From e01206de02203bcc7c2dd429fee7bafa434de0e2 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: raptorreplica Date: Mon, 12 Oct 2026 02:09:36 +1100 Subject: [PATCH] Record corrected terrain families and 1844-frame development closure --- docs/hd-art.md | 14 +- docs/hd-backlog.md | 38 +- docs/hd-completion.json | 15466 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++-- docs/hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md | 49 +- 4 files changed, 14761 insertions(+), 806 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/hd-art.md b/docs/hd-art.md index 40675e38..da10badf 100644 --- a/docs/hd-art.md +++ b/docs/hd-art.md @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ The Rust Options screen includes **HD art**. It starts disabled. Enable it to use reviewed artwork from the selected data directory's `hd/hd.json`; each missing or rejected frame keeps the selected original / 2x / 3x / 4x crisp treatment. The bundled runtime uses `data/`, while development artwork and review jobs live under `../data/`. The scale setting still determines the indexed rendering resolution, and the HD toggle can be changed while paused. HD art is presentation only: simulation, collision sizes, banking positions and save content IDs stay unchanged. -The development base-game pack currently supplies **1,812 reviewed replacement frames in 765 complete sequences**. These include all twenty-one light, dark and firing-flash player poses, 232 boss frames, complete vehicle families, ground defenses and opening bunkers, all forty-seven equipment and pickup pictures, projectile and effect animations, eleven HUD picture glyphs, nine pilot portraits, four difficulty portraits, both title logos, three standalone opening cards and 960 canonical terrain tiles. The released Linux/Windows runtime retains the earlier exact1,148-frame /421-sequence snapshot; the later 664 outer development additions are separate. Root completed both final Stage2 archives and Linux/Windows platform validation at this exact 1,148-frame snapshot; the previous 800-frame archives and their proofs remain historical. Later candidates and approvals stay outside this frozen runtime checkpoint. The complete catalog backlog and generation status are listed in [hd-backlog.md](hd-backlog.md). +The development base-game pack currently supplies **1,844 reviewed replacement frames in 797 complete sequences**. These include all twenty-one light, dark and firing-flash player poses, 232 boss frames, complete vehicle families, ground defenses and opening bunkers, all forty-seven equipment and pickup pictures, projectile and effect animations, eleven HUD picture glyphs, nine pilot portraits, four difficulty portraits, both title logos, three standalone opening cards and 992 canonical terrain tiles. The released Linux/Windows runtime retains the earlier exact1,148-frame /421-sequence snapshot; the later 696 outer development additions are separate. Root completed both final Stage2 archives and Linux/Windows platform validation at this exact 1,148-frame snapshot; the previous 800-frame archives and their proofs remain historical. Later candidates and approvals stay outside this frozen runtime checkpoint. The complete catalog backlog and generation status are listed in [hd-backlog.md](hd-backlog.md). | Reviewed artwork | Original asset IDs | Supplied / complete frames | | --- | --- | ---: | @@ -153,6 +153,7 @@ The development base-game pack currently supplies **1,812 reviewed replacement f | Damaged dark-craft pictures | `0x3009a`, `0x3009b`, `0x300a2` | 3 / 3 | | Complete classic menu lettering | `0x10023`–`0x1002a` | 8 / 8 | | Source shore, buildings and one damaged terrain picture | `0x10480`–`0x1049f` | 32 / 32 | +| Corrected fine soil, rail, mesh and ridge families | `0x10460`–`0x1047f` | 32 / 32 | | Further source shores, water and angular ridges | `0x104a0`–`0x104af` | 16 / 16 | | Fine industrial shore, grilles, pipes and damaged remnants | `0x201dd`–`0x2020c` | 48 / 48 | | Corrected planted green rows and continuous grass | `0x2014d`–`0x2016c` | 32 / 32 | @@ -355,3 +356,14 @@ The new shores, dark grooves, rail and ridge endpoints, seven grille bars, roof Manifest `9e439f7d1804d6ca020ed6a8907a39298edcddd906ebbab6c9b05231a413d463`, provenance `9d38b6be9f524463c9baa5c1dfed1a33a9deb69a5e76532115c0e59a4819414f`, approval `24632a8e3d1183af0489f48076506ed154e36be8d50e6c5f5ae0c6ce0e0645cc` and canonical registration `90d8fd0e44edec76233325f4aa1b52494546da074d7dc698f9c6a7f457c5bb85` bind the exact complete families. Private future input ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-1812-20261012/pack/ contains 704 files / 1,481,569,435 bytes with distinct private inodes; handoff `2f408e91f30ca1dde263bf2ba3e6e182514abd145f7b3743756466e7e6e85e9f`. The prior 1748 handoff and all 6,853 packaged runtime files remain exact. Released runtime stays **1,148 frames / 421 sequences with 45 accepted mods**. Parent alone coordinates any later runtime copy, build or export. The pending snapshot records **610 independently approved unregistered pictures** requiring coordinator review, including 16 original12 pictures with a missing saved-prompt provenance gap. Corrected 10460/10470 and newer source-contour repairs are future-only. Source-rib, atlas-edge, erased detail, worm and opaque-scene holds remain separate. Original catalog completion, seamless mixed-terrain maps, live Host, palette timing and UI-route coverage are not established by this registration. + + +Batch 1844 adds **32 terrain pictures in two complete families**, 10460–1046f and 10470–1047f, yielding **1,844 / 5,753 originals**, **797 complete sequences** and **992 terrain pictures**. Coordinator review `31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604` records actual inspection of all 32 full selected raw canvases and eight complete source/current 1–4/native 2–3 boards. Independent full cardinal/native context receipts remain separately pinned; no new coordinator terrain-context invocation is claimed. + +Fourteen genuine material corrections replace the enlarged cellular finish while preserving source rail endpoints, mesh apertures, ridges and muted colors. The other seven/eleven bindings and 35/55 outputs remain exact. Source angular shade fields, stronger ridge relief, native 1 smoothing and HD/original density rectangles are explicit qualifications. Retained 1046e rough mottling and 10470/10478 faceted source shade fields were accepted after direct source/actual 1–4 inspection; this does not claim uniform smooth texture or identical RGB. Unused 1047d stays gallery-only, with no state/wreck claim. Held historical main artwork, early probe evidence and rejected 1047a-v2 remain unchanged. + +Full current Rust proof `ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5` compares all **9,220 source/scaled outputs** exactly: 9,060 prior 1812 outputs plus 160 new, including 7,376 scaled outputs. Every 1812 baseline binding remains exact. Actual immutable c0c3/compatible ba61 dependencies, both literal false age guards and all 18 recursive source SHA/size/mtime records are stable. The 116 combined contact pages are hash-bound, not described as freshly inspected. Two exact accepted sibling candidates were promoted for the official registrar only after preserving old main/coordinator/job bytes in SHA-named history; explicit sibling/source/raw/proof pixels were unchanged. + +Manifest `23a51de8c951ad06c104af7dfc227a9a19117cc032bb5371772b5d8e7b9e39d4`, provenance `693ee4002f1868aa35a497272a7bce92839c5bd54fd0036f95203c2e46deed8d`, approval `c893608e818198db424324f3949a98ecbf9ee20c8d631c738c6cf6031e210a9c` and registration `a1279b7a68771fd1a2fc1db964f8f397e612f02db3f54a288326913f54c6c99c` bind the accepted families. Immutable private input ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-1844-20261012/pack/ contains 736 files / 1,584,801,769 bytes with distinct private inodes; handoff `d10580305bfcb17f738849dc02356a35911c093ab7cb1140c1627caa443edf42`. Every 1812 handoff payload and all 6,853 packaged runtime files remain exact. Released runtime stays **1,148 frames / 421 sequences with 45 accepted mods**; parent alone controls any later copy/build/export. + +The frozen pending snapshot has **738 independently approved unregistered pictures** requiring coordinator review, including 16 original 12 pictures with a missing saved-prompt provenance gap. Source-rib, atlas-border, misplaced shallow panels, erased low-scale lavender/ember cues, square material, worm and opaque-scene holds remain separate. Registration does not establish catalog completion, seamless mixed maps, live Host, palette timing or UI-route coverage. diff --git a/docs/hd-backlog.md b/docs/hd-backlog.md index ea472b72..b92f4da1 100644 --- a/docs/hd-backlog.md +++ b/docs/hd-backlog.md @@ -1,8 +1,8 @@ # Original artwork HD backlog -The checked catalog contains **5,753 standalone picture frames**. The active outer HD pack supplies **1,812**; **3,941** still await a registered HD replacement. All original IDs, including unnamed/unused graphics and destroyed variants, remain required. Authored mod art is separate. The outer pack contains 1,812 reviewed originals in 765 complete sequences after current 9,060-PPM continuity. Completed Linux/Windows Stage2 packages retain 1,148 frames / 421 sequences and 45 accepted mods, with every released binary/library/manifest/data byte unchanged. The private future input is ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-1812-20261012/pack/, handoff SHA `2f408e91f30ca1dde263bf2ba3e6e182514abd145f7b3743756466e7e6e85e9f`; parent alone selects a runtime update. +The checked catalog contains **5,753 standalone picture frames**. The active outer HD pack supplies **1,844**; **3,909** still await a registered HD replacement. All original IDs, including unnamed/unused graphics and destroyed variants, remain required. Authored mod art is separate. Current coverage is 1,844 reviewed originals in 797 complete sequences after 9,220 exact source/scaled output comparisons. Linux/Windows Stage2 packages retain 1,148 frames/ 421 sequences and 45 accepted mods, with every released binary/library/manifest/data byte unchanged. Private future input ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-1844-20261012/pack/ has handoff SHA `d10580305bfcb17f738849dc02356a35911c093ab7cb1140c1627caa443edf42`; parent alone selects a runtime update. -Batch 1812 adds 64 terrain pictures in four complete families: 104a0 and Terrain2 originals 14–16. All 21 selected full raws and 16 complete source/native 1–4 boards were coordinator-inspected. All 9,060 current source/scaled outputs match accepted references, both source guards are false, and all 18 recursive sources are stable. No sibling promotion occurred. Corrected 10460/10470 remain future-only despite independent approval; source-rib, atlas-edge and material/detail holds remain separate. The pending snapshot has 610 independently approved unregistered pictures, including 16 with a missing-prompt gap requiring parent policy. Mixed HD/original material islands remain an accepted limitation. +Batch1844 adds corrected 10460/10470 complete 32 after independent context review, coordinator inspection of32 full raws/eight complete source/current scale boards and whole 1844 continuity. Fourteen genuine fine-material corrections preserve source rail/mesh/ridge geometry; seven/eleven unchanged siblings and all held history remain exact. Two accepted sibling promotions preserve old mains separately. Both source-age guards are false and all 18 recursive sources stable. Mixed HD/original grain/value islands, stronger source shade relief and retained irregular mottling are accepted qualifications. The pending snapshot has 738 independently approved unregistered pictures; 16 original 12 targets retain a missing-prompt provenance gap. Whole-family source-rib, border, panel-position, lavender/ember legibility and square-finish holds remain separate. | Category | Picture frames | Registered HD | Missing HD | Declared sequences / terrain sets | | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | @@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ Batch 1812 adds 64 terrain pictures in four complete families: 104a0 and Terrain | Player and enemy projectiles | 51 | 45 | 6 | 18 | | Explosions and effects | 281 | 219 | 62 | 25 | | Equipment and pickups | 47 | 47 | 0 | 23 | -| Terrain | 4,535 | 960 | 3,575 | 4 | +| Terrain | 4,535 | 992 | 3,543 | 4 | | Menus, portraits, HUD and other pictures | 150 | 77 | 73 | mixed static / animated | ## Registered pack and generation jobs @@ -786,6 +786,38 @@ Only registered frames passing canvas, source-hash, PNG and alpha checks count a | Terrain 2020a | `0x2020a` | 1 / 1 | | Terrain 2020b | `0x2020b` | 1 / 1 | | Terrain 2020c | `0x2020c` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10460 standalone correction | `0x10460` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10461 standalone correction | `0x10461` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10462 standalone correction | `0x10462` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10463 standalone correction | `0x10463` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10464 standalone correction | `0x10464` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10465 standalone correction | `0x10465` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10466 standalone correction | `0x10466` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10467 standalone correction | `0x10467` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10468 standalone correction | `0x10468` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10469 standalone correction | `0x10469` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 1046a standalone correction | `0x1046a` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 1046b standalone correction | `0x1046b` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 1046c standalone correction | `0x1046c` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 1046d standalone correction | `0x1046d` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 1046e standalone correction | `0x1046e` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 1046f standalone correction | `0x1046f` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10470 standalone correction | `0x10470` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10471 standalone correction | `0x10471` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10472 standalone correction | `0x10472` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10473 standalone correction | `0x10473` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10474 standalone correction | `0x10474` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10475 standalone correction | `0x10475` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10476 standalone correction | `0x10476` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10477 standalone correction | `0x10477` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10478 standalone correction | `0x10478` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10479 standalone correction | `0x10479` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 1047a standalone correction | `0x1047a` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 1047b standalone correction | `0x1047b` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 1047c standalone correction | `0x1047c` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 1047d standalone correction | `0x1047d` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 1047e standalone correction | `0x1047e` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 1047f standalone correction | `0x1047f` | 1 / 1 | | Generation job | Status | | --- | --- | diff --git a/docs/hd-completion.json b/docs/hd-completion.json index 96fa0b6d..3ecb7b96 100644 --- a/docs/hd-completion.json +++ b/docs/hd-completion.json @@ -19,10 +19,10 @@ ], "stage_contract": "Every generated candidate stays distinct from review, registration and render reachability. Original-only fallback is temporary for every required picture. Native cinematics/fonts have explicit preservation exceptions, not HD claims.", "picture_status_counts": { - "registered": 1792, - "inprogress": 650, + "registered": 1824, + "inprogress": 616, "renderreachable": 20, - "candidate": 2683, + "candidate": 2685, "missing": 608 }, "assets": { @@ -176945,7 +176945,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10460", "family_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -176959,36 +176959,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "51f65619499d20f54fa9493635b9ec57ce6bc0bdc9dcffe527495be3e8a7b6ab", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.647995+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10461", - "10463", - "10464", - "10465", - "10466", - "1046a", - "1046b", - "1046c", - "1046d" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "e6fcbe38ceff45160d84841405e8363db4a15fdb4cd462cd46ebfdd65016fbab", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.796043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 6a639187edfd3fc8bd3fbee44c0aa5281f89016932da8b50951c3c3d036fe8f1", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10460-original.ppm", + "sha256": "898b3c1a6fdbd1d6bab7291ea1543b5e5615e13f11d93604a56a89dcf35b7648", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8ccea87926d7ef3505c568f6737b4ff851fbb9bbec30ded88b9770c828aa751f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "02c28841546da2fde0753a1ebbc6e4e2b3e856c18a293ba47aca28fec8a74f29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "764632e5b9e3adc93dfa7504f894d585ce7a5938469c965720ae7f5b4eaac314", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "824525dd48f88085b24a76dfd6cc3d4432047ba7a259db40219be93331992691", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26cc194328aef2dafd75e1190bda8278a41876bf152f58c9207c3a9b760d32e6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "546b47110af067d026f8670639bd4b3bf3923653fde79af6afc003d236bfd9db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0bf6f6989d65d892f5984135190af10e167d132f47cff0236397bd66bfdd8907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "15f6ec7f8ab75cedec0fd4be7298804772cd4d1e9991363ae5ef0c268fa5b4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a71a3f345b92174973fb61369574b658584f31ac3b6b18fae2821506c990f450", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f45ba5f1464339e5268cbd2b175c22cd272c6f2bf43951c59277d09c2f9494bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "636c8fe8568c3992921fb8102da33993531f9f45dd791f9a07e24654798223b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "597fd8c9cfdc20ad5c8c6735cba7543bebe0613faca382d4cc92a1aaa84d2eb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cb51b539f24dedc959b46ea4fcfa1de9b8d9e77580944432c16b955147031a1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6b7fa69282aec6b173caa39ab883a6f091b2ab8cc029b94eea5e97144551fcbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9f396545b1928abfe8ac606ebda3f58ee0f17c99633f1fae4b2d85fea2206dd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85d1b4b05bf45fe304b1ccb661038af6ffa27774aa31c22446f715cc2b42e40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5f16a8fbfe6fec61b1cc9756b51f05d460b5366275d0cd35d47d58c6909f08f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8d407588964c73e6639940e634e74d0e6e289fc292631dd16ba70289715a0df9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e6aac54d2a1ff7e61f6496cb5aaf07f63b4fb99442d828368f34af3e239528a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b33e48c44028411ea2d5a1b558f5bd4e105c4377ab78226feb3923783d01a033", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "421f2cd698da4d58e2d8b1176bc0bdfe273c8f13d50c82d0d8d7dca972bfe544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "75d6426d1d07032e87e70918df6394c740085ffe11fc043e88d0fec8c1fd492b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56a950961dd5e9db6ab8a0f0f05b851b12b720161242f7106884afbf40c5af1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ba5dbc75e7c13a721bacdec8f71e239e8280d45612ebda32fcc2f577ad7c6228", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ceb556a184ace68d4c364694bc5befae02b8f00a9c23ef64cc033fe419614b57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac29c75b5f2d1bc376eee8605f1558d5d2e4a7898c82171e88545feca5eaa7a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3d56ac096c2ec9337ac727297e726a975e2b186ab97eb14dd3b714ead3382fcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4b86e58799dbb953a6173f9d5df01c39c9183188f74494fbcdafd78f7d16fbe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ea69fe44bfac61674e6866fc00ee06b70e0ed423a6faf19a3d2eb1965fed853c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1072a95735a18956761f4ce44b3ff6a0067f75f272daed0b5bb582dd223400e9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "316e340614bcc1ee4233263634b85b8de3160aaadd2e25726eff86b4aae6031a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4b51447841eb462b312dbaff6e11ba8406b07cc81f8efe92924e47364c0fb4fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "77e21af78bece3d34276237b0095e7998861fc7130cc80b995ce7d50353f0a60", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12a534545dfe8517f5f35a3416521c973fa0d859cfa40dbac0669d60c7c7dc63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-original.ppm", + "sha256": "27748411c905ecb51b413582b2a6eafc587ca774a1b89dd55100a05981f9ce56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "935f8bbaa2815d02ca77e1d222d21bddc09cc3dfd510ed5507c4eb27c0ed2b99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2c66b6874c47e5fd2dafb1ab9d9b87067dd7e46e2778c9a02f7617c181cc8473", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4f82a853ef7f8b3aaa1a359332aa53f05bfb52a63657aab4110815f81ef510d8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "acaadaa9ade781b07308d01fb953e2e60773d35cec3381a78c171c4a78ae6702", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75d3e8bf210b11e36cb1b4cf5f74f30cea322598d210963fcde115140378cf88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "12ea419d4824f5009acc727dfc85699e889b4e06e8c5aa35578891d4d9f81fc2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e755de57acddc93bb716d6a4b665019eedd609c5f3a59a3bc7aabbf9e7b51203", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "deeb6d253fe4efb60698e2c17b04b54dc50542926ef1cde457deb39c85f564fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0f51e854b6b03b245bd190c787e9de204993906fbdcf20a0761d586cb67e4cbd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c111f88fefcb3ce81b4b8f4481111293f9679851f40e19102278f886bdd07f21", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6305433d67b224f608635195c77d18809ad0c00a1893efb5598852e477a34a7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ef5d6f078b7aa9e858629865d9f5497fecbf1b8a5fdcd908844e45877eaf40c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5c9f8ca3e9ac2f49e0922ba8d308331b2ddcef253924dc86c468cb1477371721", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "57ccebc2a2409df1dfc9d9c78fc23950ad31a4e223e0bed57ff5f723159b76ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5d7734f7e7a6b7c25416ec4c6ba51447a7d7ced46886ef4d47bafa49bcfcad53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85697cabd91fe979f6b44429c83e4caa3052f2ced9d9c82837531bd68d11fa88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7e3efe1b2659646f933f632338787ff0bad46dfbecc573f8db258d383edec032", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7c21ace6e1701014de3ab95674736b3d4a3883f51edd15cc1b034a273fb8109b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cea03b5bd710950f0a4ef149f9d2f7ec8c542c234c81bf7fa7a45dfa128ff997", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d94829dc36a046a7112f7aea8626c582cbc2be7c9297411037c7f988d8a249", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "90dcccc15fecf7efbf56eea2ddc31d80b6696a1ba7c73bc57b08ce9d06e189a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8ec111d8aa7631f0bb6bbd354ff80df4684920297cc665f0dc887df5c8118123", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e01305134e4f4c9631cdd134e44ec2a8e716527ea86a73a3e434a63261460311", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "739d057c7381f3fe07e4fc22a43f09e0cf80e0bb25981242408b46a5635217b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c381eff884cc01744e69c8db42c1a5aba56dbf20225fd98eb92e437041ceceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ece3d9f78ffa10dc14b795700a41cebc30932e1e4c570038e3b1c917c43562", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f2a41c469ddfe5972e08e0c6f09acc4204e2e93a0f0645406591686967892596", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bcd76dfa305e7540d343aae8ecc2598b5f073f6fd260cd2e6a6d9fca18016150", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f50487375fcf946268136e5ff9e625f1474366792edec5a8a13ea49c1a530408", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a7ccea589e8dd6f3cba31f3aa5f1d5f77bb3029bc0286f2ecbb336349092ad10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f127a50306a634c12dbd18a36e4407a0a4dc5d56a8e2269858b4475a8c8590", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a5438499352ee5f30f919f08517a054a5e7d818ee07260aacec14adde18a765", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c8af1ab49929b1f36db885ffc5d3f2f99cb2a47526ddf56ff4bcf8473fad607", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "651998a2fce220108396b8910e0ea10681c997dc25abbdc0f0f6656b283317f3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "139968d1e25c6af2067fd62ced01a0ca93f0df02ab686422c45b7e5f682f150b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "60b5aa372b038498eb1838b1a1acfe1aa835ee9f57658b74026d66c0df588895", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f81973afc08692f1c241ac6103efb90f3455d2794726164f5e0a2227258e899d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ef2cc83858f43c5c57ca0734c62e1ef3a9f409bdaa646313e1c125d94caef1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a073c510f4338a77c9d27f197766de62298dc06447aa3d1328eb47a5a2baea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "56630435871566b9f3584d53e0b35dc0ce4c5562e4d57a8ecc56aa802a3612ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2f8b3129470d47676376ba5af87c57841c19f886ad34655320a8557877a8fce6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1cdac0a8da58aacc95ba1dba8b08f4ea05709ed42486891762e982885497ee31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d3c3e919b2334cc9f1deed0399f2b33f6875db35c50e81ad30bdec60618f0fe4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f1510be6ac21152bdf66eea74a787f634dfb9d0e3867017ae7684ef837dcd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10460/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "f9ee03e0653f7884ffc8ce8efad0f229e9c7ced6ae5c4fc0b9de130913b8afdc" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace-job.json", + "sha256": "b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.678581+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "10461": { @@ -177010,7 +177437,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10461", "family_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -177024,36 +177451,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "51f65619499d20f54fa9493635b9ec57ce6bc0bdc9dcffe527495be3e8a7b6ab", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.647995+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10461", - "10463", - "10464", - "10465", - "10466", - "1046a", - "1046b", - "1046c", - "1046d" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "e6fcbe38ceff45160d84841405e8363db4a15fdb4cd462cd46ebfdd65016fbab", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.796043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 6a639187edfd3fc8bd3fbee44c0aa5281f89016932da8b50951c3c3d036fe8f1", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10460-original.ppm", + "sha256": "898b3c1a6fdbd1d6bab7291ea1543b5e5615e13f11d93604a56a89dcf35b7648", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8ccea87926d7ef3505c568f6737b4ff851fbb9bbec30ded88b9770c828aa751f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "02c28841546da2fde0753a1ebbc6e4e2b3e856c18a293ba47aca28fec8a74f29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "764632e5b9e3adc93dfa7504f894d585ce7a5938469c965720ae7f5b4eaac314", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "824525dd48f88085b24a76dfd6cc3d4432047ba7a259db40219be93331992691", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26cc194328aef2dafd75e1190bda8278a41876bf152f58c9207c3a9b760d32e6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "546b47110af067d026f8670639bd4b3bf3923653fde79af6afc003d236bfd9db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0bf6f6989d65d892f5984135190af10e167d132f47cff0236397bd66bfdd8907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "15f6ec7f8ab75cedec0fd4be7298804772cd4d1e9991363ae5ef0c268fa5b4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a71a3f345b92174973fb61369574b658584f31ac3b6b18fae2821506c990f450", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f45ba5f1464339e5268cbd2b175c22cd272c6f2bf43951c59277d09c2f9494bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "636c8fe8568c3992921fb8102da33993531f9f45dd791f9a07e24654798223b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "597fd8c9cfdc20ad5c8c6735cba7543bebe0613faca382d4cc92a1aaa84d2eb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cb51b539f24dedc959b46ea4fcfa1de9b8d9e77580944432c16b955147031a1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6b7fa69282aec6b173caa39ab883a6f091b2ab8cc029b94eea5e97144551fcbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9f396545b1928abfe8ac606ebda3f58ee0f17c99633f1fae4b2d85fea2206dd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85d1b4b05bf45fe304b1ccb661038af6ffa27774aa31c22446f715cc2b42e40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5f16a8fbfe6fec61b1cc9756b51f05d460b5366275d0cd35d47d58c6909f08f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8d407588964c73e6639940e634e74d0e6e289fc292631dd16ba70289715a0df9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e6aac54d2a1ff7e61f6496cb5aaf07f63b4fb99442d828368f34af3e239528a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b33e48c44028411ea2d5a1b558f5bd4e105c4377ab78226feb3923783d01a033", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "421f2cd698da4d58e2d8b1176bc0bdfe273c8f13d50c82d0d8d7dca972bfe544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "75d6426d1d07032e87e70918df6394c740085ffe11fc043e88d0fec8c1fd492b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56a950961dd5e9db6ab8a0f0f05b851b12b720161242f7106884afbf40c5af1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ba5dbc75e7c13a721bacdec8f71e239e8280d45612ebda32fcc2f577ad7c6228", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ceb556a184ace68d4c364694bc5befae02b8f00a9c23ef64cc033fe419614b57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac29c75b5f2d1bc376eee8605f1558d5d2e4a7898c82171e88545feca5eaa7a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3d56ac096c2ec9337ac727297e726a975e2b186ab97eb14dd3b714ead3382fcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4b86e58799dbb953a6173f9d5df01c39c9183188f74494fbcdafd78f7d16fbe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ea69fe44bfac61674e6866fc00ee06b70e0ed423a6faf19a3d2eb1965fed853c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1072a95735a18956761f4ce44b3ff6a0067f75f272daed0b5bb582dd223400e9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "316e340614bcc1ee4233263634b85b8de3160aaadd2e25726eff86b4aae6031a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4b51447841eb462b312dbaff6e11ba8406b07cc81f8efe92924e47364c0fb4fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "77e21af78bece3d34276237b0095e7998861fc7130cc80b995ce7d50353f0a60", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12a534545dfe8517f5f35a3416521c973fa0d859cfa40dbac0669d60c7c7dc63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-original.ppm", + "sha256": "27748411c905ecb51b413582b2a6eafc587ca774a1b89dd55100a05981f9ce56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "935f8bbaa2815d02ca77e1d222d21bddc09cc3dfd510ed5507c4eb27c0ed2b99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2c66b6874c47e5fd2dafb1ab9d9b87067dd7e46e2778c9a02f7617c181cc8473", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4f82a853ef7f8b3aaa1a359332aa53f05bfb52a63657aab4110815f81ef510d8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "acaadaa9ade781b07308d01fb953e2e60773d35cec3381a78c171c4a78ae6702", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75d3e8bf210b11e36cb1b4cf5f74f30cea322598d210963fcde115140378cf88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "12ea419d4824f5009acc727dfc85699e889b4e06e8c5aa35578891d4d9f81fc2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e755de57acddc93bb716d6a4b665019eedd609c5f3a59a3bc7aabbf9e7b51203", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "deeb6d253fe4efb60698e2c17b04b54dc50542926ef1cde457deb39c85f564fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0f51e854b6b03b245bd190c787e9de204993906fbdcf20a0761d586cb67e4cbd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c111f88fefcb3ce81b4b8f4481111293f9679851f40e19102278f886bdd07f21", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6305433d67b224f608635195c77d18809ad0c00a1893efb5598852e477a34a7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ef5d6f078b7aa9e858629865d9f5497fecbf1b8a5fdcd908844e45877eaf40c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5c9f8ca3e9ac2f49e0922ba8d308331b2ddcef253924dc86c468cb1477371721", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "57ccebc2a2409df1dfc9d9c78fc23950ad31a4e223e0bed57ff5f723159b76ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5d7734f7e7a6b7c25416ec4c6ba51447a7d7ced46886ef4d47bafa49bcfcad53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85697cabd91fe979f6b44429c83e4caa3052f2ced9d9c82837531bd68d11fa88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7e3efe1b2659646f933f632338787ff0bad46dfbecc573f8db258d383edec032", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7c21ace6e1701014de3ab95674736b3d4a3883f51edd15cc1b034a273fb8109b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cea03b5bd710950f0a4ef149f9d2f7ec8c542c234c81bf7fa7a45dfa128ff997", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d94829dc36a046a7112f7aea8626c582cbc2be7c9297411037c7f988d8a249", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "90dcccc15fecf7efbf56eea2ddc31d80b6696a1ba7c73bc57b08ce9d06e189a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8ec111d8aa7631f0bb6bbd354ff80df4684920297cc665f0dc887df5c8118123", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e01305134e4f4c9631cdd134e44ec2a8e716527ea86a73a3e434a63261460311", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "739d057c7381f3fe07e4fc22a43f09e0cf80e0bb25981242408b46a5635217b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c381eff884cc01744e69c8db42c1a5aba56dbf20225fd98eb92e437041ceceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ece3d9f78ffa10dc14b795700a41cebc30932e1e4c570038e3b1c917c43562", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f2a41c469ddfe5972e08e0c6f09acc4204e2e93a0f0645406591686967892596", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bcd76dfa305e7540d343aae8ecc2598b5f073f6fd260cd2e6a6d9fca18016150", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f50487375fcf946268136e5ff9e625f1474366792edec5a8a13ea49c1a530408", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a7ccea589e8dd6f3cba31f3aa5f1d5f77bb3029bc0286f2ecbb336349092ad10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f127a50306a634c12dbd18a36e4407a0a4dc5d56a8e2269858b4475a8c8590", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a5438499352ee5f30f919f08517a054a5e7d818ee07260aacec14adde18a765", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c8af1ab49929b1f36db885ffc5d3f2f99cb2a47526ddf56ff4bcf8473fad607", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "651998a2fce220108396b8910e0ea10681c997dc25abbdc0f0f6656b283317f3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "139968d1e25c6af2067fd62ced01a0ca93f0df02ab686422c45b7e5f682f150b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "60b5aa372b038498eb1838b1a1acfe1aa835ee9f57658b74026d66c0df588895", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f81973afc08692f1c241ac6103efb90f3455d2794726164f5e0a2227258e899d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ef2cc83858f43c5c57ca0734c62e1ef3a9f409bdaa646313e1c125d94caef1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a073c510f4338a77c9d27f197766de62298dc06447aa3d1328eb47a5a2baea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "56630435871566b9f3584d53e0b35dc0ce4c5562e4d57a8ecc56aa802a3612ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2f8b3129470d47676376ba5af87c57841c19f886ad34655320a8557877a8fce6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1cdac0a8da58aacc95ba1dba8b08f4ea05709ed42486891762e982885497ee31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d3c3e919b2334cc9f1deed0399f2b33f6875db35c50e81ad30bdec60618f0fe4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f1510be6ac21152bdf66eea74a787f634dfb9d0e3867017ae7684ef837dcd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10460/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "f9ee03e0653f7884ffc8ce8efad0f229e9c7ced6ae5c4fc0b9de130913b8afdc" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace-job.json", + "sha256": "b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.678581+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "10462": { @@ -177075,7 +177929,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10462", "family_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -177089,36 +177943,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "51f65619499d20f54fa9493635b9ec57ce6bc0bdc9dcffe527495be3e8a7b6ab", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.647995+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10461", - "10463", - "10464", - "10465", - "10466", - "1046a", - "1046b", - "1046c", - "1046d" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "e6fcbe38ceff45160d84841405e8363db4a15fdb4cd462cd46ebfdd65016fbab", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.796043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 6a639187edfd3fc8bd3fbee44c0aa5281f89016932da8b50951c3c3d036fe8f1", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10460-original.ppm", + "sha256": "898b3c1a6fdbd1d6bab7291ea1543b5e5615e13f11d93604a56a89dcf35b7648", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8ccea87926d7ef3505c568f6737b4ff851fbb9bbec30ded88b9770c828aa751f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "02c28841546da2fde0753a1ebbc6e4e2b3e856c18a293ba47aca28fec8a74f29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "764632e5b9e3adc93dfa7504f894d585ce7a5938469c965720ae7f5b4eaac314", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "824525dd48f88085b24a76dfd6cc3d4432047ba7a259db40219be93331992691", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26cc194328aef2dafd75e1190bda8278a41876bf152f58c9207c3a9b760d32e6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "546b47110af067d026f8670639bd4b3bf3923653fde79af6afc003d236bfd9db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0bf6f6989d65d892f5984135190af10e167d132f47cff0236397bd66bfdd8907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "15f6ec7f8ab75cedec0fd4be7298804772cd4d1e9991363ae5ef0c268fa5b4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a71a3f345b92174973fb61369574b658584f31ac3b6b18fae2821506c990f450", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f45ba5f1464339e5268cbd2b175c22cd272c6f2bf43951c59277d09c2f9494bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "636c8fe8568c3992921fb8102da33993531f9f45dd791f9a07e24654798223b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "597fd8c9cfdc20ad5c8c6735cba7543bebe0613faca382d4cc92a1aaa84d2eb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cb51b539f24dedc959b46ea4fcfa1de9b8d9e77580944432c16b955147031a1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6b7fa69282aec6b173caa39ab883a6f091b2ab8cc029b94eea5e97144551fcbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9f396545b1928abfe8ac606ebda3f58ee0f17c99633f1fae4b2d85fea2206dd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85d1b4b05bf45fe304b1ccb661038af6ffa27774aa31c22446f715cc2b42e40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5f16a8fbfe6fec61b1cc9756b51f05d460b5366275d0cd35d47d58c6909f08f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8d407588964c73e6639940e634e74d0e6e289fc292631dd16ba70289715a0df9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e6aac54d2a1ff7e61f6496cb5aaf07f63b4fb99442d828368f34af3e239528a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b33e48c44028411ea2d5a1b558f5bd4e105c4377ab78226feb3923783d01a033", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "421f2cd698da4d58e2d8b1176bc0bdfe273c8f13d50c82d0d8d7dca972bfe544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "75d6426d1d07032e87e70918df6394c740085ffe11fc043e88d0fec8c1fd492b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56a950961dd5e9db6ab8a0f0f05b851b12b720161242f7106884afbf40c5af1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ba5dbc75e7c13a721bacdec8f71e239e8280d45612ebda32fcc2f577ad7c6228", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ceb556a184ace68d4c364694bc5befae02b8f00a9c23ef64cc033fe419614b57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac29c75b5f2d1bc376eee8605f1558d5d2e4a7898c82171e88545feca5eaa7a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3d56ac096c2ec9337ac727297e726a975e2b186ab97eb14dd3b714ead3382fcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4b86e58799dbb953a6173f9d5df01c39c9183188f74494fbcdafd78f7d16fbe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ea69fe44bfac61674e6866fc00ee06b70e0ed423a6faf19a3d2eb1965fed853c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1072a95735a18956761f4ce44b3ff6a0067f75f272daed0b5bb582dd223400e9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "316e340614bcc1ee4233263634b85b8de3160aaadd2e25726eff86b4aae6031a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4b51447841eb462b312dbaff6e11ba8406b07cc81f8efe92924e47364c0fb4fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "77e21af78bece3d34276237b0095e7998861fc7130cc80b995ce7d50353f0a60", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12a534545dfe8517f5f35a3416521c973fa0d859cfa40dbac0669d60c7c7dc63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-original.ppm", + "sha256": "27748411c905ecb51b413582b2a6eafc587ca774a1b89dd55100a05981f9ce56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "935f8bbaa2815d02ca77e1d222d21bddc09cc3dfd510ed5507c4eb27c0ed2b99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2c66b6874c47e5fd2dafb1ab9d9b87067dd7e46e2778c9a02f7617c181cc8473", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4f82a853ef7f8b3aaa1a359332aa53f05bfb52a63657aab4110815f81ef510d8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "acaadaa9ade781b07308d01fb953e2e60773d35cec3381a78c171c4a78ae6702", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75d3e8bf210b11e36cb1b4cf5f74f30cea322598d210963fcde115140378cf88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "12ea419d4824f5009acc727dfc85699e889b4e06e8c5aa35578891d4d9f81fc2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e755de57acddc93bb716d6a4b665019eedd609c5f3a59a3bc7aabbf9e7b51203", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "deeb6d253fe4efb60698e2c17b04b54dc50542926ef1cde457deb39c85f564fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0f51e854b6b03b245bd190c787e9de204993906fbdcf20a0761d586cb67e4cbd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c111f88fefcb3ce81b4b8f4481111293f9679851f40e19102278f886bdd07f21", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6305433d67b224f608635195c77d18809ad0c00a1893efb5598852e477a34a7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ef5d6f078b7aa9e858629865d9f5497fecbf1b8a5fdcd908844e45877eaf40c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5c9f8ca3e9ac2f49e0922ba8d308331b2ddcef253924dc86c468cb1477371721", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "57ccebc2a2409df1dfc9d9c78fc23950ad31a4e223e0bed57ff5f723159b76ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5d7734f7e7a6b7c25416ec4c6ba51447a7d7ced46886ef4d47bafa49bcfcad53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85697cabd91fe979f6b44429c83e4caa3052f2ced9d9c82837531bd68d11fa88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7e3efe1b2659646f933f632338787ff0bad46dfbecc573f8db258d383edec032", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7c21ace6e1701014de3ab95674736b3d4a3883f51edd15cc1b034a273fb8109b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cea03b5bd710950f0a4ef149f9d2f7ec8c542c234c81bf7fa7a45dfa128ff997", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d94829dc36a046a7112f7aea8626c582cbc2be7c9297411037c7f988d8a249", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "90dcccc15fecf7efbf56eea2ddc31d80b6696a1ba7c73bc57b08ce9d06e189a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8ec111d8aa7631f0bb6bbd354ff80df4684920297cc665f0dc887df5c8118123", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e01305134e4f4c9631cdd134e44ec2a8e716527ea86a73a3e434a63261460311", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "739d057c7381f3fe07e4fc22a43f09e0cf80e0bb25981242408b46a5635217b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c381eff884cc01744e69c8db42c1a5aba56dbf20225fd98eb92e437041ceceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ece3d9f78ffa10dc14b795700a41cebc30932e1e4c570038e3b1c917c43562", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f2a41c469ddfe5972e08e0c6f09acc4204e2e93a0f0645406591686967892596", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bcd76dfa305e7540d343aae8ecc2598b5f073f6fd260cd2e6a6d9fca18016150", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f50487375fcf946268136e5ff9e625f1474366792edec5a8a13ea49c1a530408", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a7ccea589e8dd6f3cba31f3aa5f1d5f77bb3029bc0286f2ecbb336349092ad10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f127a50306a634c12dbd18a36e4407a0a4dc5d56a8e2269858b4475a8c8590", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a5438499352ee5f30f919f08517a054a5e7d818ee07260aacec14adde18a765", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c8af1ab49929b1f36db885ffc5d3f2f99cb2a47526ddf56ff4bcf8473fad607", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "651998a2fce220108396b8910e0ea10681c997dc25abbdc0f0f6656b283317f3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "139968d1e25c6af2067fd62ced01a0ca93f0df02ab686422c45b7e5f682f150b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "60b5aa372b038498eb1838b1a1acfe1aa835ee9f57658b74026d66c0df588895", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f81973afc08692f1c241ac6103efb90f3455d2794726164f5e0a2227258e899d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ef2cc83858f43c5c57ca0734c62e1ef3a9f409bdaa646313e1c125d94caef1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a073c510f4338a77c9d27f197766de62298dc06447aa3d1328eb47a5a2baea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "56630435871566b9f3584d53e0b35dc0ce4c5562e4d57a8ecc56aa802a3612ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2f8b3129470d47676376ba5af87c57841c19f886ad34655320a8557877a8fce6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1cdac0a8da58aacc95ba1dba8b08f4ea05709ed42486891762e982885497ee31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d3c3e919b2334cc9f1deed0399f2b33f6875db35c50e81ad30bdec60618f0fe4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f1510be6ac21152bdf66eea74a787f634dfb9d0e3867017ae7684ef837dcd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10460/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "f9ee03e0653f7884ffc8ce8efad0f229e9c7ced6ae5c4fc0b9de130913b8afdc" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace-job.json", + "sha256": "b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.678581+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "10463": { @@ -177140,7 +178421,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10463", "family_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -177154,36 +178435,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "51f65619499d20f54fa9493635b9ec57ce6bc0bdc9dcffe527495be3e8a7b6ab", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.647995+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10461", - "10463", - "10464", - "10465", - "10466", - "1046a", - "1046b", - "1046c", - "1046d" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "e6fcbe38ceff45160d84841405e8363db4a15fdb4cd462cd46ebfdd65016fbab", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.796043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 