dbfe84596f83e5508df8947af2a25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0fcc271ecc1b71ad4219976b58a976537849c70c584c485a2eb1298eb8fcecd6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7942f0600eb6386e8928fd6f4850910cfad42a983592ea20dc08aeff66876f4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "df4296686502f7cbee4de63946c5e7c130a1e9f38119b71bdb115c8096754f19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e9920c7eabf49a704c88367e5c30d3774bcb810019725189e307e7a3eee2b30c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9858fac0ccbe5f431c872256ea80eeceaac1796474443d86448adc9fdc668594", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "30e567de236a8d621adc4f8034447dfde50869ed6e80cc1444385a6790700905", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c58e51280ad84e332d145973d8c45630480c90d3d4803a1c855f89bbe91f1851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b95aa16bb1913d6689693d3861e833c986f94073176d470fea4e0f26049e4241", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e0d9c3855b0f1ddc258a1648ac62539f5bbd4f1a78ded6a032b1ba3bc5960fc8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "14c36f40ee716610c6a4408fd209cf8454ce57ae4fc097d9c7431b4a74e402b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a871534279e983547fcbdbfe789349d034abe113b41583a46a503f44e7996b4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf87cf24e0a27e5ab7fe118f654bdc2980fa5ae25032673d569dda9cf4705ea3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eacd52d9fc804f1c58108655cc294a9b7fdcbb2f992b12405fc1394ce27c4c09", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8e16e3e7a3d814d85d0c0e7b4b10468bf8f7bdf0316b36ec383a1104919e22c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d944d4863d7a8cb82695f4601d5ab2eb9afdf91738e7f41738198574b1cdeb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "32f046e795625f4021213a3aa5ccb940526bb31e6128c16c1ac0428f94e97dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "37b1f7657f226c5f62ee5acb752c470a27c98ccd688a99403eca51696bb764ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b734e84320c0b0d18b6f7c005626c457d2cc593784846c584a71d5f011070a39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa64abc2903dbf3f90ae4e8b2e41dee899943e1d254498a579970f5f23262355", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "872d16ded97babfc182fe0c0e495ed1708ee87134ef8d3110e605c960b18a70f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6183848a6b396e8d351368bde6fc0f3be7125ac080ae4b9519eec1d95b6f8adb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d94ecafbd7cc7909cda32fd1853832bc78e0f2f7dd54aeceafb02c34936f9b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e3aa51b24375334a6b28d727af48188e5c0daa706d55850431b92c2cf07baaf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-original.ppm", + "sha256": "576dd05985e677f2268476886d87ba016fcac4927169bed5b39365b771c5bde3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36a73df1a2bd68ca78a189af9a9fb17355a9cadcb65783e7df2cfefa529081b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c241429b850a5d20818c9dd78184696c1631c991f04429ecc4fdb9a92c3ca46b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d10d52afcc7c547b2eaab1eac2cc3be291ddc89c5c5d518dcc13b66416cb3976", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2c942d9c19cb1384d6fd34f3083e8051413b11aa71b09bba5ace9f81c965c3f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108b3c22271faa45aa5c43859198c22fbdb083c24c18a80288061283bae9d1a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "be701e99bc926803ffbab6595ef1ec66c9dc451f2f47d1017061c9f8462ee0f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf6a1e4712a233400c5687a34987ea8332704958440620223c07577082e4edfc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "162a24b500a597dadb139e01557548c8f5c81d30d5e4766fa467dc1a2f33b8d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13d6aed360f87778296c7ac376e28812b36b45ae79ca29c1e1f53c3907fb4544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-original.ppm", + "sha256": "50af887f191e4dd9150559986f04f668b982b10514a2100a1a99242123f5708c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6cbb570bba40b8dc55886984d4b8cd85e9f2bf3e655289e102b5745face5b16d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "134d706f1bdbab4ff33b723d052a85fd2517e39046f8e6340e3498adddaf91f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ab88687e43871ab0f5da01ae4b1405712ca2e05c975d0688bc4f8826c627fdd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a09bf32551e65e375f9c0882972e6ca620cc98cb9adb02b59f5249ce16df42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75e07f7a0716808fc84c6d10e91d2877fc505235cd9178517a49adae645aee5d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db19dd301625261e0e2236b0036c624ca1b019bb3949f6fb5acbf7d5df325be4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "09b5cdd83bcb56dde10e91697a84725dcc5751fca835cb4c3332ab7e27d1a572", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "55da754def7e5bc52d0b759d776376b5b318a6ee22d7592c1ed305e98911c9d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4cf8d944587c4d4f12134bcf94d11158ce37254b26e2155cd7e1368f753c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f256b1ae087ecd3a614d6240937d33a8b980e2c68faf30730aa5f41b0d57f513", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4014a": { @@ -346519,7 +379176,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4014a", "family_id": "terrain-40145-40154", "job_id": "terrain-40145-40154", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -346535,6 +379192,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/candidate.json", "sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2344fd05aa5b7c66672308e99c535e5705923b8190304488208a0861cb927f2b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.766043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40145 retains its lower-left hollow cluster; 40146 retains the shallow central circular hollow; 40147 retains its two aligned depressions. Gallery-only40150/40151 retain occupied dark upper fissure backing. Native4014c/4014d/4014e/40153/40154 keep principal branching and star-junction placements.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 bb185aa389fce46555aea78a6a1683227216ecf2a5a8d635cc65f49b2a741eb1", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40145", + "40146", + "40147", + "40148" + ], + "sha256": "2118ba900c0c0e2423a8e70d6941c91a9f69f3f8fcbf9a1af901c40303c67bd7", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40149", + "4014a", + "4014b", + "4014c" + ], + "sha256": "0a5cbd63e0de911fc18a7edeaa007217dcfd9788adaede2c9d6c74f45364c145", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4014d", + "4014e", + "4014f", + "40150" + ], + "sha256": "2e7f0573e1d6ee9560ee01a5c3282fdd31c78192b96af3458b379c7467ccaced", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40151", + "40152", + "40153", + "40154" + ], + "sha256": "0b1b4ab14f02637594f12b6cc247190baa3994124dd0794558be10fd2d1bceba", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40145-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d3d70f233a01d7abd4f99f5785511bcb31dac038bed5413cabc5919cab4c3023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "712038c91c2f71c8ea7beb167c5d8f2c2287c84297778413a021b2041eae9089", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c8ed44987088709d60ea4601841a6fe03e0aee2836f0fe1271903777b35ac415", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3df2186222e743dbdf01202d15df6e757237e5286cab713aaa93204203bc757", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ff6a432d41188eb75be732b616e4cbac8c9351065cce8b23ebff926d09568d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2e2fd14c542ca7a499cdd111cb871297b91804b86caaad952806b0810ab0232f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6b9a0189815c49a13f07b5b2c9d2756c8819b5cf1130be813a40817bfd71c8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "183ccdaf00c2faa210d66cca9c0d55f20c106f8d1179d577a01d16b82c4fdf0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f7c11063e6718ea9664dac1c0a0dac3cdb091d1e67475a7b56eae5ebd3171aae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3ad735c66ba344d083c78394626f3093050b01fe339c8fcfce9184eca6b0904b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47cf688f58791501a4d9c72de1aae6c70fa0748434582dcaff023a062f07deb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "34344c20d4c890c4ed0e322140821675c54d72eb0c8f77a219373515340cb89b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2337cd2cb51b1bf08f1886a28b835d0efab680db6d70c85c5abd354454f86efd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f5a698a47610e48657fbf5f952737fb44f0c7bd30c3b51ed0150803d136cc7a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0ef70b37f1735ea91dc5b13aee07dbeab6f81f1928a9195be975055912986fbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37eeacd053883ac70308e1b076e84d75b70763e875a9941c29177c807cb0b378", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b0176ba6d6c12400f8c73cdb798130c06b93f672f70e0d73c7d631a0ead48ab4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "453ba7b0658ca37054dbef42d5ad8afe45b105fe2b15a7638bac7e4bbed7b89e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5b675158947fe902f96d22baa3b11bd401a695c6c3428034f4f190fdb03b872a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30f5fd28184fac4a0b21157bfc4ae306c73362822cc28f9ced29953ef9c2d02e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5751a4627be0ea4c5d4a635b401018e26e263c48a2dd9b28276bdb8281ac884b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "715c8d864841d54f0c39d895c19755d74da18d5857aa7d0862209c0d62b938bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6fee49860d4b68f0dcc2b03bc7703673aa90efc32aee96bc26d9b45fecd04eb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "35ee74f2d64f4bf2c295e9e75c87639165870593fba7f8a1463ed89d7b210c9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3edc9040b90398736e5a78a76d7c1952a08368305b4468444c75449806d00c9d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b7e34eac197540f8e3271bcdf73c137d0e9a0f8c8d1d9df41a8d68eb70d79646", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e86404d4d0bf397ad60e791edb18757e1659a0b188ba183e204317af46233710", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "607c10ed2b7ff31161c81db47927047fc4983c42c42135f7d6334dc852e8c208", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e638432b60f1eca0d66ee07b4f96c33e4e7d84e4c25c3331282173661598483", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "96c61d79de108b033f65d19d6c9599cb3cf191aafe50bbd5d0300efa3d690490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b4f67a2e1973d62a0e7ccd26295b0b973b776cecfc5149498e6a689eea7a690e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7346d5f88722c03895376cbc42f5961581e5c01dff245416e8661730bfc96a6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ff9e1ea59e6cdf8be1d2b00892fec9f7c69e1d49f7390d7c0e1be4f8008c29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36c37ee3a3539a991f457b0936fcb50d7ec2404c049e4eea9f79b52095c6424", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e186b4dc36b0c9ad581d57924014764f3abbe04d15def19024090213fe857d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0c452dca8986320b8a6fe724a9cf310f856dbfe84596f83e5508df8947af2a25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0fcc271ecc1b71ad4219976b58a976537849c70c584c485a2eb1298eb8fcecd6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7942f0600eb6386e8928fd6f4850910cfad42a983592ea20dc08aeff66876f4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "df4296686502f7cbee4de63946c5e7c130a1e9f38119b71bdb115c8096754f19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e9920c7eabf49a704c88367e5c30d3774bcb810019725189e307e7a3eee2b30c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9858fac0ccbe5f431c872256ea80eeceaac1796474443d86448adc9fdc668594", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "30e567de236a8d621adc4f8034447dfde50869ed6e80cc1444385a6790700905", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c58e51280ad84e332d145973d8c45630480c90d3d4803a1c855f89bbe91f1851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b95aa16bb1913d6689693d3861e833c986f94073176d470fea4e0f26049e4241", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e0d9c3855b0f1ddc258a1648ac62539f5bbd4f1a78ded6a032b1ba3bc5960fc8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "14c36f40ee716610c6a4408fd209cf8454ce57ae4fc097d9c7431b4a74e402b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a871534279e983547fcbdbfe789349d034abe113b41583a46a503f44e7996b4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf87cf24e0a27e5ab7fe118f654bdc2980fa5ae25032673d569dda9cf4705ea3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eacd52d9fc804f1c58108655cc294a9b7fdcbb2f992b12405fc1394ce27c4c09", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8e16e3e7a3d814d85d0c0e7b4b10468bf8f7bdf0316b36ec383a1104919e22c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d944d4863d7a8cb82695f4601d5ab2eb9afdf91738e7f41738198574b1cdeb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "32f046e795625f4021213a3aa5ccb940526bb31e6128c16c1ac0428f94e97dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "37b1f7657f226c5f62ee5acb752c470a27c98ccd688a99403eca51696bb764ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b734e84320c0b0d18b6f7c005626c457d2cc593784846c584a71d5f011070a39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa64abc2903dbf3f90ae4e8b2e41dee899943e1d254498a579970f5f23262355", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "872d16ded97babfc182fe0c0e495ed1708ee87134ef8d3110e605c960b18a70f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6183848a6b396e8d351368bde6fc0f3be7125ac080ae4b9519eec1d95b6f8adb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d94ecafbd7cc7909cda32fd1853832bc78e0f2f7dd54aeceafb02c34936f9b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e3aa51b24375334a6b28d727af48188e5c0daa706d55850431b92c2cf07baaf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-original.ppm", + "sha256": "576dd05985e677f2268476886d87ba016fcac4927169bed5b39365b771c5bde3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36a73df1a2bd68ca78a189af9a9fb17355a9cadcb65783e7df2cfefa529081b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c241429b850a5d20818c9dd78184696c1631c991f04429ecc4fdb9a92c3ca46b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d10d52afcc7c547b2eaab1eac2cc3be291ddc89c5c5d518dcc13b66416cb3976", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2c942d9c19cb1384d6fd34f3083e8051413b11aa71b09bba5ace9f81c965c3f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108b3c22271faa45aa5c43859198c22fbdb083c24c18a80288061283bae9d1a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "be701e99bc926803ffbab6595ef1ec66c9dc451f2f47d1017061c9f8462ee0f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf6a1e4712a233400c5687a34987ea8332704958440620223c07577082e4edfc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "162a24b500a597dadb139e01557548c8f5c81d30d5e4766fa467dc1a2f33b8d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13d6aed360f87778296c7ac376e28812b36b45ae79ca29c1e1f53c3907fb4544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-original.ppm", + "sha256": "50af887f191e4dd9150559986f04f668b982b10514a2100a1a99242123f5708c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6cbb570bba40b8dc55886984d4b8cd85e9f2bf3e655289e102b5745face5b16d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "134d706f1bdbab4ff33b723d052a85fd2517e39046f8e6340e3498adddaf91f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ab88687e43871ab0f5da01ae4b1405712ca2e05c975d0688bc4f8826c627fdd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a09bf32551e65e375f9c0882972e6ca620cc98cb9adb02b59f5249ce16df42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75e07f7a0716808fc84c6d10e91d2877fc505235cd9178517a49adae645aee5d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db19dd301625261e0e2236b0036c624ca1b019bb3949f6fb5acbf7d5df325be4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "09b5cdd83bcb56dde10e91697a84725dcc5751fca835cb4c3332ab7e27d1a572", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "55da754def7e5bc52d0b759d776376b5b318a6ee22d7592c1ed305e98911c9d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4cf8d944587c4d4f12134bcf94d11158ce37254b26e2155cd7e1368f753c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f256b1ae087ecd3a614d6240937d33a8b980e2c68faf30730aa5f41b0d57f513", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4014b": { @@ -346556,7 +379683,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4014b", "family_id": "terrain-40145-40154", "job_id": "terrain-40145-40154", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -346572,6 +379699,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/candidate.json", "sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2344fd05aa5b7c66672308e99c535e5705923b8190304488208a0861cb927f2b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.766043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40145 retains its lower-left hollow cluster; 40146 retains the shallow central circular hollow; 40147 retains its two aligned depressions. Gallery-only40150/40151 retain occupied dark upper fissure backing. Native4014c/4014d/4014e/40153/40154 keep principal branching and star-junction placements.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 bb185aa389fce46555aea78a6a1683227216ecf2a5a8d635cc65f49b2a741eb1", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40145", + "40146", + "40147", + "40148" + ], + "sha256": "2118ba900c0c0e2423a8e70d6941c91a9f69f3f8fcbf9a1af901c40303c67bd7", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40149", + "4014a", + "4014b", + "4014c" + ], + "sha256": "0a5cbd63e0de911fc18a7edeaa007217dcfd9788adaede2c9d6c74f45364c145", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4014d", + "4014e", + "4014f", + "40150" + ], + "sha256": "2e7f0573e1d6ee9560ee01a5c3282fdd31c78192b96af3458b379c7467ccaced", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40151", + "40152", + "40153", + "40154" + ], + "sha256": "0b1b4ab14f02637594f12b6cc247190baa3994124dd0794558be10fd2d1bceba", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40145-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d3d70f233a01d7abd4f99f5785511bcb31dac038bed5413cabc5919cab4c3023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "712038c91c2f71c8ea7beb167c5d8f2c2287c84297778413a021b2041eae9089", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c8ed44987088709d60ea4601841a6fe03e0aee2836f0fe1271903777b35ac415", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3df2186222e743dbdf01202d15df6e757237e5286cab713aaa93204203bc757", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ff6a432d41188eb75be732b616e4cbac8c9351065cce8b23ebff926d09568d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2e2fd14c542ca7a499cdd111cb871297b91804b86caaad952806b0810ab0232f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6b9a0189815c49a13f07b5b2c9d2756c8819b5cf1130be813a40817bfd71c8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "183ccdaf00c2faa210d66cca9c0d55f20c106f8d1179d577a01d16b82c4fdf0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f7c11063e6718ea9664dac1c0a0dac3cdb091d1e67475a7b56eae5ebd3171aae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3ad735c66ba344d083c78394626f3093050b01fe339c8fcfce9184eca6b0904b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47cf688f58791501a4d9c72de1aae6c70fa0748434582dcaff023a062f07deb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "34344c20d4c890c4ed0e322140821675c54d72eb0c8f77a219373515340cb89b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2337cd2cb51b1bf08f1886a28b835d0efab680db6d70c85c5abd354454f86efd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f5a698a47610e48657fbf5f952737fb44f0c7bd30c3b51ed0150803d136cc7a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0ef70b37f1735ea91dc5b13aee07dbeab6f81f1928a9195be975055912986fbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37eeacd053883ac70308e1b076e84d75b70763e875a9941c29177c807cb0b378", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b0176ba6d6c12400f8c73cdb798130c06b93f672f70e0d73c7d631a0ead48ab4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "453ba7b0658ca37054dbef42d5ad8afe45b105fe2b15a7638bac7e4bbed7b89e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5b675158947fe902f96d22baa3b11bd401a695c6c3428034f4f190fdb03b872a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30f5fd28184fac4a0b21157bfc4ae306c73362822cc28f9ced29953ef9c2d02e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5751a4627be0ea4c5d4a635b401018e26e263c48a2dd9b28276bdb8281ac884b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "715c8d864841d54f0c39d895c19755d74da18d5857aa7d0862209c0d62b938bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6fee49860d4b68f0dcc2b03bc7703673aa90efc32aee96bc26d9b45fecd04eb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "35ee74f2d64f4bf2c295e9e75c87639165870593fba7f8a1463ed89d7b210c9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3edc9040b90398736e5a78a76d7c1952a08368305b4468444c75449806d00c9d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b7e34eac197540f8e3271bcdf73c137d0e9a0f8c8d1d9df41a8d68eb70d79646", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e86404d4d0bf397ad60e791edb18757e1659a0b188ba183e204317af46233710", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "607c10ed2b7ff31161c81db47927047fc4983c42c42135f7d6334dc852e8c208", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e638432b60f1eca0d66ee07b4f96c33e4e7d84e4c25c3331282173661598483", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "96c61d79de108b033f65d19d6c9599cb3cf191aafe50bbd5d0300efa3d690490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b4f67a2e1973d62a0e7ccd26295b0b973b776cecfc5149498e6a689eea7a690e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7346d5f88722c03895376cbc42f5961581e5c01dff245416e8661730bfc96a6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ff9e1ea59e6cdf8be1d2b00892fec9f7c69e1d49f7390d7c0e1be4f8008c29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36c37ee3a3539a991f457b0936fcb50d7ec2404c049e4eea9f79b52095c6424", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e186b4dc36b0c9ad581d57924014764f3abbe04d15def19024090213fe857d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0c452dca8986320b8a6fe724a9cf310f856dbfe84596f83e5508df8947af2a25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0fcc271ecc1b71ad4219976b58a976537849c70c584c485a2eb1298eb8fcecd6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7942f0600eb6386e8928fd6f4850910cfad42a983592ea20dc08aeff66876f4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "df4296686502f7cbee4de63946c5e7c130a1e9f38119b71bdb115c8096754f19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e9920c7eabf49a704c88367e5c30d3774bcb810019725189e307e7a3eee2b30c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9858fac0ccbe5f431c872256ea80eeceaac1796474443d86448adc9fdc668594", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "30e567de236a8d621adc4f8034447dfde50869ed6e80cc1444385a6790700905", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c58e51280ad84e332d145973d8c45630480c90d3d4803a1c855f89bbe91f1851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b95aa16bb1913d6689693d3861e833c986f94073176d470fea4e0f26049e4241", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e0d9c3855b0f1ddc258a1648ac62539f5bbd4f1a78ded6a032b1ba3bc5960fc8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "14c36f40ee716610c6a4408fd209cf8454ce57ae4fc097d9c7431b4a74e402b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a871534279e983547fcbdbfe789349d034abe113b41583a46a503f44e7996b4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf87cf24e0a27e5ab7fe118f654bdc2980fa5ae25032673d569dda9cf4705ea3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eacd52d9fc804f1c58108655cc294a9b7fdcbb2f992b12405fc1394ce27c4c09", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8e16e3e7a3d814d85d0c0e7b4b10468bf8f7bdf0316b36ec383a1104919e22c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d944d4863d7a8cb82695f4601d5ab2eb9afdf91738e7f41738198574b1cdeb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "32f046e795625f4021213a3aa5ccb940526bb31e6128c16c1ac0428f94e97dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "37b1f7657f226c5f62ee5acb752c470a27c98ccd688a99403eca51696bb764ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b734e84320c0b0d18b6f7c005626c457d2cc593784846c584a71d5f011070a39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa64abc2903dbf3f90ae4e8b2e41dee899943e1d254498a579970f5f23262355", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "872d16ded97babfc182fe0c0e495ed1708ee87134ef8d3110e605c960b18a70f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6183848a6b396e8d351368bde6fc0f3be7125ac080ae4b9519eec1d95b6f8adb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d94ecafbd7cc7909cda32fd1853832bc78e0f2f7dd54aeceafb02c34936f9b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e3aa51b24375334a6b28d727af48188e5c0daa706d55850431b92c2cf07baaf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-original.ppm", + "sha256": "576dd05985e677f2268476886d87ba016fcac4927169bed5b39365b771c5bde3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36a73df1a2bd68ca78a189af9a9fb17355a9cadcb65783e7df2cfefa529081b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c241429b850a5d20818c9dd78184696c1631c991f04429ecc4fdb9a92c3ca46b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d10d52afcc7c547b2eaab1eac2cc3be291ddc89c5c5d518dcc13b66416cb3976", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2c942d9c19cb1384d6fd34f3083e8051413b11aa71b09bba5ace9f81c965c3f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108b3c22271faa45aa5c43859198c22fbdb083c24c18a80288061283bae9d1a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "be701e99bc926803ffbab6595ef1ec66c9dc451f2f47d1017061c9f8462ee0f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf6a1e4712a233400c5687a34987ea8332704958440620223c07577082e4edfc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "162a24b500a597dadb139e01557548c8f5c81d30d5e4766fa467dc1a2f33b8d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13d6aed360f87778296c7ac376e28812b36b45ae79ca29c1e1f53c3907fb4544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-original.ppm", + "sha256": "50af887f191e4dd9150559986f04f668b982b10514a2100a1a99242123f5708c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6cbb570bba40b8dc55886984d4b8cd85e9f2bf3e655289e102b5745face5b16d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "134d706f1bdbab4ff33b723d052a85fd2517e39046f8e6340e3498adddaf91f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ab88687e43871ab0f5da01ae4b1405712ca2e05c975d0688bc4f8826c627fdd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a09bf32551e65e375f9c0882972e6ca620cc98cb9adb02b59f5249ce16df42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75e07f7a0716808fc84c6d10e91d2877fc505235cd9178517a49adae645aee5d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db19dd301625261e0e2236b0036c624ca1b019bb3949f6fb5acbf7d5df325be4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "09b5cdd83bcb56dde10e91697a84725dcc5751fca835cb4c3332ab7e27d1a572", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "55da754def7e5bc52d0b759d776376b5b318a6ee22d7592c1ed305e98911c9d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4cf8d944587c4d4f12134bcf94d11158ce37254b26e2155cd7e1368f753c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f256b1ae087ecd3a614d6240937d33a8b980e2c68faf30730aa5f41b0d57f513", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4014c": { @@ -346593,7 +380190,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4014c", "family_id": "terrain-40145-40154", "job_id": "terrain-40145-40154", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -346609,6 +380206,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/candidate.json", "sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2344fd05aa5b7c66672308e99c535e5705923b8190304488208a0861cb927f2b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.766043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40145 retains its lower-left hollow cluster; 40146 retains the shallow central circular hollow; 40147 retains its two aligned depressions. Gallery-only40150/40151 retain occupied dark upper fissure backing. Native4014c/4014d/4014e/40153/40154 keep principal branching and star-junction placements.