diff --git a/docs/hd-art.md b/docs/hd-art.md index 6f2214d3..a855585a 100644 --- a/docs/hd-art.md +++ b/docs/hd-art.md @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ The Rust Options screen includes **HD art**. It starts disabled. Enable it to use reviewed artwork from the selected data directory's `hd/hd.json`; each missing or rejected frame keeps the selected original / 2x / 3x / 4x crisp treatment. The bundled runtime uses `data/`, while development artwork and review jobs live under `../data/`. The scale setting still determines the indexed rendering resolution, and the HD toggle can be changed while paused. HD art is presentation only: simulation, collision sizes, banking positions and save content IDs stay unchanged. -The development base-game pack currently supplies **1,071 reviewed replacement frames in 400 complete sequences**. These include all twenty-one light, dark and firing-flash player poses, 232 boss frames, complete vehicle families, ground defenses and opening bunkers, all forty-seven equipment and pickup pictures, projectile and effect animations, eleven HUD picture glyphs, nine pilot portraits, four difficulty portraits, both title logos, three standalone opening cards and 352 canonical terrain tiles. The tracked Linux/Windows playable snapshots contain the separately frozen 800 reviewed frames, copied by the root assembler and committed at `964ba93`. Later development approvals remain separate from this runtime checkpoint. The complete catalog backlog and generation status are listed in [hd-backlog.md](hd-backlog.md). +The development base-game pack currently supplies **1,148 reviewed replacement frames in 421 complete sequences**. These include all twenty-one light, dark and firing-flash player poses, 232 boss frames, complete vehicle families, ground defenses and opening bunkers, all forty-seven equipment and pickup pictures, projectile and effect animations, eleven HUD picture glyphs, nine pilot portraits, four difficulty portraits, both title logos, three standalone opening cards and 416 canonical terrain tiles. The tracked Linux/Windows playable snapshots contain the separately frozen 800 reviewed frames, copied by the root assembler and committed at `964ba93`. Later development approvals remain separate from this runtime checkpoint. The complete catalog backlog and generation status are listed in [hd-backlog.md](hd-backlog.md). | Reviewed artwork | Original asset IDs | Supplied / complete frames | | --- | --- | ---: | @@ -32,6 +32,7 @@ The development base-game pack currently supplies **1,071 reviewed replacement f | Fine-metal third-campaign craft | `0x3004c`, `0x3004f`, `0x30055`, `0x3005c`, `0x30065`, `0x30068`, `0x3006b`, `0x3006e`, `0x30073` | 9 / 9 | | Additional third-campaign hull and pod craft | `0x3008f`, `0x30092`, `0x30095`, `0x30098` | 4 / 4 | | Restored gray structure and dark-post craft | `0x300ac`, `0x3009d` | 2 / 2 | +| Fourth-campaign asymmetric ground structure | `0x40088` | 1 / 1 | | Third-campaign tread, slat and fork families | `0x30074`–`0x30077`, `0x30080`–`0x30088`, `0x3008b`–`0x3008c` | 15 / 15 | | Corrected third-campaign boss | `0x30044` | 1 / 1 | | Restored asymmetric hull and lower-bridge bosses | `0x10310`, `0x200a3` | 2 / 2 | @@ -106,6 +107,7 @@ The development base-game pack currently supplies **1,071 reviewed replacement f | Laser impact phases | `0x10229`–`0x1022c` | 4 / 4 | | Shield light masks | `0x10249`–`0x1024c` | 4 / 4 | | Medium air explosion | `0x101d8`–`0x101e4` | 13 / 13 | +| Repaired large air explosion | `0x101e5`–`0x101f0` | 12 / 12 | | Small ground explosion | `0x1027d`–`0x1029f` | 35 / 35 | | Pilot portraits, small and retained large variants | `0x10111`–`0x10119` | 9 / 9 | | Original English and Chinese title logos | `0x10013`, `0x10014` | 2 / 2 | @@ -126,6 +128,7 @@ The development base-game pack currently supplies **1,071 reviewed replacement f | Canonical terrain set 1, first shard | `0x10360`–`0x1036f` | 16 / 16 | | Canonical terrain set 2, corrected first shard | `0x2010d`–`0x2011c` | 16 / 16 | | Canonical industrial terrain, first two shards | `0x300ed`–`0x3010c` | 32 / 32 | +| Further destroyed industrial terrain | `0x3011d`–`0x3012c` | 16 / 16 | | Soil, foliage, shadow and rubble terrain | `0x10390`–`0x103af` | 32 / 32 | | Industrial, soil and canal terrain | `0x103b0`–`0x103cf` | 32 / 32 | | Source coast, bridge and water terrain | `0x103e0`–`0x103ef` | 16 / 16 | @@ -135,13 +138,15 @@ The development base-game pack currently supplies **1,071 reviewed replacement f | Fourth-campaign radar, damage and controls | `0x40115`–`0x40134` | 32 / 32 | | Fourth-campaign cracked soil and rock terrain | `0x40135`–`0x40154` | 32 / 32 | | Fourth-campaign rocks, cracks and upper foliage | `0x40155`–`0x40174` | 32 / 32 | +| Fourth-campaign lower foliage, cliffs and rocky ground | `0x40175`–`0x40194` | 32 / 32 | | Source shoreline, fences and rocks | `0x103f0`–`0x103ff` | 16 / 16 | +| Intact and damaged buildings, rocks and crossings | `0x10410`–`0x1041f` | 16 / 16 | Every registered frame passed the exact original source hash, logical canvas, aspect, visible alpha and path checks. Complete contact sheets were inspected at source size and the 4× presentation size; per-frame geometry metrics and review evidence remain with each family. Their logical collision sizes are unchanged. Small contours and interpreted metal detail differ. Missing artwork keeps the crisp original fallback. HD remains an opt-in preview while the remaining catalog and game screenshots are reviewed. An actual Rust `HdAssets::sprite` pass also checked all registered frames at scales 1–4 with the game palette: every output has the expected dimensions and visible pixels, and the pack reports no diagnostics. Complete 4× source/HD sheets from that runtime path were reviewed for readable projectiles, equipment alignment, banking progression and energy-ring timing stages. These sprite checks complement live gameplay captures and do not establish full-game visual completion. -The current 1,071-frame development snapshot passed 4,284 actual scale checks. All 5,355 original and rendered PPMs are byte-identical to independently accepted references, with both source-age guards clear and the tested immutable library pinned by SHA and original build time. All 985 ordinary sources introduce no reserved palette labels; 83 sources retain legitimate gameplay classes, and the three opening cards use their authentic static palettes. Historical smaller-pack proofs, including the packaged 800-frame snapshot, remain separate. +The current 1,148-frame development snapshot passed 4,592 actual scale checks against the final Stage2 API source build. All 5,740 original and rendered PPMs are byte-identical to independently accepted references. Both source-age guards are clear, every Rust source hash remains unchanged through closure, and the actual immutable release library is pinned by SHA and original build time. All 1058 ordinary sources introduce no reserved palette labels; 87 sources retain legitimate gameplay classes, and the three opening cards use their authentic static palettes. Historical smaller-pack proofs, including development1,071 and the packaged800 snapshot, remain separate. The earlier1,148 attempt has identical pixels but an honestly recorded broad stale-source flag after root's intervening formatting/API changes; it is retained as supplementary evidence. The 189 additional boss frames passed complete source/1×/4× and native 2×/3× review across 56 full families. Opaque component panels, weapon apertures and source phases remain recognizable; fine material detail and minor contour interpretations are disclosed per family. These gallery decisions do not certify complete assembled-boss joins or native encounter placement. The shortened paired bottom feet in `0x200a2`, lost painted wing/strut cells in `0x30045`, Mole's missing initial blink, other contracted hulls remain held and are excluded. The later repaired asymmetric hull, lower bridge and complete EBOSS6 phases are reviewed separately below. @@ -276,3 +281,11 @@ LargeAir's newer v9 still remains held: repaired first/late pairs improve the ea A further 34-frame development batch adds two complete craft singles and thirty-two terrain tiles. All 170 source/scaled PPMs match independently accepted references, and all ten complete source/native1/HD4 pages on two boards were inspected before registration. The gray structure300ac retains its upper crossbar, central inset and lower supports. Dark craft3009d retains its posts, pods, aperture and feet, with two very dark native corner losses accepted and all higher-scale source cells plus genuine252/253 cues retained. Terrain40155–40174 retains source crack branches, rock counts/offsets and divots. Corrected40157 preserves the authentic short upper-left fragment and lower-left branch;4015b excludes the rejected foreign right crack and bottom rock. Coarser standalone soil against surrounding atlas gravel remains an accepted density difference. Upper foliage40172/73 retains source organic outlines and shadows with finer leaves. Its lower40179/7a partners remain original fallback in the actual160-tile review pack. Their separate complete four-HD-cell object diagnostic is context-only and does not admit those lower two. Twenty-two native contexts/eighty-two cardinal pairs produce544 current scale compositions; no state partners exist, and ten unused IDs remain gallery-only. Original-fallback contrast and future HD-neighbor re-review remain explicit. + +The next77-frame batch adds six complete job families: the repaired twelve-phase large air explosion, STAG02, destroyed industrial terrain3011d–3012c, terrain10410–1041f and fourth-campaign40175–40194. Their candidate manifests contain21 sequences because10410 uses sixteen standalone tile sequences. All385 source/scaled PPMs match independent references, and all twenty complete source/native1/HD4 pages on six unresampled boards were actually inspected before registration. + +LargeAirv11 restores the original seven-cell inner lip and four of five upper-shoulder cells, keeping the authentic flash/rays, expanding core, hollow rings and detached fading fragments. Remaining dim perimeter/endpoint changes and stronger hot grain in the corrected two phases are accepted explicitly; earlier v6/v9 holds remain unchanged. The opaque STAG02 structure retains its original asymmetric walls, outer rails, clipped stacks and central machinery; fine wear and darker mean gray are accepted after internal visual comparison, rather than an alpha-only test. + +The industrial destroyed cohort retains surviving straight gray frame segments, source dark scorch/rubble routing and warm original flecks. Brighter crack/rubble detail and fallback grain contrast are disclosed. Four other gray-remnant failures in the preceding3010d–3011c family remain held, with no partial-family admission. Terrain10410–1041f preserves original intact/damaged panel geometry, separate rock groups and stippled crossing rhythm. Authentic new destroyed targets10410/12/14 and whole-family state proof are bound; foreign partners remain original. Its rough chipped1041f material and2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted differences. The other10400 family is still held on unsupported rectangular organic-ground panels in10406. + +The lower bush40179/7a is now independently reviewed in the target scope and admitted with source organic outlines/shadows, completing the previously context-only four-cell object. The cliff and ground cohort preserves slope directions, rock positions and original brown/orange region boundaries. Its genuine no-gridv2 raw is the accepted binding; rejected gridlinedv1 remains preserved. Six unused IDs remain gallery-only; the selected40178 scene is authentic source-layout supporting evidence, while independently repeated liveHost or whole-map seamlessness is not claimed. diff --git a/docs/hd-backlog.md b/docs/hd-backlog.md index 5a4ecaa2..899b970d 100644 --- a/docs/hd-backlog.md +++ b/docs/hd-backlog.md @@ -1,16 +1,16 @@ # Original artwork HD backlog -The checked catalog contains **5,753 standalone picture frames**. The active local HD pack supplies **1,071**; **4,682** have no registered HD replacement. These counts include unnamed graphics outside `sprites/`. Scale2x/3x/4x filtering is crisp scaling, not a newly authored HD replacement. Authored mod SD/HD art is separate from this original-catalog audit. +The checked catalog contains **5,753 standalone picture frames**. The active local HD pack supplies **1,148**; **4,605** have no registered HD replacement. These counts include unnamed graphics outside `sprites/`. Scale2x/3x/4x filtering is crisp scaling, not a newly authored HD replacement. Authored mod SD/HD art is separate from this original-catalog audit. | Category | Picture frames | Registered HD | Missing HD | Declared sequences / terrain sets | | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | | Player banking | 21 | 21 | 0 | 3 | | Bosses | 249 | 232 | 17 | 79 | -| Enemies and ground objects | 419 | 150 | 269 | 183 | +| Enemies and ground objects | 419 | 151 | 268 | 183 | | Player and enemy projectiles | 51 | 45 | 6 | 18 | -| Explosions and effects | 281 | 164 | 117 | 25 | +| Explosions and effects | 281 | 176 | 105 | 25 | | Equipment and pickups | 47 | 47 | 0 | 23 | -| Terrain | 4,535 | 352 | 4,183 | 4 | +| Terrain | 4,535 | 416 | 4,119 | 4 | | Menus, portraits, HUD and other pictures | 150 | 60 | 90 | mixed static / animated | ## Registered pack and generation jobs @@ -419,6 +419,27 @@ Only registered frames passing canvas, source-hash, PNG and alpha checks count a | DSHP11G3_PIC | `0x3009d` | 1 / 1 | | canonical-terrain-40155-40164 | `0x40155` | 16 / 16 | | canonical-terrain-40165-40174 | `0x40165` | 16 / 16 | +| Large air explosion padded replacement v10 | `0x101e5` | 12 / 12 | +| STAG02G4_PIC | `0x40088` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain set 3 shard 4 | `0x3011d` | 16 / 16 | +| Terrain 10410 standalone correction | `0x10410` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10411 standalone correction | `0x10411` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10412 standalone correction | `0x10412` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10413 standalone correction | `0x10413` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10414 standalone correction | `0x10414` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10415 standalone correction | `0x10415` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10416 standalone correction | `0x10416` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10417 standalone correction | `0x10417` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10418 standalone correction | `0x10418` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 10419 standalone correction | `0x10419` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 1041a standalone correction | `0x1041a` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 1041b standalone correction | `0x1041b` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 1041c standalone correction | `0x1041c` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 1041d standalone correction | `0x1041d` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 1041e standalone correction | `0x1041e` | 1 / 1 | +| Terrain 1041f standalone correction | `0x1041f` | 1 / 1 | +| canonical-terrain-40175-40184 | `0x40175` | 16 / 16 | +| canonical-terrain-40185-40194 | `0x40185` | 16 / 16 | | Generation job | Status | | --- | --- | diff --git a/docs/hd-completion.json b/docs/hd-completion.json index beffc738..d0fbfb38 100644 --- a/docs/hd-completion.json +++ b/docs/hd-completion.json @@ -19,11 +19,11 @@ ], "stage_contract": "Every generated candidate stays distinct from review, registration and render reachability. Original-only fallback is temporary for every required picture. Native cinematics/fonts have explicit preservation exceptions, not HD claims.", "picture_status_counts": { - "registered": 1051, - "missing": 1927, - "inprogress": 1022, + "registered": 1128, + "missing": 1831, + "inprogress": 1019, "renderreachable": 20, - "candidate": 1733 + "candidate": 1755 }, "assets": { "10001": { @@ -14543,7 +14543,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -14576,7 +14576,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -14609,7 +14609,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -14642,7 +14642,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -14675,7 +14675,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -14708,7 +14708,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -14741,7 +14741,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -14774,7 +14774,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -14807,7 +14807,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -14840,7 +14840,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -14873,7 +14873,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -14906,7 +14906,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -14939,7 +14939,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -14972,7 +14972,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15005,7 +15005,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15038,7 +15038,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15071,7 +15071,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15104,7 +15104,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15137,7 +15137,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15170,7 +15170,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15203,7 +15203,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15236,7 +15236,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15269,7 +15269,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15302,7 +15302,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15335,7 +15335,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15368,7 +15368,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15401,7 +15401,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15434,7 +15434,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15467,7 +15467,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15500,7 +15500,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15533,7 +15533,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15566,7 +15566,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15599,7 +15599,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15632,7 +15632,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15665,7 +15665,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15698,7 +15698,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15731,7 +15731,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15764,7 +15764,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15797,7 +15797,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15830,7 +15830,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15863,7 +15863,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -15896,7 +15896,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10164-1018d/candidate.json", - "sha256": "da4f6b7edd14e6ddbb25e573ef39efba301b7ea61ec62ca6ab0ce9a06b75759f", + "sha256": "6a3cf22669ed39574ec38e5c23b4727060f66052f84e4c0fc4f4c71ceaa531eb", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -26767,7 +26767,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101e5", "family_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", "job_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -26779,6 +26779,356 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", "sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d076a630af46f5c0f0ed37ea6b32c9665206da421ce89cba9d89de5532f16fbb", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.529798+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [\"APPROVED all12 frames after independent complete authentic-source/untouched-raw/native1\\u20134/native2\\u20133/fade/material/negative-space and actual terrain Canvas review. Major source ordering from small detached ray-star, ivory peak, yellow dark-core phase, open rust ring and sparse detached fading fragments remains recognizable, with original48canvas/[0,0] anchors. This is not a claim of exact source-pixel color/mask identity or live animation timing.\", \"Genuinev10 restores every one of the seven connected101eb inner-lip cells at21..23,17..19 with full occupied subpixel coverage at every scale. Native whole-cell losses fall72\\u21923 and4\\u00d7 losses30\\u21922. The source core opening no longer cuts deeply into the original painted lip. One remaining RGB89/28/4 inner-corner cell(23,16) is absent allscales, and outer upper-right RGB130/36/16(32,5) is also absent; a third native outer-right shoulder cell(43,12),RGB105/36/4, survives4\\u00d7. These are explicitly accepted minor isolated corner changes after visual crop/context inspection. Source enclosed holearea127 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea127.625 supports that inspection rather than replacing it.\", \"Genuinev10 restores four of five101ec original painted shoulder cells10..14,4 at every scale. Dim outer endpoint(14,4) remains absent allscales, alongside dim lower outer(14,45); three other low-scale corner cells return at4\\u00d7. Native losses94\\u21925 and4\\u00d7 losses14\\u21922. The original connected shoulder/rim band is visibly retained; the residual two exterior endpoint changes are accepted. Source coreholearea249 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea250.875 is disclosed; no new interior material fills the intended hole.\", \"Unchanged101e7/101e8/101e9/101ea retain their main lobes/rays and peak/dark-core shape. Whole source losses at4\\u00d7 are4/8/6/17, including connected small exterior edge strips in101e9/101ea. Every exact coordinate/index/RGB is enumerated. Source/native/mask and full composition inspection show localized external smoothing/notches rather than the earlier deep connected inner-lip or five-cell shoulder removal. These are accepted qualifications, including native20/29/37/62 wholly missing cells and four added native samples in101ea; no universal numeric allowance is implied.\", \"Previously restored first2 and late2 remain exact v9 bindings and are reassessed in the whole sequence:101e5 zero whole losses allscales;101e6 two native/one2\\u00d7/none3\\u20134\\u00d7. 101ed persistent(19,4) and101ee persistent(12..14,42), allRGB89/28/4, remain small exterior notches with the adjacent ring continuous. Last101ef has25 native andone4\\u00d7 lossRGB69/28/24(35,4);101f0 eight native andzero2\\u20134\\u00d7 losses. Ring break-up, detached fragment placements and tiny end remnants remain readable, with their exact area/edge/addition differences recorded.\", \"New101eb/101ec have conspicuously stronger organic flame grain, small hot yellow patches and higher local contrast than the original flat orange fields and smoother unchanged middle phases. This material transition is visible especially4\\u00d7 and is explicitly accepted after the complete sequence and actual terrain composition were inspected. Their integrated base-palette luminance ratios at4\\u00d7 are1.032/1.003 of source, and native meanRGB191.747/105.266/19.523 versus source192.898/98.785/19.606 for101eb, 182.017/89.871/18.054 versus185.136/87.098/19.042 for101ec. Near source means are diagnostic support, not proof that local brightness/material is identical. Stronger step-field texture in unchanged first2/late2 and the smoother grain in other phases are likewise disclosed.\", \"The full rise from yellow rays through ivory peak and the subsequent warmer/dimmer thinning ring and fragments remain clear. Last phases are somewhat dimmer/thinner than original: integrated4\\u00d7 luminance ratios101ed/ee/ef/f0 approximately.968/.930/.834/.851. They remain visible against authentic terrain, including every thin end fragment, so the darker fade treatment is accepted after actual composition review; no timing, audio, shadows or original mission backdrop is inferred.\", \"No visible broad brown background veil occurs in actual indexed/context proof. Nonzero rawRGB underalpha0 is hidden, not foreground. Source/output ordinary palette classes0..239 remain ordinary; no reserved/fire/water/blink semantics are invented. All current raws byte-match their genuine built-in outputs, with original binary/palette/reference PNG, prompt/provenance, candidate, exact immutable library and all actual evidence hash-bound.\", \"Original48-in64 viewports are independently verified in all references. V11 metadata chooses470-square crops78,78 and705,78 for newv10 cells, retaining everyalpha16/32 sample while excluding79/69 faintalpha1\\u201315 padding specks. No rawRGB/alpha repair or loader compensation was performed. Other10 bindings are byte-identical to v9, with52/60 actual spritePPMs and88/96CanvasPPMs unchanged.\", \"Approval is restricted to this exact complete-family independent artwork/indexed/crop/native-composition review. Coordinator registration/render reachability and live timing verification remain separate. Historicalv6/v9 and4006e holds remain preserved byte-for-byte; no production/source/global/Git/policy change was made.\"] \"Read-only complete-family source/hash-bound artwork/native gallery/crop/blitter review. Isolated ignored evidence writes only; no artwork/raw/candidate/source/global manifest/ledger/Git/registration/promotion or policy edits and no live Host claims. All earlier accepted/held artifacts remain preserved.\" All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 b493fa7d8f28a357d7fc4cc9e21fdedecaeb16f4f029c43e14aa7e12489e6b18", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101e5", + "101e6", + "101e7", + "101e8" + ], + "sha256": "f538dd1743bd39e36e6190882712540652a5db7aa81e0d9ab11221ac28ed693a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101e9", + "101ea", + "101eb", + "101ec" + ], + "sha256": "de4bb446e004c2a8f5e7bbf42b725d6db1d771114612a880fac7fcff741a0838", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ed", + "101ee", + "101ef", + "101f0" + ], + "sha256": "684357deae6d6d0a0433044b5abe8fd82fe3a2f7323be7b53e1ea3c90bd058c8", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101e5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1f0dcb0e0cdb9955675a37ba428be30db913c8d085088c26d90727979537f81b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d045049dd0d130ddb842ba2f13de3626001f102372da4f377585b5778f523a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ebd239e9e2efa9f643f2f5e9de12b442b54f05869ab03b8f50f09a488991fb55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4d0416ee8d3b31e1e750649a57261bbc6935f7c72405dec1f40c3b1c856920b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "91b655475797eb4eb0bc0f4ef2afcd6c0a8e5a63c43fe5f8bf639bb12753678b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d21530de88f2de5f3419e86581ea05939b3669a8c7afcd003c0deba267d17ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e79e0c2e8f7477f63f66ec8d73036da7874eb1d09e57e004bc277bc96f832514", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "98a140f6d56b9c1b55a1d999f20613b37b6b272ecfd5c560f24aba6de5063065", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "297d1b6117513576a45c4b59a3a510ee78e97b046cffe3851bc4832ed09c852f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a2538e1defca06ad217e76711bfd87353d37aba0d895d455700896c84a291aab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d1c4dda25106c9223a2b206a7b2092e34ff051cd0e0101e5f390fb3c5b1cd40", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ef216ae0207c06da15a54457a63c3d0d791ad1a0b642790931039332fb30851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2cf1eed2d0f482a2cb2e5dda8c4b0f7e787349c2a0be068943f179eab2a30b91", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "943bc627354dee1ed8fc342ed43a550a96a1f6e122265e1fd6e7b55ebd7b837a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7d308b0c0664ebedc8a48c1924df647e8ab5356f10369ff76d9745480b70258f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f71821252794fdcc162df4559ad89a9e17c83e865c9c42eb5e5fe6e1486c77ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4bd0246a19a3b99f9cc74908a97055ffa3125d269d55ab200b8913e1da35350d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2577a62301f6a0f48d28d96ba9d9677be3854363ad850261432b2f7848cb4efb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2c8462de5321a9aa8c010ac4ee3d1d7d9f99d4cebdd8ff360eaa11f2c98f8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "494c95630519c1f8f86b021953a4c1d004ab88291314d8214ae99bf46a66d773", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f60863bbd5bcc7586ddc30ac1104f7f617937d75db7d282cf4cbd40241f3fdee", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd3e6bf5f4efdaf5658aa715063afd7d71bf44f92c83cb54a9ab3333a7595f3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c7213976a82bc0776f3510079df457ea7c9d561b3250c060218c5bebf86802ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "48318af464b9331842af91d10d6af1aa6397007237c7b92a1c470e35a889de4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "14e8ebb425dfb8ccd9409cf5d10a3ba47a48c640fb2d6d00f262e9f1f54e30ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "841cf80c9e38c2d806342159bb9df36735222eb5c02e2da487a7373e39b8ca41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1776f3d7da186cd16b8e1948c0360c657926d588d092af0cc7fe685443ccddb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1c7b06f6f9bc3d8ec13cbf372961ab221ee571fa694a89794fba1e959171808a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b825ed0c4adaa6e69d46ed0d8addbfe3ad8415760b007ded9436b30b54726ac3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e7902214bcae894a78f3bb2f3cbfaf3d8a678d9623d4770827a0870422e91a02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "dde5fb91c3311bf3fa2b01905d8caca2b2272493a1d51f64c0d4cee884067de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21c7bcf6cc45834948676da6479310c03dbf79456f34a3562683058b548969e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c9d7e6a599473df325f24b4b28d0799b839ec9a2e66d3d147dec247db9d3cb99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2aefbdd2188bde4893296b179e0d67be03ece889ec14aa3cb0535c68013afae9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b8c11a52fa012a481638d5d2bd9ec34574447f7b2327e6b4e08f75b188adaf54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bf8e5608f8984526fc149a48e274bca2415ff7ee3fd47f8f247c21544d5d1d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cffa953ed1fc083bf92b6269ec59665572c102574778838aea9ad6626d6e87dd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "71c36d6e2b80109eff72988d92a4db4bf9441b18238c84a5f65695cc1e0eda58", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e66c182cb0d85e907e2467a9d2099bb64250efa5c04b6242d22a312481a8534d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4d2de0382aab4b9d578e2ba5c0ce46f9513ed386d403de911c45f97f23dc0f6a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9de8ca5ea46dd3b7fb10272af40d4a778b25b6dfeacbf401f2c8d69a8d02f222", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b88c981403cfafb4a2206e6d6e8a08977ce2e858f47b731beaf561036b7a04a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9ff5c14f677825b319fdf224dd76e11c54f72433e776bf4682d054d339eacb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1637367b461cb9593d876f3265104a08d3355752e11ea8e00b1715cf35090cc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d9b437b8412b04022303d44584b1bae64d7d0dae91ce7f34c697ff30e5048e3d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6b37b21fe0dd4dca9d9c1c037644f7dba87b5e0a63c5f5afbdb2176d14cfbeab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5647d9a5be366499e4f21b7a93b5497336f885bbb9bf02c935db7d91a750d68b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17a0a59d06a1e03de2bcbb4124e98a5839599eeb0d2b9239f46630d390c44779", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e76c109cfed21bad70607a5598b573b36d74d329c5bbb4885b51cc8cc5c71add", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7424f6878ac9f5df2304792473d5d05a97e7bded83f42f56d9a306571bf92175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2bf087b9dc7262e6a7ebdff41229822f38ca6795c94ee09bab2bd41969039512", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "752521664a85227c529765ddb1dd0463f96368fcb229bea9ba5ef140f2d30c23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f3d0047c70393e7513e25fc78cd97afde4ae3244b5532d4942e7e0d33d1334ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "80b29ba7d609a9591ae4a4b0671f61732115e3ff36a066dee07de29c65cbb0bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-original.ppm", + "sha256": "45f5d6af2b45c1a6b4ddd54e54c466cddf89ff53b8336aec5fbf1496de18adf5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a9396ab8a52c6d339872924781cb3fab345e4df4da9a5a28b2436c56969fc3b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dbb76c8288ae094d486d92c66c68a8fb69136647a980a36c5a31135def55df9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9699b366b52bf67eb86e244e1a050147573f2548be9e2e1a60d837a76437181", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d57684ff7879bb3edfde6a0b3c12dcad79e2757f82a6802027a3c2e88e3e202f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f7be90319ec076ba5932356ad61a6518b33ad5ab66487f9d63034a613e4417f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101e6": { @@ -26800,7 +27150,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101e6", "family_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", "job_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -26812,6 +27162,356 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", "sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d076a630af46f5c0f0ed37ea6b32c9665206da421ce89cba9d89de5532f16fbb", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.529798+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [\"APPROVED all12 frames after independent complete authentic-source/untouched-raw/native1\\u20134/native2\\u20133/fade/material/negative-space and actual terrain Canvas review. Major source ordering from small detached ray-star, ivory peak, yellow dark-core phase, open rust ring and sparse detached fading fragments remains recognizable, with original48canvas/[0,0] anchors. This is not a claim of exact source-pixel color/mask identity or live animation timing.\", \"Genuinev10 restores every one of the seven connected101eb inner-lip cells at21..23,17..19 with full occupied subpixel coverage at every scale. Native whole-cell losses fall72\\u21923 and4\\u00d7 losses30\\u21922. The source core opening no longer cuts deeply into the original painted lip. One remaining RGB89/28/4 inner-corner cell(23,16) is absent allscales, and outer upper-right RGB130/36/16(32,5) is also absent; a third native outer-right shoulder cell(43,12),RGB105/36/4, survives4\\u00d7. These are explicitly accepted minor isolated corner changes after visual crop/context inspection. Source enclosed holearea127 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea127.625 supports that inspection rather than replacing it.\", \"Genuinev10 restores four of five101ec original painted shoulder cells10..14,4 at every scale. Dim outer endpoint(14,4) remains absent allscales, alongside dim lower outer(14,45); three other low-scale corner cells return at4\\u00d7. Native losses94\\u21925 and4\\u00d7 losses14\\u21922. The original connected shoulder/rim band is visibly retained; the residual two exterior endpoint changes are accepted. Source coreholearea249 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea250.875 is disclosed; no new interior material fills the intended hole.\", \"Unchanged101e7/101e8/101e9/101ea retain their main lobes/rays and peak/dark-core shape. Whole source losses at4\\u00d7 are4/8/6/17, including connected small exterior edge strips in101e9/101ea. Every exact coordinate/index/RGB is enumerated. Source/native/mask and full composition inspection show localized external smoothing/notches rather than the earlier deep connected inner-lip or five-cell shoulder removal. These are accepted qualifications, including native20/29/37/62 wholly missing cells and four added native samples in101ea; no universal numeric allowance is implied.\", \"Previously restored first2 and late2 remain exact v9 bindings and are reassessed in the whole sequence:101e5 zero whole losses allscales;101e6 two native/one2\\u00d7/none3\\u20134\\u00d7. 101ed persistent(19,4) and101ee persistent(12..14,42), allRGB89/28/4, remain small exterior notches with the adjacent ring continuous. Last101ef has25 native andone4\\u00d7 lossRGB69/28/24(35,4);101f0 eight native andzero2\\u20134\\u00d7 losses. Ring break-up, detached fragment placements and tiny end remnants remain readable, with their exact area/edge/addition differences recorded.\", \"New101eb/101ec have conspicuously stronger organic flame grain, small hot yellow patches and higher local contrast than the original flat orange fields and smoother unchanged middle phases. This material transition is visible especially4\\u00d7 and is explicitly accepted after the complete sequence and actual terrain composition were inspected. Their integrated base-palette luminance ratios at4\\u00d7 are1.032/1.003 of source, and native meanRGB191.747/105.266/19.523 versus source192.898/98.785/19.606 for101eb, 182.017/89.871/18.054 versus185.136/87.098/19.042 for101ec. Near source means are diagnostic support, not proof that local brightness/material is identical. Stronger step-field texture in unchanged first2/late2 and the smoother grain in other phases are likewise disclosed.\", \"The full rise from yellow rays through ivory peak and the subsequent warmer/dimmer thinning ring and fragments remain clear. Last phases are somewhat dimmer/thinner than original: integrated4\\u00d7 luminance ratios101ed/ee/ef/f0 approximately.968/.930/.834/.851. They remain visible against authentic terrain, including every thin end fragment, so the darker fade treatment is accepted after actual composition review; no timing, audio, shadows or original mission backdrop is inferred.\", \"No visible broad brown background veil occurs in actual indexed/context proof. Nonzero rawRGB underalpha0 is hidden, not foreground. Source/output ordinary palette classes0..239 remain ordinary; no reserved/fire/water/blink semantics are invented. All current raws byte-match their genuine built-in outputs, with original binary/palette/reference PNG, prompt/provenance, candidate, exact immutable library and all actual evidence hash-bound.\", \"Original48-in64 viewports are independently verified in all references. V11 metadata chooses470-square crops78,78 and705,78 for newv10 cells, retaining everyalpha16/32 sample while excluding79/69 faintalpha1\\u201315 padding specks. No rawRGB/alpha repair or loader compensation was performed. Other10 bindings are byte-identical to v9, with52/60 actual spritePPMs and88/96CanvasPPMs unchanged.\", \"Approval is restricted to this exact complete-family independent artwork/indexed/crop/native-composition review. Coordinator registration/render reachability and live timing verification remain separate. Historicalv6/v9 and4006e holds remain preserved byte-for-byte; no production/source/global/Git/policy change was made.\"] \"Read-only complete-family source/hash-bound artwork/native gallery/crop/blitter review. Isolated ignored evidence writes only; no artwork/raw/candidate/source/global manifest/ledger/Git/registration/promotion or policy edits and no live Host claims. All earlier accepted/held artifacts remain preserved.\" All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 b493fa7d8f28a357d7fc4cc9e21fdedecaeb16f4f029c43e14aa7e12489e6b18", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101e5", + "101e6", + "101e7", + "101e8" + ], + "sha256": "f538dd1743bd39e36e6190882712540652a5db7aa81e0d9ab11221ac28ed693a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101e9", + "101ea", + "101eb", + "101ec" + ], + "sha256": "de4bb446e004c2a8f5e7bbf42b725d6db1d771114612a880fac7fcff741a0838", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ed", + "101ee", + "101ef", + "101f0" + ], + "sha256": "684357deae6d6d0a0433044b5abe8fd82fe3a2f7323be7b53e1ea3c90bd058c8", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101e5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1f0dcb0e0cdb9955675a37ba428be30db913c8d085088c26d90727979537f81b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d045049dd0d130ddb842ba2f13de3626001f102372da4f377585b5778f523a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ebd239e9e2efa9f643f2f5e9de12b442b54f05869ab03b8f50f09a488991fb55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4d0416ee8d3b31e1e750649a57261bbc6935f7c72405dec1f40c3b1c856920b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "91b655475797eb4eb0bc0f4ef2afcd6c0a8e5a63c43fe5f8bf639bb12753678b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d21530de88f2de5f3419e86581ea05939b3669a8c7afcd003c0deba267d17ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e79e0c2e8f7477f63f66ec8d73036da7874eb1d09e57e004bc277bc96f832514", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "98a140f6d56b9c1b55a1d999f20613b37b6b272ecfd5c560f24aba6de5063065", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "297d1b6117513576a45c4b59a3a510ee78e97b046cffe3851bc4832ed09c852f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a2538e1defca06ad217e76711bfd87353d37aba0d895d455700896c84a291aab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d1c4dda25106c9223a2b206a7b2092e34ff051cd0e0101e5f390fb3c5b1cd40", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ef216ae0207c06da15a54457a63c3d0d791ad1a0b642790931039332fb30851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2cf1eed2d0f482a2cb2e5dda8c4b0f7e787349c2a0be068943f179eab2a30b91", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "943bc627354dee1ed8fc342ed43a550a96a1f6e122265e1fd6e7b55ebd7b837a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7d308b0c0664ebedc8a48c1924df647e8ab5356f10369ff76d9745480b70258f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f71821252794fdcc162df4559ad89a9e17c83e865c9c42eb5e5fe6e1486c77ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4bd0246a19a3b99f9cc74908a97055ffa3125d269d55ab200b8913e1da35350d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2577a62301f6a0f48d28d96ba9d9677be3854363ad850261432b2f7848cb4efb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2c8462de5321a9aa8c010ac4ee3d1d7d9f99d4cebdd8ff360eaa11f2c98f8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "494c95630519c1f8f86b021953a4c1d004ab88291314d8214ae99bf46a66d773", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f60863bbd5bcc7586ddc30ac1104f7f617937d75db7d282cf4cbd40241f3fdee", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd3e6bf5f4efdaf5658aa715063afd7d71bf44f92c83cb54a9ab3333a7595f3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c7213976a82bc0776f3510079df457ea7c9d561b3250c060218c5bebf86802ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "48318af464b9331842af91d10d6af1aa6397007237c7b92a1c470e35a889de4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "14e8ebb425dfb8ccd9409cf5d10a3ba47a48c640fb2d6d00f262e9f1f54e30ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "841cf80c9e38c2d806342159bb9df36735222eb5c02e2da487a7373e39b8ca41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1776f3d7da186cd16b8e1948c0360c657926d588d092af0cc7fe685443ccddb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1c7b06f6f9bc3d8ec13cbf372961ab221ee571fa694a89794fba1e959171808a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b825ed0c4adaa6e69d46ed0d8addbfe3ad8415760b007ded9436b30b54726ac3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e7902214bcae894a78f3bb2f3cbfaf3d8a678d9623d4770827a0870422e91a02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "dde5fb91c3311bf3fa2b01905d8caca2b2272493a1d51f64c0d4cee884067de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21c7bcf6cc45834948676da6479310c03dbf79456f34a3562683058b548969e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c9d7e6a599473df325f24b4b28d0799b839ec9a2e66d3d147dec247db9d3cb99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2aefbdd2188bde4893296b179e0d67be03ece889ec14aa3cb0535c68013afae9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b8c11a52fa012a481638d5d2bd9ec34574447f7b2327e6b4e08f75b188adaf54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bf8e5608f8984526fc149a48e274bca2415ff7ee3fd47f8f247c21544d5d1d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cffa953ed1fc083bf92b6269ec59665572c102574778838aea9ad6626d6e87dd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "71c36d6e2b80109eff72988d92a4db4bf9441b18238c84a5f65695cc1e0eda58", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e66c182cb0d85e907e2467a9d2099bb64250efa5c04b6242d22a312481a8534d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4d2de0382aab4b9d578e2ba5c0ce46f9513ed386d403de911c45f97f23dc0f6a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9de8ca5ea46dd3b7fb10272af40d4a778b25b6dfeacbf401f2c8d69a8d02f222", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b88c981403cfafb4a2206e6d6e8a08977ce2e858f47b731beaf561036b7a04a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9ff5c14f677825b319fdf224dd76e11c54f72433e776bf4682d054d339eacb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1637367b461cb9593d876f3265104a08d3355752e11ea8e00b1715cf35090cc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d9b437b8412b04022303d44584b1bae64d7d0dae91ce7f34c697ff30e5048e3d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6b37b21fe0dd4dca9d9c1c037644f7dba87b5e0a63c5f5afbdb2176d14cfbeab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5647d9a5be366499e4f21b7a93b5497336f885bbb9bf02c935db7d91a750d68b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17a0a59d06a1e03de2bcbb4124e98a5839599eeb0d2b9239f46630d390c44779", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e76c109cfed21bad70607a5598b573b36d74d329c5bbb4885b51cc8cc5c71add", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7424f6878ac9f5df2304792473d5d05a97e7bded83f42f56d9a306571bf92175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2bf087b9dc7262e6a7ebdff41229822f38ca6795c94ee09bab2bd41969039512", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "752521664a85227c529765ddb1dd0463f96368fcb229bea9ba5ef140f2d30c23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f3d0047c70393e7513e25fc78cd97afde4ae3244b5532d4942e7e0d33d1334ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "80b29ba7d609a9591ae4a4b0671f61732115e3ff36a066dee07de29c65cbb0bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-original.ppm", + "sha256": "45f5d6af2b45c1a6b4ddd54e54c466cddf89ff53b8336aec5fbf1496de18adf5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a9396ab8a52c6d339872924781cb3fab345e4df4da9a5a28b2436c56969fc3b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dbb76c8288ae094d486d92c66c68a8fb69136647a980a36c5a31135def55df9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9699b366b52bf67eb86e244e1a050147573f2548be9e2e1a60d837a76437181", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d57684ff7879bb3edfde6a0b3c12dcad79e2757f82a6802027a3c2e88e3e202f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f7be90319ec076ba5932356ad61a6518b33ad5ab66487f9d63034a613e4417f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101e7": { @@ -26833,7 +27533,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101e7", "family_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", "job_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -26845,6 +27545,356 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", "sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d076a630af46f5c0f0ed37ea6b32c9665206da421ce89cba9d89de5532f16fbb", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.529798+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [\"APPROVED all12 frames after independent complete authentic-source/untouched-raw/native1\\u20134/native2\\u20133/fade/material/negative-space and actual terrain Canvas review. Major source ordering from small detached ray-star, ivory peak, yellow dark-core phase, open rust ring and sparse detached fading fragments remains recognizable, with original48canvas/[0,0] anchors. This is not a claim of exact source-pixel color/mask identity or live animation timing.\", \"Genuinev10 restores every one of the seven connected101eb inner-lip cells at21..23,17..19 with full occupied subpixel coverage at every scale. Native whole-cell losses fall72\\u21923 and4\\u00d7 losses30\\u21922. The source core opening no longer cuts deeply into the original painted lip. One remaining RGB89/28/4 inner-corner cell(23,16) is absent allscales, and outer upper-right RGB130/36/16(32,5) is also absent; a third native outer-right shoulder cell(43,12),RGB105/36/4, survives4\\u00d7. These are explicitly accepted minor isolated corner changes after visual crop/context inspection. Source enclosed holearea127 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea127.625 supports that inspection rather than replacing it.\", \"Genuinev10 restores four of five101ec original painted shoulder cells10..14,4 at every scale. Dim outer endpoint(14,4) remains absent allscales, alongside dim lower outer(14,45); three other low-scale corner cells return at4\\u00d7. Native losses94\\u21925 and4\\u00d7 losses14\\u21922. The original connected shoulder/rim band is visibly retained; the residual two exterior endpoint changes are accepted. Source coreholearea249 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea250.875 is disclosed; no new interior material fills the intended hole.\", \"Unchanged101e7/101e8/101e9/101ea retain their main lobes/rays and peak/dark-core shape. Whole source losses at4\\u00d7 are4/8/6/17, including connected small exterior edge strips in101e9/101ea. Every exact coordinate/index/RGB is enumerated. Source/native/mask and full composition inspection show localized external smoothing/notches rather than the earlier deep connected inner-lip or five-cell shoulder removal. These are accepted qualifications, including native20/29/37/62 wholly missing cells and four added native samples in101ea; no universal numeric allowance is implied.\", \"Previously restored first2 and late2 remain exact v9 bindings and are reassessed in the whole sequence:101e5 zero whole losses allscales;101e6 two native/one2\\u00d7/none3\\u20134\\u00d7. 101ed persistent(19,4) and101ee persistent(12..14,42), allRGB89/28/4, remain small exterior notches with the adjacent ring continuous. Last101ef has25 native andone4\\u00d7 lossRGB69/28/24(35,4);101f0 eight native andzero2\\u20134\\u00d7 losses. Ring break-up, detached fragment placements and tiny end remnants remain readable, with their exact area/edge/addition differences recorded.\", \"New101eb/101ec have conspicuously stronger organic flame grain, small hot yellow patches and higher local contrast than the original flat orange fields and smoother unchanged middle phases. This material transition is visible especially4\\u00d7 and is explicitly accepted after the complete sequence and actual terrain composition were inspected. Their integrated base-palette luminance ratios at4\\u00d7 are1.032/1.003 of source, and native meanRGB191.747/105.266/19.523 versus source192.898/98.785/19.606 for101eb, 182.017/89.871/18.054 versus185.136/87.098/19.042 for101ec. Near source means are diagnostic support, not proof that local brightness/material is identical. Stronger step-field texture in unchanged first2/late2 and the smoother grain in other phases are likewise disclosed.\", \"The full rise from yellow rays through ivory peak and the subsequent warmer/dimmer thinning ring and fragments remain clear. Last phases are somewhat dimmer/thinner than original: integrated4\\u00d7 luminance ratios101ed/ee/ef/f0 approximately.968/.930/.834/.851. They remain visible against authentic terrain, including every thin end fragment, so the darker fade treatment is accepted after actual composition review; no timing, audio, shadows or original mission backdrop is inferred.\", \"No visible broad brown background veil occurs in actual indexed/context proof. Nonzero rawRGB underalpha0 is hidden, not foreground. Source/output ordinary palette classes0..239 remain ordinary; no reserved/fire/water/blink semantics are invented. All current raws byte-match their genuine built-in outputs, with original binary/palette/reference PNG, prompt/provenance, candidate, exact immutable library and all actual evidence hash-bound.\", \"Original48-in64 viewports are independently verified in all references. V11 metadata chooses470-square crops78,78 and705,78 for newv10 cells, retaining everyalpha16/32 sample while excluding79/69 faintalpha1\\u201315 padding specks. No rawRGB/alpha repair or loader compensation was performed. Other10 bindings are byte-identical to v9, with52/60 actual spritePPMs and88/96CanvasPPMs unchanged.\", \"Approval is restricted to this exact complete-family independent artwork/indexed/crop/native-composition review. Coordinator registration/render reachability and live timing verification remain separate. Historicalv6/v9 and4006e holds remain preserved byte-for-byte; no production/source/global/Git/policy change was made.\"] \"Read-only complete-family source/hash-bound artwork/native gallery/crop/blitter review. Isolated ignored evidence writes only; no artwork/raw/candidate/source/global manifest/ledger/Git/registration/promotion or policy edits and no live Host claims. All earlier accepted/held artifacts remain preserved.\" All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 b493fa7d8f28a357d7fc4cc9e21fdedecaeb16f4f029c43e14aa7e12489e6b18", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101e5", + "101e6", + "101e7", + "101e8" + ], + "sha256": "f538dd1743bd39e36e6190882712540652a5db7aa81e0d9ab11221ac28ed693a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101e9", + "101ea", + "101eb", + "101ec" + ], + "sha256": "de4bb446e004c2a8f5e7bbf42b725d6db1d771114612a880fac7fcff741a0838", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ed", + "101ee", + "101ef", + "101f0" + ], + "sha256": "684357deae6d6d0a0433044b5abe8fd82fe3a2f7323be7b53e1ea3c90bd058c8", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101e5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1f0dcb0e0cdb9955675a37ba428be30db913c8d085088c26d90727979537f81b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d045049dd0d130ddb842ba2f13de3626001f102372da4f377585b5778f523a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ebd239e9e2efa9f643f2f5e9de12b442b54f05869ab03b8f50f09a488991fb55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4d0416ee8d3b31e1e750649a57261bbc6935f7c72405dec1f40c3b1c856920b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "91b655475797eb4eb0bc0f4ef2afcd6c0a8e5a63c43fe5f8bf639bb12753678b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d21530de88f2de5f3419e86581ea05939b3669a8c7afcd003c0deba267d17ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e79e0c2e8f7477f63f66ec8d73036da7874eb1d09e57e004bc277bc96f832514", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "98a140f6d56b9c1b55a1d999f20613b37b6b272ecfd5c560f24aba6de5063065", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "297d1b6117513576a45c4b59a3a510ee78e97b046cffe3851bc4832ed09c852f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a2538e1defca06ad217e76711bfd87353d37aba0d895d455700896c84a291aab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d1c4dda25106c9223a2b206a7b2092e34ff051cd0e0101e5f390fb3c5b1cd40", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ef216ae0207c06da15a54457a63c3d0d791ad1a0b642790931039332fb30851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2cf1eed2d0f482a2cb2e5dda8c4b0f7e787349c2a0be068943f179eab2a30b91", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "943bc627354dee1ed8fc342ed43a550a96a1f6e122265e1fd6e7b55ebd7b837a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7d308b0c0664ebedc8a48c1924df647e8ab5356f10369ff76d9745480b70258f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f71821252794fdcc162df4559ad89a9e17c83e865c9c42eb5e5fe6e1486c77ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4bd0246a19a3b99f9cc74908a97055ffa3125d269d55ab200b8913e1da35350d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2577a62301f6a0f48d28d96ba9d9677be3854363ad850261432b2f7848cb4efb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2c8462de5321a9aa8c010ac4ee3d1d7d9f99d4cebdd8ff360eaa11f2c98f8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "494c95630519c1f8f86b021953a4c1d004ab88291314d8214ae99bf46a66d773", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f60863bbd5bcc7586ddc30ac1104f7f617937d75db7d282cf4cbd40241f3fdee", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd3e6bf5f4efdaf5658aa715063afd7d71bf44f92c83cb54a9ab3333a7595f3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c7213976a82bc0776f3510079df457ea7c9d561b3250c060218c5bebf86802ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "48318af464b9331842af91d10d6af1aa6397007237c7b92a1c470e35a889de4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "14e8ebb425dfb8ccd9409cf5d10a3ba47a48c640fb2d6d00f262e9f1f54e30ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "841cf80c9e38c2d806342159bb9df36735222eb5c02e2da487a7373e39b8ca41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1776f3d7da186cd16b8e1948c0360c657926d588d092af0cc7fe685443ccddb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1c7b06f6f9bc3d8ec13cbf372961ab221ee571fa694a89794fba1e959171808a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b825ed0c4adaa6e69d46ed0d8addbfe3ad8415760b007ded9436b30b54726ac3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e7902214bcae894a78f3bb2f3cbfaf3d8a678d9623d4770827a0870422e91a02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "dde5fb91c3311bf3fa2b01905d8caca2b2272493a1d51f64c0d4cee884067de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21c7bcf6cc45834948676da6479310c03dbf79456f34a3562683058b548969e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c9d7e6a599473df325f24b4b28d0799b839ec9a2e66d3d147dec247db9d3cb99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2aefbdd2188bde4893296b179e0d67be03ece889ec14aa3cb0535c68013afae9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b8c11a52fa012a481638d5d2bd9ec34574447f7b2327e6b4e08f75b188adaf54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bf8e5608f8984526fc149a48e274bca2415ff7ee3fd47f8f247c21544d5d1d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cffa953ed1fc083bf92b6269ec59665572c102574778838aea9ad6626d6e87dd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "71c36d6e2b80109eff72988d92a4db4bf9441b18238c84a5f65695cc1e0eda58", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e66c182cb0d85e907e2467a9d2099bb64250efa5c04b6242d22a312481a8534d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4d2de0382aab4b9d578e2ba5c0ce46f9513ed386d403de911c45f97f23dc0f6a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9de8ca5ea46dd3b7fb10272af40d4a778b25b6dfeacbf401f2c8d69a8d02f222", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b88c981403cfafb4a2206e6d6e8a08977ce2e858f47b731beaf561036b7a04a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9ff5c14f677825b319fdf224dd76e11c54f72433e776bf4682d054d339eacb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1637367b461cb9593d876f3265104a08d3355752e11ea8e00b1715cf35090cc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d9b437b8412b04022303d44584b1bae64d7d0dae91ce7f34c697ff30e5048e3d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6b37b21fe0dd4dca9d9c1c037644f7dba87b5e0a63c5f5afbdb2176d14cfbeab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5647d9a5be366499e4f21b7a93b5497336f885bbb9bf02c935db7d91a750d68b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17a0a59d06a1e03de2bcbb4124e98a5839599eeb0d2b9239f46630d390c44779", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e76c109cfed21bad70607a5598b573b36d74d329c5bbb4885b51cc8cc5c71add", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7424f6878ac9f5df2304792473d5d05a97e7bded83f42f56d9a306571bf92175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2bf087b9dc7262e6a7ebdff41229822f38ca6795c94ee09bab2bd41969039512", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "752521664a85227c529765ddb1dd0463f96368fcb229bea9ba5ef140f2d30c23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f3d0047c70393e7513e25fc78cd97afde4ae3244b5532d4942e7e0d33d1334ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "80b29ba7d609a9591ae4a4b0671f61732115e3ff36a066dee07de29c65cbb0bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-original.ppm", + "sha256": "45f5d6af2b45c1a6b4ddd54e54c466cddf89ff53b8336aec5fbf1496de18adf5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a9396ab8a52c6d339872924781cb3fab345e4df4da9a5a28b2436c56969fc3b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dbb76c8288ae094d486d92c66c68a8fb69136647a980a36c5a31135def55df9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9699b366b52bf67eb86e244e1a050147573f2548be9e2e1a60d837a76437181", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d57684ff7879bb3edfde6a0b3c12dcad79e2757f82a6802027a3c2e88e3e202f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f7be90319ec076ba5932356ad61a6518b33ad5ab66487f9d63034a613e4417f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101e8": { @@ -26866,7 +27916,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101e8", "family_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", "job_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -26878,6 +27928,356 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", "sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d076a630af46f5c0f0ed37ea6b32c9665206da421ce89cba9d89de5532f16fbb", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.529798+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [\"APPROVED all12 frames after independent complete authentic-source/untouched-raw/native1\\u20134/native2\\u20133/fade/material/negative-space and actual terrain Canvas review. Major source ordering from small detached ray-star, ivory peak, yellow dark-core phase, open rust ring and sparse detached fading fragments remains recognizable, with original48canvas/[0,0] anchors. This is not a claim of exact source-pixel color/mask identity or live animation timing.\", \"Genuinev10 restores every one of the seven connected101eb inner-lip cells at21..23,17..19 with full occupied subpixel coverage at every scale. Native whole-cell losses fall72\\u21923 and4\\u00d7 losses30\\u21922. The source core opening no longer cuts deeply into the original painted lip. One remaining RGB89/28/4 inner-corner cell(23,16) is absent allscales, and outer upper-right RGB130/36/16(32,5) is also absent; a third native outer-right shoulder cell(43,12),RGB105/36/4, survives4\\u00d7. These are explicitly accepted minor isolated corner changes after visual crop/context inspection. Source enclosed holearea127 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea127.625 supports that inspection rather than replacing it.\", \"Genuinev10 restores four of five101ec original painted shoulder cells10..14,4 at every scale. Dim outer endpoint(14,4) remains absent allscales, alongside dim lower outer(14,45); three other low-scale corner cells return at4\\u00d7. Native losses94\\u21925 and4\\u00d7 losses14\\u21922. The original connected shoulder/rim band is visibly retained; the residual two exterior endpoint changes are accepted. Source coreholearea249 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea250.875 is disclosed; no new interior material fills the intended hole.\", \"Unchanged101e7/101e8/101e9/101ea retain their main lobes/rays and peak/dark-core shape. Whole source losses at4\\u00d7 are4/8/6/17, including connected small exterior edge strips in101e9/101ea. Every exact coordinate/index/RGB is enumerated. Source/native/mask and full composition inspection show localized external smoothing/notches rather than the earlier deep connected inner-lip or five-cell shoulder removal. These are accepted qualifications, including native20/29/37/62 wholly missing cells and four added native samples in101ea; no universal numeric allowance is implied.\", \"Previously restored first2 and late2 remain exact v9 bindings and are reassessed in the whole sequence:101e5 zero whole losses allscales;101e6 two native/one2\\u00d7/none3\\u20134\\u00d7. 101ed persistent(19,4) and101ee persistent(12..14,42), allRGB89/28/4, remain small exterior notches with the adjacent ring continuous. Last101ef has25 native andone4\\u00d7 lossRGB69/28/24(35,4);101f0 eight native andzero2\\u20134\\u00d7 losses. Ring break-up, detached fragment placements and tiny end remnants remain readable, with their exact area/edge/addition differences recorded.\", \"New101eb/101ec have conspicuously stronger organic flame grain, small hot yellow patches and higher local contrast than the original flat orange fields and smoother unchanged middle phases. This material transition is visible especially4\\u00d7 and is explicitly accepted after the complete sequence and actual terrain composition were inspected. Their integrated base-palette luminance ratios at4\\u00d7 are1.032/1.003 of source, and native meanRGB191.747/105.266/19.523 versus source192.898/98.785/19.606 for101eb, 182.017/89.871/18.054 versus185.136/87.098/19.042 for101ec. Near source means are diagnostic support, not proof that local brightness/material is identical. Stronger step-field texture in unchanged first2/late2 and the smoother grain in other phases are likewise disclosed.\", \"The full rise from yellow rays through ivory peak and the subsequent warmer/dimmer thinning ring and fragments remain clear. Last phases are somewhat dimmer/thinner than original: integrated4\\u00d7 luminance ratios101ed/ee/ef/f0 approximately.968/.930/.834/.851. They remain visible against authentic terrain, including every thin end fragment, so the darker fade treatment is accepted after actual composition review; no timing, audio, shadows or original mission backdrop is inferred.\", \"No visible broad brown background veil occurs in actual indexed/context proof. Nonzero rawRGB underalpha0 is hidden, not foreground. Source/output ordinary palette classes0..239 remain ordinary; no reserved/fire/water/blink semantics are invented. All current raws byte-match their genuine built-in outputs, with original binary/palette/reference PNG, prompt/provenance, candidate, exact immutable library and all actual evidence hash-bound.\", \"Original48-in64 viewports are independently verified in all references. V11 metadata chooses470-square crops78,78 and705,78 for newv10 cells, retaining everyalpha16/32 sample while excluding79/69 faintalpha1\\u201315 padding specks. No rawRGB/alpha repair or loader compensation was performed. Other10 bindings are byte-identical to v9, with52/60 actual spritePPMs and88/96CanvasPPMs unchanged.\", \"Approval is restricted to this exact complete-family independent artwork/indexed/crop/native-composition review. Coordinator registration/render reachability and live timing verification remain separate. Historicalv6/v9 and4006e holds remain preserved byte-for-byte; no production/source/global/Git/policy change was made.\"] \"Read-only complete-family source/hash-bound artwork/native gallery/crop/blitter review. Isolated ignored evidence writes only; no artwork/raw/candidate/source/global manifest/ledger/Git/registration/promotion or policy edits and no live Host claims. All earlier accepted/held artifacts remain preserved.\" All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 b493fa7d8f28a357d7fc4cc9e21fdedecaeb16f4f029c43e14aa7e12489e6b18", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101e5", + "101e6", + "101e7", + "101e8" + ], + "sha256": "f538dd1743bd39e36e6190882712540652a5db7aa81e0d9ab11221ac28ed693a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101e9", + "101ea", + "101eb", + "101ec" + ], + "sha256": "de4bb446e004c2a8f5e7bbf42b725d6db1d771114612a880fac7fcff741a0838", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ed", + "101ee", + "101ef", + "101f0" + ], + "sha256": "684357deae6d6d0a0433044b5abe8fd82fe3a2f7323be7b53e1ea3c90bd058c8", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101e5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1f0dcb0e0cdb9955675a37ba428be30db913c8d085088c26d90727979537f81b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d045049dd0d130ddb842ba2f13de3626001f102372da4f377585b5778f523a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ebd239e9e2efa9f643f2f5e9de12b442b54f05869ab03b8f50f09a488991fb55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4d0416ee8d3b31e1e750649a57261bbc6935f7c72405dec1f40c3b1c856920b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "91b655475797eb4eb0bc0f4ef2afcd6c0a8e5a63c43fe5f8bf639bb12753678b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d21530de88f2de5f3419e86581ea05939b3669a8c7afcd003c0deba267d17ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e79e0c2e8f7477f63f66ec8d73036da7874eb1d09e57e004bc277bc96f832514", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "98a140f6d56b9c1b55a1d999f20613b37b6b272ecfd5c560f24aba6de5063065", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "297d1b6117513576a45c4b59a3a510ee78e97b046cffe3851bc4832ed09c852f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a2538e1defca06ad217e76711bfd87353d37aba0d895d455700896c84a291aab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d1c4dda25106c9223a2b206a7b2092e34ff051cd0e0101e5f390fb3c5b1cd40", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ef216ae0207c06da15a54457a63c3d0d791ad1a0b642790931039332fb30851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2cf1eed2d0f482a2cb2e5dda8c4b0f7e787349c2a0be068943f179eab2a30b91", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "943bc627354dee1ed8fc342ed43a550a96a1f6e122265e1fd6e7b55ebd7b837a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7d308b0c0664ebedc8a48c1924df647e8ab5356f10369ff76d9745480b70258f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f71821252794fdcc162df4559ad89a9e17c83e865c9c42eb5e5fe6e1486c77ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4bd0246a19a3b99f9cc74908a97055ffa3125d269d55ab200b8913e1da35350d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2577a62301f6a0f48d28d96ba9d9677be3854363ad850261432b2f7848cb4efb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2c8462de5321a9aa8c010ac4ee3d1d7d9f99d4cebdd8ff360eaa11f2c98f8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "494c95630519c1f8f86b021953a4c1d004ab88291314d8214ae99bf46a66d773", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f60863bbd5bcc7586ddc30ac1104f7f617937d75db7d282cf4cbd40241f3fdee", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd3e6bf5f4efdaf5658aa715063afd7d71bf44f92c83cb54a9ab3333a7595f3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c7213976a82bc0776f3510079df457ea7c9d561b3250c060218c5bebf86802ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "48318af464b9331842af91d10d6af1aa6397007237c7b92a1c470e35a889de4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "14e8ebb425dfb8ccd9409cf5d10a3ba47a48c640fb2d6d00f262e9f1f54e30ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "841cf80c9e38c2d806342159bb9df36735222eb5c02e2da487a7373e39b8ca41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1776f3d7da186cd16b8e1948c0360c657926d588d092af0cc7fe685443ccddb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1c7b06f6f9bc3d8ec13cbf372961ab221ee571fa694a89794fba1e959171808a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b825ed0c4adaa6e69d46ed0d8addbfe3ad8415760b007ded9436b30b54726ac3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e7902214bcae894a78f3bb2f3cbfaf3d8a678d9623d4770827a0870422e91a02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "dde5fb91c3311bf3fa2b01905d8caca2b2272493a1d51f64c0d4cee884067de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21c7bcf6cc45834948676da6479310c03dbf79456f34a3562683058b548969e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c9d7e6a599473df325f24b4b28d0799b839ec9a2e66d3d147dec247db9d3cb99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2aefbdd2188bde4893296b179e0d67be03ece889ec14aa3cb0535c68013afae9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b8c11a52fa012a481638d5d2bd9ec34574447f7b2327e6b4e08f75b188adaf54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bf8e5608f8984526fc149a48e274bca2415ff7ee3fd47f8f247c21544d5d1d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cffa953ed1fc083bf92b6269ec59665572c102574778838aea9ad6626d6e87dd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "71c36d6e2b80109eff72988d92a4db4bf9441b18238c84a5f65695cc1e0eda58", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e66c182cb0d85e907e2467a9d2099bb64250efa5c04b6242d22a312481a8534d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4d2de0382aab4b9d578e2ba5c0ce46f9513ed386d403de911c45f97f23dc0f6a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9de8ca5ea46dd3b7fb10272af40d4a778b25b6dfeacbf401f2c8d69a8d02f222", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b88c981403cfafb4a2206e6d6e8a08977ce2e858f47b731beaf561036b7a04a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9ff5c14f677825b319fdf224dd76e11c54f72433e776bf4682d054d339eacb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1637367b461cb9593d876f3265104a08d3355752e11ea8e00b1715cf35090cc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d9b437b8412b04022303d44584b1bae64d7d0dae91ce7f34c697ff30e5048e3d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6b37b21fe0dd4dca9d9c1c037644f7dba87b5e0a63c5f5afbdb2176d14cfbeab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5647d9a5be366499e4f21b7a93b5497336f885bbb9bf02c935db7d91a750d68b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17a0a59d06a1e03de2bcbb4124e98a5839599eeb0d2b9239f46630d390c44779", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e76c109cfed21bad70607a5598b573b36d74d329c5bbb4885b51cc8cc5c71add", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7424f6878ac9f5df2304792473d5d05a97e7bded83f42f56d9a306571bf92175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2bf087b9dc7262e6a7ebdff41229822f38ca6795c94ee09bab2bd41969039512", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "752521664a85227c529765ddb1dd0463f96368fcb229bea9ba5ef140f2d30c23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f3d0047c70393e7513e25fc78cd97afde4ae3244b5532d4942e7e0d33d1334ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "80b29ba7d609a9591ae4a4b0671f61732115e3ff36a066dee07de29c65cbb0bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-original.ppm", + "sha256": "45f5d6af2b45c1a6b4ddd54e54c466cddf89ff53b8336aec5fbf1496de18adf5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a9396ab8a52c6d339872924781cb3fab345e4df4da9a5a28b2436c56969fc3b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dbb76c8288ae094d486d92c66c68a8fb69136647a980a36c5a31135def55df9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9699b366b52bf67eb86e244e1a050147573f2548be9e2e1a60d837a76437181", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d57684ff7879bb3edfde6a0b3c12dcad79e2757f82a6802027a3c2e88e3e202f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f7be90319ec076ba5932356ad61a6518b33ad5ab66487f9d63034a613e4417f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101e9": { @@ -26899,7 +28299,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101e9", "family_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", "job_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -26911,6 +28311,356 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", "sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d076a630af46f5c0f0ed37ea6b32c9665206da421ce89cba9d89de5532f16fbb", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.529798+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [\"APPROVED all12 frames after independent complete authentic-source/untouched-raw/native1\\u20134/native2\\u20133/fade/material/negative-space and actual terrain Canvas review. Major source ordering from small detached ray-star, ivory peak, yellow dark-core phase, open rust ring and sparse detached fading fragments remains recognizable, with original48canvas/[0,0] anchors. This is not a claim of exact source-pixel color/mask identity or live animation timing.\", \"Genuinev10 restores every one of the seven connected101eb inner-lip cells at21..23,17..19 with full occupied subpixel coverage at every scale. Native whole-cell losses fall72\\u21923 and4\\u00d7 losses30\\u21922. The source core opening no longer cuts deeply into the original painted lip. One remaining RGB89/28/4 inner-corner cell(23,16) is absent allscales, and outer upper-right RGB130/36/16(32,5) is also absent; a third native outer-right shoulder cell(43,12),RGB105/36/4, survives4\\u00d7. These are explicitly accepted minor isolated corner changes after visual crop/context inspection. Source enclosed holearea127 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea127.625 supports that inspection rather than replacing it.\", \"Genuinev10 restores four of five101ec original painted shoulder cells10..14,4 at every scale. Dim outer endpoint(14,4) remains absent allscales, alongside dim lower outer(14,45); three other low-scale corner cells return at4\\u00d7. Native losses94\\u21925 and4\\u00d7 losses14\\u21922. The original connected shoulder/rim band is visibly retained; the residual two exterior endpoint changes are accepted. Source coreholearea249 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea250.875 is disclosed; no new interior material fills the intended hole.\", \"Unchanged101e7/101e8/101e9/101ea retain their main lobes/rays and peak/dark-core shape. Whole source losses at4\\u00d7 are4/8/6/17, including connected small exterior edge strips in101e9/101ea. Every exact coordinate/index/RGB is enumerated. Source/native/mask and full composition inspection show localized external smoothing/notches rather than the earlier deep connected inner-lip or five-cell shoulder removal. These are accepted qualifications, including native20/29/37/62 wholly missing cells and four added native samples in101ea; no universal numeric allowance is implied.\", \"Previously restored first2 and late2 remain exact v9 bindings and are reassessed in the whole sequence:101e5 zero whole losses allscales;101e6 two native/one2\\u00d7/none3\\u20134\\u00d7. 101ed persistent(19,4) and101ee persistent(12..14,42), allRGB89/28/4, remain small exterior notches with the adjacent ring continuous. Last101ef has25 native andone4\\u00d7 lossRGB69/28/24(35,4);101f0 eight native andzero2\\u20134\\u00d7 losses. Ring break-up, detached fragment placements and tiny end remnants remain readable, with their exact area/edge/addition differences recorded.\", \"New101eb/101ec have conspicuously stronger organic flame grain, small hot yellow patches and higher local contrast than the original flat orange fields and smoother unchanged middle phases. This material transition is visible especially4\\u00d7 and is explicitly accepted after the complete sequence and actual terrain composition were inspected. Their integrated base-palette luminance ratios at4\\u00d7 are1.032/1.003 of source, and native meanRGB191.747/105.266/19.523 versus source192.898/98.785/19.606 for101eb, 182.017/89.871/18.054 versus185.136/87.098/19.042 for101ec. Near source means are diagnostic support, not proof that local brightness/material is identical. Stronger step-field texture in unchanged first2/late2 and the smoother grain in other phases are likewise disclosed.\", \"The full rise from yellow rays through ivory peak and the subsequent warmer/dimmer thinning ring and fragments remain clear. Last phases are somewhat dimmer/thinner than original: integrated4\\u00d7 luminance ratios101ed/ee/ef/f0 approximately.968/.930/.834/.851. They remain visible against authentic terrain, including every thin end fragment, so the darker fade treatment is accepted after actual composition review; no timing, audio, shadows or original mission backdrop is inferred.\", \"No visible broad brown background veil occurs in actual indexed/context proof. Nonzero rawRGB underalpha0 is hidden, not foreground. Source/output ordinary palette classes0..239 remain ordinary; no reserved/fire/water/blink semantics are invented. All current raws byte-match their genuine built-in outputs, with original binary/palette/reference PNG, prompt/provenance, candidate, exact immutable library and all actual evidence hash-bound.\", \"Original48-in64 viewports are independently verified in all references. V11 metadata chooses470-square crops78,78 and705,78 for newv10 cells, retaining everyalpha16/32 sample while excluding79/69 faintalpha1\\u201315 padding specks. No rawRGB/alpha repair or loader compensation was performed. Other10 bindings are byte-identical to v9, with52/60 actual spritePPMs and88/96CanvasPPMs unchanged.\", \"Approval is restricted to this exact complete-family independent artwork/indexed/crop/native-composition review. Coordinator registration/render reachability and live timing verification remain separate. Historicalv6/v9 and4006e holds remain preserved byte-for-byte; no production/source/global/Git/policy change was made.\"] \"Read-only complete-family source/hash-bound artwork/native gallery/crop/blitter review. Isolated ignored evidence writes only; no artwork/raw/candidate/source/global manifest/ledger/Git/registration/promotion or policy edits and no live Host claims. All earlier accepted/held artifacts remain preserved.\" All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 b493fa7d8f28a357d7fc4cc9e21fdedecaeb16f4f029c43e14aa7e12489e6b18", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101e5", + "101e6", + "101e7", + "101e8" + ], + "sha256": "f538dd1743bd39e36e6190882712540652a5db7aa81e0d9ab11221ac28ed693a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101e9", + "101ea", + "101eb", + "101ec" + ], + "sha256": "de4bb446e004c2a8f5e7bbf42b725d6db1d771114612a880fac7fcff741a0838", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ed", + "101ee", + "101ef", + "101f0" + ], + "sha256": "684357deae6d6d0a0433044b5abe8fd82fe3a2f7323be7b53e1ea3c90bd058c8", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101e5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1f0dcb0e0cdb9955675a37ba428be30db913c8d085088c26d90727979537f81b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d045049dd0d130ddb842ba2f13de3626001f102372da4f377585b5778f523a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ebd239e9e2efa9f643f2f5e9de12b442b54f05869ab03b8f50f09a488991fb55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4d0416ee8d3b31e1e750649a57261bbc6935f7c72405dec1f40c3b1c856920b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "91b655475797eb4eb0bc0f4ef2afcd6c0a8e5a63c43fe5f8bf639bb12753678b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d21530de88f2de5f3419e86581ea05939b3669a8c7afcd003c0deba267d17ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e79e0c2e8f7477f63f66ec8d73036da7874eb1d09e57e004bc277bc96f832514", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "98a140f6d56b9c1b55a1d999f20613b37b6b272ecfd5c560f24aba6de5063065", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "297d1b6117513576a45c4b59a3a510ee78e97b046cffe3851bc4832ed09c852f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a2538e1defca06ad217e76711bfd87353d37aba0d895d455700896c84a291aab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d1c4dda25106c9223a2b206a7b2092e34ff051cd0e0101e5f390fb3c5b1cd40", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ef216ae0207c06da15a54457a63c3d0d791ad1a0b642790931039332fb30851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2cf1eed2d0f482a2cb2e5dda8c4b0f7e787349c2a0be068943f179eab2a30b91", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "943bc627354dee1ed8fc342ed43a550a96a1f6e122265e1fd6e7b55ebd7b837a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7d308b0c0664ebedc8a48c1924df647e8ab5356f10369ff76d9745480b70258f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f71821252794fdcc162df4559ad89a9e17c83e865c9c42eb5e5fe6e1486c77ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4bd0246a19a3b99f9cc74908a97055ffa3125d269d55ab200b8913e1da35350d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2577a62301f6a0f48d28d96ba9d9677be3854363ad850261432b2f7848cb4efb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2c8462de5321a9aa8c010ac4ee3d1d7d9f99d4cebdd8ff360eaa11f2c98f8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "494c95630519c1f8f86b021953a4c1d004ab88291314d8214ae99bf46a66d773", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f60863bbd5bcc7586ddc30ac1104f7f617937d75db7d282cf4cbd40241f3fdee", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd3e6bf5f4efdaf5658aa715063afd7d71bf44f92c83cb54a9ab3333a7595f3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c7213976a82bc0776f3510079df457ea7c9d561b3250c060218c5bebf86802ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "48318af464b9331842af91d10d6af1aa6397007237c7b92a1c470e35a889de4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "14e8ebb425dfb8ccd9409cf5d10a3ba47a48c640fb2d6d00f262e9f1f54e30ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "841cf80c9e38c2d806342159bb9df36735222eb5c02e2da487a7373e39b8ca41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1776f3d7da186cd16b8e1948c0360c657926d588d092af0cc7fe685443ccddb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1c7b06f6f9bc3d8ec13cbf372961ab221ee571fa694a89794fba1e959171808a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b825ed0c4adaa6e69d46ed0d8addbfe3ad8415760b007ded9436b30b54726ac3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e7902214bcae894a78f3bb2f3cbfaf3d8a678d9623d4770827a0870422e91a02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "dde5fb91c3311bf3fa2b01905d8caca2b2272493a1d51f64c0d4cee884067de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21c7bcf6cc45834948676da6479310c03dbf79456f34a3562683058b548969e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c9d7e6a599473df325f24b4b28d0799b839ec9a2e66d3d147dec247db9d3cb99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2aefbdd2188bde4893296b179e0d67be03ece889ec14aa3cb0535c68013afae9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b8c11a52fa012a481638d5d2bd9ec34574447f7b2327e6b4e08f75b188adaf54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bf8e5608f8984526fc149a48e274bca2415ff7ee3fd47f8f247c21544d5d1d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cffa953ed1fc083bf92b6269ec59665572c102574778838aea9ad6626d6e87dd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "71c36d6e2b80109eff72988d92a4db4bf9441b18238c84a5f65695cc1e0eda58", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e66c182cb0d85e907e2467a9d2099bb64250efa5c04b6242d22a312481a8534d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4d2de0382aab4b9d578e2ba5c0ce46f9513ed386d403de911c45f97f23dc0f6a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9de8ca5ea46dd3b7fb10272af40d4a778b25b6dfeacbf401f2c8d69a8d02f222", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b88c981403cfafb4a2206e6d6e8a08977ce2e858f47b731beaf561036b7a04a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9ff5c14f677825b319fdf224dd76e11c54f72433e776bf4682d054d339eacb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1637367b461cb9593d876f3265104a08d3355752e11ea8e00b1715cf35090cc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d9b437b8412b04022303d44584b1bae64d7d0dae91ce7f34c697ff30e5048e3d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6b37b21fe0dd4dca9d9c1c037644f7dba87b5e0a63c5f5afbdb2176d14cfbeab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5647d9a5be366499e4f21b7a93b5497336f885bbb9bf02c935db7d91a750d68b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17a0a59d06a1e03de2bcbb4124e98a5839599eeb0d2b9239f46630d390c44779", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e76c109cfed21bad70607a5598b573b36d74d329c5bbb4885b51cc8cc5c71add", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7424f6878ac9f5df2304792473d5d05a97e7bded83f42f56d9a306571bf92175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2bf087b9dc7262e6a7ebdff41229822f38ca6795c94ee09bab2bd41969039512", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "752521664a85227c529765ddb1dd0463f96368fcb229bea9ba5ef140f2d30c23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f3d0047c70393e7513e25fc78cd97afde4ae3244b5532d4942e7e0d33d1334ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "80b29ba7d609a9591ae4a4b0671f61732115e3ff36a066dee07de29c65cbb0bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-original.ppm", + "sha256": "45f5d6af2b45c1a6b4ddd54e54c466cddf89ff53b8336aec5fbf1496de18adf5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a9396ab8a52c6d339872924781cb3fab345e4df4da9a5a28b2436c56969fc3b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dbb76c8288ae094d486d92c66c68a8fb69136647a980a36c5a31135def55df9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9699b366b52bf67eb86e244e1a050147573f2548be9e2e1a60d837a76437181", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d57684ff7879bb3edfde6a0b3c12dcad79e2757f82a6802027a3c2e88e3e202f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f7be90319ec076ba5932356ad61a6518b33ad5ab66487f9d63034a613e4417f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101ea": { @@ -26932,7 +28682,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101ea", "family_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", "job_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -26944,6 +28694,356 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", "sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d076a630af46f5c0f0ed37ea6b32c9665206da421ce89cba9d89de5532f16fbb", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.529798+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [\"APPROVED all12 frames after independent complete authentic-source/untouched-raw/native1\\u20134/native2\\u20133/fade/material/negative-space and actual terrain Canvas review. Major source ordering from small detached ray-star, ivory peak, yellow dark-core phase, open rust ring and sparse detached fading fragments remains recognizable, with original48canvas/[0,0] anchors. This is not a claim of exact source-pixel color/mask identity or live animation timing.\", \"Genuinev10 restores every one of the seven connected101eb inner-lip cells at21..23,17..19 with full occupied subpixel coverage at every scale. Native whole-cell losses fall72\\u21923 and4\\u00d7 losses30\\u21922. The source core opening no longer cuts deeply into the original painted lip. One remaining RGB89/28/4 inner-corner cell(23,16) is absent allscales, and outer upper-right RGB130/36/16(32,5) is also absent; a third native outer-right shoulder cell(43,12),RGB105/36/4, survives4\\u00d7. These are explicitly accepted minor isolated corner changes after visual crop/context inspection. Source enclosed holearea127 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea127.625 supports that inspection rather than replacing it.\", \"Genuinev10 restores four of five101ec original painted shoulder cells10..14,4 at every scale. Dim outer endpoint(14,4) remains absent allscales, alongside dim lower outer(14,45); three other low-scale corner cells return at4\\u00d7. Native losses94\\u21925 and4\\u00d7 losses14\\u21922. The original connected shoulder/rim band is visibly retained; the residual two exterior endpoint changes are accepted. Source coreholearea249 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea250.875 is disclosed; no new interior material fills the intended hole.\", \"Unchanged101e7/101e8/101e9/101ea retain their main lobes/rays and peak/dark-core shape. Whole source losses at4\\u00d7 are4/8/6/17, including connected small exterior edge strips in101e9/101ea. Every exact coordinate/index/RGB is enumerated. Source/native/mask and full composition inspection show localized external smoothing/notches rather than the earlier deep connected inner-lip or five-cell shoulder removal. These are accepted qualifications, including native20/29/37/62 wholly missing cells and four added native samples in101ea; no universal numeric allowance is implied.\", \"Previously restored first2 and late2 remain exact v9 bindings and are reassessed in the whole sequence:101e5 zero whole losses allscales;101e6 two native/one2\\u00d7/none3\\u20134\\u00d7. 101ed persistent(19,4) and101ee persistent(12..14,42), allRGB89/28/4, remain small exterior notches with the adjacent ring continuous. Last101ef has25 native andone4\\u00d7 lossRGB69/28/24(35,4);101f0 eight native andzero2\\u20134\\u00d7 losses. Ring break-up, detached fragment placements and tiny end remnants remain readable, with their exact area/edge/addition differences recorded.\", \"New101eb/101ec have conspicuously stronger organic flame grain, small hot yellow patches and higher local contrast than the original flat orange fields and smoother unchanged middle phases. This material transition is visible especially4\\u00d7 and is explicitly accepted after the complete sequence and actual terrain composition were inspected. Their integrated base-palette luminance ratios at4\\u00d7 are1.032/1.003 of source, and native meanRGB191.747/105.266/19.523 versus source192.898/98.785/19.606 for101eb, 182.017/89.871/18.054 versus185.136/87.098/19.042 for101ec. Near source means are diagnostic support, not proof that local brightness/material is identical. Stronger step-field texture in unchanged first2/late2 and the smoother grain in other phases are likewise disclosed.\", \"The full rise from yellow rays through ivory peak and the subsequent warmer/dimmer thinning ring and fragments remain clear. Last phases are somewhat dimmer/thinner than original: integrated4\\u00d7 luminance ratios101ed/ee/ef/f0 approximately.968/.930/.834/.851. They remain visible against authentic terrain, including every thin end fragment, so the darker fade treatment is accepted after actual composition review; no timing, audio, shadows or original mission backdrop is inferred.\", \"No visible broad brown background veil occurs in actual indexed/context proof. Nonzero rawRGB underalpha0 is hidden, not foreground. Source/output ordinary palette classes0..239 remain ordinary; no reserved/fire/water/blink semantics are invented. All current raws byte-match their genuine built-in outputs, with original binary/palette/reference PNG, prompt/provenance, candidate, exact immutable library and all actual evidence hash-bound.\", \"Original48-in64 viewports are independently verified in all references. V11 metadata chooses470-square crops78,78 and705,78 for newv10 cells, retaining everyalpha16/32 sample while excluding79/69 faintalpha1\\u201315 padding specks. No rawRGB/alpha repair or loader compensation was performed. Other10 bindings are byte-identical to v9, with52/60 actual spritePPMs and88/96CanvasPPMs unchanged.\", \"Approval is restricted to this exact complete-family independent artwork/indexed/crop/native-composition review. Coordinator registration/render reachability and live timing verification remain separate. Historicalv6/v9 and4006e holds remain preserved byte-for-byte; no production/source/global/Git/policy change was made.\"] \"Read-only complete-family source/hash-bound artwork/native gallery/crop/blitter review. Isolated ignored evidence writes only; no artwork/raw/candidate/source/global manifest/ledger/Git/registration/promotion or policy edits and no live Host claims. All earlier accepted/held artifacts remain preserved.\" All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 b493fa7d8f28a357d7fc4cc9e21fdedecaeb16f4f029c43e14aa7e12489e6b18", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101e5", + "101e6", + "101e7", + "101e8" + ], + "sha256": "f538dd1743bd39e36e6190882712540652a5db7aa81e0d9ab11221ac28ed693a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101e9", + "101ea", + "101eb", + "101ec" + ], + "sha256": "de4bb446e004c2a8f5e7bbf42b725d6db1d771114612a880fac7fcff741a0838", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ed", + "101ee", + "101ef", + "101f0" + ], + "sha256": "684357deae6d6d0a0433044b5abe8fd82fe3a2f7323be7b53e1ea3c90bd058c8", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101e5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1f0dcb0e0cdb9955675a37ba428be30db913c8d085088c26d90727979537f81b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d045049dd0d130ddb842ba2f13de3626001f102372da4f377585b5778f523a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ebd239e9e2efa9f643f2f5e9de12b442b54f05869ab03b8f50f09a488991fb55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4d0416ee8d3b31e1e750649a57261bbc6935f7c72405dec1f40c3b1c856920b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "91b655475797eb4eb0bc0f4ef2afcd6c0a8e5a63c43fe5f8bf639bb12753678b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d21530de88f2de5f3419e86581ea05939b3669a8c7afcd003c0deba267d17ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e79e0c2e8f7477f63f66ec8d73036da7874eb1d09e57e004bc277bc96f832514", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "98a140f6d56b9c1b55a1d999f20613b37b6b272ecfd5c560f24aba6de5063065", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "297d1b6117513576a45c4b59a3a510ee78e97b046cffe3851bc4832ed09c852f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a2538e1defca06ad217e76711bfd87353d37aba0d895d455700896c84a291aab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d1c4dda25106c9223a2b206a7b2092e34ff051cd0e0101e5f390fb3c5b1cd40", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ef216ae0207c06da15a54457a63c3d0d791ad1a0b642790931039332fb30851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2cf1eed2d0f482a2cb2e5dda8c4b0f7e787349c2a0be068943f179eab2a30b91", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "943bc627354dee1ed8fc342ed43a550a96a1f6e122265e1fd6e7b55ebd7b837a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7d308b0c0664ebedc8a48c1924df647e8ab5356f10369ff76d9745480b70258f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f71821252794fdcc162df4559ad89a9e17c83e865c9c42eb5e5fe6e1486c77ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4bd0246a19a3b99f9cc74908a97055ffa3125d269d55ab200b8913e1da35350d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2577a62301f6a0f48d28d96ba9d9677be3854363ad850261432b2f7848cb4efb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2c8462de5321a9aa8c010ac4ee3d1d7d9f99d4cebdd8ff360eaa11f2c98f8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "494c95630519c1f8f86b021953a4c1d004ab88291314d8214ae99bf46a66d773", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f60863bbd5bcc7586ddc30ac1104f7f617937d75db7d282cf4cbd40241f3fdee", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd3e6bf5f4efdaf5658aa715063afd7d71bf44f92c83cb54a9ab3333a7595f3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c7213976a82bc0776f3510079df457ea7c9d561b3250c060218c5bebf86802ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "48318af464b9331842af91d10d6af1aa6397007237c7b92a1c470e35a889de4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "14e8ebb425dfb8ccd9409cf5d10a3ba47a48c640fb2d6d00f262e9f1f54e30ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "841cf80c9e38c2d806342159bb9df36735222eb5c02e2da487a7373e39b8ca41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1776f3d7da186cd16b8e1948c0360c657926d588d092af0cc7fe685443ccddb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1c7b06f6f9bc3d8ec13cbf372961ab221ee571fa694a89794fba1e959171808a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b825ed0c4adaa6e69d46ed0d8addbfe3ad8415760b007ded9436b30b54726ac3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e7902214bcae894a78f3bb2f3cbfaf3d8a678d9623d4770827a0870422e91a02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "dde5fb91c3311bf3fa2b01905d8caca2b2272493a1d51f64c0d4cee884067de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21c7bcf6cc45834948676da6479310c03dbf79456f34a3562683058b548969e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c9d7e6a599473df325f24b4b28d0799b839ec9a2e66d3d147dec247db9d3cb99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2aefbdd2188bde4893296b179e0d67be03ece889ec14aa3cb0535c68013afae9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b8c11a52fa012a481638d5d2bd9ec34574447f7b2327e6b4e08f75b188adaf54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bf8e5608f8984526fc149a48e274bca2415ff7ee3fd47f8f247c21544d5d1d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cffa953ed1fc083bf92b6269ec59665572c102574778838aea9ad6626d6e87dd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "71c36d6e2b80109eff72988d92a4db4bf9441b18238c84a5f65695cc1e0eda58", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e66c182cb0d85e907e2467a9d2099bb64250efa5c04b6242d22a312481a8534d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4d2de0382aab4b9d578e2ba5c0ce46f9513ed386d403de911c45f97f23dc0f6a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9de8ca5ea46dd3b7fb10272af40d4a778b25b6dfeacbf401f2c8d69a8d02f222", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b88c981403cfafb4a2206e6d6e8a08977ce2e858f47b731beaf561036b7a04a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9ff5c14f677825b319fdf224dd76e11c54f72433e776bf4682d054d339eacb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1637367b461cb9593d876f3265104a08d3355752e11ea8e00b1715cf35090cc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d9b437b8412b04022303d44584b1bae64d7d0dae91ce7f34c697ff30e5048e3d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6b37b21fe0dd4dca9d9c1c037644f7dba87b5e0a63c5f5afbdb2176d14cfbeab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5647d9a5be366499e4f21b7a93b5497336f885bbb9bf02c935db7d91a750d68b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17a0a59d06a1e03de2bcbb4124e98a5839599eeb0d2b9239f46630d390c44779", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e76c109cfed21bad70607a5598b573b36d74d329c5bbb4885b51cc8cc5c71add", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7424f6878ac9f5df2304792473d5d05a97e7bded83f42f56d9a306571bf92175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2bf087b9dc7262e6a7ebdff41229822f38ca6795c94ee09bab2bd41969039512", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "752521664a85227c529765ddb1dd0463f96368fcb229bea9ba5ef140f2d30c23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f3d0047c70393e7513e25fc78cd97afde4ae3244b5532d4942e7e0d33d1334ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "80b29ba7d609a9591ae4a4b0671f61732115e3ff36a066dee07de29c65cbb0bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-original.ppm", + "sha256": "45f5d6af2b45c1a6b4ddd54e54c466cddf89ff53b8336aec5fbf1496de18adf5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a9396ab8a52c6d339872924781cb3fab345e4df4da9a5a28b2436c56969fc3b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dbb76c8288ae094d486d92c66c68a8fb69136647a980a36c5a31135def55df9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9699b366b52bf67eb86e244e1a050147573f2548be9e2e1a60d837a76437181", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d57684ff7879bb3edfde6a0b3c12dcad79e2757f82a6802027a3c2e88e3e202f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f7be90319ec076ba5932356ad61a6518b33ad5ab66487f9d63034a613e4417f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101eb": { @@ -26965,7 +29065,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101eb", "family_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", "job_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -26977,6 +29077,356 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", "sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d076a630af46f5c0f0ed37ea6b32c9665206da421ce89cba9d89de5532f16fbb", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.529798+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [\"APPROVED all12 frames after independent complete authentic-source/untouched-raw/native1\\u20134/native2\\u20133/fade/material/negative-space and actual terrain Canvas review. Major source ordering from small detached ray-star, ivory peak, yellow dark-core phase, open rust ring and sparse detached fading fragments remains recognizable, with original48canvas/[0,0] anchors. This is not a claim of exact source-pixel color/mask identity or live animation timing.\", \"Genuinev10 restores every one of the seven connected101eb inner-lip cells at21..23,17..19 with full occupied subpixel coverage at every scale. Native whole-cell losses fall72\\u21923 and4\\u00d7 losses30\\u21922. The source core opening no longer cuts deeply into the original painted lip. One remaining RGB89/28/4 inner-corner cell(23,16) is absent allscales, and outer upper-right RGB130/36/16(32,5) is also absent; a third native outer-right shoulder cell(43,12),RGB105/36/4, survives4\\u00d7. These are explicitly accepted minor isolated corner changes after visual crop/context inspection. Source enclosed holearea127 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea127.625 supports that inspection rather than replacing it.\", \"Genuinev10 restores four of five101ec original painted shoulder cells10..14,4 at every scale. Dim outer endpoint(14,4) remains absent allscales, alongside dim lower outer(14,45); three other low-scale corner cells return at4\\u00d7. Native losses94\\u21925 and4\\u00d7 losses14\\u21922. The original connected shoulder/rim band is visibly retained; the residual two exterior endpoint changes are accepted. Source coreholearea249 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea250.875 is disclosed; no new interior material fills the intended hole.\", \"Unchanged101e7/101e8/101e9/101ea retain their main lobes/rays and peak/dark-core shape. Whole source losses at4\\u00d7 are4/8/6/17, including connected small exterior edge strips in101e9/101ea. Every exact coordinate/index/RGB is enumerated. Source/native/mask and full composition inspection show localized external smoothing/notches rather than the earlier deep connected inner-lip or five-cell shoulder removal. These are accepted qualifications, including native20/29/37/62 wholly missing cells and four added native samples in101ea; no universal numeric allowance is implied.\", \"Previously restored first2 and late2 remain exact v9 bindings and are reassessed in the whole sequence:101e5 zero whole losses allscales;101e6 two native/one2\\u00d7/none3\\u20134\\u00d7. 101ed persistent(19,4) and101ee persistent(12..14,42), allRGB89/28/4, remain small exterior notches with the adjacent ring continuous. Last101ef has25 native andone4\\u00d7 lossRGB69/28/24(35,4);101f0 eight native andzero2\\u20134\\u00d7 losses. Ring break-up, detached fragment placements and tiny end remnants remain readable, with their exact area/edge/addition differences recorded.\", \"New101eb/101ec have conspicuously stronger organic flame grain, small hot yellow patches and higher local contrast than the original flat orange fields and smoother unchanged middle phases. This material transition is visible especially4\\u00d7 and is explicitly accepted after the complete sequence and actual terrain composition were inspected. Their integrated base-palette luminance ratios at4\\u00d7 are1.032/1.003 of source, and native meanRGB191.747/105.266/19.523 versus source192.898/98.785/19.606 for101eb, 182.017/89.871/18.054 versus185.136/87.098/19.042 for101ec. Near source means are diagnostic support, not proof that local brightness/material is identical. Stronger step-field texture in unchanged first2/late2 and the smoother grain in other phases are likewise disclosed.\", \"The full rise from yellow rays through ivory peak and the subsequent warmer/dimmer thinning ring and fragments remain clear. Last phases are somewhat dimmer/thinner than original: integrated4\\u00d7 luminance ratios101ed/ee/ef/f0 approximately.968/.930/.834/.851. They remain visible against authentic terrain, including every thin end fragment, so the darker fade treatment is accepted after actual composition review; no timing, audio, shadows or original mission backdrop is inferred.