6a639187edfd3fc8bd3fbee44c0aa5281f89016932da8b50951c3c3d036fe8f1", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10460-original.ppm", + "sha256": "898b3c1a6fdbd1d6bab7291ea1543b5e5615e13f11d93604a56a89dcf35b7648", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8ccea87926d7ef3505c568f6737b4ff851fbb9bbec30ded88b9770c828aa751f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "02c28841546da2fde0753a1ebbc6e4e2b3e856c18a293ba47aca28fec8a74f29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "764632e5b9e3adc93dfa7504f894d585ce7a5938469c965720ae7f5b4eaac314", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "824525dd48f88085b24a76dfd6cc3d4432047ba7a259db40219be93331992691", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26cc194328aef2dafd75e1190bda8278a41876bf152f58c9207c3a9b760d32e6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "546b47110af067d026f8670639bd4b3bf3923653fde79af6afc003d236bfd9db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0bf6f6989d65d892f5984135190af10e167d132f47cff0236397bd66bfdd8907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "15f6ec7f8ab75cedec0fd4be7298804772cd4d1e9991363ae5ef0c268fa5b4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a71a3f345b92174973fb61369574b658584f31ac3b6b18fae2821506c990f450", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f45ba5f1464339e5268cbd2b175c22cd272c6f2bf43951c59277d09c2f9494bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "636c8fe8568c3992921fb8102da33993531f9f45dd791f9a07e24654798223b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "597fd8c9cfdc20ad5c8c6735cba7543bebe0613faca382d4cc92a1aaa84d2eb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cb51b539f24dedc959b46ea4fcfa1de9b8d9e77580944432c16b955147031a1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6b7fa69282aec6b173caa39ab883a6f091b2ab8cc029b94eea5e97144551fcbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9f396545b1928abfe8ac606ebda3f58ee0f17c99633f1fae4b2d85fea2206dd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85d1b4b05bf45fe304b1ccb661038af6ffa27774aa31c22446f715cc2b42e40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5f16a8fbfe6fec61b1cc9756b51f05d460b5366275d0cd35d47d58c6909f08f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8d407588964c73e6639940e634e74d0e6e289fc292631dd16ba70289715a0df9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e6aac54d2a1ff7e61f6496cb5aaf07f63b4fb99442d828368f34af3e239528a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b33e48c44028411ea2d5a1b558f5bd4e105c4377ab78226feb3923783d01a033", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "421f2cd698da4d58e2d8b1176bc0bdfe273c8f13d50c82d0d8d7dca972bfe544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "75d6426d1d07032e87e70918df6394c740085ffe11fc043e88d0fec8c1fd492b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56a950961dd5e9db6ab8a0f0f05b851b12b720161242f7106884afbf40c5af1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ba5dbc75e7c13a721bacdec8f71e239e8280d45612ebda32fcc2f577ad7c6228", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ceb556a184ace68d4c364694bc5befae02b8f00a9c23ef64cc033fe419614b57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac29c75b5f2d1bc376eee8605f1558d5d2e4a7898c82171e88545feca5eaa7a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3d56ac096c2ec9337ac727297e726a975e2b186ab97eb14dd3b714ead3382fcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4b86e58799dbb953a6173f9d5df01c39c9183188f74494fbcdafd78f7d16fbe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ea69fe44bfac61674e6866fc00ee06b70e0ed423a6faf19a3d2eb1965fed853c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1072a95735a18956761f4ce44b3ff6a0067f75f272daed0b5bb582dd223400e9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "316e340614bcc1ee4233263634b85b8de3160aaadd2e25726eff86b4aae6031a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4b51447841eb462b312dbaff6e11ba8406b07cc81f8efe92924e47364c0fb4fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "77e21af78bece3d34276237b0095e7998861fc7130cc80b995ce7d50353f0a60", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12a534545dfe8517f5f35a3416521c973fa0d859cfa40dbac0669d60c7c7dc63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-original.ppm", + "sha256": "27748411c905ecb51b413582b2a6eafc587ca774a1b89dd55100a05981f9ce56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "935f8bbaa2815d02ca77e1d222d21bddc09cc3dfd510ed5507c4eb27c0ed2b99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2c66b6874c47e5fd2dafb1ab9d9b87067dd7e46e2778c9a02f7617c181cc8473", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4f82a853ef7f8b3aaa1a359332aa53f05bfb52a63657aab4110815f81ef510d8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "acaadaa9ade781b07308d01fb953e2e60773d35cec3381a78c171c4a78ae6702", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75d3e8bf210b11e36cb1b4cf5f74f30cea322598d210963fcde115140378cf88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "12ea419d4824f5009acc727dfc85699e889b4e06e8c5aa35578891d4d9f81fc2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e755de57acddc93bb716d6a4b665019eedd609c5f3a59a3bc7aabbf9e7b51203", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "deeb6d253fe4efb60698e2c17b04b54dc50542926ef1cde457deb39c85f564fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0f51e854b6b03b245bd190c787e9de204993906fbdcf20a0761d586cb67e4cbd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c111f88fefcb3ce81b4b8f4481111293f9679851f40e19102278f886bdd07f21", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6305433d67b224f608635195c77d18809ad0c00a1893efb5598852e477a34a7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ef5d6f078b7aa9e858629865d9f5497fecbf1b8a5fdcd908844e45877eaf40c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5c9f8ca3e9ac2f49e0922ba8d308331b2ddcef253924dc86c468cb1477371721", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "57ccebc2a2409df1dfc9d9c78fc23950ad31a4e223e0bed57ff5f723159b76ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5d7734f7e7a6b7c25416ec4c6ba51447a7d7ced46886ef4d47bafa49bcfcad53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85697cabd91fe979f6b44429c83e4caa3052f2ced9d9c82837531bd68d11fa88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7e3efe1b2659646f933f632338787ff0bad46dfbecc573f8db258d383edec032", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7c21ace6e1701014de3ab95674736b3d4a3883f51edd15cc1b034a273fb8109b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cea03b5bd710950f0a4ef149f9d2f7ec8c542c234c81bf7fa7a45dfa128ff997", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d94829dc36a046a7112f7aea8626c582cbc2be7c9297411037c7f988d8a249", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "90dcccc15fecf7efbf56eea2ddc31d80b6696a1ba7c73bc57b08ce9d06e189a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8ec111d8aa7631f0bb6bbd354ff80df4684920297cc665f0dc887df5c8118123", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e01305134e4f4c9631cdd134e44ec2a8e716527ea86a73a3e434a63261460311", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "739d057c7381f3fe07e4fc22a43f09e0cf80e0bb25981242408b46a5635217b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c381eff884cc01744e69c8db42c1a5aba56dbf20225fd98eb92e437041ceceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ece3d9f78ffa10dc14b795700a41cebc30932e1e4c570038e3b1c917c43562", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f2a41c469ddfe5972e08e0c6f09acc4204e2e93a0f0645406591686967892596", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bcd76dfa305e7540d343aae8ecc2598b5f073f6fd260cd2e6a6d9fca18016150", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f50487375fcf946268136e5ff9e625f1474366792edec5a8a13ea49c1a530408", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a7ccea589e8dd6f3cba31f3aa5f1d5f77bb3029bc0286f2ecbb336349092ad10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f127a50306a634c12dbd18a36e4407a0a4dc5d56a8e2269858b4475a8c8590", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a5438499352ee5f30f919f08517a054a5e7d818ee07260aacec14adde18a765", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c8af1ab49929b1f36db885ffc5d3f2f99cb2a47526ddf56ff4bcf8473fad607", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "651998a2fce220108396b8910e0ea10681c997dc25abbdc0f0f6656b283317f3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "139968d1e25c6af2067fd62ced01a0ca93f0df02ab686422c45b7e5f682f150b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "60b5aa372b038498eb1838b1a1acfe1aa835ee9f57658b74026d66c0df588895", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f81973afc08692f1c241ac6103efb90f3455d2794726164f5e0a2227258e899d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ef2cc83858f43c5c57ca0734c62e1ef3a9f409bdaa646313e1c125d94caef1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a073c510f4338a77c9d27f197766de62298dc06447aa3d1328eb47a5a2baea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "56630435871566b9f3584d53e0b35dc0ce4c5562e4d57a8ecc56aa802a3612ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2f8b3129470d47676376ba5af87c57841c19f886ad34655320a8557877a8fce6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1cdac0a8da58aacc95ba1dba8b08f4ea05709ed42486891762e982885497ee31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d3c3e919b2334cc9f1deed0399f2b33f6875db35c50e81ad30bdec60618f0fe4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f1510be6ac21152bdf66eea74a787f634dfb9d0e3867017ae7684ef837dcd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10460/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "f9ee03e0653f7884ffc8ce8efad0f229e9c7ced6ae5c4fc0b9de130913b8afdc" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace-job.json", + "sha256": "b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.678581+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "10464": { @@ -177205,7 +178913,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10464", "family_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -177219,36 +178927,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "51f65619499d20f54fa9493635b9ec57ce6bc0bdc9dcffe527495be3e8a7b6ab", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.647995+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10461", - "10463", - "10464", - "10465", - "10466", - "1046a", - "1046b", - "1046c", - "1046d" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "e6fcbe38ceff45160d84841405e8363db4a15fdb4cd462cd46ebfdd65016fbab", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.796043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 6a639187edfd3fc8bd3fbee44c0aa5281f89016932da8b50951c3c3d036fe8f1", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10460-original.ppm", + "sha256": "898b3c1a6fdbd1d6bab7291ea1543b5e5615e13f11d93604a56a89dcf35b7648", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8ccea87926d7ef3505c568f6737b4ff851fbb9bbec30ded88b9770c828aa751f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "02c28841546da2fde0753a1ebbc6e4e2b3e856c18a293ba47aca28fec8a74f29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "764632e5b9e3adc93dfa7504f894d585ce7a5938469c965720ae7f5b4eaac314", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "824525dd48f88085b24a76dfd6cc3d4432047ba7a259db40219be93331992691", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26cc194328aef2dafd75e1190bda8278a41876bf152f58c9207c3a9b760d32e6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "546b47110af067d026f8670639bd4b3bf3923653fde79af6afc003d236bfd9db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0bf6f6989d65d892f5984135190af10e167d132f47cff0236397bd66bfdd8907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "15f6ec7f8ab75cedec0fd4be7298804772cd4d1e9991363ae5ef0c268fa5b4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a71a3f345b92174973fb61369574b658584f31ac3b6b18fae2821506c990f450", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f45ba5f1464339e5268cbd2b175c22cd272c6f2bf43951c59277d09c2f9494bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "636c8fe8568c3992921fb8102da33993531f9f45dd791f9a07e24654798223b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "597fd8c9cfdc20ad5c8c6735cba7543bebe0613faca382d4cc92a1aaa84d2eb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cb51b539f24dedc959b46ea4fcfa1de9b8d9e77580944432c16b955147031a1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6b7fa69282aec6b173caa39ab883a6f091b2ab8cc029b94eea5e97144551fcbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9f396545b1928abfe8ac606ebda3f58ee0f17c99633f1fae4b2d85fea2206dd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85d1b4b05bf45fe304b1ccb661038af6ffa27774aa31c22446f715cc2b42e40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5f16a8fbfe6fec61b1cc9756b51f05d460b5366275d0cd35d47d58c6909f08f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8d407588964c73e6639940e634e74d0e6e289fc292631dd16ba70289715a0df9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e6aac54d2a1ff7e61f6496cb5aaf07f63b4fb99442d828368f34af3e239528a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b33e48c44028411ea2d5a1b558f5bd4e105c4377ab78226feb3923783d01a033", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "421f2cd698da4d58e2d8b1176bc0bdfe273c8f13d50c82d0d8d7dca972bfe544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "75d6426d1d07032e87e70918df6394c740085ffe11fc043e88d0fec8c1fd492b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56a950961dd5e9db6ab8a0f0f05b851b12b720161242f7106884afbf40c5af1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ba5dbc75e7c13a721bacdec8f71e239e8280d45612ebda32fcc2f577ad7c6228", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ceb556a184ace68d4c364694bc5befae02b8f00a9c23ef64cc033fe419614b57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac29c75b5f2d1bc376eee8605f1558d5d2e4a7898c82171e88545feca5eaa7a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3d56ac096c2ec9337ac727297e726a975e2b186ab97eb14dd3b714ead3382fcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4b86e58799dbb953a6173f9d5df01c39c9183188f74494fbcdafd78f7d16fbe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ea69fe44bfac61674e6866fc00ee06b70e0ed423a6faf19a3d2eb1965fed853c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1072a95735a18956761f4ce44b3ff6a0067f75f272daed0b5bb582dd223400e9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "316e340614bcc1ee4233263634b85b8de3160aaadd2e25726eff86b4aae6031a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4b51447841eb462b312dbaff6e11ba8406b07cc81f8efe92924e47364c0fb4fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "77e21af78bece3d34276237b0095e7998861fc7130cc80b995ce7d50353f0a60", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12a534545dfe8517f5f35a3416521c973fa0d859cfa40dbac0669d60c7c7dc63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-original.ppm", + "sha256": "27748411c905ecb51b413582b2a6eafc587ca774a1b89dd55100a05981f9ce56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "935f8bbaa2815d02ca77e1d222d21bddc09cc3dfd510ed5507c4eb27c0ed2b99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2c66b6874c47e5fd2dafb1ab9d9b87067dd7e46e2778c9a02f7617c181cc8473", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4f82a853ef7f8b3aaa1a359332aa53f05bfb52a63657aab4110815f81ef510d8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "acaadaa9ade781b07308d01fb953e2e60773d35cec3381a78c171c4a78ae6702", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75d3e8bf210b11e36cb1b4cf5f74f30cea322598d210963fcde115140378cf88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "12ea419d4824f5009acc727dfc85699e889b4e06e8c5aa35578891d4d9f81fc2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e755de57acddc93bb716d6a4b665019eedd609c5f3a59a3bc7aabbf9e7b51203", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "deeb6d253fe4efb60698e2c17b04b54dc50542926ef1cde457deb39c85f564fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0f51e854b6b03b245bd190c787e9de204993906fbdcf20a0761d586cb67e4cbd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c111f88fefcb3ce81b4b8f4481111293f9679851f40e19102278f886bdd07f21", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6305433d67b224f608635195c77d18809ad0c00a1893efb5598852e477a34a7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ef5d6f078b7aa9e858629865d9f5497fecbf1b8a5fdcd908844e45877eaf40c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5c9f8ca3e9ac2f49e0922ba8d308331b2ddcef253924dc86c468cb1477371721", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "57ccebc2a2409df1dfc9d9c78fc23950ad31a4e223e0bed57ff5f723159b76ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5d7734f7e7a6b7c25416ec4c6ba51447a7d7ced46886ef4d47bafa49bcfcad53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85697cabd91fe979f6b44429c83e4caa3052f2ced9d9c82837531bd68d11fa88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7e3efe1b2659646f933f632338787ff0bad46dfbecc573f8db258d383edec032", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7c21ace6e1701014de3ab95674736b3d4a3883f51edd15cc1b034a273fb8109b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cea03b5bd710950f0a4ef149f9d2f7ec8c542c234c81bf7fa7a45dfa128ff997", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d94829dc36a046a7112f7aea8626c582cbc2be7c9297411037c7f988d8a249", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "90dcccc15fecf7efbf56eea2ddc31d80b6696a1ba7c73bc57b08ce9d06e189a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8ec111d8aa7631f0bb6bbd354ff80df4684920297cc665f0dc887df5c8118123", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e01305134e4f4c9631cdd134e44ec2a8e716527ea86a73a3e434a63261460311", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "739d057c7381f3fe07e4fc22a43f09e0cf80e0bb25981242408b46a5635217b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c381eff884cc01744e69c8db42c1a5aba56dbf20225fd98eb92e437041ceceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ece3d9f78ffa10dc14b795700a41cebc30932e1e4c570038e3b1c917c43562", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f2a41c469ddfe5972e08e0c6f09acc4204e2e93a0f0645406591686967892596", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bcd76dfa305e7540d343aae8ecc2598b5f073f6fd260cd2e6a6d9fca18016150", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f50487375fcf946268136e5ff9e625f1474366792edec5a8a13ea49c1a530408", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a7ccea589e8dd6f3cba31f3aa5f1d5f77bb3029bc0286f2ecbb336349092ad10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f127a50306a634c12dbd18a36e4407a0a4dc5d56a8e2269858b4475a8c8590", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a5438499352ee5f30f919f08517a054a5e7d818ee07260aacec14adde18a765", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c8af1ab49929b1f36db885ffc5d3f2f99cb2a47526ddf56ff4bcf8473fad607", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "651998a2fce220108396b8910e0ea10681c997dc25abbdc0f0f6656b283317f3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "139968d1e25c6af2067fd62ced01a0ca93f0df02ab686422c45b7e5f682f150b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "60b5aa372b038498eb1838b1a1acfe1aa835ee9f57658b74026d66c0df588895", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f81973afc08692f1c241ac6103efb90f3455d2794726164f5e0a2227258e899d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ef2cc83858f43c5c57ca0734c62e1ef3a9f409bdaa646313e1c125d94caef1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a073c510f4338a77c9d27f197766de62298dc06447aa3d1328eb47a5a2baea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "56630435871566b9f3584d53e0b35dc0ce4c5562e4d57a8ecc56aa802a3612ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2f8b3129470d47676376ba5af87c57841c19f886ad34655320a8557877a8fce6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1cdac0a8da58aacc95ba1dba8b08f4ea05709ed42486891762e982885497ee31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d3c3e919b2334cc9f1deed0399f2b33f6875db35c50e81ad30bdec60618f0fe4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f1510be6ac21152bdf66eea74a787f634dfb9d0e3867017ae7684ef837dcd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10460/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "f9ee03e0653f7884ffc8ce8efad0f229e9c7ced6ae5c4fc0b9de130913b8afdc" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace-job.json", + "sha256": "b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.678581+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "10465": { @@ -177270,7 +179405,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10465", "family_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -177284,36 +179419,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "51f65619499d20f54fa9493635b9ec57ce6bc0bdc9dcffe527495be3e8a7b6ab", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.647995+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10461", - "10463", - "10464", - "10465", - "10466", - "1046a", - "1046b", - "1046c", - "1046d" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "e6fcbe38ceff45160d84841405e8363db4a15fdb4cd462cd46ebfdd65016fbab", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.796043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 6a639187edfd3fc8bd3fbee44c0aa5281f89016932da8b50951c3c3d036fe8f1", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10460-original.ppm", + "sha256": "898b3c1a6fdbd1d6bab7291ea1543b5e5615e13f11d93604a56a89dcf35b7648", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8ccea87926d7ef3505c568f6737b4ff851fbb9bbec30ded88b9770c828aa751f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "02c28841546da2fde0753a1ebbc6e4e2b3e856c18a293ba47aca28fec8a74f29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "764632e5b9e3adc93dfa7504f894d585ce7a5938469c965720ae7f5b4eaac314", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "824525dd48f88085b24a76dfd6cc3d4432047ba7a259db40219be93331992691", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26cc194328aef2dafd75e1190bda8278a41876bf152f58c9207c3a9b760d32e6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "546b47110af067d026f8670639bd4b3bf3923653fde79af6afc003d236bfd9db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0bf6f6989d65d892f5984135190af10e167d132f47cff0236397bd66bfdd8907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "15f6ec7f8ab75cedec0fd4be7298804772cd4d1e9991363ae5ef0c268fa5b4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a71a3f345b92174973fb61369574b658584f31ac3b6b18fae2821506c990f450", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f45ba5f1464339e5268cbd2b175c22cd272c6f2bf43951c59277d09c2f9494bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "636c8fe8568c3992921fb8102da33993531f9f45dd791f9a07e24654798223b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "597fd8c9cfdc20ad5c8c6735cba7543bebe0613faca382d4cc92a1aaa84d2eb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cb51b539f24dedc959b46ea4fcfa1de9b8d9e77580944432c16b955147031a1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6b7fa69282aec6b173caa39ab883a6f091b2ab8cc029b94eea5e97144551fcbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9f396545b1928abfe8ac606ebda3f58ee0f17c99633f1fae4b2d85fea2206dd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85d1b4b05bf45fe304b1ccb661038af6ffa27774aa31c22446f715cc2b42e40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5f16a8fbfe6fec61b1cc9756b51f05d460b5366275d0cd35d47d58c6909f08f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8d407588964c73e6639940e634e74d0e6e289fc292631dd16ba70289715a0df9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e6aac54d2a1ff7e61f6496cb5aaf07f63b4fb99442d828368f34af3e239528a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b33e48c44028411ea2d5a1b558f5bd4e105c4377ab78226feb3923783d01a033", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "421f2cd698da4d58e2d8b1176bc0bdfe273c8f13d50c82d0d8d7dca972bfe544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "75d6426d1d07032e87e70918df6394c740085ffe11fc043e88d0fec8c1fd492b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56a950961dd5e9db6ab8a0f0f05b851b12b720161242f7106884afbf40c5af1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ba5dbc75e7c13a721bacdec8f71e239e8280d45612ebda32fcc2f577ad7c6228", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ceb556a184ace68d4c364694bc5befae02b8f00a9c23ef64cc033fe419614b57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac29c75b5f2d1bc376eee8605f1558d5d2e4a7898c82171e88545feca5eaa7a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3d56ac096c2ec9337ac727297e726a975e2b186ab97eb14dd3b714ead3382fcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4b86e58799dbb953a6173f9d5df01c39c9183188f74494fbcdafd78f7d16fbe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ea69fe44bfac61674e6866fc00ee06b70e0ed423a6faf19a3d2eb1965fed853c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1072a95735a18956761f4ce44b3ff6a0067f75f272daed0b5bb582dd223400e9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "316e340614bcc1ee4233263634b85b8de3160aaadd2e25726eff86b4aae6031a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4b51447841eb462b312dbaff6e11ba8406b07cc81f8efe92924e47364c0fb4fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "77e21af78bece3d34276237b0095e7998861fc7130cc80b995ce7d50353f0a60", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12a534545dfe8517f5f35a3416521c973fa0d859cfa40dbac0669d60c7c7dc63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-original.ppm", + "sha256": "27748411c905ecb51b413582b2a6eafc587ca774a1b89dd55100a05981f9ce56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "935f8bbaa2815d02ca77e1d222d21bddc09cc3dfd510ed5507c4eb27c0ed2b99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2c66b6874c47e5fd2dafb1ab9d9b87067dd7e46e2778c9a02f7617c181cc8473", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4f82a853ef7f8b3aaa1a359332aa53f05bfb52a63657aab4110815f81ef510d8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "acaadaa9ade781b07308d01fb953e2e60773d35cec3381a78c171c4a78ae6702", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75d3e8bf210b11e36cb1b4cf5f74f30cea322598d210963fcde115140378cf88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "12ea419d4824f5009acc727dfc85699e889b4e06e8c5aa35578891d4d9f81fc2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e755de57acddc93bb716d6a4b665019eedd609c5f3a59a3bc7aabbf9e7b51203", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "deeb6d253fe4efb60698e2c17b04b54dc50542926ef1cde457deb39c85f564fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0f51e854b6b03b245bd190c787e9de204993906fbdcf20a0761d586cb67e4cbd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c111f88fefcb3ce81b4b8f4481111293f9679851f40e19102278f886bdd07f21", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6305433d67b224f608635195c77d18809ad0c00a1893efb5598852e477a34a7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ef5d6f078b7aa9e858629865d9f5497fecbf1b8a5fdcd908844e45877eaf40c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5c9f8ca3e9ac2f49e0922ba8d308331b2ddcef253924dc86c468cb1477371721", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "57ccebc2a2409df1dfc9d9c78fc23950ad31a4e223e0bed57ff5f723159b76ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5d7734f7e7a6b7c25416ec4c6ba51447a7d7ced46886ef4d47bafa49bcfcad53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85697cabd91fe979f6b44429c83e4caa3052f2ced9d9c82837531bd68d11fa88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7e3efe1b2659646f933f632338787ff0bad46dfbecc573f8db258d383edec032", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7c21ace6e1701014de3ab95674736b3d4a3883f51edd15cc1b034a273fb8109b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cea03b5bd710950f0a4ef149f9d2f7ec8c542c234c81bf7fa7a45dfa128ff997", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d94829dc36a046a7112f7aea8626c582cbc2be7c9297411037c7f988d8a249", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "90dcccc15fecf7efbf56eea2ddc31d80b6696a1ba7c73bc57b08ce9d06e189a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8ec111d8aa7631f0bb6bbd354ff80df4684920297cc665f0dc887df5c8118123", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e01305134e4f4c9631cdd134e44ec2a8e716527ea86a73a3e434a63261460311", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "739d057c7381f3fe07e4fc22a43f09e0cf80e0bb25981242408b46a5635217b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c381eff884cc01744e69c8db42c1a5aba56dbf20225fd98eb92e437041ceceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ece3d9f78ffa10dc14b795700a41cebc30932e1e4c570038e3b1c917c43562", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f2a41c469ddfe5972e08e0c6f09acc4204e2e93a0f0645406591686967892596", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bcd76dfa305e7540d343aae8ecc2598b5f073f6fd260cd2e6a6d9fca18016150", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f50487375fcf946268136e5ff9e625f1474366792edec5a8a13ea49c1a530408", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a7ccea589e8dd6f3cba31f3aa5f1d5f77bb3029bc0286f2ecbb336349092ad10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f127a50306a634c12dbd18a36e4407a0a4dc5d56a8e2269858b4475a8c8590", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a5438499352ee5f30f919f08517a054a5e7d818ee07260aacec14adde18a765", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c8af1ab49929b1f36db885ffc5d3f2f99cb2a47526ddf56ff4bcf8473fad607", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "651998a2fce220108396b8910e0ea10681c997dc25abbdc0f0f6656b283317f3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "139968d1e25c6af2067fd62ced01a0ca93f0df02ab686422c45b7e5f682f150b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "60b5aa372b038498eb1838b1a1acfe1aa835ee9f57658b74026d66c0df588895", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f81973afc08692f1c241ac6103efb90f3455d2794726164f5e0a2227258e899d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ef2cc83858f43c5c57ca0734c62e1ef3a9f409bdaa646313e1c125d94caef1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a073c510f4338a77c9d27f197766de62298dc06447aa3d1328eb47a5a2baea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "56630435871566b9f3584d53e0b35dc0ce4c5562e4d57a8ecc56aa802a3612ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2f8b3129470d47676376ba5af87c57841c19f886ad34655320a8557877a8fce6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1cdac0a8da58aacc95ba1dba8b08f4ea05709ed42486891762e982885497ee31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d3c3e919b2334cc9f1deed0399f2b33f6875db35c50e81ad30bdec60618f0fe4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f1510be6ac21152bdf66eea74a787f634dfb9d0e3867017ae7684ef837dcd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10460/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "f9ee03e0653f7884ffc8ce8efad0f229e9c7ced6ae5c4fc0b9de130913b8afdc" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace-job.json", + "sha256": "b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.678581+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "10466": { @@ -177335,7 +179897,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10466", "family_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -177349,36 +179911,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "51f65619499d20f54fa9493635b9ec57ce6bc0bdc9dcffe527495be3e8a7b6ab", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.647995+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10461", - "10463", - "10464", - "10465", - "10466", - "1046a", - "1046b", - "1046c", - "1046d" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "e6fcbe38ceff45160d84841405e8363db4a15fdb4cd462cd46ebfdd65016fbab", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.796043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 6a639187edfd3fc8bd3fbee44c0aa5281f89016932da8b50951c3c3d036fe8f1", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10460-original.ppm", + "sha256": "898b3c1a6fdbd1d6bab7291ea1543b5e5615e13f11d93604a56a89dcf35b7648", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8ccea87926d7ef3505c568f6737b4ff851fbb9bbec30ded88b9770c828aa751f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "02c28841546da2fde0753a1ebbc6e4e2b3e856c18a293ba47aca28fec8a74f29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "764632e5b9e3adc93dfa7504f894d585ce7a5938469c965720ae7f5b4eaac314", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "824525dd48f88085b24a76dfd6cc3d4432047ba7a259db40219be93331992691", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26cc194328aef2dafd75e1190bda8278a41876bf152f58c9207c3a9b760d32e6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "546b47110af067d026f8670639bd4b3bf3923653fde79af6afc003d236bfd9db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0bf6f6989d65d892f5984135190af10e167d132f47cff0236397bd66bfdd8907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "15f6ec7f8ab75cedec0fd4be7298804772cd4d1e9991363ae5ef0c268fa5b4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a71a3f345b92174973fb61369574b658584f31ac3b6b18fae2821506c990f450", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f45ba5f1464339e5268cbd2b175c22cd272c6f2bf43951c59277d09c2f9494bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "636c8fe8568c3992921fb8102da33993531f9f45dd791f9a07e24654798223b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "597fd8c9cfdc20ad5c8c6735cba7543bebe0613faca382d4cc92a1aaa84d2eb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cb51b539f24dedc959b46ea4fcfa1de9b8d9e77580944432c16b955147031a1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6b7fa69282aec6b173caa39ab883a6f091b2ab8cc029b94eea5e97144551fcbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9f396545b1928abfe8ac606ebda3f58ee0f17c99633f1fae4b2d85fea2206dd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85d1b4b05bf45fe304b1ccb661038af6ffa27774aa31c22446f715cc2b42e40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5f16a8fbfe6fec61b1cc9756b51f05d460b5366275d0cd35d47d58c6909f08f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8d407588964c73e6639940e634e74d0e6e289fc292631dd16ba70289715a0df9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e6aac54d2a1ff7e61f6496cb5aaf07f63b4fb99442d828368f34af3e239528a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b33e48c44028411ea2d5a1b558f5bd4e105c4377ab78226feb3923783d01a033", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "421f2cd698da4d58e2d8b1176bc0bdfe273c8f13d50c82d0d8d7dca972bfe544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "75d6426d1d07032e87e70918df6394c740085ffe11fc043e88d0fec8c1fd492b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56a950961dd5e9db6ab8a0f0f05b851b12b720161242f7106884afbf40c5af1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ba5dbc75e7c13a721bacdec8f71e239e8280d45612ebda32fcc2f577ad7c6228", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ceb556a184ace68d4c364694bc5befae02b8f00a9c23ef64cc033fe419614b57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac29c75b5f2d1bc376eee8605f1558d5d2e4a7898c82171e88545feca5eaa7a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3d56ac096c2ec9337ac727297e726a975e2b186ab97eb14dd3b714ead3382fcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4b86e58799dbb953a6173f9d5df01c39c9183188f74494fbcdafd78f7d16fbe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ea69fe44bfac61674e6866fc00ee06b70e0ed423a6faf19a3d2eb1965fed853c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1072a95735a18956761f4ce44b3ff6a0067f75f272daed0b5bb582dd223400e9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "316e340614bcc1ee4233263634b85b8de3160aaadd2e25726eff86b4aae6031a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4b51447841eb462b312dbaff6e11ba8406b07cc81f8efe92924e47364c0fb4fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "77e21af78bece3d34276237b0095e7998861fc7130cc80b995ce7d50353f0a60", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12a534545dfe8517f5f35a3416521c973fa0d859cfa40dbac0669d60c7c7dc63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-original.ppm", + "sha256": "27748411c905ecb51b413582b2a6eafc587ca774a1b89dd55100a05981f9ce56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "935f8bbaa2815d02ca77e1d222d21bddc09cc3dfd510ed5507c4eb27c0ed2b99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2c66b6874c47e5fd2dafb1ab9d9b87067dd7e46e2778c9a02f7617c181cc8473", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4f82a853ef7f8b3aaa1a359332aa53f05bfb52a63657aab4110815f81ef510d8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "acaadaa9ade781b07308d01fb953e2e60773d35cec3381a78c171c4a78ae6702", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75d3e8bf210b11e36cb1b4cf5f74f30cea322598d210963fcde115140378cf88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "12ea419d4824f5009acc727dfc85699e889b4e06e8c5aa35578891d4d9f81fc2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e755de57acddc93bb716d6a4b665019eedd609c5f3a59a3bc7aabbf9e7b51203", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "deeb6d253fe4efb60698e2c17b04b54dc50542926ef1cde457deb39c85f564fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0f51e854b6b03b245bd190c787e9de204993906fbdcf20a0761d586cb67e4cbd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c111f88fefcb3ce81b4b8f4481111293f9679851f40e19102278f886bdd07f21", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6305433d67b224f608635195c77d18809ad0c00a1893efb5598852e477a34a7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ef5d6f078b7aa9e858629865d9f5497fecbf1b8a5fdcd908844e45877eaf40c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5c9f8ca3e9ac2f49e0922ba8d308331b2ddcef253924dc86c468cb1477371721", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "57ccebc2a2409df1dfc9d9c78fc23950ad31a4e223e0bed57ff5f723159b76ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5d7734f7e7a6b7c25416ec4c6ba51447a7d7ced46886ef4d47bafa49bcfcad53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85697cabd91fe979f6b44429c83e4caa3052f2ced9d9c82837531bd68d11fa88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7e3efe1b2659646f933f632338787ff0bad46dfbecc573f8db258d383edec032", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7c21ace6e1701014de3ab95674736b3d4a3883f51edd15cc1b034a273fb8109b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cea03b5bd710950f0a4ef149f9d2f7ec8c542c234c81bf7fa7a45dfa128ff997", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d94829dc36a046a7112f7aea8626c582cbc2be7c9297411037c7f988d8a249", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "90dcccc15fecf7efbf56eea2ddc31d80b6696a1ba7c73bc57b08ce9d06e189a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8ec111d8aa7631f0bb6bbd354ff80df4684920297cc665f0dc887df5c8118123", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e01305134e4f4c9631cdd134e44ec2a8e716527ea86a73a3e434a63261460311", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "739d057c7381f3fe07e4fc22a43f09e0cf80e0bb25981242408b46a5635217b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c381eff884cc01744e69c8db42c1a5aba56dbf20225fd98eb92e437041ceceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ece3d9f78ffa10dc14b795700a41cebc30932e1e4c570038e3b1c917c43562", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f2a41c469ddfe5972e08e0c6f09acc4204e2e93a0f0645406591686967892596", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bcd76dfa305e7540d343aae8ecc2598b5f073f6fd260cd2e6a6d9fca18016150", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f50487375fcf946268136e5ff9e625f1474366792edec5a8a13ea49c1a530408", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a7ccea589e8dd6f3cba31f3aa5f1d5f77bb3029bc0286f2ecbb336349092ad10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f127a50306a634c12dbd18a36e4407a0a4dc5d56a8e2269858b4475a8c8590", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a5438499352ee5f30f919f08517a054a5e7d818ee07260aacec14adde18a765", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c8af1ab49929b1f36db885ffc5d3f2f99cb2a47526ddf56ff4bcf8473fad607", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "651998a2fce220108396b8910e0ea10681c997dc25abbdc0f0f6656b283317f3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "139968d1e25c6af2067fd62ced01a0ca93f0df02ab686422c45b7e5f682f150b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "60b5aa372b038498eb1838b1a1acfe1aa835ee9f57658b74026d66c0df588895", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f81973afc08692f1c241ac6103efb90f3455d2794726164f5e0a2227258e899d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ef2cc83858f43c5c57ca0734c62e1ef3a9f409bdaa646313e1c125d94caef1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a073c510f4338a77c9d27f197766de62298dc06447aa3d1328eb47a5a2baea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "56630435871566b9f3584d53e0b35dc0ce4c5562e4d57a8ecc56aa802a3612ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2f8b3129470d47676376ba5af87c57841c19f886ad34655320a8557877a8fce6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1cdac0a8da58aacc95ba1dba8b08f4ea05709ed42486891762e982885497ee31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d3c3e919b2334cc9f1deed0399f2b33f6875db35c50e81ad30bdec60618f0fe4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f1510be6ac21152bdf66eea74a787f634dfb9d0e3867017ae7684ef837dcd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10460/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "f9ee03e0653f7884ffc8ce8efad0f229e9c7ced6ae5c4fc0b9de130913b8afdc" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace-job.json", + "sha256": "b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.678581+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "10467": { @@ -177400,7 +180389,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10467", "family_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -177414,36 +180403,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "51f65619499d20f54fa9493635b9ec57ce6bc0bdc9dcffe527495be3e8a7b6ab", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.647995+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10461", - "10463", - "10464", - "10465", - "10466", - "1046a", - "1046b", - "1046c", - "1046d" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "e6fcbe38ceff45160d84841405e8363db4a15fdb4cd462cd46ebfdd65016fbab", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.796043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 6a639187edfd3fc8bd3fbee44c0aa5281f89016932da8b50951c3c3d036fe8f1", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10460-original.ppm", + "sha256": "898b3c1a6fdbd1d6bab7291ea1543b5e5615e13f11d93604a56a89dcf35b7648", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8ccea87926d7ef3505c568f6737b4ff851fbb9bbec30ded88b9770c828aa751f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "02c28841546da2fde0753a1ebbc6e4e2b3e856c18a293ba47aca28fec8a74f29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "764632e5b9e3adc93dfa7504f894d585ce7a5938469c965720ae7f5b4eaac314", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "824525dd48f88085b24a76dfd6cc3d4432047ba7a259db40219be93331992691", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26cc194328aef2dafd75e1190bda8278a41876bf152f58c9207c3a9b760d32e6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "546b47110af067d026f8670639bd4b3bf3923653fde79af6afc003d236bfd9db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0bf6f6989d65d892f5984135190af10e167d132f47cff0236397bd66bfdd8907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "15f6ec7f8ab75cedec0fd4be7298804772cd4d1e9991363ae5ef0c268fa5b4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a71a3f345b92174973fb61369574b658584f31ac3b6b18fae2821506c990f450", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f45ba5f1464339e5268cbd2b175c22cd272c6f2bf43951c59277d09c2f9494bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "636c8fe8568c3992921fb8102da33993531f9f45dd791f9a07e24654798223b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "597fd8c9cfdc20ad5c8c6735cba7543bebe0613faca382d4cc92a1aaa84d2eb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cb51b539f24dedc959b46ea4fcfa1de9b8d9e77580944432c16b955147031a1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6b7fa69282aec6b173caa39ab883a6f091b2ab8cc029b94eea5e97144551fcbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9f396545b1928abfe8ac606ebda3f58ee0f17c99633f1fae4b2d85fea2206dd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85d1b4b05bf45fe304b1ccb661038af6ffa27774aa31c22446f715cc2b42e40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5f16a8fbfe6fec61b1cc9756b51f05d460b5366275d0cd35d47d58c6909f08f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8d407588964c73e6639940e634e74d0e6e289fc292631dd16ba70289715a0df9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e6aac54d2a1ff7e61f6496cb5aaf07f63b4fb99442d828368f34af3e239528a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b33e48c44028411ea2d5a1b558f5bd4e105c4377ab78226feb3923783d01a033", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "421f2cd698da4d58e2d8b1176bc0bdfe273c8f13d50c82d0d8d7dca972bfe544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "75d6426d1d07032e87e70918df6394c740085ffe11fc043e88d0fec8c1fd492b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56a950961dd5e9db6ab8a0f0f05b851b12b720161242f7106884afbf40c5af1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ba5dbc75e7c13a721bacdec8f71e239e8280d45612ebda32fcc2f577ad7c6228", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ceb556a184ace68d4c364694bc5befae02b8f00a9c23ef64cc033fe419614b57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac29c75b5f2d1bc376eee8605f1558d5d2e4a7898c82171e88545feca5eaa7a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3d56ac096c2ec9337ac727297e726a975e2b186ab97eb14dd3b714ead3382fcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4b86e58799dbb953a6173f9d5df01c39c9183188f74494fbcdafd78f7d16fbe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ea69fe44bfac61674e6866fc00ee06b70e0ed423a6faf19a3d2eb1965fed853c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1072a95735a18956761f4ce44b3ff6a0067f75f272daed0b5bb582dd223400e9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "316e340614bcc1ee4233263634b85b8de3160aaadd2e25726eff86b4aae6031a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4b51447841eb462b312dbaff6e11ba8406b07cc81f8efe92924e47364c0fb4fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "77e21af78bece3d34276237b0095e7998861fc7130cc80b995ce7d50353f0a60", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12a534545dfe8517f5f35a3416521c973fa0d859cfa40dbac0669d60c7c7dc63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-original.ppm", + "sha256": "27748411c905ecb51b413582b2a6eafc587ca774a1b89dd55100a05981f9ce56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "935f8bbaa2815d02ca77e1d222d21bddc09cc3dfd510ed5507c4eb27c0ed2b99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2c66b6874c47e5fd2dafb1ab9d9b87067dd7e46e2778c9a02f7617c181cc8473", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4f82a853ef7f8b3aaa1a359332aa53f05bfb52a63657aab4110815f81ef510d8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "acaadaa9ade781b07308d01fb953e2e60773d35cec3381a78c171c4a78ae6702", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75d3e8bf210b11e36cb1b4cf5f74f30cea322598d210963fcde115140378cf88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "12ea419d4824f5009acc727dfc85699e889b4e06e8c5aa35578891d4d9f81fc2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e755de57acddc93bb716d6a4b665019eedd609c5f3a59a3bc7aabbf9e7b51203", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "deeb6d253fe4efb60698e2c17b04b54dc50542926ef1cde457deb39c85f564fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0f51e854b6b03b245bd190c787e9de204993906fbdcf20a0761d586cb67e4cbd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c111f88fefcb3ce81b4b8f4481111293f9679851f40e19102278f886bdd07f21", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6305433d67b224f608635195c77d18809ad0c00a1893efb5598852e477a34a7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ef5d6f078b7aa9e858629865d9f5497fecbf1b8a5fdcd908844e45877eaf40c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5c9f8ca3e9ac2f49e0922ba8d308331b2ddcef253924dc86c468cb1477371721", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "57ccebc2a2409df1dfc9d9c78fc23950ad31a4e223e0bed57ff5f723159b76ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5d7734f7e7a6b7c25416ec4c6ba51447a7d7ced46886ef4d47bafa49bcfcad53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85697cabd91fe979f6b44429c83e4caa3052f2ced9d9c82837531bd68d11fa88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7e3efe1b2659646f933f632338787ff0bad46dfbecc573f8db258d383edec032", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7c21ace6e1701014de3ab95674736b3d4a3883f51edd15cc1b034a273fb8109b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cea03b5bd710950f0a4ef149f9d2f7ec8c542c234c81bf7fa7a45dfa128ff997", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d94829dc36a046a7112f7aea8626c582cbc2be7c9297411037c7f988d8a249", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "90dcccc15fecf7efbf56eea2ddc31d80b6696a1ba7c73bc57b08ce9d06e189a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8ec111d8aa7631f0bb6bbd354ff80df4684920297cc665f0dc887df5c8118123", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e01305134e4f4c9631cdd134e44ec2a8e716527ea86a73a3e434a63261460311", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "739d057c7381f3fe07e4fc22a43f09e0cf80e0bb25981242408b46a5635217b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c381eff884cc01744e69c8db42c1a5aba56dbf20225fd98eb92e437041ceceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ece3d9f78ffa10dc14b795700a41cebc30932e1e4c570038e3b1c917c43562", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f2a41c469ddfe5972e08e0c6f09acc4204e2e93a0f0645406591686967892596", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bcd76dfa305e7540d343aae8ecc2598b5f073f6fd260cd2e6a6d9fca18016150", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f50487375fcf946268136e5ff9e625f1474366792edec5a8a13ea49c1a530408", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a7ccea589e8dd6f3cba31f3aa5f1d5f77bb3029bc0286f2ecbb336349092ad10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f127a50306a634c12dbd18a36e4407a0a4dc5d56a8e2269858b4475a8c8590", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a5438499352ee5f30f919f08517a054a5e7d818ee07260aacec14adde18a765", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c8af1ab49929b1f36db885ffc5d3f2f99cb2a47526ddf56ff4bcf8473fad607", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "651998a2fce220108396b8910e0ea10681c997dc25abbdc0f0f6656b283317f3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "139968d1e25c6af2067fd62ced01a0ca93f0df02ab686422c45b7e5f682f150b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "60b5aa372b038498eb1838b1a1acfe1aa835ee9f57658b74026d66c0df588895", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f81973afc08692f1c241ac6103efb90f3455d2794726164f5e0a2227258e899d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ef2cc83858f43c5c57ca0734c62e1ef3a9f409bdaa646313e1c125d94caef1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a073c510f4338a77c9d27f197766de62298dc06447aa3d1328eb47a5a2baea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "56630435871566b9f3584d53e0b35dc0ce4c5562e4d57a8ecc56aa802a3612ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2f8b3129470d47676376ba5af87c57841c19f886ad34655320a8557877a8fce6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1cdac0a8da58aacc95ba1dba8b08f4ea05709ed42486891762e982885497ee31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d3c3e919b2334cc9f1deed0399f2b33f6875db35c50e81ad30bdec60618f0fe4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f1510be6ac21152bdf66eea74a787f634dfb9d0e3867017ae7684ef837dcd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10460/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "f9ee03e0653f7884ffc8ce8efad0f229e9c7ced6ae5c4fc0b9de130913b8afdc" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace-job.json", + "sha256": "b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.678581+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "10468": { @@ -177465,7 +180881,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10468", "family_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -177479,36 +180895,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "51f65619499d20f54fa9493635b9ec57ce6bc0bdc9dcffe527495be3e8a7b6ab", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.647995+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10461", - "10463", - "10464", - "10465", - "10466", - "1046a", - "1046b", - "1046c", - "1046d" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "e6fcbe38ceff45160d84841405e8363db4a15fdb4cd462cd46ebfdd65016fbab", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.796043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 6a639187edfd3fc8bd3fbee44c0aa5281f89016932da8b50951c3c3d036fe8f1", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10460-original.ppm", + "sha256": "898b3c1a6fdbd1d6bab7291ea1543b5e5615e13f11d93604a56a89dcf35b7648", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8ccea87926d7ef3505c568f6737b4ff851fbb9bbec30ded88b9770c828aa751f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "02c28841546da2fde0753a1ebbc6e4e2b3e856c18a293ba47aca28fec8a74f29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "764632e5b9e3adc93dfa7504f894d585ce7a5938469c965720ae7f5b4eaac314", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "824525dd48f88085b24a76dfd6cc3d4432047ba7a259db40219be93331992691", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26cc194328aef2dafd75e1190bda8278a41876bf152f58c9207c3a9b760d32e6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "546b47110af067d026f8670639bd4b3bf3923653fde79af6afc003d236bfd9db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0bf6f6989d65d892f5984135190af10e167d132f47cff0236397bd66bfdd8907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "15f6ec7f8ab75cedec0fd4be7298804772cd4d1e9991363ae5ef0c268fa5b4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a71a3f345b92174973fb61369574b658584f31ac3b6b18fae2821506c990f450", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f45ba5f1464339e5268cbd2b175c22cd272c6f2bf43951c59277d09c2f9494bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "636c8fe8568c3992921fb8102da33993531f9f45dd791f9a07e24654798223b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "597fd8c9cfdc20ad5c8c6735cba7543bebe0613faca382d4cc92a1aaa84d2eb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cb51b539f24dedc959b46ea4fcfa1de9b8d9e77580944432c16b955147031a1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6b7fa69282aec6b173caa39ab883a6f091b2ab8cc029b94eea5e97144551fcbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9f396545b1928abfe8ac606ebda3f58ee0f17c99633f1fae4b2d85fea2206dd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85d1b4b05bf45fe304b1ccb661038af6ffa27774aa31c22446f715cc2b42e40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5f16a8fbfe6fec61b1cc9756b51f05d460b5366275d0cd35d47d58c6909f08f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8d407588964c73e6639940e634e74d0e6e289fc292631dd16ba70289715a0df9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e6aac54d2a1ff7e61f6496cb5aaf07f63b4fb99442d828368f34af3e239528a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b33e48c44028411ea2d5a1b558f5bd4e105c4377ab78226feb3923783d01a033", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "421f2cd698da4d58e2d8b1176bc0bdfe273c8f13d50c82d0d8d7dca972bfe544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "75d6426d1d07032e87e70918df6394c740085ffe11fc043e88d0fec8c1fd492b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56a950961dd5e9db6ab8a0f0f05b851b12b720161242f7106884afbf40c5af1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ba5dbc75e7c13a721bacdec8f71e239e8280d45612ebda32fcc2f577ad7c6228", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ceb556a184ace68d4c364694bc5befae02b8f00a9c23ef64cc033fe419614b57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac29c75b5f2d1bc376eee8605f1558d5d2e4a7898c82171e88545feca5eaa7a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3d56ac096c2ec9337ac727297e726a975e2b186ab97eb14dd3b714ead3382fcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4b86e58799dbb953a6173f9d5df01c39c9183188f74494fbcdafd78f7d16fbe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ea69fe44bfac61674e6866fc00ee06b70e0ed423a6faf19a3d2eb1965fed853c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1072a95735a18956761f4ce44b3ff6a0067f75f272daed0b5bb582dd223400e9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "316e340614bcc1ee4233263634b85b8de3160aaadd2e25726eff86b4aae6031a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4b51447841eb462b312dbaff6e11ba8406b07cc81f8efe92924e47364c0fb4fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "77e21af78bece3d34276237b0095e7998861fc7130cc80b995ce7d50353f0a60", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12a534545dfe8517f5f35a3416521c973fa0d859cfa40dbac0669d60c7c7dc63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-original.ppm", + "sha256": "27748411c905ecb51b413582b2a6eafc587ca774a1b89dd55100a05981f9ce56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "935f8bbaa2815d02ca77e1d222d21bddc09cc3dfd510ed5507c4eb27c0ed2b99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2c66b6874c47e5fd2dafb1ab9d9b87067dd7e46e2778c9a02f7617c181cc8473", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4f82a853ef7f8b3aaa1a359332aa53f05bfb52a63657aab4110815f81ef510d8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "acaadaa9ade781b07308d01fb953e2e60773d35cec3381a78c171c4a78ae6702", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75d3e8bf210b11e36cb1b4cf5f74f30cea322598d210963fcde115140378cf88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "12ea419d4824f5009acc727dfc85699e889b4e06e8c5aa35578891d4d9f81fc2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e755de57acddc93bb716d6a4b665019eedd609c5f3a59a3bc7aabbf9e7b51203", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "deeb6d253fe4efb60698e2c17b04b54dc50542926ef1cde457deb39c85f564fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0f51e854b6b03b245bd190c787e9de204993906fbdcf20a0761d586cb67e4cbd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c111f88fefcb3ce81b4b8f4481111293f9679851f40e19102278f886bdd07f21", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6305433d67b224f608635195c77d18809ad0c00a1893efb5598852e477a34a7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ef5d6f078b7aa9e858629865d9f5497fecbf1b8a5fdcd908844e45877eaf40c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5c9f8ca3e9ac2f49e0922ba8d308331b2ddcef253924dc86c468cb1477371721", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "57ccebc2a2409df1dfc9d9c78fc23950ad31a4e223e0bed57ff5f723159b76ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5d7734f7e7a6b7c25416ec4c6ba51447a7d7ced46886ef4d47bafa49bcfcad53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85697cabd91fe979f6b44429c83e4caa3052f2ced9d9c82837531bd68d11fa88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7e3efe1b2659646f933f632338787ff0bad46dfbecc573f8db258d383edec032", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7c21ace6e1701014de3ab95674736b3d4a3883f51edd15cc1b034a273fb8109b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cea03b5bd710950f0a4ef149f9d2f7ec8c542c234c81bf7fa7a45dfa128ff997", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d94829dc36a046a7112f7aea8626c582cbc2be7c9297411037c7f988d8a249", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "90dcccc15fecf7efbf56eea2ddc31d80b6696a1ba7c73bc57b08ce9d06e189a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8ec111d8aa7631f0bb6bbd354ff80df4684920297cc665f0dc887df5c8118123", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e01305134e4f4c9631cdd134e44ec2a8e716527ea86a73a3e434a63261460311", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "739d057c7381f3fe07e4fc22a43f09e0cf80e0bb25981242408b46a5635217b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c381eff884cc01744e69c8db42c1a5aba56dbf20225fd98eb92e437041ceceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ece3d9f78ffa10dc14b795700a41cebc30932e1e4c570038e3b1c917c43562", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f2a41c469ddfe5972e08e0c6f09acc4204e2e93a0f0645406591686967892596", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bcd76dfa305e7540d343aae8ecc2598b5f073f6fd260cd2e6a6d9fca18016150", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f50487375fcf946268136e5ff9e625f1474366792edec5a8a13ea49c1a530408", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a7ccea589e8dd6f3cba31f3aa5f1d5f77bb3029bc0286f2ecbb336349092ad10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f127a50306a634c12dbd18a36e4407a0a4dc5d56a8e2269858b4475a8c8590", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a5438499352ee5f30f919f08517a054a5e7d818ee07260aacec14adde18a765", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c8af1ab49929b1f36db885ffc5d3f2f99cb2a47526ddf56ff4bcf8473fad607", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "651998a2fce220108396b8910e0ea10681c997dc25abbdc0f0f6656b283317f3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "139968d1e25c6af2067fd62ced01a0ca93f0df02ab686422c45b7e5f682f150b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "60b5aa372b038498eb1838b1a1acfe1aa835ee9f57658b74026d66c0df588895", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f81973afc08692f1c241ac6103efb90f3455d2794726164f5e0a2227258e899d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ef2cc83858f43c5c57ca0734c62e1ef3a9f409bdaa646313e1c125d94caef1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a073c510f4338a77c9d27f197766de62298dc06447aa3d1328eb47a5a2baea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "56630435871566b9f3584d53e0b35dc0ce4c5562e4d57a8ecc56aa802a3612ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2f8b3129470d47676376ba5af87c57841c19f886ad34655320a8557877a8fce6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1cdac0a8da58aacc95ba1dba8b08f4ea05709ed42486891762e982885497ee31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d3c3e919b2334cc9f1deed0399f2b33f6875db35c50e81ad30bdec60618f0fe4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f1510be6ac21152bdf66eea74a787f634dfb9d0e3867017ae7684ef837dcd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10460/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "f9ee03e0653f7884ffc8ce8efad0f229e9c7ced6ae5c4fc0b9de130913b8afdc" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace-job.json", + "sha256": "b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.678581+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "10469": { @@ -177530,7 +181373,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10469", "family_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -177544,36 +181387,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "51f65619499d20f54fa9493635b9ec57ce6bc0bdc9dcffe527495be3e8a7b6ab", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.647995+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10461", - "10463", - "10464", - "10465", - "10466", - "1046a", - "1046b", - "1046c", - "1046d" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "e6fcbe38ceff45160d84841405e8363db4a15fdb4cd462cd46ebfdd65016fbab", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.796043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 6a639187edfd3fc8bd3fbee44c0aa5281f89016932da8b50951c3c3d036fe8f1", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10460-original.ppm", + "sha256": "898b3c1a6fdbd1d6bab7291ea1543b5e5615e13f11d93604a56a89dcf35b7648", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8ccea87926d7ef3505c568f6737b4ff851fbb9bbec30ded88b9770c828aa751f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "02c28841546da2fde0753a1ebbc6e4e2b3e856c18a293ba47aca28fec8a74f29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "764632e5b9e3adc93dfa7504f894d585ce7a5938469c965720ae7f5b4eaac314", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "824525dd48f88085b24a76dfd6cc3d4432047ba7a259db40219be93331992691", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26cc194328aef2dafd75e1190bda8278a41876bf152f58c9207c3a9b760d32e6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "546b47110af067d026f8670639bd4b3bf3923653fde79af6afc003d236bfd9db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0bf6f6989d65d892f5984135190af10e167d132f47cff0236397bd66bfdd8907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "15f6ec7f8ab75cedec0fd4be7298804772cd4d1e9991363ae5ef0c268fa5b4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a71a3f345b92174973fb61369574b658584f31ac3b6b18fae2821506c990f450", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f45ba5f1464339e5268cbd2b175c22cd272c6f2bf43951c59277d09c2f9494bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "636c8fe8568c3992921fb8102da33993531f9f45dd791f9a07e24654798223b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "597fd8c9cfdc20ad5c8c6735cba7543bebe0613faca382d4cc92a1aaa84d2eb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cb51b539f24dedc959b46ea4fcfa1de9b8d9e77580944432c16b955147031a1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6b7fa69282aec6b173caa39ab883a6f091b2ab8cc029b94eea5e97144551fcbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9f396545b1928abfe8ac606ebda3f58ee0f17c99633f1fae4b2d85fea2206dd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85d1b4b05bf45fe304b1ccb661038af6ffa27774aa31c22446f715cc2b42e40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5f16a8fbfe6fec61b1cc9756b51f05d460b5366275d0cd35d47d58c6909f08f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8d407588964c73e6639940e634e74d0e6e289fc292631dd16ba70289715a0df9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e6aac54d2a1ff7e61f6496cb5aaf07f63b4fb99442d828368f34af3e239528a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b33e48c44028411ea2d5a1b558f5bd4e105c4377ab78226feb3923783d01a033", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "421f2cd698da4d58e2d8b1176bc0bdfe273c8f13d50c82d0d8d7dca972bfe544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "75d6426d1d07032e87e70918df6394c740085ffe11fc043e88d0fec8c1fd492b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56a950961dd5e9db6ab8a0f0f05b851b12b720161242f7106884afbf40c5af1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ba5dbc75e7c13a721bacdec8f71e239e8280d45612ebda32fcc2f577ad7c6228", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ceb556a184ace68d4c364694bc5befae02b8f00a9c23ef64cc033fe419614b57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac29c75b5f2d1bc376eee8605f1558d5d2e4a7898c82171e88545feca5eaa7a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3d56ac096c2ec9337ac727297e726a975e2b186ab97eb14dd3b714ead3382fcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4b86e58799dbb953a6173f9d5df01c39c9183188f74494fbcdafd78f7d16fbe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ea69fe44bfac61674e6866fc00ee06b70e0ed423a6faf19a3d2eb1965fed853c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1072a95735a18956761f4ce44b3ff6a0067f75f272daed0b5bb582dd223400e9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "316e340614bcc1ee4233263634b85b8de3160aaadd2e25726eff86b4aae6031a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4b51447841eb462b312dbaff6e11ba8406b07cc81f8efe92924e47364c0fb4fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "77e21af78bece3d34276237b0095e7998861fc7130cc80b995ce7d50353f0a60", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12a534545dfe8517f5f35a3416521c973fa0d859cfa40dbac0669d60c7c7dc63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-original.ppm", + "sha256": "27748411c905ecb51b413582b2a6eafc587ca774a1b89dd55100a05981f9ce56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "935f8bbaa2815d02ca77e1d222d21bddc09cc3dfd510ed5507c4eb27c0ed2b99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2c66b6874c47e5fd2dafb1ab9d9b87067dd7e46e2778c9a02f7617c181cc8473", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4f82a853ef7f8b3aaa1a359332aa53f05bfb52a63657aab4110815f81ef510d8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "acaadaa9ade781b07308d01fb953e2e60773d35cec3381a78c171c4a78ae6702", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75d3e8bf210b11e36cb1b4cf5f74f30cea322598d210963fcde115140378cf88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "12ea419d4824f5009acc727dfc85699e889b4e06e8c5aa35578891d4d9f81fc2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e755de57acddc93bb716d6a4b665019eedd609c5f3a59a3bc7aabbf9e7b51203", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "deeb6d253fe4efb60698e2c17b04b54dc50542926ef1cde457deb39c85f564fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0f51e854b6b03b245bd190c787e9de204993906fbdcf20a0761d586cb67e4cbd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c111f88fefcb3ce81b4b8f4481111293f9679851f40e19102278f886bdd07f21", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6305433d67b224f608635195c77d18809ad0c00a1893efb5598852e477a34a7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ef5d6f078b7aa9e858629865d9f5497fecbf1b8a5fdcd908844e45877eaf40c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5c9f8ca3e9ac2f49e0922ba8d308331b2ddcef253924dc86c468cb1477371721", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "57ccebc2a2409df1dfc9d9c78fc23950ad31a4e223e0bed57ff5f723159b76ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5d7734f7e7a6b7c25416ec4c6ba51447a7d7ced46886ef4d47bafa49bcfcad53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85697cabd91fe979f6b44429c83e4caa3052f2ced9d9c82837531bd68d11fa88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7e3efe1b2659646f933f632338787ff0bad46dfbecc573f8db258d383edec032", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7c21ace6e1701014de3ab95674736b3d4a3883f51edd15cc1b034a273fb8109b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cea03b5bd710950f0a4ef149f9d2f7ec8c542c234c81bf7fa7a45dfa128ff997", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d94829dc36a046a7112f7aea8626c582cbc2be7c9297411037c7f988d8a249", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "90dcccc15fecf7efbf56eea2ddc31d80b6696a1ba7c73bc57b08ce9d06e189a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8ec111d8aa7631f0bb6bbd354ff80df4684920297cc665f0dc887df5c8118123", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e01305134e4f4c9631cdd134e44ec2a8e716527ea86a73a3e434a63261460311", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "739d057c7381f3fe07e4fc22a43f09e0cf80e0bb25981242408b46a5635217b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c381eff884cc01744e69c8db42c1a5aba56dbf20225fd98eb92e437041ceceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ece3d9f78ffa10dc14b795700a41cebc30932e1e4c570038e3b1c917c43562", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f2a41c469ddfe5972e08e0c6f09acc4204e2e93a0f0645406591686967892596", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bcd76dfa305e7540d343aae8ecc2598b5f073f6fd260cd2e6a6d9fca18016150", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f50487375fcf946268136e5ff9e625f1474366792edec5a8a13ea49c1a530408", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a7ccea589e8dd6f3cba31f3aa5f1d5f77bb3029bc0286f2ecbb336349092ad10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f127a50306a634c12dbd18a36e4407a0a4dc5d56a8e2269858b4475a8c8590", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a5438499352ee5f30f919f08517a054a5e7d818ee07260aacec14adde18a765", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c8af1ab49929b1f36db885ffc5d3f2f99cb2a47526ddf56ff4bcf8473fad607", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "651998a2fce220108396b8910e0ea10681c997dc25abbdc0f0f6656b283317f3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "139968d1e25c6af2067fd62ced01a0ca93f0df02ab686422c45b7e5f682f150b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "60b5aa372b038498eb1838b1a1acfe1aa835ee9f57658b74026d66c0df588895", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f81973afc08692f1c241ac6103efb90f3455d2794726164f5e0a2227258e899d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ef2cc83858f43c5c57ca0734c62e1ef3a9f409bdaa646313e1c125d94caef1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a073c510f4338a77c9d27f197766de62298dc06447aa3d1328eb47a5a2baea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "56630435871566b9f3584d53e0b35dc0ce4c5562e4d57a8ecc56aa802a3612ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2f8b3129470d47676376ba5af87c57841c19f886ad34655320a8557877a8fce6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1cdac0a8da58aacc95ba1dba8b08f4ea05709ed42486891762e982885497ee31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d3c3e919b2334cc9f1deed0399f2b33f6875db35c50e81ad30bdec60618f0fe4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f1510be6ac21152bdf66eea74a787f634dfb9d0e3867017ae7684ef837dcd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10460/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "f9ee03e0653f7884ffc8ce8efad0f229e9c7ced6ae5c4fc0b9de130913b8afdc" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace-job.json", + "sha256": "b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.678581+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "1046a": { @@ -177595,7 +181865,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1046a", "family_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -177609,36 +181879,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "51f65619499d20f54fa9493635b9ec57ce6bc0bdc9dcffe527495be3e8a7b6ab", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.647995+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10461", - "10463", - "10464", - "10465", - "10466", - "1046a", - "1046b", - "1046c", - "1046d" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "e6fcbe38ceff45160d84841405e8363db4a15fdb4cd462cd46ebfdd65016fbab", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.796043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 6a639187edfd3fc8bd3fbee44c0aa5281f89016932da8b50951c3c3d036fe8f1", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10460-original.ppm", + "sha256": "898b3c1a6fdbd1d6bab7291ea1543b5e5615e13f11d93604a56a89dcf35b7648", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8ccea87926d7ef3505c568f6737b4ff851fbb9bbec30ded88b9770c828aa751f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "02c28841546da2fde0753a1ebbc6e4e2b3e856c18a293ba47aca28fec8a74f29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "764632e5b9e3adc93dfa7504f894d585ce7a5938469c965720ae7f5b4eaac314", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "824525dd48f88085b24a76dfd6cc3d4432047ba7a259db40219be93331992691", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26cc194328aef2dafd75e1190bda8278a41876bf152f58c9207c3a9b760d32e6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "546b47110af067d026f8670639bd4b3bf3923653fde79af6afc003d236bfd9db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0bf6f6989d65d892f5984135190af10e167d132f47cff0236397bd66bfdd8907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "15f6ec7f8ab75cedec0fd4be7298804772cd4d1e9991363ae5ef0c268fa5b4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a71a3f345b92174973fb61369574b658584f31ac3b6b18fae2821506c990f450", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f45ba5f1464339e5268cbd2b175c22cd272c6f2bf43951c59277d09c2f9494bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "636c8fe8568c3992921fb8102da33993531f9f45dd791f9a07e24654798223b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "597fd8c9cfdc20ad5c8c6735cba7543bebe0613faca382d4cc92a1aaa84d2eb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cb51b539f24dedc959b46ea4fcfa1de9b8d9e77580944432c16b955147031a1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6b7fa69282aec6b173caa39ab883a6f091b2ab8cc029b94eea5e97144551fcbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9f396545b1928abfe8ac606ebda3f58ee0f17c99633f1fae4b2d85fea2206dd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85d1b4b05bf45fe304b1ccb661038af6ffa27774aa31c22446f715cc2b42e40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5f16a8fbfe6fec61b1cc9756b51f05d460b5366275d0cd35d47d58c6909f08f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8d407588964c73e6639940e634e74d0e6e289fc292631dd16ba70289715a0df9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e6aac54d2a1ff7e61f6496cb5aaf07f63b4fb99442d828368f34af3e239528a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b33e48c44028411ea2d5a1b558f5bd4e105c4377ab78226feb3923783d01a033", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "421f2cd698da4d58e2d8b1176bc0bdfe273c8f13d50c82d0d8d7dca972bfe544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "75d6426d1d07032e87e70918df6394c740085ffe11fc043e88d0fec8c1fd492b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56a950961dd5e9db6ab8a0f0f05b851b12b720161242f7106884afbf40c5af1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ba5dbc75e7c13a721bacdec8f71e239e8280d45612ebda32fcc2f577ad7c6228", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ceb556a184ace68d4c364694bc5befae02b8f00a9c23ef64cc033fe419614b57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac29c75b5f2d1bc376eee8605f1558d5d2e4a7898c82171e88545feca5eaa7a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3d56ac096c2ec9337ac727297e726a975e2b186ab97eb14dd3b714ead3382fcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4b86e58799dbb953a6173f9d5df01c39c9183188f74494fbcdafd78f7d16fbe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ea69fe44bfac61674e6866fc00ee06b70e0ed423a6faf19a3d2eb1965fed853c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1072a95735a18956761f4ce44b3ff6a0067f75f272daed0b5bb582dd223400e9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "316e340614bcc1ee4233263634b85b8de3160aaadd2e25726eff86b4aae6031a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4b51447841eb462b312dbaff6e11ba8406b07cc81f8efe92924e47364c0fb4fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "77e21af78bece3d34276237b0095e7998861fc7130cc80b995ce7d50353f0a60", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12a534545dfe8517f5f35a3416521c973fa0d859cfa40dbac0669d60c7c7dc63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-original.ppm", + "sha256": "27748411c905ecb51b413582b2a6eafc587ca774a1b89dd55100a05981f9ce56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "935f8bbaa2815d02ca77e1d222d21bddc09cc3dfd510ed5507c4eb27c0ed2b99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2c66b6874c47e5fd2dafb1ab9d9b87067dd7e46e2778c9a02f7617c181cc8473", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4f82a853ef7f8b3aaa1a359332aa53f05bfb52a63657aab4110815f81ef510d8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "acaadaa9ade781b07308d01fb953e2e60773d35cec3381a78c171c4a78ae6702", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75d3e8bf210b11e36cb1b4cf5f74f30cea322598d210963fcde115140378cf88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "12ea419d4824f5009acc727dfc85699e889b4e06e8c5aa35578891d4d9f81fc2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e755de57acddc93bb716d6a4b665019eedd609c5f3a59a3bc7aabbf9e7b51203", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "deeb6d253fe4efb60698e2c17b04b54dc50542926ef1cde457deb39c85f564fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0f51e854b6b03b245bd190c787e9de204993906fbdcf20a0761d586cb67e4cbd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c111f88fefcb3ce81b4b8f4481111293f9679851f40e19102278f886bdd07f21", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6305433d67b224f608635195c77d18809ad0c00a1893efb5598852e477a34a7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ef5d6f078b7aa9e858629865d9f5497fecbf1b8a5fdcd908844e45877eaf40c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5c9f8ca3e9ac2f49e0922ba8d308331b2ddcef253924dc86c468cb1477371721", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "57ccebc2a2409df1dfc9d9c78fc23950ad31a4e223e0bed57ff5f723159b76ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5d7734f7e7a6b7c25416ec4c6ba51447a7d7ced46886ef4d47bafa49bcfcad53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85697cabd91fe979f6b44429c83e4caa3052f2ced9d9c82837531bd68d11fa88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7e3efe1b2659646f933f632338787ff0bad46dfbecc573f8db258d383edec032", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7c21ace6e1701014de3ab95674736b3d4a3883f51edd15cc1b034a273fb8109b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cea03b5bd710950f0a4ef149f9d2f7ec8c542c234c81bf7fa7a45dfa128ff997", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d94829dc36a046a7112f7aea8626c582cbc2be7c9297411037c7f988d8a249", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "90dcccc15fecf7efbf56eea2ddc31d80b6696a1ba7c73bc57b08ce9d06e189a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8ec111d8aa7631f0bb6bbd354ff80df4684920297cc665f0dc887df5c8118123", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e01305134e4f4c9631cdd134e44ec2a8e716527ea86a73a3e434a63261460311", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "739d057c7381f3fe07e4fc22a43f09e0cf80e0bb25981242408b46a5635217b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c381eff884cc01744e69c8db42c1a5aba56dbf20225fd98eb92e437041ceceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ece3d9f78ffa10dc14b795700a41cebc30932e1e4c570038e3b1c917c43562", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f2a41c469ddfe5972e08e0c6f09acc4204e2e93a0f0645406591686967892596", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bcd76dfa305e7540d343aae8ecc2598b5f073f6fd260cd2e6a6d9fca18016150", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f50487375fcf946268136e5ff9e625f1474366792edec5a8a13ea49c1a530408", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a7ccea589e8dd6f3cba31f3aa5f1d5f77bb3029bc0286f2ecbb336349092ad10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f127a50306a634c12dbd18a36e4407a0a4dc5d56a8e2269858b4475a8c8590", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a5438499352ee5f30f919f08517a054a5e7d818ee07260aacec14adde18a765", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c8af1ab49929b1f36db885ffc5d3f2f99cb2a47526ddf56ff4bcf8473fad607", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "651998a2fce220108396b8910e0ea10681c997dc25abbdc0f0f6656b283317f3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "139968d1e25c6af2067fd62ced01a0ca93f0df02ab686422c45b7e5f682f150b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "60b5aa372b038498eb1838b1a1acfe1aa835ee9f57658b74026d66c0df588895", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f81973afc08692f1c241ac6103efb90f3455d2794726164f5e0a2227258e899d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ef2cc83858f43c5c57ca0734c62e1ef3a9f409bdaa646313e1c125d94caef1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a073c510f4338a77c9d27f197766de62298dc06447aa3d1328eb47a5a2baea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "56630435871566b9f3584d53e0b35dc0ce4c5562e4d57a8ecc56aa802a3612ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2f8b3129470d47676376ba5af87c57841c19f886ad34655320a8557877a8fce6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1cdac0a8da58aacc95ba1dba8b08f4ea05709ed42486891762e982885497ee31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d3c3e919b2334cc9f1deed0399f2b33f6875db35c50e81ad30bdec60618f0fe4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f1510be6ac21152bdf66eea74a787f634dfb9d0e3867017ae7684ef837dcd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10460/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "f9ee03e0653f7884ffc8ce8efad0f229e9c7ced6ae5c4fc0b9de130913b8afdc" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace-job.json", + "sha256": "b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.678581+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "1046b": { @@ -177660,7 +182357,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1046b", "family_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -177674,36 +182371,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "51f65619499d20f54fa9493635b9ec57ce6bc0bdc9dcffe527495be3e8a7b6ab", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.647995+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10461", - "10463", - "10464", - "10465", - "10466", - "1046a", - "1046b", - "1046c", - "1046d" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "e6fcbe38ceff45160d84841405e8363db4a15fdb4cd462cd46ebfdd65016fbab", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.796043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 6a639187edfd3fc8bd3fbee44c0aa5281f89016932da8b50951c3c3d036fe8f1", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10460-original.ppm", + "sha256": "898b3c1a6fdbd1d6bab7291ea1543b5e5615e13f11d93604a56a89dcf35b7648", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8ccea87926d7ef3505c568f6737b4ff851fbb9bbec30ded88b9770c828aa751f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "02c28841546da2fde0753a1ebbc6e4e2b3e856c18a293ba47aca28fec8a74f29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "764632e5b9e3adc93dfa7504f894d585ce7a5938469c965720ae7f5b4eaac314", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "824525dd48f88085b24a76dfd6cc3d4432047ba7a259db40219be93331992691", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26cc194328aef2dafd75e1190bda8278a41876bf152f58c9207c3a9b760d32e6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "546b47110af067d026f8670639bd4b3bf3923653fde79af6afc003d236bfd9db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0bf6f6989d65d892f5984135190af10e167d132f47cff0236397bd66bfdd8907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "15f6ec7f8ab75cedec0fd4be7298804772cd4d1e9991363ae5ef0c268fa5b4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a71a3f345b92174973fb61369574b658584f31ac3b6b18fae2821506c990f450", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f45ba5f1464339e5268cbd2b175c22cd272c6f2bf43951c59277d09c2f9494bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "636c8fe8568c3992921fb8102da33993531f9f45dd791f9a07e24654798223b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "597fd8c9cfdc20ad5c8c6735cba7543bebe0613faca382d4cc92a1aaa84d2eb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cb51b539f24dedc959b46ea4fcfa1de9b8d9e77580944432c16b955147031a1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6b7fa69282aec6b173caa39ab883a6f091b2ab8cc029b94eea5e97144551fcbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9f396545b1928abfe8ac606ebda3f58ee0f17c99633f1fae4b2d85fea2206dd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85d1b4b05bf45fe304b1ccb661038af6ffa27774aa31c22446f715cc2b42e40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5f16a8fbfe6fec61b1cc9756b51f05d460b5366275d0cd35d47d58c6909f08f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8d407588964c73e6639940e634e74d0e6e289fc292631dd16ba70289715a0df9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e6aac54d2a1ff7e61f6496cb5aaf07f63b4fb99442d828368f34af3e239528a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b33e48c44028411ea2d5a1b558f5bd4e105c4377ab78226feb3923783d01a033", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "421f2cd698da4d58e2d8b1176bc0bdfe273c8f13d50c82d0d8d7dca972bfe544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "75d6426d1d07032e87e70918df6394c740085ffe11fc043e88d0fec8c1fd492b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56a950961dd5e9db6ab8a0f0f05b851b12b720161242f7106884afbf40c5af1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ba5dbc75e7c13a721bacdec8f71e239e8280d45612ebda32fcc2f577ad7c6228", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ceb556a184ace68d4c364694bc5befae02b8f00a9c23ef64cc033fe419614b57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac29c75b5f2d1bc376eee8605f1558d5d2e4a7898c82171e88545feca5eaa7a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3d56ac096c2ec9337ac727297e726a975e2b186ab97eb14dd3b714ead3382fcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4b86e58799dbb953a6173f9d5df01c39c9183188f74494fbcdafd78f7d16fbe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ea69fe44bfac61674e6866fc00ee06b70e0ed423a6faf19a3d2eb1965fed853c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1072a95735a18956761f4ce44b3ff6a0067f75f272daed0b5bb582dd223400e9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "316e340614bcc1ee4233263634b85b8de3160aaadd2e25726eff86b4aae6031a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4b51447841eb462b312dbaff6e11ba8406b07cc81f8efe92924e47364c0fb4fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "77e21af78bece3d34276237b0095e7998861fc7130cc80b995ce7d50353f0a60", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12a534545dfe8517f5f35a3416521c973fa0d859cfa40dbac0669d60c7c7dc63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-original.ppm", + "sha256": "27748411c905ecb51b413582b2a6eafc587ca774a1b89dd55100a05981f9ce56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "935f8bbaa2815d02ca77e1d222d21bddc09cc3dfd510ed5507c4eb27c0ed2b99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2c66b6874c47e5fd2dafb1ab9d9b87067dd7e46e2778c9a02f7617c181cc8473", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4f82a853ef7f8b3aaa1a359332aa53f05bfb52a63657aab4110815f81ef510d8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "acaadaa9ade781b07308d01fb953e2e60773d35cec3381a78c171c4a78ae6702", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75d3e8bf210b11e36cb1b4cf5f74f30cea322598d210963fcde115140378cf88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "12ea419d4824f5009acc727dfc85699e889b4e06e8c5aa35578891d4d9f81fc2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e755de57acddc93bb716d6a4b665019eedd609c5f3a59a3bc7aabbf9e7b51203", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "deeb6d253fe4efb60698e2c17b04b54dc50542926ef1cde457deb39c85f564fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0f51e854b6b03b245bd190c787e9de204993906fbdcf20a0761d586cb67e4cbd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c111f88fefcb3ce81b4b8f4481111293f9679851f40e19102278f886bdd07f21", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6305433d67b224f608635195c77d18809ad0c00a1893efb5598852e477a34a7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ef5d6f078b7aa9e858629865d9f5497fecbf1b8a5fdcd908844e45877eaf40c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5c9f8ca3e9ac2f49e0922ba8d308331b2ddcef253924dc86c468cb1477371721", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "57ccebc2a2409df1dfc9d9c78fc23950ad31a4e223e0bed57ff5f723159b76ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5d7734f7e7a6b7c25416ec4c6ba51447a7d7ced46886ef4d47bafa49bcfcad53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85697cabd91fe979f6b44429c83e4caa3052f2ced9d9c82837531bd68d11fa88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7e3efe1b2659646f933f632338787ff0bad46dfbecc573f8db258d383edec032", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7c21ace6e1701014de3ab95674736b3d4a3883f51edd15cc1b034a273fb8109b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cea03b5bd710950f0a4ef149f9d2f7ec8c542c234c81bf7fa7a45dfa128ff997", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d94829dc36a046a7112f7aea8626c582cbc2be7c9297411037c7f988d8a249", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "90dcccc15fecf7efbf56eea2ddc31d80b6696a1ba7c73bc57b08ce9d06e189a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8ec111d8aa7631f0bb6bbd354ff80df4684920297cc665f0dc887df5c8118123", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e01305134e4f4c9631cdd134e44ec2a8e716527ea86a73a3e434a63261460311", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "739d057c7381f3fe07e4fc22a43f09e0cf80e0bb25981242408b46a5635217b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c381eff884cc01744e69c8db42c1a5aba56dbf20225fd98eb92e437041ceceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ece3d9f78ffa10dc14b795700a41cebc30932e1e4c570038e3b1c917c43562", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f2a41c469ddfe5972e08e0c6f09acc4204e2e93a0f0645406591686967892596", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bcd76dfa305e7540d343aae8ecc2598b5f073f6fd260cd2e6a6d9fca18016150", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f50487375fcf946268136e5ff9e625f1474366792edec5a8a13ea49c1a530408", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a7ccea589e8dd6f3cba31f3aa5f1d5f77bb3029bc0286f2ecbb336349092ad10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f127a50306a634c12dbd18a36e4407a0a4dc5d56a8e2269858b4475a8c8590", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a5438499352ee5f30f919f08517a054a5e7d818ee07260aacec14adde18a765", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c8af1ab49929b1f36db885ffc5d3f2f99cb2a47526ddf56ff4bcf8473fad607", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "651998a2fce220108396b8910e0ea10681c997dc25abbdc0f0f6656b283317f3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "139968d1e25c6af2067fd62ced01a0ca93f0df02ab686422c45b7e5f682f150b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "60b5aa372b038498eb1838b1a1acfe1aa835ee9f57658b74026d66c0df588895", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f81973afc08692f1c241ac6103efb90f3455d2794726164f5e0a2227258e899d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ef2cc83858f43c5c57ca0734c62e1ef3a9f409bdaa646313e1c125d94caef1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a073c510f4338a77c9d27f197766de62298dc06447aa3d1328eb47a5a2baea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "56630435871566b9f3584d53e0b35dc0ce4c5562e4d57a8ecc56aa802a3612ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2f8b3129470d47676376ba5af87c57841c19f886ad34655320a8557877a8fce6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1cdac0a8da58aacc95ba1dba8b08f4ea05709ed42486891762e982885497ee31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d3c3e919b2334cc9f1deed0399f2b33f6875db35c50e81ad30bdec60618f0fe4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f1510be6ac21152bdf66eea74a787f634dfb9d0e3867017ae7684ef837dcd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10460/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "f9ee03e0653f7884ffc8ce8efad0f229e9c7ced6ae5c4fc0b9de130913b8afdc" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace-job.json", + "sha256": "b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.678581+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "1046c": { @@ -177725,7 +182849,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1046c", "family_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -177739,36 +182863,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "51f65619499d20f54fa9493635b9ec57ce6bc0bdc9dcffe527495be3e8a7b6ab", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.647995+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10461", - "10463", - "10464", - "10465", - "10466", - "1046a", - "1046b", - "1046c", - "1046d" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "e6fcbe38ceff45160d84841405e8363db4a15fdb4cd462cd46ebfdd65016fbab", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.796043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 