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 bb185aa389fce46555aea78a6a1683227216ecf2a5a8d635cc65f49b2a741eb1", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40145", + "40146", + "40147", + "40148" + ], + "sha256": "2118ba900c0c0e2423a8e70d6941c91a9f69f3f8fcbf9a1af901c40303c67bd7", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40149", + "4014a", + "4014b", + "4014c" + ], + "sha256": "0a5cbd63e0de911fc18a7edeaa007217dcfd9788adaede2c9d6c74f45364c145", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4014d", + "4014e", + "4014f", + "40150" + ], + "sha256": "2e7f0573e1d6ee9560ee01a5c3282fdd31c78192b96af3458b379c7467ccaced", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40151", + "40152", + "40153", + "40154" + ], + "sha256": "0b1b4ab14f02637594f12b6cc247190baa3994124dd0794558be10fd2d1bceba", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40145-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d3d70f233a01d7abd4f99f5785511bcb31dac038bed5413cabc5919cab4c3023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "712038c91c2f71c8ea7beb167c5d8f2c2287c84297778413a021b2041eae9089", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c8ed44987088709d60ea4601841a6fe03e0aee2836f0fe1271903777b35ac415", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3df2186222e743dbdf01202d15df6e757237e5286cab713aaa93204203bc757", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ff6a432d41188eb75be732b616e4cbac8c9351065cce8b23ebff926d09568d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2e2fd14c542ca7a499cdd111cb871297b91804b86caaad952806b0810ab0232f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6b9a0189815c49a13f07b5b2c9d2756c8819b5cf1130be813a40817bfd71c8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "183ccdaf00c2faa210d66cca9c0d55f20c106f8d1179d577a01d16b82c4fdf0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f7c11063e6718ea9664dac1c0a0dac3cdb091d1e67475a7b56eae5ebd3171aae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3ad735c66ba344d083c78394626f3093050b01fe339c8fcfce9184eca6b0904b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47cf688f58791501a4d9c72de1aae6c70fa0748434582dcaff023a062f07deb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "34344c20d4c890c4ed0e322140821675c54d72eb0c8f77a219373515340cb89b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2337cd2cb51b1bf08f1886a28b835d0efab680db6d70c85c5abd354454f86efd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f5a698a47610e48657fbf5f952737fb44f0c7bd30c3b51ed0150803d136cc7a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0ef70b37f1735ea91dc5b13aee07dbeab6f81f1928a9195be975055912986fbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37eeacd053883ac70308e1b076e84d75b70763e875a9941c29177c807cb0b378", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b0176ba6d6c12400f8c73cdb798130c06b93f672f70e0d73c7d631a0ead48ab4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "453ba7b0658ca37054dbef42d5ad8afe45b105fe2b15a7638bac7e4bbed7b89e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5b675158947fe902f96d22baa3b11bd401a695c6c3428034f4f190fdb03b872a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30f5fd28184fac4a0b21157bfc4ae306c73362822cc28f9ced29953ef9c2d02e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5751a4627be0ea4c5d4a635b401018e26e263c48a2dd9b28276bdb8281ac884b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "715c8d864841d54f0c39d895c19755d74da18d5857aa7d0862209c0d62b938bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6fee49860d4b68f0dcc2b03bc7703673aa90efc32aee96bc26d9b45fecd04eb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "35ee74f2d64f4bf2c295e9e75c87639165870593fba7f8a1463ed89d7b210c9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3edc9040b90398736e5a78a76d7c1952a08368305b4468444c75449806d00c9d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b7e34eac197540f8e3271bcdf73c137d0e9a0f8c8d1d9df41a8d68eb70d79646", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e86404d4d0bf397ad60e791edb18757e1659a0b188ba183e204317af46233710", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "607c10ed2b7ff31161c81db47927047fc4983c42c42135f7d6334dc852e8c208", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e638432b60f1eca0d66ee07b4f96c33e4e7d84e4c25c3331282173661598483", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "96c61d79de108b033f65d19d6c9599cb3cf191aafe50bbd5d0300efa3d690490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b4f67a2e1973d62a0e7ccd26295b0b973b776cecfc5149498e6a689eea7a690e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7346d5f88722c03895376cbc42f5961581e5c01dff245416e8661730bfc96a6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ff9e1ea59e6cdf8be1d2b00892fec9f7c69e1d49f7390d7c0e1be4f8008c29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36c37ee3a3539a991f457b0936fcb50d7ec2404c049e4eea9f79b52095c6424", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e186b4dc36b0c9ad581d57924014764f3abbe04d15def19024090213fe857d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0c452dca8986320b8a6fe724a9cf310f856dbfe84596f83e5508df8947af2a25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0fcc271ecc1b71ad4219976b58a976537849c70c584c485a2eb1298eb8fcecd6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7942f0600eb6386e8928fd6f4850910cfad42a983592ea20dc08aeff66876f4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "df4296686502f7cbee4de63946c5e7c130a1e9f38119b71bdb115c8096754f19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e9920c7eabf49a704c88367e5c30d3774bcb810019725189e307e7a3eee2b30c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9858fac0ccbe5f431c872256ea80eeceaac1796474443d86448adc9fdc668594", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "30e567de236a8d621adc4f8034447dfde50869ed6e80cc1444385a6790700905", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c58e51280ad84e332d145973d8c45630480c90d3d4803a1c855f89bbe91f1851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b95aa16bb1913d6689693d3861e833c986f94073176d470fea4e0f26049e4241", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e0d9c3855b0f1ddc258a1648ac62539f5bbd4f1a78ded6a032b1ba3bc5960fc8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "14c36f40ee716610c6a4408fd209cf8454ce57ae4fc097d9c7431b4a74e402b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a871534279e983547fcbdbfe789349d034abe113b41583a46a503f44e7996b4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf87cf24e0a27e5ab7fe118f654bdc2980fa5ae25032673d569dda9cf4705ea3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eacd52d9fc804f1c58108655cc294a9b7fdcbb2f992b12405fc1394ce27c4c09", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8e16e3e7a3d814d85d0c0e7b4b10468bf8f7bdf0316b36ec383a1104919e22c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d944d4863d7a8cb82695f4601d5ab2eb9afdf91738e7f41738198574b1cdeb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "32f046e795625f4021213a3aa5ccb940526bb31e6128c16c1ac0428f94e97dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "37b1f7657f226c5f62ee5acb752c470a27c98ccd688a99403eca51696bb764ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b734e84320c0b0d18b6f7c005626c457d2cc593784846c584a71d5f011070a39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa64abc2903dbf3f90ae4e8b2e41dee899943e1d254498a579970f5f23262355", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "872d16ded97babfc182fe0c0e495ed1708ee87134ef8d3110e605c960b18a70f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6183848a6b396e8d351368bde6fc0f3be7125ac080ae4b9519eec1d95b6f8adb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d94ecafbd7cc7909cda32fd1853832bc78e0f2f7dd54aeceafb02c34936f9b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e3aa51b24375334a6b28d727af48188e5c0daa706d55850431b92c2cf07baaf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-original.ppm", + "sha256": "576dd05985e677f2268476886d87ba016fcac4927169bed5b39365b771c5bde3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36a73df1a2bd68ca78a189af9a9fb17355a9cadcb65783e7df2cfefa529081b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c241429b850a5d20818c9dd78184696c1631c991f04429ecc4fdb9a92c3ca46b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d10d52afcc7c547b2eaab1eac2cc3be291ddc89c5c5d518dcc13b66416cb3976", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2c942d9c19cb1384d6fd34f3083e8051413b11aa71b09bba5ace9f81c965c3f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108b3c22271faa45aa5c43859198c22fbdb083c24c18a80288061283bae9d1a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "be701e99bc926803ffbab6595ef1ec66c9dc451f2f47d1017061c9f8462ee0f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf6a1e4712a233400c5687a34987ea8332704958440620223c07577082e4edfc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "162a24b500a597dadb139e01557548c8f5c81d30d5e4766fa467dc1a2f33b8d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13d6aed360f87778296c7ac376e28812b36b45ae79ca29c1e1f53c3907fb4544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-original.ppm", + "sha256": "50af887f191e4dd9150559986f04f668b982b10514a2100a1a99242123f5708c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6cbb570bba40b8dc55886984d4b8cd85e9f2bf3e655289e102b5745face5b16d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "134d706f1bdbab4ff33b723d052a85fd2517e39046f8e6340e3498adddaf91f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ab88687e43871ab0f5da01ae4b1405712ca2e05c975d0688bc4f8826c627fdd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a09bf32551e65e375f9c0882972e6ca620cc98cb9adb02b59f5249ce16df42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75e07f7a0716808fc84c6d10e91d2877fc505235cd9178517a49adae645aee5d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db19dd301625261e0e2236b0036c624ca1b019bb3949f6fb5acbf7d5df325be4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "09b5cdd83bcb56dde10e91697a84725dcc5751fca835cb4c3332ab7e27d1a572", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "55da754def7e5bc52d0b759d776376b5b318a6ee22d7592c1ed305e98911c9d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4cf8d944587c4d4f12134bcf94d11158ce37254b26e2155cd7e1368f753c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f256b1ae087ecd3a614d6240937d33a8b980e2c68faf30730aa5f41b0d57f513", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4014d": { @@ -346630,7 +380697,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4014d", "family_id": "terrain-40145-40154", "job_id": "terrain-40145-40154", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -346646,6 +380713,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/candidate.json", "sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2344fd05aa5b7c66672308e99c535e5705923b8190304488208a0861cb927f2b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.766043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40145 retains its lower-left hollow cluster; 40146 retains the shallow central circular hollow; 40147 retains its two aligned depressions. Gallery-only40150/40151 retain occupied dark upper fissure backing. Native4014c/4014d/4014e/40153/40154 keep principal branching and star-junction placements.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 bb185aa389fce46555aea78a6a1683227216ecf2a5a8d635cc65f49b2a741eb1", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40145", + "40146", + "40147", + "40148" + ], + "sha256": "2118ba900c0c0e2423a8e70d6941c91a9f69f3f8fcbf9a1af901c40303c67bd7", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40149", + "4014a", + "4014b", + "4014c" + ], + "sha256": "0a5cbd63e0de911fc18a7edeaa007217dcfd9788adaede2c9d6c74f45364c145", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4014d", + "4014e", + "4014f", + "40150" + ], + "sha256": "2e7f0573e1d6ee9560ee01a5c3282fdd31c78192b96af3458b379c7467ccaced", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40151", + "40152", + "40153", + "40154" + ], + "sha256": "0b1b4ab14f02637594f12b6cc247190baa3994124dd0794558be10fd2d1bceba", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40145-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d3d70f233a01d7abd4f99f5785511bcb31dac038bed5413cabc5919cab4c3023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "712038c91c2f71c8ea7beb167c5d8f2c2287c84297778413a021b2041eae9089", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c8ed44987088709d60ea4601841a6fe03e0aee2836f0fe1271903777b35ac415", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3df2186222e743dbdf01202d15df6e757237e5286cab713aaa93204203bc757", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ff6a432d41188eb75be732b616e4cbac8c9351065cce8b23ebff926d09568d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2e2fd14c542ca7a499cdd111cb871297b91804b86caaad952806b0810ab0232f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6b9a0189815c49a13f07b5b2c9d2756c8819b5cf1130be813a40817bfd71c8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "183ccdaf00c2faa210d66cca9c0d55f20c106f8d1179d577a01d16b82c4fdf0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f7c11063e6718ea9664dac1c0a0dac3cdb091d1e67475a7b56eae5ebd3171aae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3ad735c66ba344d083c78394626f3093050b01fe339c8fcfce9184eca6b0904b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47cf688f58791501a4d9c72de1aae6c70fa0748434582dcaff023a062f07deb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "34344c20d4c890c4ed0e322140821675c54d72eb0c8f77a219373515340cb89b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2337cd2cb51b1bf08f1886a28b835d0efab680db6d70c85c5abd354454f86efd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f5a698a47610e48657fbf5f952737fb44f0c7bd30c3b51ed0150803d136cc7a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0ef70b37f1735ea91dc5b13aee07dbeab6f81f1928a9195be975055912986fbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37eeacd053883ac70308e1b076e84d75b70763e875a9941c29177c807cb0b378", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b0176ba6d6c12400f8c73cdb798130c06b93f672f70e0d73c7d631a0ead48ab4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "453ba7b0658ca37054dbef42d5ad8afe45b105fe2b15a7638bac7e4bbed7b89e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5b675158947fe902f96d22baa3b11bd401a695c6c3428034f4f190fdb03b872a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30f5fd28184fac4a0b21157bfc4ae306c73362822cc28f9ced29953ef9c2d02e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5751a4627be0ea4c5d4a635b401018e26e263c48a2dd9b28276bdb8281ac884b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "715c8d864841d54f0c39d895c19755d74da18d5857aa7d0862209c0d62b938bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6fee49860d4b68f0dcc2b03bc7703673aa90efc32aee96bc26d9b45fecd04eb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "35ee74f2d64f4bf2c295e9e75c87639165870593fba7f8a1463ed89d7b210c9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3edc9040b90398736e5a78a76d7c1952a08368305b4468444c75449806d00c9d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b7e34eac197540f8e3271bcdf73c137d0e9a0f8c8d1d9df41a8d68eb70d79646", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e86404d4d0bf397ad60e791edb18757e1659a0b188ba183e204317af46233710", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "607c10ed2b7ff31161c81db47927047fc4983c42c42135f7d6334dc852e8c208", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e638432b60f1eca0d66ee07b4f96c33e4e7d84e4c25c3331282173661598483", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "96c61d79de108b033f65d19d6c9599cb3cf191aafe50bbd5d0300efa3d690490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b4f67a2e1973d62a0e7ccd26295b0b973b776cecfc5149498e6a689eea7a690e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7346d5f88722c03895376cbc42f5961581e5c01dff245416e8661730bfc96a6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ff9e1ea59e6cdf8be1d2b00892fec9f7c69e1d49f7390d7c0e1be4f8008c29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36c37ee3a3539a991f457b0936fcb50d7ec2404c049e4eea9f79b52095c6424", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e186b4dc36b0c9ad581d57924014764f3abbe04d15def19024090213fe857d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0c452dca8986320b8a6fe724a9cf310f856dbfe84596f83e5508df8947af2a25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0fcc271ecc1b71ad4219976b58a976537849c70c584c485a2eb1298eb8fcecd6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7942f0600eb6386e8928fd6f4850910cfad42a983592ea20dc08aeff66876f4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "df4296686502f7cbee4de63946c5e7c130a1e9f38119b71bdb115c8096754f19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e9920c7eabf49a704c88367e5c30d3774bcb810019725189e307e7a3eee2b30c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9858fac0ccbe5f431c872256ea80eeceaac1796474443d86448adc9fdc668594", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "30e567de236a8d621adc4f8034447dfde50869ed6e80cc1444385a6790700905", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c58e51280ad84e332d145973d8c45630480c90d3d4803a1c855f89bbe91f1851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b95aa16bb1913d6689693d3861e833c986f94073176d470fea4e0f26049e4241", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e0d9c3855b0f1ddc258a1648ac62539f5bbd4f1a78ded6a032b1ba3bc5960fc8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "14c36f40ee716610c6a4408fd209cf8454ce57ae4fc097d9c7431b4a74e402b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a871534279e983547fcbdbfe789349d034abe113b41583a46a503f44e7996b4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf87cf24e0a27e5ab7fe118f654bdc2980fa5ae25032673d569dda9cf4705ea3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eacd52d9fc804f1c58108655cc294a9b7fdcbb2f992b12405fc1394ce27c4c09", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8e16e3e7a3d814d85d0c0e7b4b10468bf8f7bdf0316b36ec383a1104919e22c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d944d4863d7a8cb82695f4601d5ab2eb9afdf91738e7f41738198574b1cdeb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "32f046e795625f4021213a3aa5ccb940526bb31e6128c16c1ac0428f94e97dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "37b1f7657f226c5f62ee5acb752c470a27c98ccd688a99403eca51696bb764ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b734e84320c0b0d18b6f7c005626c457d2cc593784846c584a71d5f011070a39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa64abc2903dbf3f90ae4e8b2e41dee899943e1d254498a579970f5f23262355", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "872d16ded97babfc182fe0c0e495ed1708ee87134ef8d3110e605c960b18a70f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6183848a6b396e8d351368bde6fc0f3be7125ac080ae4b9519eec1d95b6f8adb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d94ecafbd7cc7909cda32fd1853832bc78e0f2f7dd54aeceafb02c34936f9b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e3aa51b24375334a6b28d727af48188e5c0daa706d55850431b92c2cf07baaf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-original.ppm", + "sha256": "576dd05985e677f2268476886d87ba016fcac4927169bed5b39365b771c5bde3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36a73df1a2bd68ca78a189af9a9fb17355a9cadcb65783e7df2cfefa529081b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c241429b850a5d20818c9dd78184696c1631c991f04429ecc4fdb9a92c3ca46b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d10d52afcc7c547b2eaab1eac2cc3be291ddc89c5c5d518dcc13b66416cb3976", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2c942d9c19cb1384d6fd34f3083e8051413b11aa71b09bba5ace9f81c965c3f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108b3c22271faa45aa5c43859198c22fbdb083c24c18a80288061283bae9d1a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "be701e99bc926803ffbab6595ef1ec66c9dc451f2f47d1017061c9f8462ee0f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf6a1e4712a233400c5687a34987ea8332704958440620223c07577082e4edfc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "162a24b500a597dadb139e01557548c8f5c81d30d5e4766fa467dc1a2f33b8d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13d6aed360f87778296c7ac376e28812b36b45ae79ca29c1e1f53c3907fb4544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-original.ppm", + "sha256": "50af887f191e4dd9150559986f04f668b982b10514a2100a1a99242123f5708c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6cbb570bba40b8dc55886984d4b8cd85e9f2bf3e655289e102b5745face5b16d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "134d706f1bdbab4ff33b723d052a85fd2517e39046f8e6340e3498adddaf91f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ab88687e43871ab0f5da01ae4b1405712ca2e05c975d0688bc4f8826c627fdd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a09bf32551e65e375f9c0882972e6ca620cc98cb9adb02b59f5249ce16df42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75e07f7a0716808fc84c6d10e91d2877fc505235cd9178517a49adae645aee5d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db19dd301625261e0e2236b0036c624ca1b019bb3949f6fb5acbf7d5df325be4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "09b5cdd83bcb56dde10e91697a84725dcc5751fca835cb4c3332ab7e27d1a572", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "55da754def7e5bc52d0b759d776376b5b318a6ee22d7592c1ed305e98911c9d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4cf8d944587c4d4f12134bcf94d11158ce37254b26e2155cd7e1368f753c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f256b1ae087ecd3a614d6240937d33a8b980e2c68faf30730aa5f41b0d57f513", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4014e": { @@ -346667,7 +381204,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4014e", "family_id": "terrain-40145-40154", "job_id": "terrain-40145-40154", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -346683,6 +381220,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/candidate.json", "sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2344fd05aa5b7c66672308e99c535e5705923b8190304488208a0861cb927f2b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.766043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40145 retains its lower-left hollow cluster; 40146 retains the shallow central circular hollow; 40147 retains its two aligned depressions. Gallery-only40150/40151 retain occupied dark upper fissure backing. Native4014c/4014d/4014e/40153/40154 keep principal branching and star-junction placements.