\", \"No visible broad brown background veil occurs in actual indexed/context proof. Nonzero rawRGB underalpha0 is hidden, not foreground. Source/output ordinary palette classes0..239 remain ordinary; no reserved/fire/water/blink semantics are invented. All current raws byte-match their genuine built-in outputs, with original binary/palette/reference PNG, prompt/provenance, candidate, exact immutable library and all actual evidence hash-bound.\", \"Original48-in64 viewports are independently verified in all references. V11 metadata chooses470-square crops78,78 and705,78 for newv10 cells, retaining everyalpha16/32 sample while excluding79/69 faintalpha1\\u201315 padding specks. No rawRGB/alpha repair or loader compensation was performed. Other10 bindings are byte-identical to v9, with52/60 actual spritePPMs and88/96CanvasPPMs unchanged.\", \"Approval is restricted to this exact complete-family independent artwork/indexed/crop/native-composition review. Coordinator registration/render reachability and live timing verification remain separate. Historicalv6/v9 and4006e holds remain preserved byte-for-byte; no production/source/global/Git/policy change was made.\"] \"Read-only complete-family source/hash-bound artwork/native gallery/crop/blitter review. Isolated ignored evidence writes only; no artwork/raw/candidate/source/global manifest/ledger/Git/registration/promotion or policy edits and no live Host claims. All earlier accepted/held artifacts remain preserved.\" All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 b493fa7d8f28a357d7fc4cc9e21fdedecaeb16f4f029c43e14aa7e12489e6b18", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101e5", + "101e6", + "101e7", + "101e8" + ], + "sha256": "f538dd1743bd39e36e6190882712540652a5db7aa81e0d9ab11221ac28ed693a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101e9", + "101ea", + "101eb", + "101ec" + ], + "sha256": "de4bb446e004c2a8f5e7bbf42b725d6db1d771114612a880fac7fcff741a0838", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ed", + "101ee", + "101ef", + "101f0" + ], + "sha256": "684357deae6d6d0a0433044b5abe8fd82fe3a2f7323be7b53e1ea3c90bd058c8", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101e5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1f0dcb0e0cdb9955675a37ba428be30db913c8d085088c26d90727979537f81b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d045049dd0d130ddb842ba2f13de3626001f102372da4f377585b5778f523a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ebd239e9e2efa9f643f2f5e9de12b442b54f05869ab03b8f50f09a488991fb55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4d0416ee8d3b31e1e750649a57261bbc6935f7c72405dec1f40c3b1c856920b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "91b655475797eb4eb0bc0f4ef2afcd6c0a8e5a63c43fe5f8bf639bb12753678b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d21530de88f2de5f3419e86581ea05939b3669a8c7afcd003c0deba267d17ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e79e0c2e8f7477f63f66ec8d73036da7874eb1d09e57e004bc277bc96f832514", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "98a140f6d56b9c1b55a1d999f20613b37b6b272ecfd5c560f24aba6de5063065", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "297d1b6117513576a45c4b59a3a510ee78e97b046cffe3851bc4832ed09c852f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a2538e1defca06ad217e76711bfd87353d37aba0d895d455700896c84a291aab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d1c4dda25106c9223a2b206a7b2092e34ff051cd0e0101e5f390fb3c5b1cd40", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ef216ae0207c06da15a54457a63c3d0d791ad1a0b642790931039332fb30851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2cf1eed2d0f482a2cb2e5dda8c4b0f7e787349c2a0be068943f179eab2a30b91", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "943bc627354dee1ed8fc342ed43a550a96a1f6e122265e1fd6e7b55ebd7b837a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7d308b0c0664ebedc8a48c1924df647e8ab5356f10369ff76d9745480b70258f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f71821252794fdcc162df4559ad89a9e17c83e865c9c42eb5e5fe6e1486c77ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4bd0246a19a3b99f9cc74908a97055ffa3125d269d55ab200b8913e1da35350d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2577a62301f6a0f48d28d96ba9d9677be3854363ad850261432b2f7848cb4efb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2c8462de5321a9aa8c010ac4ee3d1d7d9f99d4cebdd8ff360eaa11f2c98f8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "494c95630519c1f8f86b021953a4c1d004ab88291314d8214ae99bf46a66d773", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f60863bbd5bcc7586ddc30ac1104f7f617937d75db7d282cf4cbd40241f3fdee", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd3e6bf5f4efdaf5658aa715063afd7d71bf44f92c83cb54a9ab3333a7595f3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c7213976a82bc0776f3510079df457ea7c9d561b3250c060218c5bebf86802ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "48318af464b9331842af91d10d6af1aa6397007237c7b92a1c470e35a889de4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "14e8ebb425dfb8ccd9409cf5d10a3ba47a48c640fb2d6d00f262e9f1f54e30ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "841cf80c9e38c2d806342159bb9df36735222eb5c02e2da487a7373e39b8ca41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1776f3d7da186cd16b8e1948c0360c657926d588d092af0cc7fe685443ccddb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1c7b06f6f9bc3d8ec13cbf372961ab221ee571fa694a89794fba1e959171808a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b825ed0c4adaa6e69d46ed0d8addbfe3ad8415760b007ded9436b30b54726ac3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e7902214bcae894a78f3bb2f3cbfaf3d8a678d9623d4770827a0870422e91a02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "dde5fb91c3311bf3fa2b01905d8caca2b2272493a1d51f64c0d4cee884067de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21c7bcf6cc45834948676da6479310c03dbf79456f34a3562683058b548969e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c9d7e6a599473df325f24b4b28d0799b839ec9a2e66d3d147dec247db9d3cb99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2aefbdd2188bde4893296b179e0d67be03ece889ec14aa3cb0535c68013afae9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b8c11a52fa012a481638d5d2bd9ec34574447f7b2327e6b4e08f75b188adaf54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bf8e5608f8984526fc149a48e274bca2415ff7ee3fd47f8f247c21544d5d1d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cffa953ed1fc083bf92b6269ec59665572c102574778838aea9ad6626d6e87dd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "71c36d6e2b80109eff72988d92a4db4bf9441b18238c84a5f65695cc1e0eda58", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e66c182cb0d85e907e2467a9d2099bb64250efa5c04b6242d22a312481a8534d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4d2de0382aab4b9d578e2ba5c0ce46f9513ed386d403de911c45f97f23dc0f6a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9de8ca5ea46dd3b7fb10272af40d4a778b25b6dfeacbf401f2c8d69a8d02f222", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b88c981403cfafb4a2206e6d6e8a08977ce2e858f47b731beaf561036b7a04a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9ff5c14f677825b319fdf224dd76e11c54f72433e776bf4682d054d339eacb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1637367b461cb9593d876f3265104a08d3355752e11ea8e00b1715cf35090cc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d9b437b8412b04022303d44584b1bae64d7d0dae91ce7f34c697ff30e5048e3d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6b37b21fe0dd4dca9d9c1c037644f7dba87b5e0a63c5f5afbdb2176d14cfbeab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5647d9a5be366499e4f21b7a93b5497336f885bbb9bf02c935db7d91a750d68b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17a0a59d06a1e03de2bcbb4124e98a5839599eeb0d2b9239f46630d390c44779", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e76c109cfed21bad70607a5598b573b36d74d329c5bbb4885b51cc8cc5c71add", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7424f6878ac9f5df2304792473d5d05a97e7bded83f42f56d9a306571bf92175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2bf087b9dc7262e6a7ebdff41229822f38ca6795c94ee09bab2bd41969039512", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "752521664a85227c529765ddb1dd0463f96368fcb229bea9ba5ef140f2d30c23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f3d0047c70393e7513e25fc78cd97afde4ae3244b5532d4942e7e0d33d1334ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "80b29ba7d609a9591ae4a4b0671f61732115e3ff36a066dee07de29c65cbb0bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-original.ppm", + "sha256": "45f5d6af2b45c1a6b4ddd54e54c466cddf89ff53b8336aec5fbf1496de18adf5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a9396ab8a52c6d339872924781cb3fab345e4df4da9a5a28b2436c56969fc3b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dbb76c8288ae094d486d92c66c68a8fb69136647a980a36c5a31135def55df9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9699b366b52bf67eb86e244e1a050147573f2548be9e2e1a60d837a76437181", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d57684ff7879bb3edfde6a0b3c12dcad79e2757f82a6802027a3c2e88e3e202f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f7be90319ec076ba5932356ad61a6518b33ad5ab66487f9d63034a613e4417f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101ec": { @@ -26998,7 +29448,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101ec", "family_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", "job_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -27010,6 +29460,356 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", "sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d076a630af46f5c0f0ed37ea6b32c9665206da421ce89cba9d89de5532f16fbb", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.529798+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [\"APPROVED all12 frames after independent complete authentic-source/untouched-raw/native1\\u20134/native2\\u20133/fade/material/negative-space and actual terrain Canvas review. Major source ordering from small detached ray-star, ivory peak, yellow dark-core phase, open rust ring and sparse detached fading fragments remains recognizable, with original48canvas/[0,0] anchors. This is not a claim of exact source-pixel color/mask identity or live animation timing.\", \"Genuinev10 restores every one of the seven connected101eb inner-lip cells at21..23,17..19 with full occupied subpixel coverage at every scale. Native whole-cell losses fall72\\u21923 and4\\u00d7 losses30\\u21922. The source core opening no longer cuts deeply into the original painted lip. One remaining RGB89/28/4 inner-corner cell(23,16) is absent allscales, and outer upper-right RGB130/36/16(32,5) is also absent; a third native outer-right shoulder cell(43,12),RGB105/36/4, survives4\\u00d7. These are explicitly accepted minor isolated corner changes after visual crop/context inspection. Source enclosed holearea127 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea127.625 supports that inspection rather than replacing it.\", \"Genuinev10 restores four of five101ec original painted shoulder cells10..14,4 at every scale. Dim outer endpoint(14,4) remains absent allscales, alongside dim lower outer(14,45); three other low-scale corner cells return at4\\u00d7. Native losses94\\u21925 and4\\u00d7 losses14\\u21922. The original connected shoulder/rim band is visibly retained; the residual two exterior endpoint changes are accepted. Source coreholearea249 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea250.875 is disclosed; no new interior material fills the intended hole.\", \"Unchanged101e7/101e8/101e9/101ea retain their main lobes/rays and peak/dark-core shape. Whole source losses at4\\u00d7 are4/8/6/17, including connected small exterior edge strips in101e9/101ea. Every exact coordinate/index/RGB is enumerated. Source/native/mask and full composition inspection show localized external smoothing/notches rather than the earlier deep connected inner-lip or five-cell shoulder removal. These are accepted qualifications, including native20/29/37/62 wholly missing cells and four added native samples in101ea; no universal numeric allowance is implied.\", \"Previously restored first2 and late2 remain exact v9 bindings and are reassessed in the whole sequence:101e5 zero whole losses allscales;101e6 two native/one2\\u00d7/none3\\u20134\\u00d7. 101ed persistent(19,4) and101ee persistent(12..14,42), allRGB89/28/4, remain small exterior notches with the adjacent ring continuous. Last101ef has25 native andone4\\u00d7 lossRGB69/28/24(35,4);101f0 eight native andzero2\\u20134\\u00d7 losses. Ring break-up, detached fragment placements and tiny end remnants remain readable, with their exact area/edge/addition differences recorded.\", \"New101eb/101ec have conspicuously stronger organic flame grain, small hot yellow patches and higher local contrast than the original flat orange fields and smoother unchanged middle phases. This material transition is visible especially4\\u00d7 and is explicitly accepted after the complete sequence and actual terrain composition were inspected. Their integrated base-palette luminance ratios at4\\u00d7 are1.032/1.003 of source, and native meanRGB191.747/105.266/19.523 versus source192.898/98.785/19.606 for101eb, 182.017/89.871/18.054 versus185.136/87.098/19.042 for101ec. Near source means are diagnostic support, not proof that local brightness/material is identical. Stronger step-field texture in unchanged first2/late2 and the smoother grain in other phases are likewise disclosed.\", \"The full rise from yellow rays through ivory peak and the subsequent warmer/dimmer thinning ring and fragments remain clear. Last phases are somewhat dimmer/thinner than original: integrated4\\u00d7 luminance ratios101ed/ee/ef/f0 approximately.968/.930/.834/.851. They remain visible against authentic terrain, including every thin end fragment, so the darker fade treatment is accepted after actual composition review; no timing, audio, shadows or original mission backdrop is inferred.\", \"No visible broad brown background veil occurs in actual indexed/context proof. Nonzero rawRGB underalpha0 is hidden, not foreground. Source/output ordinary palette classes0..239 remain ordinary; no reserved/fire/water/blink semantics are invented. All current raws byte-match their genuine built-in outputs, with original binary/palette/reference PNG, prompt/provenance, candidate, exact immutable library and all actual evidence hash-bound.\", \"Original48-in64 viewports are independently verified in all references. V11 metadata chooses470-square crops78,78 and705,78 for newv10 cells, retaining everyalpha16/32 sample while excluding79/69 faintalpha1\\u201315 padding specks. No rawRGB/alpha repair or loader compensation was performed. Other10 bindings are byte-identical to v9, with52/60 actual spritePPMs and88/96CanvasPPMs unchanged.\", \"Approval is restricted to this exact complete-family independent artwork/indexed/crop/native-composition review. Coordinator registration/render reachability and live timing verification remain separate. Historicalv6/v9 and4006e holds remain preserved byte-for-byte; no production/source/global/Git/policy change was made.\"] \"Read-only complete-family source/hash-bound artwork/native gallery/crop/blitter review. Isolated ignored evidence writes only; no artwork/raw/candidate/source/global manifest/ledger/Git/registration/promotion or policy edits and no live Host claims. All earlier accepted/held artifacts remain preserved.\" All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 b493fa7d8f28a357d7fc4cc9e21fdedecaeb16f4f029c43e14aa7e12489e6b18", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101e5", + "101e6", + "101e7", + "101e8" + ], + "sha256": "f538dd1743bd39e36e6190882712540652a5db7aa81e0d9ab11221ac28ed693a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101e9", + "101ea", + "101eb", + "101ec" + ], + "sha256": "de4bb446e004c2a8f5e7bbf42b725d6db1d771114612a880fac7fcff741a0838", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ed", + "101ee", + "101ef", + "101f0" + ], + "sha256": "684357deae6d6d0a0433044b5abe8fd82fe3a2f7323be7b53e1ea3c90bd058c8", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101e5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1f0dcb0e0cdb9955675a37ba428be30db913c8d085088c26d90727979537f81b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d045049dd0d130ddb842ba2f13de3626001f102372da4f377585b5778f523a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ebd239e9e2efa9f643f2f5e9de12b442b54f05869ab03b8f50f09a488991fb55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4d0416ee8d3b31e1e750649a57261bbc6935f7c72405dec1f40c3b1c856920b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "91b655475797eb4eb0bc0f4ef2afcd6c0a8e5a63c43fe5f8bf639bb12753678b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d21530de88f2de5f3419e86581ea05939b3669a8c7afcd003c0deba267d17ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e79e0c2e8f7477f63f66ec8d73036da7874eb1d09e57e004bc277bc96f832514", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "98a140f6d56b9c1b55a1d999f20613b37b6b272ecfd5c560f24aba6de5063065", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "297d1b6117513576a45c4b59a3a510ee78e97b046cffe3851bc4832ed09c852f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a2538e1defca06ad217e76711bfd87353d37aba0d895d455700896c84a291aab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d1c4dda25106c9223a2b206a7b2092e34ff051cd0e0101e5f390fb3c5b1cd40", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ef216ae0207c06da15a54457a63c3d0d791ad1a0b642790931039332fb30851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2cf1eed2d0f482a2cb2e5dda8c4b0f7e787349c2a0be068943f179eab2a30b91", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "943bc627354dee1ed8fc342ed43a550a96a1f6e122265e1fd6e7b55ebd7b837a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7d308b0c0664ebedc8a48c1924df647e8ab5356f10369ff76d9745480b70258f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f71821252794fdcc162df4559ad89a9e17c83e865c9c42eb5e5fe6e1486c77ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4bd0246a19a3b99f9cc74908a97055ffa3125d269d55ab200b8913e1da35350d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2577a62301f6a0f48d28d96ba9d9677be3854363ad850261432b2f7848cb4efb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2c8462de5321a9aa8c010ac4ee3d1d7d9f99d4cebdd8ff360eaa11f2c98f8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "494c95630519c1f8f86b021953a4c1d004ab88291314d8214ae99bf46a66d773", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f60863bbd5bcc7586ddc30ac1104f7f617937d75db7d282cf4cbd40241f3fdee", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd3e6bf5f4efdaf5658aa715063afd7d71bf44f92c83cb54a9ab3333a7595f3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c7213976a82bc0776f3510079df457ea7c9d561b3250c060218c5bebf86802ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "48318af464b9331842af91d10d6af1aa6397007237c7b92a1c470e35a889de4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "14e8ebb425dfb8ccd9409cf5d10a3ba47a48c640fb2d6d00f262e9f1f54e30ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "841cf80c9e38c2d806342159bb9df36735222eb5c02e2da487a7373e39b8ca41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1776f3d7da186cd16b8e1948c0360c657926d588d092af0cc7fe685443ccddb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1c7b06f6f9bc3d8ec13cbf372961ab221ee571fa694a89794fba1e959171808a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b825ed0c4adaa6e69d46ed0d8addbfe3ad8415760b007ded9436b30b54726ac3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e7902214bcae894a78f3bb2f3cbfaf3d8a678d9623d4770827a0870422e91a02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "dde5fb91c3311bf3fa2b01905d8caca2b2272493a1d51f64c0d4cee884067de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21c7bcf6cc45834948676da6479310c03dbf79456f34a3562683058b548969e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c9d7e6a599473df325f24b4b28d0799b839ec9a2e66d3d147dec247db9d3cb99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2aefbdd2188bde4893296b179e0d67be03ece889ec14aa3cb0535c68013afae9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b8c11a52fa012a481638d5d2bd9ec34574447f7b2327e6b4e08f75b188adaf54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bf8e5608f8984526fc149a48e274bca2415ff7ee3fd47f8f247c21544d5d1d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cffa953ed1fc083bf92b6269ec59665572c102574778838aea9ad6626d6e87dd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "71c36d6e2b80109eff72988d92a4db4bf9441b18238c84a5f65695cc1e0eda58", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e66c182cb0d85e907e2467a9d2099bb64250efa5c04b6242d22a312481a8534d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4d2de0382aab4b9d578e2ba5c0ce46f9513ed386d403de911c45f97f23dc0f6a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9de8ca5ea46dd3b7fb10272af40d4a778b25b6dfeacbf401f2c8d69a8d02f222", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b88c981403cfafb4a2206e6d6e8a08977ce2e858f47b731beaf561036b7a04a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9ff5c14f677825b319fdf224dd76e11c54f72433e776bf4682d054d339eacb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1637367b461cb9593d876f3265104a08d3355752e11ea8e00b1715cf35090cc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d9b437b8412b04022303d44584b1bae64d7d0dae91ce7f34c697ff30e5048e3d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6b37b21fe0dd4dca9d9c1c037644f7dba87b5e0a63c5f5afbdb2176d14cfbeab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5647d9a5be366499e4f21b7a93b5497336f885bbb9bf02c935db7d91a750d68b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17a0a59d06a1e03de2bcbb4124e98a5839599eeb0d2b9239f46630d390c44779", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e76c109cfed21bad70607a5598b573b36d74d329c5bbb4885b51cc8cc5c71add", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7424f6878ac9f5df2304792473d5d05a97e7bded83f42f56d9a306571bf92175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2bf087b9dc7262e6a7ebdff41229822f38ca6795c94ee09bab2bd41969039512", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "752521664a85227c529765ddb1dd0463f96368fcb229bea9ba5ef140f2d30c23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f3d0047c70393e7513e25fc78cd97afde4ae3244b5532d4942e7e0d33d1334ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "80b29ba7d609a9591ae4a4b0671f61732115e3ff36a066dee07de29c65cbb0bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-original.ppm", + "sha256": "45f5d6af2b45c1a6b4ddd54e54c466cddf89ff53b8336aec5fbf1496de18adf5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a9396ab8a52c6d339872924781cb3fab345e4df4da9a5a28b2436c56969fc3b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dbb76c8288ae094d486d92c66c68a8fb69136647a980a36c5a31135def55df9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9699b366b52bf67eb86e244e1a050147573f2548be9e2e1a60d837a76437181", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d57684ff7879bb3edfde6a0b3c12dcad79e2757f82a6802027a3c2e88e3e202f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f7be90319ec076ba5932356ad61a6518b33ad5ab66487f9d63034a613e4417f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101ed": { @@ -27031,7 +29831,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101ed", "family_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", "job_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -27043,6 +29843,356 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", "sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d076a630af46f5c0f0ed37ea6b32c9665206da421ce89cba9d89de5532f16fbb", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.529798+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [\"APPROVED all12 frames after independent complete authentic-source/untouched-raw/native1\\u20134/native2\\u20133/fade/material/negative-space and actual terrain Canvas review. Major source ordering from small detached ray-star, ivory peak, yellow dark-core phase, open rust ring and sparse detached fading fragments remains recognizable, with original48canvas/[0,0] anchors. This is not a claim of exact source-pixel color/mask identity or live animation timing.\", \"Genuinev10 restores every one of the seven connected101eb inner-lip cells at21..23,17..19 with full occupied subpixel coverage at every scale. Native whole-cell losses fall72\\u21923 and4\\u00d7 losses30\\u21922. The source core opening no longer cuts deeply into the original painted lip. One remaining RGB89/28/4 inner-corner cell(23,16) is absent allscales, and outer upper-right RGB130/36/16(32,5) is also absent; a third native outer-right shoulder cell(43,12),RGB105/36/4, survives4\\u00d7. These are explicitly accepted minor isolated corner changes after visual crop/context inspection. Source enclosed holearea127 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea127.625 supports that inspection rather than replacing it.\", \"Genuinev10 restores four of five101ec original painted shoulder cells10..14,4 at every scale. Dim outer endpoint(14,4) remains absent allscales, alongside dim lower outer(14,45); three other low-scale corner cells return at4\\u00d7. Native losses94\\u21925 and4\\u00d7 losses14\\u21922. The original connected shoulder/rim band is visibly retained; the residual two exterior endpoint changes are accepted. Source coreholearea249 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea250.875 is disclosed; no new interior material fills the intended hole.\", \"Unchanged101e7/101e8/101e9/101ea retain their main lobes/rays and peak/dark-core shape. Whole source losses at4\\u00d7 are4/8/6/17, including connected small exterior edge strips in101e9/101ea. Every exact coordinate/index/RGB is enumerated. Source/native/mask and full composition inspection show localized external smoothing/notches rather than the earlier deep connected inner-lip or five-cell shoulder removal. These are accepted qualifications, including native20/29/37/62 wholly missing cells and four added native samples in101ea; no universal numeric allowance is implied.\", \"Previously restored first2 and late2 remain exact v9 bindings and are reassessed in the whole sequence:101e5 zero whole losses allscales;101e6 two native/one2\\u00d7/none3\\u20134\\u00d7. 101ed persistent(19,4) and101ee persistent(12..14,42), allRGB89/28/4, remain small exterior notches with the adjacent ring continuous. Last101ef has25 native andone4\\u00d7 lossRGB69/28/24(35,4);101f0 eight native andzero2\\u20134\\u00d7 losses. Ring break-up, detached fragment placements and tiny end remnants remain readable, with their exact area/edge/addition differences recorded.\", \"New101eb/101ec have conspicuously stronger organic flame grain, small hot yellow patches and higher local contrast than the original flat orange fields and smoother unchanged middle phases. This material transition is visible especially4\\u00d7 and is explicitly accepted after the complete sequence and actual terrain composition were inspected. Their integrated base-palette luminance ratios at4\\u00d7 are1.032/1.003 of source, and native meanRGB191.747/105.266/19.523 versus source192.898/98.785/19.606 for101eb, 182.017/89.871/18.054 versus185.136/87.098/19.042 for101ec. Near source means are diagnostic support, not proof that local brightness/material is identical. Stronger step-field texture in unchanged first2/late2 and the smoother grain in other phases are likewise disclosed.\", \"The full rise from yellow rays through ivory peak and the subsequent warmer/dimmer thinning ring and fragments remain clear. Last phases are somewhat dimmer/thinner than original: integrated4\\u00d7 luminance ratios101ed/ee/ef/f0 approximately.968/.930/.834/.851. They remain visible against authentic terrain, including every thin end fragment, so the darker fade treatment is accepted after actual composition review; no timing, audio, shadows or original mission backdrop is inferred.\", \"No visible broad brown background veil occurs in actual indexed/context proof. Nonzero rawRGB underalpha0 is hidden, not foreground. Source/output ordinary palette classes0..239 remain ordinary; no reserved/fire/water/blink semantics are invented. All current raws byte-match their genuine built-in outputs, with original binary/palette/reference PNG, prompt/provenance, candidate, exact immutable library and all actual evidence hash-bound.\", \"Original48-in64 viewports are independently verified in all references. V11 metadata chooses470-square crops78,78 and705,78 for newv10 cells, retaining everyalpha16/32 sample while excluding79/69 faintalpha1\\u201315 padding specks. No rawRGB/alpha repair or loader compensation was performed. Other10 bindings are byte-identical to v9, with52/60 actual spritePPMs and88/96CanvasPPMs unchanged.\", \"Approval is restricted to this exact complete-family independent artwork/indexed/crop/native-composition review. Coordinator registration/render reachability and live timing verification remain separate. Historicalv6/v9 and4006e holds remain preserved byte-for-byte; no production/source/global/Git/policy change was made.\"] \"Read-only complete-family source/hash-bound artwork/native gallery/crop/blitter review. Isolated ignored evidence writes only; no artwork/raw/candidate/source/global manifest/ledger/Git/registration/promotion or policy edits and no live Host claims. All earlier accepted/held artifacts remain preserved.\" All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 b493fa7d8f28a357d7fc4cc9e21fdedecaeb16f4f029c43e14aa7e12489e6b18", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101e5", + "101e6", + "101e7", + "101e8" + ], + "sha256": "f538dd1743bd39e36e6190882712540652a5db7aa81e0d9ab11221ac28ed693a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101e9", + "101ea", + "101eb", + "101ec" + ], + "sha256": "de4bb446e004c2a8f5e7bbf42b725d6db1d771114612a880fac7fcff741a0838", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ed", + "101ee", + "101ef", + "101f0" + ], + "sha256": "684357deae6d6d0a0433044b5abe8fd82fe3a2f7323be7b53e1ea3c90bd058c8", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101e5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1f0dcb0e0cdb9955675a37ba428be30db913c8d085088c26d90727979537f81b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d045049dd0d130ddb842ba2f13de3626001f102372da4f377585b5778f523a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ebd239e9e2efa9f643f2f5e9de12b442b54f05869ab03b8f50f09a488991fb55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4d0416ee8d3b31e1e750649a57261bbc6935f7c72405dec1f40c3b1c856920b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "91b655475797eb4eb0bc0f4ef2afcd6c0a8e5a63c43fe5f8bf639bb12753678b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d21530de88f2de5f3419e86581ea05939b3669a8c7afcd003c0deba267d17ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e79e0c2e8f7477f63f66ec8d73036da7874eb1d09e57e004bc277bc96f832514", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "98a140f6d56b9c1b55a1d999f20613b37b6b272ecfd5c560f24aba6de5063065", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "297d1b6117513576a45c4b59a3a510ee78e97b046cffe3851bc4832ed09c852f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a2538e1defca06ad217e76711bfd87353d37aba0d895d455700896c84a291aab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d1c4dda25106c9223a2b206a7b2092e34ff051cd0e0101e5f390fb3c5b1cd40", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ef216ae0207c06da15a54457a63c3d0d791ad1a0b642790931039332fb30851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2cf1eed2d0f482a2cb2e5dda8c4b0f7e787349c2a0be068943f179eab2a30b91", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "943bc627354dee1ed8fc342ed43a550a96a1f6e122265e1fd6e7b55ebd7b837a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7d308b0c0664ebedc8a48c1924df647e8ab5356f10369ff76d9745480b70258f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f71821252794fdcc162df4559ad89a9e17c83e865c9c42eb5e5fe6e1486c77ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4bd0246a19a3b99f9cc74908a97055ffa3125d269d55ab200b8913e1da35350d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2577a62301f6a0f48d28d96ba9d9677be3854363ad850261432b2f7848cb4efb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2c8462de5321a9aa8c010ac4ee3d1d7d9f99d4cebdd8ff360eaa11f2c98f8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "494c95630519c1f8f86b021953a4c1d004ab88291314d8214ae99bf46a66d773", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f60863bbd5bcc7586ddc30ac1104f7f617937d75db7d282cf4cbd40241f3fdee", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd3e6bf5f4efdaf5658aa715063afd7d71bf44f92c83cb54a9ab3333a7595f3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c7213976a82bc0776f3510079df457ea7c9d561b3250c060218c5bebf86802ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "48318af464b9331842af91d10d6af1aa6397007237c7b92a1c470e35a889de4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "14e8ebb425dfb8ccd9409cf5d10a3ba47a48c640fb2d6d00f262e9f1f54e30ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "841cf80c9e38c2d806342159bb9df36735222eb5c02e2da487a7373e39b8ca41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1776f3d7da186cd16b8e1948c0360c657926d588d092af0cc7fe685443ccddb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1c7b06f6f9bc3d8ec13cbf372961ab221ee571fa694a89794fba1e959171808a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b825ed0c4adaa6e69d46ed0d8addbfe3ad8415760b007ded9436b30b54726ac3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e7902214bcae894a78f3bb2f3cbfaf3d8a678d9623d4770827a0870422e91a02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "dde5fb91c3311bf3fa2b01905d8caca2b2272493a1d51f64c0d4cee884067de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21c7bcf6cc45834948676da6479310c03dbf79456f34a3562683058b548969e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c9d7e6a599473df325f24b4b28d0799b839ec9a2e66d3d147dec247db9d3cb99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2aefbdd2188bde4893296b179e0d67be03ece889ec14aa3cb0535c68013afae9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b8c11a52fa012a481638d5d2bd9ec34574447f7b2327e6b4e08f75b188adaf54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bf8e5608f8984526fc149a48e274bca2415ff7ee3fd47f8f247c21544d5d1d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cffa953ed1fc083bf92b6269ec59665572c102574778838aea9ad6626d6e87dd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "71c36d6e2b80109eff72988d92a4db4bf9441b18238c84a5f65695cc1e0eda58", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e66c182cb0d85e907e2467a9d2099bb64250efa5c04b6242d22a312481a8534d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4d2de0382aab4b9d578e2ba5c0ce46f9513ed386d403de911c45f97f23dc0f6a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9de8ca5ea46dd3b7fb10272af40d4a778b25b6dfeacbf401f2c8d69a8d02f222", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b88c981403cfafb4a2206e6d6e8a08977ce2e858f47b731beaf561036b7a04a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9ff5c14f677825b319fdf224dd76e11c54f72433e776bf4682d054d339eacb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1637367b461cb9593d876f3265104a08d3355752e11ea8e00b1715cf35090cc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d9b437b8412b04022303d44584b1bae64d7d0dae91ce7f34c697ff30e5048e3d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6b37b21fe0dd4dca9d9c1c037644f7dba87b5e0a63c5f5afbdb2176d14cfbeab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5647d9a5be366499e4f21b7a93b5497336f885bbb9bf02c935db7d91a750d68b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17a0a59d06a1e03de2bcbb4124e98a5839599eeb0d2b9239f46630d390c44779", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e76c109cfed21bad70607a5598b573b36d74d329c5bbb4885b51cc8cc5c71add", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7424f6878ac9f5df2304792473d5d05a97e7bded83f42f56d9a306571bf92175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2bf087b9dc7262e6a7ebdff41229822f38ca6795c94ee09bab2bd41969039512", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "752521664a85227c529765ddb1dd0463f96368fcb229bea9ba5ef140f2d30c23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f3d0047c70393e7513e25fc78cd97afde4ae3244b5532d4942e7e0d33d1334ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "80b29ba7d609a9591ae4a4b0671f61732115e3ff36a066dee07de29c65cbb0bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-original.ppm", + "sha256": "45f5d6af2b45c1a6b4ddd54e54c466cddf89ff53b8336aec5fbf1496de18adf5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a9396ab8a52c6d339872924781cb3fab345e4df4da9a5a28b2436c56969fc3b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dbb76c8288ae094d486d92c66c68a8fb69136647a980a36c5a31135def55df9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9699b366b52bf67eb86e244e1a050147573f2548be9e2e1a60d837a76437181", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d57684ff7879bb3edfde6a0b3c12dcad79e2757f82a6802027a3c2e88e3e202f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f7be90319ec076ba5932356ad61a6518b33ad5ab66487f9d63034a613e4417f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101ee": { @@ -27064,7 +30214,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101ee", "family_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", "job_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -27076,6 +30226,356 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", "sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d076a630af46f5c0f0ed37ea6b32c9665206da421ce89cba9d89de5532f16fbb", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.529798+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [\"APPROVED all12 frames after independent complete authentic-source/untouched-raw/native1\\u20134/native2\\u20133/fade/material/negative-space and actual terrain Canvas review. Major source ordering from small detached ray-star, ivory peak, yellow dark-core phase, open rust ring and sparse detached fading fragments remains recognizable, with original48canvas/[0,0] anchors. This is not a claim of exact source-pixel color/mask identity or live animation timing.\", \"Genuinev10 restores every one of the seven connected101eb inner-lip cells at21..23,17..19 with full occupied subpixel coverage at every scale. Native whole-cell losses fall72\\u21923 and4\\u00d7 losses30\\u21922. The source core opening no longer cuts deeply into the original painted lip. One remaining RGB89/28/4 inner-corner cell(23,16) is absent allscales, and outer upper-right RGB130/36/16(32,5) is also absent; a third native outer-right shoulder cell(43,12),RGB105/36/4, survives4\\u00d7. These are explicitly accepted minor isolated corner changes after visual crop/context inspection. Source enclosed holearea127 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea127.625 supports that inspection rather than replacing it.\", \"Genuinev10 restores four of five101ec original painted shoulder cells10..14,4 at every scale. Dim outer endpoint(14,4) remains absent allscales, alongside dim lower outer(14,45); three other low-scale corner cells return at4\\u00d7. Native losses94\\u21925 and4\\u00d7 losses14\\u21922. The original connected shoulder/rim band is visibly retained; the residual two exterior endpoint changes are accepted. Source coreholearea249 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea250.875 is disclosed; no new interior material fills the intended hole.\", \"Unchanged101e7/101e8/101e9/101ea retain their main lobes/rays and peak/dark-core shape. Whole source losses at4\\u00d7 are4/8/6/17, including connected small exterior edge strips in101e9/101ea. Every exact coordinate/index/RGB is enumerated. Source/native/mask and full composition inspection show localized external smoothing/notches rather than the earlier deep connected inner-lip or five-cell shoulder removal. These are accepted qualifications, including native20/29/37/62 wholly missing cells and four added native samples in101ea; no universal numeric allowance is implied.\", \"Previously restored first2 and late2 remain exact v9 bindings and are reassessed in the whole sequence:101e5 zero whole losses allscales;101e6 two native/one2\\u00d7/none3\\u20134\\u00d7. 101ed persistent(19,4) and101ee persistent(12..14,42), allRGB89/28/4, remain small exterior notches with the adjacent ring continuous. Last101ef has25 native andone4\\u00d7 lossRGB69/28/24(35,4);101f0 eight native andzero2\\u20134\\u00d7 losses. Ring break-up, detached fragment placements and tiny end remnants remain readable, with their exact area/edge/addition differences recorded.\", \"New101eb/101ec have conspicuously stronger organic flame grain, small hot yellow patches and higher local contrast than the original flat orange fields and smoother unchanged middle phases. This material transition is visible especially4\\u00d7 and is explicitly accepted after the complete sequence and actual terrain composition were inspected. Their integrated base-palette luminance ratios at4\\u00d7 are1.032/1.003 of source, and native meanRGB191.747/105.266/19.523 versus source192.898/98.785/19.606 for101eb, 182.017/89.871/18.054 versus185.136/87.098/19.042 for101ec. Near source means are diagnostic support, not proof that local brightness/material is identical. Stronger step-field texture in unchanged first2/late2 and the smoother grain in other phases are likewise disclosed.\", \"The full rise from yellow rays through ivory peak and the subsequent warmer/dimmer thinning ring and fragments remain clear. Last phases are somewhat dimmer/thinner than original: integrated4\\u00d7 luminance ratios101ed/ee/ef/f0 approximately.968/.930/.834/.851. They remain visible against authentic terrain, including every thin end fragment, so the darker fade treatment is accepted after actual composition review; no timing, audio, shadows or original mission backdrop is inferred.\", \"No visible broad brown background veil occurs in actual indexed/context proof. Nonzero rawRGB underalpha0 is hidden, not foreground. Source/output ordinary palette classes0..239 remain ordinary; no reserved/fire/water/blink semantics are invented. All current raws byte-match their genuine built-in outputs, with original binary/palette/reference PNG, prompt/provenance, candidate, exact immutable library and all actual evidence hash-bound.\", \"Original48-in64 viewports are independently verified in all references. V11 metadata chooses470-square crops78,78 and705,78 for newv10 cells, retaining everyalpha16/32 sample while excluding79/69 faintalpha1\\u201315 padding specks. No rawRGB/alpha repair or loader compensation was performed. Other10 bindings are byte-identical to v9, with52/60 actual spritePPMs and88/96CanvasPPMs unchanged.\", \"Approval is restricted to this exact complete-family independent artwork/indexed/crop/native-composition review. Coordinator registration/render reachability and live timing verification remain separate. Historicalv6/v9 and4006e holds remain preserved byte-for-byte; no production/source/global/Git/policy change was made.\"] \"Read-only complete-family source/hash-bound artwork/native gallery/crop/blitter review. Isolated ignored evidence writes only; no artwork/raw/candidate/source/global manifest/ledger/Git/registration/promotion or policy edits and no live Host claims. All earlier accepted/held artifacts remain preserved.\" All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 b493fa7d8f28a357d7fc4cc9e21fdedecaeb16f4f029c43e14aa7e12489e6b18", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101e5", + "101e6", + "101e7", + "101e8" + ], + "sha256": "f538dd1743bd39e36e6190882712540652a5db7aa81e0d9ab11221ac28ed693a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101e9", + "101ea", + "101eb", + "101ec" + ], + "sha256": "de4bb446e004c2a8f5e7bbf42b725d6db1d771114612a880fac7fcff741a0838", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ed", + "101ee", + "101ef", + "101f0" + ], + "sha256": "684357deae6d6d0a0433044b5abe8fd82fe3a2f7323be7b53e1ea3c90bd058c8", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101e5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1f0dcb0e0cdb9955675a37ba428be30db913c8d085088c26d90727979537f81b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d045049dd0d130ddb842ba2f13de3626001f102372da4f377585b5778f523a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ebd239e9e2efa9f643f2f5e9de12b442b54f05869ab03b8f50f09a488991fb55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4d0416ee8d3b31e1e750649a57261bbc6935f7c72405dec1f40c3b1c856920b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "91b655475797eb4eb0bc0f4ef2afcd6c0a8e5a63c43fe5f8bf639bb12753678b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d21530de88f2de5f3419e86581ea05939b3669a8c7afcd003c0deba267d17ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e79e0c2e8f7477f63f66ec8d73036da7874eb1d09e57e004bc277bc96f832514", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "98a140f6d56b9c1b55a1d999f20613b37b6b272ecfd5c560f24aba6de5063065", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "297d1b6117513576a45c4b59a3a510ee78e97b046cffe3851bc4832ed09c852f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a2538e1defca06ad217e76711bfd87353d37aba0d895d455700896c84a291aab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d1c4dda25106c9223a2b206a7b2092e34ff051cd0e0101e5f390fb3c5b1cd40", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ef216ae0207c06da15a54457a63c3d0d791ad1a0b642790931039332fb30851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2cf1eed2d0f482a2cb2e5dda8c4b0f7e787349c2a0be068943f179eab2a30b91", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "943bc627354dee1ed8fc342ed43a550a96a1f6e122265e1fd6e7b55ebd7b837a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7d308b0c0664ebedc8a48c1924df647e8ab5356f10369ff76d9745480b70258f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f71821252794fdcc162df4559ad89a9e17c83e865c9c42eb5e5fe6e1486c77ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4bd0246a19a3b99f9cc74908a97055ffa3125d269d55ab200b8913e1da35350d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2577a62301f6a0f48d28d96ba9d9677be3854363ad850261432b2f7848cb4efb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2c8462de5321a9aa8c010ac4ee3d1d7d9f99d4cebdd8ff360eaa11f2c98f8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "494c95630519c1f8f86b021953a4c1d004ab88291314d8214ae99bf46a66d773", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f60863bbd5bcc7586ddc30ac1104f7f617937d75db7d282cf4cbd40241f3fdee", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd3e6bf5f4efdaf5658aa715063afd7d71bf44f92c83cb54a9ab3333a7595f3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c7213976a82bc0776f3510079df457ea7c9d561b3250c060218c5bebf86802ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "48318af464b9331842af91d10d6af1aa6397007237c7b92a1c470e35a889de4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "14e8ebb425dfb8ccd9409cf5d10a3ba47a48c640fb2d6d00f262e9f1f54e30ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "841cf80c9e38c2d806342159bb9df36735222eb5c02e2da487a7373e39b8ca41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1776f3d7da186cd16b8e1948c0360c657926d588d092af0cc7fe685443ccddb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1c7b06f6f9bc3d8ec13cbf372961ab221ee571fa694a89794fba1e959171808a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b825ed0c4adaa6e69d46ed0d8addbfe3ad8415760b007ded9436b30b54726ac3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e7902214bcae894a78f3bb2f3cbfaf3d8a678d9623d4770827a0870422e91a02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "dde5fb91c3311bf3fa2b01905d8caca2b2272493a1d51f64c0d4cee884067de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21c7bcf6cc45834948676da6479310c03dbf79456f34a3562683058b548969e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c9d7e6a599473df325f24b4b28d0799b839ec9a2e66d3d147dec247db9d3cb99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2aefbdd2188bde4893296b179e0d67be03ece889ec14aa3cb0535c68013afae9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b8c11a52fa012a481638d5d2bd9ec34574447f7b2327e6b4e08f75b188adaf54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bf8e5608f8984526fc149a48e274bca2415ff7ee3fd47f8f247c21544d5d1d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cffa953ed1fc083bf92b6269ec59665572c102574778838aea9ad6626d6e87dd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "71c36d6e2b80109eff72988d92a4db4bf9441b18238c84a5f65695cc1e0eda58", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e66c182cb0d85e907e2467a9d2099bb64250efa5c04b6242d22a312481a8534d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4d2de0382aab4b9d578e2ba5c0ce46f9513ed386d403de911c45f97f23dc0f6a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9de8ca5ea46dd3b7fb10272af40d4a778b25b6dfeacbf401f2c8d69a8d02f222", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b88c981403cfafb4a2206e6d6e8a08977ce2e858f47b731beaf561036b7a04a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9ff5c14f677825b319fdf224dd76e11c54f72433e776bf4682d054d339eacb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1637367b461cb9593d876f3265104a08d3355752e11ea8e00b1715cf35090cc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d9b437b8412b04022303d44584b1bae64d7d0dae91ce7f34c697ff30e5048e3d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6b37b21fe0dd4dca9d9c1c037644f7dba87b5e0a63c5f5afbdb2176d14cfbeab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5647d9a5be366499e4f21b7a93b5497336f885bbb9bf02c935db7d91a750d68b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17a0a59d06a1e03de2bcbb4124e98a5839599eeb0d2b9239f46630d390c44779", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e76c109cfed21bad70607a5598b573b36d74d329c5bbb4885b51cc8cc5c71add", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7424f6878ac9f5df2304792473d5d05a97e7bded83f42f56d9a306571bf92175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2bf087b9dc7262e6a7ebdff41229822f38ca6795c94ee09bab2bd41969039512", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "752521664a85227c529765ddb1dd0463f96368fcb229bea9ba5ef140f2d30c23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f3d0047c70393e7513e25fc78cd97afde4ae3244b5532d4942e7e0d33d1334ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "80b29ba7d609a9591ae4a4b0671f61732115e3ff36a066dee07de29c65cbb0bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-original.ppm", + "sha256": "45f5d6af2b45c1a6b4ddd54e54c466cddf89ff53b8336aec5fbf1496de18adf5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a9396ab8a52c6d339872924781cb3fab345e4df4da9a5a28b2436c56969fc3b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dbb76c8288ae094d486d92c66c68a8fb69136647a980a36c5a31135def55df9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9699b366b52bf67eb86e244e1a050147573f2548be9e2e1a60d837a76437181", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d57684ff7879bb3edfde6a0b3c12dcad79e2757f82a6802027a3c2e88e3e202f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f7be90319ec076ba5932356ad61a6518b33ad5ab66487f9d63034a613e4417f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101ef": { @@ -27097,7 +30597,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101ef", "family_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", "job_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -27109,6 +30609,356 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", "sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d076a630af46f5c0f0ed37ea6b32c9665206da421ce89cba9d89de5532f16fbb", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.529798+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [\"APPROVED all12 frames after independent complete authentic-source/untouched-raw/native1\\u20134/native2\\u20133/fade/material/negative-space and actual terrain Canvas review. Major source ordering from small detached ray-star, ivory peak, yellow dark-core phase, open rust ring and sparse detached fading fragments remains recognizable, with original48canvas/[0,0] anchors. This is not a claim of exact source-pixel color/mask identity or live animation timing.\", \"Genuinev10 restores every one of the seven connected101eb inner-lip cells at21..23,17..19 with full occupied subpixel coverage at every scale. Native whole-cell losses fall72\\u21923 and4\\u00d7 losses30\\u21922. The source core opening no longer cuts deeply into the original painted lip. One remaining RGB89/28/4 inner-corner cell(23,16) is absent allscales, and outer upper-right RGB130/36/16(32,5) is also absent; a third native outer-right shoulder cell(43,12),RGB105/36/4, survives4\\u00d7. These are explicitly accepted minor isolated corner changes after visual crop/context inspection. Source enclosed holearea127 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea127.625 supports that inspection rather than replacing it.\", \"Genuinev10 restores four of five101ec original painted shoulder cells10..14,4 at every scale. Dim outer endpoint(14,4) remains absent allscales, alongside dim lower outer(14,45); three other low-scale corner cells return at4\\u00d7. Native losses94\\u21925 and4\\u00d7 losses14\\u21922. The original connected shoulder/rim band is visibly retained; the residual two exterior endpoint changes are accepted. Source coreholearea249 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea250.875 is disclosed; no new interior material fills the intended hole.\", \"Unchanged101e7/101e8/101e9/101ea retain their main lobes/rays and peak/dark-core shape. Whole source losses at4\\u00d7 are4/8/6/17, including connected small exterior edge strips in101e9/101ea. Every exact coordinate/index/RGB is enumerated. Source/native/mask and full composition inspection show localized external smoothing/notches rather than the earlier deep connected inner-lip or five-cell shoulder removal. These are accepted qualifications, including native20/29/37/62 wholly missing cells and four added native samples in101ea; no universal numeric allowance is implied.\", \"Previously restored first2 and late2 remain exact v9 bindings and are reassessed in the whole sequence:101e5 zero whole losses allscales;101e6 two native/one2\\u00d7/none3\\u20134\\u00d7. 101ed persistent(19,4) and101ee persistent(12..14,42), allRGB89/28/4, remain small exterior notches with the adjacent ring continuous. Last101ef has25 native andone4\\u00d7 lossRGB69/28/24(35,4);101f0 eight native andzero2\\u20134\\u00d7 losses. Ring break-up, detached fragment placements and tiny end remnants remain readable, with their exact area/edge/addition differences recorded.\", \"New101eb/101ec have conspicuously stronger organic flame grain, small hot yellow patches and higher local contrast than the original flat orange fields and smoother unchanged middle phases. This material transition is visible especially4\\u00d7 and is explicitly accepted after the complete sequence and actual terrain composition were inspected. Their integrated base-palette luminance ratios at4\\u00d7 are1.032/1.003 of source, and native meanRGB191.747/105.266/19.523 versus source192.898/98.785/19.606 for101eb, 182.017/89.871/18.054 versus185.136/87.098/19.042 for101ec. Near source means are diagnostic support, not proof that local brightness/material is identical. Stronger step-field texture in unchanged first2/late2 and the smoother grain in other phases are likewise disclosed.\", \"The full rise from yellow rays through ivory peak and the subsequent warmer/dimmer thinning ring and fragments remain clear. Last phases are somewhat dimmer/thinner than original: integrated4\\u00d7 luminance ratios101ed/ee/ef/f0 approximately.968/.930/.834/.851. They remain visible against authentic terrain, including every thin end fragment, so the darker fade treatment is accepted after actual composition review; no timing, audio, shadows or original mission backdrop is inferred.\", \"No visible broad brown background veil occurs in actual indexed/context proof. Nonzero rawRGB underalpha0 is hidden, not foreground. Source/output ordinary palette classes0..239 remain ordinary; no reserved/fire/water/blink semantics are invented. All current raws byte-match their genuine built-in outputs, with original binary/palette/reference PNG, prompt/provenance, candidate, exact immutable library and all actual evidence hash-bound.\", \"Original48-in64 viewports are independently verified in all references. V11 metadata chooses470-square crops78,78 and705,78 for newv10 cells, retaining everyalpha16/32 sample while excluding79/69 faintalpha1\\u201315 padding specks. No rawRGB/alpha repair or loader compensation was performed. Other10 bindings are byte-identical to v9, with52/60 actual spritePPMs and88/96CanvasPPMs unchanged.\", \"Approval is restricted to this exact complete-family independent artwork/indexed/crop/native-composition review. Coordinator registration/render reachability and live timing verification remain separate. Historicalv6/v9 and4006e holds remain preserved byte-for-byte; no production/source/global/Git/policy change was made.\"] \"Read-only complete-family source/hash-bound artwork/native gallery/crop/blitter review. Isolated ignored evidence writes only; no artwork/raw/candidate/source/global manifest/ledger/Git/registration/promotion or policy edits and no live Host claims. All earlier accepted/held artifacts remain preserved.\" All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 b493fa7d8f28a357d7fc4cc9e21fdedecaeb16f4f029c43e14aa7e12489e6b18", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101e5", + "101e6", + "101e7", + "101e8" + ], + "sha256": "f538dd1743bd39e36e6190882712540652a5db7aa81e0d9ab11221ac28ed693a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101e9", + "101ea", + "101eb", + "101ec" + ], + "sha256": "de4bb446e004c2a8f5e7bbf42b725d6db1d771114612a880fac7fcff741a0838", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ed", + "101ee", + "101ef", + "101f0" + ], + "sha256": "684357deae6d6d0a0433044b5abe8fd82fe3a2f7323be7b53e1ea3c90bd058c8", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101e5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1f0dcb0e0cdb9955675a37ba428be30db913c8d085088c26d90727979537f81b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d045049dd0d130ddb842ba2f13de3626001f102372da4f377585b5778f523a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ebd239e9e2efa9f643f2f5e9de12b442b54f05869ab03b8f50f09a488991fb55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4d0416ee8d3b31e1e750649a57261bbc6935f7c72405dec1f40c3b1c856920b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "91b655475797eb4eb0bc0f4ef2afcd6c0a8e5a63c43fe5f8bf639bb12753678b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d21530de88f2de5f3419e86581ea05939b3669a8c7afcd003c0deba267d17ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e79e0c2e8f7477f63f66ec8d73036da7874eb1d09e57e004bc277bc96f832514", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "98a140f6d56b9c1b55a1d999f20613b37b6b272ecfd5c560f24aba6de5063065", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "297d1b6117513576a45c4b59a3a510ee78e97b046cffe3851bc4832ed09c852f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a2538e1defca06ad217e76711bfd87353d37aba0d895d455700896c84a291aab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d1c4dda25106c9223a2b206a7b2092e34ff051cd0e0101e5f390fb3c5b1cd40", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ef216ae0207c06da15a54457a63c3d0d791ad1a0b642790931039332fb30851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2cf1eed2d0f482a2cb2e5dda8c4b0f7e787349c2a0be068943f179eab2a30b91", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "943bc627354dee1ed8fc342ed43a550a96a1f6e122265e1fd6e7b55ebd7b837a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7d308b0c0664ebedc8a48c1924df647e8ab5356f10369ff76d9745480b70258f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f71821252794fdcc162df4559ad89a9e17c83e865c9c42eb5e5fe6e1486c77ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4bd0246a19a3b99f9cc74908a97055ffa3125d269d55ab200b8913e1da35350d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2577a62301f6a0f48d28d96ba9d9677be3854363ad850261432b2f7848cb4efb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2c8462de5321a9aa8c010ac4ee3d1d7d9f99d4cebdd8ff360eaa11f2c98f8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "494c95630519c1f8f86b021953a4c1d004ab88291314d8214ae99bf46a66d773", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f60863bbd5bcc7586ddc30ac1104f7f617937d75db7d282cf4cbd40241f3fdee", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd3e6bf5f4efdaf5658aa715063afd7d71bf44f92c83cb54a9ab3333a7595f3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c7213976a82bc0776f3510079df457ea7c9d561b3250c060218c5bebf86802ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "48318af464b9331842af91d10d6af1aa6397007237c7b92a1c470e35a889de4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "14e8ebb425dfb8ccd9409cf5d10a3ba47a48c640fb2d6d00f262e9f1f54e30ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "841cf80c9e38c2d806342159bb9df36735222eb5c02e2da487a7373e39b8ca41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1776f3d7da186cd16b8e1948c0360c657926d588d092af0cc7fe685443ccddb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1c7b06f6f9bc3d8ec13cbf372961ab221ee571fa694a89794fba1e959171808a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b825ed0c4adaa6e69d46ed0d8addbfe3ad8415760b007ded9436b30b54726ac3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e7902214bcae894a78f3bb2f3cbfaf3d8a678d9623d4770827a0870422e91a02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "dde5fb91c3311bf3fa2b01905d8caca2b2272493a1d51f64c0d4cee884067de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21c7bcf6cc45834948676da6479310c03dbf79456f34a3562683058b548969e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c9d7e6a599473df325f24b4b28d0799b839ec9a2e66d3d147dec247db9d3cb99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2aefbdd2188bde4893296b179e0d67be03ece889ec14aa3cb0535c68013afae9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b8c11a52fa012a481638d5d2bd9ec34574447f7b2327e6b4e08f75b188adaf54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bf8e5608f8984526fc149a48e274bca2415ff7ee3fd47f8f247c21544d5d1d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cffa953ed1fc083bf92b6269ec59665572c102574778838aea9ad6626d6e87dd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "71c36d6e2b80109eff72988d92a4db4bf9441b18238c84a5f65695cc1e0eda58", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e66c182cb0d85e907e2467a9d2099bb64250efa5c04b6242d22a312481a8534d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4d2de0382aab4b9d578e2ba5c0ce46f9513ed386d403de911c45f97f23dc0f6a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9de8ca5ea46dd3b7fb10272af40d4a778b25b6dfeacbf401f2c8d69a8d02f222", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b88c981403cfafb4a2206e6d6e8a08977ce2e858f47b731beaf561036b7a04a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9ff5c14f677825b319fdf224dd76e11c54f72433e776bf4682d054d339eacb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1637367b461cb9593d876f3265104a08d3355752e11ea8e00b1715cf35090cc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d9b437b8412b04022303d44584b1bae64d7d0dae91ce7f34c697ff30e5048e3d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6b37b21fe0dd4dca9d9c1c037644f7dba87b5e0a63c5f5afbdb2176d14cfbeab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5647d9a5be366499e4f21b7a93b5497336f885bbb9bf02c935db7d91a750d68b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17a0a59d06a1e03de2bcbb4124e98a5839599eeb0d2b9239f46630d390c44779", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e76c109cfed21bad70607a5598b573b36d74d329c5bbb4885b51cc8cc5c71add", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7424f6878ac9f5df2304792473d5d05a97e7bded83f42f56d9a306571bf92175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2bf087b9dc7262e6a7ebdff41229822f38ca6795c94ee09bab2bd41969039512", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "752521664a85227c529765ddb1dd0463f96368fcb229bea9ba5ef140f2d30c23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f3d0047c70393e7513e25fc78cd97afde4ae3244b5532d4942e7e0d33d1334ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "80b29ba7d609a9591ae4a4b0671f61732115e3ff36a066dee07de29c65cbb0bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-original.ppm", + "sha256": "45f5d6af2b45c1a6b4ddd54e54c466cddf89ff53b8336aec5fbf1496de18adf5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a9396ab8a52c6d339872924781cb3fab345e4df4da9a5a28b2436c56969fc3b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dbb76c8288ae094d486d92c66c68a8fb69136647a980a36c5a31135def55df9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9699b366b52bf67eb86e244e1a050147573f2548be9e2e1a60d837a76437181", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d57684ff7879bb3edfde6a0b3c12dcad79e2757f82a6802027a3c2e88e3e202f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f7be90319ec076ba5932356ad61a6518b33ad5ab66487f9d63034a613e4417f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101f0": { @@ -27130,7 +30980,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "101f0", "family_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", "job_id": "effects-101e5-101f0", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -27142,6 +30992,356 @@ "manifest": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/candidate.json", "sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "684d671d8756f72ab0146cd6aabc6498a2916a6706cb1f1f60e6ee15cfa266e1", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "d076a630af46f5c0f0ed37ea6b32c9665206da421ce89cba9d89de5532f16fbb", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.529798+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/effects-101e5-101f0/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [\"APPROVED all12 frames after independent complete authentic-source/untouched-raw/native1\\u20134/native2\\u20133/fade/material/negative-space and actual terrain Canvas review. Major source ordering from small detached ray-star, ivory peak, yellow dark-core phase, open rust ring and sparse detached fading fragments remains recognizable, with original48canvas/[0,0] anchors. This is not a claim of exact source-pixel color/mask identity or live animation timing.\", \"Genuinev10 restores every one of the seven connected101eb inner-lip cells at21..23,17..19 with full occupied subpixel coverage at every scale. Native whole-cell losses fall72\\u21923 and4\\u00d7 losses30\\u21922. The source core opening no longer cuts deeply into the original painted lip. One remaining RGB89/28/4 inner-corner cell(23,16) is absent allscales, and outer upper-right RGB130/36/16(32,5) is also absent; a third native outer-right shoulder cell(43,12),RGB105/36/4, survives4\\u00d7. These are explicitly accepted minor isolated corner changes after visual crop/context inspection. Source enclosed holearea127 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea127.625 supports that inspection rather than replacing it.\", \"Genuinev10 restores four of five101ec original painted shoulder cells10..14,4 at every scale. Dim outer endpoint(14,4) remains absent allscales, alongside dim lower outer(14,45); three other low-scale corner cells return at4\\u00d7. Native losses94\\u21925 and4\\u00d7 losses14\\u21922. The original connected shoulder/rim band is visibly retained; the residual two exterior endpoint changes are accepted. Source coreholearea249 versus actual4\\u00d7 logicalarea250.875 is disclosed; no new interior material fills the intended hole.\", \"Unchanged101e7/101e8/101e9/101ea retain their main lobes/rays and peak/dark-core shape. Whole source losses at4\\u00d7 are4/8/6/17, including connected small exterior edge strips in101e9/101ea. Every exact coordinate/index/RGB is enumerated. Source/native/mask and full composition inspection show localized external smoothing/notches rather than the earlier deep connected inner-lip or five-cell shoulder removal. These are accepted qualifications, including native20/29/37/62 wholly missing cells and four added native samples in101ea; no universal numeric allowance is implied.\", \"Previously restored first2 and late2 remain exact v9 bindings and are reassessed in the whole sequence:101e5 zero whole losses allscales;101e6 two native/one2\\u00d7/none3\\u20134\\u00d7. 101ed persistent(19,4) and101ee persistent(12..14,42), allRGB89/28/4, remain small exterior notches with the adjacent ring continuous. Last101ef has25 native andone4\\u00d7 lossRGB69/28/24(35,4);101f0 eight native andzero2\\u20134\\u00d7 losses. Ring break-up, detached fragment placements and tiny end remnants remain readable, with their exact area/edge/addition differences recorded.\", \"New101eb/101ec have conspicuously stronger organic flame grain, small hot yellow patches and higher local contrast than the original flat orange fields and smoother unchanged middle phases. This material transition is visible especially4\\u00d7 and is explicitly accepted after the complete sequence and actual terrain composition were inspected. Their integrated base-palette luminance ratios at4\\u00d7 are1.032/1.003 of source, and native meanRGB191.747/105.266/19.523 versus source192.898/98.785/19.606 for101eb, 182.017/89.871/18.054 versus185.136/87.098/19.042 for101ec. Near source means are diagnostic support, not proof that local brightness/material is identical. Stronger step-field texture in unchanged first2/late2 and the smoother grain in other phases are likewise disclosed.\", \"The full rise from yellow rays through ivory peak and the subsequent warmer/dimmer thinning ring and fragments remain clear. Last phases are somewhat dimmer/thinner than original: integrated4\\u00d7 luminance ratios101ed/ee/ef/f0 approximately.968/.930/.834/.851. They remain visible against authentic terrain, including every thin end fragment, so the darker fade treatment is accepted after actual composition review; no timing, audio, shadows or original mission backdrop is inferred.\", \"No visible broad brown background veil occurs in actual indexed/context proof. Nonzero rawRGB underalpha0 is hidden, not foreground. Source/output ordinary palette classes0..239 remain ordinary; no reserved/fire/water/blink semantics are invented. All current raws byte-match their genuine built-in outputs, with original binary/palette/reference PNG, prompt/provenance, candidate, exact immutable library and all actual evidence hash-bound.\", \"Original48-in64 viewports are independently verified in all references. V11 metadata chooses470-square crops78,78 and705,78 for newv10 cells, retaining everyalpha16/32 sample while excluding79/69 faintalpha1\\u201315 padding specks. No rawRGB/alpha repair or loader compensation was performed. Other10 bindings are byte-identical to v9, with52/60 actual spritePPMs and88/96CanvasPPMs unchanged.\", \"Approval is restricted to this exact complete-family independent artwork/indexed/crop/native-composition review. Coordinator registration/render reachability and live timing verification remain separate. Historicalv6/v9 and4006e holds remain preserved byte-for-byte; no production/source/global/Git/policy change was made.\"] \"Read-only complete-family source/hash-bound artwork/native gallery/crop/blitter review. Isolated ignored evidence writes only; no artwork/raw/candidate/source/global manifest/ledger/Git/registration/promotion or policy edits and no live Host claims. All earlier accepted/held artifacts remain preserved.\" All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 b493fa7d8f28a357d7fc4cc9e21fdedecaeb16f4f029c43e14aa7e12489e6b18", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "101e5", + "101e6", + "101e7", + "101e8" + ], + "sha256": "f538dd1743bd39e36e6190882712540652a5db7aa81e0d9ab11221ac28ed693a", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "101e9", + "101ea", + "101eb", + "101ec" + ], + "sha256": "de4bb446e004c2a8f5e7bbf42b725d6db1d771114612a880fac7fcff741a0838", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "101ed", + "101ee", + "101ef", + "101f0" + ], + "sha256": "684357deae6d6d0a0433044b5abe8fd82fe3a2f7323be7b53e1ea3c90bd058c8", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "101e5-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1f0dcb0e0cdb9955675a37ba428be30db913c8d085088c26d90727979537f81b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5d045049dd0d130ddb842ba2f13de3626001f102372da4f377585b5778f523a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ebd239e9e2efa9f643f2f5e9de12b442b54f05869ab03b8f50f09a488991fb55", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4d0416ee8d3b31e1e750649a57261bbc6935f7c72405dec1f40c3b1c856920b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e5-original.ppm", + "sha256": "91b655475797eb4eb0bc0f4ef2afcd6c0a8e5a63c43fe5f8bf639bb12753678b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e5-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d21530de88f2de5f3419e86581ea05939b3669a8c7afcd003c0deba267d17ab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e79e0c2e8f7477f63f66ec8d73036da7874eb1d09e57e004bc277bc96f832514", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "98a140f6d56b9c1b55a1d999f20613b37b6b272ecfd5c560f24aba6de5063065", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "297d1b6117513576a45c4b59a3a510ee78e97b046cffe3851bc4832ed09c852f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e6-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a2538e1defca06ad217e76711bfd87353d37aba0d895d455700896c84a291aab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e6-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d1c4dda25106c9223a2b206a7b2092e34ff051cd0e0101e5f390fb3c5b1cd40", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ef216ae0207c06da15a54457a63c3d0d791ad1a0b642790931039332fb30851", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2cf1eed2d0f482a2cb2e5dda8c4b0f7e787349c2a0be068943f179eab2a30b91", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "943bc627354dee1ed8fc342ed43a550a96a1f6e122265e1fd6e7b55ebd7b837a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e7-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7d308b0c0664ebedc8a48c1924df647e8ab5356f10369ff76d9745480b70258f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e7-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f71821252794fdcc162df4559ad89a9e17c83e865c9c42eb5e5fe6e1486c77ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4bd0246a19a3b99f9cc74908a97055ffa3125d269d55ab200b8913e1da35350d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "2577a62301f6a0f48d28d96ba9d9677be3854363ad850261432b2f7848cb4efb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3b2c8462de5321a9aa8c010ac4ee3d1d7d9f99d4cebdd8ff360eaa11f2c98f8e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e8-original.ppm", + "sha256": "494c95630519c1f8f86b021953a4c1d004ab88291314d8214ae99bf46a66d773", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e8-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f60863bbd5bcc7586ddc30ac1104f7f617937d75db7d282cf4cbd40241f3fdee", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd3e6bf5f4efdaf5658aa715063afd7d71bf44f92c83cb54a9ab3333a7595f3f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c7213976a82bc0776f3510079df457ea7c9d561b3250c060218c5bebf86802ef", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "48318af464b9331842af91d10d6af1aa6397007237c7b92a1c470e35a889de4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101e9-original.ppm", + "sha256": "14e8ebb425dfb8ccd9409cf5d10a3ba47a48c640fb2d6d00f262e9f1f54e30ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101e9-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "841cf80c9e38c2d806342159bb9df36735222eb5c02e2da487a7373e39b8ca41", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1776f3d7da186cd16b8e1948c0360c657926d588d092af0cc7fe685443ccddb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1c7b06f6f9bc3d8ec13cbf372961ab221ee571fa694a89794fba1e959171808a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b825ed0c4adaa6e69d46ed0d8addbfe3ad8415760b007ded9436b30b54726ac3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ea-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e7902214bcae894a78f3bb2f3cbfaf3d8a678d9623d4770827a0870422e91a02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ea-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "dde5fb91c3311bf3fa2b01905d8caca2b2272493a1d51f64c0d4cee884067de0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "21c7bcf6cc45834948676da6479310c03dbf79456f34a3562683058b548969e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c9d7e6a599473df325f24b4b28d0799b839ec9a2e66d3d147dec247db9d3cb99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2aefbdd2188bde4893296b179e0d67be03ece889ec14aa3cb0535c68013afae9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101eb-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b8c11a52fa012a481638d5d2bd9ec34574447f7b2327e6b4e08f75b188adaf54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101eb-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "bf8e5608f8984526fc149a48e274bca2415ff7ee3fd47f8f247c21544d5d1d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cffa953ed1fc083bf92b6269ec59665572c102574778838aea9ad6626d6e87dd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "71c36d6e2b80109eff72988d92a4db4bf9441b18238c84a5f65695cc1e0eda58", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e66c182cb0d85e907e2467a9d2099bb64250efa5c04b6242d22a312481a8534d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ec-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4d2de0382aab4b9d578e2ba5c0ce46f9513ed386d403de911c45f97f23dc0f6a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ec-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9de8ca5ea46dd3b7fb10272af40d4a778b25b6dfeacbf401f2c8d69a8d02f222", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5b88c981403cfafb4a2206e6d6e8a08977ce2e858f47b731beaf561036b7a04a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9ff5c14f677825b319fdf224dd76e11c54f72433e776bf4682d054d339eacb8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1637367b461cb9593d876f3265104a08d3355752e11ea8e00b1715cf35090cc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ed-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d9b437b8412b04022303d44584b1bae64d7d0dae91ce7f34c697ff30e5048e3d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ed-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6b37b21fe0dd4dca9d9c1c037644f7dba87b5e0a63c5f5afbdb2176d14cfbeab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5647d9a5be366499e4f21b7a93b5497336f885bbb9bf02c935db7d91a750d68b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "17a0a59d06a1e03de2bcbb4124e98a5839599eeb0d2b9239f46630d390c44779", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "e76c109cfed21bad70607a5598b573b36d74d329c5bbb4885b51cc8cc5c71add", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ee-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7424f6878ac9f5df2304792473d5d05a97e7bded83f42f56d9a306571bf92175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ee-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2bf087b9dc7262e6a7ebdff41229822f38ca6795c94ee09bab2bd41969039512", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "752521664a85227c529765ddb1dd0463f96368fcb229bea9ba5ef140f2d30c23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f3d0047c70393e7513e25fc78cd97afde4ae3244b5532d4942e7e0d33d1334ed", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "80b29ba7d609a9591ae4a4b0671f61732115e3ff36a066dee07de29c65cbb0bb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101ef-original.ppm", + "sha256": "45f5d6af2b45c1a6b4ddd54e54c466cddf89ff53b8336aec5fbf1496de18adf5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101ef-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "a9396ab8a52c6d339872924781cb3fab345e4df4da9a5a28b2436c56969fc3b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dbb76c8288ae094d486d92c66c68a8fb69136647a980a36c5a31135def55df9e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a9699b366b52bf67eb86e244e1a050147573f2548be9e2e1a60d837a76437181", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d57684ff7879bb3edfde6a0b3c12dcad79e2757f82a6802027a3c2e88e3e202f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "101f0-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f7be90319ec076ba5932356ad61a6518b33ad5ab66487f9d63034a613e4417f8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/largeair-v11/runtime/101f0-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "101f1": { @@ -36779,7 +40979,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -36812,7 +41012,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -36845,7 +41045,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -36878,7 +41078,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -36911,7 +41111,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -36944,7 +41144,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -36977,7 +41177,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37010,7 +41210,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37043,7 +41243,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37076,7 +41276,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37109,7 +41309,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37142,7 +41342,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37175,7 +41375,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37208,7 +41408,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37241,7 +41441,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37274,7 +41474,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37307,7 +41507,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37340,7 +41540,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37373,7 +41573,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37406,7 +41606,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37439,7 +41639,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37472,7 +41672,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37505,7 +41705,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37538,7 +41738,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37571,7 +41771,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37604,7 +41804,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-10252-1026b/candidate.json", - "sha256": "90552e258810f52deafc68b8b39a420ec6593be8ec535eaa9157414a241dedd8", + "sha256": "0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37637,7 +41837,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0df833fc48559ca06dc015efc2182a6ebc0774b48ad191de105bca1e84648ce7", + "sha256": "f051c1f16ed93f9fb832b88b95e0a5570b08851217056dca8d1827d8d361f717", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37670,7 +41870,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0df833fc48559ca06dc015efc2182a6ebc0774b48ad191de105bca1e84648ce7", + "sha256": "f051c1f16ed93f9fb832b88b95e0a5570b08851217056dca8d1827d8d361f717", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37703,7 +41903,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0df833fc48559ca06dc015efc2182a6ebc0774b48ad191de105bca1e84648ce7", + "sha256": "f051c1f16ed93f9fb832b88b95e0a5570b08851217056dca8d1827d8d361f717", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37736,7 +41936,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0df833fc48559ca06dc015efc2182a6ebc0774b48ad191de105bca1e84648ce7", + "sha256": "f051c1f16ed93f9fb832b88b95e0a5570b08851217056dca8d1827d8d361f717", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37769,7 +41969,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0df833fc48559ca06dc015efc2182a6ebc0774b48ad191de105bca1e84648ce7", + "sha256": "f051c1f16ed93f9fb832b88b95e0a5570b08851217056dca8d1827d8d361f717", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37802,7 +42002,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0df833fc48559ca06dc015efc2182a6ebc0774b48ad191de105bca1e84648ce7", + "sha256": "f051c1f16ed93f9fb832b88b95e0a5570b08851217056dca8d1827d8d361f717", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37835,7 +42035,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0df833fc48559ca06dc015efc2182a6ebc0774b48ad191de105bca1e84648ce7", + "sha256": "f051c1f16ed93f9fb832b88b95e0a5570b08851217056dca8d1827d8d361f717", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37868,7 +42068,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0df833fc48559ca06dc015efc2182a6ebc0774b48ad191de105bca1e84648ce7", + "sha256": "f051c1f16ed93f9fb832b88b95e0a5570b08851217056dca8d1827d8d361f717", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37901,7 +42101,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0df833fc48559ca06dc015efc2182a6ebc0774b48ad191de105bca1e84648ce7", + "sha256": "f051c1f16ed93f9fb832b88b95e0a5570b08851217056dca8d1827d8d361f717", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37934,7 +42134,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0df833fc48559ca06dc015efc2182a6ebc0774b48ad191de105bca1e84648ce7", + "sha256": "f051c1f16ed93f9fb832b88b95e0a5570b08851217056dca8d1827d8d361f717", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -37967,7 +42167,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0df833fc48559ca06dc015efc2182a6ebc0774b48ad191de105bca1e84648ce7", + "sha256": "f051c1f16ed93f9fb832b88b95e0a5570b08851217056dca8d1827d8d361f717", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -38000,7 +42200,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0df833fc48559ca06dc015efc2182a6ebc0774b48ad191de105bca1e84648ce7", + "sha256": "f051c1f16ed93f9fb832b88b95e0a5570b08851217056dca8d1827d8d361f717", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -38033,7 +42233,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0df833fc48559ca06dc015efc2182a6ebc0774b48ad191de105bca1e84648ce7", + "sha256": "f051c1f16ed93f9fb832b88b95e0a5570b08851217056dca8d1827d8d361f717", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -38066,7 +42266,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0df833fc48559ca06dc015efc2182a6ebc0774b48ad191de105bca1e84648ce7", + "sha256": "f051c1f16ed93f9fb832b88b95e0a5570b08851217056dca8d1827d8d361f717", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -38099,7 +42299,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0df833fc48559ca06dc015efc2182a6ebc0774b48ad191de105bca1e84648ce7", + "sha256": "f051c1f16ed93f9fb832b88b95e0a5570b08851217056dca8d1827d8d361f717", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -38132,7 +42332,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0df833fc48559ca06dc015efc2182a6ebc0774b48ad191de105bca1e84648ce7", + "sha256": "f051c1f16ed93f9fb832b88b95e0a5570b08851217056dca8d1827d8d361f717", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -38165,7 +42365,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/effects-1026c-1027c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "0df833fc48559ca06dc015efc2182a6ebc0774b48ad191de105bca1e84648ce7", + "sha256": "f051c1f16ed93f9fb832b88b95e0a5570b08851217056dca8d1827d8d361f717", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -135843,7 +140043,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10400-1040f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "921ad8c070b11c9691c121f7f1681422d0a063221fcfca8043f4278a768cd5ef", + "sha256": "cb3246274e5f9f02449a8519f6ed6c53b757f7475f27ad2650864e9dc3c7d2c9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -135880,7 +140080,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10400-1040f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "921ad8c070b11c9691c121f7f1681422d0a063221fcfca8043f4278a768cd5ef", + "sha256": "cb3246274e5f9f02449a8519f6ed6c53b757f7475f27ad2650864e9dc3c7d2c9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -135917,7 +140117,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10400-1040f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "921ad8c070b11c9691c121f7f1681422d0a063221fcfca8043f4278a768cd5ef", + "sha256": "cb3246274e5f9f02449a8519f6ed6c53b757f7475f27ad2650864e9dc3c7d2c9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -135954,7 +140154,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10400-1040f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "921ad8c070b11c9691c121f7f1681422d0a063221fcfca8043f4278a768cd5ef", + "sha256": "cb3246274e5f9f02449a8519f6ed6c53b757f7475f27ad2650864e9dc3c7d2c9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -135991,7 +140191,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10400-1040f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "921ad8c070b11c9691c121f7f1681422d0a063221fcfca8043f4278a768cd5ef", + "sha256": "cb3246274e5f9f02449a8519f6ed6c53b757f7475f27ad2650864e9dc3c7d2c9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -136028,7 +140228,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10400-1040f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "921ad8c070b11c9691c121f7f1681422d0a063221fcfca8043f4278a768cd5ef", + "sha256": "cb3246274e5f9f02449a8519f6ed6c53b757f7475f27ad2650864e9dc3c7d2c9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -136065,7 +140265,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10400-1040f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "921ad8c070b11c9691c121f7f1681422d0a063221fcfca8043f4278a768cd5ef", + "sha256": "cb3246274e5f9f02449a8519f6ed6c53b757f7475f27ad2650864e9dc3c7d2c9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -136102,7 +140302,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10400-1040f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "921ad8c070b11c9691c121f7f1681422d0a063221fcfca8043f4278a768cd5ef", + "sha256": "cb3246274e5f9f02449a8519f6ed6c53b757f7475f27ad2650864e9dc3c7d2c9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -136139,7 +140339,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10400-1040f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "921ad8c070b11c9691c121f7f1681422d0a063221fcfca8043f4278a768cd5ef", + "sha256": "cb3246274e5f9f02449a8519f6ed6c53b757f7475f27ad2650864e9dc3c7d2c9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -136176,7 +140376,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10400-1040f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "921ad8c070b11c9691c121f7f1681422d0a063221fcfca8043f4278a768cd5ef", + "sha256": "cb3246274e5f9f02449a8519f6ed6c53b757f7475f27ad2650864e9dc3c7d2c9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -136213,7 +140413,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10400-1040f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "921ad8c070b11c9691c121f7f1681422d0a063221fcfca8043f4278a768cd5ef", + "sha256": "cb3246274e5f9f02449a8519f6ed6c53b757f7475f27ad2650864e9dc3c7d2c9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -136250,7 +140450,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10400-1040f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "921ad8c070b11c9691c121f7f1681422d0a063221fcfca8043f4278a768cd5ef", + "sha256": "cb3246274e5f9f02449a8519f6ed6c53b757f7475f27ad2650864e9dc3c7d2c9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -136287,7 +140487,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10400-1040f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "921ad8c070b11c9691c121f7f1681422d0a063221fcfca8043f4278a768cd5ef", + "sha256": "cb3246274e5f9f02449a8519f6ed6c53b757f7475f27ad2650864e9dc3c7d2c9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -136324,7 +140524,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10400-1040f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "921ad8c070b11c9691c121f7f1681422d0a063221fcfca8043f4278a768cd5ef", + "sha256": "cb3246274e5f9f02449a8519f6ed6c53b757f7475f27ad2650864e9dc3c7d2c9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -136361,7 +140561,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10400-1040f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "921ad8c070b11c9691c121f7f1681422d0a063221fcfca8043f4278a768cd5ef", + "sha256": "cb3246274e5f9f02449a8519f6ed6c53b757f7475f27ad2650864e9dc3c7d2c9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -136398,7 +140598,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10400-1040f/candidate.json", - "sha256": "921ad8c070b11c9691c121f7f1681422d0a063221fcfca8043f4278a768cd5ef", + "sha256": "cb3246274e5f9f02449a8519f6ed6c53b757f7475f27ad2650864e9dc3c7d2c9", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -136421,7 +140621,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10410", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -136437,6 +140637,467 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", "sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eeac825831b65f3085ee3a93cde1178da43f46775d29db1ec47f6c416d09f6e8", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.866714+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"10410/10411/10412\": \"Wide/tall corrugated roof geometry, side posts, surviving broken metal strips, charred openings and original ember placements remain source-relative. Both new wrecks were compared with authentic intact source partners at all recorded same-position contexts; no reconstructed intact roof was approved.\", \"10413/10414/10416\": \"Brown/grey horizontal wall bands and dark lower recesses preserve original source structure. Complete-family same-position transitions preserve continuous neighbor wall placement while removing the damaged tile structure; charred occupied backing is retained. Cracked masonry and rubble are a detail/material interpretation within the original regions, not a new detached building.\", \"10415\": \"Five original small pale rock groupings and their shadows remain separated at the original positions; chipped grain is accepted as added detail.\", \"10417\": \"Separate pale vertical/horizontal blocks, cyan box, lower grey block and two original animated ember cells preserve source placement; blocks have finer cracks/edges.\", \"10418/10419/1041a/1041b/1041c\": \"Original asymmetric rock masses, peaks, pale ledges and dark lower faces remain identifiable across all scales and authentic contexts. Fine chipped facets/grain are accepted; original state partners remain original artwork.\", \"1041d/1041e/1041f\": \"Original dotted border lines and cross-junction gaps remain aligned. The unchanged high-resolution raw 1041f contains irregular chipped pale fragments, not continuous stone panels. Native scales3/4 retain some square/stipple rhythm because the original one-pixel pale cells occupy very small areas. This disclosed over-literal rhythm is accepted as source placement fidelity after viewing raw and every actual scale, including all native neighbors.\"} {\"historical_job_sha256\": \"c703e6899b27905486538d0622bd111e22845b923c03dae26c87f4a003bb6cd4\", \"current_job_sha256\": \"0f6ab3d989aa9a16e71c9b69bc21e646675f2e4a4755b27fde1f75d1ec4e976d\", \"historical_artifact\": \"frozen/generated/historical-native-job-c703e689-reconstructed.json\", \"historical_retention_scope\": \"Author reconstructed full historical bytes from retained16 per-frame original job copies; exact serialized SHA c703e689 verified independently. This is not claimed to be retained original full-file bytes.\", \"reconstruction_provenance_sha256\": \"0fc2d4cd6479a0a29a6f64eab342cdf9c32ceac4d1d44293fddeaec08e8f38b4\", \"only_semantic_changes\": {\"target_statuses\": [{\"asset\": \"10410\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10411\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10412\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10413\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10414\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10415\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10416\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10417\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10418\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10419\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041a\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041b\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041c\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041d\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041e\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041f\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}], \"status_counts\": {\"before\": {\"inprogress\": 16}, \"after\": {\"candidate\": 16}}}, \"all_sources_geometry_roles_partners_neighbors_samples_and_contracts_exact\": true, \"author_explanation\": \"Shared hd_job_queue.py refreshes status metadata across jobs. Current0f6 job was already frozen before this independent rendering; old author proof remains historical. Neither discrepancy affects raw/frame bindings or terrain context data.\"} [\"Opaque mask IoU1 is trivial and was not used as material or geometry approval. All source/raw/full actual1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 images were visually inspected.\", \"Palette quantization/blockiness remains visible at2/3. New HD ground/rock/metal grain remains denser and sharper beside original fallback tiles; square texture-density boundaries can remain visible in mixed scenes. This approval does not assert uniform whole-mission material or complete HD fallback coverage.\", \"Foreign1040f/104ed/104ee/104f5 remain original in all independently rendered full-family and state scenes. Private HD1040f pack was excluded.\", \"State proof renders declared original source partner substitution at the same recorded position. First4pairs9positions are native target/state contexts; remaining6pairs17positions are explicitly synthetic declared source-state substitutions at authentic intact occurrences. No live destruction timing/reachability or live Host/whole-mission validation is claimed.\", \"Native scene and cardinal corpus comes from canonical supplied source contexts; no invented source occurrences. No new gameplay scrolling/boss assembly test is claimed.\", \"Animated palette240\\u2013255 pixels are legitimate source effects:10410=5,10412=4,10414=8,10417=2. Current loader source-relative class totals expand byscale\\u00b2. Static capture does not prove full palette cycling phases.\", \"Review only; no production manifest/source/art/Git writes, registration or promotion.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 37f5c4b26f9086c3724a4b13249981acf54dfaba4d5a0e7b861a928a50a3f187", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "10410", + "10411", + "10412", + "10413" + ], + "sha256": "dfdf91ff2260f9e5cd5afab1d62ce1182bd399635f3307843138a778f4f65beb", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "10414", + "10415", + "10416", + "10417" + ], + "sha256": "989a797ac864e72c88805fcbdd5b8e494db6c307a75f5facea86bd602a2bd104", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "10418", + "10419", + "1041a", + "1041b" + ], + "sha256": "c2856b9eda30d17110fea211e769ce0adf65b15a3254ff4a57a427ac079197d2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "1041c", + "1041d", + "1041e", + "1041f" + ], + "sha256": "e5cfb639df3fcc47a4533af97884a9163409c2e4db6a0fa59a1fb7e3ad926224", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10410-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac8fc607959f5f14c0b942da5f21fb0f26e3336edd6ff8d352ed6f2b503b8e7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c39bff33a03e8367c725d1bb68613df96c60841e37d5ed3bdac0f2acb9ca18a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e045baa994ac7ea4b62c3e3020ae3266b48b3ef03118282a0918dc1dd2e91aeb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5c181c77cc497bcbd185796574207fe4e89623ce13053ca246c16ee904690812", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b9f1b7fcf833e60b7ade5f3e678896f72c5e78fa85ba6792e7fc78424ebd8958", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cc3fd56d3e61a9d919b9a0b7e67caa0aa932f394d5232477f44c37d48c91b5dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "932c116e449199fc8b4c26e522c73c339bc1fda4e3a6382eb26d25a3366e7174", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1dee0695f73c8701c567fc18ecaa11bf56fa74d6833a34fa7f6dfc92b7ca51b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c3c2129b8f2cd34b744e494087f53ba5691c8dd83849b161b0c59292a9f6cdb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5f1190f320faaaab142e030bef2196496759b6856f0c96a5c2fcd38d5767a390", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9f0e642fd58f9c42103b6f71341ef663c208bfab3ed737a6cb109d147b9077a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "049a788257cb017d0dc19cd5e7c2e03f869b73343ff005d736e98afa977fc878", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cdd053889c26c1f7e66934f6680eb07b5772cbe80632082b4627eb5196f09c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a398fafa05cf760e4907d6e63eaed92193724591cf0d8031e54f440238e423e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52ce7e36ddd901308955a916f87b21a51418658e416615ef23fc08a83d09c70e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4ccaf6751ec10bedbabf226ac52d17ce80d51ff4164b19bb82494123e51f6c92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a1d70e398ae3867c7e2717d1e0d5ac80f7af9356a8c02ad7ebdc034a085f03d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f51f5c4b055955c6e8e9e4803e8ca57ffb833e72d7c93b50cffd421cbcff375", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b9dfb1fa7af5b64bc1f013d4f77d90bd2faa6be226b72f5577f46faee0f654f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-original.ppm", + "sha256": "07815b537b8df019f9a8b3bb100f205b20bdac607b06a3a883674728f51a1961", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "474b5cb2530effe4d8ce79d3b57eda23f795718dfc30fe1591b179e2cde17adc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7c3940d23b448558f7689b1b3171c41a0a99f8b92ccfb62e0fc243523df679fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ccfd3f02fb94e39d606e6b5039dc09a535027f5b1193161af1ad8482a1452c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab016bb7ae2ca976bdec92013b52f2ee0c9a0f249b5998fb63dd3e6d7964b07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-original.ppm", + "sha256": "731d2ad7d40da37dcf6d85fa128aec8f652bb3c5e3a3a1cab7bf97f6ccd55c63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "52ee4577a74f409c5f90aad05f39a8f462f139685398bcb5c92ca0208f0150e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a81c58b827f4533f41f6413a366a8f5e707f8b43039fc823ce9863fb0646e57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3221d17f268e21888a795e88ef677f5219f72a7788e57903fd900f55bbbf3556", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "81ca18fc0aae76a37f36e697efbdc6aa7a56acabfd7e20ce64d0cb5c38ffdaad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a04d2b78a0fe288544345cfbf99e031d1342591773c132de94f1a1a02a828c82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1fa8cb4aa3db5303d7e17c62876e69a352be0e71e34022902b3d5715ff56e4b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "557c5202b8790b5199d326695425b14f2f66b7f4beb101d38dd7b3dec54aa94e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a4ea4b96e7a9a77c54a8fee0f71718baecc64361ed931145badc415eb372ab90", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8797c65adee550343f481e5f5790ffc89b2b133f79bcafe3d67cfdf632cc594a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0f589865a0b7837ea238e4012e2dbb70d8f3b8b165127016fced78e0269b59cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "aaa8bfc0d7576c76523b26dc6ffdb70c966c03fc4f24eb0003cb9fb984f79490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "421cd09e4c241a019cb279c1cecf404f83c892a4bd7dbaa652ceaaea037fbd2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "84414bf8ec17dcfb3608cb42cc586f41fdbff735bc0f5b5d97434d0692424c3e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "83585b540986dd9f78869a8930858bd0dc141b69990b7ad6d91e36b2efc47cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0986dfc3e26d68f0e04195cdf9d1e2b7f5da2cd23b880af56b9384ef963f7c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7588543821be396ed14b6bd3e78bb0c3e079cbe2b94613ad9ab155c7605697bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "72acdde37443a6200d4157882b0d13f182ab41b24f58e3067d104b47488b00cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bb31621cec2f76017cf3f224cc20b0ddd78e126c51a1b8a2f6d4e411fc1d3987", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e0fbc5e011994fd47197aec6f8e662b4816afd311c927b2031f2392ad459ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eb6deecd0c170702e64f0d50f246dd37c12d02c3e21f68fd1d2be8d3fee83348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47acf1e50b2c79375a79cf912e60dcbdf36a1a60de9a826816c2f1559d9869a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd88e0e034a3c6989221dcc7e1993969a120d8436f30b4cec883869b54b4c907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d9171e08c11d28e13c7d5e704a9a8c5b38f56f90e2a9195e7054cc9c5c70c6d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "569a261febe59ad14728c89b23cc8dc5c24c525e8c1777fc4b16a8c6cc8a7a19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-original.ppm", + "sha256": "568481e4973c48993eef1f19374db65ef81246c8f2f1b0541666b8534c827e1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2cb304f42ba13ca5d827403c075d5577fb0bbe462db7988b2c02bf60801ab1f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f486227c734f2925f00ba67e70491f2bc6f38724a2166133fa23197788bb6cdc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e68f73973e511dcbbd6d48a9feeedd02c59cfc336a0228daffb0af67aec23a75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4ef398a88feec37105119dcdc37bab7fa0587b72c684702221829c12182de892", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b2c5dde1e1278d7534e9d7b4d1bf538d43f2e575426fcfe70e70c9cebdb15c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "236cc9a65e1e10ef753cc7316e25ae00e89b25dd5f80f9f35ec4765bc8fd2246", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "93dcfcd8359586da4dc1653e5f139e055d6cd3ec64c5cc004c18b2cf09db1bd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ee030edc5f9bc4ed6e197dbc81561d99798626f2cbe9750f2e8e2a55292e6896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2d32515adf639db9afc206140be51c7de52e74d1c3f3146687bfe6fe4ca4baaa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "63ad4f656faaf16f8f5eabbe8298d9aeb5e0a642d6f23ee4696176da0e3559d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06d2a2a8ac1058499d10e311463dd6835201f001e14345fcb6913c182246a03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0a6814ad21c8b8bf9a11822713f299eda7eed35ff13b710c6cec53b4e15f83eb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c4f962337cfcacc4ea63bb3b6160b40f1c63145b7cf4d750611e731aeb79894", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "424b024a191e23319c0785e1d1a9980d62fa6e593febfafcb9f7c72649e3d14d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26e2a8951641c52a403495952e503bc1017911e8681a96e595b5ece7cfb2e516", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b0cbd4b654d771773680f4f04f96fb65630d04027e484be2346313a1e1cfa82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8b66f6973fc86b3ef08a70a8bef6a397af7a487523956147167099a77f5c99df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "60373b77be34a563be55f6c85aba51fa41c47e2ccab98b16fb5b27a30d6ef1f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "606804f250f7244c0d6ed1b2646798104a885be8da8e993d5e154dd6dcaef12f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e1c234832095bcb0724c60c030b34a0d9994361dff8ecf5bc9c0cd256a66024e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c8c90b8af19dc87065ff61cb9aea1481b33c4d58d051a91ff6e37fd516a5a3b5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b1875fffa16d39852af9d76ad362a705660166359f4a0d056c90e4fe5c3516c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a69bca1ff1997e749b9994a4b186bc6c381070292d3ec38b0aca0ce21f8ebdcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ef96b177a79477741a94979f135364b814764b6a717809947c08f8b4d2de232", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "38cd254a04df76a5439136d51ae7c4a60bc02c23eadfd671e8bd7c5222ac7410", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2393ddef6f77d0f58cf018dc11bc4372f4783513e92726536a7aec53f6471d56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acded7cffcd4762f83293964eb7cea418769f251ce5f4de0feb8e54e16be156f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "edb024afb9c5b2bc80b0a9b13f8fa52ac69a302ab43d910026d58e66c53bc1a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36ee8a23a83692aa4f2741be3f1125e9b005adb130b893cb804c8d85fdeccc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cf5c9c74844d1ed57b443a3c02d305dbd234e7b6a5acba984b2e732e42825f67", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "10411": { @@ -136458,7 +141119,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10411", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -136474,6 +141135,467 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", "sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eeac825831b65f3085ee3a93cde1178da43f46775d29db1ec47f6c416d09f6e8", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.866714+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"10410/10411/10412\": \"Wide/tall corrugated roof geometry, side posts, surviving broken metal strips, charred openings and original ember placements remain source-relative. Both new wrecks were compared with authentic intact source partners at all recorded same-position contexts; no reconstructed intact roof was approved.