6a639187edfd3fc8bd3fbee44c0aa5281f89016932da8b50951c3c3d036fe8f1", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10460-original.ppm", + "sha256": "898b3c1a6fdbd1d6bab7291ea1543b5e5615e13f11d93604a56a89dcf35b7648", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8ccea87926d7ef3505c568f6737b4ff851fbb9bbec30ded88b9770c828aa751f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "02c28841546da2fde0753a1ebbc6e4e2b3e856c18a293ba47aca28fec8a74f29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "764632e5b9e3adc93dfa7504f894d585ce7a5938469c965720ae7f5b4eaac314", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "824525dd48f88085b24a76dfd6cc3d4432047ba7a259db40219be93331992691", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26cc194328aef2dafd75e1190bda8278a41876bf152f58c9207c3a9b760d32e6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "546b47110af067d026f8670639bd4b3bf3923653fde79af6afc003d236bfd9db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0bf6f6989d65d892f5984135190af10e167d132f47cff0236397bd66bfdd8907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "15f6ec7f8ab75cedec0fd4be7298804772cd4d1e9991363ae5ef0c268fa5b4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a71a3f345b92174973fb61369574b658584f31ac3b6b18fae2821506c990f450", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f45ba5f1464339e5268cbd2b175c22cd272c6f2bf43951c59277d09c2f9494bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "636c8fe8568c3992921fb8102da33993531f9f45dd791f9a07e24654798223b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "597fd8c9cfdc20ad5c8c6735cba7543bebe0613faca382d4cc92a1aaa84d2eb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cb51b539f24dedc959b46ea4fcfa1de9b8d9e77580944432c16b955147031a1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6b7fa69282aec6b173caa39ab883a6f091b2ab8cc029b94eea5e97144551fcbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9f396545b1928abfe8ac606ebda3f58ee0f17c99633f1fae4b2d85fea2206dd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85d1b4b05bf45fe304b1ccb661038af6ffa27774aa31c22446f715cc2b42e40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5f16a8fbfe6fec61b1cc9756b51f05d460b5366275d0cd35d47d58c6909f08f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8d407588964c73e6639940e634e74d0e6e289fc292631dd16ba70289715a0df9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e6aac54d2a1ff7e61f6496cb5aaf07f63b4fb99442d828368f34af3e239528a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b33e48c44028411ea2d5a1b558f5bd4e105c4377ab78226feb3923783d01a033", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "421f2cd698da4d58e2d8b1176bc0bdfe273c8f13d50c82d0d8d7dca972bfe544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "75d6426d1d07032e87e70918df6394c740085ffe11fc043e88d0fec8c1fd492b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56a950961dd5e9db6ab8a0f0f05b851b12b720161242f7106884afbf40c5af1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ba5dbc75e7c13a721bacdec8f71e239e8280d45612ebda32fcc2f577ad7c6228", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ceb556a184ace68d4c364694bc5befae02b8f00a9c23ef64cc033fe419614b57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac29c75b5f2d1bc376eee8605f1558d5d2e4a7898c82171e88545feca5eaa7a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3d56ac096c2ec9337ac727297e726a975e2b186ab97eb14dd3b714ead3382fcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4b86e58799dbb953a6173f9d5df01c39c9183188f74494fbcdafd78f7d16fbe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ea69fe44bfac61674e6866fc00ee06b70e0ed423a6faf19a3d2eb1965fed853c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1072a95735a18956761f4ce44b3ff6a0067f75f272daed0b5bb582dd223400e9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "316e340614bcc1ee4233263634b85b8de3160aaadd2e25726eff86b4aae6031a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4b51447841eb462b312dbaff6e11ba8406b07cc81f8efe92924e47364c0fb4fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "77e21af78bece3d34276237b0095e7998861fc7130cc80b995ce7d50353f0a60", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12a534545dfe8517f5f35a3416521c973fa0d859cfa40dbac0669d60c7c7dc63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-original.ppm", + "sha256": "27748411c905ecb51b413582b2a6eafc587ca774a1b89dd55100a05981f9ce56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "935f8bbaa2815d02ca77e1d222d21bddc09cc3dfd510ed5507c4eb27c0ed2b99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2c66b6874c47e5fd2dafb1ab9d9b87067dd7e46e2778c9a02f7617c181cc8473", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4f82a853ef7f8b3aaa1a359332aa53f05bfb52a63657aab4110815f81ef510d8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "acaadaa9ade781b07308d01fb953e2e60773d35cec3381a78c171c4a78ae6702", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75d3e8bf210b11e36cb1b4cf5f74f30cea322598d210963fcde115140378cf88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "12ea419d4824f5009acc727dfc85699e889b4e06e8c5aa35578891d4d9f81fc2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e755de57acddc93bb716d6a4b665019eedd609c5f3a59a3bc7aabbf9e7b51203", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "deeb6d253fe4efb60698e2c17b04b54dc50542926ef1cde457deb39c85f564fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0f51e854b6b03b245bd190c787e9de204993906fbdcf20a0761d586cb67e4cbd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c111f88fefcb3ce81b4b8f4481111293f9679851f40e19102278f886bdd07f21", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6305433d67b224f608635195c77d18809ad0c00a1893efb5598852e477a34a7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ef5d6f078b7aa9e858629865d9f5497fecbf1b8a5fdcd908844e45877eaf40c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5c9f8ca3e9ac2f49e0922ba8d308331b2ddcef253924dc86c468cb1477371721", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "57ccebc2a2409df1dfc9d9c78fc23950ad31a4e223e0bed57ff5f723159b76ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5d7734f7e7a6b7c25416ec4c6ba51447a7d7ced46886ef4d47bafa49bcfcad53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85697cabd91fe979f6b44429c83e4caa3052f2ced9d9c82837531bd68d11fa88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7e3efe1b2659646f933f632338787ff0bad46dfbecc573f8db258d383edec032", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7c21ace6e1701014de3ab95674736b3d4a3883f51edd15cc1b034a273fb8109b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cea03b5bd710950f0a4ef149f9d2f7ec8c542c234c81bf7fa7a45dfa128ff997", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d94829dc36a046a7112f7aea8626c582cbc2be7c9297411037c7f988d8a249", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "90dcccc15fecf7efbf56eea2ddc31d80b6696a1ba7c73bc57b08ce9d06e189a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8ec111d8aa7631f0bb6bbd354ff80df4684920297cc665f0dc887df5c8118123", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e01305134e4f4c9631cdd134e44ec2a8e716527ea86a73a3e434a63261460311", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "739d057c7381f3fe07e4fc22a43f09e0cf80e0bb25981242408b46a5635217b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c381eff884cc01744e69c8db42c1a5aba56dbf20225fd98eb92e437041ceceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ece3d9f78ffa10dc14b795700a41cebc30932e1e4c570038e3b1c917c43562", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f2a41c469ddfe5972e08e0c6f09acc4204e2e93a0f0645406591686967892596", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bcd76dfa305e7540d343aae8ecc2598b5f073f6fd260cd2e6a6d9fca18016150", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f50487375fcf946268136e5ff9e625f1474366792edec5a8a13ea49c1a530408", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a7ccea589e8dd6f3cba31f3aa5f1d5f77bb3029bc0286f2ecbb336349092ad10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f127a50306a634c12dbd18a36e4407a0a4dc5d56a8e2269858b4475a8c8590", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a5438499352ee5f30f919f08517a054a5e7d818ee07260aacec14adde18a765", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c8af1ab49929b1f36db885ffc5d3f2f99cb2a47526ddf56ff4bcf8473fad607", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "651998a2fce220108396b8910e0ea10681c997dc25abbdc0f0f6656b283317f3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "139968d1e25c6af2067fd62ced01a0ca93f0df02ab686422c45b7e5f682f150b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "60b5aa372b038498eb1838b1a1acfe1aa835ee9f57658b74026d66c0df588895", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f81973afc08692f1c241ac6103efb90f3455d2794726164f5e0a2227258e899d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ef2cc83858f43c5c57ca0734c62e1ef3a9f409bdaa646313e1c125d94caef1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a073c510f4338a77c9d27f197766de62298dc06447aa3d1328eb47a5a2baea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "56630435871566b9f3584d53e0b35dc0ce4c5562e4d57a8ecc56aa802a3612ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2f8b3129470d47676376ba5af87c57841c19f886ad34655320a8557877a8fce6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1cdac0a8da58aacc95ba1dba8b08f4ea05709ed42486891762e982885497ee31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d3c3e919b2334cc9f1deed0399f2b33f6875db35c50e81ad30bdec60618f0fe4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f1510be6ac21152bdf66eea74a787f634dfb9d0e3867017ae7684ef837dcd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10460/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "f9ee03e0653f7884ffc8ce8efad0f229e9c7ced6ae5c4fc0b9de130913b8afdc" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace-job.json", + "sha256": "b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.678581+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "1046d": { @@ -177790,7 +183341,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1046d", "family_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -177804,36 +183355,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "51f65619499d20f54fa9493635b9ec57ce6bc0bdc9dcffe527495be3e8a7b6ab", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.647995+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10461", - "10463", - "10464", - "10465", - "10466", - "1046a", - "1046b", - "1046c", - "1046d" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "e6fcbe38ceff45160d84841405e8363db4a15fdb4cd462cd46ebfdd65016fbab", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.796043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 6a639187edfd3fc8bd3fbee44c0aa5281f89016932da8b50951c3c3d036fe8f1", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10460-original.ppm", + "sha256": "898b3c1a6fdbd1d6bab7291ea1543b5e5615e13f11d93604a56a89dcf35b7648", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8ccea87926d7ef3505c568f6737b4ff851fbb9bbec30ded88b9770c828aa751f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "02c28841546da2fde0753a1ebbc6e4e2b3e856c18a293ba47aca28fec8a74f29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "764632e5b9e3adc93dfa7504f894d585ce7a5938469c965720ae7f5b4eaac314", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "824525dd48f88085b24a76dfd6cc3d4432047ba7a259db40219be93331992691", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26cc194328aef2dafd75e1190bda8278a41876bf152f58c9207c3a9b760d32e6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "546b47110af067d026f8670639bd4b3bf3923653fde79af6afc003d236bfd9db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0bf6f6989d65d892f5984135190af10e167d132f47cff0236397bd66bfdd8907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "15f6ec7f8ab75cedec0fd4be7298804772cd4d1e9991363ae5ef0c268fa5b4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a71a3f345b92174973fb61369574b658584f31ac3b6b18fae2821506c990f450", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f45ba5f1464339e5268cbd2b175c22cd272c6f2bf43951c59277d09c2f9494bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "636c8fe8568c3992921fb8102da33993531f9f45dd791f9a07e24654798223b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "597fd8c9cfdc20ad5c8c6735cba7543bebe0613faca382d4cc92a1aaa84d2eb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cb51b539f24dedc959b46ea4fcfa1de9b8d9e77580944432c16b955147031a1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6b7fa69282aec6b173caa39ab883a6f091b2ab8cc029b94eea5e97144551fcbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9f396545b1928abfe8ac606ebda3f58ee0f17c99633f1fae4b2d85fea2206dd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85d1b4b05bf45fe304b1ccb661038af6ffa27774aa31c22446f715cc2b42e40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5f16a8fbfe6fec61b1cc9756b51f05d460b5366275d0cd35d47d58c6909f08f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8d407588964c73e6639940e634e74d0e6e289fc292631dd16ba70289715a0df9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e6aac54d2a1ff7e61f6496cb5aaf07f63b4fb99442d828368f34af3e239528a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b33e48c44028411ea2d5a1b558f5bd4e105c4377ab78226feb3923783d01a033", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "421f2cd698da4d58e2d8b1176bc0bdfe273c8f13d50c82d0d8d7dca972bfe544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "75d6426d1d07032e87e70918df6394c740085ffe11fc043e88d0fec8c1fd492b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56a950961dd5e9db6ab8a0f0f05b851b12b720161242f7106884afbf40c5af1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ba5dbc75e7c13a721bacdec8f71e239e8280d45612ebda32fcc2f577ad7c6228", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ceb556a184ace68d4c364694bc5befae02b8f00a9c23ef64cc033fe419614b57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac29c75b5f2d1bc376eee8605f1558d5d2e4a7898c82171e88545feca5eaa7a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3d56ac096c2ec9337ac727297e726a975e2b186ab97eb14dd3b714ead3382fcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4b86e58799dbb953a6173f9d5df01c39c9183188f74494fbcdafd78f7d16fbe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ea69fe44bfac61674e6866fc00ee06b70e0ed423a6faf19a3d2eb1965fed853c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1072a95735a18956761f4ce44b3ff6a0067f75f272daed0b5bb582dd223400e9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "316e340614bcc1ee4233263634b85b8de3160aaadd2e25726eff86b4aae6031a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4b51447841eb462b312dbaff6e11ba8406b07cc81f8efe92924e47364c0fb4fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "77e21af78bece3d34276237b0095e7998861fc7130cc80b995ce7d50353f0a60", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12a534545dfe8517f5f35a3416521c973fa0d859cfa40dbac0669d60c7c7dc63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-original.ppm", + "sha256": "27748411c905ecb51b413582b2a6eafc587ca774a1b89dd55100a05981f9ce56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "935f8bbaa2815d02ca77e1d222d21bddc09cc3dfd510ed5507c4eb27c0ed2b99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2c66b6874c47e5fd2dafb1ab9d9b87067dd7e46e2778c9a02f7617c181cc8473", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4f82a853ef7f8b3aaa1a359332aa53f05bfb52a63657aab4110815f81ef510d8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "acaadaa9ade781b07308d01fb953e2e60773d35cec3381a78c171c4a78ae6702", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75d3e8bf210b11e36cb1b4cf5f74f30cea322598d210963fcde115140378cf88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "12ea419d4824f5009acc727dfc85699e889b4e06e8c5aa35578891d4d9f81fc2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e755de57acddc93bb716d6a4b665019eedd609c5f3a59a3bc7aabbf9e7b51203", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "deeb6d253fe4efb60698e2c17b04b54dc50542926ef1cde457deb39c85f564fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0f51e854b6b03b245bd190c787e9de204993906fbdcf20a0761d586cb67e4cbd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c111f88fefcb3ce81b4b8f4481111293f9679851f40e19102278f886bdd07f21", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6305433d67b224f608635195c77d18809ad0c00a1893efb5598852e477a34a7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ef5d6f078b7aa9e858629865d9f5497fecbf1b8a5fdcd908844e45877eaf40c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5c9f8ca3e9ac2f49e0922ba8d308331b2ddcef253924dc86c468cb1477371721", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "57ccebc2a2409df1dfc9d9c78fc23950ad31a4e223e0bed57ff5f723159b76ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5d7734f7e7a6b7c25416ec4c6ba51447a7d7ced46886ef4d47bafa49bcfcad53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85697cabd91fe979f6b44429c83e4caa3052f2ced9d9c82837531bd68d11fa88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7e3efe1b2659646f933f632338787ff0bad46dfbecc573f8db258d383edec032", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7c21ace6e1701014de3ab95674736b3d4a3883f51edd15cc1b034a273fb8109b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cea03b5bd710950f0a4ef149f9d2f7ec8c542c234c81bf7fa7a45dfa128ff997", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d94829dc36a046a7112f7aea8626c582cbc2be7c9297411037c7f988d8a249", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "90dcccc15fecf7efbf56eea2ddc31d80b6696a1ba7c73bc57b08ce9d06e189a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8ec111d8aa7631f0bb6bbd354ff80df4684920297cc665f0dc887df5c8118123", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e01305134e4f4c9631cdd134e44ec2a8e716527ea86a73a3e434a63261460311", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "739d057c7381f3fe07e4fc22a43f09e0cf80e0bb25981242408b46a5635217b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c381eff884cc01744e69c8db42c1a5aba56dbf20225fd98eb92e437041ceceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ece3d9f78ffa10dc14b795700a41cebc30932e1e4c570038e3b1c917c43562", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f2a41c469ddfe5972e08e0c6f09acc4204e2e93a0f0645406591686967892596", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bcd76dfa305e7540d343aae8ecc2598b5f073f6fd260cd2e6a6d9fca18016150", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f50487375fcf946268136e5ff9e625f1474366792edec5a8a13ea49c1a530408", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a7ccea589e8dd6f3cba31f3aa5f1d5f77bb3029bc0286f2ecbb336349092ad10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f127a50306a634c12dbd18a36e4407a0a4dc5d56a8e2269858b4475a8c8590", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a5438499352ee5f30f919f08517a054a5e7d818ee07260aacec14adde18a765", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c8af1ab49929b1f36db885ffc5d3f2f99cb2a47526ddf56ff4bcf8473fad607", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "651998a2fce220108396b8910e0ea10681c997dc25abbdc0f0f6656b283317f3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "139968d1e25c6af2067fd62ced01a0ca93f0df02ab686422c45b7e5f682f150b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "60b5aa372b038498eb1838b1a1acfe1aa835ee9f57658b74026d66c0df588895", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f81973afc08692f1c241ac6103efb90f3455d2794726164f5e0a2227258e899d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ef2cc83858f43c5c57ca0734c62e1ef3a9f409bdaa646313e1c125d94caef1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a073c510f4338a77c9d27f197766de62298dc06447aa3d1328eb47a5a2baea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "56630435871566b9f3584d53e0b35dc0ce4c5562e4d57a8ecc56aa802a3612ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2f8b3129470d47676376ba5af87c57841c19f886ad34655320a8557877a8fce6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1cdac0a8da58aacc95ba1dba8b08f4ea05709ed42486891762e982885497ee31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d3c3e919b2334cc9f1deed0399f2b33f6875db35c50e81ad30bdec60618f0fe4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f1510be6ac21152bdf66eea74a787f634dfb9d0e3867017ae7684ef837dcd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10460/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "f9ee03e0653f7884ffc8ce8efad0f229e9c7ced6ae5c4fc0b9de130913b8afdc" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace-job.json", + "sha256": "b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.678581+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "1046e": { @@ -177855,7 +183833,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1046e", "family_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -177869,36 +183847,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "51f65619499d20f54fa9493635b9ec57ce6bc0bdc9dcffe527495be3e8a7b6ab", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.647995+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10461", - "10463", - "10464", - "10465", - "10466", - "1046a", - "1046b", - "1046c", - "1046d" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "e6fcbe38ceff45160d84841405e8363db4a15fdb4cd462cd46ebfdd65016fbab", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.796043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 6a639187edfd3fc8bd3fbee44c0aa5281f89016932da8b50951c3c3d036fe8f1", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10460-original.ppm", + "sha256": "898b3c1a6fdbd1d6bab7291ea1543b5e5615e13f11d93604a56a89dcf35b7648", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8ccea87926d7ef3505c568f6737b4ff851fbb9bbec30ded88b9770c828aa751f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "02c28841546da2fde0753a1ebbc6e4e2b3e856c18a293ba47aca28fec8a74f29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "764632e5b9e3adc93dfa7504f894d585ce7a5938469c965720ae7f5b4eaac314", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "824525dd48f88085b24a76dfd6cc3d4432047ba7a259db40219be93331992691", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26cc194328aef2dafd75e1190bda8278a41876bf152f58c9207c3a9b760d32e6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "546b47110af067d026f8670639bd4b3bf3923653fde79af6afc003d236bfd9db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0bf6f6989d65d892f5984135190af10e167d132f47cff0236397bd66bfdd8907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "15f6ec7f8ab75cedec0fd4be7298804772cd4d1e9991363ae5ef0c268fa5b4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a71a3f345b92174973fb61369574b658584f31ac3b6b18fae2821506c990f450", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f45ba5f1464339e5268cbd2b175c22cd272c6f2bf43951c59277d09c2f9494bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "636c8fe8568c3992921fb8102da33993531f9f45dd791f9a07e24654798223b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "597fd8c9cfdc20ad5c8c6735cba7543bebe0613faca382d4cc92a1aaa84d2eb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cb51b539f24dedc959b46ea4fcfa1de9b8d9e77580944432c16b955147031a1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6b7fa69282aec6b173caa39ab883a6f091b2ab8cc029b94eea5e97144551fcbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9f396545b1928abfe8ac606ebda3f58ee0f17c99633f1fae4b2d85fea2206dd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85d1b4b05bf45fe304b1ccb661038af6ffa27774aa31c22446f715cc2b42e40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5f16a8fbfe6fec61b1cc9756b51f05d460b5366275d0cd35d47d58c6909f08f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8d407588964c73e6639940e634e74d0e6e289fc292631dd16ba70289715a0df9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e6aac54d2a1ff7e61f6496cb5aaf07f63b4fb99442d828368f34af3e239528a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b33e48c44028411ea2d5a1b558f5bd4e105c4377ab78226feb3923783d01a033", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "421f2cd698da4d58e2d8b1176bc0bdfe273c8f13d50c82d0d8d7dca972bfe544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "75d6426d1d07032e87e70918df6394c740085ffe11fc043e88d0fec8c1fd492b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56a950961dd5e9db6ab8a0f0f05b851b12b720161242f7106884afbf40c5af1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ba5dbc75e7c13a721bacdec8f71e239e8280d45612ebda32fcc2f577ad7c6228", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ceb556a184ace68d4c364694bc5befae02b8f00a9c23ef64cc033fe419614b57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac29c75b5f2d1bc376eee8605f1558d5d2e4a7898c82171e88545feca5eaa7a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3d56ac096c2ec9337ac727297e726a975e2b186ab97eb14dd3b714ead3382fcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4b86e58799dbb953a6173f9d5df01c39c9183188f74494fbcdafd78f7d16fbe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ea69fe44bfac61674e6866fc00ee06b70e0ed423a6faf19a3d2eb1965fed853c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1072a95735a18956761f4ce44b3ff6a0067f75f272daed0b5bb582dd223400e9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "316e340614bcc1ee4233263634b85b8de3160aaadd2e25726eff86b4aae6031a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4b51447841eb462b312dbaff6e11ba8406b07cc81f8efe92924e47364c0fb4fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "77e21af78bece3d34276237b0095e7998861fc7130cc80b995ce7d50353f0a60", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12a534545dfe8517f5f35a3416521c973fa0d859cfa40dbac0669d60c7c7dc63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-original.ppm", + "sha256": "27748411c905ecb51b413582b2a6eafc587ca774a1b89dd55100a05981f9ce56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "935f8bbaa2815d02ca77e1d222d21bddc09cc3dfd510ed5507c4eb27c0ed2b99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2c66b6874c47e5fd2dafb1ab9d9b87067dd7e46e2778c9a02f7617c181cc8473", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4f82a853ef7f8b3aaa1a359332aa53f05bfb52a63657aab4110815f81ef510d8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "acaadaa9ade781b07308d01fb953e2e60773d35cec3381a78c171c4a78ae6702", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75d3e8bf210b11e36cb1b4cf5f74f30cea322598d210963fcde115140378cf88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "12ea419d4824f5009acc727dfc85699e889b4e06e8c5aa35578891d4d9f81fc2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e755de57acddc93bb716d6a4b665019eedd609c5f3a59a3bc7aabbf9e7b51203", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "deeb6d253fe4efb60698e2c17b04b54dc50542926ef1cde457deb39c85f564fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0f51e854b6b03b245bd190c787e9de204993906fbdcf20a0761d586cb67e4cbd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c111f88fefcb3ce81b4b8f4481111293f9679851f40e19102278f886bdd07f21", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6305433d67b224f608635195c77d18809ad0c00a1893efb5598852e477a34a7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ef5d6f078b7aa9e858629865d9f5497fecbf1b8a5fdcd908844e45877eaf40c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5c9f8ca3e9ac2f49e0922ba8d308331b2ddcef253924dc86c468cb1477371721", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "57ccebc2a2409df1dfc9d9c78fc23950ad31a4e223e0bed57ff5f723159b76ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5d7734f7e7a6b7c25416ec4c6ba51447a7d7ced46886ef4d47bafa49bcfcad53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85697cabd91fe979f6b44429c83e4caa3052f2ced9d9c82837531bd68d11fa88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7e3efe1b2659646f933f632338787ff0bad46dfbecc573f8db258d383edec032", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7c21ace6e1701014de3ab95674736b3d4a3883f51edd15cc1b034a273fb8109b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cea03b5bd710950f0a4ef149f9d2f7ec8c542c234c81bf7fa7a45dfa128ff997", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d94829dc36a046a7112f7aea8626c582cbc2be7c9297411037c7f988d8a249", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "90dcccc15fecf7efbf56eea2ddc31d80b6696a1ba7c73bc57b08ce9d06e189a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8ec111d8aa7631f0bb6bbd354ff80df4684920297cc665f0dc887df5c8118123", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e01305134e4f4c9631cdd134e44ec2a8e716527ea86a73a3e434a63261460311", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "739d057c7381f3fe07e4fc22a43f09e0cf80e0bb25981242408b46a5635217b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c381eff884cc01744e69c8db42c1a5aba56dbf20225fd98eb92e437041ceceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ece3d9f78ffa10dc14b795700a41cebc30932e1e4c570038e3b1c917c43562", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f2a41c469ddfe5972e08e0c6f09acc4204e2e93a0f0645406591686967892596", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bcd76dfa305e7540d343aae8ecc2598b5f073f6fd260cd2e6a6d9fca18016150", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f50487375fcf946268136e5ff9e625f1474366792edec5a8a13ea49c1a530408", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a7ccea589e8dd6f3cba31f3aa5f1d5f77bb3029bc0286f2ecbb336349092ad10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f127a50306a634c12dbd18a36e4407a0a4dc5d56a8e2269858b4475a8c8590", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a5438499352ee5f30f919f08517a054a5e7d818ee07260aacec14adde18a765", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c8af1ab49929b1f36db885ffc5d3f2f99cb2a47526ddf56ff4bcf8473fad607", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "651998a2fce220108396b8910e0ea10681c997dc25abbdc0f0f6656b283317f3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "139968d1e25c6af2067fd62ced01a0ca93f0df02ab686422c45b7e5f682f150b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "60b5aa372b038498eb1838b1a1acfe1aa835ee9f57658b74026d66c0df588895", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f81973afc08692f1c241ac6103efb90f3455d2794726164f5e0a2227258e899d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ef2cc83858f43c5c57ca0734c62e1ef3a9f409bdaa646313e1c125d94caef1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a073c510f4338a77c9d27f197766de62298dc06447aa3d1328eb47a5a2baea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "56630435871566b9f3584d53e0b35dc0ce4c5562e4d57a8ecc56aa802a3612ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2f8b3129470d47676376ba5af87c57841c19f886ad34655320a8557877a8fce6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1cdac0a8da58aacc95ba1dba8b08f4ea05709ed42486891762e982885497ee31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d3c3e919b2334cc9f1deed0399f2b33f6875db35c50e81ad30bdec60618f0fe4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f1510be6ac21152bdf66eea74a787f634dfb9d0e3867017ae7684ef837dcd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10460/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "f9ee03e0653f7884ffc8ce8efad0f229e9c7ced6ae5c4fc0b9de130913b8afdc" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace-job.json", + "sha256": "b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.678581+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "1046f": { @@ -177920,7 +184325,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1046f", "family_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -177934,36 +184339,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "51f65619499d20f54fa9493635b9ec57ce6bc0bdc9dcffe527495be3e8a7b6ab", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.647995+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10461", - "10463", - "10464", - "10465", - "10466", - "1046a", - "1046b", - "1046c", - "1046d" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "e6fcbe38ceff45160d84841405e8363db4a15fdb4cd462cd46ebfdd65016fbab", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.796043+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 6a639187edfd3fc8bd3fbee44c0aa5281f89016932da8b50951c3c3d036fe8f1", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10460-original.ppm", + "sha256": "898b3c1a6fdbd1d6bab7291ea1543b5e5615e13f11d93604a56a89dcf35b7648", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8ccea87926d7ef3505c568f6737b4ff851fbb9bbec30ded88b9770c828aa751f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "02c28841546da2fde0753a1ebbc6e4e2b3e856c18a293ba47aca28fec8a74f29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "764632e5b9e3adc93dfa7504f894d585ce7a5938469c965720ae7f5b4eaac314", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10460-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "824525dd48f88085b24a76dfd6cc3d4432047ba7a259db40219be93331992691", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10460-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26cc194328aef2dafd75e1190bda8278a41876bf152f58c9207c3a9b760d32e6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "546b47110af067d026f8670639bd4b3bf3923653fde79af6afc003d236bfd9db", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0bf6f6989d65d892f5984135190af10e167d132f47cff0236397bd66bfdd8907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "15f6ec7f8ab75cedec0fd4be7298804772cd4d1e9991363ae5ef0c268fa5b4ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10461-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a71a3f345b92174973fb61369574b658584f31ac3b6b18fae2821506c990f450", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10461-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f45ba5f1464339e5268cbd2b175c22cd272c6f2bf43951c59277d09c2f9494bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "636c8fe8568c3992921fb8102da33993531f9f45dd791f9a07e24654798223b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "597fd8c9cfdc20ad5c8c6735cba7543bebe0613faca382d4cc92a1aaa84d2eb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cb51b539f24dedc959b46ea4fcfa1de9b8d9e77580944432c16b955147031a1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10462-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6b7fa69282aec6b173caa39ab883a6f091b2ab8cc029b94eea5e97144551fcbb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10462-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9f396545b1928abfe8ac606ebda3f58ee0f17c99633f1fae4b2d85fea2206dd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85d1b4b05bf45fe304b1ccb661038af6ffa27774aa31c22446f715cc2b42e40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5f16a8fbfe6fec61b1cc9756b51f05d460b5366275d0cd35d47d58c6909f08f5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8d407588964c73e6639940e634e74d0e6e289fc292631dd16ba70289715a0df9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10463-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e6aac54d2a1ff7e61f6496cb5aaf07f63b4fb99442d828368f34af3e239528a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10463-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b33e48c44028411ea2d5a1b558f5bd4e105c4377ab78226feb3923783d01a033", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "421f2cd698da4d58e2d8b1176bc0bdfe273c8f13d50c82d0d8d7dca972bfe544", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "75d6426d1d07032e87e70918df6394c740085ffe11fc043e88d0fec8c1fd492b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56a950961dd5e9db6ab8a0f0f05b851b12b720161242f7106884afbf40c5af1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10464-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ba5dbc75e7c13a721bacdec8f71e239e8280d45612ebda32fcc2f577ad7c6228", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10464-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ceb556a184ace68d4c364694bc5befae02b8f00a9c23ef64cc033fe419614b57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac29c75b5f2d1bc376eee8605f1558d5d2e4a7898c82171e88545feca5eaa7a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "3d56ac096c2ec9337ac727297e726a975e2b186ab97eb14dd3b714ead3382fcf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4b86e58799dbb953a6173f9d5df01c39c9183188f74494fbcdafd78f7d16fbe7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10465-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ea69fe44bfac61674e6866fc00ee06b70e0ed423a6faf19a3d2eb1965fed853c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10465-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-original.ppm", + "sha256": "1072a95735a18956761f4ce44b3ff6a0067f75f272daed0b5bb582dd223400e9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "316e340614bcc1ee4233263634b85b8de3160aaadd2e25726eff86b4aae6031a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4b51447841eb462b312dbaff6e11ba8406b07cc81f8efe92924e47364c0fb4fc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "77e21af78bece3d34276237b0095e7998861fc7130cc80b995ce7d50353f0a60", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10466-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12a534545dfe8517f5f35a3416521c973fa0d859cfa40dbac0669d60c7c7dc63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10466-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-original.ppm", + "sha256": "27748411c905ecb51b413582b2a6eafc587ca774a1b89dd55100a05981f9ce56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "935f8bbaa2815d02ca77e1d222d21bddc09cc3dfd510ed5507c4eb27c0ed2b99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2c66b6874c47e5fd2dafb1ab9d9b87067dd7e46e2778c9a02f7617c181cc8473", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4f82a853ef7f8b3aaa1a359332aa53f05bfb52a63657aab4110815f81ef510d8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10467-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "acaadaa9ade781b07308d01fb953e2e60773d35cec3381a78c171c4a78ae6702", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10467-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-original.ppm", + "sha256": "75d3e8bf210b11e36cb1b4cf5f74f30cea322598d210963fcde115140378cf88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "12ea419d4824f5009acc727dfc85699e889b4e06e8c5aa35578891d4d9f81fc2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e755de57acddc93bb716d6a4b665019eedd609c5f3a59a3bc7aabbf9e7b51203", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "deeb6d253fe4efb60698e2c17b04b54dc50542926ef1cde457deb39c85f564fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10468-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0f51e854b6b03b245bd190c787e9de204993906fbdcf20a0761d586cb67e4cbd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10468-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c111f88fefcb3ce81b4b8f4481111293f9679851f40e19102278f886bdd07f21", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6305433d67b224f608635195c77d18809ad0c00a1893efb5598852e477a34a7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ef5d6f078b7aa9e858629865d9f5497fecbf1b8a5fdcd908844e45877eaf40c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5c9f8ca3e9ac2f49e0922ba8d308331b2ddcef253924dc86c468cb1477371721", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10469-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "57ccebc2a2409df1dfc9d9c78fc23950ad31a4e223e0bed57ff5f723159b76ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/10469-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5d7734f7e7a6b7c25416ec4c6ba51447a7d7ced46886ef4d47bafa49bcfcad53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85697cabd91fe979f6b44429c83e4caa3052f2ced9d9c82837531bd68d11fa88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7e3efe1b2659646f933f632338787ff0bad46dfbecc573f8db258d383edec032", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7c21ace6e1701014de3ab95674736b3d4a3883f51edd15cc1b034a273fb8109b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "cea03b5bd710950f0a4ef149f9d2f7ec8c542c234c81bf7fa7a45dfa128ff997", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c6d94829dc36a046a7112f7aea8626c582cbc2be7c9297411037c7f988d8a249", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "90dcccc15fecf7efbf56eea2ddc31d80b6696a1ba7c73bc57b08ce9d06e189a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8ec111d8aa7631f0bb6bbd354ff80df4684920297cc665f0dc887df5c8118123", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e01305134e4f4c9631cdd134e44ec2a8e716527ea86a73a3e434a63261460311", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "739d057c7381f3fe07e4fc22a43f09e0cf80e0bb25981242408b46a5635217b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8c381eff884cc01744e69c8db42c1a5aba56dbf20225fd98eb92e437041ceceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a0ece3d9f78ffa10dc14b795700a41cebc30932e1e4c570038e3b1c917c43562", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f2a41c469ddfe5972e08e0c6f09acc4204e2e93a0f0645406591686967892596", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bcd76dfa305e7540d343aae8ecc2598b5f073f6fd260cd2e6a6d9fca18016150", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f50487375fcf946268136e5ff9e625f1474366792edec5a8a13ea49c1a530408", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a7ccea589e8dd6f3cba31f3aa5f1d5f77bb3029bc0286f2ecbb336349092ad10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f127a50306a634c12dbd18a36e4407a0a4dc5d56a8e2269858b4475a8c8590", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a5438499352ee5f30f919f08517a054a5e7d818ee07260aacec14adde18a765", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4c8af1ab49929b1f36db885ffc5d3f2f99cb2a47526ddf56ff4bcf8473fad607", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "651998a2fce220108396b8910e0ea10681c997dc25abbdc0f0f6656b283317f3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "139968d1e25c6af2067fd62ced01a0ca93f0df02ab686422c45b7e5f682f150b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "60b5aa372b038498eb1838b1a1acfe1aa835ee9f57658b74026d66c0df588895", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f81973afc08692f1c241ac6103efb90f3455d2794726164f5e0a2227258e899d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "8ef2cc83858f43c5c57ca0734c62e1ef3a9f409bdaa646313e1c125d94caef1d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "27a073c510f4338a77c9d27f197766de62298dc06447aa3d1328eb47a5a2baea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "56630435871566b9f3584d53e0b35dc0ce4c5562e4d57a8ecc56aa802a3612ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2f8b3129470d47676376ba5af87c57841c19f886ad34655320a8557877a8fce6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1cdac0a8da58aacc95ba1dba8b08f4ea05709ed42486891762e982885497ee31", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d3c3e919b2334cc9f1deed0399f2b33f6875db35c50e81ad30bdec60618f0fe4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1046f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8f1510be6ac21152bdf66eea74a787f634dfb9d0e3867017ae7684ef837dcd5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10460-material-v2/runtime/1046f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10460/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "f9ee03e0653f7884ffc8ce8efad0f229e9c7ced6ae5c4fc0b9de130913b8afdc" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "c0a3242a15f26fe701bd2f1dbcab26295ffbe904bc2fa178bbc5eba40ba75ef1" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace-job.json", + "sha256": "b7041a7ea22acc7f9aaeec1cbcaeb3e8e359730d7fb33b25149d347a829aaace" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.678581+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10460-1046f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10460-1046f/d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794-candidate.json", + "sha256": "d192fd663d1dfef05c9d0826de363ccc70703238d3d10cec3ce844d535efa794" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10460-1046f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f4d3f0520348ad1c37e45c3a57768c64413c75cb50cc475953619a3c0a404960" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "10470": { @@ -177985,7 +184817,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10470", "family_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -177999,32 +184831,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "8538bd43d98378c55e248f4f4d2248ceb1e9fbc59d1e510c5bc6326573cba810", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.649797+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10474", - "10476", - "10477", - "10479", - "1047a" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2602d2ad68e08a4045538f0919d254ecef5d5117a8210a3b8dbc508e27538e43", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:51.075701+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 c38a62fb477a711ae579489c1478b8f1afe5fadf8474a153546f5085c4e5ee9f", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10470-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bd625546c17e03e98838a125657d09eacc81daa7b549e3efcf68586d8f1194a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "20bc1c132fda81b41c0d8b31480ff68a12030d112ac919d1ee889cdaba6ea806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1e405278eb144f3f3d653ef8f9a4db13aa189d8dfef55a92971ecb3d82b282a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0dece6615c9a8d8b2e7020a7e6f91f39ebd8dd530948699615d074cbfe43266d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9839f8f1e27a0ff5124e7440e5f680cf734a7d71b7901914c1839cc3c46b65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9abd07f393655c3a1e6549d7caa556cb57c6177b827d0371cf2810bff655430a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2034a1bcc4de1123dcc0360510150e655c4bc0e0a669b16e618d92c8a1fa62ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4af1e4375d607d0587f1db44f724cf924079189f35bd926504e21dd773e6de84", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "096ec1689828fbaaff0397b6c032747ab7320ec3fc5d7afef687effdf1a25dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0919cd59b0a1bd4a0152e02dd40542af639d7850b3c8bf9b7b87ccdc03d770c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-original.ppm", + "sha256": "334f2bc0dc3a27d7076e90190e72710e7cdb24791a1eb577a24c1971c15945f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bb6fb8b793c4b5157957040ed29dceb3748ce4c74fb3307f0c1a3f16fb3072a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b630f5d34fa1bcc3bf848ef8c7bef453e177d43656fdb75ac3ff2cb93d9b499e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "485032866f5d6e8d6f6ceafbe2a5f6ad3a34aa67bddafe93397a8758a807e651", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "24cf3b3210de0257ceb7a9cec5874514d4daf1dce28aa4ae0eadc75c8b1dc94b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6b31d0c586f1f3fc418e58460984b97954239c85c3912f1486221c9cb78892a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a961c58cb6bd7a880cf9f1775d5a24c2695a1ccdbea647b0dbd6f4c07d1cb78f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d415bf900ebff6f7a7af34b0de2f017b3fa9d3a40fa1f2b4ea2d5550d6be51f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ecdea058c1e8471850defc02e296fc32641cb8f088846b27c7ca694666c9672f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e1095c48a16d0e7481edaf8fbedd1443ad5151d60b8447ed06a6dcc56e999a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-original.ppm", + "sha256": "64214d0fb30168d098dce502c30b1481827439ba4a12ac33c36d2969ae4f9cd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b63aa408a9dc740fd32ca4224a7affe26b71d47ed05df5d761a8426ac18172f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9aa2417cfa39e82db3c868b9a220adf16167fabc2326fe2ecbcda43b8809e2df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cd72651ff813d84b0e75ba66e36369c337817736bf42a49605ebd888d53a8462", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e56ac217b8a215f5c2b87e15104bc8cde3c2bdf613b5289c31860b5c4e1cb227", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05909a594988a6f74f8e0702c6869d0a02d048ddad9f8f272342319e0f9f1d5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2b1e3df24742e69f757554ed3c1d40962c0a76e485c54d0490afe4f621310ac6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e999ce4d31407ce10a5dd5a68a942afd8f741ac5032cf54a247506bcdb427005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5131e4908efbe1b47f0afd25a47bebfeff017e82f72c936e12fce03e75f0374e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e984aa369db6628cbcd912d27b23404131f9eb709b35fb7cded6644e8436302d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-original.ppm", + "sha256": "175210f0e0f8f4f12e52e6499964f921a6f78eb1b5e9d8babbe7552bfb1a5cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4672b70ea6ed108a16a13323e59088065413036142910239b409e532e324bea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9b5e01b8e84118e1facb7e6fbfd0f86fa8d94dbeab484a8db9e6d6534224db3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "909996c4446ec4595dd198d0fdc8f9417066cb72764933d87c1eadce4f4c786e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ed1508b9a886f776ef5cd472b60624c85f4f61fa1a1068977335525b963257b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7deecc5150ee6e6546df8c7b459d3a2de97afc3c0d26302b0daeaed767dccb2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7f4fc524342dba04c5768162dfb438c2dbe1fab5c8046e68c3c6e9b2fb3df6c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acd3d077b4a5693673ed730aef43684eebca298e6a68c6c4520c64430eaaceb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "91f02513747527b8601f2daf7bec364b081d576d74b73d07fb88097cebca1781", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "116797ac4574103c8397cd8e62484ee797cbca4fc9f5df621be219dcf071c9bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6c1de18299c04cb685160345d40628ff0419e700e7e442fc313167d7cb04a995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bff5413151f8d435e9ba967964998577b0b5f968a03884ce7ea26ce83b9a8060", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "315e7df7dd072a2652747d825ad15aedb8bbedd41c70291f534ceb99a8087b0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6a2aa7c38dc9c25b6e431f10b8e8a759ff7f0fb3d306d7f36d6e5c7aa304fd88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b911113afefb1055e916b2bd51fe1010aeca8c18c0b47064dfe5aa6182c025", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c5bff6a3448fdfc8693d0eb9fd87b34864ecbaee9bcf69ea33e642eaa8dda5f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5237519282cf98bc9aa180a99d449d8042dc9c8ae8538055bcaecacf6f4f55c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "880bd7dacf659719329b93f0cd2618c5a3934cc016d346706af45d55cc4bd97d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "62a3aa099d63717345d62d4658a93b3f53977792dac07740ad30e0e6dfe18264", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "16eede0f48eb3b6c02f2eb36a153812165dd414e85c49af884306402c182d7c6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d2fef3ea65b658e9058ccf8c48d5eea2543685a8acaf8bfc75e0ea5977973287", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0a817f9a2ace8d3dbb7593b5881e8db39e13d57b86ca7f5d04753bda4f791c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8daf0b00f06a97b439b9d6b7681b323f87b61f7e3be8cb16fc79fc3874cdb2a3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3d40f4364a93ea0e190766527d2f2beed1b232d7699642da0797bf2673b151de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "58aa2a4eb56cffc655954900066d6e726f2beb136e8fd33d14fe1c492b758da6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c364869538cf858d60171bcd5e55c4b64a39073585309425b7c61e78f2b0d38a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e828b91490e6657ae11201a7156d0cec8994987112a5cd7bb8d923ca239a481c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bbae96ec0b7e41c83592b7de4f2ab81cb31b37c803da239d4f3f679d07a37a24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "87c6619f0bb38a0458f96762b9e5aa18e85220dbf829752a129d7d5b1de8eee1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "92e40c4e8704c0a7604709b5b5fe4a8dd3b89ce11448e7e794ea522592d2a63f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "71b605246a09e679b8db2fa18d9ce3112b41e914fbd78d59aebfb1b21b1b3481", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0e5ef1d99d10bcafefce408b3fde6de259ffb1e0025894782de617247543efc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b30120203184a2ac8d7837d4d0ec7c6827c47fa85587bd55a2093eea326e5626", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5daa0ceba44cc1bed48feb4a2503b7dabf9cc7da37061ce18672f8f0d585c1a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3c12481dc1fb93f96df4c408aff753fb66d9a1b019bd76e9b4c39e9ba5673984", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fcc854c50e172cad85c37169048cfe2f2ccaec7d521bb27e62582d42f47c208b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1d2fe02669628fd79ce7feb1800816c630176b96ba6c6921614192bd4c1d217", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "41afe953c64acb133b1b5614015c331b27fe0f572d8d62f00a177d7eb3ccced5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1f7acbe8907c2b74c903bf8b3c527c22c8211e235cc2358a5a200814d2510a1e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12155709716dd82a436b99f7ed1209344bbaca4a3660f32496cc71b74de8d9da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90616d486ffc3487f3aaedfd3bc88573f58fc177da93ad57e1a59210cc2359b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df4ce446eef081aed7ab58bcb243434772e24895a39101a7dcd4cde5e0ca439", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "31b88339313d690b7859435f8701bfd55acacaff96376521768c6f17c856d855", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "79c1336474463a8bcc98504e08c6ceb4fc8e736eaa48e2cf29c3b7c5d8397f11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0da0a1a0c9d9e7dc1cda86c0d333a95f2812adcc7c738256d0d1750104f4b6f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e36c886ed1d7156301b095ad31f5b0723f25ba385a584e4f474f672a1a01f4c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "01d58dc50ca5f902bb7429112cb2a2b751fdfab6a04f0c5ffec21a3009393b7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6dd907b35448520581b950ef443b8fb487bc9867aa9bf283a517ce9a5790086", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74ba48327ac2590614cca2a91ba3495dab606495bbed46faacb23799ef5fa485", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c54b5d64ffd54d208767dbf2daeb16c0364e6bea2ddd32d0f3bcdb27e7065c51", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10470/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "797008b0b4dcbb1d21ee3b1592a68e52d3ea21a6ce70fa1f4f20c5f69745b18e" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17-job.json", + "sha256": "f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.962358+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "10471": { @@ -178046,7 +185309,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10471", "family_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -178060,32 +185323,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "8538bd43d98378c55e248f4f4d2248ceb1e9fbc59d1e510c5bc6326573cba810", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.649797+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10474", - "10476", - "10477", - "10479", - "1047a" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2602d2ad68e08a4045538f0919d254ecef5d5117a8210a3b8dbc508e27538e43", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:51.075701+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 c38a62fb477a711ae579489c1478b8f1afe5fadf8474a153546f5085c4e5ee9f", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10470-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bd625546c17e03e98838a125657d09eacc81daa7b549e3efcf68586d8f1194a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "20bc1c132fda81b41c0d8b31480ff68a12030d112ac919d1ee889cdaba6ea806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1e405278eb144f3f3d653ef8f9a4db13aa189d8dfef55a92971ecb3d82b282a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0dece6615c9a8d8b2e7020a7e6f91f39ebd8dd530948699615d074cbfe43266d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9839f8f1e27a0ff5124e7440e5f680cf734a7d71b7901914c1839cc3c46b65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9abd07f393655c3a1e6549d7caa556cb57c6177b827d0371cf2810bff655430a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2034a1bcc4de1123dcc0360510150e655c4bc0e0a669b16e618d92c8a1fa62ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4af1e4375d607d0587f1db44f724cf924079189f35bd926504e21dd773e6de84", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "096ec1689828fbaaff0397b6c032747ab7320ec3fc5d7afef687effdf1a25dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0919cd59b0a1bd4a0152e02dd40542af639d7850b3c8bf9b7b87ccdc03d770c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-original.ppm", + "sha256": "334f2bc0dc3a27d7076e90190e72710e7cdb24791a1eb577a24c1971c15945f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bb6fb8b793c4b5157957040ed29dceb3748ce4c74fb3307f0c1a3f16fb3072a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b630f5d34fa1bcc3bf848ef8c7bef453e177d43656fdb75ac3ff2cb93d9b499e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "485032866f5d6e8d6f6ceafbe2a5f6ad3a34aa67bddafe93397a8758a807e651", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "24cf3b3210de0257ceb7a9cec5874514d4daf1dce28aa4ae0eadc75c8b1dc94b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6b31d0c586f1f3fc418e58460984b97954239c85c3912f1486221c9cb78892a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a961c58cb6bd7a880cf9f1775d5a24c2695a1ccdbea647b0dbd6f4c07d1cb78f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d415bf900ebff6f7a7af34b0de2f017b3fa9d3a40fa1f2b4ea2d5550d6be51f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ecdea058c1e8471850defc02e296fc32641cb8f088846b27c7ca694666c9672f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e1095c48a16d0e7481edaf8fbedd1443ad5151d60b8447ed06a6dcc56e999a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-original.ppm", + "sha256": "64214d0fb30168d098dce502c30b1481827439ba4a12ac33c36d2969ae4f9cd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b63aa408a9dc740fd32ca4224a7affe26b71d47ed05df5d761a8426ac18172f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9aa2417cfa39e82db3c868b9a220adf16167fabc2326fe2ecbcda43b8809e2df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cd72651ff813d84b0e75ba66e36369c337817736bf42a49605ebd888d53a8462", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e56ac217b8a215f5c2b87e15104bc8cde3c2bdf613b5289c31860b5c4e1cb227", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05909a594988a6f74f8e0702c6869d0a02d048ddad9f8f272342319e0f9f1d5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2b1e3df24742e69f757554ed3c1d40962c0a76e485c54d0490afe4f621310ac6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e999ce4d31407ce10a5dd5a68a942afd8f741ac5032cf54a247506bcdb427005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5131e4908efbe1b47f0afd25a47bebfeff017e82f72c936e12fce03e75f0374e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e984aa369db6628cbcd912d27b23404131f9eb709b35fb7cded6644e8436302d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-original.ppm", + "sha256": "175210f0e0f8f4f12e52e6499964f921a6f78eb1b5e9d8babbe7552bfb1a5cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4672b70ea6ed108a16a13323e59088065413036142910239b409e532e324bea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9b5e01b8e84118e1facb7e6fbfd0f86fa8d94dbeab484a8db9e6d6534224db3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "909996c4446ec4595dd198d0fdc8f9417066cb72764933d87c1eadce4f4c786e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ed1508b9a886f776ef5cd472b60624c85f4f61fa1a1068977335525b963257b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7deecc5150ee6e6546df8c7b459d3a2de97afc3c0d26302b0daeaed767dccb2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7f4fc524342dba04c5768162dfb438c2dbe1fab5c8046e68c3c6e9b2fb3df6c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acd3d077b4a5693673ed730aef43684eebca298e6a68c6c4520c64430eaaceb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "91f02513747527b8601f2daf7bec364b081d576d74b73d07fb88097cebca1781", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "116797ac4574103c8397cd8e62484ee797cbca4fc9f5df621be219dcf071c9bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6c1de18299c04cb685160345d40628ff0419e700e7e442fc313167d7cb04a995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bff5413151f8d435e9ba967964998577b0b5f968a03884ce7ea26ce83b9a8060", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "315e7df7dd072a2652747d825ad15aedb8bbedd41c70291f534ceb99a8087b0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6a2aa7c38dc9c25b6e431f10b8e8a759ff7f0fb3d306d7f36d6e5c7aa304fd88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b911113afefb1055e916b2bd51fe1010aeca8c18c0b47064dfe5aa6182c025", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c5bff6a3448fdfc8693d0eb9fd87b34864ecbaee9bcf69ea33e642eaa8dda5f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5237519282cf98bc9aa180a99d449d8042dc9c8ae8538055bcaecacf6f4f55c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "880bd7dacf659719329b93f0cd2618c5a3934cc016d346706af45d55cc4bd97d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "62a3aa099d63717345d62d4658a93b3f53977792dac07740ad30e0e6dfe18264", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "16eede0f48eb3b6c02f2eb36a153812165dd414e85c49af884306402c182d7c6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d2fef3ea65b658e9058ccf8c48d5eea2543685a8acaf8bfc75e0ea5977973287", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0a817f9a2ace8d3dbb7593b5881e8db39e13d57b86ca7f5d04753bda4f791c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8daf0b00f06a97b439b9d6b7681b323f87b61f7e3be8cb16fc79fc3874cdb2a3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3d40f4364a93ea0e190766527d2f2beed1b232d7699642da0797bf2673b151de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "58aa2a4eb56cffc655954900066d6e726f2beb136e8fd33d14fe1c492b758da6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c364869538cf858d60171bcd5e55c4b64a39073585309425b7c61e78f2b0d38a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e828b91490e6657ae11201a7156d0cec8994987112a5cd7bb8d923ca239a481c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bbae96ec0b7e41c83592b7de4f2ab81cb31b37c803da239d4f3f679d07a37a24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "87c6619f0bb38a0458f96762b9e5aa18e85220dbf829752a129d7d5b1de8eee1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "92e40c4e8704c0a7604709b5b5fe4a8dd3b89ce11448e7e794ea522592d2a63f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "71b605246a09e679b8db2fa18d9ce3112b41e914fbd78d59aebfb1b21b1b3481", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0e5ef1d99d10bcafefce408b3fde6de259ffb1e0025894782de617247543efc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b30120203184a2ac8d7837d4d0ec7c6827c47fa85587bd55a2093eea326e5626", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5daa0ceba44cc1bed48feb4a2503b7dabf9cc7da37061ce18672f8f0d585c1a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3c12481dc1fb93f96df4c408aff753fb66d9a1b019bd76e9b4c39e9ba5673984", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fcc854c50e172cad85c37169048cfe2f2ccaec7d521bb27e62582d42f47c208b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1d2fe02669628fd79ce7feb1800816c630176b96ba6c6921614192bd4c1d217", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "41afe953c64acb133b1b5614015c331b27fe0f572d8d62f00a177d7eb3ccced5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1f7acbe8907c2b74c903bf8b3c527c22c8211e235cc2358a5a200814d2510a1e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12155709716dd82a436b99f7ed1209344bbaca4a3660f32496cc71b74de8d9da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90616d486ffc3487f3aaedfd3bc88573f58fc177da93ad57e1a59210cc2359b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df4ce446eef081aed7ab58bcb243434772e24895a39101a7dcd4cde5e0ca439", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "31b88339313d690b7859435f8701bfd55acacaff96376521768c6f17c856d855", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "79c1336474463a8bcc98504e08c6ceb4fc8e736eaa48e2cf29c3b7c5d8397f11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0da0a1a0c9d9e7dc1cda86c0d333a95f2812adcc7c738256d0d1750104f4b6f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e36c886ed1d7156301b095ad31f5b0723f25ba385a584e4f474f672a1a01f4c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "01d58dc50ca5f902bb7429112cb2a2b751fdfab6a04f0c5ffec21a3009393b7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6dd907b35448520581b950ef443b8fb487bc9867aa9bf283a517ce9a5790086", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74ba48327ac2590614cca2a91ba3495dab606495bbed46faacb23799ef5fa485", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c54b5d64ffd54d208767dbf2daeb16c0364e6bea2ddd32d0f3bcdb27e7065c51", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10470/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "797008b0b4dcbb1d21ee3b1592a68e52d3ea21a6ce70fa1f4f20c5f69745b18e" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17-job.json", + "sha256": "f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.962358+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "10472": { @@ -178107,7 +185801,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10472", "family_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -178121,32 +185815,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "8538bd43d98378c55e248f4f4d2248ceb1e9fbc59d1e510c5bc6326573cba810", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.649797+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10474", - "10476", - "10477", - "10479", - "1047a" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2602d2ad68e08a4045538f0919d254ecef5d5117a8210a3b8dbc508e27538e43", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:51.075701+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 c38a62fb477a711ae579489c1478b8f1afe5fadf8474a153546f5085c4e5ee9f", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10470-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bd625546c17e03e98838a125657d09eacc81daa7b549e3efcf68586d8f1194a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "20bc1c132fda81b41c0d8b31480ff68a12030d112ac919d1ee889cdaba6ea806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1e405278eb144f3f3d653ef8f9a4db13aa189d8dfef55a92971ecb3d82b282a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0dece6615c9a8d8b2e7020a7e6f91f39ebd8dd530948699615d074cbfe43266d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9839f8f1e27a0ff5124e7440e5f680cf734a7d71b7901914c1839cc3c46b65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9abd07f393655c3a1e6549d7caa556cb57c6177b827d0371cf2810bff655430a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2034a1bcc4de1123dcc0360510150e655c4bc0e0a669b16e618d92c8a1fa62ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4af1e4375d607d0587f1db44f724cf924079189f35bd926504e21dd773e6de84", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "096ec1689828fbaaff0397b6c032747ab7320ec3fc5d7afef687effdf1a25dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0919cd59b0a1bd4a0152e02dd40542af639d7850b3c8bf9b7b87ccdc03d770c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-original.ppm", + "sha256": "334f2bc0dc3a27d7076e90190e72710e7cdb24791a1eb577a24c1971c15945f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bb6fb8b793c4b5157957040ed29dceb3748ce4c74fb3307f0c1a3f16fb3072a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b630f5d34fa1bcc3bf848ef8c7bef453e177d43656fdb75ac3ff2cb93d9b499e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "485032866f5d6e8d6f6ceafbe2a5f6ad3a34aa67bddafe93397a8758a807e651", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "24cf3b3210de0257ceb7a9cec5874514d4daf1dce28aa4ae0eadc75c8b1dc94b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6b31d0c586f1f3fc418e58460984b97954239c85c3912f1486221c9cb78892a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a961c58cb6bd7a880cf9f1775d5a24c2695a1ccdbea647b0dbd6f4c07d1cb78f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d415bf900ebff6f7a7af34b0de2f017b3fa9d3a40fa1f2b4ea2d5550d6be51f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ecdea058c1e8471850defc02e296fc32641cb8f088846b27c7ca694666c9672f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e1095c48a16d0e7481edaf8fbedd1443ad5151d60b8447ed06a6dcc56e999a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-original.ppm", + "sha256": "64214d0fb30168d098dce502c30b1481827439ba4a12ac33c36d2969ae4f9cd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b63aa408a9dc740fd32ca4224a7affe26b71d47ed05df5d761a8426ac18172f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9aa2417cfa39e82db3c868b9a220adf16167fabc2326fe2ecbcda43b8809e2df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cd72651ff813d84b0e75ba66e36369c337817736bf42a49605ebd888d53a8462", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e56ac217b8a215f5c2b87e15104bc8cde3c2bdf613b5289c31860b5c4e1cb227", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05909a594988a6f74f8e0702c6869d0a02d048ddad9f8f272342319e0f9f1d5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2b1e3df24742e69f757554ed3c1d40962c0a76e485c54d0490afe4f621310ac6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e999ce4d31407ce10a5dd5a68a942afd8f741ac5032cf54a247506bcdb427005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5131e4908efbe1b47f0afd25a47bebfeff017e82f72c936e12fce03e75f0374e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e984aa369db6628cbcd912d27b23404131f9eb709b35fb7cded6644e8436302d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-original.ppm", + "sha256": "175210f0e0f8f4f12e52e6499964f921a6f78eb1b5e9d8babbe7552bfb1a5cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4672b70ea6ed108a16a13323e59088065413036142910239b409e532e324bea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9b5e01b8e84118e1facb7e6fbfd0f86fa8d94dbeab484a8db9e6d6534224db3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "909996c4446ec4595dd198d0fdc8f9417066cb72764933d87c1eadce4f4c786e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ed1508b9a886f776ef5cd472b60624c85f4f61fa1a1068977335525b963257b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7deecc5150ee6e6546df8c7b459d3a2de97afc3c0d26302b0daeaed767dccb2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7f4fc524342dba04c5768162dfb438c2dbe1fab5c8046e68c3c6e9b2fb3df6c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acd3d077b4a5693673ed730aef43684eebca298e6a68c6c4520c64430eaaceb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "91f02513747527b8601f2daf7bec364b081d576d74b73d07fb88097cebca1781", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "116797ac4574103c8397cd8e62484ee797cbca4fc9f5df621be219dcf071c9bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6c1de18299c04cb685160345d40628ff0419e700e7e442fc313167d7cb04a995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bff5413151f8d435e9ba967964998577b0b5f968a03884ce7ea26ce83b9a8060", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "315e7df7dd072a2652747d825ad15aedb8bbedd41c70291f534ceb99a8087b0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6a2aa7c38dc9c25b6e431f10b8e8a759ff7f0fb3d306d7f36d6e5c7aa304fd88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b911113afefb1055e916b2bd51fe1010aeca8c18c0b47064dfe5aa6182c025", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c5bff6a3448fdfc8693d0eb9fd87b34864ecbaee9bcf69ea33e642eaa8dda5f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5237519282cf98bc9aa180a99d449d8042dc9c8ae8538055bcaecacf6f4f55c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "880bd7dacf659719329b93f0cd2618c5a3934cc016d346706af45d55cc4bd97d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "62a3aa099d63717345d62d4658a93b3f53977792dac07740ad30e0e6dfe18264", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "16eede0f48eb3b6c02f2eb36a153812165dd414e85c49af884306402c182d7c6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d2fef3ea65b658e9058ccf8c48d5eea2543685a8acaf8bfc75e0ea5977973287", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0a817f9a2ace8d3dbb7593b5881e8db39e13d57b86ca7f5d04753bda4f791c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8daf0b00f06a97b439b9d6b7681b323f87b61f7e3be8cb16fc79fc3874cdb2a3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3d40f4364a93ea0e190766527d2f2beed1b232d7699642da0797bf2673b151de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "58aa2a4eb56cffc655954900066d6e726f2beb136e8fd33d14fe1c492b758da6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c364869538cf858d60171bcd5e55c4b64a39073585309425b7c61e78f2b0d38a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e828b91490e6657ae11201a7156d0cec8994987112a5cd7bb8d923ca239a481c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bbae96ec0b7e41c83592b7de4f2ab81cb31b37c803da239d4f3f679d07a37a24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "87c6619f0bb38a0458f96762b9e5aa18e85220dbf829752a129d7d5b1de8eee1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "92e40c4e8704c0a7604709b5b5fe4a8dd3b89ce11448e7e794ea522592d2a63f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "71b605246a09e679b8db2fa18d9ce3112b41e914fbd78d59aebfb1b21b1b3481", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0e5ef1d99d10bcafefce408b3fde6de259ffb1e0025894782de617247543efc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b30120203184a2ac8d7837d4d0ec7c6827c47fa85587bd55a2093eea326e5626", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5daa0ceba44cc1bed48feb4a2503b7dabf9cc7da37061ce18672f8f0d585c1a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3c12481dc1fb93f96df4c408aff753fb66d9a1b019bd76e9b4c39e9ba5673984", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fcc854c50e172cad85c37169048cfe2f2ccaec7d521bb27e62582d42f47c208b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1d2fe02669628fd79ce7feb1800816c630176b96ba6c6921614192bd4c1d217", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "41afe953c64acb133b1b5614015c331b27fe0f572d8d62f00a177d7eb3ccced5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1f7acbe8907c2b74c903bf8b3c527c22c8211e235cc2358a5a200814d2510a1e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12155709716dd82a436b99f7ed1209344bbaca4a3660f32496cc71b74de8d9da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90616d486ffc3487f3aaedfd3bc88573f58fc177da93ad57e1a59210cc2359b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df4ce446eef081aed7ab58bcb243434772e24895a39101a7dcd4cde5e0ca439", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "31b88339313d690b7859435f8701bfd55acacaff96376521768c6f17c856d855", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "79c1336474463a8bcc98504e08c6ceb4fc8e736eaa48e2cf29c3b7c5d8397f11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0da0a1a0c9d9e7dc1cda86c0d333a95f2812adcc7c738256d0d1750104f4b6f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e36c886ed1d7156301b095ad31f5b0723f25ba385a584e4f474f672a1a01f4c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "01d58dc50ca5f902bb7429112cb2a2b751fdfab6a04f0c5ffec21a3009393b7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6dd907b35448520581b950ef443b8fb487bc9867aa9bf283a517ce9a5790086", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74ba48327ac2590614cca2a91ba3495dab606495bbed46faacb23799ef5fa485", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c54b5d64ffd54d208767dbf2daeb16c0364e6bea2ddd32d0f3bcdb27e7065c51", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10470/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "797008b0b4dcbb1d21ee3b1592a68e52d3ea21a6ce70fa1f4f20c5f69745b18e" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17-job.json", + "sha256": "f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.962358+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "10473": { @@ -178168,7 +186293,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10473", "family_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -178182,32 +186307,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "8538bd43d98378c55e248f4f4d2248ceb1e9fbc59d1e510c5bc6326573cba810", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.649797+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10474", - "10476", - "10477", - "10479", - "1047a" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2602d2ad68e08a4045538f0919d254ecef5d5117a8210a3b8dbc508e27538e43", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:51.075701+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 c38a62fb477a711ae579489c1478b8f1afe5fadf8474a153546f5085c4e5ee9f", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10470-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bd625546c17e03e98838a125657d09eacc81daa7b549e3efcf68586d8f1194a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "20bc1c132fda81b41c0d8b31480ff68a12030d112ac919d1ee889cdaba6ea806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1e405278eb144f3f3d653ef8f9a4db13aa189d8dfef55a92971ecb3d82b282a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0dece6615c9a8d8b2e7020a7e6f91f39ebd8dd530948699615d074cbfe43266d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9839f8f1e27a0ff5124e7440e5f680cf734a7d71b7901914c1839cc3c46b65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9abd07f393655c3a1e6549d7caa556cb57c6177b827d0371cf2810bff655430a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2034a1bcc4de1123dcc0360510150e655c4bc0e0a669b16e618d92c8a1fa62ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4af1e4375d607d0587f1db44f724cf924079189f35bd926504e21dd773e6de84", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "096ec1689828fbaaff0397b6c032747ab7320ec3fc5d7afef687effdf1a25dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0919cd59b0a1bd4a0152e02dd40542af639d7850b3c8bf9b7b87ccdc03d770c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-original.ppm", + "sha256": "334f2bc0dc3a27d7076e90190e72710e7cdb24791a1eb577a24c1971c15945f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bb6fb8b793c4b5157957040ed29dceb3748ce4c74fb3307f0c1a3f16fb3072a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b630f5d34fa1bcc3bf848ef8c7bef453e177d43656fdb75ac3ff2cb93d9b499e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "485032866f5d6e8d6f6ceafbe2a5f6ad3a34aa67bddafe93397a8758a807e651", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "24cf3b3210de0257ceb7a9cec5874514d4daf1dce28aa4ae0eadc75c8b1dc94b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6b31d0c586f1f3fc418e58460984b97954239c85c3912f1486221c9cb78892a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a961c58cb6bd7a880cf9f1775d5a24c2695a1ccdbea647b0dbd6f4c07d1cb78f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d415bf900ebff6f7a7af34b0de2f017b3fa9d3a40fa1f2b4ea2d5550d6be51f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ecdea058c1e8471850defc02e296fc32641cb8f088846b27c7ca694666c9672f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e1095c48a16d0e7481edaf8fbedd1443ad5151d60b8447ed06a6dcc56e999a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-original.ppm", + "sha256": "64214d0fb30168d098dce502c30b1481827439ba4a12ac33c36d2969ae4f9cd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b63aa408a9dc740fd32ca4224a7affe26b71d47ed05df5d761a8426ac18172f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9aa2417cfa39e82db3c868b9a220adf16167fabc2326fe2ecbcda43b8809e2df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cd72651ff813d84b0e75ba66e36369c337817736bf42a49605ebd888d53a8462", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e56ac217b8a215f5c2b87e15104bc8cde3c2bdf613b5289c31860b5c4e1cb227", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05909a594988a6f74f8e0702c6869d0a02d048ddad9f8f272342319e0f9f1d5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2b1e3df24742e69f757554ed3c1d40962c0a76e485c54d0490afe4f621310ac6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e999ce4d31407ce10a5dd5a68a942afd8f741ac5032cf54a247506bcdb427005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5131e4908efbe1b47f0afd25a47bebfeff017e82f72c936e12fce03e75f0374e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e984aa369db6628cbcd912d27b23404131f9eb709b35fb7cded6644e8436302d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-original.ppm", + "sha256": "175210f0e0f8f4f12e52e6499964f921a6f78eb1b5e9d8babbe7552bfb1a5cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4672b70ea6ed108a16a13323e59088065413036142910239b409e532e324bea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9b5e01b8e84118e1facb7e6fbfd0f86fa8d94dbeab484a8db9e6d6534224db3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "909996c4446ec4595dd198d0fdc8f9417066cb72764933d87c1eadce4f4c786e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ed1508b9a886f776ef5cd472b60624c85f4f61fa1a1068977335525b963257b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7deecc5150ee6e6546df8c7b459d3a2de97afc3c0d26302b0daeaed767dccb2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7f4fc524342dba04c5768162dfb438c2dbe1fab5c8046e68c3c6e9b2fb3df6c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acd3d077b4a5693673ed730aef43684eebca298e6a68c6c4520c64430eaaceb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "91f02513747527b8601f2daf7bec364b081d576d74b73d07fb88097cebca1781", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "116797ac4574103c8397cd8e62484ee797cbca4fc9f5df621be219dcf071c9bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6c1de18299c04cb685160345d40628ff0419e700e7e442fc313167d7cb04a995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bff5413151f8d435e9ba967964998577b0b5f968a03884ce7ea26ce83b9a8060", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "315e7df7dd072a2652747d825ad15aedb8bbedd41c70291f534ceb99a8087b0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6a2aa7c38dc9c25b6e431f10b8e8a759ff7f0fb3d306d7f36d6e5c7aa304fd88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b911113afefb1055e916b2bd51fe1010aeca8c18c0b47064dfe5aa6182c025", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c5bff6a3448fdfc8693d0eb9fd87b34864ecbaee9bcf69ea33e642eaa8dda5f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5237519282cf98bc9aa180a99d449d8042dc9c8ae8538055bcaecacf6f4f55c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "880bd7dacf659719329b93f0cd2618c5a3934cc016d346706af45d55cc4bd97d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "62a3aa099d63717345d62d4658a93b3f53977792dac07740ad30e0e6dfe18264", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "16eede0f48eb3b6c02f2eb36a153812165dd414e85c49af884306402c182d7c6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d2fef3ea65b658e9058ccf8c48d5eea2543685a8acaf8bfc75e0ea5977973287", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0a817f9a2ace8d3dbb7593b5881e8db39e13d57b86ca7f5d04753bda4f791c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8daf0b00f06a97b439b9d6b7681b323f87b61f7e3be8cb16fc79fc3874cdb2a3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3d40f4364a93ea0e190766527d2f2beed1b232d7699642da0797bf2673b151de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "58aa2a4eb56cffc655954900066d6e726f2beb136e8fd33d14fe1c492b758da6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c364869538cf858d60171bcd5e55c4b64a39073585309425b7c61e78f2b0d38a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e828b91490e6657ae11201a7156d0cec8994987112a5cd7bb8d923ca239a481c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bbae96ec0b7e41c83592b7de4f2ab81cb31b37c803da239d4f3f679d07a37a24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "87c6619f0bb38a0458f96762b9e5aa18e85220dbf829752a129d7d5b1de8eee1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "92e40c4e8704c0a7604709b5b5fe4a8dd3b89ce11448e7e794ea522592d2a63f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "71b605246a09e679b8db2fa18d9ce3112b41e914fbd78d59aebfb1b21b1b3481", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0e5ef1d99d10bcafefce408b3fde6de259ffb1e0025894782de617247543efc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b30120203184a2ac8d7837d4d0ec7c6827c47fa85587bd55a2093eea326e5626", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5daa0ceba44cc1bed48feb4a2503b7dabf9cc7da37061ce18672f8f0d585c1a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3c12481dc1fb93f96df4c408aff753fb66d9a1b019bd76e9b4c39e9ba5673984", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fcc854c50e172cad85c37169048cfe2f2ccaec7d521bb27e62582d42f47c208b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1d2fe02669628fd79ce7feb1800816c630176b96ba6c6921614192bd4c1d217", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "41afe953c64acb133b1b5614015c331b27fe0f572d8d62f00a177d7eb3ccced5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1f7acbe8907c2b74c903bf8b3c527c22c8211e235cc2358a5a200814d2510a1e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12155709716dd82a436b99f7ed1209344bbaca4a3660f32496cc71b74de8d9da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90616d486ffc3487f3aaedfd3bc88573f58fc177da93ad57e1a59210cc2359b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df4ce446eef081aed7ab58bcb243434772e24895a39101a7dcd4cde5e0ca439", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "31b88339313d690b7859435f8701bfd55acacaff96376521768c6f17c856d855", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "79c1336474463a8bcc98504e08c6ceb4fc8e736eaa48e2cf29c3b7c5d8397f11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0da0a1a0c9d9e7dc1cda86c0d333a95f2812adcc7c738256d0d1750104f4b6f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e36c886ed1d7156301b095ad31f5b0723f25ba385a584e4f474f672a1a01f4c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "01d58dc50ca5f902bb7429112cb2a2b751fdfab6a04f0c5ffec21a3009393b7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6dd907b35448520581b950ef443b8fb487bc9867aa9bf283a517ce9a5790086", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74ba48327ac2590614cca2a91ba3495dab606495bbed46faacb23799ef5fa485", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c54b5d64ffd54d208767dbf2daeb16c0364e6bea2ddd32d0f3bcdb27e7065c51", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10470/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "797008b0b4dcbb1d21ee3b1592a68e52d3ea21a6ce70fa1f4f20c5f69745b18e" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17-job.json", + "sha256": "f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.962358+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "10474": { @@ -178229,7 +186785,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10474", "family_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -178243,32 +186799,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "8538bd43d98378c55e248f4f4d2248ceb1e9fbc59d1e510c5bc6326573cba810", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.649797+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10474", - "10476", - "10477", - "10479", - "1047a" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2602d2ad68e08a4045538f0919d254ecef5d5117a8210a3b8dbc508e27538e43", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:51.075701+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 c38a62fb477a711ae579489c1478b8f1afe5fadf8474a153546f5085c4e5ee9f", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10470-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bd625546c17e03e98838a125657d09eacc81daa7b549e3efcf68586d8f1194a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "20bc1c132fda81b41c0d8b31480ff68a12030d112ac919d1ee889cdaba6ea806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1e405278eb144f3f3d653ef8f9a4db13aa189d8dfef55a92971ecb3d82b282a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0dece6615c9a8d8b2e7020a7e6f91f39ebd8dd530948699615d074cbfe43266d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9839f8f1e27a0ff5124e7440e5f680cf734a7d71b7901914c1839cc3c46b65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9abd07f393655c3a1e6549d7caa556cb57c6177b827d0371cf2810bff655430a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2034a1bcc4de1123dcc0360510150e655c4bc0e0a669b16e618d92c8a1fa62ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4af1e4375d607d0587f1db44f724cf924079189f35bd926504e21dd773e6de84", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "096ec1689828fbaaff0397b6c032747ab7320ec3fc5d7afef687effdf1a25dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0919cd59b0a1bd4a0152e02dd40542af639d7850b3c8bf9b7b87ccdc03d770c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-original.ppm", + "sha256": "334f2bc0dc3a27d7076e90190e72710e7cdb24791a1eb577a24c1971c15945f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bb6fb8b793c4b5157957040ed29dceb3748ce4c74fb3307f0c1a3f16fb3072a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b630f5d34fa1bcc3bf848ef8c7bef453e177d43656fdb75ac3ff2cb93d9b499e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "485032866f5d6e8d6f6ceafbe2a5f6ad3a34aa67bddafe93397a8758a807e651", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "24cf3b3210de0257ceb7a9cec5874514d4daf1dce28aa4ae0eadc75c8b1dc94b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6b31d0c586f1f3fc418e58460984b97954239c85c3912f1486221c9cb78892a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a961c58cb6bd7a880cf9f1775d5a24c2695a1ccdbea647b0dbd6f4c07d1cb78f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d415bf900ebff6f7a7af34b0de2f017b3fa9d3a40fa1f2b4ea2d5550d6be51f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ecdea058c1e8471850defc02e296fc32641cb8f088846b27c7ca694666c9672f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e1095c48a16d0e7481edaf8fbedd1443ad5151d60b8447ed06a6dcc56e999a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-original.ppm", + "sha256": "64214d0fb30168d098dce502c30b1481827439ba4a12ac33c36d2969ae4f9cd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b63aa408a9dc740fd32ca4224a7affe26b71d47ed05df5d761a8426ac18172f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9aa2417cfa39e82db3c868b9a220adf16167fabc2326fe2ecbcda43b8809e2df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cd72651ff813d84b0e75ba66e36369c337817736bf42a49605ebd888d53a8462", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e56ac217b8a215f5c2b87e15104bc8cde3c2bdf613b5289c31860b5c4e1cb227", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05909a594988a6f74f8e0702c6869d0a02d048ddad9f8f272342319e0f9f1d5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2b1e3df24742e69f757554ed3c1d40962c0a76e485c54d0490afe4f621310ac6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e999ce4d31407ce10a5dd5a68a942afd8f741ac5032cf54a247506bcdb427005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5131e4908efbe1b47f0afd25a47bebfeff017e82f72c936e12fce03e75f0374e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e984aa369db6628cbcd912d27b23404131f9eb709b35fb7cded6644e8436302d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-original.ppm", + "sha256": "175210f0e0f8f4f12e52e6499964f921a6f78eb1b5e9d8babbe7552bfb1a5cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4672b70ea6ed108a16a13323e59088065413036142910239b409e532e324bea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9b5e01b8e84118e1facb7e6fbfd0f86fa8d94dbeab484a8db9e6d6534224db3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "909996c4446ec4595dd198d0fdc8f9417066cb72764933d87c1eadce4f4c786e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ed1508b9a886f776ef5cd472b60624c85f4f61fa1a1068977335525b963257b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7deecc5150ee6e6546df8c7b459d3a2de97afc3c0d26302b0daeaed767dccb2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7f4fc524342dba04c5768162dfb438c2dbe1fab5c8046e68c3c6e9b2fb3df6c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acd3d077b4a5693673ed730aef43684eebca298e6a68c6c4520c64430eaaceb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "91f02513747527b8601f2daf7bec364b081d576d74b73d07fb88097cebca1781", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "116797ac4574103c8397cd8e62484ee797cbca4fc9f5df621be219dcf071c9bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6c1de18299c04cb685160345d40628ff0419e700e7e442fc313167d7cb04a995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bff5413151f8d435e9ba967964998577b0b5f968a03884ce7ea26ce83b9a8060", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "315e7df7dd072a2652747d825ad15aedb8bbedd41c70291f534ceb99a8087b0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6a2aa7c38dc9c25b6e431f10b8e8a759ff7f0fb3d306d7f36d6e5c7aa304fd88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b911113afefb1055e916b2bd51fe1010aeca8c18c0b47064dfe5aa6182c025", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c5bff6a3448fdfc8693d0eb9fd87b34864ecbaee9bcf69ea33e642eaa8dda5f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5237519282cf98bc9aa180a99d449d8042dc9c8ae8538055bcaecacf6f4f55c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "880bd7dacf659719329b93f0cd2618c5a3934cc016d346706af45d55cc4bd97d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "62a3aa099d63717345d62d4658a93b3f53977792dac07740ad30e0e6dfe18264", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "16eede0f48eb3b6c02f2eb36a153812165dd414e85c49af884306402c182d7c6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d2fef3ea65b658e9058ccf8c48d5eea2543685a8acaf8bfc75e0ea5977973287", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0a817f9a2ace8d3dbb7593b5881e8db39e13d57b86ca7f5d04753bda4f791c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8daf0b00f06a97b439b9d6b7681b323f87b61f7e3be8cb16fc79fc3874cdb2a3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3d40f4364a93ea0e190766527d2f2beed1b232d7699642da0797bf2673b151de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "58aa2a4eb56cffc655954900066d6e726f2beb136e8fd33d14fe1c492b758da6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c364869538cf858d60171bcd5e55c4b64a39073585309425b7c61e78f2b0d38a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e828b91490e6657ae11201a7156d0cec8994987112a5cd7bb8d923ca239a481c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bbae96ec0b7e41c83592b7de4f2ab81cb31b37c803da239d4f3f679d07a37a24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "87c6619f0bb38a0458f96762b9e5aa18e85220dbf829752a129d7d5b1de8eee1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "92e40c4e8704c0a7604709b5b5fe4a8dd3b89ce11448e7e794ea522592d2a63f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "71b605246a09e679b8db2fa18d9ce3112b41e914fbd78d59aebfb1b21b1b3481", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0e5ef1d99d10bcafefce408b3fde6de259ffb1e0025894782de617247543efc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b30120203184a2ac8d7837d4d0ec7c6827c47fa85587bd55a2093eea326e5626", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5daa0ceba44cc1bed48feb4a2503b7dabf9cc7da37061ce18672f8f0d585c1a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3c12481dc1fb93f96df4c408aff753fb66d9a1b019bd76e9b4c39e9ba5673984", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fcc854c50e172cad85c37169048cfe2f2ccaec7d521bb27e62582d42f47c208b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1d2fe02669628fd79ce7feb1800816c630176b96ba6c6921614192bd4c1d217", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "41afe953c64acb133b1b5614015c331b27fe0f572d8d62f00a177d7eb3ccced5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1f7acbe8907c2b74c903bf8b3c527c22c8211e235cc2358a5a200814d2510a1e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12155709716dd82a436b99f7ed1209344bbaca4a3660f32496cc71b74de8d9da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90616d486ffc3487f3aaedfd3bc88573f58fc177da93ad57e1a59210cc2359b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df4ce446eef081aed7ab58bcb243434772e24895a39101a7dcd4cde5e0ca439", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "31b88339313d690b7859435f8701bfd55acacaff96376521768c6f17c856d855", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "79c1336474463a8bcc98504e08c6ceb4fc8e736eaa48e2cf29c3b7c5d8397f11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0da0a1a0c9d9e7dc1cda86c0d333a95f2812adcc7c738256d0d1750104f4b6f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e36c886ed1d7156301b095ad31f5b0723f25ba385a584e4f474f672a1a01f4c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "01d58dc50ca5f902bb7429112cb2a2b751fdfab6a04f0c5ffec21a3009393b7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6dd907b35448520581b950ef443b8fb487bc9867aa9bf283a517ce9a5790086", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74ba48327ac2590614cca2a91ba3495dab606495bbed46faacb23799ef5fa485", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c54b5d64ffd54d208767dbf2daeb16c0364e6bea2ddd32d0f3bcdb27e7065c51", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10470/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "797008b0b4dcbb1d21ee3b1592a68e52d3ea21a6ce70fa1f4f20c5f69745b18e" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17-job.json", + "sha256": "f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.962358+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "10475": { @@ -178290,7 +187277,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10475", "family_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -178304,32 +187291,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "8538bd43d98378c55e248f4f4d2248ceb1e9fbc59d1e510c5bc6326573cba810", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.649797+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10474", - "10476", - "10477", - "10479", - "1047a" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2602d2ad68e08a4045538f0919d254ecef5d5117a8210a3b8dbc508e27538e43", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:51.075701+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 c38a62fb477a711ae579489c1478b8f1afe5fadf8474a153546f5085c4e5ee9f", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10470-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bd625546c17e03e98838a125657d09eacc81daa7b549e3efcf68586d8f1194a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "20bc1c132fda81b41c0d8b31480ff68a12030d112ac919d1ee889cdaba6ea806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1e405278eb144f3f3d653ef8f9a4db13aa189d8dfef55a92971ecb3d82b282a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0dece6615c9a8d8b2e7020a7e6f91f39ebd8dd530948699615d074cbfe43266d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9839f8f1e27a0ff5124e7440e5f680cf734a7d71b7901914c1839cc3c46b65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9abd07f393655c3a1e6549d7caa556cb57c6177b827d0371cf2810bff655430a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2034a1bcc4de1123dcc0360510150e655c4bc0e0a669b16e618d92c8a1fa62ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4af1e4375d607d0587f1db44f724cf924079189f35bd926504e21dd773e6de84", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "096ec1689828fbaaff0397b6c032747ab7320ec3fc5d7afef687effdf1a25dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0919cd59b0a1bd4a0152e02dd40542af639d7850b3c8bf9b7b87ccdc03d770c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-original.ppm", + "sha256": "334f2bc0dc3a27d7076e90190e72710e7cdb24791a1eb577a24c1971c15945f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bb6fb8b793c4b5157957040ed29dceb3748ce4c74fb3307f0c1a3f16fb3072a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b630f5d34fa1bcc3bf848ef8c7bef453e177d43656fdb75ac3ff2cb93d9b499e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "485032866f5d6e8d6f6ceafbe2a5f6ad3a34aa67bddafe93397a8758a807e651", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "24cf3b3210de0257ceb7a9cec5874514d4daf1dce28aa4ae0eadc75c8b1dc94b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6b31d0c586f1f3fc418e58460984b97954239c85c3912f1486221c9cb78892a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a961c58cb6bd7a880cf9f1775d5a24c2695a1ccdbea647b0dbd6f4c07d1cb78f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d415bf900ebff6f7a7af34b0de2f017b3fa9d3a40fa1f2b4ea2d5550d6be51f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ecdea058c1e8471850defc02e296fc32641cb8f088846b27c7ca694666c9672f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e1095c48a16d0e7481edaf8fbedd1443ad5151d60b8447ed06a6dcc56e999a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-original.ppm", + "sha256": "64214d0fb30168d098dce502c30b1481827439ba4a12ac33c36d2969ae4f9cd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b63aa408a9dc740fd32ca4224a7affe26b71d47ed05df5d761a8426ac18172f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9aa2417cfa39e82db3c868b9a220adf16167fabc2326fe2ecbcda43b8809e2df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cd72651ff813d84b0e75ba66e36369c337817736bf42a49605ebd888d53a8462", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e56ac217b8a215f5c2b87e15104bc8cde3c2bdf613b5289c31860b5c4e1cb227", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05909a594988a6f74f8e0702c6869d0a02d048ddad9f8f272342319e0f9f1d5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2b1e3df24742e69f757554ed3c1d40962c0a76e485c54d0490afe4f621310ac6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e999ce4d31407ce10a5dd5a68a942afd8f741ac5032cf54a247506bcdb427005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5131e4908efbe1b47f0afd25a47bebfeff017e82f72c936e12fce03e75f0374e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e984aa369db6628cbcd912d27b23404131f9eb709b35fb7cded6644e8436302d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-original.ppm", + "sha256": "175210f0e0f8f4f12e52e6499964f921a6f78eb1b5e9d8babbe7552bfb1a5cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4672b70ea6ed108a16a13323e59088065413036142910239b409e532e324bea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9b5e01b8e84118e1facb7e6fbfd0f86fa8d94dbeab484a8db9e6d6534224db3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "909996c4446ec4595dd198d0fdc8f9417066cb72764933d87c1eadce4f4c786e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ed1508b9a886f776ef5cd472b60624c85f4f61fa1a1068977335525b963257b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7deecc5150ee6e6546df8c7b459d3a2de97afc3c0d26302b0daeaed767dccb2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7f4fc524342dba04c5768162dfb438c2dbe1fab5c8046e68c3c6e9b2fb3df6c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acd3d077b4a5693673ed730aef43684eebca298e6a68c6c4520c64430eaaceb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "91f02513747527b8601f2daf7bec364b081d576d74b73d07fb88097cebca1781", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "116797ac4574103c8397cd8e62484ee797cbca4fc9f5df621be219dcf071c9bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6c1de18299c04cb685160345d40628ff0419e700e7e442fc313167d7cb04a995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bff5413151f8d435e9ba967964998577b0b5f968a03884ce7ea26ce83b9a8060", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "315e7df7dd072a2652747d825ad15aedb8bbedd41c70291f534ceb99a8087b0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6a2aa7c38dc9c25b6e431f10b8e8a759ff7f0fb3d306d7f36d6e5c7aa304fd88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b911113afefb1055e916b2bd51fe1010aeca8c18c0b47064dfe5aa6182c025", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c5bff6a3448fdfc8693d0eb9fd87b34864ecbaee9bcf69ea33e642eaa8dda5f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5237519282cf98bc9aa180a99d449d8042dc9c8ae8538055bcaecacf6f4f55c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "880bd7dacf659719329b93f0cd2618c5a3934cc016d346706af45d55cc4bd97d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "62a3aa099d63717345d62d4658a93b3f53977792dac07740ad30e0e6dfe18264", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "16eede0f48eb3b6c02f2eb36a153812165dd414e85c49af884306402c182d7c6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d2fef3ea65b658e9058ccf8c48d5eea2543685a8acaf8bfc75e0ea5977973287", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0a817f9a2ace8d3dbb7593b5881e8db39e13d57b86ca7f5d04753bda4f791c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8daf0b00f06a97b439b9d6b7681b323f87b61f7e3be8cb16fc79fc3874cdb2a3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3d40f4364a93ea0e190766527d2f2beed1b232d7699642da0797bf2673b151de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "58aa2a4eb56cffc655954900066d6e726f2beb136e8fd33d14fe1c492b758da6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c364869538cf858d60171bcd5e55c4b64a39073585309425b7c61e78f2b0d38a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e828b91490e6657ae11201a7156d0cec8994987112a5cd7bb8d923ca239a481c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bbae96ec0b7e41c83592b7de4f2ab81cb31b37c803da239d4f3f679d07a37a24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "87c6619f0bb38a0458f96762b9e5aa18e85220dbf829752a129d7d5b1de8eee1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "92e40c4e8704c0a7604709b5b5fe4a8dd3b89ce11448e7e794ea522592d2a63f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "71b605246a09e679b8db2fa18d9ce3112b41e914fbd78d59aebfb1b21b1b3481", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0e5ef1d99d10bcafefce408b3fde6de259ffb1e0025894782de617247543efc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b30120203184a2ac8d7837d4d0ec7c6827c47fa85587bd55a2093eea326e5626", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5daa0ceba44cc1bed48feb4a2503b7dabf9cc7da37061ce18672f8f0d585c1a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3c12481dc1fb93f96df4c408aff753fb66d9a1b019bd76e9b4c39e9ba5673984", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fcc854c50e172cad85c37169048cfe2f2ccaec7d521bb27e62582d42f47c208b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1d2fe02669628fd79ce7feb1800816c630176b96ba6c6921614192bd4c1d217", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "41afe953c64acb133b1b5614015c331b27fe0f572d8d62f00a177d7eb3ccced5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1f7acbe8907c2b74c903bf8b3c527c22c8211e235cc2358a5a200814d2510a1e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12155709716dd82a436b99f7ed1209344bbaca4a3660f32496cc71b74de8d9da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90616d486ffc3487f3aaedfd3bc88573f58fc177da93ad57e1a59210cc2359b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df4ce446eef081aed7ab58bcb243434772e24895a39101a7dcd4cde5e0ca439", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "31b88339313d690b7859435f8701bfd55acacaff96376521768c6f17c856d855", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "79c1336474463a8bcc98504e08c6ceb4fc8e736eaa48e2cf29c3b7c5d8397f11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0da0a1a0c9d9e7dc1cda86c0d333a95f2812adcc7c738256d0d1750104f4b6f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e36c886ed1d7156301b095ad31f5b0723f25ba385a584e4f474f672a1a01f4c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "01d58dc50ca5f902bb7429112cb2a2b751fdfab6a04f0c5ffec21a3009393b7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6dd907b35448520581b950ef443b8fb487bc9867aa9bf283a517ce9a5790086", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74ba48327ac2590614cca2a91ba3495dab606495bbed46faacb23799ef5fa485", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c54b5d64ffd54d208767dbf2daeb16c0364e6bea2ddd32d0f3bcdb27e7065c51", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10470/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "797008b0b4dcbb1d21ee3b1592a68e52d3ea21a6ce70fa1f4f20c5f69745b18e" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17-job.json", + "sha256": "f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.962358+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "10476": { @@ -178351,7 +187769,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10476", "family_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -178365,32 +187783,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "8538bd43d98378c55e248f4f4d2248ceb1e9fbc59d1e510c5bc6326573cba810", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.649797+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10474", - "10476", - "10477", - "10479", - "1047a" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2602d2ad68e08a4045538f0919d254ecef5d5117a8210a3b8dbc508e27538e43", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:51.075701+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 c38a62fb477a711ae579489c1478b8f1afe5fadf8474a153546f5085c4e5ee9f", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10470-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bd625546c17e03e98838a125657d09eacc81daa7b549e3efcf68586d8f1194a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "20bc1c132fda81b41c0d8b31480ff68a12030d112ac919d1ee889cdaba6ea806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1e405278eb144f3f3d653ef8f9a4db13aa189d8dfef55a92971ecb3d82b282a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0dece6615c9a8d8b2e7020a7e6f91f39ebd8dd530948699615d074cbfe43266d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9839f8f1e27a0ff5124e7440e5f680cf734a7d71b7901914c1839cc3c46b65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9abd07f393655c3a1e6549d7caa556cb57c6177b827d0371cf2810bff655430a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2034a1bcc4de1123dcc0360510150e655c4bc0e0a669b16e618d92c8a1fa62ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4af1e4375d607d0587f1db44f724cf924079189f35bd926504e21dd773e6de84", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "096ec1689828fbaaff0397b6c032747ab7320ec3fc5d7afef687effdf1a25dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0919cd59b0a1bd4a0152e02dd40542af639d7850b3c8bf9b7b87ccdc03d770c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-original.ppm", + "sha256": "334f2bc0dc3a27d7076e90190e72710e7cdb24791a1eb577a24c1971c15945f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bb6fb8b793c4b5157957040ed29dceb3748ce4c74fb3307f0c1a3f16fb3072a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b630f5d34fa1bcc3bf848ef8c7bef453e177d43656fdb75ac3ff2cb93d9b499e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "485032866f5d6e8d6f6ceafbe2a5f6ad3a34aa67bddafe93397a8758a807e651", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "24cf3b3210de0257ceb7a9cec5874514d4daf1dce28aa4ae0eadc75c8b1dc94b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6b31d0c586f1f3fc418e58460984b97954239c85c3912f1486221c9cb78892a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a961c58cb6bd7a880cf9f1775d5a24c2695a1ccdbea647b0dbd6f4c07d1cb78f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d415bf900ebff6f7a7af34b0de2f017b3fa9d3a40fa1f2b4ea2d5550d6be51f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ecdea058c1e8471850defc02e296fc32641cb8f088846b27c7ca694666c9672f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e1095c48a16d0e7481edaf8fbedd1443ad5151d60b8447ed06a6dcc56e999a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-original.ppm", + "sha256": "64214d0fb30168d098dce502c30b1481827439ba4a12ac33c36d2969ae4f9cd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b63aa408a9dc740fd32ca4224a7affe26b71d47ed05df5d761a8426ac18172f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9aa2417cfa39e82db3c868b9a220adf16167fabc2326fe2ecbcda43b8809e2df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cd72651ff813d84b0e75ba66e36369c337817736bf42a49605ebd888d53a8462", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e56ac217b8a215f5c2b87e15104bc8cde3c2bdf613b5289c31860b5c4e1cb227", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05909a594988a6f74f8e0702c6869d0a02d048ddad9f8f272342319e0f9f1d5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2b1e3df24742e69f757554ed3c1d40962c0a76e485c54d0490afe4f621310ac6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e999ce4d31407ce10a5dd5a68a942afd8f741ac5032cf54a247506bcdb427005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5131e4908efbe1b47f0afd25a47bebfeff017e82f72c936e12fce03e75f0374e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e984aa369db6628cbcd912d27b23404131f9eb709b35fb7cded6644e8436302d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-original.ppm", + "sha256": "175210f0e0f8f4f12e52e6499964f921a6f78eb1b5e9d8babbe7552bfb1a5cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4672b70ea6ed108a16a13323e59088065413036142910239b409e532e324bea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9b5e01b8e84118e1facb7e6fbfd0f86fa8d94dbeab484a8db9e6d6534224db3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "909996c4446ec4595dd198d0fdc8f9417066cb72764933d87c1eadce4f4c786e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ed1508b9a886f776ef5cd472b60624c85f4f61fa1a1068977335525b963257b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7deecc5150ee6e6546df8c7b459d3a2de97afc3c0d26302b0daeaed767dccb2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7f4fc524342dba04c5768162dfb438c2dbe1fab5c8046e68c3c6e9b2fb3df6c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acd3d077b4a5693673ed730aef43684eebca298e6a68c6c4520c64430eaaceb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "91f02513747527b8601f2daf7bec364b081d576d74b73d07fb88097cebca1781", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "116797ac4574103c8397cd8e62484ee797cbca4fc9f5df621be219dcf071c9bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6c1de18299c04cb685160345d40628ff0419e700e7e442fc313167d7cb04a995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bff5413151f8d435e9ba967964998577b0b5f968a03884ce7ea26ce83b9a8060", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "315e7df7dd072a2652747d825ad15aedb8bbedd41c70291f534ceb99a8087b0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6a2aa7c38dc9c25b6e431f10b8e8a759ff7f0fb3d306d7f36d6e5c7aa304fd88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b911113afefb1055e916b2bd51fe1010aeca8c18c0b47064dfe5aa6182c025", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c5bff6a3448fdfc8693d0eb9fd87b34864ecbaee9bcf69ea33e642eaa8dda5f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5237519282cf98bc9aa180a99d449d8042dc9c8ae8538055bcaecacf6f4f55c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "880bd7dacf659719329b93f0cd2618c5a3934cc016d346706af45d55cc4bd97d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "62a3aa099d63717345d62d4658a93b3f53977792dac07740ad30e0e6dfe18264", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "16eede0f48eb3b6c02f2eb36a153812165dd414e85c49af884306402c182d7c6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d2fef3ea65b658e9058ccf8c48d5eea2543685a8acaf8bfc75e0ea5977973287", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0a817f9a2ace8d3dbb7593b5881e8db39e13d57b86ca7f5d04753bda4f791c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8daf0b00f06a97b439b9d6b7681b323f87b61f7e3be8cb16fc79fc3874cdb2a3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3d40f4364a93ea0e190766527d2f2beed1b232d7699642da0797bf2673b151de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "58aa2a4eb56cffc655954900066d6e726f2beb136e8fd33d14fe1c492b758da6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c364869538cf858d60171bcd5e55c4b64a39073585309425b7c61e78f2b0d38a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e828b91490e6657ae11201a7156d0cec8994987112a5cd7bb8d923ca239a481c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bbae96ec0b7e41c83592b7de4f2ab81cb31b37c803da239d4f3f679d07a37a24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "87c6619f0bb38a0458f96762b9e5aa18e85220dbf829752a129d7d5b1de8eee1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "92e40c4e8704c0a7604709b5b5fe4a8dd3b89ce11448e7e794ea522592d2a63f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "71b605246a09e679b8db2fa18d9ce3112b41e914fbd78d59aebfb1b21b1b3481", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0e5ef1d99d10bcafefce408b3fde6de259ffb1e0025894782de617247543efc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b30120203184a2ac8d7837d4d0ec7c6827c47fa85587bd55a2093eea326e5626", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5daa0ceba44cc1bed48feb4a2503b7dabf9cc7da37061ce18672f8f0d585c1a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3c12481dc1fb93f96df4c408aff753fb66d9a1b019bd76e9b4c39e9ba5673984", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fcc854c50e172cad85c37169048cfe2f2ccaec7d521bb27e62582d42f47c208b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1d2fe02669628fd79ce7feb1800816c630176b96ba6c6921614192bd4c1d217", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "41afe953c64acb133b1b5614015c331b27fe0f572d8d62f00a177d7eb3ccced5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1f7acbe8907c2b74c903bf8b3c527c22c8211e235cc2358a5a200814d2510a1e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12155709716dd82a436b99f7ed1209344bbaca4a3660f32496cc71b74de8d9da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90616d486ffc3487f3aaedfd3bc88573f58fc177da93ad57e1a59210cc2359b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df4ce446eef081aed7ab58bcb243434772e24895a39101a7dcd4cde5e0ca439", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "31b88339313d690b7859435f8701bfd55acacaff96376521768c6f17c856d855", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "79c1336474463a8bcc98504e08c6ceb4fc8e736eaa48e2cf29c3b7c5d8397f11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0da0a1a0c9d9e7dc1cda86c0d333a95f2812adcc7c738256d0d1750104f4b6f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e36c886ed1d7156301b095ad31f5b0723f25ba385a584e4f474f672a1a01f4c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "01d58dc50ca5f902bb7429112cb2a2b751fdfab6a04f0c5ffec21a3009393b7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6dd907b35448520581b950ef443b8fb487bc9867aa9bf283a517ce9a5790086", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74ba48327ac2590614cca2a91ba3495dab606495bbed46faacb23799ef5fa485", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c54b5d64ffd54d208767dbf2daeb16c0364e6bea2ddd32d0f3bcdb27e7065c51", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10470/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "797008b0b4dcbb1d21ee3b1592a68e52d3ea21a6ce70fa1f4f20c5f69745b18e" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17-job.json", + "sha256": "f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.962358+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "10477": { @@ -178412,7 +188261,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10477", "family_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -178426,32 +188275,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "8538bd43d98378c55e248f4f4d2248ceb1e9fbc59d1e510c5bc6326573cba810", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.649797+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10474", - "10476", - "10477", - "10479", - "1047a" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2602d2ad68e08a4045538f0919d254ecef5d5117a8210a3b8dbc508e27538e43", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:51.075701+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 c38a62fb477a711ae579489c1478b8f1afe5fadf8474a153546f5085c4e5ee9f", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10470-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bd625546c17e03e98838a125657d09eacc81daa7b549e3efcf68586d8f1194a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "20bc1c132fda81b41c0d8b31480ff68a12030d112ac919d1ee889cdaba6ea806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1e405278eb144f3f3d653ef8f9a4db13aa189d8dfef55a92971ecb3d82b282a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0dece6615c9a8d8b2e7020a7e6f91f39ebd8dd530948699615d074cbfe43266d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9839f8f1e27a0ff5124e7440e5f680cf734a7d71b7901914c1839cc3c46b65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9abd07f393655c3a1e6549d7caa556cb57c6177b827d0371cf2810bff655430a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2034a1bcc4de1123dcc0360510150e655c4bc0e0a669b16e618d92c8a1fa62ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4af1e4375d607d0587f1db44f724cf924079189f35bd926504e21dd773e6de84", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "096ec1689828fbaaff0397b6c032747ab7320ec3fc5d7afef687effdf1a25dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0919cd59b0a1bd4a0152e02dd40542af639d7850b3c8bf9b7b87ccdc03d770c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-original.ppm", + "sha256": "334f2bc0dc3a27d7076e90190e72710e7cdb24791a1eb577a24c1971c15945f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bb6fb8b793c4b5157957040ed29dceb3748ce4c74fb3307f0c1a3f16fb3072a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b630f5d34fa1bcc3bf848ef8c7bef453e177d43656fdb75ac3ff2cb93d9b499e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "485032866f5d6e8d6f6ceafbe2a5f6ad3a34aa67bddafe93397a8758a807e651", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "24cf3b3210de0257ceb7a9cec5874514d4daf1dce28aa4ae0eadc75c8b1dc94b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6b31d0c586f1f3fc418e58460984b97954239c85c3912f1486221c9cb78892a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a961c58cb6bd7a880cf9f1775d5a24c2695a1ccdbea647b0dbd6f4c07d1cb78f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d415bf900ebff6f7a7af34b0de2f017b3fa9d3a40fa1f2b4ea2d5550d6be51f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ecdea058c1e8471850defc02e296fc32641cb8f088846b27c7ca694666c9672f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e1095c48a16d0e7481edaf8fbedd1443ad5151d60b8447ed06a6dcc56e999a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-original.ppm", + "sha256": "64214d0fb30168d098dce502c30b1481827439ba4a12ac33c36d2969ae4f9cd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b63aa408a9dc740fd32ca4224a7affe26b71d47ed05df5d761a8426ac18172f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9aa2417cfa39e82db3c868b9a220adf16167fabc2326fe2ecbcda43b8809e2df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cd72651ff813d84b0e75ba66e36369c337817736bf42a49605ebd888d53a8462", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e56ac217b8a215f5c2b87e15104bc8cde3c2bdf613b5289c31860b5c4e1cb227", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05909a594988a6f74f8e0702c6869d0a02d048ddad9f8f272342319e0f9f1d5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2b1e3df24742e69f757554ed3c1d40962c0a76e485c54d0490afe4f621310ac6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e999ce4d31407ce10a5dd5a68a942afd8f741ac5032cf54a247506bcdb427005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5131e4908efbe1b47f0afd25a47bebfeff017e82f72c936e12fce03e75f0374e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e984aa369db6628cbcd912d27b23404131f9eb709b35fb7cded6644e8436302d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-original.ppm", + "sha256": "175210f0e0f8f4f12e52e6499964f921a6f78eb1b5e9d8babbe7552bfb1a5cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4672b70ea6ed108a16a13323e59088065413036142910239b409e532e324bea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9b5e01b8e84118e1facb7e6fbfd0f86fa8d94dbeab484a8db9e6d6534224db3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "909996c4446ec4595dd198d0fdc8f9417066cb72764933d87c1eadce4f4c786e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ed1508b9a886f776ef5cd472b60624c85f4f61fa1a1068977335525b963257b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7deecc5150ee6e6546df8c7b459d3a2de97afc3c0d26302b0daeaed767dccb2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7f4fc524342dba04c5768162dfb438c2dbe1fab5c8046e68c3c6e9b2fb3df6c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acd3d077b4a5693673ed730aef43684eebca298e6a68c6c4520c64430eaaceb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "91f02513747527b8601f2daf7bec364b081d576d74b73d07fb88097cebca1781", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "116797ac4574103c8397cd8e62484ee797cbca4fc9f5df621be219dcf071c9bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6c1de18299c04cb685160345d40628ff0419e700e7e442fc313167d7cb04a995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bff5413151f8d435e9ba967964998577b0b5f968a03884ce7ea26ce83b9a8060", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "315e7df7dd072a2652747d825ad15aedb8bbedd41c70291f534ceb99a8087b0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6a2aa7c38dc9c25b6e431f10b8e8a759ff7f0fb3d306d7f36d6e5c7aa304fd88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b911113afefb1055e916b2bd51fe1010aeca8c18c0b47064dfe5aa6182c025", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c5bff6a3448fdfc8693d0eb9fd87b34864ecbaee9bcf69ea33e642eaa8dda5f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5237519282cf98bc9aa180a99d449d8042dc9c8ae8538055bcaecacf6f4f55c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "880bd7dacf659719329b93f0cd2618c5a3934cc016d346706af45d55cc4bd97d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "62a3aa099d63717345d62d4658a93b3f53977792dac07740ad30e0e6dfe18264", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "16eede0f48eb3b6c02f2eb36a153812165dd414e85c49af884306402c182d7c6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d2fef3ea65b658e9058ccf8c48d5eea2543685a8acaf8bfc75e0ea5977973287", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0a817f9a2ace8d3dbb7593b5881e8db39e13d57b86ca7f5d04753bda4f791c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8daf0b00f06a97b439b9d6b7681b323f87b61f7e3be8cb16fc79fc3874cdb2a3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3d40f4364a93ea0e190766527d2f2beed1b232d7699642da0797bf2673b151de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "58aa2a4eb56cffc655954900066d6e726f2beb136e8fd33d14fe1c492b758da6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c364869538cf858d60171bcd5e55c4b64a39073585309425b7c61e78f2b0d38a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e828b91490e6657ae11201a7156d0cec8994987112a5cd7bb8d923ca239a481c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bbae96ec0b7e41c83592b7de4f2ab81cb31b37c803da239d4f3f679d07a37a24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "87c6619f0bb38a0458f96762b9e5aa18e85220dbf829752a129d7d5b1de8eee1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "92e40c4e8704c0a7604709b5b5fe4a8dd3b89ce11448e7e794ea522592d2a63f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "71b605246a09e679b8db2fa18d9ce3112b41e914fbd78d59aebfb1b21b1b3481", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0e5ef1d99d10bcafefce408b3fde6de259ffb1e0025894782de617247543efc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b30120203184a2ac8d7837d4d0ec7c6827c47fa85587bd55a2093eea326e5626", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5daa0ceba44cc1bed48feb4a2503b7dabf9cc7da37061ce18672f8f0d585c1a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3c12481dc1fb93f96df4c408aff753fb66d9a1b019bd76e9b4c39e9ba5673984", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fcc854c50e172cad85c37169048cfe2f2ccaec7d521bb27e62582d42f47c208b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1d2fe02669628fd79ce7feb1800816c630176b96ba6c6921614192bd4c1d217", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "41afe953c64acb133b1b5614015c331b27fe0f572d8d62f00a177d7eb3ccced5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1f7acbe8907c2b74c903bf8b3c527c22c8211e235cc2358a5a200814d2510a1e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12155709716dd82a436b99f7ed1209344bbaca4a3660f32496cc71b74de8d9da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90616d486ffc3487f3aaedfd3bc88573f58fc177da93ad57e1a59210cc2359b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df4ce446eef081aed7ab58bcb243434772e24895a39101a7dcd4cde5e0ca439", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "31b88339313d690b7859435f8701bfd55acacaff96376521768c6f17c856d855", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "79c1336474463a8bcc98504e08c6ceb4fc8e736eaa48e2cf29c3b7c5d8397f11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0da0a1a0c9d9e7dc1cda86c0d333a95f2812adcc7c738256d0d1750104f4b6f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e36c886ed1d7156301b095ad31f5b0723f25ba385a584e4f474f672a1a01f4c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "01d58dc50ca5f902bb7429112cb2a2b751fdfab6a04f0c5ffec21a3009393b7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6dd907b35448520581b950ef443b8fb487bc9867aa9bf283a517ce9a5790086", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74ba48327ac2590614cca2a91ba3495dab606495bbed46faacb23799ef5fa485", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c54b5d64ffd54d208767dbf2daeb16c0364e6bea2ddd32d0f3bcdb27e7065c51", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10470/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "797008b0b4dcbb1d21ee3b1592a68e52d3ea21a6ce70fa1f4f20c5f69745b18e" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17-job.json", + "sha256": "f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.962358+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "10478": { @@ -178473,7 +188753,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10478", "family_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -178487,32 +188767,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "8538bd43d98378c55e248f4f4d2248ceb1e9fbc59d1e510c5bc6326573cba810", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.649797+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10474", - "10476", - "10477", - "10479", - "1047a" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2602d2ad68e08a4045538f0919d254ecef5d5117a8210a3b8dbc508e27538e43", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:51.075701+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 c38a62fb477a711ae579489c1478b8f1afe5fadf8474a153546f5085c4e5ee9f", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10470-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bd625546c17e03e98838a125657d09eacc81daa7b549e3efcf68586d8f1194a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "20bc1c132fda81b41c0d8b31480ff68a12030d112ac919d1ee889cdaba6ea806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1e405278eb144f3f3d653ef8f9a4db13aa189d8dfef55a92971ecb3d82b282a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0dece6615c9a8d8b2e7020a7e6f91f39ebd8dd530948699615d074cbfe43266d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9839f8f1e27a0ff5124e7440e5f680cf734a7d71b7901914c1839cc3c46b65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9abd07f393655c3a1e6549d7caa556cb57c6177b827d0371cf2810bff655430a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2034a1bcc4de1123dcc0360510150e655c4bc0e0a669b16e618d92c8a1fa62ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4af1e4375d607d0587f1db44f724cf924079189f35bd926504e21dd773e6de84", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "096ec1689828fbaaff0397b6c032747ab7320ec3fc5d7afef687effdf1a25dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0919cd59b0a1bd4a0152e02dd40542af639d7850b3c8bf9b7b87ccdc03d770c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-original.ppm", + "sha256": "334f2bc0dc3a27d7076e90190e72710e7cdb24791a1eb577a24c1971c15945f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bb6fb8b793c4b5157957040ed29dceb3748ce4c74fb3307f0c1a3f16fb3072a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b630f5d34fa1bcc3bf848ef8c7bef453e177d43656fdb75ac3ff2cb93d9b499e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "485032866f5d6e8d6f6ceafbe2a5f6ad3a34aa67bddafe93397a8758a807e651", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "24cf3b3210de0257ceb7a9cec5874514d4daf1dce28aa4ae0eadc75c8b1dc94b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6b31d0c586f1f3fc418e58460984b97954239c85c3912f1486221c9cb78892a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a961c58cb6bd7a880cf9f1775d5a24c2695a1ccdbea647b0dbd6f4c07d1cb78f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d415bf900ebff6f7a7af34b0de2f017b3fa9d3a40fa1f2b4ea2d5550d6be51f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ecdea058c1e8471850defc02e296fc32641cb8f088846b27c7ca694666c9672f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e1095c48a16d0e7481edaf8fbedd1443ad5151d60b8447ed06a6dcc56e999a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-original.ppm", + "sha256": "64214d0fb30168d098dce502c30b1481827439ba4a12ac33c36d2969ae4f9cd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b63aa408a9dc740fd32ca4224a7affe26b71d47ed05df5d761a8426ac18172f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9aa2417cfa39e82db3c868b9a220adf16167fabc2326fe2ecbcda43b8809e2df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cd72651ff813d84b0e75ba66e36369c337817736bf42a49605ebd888d53a8462", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e56ac217b8a215f5c2b87e15104bc8cde3c2bdf613b5289c31860b5c4e1cb227", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05909a594988a6f74f8e0702c6869d0a02d048ddad9f8f272342319e0f9f1d5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2b1e3df24742e69f757554ed3c1d40962c0a76e485c54d0490afe4f621310ac6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e999ce4d31407ce10a5dd5a68a942afd8f741ac5032cf54a247506bcdb427005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5131e4908efbe1b47f0afd25a47bebfeff017e82f72c936e12fce03e75f0374e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e984aa369db6628cbcd912d27b23404131f9eb709b35fb7cded6644e8436302d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-original.ppm", + "sha256": "175210f0e0f8f4f12e52e6499964f921a6f78eb1b5e9d8babbe7552bfb1a5cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4672b70ea6ed108a16a13323e59088065413036142910239b409e532e324bea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9b5e01b8e84118e1facb7e6fbfd0f86fa8d94dbeab484a8db9e6d6534224db3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "909996c4446ec4595dd198d0fdc8f9417066cb72764933d87c1eadce4f4c786e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ed1508b9a886f776ef5cd472b60624c85f4f61fa1a1068977335525b963257b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7deecc5150ee6e6546df8c7b459d3a2de97afc3c0d26302b0daeaed767dccb2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7f4fc524342dba04c5768162dfb438c2dbe1fab5c8046e68c3c6e9b2fb3df6c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acd3d077b4a5693673ed730aef43684eebca298e6a68c6c4520c64430eaaceb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "91f02513747527b8601f2daf7bec364b081d576d74b73d07fb88097cebca1781", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "116797ac4574103c8397cd8e62484ee797cbca4fc9f5df621be219dcf071c9bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6c1de18299c04cb685160345d40628ff0419e700e7e442fc313167d7cb04a995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bff5413151f8d435e9ba967964998577b0b5f968a03884ce7ea26ce83b9a8060", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "315e7df7dd072a2652747d825ad15aedb8bbedd41c70291f534ceb99a8087b0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6a2aa7c38dc9c25b6e431f10b8e8a759ff7f0fb3d306d7f36d6e5c7aa304fd88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b911113afefb1055e916b2bd51fe1010aeca8c18c0b47064dfe5aa6182c025", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c5bff6a3448fdfc8693d0eb9fd87b34864ecbaee9bcf69ea33e642eaa8dda5f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5237519282cf98bc9aa180a99d449d8042dc9c8ae8538055bcaecacf6f4f55c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "880bd7dacf659719329b93f0cd2618c5a3934cc016d346706af45d55cc4bd97d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "62a3aa099d63717345d62d4658a93b3f53977792dac07740ad30e0e6dfe18264", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "16eede0f48eb3b6c02f2eb36a153812165dd414e85c49af884306402c182d7c6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d2fef3ea65b658e9058ccf8c48d5eea2543685a8acaf8bfc75e0ea5977973287", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0a817f9a2ace8d3dbb7593b5881e8db39e13d57b86ca7f5d04753bda4f791c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8daf0b00f06a97b439b9d6b7681b323f87b61f7e3be8cb16fc79fc3874cdb2a3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3d40f4364a93ea0e190766527d2f2beed1b232d7699642da0797bf2673b151de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "58aa2a4eb56cffc655954900066d6e726f2beb136e8fd33d14fe1c492b758da6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c364869538cf858d60171bcd5e55c4b64a39073585309425b7c61e78f2b0d38a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e828b91490e6657ae11201a7156d0cec8994987112a5cd7bb8d923ca239a481c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bbae96ec0b7e41c83592b7de4f2ab81cb31b37c803da239d4f3f679d07a37a24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "87c6619f0bb38a0458f96762b9e5aa18e85220dbf829752a129d7d5b1de8eee1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "92e40c4e8704c0a7604709b5b5fe4a8dd3b89ce11448e7e794ea522592d2a63f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "71b605246a09e679b8db2fa18d9ce3112b41e914fbd78d59aebfb1b21b1b3481", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0e5ef1d99d10bcafefce408b3fde6de259ffb1e0025894782de617247543efc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b30120203184a2ac8d7837d4d0ec7c6827c47fa85587bd55a2093eea326e5626", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5daa0ceba44cc1bed48feb4a2503b7dabf9cc7da37061ce18672f8f0d585c1a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3c12481dc1fb93f96df4c408aff753fb66d9a1b019bd76e9b4c39e9ba5673984", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fcc854c50e172cad85c37169048cfe2f2ccaec7d521bb27e62582d42f47c208b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1d2fe02669628fd79ce7feb1800816c630176b96ba6c6921614192bd4c1d217", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "41afe953c64acb133b1b5614015c331b27fe0f572d8d62f00a177d7eb3ccced5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1f7acbe8907c2b74c903bf8b3c527c22c8211e235cc2358a5a200814d2510a1e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12155709716dd82a436b99f7ed1209344bbaca4a3660f32496cc71b74de8d9da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90616d486ffc3487f3aaedfd3bc88573f58fc177da93ad57e1a59210cc2359b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df4ce446eef081aed7ab58bcb243434772e24895a39101a7dcd4cde5e0ca439", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "31b88339313d690b7859435f8701bfd55acacaff96376521768c6f17c856d855", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "79c1336474463a8bcc98504e08c6ceb4fc8e736eaa48e2cf29c3b7c5d8397f11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0da0a1a0c9d9e7dc1cda86c0d333a95f2812adcc7c738256d0d1750104f4b6f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e36c886ed1d7156301b095ad31f5b0723f25ba385a584e4f474f672a1a01f4c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "01d58dc50ca5f902bb7429112cb2a2b751fdfab6a04f0c5ffec21a3009393b7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6dd907b35448520581b950ef443b8fb487bc9867aa9bf283a517ce9a5790086", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74ba48327ac2590614cca2a91ba3495dab606495bbed46faacb23799ef5fa485", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c54b5d64ffd54d208767dbf2daeb16c0364e6bea2ddd32d0f3bcdb27e7065c51", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10470/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "797008b0b4dcbb1d21ee3b1592a68e52d3ea21a6ce70fa1f4f20c5f69745b18e" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17-job.json", + "sha256": "f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.962358+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "10479": { @@ -178534,7 +189245,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10479", "family_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -178548,32 +189259,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "8538bd43d98378c55e248f4f4d2248ceb1e9fbc59d1e510c5bc6326573cba810", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.649797+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10474", - "10476", - "10477", - "10479", - "1047a" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2602d2ad68e08a4045538f0919d254ecef5d5117a8210a3b8dbc508e27538e43", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:51.075701+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 c38a62fb477a711ae579489c1478b8f1afe5fadf8474a153546f5085c4e5ee9f", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10470-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bd625546c17e03e98838a125657d09eacc81daa7b549e3efcf68586d8f1194a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "20bc1c132fda81b41c0d8b31480ff68a12030d112ac919d1ee889cdaba6ea806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1e405278eb144f3f3d653ef8f9a4db13aa189d8dfef55a92971ecb3d82b282a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0dece6615c9a8d8b2e7020a7e6f91f39ebd8dd530948699615d074cbfe43266d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9839f8f1e27a0ff5124e7440e5f680cf734a7d71b7901914c1839cc3c46b65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9abd07f393655c3a1e6549d7caa556cb57c6177b827d0371cf2810bff655430a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2034a1bcc4de1123dcc0360510150e655c4bc0e0a669b16e618d92c8a1fa62ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4af1e4375d607d0587f1db44f724cf924079189f35bd926504e21dd773e6de84", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "096ec1689828fbaaff0397b6c032747ab7320ec3fc5d7afef687effdf1a25dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0919cd59b0a1bd4a0152e02dd40542af639d7850b3c8bf9b7b87ccdc03d770c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-original.ppm", + "sha256": "334f2bc0dc3a27d7076e90190e72710e7cdb24791a1eb577a24c1971c15945f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bb6fb8b793c4b5157957040ed29dceb3748ce4c74fb3307f0c1a3f16fb3072a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b630f5d34fa1bcc3bf848ef8c7bef453e177d43656fdb75ac3ff2cb93d9b499e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "485032866f5d6e8d6f6ceafbe2a5f6ad3a34aa67bddafe93397a8758a807e651", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "24cf3b3210de0257ceb7a9cec5874514d4daf1dce28aa4ae0eadc75c8b1dc94b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6b31d0c586f1f3fc418e58460984b97954239c85c3912f1486221c9cb78892a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a961c58cb6bd7a880cf9f1775d5a24c2695a1ccdbea647b0dbd6f4c07d1cb78f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d415bf900ebff6f7a7af34b0de2f017b3fa9d3a40fa1f2b4ea2d5550d6be51f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ecdea058c1e8471850defc02e296fc32641cb8f088846b27c7ca694666c9672f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e1095c48a16d0e7481edaf8fbedd1443ad5151d60b8447ed06a6dcc56e999a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-original.ppm", + "sha256": "64214d0fb30168d098dce502c30b1481827439ba4a12ac33c36d2969ae4f9cd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b63aa408a9dc740fd32ca4224a7affe26b71d47ed05df5d761a8426ac18172f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9aa2417cfa39e82db3c868b9a220adf16167fabc2326fe2ecbcda43b8809e2df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cd72651ff813d84b0e75ba66e36369c337817736bf42a49605ebd888d53a8462", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e56ac217b8a215f5c2b87e15104bc8cde3c2bdf613b5289c31860b5c4e1cb227", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05909a594988a6f74f8e0702c6869d0a02d048ddad9f8f272342319e0f9f1d5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2b1e3df24742e69f757554ed3c1d40962c0a76e485c54d0490afe4f621310ac6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e999ce4d31407ce10a5dd5a68a942afd8f741ac5032cf54a247506bcdb427005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5131e4908efbe1b47f0afd25a47bebfeff017e82f72c936e12fce03e75f0374e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e984aa369db6628cbcd912d27b23404131f9eb709b35fb7cded6644e8436302d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-original.ppm", + "sha256": "175210f0e0f8f4f12e52e6499964f921a6f78eb1b5e9d8babbe7552bfb1a5cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4672b70ea6ed108a16a13323e59088065413036142910239b409e532e324bea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9b5e01b8e84118e1facb7e6fbfd0f86fa8d94dbeab484a8db9e6d6534224db3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "909996c4446ec4595dd198d0fdc8f9417066cb72764933d87c1eadce4f4c786e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ed1508b9a886f776ef5cd472b60624c85f4f61fa1a1068977335525b963257b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7deecc5150ee6e6546df8c7b459d3a2de97afc3c0d26302b0daeaed767dccb2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7f4fc524342dba04c5768162dfb438c2dbe1fab5c8046e68c3c6e9b2fb3df6c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acd3d077b4a5693673ed730aef43684eebca298e6a68c6c4520c64430eaaceb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "91f02513747527b8601f2daf7bec364b081d576d74b73d07fb88097cebca1781", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "116797ac4574103c8397cd8e62484ee797cbca4fc9f5df621be219dcf071c9bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6c1de18299c04cb685160345d40628ff0419e700e7e442fc313167d7cb04a995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bff5413151f8d435e9ba967964998577b0b5f968a03884ce7ea26ce83b9a8060", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "315e7df7dd072a2652747d825ad15aedb8bbedd41c70291f534ceb99a8087b0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6a2aa7c38dc9c25b6e431f10b8e8a759ff7f0fb3d306d7f36d6e5c7aa304fd88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b911113afefb1055e916b2bd51fe1010aeca8c18c0b47064dfe5aa6182c025", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c5bff6a3448fdfc8693d0eb9fd87b34864ecbaee9bcf69ea33e642eaa8dda5f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5237519282cf98bc9aa180a99d449d8042dc9c8ae8538055bcaecacf6f4f55c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "880bd7dacf659719329b93f0cd2618c5a3934cc016d346706af45d55cc4bd97d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "62a3aa099d63717345d62d4658a93b3f53977792dac07740ad30e0e6dfe18264", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "16eede0f48eb3b6c02f2eb36a153812165dd414e85c49af884306402c182d7c6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d2fef3ea65b658e9058ccf8c48d5eea2543685a8acaf8bfc75e0ea5977973287", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0a817f9a2ace8d3dbb7593b5881e8db39e13d57b86ca7f5d04753bda4f791c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8daf0b00f06a97b439b9d6b7681b323f87b61f7e3be8cb16fc79fc3874cdb2a3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3d40f4364a93ea0e190766527d2f2beed1b232d7699642da0797bf2673b151de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "58aa2a4eb56cffc655954900066d6e726f2beb136e8fd33d14fe1c492b758da6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c364869538cf858d60171bcd5e55c4b64a39073585309425b7c61e78f2b0d38a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e828b91490e6657ae11201a7156d0cec8994987112a5cd7bb8d923ca239a481c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bbae96ec0b7e41c83592b7de4f2ab81cb31b37c803da239d4f3f679d07a37a24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "87c6619f0bb38a0458f96762b9e5aa18e85220dbf829752a129d7d5b1de8eee1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "92e40c4e8704c0a7604709b5b5fe4a8dd3b89ce11448e7e794ea522592d2a63f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "71b605246a09e679b8db2fa18d9ce3112b41e914fbd78d59aebfb1b21b1b3481", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0e5ef1d99d10bcafefce408b3fde6de259ffb1e0025894782de617247543efc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b30120203184a2ac8d7837d4d0ec7c6827c47fa85587bd55a2093eea326e5626", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5daa0ceba44cc1bed48feb4a2503b7dabf9cc7da37061ce18672f8f0d585c1a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3c12481dc1fb93f96df4c408aff753fb66d9a1b019bd76e9b4c39e9ba5673984", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fcc854c50e172cad85c37169048cfe2f2ccaec7d521bb27e62582d42f47c208b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1d2fe02669628fd79ce7feb1800816c630176b96ba6c6921614192bd4c1d217", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "41afe953c64acb133b1b5614015c331b27fe0f572d8d62f00a177d7eb3ccced5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1f7acbe8907c2b74c903bf8b3c527c22c8211e235cc2358a5a200814d2510a1e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12155709716dd82a436b99f7ed1209344bbaca4a3660f32496cc71b74de8d9da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90616d486ffc3487f3aaedfd3bc88573f58fc177da93ad57e1a59210cc2359b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df4ce446eef081aed7ab58bcb243434772e24895a39101a7dcd4cde5e0ca439", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "31b88339313d690b7859435f8701bfd55acacaff96376521768c6f17c856d855", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "79c1336474463a8bcc98504e08c6ceb4fc8e736eaa48e2cf29c3b7c5d8397f11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0da0a1a0c9d9e7dc1cda86c0d333a95f2812adcc7c738256d0d1750104f4b6f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e36c886ed1d7156301b095ad31f5b0723f25ba385a584e4f474f672a1a01f4c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "01d58dc50ca5f902bb7429112cb2a2b751fdfab6a04f0c5ffec21a3009393b7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6dd907b35448520581b950ef443b8fb487bc9867aa9bf283a517ce9a5790086", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74ba48327ac2590614cca2a91ba3495dab606495bbed46faacb23799ef5fa485", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c54b5d64ffd54d208767dbf2daeb16c0364e6bea2ddd32d0f3bcdb27e7065c51", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10470/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "797008b0b4dcbb1d21ee3b1592a68e52d3ea21a6ce70fa1f4f20c5f69745b18e" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17-job.json", + "sha256": "f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.962358+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "1047a": { @@ -178595,7 +189737,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1047a", "family_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -178609,32 +189751,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "8538bd43d98378c55e248f4f4d2248ceb1e9fbc59d1e510c5bc6326573cba810", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.649797+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10474", - "10476", - "10477", - "10479", - "1047a" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2602d2ad68e08a4045538f0919d254ecef5d5117a8210a3b8dbc508e27538e43", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:51.075701+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 