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 bb185aa389fce46555aea78a6a1683227216ecf2a5a8d635cc65f49b2a741eb1", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40145", + "40146", + "40147", + "40148" + ], + "sha256": "2118ba900c0c0e2423a8e70d6941c91a9f69f3f8fcbf9a1af901c40303c67bd7", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40149", + "4014a", + "4014b", + "4014c" + ], + "sha256": "0a5cbd63e0de911fc18a7edeaa007217dcfd9788adaede2c9d6c74f45364c145", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4014d", + "4014e", + "4014f", + "40150" + ], + "sha256": "2e7f0573e1d6ee9560ee01a5c3282fdd31c78192b96af3458b379c7467ccaced", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40151", + "40152", + "40153", + "40154" + ], + "sha256": "0b1b4ab14f02637594f12b6cc247190baa3994124dd0794558be10fd2d1bceba", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40145-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d3d70f233a01d7abd4f99f5785511bcb31dac038bed5413cabc5919cab4c3023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "712038c91c2f71c8ea7beb167c5d8f2c2287c84297778413a021b2041eae9089", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c8ed44987088709d60ea4601841a6fe03e0aee2836f0fe1271903777b35ac415", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3df2186222e743dbdf01202d15df6e757237e5286cab713aaa93204203bc757", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ff6a432d41188eb75be732b616e4cbac8c9351065cce8b23ebff926d09568d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2e2fd14c542ca7a499cdd111cb871297b91804b86caaad952806b0810ab0232f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6b9a0189815c49a13f07b5b2c9d2756c8819b5cf1130be813a40817bfd71c8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "183ccdaf00c2faa210d66cca9c0d55f20c106f8d1179d577a01d16b82c4fdf0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f7c11063e6718ea9664dac1c0a0dac3cdb091d1e67475a7b56eae5ebd3171aae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3ad735c66ba344d083c78394626f3093050b01fe339c8fcfce9184eca6b0904b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47cf688f58791501a4d9c72de1aae6c70fa0748434582dcaff023a062f07deb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "34344c20d4c890c4ed0e322140821675c54d72eb0c8f77a219373515340cb89b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2337cd2cb51b1bf08f1886a28b835d0efab680db6d70c85c5abd354454f86efd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f5a698a47610e48657fbf5f952737fb44f0c7bd30c3b51ed0150803d136cc7a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0ef70b37f1735ea91dc5b13aee07dbeab6f81f1928a9195be975055912986fbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37eeacd053883ac70308e1b076e84d75b70763e875a9941c29177c807cb0b378", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b0176ba6d6c12400f8c73cdb798130c06b93f672f70e0d73c7d631a0ead48ab4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "453ba7b0658ca37054dbef42d5ad8afe45b105fe2b15a7638bac7e4bbed7b89e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5b675158947fe902f96d22baa3b11bd401a695c6c3428034f4f190fdb03b872a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30f5fd28184fac4a0b21157bfc4ae306c73362822cc28f9ced29953ef9c2d02e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5751a4627be0ea4c5d4a635b401018e26e263c48a2dd9b28276bdb8281ac884b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "715c8d864841d54f0c39d895c19755d74da18d5857aa7d0862209c0d62b938bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6fee49860d4b68f0dcc2b03bc7703673aa90efc32aee96bc26d9b45fecd04eb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "35ee74f2d64f4bf2c295e9e75c87639165870593fba7f8a1463ed89d7b210c9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3edc9040b90398736e5a78a76d7c1952a08368305b4468444c75449806d00c9d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b7e34eac197540f8e3271bcdf73c137d0e9a0f8c8d1d9df41a8d68eb70d79646", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e86404d4d0bf397ad60e791edb18757e1659a0b188ba183e204317af46233710", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "607c10ed2b7ff31161c81db47927047fc4983c42c42135f7d6334dc852e8c208", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e638432b60f1eca0d66ee07b4f96c33e4e7d84e4c25c3331282173661598483", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "96c61d79de108b033f65d19d6c9599cb3cf191aafe50bbd5d0300efa3d690490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b4f67a2e1973d62a0e7ccd26295b0b973b776cecfc5149498e6a689eea7a690e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7346d5f88722c03895376cbc42f5961581e5c01dff245416e8661730bfc96a6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ff9e1ea59e6cdf8be1d2b00892fec9f7c69e1d49f7390d7c0e1be4f8008c29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36c37ee3a3539a991f457b0936fcb50d7ec2404c049e4eea9f79b52095c6424", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e186b4dc36b0c9ad581d57924014764f3abbe04d15def19024090213fe857d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0c452dca8986320b8a6fe724a9cf310f856dbfe84596f83e5508df8947af2a25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0fcc271ecc1b71ad4219976b58a976537849c70c584c485a2eb1298eb8fcecd6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7942f0600eb6386e8928fd6f4850910cfad42a983592ea20dc08aeff66876f4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "df4296686502f7cbee4de63946c5e7c130a1e9f38119b71bdb115c8096754f19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e9920c7eabf49a704c88367e5c30d3774bcb810019725189e307e7a3eee2b30c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9858fac0ccbe5f431c872256ea80eeceaac1796474443d86448adc9fdc668594", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "30e567de236a8d621adc4f8034447dfde50869ed6e80cc1444385a6790700905", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c58e51280ad84e332d145973d8c45630480c90d3d4803a1c855f89bbe91f1851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b95aa16bb1913d6689693d3861e833c986f94073176d470fea4e0f26049e4241", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e0d9c3855b0f1ddc258a1648ac62539f5bbd4f1a78ded6a032b1ba3bc5960fc8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "14c36f40ee716610c6a4408fd209cf8454ce57ae4fc097d9c7431b4a74e402b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a871534279e983547fcbdbfe789349d034abe113b41583a46a503f44e7996b4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf87cf24e0a27e5ab7fe118f654bdc2980fa5ae25032673d569dda9cf4705ea3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eacd52d9fc804f1c58108655cc294a9b7fdcbb2f992b12405fc1394ce27c4c09", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8e16e3e7a3d814d85d0c0e7b4b10468bf8f7bdf0316b36ec383a1104919e22c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d944d4863d7a8cb82695f4601d5ab2eb9afdf91738e7f41738198574b1cdeb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "32f046e795625f4021213a3aa5ccb940526bb31e6128c16c1ac0428f94e97dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "37b1f7657f226c5f62ee5acb752c470a27c98ccd688a99403eca51696bb764ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b734e84320c0b0d18b6f7c005626c457d2cc593784846c584a71d5f011070a39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa64abc2903dbf3f90ae4e8b2e41dee899943e1d254498a579970f5f23262355", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "872d16ded97babfc182fe0c0e495ed1708ee87134ef8d3110e605c960b18a70f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6183848a6b396e8d351368bde6fc0f3be7125ac080ae4b9519eec1d95b6f8adb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d94ecafbd7cc7909cda32fd1853832bc78e0f2f7dd54aeceafb02c34936f9b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e3aa51b24375334a6b28d727af48188e5c0daa706d55850431b92c2cf07baaf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-original.ppm", + "sha256": "576dd05985e677f2268476886d87ba016fcac4927169bed5b39365b771c5bde3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36a73df1a2bd68ca78a189af9a9fb17355a9cadcb65783e7df2cfefa529081b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c241429b850a5d20818c9dd78184696c1631c991f04429ecc4fdb9a92c3ca46b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d10d52afcc7c547b2eaab1eac2cc3be291ddc89c5c5d518dcc13b66416cb3976", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2c942d9c19cb1384d6fd34f3083e8051413b11aa71b09bba5ace9f81c965c3f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108b3c22271faa45aa5c43859198c22fbdb083c24c18a80288061283bae9d1a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "be701e99bc926803ffbab6595ef1ec66c9dc451f2f47d1017061c9f8462ee0f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf6a1e4712a233400c5687a34987ea8332704958440620223c07577082e4edfc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "162a24b500a597dadb139e01557548c8f5c81d30d5e4766fa467dc1a2f33b8d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13d6aed360f87778296c7ac376e28812b36b45ae79ca29c1e1f53c3907fb4544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-original.ppm", + "sha256": "50af887f191e4dd9150559986f04f668b982b10514a2100a1a99242123f5708c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6cbb570bba40b8dc55886984d4b8cd85e9f2bf3e655289e102b5745face5b16d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "134d706f1bdbab4ff33b723d052a85fd2517e39046f8e6340e3498adddaf91f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ab88687e43871ab0f5da01ae4b1405712ca2e05c975d0688bc4f8826c627fdd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a09bf32551e65e375f9c0882972e6ca620cc98cb9adb02b59f5249ce16df42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75e07f7a0716808fc84c6d10e91d2877fc505235cd9178517a49adae645aee5d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db19dd301625261e0e2236b0036c624ca1b019bb3949f6fb5acbf7d5df325be4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "09b5cdd83bcb56dde10e91697a84725dcc5751fca835cb4c3332ab7e27d1a572", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "55da754def7e5bc52d0b759d776376b5b318a6ee22d7592c1ed305e98911c9d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4cf8d944587c4d4f12134bcf94d11158ce37254b26e2155cd7e1368f753c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f256b1ae087ecd3a614d6240937d33a8b980e2c68faf30730aa5f41b0d57f513", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4014f": { @@ -346704,7 +381711,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4014f", "family_id": "terrain-40145-40154", "job_id": "terrain-40145-40154", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -346720,6 +381727,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/candidate.json", "sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2344fd05aa5b7c66672308e99c535e5705923b8190304488208a0861cb927f2b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.766043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40145 retains its lower-left hollow cluster; 40146 retains the shallow central circular hollow; 40147 retains its two aligned depressions. Gallery-only40150/40151 retain occupied dark upper fissure backing. Native4014c/4014d/4014e/40153/40154 keep principal branching and star-junction placements.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 bb185aa389fce46555aea78a6a1683227216ecf2a5a8d635cc65f49b2a741eb1", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40145", + "40146", + "40147", + "40148" + ], + "sha256": "2118ba900c0c0e2423a8e70d6941c91a9f69f3f8fcbf9a1af901c40303c67bd7", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40149", + "4014a", + "4014b", + "4014c" + ], + "sha256": "0a5cbd63e0de911fc18a7edeaa007217dcfd9788adaede2c9d6c74f45364c145", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4014d", + "4014e", + "4014f", + "40150" + ], + "sha256": "2e7f0573e1d6ee9560ee01a5c3282fdd31c78192b96af3458b379c7467ccaced", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40151", + "40152", + "40153", + "40154" + ], + "sha256": "0b1b4ab14f02637594f12b6cc247190baa3994124dd0794558be10fd2d1bceba", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40145-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d3d70f233a01d7abd4f99f5785511bcb31dac038bed5413cabc5919cab4c3023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "712038c91c2f71c8ea7beb167c5d8f2c2287c84297778413a021b2041eae9089", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c8ed44987088709d60ea4601841a6fe03e0aee2836f0fe1271903777b35ac415", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3df2186222e743dbdf01202d15df6e757237e5286cab713aaa93204203bc757", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ff6a432d41188eb75be732b616e4cbac8c9351065cce8b23ebff926d09568d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2e2fd14c542ca7a499cdd111cb871297b91804b86caaad952806b0810ab0232f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6b9a0189815c49a13f07b5b2c9d2756c8819b5cf1130be813a40817bfd71c8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "183ccdaf00c2faa210d66cca9c0d55f20c106f8d1179d577a01d16b82c4fdf0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f7c11063e6718ea9664dac1c0a0dac3cdb091d1e67475a7b56eae5ebd3171aae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3ad735c66ba344d083c78394626f3093050b01fe339c8fcfce9184eca6b0904b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47cf688f58791501a4d9c72de1aae6c70fa0748434582dcaff023a062f07deb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "34344c20d4c890c4ed0e322140821675c54d72eb0c8f77a219373515340cb89b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2337cd2cb51b1bf08f1886a28b835d0efab680db6d70c85c5abd354454f86efd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f5a698a47610e48657fbf5f952737fb44f0c7bd30c3b51ed0150803d136cc7a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0ef70b37f1735ea91dc5b13aee07dbeab6f81f1928a9195be975055912986fbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37eeacd053883ac70308e1b076e84d75b70763e875a9941c29177c807cb0b378", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b0176ba6d6c12400f8c73cdb798130c06b93f672f70e0d73c7d631a0ead48ab4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "453ba7b0658ca37054dbef42d5ad8afe45b105fe2b15a7638bac7e4bbed7b89e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5b675158947fe902f96d22baa3b11bd401a695c6c3428034f4f190fdb03b872a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30f5fd28184fac4a0b21157bfc4ae306c73362822cc28f9ced29953ef9c2d02e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5751a4627be0ea4c5d4a635b401018e26e263c48a2dd9b28276bdb8281ac884b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "715c8d864841d54f0c39d895c19755d74da18d5857aa7d0862209c0d62b938bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6fee49860d4b68f0dcc2b03bc7703673aa90efc32aee96bc26d9b45fecd04eb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "35ee74f2d64f4bf2c295e9e75c87639165870593fba7f8a1463ed89d7b210c9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3edc9040b90398736e5a78a76d7c1952a08368305b4468444c75449806d00c9d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b7e34eac197540f8e3271bcdf73c137d0e9a0f8c8d1d9df41a8d68eb70d79646", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e86404d4d0bf397ad60e791edb18757e1659a0b188ba183e204317af46233710", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "607c10ed2b7ff31161c81db47927047fc4983c42c42135f7d6334dc852e8c208", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e638432b60f1eca0d66ee07b4f96c33e4e7d84e4c25c3331282173661598483", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "96c61d79de108b033f65d19d6c9599cb3cf191aafe50bbd5d0300efa3d690490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b4f67a2e1973d62a0e7ccd26295b0b973b776cecfc5149498e6a689eea7a690e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7346d5f88722c03895376cbc42f5961581e5c01dff245416e8661730bfc96a6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ff9e1ea59e6cdf8be1d2b00892fec9f7c69e1d49f7390d7c0e1be4f8008c29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36c37ee3a3539a991f457b0936fcb50d7ec2404c049e4eea9f79b52095c6424", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e186b4dc36b0c9ad581d57924014764f3abbe04d15def19024090213fe857d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0c452dca8986320b8a6fe724a9cf310f856dbfe84596f83e5508df8947af2a25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0fcc271ecc1b71ad4219976b58a976537849c70c584c485a2eb1298eb8fcecd6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7942f0600eb6386e8928fd6f4850910cfad42a983592ea20dc08aeff66876f4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "df4296686502f7cbee4de63946c5e7c130a1e9f38119b71bdb115c8096754f19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e9920c7eabf49a704c88367e5c30d3774bcb810019725189e307e7a3eee2b30c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9858fac0ccbe5f431c872256ea80eeceaac1796474443d86448adc9fdc668594", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "30e567de236a8d621adc4f8034447dfde50869ed6e80cc1444385a6790700905", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c58e51280ad84e332d145973d8c45630480c90d3d4803a1c855f89bbe91f1851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b95aa16bb1913d6689693d3861e833c986f94073176d470fea4e0f26049e4241", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e0d9c3855b0f1ddc258a1648ac62539f5bbd4f1a78ded6a032b1ba3bc5960fc8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "14c36f40ee716610c6a4408fd209cf8454ce57ae4fc097d9c7431b4a74e402b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a871534279e983547fcbdbfe789349d034abe113b41583a46a503f44e7996b4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf87cf24e0a27e5ab7fe118f654bdc2980fa5ae25032673d569dda9cf4705ea3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eacd52d9fc804f1c58108655cc294a9b7fdcbb2f992b12405fc1394ce27c4c09", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8e16e3e7a3d814d85d0c0e7b4b10468bf8f7bdf0316b36ec383a1104919e22c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d944d4863d7a8cb82695f4601d5ab2eb9afdf91738e7f41738198574b1cdeb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "32f046e795625f4021213a3aa5ccb940526bb31e6128c16c1ac0428f94e97dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "37b1f7657f226c5f62ee5acb752c470a27c98ccd688a99403eca51696bb764ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b734e84320c0b0d18b6f7c005626c457d2cc593784846c584a71d5f011070a39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa64abc2903dbf3f90ae4e8b2e41dee899943e1d254498a579970f5f23262355", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "872d16ded97babfc182fe0c0e495ed1708ee87134ef8d3110e605c960b18a70f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6183848a6b396e8d351368bde6fc0f3be7125ac080ae4b9519eec1d95b6f8adb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d94ecafbd7cc7909cda32fd1853832bc78e0f2f7dd54aeceafb02c34936f9b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e3aa51b24375334a6b28d727af48188e5c0daa706d55850431b92c2cf07baaf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-original.ppm", + "sha256": "576dd05985e677f2268476886d87ba016fcac4927169bed5b39365b771c5bde3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36a73df1a2bd68ca78a189af9a9fb17355a9cadcb65783e7df2cfefa529081b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c241429b850a5d20818c9dd78184696c1631c991f04429ecc4fdb9a92c3ca46b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d10d52afcc7c547b2eaab1eac2cc3be291ddc89c5c5d518dcc13b66416cb3976", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2c942d9c19cb1384d6fd34f3083e8051413b11aa71b09bba5ace9f81c965c3f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108b3c22271faa45aa5c43859198c22fbdb083c24c18a80288061283bae9d1a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "be701e99bc926803ffbab6595ef1ec66c9dc451f2f47d1017061c9f8462ee0f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf6a1e4712a233400c5687a34987ea8332704958440620223c07577082e4edfc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "162a24b500a597dadb139e01557548c8f5c81d30d5e4766fa467dc1a2f33b8d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13d6aed360f87778296c7ac376e28812b36b45ae79ca29c1e1f53c3907fb4544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-original.ppm", + "sha256": "50af887f191e4dd9150559986f04f668b982b10514a2100a1a99242123f5708c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6cbb570bba40b8dc55886984d4b8cd85e9f2bf3e655289e102b5745face5b16d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "134d706f1bdbab4ff33b723d052a85fd2517e39046f8e6340e3498adddaf91f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ab88687e43871ab0f5da01ae4b1405712ca2e05c975d0688bc4f8826c627fdd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a09bf32551e65e375f9c0882972e6ca620cc98cb9adb02b59f5249ce16df42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75e07f7a0716808fc84c6d10e91d2877fc505235cd9178517a49adae645aee5d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db19dd301625261e0e2236b0036c624ca1b019bb3949f6fb5acbf7d5df325be4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "09b5cdd83bcb56dde10e91697a84725dcc5751fca835cb4c3332ab7e27d1a572", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "55da754def7e5bc52d0b759d776376b5b318a6ee22d7592c1ed305e98911c9d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4cf8d944587c4d4f12134bcf94d11158ce37254b26e2155cd7e1368f753c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f256b1ae087ecd3a614d6240937d33a8b980e2c68faf30730aa5f41b0d57f513", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40150": { @@ -346741,7 +382218,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40150", "family_id": "terrain-40145-40154", "job_id": "terrain-40145-40154", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -346757,6 +382234,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/candidate.json", "sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2344fd05aa5b7c66672308e99c535e5705923b8190304488208a0861cb927f2b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.766043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40145 retains its lower-left hollow cluster; 40146 retains the shallow central circular hollow; 40147 retains its two aligned depressions. Gallery-only40150/40151 retain occupied dark upper fissure backing. Native4014c/4014d/4014e/40153/40154 keep principal branching and star-junction placements.