\", \"10413/10414/10416\": \"Brown/grey horizontal wall bands and dark lower recesses preserve original source structure. Complete-family same-position transitions preserve continuous neighbor wall placement while removing the damaged tile structure; charred occupied backing is retained. Cracked masonry and rubble are a detail/material interpretation within the original regions, not a new detached building.\", \"10415\": \"Five original small pale rock groupings and their shadows remain separated at the original positions; chipped grain is accepted as added detail.\", \"10417\": \"Separate pale vertical/horizontal blocks, cyan box, lower grey block and two original animated ember cells preserve source placement; blocks have finer cracks/edges.\", \"10418/10419/1041a/1041b/1041c\": \"Original asymmetric rock masses, peaks, pale ledges and dark lower faces remain identifiable across all scales and authentic contexts. Fine chipped facets/grain are accepted; original state partners remain original artwork.\", \"1041d/1041e/1041f\": \"Original dotted border lines and cross-junction gaps remain aligned. The unchanged high-resolution raw 1041f contains irregular chipped pale fragments, not continuous stone panels. Native scales3/4 retain some square/stipple rhythm because the original one-pixel pale cells occupy very small areas. This disclosed over-literal rhythm is accepted as source placement fidelity after viewing raw and every actual scale, including all native neighbors.\"} {\"historical_job_sha256\": \"c703e6899b27905486538d0622bd111e22845b923c03dae26c87f4a003bb6cd4\", \"current_job_sha256\": \"0f6ab3d989aa9a16e71c9b69bc21e646675f2e4a4755b27fde1f75d1ec4e976d\", \"historical_artifact\": \"frozen/generated/historical-native-job-c703e689-reconstructed.json\", \"historical_retention_scope\": \"Author reconstructed full historical bytes from retained16 per-frame original job copies; exact serialized SHA c703e689 verified independently. This is not claimed to be retained original full-file bytes.\", \"reconstruction_provenance_sha256\": \"0fc2d4cd6479a0a29a6f64eab342cdf9c32ceac4d1d44293fddeaec08e8f38b4\", \"only_semantic_changes\": {\"target_statuses\": [{\"asset\": \"10410\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10411\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10412\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10413\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10414\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10415\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10416\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10417\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10418\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10419\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041a\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041b\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041c\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041d\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041e\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041f\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}], \"status_counts\": {\"before\": {\"inprogress\": 16}, \"after\": {\"candidate\": 16}}}, \"all_sources_geometry_roles_partners_neighbors_samples_and_contracts_exact\": true, \"author_explanation\": \"Shared hd_job_queue.py refreshes status metadata across jobs. Current0f6 job was already frozen before this independent rendering; old author proof remains historical. Neither discrepancy affects raw/frame bindings or terrain context data.\"} [\"Opaque mask IoU1 is trivial and was not used as material or geometry approval. All source/raw/full actual1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 images were visually inspected.\", \"Palette quantization/blockiness remains visible at2/3. New HD ground/rock/metal grain remains denser and sharper beside original fallback tiles; square texture-density boundaries can remain visible in mixed scenes. This approval does not assert uniform whole-mission material or complete HD fallback coverage.\", \"Foreign1040f/104ed/104ee/104f5 remain original in all independently rendered full-family and state scenes. Private HD1040f pack was excluded.\", \"State proof renders declared original source partner substitution at the same recorded position. First4pairs9positions are native target/state contexts; remaining6pairs17positions are explicitly synthetic declared source-state substitutions at authentic intact occurrences. No live destruction timing/reachability or live Host/whole-mission validation is claimed.\", \"Native scene and cardinal corpus comes from canonical supplied source contexts; no invented source occurrences. No new gameplay scrolling/boss assembly test is claimed.\", \"Animated palette240\\u2013255 pixels are legitimate source effects:10410=5,10412=4,10414=8,10417=2. Current loader source-relative class totals expand byscale\\u00b2. Static capture does not prove full palette cycling phases.\", \"Review only; no production manifest/source/art/Git writes, registration or promotion.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 37f5c4b26f9086c3724a4b13249981acf54dfaba4d5a0e7b861a928a50a3f187", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "10410", + "10411", + "10412", + "10413" + ], + "sha256": "dfdf91ff2260f9e5cd5afab1d62ce1182bd399635f3307843138a778f4f65beb", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "10414", + "10415", + "10416", + "10417" + ], + "sha256": "989a797ac864e72c88805fcbdd5b8e494db6c307a75f5facea86bd602a2bd104", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "10418", + "10419", + "1041a", + "1041b" + ], + "sha256": "c2856b9eda30d17110fea211e769ce0adf65b15a3254ff4a57a427ac079197d2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "1041c", + "1041d", + "1041e", + "1041f" + ], + "sha256": "e5cfb639df3fcc47a4533af97884a9163409c2e4db6a0fa59a1fb7e3ad926224", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10410-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac8fc607959f5f14c0b942da5f21fb0f26e3336edd6ff8d352ed6f2b503b8e7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c39bff33a03e8367c725d1bb68613df96c60841e37d5ed3bdac0f2acb9ca18a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e045baa994ac7ea4b62c3e3020ae3266b48b3ef03118282a0918dc1dd2e91aeb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5c181c77cc497bcbd185796574207fe4e89623ce13053ca246c16ee904690812", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b9f1b7fcf833e60b7ade5f3e678896f72c5e78fa85ba6792e7fc78424ebd8958", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cc3fd56d3e61a9d919b9a0b7e67caa0aa932f394d5232477f44c37d48c91b5dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "932c116e449199fc8b4c26e522c73c339bc1fda4e3a6382eb26d25a3366e7174", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1dee0695f73c8701c567fc18ecaa11bf56fa74d6833a34fa7f6dfc92b7ca51b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c3c2129b8f2cd34b744e494087f53ba5691c8dd83849b161b0c59292a9f6cdb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5f1190f320faaaab142e030bef2196496759b6856f0c96a5c2fcd38d5767a390", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9f0e642fd58f9c42103b6f71341ef663c208bfab3ed737a6cb109d147b9077a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "049a788257cb017d0dc19cd5e7c2e03f869b73343ff005d736e98afa977fc878", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cdd053889c26c1f7e66934f6680eb07b5772cbe80632082b4627eb5196f09c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a398fafa05cf760e4907d6e63eaed92193724591cf0d8031e54f440238e423e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52ce7e36ddd901308955a916f87b21a51418658e416615ef23fc08a83d09c70e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4ccaf6751ec10bedbabf226ac52d17ce80d51ff4164b19bb82494123e51f6c92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a1d70e398ae3867c7e2717d1e0d5ac80f7af9356a8c02ad7ebdc034a085f03d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f51f5c4b055955c6e8e9e4803e8ca57ffb833e72d7c93b50cffd421cbcff375", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b9dfb1fa7af5b64bc1f013d4f77d90bd2faa6be226b72f5577f46faee0f654f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-original.ppm", + "sha256": "07815b537b8df019f9a8b3bb100f205b20bdac607b06a3a883674728f51a1961", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "474b5cb2530effe4d8ce79d3b57eda23f795718dfc30fe1591b179e2cde17adc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7c3940d23b448558f7689b1b3171c41a0a99f8b92ccfb62e0fc243523df679fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ccfd3f02fb94e39d606e6b5039dc09a535027f5b1193161af1ad8482a1452c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab016bb7ae2ca976bdec92013b52f2ee0c9a0f249b5998fb63dd3e6d7964b07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-original.ppm", + "sha256": "731d2ad7d40da37dcf6d85fa128aec8f652bb3c5e3a3a1cab7bf97f6ccd55c63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "52ee4577a74f409c5f90aad05f39a8f462f139685398bcb5c92ca0208f0150e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a81c58b827f4533f41f6413a366a8f5e707f8b43039fc823ce9863fb0646e57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3221d17f268e21888a795e88ef677f5219f72a7788e57903fd900f55bbbf3556", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "81ca18fc0aae76a37f36e697efbdc6aa7a56acabfd7e20ce64d0cb5c38ffdaad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a04d2b78a0fe288544345cfbf99e031d1342591773c132de94f1a1a02a828c82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1fa8cb4aa3db5303d7e17c62876e69a352be0e71e34022902b3d5715ff56e4b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "557c5202b8790b5199d326695425b14f2f66b7f4beb101d38dd7b3dec54aa94e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a4ea4b96e7a9a77c54a8fee0f71718baecc64361ed931145badc415eb372ab90", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8797c65adee550343f481e5f5790ffc89b2b133f79bcafe3d67cfdf632cc594a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0f589865a0b7837ea238e4012e2dbb70d8f3b8b165127016fced78e0269b59cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "aaa8bfc0d7576c76523b26dc6ffdb70c966c03fc4f24eb0003cb9fb984f79490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "421cd09e4c241a019cb279c1cecf404f83c892a4bd7dbaa652ceaaea037fbd2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "84414bf8ec17dcfb3608cb42cc586f41fdbff735bc0f5b5d97434d0692424c3e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "83585b540986dd9f78869a8930858bd0dc141b69990b7ad6d91e36b2efc47cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0986dfc3e26d68f0e04195cdf9d1e2b7f5da2cd23b880af56b9384ef963f7c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7588543821be396ed14b6bd3e78bb0c3e079cbe2b94613ad9ab155c7605697bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "72acdde37443a6200d4157882b0d13f182ab41b24f58e3067d104b47488b00cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bb31621cec2f76017cf3f224cc20b0ddd78e126c51a1b8a2f6d4e411fc1d3987", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e0fbc5e011994fd47197aec6f8e662b4816afd311c927b2031f2392ad459ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eb6deecd0c170702e64f0d50f246dd37c12d02c3e21f68fd1d2be8d3fee83348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47acf1e50b2c79375a79cf912e60dcbdf36a1a60de9a826816c2f1559d9869a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd88e0e034a3c6989221dcc7e1993969a120d8436f30b4cec883869b54b4c907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d9171e08c11d28e13c7d5e704a9a8c5b38f56f90e2a9195e7054cc9c5c70c6d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "569a261febe59ad14728c89b23cc8dc5c24c525e8c1777fc4b16a8c6cc8a7a19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-original.ppm", + "sha256": "568481e4973c48993eef1f19374db65ef81246c8f2f1b0541666b8534c827e1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2cb304f42ba13ca5d827403c075d5577fb0bbe462db7988b2c02bf60801ab1f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f486227c734f2925f00ba67e70491f2bc6f38724a2166133fa23197788bb6cdc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e68f73973e511dcbbd6d48a9feeedd02c59cfc336a0228daffb0af67aec23a75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4ef398a88feec37105119dcdc37bab7fa0587b72c684702221829c12182de892", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b2c5dde1e1278d7534e9d7b4d1bf538d43f2e575426fcfe70e70c9cebdb15c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "236cc9a65e1e10ef753cc7316e25ae00e89b25dd5f80f9f35ec4765bc8fd2246", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "93dcfcd8359586da4dc1653e5f139e055d6cd3ec64c5cc004c18b2cf09db1bd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ee030edc5f9bc4ed6e197dbc81561d99798626f2cbe9750f2e8e2a55292e6896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2d32515adf639db9afc206140be51c7de52e74d1c3f3146687bfe6fe4ca4baaa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "63ad4f656faaf16f8f5eabbe8298d9aeb5e0a642d6f23ee4696176da0e3559d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06d2a2a8ac1058499d10e311463dd6835201f001e14345fcb6913c182246a03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0a6814ad21c8b8bf9a11822713f299eda7eed35ff13b710c6cec53b4e15f83eb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c4f962337cfcacc4ea63bb3b6160b40f1c63145b7cf4d750611e731aeb79894", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "424b024a191e23319c0785e1d1a9980d62fa6e593febfafcb9f7c72649e3d14d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26e2a8951641c52a403495952e503bc1017911e8681a96e595b5ece7cfb2e516", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b0cbd4b654d771773680f4f04f96fb65630d04027e484be2346313a1e1cfa82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8b66f6973fc86b3ef08a70a8bef6a397af7a487523956147167099a77f5c99df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "60373b77be34a563be55f6c85aba51fa41c47e2ccab98b16fb5b27a30d6ef1f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "606804f250f7244c0d6ed1b2646798104a885be8da8e993d5e154dd6dcaef12f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e1c234832095bcb0724c60c030b34a0d9994361dff8ecf5bc9c0cd256a66024e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c8c90b8af19dc87065ff61cb9aea1481b33c4d58d051a91ff6e37fd516a5a3b5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b1875fffa16d39852af9d76ad362a705660166359f4a0d056c90e4fe5c3516c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a69bca1ff1997e749b9994a4b186bc6c381070292d3ec38b0aca0ce21f8ebdcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ef96b177a79477741a94979f135364b814764b6a717809947c08f8b4d2de232", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "38cd254a04df76a5439136d51ae7c4a60bc02c23eadfd671e8bd7c5222ac7410", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2393ddef6f77d0f58cf018dc11bc4372f4783513e92726536a7aec53f6471d56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acded7cffcd4762f83293964eb7cea418769f251ce5f4de0feb8e54e16be156f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "edb024afb9c5b2bc80b0a9b13f8fa52ac69a302ab43d910026d58e66c53bc1a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36ee8a23a83692aa4f2741be3f1125e9b005adb130b893cb804c8d85fdeccc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cf5c9c74844d1ed57b443a3c02d305dbd234e7b6a5acba984b2e732e42825f67", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "10412": { @@ -136495,7 +141617,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10412", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -136511,6 +141633,467 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", "sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eeac825831b65f3085ee3a93cde1178da43f46775d29db1ec47f6c416d09f6e8", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.866714+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"10410/10411/10412\": \"Wide/tall corrugated roof geometry, side posts, surviving broken metal strips, charred openings and original ember placements remain source-relative. Both new wrecks were compared with authentic intact source partners at all recorded same-position contexts; no reconstructed intact roof was approved.\", \"10413/10414/10416\": \"Brown/grey horizontal wall bands and dark lower recesses preserve original source structure. Complete-family same-position transitions preserve continuous neighbor wall placement while removing the damaged tile structure; charred occupied backing is retained. Cracked masonry and rubble are a detail/material interpretation within the original regions, not a new detached building.\", \"10415\": \"Five original small pale rock groupings and their shadows remain separated at the original positions; chipped grain is accepted as added detail.\", \"10417\": \"Separate pale vertical/horizontal blocks, cyan box, lower grey block and two original animated ember cells preserve source placement; blocks have finer cracks/edges.\", \"10418/10419/1041a/1041b/1041c\": \"Original asymmetric rock masses, peaks, pale ledges and dark lower faces remain identifiable across all scales and authentic contexts. Fine chipped facets/grain are accepted; original state partners remain original artwork.\", \"1041d/1041e/1041f\": \"Original dotted border lines and cross-junction gaps remain aligned. The unchanged high-resolution raw 1041f contains irregular chipped pale fragments, not continuous stone panels. Native scales3/4 retain some square/stipple rhythm because the original one-pixel pale cells occupy very small areas. This disclosed over-literal rhythm is accepted as source placement fidelity after viewing raw and every actual scale, including all native neighbors.\"} {\"historical_job_sha256\": \"c703e6899b27905486538d0622bd111e22845b923c03dae26c87f4a003bb6cd4\", \"current_job_sha256\": \"0f6ab3d989aa9a16e71c9b69bc21e646675f2e4a4755b27fde1f75d1ec4e976d\", \"historical_artifact\": \"frozen/generated/historical-native-job-c703e689-reconstructed.json\", \"historical_retention_scope\": \"Author reconstructed full historical bytes from retained16 per-frame original job copies; exact serialized SHA c703e689 verified independently. This is not claimed to be retained original full-file bytes.\", \"reconstruction_provenance_sha256\": \"0fc2d4cd6479a0a29a6f64eab342cdf9c32ceac4d1d44293fddeaec08e8f38b4\", \"only_semantic_changes\": {\"target_statuses\": [{\"asset\": \"10410\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10411\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10412\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10413\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10414\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10415\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10416\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10417\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10418\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10419\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041a\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041b\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041c\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041d\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041e\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041f\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}], \"status_counts\": {\"before\": {\"inprogress\": 16}, \"after\": {\"candidate\": 16}}}, \"all_sources_geometry_roles_partners_neighbors_samples_and_contracts_exact\": true, \"author_explanation\": \"Shared hd_job_queue.py refreshes status metadata across jobs. Current0f6 job was already frozen before this independent rendering; old author proof remains historical. Neither discrepancy affects raw/frame bindings or terrain context data.\"} [\"Opaque mask IoU1 is trivial and was not used as material or geometry approval. All source/raw/full actual1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 images were visually inspected.\", \"Palette quantization/blockiness remains visible at2/3. New HD ground/rock/metal grain remains denser and sharper beside original fallback tiles; square texture-density boundaries can remain visible in mixed scenes. This approval does not assert uniform whole-mission material or complete HD fallback coverage.\", \"Foreign1040f/104ed/104ee/104f5 remain original in all independently rendered full-family and state scenes. Private HD1040f pack was excluded.\", \"State proof renders declared original source partner substitution at the same recorded position. First4pairs9positions are native target/state contexts; remaining6pairs17positions are explicitly synthetic declared source-state substitutions at authentic intact occurrences. No live destruction timing/reachability or live Host/whole-mission validation is claimed.\", \"Native scene and cardinal corpus comes from canonical supplied source contexts; no invented source occurrences. No new gameplay scrolling/boss assembly test is claimed.\", \"Animated palette240\\u2013255 pixels are legitimate source effects:10410=5,10412=4,10414=8,10417=2. Current loader source-relative class totals expand byscale\\u00b2. Static capture does not prove full palette cycling phases.\", \"Review only; no production manifest/source/art/Git writes, registration or promotion.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 37f5c4b26f9086c3724a4b13249981acf54dfaba4d5a0e7b861a928a50a3f187", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "10410", + "10411", + "10412", + "10413" + ], + "sha256": "dfdf91ff2260f9e5cd5afab1d62ce1182bd399635f3307843138a778f4f65beb", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "10414", + "10415", + "10416", + "10417" + ], + "sha256": "989a797ac864e72c88805fcbdd5b8e494db6c307a75f5facea86bd602a2bd104", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "10418", + "10419", + "1041a", + "1041b" + ], + "sha256": "c2856b9eda30d17110fea211e769ce0adf65b15a3254ff4a57a427ac079197d2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "1041c", + "1041d", + "1041e", + "1041f" + ], + "sha256": "e5cfb639df3fcc47a4533af97884a9163409c2e4db6a0fa59a1fb7e3ad926224", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10410-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac8fc607959f5f14c0b942da5f21fb0f26e3336edd6ff8d352ed6f2b503b8e7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c39bff33a03e8367c725d1bb68613df96c60841e37d5ed3bdac0f2acb9ca18a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e045baa994ac7ea4b62c3e3020ae3266b48b3ef03118282a0918dc1dd2e91aeb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5c181c77cc497bcbd185796574207fe4e89623ce13053ca246c16ee904690812", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b9f1b7fcf833e60b7ade5f3e678896f72c5e78fa85ba6792e7fc78424ebd8958", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cc3fd56d3e61a9d919b9a0b7e67caa0aa932f394d5232477f44c37d48c91b5dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "932c116e449199fc8b4c26e522c73c339bc1fda4e3a6382eb26d25a3366e7174", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1dee0695f73c8701c567fc18ecaa11bf56fa74d6833a34fa7f6dfc92b7ca51b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c3c2129b8f2cd34b744e494087f53ba5691c8dd83849b161b0c59292a9f6cdb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5f1190f320faaaab142e030bef2196496759b6856f0c96a5c2fcd38d5767a390", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9f0e642fd58f9c42103b6f71341ef663c208bfab3ed737a6cb109d147b9077a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "049a788257cb017d0dc19cd5e7c2e03f869b73343ff005d736e98afa977fc878", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cdd053889c26c1f7e66934f6680eb07b5772cbe80632082b4627eb5196f09c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a398fafa05cf760e4907d6e63eaed92193724591cf0d8031e54f440238e423e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52ce7e36ddd901308955a916f87b21a51418658e416615ef23fc08a83d09c70e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4ccaf6751ec10bedbabf226ac52d17ce80d51ff4164b19bb82494123e51f6c92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a1d70e398ae3867c7e2717d1e0d5ac80f7af9356a8c02ad7ebdc034a085f03d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f51f5c4b055955c6e8e9e4803e8ca57ffb833e72d7c93b50cffd421cbcff375", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b9dfb1fa7af5b64bc1f013d4f77d90bd2faa6be226b72f5577f46faee0f654f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-original.ppm", + "sha256": "07815b537b8df019f9a8b3bb100f205b20bdac607b06a3a883674728f51a1961", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "474b5cb2530effe4d8ce79d3b57eda23f795718dfc30fe1591b179e2cde17adc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7c3940d23b448558f7689b1b3171c41a0a99f8b92ccfb62e0fc243523df679fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ccfd3f02fb94e39d606e6b5039dc09a535027f5b1193161af1ad8482a1452c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab016bb7ae2ca976bdec92013b52f2ee0c9a0f249b5998fb63dd3e6d7964b07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-original.ppm", + "sha256": "731d2ad7d40da37dcf6d85fa128aec8f652bb3c5e3a3a1cab7bf97f6ccd55c63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "52ee4577a74f409c5f90aad05f39a8f462f139685398bcb5c92ca0208f0150e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a81c58b827f4533f41f6413a366a8f5e707f8b43039fc823ce9863fb0646e57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3221d17f268e21888a795e88ef677f5219f72a7788e57903fd900f55bbbf3556", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "81ca18fc0aae76a37f36e697efbdc6aa7a56acabfd7e20ce64d0cb5c38ffdaad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a04d2b78a0fe288544345cfbf99e031d1342591773c132de94f1a1a02a828c82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1fa8cb4aa3db5303d7e17c62876e69a352be0e71e34022902b3d5715ff56e4b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "557c5202b8790b5199d326695425b14f2f66b7f4beb101d38dd7b3dec54aa94e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a4ea4b96e7a9a77c54a8fee0f71718baecc64361ed931145badc415eb372ab90", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8797c65adee550343f481e5f5790ffc89b2b133f79bcafe3d67cfdf632cc594a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0f589865a0b7837ea238e4012e2dbb70d8f3b8b165127016fced78e0269b59cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "aaa8bfc0d7576c76523b26dc6ffdb70c966c03fc4f24eb0003cb9fb984f79490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "421cd09e4c241a019cb279c1cecf404f83c892a4bd7dbaa652ceaaea037fbd2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "84414bf8ec17dcfb3608cb42cc586f41fdbff735bc0f5b5d97434d0692424c3e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "83585b540986dd9f78869a8930858bd0dc141b69990b7ad6d91e36b2efc47cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0986dfc3e26d68f0e04195cdf9d1e2b7f5da2cd23b880af56b9384ef963f7c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7588543821be396ed14b6bd3e78bb0c3e079cbe2b94613ad9ab155c7605697bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "72acdde37443a6200d4157882b0d13f182ab41b24f58e3067d104b47488b00cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bb31621cec2f76017cf3f224cc20b0ddd78e126c51a1b8a2f6d4e411fc1d3987", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e0fbc5e011994fd47197aec6f8e662b4816afd311c927b2031f2392ad459ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eb6deecd0c170702e64f0d50f246dd37c12d02c3e21f68fd1d2be8d3fee83348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47acf1e50b2c79375a79cf912e60dcbdf36a1a60de9a826816c2f1559d9869a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd88e0e034a3c6989221dcc7e1993969a120d8436f30b4cec883869b54b4c907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d9171e08c11d28e13c7d5e704a9a8c5b38f56f90e2a9195e7054cc9c5c70c6d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "569a261febe59ad14728c89b23cc8dc5c24c525e8c1777fc4b16a8c6cc8a7a19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-original.ppm", + "sha256": "568481e4973c48993eef1f19374db65ef81246c8f2f1b0541666b8534c827e1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2cb304f42ba13ca5d827403c075d5577fb0bbe462db7988b2c02bf60801ab1f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f486227c734f2925f00ba67e70491f2bc6f38724a2166133fa23197788bb6cdc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e68f73973e511dcbbd6d48a9feeedd02c59cfc336a0228daffb0af67aec23a75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4ef398a88feec37105119dcdc37bab7fa0587b72c684702221829c12182de892", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b2c5dde1e1278d7534e9d7b4d1bf538d43f2e575426fcfe70e70c9cebdb15c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "236cc9a65e1e10ef753cc7316e25ae00e89b25dd5f80f9f35ec4765bc8fd2246", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "93dcfcd8359586da4dc1653e5f139e055d6cd3ec64c5cc004c18b2cf09db1bd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ee030edc5f9bc4ed6e197dbc81561d99798626f2cbe9750f2e8e2a55292e6896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2d32515adf639db9afc206140be51c7de52e74d1c3f3146687bfe6fe4ca4baaa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "63ad4f656faaf16f8f5eabbe8298d9aeb5e0a642d6f23ee4696176da0e3559d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06d2a2a8ac1058499d10e311463dd6835201f001e14345fcb6913c182246a03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0a6814ad21c8b8bf9a11822713f299eda7eed35ff13b710c6cec53b4e15f83eb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c4f962337cfcacc4ea63bb3b6160b40f1c63145b7cf4d750611e731aeb79894", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "424b024a191e23319c0785e1d1a9980d62fa6e593febfafcb9f7c72649e3d14d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26e2a8951641c52a403495952e503bc1017911e8681a96e595b5ece7cfb2e516", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b0cbd4b654d771773680f4f04f96fb65630d04027e484be2346313a1e1cfa82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8b66f6973fc86b3ef08a70a8bef6a397af7a487523956147167099a77f5c99df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "60373b77be34a563be55f6c85aba51fa41c47e2ccab98b16fb5b27a30d6ef1f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "606804f250f7244c0d6ed1b2646798104a885be8da8e993d5e154dd6dcaef12f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e1c234832095bcb0724c60c030b34a0d9994361dff8ecf5bc9c0cd256a66024e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c8c90b8af19dc87065ff61cb9aea1481b33c4d58d051a91ff6e37fd516a5a3b5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b1875fffa16d39852af9d76ad362a705660166359f4a0d056c90e4fe5c3516c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a69bca1ff1997e749b9994a4b186bc6c381070292d3ec38b0aca0ce21f8ebdcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ef96b177a79477741a94979f135364b814764b6a717809947c08f8b4d2de232", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "38cd254a04df76a5439136d51ae7c4a60bc02c23eadfd671e8bd7c5222ac7410", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2393ddef6f77d0f58cf018dc11bc4372f4783513e92726536a7aec53f6471d56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acded7cffcd4762f83293964eb7cea418769f251ce5f4de0feb8e54e16be156f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "edb024afb9c5b2bc80b0a9b13f8fa52ac69a302ab43d910026d58e66c53bc1a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36ee8a23a83692aa4f2741be3f1125e9b005adb130b893cb804c8d85fdeccc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cf5c9c74844d1ed57b443a3c02d305dbd234e7b6a5acba984b2e732e42825f67", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "10413": { @@ -136532,7 +142115,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10413", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -136548,6 +142131,467 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", "sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eeac825831b65f3085ee3a93cde1178da43f46775d29db1ec47f6c416d09f6e8", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.866714+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"10410/10411/10412\": \"Wide/tall corrugated roof geometry, side posts, surviving broken metal strips, charred openings and original ember placements remain source-relative. Both new wrecks were compared with authentic intact source partners at all recorded same-position contexts; no reconstructed intact roof was approved.\", \"10413/10414/10416\": \"Brown/grey horizontal wall bands and dark lower recesses preserve original source structure. Complete-family same-position transitions preserve continuous neighbor wall placement while removing the damaged tile structure; charred occupied backing is retained. Cracked masonry and rubble are a detail/material interpretation within the original regions, not a new detached building.\", \"10415\": \"Five original small pale rock groupings and their shadows remain separated at the original positions; chipped grain is accepted as added detail.\", \"10417\": \"Separate pale vertical/horizontal blocks, cyan box, lower grey block and two original animated ember cells preserve source placement; blocks have finer cracks/edges.\", \"10418/10419/1041a/1041b/1041c\": \"Original asymmetric rock masses, peaks, pale ledges and dark lower faces remain identifiable across all scales and authentic contexts. Fine chipped facets/grain are accepted; original state partners remain original artwork.\", \"1041d/1041e/1041f\": \"Original dotted border lines and cross-junction gaps remain aligned. The unchanged high-resolution raw 1041f contains irregular chipped pale fragments, not continuous stone panels. Native scales3/4 retain some square/stipple rhythm because the original one-pixel pale cells occupy very small areas. This disclosed over-literal rhythm is accepted as source placement fidelity after viewing raw and every actual scale, including all native neighbors.\"} {\"historical_job_sha256\": \"c703e6899b27905486538d0622bd111e22845b923c03dae26c87f4a003bb6cd4\", \"current_job_sha256\": \"0f6ab3d989aa9a16e71c9b69bc21e646675f2e4a4755b27fde1f75d1ec4e976d\", \"historical_artifact\": \"frozen/generated/historical-native-job-c703e689-reconstructed.json\", \"historical_retention_scope\": \"Author reconstructed full historical bytes from retained16 per-frame original job copies; exact serialized SHA c703e689 verified independently. This is not claimed to be retained original full-file bytes.\", \"reconstruction_provenance_sha256\": \"0fc2d4cd6479a0a29a6f64eab342cdf9c32ceac4d1d44293fddeaec08e8f38b4\", \"only_semantic_changes\": {\"target_statuses\": [{\"asset\": \"10410\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10411\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10412\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10413\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10414\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10415\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10416\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10417\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10418\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10419\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041a\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041b\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041c\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041d\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041e\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041f\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}], \"status_counts\": {\"before\": {\"inprogress\": 16}, \"after\": {\"candidate\": 16}}}, \"all_sources_geometry_roles_partners_neighbors_samples_and_contracts_exact\": true, \"author_explanation\": \"Shared hd_job_queue.py refreshes status metadata across jobs. Current0f6 job was already frozen before this independent rendering; old author proof remains historical. Neither discrepancy affects raw/frame bindings or terrain context data.\"} [\"Opaque mask IoU1 is trivial and was not used as material or geometry approval. All source/raw/full actual1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 images were visually inspected.\", \"Palette quantization/blockiness remains visible at2/3. New HD ground/rock/metal grain remains denser and sharper beside original fallback tiles; square texture-density boundaries can remain visible in mixed scenes. This approval does not assert uniform whole-mission material or complete HD fallback coverage.\", \"Foreign1040f/104ed/104ee/104f5 remain original in all independently rendered full-family and state scenes. Private HD1040f pack was excluded.\", \"State proof renders declared original source partner substitution at the same recorded position. First4pairs9positions are native target/state contexts; remaining6pairs17positions are explicitly synthetic declared source-state substitutions at authentic intact occurrences. No live destruction timing/reachability or live Host/whole-mission validation is claimed.\", \"Native scene and cardinal corpus comes from canonical supplied source contexts; no invented source occurrences. No new gameplay scrolling/boss assembly test is claimed.\", \"Animated palette240\\u2013255 pixels are legitimate source effects:10410=5,10412=4,10414=8,10417=2. Current loader source-relative class totals expand byscale\\u00b2. Static capture does not prove full palette cycling phases.\", \"Review only; no production manifest/source/art/Git writes, registration or promotion.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 37f5c4b26f9086c3724a4b13249981acf54dfaba4d5a0e7b861a928a50a3f187", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "10410", + "10411", + "10412", + "10413" + ], + "sha256": "dfdf91ff2260f9e5cd5afab1d62ce1182bd399635f3307843138a778f4f65beb", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "10414", + "10415", + "10416", + "10417" + ], + "sha256": "989a797ac864e72c88805fcbdd5b8e494db6c307a75f5facea86bd602a2bd104", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "10418", + "10419", + "1041a", + "1041b" + ], + "sha256": "c2856b9eda30d17110fea211e769ce0adf65b15a3254ff4a57a427ac079197d2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "1041c", + "1041d", + "1041e", + "1041f" + ], + "sha256": "e5cfb639df3fcc47a4533af97884a9163409c2e4db6a0fa59a1fb7e3ad926224", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10410-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac8fc607959f5f14c0b942da5f21fb0f26e3336edd6ff8d352ed6f2b503b8e7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c39bff33a03e8367c725d1bb68613df96c60841e37d5ed3bdac0f2acb9ca18a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e045baa994ac7ea4b62c3e3020ae3266b48b3ef03118282a0918dc1dd2e91aeb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5c181c77cc497bcbd185796574207fe4e89623ce13053ca246c16ee904690812", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b9f1b7fcf833e60b7ade5f3e678896f72c5e78fa85ba6792e7fc78424ebd8958", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cc3fd56d3e61a9d919b9a0b7e67caa0aa932f394d5232477f44c37d48c91b5dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "932c116e449199fc8b4c26e522c73c339bc1fda4e3a6382eb26d25a3366e7174", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1dee0695f73c8701c567fc18ecaa11bf56fa74d6833a34fa7f6dfc92b7ca51b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c3c2129b8f2cd34b744e494087f53ba5691c8dd83849b161b0c59292a9f6cdb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5f1190f320faaaab142e030bef2196496759b6856f0c96a5c2fcd38d5767a390", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9f0e642fd58f9c42103b6f71341ef663c208bfab3ed737a6cb109d147b9077a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "049a788257cb017d0dc19cd5e7c2e03f869b73343ff005d736e98afa977fc878", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cdd053889c26c1f7e66934f6680eb07b5772cbe80632082b4627eb5196f09c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a398fafa05cf760e4907d6e63eaed92193724591cf0d8031e54f440238e423e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52ce7e36ddd901308955a916f87b21a51418658e416615ef23fc08a83d09c70e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4ccaf6751ec10bedbabf226ac52d17ce80d51ff4164b19bb82494123e51f6c92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a1d70e398ae3867c7e2717d1e0d5ac80f7af9356a8c02ad7ebdc034a085f03d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f51f5c4b055955c6e8e9e4803e8ca57ffb833e72d7c93b50cffd421cbcff375", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b9dfb1fa7af5b64bc1f013d4f77d90bd2faa6be226b72f5577f46faee0f654f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-original.ppm", + "sha256": "07815b537b8df019f9a8b3bb100f205b20bdac607b06a3a883674728f51a1961", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "474b5cb2530effe4d8ce79d3b57eda23f795718dfc30fe1591b179e2cde17adc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7c3940d23b448558f7689b1b3171c41a0a99f8b92ccfb62e0fc243523df679fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ccfd3f02fb94e39d606e6b5039dc09a535027f5b1193161af1ad8482a1452c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab016bb7ae2ca976bdec92013b52f2ee0c9a0f249b5998fb63dd3e6d7964b07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-original.ppm", + "sha256": "731d2ad7d40da37dcf6d85fa128aec8f652bb3c5e3a3a1cab7bf97f6ccd55c63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "52ee4577a74f409c5f90aad05f39a8f462f139685398bcb5c92ca0208f0150e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a81c58b827f4533f41f6413a366a8f5e707f8b43039fc823ce9863fb0646e57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3221d17f268e21888a795e88ef677f5219f72a7788e57903fd900f55bbbf3556", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "81ca18fc0aae76a37f36e697efbdc6aa7a56acabfd7e20ce64d0cb5c38ffdaad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a04d2b78a0fe288544345cfbf99e031d1342591773c132de94f1a1a02a828c82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1fa8cb4aa3db5303d7e17c62876e69a352be0e71e34022902b3d5715ff56e4b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "557c5202b8790b5199d326695425b14f2f66b7f4beb101d38dd7b3dec54aa94e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a4ea4b96e7a9a77c54a8fee0f71718baecc64361ed931145badc415eb372ab90", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8797c65adee550343f481e5f5790ffc89b2b133f79bcafe3d67cfdf632cc594a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0f589865a0b7837ea238e4012e2dbb70d8f3b8b165127016fced78e0269b59cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "aaa8bfc0d7576c76523b26dc6ffdb70c966c03fc4f24eb0003cb9fb984f79490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "421cd09e4c241a019cb279c1cecf404f83c892a4bd7dbaa652ceaaea037fbd2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "84414bf8ec17dcfb3608cb42cc586f41fdbff735bc0f5b5d97434d0692424c3e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "83585b540986dd9f78869a8930858bd0dc141b69990b7ad6d91e36b2efc47cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0986dfc3e26d68f0e04195cdf9d1e2b7f5da2cd23b880af56b9384ef963f7c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7588543821be396ed14b6bd3e78bb0c3e079cbe2b94613ad9ab155c7605697bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "72acdde37443a6200d4157882b0d13f182ab41b24f58e3067d104b47488b00cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bb31621cec2f76017cf3f224cc20b0ddd78e126c51a1b8a2f6d4e411fc1d3987", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e0fbc5e011994fd47197aec6f8e662b4816afd311c927b2031f2392ad459ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eb6deecd0c170702e64f0d50f246dd37c12d02c3e21f68fd1d2be8d3fee83348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47acf1e50b2c79375a79cf912e60dcbdf36a1a60de9a826816c2f1559d9869a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd88e0e034a3c6989221dcc7e1993969a120d8436f30b4cec883869b54b4c907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d9171e08c11d28e13c7d5e704a9a8c5b38f56f90e2a9195e7054cc9c5c70c6d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "569a261febe59ad14728c89b23cc8dc5c24c525e8c1777fc4b16a8c6cc8a7a19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-original.ppm", + "sha256": "568481e4973c48993eef1f19374db65ef81246c8f2f1b0541666b8534c827e1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2cb304f42ba13ca5d827403c075d5577fb0bbe462db7988b2c02bf60801ab1f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f486227c734f2925f00ba67e70491f2bc6f38724a2166133fa23197788bb6cdc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e68f73973e511dcbbd6d48a9feeedd02c59cfc336a0228daffb0af67aec23a75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4ef398a88feec37105119dcdc37bab7fa0587b72c684702221829c12182de892", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b2c5dde1e1278d7534e9d7b4d1bf538d43f2e575426fcfe70e70c9cebdb15c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "236cc9a65e1e10ef753cc7316e25ae00e89b25dd5f80f9f35ec4765bc8fd2246", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "93dcfcd8359586da4dc1653e5f139e055d6cd3ec64c5cc004c18b2cf09db1bd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ee030edc5f9bc4ed6e197dbc81561d99798626f2cbe9750f2e8e2a55292e6896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2d32515adf639db9afc206140be51c7de52e74d1c3f3146687bfe6fe4ca4baaa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "63ad4f656faaf16f8f5eabbe8298d9aeb5e0a642d6f23ee4696176da0e3559d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06d2a2a8ac1058499d10e311463dd6835201f001e14345fcb6913c182246a03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0a6814ad21c8b8bf9a11822713f299eda7eed35ff13b710c6cec53b4e15f83eb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c4f962337cfcacc4ea63bb3b6160b40f1c63145b7cf4d750611e731aeb79894", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "424b024a191e23319c0785e1d1a9980d62fa6e593febfafcb9f7c72649e3d14d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26e2a8951641c52a403495952e503bc1017911e8681a96e595b5ece7cfb2e516", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b0cbd4b654d771773680f4f04f96fb65630d04027e484be2346313a1e1cfa82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8b66f6973fc86b3ef08a70a8bef6a397af7a487523956147167099a77f5c99df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "60373b77be34a563be55f6c85aba51fa41c47e2ccab98b16fb5b27a30d6ef1f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "606804f250f7244c0d6ed1b2646798104a885be8da8e993d5e154dd6dcaef12f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e1c234832095bcb0724c60c030b34a0d9994361dff8ecf5bc9c0cd256a66024e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c8c90b8af19dc87065ff61cb9aea1481b33c4d58d051a91ff6e37fd516a5a3b5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b1875fffa16d39852af9d76ad362a705660166359f4a0d056c90e4fe5c3516c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a69bca1ff1997e749b9994a4b186bc6c381070292d3ec38b0aca0ce21f8ebdcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ef96b177a79477741a94979f135364b814764b6a717809947c08f8b4d2de232", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "38cd254a04df76a5439136d51ae7c4a60bc02c23eadfd671e8bd7c5222ac7410", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2393ddef6f77d0f58cf018dc11bc4372f4783513e92726536a7aec53f6471d56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acded7cffcd4762f83293964eb7cea418769f251ce5f4de0feb8e54e16be156f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "edb024afb9c5b2bc80b0a9b13f8fa52ac69a302ab43d910026d58e66c53bc1a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36ee8a23a83692aa4f2741be3f1125e9b005adb130b893cb804c8d85fdeccc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cf5c9c74844d1ed57b443a3c02d305dbd234e7b6a5acba984b2e732e42825f67", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "10414": { @@ -136569,7 +142613,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10414", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -136585,6 +142629,467 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", "sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eeac825831b65f3085ee3a93cde1178da43f46775d29db1ec47f6c416d09f6e8", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.866714+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"10410/10411/10412\": \"Wide/tall corrugated roof geometry, side posts, surviving broken metal strips, charred openings and original ember placements remain source-relative. Both new wrecks were compared with authentic intact source partners at all recorded same-position contexts; no reconstructed intact roof was approved.\", \"10413/10414/10416\": \"Brown/grey horizontal wall bands and dark lower recesses preserve original source structure. Complete-family same-position transitions preserve continuous neighbor wall placement while removing the damaged tile structure; charred occupied backing is retained. Cracked masonry and rubble are a detail/material interpretation within the original regions, not a new detached building.\", \"10415\": \"Five original small pale rock groupings and their shadows remain separated at the original positions; chipped grain is accepted as added detail.\", \"10417\": \"Separate pale vertical/horizontal blocks, cyan box, lower grey block and two original animated ember cells preserve source placement; blocks have finer cracks/edges.\", \"10418/10419/1041a/1041b/1041c\": \"Original asymmetric rock masses, peaks, pale ledges and dark lower faces remain identifiable across all scales and authentic contexts. Fine chipped facets/grain are accepted; original state partners remain original artwork.\", \"1041d/1041e/1041f\": \"Original dotted border lines and cross-junction gaps remain aligned. The unchanged high-resolution raw 1041f contains irregular chipped pale fragments, not continuous stone panels. Native scales3/4 retain some square/stipple rhythm because the original one-pixel pale cells occupy very small areas. This disclosed over-literal rhythm is accepted as source placement fidelity after viewing raw and every actual scale, including all native neighbors.\"} {\"historical_job_sha256\": \"c703e6899b27905486538d0622bd111e22845b923c03dae26c87f4a003bb6cd4\", \"current_job_sha256\": \"0f6ab3d989aa9a16e71c9b69bc21e646675f2e4a4755b27fde1f75d1ec4e976d\", \"historical_artifact\": \"frozen/generated/historical-native-job-c703e689-reconstructed.json\", \"historical_retention_scope\": \"Author reconstructed full historical bytes from retained16 per-frame original job copies; exact serialized SHA c703e689 verified independently. This is not claimed to be retained original full-file bytes.\", \"reconstruction_provenance_sha256\": \"0fc2d4cd6479a0a29a6f64eab342cdf9c32ceac4d1d44293fddeaec08e8f38b4\", \"only_semantic_changes\": {\"target_statuses\": [{\"asset\": \"10410\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10411\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10412\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10413\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10414\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10415\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10416\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10417\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10418\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10419\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041a\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041b\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041c\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041d\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041e\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041f\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}], \"status_counts\": {\"before\": {\"inprogress\": 16}, \"after\": {\"candidate\": 16}}}, \"all_sources_geometry_roles_partners_neighbors_samples_and_contracts_exact\": true, \"author_explanation\": \"Shared hd_job_queue.py refreshes status metadata across jobs. Current0f6 job was already frozen before this independent rendering; old author proof remains historical. Neither discrepancy affects raw/frame bindings or terrain context data.\"} [\"Opaque mask IoU1 is trivial and was not used as material or geometry approval. All source/raw/full actual1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 images were visually inspected.\", \"Palette quantization/blockiness remains visible at2/3. New HD ground/rock/metal grain remains denser and sharper beside original fallback tiles; square texture-density boundaries can remain visible in mixed scenes. This approval does not assert uniform whole-mission material or complete HD fallback coverage.\", \"Foreign1040f/104ed/104ee/104f5 remain original in all independently rendered full-family and state scenes. Private HD1040f pack was excluded.\", \"State proof renders declared original source partner substitution at the same recorded position. First4pairs9positions are native target/state contexts; remaining6pairs17positions are explicitly synthetic declared source-state substitutions at authentic intact occurrences. No live destruction timing/reachability or live Host/whole-mission validation is claimed.\", \"Native scene and cardinal corpus comes from canonical supplied source contexts; no invented source occurrences. No new gameplay scrolling/boss assembly test is claimed.\", \"Animated palette240\\u2013255 pixels are legitimate source effects:10410=5,10412=4,10414=8,10417=2. Current loader source-relative class totals expand byscale\\u00b2. Static capture does not prove full palette cycling phases.\", \"Review only; no production manifest/source/art/Git writes, registration or promotion.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 37f5c4b26f9086c3724a4b13249981acf54dfaba4d5a0e7b861a928a50a3f187", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "10410", + "10411", + "10412", + "10413" + ], + "sha256": "dfdf91ff2260f9e5cd5afab1d62ce1182bd399635f3307843138a778f4f65beb", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "10414", + "10415", + "10416", + "10417" + ], + "sha256": "989a797ac864e72c88805fcbdd5b8e494db6c307a75f5facea86bd602a2bd104", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "10418", + "10419", + "1041a", + "1041b" + ], + "sha256": "c2856b9eda30d17110fea211e769ce0adf65b15a3254ff4a57a427ac079197d2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "1041c", + "1041d", + "1041e", + "1041f" + ], + "sha256": "e5cfb639df3fcc47a4533af97884a9163409c2e4db6a0fa59a1fb7e3ad926224", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10410-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac8fc607959f5f14c0b942da5f21fb0f26e3336edd6ff8d352ed6f2b503b8e7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c39bff33a03e8367c725d1bb68613df96c60841e37d5ed3bdac0f2acb9ca18a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e045baa994ac7ea4b62c3e3020ae3266b48b3ef03118282a0918dc1dd2e91aeb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5c181c77cc497bcbd185796574207fe4e89623ce13053ca246c16ee904690812", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b9f1b7fcf833e60b7ade5f3e678896f72c5e78fa85ba6792e7fc78424ebd8958", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cc3fd56d3e61a9d919b9a0b7e67caa0aa932f394d5232477f44c37d48c91b5dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "932c116e449199fc8b4c26e522c73c339bc1fda4e3a6382eb26d25a3366e7174", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1dee0695f73c8701c567fc18ecaa11bf56fa74d6833a34fa7f6dfc92b7ca51b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c3c2129b8f2cd34b744e494087f53ba5691c8dd83849b161b0c59292a9f6cdb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5f1190f320faaaab142e030bef2196496759b6856f0c96a5c2fcd38d5767a390", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9f0e642fd58f9c42103b6f71341ef663c208bfab3ed737a6cb109d147b9077a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "049a788257cb017d0dc19cd5e7c2e03f869b73343ff005d736e98afa977fc878", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cdd053889c26c1f7e66934f6680eb07b5772cbe80632082b4627eb5196f09c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a398fafa05cf760e4907d6e63eaed92193724591cf0d8031e54f440238e423e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52ce7e36ddd901308955a916f87b21a51418658e416615ef23fc08a83d09c70e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4ccaf6751ec10bedbabf226ac52d17ce80d51ff4164b19bb82494123e51f6c92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a1d70e398ae3867c7e2717d1e0d5ac80f7af9356a8c02ad7ebdc034a085f03d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f51f5c4b055955c6e8e9e4803e8ca57ffb833e72d7c93b50cffd421cbcff375", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b9dfb1fa7af5b64bc1f013d4f77d90bd2faa6be226b72f5577f46faee0f654f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-original.ppm", + "sha256": "07815b537b8df019f9a8b3bb100f205b20bdac607b06a3a883674728f51a1961", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "474b5cb2530effe4d8ce79d3b57eda23f795718dfc30fe1591b179e2cde17adc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7c3940d23b448558f7689b1b3171c41a0a99f8b92ccfb62e0fc243523df679fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ccfd3f02fb94e39d606e6b5039dc09a535027f5b1193161af1ad8482a1452c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab016bb7ae2ca976bdec92013b52f2ee0c9a0f249b5998fb63dd3e6d7964b07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-original.ppm", + "sha256": "731d2ad7d40da37dcf6d85fa128aec8f652bb3c5e3a3a1cab7bf97f6ccd55c63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "52ee4577a74f409c5f90aad05f39a8f462f139685398bcb5c92ca0208f0150e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a81c58b827f4533f41f6413a366a8f5e707f8b43039fc823ce9863fb0646e57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3221d17f268e21888a795e88ef677f5219f72a7788e57903fd900f55bbbf3556", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "81ca18fc0aae76a37f36e697efbdc6aa7a56acabfd7e20ce64d0cb5c38ffdaad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a04d2b78a0fe288544345cfbf99e031d1342591773c132de94f1a1a02a828c82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1fa8cb4aa3db5303d7e17c62876e69a352be0e71e34022902b3d5715ff56e4b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "557c5202b8790b5199d326695425b14f2f66b7f4beb101d38dd7b3dec54aa94e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a4ea4b96e7a9a77c54a8fee0f71718baecc64361ed931145badc415eb372ab90", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8797c65adee550343f481e5f5790ffc89b2b133f79bcafe3d67cfdf632cc594a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0f589865a0b7837ea238e4012e2dbb70d8f3b8b165127016fced78e0269b59cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "aaa8bfc0d7576c76523b26dc6ffdb70c966c03fc4f24eb0003cb9fb984f79490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "421cd09e4c241a019cb279c1cecf404f83c892a4bd7dbaa652ceaaea037fbd2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "84414bf8ec17dcfb3608cb42cc586f41fdbff735bc0f5b5d97434d0692424c3e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "83585b540986dd9f78869a8930858bd0dc141b69990b7ad6d91e36b2efc47cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0986dfc3e26d68f0e04195cdf9d1e2b7f5da2cd23b880af56b9384ef963f7c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7588543821be396ed14b6bd3e78bb0c3e079cbe2b94613ad9ab155c7605697bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "72acdde37443a6200d4157882b0d13f182ab41b24f58e3067d104b47488b00cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bb31621cec2f76017cf3f224cc20b0ddd78e126c51a1b8a2f6d4e411fc1d3987", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e0fbc5e011994fd47197aec6f8e662b4816afd311c927b2031f2392ad459ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eb6deecd0c170702e64f0d50f246dd37c12d02c3e21f68fd1d2be8d3fee83348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47acf1e50b2c79375a79cf912e60dcbdf36a1a60de9a826816c2f1559d9869a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd88e0e034a3c6989221dcc7e1993969a120d8436f30b4cec883869b54b4c907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d9171e08c11d28e13c7d5e704a9a8c5b38f56f90e2a9195e7054cc9c5c70c6d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "569a261febe59ad14728c89b23cc8dc5c24c525e8c1777fc4b16a8c6cc8a7a19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-original.ppm", + "sha256": "568481e4973c48993eef1f19374db65ef81246c8f2f1b0541666b8534c827e1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2cb304f42ba13ca5d827403c075d5577fb0bbe462db7988b2c02bf60801ab1f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f486227c734f2925f00ba67e70491f2bc6f38724a2166133fa23197788bb6cdc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e68f73973e511dcbbd6d48a9feeedd02c59cfc336a0228daffb0af67aec23a75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4ef398a88feec37105119dcdc37bab7fa0587b72c684702221829c12182de892", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b2c5dde1e1278d7534e9d7b4d1bf538d43f2e575426fcfe70e70c9cebdb15c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "236cc9a65e1e10ef753cc7316e25ae00e89b25dd5f80f9f35ec4765bc8fd2246", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "93dcfcd8359586da4dc1653e5f139e055d6cd3ec64c5cc004c18b2cf09db1bd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ee030edc5f9bc4ed6e197dbc81561d99798626f2cbe9750f2e8e2a55292e6896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2d32515adf639db9afc206140be51c7de52e74d1c3f3146687bfe6fe4ca4baaa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "63ad4f656faaf16f8f5eabbe8298d9aeb5e0a642d6f23ee4696176da0e3559d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06d2a2a8ac1058499d10e311463dd6835201f001e14345fcb6913c182246a03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0a6814ad21c8b8bf9a11822713f299eda7eed35ff13b710c6cec53b4e15f83eb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c4f962337cfcacc4ea63bb3b6160b40f1c63145b7cf4d750611e731aeb79894", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "424b024a191e23319c0785e1d1a9980d62fa6e593febfafcb9f7c72649e3d14d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26e2a8951641c52a403495952e503bc1017911e8681a96e595b5ece7cfb2e516", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b0cbd4b654d771773680f4f04f96fb65630d04027e484be2346313a1e1cfa82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8b66f6973fc86b3ef08a70a8bef6a397af7a487523956147167099a77f5c99df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "60373b77be34a563be55f6c85aba51fa41c47e2ccab98b16fb5b27a30d6ef1f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "606804f250f7244c0d6ed1b2646798104a885be8da8e993d5e154dd6dcaef12f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e1c234832095bcb0724c60c030b34a0d9994361dff8ecf5bc9c0cd256a66024e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c8c90b8af19dc87065ff61cb9aea1481b33c4d58d051a91ff6e37fd516a5a3b5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b1875fffa16d39852af9d76ad362a705660166359f4a0d056c90e4fe5c3516c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a69bca1ff1997e749b9994a4b186bc6c381070292d3ec38b0aca0ce21f8ebdcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ef96b177a79477741a94979f135364b814764b6a717809947c08f8b4d2de232", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "38cd254a04df76a5439136d51ae7c4a60bc02c23eadfd671e8bd7c5222ac7410", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2393ddef6f77d0f58cf018dc11bc4372f4783513e92726536a7aec53f6471d56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acded7cffcd4762f83293964eb7cea418769f251ce5f4de0feb8e54e16be156f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "edb024afb9c5b2bc80b0a9b13f8fa52ac69a302ab43d910026d58e66c53bc1a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36ee8a23a83692aa4f2741be3f1125e9b005adb130b893cb804c8d85fdeccc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cf5c9c74844d1ed57b443a3c02d305dbd234e7b6a5acba984b2e732e42825f67", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "10415": { @@ -136606,7 +143111,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10415", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -136622,6 +143127,467 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", "sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eeac825831b65f3085ee3a93cde1178da43f46775d29db1ec47f6c416d09f6e8", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.866714+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"10410/10411/10412\": \"Wide/tall corrugated roof geometry, side posts, surviving broken metal strips, charred openings and original ember placements remain source-relative. Both new wrecks were compared with authentic intact source partners at all recorded same-position contexts; no reconstructed intact roof was approved.\", \"10413/10414/10416\": \"Brown/grey horizontal wall bands and dark lower recesses preserve original source structure. Complete-family same-position transitions preserve continuous neighbor wall placement while removing the damaged tile structure; charred occupied backing is retained. Cracked masonry and rubble are a detail/material interpretation within the original regions, not a new detached building.\", \"10415\": \"Five original small pale rock groupings and their shadows remain separated at the original positions; chipped grain is accepted as added detail.\", \"10417\": \"Separate pale vertical/horizontal blocks, cyan box, lower grey block and two original animated ember cells preserve source placement; blocks have finer cracks/edges.\", \"10418/10419/1041a/1041b/1041c\": \"Original asymmetric rock masses, peaks, pale ledges and dark lower faces remain identifiable across all scales and authentic contexts. Fine chipped facets/grain are accepted; original state partners remain original artwork.\", \"1041d/1041e/1041f\": \"Original dotted border lines and cross-junction gaps remain aligned. The unchanged high-resolution raw 1041f contains irregular chipped pale fragments, not continuous stone panels. Native scales3/4 retain some square/stipple rhythm because the original one-pixel pale cells occupy very small areas. This disclosed over-literal rhythm is accepted as source placement fidelity after viewing raw and every actual scale, including all native neighbors.\"} {\"historical_job_sha256\": \"c703e6899b27905486538d0622bd111e22845b923c03dae26c87f4a003bb6cd4\", \"current_job_sha256\": \"0f6ab3d989aa9a16e71c9b69bc21e646675f2e4a4755b27fde1f75d1ec4e976d\", \"historical_artifact\": \"frozen/generated/historical-native-job-c703e689-reconstructed.json\", \"historical_retention_scope\": \"Author reconstructed full historical bytes from retained16 per-frame original job copies; exact serialized SHA c703e689 verified independently. This is not claimed to be retained original full-file bytes.\", \"reconstruction_provenance_sha256\": \"0fc2d4cd6479a0a29a6f64eab342cdf9c32ceac4d1d44293fddeaec08e8f38b4\", \"only_semantic_changes\": {\"target_statuses\": [{\"asset\": \"10410\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10411\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10412\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10413\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10414\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10415\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10416\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10417\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10418\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10419\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041a\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041b\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041c\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041d\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041e\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041f\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}], \"status_counts\": {\"before\": {\"inprogress\": 16}, \"after\": {\"candidate\": 16}}}, \"all_sources_geometry_roles_partners_neighbors_samples_and_contracts_exact\": true, \"author_explanation\": \"Shared hd_job_queue.py refreshes status metadata across jobs. Current0f6 job was already frozen before this independent rendering; old author proof remains historical. Neither discrepancy affects raw/frame bindings or terrain context data.\"} [\"Opaque mask IoU1 is trivial and was not used as material or geometry approval. All source/raw/full actual1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 images were visually inspected.\", \"Palette quantization/blockiness remains visible at2/3. New HD ground/rock/metal grain remains denser and sharper beside original fallback tiles; square texture-density boundaries can remain visible in mixed scenes. This approval does not assert uniform whole-mission material or complete HD fallback coverage.\", \"Foreign1040f/104ed/104ee/104f5 remain original in all independently rendered full-family and state scenes. Private HD1040f pack was excluded.\", \"State proof renders declared original source partner substitution at the same recorded position. First4pairs9positions are native target/state contexts; remaining6pairs17positions are explicitly synthetic declared source-state substitutions at authentic intact occurrences. No live destruction timing/reachability or live Host/whole-mission validation is claimed.\", \"Native scene and cardinal corpus comes from canonical supplied source contexts; no invented source occurrences. No new gameplay scrolling/boss assembly test is claimed.\", \"Animated palette240\\u2013255 pixels are legitimate source effects:10410=5,10412=4,10414=8,10417=2. Current loader source-relative class totals expand byscale\\u00b2. Static capture does not prove full palette cycling phases.\", \"Review only; no production manifest/source/art/Git writes, registration or promotion.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 37f5c4b26f9086c3724a4b13249981acf54dfaba4d5a0e7b861a928a50a3f187", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "10410", + "10411", + "10412", + "10413" + ], + "sha256": "dfdf91ff2260f9e5cd5afab1d62ce1182bd399635f3307843138a778f4f65beb", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "10414", + "10415", + "10416", + "10417" + ], + "sha256": "989a797ac864e72c88805fcbdd5b8e494db6c307a75f5facea86bd602a2bd104", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "10418", + "10419", + "1041a", + "1041b" + ], + "sha256": "c2856b9eda30d17110fea211e769ce0adf65b15a3254ff4a57a427ac079197d2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "1041c", + "1041d", + "1041e", + "1041f" + ], + "sha256": "e5cfb639df3fcc47a4533af97884a9163409c2e4db6a0fa59a1fb7e3ad926224", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10410-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac8fc607959f5f14c0b942da5f21fb0f26e3336edd6ff8d352ed6f2b503b8e7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c39bff33a03e8367c725d1bb68613df96c60841e37d5ed3bdac0f2acb9ca18a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e045baa994ac7ea4b62c3e3020ae3266b48b3ef03118282a0918dc1dd2e91aeb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5c181c77cc497bcbd185796574207fe4e89623ce13053ca246c16ee904690812", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b9f1b7fcf833e60b7ade5f3e678896f72c5e78fa85ba6792e7fc78424ebd8958", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cc3fd56d3e61a9d919b9a0b7e67caa0aa932f394d5232477f44c37d48c91b5dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "932c116e449199fc8b4c26e522c73c339bc1fda4e3a6382eb26d25a3366e7174", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1dee0695f73c8701c567fc18ecaa11bf56fa74d6833a34fa7f6dfc92b7ca51b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c3c2129b8f2cd34b744e494087f53ba5691c8dd83849b161b0c59292a9f6cdb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5f1190f320faaaab142e030bef2196496759b6856f0c96a5c2fcd38d5767a390", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9f0e642fd58f9c42103b6f71341ef663c208bfab3ed737a6cb109d147b9077a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "049a788257cb017d0dc19cd5e7c2e03f869b73343ff005d736e98afa977fc878", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cdd053889c26c1f7e66934f6680eb07b5772cbe80632082b4627eb5196f09c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a398fafa05cf760e4907d6e63eaed92193724591cf0d8031e54f440238e423e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52ce7e36ddd901308955a916f87b21a51418658e416615ef23fc08a83d09c70e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4ccaf6751ec10bedbabf226ac52d17ce80d51ff4164b19bb82494123e51f6c92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a1d70e398ae3867c7e2717d1e0d5ac80f7af9356a8c02ad7ebdc034a085f03d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f51f5c4b055955c6e8e9e4803e8ca57ffb833e72d7c93b50cffd421cbcff375", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b9dfb1fa7af5b64bc1f013d4f77d90bd2faa6be226b72f5577f46faee0f654f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-original.ppm", + "sha256": "07815b537b8df019f9a8b3bb100f205b20bdac607b06a3a883674728f51a1961", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "474b5cb2530effe4d8ce79d3b57eda23f795718dfc30fe1591b179e2cde17adc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7c3940d23b448558f7689b1b3171c41a0a99f8b92ccfb62e0fc243523df679fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ccfd3f02fb94e39d606e6b5039dc09a535027f5b1193161af1ad8482a1452c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab016bb7ae2ca976bdec92013b52f2ee0c9a0f249b5998fb63dd3e6d7964b07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-original.ppm", + "sha256": "731d2ad7d40da37dcf6d85fa128aec8f652bb3c5e3a3a1cab7bf97f6ccd55c63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "52ee4577a74f409c5f90aad05f39a8f462f139685398bcb5c92ca0208f0150e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a81c58b827f4533f41f6413a366a8f5e707f8b43039fc823ce9863fb0646e57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3221d17f268e21888a795e88ef677f5219f72a7788e57903fd900f55bbbf3556", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "81ca18fc0aae76a37f36e697efbdc6aa7a56acabfd7e20ce64d0cb5c38ffdaad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a04d2b78a0fe288544345cfbf99e031d1342591773c132de94f1a1a02a828c82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1fa8cb4aa3db5303d7e17c62876e69a352be0e71e34022902b3d5715ff56e4b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "557c5202b8790b5199d326695425b14f2f66b7f4beb101d38dd7b3dec54aa94e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a4ea4b96e7a9a77c54a8fee0f71718baecc64361ed931145badc415eb372ab90", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8797c65adee550343f481e5f5790ffc89b2b133f79bcafe3d67cfdf632cc594a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0f589865a0b7837ea238e4012e2dbb70d8f3b8b165127016fced78e0269b59cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "aaa8bfc0d7576c76523b26dc6ffdb70c966c03fc4f24eb0003cb9fb984f79490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "421cd09e4c241a019cb279c1cecf404f83c892a4bd7dbaa652ceaaea037fbd2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "84414bf8ec17dcfb3608cb42cc586f41fdbff735bc0f5b5d97434d0692424c3e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "83585b540986dd9f78869a8930858bd0dc141b69990b7ad6d91e36b2efc47cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0986dfc3e26d68f0e04195cdf9d1e2b7f5da2cd23b880af56b9384ef963f7c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7588543821be396ed14b6bd3e78bb0c3e079cbe2b94613ad9ab155c7605697bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "72acdde37443a6200d4157882b0d13f182ab41b24f58e3067d104b47488b00cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bb31621cec2f76017cf3f224cc20b0ddd78e126c51a1b8a2f6d4e411fc1d3987", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e0fbc5e011994fd47197aec6f8e662b4816afd311c927b2031f2392ad459ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eb6deecd0c170702e64f0d50f246dd37c12d02c3e21f68fd1d2be8d3fee83348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47acf1e50b2c79375a79cf912e60dcbdf36a1a60de9a826816c2f1559d9869a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd88e0e034a3c6989221dcc7e1993969a120d8436f30b4cec883869b54b4c907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d9171e08c11d28e13c7d5e704a9a8c5b38f56f90e2a9195e7054cc9c5c70c6d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "569a261febe59ad14728c89b23cc8dc5c24c525e8c1777fc4b16a8c6cc8a7a19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-original.ppm", + "sha256": "568481e4973c48993eef1f19374db65ef81246c8f2f1b0541666b8534c827e1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2cb304f42ba13ca5d827403c075d5577fb0bbe462db7988b2c02bf60801ab1f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f486227c734f2925f00ba67e70491f2bc6f38724a2166133fa23197788bb6cdc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e68f73973e511dcbbd6d48a9feeedd02c59cfc336a0228daffb0af67aec23a75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4ef398a88feec37105119dcdc37bab7fa0587b72c684702221829c12182de892", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b2c5dde1e1278d7534e9d7b4d1bf538d43f2e575426fcfe70e70c9cebdb15c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "236cc9a65e1e10ef753cc7316e25ae00e89b25dd5f80f9f35ec4765bc8fd2246", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "93dcfcd8359586da4dc1653e5f139e055d6cd3ec64c5cc004c18b2cf09db1bd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ee030edc5f9bc4ed6e197dbc81561d99798626f2cbe9750f2e8e2a55292e6896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2d32515adf639db9afc206140be51c7de52e74d1c3f3146687bfe6fe4ca4baaa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "63ad4f656faaf16f8f5eabbe8298d9aeb5e0a642d6f23ee4696176da0e3559d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06d2a2a8ac1058499d10e311463dd6835201f001e14345fcb6913c182246a03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0a6814ad21c8b8bf9a11822713f299eda7eed35ff13b710c6cec53b4e15f83eb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c4f962337cfcacc4ea63bb3b6160b40f1c63145b7cf4d750611e731aeb79894", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "424b024a191e23319c0785e1d1a9980d62fa6e593febfafcb9f7c72649e3d14d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26e2a8951641c52a403495952e503bc1017911e8681a96e595b5ece7cfb2e516", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b0cbd4b654d771773680f4f04f96fb65630d04027e484be2346313a1e1cfa82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8b66f6973fc86b3ef08a70a8bef6a397af7a487523956147167099a77f5c99df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "60373b77be34a563be55f6c85aba51fa41c47e2ccab98b16fb5b27a30d6ef1f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "606804f250f7244c0d6ed1b2646798104a885be8da8e993d5e154dd6dcaef12f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e1c234832095bcb0724c60c030b34a0d9994361dff8ecf5bc9c0cd256a66024e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c8c90b8af19dc87065ff61cb9aea1481b33c4d58d051a91ff6e37fd516a5a3b5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b1875fffa16d39852af9d76ad362a705660166359f4a0d056c90e4fe5c3516c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a69bca1ff1997e749b9994a4b186bc6c381070292d3ec38b0aca0ce21f8ebdcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ef96b177a79477741a94979f135364b814764b6a717809947c08f8b4d2de232", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "38cd254a04df76a5439136d51ae7c4a60bc02c23eadfd671e8bd7c5222ac7410", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2393ddef6f77d0f58cf018dc11bc4372f4783513e92726536a7aec53f6471d56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acded7cffcd4762f83293964eb7cea418769f251ce5f4de0feb8e54e16be156f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "edb024afb9c5b2bc80b0a9b13f8fa52ac69a302ab43d910026d58e66c53bc1a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36ee8a23a83692aa4f2741be3f1125e9b005adb130b893cb804c8d85fdeccc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cf5c9c74844d1ed57b443a3c02d305dbd234e7b6a5acba984b2e732e42825f67", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "10416": { @@ -136643,7 +143609,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10416", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -136659,6 +143625,467 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", "sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eeac825831b65f3085ee3a93cde1178da43f46775d29db1ec47f6c416d09f6e8", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.866714+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"10410/10411/10412\": \"Wide/tall corrugated roof geometry, side posts, surviving broken metal strips, charred openings and original ember placements remain source-relative. Both new wrecks were compared with authentic intact source partners at all recorded same-position contexts; no reconstructed intact roof was approved.\", \"10413/10414/10416\": \"Brown/grey horizontal wall bands and dark lower recesses preserve original source structure. Complete-family same-position transitions preserve continuous neighbor wall placement while removing the damaged tile structure; charred occupied backing is retained. Cracked masonry and rubble are a detail/material interpretation within the original regions, not a new detached building.\", \"10415\": \"Five original small pale rock groupings and their shadows remain separated at the original positions; chipped grain is accepted as added detail.\", \"10417\": \"Separate pale vertical/horizontal blocks, cyan box, lower grey block and two original animated ember cells preserve source placement; blocks have finer cracks/edges.\", \"10418/10419/1041a/1041b/1041c\": \"Original asymmetric rock masses, peaks, pale ledges and dark lower faces remain identifiable across all scales and authentic contexts. Fine chipped facets/grain are accepted; original state partners remain original artwork.\", \"1041d/1041e/1041f\": \"Original dotted border lines and cross-junction gaps remain aligned. The unchanged high-resolution raw 1041f contains irregular chipped pale fragments, not continuous stone panels. Native scales3/4 retain some square/stipple rhythm because the original one-pixel pale cells occupy very small areas. This disclosed over-literal rhythm is accepted as source placement fidelity after viewing raw and every actual scale, including all native neighbors.\"} {\"historical_job_sha256\": \"c703e6899b27905486538d0622bd111e22845b923c03dae26c87f4a003bb6cd4\", \"current_job_sha256\": \"0f6ab3d989aa9a16e71c9b69bc21e646675f2e4a4755b27fde1f75d1ec4e976d\", \"historical_artifact\": \"frozen/generated/historical-native-job-c703e689-reconstructed.json\", \"historical_retention_scope\": \"Author reconstructed full historical bytes from retained16 per-frame original job copies; exact serialized SHA c703e689 verified independently. This is not claimed to be retained original full-file bytes.\", \"reconstruction_provenance_sha256\": \"0fc2d4cd6479a0a29a6f64eab342cdf9c32ceac4d1d44293fddeaec08e8f38b4\", \"only_semantic_changes\": {\"target_statuses\": [{\"asset\": \"10410\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10411\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10412\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10413\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10414\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10415\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10416\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10417\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10418\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10419\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041a\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041b\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041c\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041d\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041e\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041f\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}], \"status_counts\": {\"before\": {\"inprogress\": 16}, \"after\": {\"candidate\": 16}}}, \"all_sources_geometry_roles_partners_neighbors_samples_and_contracts_exact\": true, \"author_explanation\": \"Shared hd_job_queue.py refreshes status metadata across jobs. Current0f6 job was already frozen before this independent rendering; old author proof remains historical. Neither discrepancy affects raw/frame bindings or terrain context data.\"} [\"Opaque mask IoU1 is trivial and was not used as material or geometry approval. All source/raw/full actual1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 images were visually inspected.\", \"Palette quantization/blockiness remains visible at2/3. New HD ground/rock/metal grain remains denser and sharper beside original fallback tiles; square texture-density boundaries can remain visible in mixed scenes. This approval does not assert uniform whole-mission material or complete HD fallback coverage.\", \"Foreign1040f/104ed/104ee/104f5 remain original in all independently rendered full-family and state scenes. Private HD1040f pack was excluded.\", \"State proof renders declared original source partner substitution at the same recorded position. First4pairs9positions are native target/state contexts; remaining6pairs17positions are explicitly synthetic declared source-state substitutions at authentic intact occurrences. No live destruction timing/reachability or live Host/whole-mission validation is claimed.\", \"Native scene and cardinal corpus comes from canonical supplied source contexts; no invented source occurrences. No new gameplay scrolling/boss assembly test is claimed.\", \"Animated palette240\\u2013255 pixels are legitimate source effects:10410=5,10412=4,10414=8,10417=2. Current loader source-relative class totals expand byscale\\u00b2. Static capture does not prove full palette cycling phases.\", \"Review only; no production manifest/source/art/Git writes, registration or promotion.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 37f5c4b26f9086c3724a4b13249981acf54dfaba4d5a0e7b861a928a50a3f187", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "10410", + "10411", + "10412", + "10413" + ], + "sha256": "dfdf91ff2260f9e5cd5afab1d62ce1182bd399635f3307843138a778f4f65beb", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "10414", + "10415", + "10416", + "10417" + ], + "sha256": "989a797ac864e72c88805fcbdd5b8e494db6c307a75f5facea86bd602a2bd104", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "10418", + "10419", + "1041a", + "1041b" + ], + "sha256": "c2856b9eda30d17110fea211e769ce0adf65b15a3254ff4a57a427ac079197d2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "1041c", + "1041d", + "1041e", + "1041f" + ], + "sha256": "e5cfb639df3fcc47a4533af97884a9163409c2e4db6a0fa59a1fb7e3ad926224", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10410-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac8fc607959f5f14c0b942da5f21fb0f26e3336edd6ff8d352ed6f2b503b8e7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c39bff33a03e8367c725d1bb68613df96c60841e37d5ed3bdac0f2acb9ca18a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e045baa994ac7ea4b62c3e3020ae3266b48b3ef03118282a0918dc1dd2e91aeb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5c181c77cc497bcbd185796574207fe4e89623ce13053ca246c16ee904690812", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b9f1b7fcf833e60b7ade5f3e678896f72c5e78fa85ba6792e7fc78424ebd8958", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cc3fd56d3e61a9d919b9a0b7e67caa0aa932f394d5232477f44c37d48c91b5dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "932c116e449199fc8b4c26e522c73c339bc1fda4e3a6382eb26d25a3366e7174", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1dee0695f73c8701c567fc18ecaa11bf56fa74d6833a34fa7f6dfc92b7ca51b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c3c2129b8f2cd34b744e494087f53ba5691c8dd83849b161b0c59292a9f6cdb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5f1190f320faaaab142e030bef2196496759b6856f0c96a5c2fcd38d5767a390", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9f0e642fd58f9c42103b6f71341ef663c208bfab3ed737a6cb109d147b9077a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "049a788257cb017d0dc19cd5e7c2e03f869b73343ff005d736e98afa977fc878", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cdd053889c26c1f7e66934f6680eb07b5772cbe80632082b4627eb5196f09c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a398fafa05cf760e4907d6e63eaed92193724591cf0d8031e54f440238e423e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52ce7e36ddd901308955a916f87b21a51418658e416615ef23fc08a83d09c70e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4ccaf6751ec10bedbabf226ac52d17ce80d51ff4164b19bb82494123e51f6c92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a1d70e398ae3867c7e2717d1e0d5ac80f7af9356a8c02ad7ebdc034a085f03d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f51f5c4b055955c6e8e9e4803e8ca57ffb833e72d7c93b50cffd421cbcff375", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b9dfb1fa7af5b64bc1f013d4f77d90bd2faa6be226b72f5577f46faee0f654f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-original.ppm", + "sha256": "07815b537b8df019f9a8b3bb100f205b20bdac607b06a3a883674728f51a1961", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "474b5cb2530effe4d8ce79d3b57eda23f795718dfc30fe1591b179e2cde17adc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7c3940d23b448558f7689b1b3171c41a0a99f8b92ccfb62e0fc243523df679fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ccfd3f02fb94e39d606e6b5039dc09a535027f5b1193161af1ad8482a1452c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab016bb7ae2ca976bdec92013b52f2ee0c9a0f249b5998fb63dd3e6d7964b07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-original.ppm", + "sha256": "731d2ad7d40da37dcf6d85fa128aec8f652bb3c5e3a3a1cab7bf97f6ccd55c63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "52ee4577a74f409c5f90aad05f39a8f462f139685398bcb5c92ca0208f0150e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a81c58b827f4533f41f6413a366a8f5e707f8b43039fc823ce9863fb0646e57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3221d17f268e21888a795e88ef677f5219f72a7788e57903fd900f55bbbf3556", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "81ca18fc0aae76a37f36e697efbdc6aa7a56acabfd7e20ce64d0cb5c38ffdaad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a04d2b78a0fe288544345cfbf99e031d1342591773c132de94f1a1a02a828c82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1fa8cb4aa3db5303d7e17c62876e69a352be0e71e34022902b3d5715ff56e4b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "557c5202b8790b5199d326695425b14f2f66b7f4beb101d38dd7b3dec54aa94e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a4ea4b96e7a9a77c54a8fee0f71718baecc64361ed931145badc415eb372ab90", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8797c65adee550343f481e5f5790ffc89b2b133f79bcafe3d67cfdf632cc594a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0f589865a0b7837ea238e4012e2dbb70d8f3b8b165127016fced78e0269b59cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "aaa8bfc0d7576c76523b26dc6ffdb70c966c03fc4f24eb0003cb9fb984f79490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "421cd09e4c241a019cb279c1cecf404f83c892a4bd7dbaa652ceaaea037fbd2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "84414bf8ec17dcfb3608cb42cc586f41fdbff735bc0f5b5d97434d0692424c3e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "83585b540986dd9f78869a8930858bd0dc141b69990b7ad6d91e36b2efc47cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0986dfc3e26d68f0e04195cdf9d1e2b7f5da2cd23b880af56b9384ef963f7c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7588543821be396ed14b6bd3e78bb0c3e079cbe2b94613ad9ab155c7605697bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "72acdde37443a6200d4157882b0d13f182ab41b24f58e3067d104b47488b00cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bb31621cec2f76017cf3f224cc20b0ddd78e126c51a1b8a2f6d4e411fc1d3987", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e0fbc5e011994fd47197aec6f8e662b4816afd311c927b2031f2392ad459ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eb6deecd0c170702e64f0d50f246dd37c12d02c3e21f68fd1d2be8d3fee83348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47acf1e50b2c79375a79cf912e60dcbdf36a1a60de9a826816c2f1559d9869a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd88e0e034a3c6989221dcc7e1993969a120d8436f30b4cec883869b54b4c907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d9171e08c11d28e13c7d5e704a9a8c5b38f56f90e2a9195e7054cc9c5c70c6d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "569a261febe59ad14728c89b23cc8dc5c24c525e8c1777fc4b16a8c6cc8a7a19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-original.ppm", + "sha256": "568481e4973c48993eef1f19374db65ef81246c8f2f1b0541666b8534c827e1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2cb304f42ba13ca5d827403c075d5577fb0bbe462db7988b2c02bf60801ab1f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f486227c734f2925f00ba67e70491f2bc6f38724a2166133fa23197788bb6cdc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e68f73973e511dcbbd6d48a9feeedd02c59cfc336a0228daffb0af67aec23a75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4ef398a88feec37105119dcdc37bab7fa0587b72c684702221829c12182de892", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b2c5dde1e1278d7534e9d7b4d1bf538d43f2e575426fcfe70e70c9cebdb15c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "236cc9a65e1e10ef753cc7316e25ae00e89b25dd5f80f9f35ec4765bc8fd2246", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "93dcfcd8359586da4dc1653e5f139e055d6cd3ec64c5cc004c18b2cf09db1bd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ee030edc5f9bc4ed6e197dbc81561d99798626f2cbe9750f2e8e2a55292e6896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2d32515adf639db9afc206140be51c7de52e74d1c3f3146687bfe6fe4ca4baaa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "63ad4f656faaf16f8f5eabbe8298d9aeb5e0a642d6f23ee4696176da0e3559d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06d2a2a8ac1058499d10e311463dd6835201f001e14345fcb6913c182246a03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0a6814ad21c8b8bf9a11822713f299eda7eed35ff13b710c6cec53b4e15f83eb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c4f962337cfcacc4ea63bb3b6160b40f1c63145b7cf4d750611e731aeb79894", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "424b024a191e23319c0785e1d1a9980d62fa6e593febfafcb9f7c72649e3d14d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26e2a8951641c52a403495952e503bc1017911e8681a96e595b5ece7cfb2e516", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b0cbd4b654d771773680f4f04f96fb65630d04027e484be2346313a1e1cfa82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8b66f6973fc86b3ef08a70a8bef6a397af7a487523956147167099a77f5c99df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "60373b77be34a563be55f6c85aba51fa41c47e2ccab98b16fb5b27a30d6ef1f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "606804f250f7244c0d6ed1b2646798104a885be8da8e993d5e154dd6dcaef12f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e1c234832095bcb0724c60c030b34a0d9994361dff8ecf5bc9c0cd256a66024e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c8c90b8af19dc87065ff61cb9aea1481b33c4d58d051a91ff6e37fd516a5a3b5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b1875fffa16d39852af9d76ad362a705660166359f4a0d056c90e4fe5c3516c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a69bca1ff1997e749b9994a4b186bc6c381070292d3ec38b0aca0ce21f8ebdcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ef96b177a79477741a94979f135364b814764b6a717809947c08f8b4d2de232", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "38cd254a04df76a5439136d51ae7c4a60bc02c23eadfd671e8bd7c5222ac7410", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2393ddef6f77d0f58cf018dc11bc4372f4783513e92726536a7aec53f6471d56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acded7cffcd4762f83293964eb7cea418769f251ce5f4de0feb8e54e16be156f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "edb024afb9c5b2bc80b0a9b13f8fa52ac69a302ab43d910026d58e66c53bc1a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36ee8a23a83692aa4f2741be3f1125e9b005adb130b893cb804c8d85fdeccc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cf5c9c74844d1ed57b443a3c02d305dbd234e7b6a5acba984b2e732e42825f67", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "10417": { @@ -136680,7 +144107,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10417", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -136696,6 +144123,467 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", "sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eeac825831b65f3085ee3a93cde1178da43f46775d29db1ec47f6c416d09f6e8", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.866714+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"10410/10411/10412\": \"Wide/tall corrugated roof geometry, side posts, surviving broken metal strips, charred openings and original ember placements remain source-relative. Both new wrecks were compared with authentic intact source partners at all recorded same-position contexts; no reconstructed intact roof was approved.\", \"10413/10414/10416\": \"Brown/grey horizontal wall bands and dark lower recesses preserve original source structure. Complete-family same-position transitions preserve continuous neighbor wall placement while removing the damaged tile structure; charred occupied backing is retained. Cracked masonry and rubble are a detail/material interpretation within the original regions, not a new detached building.\", \"10415\": \"Five original small pale rock groupings and their shadows remain separated at the original positions; chipped grain is accepted as added detail.\", \"10417\": \"Separate pale vertical/horizontal blocks, cyan box, lower grey block and two original animated ember cells preserve source placement; blocks have finer cracks/edges.\", \"10418/10419/1041a/1041b/1041c\": \"Original asymmetric rock masses, peaks, pale ledges and dark lower faces remain identifiable across all scales and authentic contexts. Fine chipped facets/grain are accepted; original state partners remain original artwork.\", \"1041d/1041e/1041f\": \"Original dotted border lines and cross-junction gaps remain aligned. The unchanged high-resolution raw 1041f contains irregular chipped pale fragments, not continuous stone panels. Native scales3/4 retain some square/stipple rhythm because the original one-pixel pale cells occupy very small areas. This disclosed over-literal rhythm is accepted as source placement fidelity after viewing raw and every actual scale, including all native neighbors.\"} {\"historical_job_sha256\": \"c703e6899b27905486538d0622bd111e22845b923c03dae26c87f4a003bb6cd4\", \"current_job_sha256\": \"0f6ab3d989aa9a16e71c9b69bc21e646675f2e4a4755b27fde1f75d1ec4e976d\", \"historical_artifact\": \"frozen/generated/historical-native-job-c703e689-reconstructed.json\", \"historical_retention_scope\": \"Author reconstructed full historical bytes from retained16 per-frame original job copies; exact serialized SHA c703e689 verified independently. This is not claimed to be retained original full-file bytes.\", \"reconstruction_provenance_sha256\": \"0fc2d4cd6479a0a29a6f64eab342cdf9c32ceac4d1d44293fddeaec08e8f38b4\", \"only_semantic_changes\": {\"target_statuses\": [{\"asset\": \"10410\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10411\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10412\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10413\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10414\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10415\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10416\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10417\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10418\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10419\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041a\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041b\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041c\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041d\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041e\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041f\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}], \"status_counts\": {\"before\": {\"inprogress\": 16}, \"after\": {\"candidate\": 16}}}, \"all_sources_geometry_roles_partners_neighbors_samples_and_contracts_exact\": true, \"author_explanation\": \"Shared hd_job_queue.py refreshes status metadata across jobs. Current0f6 job was already frozen before this independent rendering; old author proof remains historical. Neither discrepancy affects raw/frame bindings or terrain context data.\"} [\"Opaque mask IoU1 is trivial and was not used as material or geometry approval. All source/raw/full actual1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 images were visually inspected.\", \"Palette quantization/blockiness remains visible at2/3. New HD ground/rock/metal grain remains denser and sharper beside original fallback tiles; square texture-density boundaries can remain visible in mixed scenes. This approval does not assert uniform whole-mission material or complete HD fallback coverage.\", \"Foreign1040f/104ed/104ee/104f5 remain original in all independently rendered full-family and state scenes. Private HD1040f pack was excluded.\", \"State proof renders declared original source partner substitution at the same recorded position. First4pairs9positions are native target/state contexts; remaining6pairs17positions are explicitly synthetic declared source-state substitutions at authentic intact occurrences. No live destruction timing/reachability or live Host/whole-mission validation is claimed.\", \"Native scene and cardinal corpus comes from canonical supplied source contexts; no invented source occurrences. No new gameplay scrolling/boss assembly test is claimed.\", \"Animated palette240\\u2013255 pixels are legitimate source effects:10410=5,10412=4,10414=8,10417=2. Current loader source-relative class totals expand byscale\\u00b2. Static capture does not prove full palette cycling phases.\", \"Review only; no production manifest/source/art/Git writes, registration or promotion.