c38a62fb477a711ae579489c1478b8f1afe5fadf8474a153546f5085c4e5ee9f", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10470-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bd625546c17e03e98838a125657d09eacc81daa7b549e3efcf68586d8f1194a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "20bc1c132fda81b41c0d8b31480ff68a12030d112ac919d1ee889cdaba6ea806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1e405278eb144f3f3d653ef8f9a4db13aa189d8dfef55a92971ecb3d82b282a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0dece6615c9a8d8b2e7020a7e6f91f39ebd8dd530948699615d074cbfe43266d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9839f8f1e27a0ff5124e7440e5f680cf734a7d71b7901914c1839cc3c46b65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9abd07f393655c3a1e6549d7caa556cb57c6177b827d0371cf2810bff655430a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2034a1bcc4de1123dcc0360510150e655c4bc0e0a669b16e618d92c8a1fa62ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4af1e4375d607d0587f1db44f724cf924079189f35bd926504e21dd773e6de84", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "096ec1689828fbaaff0397b6c032747ab7320ec3fc5d7afef687effdf1a25dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0919cd59b0a1bd4a0152e02dd40542af639d7850b3c8bf9b7b87ccdc03d770c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-original.ppm", + "sha256": "334f2bc0dc3a27d7076e90190e72710e7cdb24791a1eb577a24c1971c15945f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bb6fb8b793c4b5157957040ed29dceb3748ce4c74fb3307f0c1a3f16fb3072a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b630f5d34fa1bcc3bf848ef8c7bef453e177d43656fdb75ac3ff2cb93d9b499e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "485032866f5d6e8d6f6ceafbe2a5f6ad3a34aa67bddafe93397a8758a807e651", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "24cf3b3210de0257ceb7a9cec5874514d4daf1dce28aa4ae0eadc75c8b1dc94b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6b31d0c586f1f3fc418e58460984b97954239c85c3912f1486221c9cb78892a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a961c58cb6bd7a880cf9f1775d5a24c2695a1ccdbea647b0dbd6f4c07d1cb78f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d415bf900ebff6f7a7af34b0de2f017b3fa9d3a40fa1f2b4ea2d5550d6be51f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ecdea058c1e8471850defc02e296fc32641cb8f088846b27c7ca694666c9672f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e1095c48a16d0e7481edaf8fbedd1443ad5151d60b8447ed06a6dcc56e999a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-original.ppm", + "sha256": "64214d0fb30168d098dce502c30b1481827439ba4a12ac33c36d2969ae4f9cd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b63aa408a9dc740fd32ca4224a7affe26b71d47ed05df5d761a8426ac18172f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9aa2417cfa39e82db3c868b9a220adf16167fabc2326fe2ecbcda43b8809e2df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cd72651ff813d84b0e75ba66e36369c337817736bf42a49605ebd888d53a8462", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e56ac217b8a215f5c2b87e15104bc8cde3c2bdf613b5289c31860b5c4e1cb227", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05909a594988a6f74f8e0702c6869d0a02d048ddad9f8f272342319e0f9f1d5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2b1e3df24742e69f757554ed3c1d40962c0a76e485c54d0490afe4f621310ac6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e999ce4d31407ce10a5dd5a68a942afd8f741ac5032cf54a247506bcdb427005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5131e4908efbe1b47f0afd25a47bebfeff017e82f72c936e12fce03e75f0374e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e984aa369db6628cbcd912d27b23404131f9eb709b35fb7cded6644e8436302d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-original.ppm", + "sha256": "175210f0e0f8f4f12e52e6499964f921a6f78eb1b5e9d8babbe7552bfb1a5cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4672b70ea6ed108a16a13323e59088065413036142910239b409e532e324bea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9b5e01b8e84118e1facb7e6fbfd0f86fa8d94dbeab484a8db9e6d6534224db3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "909996c4446ec4595dd198d0fdc8f9417066cb72764933d87c1eadce4f4c786e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ed1508b9a886f776ef5cd472b60624c85f4f61fa1a1068977335525b963257b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7deecc5150ee6e6546df8c7b459d3a2de97afc3c0d26302b0daeaed767dccb2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7f4fc524342dba04c5768162dfb438c2dbe1fab5c8046e68c3c6e9b2fb3df6c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acd3d077b4a5693673ed730aef43684eebca298e6a68c6c4520c64430eaaceb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "91f02513747527b8601f2daf7bec364b081d576d74b73d07fb88097cebca1781", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "116797ac4574103c8397cd8e62484ee797cbca4fc9f5df621be219dcf071c9bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6c1de18299c04cb685160345d40628ff0419e700e7e442fc313167d7cb04a995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bff5413151f8d435e9ba967964998577b0b5f968a03884ce7ea26ce83b9a8060", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "315e7df7dd072a2652747d825ad15aedb8bbedd41c70291f534ceb99a8087b0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6a2aa7c38dc9c25b6e431f10b8e8a759ff7f0fb3d306d7f36d6e5c7aa304fd88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b911113afefb1055e916b2bd51fe1010aeca8c18c0b47064dfe5aa6182c025", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c5bff6a3448fdfc8693d0eb9fd87b34864ecbaee9bcf69ea33e642eaa8dda5f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5237519282cf98bc9aa180a99d449d8042dc9c8ae8538055bcaecacf6f4f55c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "880bd7dacf659719329b93f0cd2618c5a3934cc016d346706af45d55cc4bd97d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "62a3aa099d63717345d62d4658a93b3f53977792dac07740ad30e0e6dfe18264", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "16eede0f48eb3b6c02f2eb36a153812165dd414e85c49af884306402c182d7c6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d2fef3ea65b658e9058ccf8c48d5eea2543685a8acaf8bfc75e0ea5977973287", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0a817f9a2ace8d3dbb7593b5881e8db39e13d57b86ca7f5d04753bda4f791c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8daf0b00f06a97b439b9d6b7681b323f87b61f7e3be8cb16fc79fc3874cdb2a3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3d40f4364a93ea0e190766527d2f2beed1b232d7699642da0797bf2673b151de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "58aa2a4eb56cffc655954900066d6e726f2beb136e8fd33d14fe1c492b758da6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c364869538cf858d60171bcd5e55c4b64a39073585309425b7c61e78f2b0d38a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e828b91490e6657ae11201a7156d0cec8994987112a5cd7bb8d923ca239a481c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bbae96ec0b7e41c83592b7de4f2ab81cb31b37c803da239d4f3f679d07a37a24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "87c6619f0bb38a0458f96762b9e5aa18e85220dbf829752a129d7d5b1de8eee1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "92e40c4e8704c0a7604709b5b5fe4a8dd3b89ce11448e7e794ea522592d2a63f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "71b605246a09e679b8db2fa18d9ce3112b41e914fbd78d59aebfb1b21b1b3481", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0e5ef1d99d10bcafefce408b3fde6de259ffb1e0025894782de617247543efc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b30120203184a2ac8d7837d4d0ec7c6827c47fa85587bd55a2093eea326e5626", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5daa0ceba44cc1bed48feb4a2503b7dabf9cc7da37061ce18672f8f0d585c1a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3c12481dc1fb93f96df4c408aff753fb66d9a1b019bd76e9b4c39e9ba5673984", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fcc854c50e172cad85c37169048cfe2f2ccaec7d521bb27e62582d42f47c208b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1d2fe02669628fd79ce7feb1800816c630176b96ba6c6921614192bd4c1d217", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "41afe953c64acb133b1b5614015c331b27fe0f572d8d62f00a177d7eb3ccced5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1f7acbe8907c2b74c903bf8b3c527c22c8211e235cc2358a5a200814d2510a1e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12155709716dd82a436b99f7ed1209344bbaca4a3660f32496cc71b74de8d9da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90616d486ffc3487f3aaedfd3bc88573f58fc177da93ad57e1a59210cc2359b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df4ce446eef081aed7ab58bcb243434772e24895a39101a7dcd4cde5e0ca439", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "31b88339313d690b7859435f8701bfd55acacaff96376521768c6f17c856d855", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "79c1336474463a8bcc98504e08c6ceb4fc8e736eaa48e2cf29c3b7c5d8397f11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0da0a1a0c9d9e7dc1cda86c0d333a95f2812adcc7c738256d0d1750104f4b6f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e36c886ed1d7156301b095ad31f5b0723f25ba385a584e4f474f672a1a01f4c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "01d58dc50ca5f902bb7429112cb2a2b751fdfab6a04f0c5ffec21a3009393b7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6dd907b35448520581b950ef443b8fb487bc9867aa9bf283a517ce9a5790086", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74ba48327ac2590614cca2a91ba3495dab606495bbed46faacb23799ef5fa485", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c54b5d64ffd54d208767dbf2daeb16c0364e6bea2ddd32d0f3bcdb27e7065c51", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10470/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "797008b0b4dcbb1d21ee3b1592a68e52d3ea21a6ce70fa1f4f20c5f69745b18e" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17-job.json", + "sha256": "f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.962358+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "1047b": { @@ -178656,7 +190229,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1047b", "family_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -178670,32 +190243,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "8538bd43d98378c55e248f4f4d2248ceb1e9fbc59d1e510c5bc6326573cba810", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.649797+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10474", - "10476", - "10477", - "10479", - "1047a" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2602d2ad68e08a4045538f0919d254ecef5d5117a8210a3b8dbc508e27538e43", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:51.075701+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 c38a62fb477a711ae579489c1478b8f1afe5fadf8474a153546f5085c4e5ee9f", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10470-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bd625546c17e03e98838a125657d09eacc81daa7b549e3efcf68586d8f1194a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "20bc1c132fda81b41c0d8b31480ff68a12030d112ac919d1ee889cdaba6ea806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1e405278eb144f3f3d653ef8f9a4db13aa189d8dfef55a92971ecb3d82b282a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0dece6615c9a8d8b2e7020a7e6f91f39ebd8dd530948699615d074cbfe43266d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9839f8f1e27a0ff5124e7440e5f680cf734a7d71b7901914c1839cc3c46b65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9abd07f393655c3a1e6549d7caa556cb57c6177b827d0371cf2810bff655430a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2034a1bcc4de1123dcc0360510150e655c4bc0e0a669b16e618d92c8a1fa62ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4af1e4375d607d0587f1db44f724cf924079189f35bd926504e21dd773e6de84", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "096ec1689828fbaaff0397b6c032747ab7320ec3fc5d7afef687effdf1a25dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0919cd59b0a1bd4a0152e02dd40542af639d7850b3c8bf9b7b87ccdc03d770c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-original.ppm", + "sha256": "334f2bc0dc3a27d7076e90190e72710e7cdb24791a1eb577a24c1971c15945f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bb6fb8b793c4b5157957040ed29dceb3748ce4c74fb3307f0c1a3f16fb3072a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b630f5d34fa1bcc3bf848ef8c7bef453e177d43656fdb75ac3ff2cb93d9b499e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "485032866f5d6e8d6f6ceafbe2a5f6ad3a34aa67bddafe93397a8758a807e651", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "24cf3b3210de0257ceb7a9cec5874514d4daf1dce28aa4ae0eadc75c8b1dc94b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6b31d0c586f1f3fc418e58460984b97954239c85c3912f1486221c9cb78892a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a961c58cb6bd7a880cf9f1775d5a24c2695a1ccdbea647b0dbd6f4c07d1cb78f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d415bf900ebff6f7a7af34b0de2f017b3fa9d3a40fa1f2b4ea2d5550d6be51f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ecdea058c1e8471850defc02e296fc32641cb8f088846b27c7ca694666c9672f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e1095c48a16d0e7481edaf8fbedd1443ad5151d60b8447ed06a6dcc56e999a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-original.ppm", + "sha256": "64214d0fb30168d098dce502c30b1481827439ba4a12ac33c36d2969ae4f9cd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b63aa408a9dc740fd32ca4224a7affe26b71d47ed05df5d761a8426ac18172f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9aa2417cfa39e82db3c868b9a220adf16167fabc2326fe2ecbcda43b8809e2df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cd72651ff813d84b0e75ba66e36369c337817736bf42a49605ebd888d53a8462", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e56ac217b8a215f5c2b87e15104bc8cde3c2bdf613b5289c31860b5c4e1cb227", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05909a594988a6f74f8e0702c6869d0a02d048ddad9f8f272342319e0f9f1d5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2b1e3df24742e69f757554ed3c1d40962c0a76e485c54d0490afe4f621310ac6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e999ce4d31407ce10a5dd5a68a942afd8f741ac5032cf54a247506bcdb427005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5131e4908efbe1b47f0afd25a47bebfeff017e82f72c936e12fce03e75f0374e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e984aa369db6628cbcd912d27b23404131f9eb709b35fb7cded6644e8436302d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-original.ppm", + "sha256": "175210f0e0f8f4f12e52e6499964f921a6f78eb1b5e9d8babbe7552bfb1a5cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4672b70ea6ed108a16a13323e59088065413036142910239b409e532e324bea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9b5e01b8e84118e1facb7e6fbfd0f86fa8d94dbeab484a8db9e6d6534224db3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "909996c4446ec4595dd198d0fdc8f9417066cb72764933d87c1eadce4f4c786e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ed1508b9a886f776ef5cd472b60624c85f4f61fa1a1068977335525b963257b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7deecc5150ee6e6546df8c7b459d3a2de97afc3c0d26302b0daeaed767dccb2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7f4fc524342dba04c5768162dfb438c2dbe1fab5c8046e68c3c6e9b2fb3df6c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acd3d077b4a5693673ed730aef43684eebca298e6a68c6c4520c64430eaaceb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "91f02513747527b8601f2daf7bec364b081d576d74b73d07fb88097cebca1781", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "116797ac4574103c8397cd8e62484ee797cbca4fc9f5df621be219dcf071c9bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6c1de18299c04cb685160345d40628ff0419e700e7e442fc313167d7cb04a995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bff5413151f8d435e9ba967964998577b0b5f968a03884ce7ea26ce83b9a8060", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "315e7df7dd072a2652747d825ad15aedb8bbedd41c70291f534ceb99a8087b0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6a2aa7c38dc9c25b6e431f10b8e8a759ff7f0fb3d306d7f36d6e5c7aa304fd88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b911113afefb1055e916b2bd51fe1010aeca8c18c0b47064dfe5aa6182c025", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c5bff6a3448fdfc8693d0eb9fd87b34864ecbaee9bcf69ea33e642eaa8dda5f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5237519282cf98bc9aa180a99d449d8042dc9c8ae8538055bcaecacf6f4f55c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "880bd7dacf659719329b93f0cd2618c5a3934cc016d346706af45d55cc4bd97d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "62a3aa099d63717345d62d4658a93b3f53977792dac07740ad30e0e6dfe18264", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "16eede0f48eb3b6c02f2eb36a153812165dd414e85c49af884306402c182d7c6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d2fef3ea65b658e9058ccf8c48d5eea2543685a8acaf8bfc75e0ea5977973287", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0a817f9a2ace8d3dbb7593b5881e8db39e13d57b86ca7f5d04753bda4f791c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8daf0b00f06a97b439b9d6b7681b323f87b61f7e3be8cb16fc79fc3874cdb2a3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3d40f4364a93ea0e190766527d2f2beed1b232d7699642da0797bf2673b151de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "58aa2a4eb56cffc655954900066d6e726f2beb136e8fd33d14fe1c492b758da6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c364869538cf858d60171bcd5e55c4b64a39073585309425b7c61e78f2b0d38a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e828b91490e6657ae11201a7156d0cec8994987112a5cd7bb8d923ca239a481c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bbae96ec0b7e41c83592b7de4f2ab81cb31b37c803da239d4f3f679d07a37a24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "87c6619f0bb38a0458f96762b9e5aa18e85220dbf829752a129d7d5b1de8eee1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "92e40c4e8704c0a7604709b5b5fe4a8dd3b89ce11448e7e794ea522592d2a63f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "71b605246a09e679b8db2fa18d9ce3112b41e914fbd78d59aebfb1b21b1b3481", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0e5ef1d99d10bcafefce408b3fde6de259ffb1e0025894782de617247543efc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b30120203184a2ac8d7837d4d0ec7c6827c47fa85587bd55a2093eea326e5626", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5daa0ceba44cc1bed48feb4a2503b7dabf9cc7da37061ce18672f8f0d585c1a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3c12481dc1fb93f96df4c408aff753fb66d9a1b019bd76e9b4c39e9ba5673984", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fcc854c50e172cad85c37169048cfe2f2ccaec7d521bb27e62582d42f47c208b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1d2fe02669628fd79ce7feb1800816c630176b96ba6c6921614192bd4c1d217", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "41afe953c64acb133b1b5614015c331b27fe0f572d8d62f00a177d7eb3ccced5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1f7acbe8907c2b74c903bf8b3c527c22c8211e235cc2358a5a200814d2510a1e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12155709716dd82a436b99f7ed1209344bbaca4a3660f32496cc71b74de8d9da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90616d486ffc3487f3aaedfd3bc88573f58fc177da93ad57e1a59210cc2359b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df4ce446eef081aed7ab58bcb243434772e24895a39101a7dcd4cde5e0ca439", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "31b88339313d690b7859435f8701bfd55acacaff96376521768c6f17c856d855", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "79c1336474463a8bcc98504e08c6ceb4fc8e736eaa48e2cf29c3b7c5d8397f11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0da0a1a0c9d9e7dc1cda86c0d333a95f2812adcc7c738256d0d1750104f4b6f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e36c886ed1d7156301b095ad31f5b0723f25ba385a584e4f474f672a1a01f4c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "01d58dc50ca5f902bb7429112cb2a2b751fdfab6a04f0c5ffec21a3009393b7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6dd907b35448520581b950ef443b8fb487bc9867aa9bf283a517ce9a5790086", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74ba48327ac2590614cca2a91ba3495dab606495bbed46faacb23799ef5fa485", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c54b5d64ffd54d208767dbf2daeb16c0364e6bea2ddd32d0f3bcdb27e7065c51", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10470/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "797008b0b4dcbb1d21ee3b1592a68e52d3ea21a6ce70fa1f4f20c5f69745b18e" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17-job.json", + "sha256": "f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.962358+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "1047c": { @@ -178717,7 +190721,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1047c", "family_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -178731,32 +190735,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "8538bd43d98378c55e248f4f4d2248ceb1e9fbc59d1e510c5bc6326573cba810", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.649797+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10474", - "10476", - "10477", - "10479", - "1047a" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2602d2ad68e08a4045538f0919d254ecef5d5117a8210a3b8dbc508e27538e43", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:51.075701+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 c38a62fb477a711ae579489c1478b8f1afe5fadf8474a153546f5085c4e5ee9f", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10470-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bd625546c17e03e98838a125657d09eacc81daa7b549e3efcf68586d8f1194a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "20bc1c132fda81b41c0d8b31480ff68a12030d112ac919d1ee889cdaba6ea806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1e405278eb144f3f3d653ef8f9a4db13aa189d8dfef55a92971ecb3d82b282a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0dece6615c9a8d8b2e7020a7e6f91f39ebd8dd530948699615d074cbfe43266d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9839f8f1e27a0ff5124e7440e5f680cf734a7d71b7901914c1839cc3c46b65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9abd07f393655c3a1e6549d7caa556cb57c6177b827d0371cf2810bff655430a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2034a1bcc4de1123dcc0360510150e655c4bc0e0a669b16e618d92c8a1fa62ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4af1e4375d607d0587f1db44f724cf924079189f35bd926504e21dd773e6de84", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "096ec1689828fbaaff0397b6c032747ab7320ec3fc5d7afef687effdf1a25dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0919cd59b0a1bd4a0152e02dd40542af639d7850b3c8bf9b7b87ccdc03d770c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-original.ppm", + "sha256": "334f2bc0dc3a27d7076e90190e72710e7cdb24791a1eb577a24c1971c15945f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bb6fb8b793c4b5157957040ed29dceb3748ce4c74fb3307f0c1a3f16fb3072a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b630f5d34fa1bcc3bf848ef8c7bef453e177d43656fdb75ac3ff2cb93d9b499e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "485032866f5d6e8d6f6ceafbe2a5f6ad3a34aa67bddafe93397a8758a807e651", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "24cf3b3210de0257ceb7a9cec5874514d4daf1dce28aa4ae0eadc75c8b1dc94b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6b31d0c586f1f3fc418e58460984b97954239c85c3912f1486221c9cb78892a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a961c58cb6bd7a880cf9f1775d5a24c2695a1ccdbea647b0dbd6f4c07d1cb78f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d415bf900ebff6f7a7af34b0de2f017b3fa9d3a40fa1f2b4ea2d5550d6be51f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ecdea058c1e8471850defc02e296fc32641cb8f088846b27c7ca694666c9672f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e1095c48a16d0e7481edaf8fbedd1443ad5151d60b8447ed06a6dcc56e999a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-original.ppm", + "sha256": "64214d0fb30168d098dce502c30b1481827439ba4a12ac33c36d2969ae4f9cd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b63aa408a9dc740fd32ca4224a7affe26b71d47ed05df5d761a8426ac18172f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9aa2417cfa39e82db3c868b9a220adf16167fabc2326fe2ecbcda43b8809e2df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cd72651ff813d84b0e75ba66e36369c337817736bf42a49605ebd888d53a8462", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e56ac217b8a215f5c2b87e15104bc8cde3c2bdf613b5289c31860b5c4e1cb227", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05909a594988a6f74f8e0702c6869d0a02d048ddad9f8f272342319e0f9f1d5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2b1e3df24742e69f757554ed3c1d40962c0a76e485c54d0490afe4f621310ac6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e999ce4d31407ce10a5dd5a68a942afd8f741ac5032cf54a247506bcdb427005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5131e4908efbe1b47f0afd25a47bebfeff017e82f72c936e12fce03e75f0374e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e984aa369db6628cbcd912d27b23404131f9eb709b35fb7cded6644e8436302d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-original.ppm", + "sha256": "175210f0e0f8f4f12e52e6499964f921a6f78eb1b5e9d8babbe7552bfb1a5cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4672b70ea6ed108a16a13323e59088065413036142910239b409e532e324bea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9b5e01b8e84118e1facb7e6fbfd0f86fa8d94dbeab484a8db9e6d6534224db3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "909996c4446ec4595dd198d0fdc8f9417066cb72764933d87c1eadce4f4c786e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ed1508b9a886f776ef5cd472b60624c85f4f61fa1a1068977335525b963257b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7deecc5150ee6e6546df8c7b459d3a2de97afc3c0d26302b0daeaed767dccb2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7f4fc524342dba04c5768162dfb438c2dbe1fab5c8046e68c3c6e9b2fb3df6c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acd3d077b4a5693673ed730aef43684eebca298e6a68c6c4520c64430eaaceb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "91f02513747527b8601f2daf7bec364b081d576d74b73d07fb88097cebca1781", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "116797ac4574103c8397cd8e62484ee797cbca4fc9f5df621be219dcf071c9bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6c1de18299c04cb685160345d40628ff0419e700e7e442fc313167d7cb04a995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bff5413151f8d435e9ba967964998577b0b5f968a03884ce7ea26ce83b9a8060", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "315e7df7dd072a2652747d825ad15aedb8bbedd41c70291f534ceb99a8087b0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6a2aa7c38dc9c25b6e431f10b8e8a759ff7f0fb3d306d7f36d6e5c7aa304fd88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b911113afefb1055e916b2bd51fe1010aeca8c18c0b47064dfe5aa6182c025", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c5bff6a3448fdfc8693d0eb9fd87b34864ecbaee9bcf69ea33e642eaa8dda5f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5237519282cf98bc9aa180a99d449d8042dc9c8ae8538055bcaecacf6f4f55c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "880bd7dacf659719329b93f0cd2618c5a3934cc016d346706af45d55cc4bd97d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "62a3aa099d63717345d62d4658a93b3f53977792dac07740ad30e0e6dfe18264", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "16eede0f48eb3b6c02f2eb36a153812165dd414e85c49af884306402c182d7c6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d2fef3ea65b658e9058ccf8c48d5eea2543685a8acaf8bfc75e0ea5977973287", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0a817f9a2ace8d3dbb7593b5881e8db39e13d57b86ca7f5d04753bda4f791c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8daf0b00f06a97b439b9d6b7681b323f87b61f7e3be8cb16fc79fc3874cdb2a3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3d40f4364a93ea0e190766527d2f2beed1b232d7699642da0797bf2673b151de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "58aa2a4eb56cffc655954900066d6e726f2beb136e8fd33d14fe1c492b758da6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c364869538cf858d60171bcd5e55c4b64a39073585309425b7c61e78f2b0d38a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e828b91490e6657ae11201a7156d0cec8994987112a5cd7bb8d923ca239a481c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bbae96ec0b7e41c83592b7de4f2ab81cb31b37c803da239d4f3f679d07a37a24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "87c6619f0bb38a0458f96762b9e5aa18e85220dbf829752a129d7d5b1de8eee1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "92e40c4e8704c0a7604709b5b5fe4a8dd3b89ce11448e7e794ea522592d2a63f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "71b605246a09e679b8db2fa18d9ce3112b41e914fbd78d59aebfb1b21b1b3481", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0e5ef1d99d10bcafefce408b3fde6de259ffb1e0025894782de617247543efc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b30120203184a2ac8d7837d4d0ec7c6827c47fa85587bd55a2093eea326e5626", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5daa0ceba44cc1bed48feb4a2503b7dabf9cc7da37061ce18672f8f0d585c1a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3c12481dc1fb93f96df4c408aff753fb66d9a1b019bd76e9b4c39e9ba5673984", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fcc854c50e172cad85c37169048cfe2f2ccaec7d521bb27e62582d42f47c208b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1d2fe02669628fd79ce7feb1800816c630176b96ba6c6921614192bd4c1d217", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "41afe953c64acb133b1b5614015c331b27fe0f572d8d62f00a177d7eb3ccced5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1f7acbe8907c2b74c903bf8b3c527c22c8211e235cc2358a5a200814d2510a1e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12155709716dd82a436b99f7ed1209344bbaca4a3660f32496cc71b74de8d9da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90616d486ffc3487f3aaedfd3bc88573f58fc177da93ad57e1a59210cc2359b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df4ce446eef081aed7ab58bcb243434772e24895a39101a7dcd4cde5e0ca439", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "31b88339313d690b7859435f8701bfd55acacaff96376521768c6f17c856d855", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "79c1336474463a8bcc98504e08c6ceb4fc8e736eaa48e2cf29c3b7c5d8397f11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0da0a1a0c9d9e7dc1cda86c0d333a95f2812adcc7c738256d0d1750104f4b6f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e36c886ed1d7156301b095ad31f5b0723f25ba385a584e4f474f672a1a01f4c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "01d58dc50ca5f902bb7429112cb2a2b751fdfab6a04f0c5ffec21a3009393b7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6dd907b35448520581b950ef443b8fb487bc9867aa9bf283a517ce9a5790086", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74ba48327ac2590614cca2a91ba3495dab606495bbed46faacb23799ef5fa485", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c54b5d64ffd54d208767dbf2daeb16c0364e6bea2ddd32d0f3bcdb27e7065c51", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10470/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "797008b0b4dcbb1d21ee3b1592a68e52d3ea21a6ce70fa1f4f20c5f69745b18e" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17-job.json", + "sha256": "f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.962358+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "1047d": { @@ -178778,7 +191213,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1047d", "family_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -178792,32 +191227,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "8538bd43d98378c55e248f4f4d2248ceb1e9fbc59d1e510c5bc6326573cba810", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.649797+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10474", - "10476", - "10477", - "10479", - "1047a" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2602d2ad68e08a4045538f0919d254ecef5d5117a8210a3b8dbc508e27538e43", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:51.075701+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 c38a62fb477a711ae579489c1478b8f1afe5fadf8474a153546f5085c4e5ee9f", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10470-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bd625546c17e03e98838a125657d09eacc81daa7b549e3efcf68586d8f1194a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "20bc1c132fda81b41c0d8b31480ff68a12030d112ac919d1ee889cdaba6ea806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1e405278eb144f3f3d653ef8f9a4db13aa189d8dfef55a92971ecb3d82b282a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0dece6615c9a8d8b2e7020a7e6f91f39ebd8dd530948699615d074cbfe43266d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9839f8f1e27a0ff5124e7440e5f680cf734a7d71b7901914c1839cc3c46b65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9abd07f393655c3a1e6549d7caa556cb57c6177b827d0371cf2810bff655430a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2034a1bcc4de1123dcc0360510150e655c4bc0e0a669b16e618d92c8a1fa62ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4af1e4375d607d0587f1db44f724cf924079189f35bd926504e21dd773e6de84", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "096ec1689828fbaaff0397b6c032747ab7320ec3fc5d7afef687effdf1a25dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0919cd59b0a1bd4a0152e02dd40542af639d7850b3c8bf9b7b87ccdc03d770c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-original.ppm", + "sha256": "334f2bc0dc3a27d7076e90190e72710e7cdb24791a1eb577a24c1971c15945f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bb6fb8b793c4b5157957040ed29dceb3748ce4c74fb3307f0c1a3f16fb3072a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b630f5d34fa1bcc3bf848ef8c7bef453e177d43656fdb75ac3ff2cb93d9b499e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "485032866f5d6e8d6f6ceafbe2a5f6ad3a34aa67bddafe93397a8758a807e651", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "24cf3b3210de0257ceb7a9cec5874514d4daf1dce28aa4ae0eadc75c8b1dc94b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6b31d0c586f1f3fc418e58460984b97954239c85c3912f1486221c9cb78892a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a961c58cb6bd7a880cf9f1775d5a24c2695a1ccdbea647b0dbd6f4c07d1cb78f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d415bf900ebff6f7a7af34b0de2f017b3fa9d3a40fa1f2b4ea2d5550d6be51f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ecdea058c1e8471850defc02e296fc32641cb8f088846b27c7ca694666c9672f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e1095c48a16d0e7481edaf8fbedd1443ad5151d60b8447ed06a6dcc56e999a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-original.ppm", + "sha256": "64214d0fb30168d098dce502c30b1481827439ba4a12ac33c36d2969ae4f9cd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b63aa408a9dc740fd32ca4224a7affe26b71d47ed05df5d761a8426ac18172f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9aa2417cfa39e82db3c868b9a220adf16167fabc2326fe2ecbcda43b8809e2df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cd72651ff813d84b0e75ba66e36369c337817736bf42a49605ebd888d53a8462", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e56ac217b8a215f5c2b87e15104bc8cde3c2bdf613b5289c31860b5c4e1cb227", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05909a594988a6f74f8e0702c6869d0a02d048ddad9f8f272342319e0f9f1d5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2b1e3df24742e69f757554ed3c1d40962c0a76e485c54d0490afe4f621310ac6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e999ce4d31407ce10a5dd5a68a942afd8f741ac5032cf54a247506bcdb427005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5131e4908efbe1b47f0afd25a47bebfeff017e82f72c936e12fce03e75f0374e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e984aa369db6628cbcd912d27b23404131f9eb709b35fb7cded6644e8436302d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-original.ppm", + "sha256": "175210f0e0f8f4f12e52e6499964f921a6f78eb1b5e9d8babbe7552bfb1a5cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4672b70ea6ed108a16a13323e59088065413036142910239b409e532e324bea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9b5e01b8e84118e1facb7e6fbfd0f86fa8d94dbeab484a8db9e6d6534224db3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "909996c4446ec4595dd198d0fdc8f9417066cb72764933d87c1eadce4f4c786e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ed1508b9a886f776ef5cd472b60624c85f4f61fa1a1068977335525b963257b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7deecc5150ee6e6546df8c7b459d3a2de97afc3c0d26302b0daeaed767dccb2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7f4fc524342dba04c5768162dfb438c2dbe1fab5c8046e68c3c6e9b2fb3df6c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acd3d077b4a5693673ed730aef43684eebca298e6a68c6c4520c64430eaaceb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "91f02513747527b8601f2daf7bec364b081d576d74b73d07fb88097cebca1781", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "116797ac4574103c8397cd8e62484ee797cbca4fc9f5df621be219dcf071c9bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6c1de18299c04cb685160345d40628ff0419e700e7e442fc313167d7cb04a995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bff5413151f8d435e9ba967964998577b0b5f968a03884ce7ea26ce83b9a8060", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "315e7df7dd072a2652747d825ad15aedb8bbedd41c70291f534ceb99a8087b0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6a2aa7c38dc9c25b6e431f10b8e8a759ff7f0fb3d306d7f36d6e5c7aa304fd88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b911113afefb1055e916b2bd51fe1010aeca8c18c0b47064dfe5aa6182c025", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c5bff6a3448fdfc8693d0eb9fd87b34864ecbaee9bcf69ea33e642eaa8dda5f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5237519282cf98bc9aa180a99d449d8042dc9c8ae8538055bcaecacf6f4f55c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "880bd7dacf659719329b93f0cd2618c5a3934cc016d346706af45d55cc4bd97d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "62a3aa099d63717345d62d4658a93b3f53977792dac07740ad30e0e6dfe18264", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "16eede0f48eb3b6c02f2eb36a153812165dd414e85c49af884306402c182d7c6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d2fef3ea65b658e9058ccf8c48d5eea2543685a8acaf8bfc75e0ea5977973287", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0a817f9a2ace8d3dbb7593b5881e8db39e13d57b86ca7f5d04753bda4f791c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8daf0b00f06a97b439b9d6b7681b323f87b61f7e3be8cb16fc79fc3874cdb2a3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3d40f4364a93ea0e190766527d2f2beed1b232d7699642da0797bf2673b151de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "58aa2a4eb56cffc655954900066d6e726f2beb136e8fd33d14fe1c492b758da6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c364869538cf858d60171bcd5e55c4b64a39073585309425b7c61e78f2b0d38a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e828b91490e6657ae11201a7156d0cec8994987112a5cd7bb8d923ca239a481c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bbae96ec0b7e41c83592b7de4f2ab81cb31b37c803da239d4f3f679d07a37a24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "87c6619f0bb38a0458f96762b9e5aa18e85220dbf829752a129d7d5b1de8eee1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "92e40c4e8704c0a7604709b5b5fe4a8dd3b89ce11448e7e794ea522592d2a63f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "71b605246a09e679b8db2fa18d9ce3112b41e914fbd78d59aebfb1b21b1b3481", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0e5ef1d99d10bcafefce408b3fde6de259ffb1e0025894782de617247543efc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b30120203184a2ac8d7837d4d0ec7c6827c47fa85587bd55a2093eea326e5626", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5daa0ceba44cc1bed48feb4a2503b7dabf9cc7da37061ce18672f8f0d585c1a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3c12481dc1fb93f96df4c408aff753fb66d9a1b019bd76e9b4c39e9ba5673984", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fcc854c50e172cad85c37169048cfe2f2ccaec7d521bb27e62582d42f47c208b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1d2fe02669628fd79ce7feb1800816c630176b96ba6c6921614192bd4c1d217", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "41afe953c64acb133b1b5614015c331b27fe0f572d8d62f00a177d7eb3ccced5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1f7acbe8907c2b74c903bf8b3c527c22c8211e235cc2358a5a200814d2510a1e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12155709716dd82a436b99f7ed1209344bbaca4a3660f32496cc71b74de8d9da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90616d486ffc3487f3aaedfd3bc88573f58fc177da93ad57e1a59210cc2359b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df4ce446eef081aed7ab58bcb243434772e24895a39101a7dcd4cde5e0ca439", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "31b88339313d690b7859435f8701bfd55acacaff96376521768c6f17c856d855", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "79c1336474463a8bcc98504e08c6ceb4fc8e736eaa48e2cf29c3b7c5d8397f11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0da0a1a0c9d9e7dc1cda86c0d333a95f2812adcc7c738256d0d1750104f4b6f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e36c886ed1d7156301b095ad31f5b0723f25ba385a584e4f474f672a1a01f4c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "01d58dc50ca5f902bb7429112cb2a2b751fdfab6a04f0c5ffec21a3009393b7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6dd907b35448520581b950ef443b8fb487bc9867aa9bf283a517ce9a5790086", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74ba48327ac2590614cca2a91ba3495dab606495bbed46faacb23799ef5fa485", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c54b5d64ffd54d208767dbf2daeb16c0364e6bea2ddd32d0f3bcdb27e7065c51", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10470/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "797008b0b4dcbb1d21ee3b1592a68e52d3ea21a6ce70fa1f4f20c5f69745b18e" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17-job.json", + "sha256": "f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.962358+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "1047e": { @@ -178839,7 +191705,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1047e", "family_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -178853,32 +191719,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "8538bd43d98378c55e248f4f4d2248ceb1e9fbc59d1e510c5bc6326573cba810", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.649797+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10474", - "10476", - "10477", - "10479", - "1047a" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2602d2ad68e08a4045538f0919d254ecef5d5117a8210a3b8dbc508e27538e43", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:51.075701+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 c38a62fb477a711ae579489c1478b8f1afe5fadf8474a153546f5085c4e5ee9f", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10470-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bd625546c17e03e98838a125657d09eacc81daa7b549e3efcf68586d8f1194a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "20bc1c132fda81b41c0d8b31480ff68a12030d112ac919d1ee889cdaba6ea806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1e405278eb144f3f3d653ef8f9a4db13aa189d8dfef55a92971ecb3d82b282a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0dece6615c9a8d8b2e7020a7e6f91f39ebd8dd530948699615d074cbfe43266d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9839f8f1e27a0ff5124e7440e5f680cf734a7d71b7901914c1839cc3c46b65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9abd07f393655c3a1e6549d7caa556cb57c6177b827d0371cf2810bff655430a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2034a1bcc4de1123dcc0360510150e655c4bc0e0a669b16e618d92c8a1fa62ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4af1e4375d607d0587f1db44f724cf924079189f35bd926504e21dd773e6de84", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "096ec1689828fbaaff0397b6c032747ab7320ec3fc5d7afef687effdf1a25dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0919cd59b0a1bd4a0152e02dd40542af639d7850b3c8bf9b7b87ccdc03d770c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-original.ppm", + "sha256": "334f2bc0dc3a27d7076e90190e72710e7cdb24791a1eb577a24c1971c15945f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bb6fb8b793c4b5157957040ed29dceb3748ce4c74fb3307f0c1a3f16fb3072a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b630f5d34fa1bcc3bf848ef8c7bef453e177d43656fdb75ac3ff2cb93d9b499e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "485032866f5d6e8d6f6ceafbe2a5f6ad3a34aa67bddafe93397a8758a807e651", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "24cf3b3210de0257ceb7a9cec5874514d4daf1dce28aa4ae0eadc75c8b1dc94b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6b31d0c586f1f3fc418e58460984b97954239c85c3912f1486221c9cb78892a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a961c58cb6bd7a880cf9f1775d5a24c2695a1ccdbea647b0dbd6f4c07d1cb78f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d415bf900ebff6f7a7af34b0de2f017b3fa9d3a40fa1f2b4ea2d5550d6be51f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ecdea058c1e8471850defc02e296fc32641cb8f088846b27c7ca694666c9672f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e1095c48a16d0e7481edaf8fbedd1443ad5151d60b8447ed06a6dcc56e999a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-original.ppm", + "sha256": "64214d0fb30168d098dce502c30b1481827439ba4a12ac33c36d2969ae4f9cd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b63aa408a9dc740fd32ca4224a7affe26b71d47ed05df5d761a8426ac18172f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9aa2417cfa39e82db3c868b9a220adf16167fabc2326fe2ecbcda43b8809e2df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cd72651ff813d84b0e75ba66e36369c337817736bf42a49605ebd888d53a8462", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e56ac217b8a215f5c2b87e15104bc8cde3c2bdf613b5289c31860b5c4e1cb227", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05909a594988a6f74f8e0702c6869d0a02d048ddad9f8f272342319e0f9f1d5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2b1e3df24742e69f757554ed3c1d40962c0a76e485c54d0490afe4f621310ac6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e999ce4d31407ce10a5dd5a68a942afd8f741ac5032cf54a247506bcdb427005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5131e4908efbe1b47f0afd25a47bebfeff017e82f72c936e12fce03e75f0374e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e984aa369db6628cbcd912d27b23404131f9eb709b35fb7cded6644e8436302d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-original.ppm", + "sha256": "175210f0e0f8f4f12e52e6499964f921a6f78eb1b5e9d8babbe7552bfb1a5cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4672b70ea6ed108a16a13323e59088065413036142910239b409e532e324bea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9b5e01b8e84118e1facb7e6fbfd0f86fa8d94dbeab484a8db9e6d6534224db3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "909996c4446ec4595dd198d0fdc8f9417066cb72764933d87c1eadce4f4c786e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ed1508b9a886f776ef5cd472b60624c85f4f61fa1a1068977335525b963257b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7deecc5150ee6e6546df8c7b459d3a2de97afc3c0d26302b0daeaed767dccb2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7f4fc524342dba04c5768162dfb438c2dbe1fab5c8046e68c3c6e9b2fb3df6c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acd3d077b4a5693673ed730aef43684eebca298e6a68c6c4520c64430eaaceb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "91f02513747527b8601f2daf7bec364b081d576d74b73d07fb88097cebca1781", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "116797ac4574103c8397cd8e62484ee797cbca4fc9f5df621be219dcf071c9bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6c1de18299c04cb685160345d40628ff0419e700e7e442fc313167d7cb04a995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bff5413151f8d435e9ba967964998577b0b5f968a03884ce7ea26ce83b9a8060", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "315e7df7dd072a2652747d825ad15aedb8bbedd41c70291f534ceb99a8087b0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6a2aa7c38dc9c25b6e431f10b8e8a759ff7f0fb3d306d7f36d6e5c7aa304fd88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b911113afefb1055e916b2bd51fe1010aeca8c18c0b47064dfe5aa6182c025", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c5bff6a3448fdfc8693d0eb9fd87b34864ecbaee9bcf69ea33e642eaa8dda5f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5237519282cf98bc9aa180a99d449d8042dc9c8ae8538055bcaecacf6f4f55c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "880bd7dacf659719329b93f0cd2618c5a3934cc016d346706af45d55cc4bd97d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "62a3aa099d63717345d62d4658a93b3f53977792dac07740ad30e0e6dfe18264", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "16eede0f48eb3b6c02f2eb36a153812165dd414e85c49af884306402c182d7c6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d2fef3ea65b658e9058ccf8c48d5eea2543685a8acaf8bfc75e0ea5977973287", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0a817f9a2ace8d3dbb7593b5881e8db39e13d57b86ca7f5d04753bda4f791c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8daf0b00f06a97b439b9d6b7681b323f87b61f7e3be8cb16fc79fc3874cdb2a3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3d40f4364a93ea0e190766527d2f2beed1b232d7699642da0797bf2673b151de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "58aa2a4eb56cffc655954900066d6e726f2beb136e8fd33d14fe1c492b758da6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c364869538cf858d60171bcd5e55c4b64a39073585309425b7c61e78f2b0d38a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e828b91490e6657ae11201a7156d0cec8994987112a5cd7bb8d923ca239a481c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bbae96ec0b7e41c83592b7de4f2ab81cb31b37c803da239d4f3f679d07a37a24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "87c6619f0bb38a0458f96762b9e5aa18e85220dbf829752a129d7d5b1de8eee1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "92e40c4e8704c0a7604709b5b5fe4a8dd3b89ce11448e7e794ea522592d2a63f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "71b605246a09e679b8db2fa18d9ce3112b41e914fbd78d59aebfb1b21b1b3481", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0e5ef1d99d10bcafefce408b3fde6de259ffb1e0025894782de617247543efc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b30120203184a2ac8d7837d4d0ec7c6827c47fa85587bd55a2093eea326e5626", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5daa0ceba44cc1bed48feb4a2503b7dabf9cc7da37061ce18672f8f0d585c1a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3c12481dc1fb93f96df4c408aff753fb66d9a1b019bd76e9b4c39e9ba5673984", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fcc854c50e172cad85c37169048cfe2f2ccaec7d521bb27e62582d42f47c208b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1d2fe02669628fd79ce7feb1800816c630176b96ba6c6921614192bd4c1d217", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "41afe953c64acb133b1b5614015c331b27fe0f572d8d62f00a177d7eb3ccced5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1f7acbe8907c2b74c903bf8b3c527c22c8211e235cc2358a5a200814d2510a1e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12155709716dd82a436b99f7ed1209344bbaca4a3660f32496cc71b74de8d9da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90616d486ffc3487f3aaedfd3bc88573f58fc177da93ad57e1a59210cc2359b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df4ce446eef081aed7ab58bcb243434772e24895a39101a7dcd4cde5e0ca439", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "31b88339313d690b7859435f8701bfd55acacaff96376521768c6f17c856d855", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "79c1336474463a8bcc98504e08c6ceb4fc8e736eaa48e2cf29c3b7c5d8397f11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0da0a1a0c9d9e7dc1cda86c0d333a95f2812adcc7c738256d0d1750104f4b6f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e36c886ed1d7156301b095ad31f5b0723f25ba385a584e4f474f672a1a01f4c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "01d58dc50ca5f902bb7429112cb2a2b751fdfab6a04f0c5ffec21a3009393b7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6dd907b35448520581b950ef443b8fb487bc9867aa9bf283a517ce9a5790086", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74ba48327ac2590614cca2a91ba3495dab606495bbed46faacb23799ef5fa485", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c54b5d64ffd54d208767dbf2daeb16c0364e6bea2ddd32d0f3bcdb27e7065c51", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10470/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "797008b0b4dcbb1d21ee3b1592a68e52d3ea21a6ce70fa1f4f20c5f69745b18e" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17-job.json", + "sha256": "f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.962358+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "1047f": { @@ -178900,7 +192197,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1047f", "family_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -178914,32 +192211,463 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" }, "coordinator_review": { - "status": "held", - "candidate_sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca", - "frame_bindings_sha256": "8538bd43d98378c55e248f4f4d2248ceb1e9fbc59d1e510c5bc6326573cba810", - "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T13:00:30.649797+00:00", - "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Whole16 held for dominant enlarged block/cellular material in the listed14 total targets. Geometry, palette and numeric loader passes do not approve continuous fine HD material. Historical peer approval preserved.", - "exact_material_hold_targets": [ - "10474", - "10476", - "10477", - "10479", - "1047a" + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "2602d2ad68e08a4045538f0919d254ecef5d5117a8210a3b8dbc508e27538e43", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:51.075701+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/coordinator-runtime-batch1844/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Original ridge corridors, L rails, mesh apertures, vertical and horizontal fence widths, clipped rail endpoints and lower pale features remain recognizable at the actual indexed scales. Nine 10460 and five 10470 selected fine-material corrections replace the identified enlarged-cell finish while preserving the source angular shade fields. 