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 bb185aa389fce46555aea78a6a1683227216ecf2a5a8d635cc65f49b2a741eb1", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40145", + "40146", + "40147", + "40148" + ], + "sha256": "2118ba900c0c0e2423a8e70d6941c91a9f69f3f8fcbf9a1af901c40303c67bd7", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40149", + "4014a", + "4014b", + "4014c" + ], + "sha256": "0a5cbd63e0de911fc18a7edeaa007217dcfd9788adaede2c9d6c74f45364c145", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4014d", + "4014e", + "4014f", + "40150" + ], + "sha256": "2e7f0573e1d6ee9560ee01a5c3282fdd31c78192b96af3458b379c7467ccaced", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40151", + "40152", + "40153", + "40154" + ], + "sha256": "0b1b4ab14f02637594f12b6cc247190baa3994124dd0794558be10fd2d1bceba", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40145-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d3d70f233a01d7abd4f99f5785511bcb31dac038bed5413cabc5919cab4c3023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "712038c91c2f71c8ea7beb167c5d8f2c2287c84297778413a021b2041eae9089", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c8ed44987088709d60ea4601841a6fe03e0aee2836f0fe1271903777b35ac415", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3df2186222e743dbdf01202d15df6e757237e5286cab713aaa93204203bc757", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ff6a432d41188eb75be732b616e4cbac8c9351065cce8b23ebff926d09568d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2e2fd14c542ca7a499cdd111cb871297b91804b86caaad952806b0810ab0232f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6b9a0189815c49a13f07b5b2c9d2756c8819b5cf1130be813a40817bfd71c8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "183ccdaf00c2faa210d66cca9c0d55f20c106f8d1179d577a01d16b82c4fdf0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f7c11063e6718ea9664dac1c0a0dac3cdb091d1e67475a7b56eae5ebd3171aae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3ad735c66ba344d083c78394626f3093050b01fe339c8fcfce9184eca6b0904b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47cf688f58791501a4d9c72de1aae6c70fa0748434582dcaff023a062f07deb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "34344c20d4c890c4ed0e322140821675c54d72eb0c8f77a219373515340cb89b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2337cd2cb51b1bf08f1886a28b835d0efab680db6d70c85c5abd354454f86efd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f5a698a47610e48657fbf5f952737fb44f0c7bd30c3b51ed0150803d136cc7a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0ef70b37f1735ea91dc5b13aee07dbeab6f81f1928a9195be975055912986fbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37eeacd053883ac70308e1b076e84d75b70763e875a9941c29177c807cb0b378", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b0176ba6d6c12400f8c73cdb798130c06b93f672f70e0d73c7d631a0ead48ab4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "453ba7b0658ca37054dbef42d5ad8afe45b105fe2b15a7638bac7e4bbed7b89e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5b675158947fe902f96d22baa3b11bd401a695c6c3428034f4f190fdb03b872a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30f5fd28184fac4a0b21157bfc4ae306c73362822cc28f9ced29953ef9c2d02e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5751a4627be0ea4c5d4a635b401018e26e263c48a2dd9b28276bdb8281ac884b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "715c8d864841d54f0c39d895c19755d74da18d5857aa7d0862209c0d62b938bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6fee49860d4b68f0dcc2b03bc7703673aa90efc32aee96bc26d9b45fecd04eb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "35ee74f2d64f4bf2c295e9e75c87639165870593fba7f8a1463ed89d7b210c9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3edc9040b90398736e5a78a76d7c1952a08368305b4468444c75449806d00c9d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b7e34eac197540f8e3271bcdf73c137d0e9a0f8c8d1d9df41a8d68eb70d79646", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e86404d4d0bf397ad60e791edb18757e1659a0b188ba183e204317af46233710", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "607c10ed2b7ff31161c81db47927047fc4983c42c42135f7d6334dc852e8c208", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e638432b60f1eca0d66ee07b4f96c33e4e7d84e4c25c3331282173661598483", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "96c61d79de108b033f65d19d6c9599cb3cf191aafe50bbd5d0300efa3d690490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b4f67a2e1973d62a0e7ccd26295b0b973b776cecfc5149498e6a689eea7a690e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7346d5f88722c03895376cbc42f5961581e5c01dff245416e8661730bfc96a6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ff9e1ea59e6cdf8be1d2b00892fec9f7c69e1d49f7390d7c0e1be4f8008c29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36c37ee3a3539a991f457b0936fcb50d7ec2404c049e4eea9f79b52095c6424", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e186b4dc36b0c9ad581d57924014764f3abbe04d15def19024090213fe857d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0c452dca8986320b8a6fe724a9cf310f856dbfe84596f83e5508df8947af2a25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0fcc271ecc1b71ad4219976b58a976537849c70c584c485a2eb1298eb8fcecd6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7942f0600eb6386e8928fd6f4850910cfad42a983592ea20dc08aeff66876f4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "df4296686502f7cbee4de63946c5e7c130a1e9f38119b71bdb115c8096754f19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e9920c7eabf49a704c88367e5c30d3774bcb810019725189e307e7a3eee2b30c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9858fac0ccbe5f431c872256ea80eeceaac1796474443d86448adc9fdc668594", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "30e567de236a8d621adc4f8034447dfde50869ed6e80cc1444385a6790700905", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c58e51280ad84e332d145973d8c45630480c90d3d4803a1c855f89bbe91f1851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b95aa16bb1913d6689693d3861e833c986f94073176d470fea4e0f26049e4241", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e0d9c3855b0f1ddc258a1648ac62539f5bbd4f1a78ded6a032b1ba3bc5960fc8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "14c36f40ee716610c6a4408fd209cf8454ce57ae4fc097d9c7431b4a74e402b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a871534279e983547fcbdbfe789349d034abe113b41583a46a503f44e7996b4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf87cf24e0a27e5ab7fe118f654bdc2980fa5ae25032673d569dda9cf4705ea3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eacd52d9fc804f1c58108655cc294a9b7fdcbb2f992b12405fc1394ce27c4c09", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8e16e3e7a3d814d85d0c0e7b4b10468bf8f7bdf0316b36ec383a1104919e22c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d944d4863d7a8cb82695f4601d5ab2eb9afdf91738e7f41738198574b1cdeb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "32f046e795625f4021213a3aa5ccb940526bb31e6128c16c1ac0428f94e97dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "37b1f7657f226c5f62ee5acb752c470a27c98ccd688a99403eca51696bb764ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b734e84320c0b0d18b6f7c005626c457d2cc593784846c584a71d5f011070a39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa64abc2903dbf3f90ae4e8b2e41dee899943e1d254498a579970f5f23262355", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "872d16ded97babfc182fe0c0e495ed1708ee87134ef8d3110e605c960b18a70f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6183848a6b396e8d351368bde6fc0f3be7125ac080ae4b9519eec1d95b6f8adb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d94ecafbd7cc7909cda32fd1853832bc78e0f2f7dd54aeceafb02c34936f9b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e3aa51b24375334a6b28d727af48188e5c0daa706d55850431b92c2cf07baaf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-original.ppm", + "sha256": "576dd05985e677f2268476886d87ba016fcac4927169bed5b39365b771c5bde3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36a73df1a2bd68ca78a189af9a9fb17355a9cadcb65783e7df2cfefa529081b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c241429b850a5d20818c9dd78184696c1631c991f04429ecc4fdb9a92c3ca46b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d10d52afcc7c547b2eaab1eac2cc3be291ddc89c5c5d518dcc13b66416cb3976", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2c942d9c19cb1384d6fd34f3083e8051413b11aa71b09bba5ace9f81c965c3f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108b3c22271faa45aa5c43859198c22fbdb083c24c18a80288061283bae9d1a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "be701e99bc926803ffbab6595ef1ec66c9dc451f2f47d1017061c9f8462ee0f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf6a1e4712a233400c5687a34987ea8332704958440620223c07577082e4edfc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "162a24b500a597dadb139e01557548c8f5c81d30d5e4766fa467dc1a2f33b8d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13d6aed360f87778296c7ac376e28812b36b45ae79ca29c1e1f53c3907fb4544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-original.ppm", + "sha256": "50af887f191e4dd9150559986f04f668b982b10514a2100a1a99242123f5708c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6cbb570bba40b8dc55886984d4b8cd85e9f2bf3e655289e102b5745face5b16d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "134d706f1bdbab4ff33b723d052a85fd2517e39046f8e6340e3498adddaf91f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ab88687e43871ab0f5da01ae4b1405712ca2e05c975d0688bc4f8826c627fdd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a09bf32551e65e375f9c0882972e6ca620cc98cb9adb02b59f5249ce16df42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75e07f7a0716808fc84c6d10e91d2877fc505235cd9178517a49adae645aee5d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db19dd301625261e0e2236b0036c624ca1b019bb3949f6fb5acbf7d5df325be4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "09b5cdd83bcb56dde10e91697a84725dcc5751fca835cb4c3332ab7e27d1a572", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "55da754def7e5bc52d0b759d776376b5b318a6ee22d7592c1ed305e98911c9d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4cf8d944587c4d4f12134bcf94d11158ce37254b26e2155cd7e1368f753c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f256b1ae087ecd3a614d6240937d33a8b980e2c68faf30730aa5f41b0d57f513", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40151": { @@ -346778,7 +382725,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40151", "family_id": "terrain-40145-40154", "job_id": "terrain-40145-40154", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -346794,6 +382741,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/candidate.json", "sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2344fd05aa5b7c66672308e99c535e5705923b8190304488208a0861cb927f2b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.766043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40145 retains its lower-left hollow cluster; 40146 retains the shallow central circular hollow; 40147 retains its two aligned depressions. Gallery-only40150/40151 retain occupied dark upper fissure backing. Native4014c/4014d/4014e/40153/40154 keep principal branching and star-junction placements.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 bb185aa389fce46555aea78a6a1683227216ecf2a5a8d635cc65f49b2a741eb1", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40145", + "40146", + "40147", + "40148" + ], + "sha256": "2118ba900c0c0e2423a8e70d6941c91a9f69f3f8fcbf9a1af901c40303c67bd7", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40149", + "4014a", + "4014b", + "4014c" + ], + "sha256": "0a5cbd63e0de911fc18a7edeaa007217dcfd9788adaede2c9d6c74f45364c145", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4014d", + "4014e", + "4014f", + "40150" + ], + "sha256": "2e7f0573e1d6ee9560ee01a5c3282fdd31c78192b96af3458b379c7467ccaced", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40151", + "40152", + "40153", + "40154" + ], + "sha256": "0b1b4ab14f02637594f12b6cc247190baa3994124dd0794558be10fd2d1bceba", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40145-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d3d70f233a01d7abd4f99f5785511bcb31dac038bed5413cabc5919cab4c3023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "712038c91c2f71c8ea7beb167c5d8f2c2287c84297778413a021b2041eae9089", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c8ed44987088709d60ea4601841a6fe03e0aee2836f0fe1271903777b35ac415", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3df2186222e743dbdf01202d15df6e757237e5286cab713aaa93204203bc757", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ff6a432d41188eb75be732b616e4cbac8c9351065cce8b23ebff926d09568d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2e2fd14c542ca7a499cdd111cb871297b91804b86caaad952806b0810ab0232f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6b9a0189815c49a13f07b5b2c9d2756c8819b5cf1130be813a40817bfd71c8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "183ccdaf00c2faa210d66cca9c0d55f20c106f8d1179d577a01d16b82c4fdf0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f7c11063e6718ea9664dac1c0a0dac3cdb091d1e67475a7b56eae5ebd3171aae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3ad735c66ba344d083c78394626f3093050b01fe339c8fcfce9184eca6b0904b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47cf688f58791501a4d9c72de1aae6c70fa0748434582dcaff023a062f07deb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "34344c20d4c890c4ed0e322140821675c54d72eb0c8f77a219373515340cb89b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2337cd2cb51b1bf08f1886a28b835d0efab680db6d70c85c5abd354454f86efd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f5a698a47610e48657fbf5f952737fb44f0c7bd30c3b51ed0150803d136cc7a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0ef70b37f1735ea91dc5b13aee07dbeab6f81f1928a9195be975055912986fbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37eeacd053883ac70308e1b076e84d75b70763e875a9941c29177c807cb0b378", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b0176ba6d6c12400f8c73cdb798130c06b93f672f70e0d73c7d631a0ead48ab4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "453ba7b0658ca37054dbef42d5ad8afe45b105fe2b15a7638bac7e4bbed7b89e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5b675158947fe902f96d22baa3b11bd401a695c6c3428034f4f190fdb03b872a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30f5fd28184fac4a0b21157bfc4ae306c73362822cc28f9ced29953ef9c2d02e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5751a4627be0ea4c5d4a635b401018e26e263c48a2dd9b28276bdb8281ac884b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "715c8d864841d54f0c39d895c19755d74da18d5857aa7d0862209c0d62b938bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6fee49860d4b68f0dcc2b03bc7703673aa90efc32aee96bc26d9b45fecd04eb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "35ee74f2d64f4bf2c295e9e75c87639165870593fba7f8a1463ed89d7b210c9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3edc9040b90398736e5a78a76d7c1952a08368305b4468444c75449806d00c9d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b7e34eac197540f8e3271bcdf73c137d0e9a0f8c8d1d9df41a8d68eb70d79646", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e86404d4d0bf397ad60e791edb18757e1659a0b188ba183e204317af46233710", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "607c10ed2b7ff31161c81db47927047fc4983c42c42135f7d6334dc852e8c208", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e638432b60f1eca0d66ee07b4f96c33e4e7d84e4c25c3331282173661598483", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "96c61d79de108b033f65d19d6c9599cb3cf191aafe50bbd5d0300efa3d690490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b4f67a2e1973d62a0e7ccd26295b0b973b776cecfc5149498e6a689eea7a690e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7346d5f88722c03895376cbc42f5961581e5c01dff245416e8661730bfc96a6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ff9e1ea59e6cdf8be1d2b00892fec9f7c69e1d49f7390d7c0e1be4f8008c29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36c37ee3a3539a991f457b0936fcb50d7ec2404c049e4eea9f79b52095c6424", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e186b4dc36b0c9ad581d57924014764f3abbe04d15def19024090213fe857d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0c452dca8986320b8a6fe724a9cf310f856dbfe84596f83e5508df8947af2a25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0fcc271ecc1b71ad4219976b58a976537849c70c584c485a2eb1298eb8fcecd6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7942f0600eb6386e8928fd6f4850910cfad42a983592ea20dc08aeff66876f4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "df4296686502f7cbee4de63946c5e7c130a1e9f38119b71bdb115c8096754f19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e9920c7eabf49a704c88367e5c30d3774bcb810019725189e307e7a3eee2b30c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9858fac0ccbe5f431c872256ea80eeceaac1796474443d86448adc9fdc668594", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "30e567de236a8d621adc4f8034447dfde50869ed6e80cc1444385a6790700905", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c58e51280ad84e332d145973d8c45630480c90d3d4803a1c855f89bbe91f1851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b95aa16bb1913d6689693d3861e833c986f94073176d470fea4e0f26049e4241", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e0d9c3855b0f1ddc258a1648ac62539f5bbd4f1a78ded6a032b1ba3bc5960fc8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "14c36f40ee716610c6a4408fd209cf8454ce57ae4fc097d9c7431b4a74e402b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a871534279e983547fcbdbfe789349d034abe113b41583a46a503f44e7996b4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf87cf24e0a27e5ab7fe118f654bdc2980fa5ae25032673d569dda9cf4705ea3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eacd52d9fc804f1c58108655cc294a9b7fdcbb2f992b12405fc1394ce27c4c09", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8e16e3e7a3d814d85d0c0e7b4b10468bf8f7bdf0316b36ec383a1104919e22c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d944d4863d7a8cb82695f4601d5ab2eb9afdf91738e7f41738198574b1cdeb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "32f046e795625f4021213a3aa5ccb940526bb31e6128c16c1ac0428f94e97dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "37b1f7657f226c5f62ee5acb752c470a27c98ccd688a99403eca51696bb764ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b734e84320c0b0d18b6f7c005626c457d2cc593784846c584a71d5f011070a39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa64abc2903dbf3f90ae4e8b2e41dee899943e1d254498a579970f5f23262355", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "872d16ded97babfc182fe0c0e495ed1708ee87134ef8d3110e605c960b18a70f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6183848a6b396e8d351368bde6fc0f3be7125ac080ae4b9519eec1d95b6f8adb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d94ecafbd7cc7909cda32fd1853832bc78e0f2f7dd54aeceafb02c34936f9b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e3aa51b24375334a6b28d727af48188e5c0daa706d55850431b92c2cf07baaf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-original.ppm", + "sha256": "576dd05985e677f2268476886d87ba016fcac4927169bed5b39365b771c5bde3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36a73df1a2bd68ca78a189af9a9fb17355a9cadcb65783e7df2cfefa529081b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c241429b850a5d20818c9dd78184696c1631c991f04429ecc4fdb9a92c3ca46b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d10d52afcc7c547b2eaab1eac2cc3be291ddc89c5c5d518dcc13b66416cb3976", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2c942d9c19cb1384d6fd34f3083e8051413b11aa71b09bba5ace9f81c965c3f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108b3c22271faa45aa5c43859198c22fbdb083c24c18a80288061283bae9d1a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "be701e99bc926803ffbab6595ef1ec66c9dc451f2f47d1017061c9f8462ee0f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf6a1e4712a233400c5687a34987ea8332704958440620223c07577082e4edfc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "162a24b500a597dadb139e01557548c8f5c81d30d5e4766fa467dc1a2f33b8d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13d6aed360f87778296c7ac376e28812b36b45ae79ca29c1e1f53c3907fb4544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-original.ppm", + "sha256": "50af887f191e4dd9150559986f04f668b982b10514a2100a1a99242123f5708c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6cbb570bba40b8dc55886984d4b8cd85e9f2bf3e655289e102b5745face5b16d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "134d706f1bdbab4ff33b723d052a85fd2517e39046f8e6340e3498adddaf91f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ab88687e43871ab0f5da01ae4b1405712ca2e05c975d0688bc4f8826c627fdd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a09bf32551e65e375f9c0882972e6ca620cc98cb9adb02b59f5249ce16df42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75e07f7a0716808fc84c6d10e91d2877fc505235cd9178517a49adae645aee5d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db19dd301625261e0e2236b0036c624ca1b019bb3949f6fb5acbf7d5df325be4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "09b5cdd83bcb56dde10e91697a84725dcc5751fca835cb4c3332ab7e27d1a572", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "55da754def7e5bc52d0b759d776376b5b318a6ee22d7592c1ed305e98911c9d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4cf8d944587c4d4f12134bcf94d11158ce37254b26e2155cd7e1368f753c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f256b1ae087ecd3a614d6240937d33a8b980e2c68faf30730aa5f41b0d57f513", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40152": { @@ -346815,7 +383232,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40152", "family_id": "terrain-40145-40154", "job_id": "terrain-40145-40154", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -346831,6 +383248,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/candidate.json", "sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2344fd05aa5b7c66672308e99c535e5705923b8190304488208a0861cb927f2b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.766043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40145 retains its lower-left hollow cluster; 40146 retains the shallow central circular hollow; 40147 retains its two aligned depressions. Gallery-only40150/40151 retain occupied dark upper fissure backing. Native4014c/4014d/4014e/40153/40154 keep principal branching and star-junction placements.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 bb185aa389fce46555aea78a6a1683227216ecf2a5a8d635cc65f49b2a741eb1", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40145", + "40146", + "40147", + "40148" + ], + "sha256": "2118ba900c0c0e2423a8e70d6941c91a9f69f3f8fcbf9a1af901c40303c67bd7", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40149", + "4014a", + "4014b", + "4014c" + ], + "sha256": "0a5cbd63e0de911fc18a7edeaa007217dcfd9788adaede2c9d6c74f45364c145", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4014d", + "4014e", + "4014f", + "40150" + ], + "sha256": "2e7f0573e1d6ee9560ee01a5c3282fdd31c78192b96af3458b379c7467ccaced", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40151", + "40152", + "40153", + "40154" + ], + "sha256": "0b1b4ab14f02637594f12b6cc247190baa3994124dd0794558be10fd2d1bceba", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40145-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d3d70f233a01d7abd4f99f5785511bcb31dac038bed5413cabc5919cab4c3023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "712038c91c2f71c8ea7beb167c5d8f2c2287c84297778413a021b2041eae9089", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c8ed44987088709d60ea4601841a6fe03e0aee2836f0fe1271903777b35ac415", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3df2186222e743dbdf01202d15df6e757237e5286cab713aaa93204203bc757", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ff6a432d41188eb75be732b616e4cbac8c9351065cce8b23ebff926d09568d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2e2fd14c542ca7a499cdd111cb871297b91804b86caaad952806b0810ab0232f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6b9a0189815c49a13f07b5b2c9d2756c8819b5cf1130be813a40817bfd71c8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "183ccdaf00c2faa210d66cca9c0d55f20c106f8d1179d577a01d16b82c4fdf0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f7c11063e6718ea9664dac1c0a0dac3cdb091d1e67475a7b56eae5ebd3171aae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3ad735c66ba344d083c78394626f3093050b01fe339c8fcfce9184eca6b0904b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47cf688f58791501a4d9c72de1aae6c70fa0748434582dcaff023a062f07deb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "34344c20d4c890c4ed0e322140821675c54d72eb0c8f77a219373515340cb89b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2337cd2cb51b1bf08f1886a28b835d0efab680db6d70c85c5abd354454f86efd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f5a698a47610e48657fbf5f952737fb44f0c7bd30c3b51ed0150803d136cc7a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0ef70b37f1735ea91dc5b13aee07dbeab6f81f1928a9195be975055912986fbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37eeacd053883ac70308e1b076e84d75b70763e875a9941c29177c807cb0b378", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b0176ba6d6c12400f8c73cdb798130c06b93f672f70e0d73c7d631a0ead48ab4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "453ba7b0658ca37054dbef42d5ad8afe45b105fe2b15a7638bac7e4bbed7b89e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5b675158947fe902f96d22baa3b11bd401a695c6c3428034f4f190fdb03b872a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30f5fd28184fac4a0b21157bfc4ae306c73362822cc28f9ced29953ef9c2d02e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5751a4627be0ea4c5d4a635b401018e26e263c48a2dd9b28276bdb8281ac884b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "715c8d864841d54f0c39d895c19755d74da18d5857aa7d0862209c0d62b938bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6fee49860d4b68f0dcc2b03bc7703673aa90efc32aee96bc26d9b45fecd04eb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "35ee74f2d64f4bf2c295e9e75c87639165870593fba7f8a1463ed89d7b210c9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3edc9040b90398736e5a78a76d7c1952a08368305b4468444c75449806d00c9d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b7e34eac197540f8e3271bcdf73c137d0e9a0f8c8d1d9df41a8d68eb70d79646", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e86404d4d0bf397ad60e791edb18757e1659a0b188ba183e204317af46233710", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "607c10ed2b7ff31161c81db47927047fc4983c42c42135f7d6334dc852e8c208", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e638432b60f1eca0d66ee07b4f96c33e4e7d84e4c25c3331282173661598483", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "96c61d79de108b033f65d19d6c9599cb3cf191aafe50bbd5d0300efa3d690490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b4f67a2e1973d62a0e7ccd26295b0b973b776cecfc5149498e6a689eea7a690e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7346d5f88722c03895376cbc42f5961581e5c01dff245416e8661730bfc96a6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ff9e1ea59e6cdf8be1d2b00892fec9f7c69e1d49f7390d7c0e1be4f8008c29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36c37ee3a3539a991f457b0936fcb50d7ec2404c049e4eea9f79b52095c6424", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e186b4dc36b0c9ad581d57924014764f3abbe04d15def19024090213fe857d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0c452dca8986320b8a6fe724a9cf310f856dbfe84596f83e5508df8947af2a25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0fcc271ecc1b71ad4219976b58a976537849c70c584c485a2eb1298eb8fcecd6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7942f0600eb6386e8928fd6f4850910cfad42a983592ea20dc08aeff66876f4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "df4296686502f7cbee4de63946c5e7c130a1e9f38119b71bdb115c8096754f19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e9920c7eabf49a704c88367e5c30d3774bcb810019725189e307e7a3eee2b30c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9858fac0ccbe5f431c872256ea80eeceaac1796474443d86448adc9fdc668594", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "30e567de236a8d621adc4f8034447dfde50869ed6e80cc1444385a6790700905", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c58e51280ad84e332d145973d8c45630480c90d3d4803a1c855f89bbe91f1851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b95aa16bb1913d6689693d3861e833c986f94073176d470fea4e0f26049e4241", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e0d9c3855b0f1ddc258a1648ac62539f5bbd4f1a78ded6a032b1ba3bc5960fc8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "14c36f40ee716610c6a4408fd209cf8454ce57ae4fc097d9c7431b4a74e402b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a871534279e983547fcbdbfe789349d034abe113b41583a46a503f44e7996b4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf87cf24e0a27e5ab7fe118f654bdc2980fa5ae25032673d569dda9cf4705ea3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eacd52d9fc804f1c58108655cc294a9b7fdcbb2f992b12405fc1394ce27c4c09", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8e16e3e7a3d814d85d0c0e7b4b10468bf8f7bdf0316b36ec383a1104919e22c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d944d4863d7a8cb82695f4601d5ab2eb9afdf91738e7f41738198574b1cdeb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "32f046e795625f4021213a3aa5ccb940526bb31e6128c16c1ac0428f94e97dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "37b1f7657f226c5f62ee5acb752c470a27c98ccd688a99403eca51696bb764ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b734e84320c0b0d18b6f7c005626c457d2cc593784846c584a71d5f011070a39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa64abc2903dbf3f90ae4e8b2e41dee899943e1d254498a579970f5f23262355", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "872d16ded97babfc182fe0c0e495ed1708ee87134ef8d3110e605c960b18a70f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6183848a6b396e8d351368bde6fc0f3be7125ac080ae4b9519eec1d95b6f8adb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d94ecafbd7cc7909cda32fd1853832bc78e0f2f7dd54aeceafb02c34936f9b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e3aa51b24375334a6b28d727af48188e5c0daa706d55850431b92c2cf07baaf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-original.ppm", + "sha256": "576dd05985e677f2268476886d87ba016fcac4927169bed5b39365b771c5bde3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36a73df1a2bd68ca78a189af9a9fb17355a9cadcb65783e7df2cfefa529081b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c241429b850a5d20818c9dd78184696c1631c991f04429ecc4fdb9a92c3ca46b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d10d52afcc7c547b2eaab1eac2cc3be291ddc89c5c5d518dcc13b66416cb3976", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2c942d9c19cb1384d6fd34f3083e8051413b11aa71b09bba5ace9f81c965c3f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108b3c22271faa45aa5c43859198c22fbdb083c24c18a80288061283bae9d1a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "be701e99bc926803ffbab6595ef1ec66c9dc451f2f47d1017061c9f8462ee0f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf6a1e4712a233400c5687a34987ea8332704958440620223c07577082e4edfc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "162a24b500a597dadb139e01557548c8f5c81d30d5e4766fa467dc1a2f33b8d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13d6aed360f87778296c7ac376e28812b36b45ae79ca29c1e1f53c3907fb4544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-original.ppm", + "sha256": "50af887f191e4dd9150559986f04f668b982b10514a2100a1a99242123f5708c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6cbb570bba40b8dc55886984d4b8cd85e9f2bf3e655289e102b5745face5b16d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "134d706f1bdbab4ff33b723d052a85fd2517e39046f8e6340e3498adddaf91f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ab88687e43871ab0f5da01ae4b1405712ca2e05c975d0688bc4f8826c627fdd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a09bf32551e65e375f9c0882972e6ca620cc98cb9adb02b59f5249ce16df42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75e07f7a0716808fc84c6d10e91d2877fc505235cd9178517a49adae645aee5d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db19dd301625261e0e2236b0036c624ca1b019bb3949f6fb5acbf7d5df325be4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "09b5cdd83bcb56dde10e91697a84725dcc5751fca835cb4c3332ab7e27d1a572", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "55da754def7e5bc52d0b759d776376b5b318a6ee22d7592c1ed305e98911c9d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4cf8d944587c4d4f12134bcf94d11158ce37254b26e2155cd7e1368f753c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f256b1ae087ecd3a614d6240937d33a8b980e2c68faf30730aa5f41b0d57f513", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40153": { @@ -346852,7 +383739,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40153", "family_id": "terrain-40145-40154", "job_id": "terrain-40145-40154", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -346868,6 +383755,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/candidate.json", "sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2344fd05aa5b7c66672308e99c535e5705923b8190304488208a0861cb927f2b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.766043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40145 retains its lower-left hollow cluster; 40146 retains the shallow central circular hollow; 40147 retains its two aligned depressions. Gallery-only40150/40151 retain occupied dark upper fissure backing. Native4014c/4014d/4014e/40153/40154 keep principal branching and star-junction placements.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 bb185aa389fce46555aea78a6a1683227216ecf2a5a8d635cc65f49b2a741eb1", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40145", + "40146", + "40147", + "40148" + ], + "sha256": "2118ba900c0c0e2423a8e70d6941c91a9f69f3f8fcbf9a1af901c40303c67bd7", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40149", + "4014a", + "4014b", + "4014c" + ], + "sha256": "0a5cbd63e0de911fc18a7edeaa007217dcfd9788adaede2c9d6c74f45364c145", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4014d", + "4014e", + "4014f", + "40150" + ], + "sha256": "2e7f0573e1d6ee9560ee01a5c3282fdd31c78192b96af3458b379c7467ccaced", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40151", + "40152", + "40153", + "40154" + ], + "sha256": "0b1b4ab14f02637594f12b6cc247190baa3994124dd0794558be10fd2d1bceba", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40145-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d3d70f233a01d7abd4f99f5785511bcb31dac038bed5413cabc5919cab4c3023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "712038c91c2f71c8ea7beb167c5d8f2c2287c84297778413a021b2041eae9089", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c8ed44987088709d60ea4601841a6fe03e0aee2836f0fe1271903777b35ac415", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3df2186222e743dbdf01202d15df6e757237e5286cab713aaa93204203bc757", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ff6a432d41188eb75be732b616e4cbac8c9351065cce8b23ebff926d09568d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2e2fd14c542ca7a499cdd111cb871297b91804b86caaad952806b0810ab0232f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6b9a0189815c49a13f07b5b2c9d2756c8819b5cf1130be813a40817bfd71c8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "183ccdaf00c2faa210d66cca9c0d55f20c106f8d1179d577a01d16b82c4fdf0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f7c11063e6718ea9664dac1c0a0dac3cdb091d1e67475a7b56eae5ebd3171aae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3ad735c66ba344d083c78394626f3093050b01fe339c8fcfce9184eca6b0904b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47cf688f58791501a4d9c72de1aae6c70fa0748434582dcaff023a062f07deb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "34344c20d4c890c4ed0e322140821675c54d72eb0c8f77a219373515340cb89b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2337cd2cb51b1bf08f1886a28b835d0efab680db6d70c85c5abd354454f86efd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f5a698a47610e48657fbf5f952737fb44f0c7bd30c3b51ed0150803d136cc7a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0ef70b37f1735ea91dc5b13aee07dbeab6f81f1928a9195be975055912986fbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37eeacd053883ac70308e1b076e84d75b70763e875a9941c29177c807cb0b378", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b0176ba6d6c12400f8c73cdb798130c06b93f672f70e0d73c7d631a0ead48ab4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "453ba7b0658ca37054dbef42d5ad8afe45b105fe2b15a7638bac7e4bbed7b89e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5b675158947fe902f96d22baa3b11bd401a695c6c3428034f4f190fdb03b872a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30f5fd28184fac4a0b21157bfc4ae306c73362822cc28f9ced29953ef9c2d02e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5751a4627be0ea4c5d4a635b401018e26e263c48a2dd9b28276bdb8281ac884b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "715c8d864841d54f0c39d895c19755d74da18d5857aa7d0862209c0d62b938bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6fee49860d4b68f0dcc2b03bc7703673aa90efc32aee96bc26d9b45fecd04eb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "35ee74f2d64f4bf2c295e9e75c87639165870593fba7f8a1463ed89d7b210c9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3edc9040b90398736e5a78a76d7c1952a08368305b4468444c75449806d00c9d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b7e34eac197540f8e3271bcdf73c137d0e9a0f8c8d1d9df41a8d68eb70d79646", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e86404d4d0bf397ad60e791edb18757e1659a0b188ba183e204317af46233710", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "607c10ed2b7ff31161c81db47927047fc4983c42c42135f7d6334dc852e8c208", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e638432b60f1eca0d66ee07b4f96c33e4e7d84e4c25c3331282173661598483", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "96c61d79de108b033f65d19d6c9599cb3cf191aafe50bbd5d0300efa3d690490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b4f67a2e1973d62a0e7ccd26295b0b973b776cecfc5149498e6a689eea7a690e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7346d5f88722c03895376cbc42f5961581e5c01dff245416e8661730bfc96a6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ff9e1ea59e6cdf8be1d2b00892fec9f7c69e1d49f7390d7c0e1be4f8008c29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36c37ee3a3539a991f457b0936fcb50d7ec2404c049e4eea9f79b52095c6424", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e186b4dc36b0c9ad581d57924014764f3abbe04d15def19024090213fe857d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0c452dca8986320b8a6fe724a9cf310f856dbfe84596f83e5508df8947af2a25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0fcc271ecc1b71ad4219976b58a976537849c70c584c485a2eb1298eb8fcecd6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7942f0600eb6386e8928fd6f4850910cfad42a983592ea20dc08aeff66876f4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "df4296686502f7cbee4de63946c5e7c130a1e9f38119b71bdb115c8096754f19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e9920c7eabf49a704c88367e5c30d3774bcb810019725189e307e7a3eee2b30c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9858fac0ccbe5f431c872256ea80eeceaac1796474443d86448adc9fdc668594", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "30e567de236a8d621adc4f8034447dfde50869ed6e80cc1444385a6790700905", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c58e51280ad84e332d145973d8c45630480c90d3d4803a1c855f89bbe91f1851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b95aa16bb1913d6689693d3861e833c986f94073176d470fea4e0f26049e4241", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e0d9c3855b0f1ddc258a1648ac62539f5bbd4f1a78ded6a032b1ba3bc5960fc8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "14c36f40ee716610c6a4408fd209cf8454ce57ae4fc097d9c7431b4a74e402b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a871534279e983547fcbdbfe789349d034abe113b41583a46a503f44e7996b4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf87cf24e0a27e5ab7fe118f654bdc2980fa5ae25032673d569dda9cf4705ea3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eacd52d9fc804f1c58108655cc294a9b7fdcbb2f992b12405fc1394ce27c4c09", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8e16e3e7a3d814d85d0c0e7b4b10468bf8f7bdf0316b36ec383a1104919e22c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d944d4863d7a8cb82695f4601d5ab2eb9afdf91738e7f41738198574b1cdeb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "32f046e795625f4021213a3aa5ccb940526bb31e6128c16c1ac0428f94e97dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "37b1f7657f226c5f62ee5acb752c470a27c98ccd688a99403eca51696bb764ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b734e84320c0b0d18b6f7c005626c457d2cc593784846c584a71d5f011070a39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa64abc2903dbf3f90ae4e8b2e41dee899943e1d254498a579970f5f23262355", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "872d16ded97babfc182fe0c0e495ed1708ee87134ef8d3110e605c960b18a70f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6183848a6b396e8d351368bde6fc0f3be7125ac080ae4b9519eec1d95b6f8adb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d94ecafbd7cc7909cda32fd1853832bc78e0f2f7dd54aeceafb02c34936f9b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e3aa51b24375334a6b28d727af48188e5c0daa706d55850431b92c2cf07baaf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-original.ppm", + "sha256": "576dd05985e677f2268476886d87ba016fcac4927169bed5b39365b771c5bde3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36a73df1a2bd68ca78a189af9a9fb17355a9cadcb65783e7df2cfefa529081b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c241429b850a5d20818c9dd78184696c1631c991f04429ecc4fdb9a92c3ca46b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d10d52afcc7c547b2eaab1eac2cc3be291ddc89c5c5d518dcc13b66416cb3976", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2c942d9c19cb1384d6fd34f3083e8051413b11aa71b09bba5ace9f81c965c3f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108b3c22271faa45aa5c43859198c22fbdb083c24c18a80288061283bae9d1a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "be701e99bc926803ffbab6595ef1ec66c9dc451f2f47d1017061c9f8462ee0f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf6a1e4712a233400c5687a34987ea8332704958440620223c07577082e4edfc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "162a24b500a597dadb139e01557548c8f5c81d30d5e4766fa467dc1a2f33b8d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13d6aed360f87778296c7ac376e28812b36b45ae79ca29c1e1f53c3907fb4544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-original.ppm", + "sha256": "50af887f191e4dd9150559986f04f668b982b10514a2100a1a99242123f5708c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6cbb570bba40b8dc55886984d4b8cd85e9f2bf3e655289e102b5745face5b16d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "134d706f1bdbab4ff33b723d052a85fd2517e39046f8e6340e3498adddaf91f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ab88687e43871ab0f5da01ae4b1405712ca2e05c975d0688bc4f8826c627fdd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a09bf32551e65e375f9c0882972e6ca620cc98cb9adb02b59f5249ce16df42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75e07f7a0716808fc84c6d10e91d2877fc505235cd9178517a49adae645aee5d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db19dd301625261e0e2236b0036c624ca1b019bb3949f6fb5acbf7d5df325be4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "09b5cdd83bcb56dde10e91697a84725dcc5751fca835cb4c3332ab7e27d1a572", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "55da754def7e5bc52d0b759d776376b5b318a6ee22d7592c1ed305e98911c9d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4cf8d944587c4d4f12134bcf94d11158ce37254b26e2155cd7e1368f753c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f256b1ae087ecd3a614d6240937d33a8b980e2c68faf30730aa5f41b0d57f513", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40154": { @@ -346889,7 +384246,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40154", "family_id": "terrain-40145-40154", "job_id": "terrain-40145-40154", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -346905,6 +384262,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/candidate.json", "sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f69821284cbf67521cf844d699396b741079a6fc3ab1bc8c8ba89886e80432cf", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2344fd05aa5b7c66672308e99c535e5705923b8190304488208a0861cb927f2b", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:45:37.766043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40145-40154/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all 20 complete source/current Rust 1x/4x comparison pages on six unresampled boards. Boss 10310 restores the broad asymmetric hull, right circular disc, lower curved skirt and both feet; the isolated RGB113 rim cell (60,46) and two RGB4 corners missing at 4x are accepted contour interpretation, with larger low-scale losses explicitly retained. Boss 200a3 restores the continuous y35 lower bridges and central dark body; remaining outer contour losses and small right expansion are disclosed. Complete EBOSS6 preserves the bilateral opening sequence, final two pale rectangular plates, stationary horizontal central vent slats, narrow left rails and crossed diamond/herringbone floor. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted rather than claimed byte-stationary; the first six bindings and 24 outputs stay exact. Orange sparks preserve the narrow warm first rectangle, rays, separated fragments and dim brown fade. Stronger source-cell edge outlines on 101ab/101ad remain sparks at their actual presentation size; small adjacent additions and three excluded alpha16/17/19 fringe pixels in 101a8 are explicitly accepted, with every alpha>=32 meaningful pixel retained. Difficulty portraits retain original faces/glasses/eyes/visor/cigar/skull and framing; warmer fine painting and the green helmet central light mark interpreted as a shallow same-region raised tab with dark underside are accepted, not claimed unchanged hardware. Enemy singles retain authentic hull/post/pod/fork arrangements and near-black backing; fine facets/brighter bevels and 30098 sole native RGB4 corner rounding at (24,4) are accepted, while both authentic indicator classes retain full 1/4/9/16 coverage. Terrain 40135-40154 preserves source crack branch routing, rock counts/offsets and shallow divots; corrected 40138 retains its three authentic rocks without the rejected foreign fissure. Fine gravel, deeper crack contrast and local relief are accepted with the independent context joins; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and both state-partner lists are empty. Existing original-fallback density contrast stays disclosed. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new live Host/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. {\"source_geometry\": \"All original32x32 canvases/origin0 are preserved. Fissure branching, principal junctions, occupied dark rims, edge exit directions and rock/hollow placement match authentic original decoded tiles. Newly sharpened stone facets remain inside the source rock masses. Native compound cracks preserve original connections and endings; no foreign machinery or fissure introduced.\", \"materials\": \"Fine soil grain is sharper, denser and more contrasty than unchanged original soil. Mixed original/HD scenes visibly expose material patches. Accepted as disclosed remaster styling; no seamless whole-map claim. Rock lighting and brown soil identity remain source-consistent.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage/alphaIoU1 proves canvas coverage only. Artistic approval rests on complete source comparisons at actual Rust scales1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 and declared authentic context/topology evidence.\", \"specific_source_landmarks\": \"40145 retains its lower-left hollow cluster; 40146 retains the shallow central circular hollow; 40147 retains its two aligned depressions. Gallery-only40150/40151 retain occupied dark upper fissure backing. Native4014c/4014d/4014e/40153/40154 keep principal branching and star-junction placements.\", \"holds\": []} [\"Sharper/denser HD grain causes visible patches against original fallback; no seamless/fullHD whole-map proof.\", \"Exactly32 target tiles reviewed; other sharedraw cells and rejected/withdrawn variants remain outside approval.\", \"These32 have no declared damage-state pairs; no destructibility or damage artwork invented. Original fallback surroundings preserved.\", \"12 unused IDs across both families remain gallery-only; no native/live placement claim.\", \"Actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd probes, no independent liveSDL/Host cache capture.\", \"Future surrounding remasters/state joins need separate review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 bb185aa389fce46555aea78a6a1683227216ecf2a5a8d635cc65f49b2a741eb1", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "13fab78f53596eba816b47a4a160392c3a8f0ac27abdc8f408076b76b11eb721" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "81f6f45a01ef7ab37fc0e11c001b374632fff0be7124c637bf34e8d0de3efa3a" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40145", + "40146", + "40147", + "40148" + ], + "sha256": "2118ba900c0c0e2423a8e70d6941c91a9f69f3f8fcbf9a1af901c40303c67bd7", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40149", + "4014a", + "4014b", + "4014c" + ], + "sha256": "0a5cbd63e0de911fc18a7edeaa007217dcfd9788adaede2c9d6c74f45364c145", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4014d", + "4014e", + "4014f", + "40150" + ], + "sha256": "2e7f0573e1d6ee9560ee01a5c3282fdd31c78192b96af3458b379c7467ccaced", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40151", + "40152", + "40153", + "40154" + ], + "sha256": "0b1b4ab14f02637594f12b6cc247190baa3994124dd0794558be10fd2d1bceba", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1037-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40145-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d3d70f233a01d7abd4f99f5785511bcb31dac038bed5413cabc5919cab4c3023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "712038c91c2f71c8ea7beb167c5d8f2c2287c84297778413a021b2041eae9089", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c8ed44987088709d60ea4601841a6fe03e0aee2836f0fe1271903777b35ac415", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3df2186222e743dbdf01202d15df6e757237e5286cab713aaa93204203bc757", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40145-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5ff6a432d41188eb75be732b616e4cbac8c9351065cce8b23ebff926d09568d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40145-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2e2fd14c542ca7a499cdd111cb871297b91804b86caaad952806b0810ab0232f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c6b9a0189815c49a13f07b5b2c9d2756c8819b5cf1130be813a40817bfd71c8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "183ccdaf00c2faa210d66cca9c0d55f20c106f8d1179d577a01d16b82c4fdf0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f7c11063e6718ea9664dac1c0a0dac3cdb091d1e67475a7b56eae5ebd3171aae", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40146-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3ad735c66ba344d083c78394626f3093050b01fe339c8fcfce9184eca6b0904b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40146-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47cf688f58791501a4d9c72de1aae6c70fa0748434582dcaff023a062f07deb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "34344c20d4c890c4ed0e322140821675c54d72eb0c8f77a219373515340cb89b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2337cd2cb51b1bf08f1886a28b835d0efab680db6d70c85c5abd354454f86efd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f5a698a47610e48657fbf5f952737fb44f0c7bd30c3b51ed0150803d136cc7a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40147-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0ef70b37f1735ea91dc5b13aee07dbeab6f81f1928a9195be975055912986fbf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40147-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37eeacd053883ac70308e1b076e84d75b70763e875a9941c29177c807cb0b378", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b0176ba6d6c12400f8c73cdb798130c06b93f672f70e0d73c7d631a0ead48ab4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "453ba7b0658ca37054dbef42d5ad8afe45b105fe2b15a7638bac7e4bbed7b89e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5b675158947fe902f96d22baa3b11bd401a695c6c3428034f4f190fdb03b872a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40148-original.ppm", + "sha256": "30f5fd28184fac4a0b21157bfc4ae306c73362822cc28f9ced29953ef9c2d02e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40148-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5751a4627be0ea4c5d4a635b401018e26e263c48a2dd9b28276bdb8281ac884b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "715c8d864841d54f0c39d895c19755d74da18d5857aa7d0862209c0d62b938bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6fee49860d4b68f0dcc2b03bc7703673aa90efc32aee96bc26d9b45fecd04eb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "35ee74f2d64f4bf2c295e9e75c87639165870593fba7f8a1463ed89d7b210c9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40149-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3edc9040b90398736e5a78a76d7c1952a08368305b4468444c75449806d00c9d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40149-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b7e34eac197540f8e3271bcdf73c137d0e9a0f8c8d1d9df41a8d68eb70d79646", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e86404d4d0bf397ad60e791edb18757e1659a0b188ba183e204317af46233710", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "607c10ed2b7ff31161c81db47927047fc4983c42c42135f7d6334dc852e8c208", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e638432b60f1eca0d66ee07b4f96c33e4e7d84e4c25c3331282173661598483", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "96c61d79de108b033f65d19d6c9599cb3cf191aafe50bbd5d0300efa3d690490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b4f67a2e1973d62a0e7ccd26295b0b973b776cecfc5149498e6a689eea7a690e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7346d5f88722c03895376cbc42f5961581e5c01dff245416e8661730bfc96a6f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ff9e1ea59e6cdf8be1d2b00892fec9f7c69e1d49f7390d7c0e1be4f8008c29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36c37ee3a3539a991f457b0936fcb50d7ec2404c049e4eea9f79b52095c6424", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e186b4dc36b0c9ad581d57924014764f3abbe04d15def19024090213fe857d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0c452dca8986320b8a6fe724a9cf310f856dbfe84596f83e5508df8947af2a25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0fcc271ecc1b71ad4219976b58a976537849c70c584c485a2eb1298eb8fcecd6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7942f0600eb6386e8928fd6f4850910cfad42a983592ea20dc08aeff66876f4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "df4296686502f7cbee4de63946c5e7c130a1e9f38119b71bdb115c8096754f19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e9920c7eabf49a704c88367e5c30d3774bcb810019725189e307e7a3eee2b30c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9858fac0ccbe5f431c872256ea80eeceaac1796474443d86448adc9fdc668594", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "30e567de236a8d621adc4f8034447dfde50869ed6e80cc1444385a6790700905", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c58e51280ad84e332d145973d8c45630480c90d3d4803a1c855f89bbe91f1851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b95aa16bb1913d6689693d3861e833c986f94073176d470fea4e0f26049e4241", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e0d9c3855b0f1ddc258a1648ac62539f5bbd4f1a78ded6a032b1ba3bc5960fc8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "14c36f40ee716610c6a4408fd209cf8454ce57ae4fc097d9c7431b4a74e402b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a871534279e983547fcbdbfe789349d034abe113b41583a46a503f44e7996b4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf87cf24e0a27e5ab7fe118f654bdc2980fa5ae25032673d569dda9cf4705ea3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eacd52d9fc804f1c58108655cc294a9b7fdcbb2f992b12405fc1394ce27c4c09", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8e16e3e7a3d814d85d0c0e7b4b10468bf8f7bdf0316b36ec383a1104919e22c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0d944d4863d7a8cb82695f4601d5ab2eb9afdf91738e7f41738198574b1cdeb0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "32f046e795625f4021213a3aa5ccb940526bb31e6128c16c1ac0428f94e97dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "37b1f7657f226c5f62ee5acb752c470a27c98ccd688a99403eca51696bb764ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b734e84320c0b0d18b6f7c005626c457d2cc593784846c584a71d5f011070a39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4014f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fa64abc2903dbf3f90ae4e8b2e41dee899943e1d254498a579970f5f23262355", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/4014f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "872d16ded97babfc182fe0c0e495ed1708ee87134ef8d3110e605c960b18a70f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6183848a6b396e8d351368bde6fc0f3be7125ac080ae4b9519eec1d95b6f8adb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d94ecafbd7cc7909cda32fd1853832bc78e0f2f7dd54aeceafb02c34936f9b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e3aa51b24375334a6b28d727af48188e5c0daa706d55850431b92c2cf07baaf0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40150-original.ppm", + "sha256": "576dd05985e677f2268476886d87ba016fcac4927169bed5b39365b771c5bde3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40150-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36a73df1a2bd68ca78a189af9a9fb17355a9cadcb65783e7df2cfefa529081b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c241429b850a5d20818c9dd78184696c1631c991f04429ecc4fdb9a92c3ca46b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d10d52afcc7c547b2eaab1eac2cc3be291ddc89c5c5d518dcc13b66416cb3976", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2c942d9c19cb1384d6fd34f3083e8051413b11aa71b09bba5ace9f81c965c3f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40151-original.ppm", + "sha256": "108b3c22271faa45aa5c43859198c22fbdb083c24c18a80288061283bae9d1a5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40151-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "be701e99bc926803ffbab6595ef1ec66c9dc451f2f47d1017061c9f8462ee0f6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bf6a1e4712a233400c5687a34987ea8332704958440620223c07577082e4edfc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "162a24b500a597dadb139e01557548c8f5c81d30d5e4766fa467dc1a2f33b8d1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13d6aed360f87778296c7ac376e28812b36b45ae79ca29c1e1f53c3907fb4544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40152-original.ppm", + "sha256": "50af887f191e4dd9150559986f04f668b982b10514a2100a1a99242123f5708c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40152-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6cbb570bba40b8dc55886984d4b8cd85e9f2bf3e655289e102b5745face5b16d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "134d706f1bdbab4ff33b723d052a85fd2517e39046f8e6340e3498adddaf91f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ab88687e43871ab0f5da01ae4b1405712ca2e05c975d0688bc4f8826c627fdd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a09bf32551e65e375f9c0882972e6ca620cc98cb9adb02b59f5249ce16df42", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40153-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75e07f7a0716808fc84c6d10e91d2877fc505235cd9178517a49adae645aee5d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40153-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "db19dd301625261e0e2236b0036c624ca1b019bb3949f6fb5acbf7d5df325be4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "09b5cdd83bcb56dde10e91697a84725dcc5751fca835cb4c3332ab7e27d1a572", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "55da754def7e5bc52d0b759d776376b5b318a6ee22d7592c1ed305e98911c9d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9e4cf8d944587c4d4f12134bcf94d11158ce37254b26e2155cd7e1368f753c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40154-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f256b1ae087ecd3a614d6240937d33a8b980e2c68faf30730aa5f41b0d57f513", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-ground-two/terrain-40145-40154/runtime/40154-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40155": { @@ -357596,7 +395423,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40275-40284/candidate.json", - "sha256": "e0439b64d85f9377c70d9551e929af68269a2a2945111710c5a2072054b85b9a", + "sha256": "f7517141438c9002a1e71f938bd6b8c5e27d1f4dd8cd968f6e5a9784056210a4", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -357633,7 +395460,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40275-40284/candidate.json", - "sha256": "e0439b64d85f9377c70d9551e929af68269a2a2945111710c5a2072054b85b9a", + "sha256": "f7517141438c9002a1e71f938bd6b8c5e27d1f4dd8cd968f6e5a9784056210a4", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -357670,7 +395497,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40275-40284/candidate.json", - "sha256": "e0439b64d85f9377c70d9551e929af68269a2a2945111710c5a2072054b85b9a", + "sha256": "f7517141438c9002a1e71f938bd6b8c5e27d1f4dd8cd968f6e5a9784056210a4", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -357707,7 +395534,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40275-40284/candidate.json", - "sha256": "e0439b64d85f9377c70d9551e929af68269a2a2945111710c5a2072054b85b9a", + "sha256": "f7517141438c9002a1e71f938bd6b8c5e27d1f4dd8cd968f6e5a9784056210a4", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -357744,7 +395571,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40275-40284/candidate.json", - "sha256": "e0439b64d85f9377c70d9551e929af68269a2a2945111710c5a2072054b85b9a", + "sha256": "f7517141438c9002a1e71f938bd6b8c5e27d1f4dd8cd968f6e5a9784056210a4", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -357781,7 +395608,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40275-40284/candidate.json", - "sha256": "e0439b64d85f9377c70d9551e929af68269a2a2945111710c5a2072054b85b9a", + "sha256": "f7517141438c9002a1e71f938bd6b8c5e27d1f4dd8cd968f6e5a9784056210a4", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -357818,7 +395645,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40275-40284/candidate.json", - "sha256": "e0439b64d85f9377c70d9551e929af68269a2a2945111710c5a2072054b85b9a", + "sha256": "f7517141438c9002a1e71f938bd6b8c5e27d1f4dd8cd968f6e5a9784056210a4", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -357855,7 +395682,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40275-40284/candidate.json", - "sha256": "e0439b64d85f9377c70d9551e929af68269a2a2945111710c5a2072054b85b9a", + "sha256": "f7517141438c9002a1e71f938bd6b8c5e27d1f4dd8cd968f6e5a9784056210a4", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -357892,7 +395719,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40275-40284/candidate.json", - "sha256": "e0439b64d85f9377c70d9551e929af68269a2a2945111710c5a2072054b85b9a", + "sha256": "f7517141438c9002a1e71f938bd6b8c5e27d1f4dd8cd968f6e5a9784056210a4", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -357929,7 +395756,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40275-40284/candidate.json", - "sha256": "e0439b64d85f9377c70d9551e929af68269a2a2945111710c5a2072054b85b9a", + "sha256": "f7517141438c9002a1e71f938bd6b8c5e27d1f4dd8cd968f6e5a9784056210a4", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -357966,7 +395793,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40275-40284/candidate.json", - "sha256": "e0439b64d85f9377c70d9551e929af68269a2a2945111710c5a2072054b85b9a", + "sha256": "f7517141438c9002a1e71f938bd6b8c5e27d1f4dd8cd968f6e5a9784056210a4", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -358003,7 +395830,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40275-40284/candidate.json", - "sha256": "e0439b64d85f9377c70d9551e929af68269a2a2945111710c5a2072054b85b9a", + "sha256": "f7517141438c9002a1e71f938bd6b8c5e27d1f4dd8cd968f6e5a9784056210a4", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -358040,7 +395867,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40275-40284/candidate.json", - "sha256": "e0439b64d85f9377c70d9551e929af68269a2a2945111710c5a2072054b85b9a", + "sha256": "f7517141438c9002a1e71f938bd6b8c5e27d1f4dd8cd968f6e5a9784056210a4", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -358077,7 +395904,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40275-40284/candidate.json", - "sha256": "e0439b64d85f9377c70d9551e929af68269a2a2945111710c5a2072054b85b9a", + "sha256": "f7517141438c9002a1e71f938bd6b8c5e27d1f4dd8cd968f6e5a9784056210a4", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -358114,7 +395941,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40275-40284/candidate.json", - "sha256": "e0439b64d85f9377c70d9551e929af68269a2a2945111710c5a2072054b85b9a", + "sha256": "f7517141438c9002a1e71f938bd6b8c5e27d1f4dd8cd968f6e5a9784056210a4", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -358151,7 +395978,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40275-40284/candidate.json", - "sha256": "e0439b64d85f9377c70d9551e929af68269a2a2945111710c5a2072054b85b9a", + "sha256": "f7517141438c9002a1e71f938bd6b8c5e27d1f4dd8cd968f6e5a9784056210a4", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -358174,8 +396001,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40285", "family_id": "terrain-40285-40294", "job_id": "terrain-40285-40294", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358185,6 +396012,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40285-40294/candidate.json", + "sha256": "deb393294580932e277742be1a05dd33a70db7963a520504d4fdb625afcd2845", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40286": { @@ -358206,8 +396038,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40286", "family_id": "terrain-40285-40294", "job_id": "terrain-40285-40294", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358217,6 +396049,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40285-40294/candidate.json", + "sha256": "deb393294580932e277742be1a05dd33a70db7963a520504d4fdb625afcd2845", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40287": { @@ -358238,8 +396075,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40287", "family_id": "terrain-40285-40294", "job_id": "terrain-40285-40294", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358249,6 +396086,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40285-40294/candidate.json", + "sha256": "deb393294580932e277742be1a05dd33a70db7963a520504d4fdb625afcd2845", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40288": { @@ -358270,8 +396112,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40288", "family_id": "terrain-40285-40294", "job_id": "terrain-40285-40294", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358281,6 +396123,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40285-40294/candidate.json", + "sha256": "deb393294580932e277742be1a05dd33a70db7963a520504d4fdb625afcd2845", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40289": { @@ -358302,8 +396149,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40289", "family_id": "terrain-40285-40294", "job_id": "terrain-40285-40294", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358313,6 +396160,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40285-40294/candidate.json", + "sha256": "deb393294580932e277742be1a05dd33a70db7963a520504d4fdb625afcd2845", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4028a": { @@ -358334,8 +396186,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4028a", "family_id": "terrain-40285-40294", "job_id": "terrain-40285-40294", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358345,6 +396197,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40285-40294/candidate.json", + "sha256": "deb393294580932e277742be1a05dd33a70db7963a520504d4fdb625afcd2845", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4028b": { @@ -358366,8 +396223,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4028b", "family_id": "terrain-40285-40294", "job_id": "terrain-40285-40294", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358377,6 +396234,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40285-40294/candidate.json", + "sha256": "deb393294580932e277742be1a05dd33a70db7963a520504d4fdb625afcd2845", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4028c": { @@ -358398,8 +396260,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4028c", "family_id": "terrain-40285-40294", "job_id": "terrain-40285-40294", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358409,6 +396271,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40285-40294/candidate.json", + "sha256": "deb393294580932e277742be1a05dd33a70db7963a520504d4fdb625afcd2845", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4028d": { @@ -358430,8 +396297,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4028d", "family_id": "terrain-40285-40294", "job_id": "terrain-40285-40294", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358441,6 +396308,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40285-40294/candidate.json", + "sha256": "deb393294580932e277742be1a05dd33a70db7963a520504d4fdb625afcd2845", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4028e": { @@ -358462,8 +396334,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4028e", "family_id": "terrain-40285-40294", "job_id": "terrain-40285-40294", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358473,6 +396345,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40285-40294/candidate.json", + "sha256": "deb393294580932e277742be1a05dd33a70db7963a520504d4fdb625afcd2845", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4028f": { @@ -358494,8 +396371,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4028f", "family_id": "terrain-40285-40294", "job_id": "terrain-40285-40294", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358505,6 +396382,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40285-40294/candidate.json", + "sha256": "deb393294580932e277742be1a05dd33a70db7963a520504d4fdb625afcd2845", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40290": { @@ -358526,8 +396408,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40290", "family_id": "terrain-40285-40294", "job_id": "terrain-40285-40294", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358537,6 +396419,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40285-40294/candidate.json", + "sha256": "deb393294580932e277742be1a05dd33a70db7963a520504d4fdb625afcd2845", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40291": { @@ -358558,8 +396445,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40291", "family_id": "terrain-40285-40294", "job_id": "terrain-40285-40294", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358569,6 +396456,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40285-40294/candidate.json", + "sha256": "deb393294580932e277742be1a05dd33a70db7963a520504d4fdb625afcd2845", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40292": { @@ -358590,8 +396482,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40292", "family_id": "terrain-40285-40294", "job_id": "terrain-40285-40294", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358601,6 +396493,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40285-40294/candidate.json", + "sha256": "deb393294580932e277742be1a05dd33a70db7963a520504d4fdb625afcd2845", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40293": { @@ -358622,8 +396519,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40293", "family_id": "terrain-40285-40294", "job_id": "terrain-40285-40294", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358633,6 +396530,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40285-40294/candidate.json", + "sha256": "deb393294580932e277742be1a05dd33a70db7963a520504d4fdb625afcd2845", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40294": { @@ -358654,8 +396556,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40294", "family_id": "terrain-40285-40294", "job_id": "terrain-40285-40294", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358665,6 +396567,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40285-40294/candidate.json", + "sha256": "deb393294580932e277742be1a05dd33a70db7963a520504d4fdb625afcd2845", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40295": { @@ -358686,8 +396593,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40295", "family_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", "job_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358697,6 +396604,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40295-402a4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "e5d385fbab08e9cbaadc9f428142ef8234864f1cc30a2d9c5f59f7804dad4974", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40296": { @@ -358718,8 +396630,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40296", "family_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", "job_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358729,6 +396641,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40295-402a4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "e5d385fbab08e9cbaadc9f428142ef8234864f1cc30a2d9c5f59f7804dad4974", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40297": { @@ -358750,8 +396667,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40297", "family_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", "job_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358761,6 +396678,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40295-402a4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "e5d385fbab08e9cbaadc9f428142ef8234864f1cc30a2d9c5f59f7804dad4974", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40298": { @@ -358782,8 +396704,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40298", "family_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", "job_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358793,6 +396715,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40295-402a4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "e5d385fbab08e9cbaadc9f428142ef8234864f1cc30a2d9c5f59f7804dad4974", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "40299": { @@ -358814,8 +396741,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40299", "family_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", "job_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358825,6 +396752,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40295-402a4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "e5d385fbab08e9cbaadc9f428142ef8234864f1cc30a2d9c5f59f7804dad4974", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4029a": { @@ -358846,8 +396778,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4029a", "family_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", "job_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358857,6 +396789,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40295-402a4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "e5d385fbab08e9cbaadc9f428142ef8234864f1cc30a2d9c5f59f7804dad4974", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4029b": { @@ -358878,8 +396815,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4029b", "family_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", "job_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358889,6 +396826,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40295-402a4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "e5d385fbab08e9cbaadc9f428142ef8234864f1cc30a2d9c5f59f7804dad4974", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4029c": { @@ -358910,8 +396852,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4029c", "family_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", "job_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358921,6 +396863,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40295-402a4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "e5d385fbab08e9cbaadc9f428142ef8234864f1cc30a2d9c5f59f7804dad4974", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4029d": { @@ -358942,8 +396889,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4029d", "family_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", "job_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -358953,6 +396900,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40295-402a4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "e5d385fbab08e9cbaadc9f428142ef8234864f1cc30a2d9c5f59f7804dad4974", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4029e": { @@ -358974,8 +396926,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4029e", "family_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", "job_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -358985,6 +396937,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40295-402a4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "e5d385fbab08e9cbaadc9f428142ef8234864f1cc30a2d9c5f59f7804dad4974", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "4029f": { @@ -359006,8 +396963,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4029f", "family_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", "job_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -359017,6 +396974,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40295-402a4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "e5d385fbab08e9cbaadc9f428142ef8234864f1cc30a2d9c5f59f7804dad4974", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402a0": { @@ -359038,8 +397000,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402a0", "family_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", "job_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -359049,6 +397011,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40295-402a4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "e5d385fbab08e9cbaadc9f428142ef8234864f1cc30a2d9c5f59f7804dad4974", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402a1": { @@ -359070,8 +397037,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402a1", "family_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", "job_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -359081,6 +397048,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40295-402a4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "e5d385fbab08e9cbaadc9f428142ef8234864f1cc30a2d9c5f59f7804dad4974", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402a2": { @@ -359102,8 +397074,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402a2", "family_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", "job_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -359113,6 +397085,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40295-402a4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "e5d385fbab08e9cbaadc9f428142ef8234864f1cc30a2d9c5f59f7804dad4974", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402a3": { @@ -359134,8 +397111,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402a3", "family_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", "job_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -359145,6 +397122,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40295-402a4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "e5d385fbab08e9cbaadc9f428142ef8234864f1cc30a2d9c5f59f7804dad4974", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402a4": { @@ -359166,8 +397148,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402a4", "family_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", "job_id": "terrain-40295-402a4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -359177,6 +397159,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40295-402a4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "e5d385fbab08e9cbaadc9f428142ef8234864f1cc30a2d9c5f59f7804dad4974", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402a5": { @@ -359198,8 +397185,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402a5", "family_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", "job_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -359230,8 +397217,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402a6", "family_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", "job_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -359262,8 +397249,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402a7", "family_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", "job_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -359294,8 +397281,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402a8", "family_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", "job_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -359326,8 +397313,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402a9", "family_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", "job_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -359358,8 +397345,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402aa", "family_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", "job_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -359390,8 +397377,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402ab", "family_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", "job_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -359422,8 +397409,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402ac", "family_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", "job_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -359454,8 +397441,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402ad", "family_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", "job_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -359486,8 +397473,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402ae", "family_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", "job_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -359518,8 +397505,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402af", "family_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", "job_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -359550,8 +397537,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402b0", "family_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", "job_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -359582,8 +397569,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402b1", "family_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", "job_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -359614,8 +397601,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402b2", "family_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", "job_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -359646,8 +397633,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402b3", "family_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", "job_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -359678,8 +397665,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402b4", "family_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", "job_id": "terrain-402a5-402b4", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -387498,7 +425485,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "50005", "family_id": "interface-other-50005-50006", "job_id": "interface-other-50005-50006", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_dark_player", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -387510,6 +425497,82 @@ "manifest": "jobs/interface-other-50005-50006/candidate.json", "sha256": "c8981306b86d0f966d556c0accb71207a3fc235b895459c512262bf68bea96a7", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "c8981306b86d0f966d556c0accb71207a3fc235b895459c512262bf68bea96a7", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "b9b0722ef65e5803a7239be3b338711091c5488e57383fbc90dd21be3259bd90", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:31.459555+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/interface-other-50005-50006/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [{\"asset\": \"50005\", \"decision\": \"approved\", \"finding\": \"Eight dark burgundy inset slots retain source columns6\\u20139 on odd rows1\\u201315, with authentic last-slot contact at the lower edge. The right-side rail highlight and source-specific dark left/right channels remain oriented correctly. Scratched brushed gunmetal, slight pale edge reflections and burgundy recesses read as continuous material. At1x the right slot-edge pixels average toward brown and the sixth edge(9,11) is brightest/least red; all eight slots remain distinguishable and no source slot is filled with a new structural rail. This shading change is explicitly accepted, not described as exact burgundy RGB preservation.\"}, {\"asset\": \"50006\", \"decision\": \"approved\", \"finding\": \"The paired tile keeps the source opposite left-side rail highlight, eight identically placed burgundy slots and distinct dark-channel layout. Its raw grain is finer and more squiggled than the left raw; at actual2\\u20134 both are coherent scuffed gunmetal with restrained reddish recesses. Left slot-edge averages at1x are lighter/browner than original, while the entire slot pattern stays readable. All actual1\\u20134 and source repeat contexts preserve source periodic spacing and rail continuation.\"}, {\"pair\": \"50005/50006\", \"finding\": \"Complete2x3 source/allscale/raw contexts and every native raw seam crop show no added outer border/margin, shifted slot spacing or broken macro rail/channel at joins. Original side-specific shade bands persist; authored micrograin and RGB edge differences are not pixel-identical. These are two static paired lookup assets, not a newly established animation or hover-state sequence.\"}] [\"Opaque IoU1 proves only coverage. All256 source cells remain occupied per tile; internal slot/rail/channel geometry and complete material/repeat-context inspection drive this decision.\", \"Brown highlight averages can fail color predicates without removing occupied source cells. The exact colors and both thresholds are retained so later reviewers can assess this accepted shading change.\", \"New grain differs locally across independently generated left/right tiles; paired native presentation is coherent, not byte-identical or an animation stability claim.\", \"Edge metrics are diagnostic and do not establish zero seams; complete native repeated contexts were visually reviewed.\", \"Coordinator owns global registration and runtime-route completion. Earlier cursor/texture/boss holds remain unchanged.\"] {\"author_predicate\": \"R>1.4*G && R>1.4*B, no minimum-R; confirmed by author and independently reproduced\", \"author_result\": \"Original32 each; raw centers32 each; left1x31 due only to(9,11), remaining actual outputs32\", \"independent_stricter_predicate\": \"R>1.5*G && R>1.5*B && R>20\", \"independent_stricter_result\": \"8 edge centers fail at1x in each tile;6 right-edge centers fail atleft2x; actual3\\u20134 and raw centers retain32. This is threshold sensitivity to reflected edge shading, not a loader discrepancy; all ten fresh PPMs are byte-identical to author outputs.\", \"concrete_RGB_change\": \"Original left(9,11)=40/12/8; actual1x=56/40/36. Other highlighted edges are52/36/32 or48/32/28, disclosed as brown/neutral averaging rather than guaranteed red color.\", \"independent_visual_judgment\": \"Accepted isolated/brushed edge highlight variation after examining actual native and enlarged outputs, because all eight distinct recesses and source rails/channels remain visually identifiable at every scale. Color-threshold counts are supporting evidence only.\"} All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 3736f8880cd7b2f20493a884832dff71c48e0708e11cd8a69b2da1bd8f0c7a62", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "50005", + "50006" + ], + "sha256": "0ab2249d4c6da5cb4b55037ca4d5699b928f2dbab11d35b65e641ae041ed3c6a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "50005-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c1bb80ac5ffeccf971a6246717fe009dbf1814280b086dc40f2ef77b809a8159", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/runtime/50005-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "50005-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21048dd4e92be6e6d86f115c17ae335908c875aec1847177aec73657aca51c4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/runtime/50005-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "50005-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "95d0dfcdaf4e940384664e01948a722c2cea23a9f5c42d0a2075f41e4d079cc0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/runtime/50005-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "50005-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f6066051ebbf4a5541a9e806b13e974715b22a95a93d501e9f18b548123349a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/runtime/50005-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "50005-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f71a48eb217be65427880795671d8912ebcf95d7a82dad22664eda2a3c10c3fe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/runtime/50005-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "50006-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "510a675c56f383d454f6053744eadaf09af1fcd0ef96cd4137433533abf29a72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/runtime/50006-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "50006-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "44a20e86dcb04b14900eb3b3c2586c9cb50638f55c44ff5fa984aeba9e78f028", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/runtime/50006-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "50006-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f9271fa9695161896759a1c798f62365c2996413163005ba99352418ece83609", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/runtime/50006-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "50006-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0d30f6648f79d90e050ce6609f4e8fba0372cd0f8bcebf441e3d1ad4c52547d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/runtime/50006-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "50006-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5163329e64a62692bdb07f9962c010f9cc91c466937f1fd06368e6602e68cafd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/runtime/50006-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "50006": { @@ -387531,7 +425594,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "50006", "family_id": "interface-other-50005-50006", "job_id": "interface-other-50005-50006", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_dark_player", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -387543,6 +425606,82 @@ "manifest": "jobs/interface-other-50005-50006/candidate.json", "sha256": "c8981306b86d0f966d556c0accb71207a3fc235b895459c512262bf68bea96a7", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "c8981306b86d0f966d556c0accb71207a3fc235b895459c512262bf68bea96a7", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "b9b0722ef65e5803a7239be3b338711091c5488e57383fbc90dd21be3259bd90", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T07:36:31.459555+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/interface-other-50005-50006/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator inspected all15 complete source/current Rust1x/4x comparison pages on four unresampled boards. Radar arc quarters, central mast/shadow/hub, original lower control and252 lamp, separate burned foundations and soil rock/crack landmarks preserve source placement/topology. Fine gray panel seams and brown gravel are accepted with exact independent96-tile context/whole-radar/state proofs; nine damaged radar partners remain original fallback and soil density contrast stays disclosed. All four tank families retain original tread/slat/fork phases, stationary hull landmarks, broad copper panel divisions and black backing, with local1x/2x contour smoothing and quantified minor stationary shading variation accepted. TEXTURE10018 preserves the upper housing/circular inset, left recess, lower plate notches, diagonal relief and connector channels. Stronger fine scuffed metal, rust and edge contrast are accepted with peer full repeated-context and exact seam inspection. SIDETEX50005/6 retain opposite rails and all eight readable burgundy recesses, despite threshold-sensitive brown edge highlights at native1x/selected2x and different raw grain. Alpha coverage and metrics alone are not the approval basis; no new liveHost/custom-menu reachability, complete assembled boss or whole-map seamlessness is inferred. [{\"asset\": \"50005\", \"decision\": \"approved\", \"finding\": \"Eight dark burgundy inset slots retain source columns6\\u20139 on odd rows1\\u201315, with authentic last-slot contact at the lower edge. The right-side rail highlight and source-specific dark left/right channels remain oriented correctly. Scratched brushed gunmetal, slight pale edge reflections and burgundy recesses read as continuous material. At1x the right slot-edge pixels average toward brown and the sixth edge(9,11) is brightest/least red; all eight slots remain distinguishable and no source slot is filled with a new structural rail. This shading change is explicitly accepted, not described as exact burgundy RGB preservation.\"}, {\"asset\": \"50006\", \"decision\": \"approved\", \"finding\": \"The paired tile keeps the source opposite left-side rail highlight, eight identically placed burgundy slots and distinct dark-channel layout. Its raw grain is finer and more squiggled than the left raw; at actual2\\u20134 both are coherent scuffed gunmetal with restrained reddish recesses. Left slot-edge averages at1x are lighter/browner than original, while the entire slot pattern stays readable. All actual1\\u20134 and source repeat contexts preserve source periodic spacing and rail continuation.\"}, {\"pair\": \"50005/50006\", \"finding\": \"Complete2x3 source/allscale/raw contexts and every native raw seam crop show no added outer border/margin, shifted slot spacing or broken macro rail/channel at joins. Original side-specific shade bands persist; authored micrograin and RGB edge differences are not pixel-identical. These are two static paired lookup assets, not a newly established animation or hover-state sequence.\"}] [\"Opaque IoU1 proves only coverage. All256 source cells remain occupied per tile; internal slot/rail/channel geometry and complete material/repeat-context inspection drive this decision.\", \"Brown highlight averages can fail color predicates without removing occupied source cells. The exact colors and both thresholds are retained so later reviewers can assess this accepted shading change.\", \"New grain differs locally across independently generated left/right tiles; paired native presentation is coherent, not byte-identical or an animation stability claim.\", \"Edge metrics are diagnostic and do not establish zero seams; complete native repeated contexts were visually reviewed.\", \"Coordinator owns global registration and runtime-route completion. Earlier cursor/texture/boss holds remain unchanged.\"] {\"author_predicate\": \"R>1.4*G && R>1.4*B, no minimum-R; confirmed by author and independently reproduced\", \"author_result\": \"Original32 each; raw centers32 each; left1x31 due only to(9,11), remaining actual outputs32\", \"independent_stricter_predicate\": \"R>1.5*G && R>1.5*B && R>20\", \"independent_stricter_result\": \"8 edge centers fail at1x in each tile;6 right-edge centers fail atleft2x; actual3\\u20134 and raw centers retain32. This is threshold sensitivity to reflected edge shading, not a loader discrepancy; all ten fresh PPMs are byte-identical to author outputs.\", \"concrete_RGB_change\": \"Original left(9,11)=40/12/8; actual1x=56/40/36. Other highlighted edges are52/36/32 or48/32/28, disclosed as brown/neutral averaging rather than guaranteed red color.\", \"independent_visual_judgment\": \"Accepted isolated/brushed edge highlight variation after examining actual native and enlarged outputs, because all eight distinct recesses and source rails/channels remain visually identifiable at every scale. Color-threshold counts are supporting evidence only.\"} All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 3736f8880cd7b2f20493a884832dff71c48e0708e11cd8a69b2da1bd8f0c7a62", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "50005", + "50006" + ], + "sha256": "0ab2249d4c6da5cb4b55037ca4d5699b928f2dbab11d35b65e641ae041ed3c6a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next979-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "50005-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c1bb80ac5ffeccf971a6246717fe009dbf1814280b086dc40f2ef77b809a8159", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/runtime/50005-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "50005-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21048dd4e92be6e6d86f115c17ae335908c875aec1847177aec73657aca51c4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/runtime/50005-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "50005-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "95d0dfcdaf4e940384664e01948a722c2cea23a9f5c42d0a2075f41e4d079cc0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/runtime/50005-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "50005-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f6066051ebbf4a5541a9e806b13e974715b22a95a93d501e9f18b548123349a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/runtime/50005-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "50005-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f71a48eb217be65427880795671d8912ebcf95d7a82dad22664eda2a3c10c3fe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/runtime/50005-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "50006-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "510a675c56f383d454f6053744eadaf09af1fcd0ef96cd4137433533abf29a72", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/runtime/50006-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "50006-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "44a20e86dcb04b14900eb3b3c2586c9cb50638f55c44ff5fa984aeba9e78f028", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/runtime/50006-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "50006-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f9271fa9695161896759a1c798f62365c2996413163005ba99352418ece83609", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/runtime/50006-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "50006-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0d30f6648f79d90e050ce6609f4e8fba0372cd0f8bcebf441e3d1ad4c52547d5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/runtime/50006-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "50006-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5163329e64a62692bdb07f9962c010f9cc91c466937f1fd06368e6602e68cafd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-ui-side-textures-independent-review/runtime/50006-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "50019": { @@ -387802,7 +425941,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_dark_player", "target_count": 1, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 1 + "registered": 1 }, "job_file": "interface-other-10018-10018/job.json" }, @@ -387826,7 +425965,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_dark_player", "target_count": 4, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 4 + "registered": 4 }, "job_file": "interface-other-1001a-1001d/job.json" }, @@ -388355,7 +426494,7 @@ "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "target_count": 9, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 9 + "registered": 9 }, "job_file": "effects-101a5-101ad/job.json" }, @@ -389327,7 +427466,7 @@ "owner": "/root/iron_coast_3", "target_count": 1, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 1 + "registered": 1 }, "job_file": "bosses-10310-10310/job.json" }, @@ -390071,7 +428210,7 @@ "owner": "/root/iron_coast_3", "target_count": 1, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 1 + "registered": 1 }, "job_file": "bosses-200a3-200a3/job.json" }, @@ -391403,7 +429542,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "target_count": 4, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 4 + "registered": 4 }, "job_file": "enemies-30074-30077/job.json" }, @@ -391439,7 +429578,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "target_count": 5, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 5 + "registered": 5 }, "job_file": "enemies-30080-30084/job.json" }, @@ -391451,7 +429590,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "target_count": 4, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 4 + "registered": 4 }, "job_file": "enemies-30085-30088/job.json" }, @@ -391475,7 +429614,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "target_count": 2, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 2 + "registered": 2 }, "job_file": "enemies-3008b-3008c/job.json" }, @@ -391511,7 +429650,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "target_count": 1, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 1 + "registered": 1 }, "job_file": "enemies-3008f-3008f/job.json" }, @@ -391547,7 +429686,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "target_count": 1, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 1 + "registered": 1 }, "job_file": "enemies-30092-30092/job.json" }, @@ -391583,7 +429722,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "target_count": 1, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 1 + "registered": 1 }, "job_file": "enemies-30095-30095/job.json" }, @@ -391619,7 +429758,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "target_count": 1, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 1 + "registered": 1 }, "job_file": "enemies-30098-30098/job.json" }, @@ -391835,7 +429974,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "target_count": 11, "status_counts": { - "inprogress": 11 + "candidate": 11 }, "job_file": "enemies-40006-40010/job.json" }, @@ -391847,7 +429986,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "target_count": 11, "status_counts": { - "inprogress": 11 + "candidate": 11 }, "job_file": "enemies-40011-4001b/job.json" }, @@ -392051,7 +430190,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "target_count": 1, "status_counts": { - "inprogress": 1 + "candidate": 1 }, "job_file": "enemies-4006e-4006e/job.json" }, @@ -392111,7 +430250,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "target_count": 1, "status_counts": { - "inprogress": 1 + "candidate": 1 }, "job_file": "enemies-40088-40088/job.json" }, @@ -392195,7 +430334,7 @@ "owner": "/root/iron_coast_3", "target_count": 7, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 7 + "registered": 7 }, "job_file": "bosses-400ac-400b2/job.json" }, @@ -392327,7 +430466,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_dark_player", "target_count": 2, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 2 + "registered": 2 }, "job_file": "interface-other-50005-50006/job.json" }, @@ -392507,7 +430646,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "inprogress": 16 + "candidate": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-10410-1041f/job.json" }, @@ -393275,7 +431414,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "inprogress": 16 + "candidate": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-2031d-2032c/job.json" }, @@ -393287,7 +431426,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "inprogress": 16 + "candidate": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-2032d-2033c/job.json" }, @@ -393299,7 +431438,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "inprogress": 16 + "candidate": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-2033d-2034c/job.json" }, @@ -393308,10 +431447,10 @@ "name": "Terrain set 2 shard 37", "category": "Terrain", "kind": "contextual_terrain_shard", - "owner": null, + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "missing": 16 + "candidate": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-2034d-2035c/job.json" }, @@ -393320,10 +431459,10 @@ "name": "Terrain set 2 shard 38", "category": "Terrain", "kind": "contextual_terrain_shard", - "owner": null, + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "missing": 16 + "candidate": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-2035d-2036c/job.json" }, @@ -393332,10 +431471,10 @@ "name": "Terrain set 2 shard 39", "category": "Terrain", "kind": "contextual_terrain_shard", - "owner": null, + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "missing": 16 + "inprogress": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-2036d-2037c/job.json" }, @@ -393344,10 +431483,10 @@ "name": "Terrain set 2 shard 40", "category": "Terrain", "kind": "contextual_terrain_shard", - "owner": null, + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "missing": 16 + "inprogress": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-2037d-2038c/job.json" }, @@ -393356,10 +431495,10 @@ "name": "Terrain set 2 shard 41", "category": "Terrain", "kind": "contextual_terrain_shard", - "owner": null, + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "missing": 