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 37f5c4b26f9086c3724a4b13249981acf54dfaba4d5a0e7b861a928a50a3f187", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "10410", + "10411", + "10412", + "10413" + ], + "sha256": "dfdf91ff2260f9e5cd5afab1d62ce1182bd399635f3307843138a778f4f65beb", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "10414", + "10415", + "10416", + "10417" + ], + "sha256": "989a797ac864e72c88805fcbdd5b8e494db6c307a75f5facea86bd602a2bd104", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "10418", + "10419", + "1041a", + "1041b" + ], + "sha256": "c2856b9eda30d17110fea211e769ce0adf65b15a3254ff4a57a427ac079197d2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "1041c", + "1041d", + "1041e", + "1041f" + ], + "sha256": "e5cfb639df3fcc47a4533af97884a9163409c2e4db6a0fa59a1fb7e3ad926224", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10410-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac8fc607959f5f14c0b942da5f21fb0f26e3336edd6ff8d352ed6f2b503b8e7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c39bff33a03e8367c725d1bb68613df96c60841e37d5ed3bdac0f2acb9ca18a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e045baa994ac7ea4b62c3e3020ae3266b48b3ef03118282a0918dc1dd2e91aeb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5c181c77cc497bcbd185796574207fe4e89623ce13053ca246c16ee904690812", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b9f1b7fcf833e60b7ade5f3e678896f72c5e78fa85ba6792e7fc78424ebd8958", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cc3fd56d3e61a9d919b9a0b7e67caa0aa932f394d5232477f44c37d48c91b5dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "932c116e449199fc8b4c26e522c73c339bc1fda4e3a6382eb26d25a3366e7174", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1dee0695f73c8701c567fc18ecaa11bf56fa74d6833a34fa7f6dfc92b7ca51b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c3c2129b8f2cd34b744e494087f53ba5691c8dd83849b161b0c59292a9f6cdb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5f1190f320faaaab142e030bef2196496759b6856f0c96a5c2fcd38d5767a390", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9f0e642fd58f9c42103b6f71341ef663c208bfab3ed737a6cb109d147b9077a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "049a788257cb017d0dc19cd5e7c2e03f869b73343ff005d736e98afa977fc878", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cdd053889c26c1f7e66934f6680eb07b5772cbe80632082b4627eb5196f09c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a398fafa05cf760e4907d6e63eaed92193724591cf0d8031e54f440238e423e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52ce7e36ddd901308955a916f87b21a51418658e416615ef23fc08a83d09c70e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4ccaf6751ec10bedbabf226ac52d17ce80d51ff4164b19bb82494123e51f6c92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a1d70e398ae3867c7e2717d1e0d5ac80f7af9356a8c02ad7ebdc034a085f03d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f51f5c4b055955c6e8e9e4803e8ca57ffb833e72d7c93b50cffd421cbcff375", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b9dfb1fa7af5b64bc1f013d4f77d90bd2faa6be226b72f5577f46faee0f654f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-original.ppm", + "sha256": "07815b537b8df019f9a8b3bb100f205b20bdac607b06a3a883674728f51a1961", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "474b5cb2530effe4d8ce79d3b57eda23f795718dfc30fe1591b179e2cde17adc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7c3940d23b448558f7689b1b3171c41a0a99f8b92ccfb62e0fc243523df679fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ccfd3f02fb94e39d606e6b5039dc09a535027f5b1193161af1ad8482a1452c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab016bb7ae2ca976bdec92013b52f2ee0c9a0f249b5998fb63dd3e6d7964b07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-original.ppm", + "sha256": "731d2ad7d40da37dcf6d85fa128aec8f652bb3c5e3a3a1cab7bf97f6ccd55c63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "52ee4577a74f409c5f90aad05f39a8f462f139685398bcb5c92ca0208f0150e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a81c58b827f4533f41f6413a366a8f5e707f8b43039fc823ce9863fb0646e57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3221d17f268e21888a795e88ef677f5219f72a7788e57903fd900f55bbbf3556", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "81ca18fc0aae76a37f36e697efbdc6aa7a56acabfd7e20ce64d0cb5c38ffdaad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a04d2b78a0fe288544345cfbf99e031d1342591773c132de94f1a1a02a828c82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1fa8cb4aa3db5303d7e17c62876e69a352be0e71e34022902b3d5715ff56e4b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "557c5202b8790b5199d326695425b14f2f66b7f4beb101d38dd7b3dec54aa94e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a4ea4b96e7a9a77c54a8fee0f71718baecc64361ed931145badc415eb372ab90", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8797c65adee550343f481e5f5790ffc89b2b133f79bcafe3d67cfdf632cc594a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0f589865a0b7837ea238e4012e2dbb70d8f3b8b165127016fced78e0269b59cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "aaa8bfc0d7576c76523b26dc6ffdb70c966c03fc4f24eb0003cb9fb984f79490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "421cd09e4c241a019cb279c1cecf404f83c892a4bd7dbaa652ceaaea037fbd2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "84414bf8ec17dcfb3608cb42cc586f41fdbff735bc0f5b5d97434d0692424c3e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "83585b540986dd9f78869a8930858bd0dc141b69990b7ad6d91e36b2efc47cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0986dfc3e26d68f0e04195cdf9d1e2b7f5da2cd23b880af56b9384ef963f7c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7588543821be396ed14b6bd3e78bb0c3e079cbe2b94613ad9ab155c7605697bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "72acdde37443a6200d4157882b0d13f182ab41b24f58e3067d104b47488b00cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bb31621cec2f76017cf3f224cc20b0ddd78e126c51a1b8a2f6d4e411fc1d3987", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e0fbc5e011994fd47197aec6f8e662b4816afd311c927b2031f2392ad459ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eb6deecd0c170702e64f0d50f246dd37c12d02c3e21f68fd1d2be8d3fee83348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47acf1e50b2c79375a79cf912e60dcbdf36a1a60de9a826816c2f1559d9869a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd88e0e034a3c6989221dcc7e1993969a120d8436f30b4cec883869b54b4c907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d9171e08c11d28e13c7d5e704a9a8c5b38f56f90e2a9195e7054cc9c5c70c6d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "569a261febe59ad14728c89b23cc8dc5c24c525e8c1777fc4b16a8c6cc8a7a19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-original.ppm", + "sha256": "568481e4973c48993eef1f19374db65ef81246c8f2f1b0541666b8534c827e1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2cb304f42ba13ca5d827403c075d5577fb0bbe462db7988b2c02bf60801ab1f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f486227c734f2925f00ba67e70491f2bc6f38724a2166133fa23197788bb6cdc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e68f73973e511dcbbd6d48a9feeedd02c59cfc336a0228daffb0af67aec23a75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4ef398a88feec37105119dcdc37bab7fa0587b72c684702221829c12182de892", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b2c5dde1e1278d7534e9d7b4d1bf538d43f2e575426fcfe70e70c9cebdb15c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "236cc9a65e1e10ef753cc7316e25ae00e89b25dd5f80f9f35ec4765bc8fd2246", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "93dcfcd8359586da4dc1653e5f139e055d6cd3ec64c5cc004c18b2cf09db1bd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ee030edc5f9bc4ed6e197dbc81561d99798626f2cbe9750f2e8e2a55292e6896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2d32515adf639db9afc206140be51c7de52e74d1c3f3146687bfe6fe4ca4baaa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "63ad4f656faaf16f8f5eabbe8298d9aeb5e0a642d6f23ee4696176da0e3559d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06d2a2a8ac1058499d10e311463dd6835201f001e14345fcb6913c182246a03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0a6814ad21c8b8bf9a11822713f299eda7eed35ff13b710c6cec53b4e15f83eb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c4f962337cfcacc4ea63bb3b6160b40f1c63145b7cf4d750611e731aeb79894", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "424b024a191e23319c0785e1d1a9980d62fa6e593febfafcb9f7c72649e3d14d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26e2a8951641c52a403495952e503bc1017911e8681a96e595b5ece7cfb2e516", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b0cbd4b654d771773680f4f04f96fb65630d04027e484be2346313a1e1cfa82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8b66f6973fc86b3ef08a70a8bef6a397af7a487523956147167099a77f5c99df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "60373b77be34a563be55f6c85aba51fa41c47e2ccab98b16fb5b27a30d6ef1f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "606804f250f7244c0d6ed1b2646798104a885be8da8e993d5e154dd6dcaef12f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e1c234832095bcb0724c60c030b34a0d9994361dff8ecf5bc9c0cd256a66024e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c8c90b8af19dc87065ff61cb9aea1481b33c4d58d051a91ff6e37fd516a5a3b5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b1875fffa16d39852af9d76ad362a705660166359f4a0d056c90e4fe5c3516c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a69bca1ff1997e749b9994a4b186bc6c381070292d3ec38b0aca0ce21f8ebdcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ef96b177a79477741a94979f135364b814764b6a717809947c08f8b4d2de232", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "38cd254a04df76a5439136d51ae7c4a60bc02c23eadfd671e8bd7c5222ac7410", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2393ddef6f77d0f58cf018dc11bc4372f4783513e92726536a7aec53f6471d56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acded7cffcd4762f83293964eb7cea418769f251ce5f4de0feb8e54e16be156f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "edb024afb9c5b2bc80b0a9b13f8fa52ac69a302ab43d910026d58e66c53bc1a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36ee8a23a83692aa4f2741be3f1125e9b005adb130b893cb804c8d85fdeccc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cf5c9c74844d1ed57b443a3c02d305dbd234e7b6a5acba984b2e732e42825f67", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "10418": { @@ -136717,7 +144605,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10418", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -136733,6 +144621,467 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", "sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eeac825831b65f3085ee3a93cde1178da43f46775d29db1ec47f6c416d09f6e8", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.866714+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"10410/10411/10412\": \"Wide/tall corrugated roof geometry, side posts, surviving broken metal strips, charred openings and original ember placements remain source-relative. Both new wrecks were compared with authentic intact source partners at all recorded same-position contexts; no reconstructed intact roof was approved.\", \"10413/10414/10416\": \"Brown/grey horizontal wall bands and dark lower recesses preserve original source structure. Complete-family same-position transitions preserve continuous neighbor wall placement while removing the damaged tile structure; charred occupied backing is retained. Cracked masonry and rubble are a detail/material interpretation within the original regions, not a new detached building.\", \"10415\": \"Five original small pale rock groupings and their shadows remain separated at the original positions; chipped grain is accepted as added detail.\", \"10417\": \"Separate pale vertical/horizontal blocks, cyan box, lower grey block and two original animated ember cells preserve source placement; blocks have finer cracks/edges.\", \"10418/10419/1041a/1041b/1041c\": \"Original asymmetric rock masses, peaks, pale ledges and dark lower faces remain identifiable across all scales and authentic contexts. Fine chipped facets/grain are accepted; original state partners remain original artwork.\", \"1041d/1041e/1041f\": \"Original dotted border lines and cross-junction gaps remain aligned. The unchanged high-resolution raw 1041f contains irregular chipped pale fragments, not continuous stone panels. Native scales3/4 retain some square/stipple rhythm because the original one-pixel pale cells occupy very small areas. This disclosed over-literal rhythm is accepted as source placement fidelity after viewing raw and every actual scale, including all native neighbors.\"} {\"historical_job_sha256\": \"c703e6899b27905486538d0622bd111e22845b923c03dae26c87f4a003bb6cd4\", \"current_job_sha256\": \"0f6ab3d989aa9a16e71c9b69bc21e646675f2e4a4755b27fde1f75d1ec4e976d\", \"historical_artifact\": \"frozen/generated/historical-native-job-c703e689-reconstructed.json\", \"historical_retention_scope\": \"Author reconstructed full historical bytes from retained16 per-frame original job copies; exact serialized SHA c703e689 verified independently. This is not claimed to be retained original full-file bytes.\", \"reconstruction_provenance_sha256\": \"0fc2d4cd6479a0a29a6f64eab342cdf9c32ceac4d1d44293fddeaec08e8f38b4\", \"only_semantic_changes\": {\"target_statuses\": [{\"asset\": \"10410\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10411\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10412\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10413\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10414\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10415\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10416\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10417\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10418\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10419\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041a\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041b\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041c\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041d\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041e\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041f\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}], \"status_counts\": {\"before\": {\"inprogress\": 16}, \"after\": {\"candidate\": 16}}}, \"all_sources_geometry_roles_partners_neighbors_samples_and_contracts_exact\": true, \"author_explanation\": \"Shared hd_job_queue.py refreshes status metadata across jobs. Current0f6 job was already frozen before this independent rendering; old author proof remains historical. Neither discrepancy affects raw/frame bindings or terrain context data.\"} [\"Opaque mask IoU1 is trivial and was not used as material or geometry approval. All source/raw/full actual1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 images were visually inspected.\", \"Palette quantization/blockiness remains visible at2/3. New HD ground/rock/metal grain remains denser and sharper beside original fallback tiles; square texture-density boundaries can remain visible in mixed scenes. This approval does not assert uniform whole-mission material or complete HD fallback coverage.\", \"Foreign1040f/104ed/104ee/104f5 remain original in all independently rendered full-family and state scenes. Private HD1040f pack was excluded.\", \"State proof renders declared original source partner substitution at the same recorded position. First4pairs9positions are native target/state contexts; remaining6pairs17positions are explicitly synthetic declared source-state substitutions at authentic intact occurrences. No live destruction timing/reachability or live Host/whole-mission validation is claimed.\", \"Native scene and cardinal corpus comes from canonical supplied source contexts; no invented source occurrences. No new gameplay scrolling/boss assembly test is claimed.\", \"Animated palette240\\u2013255 pixels are legitimate source effects:10410=5,10412=4,10414=8,10417=2. Current loader source-relative class totals expand byscale\\u00b2. Static capture does not prove full palette cycling phases.\", \"Review only; no production manifest/source/art/Git writes, registration or promotion.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 37f5c4b26f9086c3724a4b13249981acf54dfaba4d5a0e7b861a928a50a3f187", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "10410", + "10411", + "10412", + "10413" + ], + "sha256": "dfdf91ff2260f9e5cd5afab1d62ce1182bd399635f3307843138a778f4f65beb", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "10414", + "10415", + "10416", + "10417" + ], + "sha256": "989a797ac864e72c88805fcbdd5b8e494db6c307a75f5facea86bd602a2bd104", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "10418", + "10419", + "1041a", + "1041b" + ], + "sha256": "c2856b9eda30d17110fea211e769ce0adf65b15a3254ff4a57a427ac079197d2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "1041c", + "1041d", + "1041e", + "1041f" + ], + "sha256": "e5cfb639df3fcc47a4533af97884a9163409c2e4db6a0fa59a1fb7e3ad926224", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10410-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac8fc607959f5f14c0b942da5f21fb0f26e3336edd6ff8d352ed6f2b503b8e7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c39bff33a03e8367c725d1bb68613df96c60841e37d5ed3bdac0f2acb9ca18a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e045baa994ac7ea4b62c3e3020ae3266b48b3ef03118282a0918dc1dd2e91aeb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5c181c77cc497bcbd185796574207fe4e89623ce13053ca246c16ee904690812", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b9f1b7fcf833e60b7ade5f3e678896f72c5e78fa85ba6792e7fc78424ebd8958", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cc3fd56d3e61a9d919b9a0b7e67caa0aa932f394d5232477f44c37d48c91b5dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "932c116e449199fc8b4c26e522c73c339bc1fda4e3a6382eb26d25a3366e7174", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1dee0695f73c8701c567fc18ecaa11bf56fa74d6833a34fa7f6dfc92b7ca51b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c3c2129b8f2cd34b744e494087f53ba5691c8dd83849b161b0c59292a9f6cdb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5f1190f320faaaab142e030bef2196496759b6856f0c96a5c2fcd38d5767a390", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9f0e642fd58f9c42103b6f71341ef663c208bfab3ed737a6cb109d147b9077a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "049a788257cb017d0dc19cd5e7c2e03f869b73343ff005d736e98afa977fc878", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cdd053889c26c1f7e66934f6680eb07b5772cbe80632082b4627eb5196f09c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a398fafa05cf760e4907d6e63eaed92193724591cf0d8031e54f440238e423e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52ce7e36ddd901308955a916f87b21a51418658e416615ef23fc08a83d09c70e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4ccaf6751ec10bedbabf226ac52d17ce80d51ff4164b19bb82494123e51f6c92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a1d70e398ae3867c7e2717d1e0d5ac80f7af9356a8c02ad7ebdc034a085f03d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f51f5c4b055955c6e8e9e4803e8ca57ffb833e72d7c93b50cffd421cbcff375", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b9dfb1fa7af5b64bc1f013d4f77d90bd2faa6be226b72f5577f46faee0f654f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-original.ppm", + "sha256": "07815b537b8df019f9a8b3bb100f205b20bdac607b06a3a883674728f51a1961", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "474b5cb2530effe4d8ce79d3b57eda23f795718dfc30fe1591b179e2cde17adc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7c3940d23b448558f7689b1b3171c41a0a99f8b92ccfb62e0fc243523df679fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ccfd3f02fb94e39d606e6b5039dc09a535027f5b1193161af1ad8482a1452c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab016bb7ae2ca976bdec92013b52f2ee0c9a0f249b5998fb63dd3e6d7964b07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-original.ppm", + "sha256": "731d2ad7d40da37dcf6d85fa128aec8f652bb3c5e3a3a1cab7bf97f6ccd55c63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "52ee4577a74f409c5f90aad05f39a8f462f139685398bcb5c92ca0208f0150e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a81c58b827f4533f41f6413a366a8f5e707f8b43039fc823ce9863fb0646e57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3221d17f268e21888a795e88ef677f5219f72a7788e57903fd900f55bbbf3556", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "81ca18fc0aae76a37f36e697efbdc6aa7a56acabfd7e20ce64d0cb5c38ffdaad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a04d2b78a0fe288544345cfbf99e031d1342591773c132de94f1a1a02a828c82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1fa8cb4aa3db5303d7e17c62876e69a352be0e71e34022902b3d5715ff56e4b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "557c5202b8790b5199d326695425b14f2f66b7f4beb101d38dd7b3dec54aa94e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a4ea4b96e7a9a77c54a8fee0f71718baecc64361ed931145badc415eb372ab90", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8797c65adee550343f481e5f5790ffc89b2b133f79bcafe3d67cfdf632cc594a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0f589865a0b7837ea238e4012e2dbb70d8f3b8b165127016fced78e0269b59cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "aaa8bfc0d7576c76523b26dc6ffdb70c966c03fc4f24eb0003cb9fb984f79490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "421cd09e4c241a019cb279c1cecf404f83c892a4bd7dbaa652ceaaea037fbd2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "84414bf8ec17dcfb3608cb42cc586f41fdbff735bc0f5b5d97434d0692424c3e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "83585b540986dd9f78869a8930858bd0dc141b69990b7ad6d91e36b2efc47cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0986dfc3e26d68f0e04195cdf9d1e2b7f5da2cd23b880af56b9384ef963f7c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7588543821be396ed14b6bd3e78bb0c3e079cbe2b94613ad9ab155c7605697bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "72acdde37443a6200d4157882b0d13f182ab41b24f58e3067d104b47488b00cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bb31621cec2f76017cf3f224cc20b0ddd78e126c51a1b8a2f6d4e411fc1d3987", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e0fbc5e011994fd47197aec6f8e662b4816afd311c927b2031f2392ad459ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eb6deecd0c170702e64f0d50f246dd37c12d02c3e21f68fd1d2be8d3fee83348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47acf1e50b2c79375a79cf912e60dcbdf36a1a60de9a826816c2f1559d9869a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd88e0e034a3c6989221dcc7e1993969a120d8436f30b4cec883869b54b4c907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d9171e08c11d28e13c7d5e704a9a8c5b38f56f90e2a9195e7054cc9c5c70c6d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "569a261febe59ad14728c89b23cc8dc5c24c525e8c1777fc4b16a8c6cc8a7a19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-original.ppm", + "sha256": "568481e4973c48993eef1f19374db65ef81246c8f2f1b0541666b8534c827e1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2cb304f42ba13ca5d827403c075d5577fb0bbe462db7988b2c02bf60801ab1f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f486227c734f2925f00ba67e70491f2bc6f38724a2166133fa23197788bb6cdc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e68f73973e511dcbbd6d48a9feeedd02c59cfc336a0228daffb0af67aec23a75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4ef398a88feec37105119dcdc37bab7fa0587b72c684702221829c12182de892", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b2c5dde1e1278d7534e9d7b4d1bf538d43f2e575426fcfe70e70c9cebdb15c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "236cc9a65e1e10ef753cc7316e25ae00e89b25dd5f80f9f35ec4765bc8fd2246", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "93dcfcd8359586da4dc1653e5f139e055d6cd3ec64c5cc004c18b2cf09db1bd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ee030edc5f9bc4ed6e197dbc81561d99798626f2cbe9750f2e8e2a55292e6896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2d32515adf639db9afc206140be51c7de52e74d1c3f3146687bfe6fe4ca4baaa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "63ad4f656faaf16f8f5eabbe8298d9aeb5e0a642d6f23ee4696176da0e3559d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06d2a2a8ac1058499d10e311463dd6835201f001e14345fcb6913c182246a03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0a6814ad21c8b8bf9a11822713f299eda7eed35ff13b710c6cec53b4e15f83eb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c4f962337cfcacc4ea63bb3b6160b40f1c63145b7cf4d750611e731aeb79894", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "424b024a191e23319c0785e1d1a9980d62fa6e593febfafcb9f7c72649e3d14d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26e2a8951641c52a403495952e503bc1017911e8681a96e595b5ece7cfb2e516", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b0cbd4b654d771773680f4f04f96fb65630d04027e484be2346313a1e1cfa82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8b66f6973fc86b3ef08a70a8bef6a397af7a487523956147167099a77f5c99df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "60373b77be34a563be55f6c85aba51fa41c47e2ccab98b16fb5b27a30d6ef1f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "606804f250f7244c0d6ed1b2646798104a885be8da8e993d5e154dd6dcaef12f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e1c234832095bcb0724c60c030b34a0d9994361dff8ecf5bc9c0cd256a66024e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c8c90b8af19dc87065ff61cb9aea1481b33c4d58d051a91ff6e37fd516a5a3b5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b1875fffa16d39852af9d76ad362a705660166359f4a0d056c90e4fe5c3516c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a69bca1ff1997e749b9994a4b186bc6c381070292d3ec38b0aca0ce21f8ebdcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ef96b177a79477741a94979f135364b814764b6a717809947c08f8b4d2de232", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "38cd254a04df76a5439136d51ae7c4a60bc02c23eadfd671e8bd7c5222ac7410", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2393ddef6f77d0f58cf018dc11bc4372f4783513e92726536a7aec53f6471d56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acded7cffcd4762f83293964eb7cea418769f251ce5f4de0feb8e54e16be156f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "edb024afb9c5b2bc80b0a9b13f8fa52ac69a302ab43d910026d58e66c53bc1a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36ee8a23a83692aa4f2741be3f1125e9b005adb130b893cb804c8d85fdeccc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cf5c9c74844d1ed57b443a3c02d305dbd234e7b6a5acba984b2e732e42825f67", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "10419": { @@ -136754,7 +145103,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "10419", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -136770,6 +145119,467 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", "sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eeac825831b65f3085ee3a93cde1178da43f46775d29db1ec47f6c416d09f6e8", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.866714+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"10410/10411/10412\": \"Wide/tall corrugated roof geometry, side posts, surviving broken metal strips, charred openings and original ember placements remain source-relative. Both new wrecks were compared with authentic intact source partners at all recorded same-position contexts; no reconstructed intact roof was approved.\", \"10413/10414/10416\": \"Brown/grey horizontal wall bands and dark lower recesses preserve original source structure. Complete-family same-position transitions preserve continuous neighbor wall placement while removing the damaged tile structure; charred occupied backing is retained. Cracked masonry and rubble are a detail/material interpretation within the original regions, not a new detached building.\", \"10415\": \"Five original small pale rock groupings and their shadows remain separated at the original positions; chipped grain is accepted as added detail.\", \"10417\": \"Separate pale vertical/horizontal blocks, cyan box, lower grey block and two original animated ember cells preserve source placement; blocks have finer cracks/edges.\", \"10418/10419/1041a/1041b/1041c\": \"Original asymmetric rock masses, peaks, pale ledges and dark lower faces remain identifiable across all scales and authentic contexts. Fine chipped facets/grain are accepted; original state partners remain original artwork.\", \"1041d/1041e/1041f\": \"Original dotted border lines and cross-junction gaps remain aligned. The unchanged high-resolution raw 1041f contains irregular chipped pale fragments, not continuous stone panels. Native scales3/4 retain some square/stipple rhythm because the original one-pixel pale cells occupy very small areas. This disclosed over-literal rhythm is accepted as source placement fidelity after viewing raw and every actual scale, including all native neighbors.\"} {\"historical_job_sha256\": \"c703e6899b27905486538d0622bd111e22845b923c03dae26c87f4a003bb6cd4\", \"current_job_sha256\": \"0f6ab3d989aa9a16e71c9b69bc21e646675f2e4a4755b27fde1f75d1ec4e976d\", \"historical_artifact\": \"frozen/generated/historical-native-job-c703e689-reconstructed.json\", \"historical_retention_scope\": \"Author reconstructed full historical bytes from retained16 per-frame original job copies; exact serialized SHA c703e689 verified independently. This is not claimed to be retained original full-file bytes.\", \"reconstruction_provenance_sha256\": \"0fc2d4cd6479a0a29a6f64eab342cdf9c32ceac4d1d44293fddeaec08e8f38b4\", \"only_semantic_changes\": {\"target_statuses\": [{\"asset\": \"10410\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10411\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10412\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10413\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10414\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10415\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10416\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10417\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10418\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10419\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041a\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041b\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041c\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041d\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041e\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041f\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}], \"status_counts\": {\"before\": {\"inprogress\": 16}, \"after\": {\"candidate\": 16}}}, \"all_sources_geometry_roles_partners_neighbors_samples_and_contracts_exact\": true, \"author_explanation\": \"Shared hd_job_queue.py refreshes status metadata across jobs. Current0f6 job was already frozen before this independent rendering; old author proof remains historical. Neither discrepancy affects raw/frame bindings or terrain context data.\"} [\"Opaque mask IoU1 is trivial and was not used as material or geometry approval. All source/raw/full actual1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 images were visually inspected.\", \"Palette quantization/blockiness remains visible at2/3. New HD ground/rock/metal grain remains denser and sharper beside original fallback tiles; square texture-density boundaries can remain visible in mixed scenes. This approval does not assert uniform whole-mission material or complete HD fallback coverage.\", \"Foreign1040f/104ed/104ee/104f5 remain original in all independently rendered full-family and state scenes. Private HD1040f pack was excluded.\", \"State proof renders declared original source partner substitution at the same recorded position. First4pairs9positions are native target/state contexts; remaining6pairs17positions are explicitly synthetic declared source-state substitutions at authentic intact occurrences. No live destruction timing/reachability or live Host/whole-mission validation is claimed.\", \"Native scene and cardinal corpus comes from canonical supplied source contexts; no invented source occurrences. No new gameplay scrolling/boss assembly test is claimed.\", \"Animated palette240\\u2013255 pixels are legitimate source effects:10410=5,10412=4,10414=8,10417=2. Current loader source-relative class totals expand byscale\\u00b2. Static capture does not prove full palette cycling phases.\", \"Review only; no production manifest/source/art/Git writes, registration or promotion.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 37f5c4b26f9086c3724a4b13249981acf54dfaba4d5a0e7b861a928a50a3f187", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "10410", + "10411", + "10412", + "10413" + ], + "sha256": "dfdf91ff2260f9e5cd5afab1d62ce1182bd399635f3307843138a778f4f65beb", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "10414", + "10415", + "10416", + "10417" + ], + "sha256": "989a797ac864e72c88805fcbdd5b8e494db6c307a75f5facea86bd602a2bd104", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "10418", + "10419", + "1041a", + "1041b" + ], + "sha256": "c2856b9eda30d17110fea211e769ce0adf65b15a3254ff4a57a427ac079197d2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "1041c", + "1041d", + "1041e", + "1041f" + ], + "sha256": "e5cfb639df3fcc47a4533af97884a9163409c2e4db6a0fa59a1fb7e3ad926224", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10410-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac8fc607959f5f14c0b942da5f21fb0f26e3336edd6ff8d352ed6f2b503b8e7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c39bff33a03e8367c725d1bb68613df96c60841e37d5ed3bdac0f2acb9ca18a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e045baa994ac7ea4b62c3e3020ae3266b48b3ef03118282a0918dc1dd2e91aeb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5c181c77cc497bcbd185796574207fe4e89623ce13053ca246c16ee904690812", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b9f1b7fcf833e60b7ade5f3e678896f72c5e78fa85ba6792e7fc78424ebd8958", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cc3fd56d3e61a9d919b9a0b7e67caa0aa932f394d5232477f44c37d48c91b5dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "932c116e449199fc8b4c26e522c73c339bc1fda4e3a6382eb26d25a3366e7174", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1dee0695f73c8701c567fc18ecaa11bf56fa74d6833a34fa7f6dfc92b7ca51b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c3c2129b8f2cd34b744e494087f53ba5691c8dd83849b161b0c59292a9f6cdb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5f1190f320faaaab142e030bef2196496759b6856f0c96a5c2fcd38d5767a390", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9f0e642fd58f9c42103b6f71341ef663c208bfab3ed737a6cb109d147b9077a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "049a788257cb017d0dc19cd5e7c2e03f869b73343ff005d736e98afa977fc878", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cdd053889c26c1f7e66934f6680eb07b5772cbe80632082b4627eb5196f09c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a398fafa05cf760e4907d6e63eaed92193724591cf0d8031e54f440238e423e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52ce7e36ddd901308955a916f87b21a51418658e416615ef23fc08a83d09c70e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4ccaf6751ec10bedbabf226ac52d17ce80d51ff4164b19bb82494123e51f6c92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a1d70e398ae3867c7e2717d1e0d5ac80f7af9356a8c02ad7ebdc034a085f03d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f51f5c4b055955c6e8e9e4803e8ca57ffb833e72d7c93b50cffd421cbcff375", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b9dfb1fa7af5b64bc1f013d4f77d90bd2faa6be226b72f5577f46faee0f654f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-original.ppm", + "sha256": "07815b537b8df019f9a8b3bb100f205b20bdac607b06a3a883674728f51a1961", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "474b5cb2530effe4d8ce79d3b57eda23f795718dfc30fe1591b179e2cde17adc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7c3940d23b448558f7689b1b3171c41a0a99f8b92ccfb62e0fc243523df679fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ccfd3f02fb94e39d606e6b5039dc09a535027f5b1193161af1ad8482a1452c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab016bb7ae2ca976bdec92013b52f2ee0c9a0f249b5998fb63dd3e6d7964b07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-original.ppm", + "sha256": "731d2ad7d40da37dcf6d85fa128aec8f652bb3c5e3a3a1cab7bf97f6ccd55c63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "52ee4577a74f409c5f90aad05f39a8f462f139685398bcb5c92ca0208f0150e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a81c58b827f4533f41f6413a366a8f5e707f8b43039fc823ce9863fb0646e57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3221d17f268e21888a795e88ef677f5219f72a7788e57903fd900f55bbbf3556", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "81ca18fc0aae76a37f36e697efbdc6aa7a56acabfd7e20ce64d0cb5c38ffdaad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a04d2b78a0fe288544345cfbf99e031d1342591773c132de94f1a1a02a828c82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1fa8cb4aa3db5303d7e17c62876e69a352be0e71e34022902b3d5715ff56e4b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "557c5202b8790b5199d326695425b14f2f66b7f4beb101d38dd7b3dec54aa94e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a4ea4b96e7a9a77c54a8fee0f71718baecc64361ed931145badc415eb372ab90", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8797c65adee550343f481e5f5790ffc89b2b133f79bcafe3d67cfdf632cc594a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0f589865a0b7837ea238e4012e2dbb70d8f3b8b165127016fced78e0269b59cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "aaa8bfc0d7576c76523b26dc6ffdb70c966c03fc4f24eb0003cb9fb984f79490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "421cd09e4c241a019cb279c1cecf404f83c892a4bd7dbaa652ceaaea037fbd2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "84414bf8ec17dcfb3608cb42cc586f41fdbff735bc0f5b5d97434d0692424c3e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "83585b540986dd9f78869a8930858bd0dc141b69990b7ad6d91e36b2efc47cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0986dfc3e26d68f0e04195cdf9d1e2b7f5da2cd23b880af56b9384ef963f7c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7588543821be396ed14b6bd3e78bb0c3e079cbe2b94613ad9ab155c7605697bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "72acdde37443a6200d4157882b0d13f182ab41b24f58e3067d104b47488b00cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bb31621cec2f76017cf3f224cc20b0ddd78e126c51a1b8a2f6d4e411fc1d3987", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e0fbc5e011994fd47197aec6f8e662b4816afd311c927b2031f2392ad459ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eb6deecd0c170702e64f0d50f246dd37c12d02c3e21f68fd1d2be8d3fee83348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47acf1e50b2c79375a79cf912e60dcbdf36a1a60de9a826816c2f1559d9869a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd88e0e034a3c6989221dcc7e1993969a120d8436f30b4cec883869b54b4c907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d9171e08c11d28e13c7d5e704a9a8c5b38f56f90e2a9195e7054cc9c5c70c6d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "569a261febe59ad14728c89b23cc8dc5c24c525e8c1777fc4b16a8c6cc8a7a19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-original.ppm", + "sha256": "568481e4973c48993eef1f19374db65ef81246c8f2f1b0541666b8534c827e1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2cb304f42ba13ca5d827403c075d5577fb0bbe462db7988b2c02bf60801ab1f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f486227c734f2925f00ba67e70491f2bc6f38724a2166133fa23197788bb6cdc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e68f73973e511dcbbd6d48a9feeedd02c59cfc336a0228daffb0af67aec23a75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4ef398a88feec37105119dcdc37bab7fa0587b72c684702221829c12182de892", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b2c5dde1e1278d7534e9d7b4d1bf538d43f2e575426fcfe70e70c9cebdb15c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "236cc9a65e1e10ef753cc7316e25ae00e89b25dd5f80f9f35ec4765bc8fd2246", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "93dcfcd8359586da4dc1653e5f139e055d6cd3ec64c5cc004c18b2cf09db1bd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ee030edc5f9bc4ed6e197dbc81561d99798626f2cbe9750f2e8e2a55292e6896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2d32515adf639db9afc206140be51c7de52e74d1c3f3146687bfe6fe4ca4baaa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "63ad4f656faaf16f8f5eabbe8298d9aeb5e0a642d6f23ee4696176da0e3559d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06d2a2a8ac1058499d10e311463dd6835201f001e14345fcb6913c182246a03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0a6814ad21c8b8bf9a11822713f299eda7eed35ff13b710c6cec53b4e15f83eb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c4f962337cfcacc4ea63bb3b6160b40f1c63145b7cf4d750611e731aeb79894", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "424b024a191e23319c0785e1d1a9980d62fa6e593febfafcb9f7c72649e3d14d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26e2a8951641c52a403495952e503bc1017911e8681a96e595b5ece7cfb2e516", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b0cbd4b654d771773680f4f04f96fb65630d04027e484be2346313a1e1cfa82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8b66f6973fc86b3ef08a70a8bef6a397af7a487523956147167099a77f5c99df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "60373b77be34a563be55f6c85aba51fa41c47e2ccab98b16fb5b27a30d6ef1f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "606804f250f7244c0d6ed1b2646798104a885be8da8e993d5e154dd6dcaef12f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e1c234832095bcb0724c60c030b34a0d9994361dff8ecf5bc9c0cd256a66024e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c8c90b8af19dc87065ff61cb9aea1481b33c4d58d051a91ff6e37fd516a5a3b5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b1875fffa16d39852af9d76ad362a705660166359f4a0d056c90e4fe5c3516c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a69bca1ff1997e749b9994a4b186bc6c381070292d3ec38b0aca0ce21f8ebdcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ef96b177a79477741a94979f135364b814764b6a717809947c08f8b4d2de232", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "38cd254a04df76a5439136d51ae7c4a60bc02c23eadfd671e8bd7c5222ac7410", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2393ddef6f77d0f58cf018dc11bc4372f4783513e92726536a7aec53f6471d56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acded7cffcd4762f83293964eb7cea418769f251ce5f4de0feb8e54e16be156f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "edb024afb9c5b2bc80b0a9b13f8fa52ac69a302ab43d910026d58e66c53bc1a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36ee8a23a83692aa4f2741be3f1125e9b005adb130b893cb804c8d85fdeccc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cf5c9c74844d1ed57b443a3c02d305dbd234e7b6a5acba984b2e732e42825f67", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "1041a": { @@ -136791,7 +145601,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1041a", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -136807,6 +145617,467 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", "sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eeac825831b65f3085ee3a93cde1178da43f46775d29db1ec47f6c416d09f6e8", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.866714+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"10410/10411/10412\": \"Wide/tall corrugated roof geometry, side posts, surviving broken metal strips, charred openings and original ember placements remain source-relative. Both new wrecks were compared with authentic intact source partners at all recorded same-position contexts; no reconstructed intact roof was approved.\", \"10413/10414/10416\": \"Brown/grey horizontal wall bands and dark lower recesses preserve original source structure. Complete-family same-position transitions preserve continuous neighbor wall placement while removing the damaged tile structure; charred occupied backing is retained. Cracked masonry and rubble are a detail/material interpretation within the original regions, not a new detached building.\", \"10415\": \"Five original small pale rock groupings and their shadows remain separated at the original positions; chipped grain is accepted as added detail.\", \"10417\": \"Separate pale vertical/horizontal blocks, cyan box, lower grey block and two original animated ember cells preserve source placement; blocks have finer cracks/edges.\", \"10418/10419/1041a/1041b/1041c\": \"Original asymmetric rock masses, peaks, pale ledges and dark lower faces remain identifiable across all scales and authentic contexts. Fine chipped facets/grain are accepted; original state partners remain original artwork.\", \"1041d/1041e/1041f\": \"Original dotted border lines and cross-junction gaps remain aligned. The unchanged high-resolution raw 1041f contains irregular chipped pale fragments, not continuous stone panels. Native scales3/4 retain some square/stipple rhythm because the original one-pixel pale cells occupy very small areas. This disclosed over-literal rhythm is accepted as source placement fidelity after viewing raw and every actual scale, including all native neighbors.\"} {\"historical_job_sha256\": \"c703e6899b27905486538d0622bd111e22845b923c03dae26c87f4a003bb6cd4\", \"current_job_sha256\": \"0f6ab3d989aa9a16e71c9b69bc21e646675f2e4a4755b27fde1f75d1ec4e976d\", \"historical_artifact\": \"frozen/generated/historical-native-job-c703e689-reconstructed.json\", \"historical_retention_scope\": \"Author reconstructed full historical bytes from retained16 per-frame original job copies; exact serialized SHA c703e689 verified independently. This is not claimed to be retained original full-file bytes.\", \"reconstruction_provenance_sha256\": \"0fc2d4cd6479a0a29a6f64eab342cdf9c32ceac4d1d44293fddeaec08e8f38b4\", \"only_semantic_changes\": {\"target_statuses\": [{\"asset\": \"10410\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10411\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10412\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10413\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10414\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10415\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10416\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10417\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10418\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10419\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041a\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041b\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041c\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041d\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041e\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041f\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}], \"status_counts\": {\"before\": {\"inprogress\": 16}, \"after\": {\"candidate\": 16}}}, \"all_sources_geometry_roles_partners_neighbors_samples_and_contracts_exact\": true, \"author_explanation\": \"Shared hd_job_queue.py refreshes status metadata across jobs. Current0f6 job was already frozen before this independent rendering; old author proof remains historical. Neither discrepancy affects raw/frame bindings or terrain context data.\"} [\"Opaque mask IoU1 is trivial and was not used as material or geometry approval. All source/raw/full actual1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 images were visually inspected.\", \"Palette quantization/blockiness remains visible at2/3. New HD ground/rock/metal grain remains denser and sharper beside original fallback tiles; square texture-density boundaries can remain visible in mixed scenes. This approval does not assert uniform whole-mission material or complete HD fallback coverage.\", \"Foreign1040f/104ed/104ee/104f5 remain original in all independently rendered full-family and state scenes. Private HD1040f pack was excluded.\", \"State proof renders declared original source partner substitution at the same recorded position. First4pairs9positions are native target/state contexts; remaining6pairs17positions are explicitly synthetic declared source-state substitutions at authentic intact occurrences. No live destruction timing/reachability or live Host/whole-mission validation is claimed.\", \"Native scene and cardinal corpus comes from canonical supplied source contexts; no invented source occurrences. No new gameplay scrolling/boss assembly test is claimed.\", \"Animated palette240\\u2013255 pixels are legitimate source effects:10410=5,10412=4,10414=8,10417=2. Current loader source-relative class totals expand byscale\\u00b2. Static capture does not prove full palette cycling phases.\", \"Review only; no production manifest/source/art/Git writes, registration or promotion.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 37f5c4b26f9086c3724a4b13249981acf54dfaba4d5a0e7b861a928a50a3f187", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "10410", + "10411", + "10412", + "10413" + ], + "sha256": "dfdf91ff2260f9e5cd5afab1d62ce1182bd399635f3307843138a778f4f65beb", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "10414", + "10415", + "10416", + "10417" + ], + "sha256": "989a797ac864e72c88805fcbdd5b8e494db6c307a75f5facea86bd602a2bd104", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "10418", + "10419", + "1041a", + "1041b" + ], + "sha256": "c2856b9eda30d17110fea211e769ce0adf65b15a3254ff4a57a427ac079197d2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "1041c", + "1041d", + "1041e", + "1041f" + ], + "sha256": "e5cfb639df3fcc47a4533af97884a9163409c2e4db6a0fa59a1fb7e3ad926224", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10410-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac8fc607959f5f14c0b942da5f21fb0f26e3336edd6ff8d352ed6f2b503b8e7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c39bff33a03e8367c725d1bb68613df96c60841e37d5ed3bdac0f2acb9ca18a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e045baa994ac7ea4b62c3e3020ae3266b48b3ef03118282a0918dc1dd2e91aeb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5c181c77cc497bcbd185796574207fe4e89623ce13053ca246c16ee904690812", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b9f1b7fcf833e60b7ade5f3e678896f72c5e78fa85ba6792e7fc78424ebd8958", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cc3fd56d3e61a9d919b9a0b7e67caa0aa932f394d5232477f44c37d48c91b5dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "932c116e449199fc8b4c26e522c73c339bc1fda4e3a6382eb26d25a3366e7174", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1dee0695f73c8701c567fc18ecaa11bf56fa74d6833a34fa7f6dfc92b7ca51b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c3c2129b8f2cd34b744e494087f53ba5691c8dd83849b161b0c59292a9f6cdb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5f1190f320faaaab142e030bef2196496759b6856f0c96a5c2fcd38d5767a390", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9f0e642fd58f9c42103b6f71341ef663c208bfab3ed737a6cb109d147b9077a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "049a788257cb017d0dc19cd5e7c2e03f869b73343ff005d736e98afa977fc878", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cdd053889c26c1f7e66934f6680eb07b5772cbe80632082b4627eb5196f09c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a398fafa05cf760e4907d6e63eaed92193724591cf0d8031e54f440238e423e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52ce7e36ddd901308955a916f87b21a51418658e416615ef23fc08a83d09c70e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4ccaf6751ec10bedbabf226ac52d17ce80d51ff4164b19bb82494123e51f6c92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a1d70e398ae3867c7e2717d1e0d5ac80f7af9356a8c02ad7ebdc034a085f03d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f51f5c4b055955c6e8e9e4803e8ca57ffb833e72d7c93b50cffd421cbcff375", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b9dfb1fa7af5b64bc1f013d4f77d90bd2faa6be226b72f5577f46faee0f654f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-original.ppm", + "sha256": "07815b537b8df019f9a8b3bb100f205b20bdac607b06a3a883674728f51a1961", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "474b5cb2530effe4d8ce79d3b57eda23f795718dfc30fe1591b179e2cde17adc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7c3940d23b448558f7689b1b3171c41a0a99f8b92ccfb62e0fc243523df679fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ccfd3f02fb94e39d606e6b5039dc09a535027f5b1193161af1ad8482a1452c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab016bb7ae2ca976bdec92013b52f2ee0c9a0f249b5998fb63dd3e6d7964b07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-original.ppm", + "sha256": "731d2ad7d40da37dcf6d85fa128aec8f652bb3c5e3a3a1cab7bf97f6ccd55c63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "52ee4577a74f409c5f90aad05f39a8f462f139685398bcb5c92ca0208f0150e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a81c58b827f4533f41f6413a366a8f5e707f8b43039fc823ce9863fb0646e57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3221d17f268e21888a795e88ef677f5219f72a7788e57903fd900f55bbbf3556", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "81ca18fc0aae76a37f36e697efbdc6aa7a56acabfd7e20ce64d0cb5c38ffdaad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a04d2b78a0fe288544345cfbf99e031d1342591773c132de94f1a1a02a828c82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1fa8cb4aa3db5303d7e17c62876e69a352be0e71e34022902b3d5715ff56e4b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "557c5202b8790b5199d326695425b14f2f66b7f4beb101d38dd7b3dec54aa94e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a4ea4b96e7a9a77c54a8fee0f71718baecc64361ed931145badc415eb372ab90", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8797c65adee550343f481e5f5790ffc89b2b133f79bcafe3d67cfdf632cc594a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0f589865a0b7837ea238e4012e2dbb70d8f3b8b165127016fced78e0269b59cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "aaa8bfc0d7576c76523b26dc6ffdb70c966c03fc4f24eb0003cb9fb984f79490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "421cd09e4c241a019cb279c1cecf404f83c892a4bd7dbaa652ceaaea037fbd2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "84414bf8ec17dcfb3608cb42cc586f41fdbff735bc0f5b5d97434d0692424c3e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "83585b540986dd9f78869a8930858bd0dc141b69990b7ad6d91e36b2efc47cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0986dfc3e26d68f0e04195cdf9d1e2b7f5da2cd23b880af56b9384ef963f7c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7588543821be396ed14b6bd3e78bb0c3e079cbe2b94613ad9ab155c7605697bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "72acdde37443a6200d4157882b0d13f182ab41b24f58e3067d104b47488b00cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bb31621cec2f76017cf3f224cc20b0ddd78e126c51a1b8a2f6d4e411fc1d3987", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e0fbc5e011994fd47197aec6f8e662b4816afd311c927b2031f2392ad459ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eb6deecd0c170702e64f0d50f246dd37c12d02c3e21f68fd1d2be8d3fee83348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47acf1e50b2c79375a79cf912e60dcbdf36a1a60de9a826816c2f1559d9869a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd88e0e034a3c6989221dcc7e1993969a120d8436f30b4cec883869b54b4c907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d9171e08c11d28e13c7d5e704a9a8c5b38f56f90e2a9195e7054cc9c5c70c6d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "569a261febe59ad14728c89b23cc8dc5c24c525e8c1777fc4b16a8c6cc8a7a19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-original.ppm", + "sha256": "568481e4973c48993eef1f19374db65ef81246c8f2f1b0541666b8534c827e1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2cb304f42ba13ca5d827403c075d5577fb0bbe462db7988b2c02bf60801ab1f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f486227c734f2925f00ba67e70491f2bc6f38724a2166133fa23197788bb6cdc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e68f73973e511dcbbd6d48a9feeedd02c59cfc336a0228daffb0af67aec23a75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4ef398a88feec37105119dcdc37bab7fa0587b72c684702221829c12182de892", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b2c5dde1e1278d7534e9d7b4d1bf538d43f2e575426fcfe70e70c9cebdb15c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "236cc9a65e1e10ef753cc7316e25ae00e89b25dd5f80f9f35ec4765bc8fd2246", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "93dcfcd8359586da4dc1653e5f139e055d6cd3ec64c5cc004c18b2cf09db1bd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ee030edc5f9bc4ed6e197dbc81561d99798626f2cbe9750f2e8e2a55292e6896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2d32515adf639db9afc206140be51c7de52e74d1c3f3146687bfe6fe4ca4baaa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "63ad4f656faaf16f8f5eabbe8298d9aeb5e0a642d6f23ee4696176da0e3559d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06d2a2a8ac1058499d10e311463dd6835201f001e14345fcb6913c182246a03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0a6814ad21c8b8bf9a11822713f299eda7eed35ff13b710c6cec53b4e15f83eb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c4f962337cfcacc4ea63bb3b6160b40f1c63145b7cf4d750611e731aeb79894", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "424b024a191e23319c0785e1d1a9980d62fa6e593febfafcb9f7c72649e3d14d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26e2a8951641c52a403495952e503bc1017911e8681a96e595b5ece7cfb2e516", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b0cbd4b654d771773680f4f04f96fb65630d04027e484be2346313a1e1cfa82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8b66f6973fc86b3ef08a70a8bef6a397af7a487523956147167099a77f5c99df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "60373b77be34a563be55f6c85aba51fa41c47e2ccab98b16fb5b27a30d6ef1f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "606804f250f7244c0d6ed1b2646798104a885be8da8e993d5e154dd6dcaef12f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e1c234832095bcb0724c60c030b34a0d9994361dff8ecf5bc9c0cd256a66024e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c8c90b8af19dc87065ff61cb9aea1481b33c4d58d051a91ff6e37fd516a5a3b5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b1875fffa16d39852af9d76ad362a705660166359f4a0d056c90e4fe5c3516c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a69bca1ff1997e749b9994a4b186bc6c381070292d3ec38b0aca0ce21f8ebdcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ef96b177a79477741a94979f135364b814764b6a717809947c08f8b4d2de232", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "38cd254a04df76a5439136d51ae7c4a60bc02c23eadfd671e8bd7c5222ac7410", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2393ddef6f77d0f58cf018dc11bc4372f4783513e92726536a7aec53f6471d56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acded7cffcd4762f83293964eb7cea418769f251ce5f4de0feb8e54e16be156f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "edb024afb9c5b2bc80b0a9b13f8fa52ac69a302ab43d910026d58e66c53bc1a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36ee8a23a83692aa4f2741be3f1125e9b005adb130b893cb804c8d85fdeccc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cf5c9c74844d1ed57b443a3c02d305dbd234e7b6a5acba984b2e732e42825f67", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "1041b": { @@ -136828,7 +146099,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1041b", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -136844,6 +146115,467 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", "sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eeac825831b65f3085ee3a93cde1178da43f46775d29db1ec47f6c416d09f6e8", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.866714+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"10410/10411/10412\": \"Wide/tall corrugated roof geometry, side posts, surviving broken metal strips, charred openings and original ember placements remain source-relative. Both new wrecks were compared with authentic intact source partners at all recorded same-position contexts; no reconstructed intact roof was approved.\", \"10413/10414/10416\": \"Brown/grey horizontal wall bands and dark lower recesses preserve original source structure. Complete-family same-position transitions preserve continuous neighbor wall placement while removing the damaged tile structure; charred occupied backing is retained. Cracked masonry and rubble are a detail/material interpretation within the original regions, not a new detached building.\", \"10415\": \"Five original small pale rock groupings and their shadows remain separated at the original positions; chipped grain is accepted as added detail.\", \"10417\": \"Separate pale vertical/horizontal blocks, cyan box, lower grey block and two original animated ember cells preserve source placement; blocks have finer cracks/edges.\", \"10418/10419/1041a/1041b/1041c\": \"Original asymmetric rock masses, peaks, pale ledges and dark lower faces remain identifiable across all scales and authentic contexts. Fine chipped facets/grain are accepted; original state partners remain original artwork.\", \"1041d/1041e/1041f\": \"Original dotted border lines and cross-junction gaps remain aligned. The unchanged high-resolution raw 1041f contains irregular chipped pale fragments, not continuous stone panels. Native scales3/4 retain some square/stipple rhythm because the original one-pixel pale cells occupy very small areas. This disclosed over-literal rhythm is accepted as source placement fidelity after viewing raw and every actual scale, including all native neighbors.\"} {\"historical_job_sha256\": \"c703e6899b27905486538d0622bd111e22845b923c03dae26c87f4a003bb6cd4\", \"current_job_sha256\": \"0f6ab3d989aa9a16e71c9b69bc21e646675f2e4a4755b27fde1f75d1ec4e976d\", \"historical_artifact\": \"frozen/generated/historical-native-job-c703e689-reconstructed.json\", \"historical_retention_scope\": \"Author reconstructed full historical bytes from retained16 per-frame original job copies; exact serialized SHA c703e689 verified independently. This is not claimed to be retained original full-file bytes.\", \"reconstruction_provenance_sha256\": \"0fc2d4cd6479a0a29a6f64eab342cdf9c32ceac4d1d44293fddeaec08e8f38b4\", \"only_semantic_changes\": {\"target_statuses\": [{\"asset\": \"10410\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10411\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10412\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10413\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10414\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10415\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10416\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10417\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10418\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10419\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041a\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041b\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041c\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041d\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041e\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041f\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}], \"status_counts\": {\"before\": {\"inprogress\": 16}, \"after\": {\"candidate\": 16}}}, \"all_sources_geometry_roles_partners_neighbors_samples_and_contracts_exact\": true, \"author_explanation\": \"Shared hd_job_queue.py refreshes status metadata across jobs. Current0f6 job was already frozen before this independent rendering; old author proof remains historical. Neither discrepancy affects raw/frame bindings or terrain context data.\"} [\"Opaque mask IoU1 is trivial and was not used as material or geometry approval. All source/raw/full actual1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 images were visually inspected.\", \"Palette quantization/blockiness remains visible at2/3. New HD ground/rock/metal grain remains denser and sharper beside original fallback tiles; square texture-density boundaries can remain visible in mixed scenes. This approval does not assert uniform whole-mission material or complete HD fallback coverage.\", \"Foreign1040f/104ed/104ee/104f5 remain original in all independently rendered full-family and state scenes. Private HD1040f pack was excluded.\", \"State proof renders declared original source partner substitution at the same recorded position. First4pairs9positions are native target/state contexts; remaining6pairs17positions are explicitly synthetic declared source-state substitutions at authentic intact occurrences. No live destruction timing/reachability or live Host/whole-mission validation is claimed.\", \"Native scene and cardinal corpus comes from canonical supplied source contexts; no invented source occurrences. No new gameplay scrolling/boss assembly test is claimed.\", \"Animated palette240\\u2013255 pixels are legitimate source effects:10410=5,10412=4,10414=8,10417=2. Current loader source-relative class totals expand byscale\\u00b2. Static capture does not prove full palette cycling phases.\", \"Review only; no production manifest/source/art/Git writes, registration or promotion.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 37f5c4b26f9086c3724a4b13249981acf54dfaba4d5a0e7b861a928a50a3f187", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "10410", + "10411", + "10412", + "10413" + ], + "sha256": "dfdf91ff2260f9e5cd5afab1d62ce1182bd399635f3307843138a778f4f65beb", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "10414", + "10415", + "10416", + "10417" + ], + "sha256": "989a797ac864e72c88805fcbdd5b8e494db6c307a75f5facea86bd602a2bd104", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "10418", + "10419", + "1041a", + "1041b" + ], + "sha256": "c2856b9eda30d17110fea211e769ce0adf65b15a3254ff4a57a427ac079197d2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "1041c", + "1041d", + "1041e", + "1041f" + ], + "sha256": "e5cfb639df3fcc47a4533af97884a9163409c2e4db6a0fa59a1fb7e3ad926224", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10410-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac8fc607959f5f14c0b942da5f21fb0f26e3336edd6ff8d352ed6f2b503b8e7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c39bff33a03e8367c725d1bb68613df96c60841e37d5ed3bdac0f2acb9ca18a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e045baa994ac7ea4b62c3e3020ae3266b48b3ef03118282a0918dc1dd2e91aeb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5c181c77cc497bcbd185796574207fe4e89623ce13053ca246c16ee904690812", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b9f1b7fcf833e60b7ade5f3e678896f72c5e78fa85ba6792e7fc78424ebd8958", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cc3fd56d3e61a9d919b9a0b7e67caa0aa932f394d5232477f44c37d48c91b5dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "932c116e449199fc8b4c26e522c73c339bc1fda4e3a6382eb26d25a3366e7174", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1dee0695f73c8701c567fc18ecaa11bf56fa74d6833a34fa7f6dfc92b7ca51b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c3c2129b8f2cd34b744e494087f53ba5691c8dd83849b161b0c59292a9f6cdb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5f1190f320faaaab142e030bef2196496759b6856f0c96a5c2fcd38d5767a390", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9f0e642fd58f9c42103b6f71341ef663c208bfab3ed737a6cb109d147b9077a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "049a788257cb017d0dc19cd5e7c2e03f869b73343ff005d736e98afa977fc878", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cdd053889c26c1f7e66934f6680eb07b5772cbe80632082b4627eb5196f09c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a398fafa05cf760e4907d6e63eaed92193724591cf0d8031e54f440238e423e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52ce7e36ddd901308955a916f87b21a51418658e416615ef23fc08a83d09c70e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4ccaf6751ec10bedbabf226ac52d17ce80d51ff4164b19bb82494123e51f6c92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a1d70e398ae3867c7e2717d1e0d5ac80f7af9356a8c02ad7ebdc034a085f03d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f51f5c4b055955c6e8e9e4803e8ca57ffb833e72d7c93b50cffd421cbcff375", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b9dfb1fa7af5b64bc1f013d4f77d90bd2faa6be226b72f5577f46faee0f654f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-original.ppm", + "sha256": "07815b537b8df019f9a8b3bb100f205b20bdac607b06a3a883674728f51a1961", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "474b5cb2530effe4d8ce79d3b57eda23f795718dfc30fe1591b179e2cde17adc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7c3940d23b448558f7689b1b3171c41a0a99f8b92ccfb62e0fc243523df679fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ccfd3f02fb94e39d606e6b5039dc09a535027f5b1193161af1ad8482a1452c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab016bb7ae2ca976bdec92013b52f2ee0c9a0f249b5998fb63dd3e6d7964b07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-original.ppm", + "sha256": "731d2ad7d40da37dcf6d85fa128aec8f652bb3c5e3a3a1cab7bf97f6ccd55c63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "52ee4577a74f409c5f90aad05f39a8f462f139685398bcb5c92ca0208f0150e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a81c58b827f4533f41f6413a366a8f5e707f8b43039fc823ce9863fb0646e57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3221d17f268e21888a795e88ef677f5219f72a7788e57903fd900f55bbbf3556", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "81ca18fc0aae76a37f36e697efbdc6aa7a56acabfd7e20ce64d0cb5c38ffdaad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a04d2b78a0fe288544345cfbf99e031d1342591773c132de94f1a1a02a828c82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1fa8cb4aa3db5303d7e17c62876e69a352be0e71e34022902b3d5715ff56e4b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "557c5202b8790b5199d326695425b14f2f66b7f4beb101d38dd7b3dec54aa94e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a4ea4b96e7a9a77c54a8fee0f71718baecc64361ed931145badc415eb372ab90", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8797c65adee550343f481e5f5790ffc89b2b133f79bcafe3d67cfdf632cc594a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0f589865a0b7837ea238e4012e2dbb70d8f3b8b165127016fced78e0269b59cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "aaa8bfc0d7576c76523b26dc6ffdb70c966c03fc4f24eb0003cb9fb984f79490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "421cd09e4c241a019cb279c1cecf404f83c892a4bd7dbaa652ceaaea037fbd2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "84414bf8ec17dcfb3608cb42cc586f41fdbff735bc0f5b5d97434d0692424c3e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "83585b540986dd9f78869a8930858bd0dc141b69990b7ad6d91e36b2efc47cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0986dfc3e26d68f0e04195cdf9d1e2b7f5da2cd23b880af56b9384ef963f7c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7588543821be396ed14b6bd3e78bb0c3e079cbe2b94613ad9ab155c7605697bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "72acdde37443a6200d4157882b0d13f182ab41b24f58e3067d104b47488b00cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bb31621cec2f76017cf3f224cc20b0ddd78e126c51a1b8a2f6d4e411fc1d3987", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e0fbc5e011994fd47197aec6f8e662b4816afd311c927b2031f2392ad459ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eb6deecd0c170702e64f0d50f246dd37c12d02c3e21f68fd1d2be8d3fee83348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47acf1e50b2c79375a79cf912e60dcbdf36a1a60de9a826816c2f1559d9869a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd88e0e034a3c6989221dcc7e1993969a120d8436f30b4cec883869b54b4c907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d9171e08c11d28e13c7d5e704a9a8c5b38f56f90e2a9195e7054cc9c5c70c6d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "569a261febe59ad14728c89b23cc8dc5c24c525e8c1777fc4b16a8c6cc8a7a19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-original.ppm", + "sha256": "568481e4973c48993eef1f19374db65ef81246c8f2f1b0541666b8534c827e1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2cb304f42ba13ca5d827403c075d5577fb0bbe462db7988b2c02bf60801ab1f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f486227c734f2925f00ba67e70491f2bc6f38724a2166133fa23197788bb6cdc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e68f73973e511dcbbd6d48a9feeedd02c59cfc336a0228daffb0af67aec23a75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4ef398a88feec37105119dcdc37bab7fa0587b72c684702221829c12182de892", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b2c5dde1e1278d7534e9d7b4d1bf538d43f2e575426fcfe70e70c9cebdb15c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "236cc9a65e1e10ef753cc7316e25ae00e89b25dd5f80f9f35ec4765bc8fd2246", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "93dcfcd8359586da4dc1653e5f139e055d6cd3ec64c5cc004c18b2cf09db1bd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ee030edc5f9bc4ed6e197dbc81561d99798626f2cbe9750f2e8e2a55292e6896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2d32515adf639db9afc206140be51c7de52e74d1c3f3146687bfe6fe4ca4baaa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "63ad4f656faaf16f8f5eabbe8298d9aeb5e0a642d6f23ee4696176da0e3559d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06d2a2a8ac1058499d10e311463dd6835201f001e14345fcb6913c182246a03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0a6814ad21c8b8bf9a11822713f299eda7eed35ff13b710c6cec53b4e15f83eb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c4f962337cfcacc4ea63bb3b6160b40f1c63145b7cf4d750611e731aeb79894", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "424b024a191e23319c0785e1d1a9980d62fa6e593febfafcb9f7c72649e3d14d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26e2a8951641c52a403495952e503bc1017911e8681a96e595b5ece7cfb2e516", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b0cbd4b654d771773680f4f04f96fb65630d04027e484be2346313a1e1cfa82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8b66f6973fc86b3ef08a70a8bef6a397af7a487523956147167099a77f5c99df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "60373b77be34a563be55f6c85aba51fa41c47e2ccab98b16fb5b27a30d6ef1f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "606804f250f7244c0d6ed1b2646798104a885be8da8e993d5e154dd6dcaef12f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e1c234832095bcb0724c60c030b34a0d9994361dff8ecf5bc9c0cd256a66024e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c8c90b8af19dc87065ff61cb9aea1481b33c4d58d051a91ff6e37fd516a5a3b5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b1875fffa16d39852af9d76ad362a705660166359f4a0d056c90e4fe5c3516c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a69bca1ff1997e749b9994a4b186bc6c381070292d3ec38b0aca0ce21f8ebdcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ef96b177a79477741a94979f135364b814764b6a717809947c08f8b4d2de232", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "38cd254a04df76a5439136d51ae7c4a60bc02c23eadfd671e8bd7c5222ac7410", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2393ddef6f77d0f58cf018dc11bc4372f4783513e92726536a7aec53f6471d56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acded7cffcd4762f83293964eb7cea418769f251ce5f4de0feb8e54e16be156f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "edb024afb9c5b2bc80b0a9b13f8fa52ac69a302ab43d910026d58e66c53bc1a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36ee8a23a83692aa4f2741be3f1125e9b005adb130b893cb804c8d85fdeccc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cf5c9c74844d1ed57b443a3c02d305dbd234e7b6a5acba984b2e732e42825f67", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "1041c": { @@ -136865,7 +146597,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1041c", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -136881,6 +146613,467 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", "sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eeac825831b65f3085ee3a93cde1178da43f46775d29db1ec47f6c416d09f6e8", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.866714+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"10410/10411/10412\": \"Wide/tall corrugated roof geometry, side posts, surviving broken metal strips, charred openings and original ember placements remain source-relative. Both new wrecks were compared with authentic intact source partners at all recorded same-position contexts; no reconstructed intact roof was approved.\", \"10413/10414/10416\": \"Brown/grey horizontal wall bands and dark lower recesses preserve original source structure. Complete-family same-position transitions preserve continuous neighbor wall placement while removing the damaged tile structure; charred occupied backing is retained. Cracked masonry and rubble are a detail/material interpretation within the original regions, not a new detached building.\", \"10415\": \"Five original small pale rock groupings and their shadows remain separated at the original positions; chipped grain is accepted as added detail.\", \"10417\": \"Separate pale vertical/horizontal blocks, cyan box, lower grey block and two original animated ember cells preserve source placement; blocks have finer cracks/edges.\", \"10418/10419/1041a/1041b/1041c\": \"Original asymmetric rock masses, peaks, pale ledges and dark lower faces remain identifiable across all scales and authentic contexts. Fine chipped facets/grain are accepted; original state partners remain original artwork.\", \"1041d/1041e/1041f\": \"Original dotted border lines and cross-junction gaps remain aligned. The unchanged high-resolution raw 1041f contains irregular chipped pale fragments, not continuous stone panels. Native scales3/4 retain some square/stipple rhythm because the original one-pixel pale cells occupy very small areas. This disclosed over-literal rhythm is accepted as source placement fidelity after viewing raw and every actual scale, including all native neighbors.\"} {\"historical_job_sha256\": \"c703e6899b27905486538d0622bd111e22845b923c03dae26c87f4a003bb6cd4\", \"current_job_sha256\": \"0f6ab3d989aa9a16e71c9b69bc21e646675f2e4a4755b27fde1f75d1ec4e976d\", \"historical_artifact\": \"frozen/generated/historical-native-job-c703e689-reconstructed.json\", \"historical_retention_scope\": \"Author reconstructed full historical bytes from retained16 per-frame original job copies; exact serialized SHA c703e689 verified independently. This is not claimed to be retained original full-file bytes.\", \"reconstruction_provenance_sha256\": \"0fc2d4cd6479a0a29a6f64eab342cdf9c32ceac4d1d44293fddeaec08e8f38b4\", \"only_semantic_changes\": {\"target_statuses\": [{\"asset\": \"10410\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10411\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10412\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10413\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10414\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10415\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10416\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10417\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10418\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10419\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041a\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041b\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041c\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041d\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041e\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041f\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}], \"status_counts\": {\"before\": {\"inprogress\": 16}, \"after\": {\"candidate\": 16}}}, \"all_sources_geometry_roles_partners_neighbors_samples_and_contracts_exact\": true, \"author_explanation\": \"Shared hd_job_queue.py refreshes status metadata across jobs. Current0f6 job was already frozen before this independent rendering; old author proof remains historical. Neither discrepancy affects raw/frame bindings or terrain context data.\"} [\"Opaque mask IoU1 is trivial and was not used as material or geometry approval. All source/raw/full actual1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 images were visually inspected.\", \"Palette quantization/blockiness remains visible at2/3. New HD ground/rock/metal grain remains denser and sharper beside original fallback tiles; square texture-density boundaries can remain visible in mixed scenes. This approval does not assert uniform whole-mission material or complete HD fallback coverage.\", \"Foreign1040f/104ed/104ee/104f5 remain original in all independently rendered full-family and state scenes. Private HD1040f pack was excluded.\", \"State proof renders declared original source partner substitution at the same recorded position. First4pairs9positions are native target/state contexts; remaining6pairs17positions are explicitly synthetic declared source-state substitutions at authentic intact occurrences. No live destruction timing/reachability or live Host/whole-mission validation is claimed.\", \"Native scene and cardinal corpus comes from canonical supplied source contexts; no invented source occurrences. No new gameplay scrolling/boss assembly test is claimed.\", \"Animated palette240\\u2013255 pixels are legitimate source effects:10410=5,10412=4,10414=8,10417=2. Current loader source-relative class totals expand byscale\\u00b2. Static capture does not prove full palette cycling phases.\", \"Review only; no production manifest/source/art/Git writes, registration or promotion.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 37f5c4b26f9086c3724a4b13249981acf54dfaba4d5a0e7b861a928a50a3f187", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "10410", + "10411", + "10412", + "10413" + ], + "sha256": "dfdf91ff2260f9e5cd5afab1d62ce1182bd399635f3307843138a778f4f65beb", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "10414", + "10415", + "10416", + "10417" + ], + "sha256": "989a797ac864e72c88805fcbdd5b8e494db6c307a75f5facea86bd602a2bd104", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "10418", + "10419", + "1041a", + "1041b" + ], + "sha256": "c2856b9eda30d17110fea211e769ce0adf65b15a3254ff4a57a427ac079197d2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "1041c", + "1041d", + "1041e", + "1041f" + ], + "sha256": "e5cfb639df3fcc47a4533af97884a9163409c2e4db6a0fa59a1fb7e3ad926224", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10410-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac8fc607959f5f14c0b942da5f21fb0f26e3336edd6ff8d352ed6f2b503b8e7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c39bff33a03e8367c725d1bb68613df96c60841e37d5ed3bdac0f2acb9ca18a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e045baa994ac7ea4b62c3e3020ae3266b48b3ef03118282a0918dc1dd2e91aeb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5c181c77cc497bcbd185796574207fe4e89623ce13053ca246c16ee904690812", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b9f1b7fcf833e60b7ade5f3e678896f72c5e78fa85ba6792e7fc78424ebd8958", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cc3fd56d3e61a9d919b9a0b7e67caa0aa932f394d5232477f44c37d48c91b5dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "932c116e449199fc8b4c26e522c73c339bc1fda4e3a6382eb26d25a3366e7174", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1dee0695f73c8701c567fc18ecaa11bf56fa74d6833a34fa7f6dfc92b7ca51b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c3c2129b8f2cd34b744e494087f53ba5691c8dd83849b161b0c59292a9f6cdb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5f1190f320faaaab142e030bef2196496759b6856f0c96a5c2fcd38d5767a390", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9f0e642fd58f9c42103b6f71341ef663c208bfab3ed737a6cb109d147b9077a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "049a788257cb017d0dc19cd5e7c2e03f869b73343ff005d736e98afa977fc878", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cdd053889c26c1f7e66934f6680eb07b5772cbe80632082b4627eb5196f09c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a398fafa05cf760e4907d6e63eaed92193724591cf0d8031e54f440238e423e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52ce7e36ddd901308955a916f87b21a51418658e416615ef23fc08a83d09c70e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4ccaf6751ec10bedbabf226ac52d17ce80d51ff4164b19bb82494123e51f6c92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a1d70e398ae3867c7e2717d1e0d5ac80f7af9356a8c02ad7ebdc034a085f03d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f51f5c4b055955c6e8e9e4803e8ca57ffb833e72d7c93b50cffd421cbcff375", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b9dfb1fa7af5b64bc1f013d4f77d90bd2faa6be226b72f5577f46faee0f654f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-original.ppm", + "sha256": "07815b537b8df019f9a8b3bb100f205b20bdac607b06a3a883674728f51a1961", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "474b5cb2530effe4d8ce79d3b57eda23f795718dfc30fe1591b179e2cde17adc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7c3940d23b448558f7689b1b3171c41a0a99f8b92ccfb62e0fc243523df679fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ccfd3f02fb94e39d606e6b5039dc09a535027f5b1193161af1ad8482a1452c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab016bb7ae2ca976bdec92013b52f2ee0c9a0f249b5998fb63dd3e6d7964b07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-original.ppm", + "sha256": "731d2ad7d40da37dcf6d85fa128aec8f652bb3c5e3a3a1cab7bf97f6ccd55c63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "52ee4577a74f409c5f90aad05f39a8f462f139685398bcb5c92ca0208f0150e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a81c58b827f4533f41f6413a366a8f5e707f8b43039fc823ce9863fb0646e57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3221d17f268e21888a795e88ef677f5219f72a7788e57903fd900f55bbbf3556", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "81ca18fc0aae76a37f36e697efbdc6aa7a56acabfd7e20ce64d0cb5c38ffdaad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a04d2b78a0fe288544345cfbf99e031d1342591773c132de94f1a1a02a828c82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1fa8cb4aa3db5303d7e17c62876e69a352be0e71e34022902b3d5715ff56e4b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "557c5202b8790b5199d326695425b14f2f66b7f4beb101d38dd7b3dec54aa94e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a4ea4b96e7a9a77c54a8fee0f71718baecc64361ed931145badc415eb372ab90", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8797c65adee550343f481e5f5790ffc89b2b133f79bcafe3d67cfdf632cc594a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0f589865a0b7837ea238e4012e2dbb70d8f3b8b165127016fced78e0269b59cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "aaa8bfc0d7576c76523b26dc6ffdb70c966c03fc4f24eb0003cb9fb984f79490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "421cd09e4c241a019cb279c1cecf404f83c892a4bd7dbaa652ceaaea037fbd2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "84414bf8ec17dcfb3608cb42cc586f41fdbff735bc0f5b5d97434d0692424c3e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "83585b540986dd9f78869a8930858bd0dc141b69990b7ad6d91e36b2efc47cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0986dfc3e26d68f0e04195cdf9d1e2b7f5da2cd23b880af56b9384ef963f7c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7588543821be396ed14b6bd3e78bb0c3e079cbe2b94613ad9ab155c7605697bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "72acdde37443a6200d4157882b0d13f182ab41b24f58e3067d104b47488b00cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bb31621cec2f76017cf3f224cc20b0ddd78e126c51a1b8a2f6d4e411fc1d3987", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e0fbc5e011994fd47197aec6f8e662b4816afd311c927b2031f2392ad459ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eb6deecd0c170702e64f0d50f246dd37c12d02c3e21f68fd1d2be8d3fee83348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47acf1e50b2c79375a79cf912e60dcbdf36a1a60de9a826816c2f1559d9869a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd88e0e034a3c6989221dcc7e1993969a120d8436f30b4cec883869b54b4c907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d9171e08c11d28e13c7d5e704a9a8c5b38f56f90e2a9195e7054cc9c5c70c6d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "569a261febe59ad14728c89b23cc8dc5c24c525e8c1777fc4b16a8c6cc8a7a19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-original.ppm", + "sha256": "568481e4973c48993eef1f19374db65ef81246c8f2f1b0541666b8534c827e1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2cb304f42ba13ca5d827403c075d5577fb0bbe462db7988b2c02bf60801ab1f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f486227c734f2925f00ba67e70491f2bc6f38724a2166133fa23197788bb6cdc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e68f73973e511dcbbd6d48a9feeedd02c59cfc336a0228daffb0af67aec23a75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4ef398a88feec37105119dcdc37bab7fa0587b72c684702221829c12182de892", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b2c5dde1e1278d7534e9d7b4d1bf538d43f2e575426fcfe70e70c9cebdb15c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "236cc9a65e1e10ef753cc7316e25ae00e89b25dd5f80f9f35ec4765bc8fd2246", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "93dcfcd8359586da4dc1653e5f139e055d6cd3ec64c5cc004c18b2cf09db1bd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ee030edc5f9bc4ed6e197dbc81561d99798626f2cbe9750f2e8e2a55292e6896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2d32515adf639db9afc206140be51c7de52e74d1c3f3146687bfe6fe4ca4baaa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "63ad4f656faaf16f8f5eabbe8298d9aeb5e0a642d6f23ee4696176da0e3559d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06d2a2a8ac1058499d10e311463dd6835201f001e14345fcb6913c182246a03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0a6814ad21c8b8bf9a11822713f299eda7eed35ff13b710c6cec53b4e15f83eb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c4f962337cfcacc4ea63bb3b6160b40f1c63145b7cf4d750611e731aeb79894", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "424b024a191e23319c0785e1d1a9980d62fa6e593febfafcb9f7c72649e3d14d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26e2a8951641c52a403495952e503bc1017911e8681a96e595b5ece7cfb2e516", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b0cbd4b654d771773680f4f04f96fb65630d04027e484be2346313a1e1cfa82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8b66f6973fc86b3ef08a70a8bef6a397af7a487523956147167099a77f5c99df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "60373b77be34a563be55f6c85aba51fa41c47e2ccab98b16fb5b27a30d6ef1f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "606804f250f7244c0d6ed1b2646798104a885be8da8e993d5e154dd6dcaef12f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e1c234832095bcb0724c60c030b34a0d9994361dff8ecf5bc9c0cd256a66024e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c8c90b8af19dc87065ff61cb9aea1481b33c4d58d051a91ff6e37fd516a5a3b5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b1875fffa16d39852af9d76ad362a705660166359f4a0d056c90e4fe5c3516c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a69bca1ff1997e749b9994a4b186bc6c381070292d3ec38b0aca0ce21f8ebdcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ef96b177a79477741a94979f135364b814764b6a717809947c08f8b4d2de232", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "38cd254a04df76a5439136d51ae7c4a60bc02c23eadfd671e8bd7c5222ac7410", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2393ddef6f77d0f58cf018dc11bc4372f4783513e92726536a7aec53f6471d56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acded7cffcd4762f83293964eb7cea418769f251ce5f4de0feb8e54e16be156f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "edb024afb9c5b2bc80b0a9b13f8fa52ac69a302ab43d910026d58e66c53bc1a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36ee8a23a83692aa4f2741be3f1125e9b005adb130b893cb804c8d85fdeccc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cf5c9c74844d1ed57b443a3c02d305dbd234e7b6a5acba984b2e732e42825f67", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "1041d": { @@ -136902,7 +147095,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1041d", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -136918,6 +147111,467 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", "sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eeac825831b65f3085ee3a93cde1178da43f46775d29db1ec47f6c416d09f6e8", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.866714+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"10410/10411/10412\": \"Wide/tall corrugated roof geometry, side posts, surviving broken metal strips, charred openings and original ember placements remain source-relative. Both new wrecks were compared with authentic intact source partners at all recorded same-position contexts; no reconstructed intact roof was approved.\", \"10413/10414/10416\": \"Brown/grey horizontal wall bands and dark lower recesses preserve original source structure. Complete-family same-position transitions preserve continuous neighbor wall placement while removing the damaged tile structure; charred occupied backing is retained. Cracked masonry and rubble are a detail/material interpretation within the original regions, not a new detached building.\", \"10415\": \"Five original small pale rock groupings and their shadows remain separated at the original positions; chipped grain is accepted as added detail.\", \"10417\": \"Separate pale vertical/horizontal blocks, cyan box, lower grey block and two original animated ember cells preserve source placement; blocks have finer cracks/edges.\", \"10418/10419/1041a/1041b/1041c\": \"Original asymmetric rock masses, peaks, pale ledges and dark lower faces remain identifiable across all scales and authentic contexts. Fine chipped facets/grain are accepted; original state partners remain original artwork.\", \"1041d/1041e/1041f\": \"Original dotted border lines and cross-junction gaps remain aligned. The unchanged high-resolution raw 1041f contains irregular chipped pale fragments, not continuous stone panels. Native scales3/4 retain some square/stipple rhythm because the original one-pixel pale cells occupy very small areas. This disclosed over-literal rhythm is accepted as source placement fidelity after viewing raw and every actual scale, including all native neighbors.\"} {\"historical_job_sha256\": \"c703e6899b27905486538d0622bd111e22845b923c03dae26c87f4a003bb6cd4\", \"current_job_sha256\": \"0f6ab3d989aa9a16e71c9b69bc21e646675f2e4a4755b27fde1f75d1ec4e976d\", \"historical_artifact\": \"frozen/generated/historical-native-job-c703e689-reconstructed.json\", \"historical_retention_scope\": \"Author reconstructed full historical bytes from retained16 per-frame original job copies; exact serialized SHA c703e689 verified independently. This is not claimed to be retained original full-file bytes.\", \"reconstruction_provenance_sha256\": \"0fc2d4cd6479a0a29a6f64eab342cdf9c32ceac4d1d44293fddeaec08e8f38b4\", \"only_semantic_changes\": {\"target_statuses\": [{\"asset\": \"10410\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10411\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10412\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10413\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10414\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10415\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10416\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10417\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10418\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10419\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041a\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041b\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041c\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041d\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041e\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041f\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}], \"status_counts\": {\"before\": {\"inprogress\": 16}, \"after\": {\"candidate\": 16}}}, \"all_sources_geometry_roles_partners_neighbors_samples_and_contracts_exact\": true, \"author_explanation\": \"Shared hd_job_queue.py refreshes status metadata across jobs. Current0f6 job was already frozen before this independent rendering; old author proof remains historical. Neither discrepancy affects raw/frame bindings or terrain context data.\"} [\"Opaque mask IoU1 is trivial and was not used as material or geometry approval. All source/raw/full actual1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 images were visually inspected.\", \"Palette quantization/blockiness remains visible at2/3. New HD ground/rock/metal grain remains denser and sharper beside original fallback tiles; square texture-density boundaries can remain visible in mixed scenes. This approval does not assert uniform whole-mission material or complete HD fallback coverage.\", \"Foreign1040f/104ed/104ee/104f5 remain original in all independently rendered full-family and state scenes. Private HD1040f pack was excluded.\", \"State proof renders declared original source partner substitution at the same recorded position. First4pairs9positions are native target/state contexts; remaining6pairs17positions are explicitly synthetic declared source-state substitutions at authentic intact occurrences. No live destruction timing/reachability or live Host/whole-mission validation is claimed.\", \"Native scene and cardinal corpus comes from canonical supplied source contexts; no invented source occurrences. No new gameplay scrolling/boss assembly test is claimed.\", \"Animated palette240\\u2013255 pixels are legitimate source effects:10410=5,10412=4,10414=8,10417=2. Current loader source-relative class totals expand byscale\\u00b2. Static capture does not prove full palette cycling phases.\", \"Review only; no production manifest/source/art/Git writes, registration or promotion.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 37f5c4b26f9086c3724a4b13249981acf54dfaba4d5a0e7b861a928a50a3f187", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "10410", + "10411", + "10412", + "10413" + ], + "sha256": "dfdf91ff2260f9e5cd5afab1d62ce1182bd399635f3307843138a778f4f65beb", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "10414", + "10415", + "10416", + "10417" + ], + "sha256": "989a797ac864e72c88805fcbdd5b8e494db6c307a75f5facea86bd602a2bd104", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "10418", + "10419", + "1041a", + "1041b" + ], + "sha256": "c2856b9eda30d17110fea211e769ce0adf65b15a3254ff4a57a427ac079197d2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "1041c", + "1041d", + "1041e", + "1041f" + ], + "sha256": "e5cfb639df3fcc47a4533af97884a9163409c2e4db6a0fa59a1fb7e3ad926224", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10410-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac8fc607959f5f14c0b942da5f21fb0f26e3336edd6ff8d352ed6f2b503b8e7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c39bff33a03e8367c725d1bb68613df96c60841e37d5ed3bdac0f2acb9ca18a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e045baa994ac7ea4b62c3e3020ae3266b48b3ef03118282a0918dc1dd2e91aeb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5c181c77cc497bcbd185796574207fe4e89623ce13053ca246c16ee904690812", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b9f1b7fcf833e60b7ade5f3e678896f72c5e78fa85ba6792e7fc78424ebd8958", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cc3fd56d3e61a9d919b9a0b7e67caa0aa932f394d5232477f44c37d48c91b5dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "932c116e449199fc8b4c26e522c73c339bc1fda4e3a6382eb26d25a3366e7174", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1dee0695f73c8701c567fc18ecaa11bf56fa74d6833a34fa7f6dfc92b7ca51b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c3c2129b8f2cd34b744e494087f53ba5691c8dd83849b161b0c59292a9f6cdb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5f1190f320faaaab142e030bef2196496759b6856f0c96a5c2fcd38d5767a390", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9f0e642fd58f9c42103b6f71341ef663c208bfab3ed737a6cb109d147b9077a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "049a788257cb017d0dc19cd5e7c2e03f869b73343ff005d736e98afa977fc878", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cdd053889c26c1f7e66934f6680eb07b5772cbe80632082b4627eb5196f09c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a398fafa05cf760e4907d6e63eaed92193724591cf0d8031e54f440238e423e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52ce7e36ddd901308955a916f87b21a51418658e416615ef23fc08a83d09c70e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4ccaf6751ec10bedbabf226ac52d17ce80d51ff4164b19bb82494123e51f6c92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a1d70e398ae3867c7e2717d1e0d5ac80f7af9356a8c02ad7ebdc034a085f03d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f51f5c4b055955c6e8e9e4803e8ca57ffb833e72d7c93b50cffd421cbcff375", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b9dfb1fa7af5b64bc1f013d4f77d90bd2faa6be226b72f5577f46faee0f654f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-original.ppm", + "sha256": "07815b537b8df019f9a8b3bb100f205b20bdac607b06a3a883674728f51a1961", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "474b5cb2530effe4d8ce79d3b57eda23f795718dfc30fe1591b179e2cde17adc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7c3940d23b448558f7689b1b3171c41a0a99f8b92ccfb62e0fc243523df679fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ccfd3f02fb94e39d606e6b5039dc09a535027f5b1193161af1ad8482a1452c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab016bb7ae2ca976bdec92013b52f2ee0c9a0f249b5998fb63dd3e6d7964b07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-original.ppm", + "sha256": "731d2ad7d40da37dcf6d85fa128aec8f652bb3c5e3a3a1cab7bf97f6ccd55c63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "52ee4577a74f409c5f90aad05f39a8f462f139685398bcb5c92ca0208f0150e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a81c58b827f4533f41f6413a366a8f5e707f8b43039fc823ce9863fb0646e57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3221d17f268e21888a795e88ef677f5219f72a7788e57903fd900f55bbbf3556", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "81ca18fc0aae76a37f36e697efbdc6aa7a56acabfd7e20ce64d0cb5c38ffdaad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a04d2b78a0fe288544345cfbf99e031d1342591773c132de94f1a1a02a828c82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1fa8cb4aa3db5303d7e17c62876e69a352be0e71e34022902b3d5715ff56e4b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "557c5202b8790b5199d326695425b14f2f66b7f4beb101d38dd7b3dec54aa94e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a4ea4b96e7a9a77c54a8fee0f71718baecc64361ed931145badc415eb372ab90", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8797c65adee550343f481e5f5790ffc89b2b133f79bcafe3d67cfdf632cc594a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0f589865a0b7837ea238e4012e2dbb70d8f3b8b165127016fced78e0269b59cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "aaa8bfc0d7576c76523b26dc6ffdb70c966c03fc4f24eb0003cb9fb984f79490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "421cd09e4c241a019cb279c1cecf404f83c892a4bd7dbaa652ceaaea037fbd2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "84414bf8ec17dcfb3608cb42cc586f41fdbff735bc0f5b5d97434d0692424c3e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "83585b540986dd9f78869a8930858bd0dc141b69990b7ad6d91e36b2efc47cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0986dfc3e26d68f0e04195cdf9d1e2b7f5da2cd23b880af56b9384ef963f7c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7588543821be396ed14b6bd3e78bb0c3e079cbe2b94613ad9ab155c7605697bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "72acdde37443a6200d4157882b0d13f182ab41b24f58e3067d104b47488b00cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bb31621cec2f76017cf3f224cc20b0ddd78e126c51a1b8a2f6d4e411fc1d3987", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e0fbc5e011994fd47197aec6f8e662b4816afd311c927b2031f2392ad459ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eb6deecd0c170702e64f0d50f246dd37c12d02c3e21f68fd1d2be8d3fee83348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47acf1e50b2c79375a79cf912e60dcbdf36a1a60de9a826816c2f1559d9869a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd88e0e034a3c6989221dcc7e1993969a120d8436f30b4cec883869b54b4c907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d9171e08c11d28e13c7d5e704a9a8c5b38f56f90e2a9195e7054cc9c5c70c6d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "569a261febe59ad14728c89b23cc8dc5c24c525e8c1777fc4b16a8c6cc8a7a19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-original.ppm", + "sha256": "568481e4973c48993eef1f19374db65ef81246c8f2f1b0541666b8534c827e1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2cb304f42ba13ca5d827403c075d5577fb0bbe462db7988b2c02bf60801ab1f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f486227c734f2925f00ba67e70491f2bc6f38724a2166133fa23197788bb6cdc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e68f73973e511dcbbd6d48a9feeedd02c59cfc336a0228daffb0af67aec23a75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4ef398a88feec37105119dcdc37bab7fa0587b72c684702221829c12182de892", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b2c5dde1e1278d7534e9d7b4d1bf538d43f2e575426fcfe70e70c9cebdb15c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "236cc9a65e1e10ef753cc7316e25ae00e89b25dd5f80f9f35ec4765bc8fd2246", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "93dcfcd8359586da4dc1653e5f139e055d6cd3ec64c5cc004c18b2cf09db1bd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ee030edc5f9bc4ed6e197dbc81561d99798626f2cbe9750f2e8e2a55292e6896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2d32515adf639db9afc206140be51c7de52e74d1c3f3146687bfe6fe4ca4baaa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "63ad4f656faaf16f8f5eabbe8298d9aeb5e0a642d6f23ee4696176da0e3559d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06d2a2a8ac1058499d10e311463dd6835201f001e14345fcb6913c182246a03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0a6814ad21c8b8bf9a11822713f299eda7eed35ff13b710c6cec53b4e15f83eb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c4f962337cfcacc4ea63bb3b6160b40f1c63145b7cf4d750611e731aeb79894", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "424b024a191e23319c0785e1d1a9980d62fa6e593febfafcb9f7c72649e3d14d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26e2a8951641c52a403495952e503bc1017911e8681a96e595b5ece7cfb2e516", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b0cbd4b654d771773680f4f04f96fb65630d04027e484be2346313a1e1cfa82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8b66f6973fc86b3ef08a70a8bef6a397af7a487523956147167099a77f5c99df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "60373b77be34a563be55f6c85aba51fa41c47e2ccab98b16fb5b27a30d6ef1f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "606804f250f7244c0d6ed1b2646798104a885be8da8e993d5e154dd6dcaef12f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e1c234832095bcb0724c60c030b34a0d9994361dff8ecf5bc9c0cd256a66024e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c8c90b8af19dc87065ff61cb9aea1481b33c4d58d051a91ff6e37fd516a5a3b5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b1875fffa16d39852af9d76ad362a705660166359f4a0d056c90e4fe5c3516c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a69bca1ff1997e749b9994a4b186bc6c381070292d3ec38b0aca0ce21f8ebdcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ef96b177a79477741a94979f135364b814764b6a717809947c08f8b4d2de232", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "38cd254a04df76a5439136d51ae7c4a60bc02c23eadfd671e8bd7c5222ac7410", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2393ddef6f77d0f58cf018dc11bc4372f4783513e92726536a7aec53f6471d56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acded7cffcd4762f83293964eb7cea418769f251ce5f4de0feb8e54e16be156f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "edb024afb9c5b2bc80b0a9b13f8fa52ac69a302ab43d910026d58e66c53bc1a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36ee8a23a83692aa4f2741be3f1125e9b005adb130b893cb804c8d85fdeccc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cf5c9c74844d1ed57b443a3c02d305dbd234e7b6a5acba984b2e732e42825f67", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "1041e": { @@ -136939,7 +147593,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1041e", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -136955,6 +147609,467 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", "sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eeac825831b65f3085ee3a93cde1178da43f46775d29db1ec47f6c416d09f6e8", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.866714+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"10410/10411/10412\": \"Wide/tall corrugated roof geometry, side posts, surviving broken metal strips, charred openings and original ember placements remain source-relative. Both new wrecks were compared with authentic intact source partners at all recorded same-position contexts; no reconstructed intact roof was approved.\", \"10413/10414/10416\": \"Brown/grey horizontal wall bands and dark lower recesses preserve original source structure. Complete-family same-position transitions preserve continuous neighbor wall placement while removing the damaged tile structure; charred occupied backing is retained. Cracked masonry and rubble are a detail/material interpretation within the original regions, not a new detached building.\", \"10415\": \"Five original small pale rock groupings and their shadows remain separated at the original positions; chipped grain is accepted as added detail.\", \"10417\": \"Separate pale vertical/horizontal blocks, cyan box, lower grey block and two original animated ember cells preserve source placement; blocks have finer cracks/edges.\", \"10418/10419/1041a/1041b/1041c\": \"Original asymmetric rock masses, peaks, pale ledges and dark lower faces remain identifiable across all scales and authentic contexts. Fine chipped facets/grain are accepted; original state partners remain original artwork.\", \"1041d/1041e/1041f\": \"Original dotted border lines and cross-junction gaps remain aligned. The unchanged high-resolution raw 1041f contains irregular chipped pale fragments, not continuous stone panels. Native scales3/4 retain some square/stipple rhythm because the original one-pixel pale cells occupy very small areas. This disclosed over-literal rhythm is accepted as source placement fidelity after viewing raw and every actual scale, including all native neighbors.\"} {\"historical_job_sha256\": \"c703e6899b27905486538d0622bd111e22845b923c03dae26c87f4a003bb6cd4\", \"current_job_sha256\": \"0f6ab3d989aa9a16e71c9b69bc21e646675f2e4a4755b27fde1f75d1ec4e976d\", \"historical_artifact\": \"frozen/generated/historical-native-job-c703e689-reconstructed.json\", \"historical_retention_scope\": \"Author reconstructed full historical bytes from retained16 per-frame original job copies; exact serialized SHA c703e689 verified independently. This is not claimed to be retained original full-file bytes.\", \"reconstruction_provenance_sha256\": \"0fc2d4cd6479a0a29a6f64eab342cdf9c32ceac4d1d44293fddeaec08e8f38b4\", \"only_semantic_changes\": {\"target_statuses\": [{\"asset\": \"10410\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10411\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10412\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10413\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10414\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10415\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10416\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10417\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10418\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10419\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041a\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041b\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041c\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041d\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041e\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041f\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}], \"status_counts\": {\"before\": {\"inprogress\": 16}, \"after\": {\"candidate\": 16}}}, \"all_sources_geometry_roles_partners_neighbors_samples_and_contracts_exact\": true, \"author_explanation\": \"Shared hd_job_queue.py refreshes status metadata across jobs. Current0f6 job was already frozen before this independent rendering; old author proof remains historical. Neither discrepancy affects raw/frame bindings or terrain context data.