1047a-v3 is selected; its rejected cellular v2 and all prior whole-family holds remain separate immutable history. New soil and metal grain is finer, with sharper ridge relief and stronger dark fence shadows. Native1 smooths small detail; source-derived angular shade fields remain visible at higher scales. Retained 1046e rough mottling and retained 10470/10478 faceted aggregate fields were specifically reconsidered against complete original/actual1-4 canvases. Their stronger irregular grain and source-shaped ridges are accepted qualifications in this scope, without claiming a uniformly smooth or RGB-identical material. Visible density and tone differences beside original fallback and admitted neighboring HD artwork remain the separately reviewed contextual deployment limits.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/independent-review.json, SHA256 c38a62fb477a711ae579489c1478b8f1afe5fadf8474a153546f5085c4e5ee9f", + "coordinator_material_inspection": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1812-terrain1-material32-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", + "sha256": "31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604" + }, + "current_full_pack_proof": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/private1844-current/combined-review.json", + "sha256": "ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5" + }, + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10470-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bd625546c17e03e98838a125657d09eacc81daa7b549e3efcf68586d8f1194a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "20bc1c132fda81b41c0d8b31480ff68a12030d112ac919d1ee889cdaba6ea806", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1e405278eb144f3f3d653ef8f9a4db13aa189d8dfef55a92971ecb3d82b282a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0dece6615c9a8d8b2e7020a7e6f91f39ebd8dd530948699615d074cbfe43266d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10470-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4b9839f8f1e27a0ff5124e7440e5f680cf734a7d71b7901914c1839cc3c46b65", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10470-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9abd07f393655c3a1e6549d7caa556cb57c6177b827d0371cf2810bff655430a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2034a1bcc4de1123dcc0360510150e655c4bc0e0a669b16e618d92c8a1fa62ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4af1e4375d607d0587f1db44f724cf924079189f35bd926504e21dd773e6de84", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "096ec1689828fbaaff0397b6c032747ab7320ec3fc5d7afef687effdf1a25dd2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10471-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0919cd59b0a1bd4a0152e02dd40542af639d7850b3c8bf9b7b87ccdc03d770c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10471-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-original.ppm", + "sha256": "334f2bc0dc3a27d7076e90190e72710e7cdb24791a1eb577a24c1971c15945f7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bb6fb8b793c4b5157957040ed29dceb3748ce4c74fb3307f0c1a3f16fb3072a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b630f5d34fa1bcc3bf848ef8c7bef453e177d43656fdb75ac3ff2cb93d9b499e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "485032866f5d6e8d6f6ceafbe2a5f6ad3a34aa67bddafe93397a8758a807e651", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10472-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "24cf3b3210de0257ceb7a9cec5874514d4daf1dce28aa4ae0eadc75c8b1dc94b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10472-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6b31d0c586f1f3fc418e58460984b97954239c85c3912f1486221c9cb78892a0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a961c58cb6bd7a880cf9f1775d5a24c2695a1ccdbea647b0dbd6f4c07d1cb78f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d415bf900ebff6f7a7af34b0de2f017b3fa9d3a40fa1f2b4ea2d5550d6be51f1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ecdea058c1e8471850defc02e296fc32641cb8f088846b27c7ca694666c9672f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10473-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1e1095c48a16d0e7481edaf8fbedd1443ad5151d60b8447ed06a6dcc56e999a1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10473-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-original.ppm", + "sha256": "64214d0fb30168d098dce502c30b1481827439ba4a12ac33c36d2969ae4f9cd3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b63aa408a9dc740fd32ca4224a7affe26b71d47ed05df5d761a8426ac18172f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9aa2417cfa39e82db3c868b9a220adf16167fabc2326fe2ecbcda43b8809e2df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cd72651ff813d84b0e75ba66e36369c337817736bf42a49605ebd888d53a8462", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10474-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e56ac217b8a215f5c2b87e15104bc8cde3c2bdf613b5289c31860b5c4e1cb227", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10474-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-original.ppm", + "sha256": "05909a594988a6f74f8e0702c6869d0a02d048ddad9f8f272342319e0f9f1d5e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2b1e3df24742e69f757554ed3c1d40962c0a76e485c54d0490afe4f621310ac6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e999ce4d31407ce10a5dd5a68a942afd8f741ac5032cf54a247506bcdb427005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5131e4908efbe1b47f0afd25a47bebfeff017e82f72c936e12fce03e75f0374e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10475-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e984aa369db6628cbcd912d27b23404131f9eb709b35fb7cded6644e8436302d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10475-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-original.ppm", + "sha256": "175210f0e0f8f4f12e52e6499964f921a6f78eb1b5e9d8babbe7552bfb1a5cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4672b70ea6ed108a16a13323e59088065413036142910239b409e532e324bea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9b5e01b8e84118e1facb7e6fbfd0f86fa8d94dbeab484a8db9e6d6534224db3a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "909996c4446ec4595dd198d0fdc8f9417066cb72764933d87c1eadce4f4c786e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10476-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ed1508b9a886f776ef5cd472b60624c85f4f61fa1a1068977335525b963257b9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10476-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7deecc5150ee6e6546df8c7b459d3a2de97afc3c0d26302b0daeaed767dccb2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7f4fc524342dba04c5768162dfb438c2dbe1fab5c8046e68c3c6e9b2fb3df6c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acd3d077b4a5693673ed730aef43684eebca298e6a68c6c4520c64430eaaceb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "91f02513747527b8601f2daf7bec364b081d576d74b73d07fb88097cebca1781", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10477-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "116797ac4574103c8397cd8e62484ee797cbca4fc9f5df621be219dcf071c9bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10477-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-original.ppm", + "sha256": "6c1de18299c04cb685160345d40628ff0419e700e7e442fc313167d7cb04a995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bff5413151f8d435e9ba967964998577b0b5f968a03884ce7ea26ce83b9a8060", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "315e7df7dd072a2652747d825ad15aedb8bbedd41c70291f534ceb99a8087b0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6a2aa7c38dc9c25b6e431f10b8e8a759ff7f0fb3d306d7f36d6e5c7aa304fd88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10478-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b911113afefb1055e916b2bd51fe1010aeca8c18c0b47064dfe5aa6182c025", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10478-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c5bff6a3448fdfc8693d0eb9fd87b34864ecbaee9bcf69ea33e642eaa8dda5f2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5237519282cf98bc9aa180a99d449d8042dc9c8ae8538055bcaecacf6f4f55c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "880bd7dacf659719329b93f0cd2618c5a3934cc016d346706af45d55cc4bd97d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "62a3aa099d63717345d62d4658a93b3f53977792dac07740ad30e0e6dfe18264", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10479-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "16eede0f48eb3b6c02f2eb36a153812165dd414e85c49af884306402c182d7c6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/10479-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d2fef3ea65b658e9058ccf8c48d5eea2543685a8acaf8bfc75e0ea5977973287", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0a817f9a2ace8d3dbb7593b5881e8db39e13d57b86ca7f5d04753bda4f791c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8daf0b00f06a97b439b9d6b7681b323f87b61f7e3be8cb16fc79fc3874cdb2a3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3d40f4364a93ea0e190766527d2f2beed1b232d7699642da0797bf2673b151de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "58aa2a4eb56cffc655954900066d6e726f2beb136e8fd33d14fe1c492b758da6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "c364869538cf858d60171bcd5e55c4b64a39073585309425b7c61e78f2b0d38a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e828b91490e6657ae11201a7156d0cec8994987112a5cd7bb8d923ca239a481c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bbae96ec0b7e41c83592b7de4f2ab81cb31b37c803da239d4f3f679d07a37a24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "87c6619f0bb38a0458f96762b9e5aa18e85220dbf829752a129d7d5b1de8eee1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "92e40c4e8704c0a7604709b5b5fe4a8dd3b89ce11448e7e794ea522592d2a63f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "71b605246a09e679b8db2fa18d9ce3112b41e914fbd78d59aebfb1b21b1b3481", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0e5ef1d99d10bcafefce408b3fde6de259ffb1e0025894782de617247543efc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b30120203184a2ac8d7837d4d0ec7c6827c47fa85587bd55a2093eea326e5626", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5daa0ceba44cc1bed48feb4a2503b7dabf9cc7da37061ce18672f8f0d585c1a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3c12481dc1fb93f96df4c408aff753fb66d9a1b019bd76e9b4c39e9ba5673984", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fcc854c50e172cad85c37169048cfe2f2ccaec7d521bb27e62582d42f47c208b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "d1d2fe02669628fd79ce7feb1800816c630176b96ba6c6921614192bd4c1d217", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "41afe953c64acb133b1b5614015c331b27fe0f572d8d62f00a177d7eb3ccced5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1f7acbe8907c2b74c903bf8b3c527c22c8211e235cc2358a5a200814d2510a1e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12155709716dd82a436b99f7ed1209344bbaca4a3660f32496cc71b74de8d9da", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90616d486ffc3487f3aaedfd3bc88573f58fc177da93ad57e1a59210cc2359b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3df4ce446eef081aed7ab58bcb243434772e24895a39101a7dcd4cde5e0ca439", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "31b88339313d690b7859435f8701bfd55acacaff96376521768c6f17c856d855", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "79c1336474463a8bcc98504e08c6ceb4fc8e736eaa48e2cf29c3b7c5d8397f11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0da0a1a0c9d9e7dc1cda86c0d333a95f2812adcc7c738256d0d1750104f4b6f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e36c886ed1d7156301b095ad31f5b0723f25ba385a584e4f474f672a1a01f4c5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "01d58dc50ca5f902bb7429112cb2a2b751fdfab6a04f0c5ffec21a3009393b7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e6dd907b35448520581b950ef443b8fb487bc9867aa9bf283a517ce9a5790086", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74ba48327ac2590614cca2a91ba3495dab606495bbed46faacb23799ef5fa485", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1047f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c54b5d64ffd54d208767dbf2daeb16c0364e6bea2ddd32d0f3bcdb27e7065c51", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/terrain1-10470-material-v2/runtime/1047f-hd-4.ppm" + } ], - "independent_additive_clarification": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-material-clarifications/10470/material-clarification.json", - "sha256": "797008b0b4dcbb1d21ee3b1592a68e52d3ea21a6ce70fa1f4f20c5f69745b18e" + "native_scene_scope": "Exact independent source/raw/context/cardinal/state receipts separately bound. Combined1844 is raster continuity, no new live Host or seamless map claim.", + "previous_coordinator_inputs_preserved": { + "candidate.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "coordinator-review.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87-coordinator-review.json", + "sha256": "7a39ec374af7085c71be5dd3d09e06735c34cbe4a1abd82843245d1cf1bdeb87" + }, + "job.json": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17-job.json", + "sha256": "f343e25c0850c3a3977cbf0dc5bc614c457191d9f1bd5e635dd26a013e783e17" + } }, - "coordinator_complete_review": { - "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/post1465-additional123-preflight/coordinator-complete-family-art-review.json", - "sha256": "a6ced4a79c48abf21be4e3db6e61e77b6f82aa6bc4bf35abdf1c57f652ce313c" + "exact_sibling_promotion": { + "utc": "2026-10-11T15:00:50.962358+00:00", + "job_id": "terrain-10470-1047f", + "prior_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-1844-approval-before/terrain-10470-1047f/0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca-candidate.json", + "sha256": "0d0f5605b179669e8ee9eb279f61368bcbbe2624a916c1e3707304e2a9719aca" + }, + "accepted_explicit_sibling": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate-family-material-v2.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "promoted_main": { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-10470-1047f/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f96c3d381ecc29b084e66a6d44528fd0f461ae68c0208051282eab699235454a" + }, + "exact_byte_equality": true, + "same_existing_job_identity": true, + "source_raw_crop_proof_pixels_changed": false, + "policy": "Official registrar requires the accepted existing-identity sibling as candidate.json. Prior main remains exact SHA-named history; explicit sibling candidate and all PNG/proof/source bytes unchanged." }, - "historical_previous_coordinator_review": null, - "registration": false + "registration_performed": false } }, "10480": { @@ -202113,7 +215841,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "104c0", "family_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", "job_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202124,6 +215852,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-104c0-104cf/candidate.json", + "sha256": "20bd7e447bede0b1ce53ce91f0a985194ca5ac3c36232dba337154f44ffc2126", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "104c1": { @@ -202145,7 +215878,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "104c1", "family_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", "job_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202156,6 +215889,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-104c0-104cf/candidate.json", + "sha256": "20bd7e447bede0b1ce53ce91f0a985194ca5ac3c36232dba337154f44ffc2126", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "104c2": { @@ -202177,7 +215915,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "104c2", "family_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", "job_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202188,6 +215926,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-104c0-104cf/candidate.json", + "sha256": "20bd7e447bede0b1ce53ce91f0a985194ca5ac3c36232dba337154f44ffc2126", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "104c3": { @@ -202209,7 +215952,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "104c3", "family_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", "job_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202220,6 +215963,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-104c0-104cf/candidate.json", + "sha256": "20bd7e447bede0b1ce53ce91f0a985194ca5ac3c36232dba337154f44ffc2126", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "104c4": { @@ -202241,7 +215989,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "104c4", "family_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", "job_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202252,6 +216000,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-104c0-104cf/candidate.json", + "sha256": "20bd7e447bede0b1ce53ce91f0a985194ca5ac3c36232dba337154f44ffc2126", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "104c5": { @@ -202273,7 +216026,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "104c5", "family_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", "job_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202284,6 +216037,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-104c0-104cf/candidate.json", + "sha256": "20bd7e447bede0b1ce53ce91f0a985194ca5ac3c36232dba337154f44ffc2126", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "104c6": { @@ -202305,7 +216063,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "104c6", "family_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", "job_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202316,6 +216074,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-104c0-104cf/candidate.json", + "sha256": "20bd7e447bede0b1ce53ce91f0a985194ca5ac3c36232dba337154f44ffc2126", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "104c7": { @@ -202337,7 +216100,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "104c7", "family_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", "job_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202348,6 +216111,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-104c0-104cf/candidate.json", + "sha256": "20bd7e447bede0b1ce53ce91f0a985194ca5ac3c36232dba337154f44ffc2126", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "104c8": { @@ -202369,7 +216137,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "104c8", "family_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", "job_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202380,6 +216148,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-104c0-104cf/candidate.json", + "sha256": "20bd7e447bede0b1ce53ce91f0a985194ca5ac3c36232dba337154f44ffc2126", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "104c9": { @@ -202401,7 +216174,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "104c9", "family_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", "job_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202412,6 +216185,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-104c0-104cf/candidate.json", + "sha256": "20bd7e447bede0b1ce53ce91f0a985194ca5ac3c36232dba337154f44ffc2126", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "104ca": { @@ -202433,7 +216211,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "104ca", "family_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", "job_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202444,6 +216222,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-104c0-104cf/candidate.json", + "sha256": "20bd7e447bede0b1ce53ce91f0a985194ca5ac3c36232dba337154f44ffc2126", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "104cb": { @@ -202465,7 +216248,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "104cb", "family_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", "job_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202476,6 +216259,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-104c0-104cf/candidate.json", + "sha256": "20bd7e447bede0b1ce53ce91f0a985194ca5ac3c36232dba337154f44ffc2126", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "104cc": { @@ -202497,7 +216285,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "104cc", "family_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", "job_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202508,6 +216296,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-104c0-104cf/candidate.json", + "sha256": "20bd7e447bede0b1ce53ce91f0a985194ca5ac3c36232dba337154f44ffc2126", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "104cd": { @@ -202529,7 +216322,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "104cd", "family_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", "job_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202540,6 +216333,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-104c0-104cf/candidate.json", + "sha256": "20bd7e447bede0b1ce53ce91f0a985194ca5ac3c36232dba337154f44ffc2126", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "104ce": { @@ -202561,7 +216359,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "104ce", "family_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", "job_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202572,6 +216370,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-104c0-104cf/candidate.json", + "sha256": "20bd7e447bede0b1ce53ce91f0a985194ca5ac3c36232dba337154f44ffc2126", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "104cf": { @@ -202593,7 +216396,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "104cf", "family_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", "job_id": "terrain-104c0-104cf", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -202604,6 +216407,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-104c0-104cf/candidate.json", + "sha256": "20bd7e447bede0b1ce53ce91f0a985194ca5ac3c36232dba337154f44ffc2126", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "104d0": { @@ -462791,7 +476599,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3024d-3025c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "6515dcc218c945fab6adedf203c7ae01cfc97d59386b95d77ff214c781b575fc", + "sha256": "6f999bcc8d4b815797c46fc30315170dd9798f1cdfc4fa0fd58ee2561bf3cc8b", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -462828,7 +476636,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3024d-3025c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "6515dcc218c945fab6adedf203c7ae01cfc97d59386b95d77ff214c781b575fc", + "sha256": "6f999bcc8d4b815797c46fc30315170dd9798f1cdfc4fa0fd58ee2561bf3cc8b", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -462865,7 +476673,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3024d-3025c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "6515dcc218c945fab6adedf203c7ae01cfc97d59386b95d77ff214c781b575fc", + "sha256": "6f999bcc8d4b815797c46fc30315170dd9798f1cdfc4fa0fd58ee2561bf3cc8b", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -462902,7 +476710,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3024d-3025c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "6515dcc218c945fab6adedf203c7ae01cfc97d59386b95d77ff214c781b575fc", + "sha256": "6f999bcc8d4b815797c46fc30315170dd9798f1cdfc4fa0fd58ee2561bf3cc8b", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -462939,7 +476747,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3024d-3025c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "6515dcc218c945fab6adedf203c7ae01cfc97d59386b95d77ff214c781b575fc", + "sha256": "6f999bcc8d4b815797c46fc30315170dd9798f1cdfc4fa0fd58ee2561bf3cc8b", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -462962,7 +476770,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30252", "family_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", "job_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -462973,6 +476781,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3024d-3025c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6f999bcc8d4b815797c46fc30315170dd9798f1cdfc4fa0fd58ee2561bf3cc8b", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "30253": { @@ -462994,7 +476807,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30253", "family_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", "job_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -463005,6 +476818,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3024d-3025c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6f999bcc8d4b815797c46fc30315170dd9798f1cdfc4fa0fd58ee2561bf3cc8b", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "30254": { @@ -463026,7 +476844,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30254", "family_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", "job_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -463037,6 +476855,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3024d-3025c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6f999bcc8d4b815797c46fc30315170dd9798f1cdfc4fa0fd58ee2561bf3cc8b", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "30255": { @@ -463058,7 +476881,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30255", "family_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", "job_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -463069,6 +476892,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3024d-3025c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6f999bcc8d4b815797c46fc30315170dd9798f1cdfc4fa0fd58ee2561bf3cc8b", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "30256": { @@ -463090,7 +476918,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30256", "family_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", "job_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -463101,6 +476929,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3024d-3025c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6f999bcc8d4b815797c46fc30315170dd9798f1cdfc4fa0fd58ee2561bf3cc8b", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "30257": { @@ -463122,7 +476955,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30257", "family_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", "job_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -463133,6 +476966,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3024d-3025c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6f999bcc8d4b815797c46fc30315170dd9798f1cdfc4fa0fd58ee2561bf3cc8b", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "30258": { @@ -463154,7 +476992,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30258", "family_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", "job_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -463165,6 +477003,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3024d-3025c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6f999bcc8d4b815797c46fc30315170dd9798f1cdfc4fa0fd58ee2561bf3cc8b", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "30259": { @@ -463186,7 +477029,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30259", "family_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", "job_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -463197,6 +477040,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3024d-3025c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6f999bcc8d4b815797c46fc30315170dd9798f1cdfc4fa0fd58ee2561bf3cc8b", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "3025a": { @@ -463218,7 +477066,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "3025a", "family_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", "job_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -463229,6 +477077,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3024d-3025c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6f999bcc8d4b815797c46fc30315170dd9798f1cdfc4fa0fd58ee2561bf3cc8b", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "3025b": { @@ -463250,7 +477103,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "3025b", "family_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", "job_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -463261,6 +477114,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3024d-3025c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6f999bcc8d4b815797c46fc30315170dd9798f1cdfc4fa0fd58ee2561bf3cc8b", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "3025c": { @@ -463282,7 +477140,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "3025c", "family_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", "job_id": "terrain-3024d-3025c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -463293,6 +477151,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3024d-3025c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "6f999bcc8d4b815797c46fc30315170dd9798f1cdfc4fa0fd58ee2561bf3cc8b", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "3025d": { @@ -463314,7 +477177,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "3025d", "family_id": "terrain-3025d-3026c", "job_id": "terrain-3025d-3026c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -463325,6 +477188,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3025d-3026c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "bef026690c436689e332ff4a0086613ffffdfbcd6ab30eb0d37083afb0b4343d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "3025e": { @@ -463346,7 +477214,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "3025e", "family_id": "terrain-3025d-3026c", "job_id": "terrain-3025d-3026c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -463357,6 +477225,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3025d-3026c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "bef026690c436689e332ff4a0086613ffffdfbcd6ab30eb0d37083afb0b4343d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "3025f": { @@ -463378,7 +477251,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "3025f", "family_id": "terrain-3025d-3026c", "job_id": "terrain-3025d-3026c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -463389,6 +477262,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3025d-3026c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "bef026690c436689e332ff4a0086613ffffdfbcd6ab30eb0d37083afb0b4343d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "30260": { @@ -463410,7 +477288,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30260", "family_id": "terrain-3025d-3026c", "job_id": "terrain-3025d-3026c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -463421,6 +477299,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3025d-3026c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "bef026690c436689e332ff4a0086613ffffdfbcd6ab30eb0d37083afb0b4343d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "30261": { @@ -463442,7 +477325,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30261", "family_id": "terrain-3025d-3026c", "job_id": "terrain-3025d-3026c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -463453,6 +477336,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3025d-3026c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "bef026690c436689e332ff4a0086613ffffdfbcd6ab30eb0d37083afb0b4343d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "30262": { @@ -463474,7 +477362,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30262", "family_id": "terrain-3025d-3026c", "job_id": "terrain-3025d-3026c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -463485,6 +477373,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3025d-3026c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "bef026690c436689e332ff4a0086613ffffdfbcd6ab30eb0d37083afb0b4343d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "30263": { @@ -463506,7 +477399,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30263", "family_id": "terrain-3025d-3026c", "job_id": "terrain-3025d-3026c", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -463517,6 +477410,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3025d-3026c/candidate.json", + "sha256": "bef026690c436689e332ff4a0086613ffffdfbcd6ab30eb0d37083afb0b4343d", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "30264": { @@ -717724,7 +731622,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 16 + "registered": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-10460-1046f/job.json" }, @@ -717736,7 +731634,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 16 + "registered": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-10470-1047f/job.json" }, @@ -717796,7 +731694,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "inprogress": 16 + "candidate": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-104c0-104cf/job.json" }, @@ -719381,8 +733279,7 @@ "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 5, - "inprogress": 11 + "candidate": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-3024d-3025c/job.json" }, @@ -719394,7 +733291,8 @@ "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "inprogress": 16 + "candidate": 7, + "inprogress": 9 }, "job_file": "terrain-3025d-3026c/job.json" }, diff --git a/docs/hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md b/docs/hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md index 8cc42d17..62c0c1f2 100644 --- a/docs/hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md +++ b/docs/hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # HD coordinator checkpoint — 12 October 2026 -The reviewed external development pack contains **1,812 original picture frames in 765 complete sequences**. Root has copied the exact **1,148-frame / 421-sequence** handoff into shared Linux/Windows runtime data. Root completed and validated both final Stage2 Linux/Windows archives at this exact snapshot; the previous **800-frame / 340-sequence** archives and `964ba93` assembly are historical. Root owns runtime data, binaries, libraries and archives; coordinator owns external development registration and this metadata. Bundled originals and approved runtime art are tracked under this repository's data/. Working originals, prompts, job candidates and review evidence remain external under ../data/. +The reviewed external development pack contains **1,844 original picture frames in 797 complete sequences**. Root has copied the exact **1,148-frame / 421-sequence** handoff into shared Linux/Windows runtime data. Root completed and validated both final Stage2 Linux/Windows archives at this exact snapshot; the previous **800-frame / 340-sequence** archives and `964ba93` assembly are historical. Root owns runtime data, binaries, libraries and archives; coordinator owns external development registration and this metadata. Bundled originals and approved runtime art are tracked under this repository's data/. Working originals, prompts, job candidates and review evidence remain external under ../data/. ## Verified development coverage @@ -12,11 +12,11 @@ The reviewed external development pack contains **1,812 original picture frames | Player and enemy projectiles | 45 / 51 | | Explosions and effects | 219 / 281 | | Equipment and pickups | 47 / 47 | -| Terrain | 960 / 4,535 | +| Terrain | 992 / 4,535 | | Menus, portraits, HUD and other pictures | 77 / 150 | -| Total | 1,812 / 5,753 | +| Total | 1,844 / 5,753 | -All 6,449 catalog entries and 5,753 pictures were audited with zero HD source/hash/canvas/ID errors. **3,941 pictures still await registration**. Current ledger counts are 1792 registered, 20 render-reachable, 2683 candidates, 650 in-progress and 608 missing. Candidate status is neither artistic approval nor a live occurrence. Unused/destroyed targets remain required; 303 AGX delta frames and four bitmap fonts have separate preservation policies. +All 6,449 catalog entries and 5,753 pictures were audited with zero HD source/hash/canvas/ID errors. **3,909 pictures still await registration**. Current ledger counts are 1824 registered, 20 render-reachable, 2685 candidates, 616 in-progress and 608 missing. Candidate status is neither artistic approval nor live occurrence. Unused/destroyed targets remain required; 303 AGX delta frames and four bitmap fonts retain separate policies. ## Historical Stage2 API 1,148 output proof @@ -115,22 +115,20 @@ Phase35 comprises complete PLATOON2/6, DMOON/7, TARG1G4/11 and TARG2G4/11. All f ## Durable owners and outstanding holds -Ongoing independent scopes preserve original1465 authority: Terrain1/192, Terrain2/80, Terrain3/96, Set4/256. Current admitted counts 256/224/176/304 are not silently substituted. +All ongoing independent scopes keep the original 1465 authority: Terrain1/192, Terrain2/80, Terrain3/96, Set4/256. Current counts 288/224/176/304 are not silently substituted. -- hd_full_review has qualified-approved the complete corrected 10460/10470 material siblings. Both remain future-only, with their historical coarse-material holds retained. It now reviews Terrain3 middle originals20/21 under full freeze be25f814; raised3023a interpretation remains unresolved. -- iron_coast_2 approved Set4 original39 but held whole40 for low-scale lavender fissure loss in40350/51. A source-only two-frame successor is reserved with an early40350 native1–4 method check. It now reviews41/42; faint lavender routes and ember legibility are preliminary concerns until whole-family closure. -- iron_coast_6 closed complete Set4 original37/38 approvals and now reviews43/44. Fine gravel/relief and original-fallback density rectangles remain explicit qualifications; later shared quarters are provenance only. -- iron_coast_3 approved Terrain3 late original41 and held whole42 for30380 erased shallow outlined right-strip panels. One genuine source-only correction in a complete16 sibling is reserved, preserving15 bindings and prior rejected recess/rivet variants. It now reviews43/44 after immutable owner handoff. -- iron_coast_5 held both Terrain2 original22/23 families: five edge/hardware/diagonal targets in22 and four coarse-mosaic structures in23. Early hardware/edge method probes precede the reserved later corrections. It now reviews original24 only; active rebuilding original25 is excluded. -- windows_persistence closed qualified complete16 approvals for each corrected Set4 original29/30 contour sibling. Stronger shadows/fine soil and visible warm-HD/neutral-HD/original islands remain qualifications. Original17 three-water approval stays future-only;2018d pipe-ribv4 remains held because native1 erases the fourth metal band into water. -- terrain_capture_fixture now reviews complete104b0 under literal192 context. New wreck104bd, foreign original104c4/10455, source-first partial history and all complete-family joins/states remain explicit. Final2069f v3 advice stays KEEP HELD for physical paving emphasis and muted green distinction; no additionalf/a0 call is reserved. -- hd_terrain_set_1 now has256 registered pictures. Corrected10460/70 and source/raw/proof histories are fully frozen,104b0 is complete/frozen, and disjoint104c0 preparation continues. No partial acceptance or global author registration is allowed. -- hd_terrain_set_2 now has224 registered targets and90 proposal families/1,437 IDs. Original25 fine source-single successor is complete16 with final author context QA ongoing, without approval. Original20 six-water edge repairs and original22/23 bounded source-only work remain separate reserved scopes. All prior accepted siblings/main history stay exact. -- Terrain3 middle has128 own registered targets. Original14–19 remain independently approved pending coordinator review. Originals20/21 are frozen for a peer;22 is author-complete/held and disjoint23 continues.301ae stays missing/no-retry. -- campaign_release_review preserves author-frozen45 and ongoing46, all peer folders and rejected edit/gate history. Source-contour29/30 and warm-earth17 approvals remain future-only; original40 early source-cue method precedes any40351 redraw. -- Dark-player worm caps, opaque-scene aspect/border failures, rotor/lamp/tab failures and service refusal history remain held. RITE/LEFT plans and MKS/SDL/opaque policy questions remain separate, with no extra execution implied. +- Corrected 10460/10470 complete 32 are registered in 1844 with exact accepted sibling promotion and preserved historical material holds. Terrain1 artist continues disjoint 104d0; fixture reviews frozen 104c0, including genuineCFv2 and foreign original 104b1/1048a state fallback. Complete104b0 is independently approved and awaits coordinator review. +- hd_full_review closed Terrain3 middle 20/21 complete 32 and Set4 corrected 40 complete 16 qualified approvals. It now reviews middle 22/23 under new full freezes, preserving author angular/faceted/raised-remnant and faint-mark disclosures. Middle owner has 128 own registered targets; 301ae remains missing/no-retry. +- iron_coast_3 closed Terrain3 late 43/44 complete 32 qualified approval and now reviews 45/46. All prior 41/42 and bounded30380 successor holds remain literal: upper channels and first lower lip are too high/deep/tall. The one-request correction is exhausted; no second call is reserved. +- iron_coast_2 closed Set4 original 45 complete 16 qualified approval. Originals41/42 remain whole-held for six/four low-scale lavender/ember/network cues. Author early 57 route is legible, but60 method variants retain dim/orange native yellow markers; methods and remaining eight calls stay gated, with no loader/palette/RGB compensation. +- iron_coast_6 closed Set4 original 44 complete 16 approval and original 43 whole hold on 40382 opaque near-black raw right border with allscale rendered boundary darkening. A separate genuine 40382 source-only complete sibling is reserved after the early 41/42 methods; other 15 and recovery history stay exact. +- windows_persistence preserved the complete 30380 successor HOLD and now reviews frozen Terrain2 original 20 six-water-rule successor. Coordinator early 20249 method inspected full raw/source/current1–4 and genuine repeated contexts/pairs; it is method advice only, with no whole-family approval. +- iron_coast_5 closed Terrain2 original 24/26 approvals and original 27 whole hold on five coarse installation/wreck mosaics. It now reviews 28/29 under literal 80. Original27 five-only corrections are reserved behind earlier22/23 hardware/edge/diagonal/mosaic work; intact/damaged probes precede the remaining three. +- Fixture closed Terrain2 original 25 v5 whole hold on 20303/20307 microscopic square soil/water mosaics despite valid macro/checker geometry and softened native 3–4. A separate two-source correction is reserved after earlier work; other 14 and all failed atlas/prompt history remain frozen. Final2069f v3 advice stays KEEP HELD for physical paving emphasis and muted green distinction; no additional f/a0 call is reserved. +- Terrain2 artist has 224 registered targets,90 proposal families/1,437 IDs. Accepted parents and all selected art/proofs remain frozen; current peer80 authority is literal. Missing-prompt original 12 and native 1-erased fourth2018d metal band remain separate provenance/art blockers. +- Set4 author original 46 remains partial5/11 unsubmitted and excluded from complete-family review. All frozen current40/43/44/45 and prior contour/warm-earth histories stay exact. Dark-player worm caps, opaque framing, rotor/lamp/tab/shop failures and service refusal history remain held; unexecuted RITE/LEFT plans and opening-card policy questions imply no generation. -The handoff pending snapshot records 610 unique independently approved unregistered pictures, all requiring coordinator complete-source/raw/material/current-output review. Sixteen original12 pictures also have a missing saved-prompt provenance gap requiring parent policy. There is no original5753 completion or universal seamlessness claim. +This handoff cutoff records 738 unique independently approved unregistered pictures requiring coordinator full-source/raw/material/current-output review. Sixteen original 12 pictures additionally retain the missing saved-prompt gap requiring parent policy. There is no original 5753 completion or universal seamlessness claim. ## Startup PNG source epoch and current continuity @@ -200,3 +198,18 @@ Manifest `9e439f7d1804d6ca020ed6a8907a39298edcddd906ebbab6c9b05231a413d463`, pro The pending snapshot records **610 independently approved unregistered pictures** requiring coordinator review, including 16 original12 pictures with a missing saved-prompt provenance gap. Corrected 10460/10470 and newer source-contour repairs are future-only. Source-rib, atlas-edge, erased detail, worm and opaque-scene holds remain separate. Original catalog completion, seamless mixed-terrain maps, live Host, palette timing and UI-route coverage are not established by this registration. Bookkeeping receipt `91a59876f4b9d86d763a5f38ca2e4ed1976e650077387b86a62763ad8e32efe0` checks all 698 job source/context contracts. Eight actual derived job payload changes are enumerated with exact before copies; all 690 byte-identical job payload mtimes remain unchanged. Official queue computation, locking and atomic writing were used, with identical writes skipped. Ledger status counts are {'registered': 1792, 'inprogress': 650, 'renderreachable': 20, 'candidate': 2683, 'missing': 608}. The prior 1748 handoff payload and packaged runtime inventory `6fc0642c24cae2ba04bab30ab4cd0547d62c965421b1cb49026aa8a48d351653` remain exact. No packaged copy, build or export was performed. + + +## Closed1844 outer development registration + +Batch 1844 adds **32 terrain pictures in two complete families**, 10460–1046f and 10470–1047f, yielding **1,844 / 5,753 originals**, **797 complete sequences** and **992 terrain pictures**. Coordinator review `31703b005264ea42f000433b0f3764ce658a67596833ee0d5e773e7551f1c604` records actual inspection of all 32 full selected raw canvases and eight complete source/current 1–4/native 2–3 boards. Independent full cardinal/native context receipts remain separately pinned; no new coordinator terrain-context invocation is claimed. + +Fourteen genuine material corrections replace the enlarged cellular finish while preserving source rail endpoints, mesh apertures, ridges and muted colors. The other seven/eleven bindings and 35/55 outputs remain exact. Source angular shade fields, stronger ridge relief, native 1 smoothing and HD/original density rectangles are explicit qualifications. Retained 1046e rough mottling and 10470/10478 faceted source shade fields were accepted after direct source/actual 1–4 inspection; this does not claim uniform smooth texture or identical RGB. Unused 1047d stays gallery-only, with no state/wreck claim. Held historical main artwork, early probe evidence and rejected 1047a-v2 remain unchanged. + +Full current Rust proof `ba036a721bac52d7fa7ab26ea9d7e3429a6cdddb166af8da91a40d8c240e64c5` compares all **9,220 source/scaled outputs** exactly: 9,060 prior 1812 outputs plus 160 new, including 7,376 scaled outputs. Every 1812 baseline binding remains exact. Actual immutable c0c3/compatible ba61 dependencies, both literal false age guards and all 18 recursive source SHA/size/mtime records are stable. The 116 combined contact pages are hash-bound, not described as freshly inspected. Two exact accepted sibling candidates were promoted for the official registrar only after preserving old main/coordinator/job bytes in SHA-named history; explicit sibling/source/raw/proof pixels were unchanged. + +Manifest `23a51de8c951ad06c104af7dfc227a9a19117cc032bb5371772b5d8e7b9e39d4`, provenance `693ee4002f1868aa35a497272a7bce92839c5bd54fd0036f95203c2e46deed8d`, approval `c893608e818198db424324f3949a98ecbf9ee20c8d631c738c6cf6031e210a9c` and registration `a1279b7a68771fd1a2fc1db964f8f397e612f02db3f54a288326913f54c6c99c` bind the accepted families. Immutable private input ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-1844-20261012/pack/ contains 736 files / 1,584,801,769 bytes with distinct private inodes; handoff `d10580305bfcb17f738849dc02356a35911c093ab7cb1140c1627caa443edf42`. Every 1812 handoff payload and all 6,853 packaged runtime files remain exact. Released runtime stays **1,148 frames / 421 sequences with 45 accepted mods**; parent alone controls any later copy/build/export. + +The frozen pending snapshot has **738 independently approved unregistered pictures** requiring coordinator review, including 16 original 12 pictures with a missing saved-prompt provenance gap. Source-rib, atlas-border, misplaced shallow panels, erased low-scale lavender/ember cues, square material, worm and opaque-scene holds remain separate. Registration does not establish catalog completion, seamless mixed maps, live Host, palette timing or UI-route coverage. + +Bookkeeping receipt `910d6514783b882fa6b9651f63277dbb05c94217149d0d0f1b38124e29d7e3d5` verifies all 698 job source/context contracts. Five actual derived job changes have exact before copies; all 693 byte-identical job payloads retain their mtimes. Status/count-only 104c0 and middle 23/active24 epochs are separately receipted for affected owners/reviewers. Official queue computation/locks/atomic writing were used, skipping identical writes. Current ledger counts are {'registered': 1824, 'inprogress': 616, 'renderreachable': 20, 'candidate': 2685, 'missing': 608}. No packaged copy/build/export was performed.