16 + "inprogress": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-2038d-2039c/job.json" }, @@ -393368,10 +431507,10 @@ "name": "Terrain set 2 shard 42", "category": "Terrain", "kind": "contextual_terrain_shard", - "owner": null, + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "missing": 16 + "inprogress": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-2039d-203ac/job.json" }, @@ -394091,7 +432230,8 @@ "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "inprogress": 16 + "candidate": 8, + "inprogress": 8 }, "job_file": "terrain-3019d-301ac/job.json" }, @@ -394511,7 +432651,7 @@ "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "inprogress": 16 + "candidate": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-303cd-303dc/job.json" }, @@ -394532,10 +432672,10 @@ "name": "Terrain set 3 shard 49", "category": "Terrain", "kind": "contextual_terrain_shard", - "owner": null, + "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "missing": 16 + "inprogress": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-303ed-303fc/job.json" }, @@ -394823,7 +432963,7 @@ "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 16 + "registered": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-40115-40124/job.json" }, @@ -394835,7 +432975,7 @@ "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 16 + "registered": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-40125-40134/job.json" }, @@ -394847,7 +432987,7 @@ "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 16 + "registered": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-40135-40144/job.json" }, @@ -394859,7 +432999,7 @@ "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 16 + "registered": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-40145-40154/job.json" }, @@ -395096,10 +433236,10 @@ "name": "Terrain set 4 shard 28", "category": "Terrain", "kind": "contextual_terrain_shard", - "owner": null, + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "missing": 16 + "candidate": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-40285-40294/job.json" }, @@ -395108,10 +433248,10 @@ "name": "Terrain set 4 shard 29", "category": "Terrain", "kind": "contextual_terrain_shard", - "owner": null, + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "missing": 16 + "candidate": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-40295-402a4/job.json" }, @@ -395120,10 +433260,10 @@ "name": "Terrain set 4 shard 30", "category": "Terrain", "kind": "contextual_terrain_shard", - "owner": null, + "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "missing": 16 + "inprogress": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-402a5-402b4/job.json" }, diff --git a/docs/hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md b/docs/hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md index 4e8c7130..c95b17d2 100644 --- a/docs/hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md +++ b/docs/hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md @@ -1,58 +1,63 @@ # HD coordinator checkpoint — 11 October 2026 -The reviewed external development pack contains **929 original picture frames in 377 complete sequences**. The committed Linux and Windows playable snapshots remain at **800 frames / 340 sequences**, assembled at `964ba93` from the separate immutable 800-frame handoff. Root owns runtime data, binaries, libraries and archives; coordinator owns external development registration and this metadata. Original references, prompts and review jobs remain external under `../data/`. Bundled originals and approved runtime art are tracked under this repository's `data/`. +The reviewed external development pack contains **1,037 original picture frames in 396 complete sequences**. The committed Linux and Windows playable snapshots remain **800 frames / 340 sequences**, assembled at `964ba93` from the immutable 800-frame handoff. Root owns runtime data, binaries, libraries and archives; coordinator owns external development registration and this metadata. Bundled originals and approved runtime art are tracked under this repository's data/. Working originals, prompts, job candidates and review evidence remain external under ../data/. ## Verified development coverage | Category | Registered / original pictures | | --- | ---: | | Player banking | 21 / 21 | -| Bosses | 223 / 249 | -| Enemies and ground objects | 129 / 419 | +| Bosses | 232 / 249 | +| Enemies and ground objects | 148 / 419 | | Player and enemy projectiles | 45 / 51 | -| Explosions and effects | 155 / 281 | +| Explosions and effects | 164 / 281 | | Equipment and pickups | 47 / 47 | -| Terrain | 256 / 4,535 | -| Menus, portraits, HUD and other pictures | 53 / 150 | -| Total | 929 / 5,753 | +| Terrain | 320 / 4,535 | +| Menus, portraits, HUD and other pictures | 60 / 150 | +| Total | 1,037 / 5,753 | -All 6,449 catalog entries and 5,753 pictures were audited, with zero HD source/hash/canvas/ID errors. **4,824 pictures still await registration**. The current ledger contains 909 registered, 20 render-reachable, 1,589 candidate, 1,100 in-progress and 2,135 missing pictures. Candidate status establishes neither approval nor a live scene occurrence. Unused and damaged IDs remain required. The 303 AGX delta frames and four bitmap fonts retain classic-art preservation policies and are separate from generated HD coverage. +All 6,449 catalog entries and 5,753 pictures were audited with zero HD source/hash/canvas/ID errors. **4,716 pictures still await registration**. The current ledger contains 1,017 registered, 20 render-reachable, 1,657 candidate, 1,084 in-progress and 1,975 missing pictures. Candidate status establishes neither artistic approval nor a live occurrence. Unused and damaged IDs remain required. The 303 AGX delta frames and four bitmap fonts retain their separate classic-art preservation policies. -## Current exact proof +## Current immutable output proof -`../data/hd/registered-class-review/runtime-929-current/combined-review.json` closes **3,716 actual scale outputs / 4,645 original and scaled PPMs**, all byte-identical to independently accepted references. Both source-age guards are false; diagnostics are empty. The exact immutable library is `target/hd-review-libraries/0ec6137e0e3261e813b2b863cd96c04da55e07cdf29b5c10b1d112e20f0a3daf/libraptor_replica-79676ac8bb9ed60d.rlib`, SHA `0ec6137e0e3261e813b2b863cd96c04da55e07cdf29b5c10b1d112e20f0a3daf`, original build time `1791703254797483881`. The current development `hd.json` SHA is `35897119671889de4391cc0471979338071a3b954cb7f7fbabda1c808f66808a`. Registration checks the library's exact bytes and original build age. +../data/hd/registered-class-review/runtime-1037-current/combined-review.json closes **4,148 actual scale outputs / 5,185 original and scaled PPMs**, all byte-identical to independently accepted references. Both source-age guards are false; diagnostics are empty. The exact immutable release library is `target/hd-review-libraries/0ec6137e0e3261e813b2b863cd96c04da55e07cdf29b5c10b1d112e20f0a3daf/libraptor_replica-79676ac8bb9ed60d.rlib`, SHA `0ec6137e0e3261e813b2b863cd96c04da55e07cdf29b5c10b1d112e20f0a3daf`, original build time `1791703254797483881`. The current development hd.json SHA is `707ab815114579828bcb823cc3e62efa80ea05b54ae83e83dc30c5730cde0e96`. Combined review SHA is `1a9ef32f37cc2074608d6c9ad65e1387751e912e87d7fc5cd6ffb844f31f246a`. Registration verifies exact library bytes and original build age. -All 846 ordinary source pictures introduce no reserved 240–255 labels. 80 source-class pictures retain authentic gameplay palette classes. Three opening cards use their original static 256-color palettes. Sprite/class checks are scoped to exact source/native rendering and do not infer a whole mission, custom-menu route, complete assembled boss or new destroyed partner. +All 952 ordinary source pictures introduce no reserved240–255 labels. 82 source-class pictures retain authentic gameplay classes; three opening cards use their original static256-color palettes. Exact native/source loading does not establish whole-mission completion, custom-menu reachability, complete assembled-boss joins or new destroyed artwork. -The admission journal `batch-929-approval.json` binds **129 additional frames / 22 complete families**, every candidate and peer report, all 645 accepted PPM matches and all 42 complete source/native1/HD4 pages inspected on eight unresampled boards. Families include Set4 structures 400f5–40114, terrain103f0–103ff, Power/Impact/Shield/DeathRayPower, MediumAir 13, SmallGround 35, BUTTON 4, buoy 2, cursor 50019, repeating texture 10019, eight fine-metal craft and EAGLE 30073. Exact material/contour caveats remain in peer and coordinator records. No sibling promotion was needed in this batch. +After the historical929 checkpoint, batch-979-approval.json adds **50 frames / eight complete families**, with250 exact accepted PPMs and15 complete coordinator-inspected source/native1/HD4 pages on four boards. The batch contains radar40115–40134/32, four tread/slat/fork families15, TEXTURE10018 and side trims50005/50006. batch-1037-approval.json adds **58 frames / eleven complete families**, with290 exact accepted PPMs and20 complete inspected pages on six boards: Orange9, difficulty4, craft3008f/92/95/98, ground40135–40154/32, restored10310/200a3 and complete400ac–400b2/7. Every candidate, binding, source, peer evidence, raw and current output is bound. The former held boss mains are SHA-named snapshots before exact sibling-byte promotion; all rejected versions remain unchanged. -Set4 next32 has 70 native contexts / 719 joins / 27 states and 3,392 actual composition checks. Its isolated 64 pack includes 21 unique both-HD damage pairs and four original fallback partners. Terrain 103f0 has 442 pairs / 48 real scenes, 1,960 cases / all 83 boards and no state partners. MediumAir's final local yellow lift is accepted with complete fade intensity falling 37%; tiny peripheral painted-cell losses stay disclosed. SmallGround's first four cell-edge outlines remain warm particle material, with exact warm/brown losses and two adjacent tail additions accepted. Shield has actual patterned shader proof, transparent world centers and occupied-RGB invariance; it adds no foreground paint or live timing assertion. Buoys use cyan/water 240–244 plus blink 252/253, with exact native centers and accepted higher-scale contour differences. +The radar's nine-cell native object, mast, controls and252 lamp remain source-aligned. Its70 contexts/709 pairs/17 states produce3,316 current compositions; nine radar damage partners stay original fallback. The next two ground shards preserve source crack branches, rock positions and shallow divots through36 contexts/121 pairs and756 compositions; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and there are no state partners. Fine soil density/contrast remains visible against original fallback. -## Frozen packaged800 history +Tank phases, forks and stationary architecture retain source identity with exact3–4x occupied-source coverage. Quantified minor shading variance and lower-scale contour smoothing are accepted. New30098 has one missing nativeRGB4 post corner, restored2–4, with both252/253 labels exactly1/4/9/16. Difficulty portraits retain defining faces and framing; warmer painting and the helmet's central pale mark interpreted as a restrained shallow tab with dark underside are accepted, not described as unchanged hardware. Texture repeats preserve connector and slot topology, while stronger edge contrast and burgundy threshold sensitivity remain explicit. -The historical full800 proof remains untouched at `runtime-800-current/combined-review.json`, with 3,200 scales / 4,000 accepted PPMs and immutable library `f71826f4eec106d59a55c12380ee1437a3cfeddf6f9d145480624ff5e5b8eaa5`. Root's later test-only native capture fixes did not alter the production renderer, loader, compositor or shaders. The historical proof is not retroactively associated with a newer library. +Boss10310 preserves the right disc, skirt and feet, accepting two RGB4 corners plus isolated gray rim(60,46) lost4x. Boss200a3's y35 bridges and central dark structure are restored allscales, with17 outer contour losses2–4 and small right expansion accepted. EBOSS6 retains the final two pale plates and stationary horizontal central grille/crossed lower floor; the firstsix bindings/24 outputs remain exact. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted, not byte-stationary. These are complete-family gallery decisions with no whole-boss live assembly claim. -The private handoff is `../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-800-20261011/pack/`, manifest SHA `fbf8b6a9af134e263881ce28f002259affbf0636f53d214ea34bbd8c61205f71`. `handoff-manifest.json` SHA `29821d06c34114101041e50318c5c013a9236e474716a382257d6d252c304b1e` binds all 292 pack-file hashes (290 artwork files plus manifest/provenance), source INDEX and limits. Root copied and independently verified every file into tracked runtime data: 6,742 files / 461,771,350 bytes. Linux and Windows packages, relocated launchers, catalog, HD, all 22 mods and actual SDL/audio checks passed. Later 129 development registrations do not change this frozen packaged snapshot. +Orange9 retains warm ray/fragment/fade character despite stronger4x cell-edge outlines and small adjacent additions. Three alpha16/17/19 exterior specks in101a8 are excluded, while meaningful alpha32 contour pixels are retained. Original alpha, source masks and raw RGB evidence stay distinct. Smoke4 remains held because every actual shaded output equals original nearest-neighbor output, so no visible HD improvement is established. -Earlier admission journals and sibling promotion histories remain intact, including DINO 6, SHIP 40 and corrected 30044. All old held mains/raws and prepared-but-unsubmitted SHIP 40v5 remain preserved. Metadata-only transparent-background corrections keep actual attempts, request/prompt authority, SHA-named old bytes and unchanged raw/candidate bindings. Cursor's missing historical request JSON remains explicit; no retrospective record was invented. Buoy center and cyan/water wording corrections similarly retain before-byte histories. BUTTON's separate four-flag correction was independently verified before admission. +## Frozen Linux/Windows800 history -## Durable owners and later work +The separate historical runtime-800-current/combined-review.json remains unchanged:3,200 scales/4,000 accepted PPMs using immutablef71826f4eec106d59a55c12380ee1437a3cfeddf6f9d145480624ff5e5b8eaa5. Historical929 and979 closures remain separate and are not retroactively associated with a newer library. Root's later test-only terrain capture fixes did not alter the production desktop prefix, loader, compositor or shaders. -Coordinator alone edits external development manifest/provenance/audit/ledger. Queue refresh removes registered jobs, so all owners and reviewers follow original durable job IDs rather than live offsets. Artists never register their own work. Git checkpoints stage only owned paths; `docs/hd-full-review.md` belongs to its reviewer. +The private immutable handoff is ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-800-20261011/pack/, pack manifest SHA `fbf8b6a9af134e263881ce28f002259affbf0636f53d214ea34bbd8c61205f71`. handoff-manifest.json SHA `29821d06c34114101041e50318c5c013a9236e474716a382257d6d252c304b1e` binds292 pack files:290 artwork files plus hd.json/provenance.json. Root copied and verified all into tracked data:6,742 files/461,771,350 bytes. Later237 development approvals are not included in that runtime snapshot. -- Root owns runtime assembly/platform code and deferred straight-alpha resampling, source-class alpha-anchor and encoder-rounding policy. No such loader policy changed during 929 closure. Any future actual-pixel change requires a new controlled comparison, preserving 800 / 929 history. HANGP 1010b (1619×971) remains held by strict aspect policy; no clipping, stretching or artist color compensation. -- `hd_full_review` approved four later tank families / 15 frames, still awaiting coordinator fresh closure. It exclusively reviews terrain 10400–1040f (16 frames) with 531 pairs / 46 real scenes and original damaged partners retained as fallback. Its scoped own-doc commit is `c386550`. -- `iron_coast_2` independently approved radar jobs 40115–40134 (32 frames), with exact 9-cell radar/native 252 lamp proof. It now reviews ORIGINAL jobs 7/8, 40135–40154. Nine radar damaged partners retain original fallback; no whole-map or new liveHost claim. -- `iron_coast_5` approved TEXTURE 10018 and side textures 50005/50006, still separate from929. Repeated contexts/connectors and exact seam crops were inspected; stronger highlights and burgundy threshold sensitivity are accepted disclosures. It now exclusively reviews difficulty portraits 1001a–1001d (4 frames). -- `windows_persistence` held LargeAir 12 v6 for authentic painted ray/arc and fading-ring cells absent at all/higher scales. The48-in-64 original viewport/alpha32 retention passes technically. SHIP35 v3 remains held for 55 occupied losses and both bottom feet. It now reviews new enemy singles 3008f/30092/30095/30098. -- `terrain_capture_fixture` exclusively reviews iron3's 10310 v4,200a3 v4 and seven-frame 400ac v3 siblings / 9 frames. The former right-disc/skirt, lower bridge and stationary grille/floor holds require different-peer art judgment. Its source-unchanged rounding proposal is future-scoped. Native destroyed/unused fixture fixes have exact selected-source proof and add no blanket artwork approval. -- `iron_coast_3` preserves those three frozen siblings and every failed variant. Atlas 300a8–ab v6 remains held for painted side-strip loss and partial source-class coverage. Approved 30044 stays frozen; 300a0 / 200ba palette-alpha remedies remain root-owned. -- `iron_coast_6` independently approved MediumAir 13/SmallGround 35 and the admitted enemy singles. It now exclusively reviews OrangeSparks 9 v3. Terrain children retain original middle 5–36 and late 37–68 scopes; numerous full proposals have geometry/material/fallback holds and exact immutable galleries, not automatic coverage. -- `hd_dark_player` continues original UI scope, preserving admitted files. Difficulty 4 and side 2 are frozen for peer review/closure. Original HANGP rounding hold remains untouched; no specific classic-control reachability through custom Rust menus is inferred. -- `hd_enemies_01` continues original disjoint production, preserving admitted nine craft singles and later approved tank 15. Source-cell/phase/cue holds remain explicit for damaged craft, troop poses and earlier outlines. APE refusal evidence is preserved without automatic retry. -- `campaign_integration` continues disjoint source-driven effects. Orange 9 is reserved to iron6. LargeAir corrections must be separate siblings bound to exact missing painted cells; accepted/held raws and viewport history stay frozen. Smoke 4 has no demonstrated visible HD enhancement because actual shade outputs equal original nearest-neighbor outputs. Ground gold/alpha holds, Flare source-hole/material and remaining geometry failures stay held. -- Terrain1 registered 112 tiles; 10400 peer review and bridge 103d5/6 row/material holds remain separate. Its14-target partial family stays complete=false. Terrain2 registered 48 and retains post-array footprint, water/soil density and coarse-mosaic/semantic holds. Terrain3 registered 32; invented beams, rim/material and burn-grain transitions remain held. Terrain4 registered 64; radar32 is independently approved later, while industrial compound material and mixed-fallback grain limits remain disclosed. +Native Windows third CI38121272504 passed279 tests/0failed/24ignored, exact committedGNU launcher/gameplay/full800/all22mods and a freshMSVC build. Linux/Windows relocated launch, catalog, SDL and audio checks passed. Root documentation proof is fb6574a. Final Windows archive SHA25fca23c5ca95b754cf49fcf24b07d94dec8094863e6750c1898a55d6893cbfe,602433522bytes; Linux SHA0f384c3592a1a6d9302c16769cd8aafb096464fe17150ea1a66b34743fbdc97a. Both archiveCRC/data/runtime/source/doc checks passed. No further packaged art changes are authorized by this development metadata checkpoint. -At least 50 further independently approved frames remain separate from 929: radar 32, tank 15, TEXTURE 10018 and side 2. Every later admission still requires current exact references, coordinator complete family inspection and registration. No later files are packaged by this checkpoint. +Metadata-only provenance corrections preserve before-byte snapshots and exact actual attempt/request/prompt authority. All raw/candidate/source/render bindings stay unchanged. Cursor's absent historical request JSON remains disclosed; no retrospective request history was invented. Buoy center252/253 and cyan/water240–244 wording corrections likewise retain prior bytes. BUTTON's four corrected transparency flags were independently verified. -Generation uses four shared submissions with inspected source/saved prompts, acquire→successful start→built-in await→classify/report/release in one execution before QA. Unknown cells are reconciled before retries. Continue remaining original catalog without a full-HD completion claim. +## Durable owners and outstanding holds + +Coordinator alone registers external development art and refreshes audit/ledger. Queue offsets change after admission; use original durable job IDs. Artists never approve/register their own artwork. Commit only owned paths; docs/hd-full-review.md remains reviewer-owned. Root alone assembles tracked runtime and controls future loader/alpha/shader/encoder policy. No such production policy changed during1037 closure. + +- hd_full_review exclusively reviews terrain10400–1040f. Its current10406 organic-ground-as-rectangular-slabs material hold is concrete; no complete16 approval. Other current contexts are still under full inspection. Raw/candidate remain frozen until the review completes. +- iron_coast_2 has independently approved original Set4 jobs1–8/128frames and now reviews original jobs9/10,40155–40174. Additional lower foliage cells40179/7a may appear only in a separately pinned complete-object diagnostic, without admission; the160 reviewed pack retains original fallback there. +- iron_coast_5 now independently reviews iron6's original Terrain3 shards3/4,3010d–3012c/32. Earlier joined64 state diagnostics complement individual exhaustive proof without certifying complete combined seams. Specific gray-remnant/bright-rubble material concerns require artistic judgment. +- windows_persistence holds exact LargeAirv9 for unchanged101eb's connected seven-cell inner lip and101ec's five-cell upper shoulder, with30/14 whole cells absent4x. The newly repairedfirst2/late2 phases are improved/accepted with minor edge caveats, but do not override the full-family hold. Its new exclusive singles are300ac/3009d/4006e, especially opaque internal gray/warm-center fidelity. +- terrain_capture_fixture completed the nine-frame boss sibling decisions and root's read-only rounding investigation. Its source-class/shader/scene probes do not imply blanket art or live encounter approval. +- iron_coast_3 preserves accepted10310v4/200a3v4/400acv3 plus every failed version. Atlas300a8–abv6 remains held for connected painted side-strip loss and partial source-class coverage.300a0/200ba palette-alpha issues stay root-owned. +- iron_coast_6's effects and independent enemy decisions remain bound. Its authored Terrain3 early shards3/4 stay frozen for another reviewer. Children retain original middle5–36 and late37–68 production: large held cohorts have current exact galleries, while physical soil grain, gray/char relief, invented beams/rims and mixed-fallback material concerns remain unapproved. +- campaign_integration preserves admitted Orange9 and earlier complete effects. Separate genuine LargeAir corrections may target only101eb/101ec's exact lost connected structures, retaining the other ten bindings. Flare holes/material, Ground gold/alpha and other contour holds remain explicit; no artist color compensation for loader behavior. +- hd_enemies_01 preserves admitted tanks and singles;300ac/3009d/4006e are frozen for exclusive review,40088 separately unassigned. Multipart IOTARG/DMOON production remains author-only. Damaged craft backing/cues, troop poses and APE refusal remain held. +- hd_dark_player continues the complete23-icon family102e1–102f7; partial single-icon probes are not coverage. HANGP1010b opaque1619x971 remains held by exact-aspect policy pending a separate controlled root decision. No classic-menu route is inferred through current custom Rust menus. +- Terrain1 has112 registered tiles;10400 review,10410 partial production and bridge103d5/6 row/gap/material holds are separate. Terrain2 has48 registered and many complete proposals with post-array/cap/gray machinery, water/ground density and coarse-grid holds. Its202fd–2030c unequal-panel retry stays unbound rather than distorted. Terrain3 has32 registered. Terrain4 has128 registered; later industrial compound/fallback-grain limits remain disclosed. + +The original catalog remains incomplete. Continue source-driven production and independent review, then perform exact current output continuity, complete family coordinator inspection and registration for each later batch. No later candidate is packaged or admitted merely because it decodes.