\"} [\"Opaque mask IoU1 is trivial and was not used as material or geometry approval. All source/raw/full actual1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 images were visually inspected.\", \"Palette quantization/blockiness remains visible at2/3. New HD ground/rock/metal grain remains denser and sharper beside original fallback tiles; square texture-density boundaries can remain visible in mixed scenes. This approval does not assert uniform whole-mission material or complete HD fallback coverage.\", \"Foreign1040f/104ed/104ee/104f5 remain original in all independently rendered full-family and state scenes. Private HD1040f pack was excluded.\", \"State proof renders declared original source partner substitution at the same recorded position. First4pairs9positions are native target/state contexts; remaining6pairs17positions are explicitly synthetic declared source-state substitutions at authentic intact occurrences. No live destruction timing/reachability or live Host/whole-mission validation is claimed.\", \"Native scene and cardinal corpus comes from canonical supplied source contexts; no invented source occurrences. No new gameplay scrolling/boss assembly test is claimed.\", \"Animated palette240\\u2013255 pixels are legitimate source effects:10410=5,10412=4,10414=8,10417=2. Current loader source-relative class totals expand byscale\\u00b2. Static capture does not prove full palette cycling phases.\", \"Review only; no production manifest/source/art/Git writes, registration or promotion.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 37f5c4b26f9086c3724a4b13249981acf54dfaba4d5a0e7b861a928a50a3f187", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "10410", + "10411", + "10412", + "10413" + ], + "sha256": "dfdf91ff2260f9e5cd5afab1d62ce1182bd399635f3307843138a778f4f65beb", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "10414", + "10415", + "10416", + "10417" + ], + "sha256": "989a797ac864e72c88805fcbdd5b8e494db6c307a75f5facea86bd602a2bd104", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "10418", + "10419", + "1041a", + "1041b" + ], + "sha256": "c2856b9eda30d17110fea211e769ce0adf65b15a3254ff4a57a427ac079197d2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "1041c", + "1041d", + "1041e", + "1041f" + ], + "sha256": "e5cfb639df3fcc47a4533af97884a9163409c2e4db6a0fa59a1fb7e3ad926224", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10410-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac8fc607959f5f14c0b942da5f21fb0f26e3336edd6ff8d352ed6f2b503b8e7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c39bff33a03e8367c725d1bb68613df96c60841e37d5ed3bdac0f2acb9ca18a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e045baa994ac7ea4b62c3e3020ae3266b48b3ef03118282a0918dc1dd2e91aeb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5c181c77cc497bcbd185796574207fe4e89623ce13053ca246c16ee904690812", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b9f1b7fcf833e60b7ade5f3e678896f72c5e78fa85ba6792e7fc78424ebd8958", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cc3fd56d3e61a9d919b9a0b7e67caa0aa932f394d5232477f44c37d48c91b5dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "932c116e449199fc8b4c26e522c73c339bc1fda4e3a6382eb26d25a3366e7174", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1dee0695f73c8701c567fc18ecaa11bf56fa74d6833a34fa7f6dfc92b7ca51b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c3c2129b8f2cd34b744e494087f53ba5691c8dd83849b161b0c59292a9f6cdb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5f1190f320faaaab142e030bef2196496759b6856f0c96a5c2fcd38d5767a390", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9f0e642fd58f9c42103b6f71341ef663c208bfab3ed737a6cb109d147b9077a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "049a788257cb017d0dc19cd5e7c2e03f869b73343ff005d736e98afa977fc878", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cdd053889c26c1f7e66934f6680eb07b5772cbe80632082b4627eb5196f09c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a398fafa05cf760e4907d6e63eaed92193724591cf0d8031e54f440238e423e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52ce7e36ddd901308955a916f87b21a51418658e416615ef23fc08a83d09c70e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4ccaf6751ec10bedbabf226ac52d17ce80d51ff4164b19bb82494123e51f6c92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a1d70e398ae3867c7e2717d1e0d5ac80f7af9356a8c02ad7ebdc034a085f03d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f51f5c4b055955c6e8e9e4803e8ca57ffb833e72d7c93b50cffd421cbcff375", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b9dfb1fa7af5b64bc1f013d4f77d90bd2faa6be226b72f5577f46faee0f654f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-original.ppm", + "sha256": "07815b537b8df019f9a8b3bb100f205b20bdac607b06a3a883674728f51a1961", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "474b5cb2530effe4d8ce79d3b57eda23f795718dfc30fe1591b179e2cde17adc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7c3940d23b448558f7689b1b3171c41a0a99f8b92ccfb62e0fc243523df679fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ccfd3f02fb94e39d606e6b5039dc09a535027f5b1193161af1ad8482a1452c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab016bb7ae2ca976bdec92013b52f2ee0c9a0f249b5998fb63dd3e6d7964b07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-original.ppm", + "sha256": "731d2ad7d40da37dcf6d85fa128aec8f652bb3c5e3a3a1cab7bf97f6ccd55c63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "52ee4577a74f409c5f90aad05f39a8f462f139685398bcb5c92ca0208f0150e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a81c58b827f4533f41f6413a366a8f5e707f8b43039fc823ce9863fb0646e57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3221d17f268e21888a795e88ef677f5219f72a7788e57903fd900f55bbbf3556", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "81ca18fc0aae76a37f36e697efbdc6aa7a56acabfd7e20ce64d0cb5c38ffdaad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a04d2b78a0fe288544345cfbf99e031d1342591773c132de94f1a1a02a828c82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1fa8cb4aa3db5303d7e17c62876e69a352be0e71e34022902b3d5715ff56e4b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "557c5202b8790b5199d326695425b14f2f66b7f4beb101d38dd7b3dec54aa94e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a4ea4b96e7a9a77c54a8fee0f71718baecc64361ed931145badc415eb372ab90", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8797c65adee550343f481e5f5790ffc89b2b133f79bcafe3d67cfdf632cc594a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0f589865a0b7837ea238e4012e2dbb70d8f3b8b165127016fced78e0269b59cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "aaa8bfc0d7576c76523b26dc6ffdb70c966c03fc4f24eb0003cb9fb984f79490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "421cd09e4c241a019cb279c1cecf404f83c892a4bd7dbaa652ceaaea037fbd2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "84414bf8ec17dcfb3608cb42cc586f41fdbff735bc0f5b5d97434d0692424c3e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "83585b540986dd9f78869a8930858bd0dc141b69990b7ad6d91e36b2efc47cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0986dfc3e26d68f0e04195cdf9d1e2b7f5da2cd23b880af56b9384ef963f7c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7588543821be396ed14b6bd3e78bb0c3e079cbe2b94613ad9ab155c7605697bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "72acdde37443a6200d4157882b0d13f182ab41b24f58e3067d104b47488b00cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bb31621cec2f76017cf3f224cc20b0ddd78e126c51a1b8a2f6d4e411fc1d3987", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e0fbc5e011994fd47197aec6f8e662b4816afd311c927b2031f2392ad459ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eb6deecd0c170702e64f0d50f246dd37c12d02c3e21f68fd1d2be8d3fee83348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47acf1e50b2c79375a79cf912e60dcbdf36a1a60de9a826816c2f1559d9869a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd88e0e034a3c6989221dcc7e1993969a120d8436f30b4cec883869b54b4c907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d9171e08c11d28e13c7d5e704a9a8c5b38f56f90e2a9195e7054cc9c5c70c6d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "569a261febe59ad14728c89b23cc8dc5c24c525e8c1777fc4b16a8c6cc8a7a19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-original.ppm", + "sha256": "568481e4973c48993eef1f19374db65ef81246c8f2f1b0541666b8534c827e1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2cb304f42ba13ca5d827403c075d5577fb0bbe462db7988b2c02bf60801ab1f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f486227c734f2925f00ba67e70491f2bc6f38724a2166133fa23197788bb6cdc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e68f73973e511dcbbd6d48a9feeedd02c59cfc336a0228daffb0af67aec23a75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4ef398a88feec37105119dcdc37bab7fa0587b72c684702221829c12182de892", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b2c5dde1e1278d7534e9d7b4d1bf538d43f2e575426fcfe70e70c9cebdb15c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "236cc9a65e1e10ef753cc7316e25ae00e89b25dd5f80f9f35ec4765bc8fd2246", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "93dcfcd8359586da4dc1653e5f139e055d6cd3ec64c5cc004c18b2cf09db1bd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ee030edc5f9bc4ed6e197dbc81561d99798626f2cbe9750f2e8e2a55292e6896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2d32515adf639db9afc206140be51c7de52e74d1c3f3146687bfe6fe4ca4baaa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "63ad4f656faaf16f8f5eabbe8298d9aeb5e0a642d6f23ee4696176da0e3559d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06d2a2a8ac1058499d10e311463dd6835201f001e14345fcb6913c182246a03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0a6814ad21c8b8bf9a11822713f299eda7eed35ff13b710c6cec53b4e15f83eb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c4f962337cfcacc4ea63bb3b6160b40f1c63145b7cf4d750611e731aeb79894", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "424b024a191e23319c0785e1d1a9980d62fa6e593febfafcb9f7c72649e3d14d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26e2a8951641c52a403495952e503bc1017911e8681a96e595b5ece7cfb2e516", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b0cbd4b654d771773680f4f04f96fb65630d04027e484be2346313a1e1cfa82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8b66f6973fc86b3ef08a70a8bef6a397af7a487523956147167099a77f5c99df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "60373b77be34a563be55f6c85aba51fa41c47e2ccab98b16fb5b27a30d6ef1f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "606804f250f7244c0d6ed1b2646798104a885be8da8e993d5e154dd6dcaef12f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e1c234832095bcb0724c60c030b34a0d9994361dff8ecf5bc9c0cd256a66024e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c8c90b8af19dc87065ff61cb9aea1481b33c4d58d051a91ff6e37fd516a5a3b5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b1875fffa16d39852af9d76ad362a705660166359f4a0d056c90e4fe5c3516c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a69bca1ff1997e749b9994a4b186bc6c381070292d3ec38b0aca0ce21f8ebdcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ef96b177a79477741a94979f135364b814764b6a717809947c08f8b4d2de232", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "38cd254a04df76a5439136d51ae7c4a60bc02c23eadfd671e8bd7c5222ac7410", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2393ddef6f77d0f58cf018dc11bc4372f4783513e92726536a7aec53f6471d56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acded7cffcd4762f83293964eb7cea418769f251ce5f4de0feb8e54e16be156f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "edb024afb9c5b2bc80b0a9b13f8fa52ac69a302ab43d910026d58e66c53bc1a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36ee8a23a83692aa4f2741be3f1125e9b005adb130b893cb804c8d85fdeccc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cf5c9c74844d1ed57b443a3c02d305dbd234e7b6a5acba984b2e732e42825f67", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "1041f": { @@ -136976,7 +148091,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "1041f", "family_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", "job_id": "terrain-10410-1041f", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -136992,6 +148107,467 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/candidate.json", "sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "2908cfff38a2f6ac2826de1ad5458a72815fb57086e90c3b705b916ef0f47b9d", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "eeac825831b65f3085ee3a93cde1178da43f46775d29db1ec47f6c416d09f6e8", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.866714+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-10410-1041f/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"10410/10411/10412\": \"Wide/tall corrugated roof geometry, side posts, surviving broken metal strips, charred openings and original ember placements remain source-relative. Both new wrecks were compared with authentic intact source partners at all recorded same-position contexts; no reconstructed intact roof was approved.\", \"10413/10414/10416\": \"Brown/grey horizontal wall bands and dark lower recesses preserve original source structure. Complete-family same-position transitions preserve continuous neighbor wall placement while removing the damaged tile structure; charred occupied backing is retained. Cracked masonry and rubble are a detail/material interpretation within the original regions, not a new detached building.\", \"10415\": \"Five original small pale rock groupings and their shadows remain separated at the original positions; chipped grain is accepted as added detail.\", \"10417\": \"Separate pale vertical/horizontal blocks, cyan box, lower grey block and two original animated ember cells preserve source placement; blocks have finer cracks/edges.\", \"10418/10419/1041a/1041b/1041c\": \"Original asymmetric rock masses, peaks, pale ledges and dark lower faces remain identifiable across all scales and authentic contexts. Fine chipped facets/grain are accepted; original state partners remain original artwork.\", \"1041d/1041e/1041f\": \"Original dotted border lines and cross-junction gaps remain aligned. The unchanged high-resolution raw 1041f contains irregular chipped pale fragments, not continuous stone panels. Native scales3/4 retain some square/stipple rhythm because the original one-pixel pale cells occupy very small areas. This disclosed over-literal rhythm is accepted as source placement fidelity after viewing raw and every actual scale, including all native neighbors.\"} {\"historical_job_sha256\": \"c703e6899b27905486538d0622bd111e22845b923c03dae26c87f4a003bb6cd4\", \"current_job_sha256\": \"0f6ab3d989aa9a16e71c9b69bc21e646675f2e4a4755b27fde1f75d1ec4e976d\", \"historical_artifact\": \"frozen/generated/historical-native-job-c703e689-reconstructed.json\", \"historical_retention_scope\": \"Author reconstructed full historical bytes from retained16 per-frame original job copies; exact serialized SHA c703e689 verified independently. This is not claimed to be retained original full-file bytes.\", \"reconstruction_provenance_sha256\": \"0fc2d4cd6479a0a29a6f64eab342cdf9c32ceac4d1d44293fddeaec08e8f38b4\", \"only_semantic_changes\": {\"target_statuses\": [{\"asset\": \"10410\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10411\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10412\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10413\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10414\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10415\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10416\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10417\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10418\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"10419\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041a\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041b\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041c\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041d\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041e\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}, {\"asset\": \"1041f\", \"before\": \"inprogress\", \"after\": \"candidate\"}], \"status_counts\": {\"before\": {\"inprogress\": 16}, \"after\": {\"candidate\": 16}}}, \"all_sources_geometry_roles_partners_neighbors_samples_and_contracts_exact\": true, \"author_explanation\": \"Shared hd_job_queue.py refreshes status metadata across jobs. Current0f6 job was already frozen before this independent rendering; old author proof remains historical. Neither discrepancy affects raw/frame bindings or terrain context data.\"} [\"Opaque mask IoU1 is trivial and was not used as material or geometry approval. All source/raw/full actual1\\u20134/native2\\u20133 images were visually inspected.\", \"Palette quantization/blockiness remains visible at2/3. New HD ground/rock/metal grain remains denser and sharper beside original fallback tiles; square texture-density boundaries can remain visible in mixed scenes. This approval does not assert uniform whole-mission material or complete HD fallback coverage.\", \"Foreign1040f/104ed/104ee/104f5 remain original in all independently rendered full-family and state scenes. Private HD1040f pack was excluded.\", \"State proof renders declared original source partner substitution at the same recorded position. First4pairs9positions are native target/state contexts; remaining6pairs17positions are explicitly synthetic declared source-state substitutions at authentic intact occurrences. No live destruction timing/reachability or live Host/whole-mission validation is claimed.\", \"Native scene and cardinal corpus comes from canonical supplied source contexts; no invented source occurrences. No new gameplay scrolling/boss assembly test is claimed.\", \"Animated palette240\\u2013255 pixels are legitimate source effects:10410=5,10412=4,10414=8,10417=2. Current loader source-relative class totals expand byscale\\u00b2. Static capture does not prove full palette cycling phases.\", \"Review only; no production manifest/source/art/Git writes, registration or promotion.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/review-index.json, SHA256 37f5c4b26f9086c3724a4b13249981acf54dfaba4d5a0e7b861a928a50a3f187", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "10410", + "10411", + "10412", + "10413" + ], + "sha256": "dfdf91ff2260f9e5cd5afab1d62ce1182bd399635f3307843138a778f4f65beb", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "10414", + "10415", + "10416", + "10417" + ], + "sha256": "989a797ac864e72c88805fcbdd5b8e494db6c307a75f5facea86bd602a2bd104", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "10418", + "10419", + "1041a", + "1041b" + ], + "sha256": "c2856b9eda30d17110fea211e769ce0adf65b15a3254ff4a57a427ac079197d2", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "1041c", + "1041d", + "1041e", + "1041f" + ], + "sha256": "e5cfb639df3fcc47a4533af97884a9163409c2e4db6a0fa59a1fb7e3ad926224", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "10410-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "ac8fc607959f5f14c0b942da5f21fb0f26e3336edd6ff8d352ed6f2b503b8e7b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c39bff33a03e8367c725d1bb68613df96c60841e37d5ed3bdac0f2acb9ca18a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e045baa994ac7ea4b62c3e3020ae3266b48b3ef03118282a0918dc1dd2e91aeb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5c181c77cc497bcbd185796574207fe4e89623ce13053ca246c16ee904690812", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10410-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b9f1b7fcf833e60b7ade5f3e678896f72c5e78fa85ba6792e7fc78424ebd8958", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10410-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "cc3fd56d3e61a9d919b9a0b7e67caa0aa932f394d5232477f44c37d48c91b5dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "932c116e449199fc8b4c26e522c73c339bc1fda4e3a6382eb26d25a3366e7174", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1dee0695f73c8701c567fc18ecaa11bf56fa74d6833a34fa7f6dfc92b7ca51b7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c3c2129b8f2cd34b744e494087f53ba5691c8dd83849b161b0c59292a9f6cdb9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10411-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5f1190f320faaaab142e030bef2196496759b6856f0c96a5c2fcd38d5767a390", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10411-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9f0e642fd58f9c42103b6f71341ef663c208bfab3ed737a6cb109d147b9077a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "049a788257cb017d0dc19cd5e7c2e03f869b73343ff005d736e98afa977fc878", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cdd053889c26c1f7e66934f6680eb07b5772cbe80632082b4627eb5196f09c5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a398fafa05cf760e4907d6e63eaed92193724591cf0d8031e54f440238e423e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10412-original.ppm", + "sha256": "52ce7e36ddd901308955a916f87b21a51418658e416615ef23fc08a83d09c70e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10412-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4ccaf6751ec10bedbabf226ac52d17ce80d51ff4164b19bb82494123e51f6c92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a1d70e398ae3867c7e2717d1e0d5ac80f7af9356a8c02ad7ebdc034a085f03d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f51f5c4b055955c6e8e9e4803e8ca57ffb833e72d7c93b50cffd421cbcff375", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9b9dfb1fa7af5b64bc1f013d4f77d90bd2faa6be226b72f5577f46faee0f654f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10413-original.ppm", + "sha256": "07815b537b8df019f9a8b3bb100f205b20bdac607b06a3a883674728f51a1961", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10413-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "474b5cb2530effe4d8ce79d3b57eda23f795718dfc30fe1591b179e2cde17adc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7c3940d23b448558f7689b1b3171c41a0a99f8b92ccfb62e0fc243523df679fb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0ccfd3f02fb94e39d606e6b5039dc09a535027f5b1193161af1ad8482a1452c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5ab016bb7ae2ca976bdec92013b52f2ee0c9a0f249b5998fb63dd3e6d7964b07", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10414-original.ppm", + "sha256": "731d2ad7d40da37dcf6d85fa128aec8f652bb3c5e3a3a1cab7bf97f6ccd55c63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10414-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "52ee4577a74f409c5f90aad05f39a8f462f139685398bcb5c92ca0208f0150e8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "1a81c58b827f4533f41f6413a366a8f5e707f8b43039fc823ce9863fb0646e57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3221d17f268e21888a795e88ef677f5219f72a7788e57903fd900f55bbbf3556", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "81ca18fc0aae76a37f36e697efbdc6aa7a56acabfd7e20ce64d0cb5c38ffdaad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10415-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a04d2b78a0fe288544345cfbf99e031d1342591773c132de94f1a1a02a828c82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10415-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1fa8cb4aa3db5303d7e17c62876e69a352be0e71e34022902b3d5715ff56e4b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "557c5202b8790b5199d326695425b14f2f66b7f4beb101d38dd7b3dec54aa94e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a4ea4b96e7a9a77c54a8fee0f71718baecc64361ed931145badc415eb372ab90", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8797c65adee550343f481e5f5790ffc89b2b133f79bcafe3d67cfdf632cc594a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10416-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0f589865a0b7837ea238e4012e2dbb70d8f3b8b165127016fced78e0269b59cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10416-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "aaa8bfc0d7576c76523b26dc6ffdb70c966c03fc4f24eb0003cb9fb984f79490", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "421cd09e4c241a019cb279c1cecf404f83c892a4bd7dbaa652ceaaea037fbd2f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "84414bf8ec17dcfb3608cb42cc586f41fdbff735bc0f5b5d97434d0692424c3e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "83585b540986dd9f78869a8930858bd0dc141b69990b7ad6d91e36b2efc47cb2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10417-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d0986dfc3e26d68f0e04195cdf9d1e2b7f5da2cd23b880af56b9384ef963f7c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10417-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7588543821be396ed14b6bd3e78bb0c3e079cbe2b94613ad9ab155c7605697bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "72acdde37443a6200d4157882b0d13f182ab41b24f58e3067d104b47488b00cd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bb31621cec2f76017cf3f224cc20b0ddd78e126c51a1b8a2f6d4e411fc1d3987", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2e0fbc5e011994fd47197aec6f8e662b4816afd311c927b2031f2392ad459ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10418-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eb6deecd0c170702e64f0d50f246dd37c12d02c3e21f68fd1d2be8d3fee83348", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10418-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47acf1e50b2c79375a79cf912e60dcbdf36a1a60de9a826816c2f1559d9869a6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd88e0e034a3c6989221dcc7e1993969a120d8436f30b4cec883869b54b4c907", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "d9171e08c11d28e13c7d5e704a9a8c5b38f56f90e2a9195e7054cc9c5c70c6d2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "569a261febe59ad14728c89b23cc8dc5c24c525e8c1777fc4b16a8c6cc8a7a19", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "10419-original.ppm", + "sha256": "568481e4973c48993eef1f19374db65ef81246c8f2f1b0541666b8534c827e1b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/10419-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2cb304f42ba13ca5d827403c075d5577fb0bbe462db7988b2c02bf60801ab1f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "f486227c734f2925f00ba67e70491f2bc6f38724a2166133fa23197788bb6cdc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e68f73973e511dcbbd6d48a9feeedd02c59cfc336a0228daffb0af67aec23a75", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4ef398a88feec37105119dcdc37bab7fa0587b72c684702221829c12182de892", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b4b2c5dde1e1278d7534e9d7b4d1bf538d43f2e575426fcfe70e70c9cebdb15c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "236cc9a65e1e10ef753cc7316e25ae00e89b25dd5f80f9f35ec4765bc8fd2246", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "93dcfcd8359586da4dc1653e5f139e055d6cd3ec64c5cc004c18b2cf09db1bd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ee030edc5f9bc4ed6e197dbc81561d99798626f2cbe9750f2e8e2a55292e6896", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2d32515adf639db9afc206140be51c7de52e74d1c3f3146687bfe6fe4ca4baaa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "63ad4f656faaf16f8f5eabbe8298d9aeb5e0a642d6f23ee4696176da0e3559d3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "06d2a2a8ac1058499d10e311463dd6835201f001e14345fcb6913c182246a03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0a6814ad21c8b8bf9a11822713f299eda7eed35ff13b710c6cec53b4e15f83eb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c4f962337cfcacc4ea63bb3b6160b40f1c63145b7cf4d750611e731aeb79894", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "424b024a191e23319c0785e1d1a9980d62fa6e593febfafcb9f7c72649e3d14d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "26e2a8951641c52a403495952e503bc1017911e8681a96e595b5ece7cfb2e516", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9b0cbd4b654d771773680f4f04f96fb65630d04027e484be2346313a1e1cfa82", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8b66f6973fc86b3ef08a70a8bef6a397af7a487523956147167099a77f5c99df", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "60373b77be34a563be55f6c85aba51fa41c47e2ccab98b16fb5b27a30d6ef1f9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "606804f250f7244c0d6ed1b2646798104a885be8da8e993d5e154dd6dcaef12f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e1c234832095bcb0724c60c030b34a0d9994361dff8ecf5bc9c0cd256a66024e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "c8c90b8af19dc87065ff61cb9aea1481b33c4d58d051a91ff6e37fd516a5a3b5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b1875fffa16d39852af9d76ad362a705660166359f4a0d056c90e4fe5c3516c3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a69bca1ff1997e749b9994a4b186bc6c381070292d3ec38b0aca0ce21f8ebdcc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "9ef96b177a79477741a94979f135364b814764b6a717809947c08f8b4d2de232", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "38cd254a04df76a5439136d51ae7c4a60bc02c23eadfd671e8bd7c5222ac7410", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "2393ddef6f77d0f58cf018dc11bc4372f4783513e92726536a7aec53f6471d56", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "acded7cffcd4762f83293964eb7cea418769f251ce5f4de0feb8e54e16be156f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "edb024afb9c5b2bc80b0a9b13f8fa52ac69a302ab43d910026d58e66c53bc1a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c36ee8a23a83692aa4f2741be3f1125e9b005adb130b893cb804c8d85fdeccc7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "1041f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "cf5c9c74844d1ed57b443a3c02d305dbd234e7b6a5acba984b2e732e42825f67", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-10410-fixture-review/runtime/1041f-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "10420": { @@ -210063,7 +221639,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2038d-2039c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "df2fef17fc25db25d4c25d22c0b6da3ee947d1ef7f10b63276f6929161aa49dc", + "sha256": "aaf2344557b1d146478f0dcd9c1ffd5392a08fad6e90bc3114e6ca4ca788ce24", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -210100,7 +221676,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2038d-2039c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "df2fef17fc25db25d4c25d22c0b6da3ee947d1ef7f10b63276f6929161aa49dc", + "sha256": "aaf2344557b1d146478f0dcd9c1ffd5392a08fad6e90bc3114e6ca4ca788ce24", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -210137,7 +221713,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2038d-2039c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "df2fef17fc25db25d4c25d22c0b6da3ee947d1ef7f10b63276f6929161aa49dc", + "sha256": "aaf2344557b1d146478f0dcd9c1ffd5392a08fad6e90bc3114e6ca4ca788ce24", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -210174,7 +221750,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2038d-2039c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "df2fef17fc25db25d4c25d22c0b6da3ee947d1ef7f10b63276f6929161aa49dc", + "sha256": "aaf2344557b1d146478f0dcd9c1ffd5392a08fad6e90bc3114e6ca4ca788ce24", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -210211,7 +221787,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2038d-2039c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "df2fef17fc25db25d4c25d22c0b6da3ee947d1ef7f10b63276f6929161aa49dc", + "sha256": "aaf2344557b1d146478f0dcd9c1ffd5392a08fad6e90bc3114e6ca4ca788ce24", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -210248,7 +221824,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2038d-2039c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "df2fef17fc25db25d4c25d22c0b6da3ee947d1ef7f10b63276f6929161aa49dc", + "sha256": "aaf2344557b1d146478f0dcd9c1ffd5392a08fad6e90bc3114e6ca4ca788ce24", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -210285,7 +221861,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2038d-2039c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "df2fef17fc25db25d4c25d22c0b6da3ee947d1ef7f10b63276f6929161aa49dc", + "sha256": "aaf2344557b1d146478f0dcd9c1ffd5392a08fad6e90bc3114e6ca4ca788ce24", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -210322,7 +221898,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2038d-2039c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "df2fef17fc25db25d4c25d22c0b6da3ee947d1ef7f10b63276f6929161aa49dc", + "sha256": "aaf2344557b1d146478f0dcd9c1ffd5392a08fad6e90bc3114e6ca4ca788ce24", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -210359,7 +221935,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2038d-2039c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "df2fef17fc25db25d4c25d22c0b6da3ee947d1ef7f10b63276f6929161aa49dc", + "sha256": "aaf2344557b1d146478f0dcd9c1ffd5392a08fad6e90bc3114e6ca4ca788ce24", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -210396,7 +221972,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2038d-2039c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "df2fef17fc25db25d4c25d22c0b6da3ee947d1ef7f10b63276f6929161aa49dc", + "sha256": "aaf2344557b1d146478f0dcd9c1ffd5392a08fad6e90bc3114e6ca4ca788ce24", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -210433,7 +222009,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2038d-2039c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "df2fef17fc25db25d4c25d22c0b6da3ee947d1ef7f10b63276f6929161aa49dc", + "sha256": "aaf2344557b1d146478f0dcd9c1ffd5392a08fad6e90bc3114e6ca4ca788ce24", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -210470,7 +222046,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2038d-2039c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "df2fef17fc25db25d4c25d22c0b6da3ee947d1ef7f10b63276f6929161aa49dc", + "sha256": "aaf2344557b1d146478f0dcd9c1ffd5392a08fad6e90bc3114e6ca4ca788ce24", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -210507,7 +222083,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2038d-2039c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "df2fef17fc25db25d4c25d22c0b6da3ee947d1ef7f10b63276f6929161aa49dc", + "sha256": "aaf2344557b1d146478f0dcd9c1ffd5392a08fad6e90bc3114e6ca4ca788ce24", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -210544,7 +222120,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2038d-2039c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "df2fef17fc25db25d4c25d22c0b6da3ee947d1ef7f10b63276f6929161aa49dc", + "sha256": "aaf2344557b1d146478f0dcd9c1ffd5392a08fad6e90bc3114e6ca4ca788ce24", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -210581,7 +222157,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2038d-2039c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "df2fef17fc25db25d4c25d22c0b6da3ee947d1ef7f10b63276f6929161aa49dc", + "sha256": "aaf2344557b1d146478f0dcd9c1ffd5392a08fad6e90bc3114e6ca4ca788ce24", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -210618,7 +222194,7 @@ }, "candidate": { "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2038d-2039c/candidate.json", - "sha256": "df2fef17fc25db25d4c25d22c0b6da3ee947d1ef7f10b63276f6929161aa49dc", + "sha256": "aaf2344557b1d146478f0dcd9c1ffd5392a08fad6e90bc3114e6ca4ca788ce24", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, @@ -210641,7 +222217,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2039d", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -210652,6 +222228,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2039d-203ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "641d41acd2eb582259958c125a7b5c1a579dc300b927773a6b7b14e4501c3aad", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2039e": { @@ -210673,7 +222254,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2039e", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -210684,6 +222265,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2039d-203ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "641d41acd2eb582259958c125a7b5c1a579dc300b927773a6b7b14e4501c3aad", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "2039f": { @@ -210705,7 +222291,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2039f", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -210716,6 +222302,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2039d-203ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "641d41acd2eb582259958c125a7b5c1a579dc300b927773a6b7b14e4501c3aad", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203a0": { @@ -210737,7 +222328,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203a0", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -210748,6 +222339,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2039d-203ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "641d41acd2eb582259958c125a7b5c1a579dc300b927773a6b7b14e4501c3aad", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203a1": { @@ -210769,7 +222365,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203a1", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -210780,6 +222376,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2039d-203ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "641d41acd2eb582259958c125a7b5c1a579dc300b927773a6b7b14e4501c3aad", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203a2": { @@ -210801,7 +222402,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203a2", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -210812,6 +222413,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2039d-203ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "641d41acd2eb582259958c125a7b5c1a579dc300b927773a6b7b14e4501c3aad", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203a3": { @@ -210833,7 +222439,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203a3", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -210844,6 +222450,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2039d-203ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "641d41acd2eb582259958c125a7b5c1a579dc300b927773a6b7b14e4501c3aad", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203a4": { @@ -210865,7 +222476,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203a4", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -210876,6 +222487,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2039d-203ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "641d41acd2eb582259958c125a7b5c1a579dc300b927773a6b7b14e4501c3aad", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203a5": { @@ -210897,7 +222513,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203a5", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -210908,6 +222524,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2039d-203ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "641d41acd2eb582259958c125a7b5c1a579dc300b927773a6b7b14e4501c3aad", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203a6": { @@ -210929,7 +222550,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203a6", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -210940,6 +222561,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2039d-203ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "641d41acd2eb582259958c125a7b5c1a579dc300b927773a6b7b14e4501c3aad", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203a7": { @@ -210961,7 +222587,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20395", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -210972,6 +222598,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2039d-203ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "641d41acd2eb582259958c125a7b5c1a579dc300b927773a6b7b14e4501c3aad", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203a8": { @@ -210993,7 +222624,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203a8", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -211004,6 +222635,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2039d-203ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "641d41acd2eb582259958c125a7b5c1a579dc300b927773a6b7b14e4501c3aad", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203a9": { @@ -211025,7 +222661,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203a9", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -211036,6 +222672,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2039d-203ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "641d41acd2eb582259958c125a7b5c1a579dc300b927773a6b7b14e4501c3aad", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203aa": { @@ -211057,7 +222698,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203aa", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -211068,6 +222709,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2039d-203ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "641d41acd2eb582259958c125a7b5c1a579dc300b927773a6b7b14e4501c3aad", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203ab": { @@ -211089,7 +222735,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203ab", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -211100,6 +222746,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2039d-203ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "641d41acd2eb582259958c125a7b5c1a579dc300b927773a6b7b14e4501c3aad", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203ac": { @@ -211121,7 +222772,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203ac", "family_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", "job_id": "terrain-2039d-203ac", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -211132,6 +222783,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-2039d-203ac/candidate.json", + "sha256": "641d41acd2eb582259958c125a7b5c1a579dc300b927773a6b7b14e4501c3aad", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203ad": { @@ -211153,8 +222809,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203ad", "family_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", "job_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211164,6 +222820,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203ad-203bc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "781d0cd49d3ad2cff9d8abbf84c32b14add72d3634184ca040c0ad69f8c42d31", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203ae": { @@ -211185,8 +222846,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203ae", "family_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", "job_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211196,6 +222857,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203ad-203bc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "781d0cd49d3ad2cff9d8abbf84c32b14add72d3634184ca040c0ad69f8c42d31", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203af": { @@ -211217,8 +222883,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203af", "family_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", "job_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211228,6 +222894,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203ad-203bc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "781d0cd49d3ad2cff9d8abbf84c32b14add72d3634184ca040c0ad69f8c42d31", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203b0": { @@ -211249,8 +222920,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203b0", "family_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", "job_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211260,6 +222931,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203ad-203bc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "781d0cd49d3ad2cff9d8abbf84c32b14add72d3634184ca040c0ad69f8c42d31", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203b1": { @@ -211281,8 +222957,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203b1", "family_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", "job_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211292,6 +222968,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203ad-203bc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "781d0cd49d3ad2cff9d8abbf84c32b14add72d3634184ca040c0ad69f8c42d31", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203b2": { @@ -211313,8 +222994,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20323", "family_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", "job_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -211324,6 +223005,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203ad-203bc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "781d0cd49d3ad2cff9d8abbf84c32b14add72d3634184ca040c0ad69f8c42d31", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203b3": { @@ -211345,8 +223031,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203b3", "family_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", "job_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211356,6 +223042,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203ad-203bc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "781d0cd49d3ad2cff9d8abbf84c32b14add72d3634184ca040c0ad69f8c42d31", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203b4": { @@ -211377,8 +223068,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203b4", "family_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", "job_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211388,6 +223079,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203ad-203bc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "781d0cd49d3ad2cff9d8abbf84c32b14add72d3634184ca040c0ad69f8c42d31", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203b5": { @@ -211409,8 +223105,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203b5", "family_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", "job_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211420,6 +223116,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203ad-203bc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "781d0cd49d3ad2cff9d8abbf84c32b14add72d3634184ca040c0ad69f8c42d31", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203b6": { @@ -211441,8 +223142,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203b6", "family_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", "job_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211452,6 +223153,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203ad-203bc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "781d0cd49d3ad2cff9d8abbf84c32b14add72d3634184ca040c0ad69f8c42d31", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203b7": { @@ -211473,8 +223179,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203b7", "family_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", "job_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211484,6 +223190,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203ad-203bc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "781d0cd49d3ad2cff9d8abbf84c32b14add72d3634184ca040c0ad69f8c42d31", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203b8": { @@ -211505,8 +223216,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203b8", "family_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", "job_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211516,6 +223227,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203ad-203bc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "781d0cd49d3ad2cff9d8abbf84c32b14add72d3634184ca040c0ad69f8c42d31", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203b9": { @@ -211537,8 +223253,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203b9", "family_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", "job_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211548,6 +223264,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203ad-203bc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "781d0cd49d3ad2cff9d8abbf84c32b14add72d3634184ca040c0ad69f8c42d31", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203ba": { @@ -211569,8 +223290,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203ba", "family_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", "job_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211580,6 +223301,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203ad-203bc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "781d0cd49d3ad2cff9d8abbf84c32b14add72d3634184ca040c0ad69f8c42d31", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203bb": { @@ -211601,8 +223327,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203bb", "family_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", "job_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211612,6 +223338,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203ad-203bc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "781d0cd49d3ad2cff9d8abbf84c32b14add72d3634184ca040c0ad69f8c42d31", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203bc": { @@ -211633,8 +223364,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20323", "family_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", "job_id": "terrain-203ad-203bc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -211644,6 +223375,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203ad-203bc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "781d0cd49d3ad2cff9d8abbf84c32b14add72d3634184ca040c0ad69f8c42d31", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203bd": { @@ -211665,8 +223401,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203bd", "family_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", "job_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211676,6 +223412,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203bd-203cc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "65fc4af4dc292a5c887776b599cfe6e5a2dae814720f6f96442b93ceea284dc0", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203be": { @@ -211697,8 +223438,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203be", "family_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", "job_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211708,6 +223449,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203bd-203cc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "65fc4af4dc292a5c887776b599cfe6e5a2dae814720f6f96442b93ceea284dc0", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203bf": { @@ -211729,8 +223475,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203bf", "family_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", "job_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211740,6 +223486,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203bd-203cc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "65fc4af4dc292a5c887776b599cfe6e5a2dae814720f6f96442b93ceea284dc0", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203c0": { @@ -211761,8 +223512,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203c0", "family_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", "job_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211772,6 +223523,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203bd-203cc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "65fc4af4dc292a5c887776b599cfe6e5a2dae814720f6f96442b93ceea284dc0", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203c1": { @@ -211793,8 +223549,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203c1", "family_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", "job_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211804,6 +223560,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203bd-203cc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "65fc4af4dc292a5c887776b599cfe6e5a2dae814720f6f96442b93ceea284dc0", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203c2": { @@ -211825,8 +223586,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203c2", "family_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", "job_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211836,6 +223597,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203bd-203cc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "65fc4af4dc292a5c887776b599cfe6e5a2dae814720f6f96442b93ceea284dc0", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203c3": { @@ -211857,8 +223623,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203c3", "family_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", "job_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211868,6 +223634,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203bd-203cc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "65fc4af4dc292a5c887776b599cfe6e5a2dae814720f6f96442b93ceea284dc0", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203c4": { @@ -211889,8 +223660,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203c4", "family_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", "job_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211900,6 +223671,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203bd-203cc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "65fc4af4dc292a5c887776b599cfe6e5a2dae814720f6f96442b93ceea284dc0", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203c5": { @@ -211921,8 +223697,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203c5", "family_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", "job_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211932,6 +223708,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203bd-203cc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "65fc4af4dc292a5c887776b599cfe6e5a2dae814720f6f96442b93ceea284dc0", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203c6": { @@ -211953,8 +223734,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203c6", "family_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", "job_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211964,6 +223745,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203bd-203cc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "65fc4af4dc292a5c887776b599cfe6e5a2dae814720f6f96442b93ceea284dc0", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203c7": { @@ -211985,8 +223771,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203c7", "family_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", "job_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -211996,6 +223782,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203bd-203cc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "65fc4af4dc292a5c887776b599cfe6e5a2dae814720f6f96442b93ceea284dc0", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203c8": { @@ -212017,8 +223808,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203c8", "family_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", "job_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212028,6 +223819,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203bd-203cc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "65fc4af4dc292a5c887776b599cfe6e5a2dae814720f6f96442b93ceea284dc0", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203c9": { @@ -212049,8 +223845,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203c9", "family_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", "job_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212060,6 +223856,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203bd-203cc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "65fc4af4dc292a5c887776b599cfe6e5a2dae814720f6f96442b93ceea284dc0", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203ca": { @@ -212081,8 +223882,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203ca", "family_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", "job_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212092,6 +223893,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203bd-203cc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "65fc4af4dc292a5c887776b599cfe6e5a2dae814720f6f96442b93ceea284dc0", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203cb": { @@ -212113,8 +223919,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203cb", "family_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", "job_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212124,6 +223930,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203bd-203cc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "65fc4af4dc292a5c887776b599cfe6e5a2dae814720f6f96442b93ceea284dc0", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203cc": { @@ -212145,8 +223956,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203cc", "family_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", "job_id": "terrain-203bd-203cc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212156,6 +223967,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203bd-203cc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "65fc4af4dc292a5c887776b599cfe6e5a2dae814720f6f96442b93ceea284dc0", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203cd": { @@ -212177,8 +223993,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203cd", "family_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", "job_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212188,6 +224004,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203cd-203dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f75d960567f8797a66b8736004720d0bbd71fa2a2b4c2ed2746bd8ba2a651072", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203ce": { @@ -212209,8 +224030,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203ce", "family_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", "job_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212220,6 +224041,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203cd-203dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f75d960567f8797a66b8736004720d0bbd71fa2a2b4c2ed2746bd8ba2a651072", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203cf": { @@ -212241,8 +224067,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203cf", "family_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", "job_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212252,6 +224078,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203cd-203dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f75d960567f8797a66b8736004720d0bbd71fa2a2b4c2ed2746bd8ba2a651072", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203d0": { @@ -212273,8 +224104,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203d0", "family_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", "job_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212284,6 +224115,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203cd-203dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f75d960567f8797a66b8736004720d0bbd71fa2a2b4c2ed2746bd8ba2a651072", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203d1": { @@ -212305,8 +224141,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203d1", "family_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", "job_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212316,6 +224152,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203cd-203dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f75d960567f8797a66b8736004720d0bbd71fa2a2b4c2ed2746bd8ba2a651072", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203d2": { @@ -212337,8 +224178,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203d2", "family_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", "job_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212348,6 +224189,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203cd-203dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f75d960567f8797a66b8736004720d0bbd71fa2a2b4c2ed2746bd8ba2a651072", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203d3": { @@ -212369,8 +224215,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203d3", "family_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", "job_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -212380,6 +224226,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203cd-203dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f75d960567f8797a66b8736004720d0bbd71fa2a2b4c2ed2746bd8ba2a651072", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203d4": { @@ -212401,8 +224252,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203d4", "family_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", "job_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212412,6 +224263,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203cd-203dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f75d960567f8797a66b8736004720d0bbd71fa2a2b4c2ed2746bd8ba2a651072", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203d5": { @@ -212433,8 +224289,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203d5", "family_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", "job_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -212444,6 +224300,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203cd-203dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f75d960567f8797a66b8736004720d0bbd71fa2a2b4c2ed2746bd8ba2a651072", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203d6": { @@ -212465,8 +224326,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203d6", "family_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", "job_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -212476,6 +224337,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203cd-203dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f75d960567f8797a66b8736004720d0bbd71fa2a2b4c2ed2746bd8ba2a651072", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203d7": { @@ -212497,8 +224363,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203d7", "family_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", "job_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212508,6 +224374,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203cd-203dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f75d960567f8797a66b8736004720d0bbd71fa2a2b4c2ed2746bd8ba2a651072", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203d8": { @@ -212529,8 +224400,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203d8", "family_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", "job_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212540,6 +224411,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203cd-203dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f75d960567f8797a66b8736004720d0bbd71fa2a2b4c2ed2746bd8ba2a651072", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203d9": { @@ -212561,8 +224437,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203d9", "family_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", "job_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212572,6 +224448,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203cd-203dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f75d960567f8797a66b8736004720d0bbd71fa2a2b4c2ed2746bd8ba2a651072", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203da": { @@ -212593,8 +224474,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203d6", "family_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", "job_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212604,6 +224485,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203cd-203dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f75d960567f8797a66b8736004720d0bbd71fa2a2b4c2ed2746bd8ba2a651072", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203db": { @@ -212625,8 +224511,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203db", "family_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", "job_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212636,6 +224522,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203cd-203dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f75d960567f8797a66b8736004720d0bbd71fa2a2b4c2ed2746bd8ba2a651072", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203dc": { @@ -212657,8 +224548,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203dc", "family_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", "job_id": "terrain-203cd-203dc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "candidate", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -212668,6 +224559,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-203cd-203dc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "f75d960567f8797a66b8736004720d0bbd71fa2a2b4c2ed2746bd8ba2a651072", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "203dd": { @@ -212689,8 +224585,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203dd", "family_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", "job_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212721,8 +224617,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203de", "family_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", "job_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212753,8 +224649,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203df", "family_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", "job_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212785,8 +224681,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203e0", "family_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", "job_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212817,8 +224713,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203e1", "family_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", "job_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212849,8 +224745,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203e2", "family_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", "job_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212881,8 +224777,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203e3", "family_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", "job_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212913,8 +224809,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203e4", "family_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", "job_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212945,8 +224841,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203e5", "family_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", "job_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -212977,8 +224873,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203e6", "family_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", "job_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213009,8 +224905,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203e7", "family_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", "job_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213041,8 +224937,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203e8", "family_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", "job_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213073,8 +224969,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203e9", "family_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", "job_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213105,8 +225001,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203ea", "family_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", "job_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213137,8 +225033,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203eb", "family_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", "job_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -213169,8 +225065,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203ec", "family_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", "job_id": "terrain-203dd-203ec", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -213201,8 +225097,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203ed", "family_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", "job_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -213233,8 +225129,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203ee", "family_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", "job_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213265,8 +225161,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203ef", "family_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", "job_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213297,8 +225193,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203f0", "family_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", "job_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213329,8 +225225,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203f1", "family_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", "job_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213361,8 +225257,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203f2", "family_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", "job_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -213393,8 +225289,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203f3", "family_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", "job_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -213425,8 +225321,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203f4", "family_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", "job_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213457,8 +225353,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203f5", "family_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", "job_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213489,8 +225385,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203f6", "family_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", "job_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213521,8 +225417,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203f7", "family_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", "job_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213553,8 +225449,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203f8", "family_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", "job_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -213585,8 +225481,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203f9", "family_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", "job_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -213617,8 +225513,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203fa", "family_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", "job_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213649,8 +225545,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203fb", "family_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", "job_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213681,8 +225577,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203fc", "family_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", "job_id": "terrain-203ed-203fc", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213713,8 +225609,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203fd", "family_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", "job_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213745,8 +225641,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203fe", "family_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", "job_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -213777,8 +225673,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "203ff", "family_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", "job_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213809,8 +225705,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20400", "family_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", "job_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -213841,8 +225737,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20401", "family_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", "job_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213873,8 +225769,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20402", "family_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", "job_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213905,8 +225801,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20403", "family_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", "job_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213937,8 +225833,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20404", "family_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", "job_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -213969,8 +225865,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20405", "family_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", "job_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -214001,8 +225897,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20406", "family_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", "job_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -214033,8 +225929,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20407", "family_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", "job_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, "renderer": { @@ -214065,8 +225961,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20408", "family_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", "job_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -214097,8 +225993,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "20409", "family_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", "job_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -214129,8 +226025,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2040a", "family_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", "job_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -214161,8 +226057,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2040b", "family_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", "job_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -214193,8 +226089,8 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "2040c", "family_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", "job_id": "terrain-203fd-2040c", - "status": "missing", - "owner": null, + "status": "inprogress", + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, "renderer": { @@ -251485,7 +263381,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "3011d", "family_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", "job_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "iron_coast_6", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -251501,6 +263397,472 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/candidate.json", "sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "18c9acd13ec59e49f0c08b6bc7f75566ebbae7288f30aea891b348614ff765c0", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.680654+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [{\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011d\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011d\", \"crop\": [0, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 0, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint, surviving gray roof fragments and surface partition remain in place. Stronger rubble, orange flecks and narrow radial cracks are accepted fine interpretation.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2261\", \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011e\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011e\", \"crop\": [314, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 1, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The damaged dark area and source roof-edge remnants remain readable. Pebble-like rubble and radial fine cracks strengthen detail without rebuilding an intact roof.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2262\", \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011f\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011f\", \"crop\": [627, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 2, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The near-square destroyed patch and surviving gray remnants retain their layout. Added thin dark crack lines and warm embers are accepted material detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2263\", \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30120\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30120\", \"crop\": [940, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 3, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source char shape and bordering pale structural patches remain damaged. Stronger grain/highlights are accepted rather than claimed as exact source RGB.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2264\", \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30121\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30121\", \"crop\": [0, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 4, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The central dark destruction, gray edge fragments and native surrounding building geometry remain in place. New metal/rubble detail is accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2265\", \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30122\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30122\", \"crop\": [314, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 5, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight remnant edges and damaged patch remain recognizable. Added thin radial cracks and embers remain fine damage detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2266\", \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30123\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30123\", \"crop\": [627, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 6, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The brighter left structural ribs and top remnant correspond to existing gray source fragments. The central destruction remains open/dark; sharper clean edges, stone-like rubble and orange flecks are interpretation, not an exact untouched SD material claim.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2267\", \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30124\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30124\", \"crop\": [940, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 7, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original opaque destroyed-surface tile retains its dark damaged footprint and surrounding gray fragments. Approved as source-bound gallery artwork only: the actual original registry contains no native mission samples, neighbors or state partners for this ID.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 0, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2268\", \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\", \"unused_gallery_only\": true, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30125\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30125\", \"crop\": [0, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 8, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original irregular damaged footprint and surviving gray vertical remnants are retained. Newly authored fine rubble and cracks are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2269\", \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30126\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30126\", \"crop\": [314, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 9, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source gray structural edge and dark damaged patch remain in their arrangement; brighter fine metal detail does not rebuild the entire intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2270\", \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30127\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30127\", \"crop\": [627, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 10, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source destruction and gray surviving fragments remain readable. Fine embers and grain are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2271\", \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30128\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30128\", \"crop\": [940, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 11, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint and roof-edge remnants remain in place; stronger fine cracks/highlights are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2272\", \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30129\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30129\", \"crop\": [0, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 12, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The gray linear remnants and asymmetric char geometry remain in the source arrangement. Radial fine cracks and orange highlights add damage material rather than an intact object.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2273\", \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012a\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012a\", \"crop\": [314, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 13, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The sharpened top/left metal rim and lower/right upright fragments correspond to existing source gray structures. Brighter steel and embers are accepted; the black damage remains, and no complete repaired roof appears.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2274\", \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012b\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012b\", \"crop\": [627, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 14, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The small central pale source remnant is interpreted as a short grooved metal piece; neighboring pale edges and char layout remain aligned. This is explicit material interpretation, with stronger rubble/embers, rather than exact original subpixel hardware fidelity.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 1, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2275\", \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012c\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012c\", \"crop\": [940, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 15, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight gray remnants around the broad dark damaged area remain readable. Fine stones, cracks and embers are accepted without restoring a complete intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2276\", \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}] [\"Brighter shard4 steel, radial thin cracks, rounded rubble and warm orange flecks are newly authored interpretation rather than exact SD grain/RGB. Source damaged dark areas remain damaged; no complete rebuilt roof was observed.\", \"30123/3012a existing straight gray source fragments gain cleaner metal edges.3012b central pale remnant is interpreted as a small grooved metal piece; this specific material interpretation is accepted and disclosed.\", \"Four held sibling remnants retain an approximate gray/dark area and closer1x palette average but larger native artwork loses visible straight surviving metal fragments. Opaque coverage cannot overrule that art defect.\", \"Mixed HD and ScaleNx-original tiles remain visibly different in texture density/material, including rectangular transitions in joined scenes. The two-logical-pixel edge transition is not claimed to hide every seam. No shifted major panel/roof/pipe boundary was found in the declared cases.\"] [\"All current individual declarations reviewed: up to3 authentic native samples per target, every declared cardinal ID pair and declared state-partner swap. This is not every whole map or every simultaneous destruction arrangement.\", \"Context1\\u20134 outputs were numerically checked and saved; complete fine scene galleries visually inspect native4x with64px original overviews, supplemented by every full source tile and actual1\\u20134 tile view. No claim of visually inspecting every whole context at native1/2/3.\", \"Joined64 is only127 representative context/state probes. Supporting earlier32 candidates are not newly approved here, and held4 remain held despite their inclusion in the diagnostic pack.\", \"Boundary means, full opaque mask overlap and source-class diagnostics establish neither artistic fidelity nor an invisible seam on their own.\", \"Actual static indexed loading/TerrainHd composition is verified. No live gameplay, arbitrary palette-fade cycle, mission1080p performance or unsupported route claim is made.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 755667dfb498724e17a35358d8d01541f51783b061cf26f80684c0d618ad68cb", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/complete-actual-ppm-manifest.json", + "sha256": "d330c159a081d63ce647a4f23ae9f84764b77e6ba3208b018079d321829dc89d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "3011d", + "3011e", + "3011f", + "30120" + ], + "sha256": "600f121057342084138f279aa0658376f00f4b9e4bd9de517f27028fb03b7c89", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30121", + "30122", + "30123", + "30124" + ], + "sha256": "23bad5451e0549b68fb2cf3cca3fc4b0557399bbd9b5190387cb7768a2a66c6f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "30125", + "30126", + "30127", + "30128" + ], + "sha256": "7720739a3e24872e00be5bc44e3e33a73a1e2e214352e6bbc8e7ef8ed7cfc8c4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "30129", + "3012a", + "3012b", + "3012c" + ], + "sha256": "8c976232ef3f87f905078ad64956e45187450c8c815e5847185d62be1b53de57", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "3011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47ddc428ba9c9d9a4ff0a52180f361be8b4c3f6fa958a19921cc11359cd52bd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e0a2dbf264485816ed3267ecd2c9fdeaca82660bdeef65f31c865e7a89bac3b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "402daf19f6f512ab35774f6ed760f5dd6beeb59ddcb98e9ec0cbe2e484963614", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "54b506e3c0aab49652dc095169bf8cf454f8ae0fed8bff3c1d0a68c52b834d86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f019a5361935df3e0117fd7e33e2b03787c108f5c540c23feebcd02cea3e64fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7b7c411788f55a818a1c2cf8eea745fdff2643abbae945138e848629b6de795a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ee4eb50f1339382c177f648af0add2c3f2a29aa24146e8bb364caf2bed06ea9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c1ab9b8da0357fefae1052a8ff97dc0876fa8ce6ab7c0fba0e939a2ee14a94f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "36f33b244c675e12428d57f9221dfac75fe211c80efed3f5a9450b22bcb50b2d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0fbc59221c897bde1aa195a44d6adb177b70954b21649445d087d12e475c379c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "649b8b00021215527674e058df3fd256a1ec58412bc656a62265e4511911ac27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5fd8af719d76cd017cba0b9e4b06b7e757ab376fec39c05693ef3139f6694097", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3867102b30ec60a6a0aadf2b13bb9f5f011306a51b7350d780a0e103024ac40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2076c09d7a71382739c2d0bf91888306ec65704e3090d92a15ca86dc7e1afa5c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bfb9a0c60f0c6b01b65dda24d57466f2a703f3d9b5fe926faa7942c9f3b49d04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e7f4579a56d595ba76c9e2d54321536ba3a2a8637d5e48a341742a6cf5ccd4cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7b2f9d98c2c922b243b9931c01ad61d02fe12a34a0c498d2cbf92028417391c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1e8dc9addaff9746c6dbee04189f2aaf8564c24fdea0f0951383fad1a8f3882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d26c5dd1942fa19f5b5cc8f927c17097b0dd6bef961f3e88d80808b5285ad759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af1be35802274ab0d1c46603c956f489363548583236a299b03ec9050e81dd53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0dd02a5723dfa38f8775cec3647a943dc81417295fe1267b5c8bb4e3013b1270", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dfae46f975fe415e11e77e15dc2b76de74a945bd4f57dcaebc7e3db06e932252", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9c87c2b2144a6857da73773a6de95b2ceaa34ddb464c003580004d1aebd91c45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "37da9b687aa89e9a1db920b5e9733e0ea6a73a9b325d49abb94df7cdb17855ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b3b11eff5c3f378bc986e31529c558566128d6d3cc38baedce3f63d6e41bba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4430a061e8f802ebfece64b2a74e4c9d2f3356df3d9dcc0b38ab399fbb6547b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d3068a6f407760188f934c7831a8978b1358e8d79b2394532ebcaeee5d610ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "351f358673bd32ee15bfc568a2ad8d5d9225a35341c07dad177691ba3e28c01a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "614ce68b7068d2c91714eaa7f759a4b3bd5e6e28c861046cea488f6ab224f3a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3cbfc85bc6e8eb13a412beda0aee76bba2c364bf2287a291491e5e654e77600b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f515fb9d1d66c68ba439f7ae83c4231dca92a73ff9378e158bf836e4ce68e783", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "16f0b4176b2b7e1ccbb1e6c86409d1ebb26eddc44fd0891948d4791341355f66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "95eb90b9a3cf2998bc492101cdcf5173d33705d2166ab90f5483b333983fc5a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d5462c8c176b17b062f64261b38a484e9890019d65a814e2f7b5f2f6eeee4c10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0d8fb1653d0b2f0ef5349f8d9f23f30e5cb323b2bccdce6197afcab3dd662ddd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1a027e0e27a8b818730dd5c0c5065a4448000e32f30bd648a10fc87897aaa95f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fff16fe61cc4d73d972ab9d12a52f112d8ef13fb7b37cb66c4d3db99108c9493", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ed83201f80607e31227cb59a6ac9d6a47df8e9ae61dd840c8a325bdb94ff2d27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "66cf27b7f00b72f4ac8733b72bc2b8fe0d0da239b0790317c03a84164fd3112b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "636e3d4a735c65070f1ac27eca1e2e12480ad27aab7a3c25335b9ed63a70027a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9da55e79f9c8724cebaf96ff69bac1ea23e84b4b70da1c696c8bbf117c2c2cd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ecf7acb2aaeb61dd2d728d7eeba7fe605ba2b76918015b97644fd133ac3c8171", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35a31bb6430524337048b347b350438565fc201e38153d60a99212f7ac4027e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3d63079e5a08c322c9fac8dc8ac154311ef252925d52c80d8f67d2c001c8ac45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90a1794aecdd5b5deb149dd21d4b77a2c9d5782f39c2bf418f3b40b14b46d4cc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b22802e327df7a43ff9e376c7f4aaf845d7f316c3a725c9c8ebdbde3dd3902ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd800cad574c5df989975871b2b09755df2e325e5190b4ad7869016a743bae02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74d2c4b9afb453a5dc814646c607c15f6e9a36f0257bd74998c3192b4916f8e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b4cc4e5d79e39b64fba94b3157d78eea8b44e69327d73667bc0c1e3dc120086e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9c703237fa600c8c4f635e9ec4b4cb4545da4fa768bb0f3695a8ce355c50eb5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1d991ecd07dfcacb890ac7101f944ca381bb73b073bdf1f6512724c4b16290b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "eb3015b83566d6eb34bf371da10666ed17d98d601f2c1030e68f94869067064c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81c40ad363129c77e53e1af99bd3e812ac9e933eb5d7091eb10c57d00610a08e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "697f34b746d8415d6d2e38e61f0d0737085d3981f5b1bfddc4ddc5df26425f76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "51aa7854bc4f1b5a8a6ee6c1d037b988383b415b8f6553bba5ea8c79415b9d63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "07d57094b6e20e052ff8f8da02c481058984c8781081f42d72947a22f0804c4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2d38d2a77ce433ea11ceb70d117f7c34c16b363eebb0fae4f0b49506b0b2a3b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f933dcafc0210f7dccffedfb36e2e99a18727ec501f37adb9781f765e2da6d8d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eb36aa9be293846bf1880a2f116479504770cbb86189451a3db1607d3245721c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9102e1307b087bcca0da28eefab6e294bded5fe84361e768ca8b95d4a06f3d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "56a6678ed32cdc2e9fa63defa9b0d7a5b7f45f59f1dae4b7c393deb3677ebd29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7afe25456c3f32795fde058ce1c114d8dbc2c92f940b843515fd8ab0d95aff44", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb3265816babfe4a0be59814473a8853d39683f51f110d1621ca1be2ac57ef06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7dda2d9fab9948724dd8b0884cf9370ca4cb3b9b9f9e963dbe3723f08038629a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8719368b9dea0ce143caea9a4cd15711e927acdc6f3df852a91eed7a6ce5142d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8d3e57945ea6a29a083ae6c4f1fcf08995a9971fd6ae5474af00c6b5c7c74c78", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "39db6b3a0247644fa0df7d5327d619e355a2e6891b8c842f86714f58763d1106", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6e5ebf63998007218f0d1705fbff02eafce120b1dc1585e0b26e5444f7fedfda", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c30cd53dda67959c4913124d079582303c9fd021ce258876ebbabb57e2ecae24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "69b7a3ee544111ee27eae2177134496c1fd325da2365cc5046c505e3c972ef04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "752c1ad8534130f53eb85c4ec18b67259cf7780f7dcba63132dd942457f21341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "92eeeb391492f1f28ac9a7cf9f16c7596771249836af0aa1c70e94169cd7909c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e24fab4c8b3ff68ddbdc4d639d5dd88318b7d20cc23482c9fce07f35601859e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1f4debdb9cd6900ad5a4338e2d3129dcd1ff47c4cb3771b83eba24c2b6fbb8de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8dffadf9fbed460de6480bf668f65e65555179943981f21920d69e7432e59957", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36c99dbab51a147932fef004caee8a14b8a465f590ea3b07f2c901d7abe7dedd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b8e2051339dce4c6e0c5c06d3ea596b53132677d6ad49b7f17ffb54f0f2914c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1795161adccbf83cf99216fc8ffc6b5c224cf94f43617593a520799cb7168d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f981283c260f11a57eb352eadc5aac098c61cf4108af99d26d037b53ee505469", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9fcef15e698582bef7087a4c23e4fade00d86f7c0ceb6afada84760e6a4b79e3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "3011e": { @@ -251522,7 +263884,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "3011e", "family_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", "job_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "iron_coast_6", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -251538,6 +263900,472 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/candidate.json", "sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "18c9acd13ec59e49f0c08b6bc7f75566ebbae7288f30aea891b348614ff765c0", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.680654+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [{\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011d\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011d\", \"crop\": [0, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 0, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint, surviving gray roof fragments and surface partition remain in place. Stronger rubble, orange flecks and narrow radial cracks are accepted fine interpretation.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2261\", \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011e\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011e\", \"crop\": [314, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 1, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The damaged dark area and source roof-edge remnants remain readable. Pebble-like rubble and radial fine cracks strengthen detail without rebuilding an intact roof.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2262\", \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011f\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011f\", \"crop\": [627, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 2, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The near-square destroyed patch and surviving gray remnants retain their layout. Added thin dark crack lines and warm embers are accepted material detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2263\", \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30120\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30120\", \"crop\": [940, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 3, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source char shape and bordering pale structural patches remain damaged. Stronger grain/highlights are accepted rather than claimed as exact source RGB.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2264\", \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30121\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30121\", \"crop\": [0, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 4, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The central dark destruction, gray edge fragments and native surrounding building geometry remain in place. New metal/rubble detail is accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2265\", \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30122\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30122\", \"crop\": [314, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 5, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight remnant edges and damaged patch remain recognizable. Added thin radial cracks and embers remain fine damage detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2266\", \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30123\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30123\", \"crop\": [627, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 6, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The brighter left structural ribs and top remnant correspond to existing gray source fragments. The central destruction remains open/dark; sharper clean edges, stone-like rubble and orange flecks are interpretation, not an exact untouched SD material claim.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2267\", \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30124\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30124\", \"crop\": [940, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 7, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original opaque destroyed-surface tile retains its dark damaged footprint and surrounding gray fragments. Approved as source-bound gallery artwork only: the actual original registry contains no native mission samples, neighbors or state partners for this ID.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 0, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2268\", \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\", \"unused_gallery_only\": true, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30125\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30125\", \"crop\": [0, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 8, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original irregular damaged footprint and surviving gray vertical remnants are retained. Newly authored fine rubble and cracks are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2269\", \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30126\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30126\", \"crop\": [314, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 9, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source gray structural edge and dark damaged patch remain in their arrangement; brighter fine metal detail does not rebuild the entire intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2270\", \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30127\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30127\", \"crop\": [627, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 10, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source destruction and gray surviving fragments remain readable. Fine embers and grain are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2271\", \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30128\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30128\", \"crop\": [940, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 11, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint and roof-edge remnants remain in place; stronger fine cracks/highlights are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2272\", \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30129\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30129\", \"crop\": [0, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 12, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The gray linear remnants and asymmetric char geometry remain in the source arrangement. Radial fine cracks and orange highlights add damage material rather than an intact object.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2273\", \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012a\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012a\", \"crop\": [314, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 13, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The sharpened top/left metal rim and lower/right upright fragments correspond to existing source gray structures. Brighter steel and embers are accepted; the black damage remains, and no complete repaired roof appears.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2274\", \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012b\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012b\", \"crop\": [627, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 14, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The small central pale source remnant is interpreted as a short grooved metal piece; neighboring pale edges and char layout remain aligned. This is explicit material interpretation, with stronger rubble/embers, rather than exact original subpixel hardware fidelity.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 1, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2275\", \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012c\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012c\", \"crop\": [940, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 15, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight gray remnants around the broad dark damaged area remain readable. Fine stones, cracks and embers are accepted without restoring a complete intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2276\", \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}] [\"Brighter shard4 steel, radial thin cracks, rounded rubble and warm orange flecks are newly authored interpretation rather than exact SD grain/RGB. Source damaged dark areas remain damaged; no complete rebuilt roof was observed.\", \"30123/3012a existing straight gray source fragments gain cleaner metal edges.3012b central pale remnant is interpreted as a small grooved metal piece; this specific material interpretation is accepted and disclosed.\", \"Four held sibling remnants retain an approximate gray/dark area and closer1x palette average but larger native artwork loses visible straight surviving metal fragments. Opaque coverage cannot overrule that art defect.\", \"Mixed HD and ScaleNx-original tiles remain visibly different in texture density/material, including rectangular transitions in joined scenes. The two-logical-pixel edge transition is not claimed to hide every seam. No shifted major panel/roof/pipe boundary was found in the declared cases.\"] [\"All current individual declarations reviewed: up to3 authentic native samples per target, every declared cardinal ID pair and declared state-partner swap. This is not every whole map or every simultaneous destruction arrangement.\", \"Context1\\u20134 outputs were numerically checked and saved; complete fine scene galleries visually inspect native4x with64px original overviews, supplemented by every full source tile and actual1\\u20134 tile view. No claim of visually inspecting every whole context at native1/2/3.\", \"Joined64 is only127 representative context/state probes. Supporting earlier32 candidates are not newly approved here, and held4 remain held despite their inclusion in the diagnostic pack.\", \"Boundary means, full opaque mask overlap and source-class diagnostics establish neither artistic fidelity nor an invisible seam on their own.\", \"Actual static indexed loading/TerrainHd composition is verified. No live gameplay, arbitrary palette-fade cycle, mission1080p performance or unsupported route claim is made.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 755667dfb498724e17a35358d8d01541f51783b061cf26f80684c0d618ad68cb", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/complete-actual-ppm-manifest.json", + "sha256": "d330c159a081d63ce647a4f23ae9f84764b77e6ba3208b018079d321829dc89d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "3011d", + "3011e", + "3011f", + "30120" + ], + "sha256": "600f121057342084138f279aa0658376f00f4b9e4bd9de517f27028fb03b7c89", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30121", + "30122", + "30123", + "30124" + ], + "sha256": "23bad5451e0549b68fb2cf3cca3fc4b0557399bbd9b5190387cb7768a2a66c6f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "30125", + "30126", + "30127", + "30128" + ], + "sha256": "7720739a3e24872e00be5bc44e3e33a73a1e2e214352e6bbc8e7ef8ed7cfc8c4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "30129", + "3012a", + "3012b", + "3012c" + ], + "sha256": "8c976232ef3f87f905078ad64956e45187450c8c815e5847185d62be1b53de57", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "3011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47ddc428ba9c9d9a4ff0a52180f361be8b4c3f6fa958a19921cc11359cd52bd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e0a2dbf264485816ed3267ecd2c9fdeaca82660bdeef65f31c865e7a89bac3b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "402daf19f6f512ab35774f6ed760f5dd6beeb59ddcb98e9ec0cbe2e484963614", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "54b506e3c0aab49652dc095169bf8cf454f8ae0fed8bff3c1d0a68c52b834d86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f019a5361935df3e0117fd7e33e2b03787c108f5c540c23feebcd02cea3e64fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7b7c411788f55a818a1c2cf8eea745fdff2643abbae945138e848629b6de795a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ee4eb50f1339382c177f648af0add2c3f2a29aa24146e8bb364caf2bed06ea9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c1ab9b8da0357fefae1052a8ff97dc0876fa8ce6ab7c0fba0e939a2ee14a94f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "36f33b244c675e12428d57f9221dfac75fe211c80efed3f5a9450b22bcb50b2d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0fbc59221c897bde1aa195a44d6adb177b70954b21649445d087d12e475c379c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "649b8b00021215527674e058df3fd256a1ec58412bc656a62265e4511911ac27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5fd8af719d76cd017cba0b9e4b06b7e757ab376fec39c05693ef3139f6694097", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3867102b30ec60a6a0aadf2b13bb9f5f011306a51b7350d780a0e103024ac40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2076c09d7a71382739c2d0bf91888306ec65704e3090d92a15ca86dc7e1afa5c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bfb9a0c60f0c6b01b65dda24d57466f2a703f3d9b5fe926faa7942c9f3b49d04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e7f4579a56d595ba76c9e2d54321536ba3a2a8637d5e48a341742a6cf5ccd4cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7b2f9d98c2c922b243b9931c01ad61d02fe12a34a0c498d2cbf92028417391c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1e8dc9addaff9746c6dbee04189f2aaf8564c24fdea0f0951383fad1a8f3882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d26c5dd1942fa19f5b5cc8f927c17097b0dd6bef961f3e88d80808b5285ad759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af1be35802274ab0d1c46603c956f489363548583236a299b03ec9050e81dd53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0dd02a5723dfa38f8775cec3647a943dc81417295fe1267b5c8bb4e3013b1270", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dfae46f975fe415e11e77e15dc2b76de74a945bd4f57dcaebc7e3db06e932252", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9c87c2b2144a6857da73773a6de95b2ceaa34ddb464c003580004d1aebd91c45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "37da9b687aa89e9a1db920b5e9733e0ea6a73a9b325d49abb94df7cdb17855ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b3b11eff5c3f378bc986e31529c558566128d6d3cc38baedce3f63d6e41bba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4430a061e8f802ebfece64b2a74e4c9d2f3356df3d9dcc0b38ab399fbb6547b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d3068a6f407760188f934c7831a8978b1358e8d79b2394532ebcaeee5d610ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "351f358673bd32ee15bfc568a2ad8d5d9225a35341c07dad177691ba3e28c01a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "614ce68b7068d2c91714eaa7f759a4b3bd5e6e28c861046cea488f6ab224f3a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3cbfc85bc6e8eb13a412beda0aee76bba2c364bf2287a291491e5e654e77600b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f515fb9d1d66c68ba439f7ae83c4231dca92a73ff9378e158bf836e4ce68e783", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "16f0b4176b2b7e1ccbb1e6c86409d1ebb26eddc44fd0891948d4791341355f66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "95eb90b9a3cf2998bc492101cdcf5173d33705d2166ab90f5483b333983fc5a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d5462c8c176b17b062f64261b38a484e9890019d65a814e2f7b5f2f6eeee4c10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0d8fb1653d0b2f0ef5349f8d9f23f30e5cb323b2bccdce6197afcab3dd662ddd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1a027e0e27a8b818730dd5c0c5065a4448000e32f30bd648a10fc87897aaa95f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fff16fe61cc4d73d972ab9d12a52f112d8ef13fb7b37cb66c4d3db99108c9493", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ed83201f80607e31227cb59a6ac9d6a47df8e9ae61dd840c8a325bdb94ff2d27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "66cf27b7f00b72f4ac8733b72bc2b8fe0d0da239b0790317c03a84164fd3112b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "636e3d4a735c65070f1ac27eca1e2e12480ad27aab7a3c25335b9ed63a70027a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9da55e79f9c8724cebaf96ff69bac1ea23e84b4b70da1c696c8bbf117c2c2cd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ecf7acb2aaeb61dd2d728d7eeba7fe605ba2b76918015b97644fd133ac3c8171", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35a31bb6430524337048b347b350438565fc201e38153d60a99212f7ac4027e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3d63079e5a08c322c9fac8dc8ac154311ef252925d52c80d8f67d2c001c8ac45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90a1794aecdd5b5deb149dd21d4b77a2c9d5782f39c2bf418f3b40b14b46d4cc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b22802e327df7a43ff9e376c7f4aaf845d7f316c3a725c9c8ebdbde3dd3902ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd800cad574c5df989975871b2b09755df2e325e5190b4ad7869016a743bae02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74d2c4b9afb453a5dc814646c607c15f6e9a36f0257bd74998c3192b4916f8e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b4cc4e5d79e39b64fba94b3157d78eea8b44e69327d73667bc0c1e3dc120086e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9c703237fa600c8c4f635e9ec4b4cb4545da4fa768bb0f3695a8ce355c50eb5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1d991ecd07dfcacb890ac7101f944ca381bb73b073bdf1f6512724c4b16290b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "eb3015b83566d6eb34bf371da10666ed17d98d601f2c1030e68f94869067064c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81c40ad363129c77e53e1af99bd3e812ac9e933eb5d7091eb10c57d00610a08e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "697f34b746d8415d6d2e38e61f0d0737085d3981f5b1bfddc4ddc5df26425f76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "51aa7854bc4f1b5a8a6ee6c1d037b988383b415b8f6553bba5ea8c79415b9d63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "07d57094b6e20e052ff8f8da02c481058984c8781081f42d72947a22f0804c4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2d38d2a77ce433ea11ceb70d117f7c34c16b363eebb0fae4f0b49506b0b2a3b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f933dcafc0210f7dccffedfb36e2e99a18727ec501f37adb9781f765e2da6d8d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eb36aa9be293846bf1880a2f116479504770cbb86189451a3db1607d3245721c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9102e1307b087bcca0da28eefab6e294bded5fe84361e768ca8b95d4a06f3d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "56a6678ed32cdc2e9fa63defa9b0d7a5b7f45f59f1dae4b7c393deb3677ebd29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7afe25456c3f32795fde058ce1c114d8dbc2c92f940b843515fd8ab0d95aff44", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb3265816babfe4a0be59814473a8853d39683f51f110d1621ca1be2ac57ef06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7dda2d9fab9948724dd8b0884cf9370ca4cb3b9b9f9e963dbe3723f08038629a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8719368b9dea0ce143caea9a4cd15711e927acdc6f3df852a91eed7a6ce5142d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8d3e57945ea6a29a083ae6c4f1fcf08995a9971fd6ae5474af00c6b5c7c74c78", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "39db6b3a0247644fa0df7d5327d619e355a2e6891b8c842f86714f58763d1106", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6e5ebf63998007218f0d1705fbff02eafce120b1dc1585e0b26e5444f7fedfda", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c30cd53dda67959c4913124d079582303c9fd021ce258876ebbabb57e2ecae24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "69b7a3ee544111ee27eae2177134496c1fd325da2365cc5046c505e3c972ef04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "752c1ad8534130f53eb85c4ec18b67259cf7780f7dcba63132dd942457f21341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "92eeeb391492f1f28ac9a7cf9f16c7596771249836af0aa1c70e94169cd7909c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e24fab4c8b3ff68ddbdc4d639d5dd88318b7d20cc23482c9fce07f35601859e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1f4debdb9cd6900ad5a4338e2d3129dcd1ff47c4cb3771b83eba24c2b6fbb8de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8dffadf9fbed460de6480bf668f65e65555179943981f21920d69e7432e59957", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36c99dbab51a147932fef004caee8a14b8a465f590ea3b07f2c901d7abe7dedd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b8e2051339dce4c6e0c5c06d3ea596b53132677d6ad49b7f17ffb54f0f2914c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1795161adccbf83cf99216fc8ffc6b5c224cf94f43617593a520799cb7168d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f981283c260f11a57eb352eadc5aac098c61cf4108af99d26d037b53ee505469", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9fcef15e698582bef7087a4c23e4fade00d86f7c0ceb6afada84760e6a4b79e3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "3011f": { @@ -251559,7 +264387,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "3011f", "family_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", "job_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "iron_coast_6", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -251575,6 +264403,472 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/candidate.json", "sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "18c9acd13ec59e49f0c08b6bc7f75566ebbae7288f30aea891b348614ff765c0", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.680654+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [{\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011d\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011d\", \"crop\": [0, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 0, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint, surviving gray roof fragments and surface partition remain in place. Stronger rubble, orange flecks and narrow radial cracks are accepted fine interpretation.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2261\", \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011e\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011e\", \"crop\": [314, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 1, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The damaged dark area and source roof-edge remnants remain readable. Pebble-like rubble and radial fine cracks strengthen detail without rebuilding an intact roof.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2262\", \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011f\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011f\", \"crop\": [627, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 2, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The near-square destroyed patch and surviving gray remnants retain their layout. Added thin dark crack lines and warm embers are accepted material detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2263\", \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30120\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30120\", \"crop\": [940, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 3, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source char shape and bordering pale structural patches remain damaged. Stronger grain/highlights are accepted rather than claimed as exact source RGB.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2264\", \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30121\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30121\", \"crop\": [0, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 4, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The central dark destruction, gray edge fragments and native surrounding building geometry remain in place. New metal/rubble detail is accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2265\", \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30122\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30122\", \"crop\": [314, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 5, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight remnant edges and damaged patch remain recognizable. Added thin radial cracks and embers remain fine damage detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2266\", \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30123\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30123\", \"crop\": [627, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 6, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The brighter left structural ribs and top remnant correspond to existing gray source fragments. The central destruction remains open/dark; sharper clean edges, stone-like rubble and orange flecks are interpretation, not an exact untouched SD material claim.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2267\", \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30124\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30124\", \"crop\": [940, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 7, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original opaque destroyed-surface tile retains its dark damaged footprint and surrounding gray fragments. Approved as source-bound gallery artwork only: the actual original registry contains no native mission samples, neighbors or state partners for this ID.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 0, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2268\", \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\", \"unused_gallery_only\": true, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30125\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30125\", \"crop\": [0, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 8, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original irregular damaged footprint and surviving gray vertical remnants are retained. Newly authored fine rubble and cracks are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2269\", \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30126\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30126\", \"crop\": [314, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 9, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source gray structural edge and dark damaged patch remain in their arrangement; brighter fine metal detail does not rebuild the entire intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2270\", \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30127\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30127\", \"crop\": [627, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 10, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source destruction and gray surviving fragments remain readable. Fine embers and grain are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2271\", \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30128\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30128\", \"crop\": [940, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 11, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint and roof-edge remnants remain in place; stronger fine cracks/highlights are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2272\", \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30129\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30129\", \"crop\": [0, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 12, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The gray linear remnants and asymmetric char geometry remain in the source arrangement. Radial fine cracks and orange highlights add damage material rather than an intact object.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2273\", \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012a\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012a\", \"crop\": [314, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 13, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The sharpened top/left metal rim and lower/right upright fragments correspond to existing source gray structures. Brighter steel and embers are accepted; the black damage remains, and no complete repaired roof appears.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2274\", \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012b\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012b\", \"crop\": [627, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 14, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The small central pale source remnant is interpreted as a short grooved metal piece; neighboring pale edges and char layout remain aligned. This is explicit material interpretation, with stronger rubble/embers, rather than exact original subpixel hardware fidelity.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 1, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2275\", \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012c\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012c\", \"crop\": [940, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 15, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight gray remnants around the broad dark damaged area remain readable. Fine stones, cracks and embers are accepted without restoring a complete intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2276\", \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}] [\"Brighter shard4 steel, radial thin cracks, rounded rubble and warm orange flecks are newly authored interpretation rather than exact SD grain/RGB. Source damaged dark areas remain damaged; no complete rebuilt roof was observed.\", \"30123/3012a existing straight gray source fragments gain cleaner metal edges.3012b central pale remnant is interpreted as a small grooved metal piece; this specific material interpretation is accepted and disclosed.\", \"Four held sibling remnants retain an approximate gray/dark area and closer1x palette average but larger native artwork loses visible straight surviving metal fragments. Opaque coverage cannot overrule that art defect.\", \"Mixed HD and ScaleNx-original tiles remain visibly different in texture density/material, including rectangular transitions in joined scenes. The two-logical-pixel edge transition is not claimed to hide every seam. No shifted major panel/roof/pipe boundary was found in the declared cases.\"] [\"All current individual declarations reviewed: up to3 authentic native samples per target, every declared cardinal ID pair and declared state-partner swap. This is not every whole map or every simultaneous destruction arrangement.\", \"Context1\\u20134 outputs were numerically checked and saved; complete fine scene galleries visually inspect native4x with64px original overviews, supplemented by every full source tile and actual1\\u20134 tile view. No claim of visually inspecting every whole context at native1/2/3.\", \"Joined64 is only127 representative context/state probes. Supporting earlier32 candidates are not newly approved here, and held4 remain held despite their inclusion in the diagnostic pack.\", \"Boundary means, full opaque mask overlap and source-class diagnostics establish neither artistic fidelity nor an invisible seam on their own.\", \"Actual static indexed loading/TerrainHd composition is verified. No live gameplay, arbitrary palette-fade cycle, mission1080p performance or unsupported route claim is made.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 755667dfb498724e17a35358d8d01541f51783b061cf26f80684c0d618ad68cb", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/complete-actual-ppm-manifest.json", + "sha256": "d330c159a081d63ce647a4f23ae9f84764b77e6ba3208b018079d321829dc89d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "3011d", + "3011e", + "3011f", + "30120" + ], + "sha256": "600f121057342084138f279aa0658376f00f4b9e4bd9de517f27028fb03b7c89", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30121", + "30122", + "30123", + "30124" + ], + "sha256": "23bad5451e0549b68fb2cf3cca3fc4b0557399bbd9b5190387cb7768a2a66c6f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "30125", + "30126", + "30127", + "30128" + ], + "sha256": "7720739a3e24872e00be5bc44e3e33a73a1e2e214352e6bbc8e7ef8ed7cfc8c4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "30129", + "3012a", + "3012b", + "3012c" + ], + "sha256": "8c976232ef3f87f905078ad64956e45187450c8c815e5847185d62be1b53de57", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "3011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47ddc428ba9c9d9a4ff0a52180f361be8b4c3f6fa958a19921cc11359cd52bd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e0a2dbf264485816ed3267ecd2c9fdeaca82660bdeef65f31c865e7a89bac3b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "402daf19f6f512ab35774f6ed760f5dd6beeb59ddcb98e9ec0cbe2e484963614", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "54b506e3c0aab49652dc095169bf8cf454f8ae0fed8bff3c1d0a68c52b834d86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f019a5361935df3e0117fd7e33e2b03787c108f5c540c23feebcd02cea3e64fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7b7c411788f55a818a1c2cf8eea745fdff2643abbae945138e848629b6de795a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ee4eb50f1339382c177f648af0add2c3f2a29aa24146e8bb364caf2bed06ea9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c1ab9b8da0357fefae1052a8ff97dc0876fa8ce6ab7c0fba0e939a2ee14a94f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "36f33b244c675e12428d57f9221dfac75fe211c80efed3f5a9450b22bcb50b2d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0fbc59221c897bde1aa195a44d6adb177b70954b21649445d087d12e475c379c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "649b8b00021215527674e058df3fd256a1ec58412bc656a62265e4511911ac27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5fd8af719d76cd017cba0b9e4b06b7e757ab376fec39c05693ef3139f6694097", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3867102b30ec60a6a0aadf2b13bb9f5f011306a51b7350d780a0e103024ac40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2076c09d7a71382739c2d0bf91888306ec65704e3090d92a15ca86dc7e1afa5c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bfb9a0c60f0c6b01b65dda24d57466f2a703f3d9b5fe926faa7942c9f3b49d04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e7f4579a56d595ba76c9e2d54321536ba3a2a8637d5e48a341742a6cf5ccd4cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7b2f9d98c2c922b243b9931c01ad61d02fe12a34a0c498d2cbf92028417391c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1e8dc9addaff9746c6dbee04189f2aaf8564c24fdea0f0951383fad1a8f3882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d26c5dd1942fa19f5b5cc8f927c17097b0dd6bef961f3e88d80808b5285ad759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af1be35802274ab0d1c46603c956f489363548583236a299b03ec9050e81dd53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0dd02a5723dfa38f8775cec3647a943dc81417295fe1267b5c8bb4e3013b1270", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dfae46f975fe415e11e77e15dc2b76de74a945bd4f57dcaebc7e3db06e932252", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9c87c2b2144a6857da73773a6de95b2ceaa34ddb464c003580004d1aebd91c45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "37da9b687aa89e9a1db920b5e9733e0ea6a73a9b325d49abb94df7cdb17855ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b3b11eff5c3f378bc986e31529c558566128d6d3cc38baedce3f63d6e41bba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4430a061e8f802ebfece64b2a74e4c9d2f3356df3d9dcc0b38ab399fbb6547b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d3068a6f407760188f934c7831a8978b1358e8d79b2394532ebcaeee5d610ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "351f358673bd32ee15bfc568a2ad8d5d9225a35341c07dad177691ba3e28c01a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "614ce68b7068d2c91714eaa7f759a4b3bd5e6e28c861046cea488f6ab224f3a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3cbfc85bc6e8eb13a412beda0aee76bba2c364bf2287a291491e5e654e77600b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f515fb9d1d66c68ba439f7ae83c4231dca92a73ff9378e158bf836e4ce68e783", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "16f0b4176b2b7e1ccbb1e6c86409d1ebb26eddc44fd0891948d4791341355f66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "95eb90b9a3cf2998bc492101cdcf5173d33705d2166ab90f5483b333983fc5a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d5462c8c176b17b062f64261b38a484e9890019d65a814e2f7b5f2f6eeee4c10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0d8fb1653d0b2f0ef5349f8d9f23f30e5cb323b2bccdce6197afcab3dd662ddd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1a027e0e27a8b818730dd5c0c5065a4448000e32f30bd648a10fc87897aaa95f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fff16fe61cc4d73d972ab9d12a52f112d8ef13fb7b37cb66c4d3db99108c9493", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ed83201f80607e31227cb59a6ac9d6a47df8e9ae61dd840c8a325bdb94ff2d27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "66cf27b7f00b72f4ac8733b72bc2b8fe0d0da239b0790317c03a84164fd3112b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "636e3d4a735c65070f1ac27eca1e2e12480ad27aab7a3c25335b9ed63a70027a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9da55e79f9c8724cebaf96ff69bac1ea23e84b4b70da1c696c8bbf117c2c2cd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ecf7acb2aaeb61dd2d728d7eeba7fe605ba2b76918015b97644fd133ac3c8171", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35a31bb6430524337048b347b350438565fc201e38153d60a99212f7ac4027e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3d63079e5a08c322c9fac8dc8ac154311ef252925d52c80d8f67d2c001c8ac45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90a1794aecdd5b5deb149dd21d4b77a2c9d5782f39c2bf418f3b40b14b46d4cc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b22802e327df7a43ff9e376c7f4aaf845d7f316c3a725c9c8ebdbde3dd3902ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd800cad574c5df989975871b2b09755df2e325e5190b4ad7869016a743bae02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74d2c4b9afb453a5dc814646c607c15f6e9a36f0257bd74998c3192b4916f8e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b4cc4e5d79e39b64fba94b3157d78eea8b44e69327d73667bc0c1e3dc120086e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9c703237fa600c8c4f635e9ec4b4cb4545da4fa768bb0f3695a8ce355c50eb5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1d991ecd07dfcacb890ac7101f944ca381bb73b073bdf1f6512724c4b16290b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "eb3015b83566d6eb34bf371da10666ed17d98d601f2c1030e68f94869067064c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81c40ad363129c77e53e1af99bd3e812ac9e933eb5d7091eb10c57d00610a08e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "697f34b746d8415d6d2e38e61f0d0737085d3981f5b1bfddc4ddc5df26425f76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "51aa7854bc4f1b5a8a6ee6c1d037b988383b415b8f6553bba5ea8c79415b9d63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "07d57094b6e20e052ff8f8da02c481058984c8781081f42d72947a22f0804c4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2d38d2a77ce433ea11ceb70d117f7c34c16b363eebb0fae4f0b49506b0b2a3b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f933dcafc0210f7dccffedfb36e2e99a18727ec501f37adb9781f765e2da6d8d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eb36aa9be293846bf1880a2f116479504770cbb86189451a3db1607d3245721c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9102e1307b087bcca0da28eefab6e294bded5fe84361e768ca8b95d4a06f3d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "56a6678ed32cdc2e9fa63defa9b0d7a5b7f45f59f1dae4b7c393deb3677ebd29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7afe25456c3f32795fde058ce1c114d8dbc2c92f940b843515fd8ab0d95aff44", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb3265816babfe4a0be59814473a8853d39683f51f110d1621ca1be2ac57ef06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7dda2d9fab9948724dd8b0884cf9370ca4cb3b9b9f9e963dbe3723f08038629a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8719368b9dea0ce143caea9a4cd15711e927acdc6f3df852a91eed7a6ce5142d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8d3e57945ea6a29a083ae6c4f1fcf08995a9971fd6ae5474af00c6b5c7c74c78", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "39db6b3a0247644fa0df7d5327d619e355a2e6891b8c842f86714f58763d1106", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6e5ebf63998007218f0d1705fbff02eafce120b1dc1585e0b26e5444f7fedfda", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c30cd53dda67959c4913124d079582303c9fd021ce258876ebbabb57e2ecae24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "69b7a3ee544111ee27eae2177134496c1fd325da2365cc5046c505e3c972ef04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "752c1ad8534130f53eb85c4ec18b67259cf7780f7dcba63132dd942457f21341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "92eeeb391492f1f28ac9a7cf9f16c7596771249836af0aa1c70e94169cd7909c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e24fab4c8b3ff68ddbdc4d639d5dd88318b7d20cc23482c9fce07f35601859e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1f4debdb9cd6900ad5a4338e2d3129dcd1ff47c4cb3771b83eba24c2b6fbb8de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8dffadf9fbed460de6480bf668f65e65555179943981f21920d69e7432e59957", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36c99dbab51a147932fef004caee8a14b8a465f590ea3b07f2c901d7abe7dedd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b8e2051339dce4c6e0c5c06d3ea596b53132677d6ad49b7f17ffb54f0f2914c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1795161adccbf83cf99216fc8ffc6b5c224cf94f43617593a520799cb7168d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f981283c260f11a57eb352eadc5aac098c61cf4108af99d26d037b53ee505469", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9fcef15e698582bef7087a4c23e4fade00d86f7c0ceb6afada84760e6a4b79e3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30120": { @@ -251596,7 +264890,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30120", "family_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", "job_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "iron_coast_6", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -251612,6 +264906,472 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/candidate.json", "sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "18c9acd13ec59e49f0c08b6bc7f75566ebbae7288f30aea891b348614ff765c0", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.680654+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [{\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011d\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011d\", \"crop\": [0, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 0, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint, surviving gray roof fragments and surface partition remain in place. Stronger rubble, orange flecks and narrow radial cracks are accepted fine interpretation.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2261\", \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011e\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011e\", \"crop\": [314, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 1, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The damaged dark area and source roof-edge remnants remain readable. Pebble-like rubble and radial fine cracks strengthen detail without rebuilding an intact roof.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2262\", \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011f\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011f\", \"crop\": [627, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 2, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The near-square destroyed patch and surviving gray remnants retain their layout. Added thin dark crack lines and warm embers are accepted material detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2263\", \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30120\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30120\", \"crop\": [940, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 3, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source char shape and bordering pale structural patches remain damaged. Stronger grain/highlights are accepted rather than claimed as exact source RGB.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2264\", \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30121\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30121\", \"crop\": [0, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 4, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The central dark destruction, gray edge fragments and native surrounding building geometry remain in place. New metal/rubble detail is accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2265\", \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30122\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30122\", \"crop\": [314, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 5, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight remnant edges and damaged patch remain recognizable. Added thin radial cracks and embers remain fine damage detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2266\", \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30123\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30123\", \"crop\": [627, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 6, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The brighter left structural ribs and top remnant correspond to existing gray source fragments. The central destruction remains open/dark; sharper clean edges, stone-like rubble and orange flecks are interpretation, not an exact untouched SD material claim.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2267\", \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30124\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30124\", \"crop\": [940, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 7, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original opaque destroyed-surface tile retains its dark damaged footprint and surrounding gray fragments. Approved as source-bound gallery artwork only: the actual original registry contains no native mission samples, neighbors or state partners for this ID.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 0, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2268\", \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\", \"unused_gallery_only\": true, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30125\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30125\", \"crop\": [0, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 8, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original irregular damaged footprint and surviving gray vertical remnants are retained. Newly authored fine rubble and cracks are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2269\", \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30126\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30126\", \"crop\": [314, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 9, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source gray structural edge and dark damaged patch remain in their arrangement; brighter fine metal detail does not rebuild the entire intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2270\", \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30127\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30127\", \"crop\": [627, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 10, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source destruction and gray surviving fragments remain readable. Fine embers and grain are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2271\", \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30128\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30128\", \"crop\": [940, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 11, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint and roof-edge remnants remain in place; stronger fine cracks/highlights are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2272\", \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30129\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30129\", \"crop\": [0, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 12, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The gray linear remnants and asymmetric char geometry remain in the source arrangement. Radial fine cracks and orange highlights add damage material rather than an intact object.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2273\", \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012a\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012a\", \"crop\": [314, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 13, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The sharpened top/left metal rim and lower/right upright fragments correspond to existing source gray structures. Brighter steel and embers are accepted; the black damage remains, and no complete repaired roof appears.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2274\", \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012b\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012b\", \"crop\": [627, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 14, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The small central pale source remnant is interpreted as a short grooved metal piece; neighboring pale edges and char layout remain aligned. This is explicit material interpretation, with stronger rubble/embers, rather than exact original subpixel hardware fidelity.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 1, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2275\", \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012c\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012c\", \"crop\": [940, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 15, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight gray remnants around the broad dark damaged area remain readable. Fine stones, cracks and embers are accepted without restoring a complete intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2276\", \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}] [\"Brighter shard4 steel, radial thin cracks, rounded rubble and warm orange flecks are newly authored interpretation rather than exact SD grain/RGB. Source damaged dark areas remain damaged; no complete rebuilt roof was observed.\", \"30123/3012a existing straight gray source fragments gain cleaner metal edges.3012b central pale remnant is interpreted as a small grooved metal piece; this specific material interpretation is accepted and disclosed.\", \"Four held sibling remnants retain an approximate gray/dark area and closer1x palette average but larger native artwork loses visible straight surviving metal fragments. Opaque coverage cannot overrule that art defect.\", \"Mixed HD and ScaleNx-original tiles remain visibly different in texture density/material, including rectangular transitions in joined scenes. The two-logical-pixel edge transition is not claimed to hide every seam. No shifted major panel/roof/pipe boundary was found in the declared cases.\"] [\"All current individual declarations reviewed: up to3 authentic native samples per target, every declared cardinal ID pair and declared state-partner swap. This is not every whole map or every simultaneous destruction arrangement.\", \"Context1\\u20134 outputs were numerically checked and saved; complete fine scene galleries visually inspect native4x with64px original overviews, supplemented by every full source tile and actual1\\u20134 tile view. No claim of visually inspecting every whole context at native1/2/3.\", \"Joined64 is only127 representative context/state probes. Supporting earlier32 candidates are not newly approved here, and held4 remain held despite their inclusion in the diagnostic pack.\", \"Boundary means, full opaque mask overlap and source-class diagnostics establish neither artistic fidelity nor an invisible seam on their own.\", \"Actual static indexed loading/TerrainHd composition is verified. No live gameplay, arbitrary palette-fade cycle, mission1080p performance or unsupported route claim is made.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 755667dfb498724e17a35358d8d01541f51783b061cf26f80684c0d618ad68cb", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/complete-actual-ppm-manifest.json", + "sha256": "d330c159a081d63ce647a4f23ae9f84764b77e6ba3208b018079d321829dc89d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "3011d", + "3011e", + "3011f", + "30120" + ], + "sha256": "600f121057342084138f279aa0658376f00f4b9e4bd9de517f27028fb03b7c89", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30121", + "30122", + "30123", + "30124" + ], + "sha256": "23bad5451e0549b68fb2cf3cca3fc4b0557399bbd9b5190387cb7768a2a66c6f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "30125", + "30126", + "30127", + "30128" + ], + "sha256": "7720739a3e24872e00be5bc44e3e33a73a1e2e214352e6bbc8e7ef8ed7cfc8c4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "30129", + "3012a", + "3012b", + "3012c" + ], + "sha256": "8c976232ef3f87f905078ad64956e45187450c8c815e5847185d62be1b53de57", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "3011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47ddc428ba9c9d9a4ff0a52180f361be8b4c3f6fa958a19921cc11359cd52bd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e0a2dbf264485816ed3267ecd2c9fdeaca82660bdeef65f31c865e7a89bac3b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "402daf19f6f512ab35774f6ed760f5dd6beeb59ddcb98e9ec0cbe2e484963614", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "54b506e3c0aab49652dc095169bf8cf454f8ae0fed8bff3c1d0a68c52b834d86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f019a5361935df3e0117fd7e33e2b03787c108f5c540c23feebcd02cea3e64fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7b7c411788f55a818a1c2cf8eea745fdff2643abbae945138e848629b6de795a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ee4eb50f1339382c177f648af0add2c3f2a29aa24146e8bb364caf2bed06ea9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c1ab9b8da0357fefae1052a8ff97dc0876fa8ce6ab7c0fba0e939a2ee14a94f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "36f33b244c675e12428d57f9221dfac75fe211c80efed3f5a9450b22bcb50b2d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0fbc59221c897bde1aa195a44d6adb177b70954b21649445d087d12e475c379c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "649b8b00021215527674e058df3fd256a1ec58412bc656a62265e4511911ac27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5fd8af719d76cd017cba0b9e4b06b7e757ab376fec39c05693ef3139f6694097", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3867102b30ec60a6a0aadf2b13bb9f5f011306a51b7350d780a0e103024ac40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2076c09d7a71382739c2d0bf91888306ec65704e3090d92a15ca86dc7e1afa5c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bfb9a0c60f0c6b01b65dda24d57466f2a703f3d9b5fe926faa7942c9f3b49d04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e7f4579a56d595ba76c9e2d54321536ba3a2a8637d5e48a341742a6cf5ccd4cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7b2f9d98c2c922b243b9931c01ad61d02fe12a34a0c498d2cbf92028417391c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1e8dc9addaff9746c6dbee04189f2aaf8564c24fdea0f0951383fad1a8f3882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d26c5dd1942fa19f5b5cc8f927c17097b0dd6bef961f3e88d80808b5285ad759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af1be35802274ab0d1c46603c956f489363548583236a299b03ec9050e81dd53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0dd02a5723dfa38f8775cec3647a943dc81417295fe1267b5c8bb4e3013b1270", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dfae46f975fe415e11e77e15dc2b76de74a945bd4f57dcaebc7e3db06e932252", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9c87c2b2144a6857da73773a6de95b2ceaa34ddb464c003580004d1aebd91c45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "37da9b687aa89e9a1db920b5e9733e0ea6a73a9b325d49abb94df7cdb17855ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b3b11eff5c3f378bc986e31529c558566128d6d3cc38baedce3f63d6e41bba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4430a061e8f802ebfece64b2a74e4c9d2f3356df3d9dcc0b38ab399fbb6547b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d3068a6f407760188f934c7831a8978b1358e8d79b2394532ebcaeee5d610ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "351f358673bd32ee15bfc568a2ad8d5d9225a35341c07dad177691ba3e28c01a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "614ce68b7068d2c91714eaa7f759a4b3bd5e6e28c861046cea488f6ab224f3a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3cbfc85bc6e8eb13a412beda0aee76bba2c364bf2287a291491e5e654e77600b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f515fb9d1d66c68ba439f7ae83c4231dca92a73ff9378e158bf836e4ce68e783", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "16f0b4176b2b7e1ccbb1e6c86409d1ebb26eddc44fd0891948d4791341355f66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "95eb90b9a3cf2998bc492101cdcf5173d33705d2166ab90f5483b333983fc5a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d5462c8c176b17b062f64261b38a484e9890019d65a814e2f7b5f2f6eeee4c10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0d8fb1653d0b2f0ef5349f8d9f23f30e5cb323b2bccdce6197afcab3dd662ddd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1a027e0e27a8b818730dd5c0c5065a4448000e32f30bd648a10fc87897aaa95f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fff16fe61cc4d73d972ab9d12a52f112d8ef13fb7b37cb66c4d3db99108c9493", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ed83201f80607e31227cb59a6ac9d6a47df8e9ae61dd840c8a325bdb94ff2d27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "66cf27b7f00b72f4ac8733b72bc2b8fe0d0da239b0790317c03a84164fd3112b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "636e3d4a735c65070f1ac27eca1e2e12480ad27aab7a3c25335b9ed63a70027a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9da55e79f9c8724cebaf96ff69bac1ea23e84b4b70da1c696c8bbf117c2c2cd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ecf7acb2aaeb61dd2d728d7eeba7fe605ba2b76918015b97644fd133ac3c8171", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35a31bb6430524337048b347b350438565fc201e38153d60a99212f7ac4027e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3d63079e5a08c322c9fac8dc8ac154311ef252925d52c80d8f67d2c001c8ac45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90a1794aecdd5b5deb149dd21d4b77a2c9d5782f39c2bf418f3b40b14b46d4cc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b22802e327df7a43ff9e376c7f4aaf845d7f316c3a725c9c8ebdbde3dd3902ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd800cad574c5df989975871b2b09755df2e325e5190b4ad7869016a743bae02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74d2c4b9afb453a5dc814646c607c15f6e9a36f0257bd74998c3192b4916f8e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b4cc4e5d79e39b64fba94b3157d78eea8b44e69327d73667bc0c1e3dc120086e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9c703237fa600c8c4f635e9ec4b4cb4545da4fa768bb0f3695a8ce355c50eb5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1d991ecd07dfcacb890ac7101f944ca381bb73b073bdf1f6512724c4b16290b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "eb3015b83566d6eb34bf371da10666ed17d98d601f2c1030e68f94869067064c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81c40ad363129c77e53e1af99bd3e812ac9e933eb5d7091eb10c57d00610a08e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "697f34b746d8415d6d2e38e61f0d0737085d3981f5b1bfddc4ddc5df26425f76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "51aa7854bc4f1b5a8a6ee6c1d037b988383b415b8f6553bba5ea8c79415b9d63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "07d57094b6e20e052ff8f8da02c481058984c8781081f42d72947a22f0804c4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2d38d2a77ce433ea11ceb70d117f7c34c16b363eebb0fae4f0b49506b0b2a3b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f933dcafc0210f7dccffedfb36e2e99a18727ec501f37adb9781f765e2da6d8d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eb36aa9be293846bf1880a2f116479504770cbb86189451a3db1607d3245721c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9102e1307b087bcca0da28eefab6e294bded5fe84361e768ca8b95d4a06f3d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "56a6678ed32cdc2e9fa63defa9b0d7a5b7f45f59f1dae4b7c393deb3677ebd29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7afe25456c3f32795fde058ce1c114d8dbc2c92f940b843515fd8ab0d95aff44", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb3265816babfe4a0be59814473a8853d39683f51f110d1621ca1be2ac57ef06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7dda2d9fab9948724dd8b0884cf9370ca4cb3b9b9f9e963dbe3723f08038629a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8719368b9dea0ce143caea9a4cd15711e927acdc6f3df852a91eed7a6ce5142d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8d3e57945ea6a29a083ae6c4f1fcf08995a9971fd6ae5474af00c6b5c7c74c78", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "39db6b3a0247644fa0df7d5327d619e355a2e6891b8c842f86714f58763d1106", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6e5ebf63998007218f0d1705fbff02eafce120b1dc1585e0b26e5444f7fedfda", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c30cd53dda67959c4913124d079582303c9fd021ce258876ebbabb57e2ecae24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "69b7a3ee544111ee27eae2177134496c1fd325da2365cc5046c505e3c972ef04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "752c1ad8534130f53eb85c4ec18b67259cf7780f7dcba63132dd942457f21341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "92eeeb391492f1f28ac9a7cf9f16c7596771249836af0aa1c70e94169cd7909c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e24fab4c8b3ff68ddbdc4d639d5dd88318b7d20cc23482c9fce07f35601859e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1f4debdb9cd6900ad5a4338e2d3129dcd1ff47c4cb3771b83eba24c2b6fbb8de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8dffadf9fbed460de6480bf668f65e65555179943981f21920d69e7432e59957", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36c99dbab51a147932fef004caee8a14b8a465f590ea3b07f2c901d7abe7dedd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b8e2051339dce4c6e0c5c06d3ea596b53132677d6ad49b7f17ffb54f0f2914c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1795161adccbf83cf99216fc8ffc6b5c224cf94f43617593a520799cb7168d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f981283c260f11a57eb352eadc5aac098c61cf4108af99d26d037b53ee505469", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9fcef15e698582bef7087a4c23e4fade00d86f7c0ceb6afada84760e6a4b79e3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30121": { @@ -251633,7 +265393,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30121", "family_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", "job_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "iron_coast_6", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -251649,6 +265409,472 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/candidate.json", "sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "18c9acd13ec59e49f0c08b6bc7f75566ebbae7288f30aea891b348614ff765c0", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.680654+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [{\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011d\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011d\", \"crop\": [0, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 0, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint, surviving gray roof fragments and surface partition remain in place. Stronger rubble, orange flecks and narrow radial cracks are accepted fine interpretation.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2261\", \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011e\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011e\", \"crop\": [314, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 1, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The damaged dark area and source roof-edge remnants remain readable. Pebble-like rubble and radial fine cracks strengthen detail without rebuilding an intact roof.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2262\", \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011f\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011f\", \"crop\": [627, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 2, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The near-square destroyed patch and surviving gray remnants retain their layout. Added thin dark crack lines and warm embers are accepted material detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2263\", \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30120\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30120\", \"crop\": [940, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 3, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source char shape and bordering pale structural patches remain damaged. Stronger grain/highlights are accepted rather than claimed as exact source RGB.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2264\", \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30121\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30121\", \"crop\": [0, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 4, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The central dark destruction, gray edge fragments and native surrounding building geometry remain in place. New metal/rubble detail is accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2265\", \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30122\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30122\", \"crop\": [314, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 5, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight remnant edges and damaged patch remain recognizable. Added thin radial cracks and embers remain fine damage detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2266\", \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30123\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30123\", \"crop\": [627, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 6, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The brighter left structural ribs and top remnant correspond to existing gray source fragments. The central destruction remains open/dark; sharper clean edges, stone-like rubble and orange flecks are interpretation, not an exact untouched SD material claim.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2267\", \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30124\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30124\", \"crop\": [940, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 7, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original opaque destroyed-surface tile retains its dark damaged footprint and surrounding gray fragments. Approved as source-bound gallery artwork only: the actual original registry contains no native mission samples, neighbors or state partners for this ID.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 0, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2268\", \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\", \"unused_gallery_only\": true, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30125\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30125\", \"crop\": [0, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 8, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original irregular damaged footprint and surviving gray vertical remnants are retained. Newly authored fine rubble and cracks are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2269\", \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30126\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30126\", \"crop\": [314, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 9, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source gray structural edge and dark damaged patch remain in their arrangement; brighter fine metal detail does not rebuild the entire intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2270\", \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30127\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30127\", \"crop\": [627, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 10, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source destruction and gray surviving fragments remain readable. Fine embers and grain are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2271\", \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30128\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30128\", \"crop\": [940, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 11, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint and roof-edge remnants remain in place; stronger fine cracks/highlights are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2272\", \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30129\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30129\", \"crop\": [0, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 12, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The gray linear remnants and asymmetric char geometry remain in the source arrangement. Radial fine cracks and orange highlights add damage material rather than an intact object.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2273\", \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012a\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012a\", \"crop\": [314, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 13, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The sharpened top/left metal rim and lower/right upright fragments correspond to existing source gray structures. Brighter steel and embers are accepted; the black damage remains, and no complete repaired roof appears.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2274\", \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012b\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012b\", \"crop\": [627, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 14, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The small central pale source remnant is interpreted as a short grooved metal piece; neighboring pale edges and char layout remain aligned. This is explicit material interpretation, with stronger rubble/embers, rather than exact original subpixel hardware fidelity.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 1, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2275\", \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012c\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012c\", \"crop\": [940, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 15, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight gray remnants around the broad dark damaged area remain readable. Fine stones, cracks and embers are accepted without restoring a complete intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2276\", \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}] [\"Brighter shard4 steel, radial thin cracks, rounded rubble and warm orange flecks are newly authored interpretation rather than exact SD grain/RGB. Source damaged dark areas remain damaged; no complete rebuilt roof was observed.\", \"30123/3012a existing straight gray source fragments gain cleaner metal edges.3012b central pale remnant is interpreted as a small grooved metal piece; this specific material interpretation is accepted and disclosed.\", \"Four held sibling remnants retain an approximate gray/dark area and closer1x palette average but larger native artwork loses visible straight surviving metal fragments. Opaque coverage cannot overrule that art defect.\", \"Mixed HD and ScaleNx-original tiles remain visibly different in texture density/material, including rectangular transitions in joined scenes. The two-logical-pixel edge transition is not claimed to hide every seam. No shifted major panel/roof/pipe boundary was found in the declared cases.\"] [\"All current individual declarations reviewed: up to3 authentic native samples per target, every declared cardinal ID pair and declared state-partner swap. This is not every whole map or every simultaneous destruction arrangement.\", \"Context1\\u20134 outputs were numerically checked and saved; complete fine scene galleries visually inspect native4x with64px original overviews, supplemented by every full source tile and actual1\\u20134 tile view. No claim of visually inspecting every whole context at native1/2/3.\", \"Joined64 is only127 representative context/state probes. Supporting earlier32 candidates are not newly approved here, and held4 remain held despite their inclusion in the diagnostic pack.\", \"Boundary means, full opaque mask overlap and source-class diagnostics establish neither artistic fidelity nor an invisible seam on their own.\", \"Actual static indexed loading/TerrainHd composition is verified. No live gameplay, arbitrary palette-fade cycle, mission1080p performance or unsupported route claim is made.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 755667dfb498724e17a35358d8d01541f51783b061cf26f80684c0d618ad68cb", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/complete-actual-ppm-manifest.json", + "sha256": "d330c159a081d63ce647a4f23ae9f84764b77e6ba3208b018079d321829dc89d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "3011d", + "3011e", + "3011f", + "30120" + ], + "sha256": "600f121057342084138f279aa0658376f00f4b9e4bd9de517f27028fb03b7c89", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30121", + "30122", + "30123", + "30124" + ], + "sha256": "23bad5451e0549b68fb2cf3cca3fc4b0557399bbd9b5190387cb7768a2a66c6f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "30125", + "30126", + "30127", + "30128" + ], + "sha256": "7720739a3e24872e00be5bc44e3e33a73a1e2e214352e6bbc8e7ef8ed7cfc8c4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "30129", + "3012a", + "3012b", + "3012c" + ], + "sha256": "8c976232ef3f87f905078ad64956e45187450c8c815e5847185d62be1b53de57", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "3011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47ddc428ba9c9d9a4ff0a52180f361be8b4c3f6fa958a19921cc11359cd52bd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e0a2dbf264485816ed3267ecd2c9fdeaca82660bdeef65f31c865e7a89bac3b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "402daf19f6f512ab35774f6ed760f5dd6beeb59ddcb98e9ec0cbe2e484963614", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "54b506e3c0aab49652dc095169bf8cf454f8ae0fed8bff3c1d0a68c52b834d86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f019a5361935df3e0117fd7e33e2b03787c108f5c540c23feebcd02cea3e64fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7b7c411788f55a818a1c2cf8eea745fdff2643abbae945138e848629b6de795a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ee4eb50f1339382c177f648af0add2c3f2a29aa24146e8bb364caf2bed06ea9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c1ab9b8da0357fefae1052a8ff97dc0876fa8ce6ab7c0fba0e939a2ee14a94f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "36f33b244c675e12428d57f9221dfac75fe211c80efed3f5a9450b22bcb50b2d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0fbc59221c897bde1aa195a44d6adb177b70954b21649445d087d12e475c379c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "649b8b00021215527674e058df3fd256a1ec58412bc656a62265e4511911ac27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5fd8af719d76cd017cba0b9e4b06b7e757ab376fec39c05693ef3139f6694097", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3867102b30ec60a6a0aadf2b13bb9f5f011306a51b7350d780a0e103024ac40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2076c09d7a71382739c2d0bf91888306ec65704e3090d92a15ca86dc7e1afa5c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bfb9a0c60f0c6b01b65dda24d57466f2a703f3d9b5fe926faa7942c9f3b49d04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e7f4579a56d595ba76c9e2d54321536ba3a2a8637d5e48a341742a6cf5ccd4cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7b2f9d98c2c922b243b9931c01ad61d02fe12a34a0c498d2cbf92028417391c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1e8dc9addaff9746c6dbee04189f2aaf8564c24fdea0f0951383fad1a8f3882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d26c5dd1942fa19f5b5cc8f927c17097b0dd6bef961f3e88d80808b5285ad759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af1be35802274ab0d1c46603c956f489363548583236a299b03ec9050e81dd53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0dd02a5723dfa38f8775cec3647a943dc81417295fe1267b5c8bb4e3013b1270", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dfae46f975fe415e11e77e15dc2b76de74a945bd4f57dcaebc7e3db06e932252", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9c87c2b2144a6857da73773a6de95b2ceaa34ddb464c003580004d1aebd91c45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "37da9b687aa89e9a1db920b5e9733e0ea6a73a9b325d49abb94df7cdb17855ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b3b11eff5c3f378bc986e31529c558566128d6d3cc38baedce3f63d6e41bba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4430a061e8f802ebfece64b2a74e4c9d2f3356df3d9dcc0b38ab399fbb6547b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d3068a6f407760188f934c7831a8978b1358e8d79b2394532ebcaeee5d610ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "351f358673bd32ee15bfc568a2ad8d5d9225a35341c07dad177691ba3e28c01a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "614ce68b7068d2c91714eaa7f759a4b3bd5e6e28c861046cea488f6ab224f3a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3cbfc85bc6e8eb13a412beda0aee76bba2c364bf2287a291491e5e654e77600b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f515fb9d1d66c68ba439f7ae83c4231dca92a73ff9378e158bf836e4ce68e783", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "16f0b4176b2b7e1ccbb1e6c86409d1ebb26eddc44fd0891948d4791341355f66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "95eb90b9a3cf2998bc492101cdcf5173d33705d2166ab90f5483b333983fc5a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d5462c8c176b17b062f64261b38a484e9890019d65a814e2f7b5f2f6eeee4c10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0d8fb1653d0b2f0ef5349f8d9f23f30e5cb323b2bccdce6197afcab3dd662ddd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1a027e0e27a8b818730dd5c0c5065a4448000e32f30bd648a10fc87897aaa95f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fff16fe61cc4d73d972ab9d12a52f112d8ef13fb7b37cb66c4d3db99108c9493", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ed83201f80607e31227cb59a6ac9d6a47df8e9ae61dd840c8a325bdb94ff2d27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "66cf27b7f00b72f4ac8733b72bc2b8fe0d0da239b0790317c03a84164fd3112b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "636e3d4a735c65070f1ac27eca1e2e12480ad27aab7a3c25335b9ed63a70027a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9da55e79f9c8724cebaf96ff69bac1ea23e84b4b70da1c696c8bbf117c2c2cd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ecf7acb2aaeb61dd2d728d7eeba7fe605ba2b76918015b97644fd133ac3c8171", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35a31bb6430524337048b347b350438565fc201e38153d60a99212f7ac4027e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3d63079e5a08c322c9fac8dc8ac154311ef252925d52c80d8f67d2c001c8ac45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90a1794aecdd5b5deb149dd21d4b77a2c9d5782f39c2bf418f3b40b14b46d4cc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b22802e327df7a43ff9e376c7f4aaf845d7f316c3a725c9c8ebdbde3dd3902ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd800cad574c5df989975871b2b09755df2e325e5190b4ad7869016a743bae02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74d2c4b9afb453a5dc814646c607c15f6e9a36f0257bd74998c3192b4916f8e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b4cc4e5d79e39b64fba94b3157d78eea8b44e69327d73667bc0c1e3dc120086e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9c703237fa600c8c4f635e9ec4b4cb4545da4fa768bb0f3695a8ce355c50eb5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1d991ecd07dfcacb890ac7101f944ca381bb73b073bdf1f6512724c4b16290b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "eb3015b83566d6eb34bf371da10666ed17d98d601f2c1030e68f94869067064c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81c40ad363129c77e53e1af99bd3e812ac9e933eb5d7091eb10c57d00610a08e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "697f34b746d8415d6d2e38e61f0d0737085d3981f5b1bfddc4ddc5df26425f76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "51aa7854bc4f1b5a8a6ee6c1d037b988383b415b8f6553bba5ea8c79415b9d63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "07d57094b6e20e052ff8f8da02c481058984c8781081f42d72947a22f0804c4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2d38d2a77ce433ea11ceb70d117f7c34c16b363eebb0fae4f0b49506b0b2a3b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f933dcafc0210f7dccffedfb36e2e99a18727ec501f37adb9781f765e2da6d8d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eb36aa9be293846bf1880a2f116479504770cbb86189451a3db1607d3245721c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9102e1307b087bcca0da28eefab6e294bded5fe84361e768ca8b95d4a06f3d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "56a6678ed32cdc2e9fa63defa9b0d7a5b7f45f59f1dae4b7c393deb3677ebd29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7afe25456c3f32795fde058ce1c114d8dbc2c92f940b843515fd8ab0d95aff44", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb3265816babfe4a0be59814473a8853d39683f51f110d1621ca1be2ac57ef06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7dda2d9fab9948724dd8b0884cf9370ca4cb3b9b9f9e963dbe3723f08038629a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8719368b9dea0ce143caea9a4cd15711e927acdc6f3df852a91eed7a6ce5142d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8d3e57945ea6a29a083ae6c4f1fcf08995a9971fd6ae5474af00c6b5c7c74c78", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "39db6b3a0247644fa0df7d5327d619e355a2e6891b8c842f86714f58763d1106", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6e5ebf63998007218f0d1705fbff02eafce120b1dc1585e0b26e5444f7fedfda", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c30cd53dda67959c4913124d079582303c9fd021ce258876ebbabb57e2ecae24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "69b7a3ee544111ee27eae2177134496c1fd325da2365cc5046c505e3c972ef04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "752c1ad8534130f53eb85c4ec18b67259cf7780f7dcba63132dd942457f21341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "92eeeb391492f1f28ac9a7cf9f16c7596771249836af0aa1c70e94169cd7909c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e24fab4c8b3ff68ddbdc4d639d5dd88318b7d20cc23482c9fce07f35601859e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1f4debdb9cd6900ad5a4338e2d3129dcd1ff47c4cb3771b83eba24c2b6fbb8de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8dffadf9fbed460de6480bf668f65e65555179943981f21920d69e7432e59957", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36c99dbab51a147932fef004caee8a14b8a465f590ea3b07f2c901d7abe7dedd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b8e2051339dce4c6e0c5c06d3ea596b53132677d6ad49b7f17ffb54f0f2914c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1795161adccbf83cf99216fc8ffc6b5c224cf94f43617593a520799cb7168d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f981283c260f11a57eb352eadc5aac098c61cf4108af99d26d037b53ee505469", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9fcef15e698582bef7087a4c23e4fade00d86f7c0ceb6afada84760e6a4b79e3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30122": { @@ -251670,7 +265896,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30122", "family_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", "job_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "iron_coast_6", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -251686,6 +265912,472 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/candidate.json", "sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "18c9acd13ec59e49f0c08b6bc7f75566ebbae7288f30aea891b348614ff765c0", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.680654+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [{\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011d\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011d\", \"crop\": [0, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 0, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint, surviving gray roof fragments and surface partition remain in place. Stronger rubble, orange flecks and narrow radial cracks are accepted fine interpretation.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2261\", \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011e\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011e\", \"crop\": [314, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 1, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The damaged dark area and source roof-edge remnants remain readable. Pebble-like rubble and radial fine cracks strengthen detail without rebuilding an intact roof.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2262\", \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011f\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011f\", \"crop\": [627, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 2, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The near-square destroyed patch and surviving gray remnants retain their layout. Added thin dark crack lines and warm embers are accepted material detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2263\", \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30120\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30120\", \"crop\": [940, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 3, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source char shape and bordering pale structural patches remain damaged. Stronger grain/highlights are accepted rather than claimed as exact source RGB.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2264\", \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30121\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30121\", \"crop\": [0, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 4, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The central dark destruction, gray edge fragments and native surrounding building geometry remain in place. New metal/rubble detail is accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2265\", \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30122\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30122\", \"crop\": [314, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 5, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight remnant edges and damaged patch remain recognizable. Added thin radial cracks and embers remain fine damage detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2266\", \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30123\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30123\", \"crop\": [627, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 6, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The brighter left structural ribs and top remnant correspond to existing gray source fragments. The central destruction remains open/dark; sharper clean edges, stone-like rubble and orange flecks are interpretation, not an exact untouched SD material claim.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2267\", \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30124\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30124\", \"crop\": [940, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 7, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original opaque destroyed-surface tile retains its dark damaged footprint and surrounding gray fragments. Approved as source-bound gallery artwork only: the actual original registry contains no native mission samples, neighbors or state partners for this ID.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 0, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2268\", \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\", \"unused_gallery_only\": true, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30125\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30125\", \"crop\": [0, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 8, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original irregular damaged footprint and surviving gray vertical remnants are retained. Newly authored fine rubble and cracks are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2269\", \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30126\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30126\", \"crop\": [314, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 9, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source gray structural edge and dark damaged patch remain in their arrangement; brighter fine metal detail does not rebuild the entire intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2270\", \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30127\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30127\", \"crop\": [627, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 10, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source destruction and gray surviving fragments remain readable. Fine embers and grain are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2271\", \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30128\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30128\", \"crop\": [940, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 11, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint and roof-edge remnants remain in place; stronger fine cracks/highlights are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2272\", \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30129\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30129\", \"crop\": [0, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 12, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The gray linear remnants and asymmetric char geometry remain in the source arrangement. Radial fine cracks and orange highlights add damage material rather than an intact object.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2273\", \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012a\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012a\", \"crop\": [314, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 13, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The sharpened top/left metal rim and lower/right upright fragments correspond to existing source gray structures. Brighter steel and embers are accepted; the black damage remains, and no complete repaired roof appears.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2274\", \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012b\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012b\", \"crop\": [627, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 14, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The small central pale source remnant is interpreted as a short grooved metal piece; neighboring pale edges and char layout remain aligned. This is explicit material interpretation, with stronger rubble/embers, rather than exact original subpixel hardware fidelity.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 1, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2275\", \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012c\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012c\", \"crop\": [940, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 15, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight gray remnants around the broad dark damaged area remain readable. Fine stones, cracks and embers are accepted without restoring a complete intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2276\", \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}] [\"Brighter shard4 steel, radial thin cracks, rounded rubble and warm orange flecks are newly authored interpretation rather than exact SD grain/RGB. Source damaged dark areas remain damaged; no complete rebuilt roof was observed.\", \"30123/3012a existing straight gray source fragments gain cleaner metal edges.3012b central pale remnant is interpreted as a small grooved metal piece; this specific material interpretation is accepted and disclosed.\", \"Four held sibling remnants retain an approximate gray/dark area and closer1x palette average but larger native artwork loses visible straight surviving metal fragments. Opaque coverage cannot overrule that art defect.\", \"Mixed HD and ScaleNx-original tiles remain visibly different in texture density/material, including rectangular transitions in joined scenes. The two-logical-pixel edge transition is not claimed to hide every seam. No shifted major panel/roof/pipe boundary was found in the declared cases.\"] [\"All current individual declarations reviewed: up to3 authentic native samples per target, every declared cardinal ID pair and declared state-partner swap. This is not every whole map or every simultaneous destruction arrangement.\", \"Context1\\u20134 outputs were numerically checked and saved; complete fine scene galleries visually inspect native4x with64px original overviews, supplemented by every full source tile and actual1\\u20134 tile view. No claim of visually inspecting every whole context at native1/2/3.\", \"Joined64 is only127 representative context/state probes. Supporting earlier32 candidates are not newly approved here, and held4 remain held despite their inclusion in the diagnostic pack.\", \"Boundary means, full opaque mask overlap and source-class diagnostics establish neither artistic fidelity nor an invisible seam on their own.\", \"Actual static indexed loading/TerrainHd composition is verified. No live gameplay, arbitrary palette-fade cycle, mission1080p performance or unsupported route claim is made.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 755667dfb498724e17a35358d8d01541f51783b061cf26f80684c0d618ad68cb", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/complete-actual-ppm-manifest.json", + "sha256": "d330c159a081d63ce647a4f23ae9f84764b77e6ba3208b018079d321829dc89d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "3011d", + "3011e", + "3011f", + "30120" + ], + "sha256": "600f121057342084138f279aa0658376f00f4b9e4bd9de517f27028fb03b7c89", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30121", + "30122", + "30123", + "30124" + ], + "sha256": "23bad5451e0549b68fb2cf3cca3fc4b0557399bbd9b5190387cb7768a2a66c6f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "30125", + "30126", + "30127", + "30128" + ], + "sha256": "7720739a3e24872e00be5bc44e3e33a73a1e2e214352e6bbc8e7ef8ed7cfc8c4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "30129", + "3012a", + "3012b", + "3012c" + ], + "sha256": "8c976232ef3f87f905078ad64956e45187450c8c815e5847185d62be1b53de57", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "3011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47ddc428ba9c9d9a4ff0a52180f361be8b4c3f6fa958a19921cc11359cd52bd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e0a2dbf264485816ed3267ecd2c9fdeaca82660bdeef65f31c865e7a89bac3b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "402daf19f6f512ab35774f6ed760f5dd6beeb59ddcb98e9ec0cbe2e484963614", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "54b506e3c0aab49652dc095169bf8cf454f8ae0fed8bff3c1d0a68c52b834d86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f019a5361935df3e0117fd7e33e2b03787c108f5c540c23feebcd02cea3e64fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7b7c411788f55a818a1c2cf8eea745fdff2643abbae945138e848629b6de795a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ee4eb50f1339382c177f648af0add2c3f2a29aa24146e8bb364caf2bed06ea9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c1ab9b8da0357fefae1052a8ff97dc0876fa8ce6ab7c0fba0e939a2ee14a94f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "36f33b244c675e12428d57f9221dfac75fe211c80efed3f5a9450b22bcb50b2d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0fbc59221c897bde1aa195a44d6adb177b70954b21649445d087d12e475c379c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "649b8b00021215527674e058df3fd256a1ec58412bc656a62265e4511911ac27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5fd8af719d76cd017cba0b9e4b06b7e757ab376fec39c05693ef3139f6694097", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3867102b30ec60a6a0aadf2b13bb9f5f011306a51b7350d780a0e103024ac40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2076c09d7a71382739c2d0bf91888306ec65704e3090d92a15ca86dc7e1afa5c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bfb9a0c60f0c6b01b65dda24d57466f2a703f3d9b5fe926faa7942c9f3b49d04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e7f4579a56d595ba76c9e2d54321536ba3a2a8637d5e48a341742a6cf5ccd4cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7b2f9d98c2c922b243b9931c01ad61d02fe12a34a0c498d2cbf92028417391c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1e8dc9addaff9746c6dbee04189f2aaf8564c24fdea0f0951383fad1a8f3882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d26c5dd1942fa19f5b5cc8f927c17097b0dd6bef961f3e88d80808b5285ad759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af1be35802274ab0d1c46603c956f489363548583236a299b03ec9050e81dd53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0dd02a5723dfa38f8775cec3647a943dc81417295fe1267b5c8bb4e3013b1270", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dfae46f975fe415e11e77e15dc2b76de74a945bd4f57dcaebc7e3db06e932252", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9c87c2b2144a6857da73773a6de95b2ceaa34ddb464c003580004d1aebd91c45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "37da9b687aa89e9a1db920b5e9733e0ea6a73a9b325d49abb94df7cdb17855ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b3b11eff5c3f378bc986e31529c558566128d6d3cc38baedce3f63d6e41bba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4430a061e8f802ebfece64b2a74e4c9d2f3356df3d9dcc0b38ab399fbb6547b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d3068a6f407760188f934c7831a8978b1358e8d79b2394532ebcaeee5d610ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "351f358673bd32ee15bfc568a2ad8d5d9225a35341c07dad177691ba3e28c01a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "614ce68b7068d2c91714eaa7f759a4b3bd5e6e28c861046cea488f6ab224f3a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3cbfc85bc6e8eb13a412beda0aee76bba2c364bf2287a291491e5e654e77600b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f515fb9d1d66c68ba439f7ae83c4231dca92a73ff9378e158bf836e4ce68e783", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "16f0b4176b2b7e1ccbb1e6c86409d1ebb26eddc44fd0891948d4791341355f66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "95eb90b9a3cf2998bc492101cdcf5173d33705d2166ab90f5483b333983fc5a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d5462c8c176b17b062f64261b38a484e9890019d65a814e2f7b5f2f6eeee4c10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0d8fb1653d0b2f0ef5349f8d9f23f30e5cb323b2bccdce6197afcab3dd662ddd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1a027e0e27a8b818730dd5c0c5065a4448000e32f30bd648a10fc87897aaa95f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fff16fe61cc4d73d972ab9d12a52f112d8ef13fb7b37cb66c4d3db99108c9493", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ed83201f80607e31227cb59a6ac9d6a47df8e9ae61dd840c8a325bdb94ff2d27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "66cf27b7f00b72f4ac8733b72bc2b8fe0d0da239b0790317c03a84164fd3112b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "636e3d4a735c65070f1ac27eca1e2e12480ad27aab7a3c25335b9ed63a70027a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9da55e79f9c8724cebaf96ff69bac1ea23e84b4b70da1c696c8bbf117c2c2cd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ecf7acb2aaeb61dd2d728d7eeba7fe605ba2b76918015b97644fd133ac3c8171", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35a31bb6430524337048b347b350438565fc201e38153d60a99212f7ac4027e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3d63079e5a08c322c9fac8dc8ac154311ef252925d52c80d8f67d2c001c8ac45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90a1794aecdd5b5deb149dd21d4b77a2c9d5782f39c2bf418f3b40b14b46d4cc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b22802e327df7a43ff9e376c7f4aaf845d7f316c3a725c9c8ebdbde3dd3902ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd800cad574c5df989975871b2b09755df2e325e5190b4ad7869016a743bae02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74d2c4b9afb453a5dc814646c607c15f6e9a36f0257bd74998c3192b4916f8e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b4cc4e5d79e39b64fba94b3157d78eea8b44e69327d73667bc0c1e3dc120086e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9c703237fa600c8c4f635e9ec4b4cb4545da4fa768bb0f3695a8ce355c50eb5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1d991ecd07dfcacb890ac7101f944ca381bb73b073bdf1f6512724c4b16290b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "eb3015b83566d6eb34bf371da10666ed17d98d601f2c1030e68f94869067064c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81c40ad363129c77e53e1af99bd3e812ac9e933eb5d7091eb10c57d00610a08e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "697f34b746d8415d6d2e38e61f0d0737085d3981f5b1bfddc4ddc5df26425f76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "51aa7854bc4f1b5a8a6ee6c1d037b988383b415b8f6553bba5ea8c79415b9d63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "07d57094b6e20e052ff8f8da02c481058984c8781081f42d72947a22f0804c4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2d38d2a77ce433ea11ceb70d117f7c34c16b363eebb0fae4f0b49506b0b2a3b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f933dcafc0210f7dccffedfb36e2e99a18727ec501f37adb9781f765e2da6d8d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eb36aa9be293846bf1880a2f116479504770cbb86189451a3db1607d3245721c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9102e1307b087bcca0da28eefab6e294bded5fe84361e768ca8b95d4a06f3d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "56a6678ed32cdc2e9fa63defa9b0d7a5b7f45f59f1dae4b7c393deb3677ebd29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7afe25456c3f32795fde058ce1c114d8dbc2c92f940b843515fd8ab0d95aff44", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb3265816babfe4a0be59814473a8853d39683f51f110d1621ca1be2ac57ef06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7dda2d9fab9948724dd8b0884cf9370ca4cb3b9b9f9e963dbe3723f08038629a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8719368b9dea0ce143caea9a4cd15711e927acdc6f3df852a91eed7a6ce5142d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8d3e57945ea6a29a083ae6c4f1fcf08995a9971fd6ae5474af00c6b5c7c74c78", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "39db6b3a0247644fa0df7d5327d619e355a2e6891b8c842f86714f58763d1106", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6e5ebf63998007218f0d1705fbff02eafce120b1dc1585e0b26e5444f7fedfda", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c30cd53dda67959c4913124d079582303c9fd021ce258876ebbabb57e2ecae24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "69b7a3ee544111ee27eae2177134496c1fd325da2365cc5046c505e3c972ef04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "752c1ad8534130f53eb85c4ec18b67259cf7780f7dcba63132dd942457f21341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "92eeeb391492f1f28ac9a7cf9f16c7596771249836af0aa1c70e94169cd7909c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e24fab4c8b3ff68ddbdc4d639d5dd88318b7d20cc23482c9fce07f35601859e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1f4debdb9cd6900ad5a4338e2d3129dcd1ff47c4cb3771b83eba24c2b6fbb8de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8dffadf9fbed460de6480bf668f65e65555179943981f21920d69e7432e59957", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36c99dbab51a147932fef004caee8a14b8a465f590ea3b07f2c901d7abe7dedd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b8e2051339dce4c6e0c5c06d3ea596b53132677d6ad49b7f17ffb54f0f2914c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1795161adccbf83cf99216fc8ffc6b5c224cf94f43617593a520799cb7168d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f981283c260f11a57eb352eadc5aac098c61cf4108af99d26d037b53ee505469", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9fcef15e698582bef7087a4c23e4fade00d86f7c0ceb6afada84760e6a4b79e3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30123": { @@ -251707,7 +266399,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30123", "family_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", "job_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "iron_coast_6", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -251723,6 +266415,472 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/candidate.json", "sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "18c9acd13ec59e49f0c08b6bc7f75566ebbae7288f30aea891b348614ff765c0", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.680654+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [{\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011d\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011d\", \"crop\": [0, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 0, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint, surviving gray roof fragments and surface partition remain in place. Stronger rubble, orange flecks and narrow radial cracks are accepted fine interpretation.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2261\", \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011e\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011e\", \"crop\": [314, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 1, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The damaged dark area and source roof-edge remnants remain readable. Pebble-like rubble and radial fine cracks strengthen detail without rebuilding an intact roof.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2262\", \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011f\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011f\", \"crop\": [627, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 2, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The near-square destroyed patch and surviving gray remnants retain their layout. Added thin dark crack lines and warm embers are accepted material detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2263\", \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30120\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30120\", \"crop\": [940, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 3, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source char shape and bordering pale structural patches remain damaged. Stronger grain/highlights are accepted rather than claimed as exact source RGB.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2264\", \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30121\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30121\", \"crop\": [0, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 4, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The central dark destruction, gray edge fragments and native surrounding building geometry remain in place. New metal/rubble detail is accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2265\", \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30122\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30122\", \"crop\": [314, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 5, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight remnant edges and damaged patch remain recognizable. Added thin radial cracks and embers remain fine damage detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2266\", \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30123\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30123\", \"crop\": [627, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 6, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The brighter left structural ribs and top remnant correspond to existing gray source fragments. The central destruction remains open/dark; sharper clean edges, stone-like rubble and orange flecks are interpretation, not an exact untouched SD material claim.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2267\", \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30124\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30124\", \"crop\": [940, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 7, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original opaque destroyed-surface tile retains its dark damaged footprint and surrounding gray fragments. Approved as source-bound gallery artwork only: the actual original registry contains no native mission samples, neighbors or state partners for this ID.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 0, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2268\", \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\", \"unused_gallery_only\": true, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30125\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30125\", \"crop\": [0, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 8, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original irregular damaged footprint and surviving gray vertical remnants are retained. Newly authored fine rubble and cracks are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2269\", \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30126\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30126\", \"crop\": [314, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 9, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source gray structural edge and dark damaged patch remain in their arrangement; brighter fine metal detail does not rebuild the entire intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2270\", \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30127\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30127\", \"crop\": [627, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 10, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source destruction and gray surviving fragments remain readable. Fine embers and grain are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2271\", \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30128\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30128\", \"crop\": [940, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 11, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint and roof-edge remnants remain in place; stronger fine cracks/highlights are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2272\", \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30129\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30129\", \"crop\": [0, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 12, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The gray linear remnants and asymmetric char geometry remain in the source arrangement. Radial fine cracks and orange highlights add damage material rather than an intact object.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2273\", \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012a\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012a\", \"crop\": [314, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 13, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The sharpened top/left metal rim and lower/right upright fragments correspond to existing source gray structures. Brighter steel and embers are accepted; the black damage remains, and no complete repaired roof appears.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2274\", \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012b\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012b\", \"crop\": [627, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 14, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The small central pale source remnant is interpreted as a short grooved metal piece; neighboring pale edges and char layout remain aligned. This is explicit material interpretation, with stronger rubble/embers, rather than exact original subpixel hardware fidelity.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 1, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2275\", \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012c\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012c\", \"crop\": [940, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 15, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight gray remnants around the broad dark damaged area remain readable. Fine stones, cracks and embers are accepted without restoring a complete intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2276\", \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}] [\"Brighter shard4 steel, radial thin cracks, rounded rubble and warm orange flecks are newly authored interpretation rather than exact SD grain/RGB. Source damaged dark areas remain damaged; no complete rebuilt roof was observed.\", \"30123/3012a existing straight gray source fragments gain cleaner metal edges.3012b central pale remnant is interpreted as a small grooved metal piece; this specific material interpretation is accepted and disclosed.\", \"Four held sibling remnants retain an approximate gray/dark area and closer1x palette average but larger native artwork loses visible straight surviving metal fragments. Opaque coverage cannot overrule that art defect.\", \"Mixed HD and ScaleNx-original tiles remain visibly different in texture density/material, including rectangular transitions in joined scenes. The two-logical-pixel edge transition is not claimed to hide every seam. No shifted major panel/roof/pipe boundary was found in the declared cases.\"] [\"All current individual declarations reviewed: up to3 authentic native samples per target, every declared cardinal ID pair and declared state-partner swap. This is not every whole map or every simultaneous destruction arrangement.\", \"Context1\\u20134 outputs were numerically checked and saved; complete fine scene galleries visually inspect native4x with64px original overviews, supplemented by every full source tile and actual1\\u20134 tile view. No claim of visually inspecting every whole context at native1/2/3.\", \"Joined64 is only127 representative context/state probes. Supporting earlier32 candidates are not newly approved here, and held4 remain held despite their inclusion in the diagnostic pack.\", \"Boundary means, full opaque mask overlap and source-class diagnostics establish neither artistic fidelity nor an invisible seam on their own.\", \"Actual static indexed loading/TerrainHd composition is verified. No live gameplay, arbitrary palette-fade cycle, mission1080p performance or unsupported route claim is made.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 755667dfb498724e17a35358d8d01541f51783b061cf26f80684c0d618ad68cb", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/complete-actual-ppm-manifest.json", + "sha256": "d330c159a081d63ce647a4f23ae9f84764b77e6ba3208b018079d321829dc89d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "3011d", + "3011e", + "3011f", + "30120" + ], + "sha256": "600f121057342084138f279aa0658376f00f4b9e4bd9de517f27028fb03b7c89", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30121", + "30122", + "30123", + "30124" + ], + "sha256": "23bad5451e0549b68fb2cf3cca3fc4b0557399bbd9b5190387cb7768a2a66c6f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "30125", + "30126", + "30127", + "30128" + ], + "sha256": "7720739a3e24872e00be5bc44e3e33a73a1e2e214352e6bbc8e7ef8ed7cfc8c4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "30129", + "3012a", + "3012b", + "3012c" + ], + "sha256": "8c976232ef3f87f905078ad64956e45187450c8c815e5847185d62be1b53de57", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "3011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47ddc428ba9c9d9a4ff0a52180f361be8b4c3f6fa958a19921cc11359cd52bd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e0a2dbf264485816ed3267ecd2c9fdeaca82660bdeef65f31c865e7a89bac3b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "402daf19f6f512ab35774f6ed760f5dd6beeb59ddcb98e9ec0cbe2e484963614", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "54b506e3c0aab49652dc095169bf8cf454f8ae0fed8bff3c1d0a68c52b834d86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f019a5361935df3e0117fd7e33e2b03787c108f5c540c23feebcd02cea3e64fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7b7c411788f55a818a1c2cf8eea745fdff2643abbae945138e848629b6de795a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ee4eb50f1339382c177f648af0add2c3f2a29aa24146e8bb364caf2bed06ea9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c1ab9b8da0357fefae1052a8ff97dc0876fa8ce6ab7c0fba0e939a2ee14a94f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "36f33b244c675e12428d57f9221dfac75fe211c80efed3f5a9450b22bcb50b2d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0fbc59221c897bde1aa195a44d6adb177b70954b21649445d087d12e475c379c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "649b8b00021215527674e058df3fd256a1ec58412bc656a62265e4511911ac27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5fd8af719d76cd017cba0b9e4b06b7e757ab376fec39c05693ef3139f6694097", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3867102b30ec60a6a0aadf2b13bb9f5f011306a51b7350d780a0e103024ac40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2076c09d7a71382739c2d0bf91888306ec65704e3090d92a15ca86dc7e1afa5c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bfb9a0c60f0c6b01b65dda24d57466f2a703f3d9b5fe926faa7942c9f3b49d04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e7f4579a56d595ba76c9e2d54321536ba3a2a8637d5e48a341742a6cf5ccd4cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7b2f9d98c2c922b243b9931c01ad61d02fe12a34a0c498d2cbf92028417391c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1e8dc9addaff9746c6dbee04189f2aaf8564c24fdea0f0951383fad1a8f3882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d26c5dd1942fa19f5b5cc8f927c17097b0dd6bef961f3e88d80808b5285ad759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af1be35802274ab0d1c46603c956f489363548583236a299b03ec9050e81dd53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0dd02a5723dfa38f8775cec3647a943dc81417295fe1267b5c8bb4e3013b1270", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dfae46f975fe415e11e77e15dc2b76de74a945bd4f57dcaebc7e3db06e932252", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9c87c2b2144a6857da73773a6de95b2ceaa34ddb464c003580004d1aebd91c45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "37da9b687aa89e9a1db920b5e9733e0ea6a73a9b325d49abb94df7cdb17855ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b3b11eff5c3f378bc986e31529c558566128d6d3cc38baedce3f63d6e41bba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4430a061e8f802ebfece64b2a74e4c9d2f3356df3d9dcc0b38ab399fbb6547b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d3068a6f407760188f934c7831a8978b1358e8d79b2394532ebcaeee5d610ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "351f358673bd32ee15bfc568a2ad8d5d9225a35341c07dad177691ba3e28c01a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "614ce68b7068d2c91714eaa7f759a4b3bd5e6e28c861046cea488f6ab224f3a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3cbfc85bc6e8eb13a412beda0aee76bba2c364bf2287a291491e5e654e77600b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f515fb9d1d66c68ba439f7ae83c4231dca92a73ff9378e158bf836e4ce68e783", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "16f0b4176b2b7e1ccbb1e6c86409d1ebb26eddc44fd0891948d4791341355f66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "95eb90b9a3cf2998bc492101cdcf5173d33705d2166ab90f5483b333983fc5a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d5462c8c176b17b062f64261b38a484e9890019d65a814e2f7b5f2f6eeee4c10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0d8fb1653d0b2f0ef5349f8d9f23f30e5cb323b2bccdce6197afcab3dd662ddd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1a027e0e27a8b818730dd5c0c5065a4448000e32f30bd648a10fc87897aaa95f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fff16fe61cc4d73d972ab9d12a52f112d8ef13fb7b37cb66c4d3db99108c9493", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ed83201f80607e31227cb59a6ac9d6a47df8e9ae61dd840c8a325bdb94ff2d27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "66cf27b7f00b72f4ac8733b72bc2b8fe0d0da239b0790317c03a84164fd3112b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "636e3d4a735c65070f1ac27eca1e2e12480ad27aab7a3c25335b9ed63a70027a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9da55e79f9c8724cebaf96ff69bac1ea23e84b4b70da1c696c8bbf117c2c2cd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ecf7acb2aaeb61dd2d728d7eeba7fe605ba2b76918015b97644fd133ac3c8171", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35a31bb6430524337048b347b350438565fc201e38153d60a99212f7ac4027e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3d63079e5a08c322c9fac8dc8ac154311ef252925d52c80d8f67d2c001c8ac45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90a1794aecdd5b5deb149dd21d4b77a2c9d5782f39c2bf418f3b40b14b46d4cc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b22802e327df7a43ff9e376c7f4aaf845d7f316c3a725c9c8ebdbde3dd3902ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd800cad574c5df989975871b2b09755df2e325e5190b4ad7869016a743bae02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74d2c4b9afb453a5dc814646c607c15f6e9a36f0257bd74998c3192b4916f8e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b4cc4e5d79e39b64fba94b3157d78eea8b44e69327d73667bc0c1e3dc120086e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9c703237fa600c8c4f635e9ec4b4cb4545da4fa768bb0f3695a8ce355c50eb5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1d991ecd07dfcacb890ac7101f944ca381bb73b073bdf1f6512724c4b16290b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "eb3015b83566d6eb34bf371da10666ed17d98d601f2c1030e68f94869067064c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81c40ad363129c77e53e1af99bd3e812ac9e933eb5d7091eb10c57d00610a08e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "697f34b746d8415d6d2e38e61f0d0737085d3981f5b1bfddc4ddc5df26425f76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "51aa7854bc4f1b5a8a6ee6c1d037b988383b415b8f6553bba5ea8c79415b9d63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "07d57094b6e20e052ff8f8da02c481058984c8781081f42d72947a22f0804c4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2d38d2a77ce433ea11ceb70d117f7c34c16b363eebb0fae4f0b49506b0b2a3b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f933dcafc0210f7dccffedfb36e2e99a18727ec501f37adb9781f765e2da6d8d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eb36aa9be293846bf1880a2f116479504770cbb86189451a3db1607d3245721c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9102e1307b087bcca0da28eefab6e294bded5fe84361e768ca8b95d4a06f3d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "56a6678ed32cdc2e9fa63defa9b0d7a5b7f45f59f1dae4b7c393deb3677ebd29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7afe25456c3f32795fde058ce1c114d8dbc2c92f940b843515fd8ab0d95aff44", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb3265816babfe4a0be59814473a8853d39683f51f110d1621ca1be2ac57ef06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7dda2d9fab9948724dd8b0884cf9370ca4cb3b9b9f9e963dbe3723f08038629a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8719368b9dea0ce143caea9a4cd15711e927acdc6f3df852a91eed7a6ce5142d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8d3e57945ea6a29a083ae6c4f1fcf08995a9971fd6ae5474af00c6b5c7c74c78", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "39db6b3a0247644fa0df7d5327d619e355a2e6891b8c842f86714f58763d1106", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6e5ebf63998007218f0d1705fbff02eafce120b1dc1585e0b26e5444f7fedfda", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c30cd53dda67959c4913124d079582303c9fd021ce258876ebbabb57e2ecae24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "69b7a3ee544111ee27eae2177134496c1fd325da2365cc5046c505e3c972ef04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "752c1ad8534130f53eb85c4ec18b67259cf7780f7dcba63132dd942457f21341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "92eeeb391492f1f28ac9a7cf9f16c7596771249836af0aa1c70e94169cd7909c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e24fab4c8b3ff68ddbdc4d639d5dd88318b7d20cc23482c9fce07f35601859e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1f4debdb9cd6900ad5a4338e2d3129dcd1ff47c4cb3771b83eba24c2b6fbb8de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8dffadf9fbed460de6480bf668f65e65555179943981f21920d69e7432e59957", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36c99dbab51a147932fef004caee8a14b8a465f590ea3b07f2c901d7abe7dedd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b8e2051339dce4c6e0c5c06d3ea596b53132677d6ad49b7f17ffb54f0f2914c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1795161adccbf83cf99216fc8ffc6b5c224cf94f43617593a520799cb7168d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f981283c260f11a57eb352eadc5aac098c61cf4108af99d26d037b53ee505469", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9fcef15e698582bef7087a4c23e4fade00d86f7c0ceb6afada84760e6a4b79e3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30124": { @@ -251744,7 +266902,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30124", "family_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", "job_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "iron_coast_6", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -251760,6 +266918,472 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/candidate.json", "sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "18c9acd13ec59e49f0c08b6bc7f75566ebbae7288f30aea891b348614ff765c0", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.680654+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [{\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011d\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011d\", \"crop\": [0, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 0, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint, surviving gray roof fragments and surface partition remain in place. Stronger rubble, orange flecks and narrow radial cracks are accepted fine interpretation.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2261\", \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011e\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011e\", \"crop\": [314, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 1, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The damaged dark area and source roof-edge remnants remain readable. Pebble-like rubble and radial fine cracks strengthen detail without rebuilding an intact roof.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2262\", \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011f\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011f\", \"crop\": [627, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 2, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The near-square destroyed patch and surviving gray remnants retain their layout. Added thin dark crack lines and warm embers are accepted material detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2263\", \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30120\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30120\", \"crop\": [940, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 3, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source char shape and bordering pale structural patches remain damaged. Stronger grain/highlights are accepted rather than claimed as exact source RGB.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2264\", \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30121\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30121\", \"crop\": [0, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 4, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The central dark destruction, gray edge fragments and native surrounding building geometry remain in place. New metal/rubble detail is accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2265\", \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30122\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30122\", \"crop\": [314, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 5, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight remnant edges and damaged patch remain recognizable. Added thin radial cracks and embers remain fine damage detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2266\", \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30123\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30123\", \"crop\": [627, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 6, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The brighter left structural ribs and top remnant correspond to existing gray source fragments. The central destruction remains open/dark; sharper clean edges, stone-like rubble and orange flecks are interpretation, not an exact untouched SD material claim.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2267\", \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30124\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30124\", \"crop\": [940, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 7, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original opaque destroyed-surface tile retains its dark damaged footprint and surrounding gray fragments. Approved as source-bound gallery artwork only: the actual original registry contains no native mission samples, neighbors or state partners for this ID.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 0, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2268\", \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\", \"unused_gallery_only\": true, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30125\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30125\", \"crop\": [0, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 8, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original irregular damaged footprint and surviving gray vertical remnants are retained. Newly authored fine rubble and cracks are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2269\", \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30126\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30126\", \"crop\": [314, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 9, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source gray structural edge and dark damaged patch remain in their arrangement; brighter fine metal detail does not rebuild the entire intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2270\", \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30127\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30127\", \"crop\": [627, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 10, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source destruction and gray surviving fragments remain readable. Fine embers and grain are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2271\", \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30128\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30128\", \"crop\": [940, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 11, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint and roof-edge remnants remain in place; stronger fine cracks/highlights are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2272\", \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30129\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30129\", \"crop\": [0, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 12, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The gray linear remnants and asymmetric char geometry remain in the source arrangement. Radial fine cracks and orange highlights add damage material rather than an intact object.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2273\", \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012a\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012a\", \"crop\": [314, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 13, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The sharpened top/left metal rim and lower/right upright fragments correspond to existing source gray structures. Brighter steel and embers are accepted; the black damage remains, and no complete repaired roof appears.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2274\", \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012b\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012b\", \"crop\": [627, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 14, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The small central pale source remnant is interpreted as a short grooved metal piece; neighboring pale edges and char layout remain aligned. This is explicit material interpretation, with stronger rubble/embers, rather than exact original subpixel hardware fidelity.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 1, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2275\", \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012c\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012c\", \"crop\": [940, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 15, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight gray remnants around the broad dark damaged area remain readable. Fine stones, cracks and embers are accepted without restoring a complete intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2276\", \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}] [\"Brighter shard4 steel, radial thin cracks, rounded rubble and warm orange flecks are newly authored interpretation rather than exact SD grain/RGB. Source damaged dark areas remain damaged; no complete rebuilt roof was observed.\", \"30123/3012a existing straight gray source fragments gain cleaner metal edges.3012b central pale remnant is interpreted as a small grooved metal piece; this specific material interpretation is accepted and disclosed.\", \"Four held sibling remnants retain an approximate gray/dark area and closer1x palette average but larger native artwork loses visible straight surviving metal fragments. Opaque coverage cannot overrule that art defect.\", \"Mixed HD and ScaleNx-original tiles remain visibly different in texture density/material, including rectangular transitions in joined scenes. The two-logical-pixel edge transition is not claimed to hide every seam. No shifted major panel/roof/pipe boundary was found in the declared cases.\"] [\"All current individual declarations reviewed: up to3 authentic native samples per target, every declared cardinal ID pair and declared state-partner swap. This is not every whole map or every simultaneous destruction arrangement.\", \"Context1\\u20134 outputs were numerically checked and saved; complete fine scene galleries visually inspect native4x with64px original overviews, supplemented by every full source tile and actual1\\u20134 tile view. No claim of visually inspecting every whole context at native1/2/3.\", \"Joined64 is only127 representative context/state probes. Supporting earlier32 candidates are not newly approved here, and held4 remain held despite their inclusion in the diagnostic pack.\", \"Boundary means, full opaque mask overlap and source-class diagnostics establish neither artistic fidelity nor an invisible seam on their own.\", \"Actual static indexed loading/TerrainHd composition is verified. No live gameplay, arbitrary palette-fade cycle, mission1080p performance or unsupported route claim is made.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 755667dfb498724e17a35358d8d01541f51783b061cf26f80684c0d618ad68cb", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/complete-actual-ppm-manifest.json", + "sha256": "d330c159a081d63ce647a4f23ae9f84764b77e6ba3208b018079d321829dc89d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "3011d", + "3011e", + "3011f", + "30120" + ], + "sha256": "600f121057342084138f279aa0658376f00f4b9e4bd9de517f27028fb03b7c89", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30121", + "30122", + "30123", + "30124" + ], + "sha256": "23bad5451e0549b68fb2cf3cca3fc4b0557399bbd9b5190387cb7768a2a66c6f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "30125", + "30126", + "30127", + "30128" + ], + "sha256": "7720739a3e24872e00be5bc44e3e33a73a1e2e214352e6bbc8e7ef8ed7cfc8c4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "30129", + "3012a", + "3012b", + "3012c" + ], + "sha256": "8c976232ef3f87f905078ad64956e45187450c8c815e5847185d62be1b53de57", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "3011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47ddc428ba9c9d9a4ff0a52180f361be8b4c3f6fa958a19921cc11359cd52bd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e0a2dbf264485816ed3267ecd2c9fdeaca82660bdeef65f31c865e7a89bac3b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "402daf19f6f512ab35774f6ed760f5dd6beeb59ddcb98e9ec0cbe2e484963614", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "54b506e3c0aab49652dc095169bf8cf454f8ae0fed8bff3c1d0a68c52b834d86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f019a5361935df3e0117fd7e33e2b03787c108f5c540c23feebcd02cea3e64fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7b7c411788f55a818a1c2cf8eea745fdff2643abbae945138e848629b6de795a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ee4eb50f1339382c177f648af0add2c3f2a29aa24146e8bb364caf2bed06ea9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c1ab9b8da0357fefae1052a8ff97dc0876fa8ce6ab7c0fba0e939a2ee14a94f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "36f33b244c675e12428d57f9221dfac75fe211c80efed3f5a9450b22bcb50b2d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0fbc59221c897bde1aa195a44d6adb177b70954b21649445d087d12e475c379c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "649b8b00021215527674e058df3fd256a1ec58412bc656a62265e4511911ac27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5fd8af719d76cd017cba0b9e4b06b7e757ab376fec39c05693ef3139f6694097", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3867102b30ec60a6a0aadf2b13bb9f5f011306a51b7350d780a0e103024ac40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2076c09d7a71382739c2d0bf91888306ec65704e3090d92a15ca86dc7e1afa5c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bfb9a0c60f0c6b01b65dda24d57466f2a703f3d9b5fe926faa7942c9f3b49d04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e7f4579a56d595ba76c9e2d54321536ba3a2a8637d5e48a341742a6cf5ccd4cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7b2f9d98c2c922b243b9931c01ad61d02fe12a34a0c498d2cbf92028417391c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1e8dc9addaff9746c6dbee04189f2aaf8564c24fdea0f0951383fad1a8f3882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d26c5dd1942fa19f5b5cc8f927c17097b0dd6bef961f3e88d80808b5285ad759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af1be35802274ab0d1c46603c956f489363548583236a299b03ec9050e81dd53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0dd02a5723dfa38f8775cec3647a943dc81417295fe1267b5c8bb4e3013b1270", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dfae46f975fe415e11e77e15dc2b76de74a945bd4f57dcaebc7e3db06e932252", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9c87c2b2144a6857da73773a6de95b2ceaa34ddb464c003580004d1aebd91c45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "37da9b687aa89e9a1db920b5e9733e0ea6a73a9b325d49abb94df7cdb17855ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b3b11eff5c3f378bc986e31529c558566128d6d3cc38baedce3f63d6e41bba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4430a061e8f802ebfece64b2a74e4c9d2f3356df3d9dcc0b38ab399fbb6547b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d3068a6f407760188f934c7831a8978b1358e8d79b2394532ebcaeee5d610ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "351f358673bd32ee15bfc568a2ad8d5d9225a35341c07dad177691ba3e28c01a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "614ce68b7068d2c91714eaa7f759a4b3bd5e6e28c861046cea488f6ab224f3a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3cbfc85bc6e8eb13a412beda0aee76bba2c364bf2287a291491e5e654e77600b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f515fb9d1d66c68ba439f7ae83c4231dca92a73ff9378e158bf836e4ce68e783", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "16f0b4176b2b7e1ccbb1e6c86409d1ebb26eddc44fd0891948d4791341355f66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "95eb90b9a3cf2998bc492101cdcf5173d33705d2166ab90f5483b333983fc5a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d5462c8c176b17b062f64261b38a484e9890019d65a814e2f7b5f2f6eeee4c10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0d8fb1653d0b2f0ef5349f8d9f23f30e5cb323b2bccdce6197afcab3dd662ddd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1a027e0e27a8b818730dd5c0c5065a4448000e32f30bd648a10fc87897aaa95f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fff16fe61cc4d73d972ab9d12a52f112d8ef13fb7b37cb66c4d3db99108c9493", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ed83201f80607e31227cb59a6ac9d6a47df8e9ae61dd840c8a325bdb94ff2d27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "66cf27b7f00b72f4ac8733b72bc2b8fe0d0da239b0790317c03a84164fd3112b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "636e3d4a735c65070f1ac27eca1e2e12480ad27aab7a3c25335b9ed63a70027a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9da55e79f9c8724cebaf96ff69bac1ea23e84b4b70da1c696c8bbf117c2c2cd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ecf7acb2aaeb61dd2d728d7eeba7fe605ba2b76918015b97644fd133ac3c8171", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35a31bb6430524337048b347b350438565fc201e38153d60a99212f7ac4027e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3d63079e5a08c322c9fac8dc8ac154311ef252925d52c80d8f67d2c001c8ac45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90a1794aecdd5b5deb149dd21d4b77a2c9d5782f39c2bf418f3b40b14b46d4cc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b22802e327df7a43ff9e376c7f4aaf845d7f316c3a725c9c8ebdbde3dd3902ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd800cad574c5df989975871b2b09755df2e325e5190b4ad7869016a743bae02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74d2c4b9afb453a5dc814646c607c15f6e9a36f0257bd74998c3192b4916f8e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b4cc4e5d79e39b64fba94b3157d78eea8b44e69327d73667bc0c1e3dc120086e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9c703237fa600c8c4f635e9ec4b4cb4545da4fa768bb0f3695a8ce355c50eb5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1d991ecd07dfcacb890ac7101f944ca381bb73b073bdf1f6512724c4b16290b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "eb3015b83566d6eb34bf371da10666ed17d98d601f2c1030e68f94869067064c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81c40ad363129c77e53e1af99bd3e812ac9e933eb5d7091eb10c57d00610a08e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "697f34b746d8415d6d2e38e61f0d0737085d3981f5b1bfddc4ddc5df26425f76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "51aa7854bc4f1b5a8a6ee6c1d037b988383b415b8f6553bba5ea8c79415b9d63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "07d57094b6e20e052ff8f8da02c481058984c8781081f42d72947a22f0804c4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2d38d2a77ce433ea11ceb70d117f7c34c16b363eebb0fae4f0b49506b0b2a3b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f933dcafc0210f7dccffedfb36e2e99a18727ec501f37adb9781f765e2da6d8d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eb36aa9be293846bf1880a2f116479504770cbb86189451a3db1607d3245721c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9102e1307b087bcca0da28eefab6e294bded5fe84361e768ca8b95d4a06f3d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "56a6678ed32cdc2e9fa63defa9b0d7a5b7f45f59f1dae4b7c393deb3677ebd29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7afe25456c3f32795fde058ce1c114d8dbc2c92f940b843515fd8ab0d95aff44", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb3265816babfe4a0be59814473a8853d39683f51f110d1621ca1be2ac57ef06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7dda2d9fab9948724dd8b0884cf9370ca4cb3b9b9f9e963dbe3723f08038629a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8719368b9dea0ce143caea9a4cd15711e927acdc6f3df852a91eed7a6ce5142d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8d3e57945ea6a29a083ae6c4f1fcf08995a9971fd6ae5474af00c6b5c7c74c78", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "39db6b3a0247644fa0df7d5327d619e355a2e6891b8c842f86714f58763d1106", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6e5ebf63998007218f0d1705fbff02eafce120b1dc1585e0b26e5444f7fedfda", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c30cd53dda67959c4913124d079582303c9fd021ce258876ebbabb57e2ecae24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "69b7a3ee544111ee27eae2177134496c1fd325da2365cc5046c505e3c972ef04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "752c1ad8534130f53eb85c4ec18b67259cf7780f7dcba63132dd942457f21341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "92eeeb391492f1f28ac9a7cf9f16c7596771249836af0aa1c70e94169cd7909c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e24fab4c8b3ff68ddbdc4d639d5dd88318b7d20cc23482c9fce07f35601859e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1f4debdb9cd6900ad5a4338e2d3129dcd1ff47c4cb3771b83eba24c2b6fbb8de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8dffadf9fbed460de6480bf668f65e65555179943981f21920d69e7432e59957", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36c99dbab51a147932fef004caee8a14b8a465f590ea3b07f2c901d7abe7dedd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b8e2051339dce4c6e0c5c06d3ea596b53132677d6ad49b7f17ffb54f0f2914c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1795161adccbf83cf99216fc8ffc6b5c224cf94f43617593a520799cb7168d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f981283c260f11a57eb352eadc5aac098c61cf4108af99d26d037b53ee505469", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9fcef15e698582bef7087a4c23e4fade00d86f7c0ceb6afada84760e6a4b79e3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30125": { @@ -251781,7 +267405,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30125", "family_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", "job_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "iron_coast_6", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -251797,6 +267421,472 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/candidate.json", "sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "18c9acd13ec59e49f0c08b6bc7f75566ebbae7288f30aea891b348614ff765c0", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.680654+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [{\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011d\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011d\", \"crop\": [0, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 0, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint, surviving gray roof fragments and surface partition remain in place. Stronger rubble, orange flecks and narrow radial cracks are accepted fine interpretation.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2261\", \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011e\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011e\", \"crop\": [314, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 1, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The damaged dark area and source roof-edge remnants remain readable. Pebble-like rubble and radial fine cracks strengthen detail without rebuilding an intact roof.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2262\", \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011f\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011f\", \"crop\": [627, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 2, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The near-square destroyed patch and surviving gray remnants retain their layout. Added thin dark crack lines and warm embers are accepted material detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2263\", \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30120\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30120\", \"crop\": [940, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 3, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source char shape and bordering pale structural patches remain damaged. Stronger grain/highlights are accepted rather than claimed as exact source RGB.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2264\", \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30121\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30121\", \"crop\": [0, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 4, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The central dark destruction, gray edge fragments and native surrounding building geometry remain in place. New metal/rubble detail is accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2265\", \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30122\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30122\", \"crop\": [314, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 5, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight remnant edges and damaged patch remain recognizable. Added thin radial cracks and embers remain fine damage detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2266\", \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30123\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30123\", \"crop\": [627, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 6, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The brighter left structural ribs and top remnant correspond to existing gray source fragments. The central destruction remains open/dark; sharper clean edges, stone-like rubble and orange flecks are interpretation, not an exact untouched SD material claim.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2267\", \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30124\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30124\", \"crop\": [940, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 7, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original opaque destroyed-surface tile retains its dark damaged footprint and surrounding gray fragments. Approved as source-bound gallery artwork only: the actual original registry contains no native mission samples, neighbors or state partners for this ID.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 0, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2268\", \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\", \"unused_gallery_only\": true, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30125\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30125\", \"crop\": [0, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 8, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original irregular damaged footprint and surviving gray vertical remnants are retained. Newly authored fine rubble and cracks are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2269\", \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30126\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30126\", \"crop\": [314, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 9, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source gray structural edge and dark damaged patch remain in their arrangement; brighter fine metal detail does not rebuild the entire intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2270\", \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30127\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30127\", \"crop\": [627, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 10, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source destruction and gray surviving fragments remain readable. Fine embers and grain are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2271\", \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30128\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30128\", \"crop\": [940, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 11, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint and roof-edge remnants remain in place; stronger fine cracks/highlights are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2272\", \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30129\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30129\", \"crop\": [0, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 12, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The gray linear remnants and asymmetric char geometry remain in the source arrangement. Radial fine cracks and orange highlights add damage material rather than an intact object.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2273\", \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012a\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012a\", \"crop\": [314, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 13, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The sharpened top/left metal rim and lower/right upright fragments correspond to existing source gray structures. Brighter steel and embers are accepted; the black damage remains, and no complete repaired roof appears.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2274\", \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012b\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012b\", \"crop\": [627, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 14, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The small central pale source remnant is interpreted as a short grooved metal piece; neighboring pale edges and char layout remain aligned. This is explicit material interpretation, with stronger rubble/embers, rather than exact original subpixel hardware fidelity.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 1, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2275\", \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012c\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012c\", \"crop\": [940, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 15, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight gray remnants around the broad dark damaged area remain readable. Fine stones, cracks and embers are accepted without restoring a complete intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2276\", \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}] [\"Brighter shard4 steel, radial thin cracks, rounded rubble and warm orange flecks are newly authored interpretation rather than exact SD grain/RGB. Source damaged dark areas remain damaged; no complete rebuilt roof was observed.\", \"30123/3012a existing straight gray source fragments gain cleaner metal edges.3012b central pale remnant is interpreted as a small grooved metal piece; this specific material interpretation is accepted and disclosed.\", \"Four held sibling remnants retain an approximate gray/dark area and closer1x palette average but larger native artwork loses visible straight surviving metal fragments. Opaque coverage cannot overrule that art defect.\", \"Mixed HD and ScaleNx-original tiles remain visibly different in texture density/material, including rectangular transitions in joined scenes. The two-logical-pixel edge transition is not claimed to hide every seam. No shifted major panel/roof/pipe boundary was found in the declared cases.\"] [\"All current individual declarations reviewed: up to3 authentic native samples per target, every declared cardinal ID pair and declared state-partner swap. This is not every whole map or every simultaneous destruction arrangement.\", \"Context1\\u20134 outputs were numerically checked and saved; complete fine scene galleries visually inspect native4x with64px original overviews, supplemented by every full source tile and actual1\\u20134 tile view. No claim of visually inspecting every whole context at native1/2/3.\", \"Joined64 is only127 representative context/state probes. Supporting earlier32 candidates are not newly approved here, and held4 remain held despite their inclusion in the diagnostic pack.\", \"Boundary means, full opaque mask overlap and source-class diagnostics establish neither artistic fidelity nor an invisible seam on their own.\", \"Actual static indexed loading/TerrainHd composition is verified. No live gameplay, arbitrary palette-fade cycle, mission1080p performance or unsupported route claim is made.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 755667dfb498724e17a35358d8d01541f51783b061cf26f80684c0d618ad68cb", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/complete-actual-ppm-manifest.json", + "sha256": "d330c159a081d63ce647a4f23ae9f84764b77e6ba3208b018079d321829dc89d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "3011d", + "3011e", + "3011f", + "30120" + ], + "sha256": "600f121057342084138f279aa0658376f00f4b9e4bd9de517f27028fb03b7c89", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30121", + "30122", + "30123", + "30124" + ], + "sha256": "23bad5451e0549b68fb2cf3cca3fc4b0557399bbd9b5190387cb7768a2a66c6f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "30125", + "30126", + "30127", + "30128" + ], + "sha256": "7720739a3e24872e00be5bc44e3e33a73a1e2e214352e6bbc8e7ef8ed7cfc8c4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "30129", + "3012a", + "3012b", + "3012c" + ], + "sha256": "8c976232ef3f87f905078ad64956e45187450c8c815e5847185d62be1b53de57", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "3011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47ddc428ba9c9d9a4ff0a52180f361be8b4c3f6fa958a19921cc11359cd52bd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e0a2dbf264485816ed3267ecd2c9fdeaca82660bdeef65f31c865e7a89bac3b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "402daf19f6f512ab35774f6ed760f5dd6beeb59ddcb98e9ec0cbe2e484963614", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "54b506e3c0aab49652dc095169bf8cf454f8ae0fed8bff3c1d0a68c52b834d86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f019a5361935df3e0117fd7e33e2b03787c108f5c540c23feebcd02cea3e64fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7b7c411788f55a818a1c2cf8eea745fdff2643abbae945138e848629b6de795a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ee4eb50f1339382c177f648af0add2c3f2a29aa24146e8bb364caf2bed06ea9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c1ab9b8da0357fefae1052a8ff97dc0876fa8ce6ab7c0fba0e939a2ee14a94f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "36f33b244c675e12428d57f9221dfac75fe211c80efed3f5a9450b22bcb50b2d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0fbc59221c897bde1aa195a44d6adb177b70954b21649445d087d12e475c379c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "649b8b00021215527674e058df3fd256a1ec58412bc656a62265e4511911ac27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5fd8af719d76cd017cba0b9e4b06b7e757ab376fec39c05693ef3139f6694097", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3867102b30ec60a6a0aadf2b13bb9f5f011306a51b7350d780a0e103024ac40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2076c09d7a71382739c2d0bf91888306ec65704e3090d92a15ca86dc7e1afa5c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bfb9a0c60f0c6b01b65dda24d57466f2a703f3d9b5fe926faa7942c9f3b49d04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e7f4579a56d595ba76c9e2d54321536ba3a2a8637d5e48a341742a6cf5ccd4cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7b2f9d98c2c922b243b9931c01ad61d02fe12a34a0c498d2cbf92028417391c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1e8dc9addaff9746c6dbee04189f2aaf8564c24fdea0f0951383fad1a8f3882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d26c5dd1942fa19f5b5cc8f927c17097b0dd6bef961f3e88d80808b5285ad759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af1be35802274ab0d1c46603c956f489363548583236a299b03ec9050e81dd53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0dd02a5723dfa38f8775cec3647a943dc81417295fe1267b5c8bb4e3013b1270", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dfae46f975fe415e11e77e15dc2b76de74a945bd4f57dcaebc7e3db06e932252", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9c87c2b2144a6857da73773a6de95b2ceaa34ddb464c003580004d1aebd91c45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "37da9b687aa89e9a1db920b5e9733e0ea6a73a9b325d49abb94df7cdb17855ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b3b11eff5c3f378bc986e31529c558566128d6d3cc38baedce3f63d6e41bba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4430a061e8f802ebfece64b2a74e4c9d2f3356df3d9dcc0b38ab399fbb6547b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d3068a6f407760188f934c7831a8978b1358e8d79b2394532ebcaeee5d610ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "351f358673bd32ee15bfc568a2ad8d5d9225a35341c07dad177691ba3e28c01a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "614ce68b7068d2c91714eaa7f759a4b3bd5e6e28c861046cea488f6ab224f3a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3cbfc85bc6e8eb13a412beda0aee76bba2c364bf2287a291491e5e654e77600b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f515fb9d1d66c68ba439f7ae83c4231dca92a73ff9378e158bf836e4ce68e783", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "16f0b4176b2b7e1ccbb1e6c86409d1ebb26eddc44fd0891948d4791341355f66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "95eb90b9a3cf2998bc492101cdcf5173d33705d2166ab90f5483b333983fc5a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d5462c8c176b17b062f64261b38a484e9890019d65a814e2f7b5f2f6eeee4c10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0d8fb1653d0b2f0ef5349f8d9f23f30e5cb323b2bccdce6197afcab3dd662ddd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1a027e0e27a8b818730dd5c0c5065a4448000e32f30bd648a10fc87897aaa95f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fff16fe61cc4d73d972ab9d12a52f112d8ef13fb7b37cb66c4d3db99108c9493", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ed83201f80607e31227cb59a6ac9d6a47df8e9ae61dd840c8a325bdb94ff2d27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "66cf27b7f00b72f4ac8733b72bc2b8fe0d0da239b0790317c03a84164fd3112b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "636e3d4a735c65070f1ac27eca1e2e12480ad27aab7a3c25335b9ed63a70027a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9da55e79f9c8724cebaf96ff69bac1ea23e84b4b70da1c696c8bbf117c2c2cd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ecf7acb2aaeb61dd2d728d7eeba7fe605ba2b76918015b97644fd133ac3c8171", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35a31bb6430524337048b347b350438565fc201e38153d60a99212f7ac4027e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3d63079e5a08c322c9fac8dc8ac154311ef252925d52c80d8f67d2c001c8ac45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90a1794aecdd5b5deb149dd21d4b77a2c9d5782f39c2bf418f3b40b14b46d4cc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b22802e327df7a43ff9e376c7f4aaf845d7f316c3a725c9c8ebdbde3dd3902ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd800cad574c5df989975871b2b09755df2e325e5190b4ad7869016a743bae02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74d2c4b9afb453a5dc814646c607c15f6e9a36f0257bd74998c3192b4916f8e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b4cc4e5d79e39b64fba94b3157d78eea8b44e69327d73667bc0c1e3dc120086e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9c703237fa600c8c4f635e9ec4b4cb4545da4fa768bb0f3695a8ce355c50eb5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1d991ecd07dfcacb890ac7101f944ca381bb73b073bdf1f6512724c4b16290b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "eb3015b83566d6eb34bf371da10666ed17d98d601f2c1030e68f94869067064c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81c40ad363129c77e53e1af99bd3e812ac9e933eb5d7091eb10c57d00610a08e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "697f34b746d8415d6d2e38e61f0d0737085d3981f5b1bfddc4ddc5df26425f76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "51aa7854bc4f1b5a8a6ee6c1d037b988383b415b8f6553bba5ea8c79415b9d63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "07d57094b6e20e052ff8f8da02c481058984c8781081f42d72947a22f0804c4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2d38d2a77ce433ea11ceb70d117f7c34c16b363eebb0fae4f0b49506b0b2a3b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f933dcafc0210f7dccffedfb36e2e99a18727ec501f37adb9781f765e2da6d8d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eb36aa9be293846bf1880a2f116479504770cbb86189451a3db1607d3245721c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9102e1307b087bcca0da28eefab6e294bded5fe84361e768ca8b95d4a06f3d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "56a6678ed32cdc2e9fa63defa9b0d7a5b7f45f59f1dae4b7c393deb3677ebd29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7afe25456c3f32795fde058ce1c114d8dbc2c92f940b843515fd8ab0d95aff44", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb3265816babfe4a0be59814473a8853d39683f51f110d1621ca1be2ac57ef06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7dda2d9fab9948724dd8b0884cf9370ca4cb3b9b9f9e963dbe3723f08038629a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8719368b9dea0ce143caea9a4cd15711e927acdc6f3df852a91eed7a6ce5142d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8d3e57945ea6a29a083ae6c4f1fcf08995a9971fd6ae5474af00c6b5c7c74c78", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "39db6b3a0247644fa0df7d5327d619e355a2e6891b8c842f86714f58763d1106", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6e5ebf63998007218f0d1705fbff02eafce120b1dc1585e0b26e5444f7fedfda", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c30cd53dda67959c4913124d079582303c9fd021ce258876ebbabb57e2ecae24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "69b7a3ee544111ee27eae2177134496c1fd325da2365cc5046c505e3c972ef04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "752c1ad8534130f53eb85c4ec18b67259cf7780f7dcba63132dd942457f21341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "92eeeb391492f1f28ac9a7cf9f16c7596771249836af0aa1c70e94169cd7909c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e24fab4c8b3ff68ddbdc4d639d5dd88318b7d20cc23482c9fce07f35601859e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1f4debdb9cd6900ad5a4338e2d3129dcd1ff47c4cb3771b83eba24c2b6fbb8de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8dffadf9fbed460de6480bf668f65e65555179943981f21920d69e7432e59957", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36c99dbab51a147932fef004caee8a14b8a465f590ea3b07f2c901d7abe7dedd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b8e2051339dce4c6e0c5c06d3ea596b53132677d6ad49b7f17ffb54f0f2914c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1795161adccbf83cf99216fc8ffc6b5c224cf94f43617593a520799cb7168d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f981283c260f11a57eb352eadc5aac098c61cf4108af99d26d037b53ee505469", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9fcef15e698582bef7087a4c23e4fade00d86f7c0ceb6afada84760e6a4b79e3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30126": { @@ -251818,7 +267908,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30126", "family_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", "job_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "iron_coast_6", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -251834,6 +267924,472 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/candidate.json", "sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "18c9acd13ec59e49f0c08b6bc7f75566ebbae7288f30aea891b348614ff765c0", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.680654+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [{\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011d\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011d\", \"crop\": [0, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 0, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint, surviving gray roof fragments and surface partition remain in place. Stronger rubble, orange flecks and narrow radial cracks are accepted fine interpretation.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2261\", \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011e\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011e\", \"crop\": [314, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 1, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The damaged dark area and source roof-edge remnants remain readable. Pebble-like rubble and radial fine cracks strengthen detail without rebuilding an intact roof.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2262\", \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011f\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011f\", \"crop\": [627, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 2, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The near-square destroyed patch and surviving gray remnants retain their layout. Added thin dark crack lines and warm embers are accepted material detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2263\", \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30120\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30120\", \"crop\": [940, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 3, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source char shape and bordering pale structural patches remain damaged. Stronger grain/highlights are accepted rather than claimed as exact source RGB.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2264\", \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30121\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30121\", \"crop\": [0, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 4, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The central dark destruction, gray edge fragments and native surrounding building geometry remain in place. New metal/rubble detail is accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2265\", \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30122\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30122\", \"crop\": [314, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 5, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight remnant edges and damaged patch remain recognizable. Added thin radial cracks and embers remain fine damage detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2266\", \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30123\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30123\", \"crop\": [627, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 6, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The brighter left structural ribs and top remnant correspond to existing gray source fragments. The central destruction remains open/dark; sharper clean edges, stone-like rubble and orange flecks are interpretation, not an exact untouched SD material claim.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2267\", \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30124\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30124\", \"crop\": [940, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 7, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original opaque destroyed-surface tile retains its dark damaged footprint and surrounding gray fragments. Approved as source-bound gallery artwork only: the actual original registry contains no native mission samples, neighbors or state partners for this ID.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 0, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2268\", \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\", \"unused_gallery_only\": true, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30125\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30125\", \"crop\": [0, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 8, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original irregular damaged footprint and surviving gray vertical remnants are retained. Newly authored fine rubble and cracks are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2269\", \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30126\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30126\", \"crop\": [314, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 9, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source gray structural edge and dark damaged patch remain in their arrangement; brighter fine metal detail does not rebuild the entire intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2270\", \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30127\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30127\", \"crop\": [627, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 10, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source destruction and gray surviving fragments remain readable. Fine embers and grain are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2271\", \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30128\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30128\", \"crop\": [940, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 11, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint and roof-edge remnants remain in place; stronger fine cracks/highlights are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2272\", \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30129\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30129\", \"crop\": [0, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 12, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The gray linear remnants and asymmetric char geometry remain in the source arrangement. Radial fine cracks and orange highlights add damage material rather than an intact object.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2273\", \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012a\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012a\", \"crop\": [314, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 13, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The sharpened top/left metal rim and lower/right upright fragments correspond to existing source gray structures. Brighter steel and embers are accepted; the black damage remains, and no complete repaired roof appears.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2274\", \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012b\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012b\", \"crop\": [627, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 14, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The small central pale source remnant is interpreted as a short grooved metal piece; neighboring pale edges and char layout remain aligned. This is explicit material interpretation, with stronger rubble/embers, rather than exact original subpixel hardware fidelity.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 1, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2275\", \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012c\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012c\", \"crop\": [940, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 15, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight gray remnants around the broad dark damaged area remain readable. Fine stones, cracks and embers are accepted without restoring a complete intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2276\", \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}] [\"Brighter shard4 steel, radial thin cracks, rounded rubble and warm orange flecks are newly authored interpretation rather than exact SD grain/RGB. Source damaged dark areas remain damaged; no complete rebuilt roof was observed.\", \"30123/3012a existing straight gray source fragments gain cleaner metal edges.3012b central pale remnant is interpreted as a small grooved metal piece; this specific material interpretation is accepted and disclosed.\", \"Four held sibling remnants retain an approximate gray/dark area and closer1x palette average but larger native artwork loses visible straight surviving metal fragments. Opaque coverage cannot overrule that art defect.\", \"Mixed HD and ScaleNx-original tiles remain visibly different in texture density/material, including rectangular transitions in joined scenes. The two-logical-pixel edge transition is not claimed to hide every seam. No shifted major panel/roof/pipe boundary was found in the declared cases.\"] [\"All current individual declarations reviewed: up to3 authentic native samples per target, every declared cardinal ID pair and declared state-partner swap. This is not every whole map or every simultaneous destruction arrangement.\", \"Context1\\u20134 outputs were numerically checked and saved; complete fine scene galleries visually inspect native4x with64px original overviews, supplemented by every full source tile and actual1\\u20134 tile view. No claim of visually inspecting every whole context at native1/2/3.\", \"Joined64 is only127 representative context/state probes. Supporting earlier32 candidates are not newly approved here, and held4 remain held despite their inclusion in the diagnostic pack.\", \"Boundary means, full opaque mask overlap and source-class diagnostics establish neither artistic fidelity nor an invisible seam on their own.\", \"Actual static indexed loading/TerrainHd composition is verified. No live gameplay, arbitrary palette-fade cycle, mission1080p performance or unsupported route claim is made.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 755667dfb498724e17a35358d8d01541f51783b061cf26f80684c0d618ad68cb", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/complete-actual-ppm-manifest.json", + "sha256": "d330c159a081d63ce647a4f23ae9f84764b77e6ba3208b018079d321829dc89d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "3011d", + "3011e", + "3011f", + "30120" + ], + "sha256": "600f121057342084138f279aa0658376f00f4b9e4bd9de517f27028fb03b7c89", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30121", + "30122", + "30123", + "30124" + ], + "sha256": "23bad5451e0549b68fb2cf3cca3fc4b0557399bbd9b5190387cb7768a2a66c6f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "30125", + "30126", + "30127", + "30128" + ], + "sha256": "7720739a3e24872e00be5bc44e3e33a73a1e2e214352e6bbc8e7ef8ed7cfc8c4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "30129", + "3012a", + "3012b", + "3012c" + ], + "sha256": "8c976232ef3f87f905078ad64956e45187450c8c815e5847185d62be1b53de57", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "3011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47ddc428ba9c9d9a4ff0a52180f361be8b4c3f6fa958a19921cc11359cd52bd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e0a2dbf264485816ed3267ecd2c9fdeaca82660bdeef65f31c865e7a89bac3b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "402daf19f6f512ab35774f6ed760f5dd6beeb59ddcb98e9ec0cbe2e484963614", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "54b506e3c0aab49652dc095169bf8cf454f8ae0fed8bff3c1d0a68c52b834d86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f019a5361935df3e0117fd7e33e2b03787c108f5c540c23feebcd02cea3e64fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7b7c411788f55a818a1c2cf8eea745fdff2643abbae945138e848629b6de795a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ee4eb50f1339382c177f648af0add2c3f2a29aa24146e8bb364caf2bed06ea9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c1ab9b8da0357fefae1052a8ff97dc0876fa8ce6ab7c0fba0e939a2ee14a94f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "36f33b244c675e12428d57f9221dfac75fe211c80efed3f5a9450b22bcb50b2d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0fbc59221c897bde1aa195a44d6adb177b70954b21649445d087d12e475c379c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "649b8b00021215527674e058df3fd256a1ec58412bc656a62265e4511911ac27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5fd8af719d76cd017cba0b9e4b06b7e757ab376fec39c05693ef3139f6694097", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3867102b30ec60a6a0aadf2b13bb9f5f011306a51b7350d780a0e103024ac40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2076c09d7a71382739c2d0bf91888306ec65704e3090d92a15ca86dc7e1afa5c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bfb9a0c60f0c6b01b65dda24d57466f2a703f3d9b5fe926faa7942c9f3b49d04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e7f4579a56d595ba76c9e2d54321536ba3a2a8637d5e48a341742a6cf5ccd4cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7b2f9d98c2c922b243b9931c01ad61d02fe12a34a0c498d2cbf92028417391c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1e8dc9addaff9746c6dbee04189f2aaf8564c24fdea0f0951383fad1a8f3882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d26c5dd1942fa19f5b5cc8f927c17097b0dd6bef961f3e88d80808b5285ad759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af1be35802274ab0d1c46603c956f489363548583236a299b03ec9050e81dd53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0dd02a5723dfa38f8775cec3647a943dc81417295fe1267b5c8bb4e3013b1270", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dfae46f975fe415e11e77e15dc2b76de74a945bd4f57dcaebc7e3db06e932252", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9c87c2b2144a6857da73773a6de95b2ceaa34ddb464c003580004d1aebd91c45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "37da9b687aa89e9a1db920b5e9733e0ea6a73a9b325d49abb94df7cdb17855ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b3b11eff5c3f378bc986e31529c558566128d6d3cc38baedce3f63d6e41bba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4430a061e8f802ebfece64b2a74e4c9d2f3356df3d9dcc0b38ab399fbb6547b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d3068a6f407760188f934c7831a8978b1358e8d79b2394532ebcaeee5d610ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "351f358673bd32ee15bfc568a2ad8d5d9225a35341c07dad177691ba3e28c01a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "614ce68b7068d2c91714eaa7f759a4b3bd5e6e28c861046cea488f6ab224f3a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3cbfc85bc6e8eb13a412beda0aee76bba2c364bf2287a291491e5e654e77600b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f515fb9d1d66c68ba439f7ae83c4231dca92a73ff9378e158bf836e4ce68e783", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "16f0b4176b2b7e1ccbb1e6c86409d1ebb26eddc44fd0891948d4791341355f66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "95eb90b9a3cf2998bc492101cdcf5173d33705d2166ab90f5483b333983fc5a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d5462c8c176b17b062f64261b38a484e9890019d65a814e2f7b5f2f6eeee4c10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0d8fb1653d0b2f0ef5349f8d9f23f30e5cb323b2bccdce6197afcab3dd662ddd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1a027e0e27a8b818730dd5c0c5065a4448000e32f30bd648a10fc87897aaa95f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fff16fe61cc4d73d972ab9d12a52f112d8ef13fb7b37cb66c4d3db99108c9493", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ed83201f80607e31227cb59a6ac9d6a47df8e9ae61dd840c8a325bdb94ff2d27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "66cf27b7f00b72f4ac8733b72bc2b8fe0d0da239b0790317c03a84164fd3112b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "636e3d4a735c65070f1ac27eca1e2e12480ad27aab7a3c25335b9ed63a70027a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9da55e79f9c8724cebaf96ff69bac1ea23e84b4b70da1c696c8bbf117c2c2cd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ecf7acb2aaeb61dd2d728d7eeba7fe605ba2b76918015b97644fd133ac3c8171", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35a31bb6430524337048b347b350438565fc201e38153d60a99212f7ac4027e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3d63079e5a08c322c9fac8dc8ac154311ef252925d52c80d8f67d2c001c8ac45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90a1794aecdd5b5deb149dd21d4b77a2c9d5782f39c2bf418f3b40b14b46d4cc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b22802e327df7a43ff9e376c7f4aaf845d7f316c3a725c9c8ebdbde3dd3902ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd800cad574c5df989975871b2b09755df2e325e5190b4ad7869016a743bae02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74d2c4b9afb453a5dc814646c607c15f6e9a36f0257bd74998c3192b4916f8e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b4cc4e5d79e39b64fba94b3157d78eea8b44e69327d73667bc0c1e3dc120086e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9c703237fa600c8c4f635e9ec4b4cb4545da4fa768bb0f3695a8ce355c50eb5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1d991ecd07dfcacb890ac7101f944ca381bb73b073bdf1f6512724c4b16290b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "eb3015b83566d6eb34bf371da10666ed17d98d601f2c1030e68f94869067064c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81c40ad363129c77e53e1af99bd3e812ac9e933eb5d7091eb10c57d00610a08e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "697f34b746d8415d6d2e38e61f0d0737085d3981f5b1bfddc4ddc5df26425f76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "51aa7854bc4f1b5a8a6ee6c1d037b988383b415b8f6553bba5ea8c79415b9d63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "07d57094b6e20e052ff8f8da02c481058984c8781081f42d72947a22f0804c4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2d38d2a77ce433ea11ceb70d117f7c34c16b363eebb0fae4f0b49506b0b2a3b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f933dcafc0210f7dccffedfb36e2e99a18727ec501f37adb9781f765e2da6d8d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eb36aa9be293846bf1880a2f116479504770cbb86189451a3db1607d3245721c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9102e1307b087bcca0da28eefab6e294bded5fe84361e768ca8b95d4a06f3d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "56a6678ed32cdc2e9fa63defa9b0d7a5b7f45f59f1dae4b7c393deb3677ebd29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7afe25456c3f32795fde058ce1c114d8dbc2c92f940b843515fd8ab0d95aff44", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb3265816babfe4a0be59814473a8853d39683f51f110d1621ca1be2ac57ef06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7dda2d9fab9948724dd8b0884cf9370ca4cb3b9b9f9e963dbe3723f08038629a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8719368b9dea0ce143caea9a4cd15711e927acdc6f3df852a91eed7a6ce5142d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8d3e57945ea6a29a083ae6c4f1fcf08995a9971fd6ae5474af00c6b5c7c74c78", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "39db6b3a0247644fa0df7d5327d619e355a2e6891b8c842f86714f58763d1106", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6e5ebf63998007218f0d1705fbff02eafce120b1dc1585e0b26e5444f7fedfda", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c30cd53dda67959c4913124d079582303c9fd021ce258876ebbabb57e2ecae24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "69b7a3ee544111ee27eae2177134496c1fd325da2365cc5046c505e3c972ef04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "752c1ad8534130f53eb85c4ec18b67259cf7780f7dcba63132dd942457f21341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "92eeeb391492f1f28ac9a7cf9f16c7596771249836af0aa1c70e94169cd7909c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e24fab4c8b3ff68ddbdc4d639d5dd88318b7d20cc23482c9fce07f35601859e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1f4debdb9cd6900ad5a4338e2d3129dcd1ff47c4cb3771b83eba24c2b6fbb8de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8dffadf9fbed460de6480bf668f65e65555179943981f21920d69e7432e59957", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36c99dbab51a147932fef004caee8a14b8a465f590ea3b07f2c901d7abe7dedd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b8e2051339dce4c6e0c5c06d3ea596b53132677d6ad49b7f17ffb54f0f2914c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1795161adccbf83cf99216fc8ffc6b5c224cf94f43617593a520799cb7168d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f981283c260f11a57eb352eadc5aac098c61cf4108af99d26d037b53ee505469", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9fcef15e698582bef7087a4c23e4fade00d86f7c0ceb6afada84760e6a4b79e3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30127": { @@ -251855,7 +268411,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30127", "family_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", "job_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "iron_coast_6", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -251871,6 +268427,472 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/candidate.json", "sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "18c9acd13ec59e49f0c08b6bc7f75566ebbae7288f30aea891b348614ff765c0", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.680654+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [{\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011d\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011d\", \"crop\": [0, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 0, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint, surviving gray roof fragments and surface partition remain in place. Stronger rubble, orange flecks and narrow radial cracks are accepted fine interpretation.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2261\", \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011e\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011e\", \"crop\": [314, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 1, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The damaged dark area and source roof-edge remnants remain readable. Pebble-like rubble and radial fine cracks strengthen detail without rebuilding an intact roof.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2262\", \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011f\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011f\", \"crop\": [627, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 2, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The near-square destroyed patch and surviving gray remnants retain their layout. Added thin dark crack lines and warm embers are accepted material detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2263\", \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30120\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30120\", \"crop\": [940, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 3, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source char shape and bordering pale structural patches remain damaged. Stronger grain/highlights are accepted rather than claimed as exact source RGB.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2264\", \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30121\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30121\", \"crop\": [0, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 4, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The central dark destruction, gray edge fragments and native surrounding building geometry remain in place. New metal/rubble detail is accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2265\", \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30122\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30122\", \"crop\": [314, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 5, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight remnant edges and damaged patch remain recognizable. Added thin radial cracks and embers remain fine damage detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2266\", \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30123\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30123\", \"crop\": [627, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 6, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The brighter left structural ribs and top remnant correspond to existing gray source fragments. The central destruction remains open/dark; sharper clean edges, stone-like rubble and orange flecks are interpretation, not an exact untouched SD material claim.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2267\", \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30124\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30124\", \"crop\": [940, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 7, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original opaque destroyed-surface tile retains its dark damaged footprint and surrounding gray fragments. Approved as source-bound gallery artwork only: the actual original registry contains no native mission samples, neighbors or state partners for this ID.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 0, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2268\", \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\", \"unused_gallery_only\": true, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30125\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30125\", \"crop\": [0, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 8, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original irregular damaged footprint and surviving gray vertical remnants are retained. Newly authored fine rubble and cracks are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2269\", \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30126\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30126\", \"crop\": [314, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 9, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source gray structural edge and dark damaged patch remain in their arrangement; brighter fine metal detail does not rebuild the entire intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2270\", \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30127\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30127\", \"crop\": [627, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 10, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source destruction and gray surviving fragments remain readable. Fine embers and grain are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2271\", \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30128\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30128\", \"crop\": [940, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 11, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint and roof-edge remnants remain in place; stronger fine cracks/highlights are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2272\", \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30129\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30129\", \"crop\": [0, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 12, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The gray linear remnants and asymmetric char geometry remain in the source arrangement. Radial fine cracks and orange highlights add damage material rather than an intact object.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2273\", \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012a\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012a\", \"crop\": [314, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 13, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The sharpened top/left metal rim and lower/right upright fragments correspond to existing source gray structures. Brighter steel and embers are accepted; the black damage remains, and no complete repaired roof appears.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2274\", \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012b\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012b\", \"crop\": [627, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 14, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The small central pale source remnant is interpreted as a short grooved metal piece; neighboring pale edges and char layout remain aligned. This is explicit material interpretation, with stronger rubble/embers, rather than exact original subpixel hardware fidelity.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 1, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2275\", \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012c\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012c\", \"crop\": [940, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 15, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight gray remnants around the broad dark damaged area remain readable. Fine stones, cracks and embers are accepted without restoring a complete intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2276\", \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}] [\"Brighter shard4 steel, radial thin cracks, rounded rubble and warm orange flecks are newly authored interpretation rather than exact SD grain/RGB. Source damaged dark areas remain damaged; no complete rebuilt roof was observed.\", \"30123/3012a existing straight gray source fragments gain cleaner metal edges.3012b central pale remnant is interpreted as a small grooved metal piece; this specific material interpretation is accepted and disclosed.\", \"Four held sibling remnants retain an approximate gray/dark area and closer1x palette average but larger native artwork loses visible straight surviving metal fragments. Opaque coverage cannot overrule that art defect.\", \"Mixed HD and ScaleNx-original tiles remain visibly different in texture density/material, including rectangular transitions in joined scenes. The two-logical-pixel edge transition is not claimed to hide every seam. No shifted major panel/roof/pipe boundary was found in the declared cases.\"] [\"All current individual declarations reviewed: up to3 authentic native samples per target, every declared cardinal ID pair and declared state-partner swap. This is not every whole map or every simultaneous destruction arrangement.\", \"Context1\\u20134 outputs were numerically checked and saved; complete fine scene galleries visually inspect native4x with64px original overviews, supplemented by every full source tile and actual1\\u20134 tile view. No claim of visually inspecting every whole context at native1/2/3.\", \"Joined64 is only127 representative context/state probes. Supporting earlier32 candidates are not newly approved here, and held4 remain held despite their inclusion in the diagnostic pack.\", \"Boundary means, full opaque mask overlap and source-class diagnostics establish neither artistic fidelity nor an invisible seam on their own.\", \"Actual static indexed loading/TerrainHd composition is verified. No live gameplay, arbitrary palette-fade cycle, mission1080p performance or unsupported route claim is made.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 755667dfb498724e17a35358d8d01541f51783b061cf26f80684c0d618ad68cb", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/complete-actual-ppm-manifest.json", + "sha256": "d330c159a081d63ce647a4f23ae9f84764b77e6ba3208b018079d321829dc89d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "3011d", + "3011e", + "3011f", + "30120" + ], + "sha256": "600f121057342084138f279aa0658376f00f4b9e4bd9de517f27028fb03b7c89", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30121", + "30122", + "30123", + "30124" + ], + "sha256": "23bad5451e0549b68fb2cf3cca3fc4b0557399bbd9b5190387cb7768a2a66c6f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "30125", + "30126", + "30127", + "30128" + ], + "sha256": "7720739a3e24872e00be5bc44e3e33a73a1e2e214352e6bbc8e7ef8ed7cfc8c4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "30129", + "3012a", + "3012b", + "3012c" + ], + "sha256": "8c976232ef3f87f905078ad64956e45187450c8c815e5847185d62be1b53de57", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "3011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47ddc428ba9c9d9a4ff0a52180f361be8b4c3f6fa958a19921cc11359cd52bd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e0a2dbf264485816ed3267ecd2c9fdeaca82660bdeef65f31c865e7a89bac3b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "402daf19f6f512ab35774f6ed760f5dd6beeb59ddcb98e9ec0cbe2e484963614", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "54b506e3c0aab49652dc095169bf8cf454f8ae0fed8bff3c1d0a68c52b834d86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f019a5361935df3e0117fd7e33e2b03787c108f5c540c23feebcd02cea3e64fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7b7c411788f55a818a1c2cf8eea745fdff2643abbae945138e848629b6de795a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ee4eb50f1339382c177f648af0add2c3f2a29aa24146e8bb364caf2bed06ea9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c1ab9b8da0357fefae1052a8ff97dc0876fa8ce6ab7c0fba0e939a2ee14a94f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "36f33b244c675e12428d57f9221dfac75fe211c80efed3f5a9450b22bcb50b2d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0fbc59221c897bde1aa195a44d6adb177b70954b21649445d087d12e475c379c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "649b8b00021215527674e058df3fd256a1ec58412bc656a62265e4511911ac27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5fd8af719d76cd017cba0b9e4b06b7e757ab376fec39c05693ef3139f6694097", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3867102b30ec60a6a0aadf2b13bb9f5f011306a51b7350d780a0e103024ac40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2076c09d7a71382739c2d0bf91888306ec65704e3090d92a15ca86dc7e1afa5c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bfb9a0c60f0c6b01b65dda24d57466f2a703f3d9b5fe926faa7942c9f3b49d04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e7f4579a56d595ba76c9e2d54321536ba3a2a8637d5e48a341742a6cf5ccd4cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7b2f9d98c2c922b243b9931c01ad61d02fe12a34a0c498d2cbf92028417391c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1e8dc9addaff9746c6dbee04189f2aaf8564c24fdea0f0951383fad1a8f3882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d26c5dd1942fa19f5b5cc8f927c17097b0dd6bef961f3e88d80808b5285ad759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af1be35802274ab0d1c46603c956f489363548583236a299b03ec9050e81dd53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0dd02a5723dfa38f8775cec3647a943dc81417295fe1267b5c8bb4e3013b1270", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dfae46f975fe415e11e77e15dc2b76de74a945bd4f57dcaebc7e3db06e932252", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9c87c2b2144a6857da73773a6de95b2ceaa34ddb464c003580004d1aebd91c45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "37da9b687aa89e9a1db920b5e9733e0ea6a73a9b325d49abb94df7cdb17855ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b3b11eff5c3f378bc986e31529c558566128d6d3cc38baedce3f63d6e41bba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4430a061e8f802ebfece64b2a74e4c9d2f3356df3d9dcc0b38ab399fbb6547b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d3068a6f407760188f934c7831a8978b1358e8d79b2394532ebcaeee5d610ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "351f358673bd32ee15bfc568a2ad8d5d9225a35341c07dad177691ba3e28c01a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "614ce68b7068d2c91714eaa7f759a4b3bd5e6e28c861046cea488f6ab224f3a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3cbfc85bc6e8eb13a412beda0aee76bba2c364bf2287a291491e5e654e77600b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f515fb9d1d66c68ba439f7ae83c4231dca92a73ff9378e158bf836e4ce68e783", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "16f0b4176b2b7e1ccbb1e6c86409d1ebb26eddc44fd0891948d4791341355f66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "95eb90b9a3cf2998bc492101cdcf5173d33705d2166ab90f5483b333983fc5a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d5462c8c176b17b062f64261b38a484e9890019d65a814e2f7b5f2f6eeee4c10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0d8fb1653d0b2f0ef5349f8d9f23f30e5cb323b2bccdce6197afcab3dd662ddd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1a027e0e27a8b818730dd5c0c5065a4448000e32f30bd648a10fc87897aaa95f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fff16fe61cc4d73d972ab9d12a52f112d8ef13fb7b37cb66c4d3db99108c9493", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ed83201f80607e31227cb59a6ac9d6a47df8e9ae61dd840c8a325bdb94ff2d27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "66cf27b7f00b72f4ac8733b72bc2b8fe0d0da239b0790317c03a84164fd3112b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "636e3d4a735c65070f1ac27eca1e2e12480ad27aab7a3c25335b9ed63a70027a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9da55e79f9c8724cebaf96ff69bac1ea23e84b4b70da1c696c8bbf117c2c2cd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ecf7acb2aaeb61dd2d728d7eeba7fe605ba2b76918015b97644fd133ac3c8171", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35a31bb6430524337048b347b350438565fc201e38153d60a99212f7ac4027e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3d63079e5a08c322c9fac8dc8ac154311ef252925d52c80d8f67d2c001c8ac45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90a1794aecdd5b5deb149dd21d4b77a2c9d5782f39c2bf418f3b40b14b46d4cc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b22802e327df7a43ff9e376c7f4aaf845d7f316c3a725c9c8ebdbde3dd3902ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd800cad574c5df989975871b2b09755df2e325e5190b4ad7869016a743bae02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74d2c4b9afb453a5dc814646c607c15f6e9a36f0257bd74998c3192b4916f8e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b4cc4e5d79e39b64fba94b3157d78eea8b44e69327d73667bc0c1e3dc120086e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9c703237fa600c8c4f635e9ec4b4cb4545da4fa768bb0f3695a8ce355c50eb5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1d991ecd07dfcacb890ac7101f944ca381bb73b073bdf1f6512724c4b16290b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "eb3015b83566d6eb34bf371da10666ed17d98d601f2c1030e68f94869067064c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81c40ad363129c77e53e1af99bd3e812ac9e933eb5d7091eb10c57d00610a08e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "697f34b746d8415d6d2e38e61f0d0737085d3981f5b1bfddc4ddc5df26425f76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "51aa7854bc4f1b5a8a6ee6c1d037b988383b415b8f6553bba5ea8c79415b9d63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "07d57094b6e20e052ff8f8da02c481058984c8781081f42d72947a22f0804c4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2d38d2a77ce433ea11ceb70d117f7c34c16b363eebb0fae4f0b49506b0b2a3b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f933dcafc0210f7dccffedfb36e2e99a18727ec501f37adb9781f765e2da6d8d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eb36aa9be293846bf1880a2f116479504770cbb86189451a3db1607d3245721c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9102e1307b087bcca0da28eefab6e294bded5fe84361e768ca8b95d4a06f3d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "56a6678ed32cdc2e9fa63defa9b0d7a5b7f45f59f1dae4b7c393deb3677ebd29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7afe25456c3f32795fde058ce1c114d8dbc2c92f940b843515fd8ab0d95aff44", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb3265816babfe4a0be59814473a8853d39683f51f110d1621ca1be2ac57ef06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7dda2d9fab9948724dd8b0884cf9370ca4cb3b9b9f9e963dbe3723f08038629a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8719368b9dea0ce143caea9a4cd15711e927acdc6f3df852a91eed7a6ce5142d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8d3e57945ea6a29a083ae6c4f1fcf08995a9971fd6ae5474af00c6b5c7c74c78", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "39db6b3a0247644fa0df7d5327d619e355a2e6891b8c842f86714f58763d1106", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6e5ebf63998007218f0d1705fbff02eafce120b1dc1585e0b26e5444f7fedfda", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c30cd53dda67959c4913124d079582303c9fd021ce258876ebbabb57e2ecae24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "69b7a3ee544111ee27eae2177134496c1fd325da2365cc5046c505e3c972ef04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "752c1ad8534130f53eb85c4ec18b67259cf7780f7dcba63132dd942457f21341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "92eeeb391492f1f28ac9a7cf9f16c7596771249836af0aa1c70e94169cd7909c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e24fab4c8b3ff68ddbdc4d639d5dd88318b7d20cc23482c9fce07f35601859e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1f4debdb9cd6900ad5a4338e2d3129dcd1ff47c4cb3771b83eba24c2b6fbb8de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8dffadf9fbed460de6480bf668f65e65555179943981f21920d69e7432e59957", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36c99dbab51a147932fef004caee8a14b8a465f590ea3b07f2c901d7abe7dedd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b8e2051339dce4c6e0c5c06d3ea596b53132677d6ad49b7f17ffb54f0f2914c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1795161adccbf83cf99216fc8ffc6b5c224cf94f43617593a520799cb7168d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f981283c260f11a57eb352eadc5aac098c61cf4108af99d26d037b53ee505469", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9fcef15e698582bef7087a4c23e4fade00d86f7c0ceb6afada84760e6a4b79e3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30128": { @@ -251892,7 +268914,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30128", "family_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", "job_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "iron_coast_6", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -251908,6 +268930,472 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/candidate.json", "sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "18c9acd13ec59e49f0c08b6bc7f75566ebbae7288f30aea891b348614ff765c0", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.680654+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [{\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011d\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011d\", \"crop\": [0, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 0, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint, surviving gray roof fragments and surface partition remain in place. Stronger rubble, orange flecks and narrow radial cracks are accepted fine interpretation.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2261\", \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011e\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011e\", \"crop\": [314, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 1, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The damaged dark area and source roof-edge remnants remain readable. Pebble-like rubble and radial fine cracks strengthen detail without rebuilding an intact roof.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2262\", \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011f\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011f\", \"crop\": [627, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 2, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The near-square destroyed patch and surviving gray remnants retain their layout. Added thin dark crack lines and warm embers are accepted material detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2263\", \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30120\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30120\", \"crop\": [940, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 3, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source char shape and bordering pale structural patches remain damaged. Stronger grain/highlights are accepted rather than claimed as exact source RGB.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2264\", \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30121\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30121\", \"crop\": [0, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 4, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The central dark destruction, gray edge fragments and native surrounding building geometry remain in place. New metal/rubble detail is accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2265\", \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30122\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30122\", \"crop\": [314, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 5, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight remnant edges and damaged patch remain recognizable. Added thin radial cracks and embers remain fine damage detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2266\", \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30123\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30123\", \"crop\": [627, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 6, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The brighter left structural ribs and top remnant correspond to existing gray source fragments. The central destruction remains open/dark; sharper clean edges, stone-like rubble and orange flecks are interpretation, not an exact untouched SD material claim.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2267\", \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30124\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30124\", \"crop\": [940, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 7, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original opaque destroyed-surface tile retains its dark damaged footprint and surrounding gray fragments. Approved as source-bound gallery artwork only: the actual original registry contains no native mission samples, neighbors or state partners for this ID.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 0, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2268\", \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\", \"unused_gallery_only\": true, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30125\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30125\", \"crop\": [0, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 8, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original irregular damaged footprint and surviving gray vertical remnants are retained. Newly authored fine rubble and cracks are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2269\", \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30126\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30126\", \"crop\": [314, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 9, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source gray structural edge and dark damaged patch remain in their arrangement; brighter fine metal detail does not rebuild the entire intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2270\", \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30127\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30127\", \"crop\": [627, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 10, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source destruction and gray surviving fragments remain readable. Fine embers and grain are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2271\", \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30128\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30128\", \"crop\": [940, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 11, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint and roof-edge remnants remain in place; stronger fine cracks/highlights are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2272\", \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30129\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30129\", \"crop\": [0, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 12, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The gray linear remnants and asymmetric char geometry remain in the source arrangement. Radial fine cracks and orange highlights add damage material rather than an intact object.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2273\", \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012a\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012a\", \"crop\": [314, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 13, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The sharpened top/left metal rim and lower/right upright fragments correspond to existing source gray structures. Brighter steel and embers are accepted; the black damage remains, and no complete repaired roof appears.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2274\", \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012b\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012b\", \"crop\": [627, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 14, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The small central pale source remnant is interpreted as a short grooved metal piece; neighboring pale edges and char layout remain aligned. This is explicit material interpretation, with stronger rubble/embers, rather than exact original subpixel hardware fidelity.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 1, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2275\", \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012c\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012c\", \"crop\": [940, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 15, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight gray remnants around the broad dark damaged area remain readable. Fine stones, cracks and embers are accepted without restoring a complete intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2276\", \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}] [\"Brighter shard4 steel, radial thin cracks, rounded rubble and warm orange flecks are newly authored interpretation rather than exact SD grain/RGB. Source damaged dark areas remain damaged; no complete rebuilt roof was observed.\", \"30123/3012a existing straight gray source fragments gain cleaner metal edges.3012b central pale remnant is interpreted as a small grooved metal piece; this specific material interpretation is accepted and disclosed.\", \"Four held sibling remnants retain an approximate gray/dark area and closer1x palette average but larger native artwork loses visible straight surviving metal fragments. Opaque coverage cannot overrule that art defect.\", \"Mixed HD and ScaleNx-original tiles remain visibly different in texture density/material, including rectangular transitions in joined scenes. The two-logical-pixel edge transition is not claimed to hide every seam. No shifted major panel/roof/pipe boundary was found in the declared cases.\"] [\"All current individual declarations reviewed: up to3 authentic native samples per target, every declared cardinal ID pair and declared state-partner swap. This is not every whole map or every simultaneous destruction arrangement.\", \"Context1\\u20134 outputs were numerically checked and saved; complete fine scene galleries visually inspect native4x with64px original overviews, supplemented by every full source tile and actual1\\u20134 tile view. No claim of visually inspecting every whole context at native1/2/3.\", \"Joined64 is only127 representative context/state probes. Supporting earlier32 candidates are not newly approved here, and held4 remain held despite their inclusion in the diagnostic pack.\", \"Boundary means, full opaque mask overlap and source-class diagnostics establish neither artistic fidelity nor an invisible seam on their own.\", \"Actual static indexed loading/TerrainHd composition is verified. No live gameplay, arbitrary palette-fade cycle, mission1080p performance or unsupported route claim is made.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 755667dfb498724e17a35358d8d01541f51783b061cf26f80684c0d618ad68cb", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/complete-actual-ppm-manifest.json", + "sha256": "d330c159a081d63ce647a4f23ae9f84764b77e6ba3208b018079d321829dc89d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "3011d", + "3011e", + "3011f", + "30120" + ], + "sha256": "600f121057342084138f279aa0658376f00f4b9e4bd9de517f27028fb03b7c89", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30121", + "30122", + "30123", + "30124" + ], + "sha256": "23bad5451e0549b68fb2cf3cca3fc4b0557399bbd9b5190387cb7768a2a66c6f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "30125", + "30126", + "30127", + "30128" + ], + "sha256": "7720739a3e24872e00be5bc44e3e33a73a1e2e214352e6bbc8e7ef8ed7cfc8c4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "30129", + "3012a", + "3012b", + "3012c" + ], + "sha256": "8c976232ef3f87f905078ad64956e45187450c8c815e5847185d62be1b53de57", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "3011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47ddc428ba9c9d9a4ff0a52180f361be8b4c3f6fa958a19921cc11359cd52bd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e0a2dbf264485816ed3267ecd2c9fdeaca82660bdeef65f31c865e7a89bac3b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "402daf19f6f512ab35774f6ed760f5dd6beeb59ddcb98e9ec0cbe2e484963614", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "54b506e3c0aab49652dc095169bf8cf454f8ae0fed8bff3c1d0a68c52b834d86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f019a5361935df3e0117fd7e33e2b03787c108f5c540c23feebcd02cea3e64fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7b7c411788f55a818a1c2cf8eea745fdff2643abbae945138e848629b6de795a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ee4eb50f1339382c177f648af0add2c3f2a29aa24146e8bb364caf2bed06ea9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c1ab9b8da0357fefae1052a8ff97dc0876fa8ce6ab7c0fba0e939a2ee14a94f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "36f33b244c675e12428d57f9221dfac75fe211c80efed3f5a9450b22bcb50b2d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0fbc59221c897bde1aa195a44d6adb177b70954b21649445d087d12e475c379c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "649b8b00021215527674e058df3fd256a1ec58412bc656a62265e4511911ac27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5fd8af719d76cd017cba0b9e4b06b7e757ab376fec39c05693ef3139f6694097", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3867102b30ec60a6a0aadf2b13bb9f5f011306a51b7350d780a0e103024ac40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2076c09d7a71382739c2d0bf91888306ec65704e3090d92a15ca86dc7e1afa5c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bfb9a0c60f0c6b01b65dda24d57466f2a703f3d9b5fe926faa7942c9f3b49d04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e7f4579a56d595ba76c9e2d54321536ba3a2a8637d5e48a341742a6cf5ccd4cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7b2f9d98c2c922b243b9931c01ad61d02fe12a34a0c498d2cbf92028417391c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1e8dc9addaff9746c6dbee04189f2aaf8564c24fdea0f0951383fad1a8f3882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d26c5dd1942fa19f5b5cc8f927c17097b0dd6bef961f3e88d80808b5285ad759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af1be35802274ab0d1c46603c956f489363548583236a299b03ec9050e81dd53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0dd02a5723dfa38f8775cec3647a943dc81417295fe1267b5c8bb4e3013b1270", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dfae46f975fe415e11e77e15dc2b76de74a945bd4f57dcaebc7e3db06e932252", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9c87c2b2144a6857da73773a6de95b2ceaa34ddb464c003580004d1aebd91c45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "37da9b687aa89e9a1db920b5e9733e0ea6a73a9b325d49abb94df7cdb17855ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b3b11eff5c3f378bc986e31529c558566128d6d3cc38baedce3f63d6e41bba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4430a061e8f802ebfece64b2a74e4c9d2f3356df3d9dcc0b38ab399fbb6547b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d3068a6f407760188f934c7831a8978b1358e8d79b2394532ebcaeee5d610ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "351f358673bd32ee15bfc568a2ad8d5d9225a35341c07dad177691ba3e28c01a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "614ce68b7068d2c91714eaa7f759a4b3bd5e6e28c861046cea488f6ab224f3a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3cbfc85bc6e8eb13a412beda0aee76bba2c364bf2287a291491e5e654e77600b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f515fb9d1d66c68ba439f7ae83c4231dca92a73ff9378e158bf836e4ce68e783", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "16f0b4176b2b7e1ccbb1e6c86409d1ebb26eddc44fd0891948d4791341355f66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "95eb90b9a3cf2998bc492101cdcf5173d33705d2166ab90f5483b333983fc5a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d5462c8c176b17b062f64261b38a484e9890019d65a814e2f7b5f2f6eeee4c10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0d8fb1653d0b2f0ef5349f8d9f23f30e5cb323b2bccdce6197afcab3dd662ddd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1a027e0e27a8b818730dd5c0c5065a4448000e32f30bd648a10fc87897aaa95f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fff16fe61cc4d73d972ab9d12a52f112d8ef13fb7b37cb66c4d3db99108c9493", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ed83201f80607e31227cb59a6ac9d6a47df8e9ae61dd840c8a325bdb94ff2d27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "66cf27b7f00b72f4ac8733b72bc2b8fe0d0da239b0790317c03a84164fd3112b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "636e3d4a735c65070f1ac27eca1e2e12480ad27aab7a3c25335b9ed63a70027a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9da55e79f9c8724cebaf96ff69bac1ea23e84b4b70da1c696c8bbf117c2c2cd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ecf7acb2aaeb61dd2d728d7eeba7fe605ba2b76918015b97644fd133ac3c8171", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35a31bb6430524337048b347b350438565fc201e38153d60a99212f7ac4027e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3d63079e5a08c322c9fac8dc8ac154311ef252925d52c80d8f67d2c001c8ac45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90a1794aecdd5b5deb149dd21d4b77a2c9d5782f39c2bf418f3b40b14b46d4cc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b22802e327df7a43ff9e376c7f4aaf845d7f316c3a725c9c8ebdbde3dd3902ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd800cad574c5df989975871b2b09755df2e325e5190b4ad7869016a743bae02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74d2c4b9afb453a5dc814646c607c15f6e9a36f0257bd74998c3192b4916f8e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b4cc4e5d79e39b64fba94b3157d78eea8b44e69327d73667bc0c1e3dc120086e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9c703237fa600c8c4f635e9ec4b4cb4545da4fa768bb0f3695a8ce355c50eb5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1d991ecd07dfcacb890ac7101f944ca381bb73b073bdf1f6512724c4b16290b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "eb3015b83566d6eb34bf371da10666ed17d98d601f2c1030e68f94869067064c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81c40ad363129c77e53e1af99bd3e812ac9e933eb5d7091eb10c57d00610a08e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "697f34b746d8415d6d2e38e61f0d0737085d3981f5b1bfddc4ddc5df26425f76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "51aa7854bc4f1b5a8a6ee6c1d037b988383b415b8f6553bba5ea8c79415b9d63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "07d57094b6e20e052ff8f8da02c481058984c8781081f42d72947a22f0804c4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2d38d2a77ce433ea11ceb70d117f7c34c16b363eebb0fae4f0b49506b0b2a3b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f933dcafc0210f7dccffedfb36e2e99a18727ec501f37adb9781f765e2da6d8d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eb36aa9be293846bf1880a2f116479504770cbb86189451a3db1607d3245721c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9102e1307b087bcca0da28eefab6e294bded5fe84361e768ca8b95d4a06f3d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "56a6678ed32cdc2e9fa63defa9b0d7a5b7f45f59f1dae4b7c393deb3677ebd29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7afe25456c3f32795fde058ce1c114d8dbc2c92f940b843515fd8ab0d95aff44", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb3265816babfe4a0be59814473a8853d39683f51f110d1621ca1be2ac57ef06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7dda2d9fab9948724dd8b0884cf9370ca4cb3b9b9f9e963dbe3723f08038629a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8719368b9dea0ce143caea9a4cd15711e927acdc6f3df852a91eed7a6ce5142d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8d3e57945ea6a29a083ae6c4f1fcf08995a9971fd6ae5474af00c6b5c7c74c78", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "39db6b3a0247644fa0df7d5327d619e355a2e6891b8c842f86714f58763d1106", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6e5ebf63998007218f0d1705fbff02eafce120b1dc1585e0b26e5444f7fedfda", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c30cd53dda67959c4913124d079582303c9fd021ce258876ebbabb57e2ecae24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "69b7a3ee544111ee27eae2177134496c1fd325da2365cc5046c505e3c972ef04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "752c1ad8534130f53eb85c4ec18b67259cf7780f7dcba63132dd942457f21341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "92eeeb391492f1f28ac9a7cf9f16c7596771249836af0aa1c70e94169cd7909c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e24fab4c8b3ff68ddbdc4d639d5dd88318b7d20cc23482c9fce07f35601859e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1f4debdb9cd6900ad5a4338e2d3129dcd1ff47c4cb3771b83eba24c2b6fbb8de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8dffadf9fbed460de6480bf668f65e65555179943981f21920d69e7432e59957", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36c99dbab51a147932fef004caee8a14b8a465f590ea3b07f2c901d7abe7dedd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b8e2051339dce4c6e0c5c06d3ea596b53132677d6ad49b7f17ffb54f0f2914c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1795161adccbf83cf99216fc8ffc6b5c224cf94f43617593a520799cb7168d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f981283c260f11a57eb352eadc5aac098c61cf4108af99d26d037b53ee505469", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9fcef15e698582bef7087a4c23e4fade00d86f7c0ceb6afada84760e6a4b79e3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "30129": { @@ -251929,7 +269417,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "30129", "family_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", "job_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "iron_coast_6", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -251945,6 +269433,472 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/candidate.json", "sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "18c9acd13ec59e49f0c08b6bc7f75566ebbae7288f30aea891b348614ff765c0", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.680654+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [{\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011d\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011d\", \"crop\": [0, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 0, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint, surviving gray roof fragments and surface partition remain in place. Stronger rubble, orange flecks and narrow radial cracks are accepted fine interpretation.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2261\", \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011e\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011e\", \"crop\": [314, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 1, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The damaged dark area and source roof-edge remnants remain readable. Pebble-like rubble and radial fine cracks strengthen detail without rebuilding an intact roof.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2262\", \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011f\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011f\", \"crop\": [627, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 2, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The near-square destroyed patch and surviving gray remnants retain their layout. Added thin dark crack lines and warm embers are accepted material detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2263\", \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30120\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30120\", \"crop\": [940, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 3, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source char shape and bordering pale structural patches remain damaged. Stronger grain/highlights are accepted rather than claimed as exact source RGB.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2264\", \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30121\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30121\", \"crop\": [0, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 4, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The central dark destruction, gray edge fragments and native surrounding building geometry remain in place. New metal/rubble detail is accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2265\", \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30122\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30122\", \"crop\": [314, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 5, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight remnant edges and damaged patch remain recognizable. Added thin radial cracks and embers remain fine damage detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2266\", \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30123\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30123\", \"crop\": [627, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 6, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The brighter left structural ribs and top remnant correspond to existing gray source fragments. The central destruction remains open/dark; sharper clean edges, stone-like rubble and orange flecks are interpretation, not an exact untouched SD material claim.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2267\", \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30124\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30124\", \"crop\": [940, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 7, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original opaque destroyed-surface tile retains its dark damaged footprint and surrounding gray fragments. Approved as source-bound gallery artwork only: the actual original registry contains no native mission samples, neighbors or state partners for this ID.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 0, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2268\", \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\", \"unused_gallery_only\": true, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30125\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30125\", \"crop\": [0, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 8, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original irregular damaged footprint and surviving gray vertical remnants are retained. Newly authored fine rubble and cracks are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2269\", \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30126\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30126\", \"crop\": [314, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 9, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source gray structural edge and dark damaged patch remain in their arrangement; brighter fine metal detail does not rebuild the entire intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2270\", \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30127\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30127\", \"crop\": [627, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 10, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source destruction and gray surviving fragments remain readable. Fine embers and grain are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2271\", \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30128\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30128\", \"crop\": [940, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 11, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint and roof-edge remnants remain in place; stronger fine cracks/highlights are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2272\", \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30129\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30129\", \"crop\": [0, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 12, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The gray linear remnants and asymmetric char geometry remain in the source arrangement. Radial fine cracks and orange highlights add damage material rather than an intact object.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2273\", \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012a\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012a\", \"crop\": [314, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 13, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The sharpened top/left metal rim and lower/right upright fragments correspond to existing source gray structures. Brighter steel and embers are accepted; the black damage remains, and no complete repaired roof appears.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2274\", \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012b\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012b\", \"crop\": [627, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 14, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The small central pale source remnant is interpreted as a short grooved metal piece; neighboring pale edges and char layout remain aligned. This is explicit material interpretation, with stronger rubble/embers, rather than exact original subpixel hardware fidelity.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 1, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2275\", \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012c\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012c\", \"crop\": [940, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 15, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight gray remnants around the broad dark damaged area remain readable. Fine stones, cracks and embers are accepted without restoring a complete intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2276\", \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}] [\"Brighter shard4 steel, radial thin cracks, rounded rubble and warm orange flecks are newly authored interpretation rather than exact SD grain/RGB. Source damaged dark areas remain damaged; no complete rebuilt roof was observed.\", \"30123/3012a existing straight gray source fragments gain cleaner metal edges.3012b central pale remnant is interpreted as a small grooved metal piece; this specific material interpretation is accepted and disclosed.\", \"Four held sibling remnants retain an approximate gray/dark area and closer1x palette average but larger native artwork loses visible straight surviving metal fragments. Opaque coverage cannot overrule that art defect.\", \"Mixed HD and ScaleNx-original tiles remain visibly different in texture density/material, including rectangular transitions in joined scenes. The two-logical-pixel edge transition is not claimed to hide every seam. No shifted major panel/roof/pipe boundary was found in the declared cases.\"] [\"All current individual declarations reviewed: up to3 authentic native samples per target, every declared cardinal ID pair and declared state-partner swap. This is not every whole map or every simultaneous destruction arrangement.\", \"Context1\\u20134 outputs were numerically checked and saved; complete fine scene galleries visually inspect native4x with64px original overviews, supplemented by every full source tile and actual1\\u20134 tile view. No claim of visually inspecting every whole context at native1/2/3.\", \"Joined64 is only127 representative context/state probes. Supporting earlier32 candidates are not newly approved here, and held4 remain held despite their inclusion in the diagnostic pack.\", \"Boundary means, full opaque mask overlap and source-class diagnostics establish neither artistic fidelity nor an invisible seam on their own.\", \"Actual static indexed loading/TerrainHd composition is verified. No live gameplay, arbitrary palette-fade cycle, mission1080p performance or unsupported route claim is made.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 755667dfb498724e17a35358d8d01541f51783b061cf26f80684c0d618ad68cb", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/complete-actual-ppm-manifest.json", + "sha256": "d330c159a081d63ce647a4f23ae9f84764b77e6ba3208b018079d321829dc89d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "3011d", + "3011e", + "3011f", + "30120" + ], + "sha256": "600f121057342084138f279aa0658376f00f4b9e4bd9de517f27028fb03b7c89", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30121", + "30122", + "30123", + "30124" + ], + "sha256": "23bad5451e0549b68fb2cf3cca3fc4b0557399bbd9b5190387cb7768a2a66c6f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "30125", + "30126", + "30127", + "30128" + ], + "sha256": "7720739a3e24872e00be5bc44e3e33a73a1e2e214352e6bbc8e7ef8ed7cfc8c4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "30129", + "3012a", + "3012b", + "3012c" + ], + "sha256": "8c976232ef3f87f905078ad64956e45187450c8c815e5847185d62be1b53de57", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "3011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47ddc428ba9c9d9a4ff0a52180f361be8b4c3f6fa958a19921cc11359cd52bd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e0a2dbf264485816ed3267ecd2c9fdeaca82660bdeef65f31c865e7a89bac3b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "402daf19f6f512ab35774f6ed760f5dd6beeb59ddcb98e9ec0cbe2e484963614", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "54b506e3c0aab49652dc095169bf8cf454f8ae0fed8bff3c1d0a68c52b834d86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f019a5361935df3e0117fd7e33e2b03787c108f5c540c23feebcd02cea3e64fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7b7c411788f55a818a1c2cf8eea745fdff2643abbae945138e848629b6de795a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ee4eb50f1339382c177f648af0add2c3f2a29aa24146e8bb364caf2bed06ea9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c1ab9b8da0357fefae1052a8ff97dc0876fa8ce6ab7c0fba0e939a2ee14a94f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "36f33b244c675e12428d57f9221dfac75fe211c80efed3f5a9450b22bcb50b2d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0fbc59221c897bde1aa195a44d6adb177b70954b21649445d087d12e475c379c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "649b8b00021215527674e058df3fd256a1ec58412bc656a62265e4511911ac27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5fd8af719d76cd017cba0b9e4b06b7e757ab376fec39c05693ef3139f6694097", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3867102b30ec60a6a0aadf2b13bb9f5f011306a51b7350d780a0e103024ac40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2076c09d7a71382739c2d0bf91888306ec65704e3090d92a15ca86dc7e1afa5c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bfb9a0c60f0c6b01b65dda24d57466f2a703f3d9b5fe926faa7942c9f3b49d04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e7f4579a56d595ba76c9e2d54321536ba3a2a8637d5e48a341742a6cf5ccd4cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7b2f9d98c2c922b243b9931c01ad61d02fe12a34a0c498d2cbf92028417391c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1e8dc9addaff9746c6dbee04189f2aaf8564c24fdea0f0951383fad1a8f3882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d26c5dd1942fa19f5b5cc8f927c17097b0dd6bef961f3e88d80808b5285ad759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af1be35802274ab0d1c46603c956f489363548583236a299b03ec9050e81dd53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0dd02a5723dfa38f8775cec3647a943dc81417295fe1267b5c8bb4e3013b1270", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dfae46f975fe415e11e77e15dc2b76de74a945bd4f57dcaebc7e3db06e932252", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9c87c2b2144a6857da73773a6de95b2ceaa34ddb464c003580004d1aebd91c45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "37da9b687aa89e9a1db920b5e9733e0ea6a73a9b325d49abb94df7cdb17855ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b3b11eff5c3f378bc986e31529c558566128d6d3cc38baedce3f63d6e41bba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4430a061e8f802ebfece64b2a74e4c9d2f3356df3d9dcc0b38ab399fbb6547b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d3068a6f407760188f934c7831a8978b1358e8d79b2394532ebcaeee5d610ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "351f358673bd32ee15bfc568a2ad8d5d9225a35341c07dad177691ba3e28c01a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "614ce68b7068d2c91714eaa7f759a4b3bd5e6e28c861046cea488f6ab224f3a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3cbfc85bc6e8eb13a412beda0aee76bba2c364bf2287a291491e5e654e77600b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f515fb9d1d66c68ba439f7ae83c4231dca92a73ff9378e158bf836e4ce68e783", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "16f0b4176b2b7e1ccbb1e6c86409d1ebb26eddc44fd0891948d4791341355f66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "95eb90b9a3cf2998bc492101cdcf5173d33705d2166ab90f5483b333983fc5a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d5462c8c176b17b062f64261b38a484e9890019d65a814e2f7b5f2f6eeee4c10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0d8fb1653d0b2f0ef5349f8d9f23f30e5cb323b2bccdce6197afcab3dd662ddd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1a027e0e27a8b818730dd5c0c5065a4448000e32f30bd648a10fc87897aaa95f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fff16fe61cc4d73d972ab9d12a52f112d8ef13fb7b37cb66c4d3db99108c9493", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ed83201f80607e31227cb59a6ac9d6a47df8e9ae61dd840c8a325bdb94ff2d27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "66cf27b7f00b72f4ac8733b72bc2b8fe0d0da239b0790317c03a84164fd3112b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "636e3d4a735c65070f1ac27eca1e2e12480ad27aab7a3c25335b9ed63a70027a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9da55e79f9c8724cebaf96ff69bac1ea23e84b4b70da1c696c8bbf117c2c2cd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ecf7acb2aaeb61dd2d728d7eeba7fe605ba2b76918015b97644fd133ac3c8171", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35a31bb6430524337048b347b350438565fc201e38153d60a99212f7ac4027e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3d63079e5a08c322c9fac8dc8ac154311ef252925d52c80d8f67d2c001c8ac45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90a1794aecdd5b5deb149dd21d4b77a2c9d5782f39c2bf418f3b40b14b46d4cc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b22802e327df7a43ff9e376c7f4aaf845d7f316c3a725c9c8ebdbde3dd3902ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd800cad574c5df989975871b2b09755df2e325e5190b4ad7869016a743bae02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74d2c4b9afb453a5dc814646c607c15f6e9a36f0257bd74998c3192b4916f8e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b4cc4e5d79e39b64fba94b3157d78eea8b44e69327d73667bc0c1e3dc120086e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9c703237fa600c8c4f635e9ec4b4cb4545da4fa768bb0f3695a8ce355c50eb5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1d991ecd07dfcacb890ac7101f944ca381bb73b073bdf1f6512724c4b16290b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "eb3015b83566d6eb34bf371da10666ed17d98d601f2c1030e68f94869067064c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81c40ad363129c77e53e1af99bd3e812ac9e933eb5d7091eb10c57d00610a08e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "697f34b746d8415d6d2e38e61f0d0737085d3981f5b1bfddc4ddc5df26425f76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "51aa7854bc4f1b5a8a6ee6c1d037b988383b415b8f6553bba5ea8c79415b9d63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "07d57094b6e20e052ff8f8da02c481058984c8781081f42d72947a22f0804c4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2d38d2a77ce433ea11ceb70d117f7c34c16b363eebb0fae4f0b49506b0b2a3b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f933dcafc0210f7dccffedfb36e2e99a18727ec501f37adb9781f765e2da6d8d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eb36aa9be293846bf1880a2f116479504770cbb86189451a3db1607d3245721c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9102e1307b087bcca0da28eefab6e294bded5fe84361e768ca8b95d4a06f3d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "56a6678ed32cdc2e9fa63defa9b0d7a5b7f45f59f1dae4b7c393deb3677ebd29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7afe25456c3f32795fde058ce1c114d8dbc2c92f940b843515fd8ab0d95aff44", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb3265816babfe4a0be59814473a8853d39683f51f110d1621ca1be2ac57ef06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7dda2d9fab9948724dd8b0884cf9370ca4cb3b9b9f9e963dbe3723f08038629a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8719368b9dea0ce143caea9a4cd15711e927acdc6f3df852a91eed7a6ce5142d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8d3e57945ea6a29a083ae6c4f1fcf08995a9971fd6ae5474af00c6b5c7c74c78", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "39db6b3a0247644fa0df7d5327d619e355a2e6891b8c842f86714f58763d1106", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6e5ebf63998007218f0d1705fbff02eafce120b1dc1585e0b26e5444f7fedfda", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c30cd53dda67959c4913124d079582303c9fd021ce258876ebbabb57e2ecae24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "69b7a3ee544111ee27eae2177134496c1fd325da2365cc5046c505e3c972ef04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "752c1ad8534130f53eb85c4ec18b67259cf7780f7dcba63132dd942457f21341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "92eeeb391492f1f28ac9a7cf9f16c7596771249836af0aa1c70e94169cd7909c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e24fab4c8b3ff68ddbdc4d639d5dd88318b7d20cc23482c9fce07f35601859e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1f4debdb9cd6900ad5a4338e2d3129dcd1ff47c4cb3771b83eba24c2b6fbb8de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8dffadf9fbed460de6480bf668f65e65555179943981f21920d69e7432e59957", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36c99dbab51a147932fef004caee8a14b8a465f590ea3b07f2c901d7abe7dedd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b8e2051339dce4c6e0c5c06d3ea596b53132677d6ad49b7f17ffb54f0f2914c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1795161adccbf83cf99216fc8ffc6b5c224cf94f43617593a520799cb7168d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f981283c260f11a57eb352eadc5aac098c61cf4108af99d26d037b53ee505469", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9fcef15e698582bef7087a4c23e4fade00d86f7c0ceb6afada84760e6a4b79e3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "3012a": { @@ -251966,7 +269920,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "3012a", "family_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", "job_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "iron_coast_6", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -251982,6 +269936,472 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/candidate.json", "sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "18c9acd13ec59e49f0c08b6bc7f75566ebbae7288f30aea891b348614ff765c0", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.680654+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [{\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011d\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011d\", \"crop\": [0, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 0, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint, surviving gray roof fragments and surface partition remain in place. Stronger rubble, orange flecks and narrow radial cracks are accepted fine interpretation.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2261\", \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011e\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011e\", \"crop\": [314, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 1, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The damaged dark area and source roof-edge remnants remain readable. Pebble-like rubble and radial fine cracks strengthen detail without rebuilding an intact roof.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2262\", \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011f\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011f\", \"crop\": [627, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 2, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The near-square destroyed patch and surviving gray remnants retain their layout. Added thin dark crack lines and warm embers are accepted material detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2263\", \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30120\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30120\", \"crop\": [940, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 3, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source char shape and bordering pale structural patches remain damaged. Stronger grain/highlights are accepted rather than claimed as exact source RGB.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2264\", \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30121\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30121\", \"crop\": [0, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 4, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The central dark destruction, gray edge fragments and native surrounding building geometry remain in place. New metal/rubble detail is accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2265\", \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30122\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30122\", \"crop\": [314, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 5, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight remnant edges and damaged patch remain recognizable. Added thin radial cracks and embers remain fine damage detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2266\", \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30123\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30123\", \"crop\": [627, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 6, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The brighter left structural ribs and top remnant correspond to existing gray source fragments. The central destruction remains open/dark; sharper clean edges, stone-like rubble and orange flecks are interpretation, not an exact untouched SD material claim.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2267\", \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30124\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30124\", \"crop\": [940, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 7, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original opaque destroyed-surface tile retains its dark damaged footprint and surrounding gray fragments. Approved as source-bound gallery artwork only: the actual original registry contains no native mission samples, neighbors or state partners for this ID.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 0, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2268\", \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\", \"unused_gallery_only\": true, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30125\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30125\", \"crop\": [0, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 8, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original irregular damaged footprint and surviving gray vertical remnants are retained. Newly authored fine rubble and cracks are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2269\", \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30126\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30126\", \"crop\": [314, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 9, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source gray structural edge and dark damaged patch remain in their arrangement; brighter fine metal detail does not rebuild the entire intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2270\", \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30127\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30127\", \"crop\": [627, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 10, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source destruction and gray surviving fragments remain readable. Fine embers and grain are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2271\", \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30128\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30128\", \"crop\": [940, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 11, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint and roof-edge remnants remain in place; stronger fine cracks/highlights are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2272\", \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30129\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30129\", \"crop\": [0, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 12, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The gray linear remnants and asymmetric char geometry remain in the source arrangement. Radial fine cracks and orange highlights add damage material rather than an intact object.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2273\", \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012a\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012a\", \"crop\": [314, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 13, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The sharpened top/left metal rim and lower/right upright fragments correspond to existing source gray structures. Brighter steel and embers are accepted; the black damage remains, and no complete repaired roof appears.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2274\", \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012b\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012b\", \"crop\": [627, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 14, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The small central pale source remnant is interpreted as a short grooved metal piece; neighboring pale edges and char layout remain aligned. This is explicit material interpretation, with stronger rubble/embers, rather than exact original subpixel hardware fidelity.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 1, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2275\", \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012c\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012c\", \"crop\": [940, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 15, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight gray remnants around the broad dark damaged area remain readable. Fine stones, cracks and embers are accepted without restoring a complete intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2276\", \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}] [\"Brighter shard4 steel, radial thin cracks, rounded rubble and warm orange flecks are newly authored interpretation rather than exact SD grain/RGB. Source damaged dark areas remain damaged; no complete rebuilt roof was observed.\", \"30123/3012a existing straight gray source fragments gain cleaner metal edges.3012b central pale remnant is interpreted as a small grooved metal piece; this specific material interpretation is accepted and disclosed.\", \"Four held sibling remnants retain an approximate gray/dark area and closer1x palette average but larger native artwork loses visible straight surviving metal fragments. Opaque coverage cannot overrule that art defect.\", \"Mixed HD and ScaleNx-original tiles remain visibly different in texture density/material, including rectangular transitions in joined scenes. The two-logical-pixel edge transition is not claimed to hide every seam. No shifted major panel/roof/pipe boundary was found in the declared cases.\"] [\"All current individual declarations reviewed: up to3 authentic native samples per target, every declared cardinal ID pair and declared state-partner swap. This is not every whole map or every simultaneous destruction arrangement.\", \"Context1\\u20134 outputs were numerically checked and saved; complete fine scene galleries visually inspect native4x with64px original overviews, supplemented by every full source tile and actual1\\u20134 tile view. No claim of visually inspecting every whole context at native1/2/3.\", \"Joined64 is only127 representative context/state probes. Supporting earlier32 candidates are not newly approved here, and held4 remain held despite their inclusion in the diagnostic pack.\", \"Boundary means, full opaque mask overlap and source-class diagnostics establish neither artistic fidelity nor an invisible seam on their own.\", \"Actual static indexed loading/TerrainHd composition is verified. No live gameplay, arbitrary palette-fade cycle, mission1080p performance or unsupported route claim is made.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 755667dfb498724e17a35358d8d01541f51783b061cf26f80684c0d618ad68cb", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/complete-actual-ppm-manifest.json", + "sha256": "d330c159a081d63ce647a4f23ae9f84764b77e6ba3208b018079d321829dc89d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "3011d", + "3011e", + "3011f", + "30120" + ], + "sha256": "600f121057342084138f279aa0658376f00f4b9e4bd9de517f27028fb03b7c89", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30121", + "30122", + "30123", + "30124" + ], + "sha256": "23bad5451e0549b68fb2cf3cca3fc4b0557399bbd9b5190387cb7768a2a66c6f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "30125", + "30126", + "30127", + "30128" + ], + "sha256": "7720739a3e24872e00be5bc44e3e33a73a1e2e214352e6bbc8e7ef8ed7cfc8c4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "30129", + "3012a", + "3012b", + "3012c" + ], + "sha256": "8c976232ef3f87f905078ad64956e45187450c8c815e5847185d62be1b53de57", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "3011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47ddc428ba9c9d9a4ff0a52180f361be8b4c3f6fa958a19921cc11359cd52bd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e0a2dbf264485816ed3267ecd2c9fdeaca82660bdeef65f31c865e7a89bac3b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "402daf19f6f512ab35774f6ed760f5dd6beeb59ddcb98e9ec0cbe2e484963614", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "54b506e3c0aab49652dc095169bf8cf454f8ae0fed8bff3c1d0a68c52b834d86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f019a5361935df3e0117fd7e33e2b03787c108f5c540c23feebcd02cea3e64fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7b7c411788f55a818a1c2cf8eea745fdff2643abbae945138e848629b6de795a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ee4eb50f1339382c177f648af0add2c3f2a29aa24146e8bb364caf2bed06ea9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c1ab9b8da0357fefae1052a8ff97dc0876fa8ce6ab7c0fba0e939a2ee14a94f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "36f33b244c675e12428d57f9221dfac75fe211c80efed3f5a9450b22bcb50b2d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0fbc59221c897bde1aa195a44d6adb177b70954b21649445d087d12e475c379c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "649b8b00021215527674e058df3fd256a1ec58412bc656a62265e4511911ac27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5fd8af719d76cd017cba0b9e4b06b7e757ab376fec39c05693ef3139f6694097", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3867102b30ec60a6a0aadf2b13bb9f5f011306a51b7350d780a0e103024ac40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2076c09d7a71382739c2d0bf91888306ec65704e3090d92a15ca86dc7e1afa5c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bfb9a0c60f0c6b01b65dda24d57466f2a703f3d9b5fe926faa7942c9f3b49d04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e7f4579a56d595ba76c9e2d54321536ba3a2a8637d5e48a341742a6cf5ccd4cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7b2f9d98c2c922b243b9931c01ad61d02fe12a34a0c498d2cbf92028417391c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1e8dc9addaff9746c6dbee04189f2aaf8564c24fdea0f0951383fad1a8f3882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d26c5dd1942fa19f5b5cc8f927c17097b0dd6bef961f3e88d80808b5285ad759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af1be35802274ab0d1c46603c956f489363548583236a299b03ec9050e81dd53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0dd02a5723dfa38f8775cec3647a943dc81417295fe1267b5c8bb4e3013b1270", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dfae46f975fe415e11e77e15dc2b76de74a945bd4f57dcaebc7e3db06e932252", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9c87c2b2144a6857da73773a6de95b2ceaa34ddb464c003580004d1aebd91c45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "37da9b687aa89e9a1db920b5e9733e0ea6a73a9b325d49abb94df7cdb17855ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b3b11eff5c3f378bc986e31529c558566128d6d3cc38baedce3f63d6e41bba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4430a061e8f802ebfece64b2a74e4c9d2f3356df3d9dcc0b38ab399fbb6547b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d3068a6f407760188f934c7831a8978b1358e8d79b2394532ebcaeee5d610ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "351f358673bd32ee15bfc568a2ad8d5d9225a35341c07dad177691ba3e28c01a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "614ce68b7068d2c91714eaa7f759a4b3bd5e6e28c861046cea488f6ab224f3a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3cbfc85bc6e8eb13a412beda0aee76bba2c364bf2287a291491e5e654e77600b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f515fb9d1d66c68ba439f7ae83c4231dca92a73ff9378e158bf836e4ce68e783", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "16f0b4176b2b7e1ccbb1e6c86409d1ebb26eddc44fd0891948d4791341355f66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "95eb90b9a3cf2998bc492101cdcf5173d33705d2166ab90f5483b333983fc5a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d5462c8c176b17b062f64261b38a484e9890019d65a814e2f7b5f2f6eeee4c10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0d8fb1653d0b2f0ef5349f8d9f23f30e5cb323b2bccdce6197afcab3dd662ddd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1a027e0e27a8b818730dd5c0c5065a4448000e32f30bd648a10fc87897aaa95f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fff16fe61cc4d73d972ab9d12a52f112d8ef13fb7b37cb66c4d3db99108c9493", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ed83201f80607e31227cb59a6ac9d6a47df8e9ae61dd840c8a325bdb94ff2d27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "66cf27b7f00b72f4ac8733b72bc2b8fe0d0da239b0790317c03a84164fd3112b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "636e3d4a735c65070f1ac27eca1e2e12480ad27aab7a3c25335b9ed63a70027a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9da55e79f9c8724cebaf96ff69bac1ea23e84b4b70da1c696c8bbf117c2c2cd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ecf7acb2aaeb61dd2d728d7eeba7fe605ba2b76918015b97644fd133ac3c8171", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35a31bb6430524337048b347b350438565fc201e38153d60a99212f7ac4027e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3d63079e5a08c322c9fac8dc8ac154311ef252925d52c80d8f67d2c001c8ac45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90a1794aecdd5b5deb149dd21d4b77a2c9d5782f39c2bf418f3b40b14b46d4cc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b22802e327df7a43ff9e376c7f4aaf845d7f316c3a725c9c8ebdbde3dd3902ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd800cad574c5df989975871b2b09755df2e325e5190b4ad7869016a743bae02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74d2c4b9afb453a5dc814646c607c15f6e9a36f0257bd74998c3192b4916f8e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b4cc4e5d79e39b64fba94b3157d78eea8b44e69327d73667bc0c1e3dc120086e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9c703237fa600c8c4f635e9ec4b4cb4545da4fa768bb0f3695a8ce355c50eb5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1d991ecd07dfcacb890ac7101f944ca381bb73b073bdf1f6512724c4b16290b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "eb3015b83566d6eb34bf371da10666ed17d98d601f2c1030e68f94869067064c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81c40ad363129c77e53e1af99bd3e812ac9e933eb5d7091eb10c57d00610a08e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "697f34b746d8415d6d2e38e61f0d0737085d3981f5b1bfddc4ddc5df26425f76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "51aa7854bc4f1b5a8a6ee6c1d037b988383b415b8f6553bba5ea8c79415b9d63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "07d57094b6e20e052ff8f8da02c481058984c8781081f42d72947a22f0804c4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2d38d2a77ce433ea11ceb70d117f7c34c16b363eebb0fae4f0b49506b0b2a3b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f933dcafc0210f7dccffedfb36e2e99a18727ec501f37adb9781f765e2da6d8d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eb36aa9be293846bf1880a2f116479504770cbb86189451a3db1607d3245721c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9102e1307b087bcca0da28eefab6e294bded5fe84361e768ca8b95d4a06f3d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "56a6678ed32cdc2e9fa63defa9b0d7a5b7f45f59f1dae4b7c393deb3677ebd29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7afe25456c3f32795fde058ce1c114d8dbc2c92f940b843515fd8ab0d95aff44", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb3265816babfe4a0be59814473a8853d39683f51f110d1621ca1be2ac57ef06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7dda2d9fab9948724dd8b0884cf9370ca4cb3b9b9f9e963dbe3723f08038629a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8719368b9dea0ce143caea9a4cd15711e927acdc6f3df852a91eed7a6ce5142d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8d3e57945ea6a29a083ae6c4f1fcf08995a9971fd6ae5474af00c6b5c7c74c78", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "39db6b3a0247644fa0df7d5327d619e355a2e6891b8c842f86714f58763d1106", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6e5ebf63998007218f0d1705fbff02eafce120b1dc1585e0b26e5444f7fedfda", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c30cd53dda67959c4913124d079582303c9fd021ce258876ebbabb57e2ecae24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "69b7a3ee544111ee27eae2177134496c1fd325da2365cc5046c505e3c972ef04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "752c1ad8534130f53eb85c4ec18b67259cf7780f7dcba63132dd942457f21341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "92eeeb391492f1f28ac9a7cf9f16c7596771249836af0aa1c70e94169cd7909c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e24fab4c8b3ff68ddbdc4d639d5dd88318b7d20cc23482c9fce07f35601859e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1f4debdb9cd6900ad5a4338e2d3129dcd1ff47c4cb3771b83eba24c2b6fbb8de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8dffadf9fbed460de6480bf668f65e65555179943981f21920d69e7432e59957", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36c99dbab51a147932fef004caee8a14b8a465f590ea3b07f2c901d7abe7dedd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b8e2051339dce4c6e0c5c06d3ea596b53132677d6ad49b7f17ffb54f0f2914c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1795161adccbf83cf99216fc8ffc6b5c224cf94f43617593a520799cb7168d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f981283c260f11a57eb352eadc5aac098c61cf4108af99d26d037b53ee505469", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9fcef15e698582bef7087a4c23e4fade00d86f7c0ceb6afada84760e6a4b79e3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "3012b": { @@ -252003,7 +270423,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "3012b", "family_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", "job_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "iron_coast_6", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -252019,6 +270439,472 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/candidate.json", "sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "18c9acd13ec59e49f0c08b6bc7f75566ebbae7288f30aea891b348614ff765c0", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.680654+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [{\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011d\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011d\", \"crop\": [0, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 0, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint, surviving gray roof fragments and surface partition remain in place. Stronger rubble, orange flecks and narrow radial cracks are accepted fine interpretation.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2261\", \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011e\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011e\", \"crop\": [314, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 1, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The damaged dark area and source roof-edge remnants remain readable. Pebble-like rubble and radial fine cracks strengthen detail without rebuilding an intact roof.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2262\", \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011f\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011f\", \"crop\": [627, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 2, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The near-square destroyed patch and surviving gray remnants retain their layout. Added thin dark crack lines and warm embers are accepted material detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2263\", \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30120\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30120\", \"crop\": [940, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 3, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source char shape and bordering pale structural patches remain damaged. Stronger grain/highlights are accepted rather than claimed as exact source RGB.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2264\", \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30121\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30121\", \"crop\": [0, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 4, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The central dark destruction, gray edge fragments and native surrounding building geometry remain in place. New metal/rubble detail is accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2265\", \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30122\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30122\", \"crop\": [314, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 5, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight remnant edges and damaged patch remain recognizable. Added thin radial cracks and embers remain fine damage detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2266\", \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30123\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30123\", \"crop\": [627, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 6, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The brighter left structural ribs and top remnant correspond to existing gray source fragments. The central destruction remains open/dark; sharper clean edges, stone-like rubble and orange flecks are interpretation, not an exact untouched SD material claim.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2267\", \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30124\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30124\", \"crop\": [940, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 7, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original opaque destroyed-surface tile retains its dark damaged footprint and surrounding gray fragments. Approved as source-bound gallery artwork only: the actual original registry contains no native mission samples, neighbors or state partners for this ID.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 0, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2268\", \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\", \"unused_gallery_only\": true, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30125\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30125\", \"crop\": [0, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 8, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original irregular damaged footprint and surviving gray vertical remnants are retained. Newly authored fine rubble and cracks are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2269\", \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30126\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30126\", \"crop\": [314, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 9, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source gray structural edge and dark damaged patch remain in their arrangement; brighter fine metal detail does not rebuild the entire intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2270\", \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30127\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30127\", \"crop\": [627, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 10, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source destruction and gray surviving fragments remain readable. Fine embers and grain are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2271\", \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30128\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30128\", \"crop\": [940, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 11, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint and roof-edge remnants remain in place; stronger fine cracks/highlights are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2272\", \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30129\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30129\", \"crop\": [0, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 12, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The gray linear remnants and asymmetric char geometry remain in the source arrangement. Radial fine cracks and orange highlights add damage material rather than an intact object.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2273\", \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012a\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012a\", \"crop\": [314, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 13, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The sharpened top/left metal rim and lower/right upright fragments correspond to existing source gray structures. Brighter steel and embers are accepted; the black damage remains, and no complete repaired roof appears.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2274\", \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012b\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012b\", \"crop\": [627, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 14, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The small central pale source remnant is interpreted as a short grooved metal piece; neighboring pale edges and char layout remain aligned. This is explicit material interpretation, with stronger rubble/embers, rather than exact original subpixel hardware fidelity.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 1, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2275\", \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012c\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012c\", \"crop\": [940, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 15, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight gray remnants around the broad dark damaged area remain readable. Fine stones, cracks and embers are accepted without restoring a complete intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2276\", \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}] [\"Brighter shard4 steel, radial thin cracks, rounded rubble and warm orange flecks are newly authored interpretation rather than exact SD grain/RGB. Source damaged dark areas remain damaged; no complete rebuilt roof was observed.\", \"30123/3012a existing straight gray source fragments gain cleaner metal edges.3012b central pale remnant is interpreted as a small grooved metal piece; this specific material interpretation is accepted and disclosed.\", \"Four held sibling remnants retain an approximate gray/dark area and closer1x palette average but larger native artwork loses visible straight surviving metal fragments. Opaque coverage cannot overrule that art defect.\", \"Mixed HD and ScaleNx-original tiles remain visibly different in texture density/material, including rectangular transitions in joined scenes. The two-logical-pixel edge transition is not claimed to hide every seam. No shifted major panel/roof/pipe boundary was found in the declared cases.\"] [\"All current individual declarations reviewed: up to3 authentic native samples per target, every declared cardinal ID pair and declared state-partner swap. This is not every whole map or every simultaneous destruction arrangement.\", \"Context1\\u20134 outputs were numerically checked and saved; complete fine scene galleries visually inspect native4x with64px original overviews, supplemented by every full source tile and actual1\\u20134 tile view. No claim of visually inspecting every whole context at native1/2/3.\", \"Joined64 is only127 representative context/state probes. Supporting earlier32 candidates are not newly approved here, and held4 remain held despite their inclusion in the diagnostic pack.\", \"Boundary means, full opaque mask overlap and source-class diagnostics establish neither artistic fidelity nor an invisible seam on their own.\", \"Actual static indexed loading/TerrainHd composition is verified. No live gameplay, arbitrary palette-fade cycle, mission1080p performance or unsupported route claim is made.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 755667dfb498724e17a35358d8d01541f51783b061cf26f80684c0d618ad68cb", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/complete-actual-ppm-manifest.json", + "sha256": "d330c159a081d63ce647a4f23ae9f84764b77e6ba3208b018079d321829dc89d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "3011d", + "3011e", + "3011f", + "30120" + ], + "sha256": "600f121057342084138f279aa0658376f00f4b9e4bd9de517f27028fb03b7c89", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30121", + "30122", + "30123", + "30124" + ], + "sha256": "23bad5451e0549b68fb2cf3cca3fc4b0557399bbd9b5190387cb7768a2a66c6f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "30125", + "30126", + "30127", + "30128" + ], + "sha256": "7720739a3e24872e00be5bc44e3e33a73a1e2e214352e6bbc8e7ef8ed7cfc8c4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "30129", + "3012a", + "3012b", + "3012c" + ], + "sha256": "8c976232ef3f87f905078ad64956e45187450c8c815e5847185d62be1b53de57", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "3011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47ddc428ba9c9d9a4ff0a52180f361be8b4c3f6fa958a19921cc11359cd52bd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e0a2dbf264485816ed3267ecd2c9fdeaca82660bdeef65f31c865e7a89bac3b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "402daf19f6f512ab35774f6ed760f5dd6beeb59ddcb98e9ec0cbe2e484963614", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "54b506e3c0aab49652dc095169bf8cf454f8ae0fed8bff3c1d0a68c52b834d86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f019a5361935df3e0117fd7e33e2b03787c108f5c540c23feebcd02cea3e64fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7b7c411788f55a818a1c2cf8eea745fdff2643abbae945138e848629b6de795a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ee4eb50f1339382c177f648af0add2c3f2a29aa24146e8bb364caf2bed06ea9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c1ab9b8da0357fefae1052a8ff97dc0876fa8ce6ab7c0fba0e939a2ee14a94f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "36f33b244c675e12428d57f9221dfac75fe211c80efed3f5a9450b22bcb50b2d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0fbc59221c897bde1aa195a44d6adb177b70954b21649445d087d12e475c379c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "649b8b00021215527674e058df3fd256a1ec58412bc656a62265e4511911ac27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5fd8af719d76cd017cba0b9e4b06b7e757ab376fec39c05693ef3139f6694097", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3867102b30ec60a6a0aadf2b13bb9f5f011306a51b7350d780a0e103024ac40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2076c09d7a71382739c2d0bf91888306ec65704e3090d92a15ca86dc7e1afa5c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bfb9a0c60f0c6b01b65dda24d57466f2a703f3d9b5fe926faa7942c9f3b49d04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e7f4579a56d595ba76c9e2d54321536ba3a2a8637d5e48a341742a6cf5ccd4cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7b2f9d98c2c922b243b9931c01ad61d02fe12a34a0c498d2cbf92028417391c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1e8dc9addaff9746c6dbee04189f2aaf8564c24fdea0f0951383fad1a8f3882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d26c5dd1942fa19f5b5cc8f927c17097b0dd6bef961f3e88d80808b5285ad759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af1be35802274ab0d1c46603c956f489363548583236a299b03ec9050e81dd53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0dd02a5723dfa38f8775cec3647a943dc81417295fe1267b5c8bb4e3013b1270", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dfae46f975fe415e11e77e15dc2b76de74a945bd4f57dcaebc7e3db06e932252", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9c87c2b2144a6857da73773a6de95b2ceaa34ddb464c003580004d1aebd91c45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "37da9b687aa89e9a1db920b5e9733e0ea6a73a9b325d49abb94df7cdb17855ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b3b11eff5c3f378bc986e31529c558566128d6d3cc38baedce3f63d6e41bba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4430a061e8f802ebfece64b2a74e4c9d2f3356df3d9dcc0b38ab399fbb6547b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d3068a6f407760188f934c7831a8978b1358e8d79b2394532ebcaeee5d610ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "351f358673bd32ee15bfc568a2ad8d5d9225a35341c07dad177691ba3e28c01a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "614ce68b7068d2c91714eaa7f759a4b3bd5e6e28c861046cea488f6ab224f3a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3cbfc85bc6e8eb13a412beda0aee76bba2c364bf2287a291491e5e654e77600b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f515fb9d1d66c68ba439f7ae83c4231dca92a73ff9378e158bf836e4ce68e783", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "16f0b4176b2b7e1ccbb1e6c86409d1ebb26eddc44fd0891948d4791341355f66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "95eb90b9a3cf2998bc492101cdcf5173d33705d2166ab90f5483b333983fc5a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d5462c8c176b17b062f64261b38a484e9890019d65a814e2f7b5f2f6eeee4c10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0d8fb1653d0b2f0ef5349f8d9f23f30e5cb323b2bccdce6197afcab3dd662ddd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1a027e0e27a8b818730dd5c0c5065a4448000e32f30bd648a10fc87897aaa95f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fff16fe61cc4d73d972ab9d12a52f112d8ef13fb7b37cb66c4d3db99108c9493", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ed83201f80607e31227cb59a6ac9d6a47df8e9ae61dd840c8a325bdb94ff2d27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "66cf27b7f00b72f4ac8733b72bc2b8fe0d0da239b0790317c03a84164fd3112b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "636e3d4a735c65070f1ac27eca1e2e12480ad27aab7a3c25335b9ed63a70027a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9da55e79f9c8724cebaf96ff69bac1ea23e84b4b70da1c696c8bbf117c2c2cd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ecf7acb2aaeb61dd2d728d7eeba7fe605ba2b76918015b97644fd133ac3c8171", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35a31bb6430524337048b347b350438565fc201e38153d60a99212f7ac4027e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3d63079e5a08c322c9fac8dc8ac154311ef252925d52c80d8f67d2c001c8ac45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90a1794aecdd5b5deb149dd21d4b77a2c9d5782f39c2bf418f3b40b14b46d4cc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b22802e327df7a43ff9e376c7f4aaf845d7f316c3a725c9c8ebdbde3dd3902ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd800cad574c5df989975871b2b09755df2e325e5190b4ad7869016a743bae02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74d2c4b9afb453a5dc814646c607c15f6e9a36f0257bd74998c3192b4916f8e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b4cc4e5d79e39b64fba94b3157d78eea8b44e69327d73667bc0c1e3dc120086e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9c703237fa600c8c4f635e9ec4b4cb4545da4fa768bb0f3695a8ce355c50eb5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1d991ecd07dfcacb890ac7101f944ca381bb73b073bdf1f6512724c4b16290b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "eb3015b83566d6eb34bf371da10666ed17d98d601f2c1030e68f94869067064c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81c40ad363129c77e53e1af99bd3e812ac9e933eb5d7091eb10c57d00610a08e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "697f34b746d8415d6d2e38e61f0d0737085d3981f5b1bfddc4ddc5df26425f76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "51aa7854bc4f1b5a8a6ee6c1d037b988383b415b8f6553bba5ea8c79415b9d63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "07d57094b6e20e052ff8f8da02c481058984c8781081f42d72947a22f0804c4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2d38d2a77ce433ea11ceb70d117f7c34c16b363eebb0fae4f0b49506b0b2a3b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f933dcafc0210f7dccffedfb36e2e99a18727ec501f37adb9781f765e2da6d8d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eb36aa9be293846bf1880a2f116479504770cbb86189451a3db1607d3245721c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9102e1307b087bcca0da28eefab6e294bded5fe84361e768ca8b95d4a06f3d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "56a6678ed32cdc2e9fa63defa9b0d7a5b7f45f59f1dae4b7c393deb3677ebd29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7afe25456c3f32795fde058ce1c114d8dbc2c92f940b843515fd8ab0d95aff44", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb3265816babfe4a0be59814473a8853d39683f51f110d1621ca1be2ac57ef06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7dda2d9fab9948724dd8b0884cf9370ca4cb3b9b9f9e963dbe3723f08038629a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8719368b9dea0ce143caea9a4cd15711e927acdc6f3df852a91eed7a6ce5142d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8d3e57945ea6a29a083ae6c4f1fcf08995a9971fd6ae5474af00c6b5c7c74c78", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "39db6b3a0247644fa0df7d5327d619e355a2e6891b8c842f86714f58763d1106", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6e5ebf63998007218f0d1705fbff02eafce120b1dc1585e0b26e5444f7fedfda", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c30cd53dda67959c4913124d079582303c9fd021ce258876ebbabb57e2ecae24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "69b7a3ee544111ee27eae2177134496c1fd325da2365cc5046c505e3c972ef04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "752c1ad8534130f53eb85c4ec18b67259cf7780f7dcba63132dd942457f21341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "92eeeb391492f1f28ac9a7cf9f16c7596771249836af0aa1c70e94169cd7909c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e24fab4c8b3ff68ddbdc4d639d5dd88318b7d20cc23482c9fce07f35601859e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1f4debdb9cd6900ad5a4338e2d3129dcd1ff47c4cb3771b83eba24c2b6fbb8de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8dffadf9fbed460de6480bf668f65e65555179943981f21920d69e7432e59957", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36c99dbab51a147932fef004caee8a14b8a465f590ea3b07f2c901d7abe7dedd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b8e2051339dce4c6e0c5c06d3ea596b53132677d6ad49b7f17ffb54f0f2914c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1795161adccbf83cf99216fc8ffc6b5c224cf94f43617593a520799cb7168d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f981283c260f11a57eb352eadc5aac098c61cf4108af99d26d037b53ee505469", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9fcef15e698582bef7087a4c23e4fade00d86f7c0ceb6afada84760e6a4b79e3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "3012c": { @@ -252040,7 +270926,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "3012c", "family_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", "job_id": "terrain-3011d-3012c", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "iron_coast_6", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -252056,6 +270942,472 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/candidate.json", "sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "1e6d6b08e99f00610232cb775f5317e0a9183581e5fa1307a0aa5ff65c205377", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "18c9acd13ec59e49f0c08b6bc7f75566ebbae7288f30aea891b348614ff765c0", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.680654+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [{\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011d\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011d\", \"crop\": [0, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 0, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint, surviving gray roof fragments and surface partition remain in place. Stronger rubble, orange flecks and narrow radial cracks are accepted fine interpretation.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2261\", \"source_sha256\": \"a3d414206f2153a5f4a27b72feb5d690afb26b00a65d138e23a9e19d67084a5c\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011e\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011e\", \"crop\": [314, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 1, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The damaged dark area and source roof-edge remnants remain readable. Pebble-like rubble and radial fine cracks strengthen detail without rebuilding an intact roof.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2262\", \"source_sha256\": \"70364d5c1c25b47fedb409710b1ec8988cebf0f59c5621758894d55066db162b\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3011f\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3011f\", \"crop\": [627, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 2, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The near-square destroyed patch and surviving gray remnants retain their layout. Added thin dark crack lines and warm embers are accepted material detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2263\", \"source_sha256\": \"12c6bae7e0530783fabfa954094f7991b41f591d72fac8fac54dd7987eef3f54\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30120\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30120\", \"crop\": [940, 0, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 3, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source char shape and bordering pale structural patches remain damaged. Stronger grain/highlights are accepted rather than claimed as exact source RGB.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2264\", \"source_sha256\": \"bd5c4eebe9a4674d9852de3256e3024d2bbb2785b9fa26e35d94d3dee70795c9\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30121\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30121\", \"crop\": [0, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 4, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The central dark destruction, gray edge fragments and native surrounding building geometry remain in place. New metal/rubble detail is accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2265\", \"source_sha256\": \"34bcd4e5b3e4ad6c4ca73d3b99a06fd9547432631170aa06e2878e0c220183c7\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30122\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30122\", \"crop\": [314, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 5, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight remnant edges and damaged patch remain recognizable. Added thin radial cracks and embers remain fine damage detail.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2266\", \"source_sha256\": \"a7f7bc2d42dbfcd43a2be3e57e1c50c461924fb763c1b7e7d8320927fbccc2b6\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30123\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30123\", \"crop\": [627, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 6, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The brighter left structural ribs and top remnant correspond to existing gray source fragments. The central destruction remains open/dark; sharper clean edges, stone-like rubble and orange flecks are interpretation, not an exact untouched SD material claim.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2267\", \"source_sha256\": \"57bb69fc9654b9f8379f32e79de768792c19c5d768beef4b55f115e5882a3698\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30124\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30124\", \"crop\": [940, 314, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 7, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original opaque destroyed-surface tile retains its dark damaged footprint and surrounding gray fragments. Approved as source-bound gallery artwork only: the actual original registry contains no native mission samples, neighbors or state partners for this ID.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 0, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2268\", \"source_sha256\": \"f1f263e76155f5c489e8e059719fa3fdefbc8788f17c9dc3d2073b1bb77958c2\", \"unused_gallery_only\": true, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30125\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30125\", \"crop\": [0, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 8, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The original irregular damaged footprint and surviving gray vertical remnants are retained. Newly authored fine rubble and cracks are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2269\", \"source_sha256\": \"e9878e6b28aa277c71d286e4e16c602e5abea711c36065c0e696e10b1e87dd65\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30126\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30126\", \"crop\": [314, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 9, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source gray structural edge and dark damaged patch remain in their arrangement; brighter fine metal detail does not rebuild the entire intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2270\", \"source_sha256\": \"490bfdbc8339b51c375aec599ae2e7c5b861a3aa8b3f21ce8568ef303b20e77d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30127\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30127\", \"crop\": [627, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 10, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source destruction and gray surviving fragments remain readable. Fine embers and grain are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2271\", \"source_sha256\": \"93347f2690aa75856cb4f8e4cf6c8c13389eee7570567cd15c8b848fb180b6b4\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30128\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30128\", \"crop\": [940, 627, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 11, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source dark damaged footprint and roof-edge remnants remain in place; stronger fine cracks/highlights are accepted.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2272\", \"source_sha256\": \"d336fea81b2eefc81c8cacbb13d51696c28ec54b6c05a191419ffd8bf5ab0b4f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"30129\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"30129\", \"crop\": [0, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 12, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The gray linear remnants and asymmetric char geometry remain in the source arrangement. Radial fine cracks and orange highlights add damage material rather than an intact object.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2273\", \"source_sha256\": \"268fcaf7e40831b6d5481c718b11864791ca8680927144779b7e8f107323c46f\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012a\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012a\", \"crop\": [314, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 13, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The sharpened top/left metal rim and lower/right upright fragments correspond to existing source gray structures. Brighter steel and embers are accepted; the black damage remains, and no complete repaired roof appears.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2274\", \"source_sha256\": \"976e1367ae6fc39df071f227379c4d5e2c545904a09a6123c02e5044e7679488\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012b\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012b\", \"crop\": [627, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 14, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The small central pale source remnant is interpreted as a short grooved metal piece; neighboring pale edges and char layout remain aligned. This is explicit material interpretation, with stronger rubble/embers, rather than exact original subpixel hardware fidelity.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 1, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2275\", \"source_sha256\": \"ec64959901e5b5b6149abcaf243886975684dd67bac8420dbe9de1e5d30f55d5\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}, {\"approximate_source_regions\": [], \"asset\": \"3012c\", \"candidate_binding\": {\"asset\": \"3012c\", \"crop\": [940, 940, 313, 313], \"file\": \"jobs/terrain-3011d-3012c/generated/raw-atlas-v1.png\", \"frame\": 15, \"logical_height\": 32, \"logical_width\": 32, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\"}, \"fidelity_finding\": \"The source surviving straight gray remnants around the broad dark damaged area remain readable. Fine stones, cracks and embers are accepted without restoring a complete intact structure.\", \"fix_guidance\": null, \"logical_canvas\": [32, 32], \"native_sample_count\": 3, \"origin\": [0, 0], \"raw_sha256\": \"d517f2bfeb62289419a239904edea81b7cfa50aee9fa84e06191b8231cc7ebf7\", \"source_path\": \"/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.2276\", \"source_sha256\": \"f331194d9cd27bfbcb69ceff40c0d35df4e59d8e81aa229b96f3429dad0df86d\", \"unused_gallery_only\": false, \"verdict\": \"approved\"}] [\"Brighter shard4 steel, radial thin cracks, rounded rubble and warm orange flecks are newly authored interpretation rather than exact SD grain/RGB. Source damaged dark areas remain damaged; no complete rebuilt roof was observed.\", \"30123/3012a existing straight gray source fragments gain cleaner metal edges.3012b central pale remnant is interpreted as a small grooved metal piece; this specific material interpretation is accepted and disclosed.\", \"Four held sibling remnants retain an approximate gray/dark area and closer1x palette average but larger native artwork loses visible straight surviving metal fragments. Opaque coverage cannot overrule that art defect.\", \"Mixed HD and ScaleNx-original tiles remain visibly different in texture density/material, including rectangular transitions in joined scenes. The two-logical-pixel edge transition is not claimed to hide every seam. No shifted major panel/roof/pipe boundary was found in the declared cases.\"] [\"All current individual declarations reviewed: up to3 authentic native samples per target, every declared cardinal ID pair and declared state-partner swap. This is not every whole map or every simultaneous destruction arrangement.\", \"Context1\\u20134 outputs were numerically checked and saved; complete fine scene galleries visually inspect native4x with64px original overviews, supplemented by every full source tile and actual1\\u20134 tile view. No claim of visually inspecting every whole context at native1/2/3.\", \"Joined64 is only127 representative context/state probes. Supporting earlier32 candidates are not newly approved here, and held4 remain held despite their inclusion in the diagnostic pack.\", \"Boundary means, full opaque mask overlap and source-class diagnostics establish neither artistic fidelity nor an invisible seam on their own.\", \"Actual static indexed loading/TerrainHd composition is verified. No live gameplay, arbitrary palette-fade cycle, mission1080p performance or unsupported route claim is made.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/independent-review.json, SHA256 755667dfb498724e17a35358d8d01541f51783b061cf26f80684c0d618ad68cb", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/complete-actual-ppm-manifest.json", + "sha256": "d330c159a081d63ce647a4f23ae9f84764b77e6ba3208b018079d321829dc89d" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "3011d", + "3011e", + "3011f", + "30120" + ], + "sha256": "600f121057342084138f279aa0658376f00f4b9e4bd9de517f27028fb03b7c89", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "30121", + "30122", + "30123", + "30124" + ], + "sha256": "23bad5451e0549b68fb2cf3cca3fc4b0557399bbd9b5190387cb7768a2a66c6f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "30125", + "30126", + "30127", + "30128" + ], + "sha256": "7720739a3e24872e00be5bc44e3e33a73a1e2e214352e6bbc8e7ef8ed7cfc8c4", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "30129", + "3012a", + "3012b", + "3012c" + ], + "sha256": "8c976232ef3f87f905078ad64956e45187450c8c815e5847185d62be1b53de57", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "3011d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "47ddc428ba9c9d9a4ff0a52180f361be8b4c3f6fa958a19921cc11359cd52bd9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "e0a2dbf264485816ed3267ecd2c9fdeaca82660bdeef65f31c865e7a89bac3b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "402daf19f6f512ab35774f6ed760f5dd6beeb59ddcb98e9ec0cbe2e484963614", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "54b506e3c0aab49652dc095169bf8cf454f8ae0fed8bff3c1d0a68c52b834d86", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f019a5361935df3e0117fd7e33e2b03787c108f5c540c23feebcd02cea3e64fd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "7b7c411788f55a818a1c2cf8eea745fdff2643abbae945138e848629b6de795a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "0ee4eb50f1339382c177f648af0add2c3f2a29aa24146e8bb364caf2bed06ea9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c1ab9b8da0357fefae1052a8ff97dc0876fa8ce6ab7c0fba0e939a2ee14a94f4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "36f33b244c675e12428d57f9221dfac75fe211c80efed3f5a9450b22bcb50b2d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0fbc59221c897bde1aa195a44d6adb177b70954b21649445d087d12e475c379c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "649b8b00021215527674e058df3fd256a1ec58412bc656a62265e4511911ac27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "5fd8af719d76cd017cba0b9e4b06b7e757ab376fec39c05693ef3139f6694097", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "3867102b30ec60a6a0aadf2b13bb9f5f011306a51b7350d780a0e103024ac40b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "2076c09d7a71382739c2d0bf91888306ec65704e3090d92a15ca86dc7e1afa5c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3011f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "bfb9a0c60f0c6b01b65dda24d57466f2a703f3d9b5fe926faa7942c9f3b49d04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3011f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e7f4579a56d595ba76c9e2d54321536ba3a2a8637d5e48a341742a6cf5ccd4cf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7b2f9d98c2c922b243b9931c01ad61d02fe12a34a0c498d2cbf92028417391c9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f1e8dc9addaff9746c6dbee04189f2aaf8564c24fdea0f0951383fad1a8f3882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d26c5dd1942fa19f5b5cc8f927c17097b0dd6bef961f3e88d80808b5285ad759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30120-original.ppm", + "sha256": "af1be35802274ab0d1c46603c956f489363548583236a299b03ec9050e81dd53", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30120-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0dd02a5723dfa38f8775cec3647a943dc81417295fe1267b5c8bb4e3013b1270", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "dfae46f975fe415e11e77e15dc2b76de74a945bd4f57dcaebc7e3db06e932252", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9c87c2b2144a6857da73773a6de95b2ceaa34ddb464c003580004d1aebd91c45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "37da9b687aa89e9a1db920b5e9733e0ea6a73a9b325d49abb94df7cdb17855ca", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30121-original.ppm", + "sha256": "f3b3b11eff5c3f378bc986e31529c558566128d6d3cc38baedce3f63d6e41bba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30121-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "4430a061e8f802ebfece64b2a74e4c9d2f3356df3d9dcc0b38ab399fbb6547b0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d3068a6f407760188f934c7831a8978b1358e8d79b2394532ebcaeee5d610ac4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "351f358673bd32ee15bfc568a2ad8d5d9225a35341c07dad177691ba3e28c01a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "614ce68b7068d2c91714eaa7f759a4b3bd5e6e28c861046cea488f6ab224f3a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30122-original.ppm", + "sha256": "3cbfc85bc6e8eb13a412beda0aee76bba2c364bf2287a291491e5e654e77600b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30122-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f515fb9d1d66c68ba439f7ae83c4231dca92a73ff9378e158bf836e4ce68e783", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "16f0b4176b2b7e1ccbb1e6c86409d1ebb26eddc44fd0891948d4791341355f66", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "95eb90b9a3cf2998bc492101cdcf5173d33705d2166ab90f5483b333983fc5a8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d5462c8c176b17b062f64261b38a484e9890019d65a814e2f7b5f2f6eeee4c10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30123-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0d8fb1653d0b2f0ef5349f8d9f23f30e5cb323b2bccdce6197afcab3dd662ddd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30123-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1a027e0e27a8b818730dd5c0c5065a4448000e32f30bd648a10fc87897aaa95f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fff16fe61cc4d73d972ab9d12a52f112d8ef13fb7b37cb66c4d3db99108c9493", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ed83201f80607e31227cb59a6ac9d6a47df8e9ae61dd840c8a325bdb94ff2d27", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "66cf27b7f00b72f4ac8733b72bc2b8fe0d0da239b0790317c03a84164fd3112b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30124-original.ppm", + "sha256": "636e3d4a735c65070f1ac27eca1e2e12480ad27aab7a3c25335b9ed63a70027a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30124-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "9da55e79f9c8724cebaf96ff69bac1ea23e84b4b70da1c696c8bbf117c2c2cd7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "ecf7acb2aaeb61dd2d728d7eeba7fe605ba2b76918015b97644fd133ac3c8171", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35a31bb6430524337048b347b350438565fc201e38153d60a99212f7ac4027e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "3d63079e5a08c322c9fac8dc8ac154311ef252925d52c80d8f67d2c001c8ac45", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30125-original.ppm", + "sha256": "90a1794aecdd5b5deb149dd21d4b77a2c9d5782f39c2bf418f3b40b14b46d4cc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30125-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b22802e327df7a43ff9e376c7f4aaf845d7f316c3a725c9c8ebdbde3dd3902ff", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fd800cad574c5df989975871b2b09755df2e325e5190b4ad7869016a743bae02", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "74d2c4b9afb453a5dc814646c607c15f6e9a36f0257bd74998c3192b4916f8e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b4cc4e5d79e39b64fba94b3157d78eea8b44e69327d73667bc0c1e3dc120086e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30126-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9c703237fa600c8c4f635e9ec4b4cb4545da4fa768bb0f3695a8ce355c50eb5f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30126-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1d991ecd07dfcacb890ac7101f944ca381bb73b073bdf1f6512724c4b16290b3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "eb3015b83566d6eb34bf371da10666ed17d98d601f2c1030e68f94869067064c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "81c40ad363129c77e53e1af99bd3e812ac9e933eb5d7091eb10c57d00610a08e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "697f34b746d8415d6d2e38e61f0d0737085d3981f5b1bfddc4ddc5df26425f76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30127-original.ppm", + "sha256": "51aa7854bc4f1b5a8a6ee6c1d037b988383b415b8f6553bba5ea8c79415b9d63", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30127-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "07d57094b6e20e052ff8f8da02c481058984c8781081f42d72947a22f0804c4b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2d38d2a77ce433ea11ceb70d117f7c34c16b363eebb0fae4f0b49506b0b2a3b1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f933dcafc0210f7dccffedfb36e2e99a18727ec501f37adb9781f765e2da6d8d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "eb36aa9be293846bf1880a2f116479504770cbb86189451a3db1607d3245721c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30128-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9102e1307b087bcca0da28eefab6e294bded5fe84361e768ca8b95d4a06f3d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30128-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "56a6678ed32cdc2e9fa63defa9b0d7a5b7f45f59f1dae4b7c393deb3677ebd29", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "7afe25456c3f32795fde058ce1c114d8dbc2c92f940b843515fd8ab0d95aff44", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fb3265816babfe4a0be59814473a8853d39683f51f110d1621ca1be2ac57ef06", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "7dda2d9fab9948724dd8b0884cf9370ca4cb3b9b9f9e963dbe3723f08038629a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "30129-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8719368b9dea0ce143caea9a4cd15711e927acdc6f3df852a91eed7a6ce5142d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/30129-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "8d3e57945ea6a29a083ae6c4f1fcf08995a9971fd6ae5474af00c6b5c7c74c78", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "39db6b3a0247644fa0df7d5327d619e355a2e6891b8c842f86714f58763d1106", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6e5ebf63998007218f0d1705fbff02eafce120b1dc1585e0b26e5444f7fedfda", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c30cd53dda67959c4913124d079582303c9fd021ce258876ebbabb57e2ecae24", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "69b7a3ee544111ee27eae2177134496c1fd325da2365cc5046c505e3c972ef04", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "752c1ad8534130f53eb85c4ec18b67259cf7780f7dcba63132dd942457f21341", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "92eeeb391492f1f28ac9a7cf9f16c7596771249836af0aa1c70e94169cd7909c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "9e24fab4c8b3ff68ddbdc4d639d5dd88318b7d20cc23482c9fce07f35601859e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1f4debdb9cd6900ad5a4338e2d3129dcd1ff47c4cb3771b83eba24c2b6fbb8de", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8dffadf9fbed460de6480bf668f65e65555179943981f21920d69e7432e59957", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "36c99dbab51a147932fef004caee8a14b8a465f590ea3b07f2c901d7abe7dedd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b8e2051339dce4c6e0c5c06d3ea596b53132677d6ad49b7f17ffb54f0f2914c8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1795161adccbf83cf99216fc8ffc6b5c224cf94f43617593a520799cb7168d9a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f981283c260f11a57eb352eadc5aac098c61cf4108af99d26d037b53ee505469", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "3012c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "9fcef15e698582bef7087a4c23e4fade00d86f7c0ceb6afada84760e6a4b79e3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-terrain-set3-shards34-independent-review/terrain-3011d-3012c/sprite-runtime/3012c-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "3012d": { @@ -256813,7 +276165,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "301ad", "family_id": "terrain-301ad-301bc", "job_id": "terrain-301ad-301bc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -256824,6 +276176,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-301ad-301bc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "53b085d431565aca059d15d6d731718f8560d735135b52e6aaae7cec7699bf6c", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "301ae": { @@ -256877,7 +276234,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "301af", "family_id": "terrain-301ad-301bc", "job_id": "terrain-301ad-301bc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -256888,6 +276245,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-301ad-301bc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "53b085d431565aca059d15d6d731718f8560d735135b52e6aaae7cec7699bf6c", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "301b0": { @@ -256909,7 +276271,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "301b0", "family_id": "terrain-301ad-301bc", "job_id": "terrain-301ad-301bc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -256920,6 +276282,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-301ad-301bc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "53b085d431565aca059d15d6d731718f8560d735135b52e6aaae7cec7699bf6c", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "301b1": { @@ -276205,7 +295572,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303ed", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -276216,6 +295583,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303ed-303fc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "5fffe041eded4ee8fa9485f18d8f0394fc001d46e52f67dcbb998080b74f5141", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303ee": { @@ -276237,7 +295609,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303ee", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -276248,6 +295620,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303ed-303fc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "5fffe041eded4ee8fa9485f18d8f0394fc001d46e52f67dcbb998080b74f5141", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303ef": { @@ -276269,7 +295646,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303ef", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -276280,6 +295657,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303ed-303fc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "5fffe041eded4ee8fa9485f18d8f0394fc001d46e52f67dcbb998080b74f5141", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303f0": { @@ -276301,7 +295683,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303f0", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -276312,6 +295694,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303ed-303fc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "5fffe041eded4ee8fa9485f18d8f0394fc001d46e52f67dcbb998080b74f5141", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303f1": { @@ -276333,7 +295720,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303f1", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -276344,6 +295731,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303ed-303fc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "5fffe041eded4ee8fa9485f18d8f0394fc001d46e52f67dcbb998080b74f5141", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303f2": { @@ -276365,7 +295757,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303f2", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -276376,6 +295768,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303ed-303fc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "5fffe041eded4ee8fa9485f18d8f0394fc001d46e52f67dcbb998080b74f5141", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303f3": { @@ -276397,7 +295794,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303f3", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -276408,6 +295805,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303ed-303fc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "5fffe041eded4ee8fa9485f18d8f0394fc001d46e52f67dcbb998080b74f5141", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303f4": { @@ -276429,7 +295831,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303f4", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -276440,6 +295842,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303ed-303fc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "5fffe041eded4ee8fa9485f18d8f0394fc001d46e52f67dcbb998080b74f5141", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303f5": { @@ -276461,7 +295868,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303f5", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -276472,6 +295879,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303ed-303fc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "5fffe041eded4ee8fa9485f18d8f0394fc001d46e52f67dcbb998080b74f5141", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303f6": { @@ -276493,7 +295905,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303f6", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -276504,6 +295916,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303ed-303fc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "5fffe041eded4ee8fa9485f18d8f0394fc001d46e52f67dcbb998080b74f5141", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303f7": { @@ -276525,7 +295942,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303f7", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -276536,6 +295953,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303ed-303fc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "5fffe041eded4ee8fa9485f18d8f0394fc001d46e52f67dcbb998080b74f5141", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303f8": { @@ -276557,7 +295979,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303f8", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -276568,6 +295990,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303ed-303fc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "5fffe041eded4ee8fa9485f18d8f0394fc001d46e52f67dcbb998080b74f5141", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303f9": { @@ -276589,7 +296016,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303f9", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -276600,6 +296027,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303ed-303fc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "5fffe041eded4ee8fa9485f18d8f0394fc001d46e52f67dcbb998080b74f5141", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303fa": { @@ -276621,7 +296053,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303fa", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -276632,6 +296064,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303ed-303fc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "5fffe041eded4ee8fa9485f18d8f0394fc001d46e52f67dcbb998080b74f5141", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303fb": { @@ -276653,7 +296090,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303fb", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -276664,6 +296101,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303ed-303fc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "5fffe041eded4ee8fa9485f18d8f0394fc001d46e52f67dcbb998080b74f5141", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303fc": { @@ -276685,7 +296127,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "303fc", "family_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", "job_id": "terrain-303ed-303fc", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -276696,6 +296138,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-303ed-303fc/candidate.json", + "sha256": "5fffe041eded4ee8fa9485f18d8f0394fc001d46e52f67dcbb998080b74f5141", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "303fd": { @@ -302699,7 +322146,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40088", "family_id": "enemies-40088-40088", "job_id": "enemies-40088-40088", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -302711,6 +322158,56 @@ "manifest": "jobs/enemies-40088-40088/candidate.json", "sha256": "da9700e956771494e03ca922ccf57e929e15eda5b4fa9e11b8cee0a171e4e709", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "da9700e956771494e03ca922ccf57e929e15eda5b4fa9e11b8cee0a171e4e709", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "f2b0c347a44cd7dbcebe45a1ca2bf5bdedf95a8b8c58a3943d13e52d52ace967", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:39.613433+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/enemies-40088-40088/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. [\"APPROVED the complete32\\u00d732 opaque STAG02 single after source-driven internal architecture review. The outer vertical rails, broad upper panels, framed central recessed machinery, narrow lower gray strut, top/bottom center cropped stacks and asymmetric dark-left/gray-right walls remain in the original arrangement and retain clear relative contrast at actual1\\u20134.\", \"Untouched generated raw adds fine worn-metal grain, seams, rivets and inset vent subdivisions within the original forms. Local bevels are brighter and the tile is slightly darker overall: source mean gray97.254 versus actualHD1\\u20134 means87.358/87.263/87.182/87.157. Fixed source-coordinate dark recess, gray wall and strut samples remain distinct. These material differences are accepted after full-source/raw/all-native-scale/internal-landmark and terrain context views; no exact per-pixel gray or semantic geometry equality is claimed.\", \"Entire1254\\u00d71254 raw is used without crop; every alpha sample is255. Nativecanvas32\\u00d732 and origin0 are unchanged. Source1024occupied cells and all actual1\\u20134 opaque coverage are complete; alphaIoU1 is trivial here and was not used as the basis for internal fidelity. Source has no reserved/blink/cycling indices, and actual palettes add none.\", \"Original source reference matches actual Catalog-decoded binary RGB and transparency. Untouched job raw matches the original built-in output byte-for-byte. Candidate, original binary/palette/PNG, prompt/provenance, immutable Rust library and all5sprite/8Canvas PPMs and review pages are hash-bound. Both source freshness guards are false and rechecked.\", \"Approval covers exact complete-single artwork, indexed rendering and isolated diagnostic composition only. Production registration and live scene reachability remain coordinator work; no live Host route or timing claim is made.\"] \"Isolated ignored reference writes only; no artwork/raw/candidate/source/global manifest/ledger/Git/registration/promotion edits or live Host claims. All prior peer verdicts and holds remain frozen.\" All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/stag02/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 40245ee5b71b9d64a84dc9829cceaba1b572bd9131a52fb0e622958af17d4ee8", + "additional_independent_evidence": [], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet.png", + "assets": [ + "40088" + ], + "sha256": "88def6dbcf22770a0179e5443a731bb0b994e7a4a3dffab7bf4669dd3e38757d", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40088-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "96367b6ca1b50c95b2a6617e5bc7526fe56c981f42f9309c880d9d188b48c9a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/stag02/runtime/40088-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40088-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "c1eb9bc8a5de7a537647c239ba1d0b7a2d9f0ac232b0f300f9f4c2dffa4db470", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/stag02/runtime/40088-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40088-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "ae12a0ddf2c956cdc4a0e57f84742997e1ccbec90f2eb649a2727cf588e13f61", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/stag02/runtime/40088-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40088-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "8183a4b92f6784e4663bd8592d7f3223cb6bd265d9e6155bab094c2367f748e3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/stag02/runtime/40088-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40088-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a94bdde8252e1138dbc717e666afb68ec35cff32e2e003fd5415a2b8b6d06786", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/windows-persistence-hd-review/stag02/runtime/40088-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40089": { @@ -401557,7 +421054,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40175", "family_id": "terrain-40175-40184", "job_id": "terrain-40175-40184", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -401573,6 +421070,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/candidate.json", "sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "8543023fde3b6b84891d01eb451a16fad2addded56c7c2cebe254879b00d2c9f", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.030084+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"40175\\u201340178/4017b/4017c preserve principal rock counts, positions, direction and shadows. Lower40179/4017a join the exact previous40172/40173 into genuine2x2 foliage: annular outer shape, brown clearing and gray/black center feature remain in source regions. More pointed/brighter leaves are disclosed. Cliff entry/corner IDs4017d\\u201340184 retain ground-region boundaries and dark backing.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 f98c2f25a474e99230a8816cf9fc4ce906751bb3468fe746b31711569d047659", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40175", + "40176", + "40177", + "40178" + ], + "sha256": "baf8a618582337dea9958755bd074ecee0a1b107e8bdb5a1bff5601617fdd1a5", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40179", + "4017a", + "4017b", + "4017c" + ], + "sha256": "8af97e923d27551993dc9182cc9a3385ebc7a15a4845f7478ea79acf8bb777e3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4017d", + "4017e", + "4017f", + "40180" + ], + "sha256": "0da99b203d9361afdcefbb09554f5fa2233e119c40b4ae1aaa8ead2e6437743f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40181", + "40182", + "40183", + "40184" + ], + "sha256": "a217bdf6516f93eb9f1e8fbf815e5034b8e6010a94dfc52c5980acb29de4827c", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40175-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0aa5d3c2bfa94a3b5780f2543358d32dea7d1e0fab338173eb5d8dc4ba2867e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fce5b0c52a5c07375e7b8024fd2ca588f3d088a7bb78fd610f4800792af40258", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a9b21fd26f8d4122bf0a0c6fca08455b0f2c447b44fa05b1ad721ba726d2230", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fa59c26521f9c024d932c2ffe7168a951d661c700c7feca073fffd57425818aa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-original.ppm", + "sha256": "282a343dfe124561381ce0b953f1cec731868885e739eca852f90d34a4bb1b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6517863214a17e3d23148b4ecf8a76b983fcc054a29a57016de5c0044fec0701", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "957337b9cbd52d8bff2f5fb70e2155a45a7df7ef0d7cbbdc129c6c798ce83ea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fd0263c80084257e0a7f93375f99c21a5363139cdd45df296e313b328c141f92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "23277e44cdb548031e720e4baea69dca528bd84116ae8f2233c2d43348fa3fd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-original.ppm", + "sha256": "13bfd8b96679f597d574f0595b27fb670417a2aca94d8c368de22d60d26d246c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "557d88897612db5c8586e4a0fd613da184e624a0c15e8d0717a042c482586167", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "554c16a220c02af33c17c862abade23d9ba30b8ece056365a7b363a56683b36f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e126f1292647f8a861cfba270f12185ef0657e1757cf75af7af196c3cc03dc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "86c686822d40526bf80add427720795789fcbff2a7cfb5adc75d9e04af59d292", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-original.ppm", + "sha256": "979d9bccc77d8a54f7a27178a1a6bfe21007edb03bd5fc78cecbb0bc94c20673", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "23ebebde20b9949b061db01f18c5a1eecf471d96c5c058f7e2abd18b3baed259", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a988159f09570a747334ff446aece165dec444bcb68bbb7a47cf1c80d0f584bd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf2e6e5733020a190e73464ceb44ef07d8aa897e588483e8f0e933a6b7cd0ae3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d3f74942ba9e1ee35aad86976773f8cdc3129eed6a1cac35badba032bcbca46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fb41de86fcc764c07ea8a360653f1268e2e6b2d0b8cf2e8201cbc4ce6265952f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0783ab05df05f1dc3596509ff01aac6597d6dd97dea37b7f6aeb8df81db0253a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "033761f83b193348bdf877c3d0b18a01b56eaf257dc817b84e3d8099d8c366bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c5a101874492e6b4193e33ab561d015a9647c81c21d847e96ac5df35ac1b4e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f5f4a69131f1ccb92f9bab73e65dee8624c5fffc419b930fb540c66beb0321", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0cca56783f10f88287ac5780677ae6a286fd3bdf03625be9a47a400f8f912769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85c96cb980ad678f2986943ed4cdd6371375ebfa457e4ced36143acc4a16abc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "29ef10a332c927b7b37aebc455f2ff09abac9d741dce2d464090a87e2e602053", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "40bef7d8b54748e1d7a2699479f3296a567e333b75cbdc0b9a81672f422c3ada", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f8864b5e6d1e427a75bb713c85e3e36c745902b7cd3748b3b590ce260e62c3b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b0669cde458f09abb74261dabfe48cd746b4dca4378ece159317e19cba2d079c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1c6449e26ffdb2085c68600f2241a9dbe0a046e904a55f020a680b6220ae87b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "247892a4eec5e754b1e75600e95bce92423778e95d3aa93582966dc2af0a8c13", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "307cca8dcdeff4e7e29c6da004c552a5a390c8f455c940ad85015784ab44c676", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ae2631cf0e9557c37b7f0e7cd1667a9e41841ae0f0e26a249059c15633dc0a0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0089a7e6524fb6b6dd61e6b895779f446aecfc1f475433d789026cce24da16c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f2b57ad6ee62dcf8617ec64e4fff5bdb5c3f21f79bd3b6e51d93b2a6f27c0c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9381c149b26c515cb867267f203c2e49d8fe09f1ce9c15d98948305a2475ca1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7b0104d96795aa9bc2dab053dbbc69a97de014eb143a41aed2d39ab0d82c8d25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13c6e07a392cf0849ea2638ec922b60ae0779137ab7b4f3045c290a223f8b367", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de884c8dde84b8a799a58611b8a38a847b7ce2e672083c91aa987ab76f7db8a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b224faeea178c3f7bde612f6105db0dc09ad0738b0bcf2f3b5a3b9b6c1c3b0ea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d5d2b5fcdffd8813bc9937ebf0d419e9e6cd74ece4b87f621f6beae740279903", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4321327869426e1dcaa31a7943a0ae1af27f0a913d78be5680ef4d4d44431695", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "60d68af74114d6ec83f6b549a3a22c545fa0468e92cfddf8fb609b1fef3cc625", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7ba09103d7cdaf7f557efc64b20ce741c29ad1af07d87d87518017e90fbbecc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "824a0739065c7471a5dc4d98ca6068784870d1059f1c30c708ba27f67650c9ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "305214fe539963e5e3354660addf3ba2425cef644785c7e73698c944bf8abe99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "97ec1514749eb39695e3d04de0d8841ea60f319713cc255b43a791d9d3fcab38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4c23901aca2608cc6e4c03b31b83de23e924cef5358196a2f3260847ef4add69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d29b2f7c6d934b2040c6f146c3fe1b78f8bd3e438ae4e9ff85acc67a341aed8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5dd4d598fe807ad2a8f291fd93595e494b260c8858af98c5960741e0c7b43ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a32c58da92f7f32e26e30703c86942164cdf3e48f3f29155302f8c73a568673f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e724c789745ff5b797ebc354ce56241ffb3662170a5e1e9e49f5b21f7c4ff023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12ec2879e7b5cac704691c53a3dfe6b10e1e71c90636dd78524a54c3f2c50a11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "66f7b4f49e7eb352f9565efc7d223bea17e49648545092f0b747f3e156048b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0f62020dfa03bd38c3ad4dee9d3238321b076aaf79f6d642cbde22433904dceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "454238a25f2d8c5d862f6d9ffbf5b21fde87b893c7511cc2515d478fb00e9465", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c5dd1fab062c3495d21b5e3bb11b17367c8e52f7130519854b70f3ff72f3fb83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a242ec39d98cd01c90ed133b68e73f5d2bcb7a15e8001b7760d0ea0a38e63420", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ac39a8450e5f3ddd47532b6be1c377f5f9618a2fa433362483717f7bf2252ac7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54fc5534af0340a39c899e044621806248a049d046e8a14643b4a55f9c4bdb79", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bcc7958019ae9e38717fb174782d4d89dba667f952c424eaccb6ddbbe99819fe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a885231ab43a68bfb956ce409c6e4eb1fdfc6d8cd04160cdf1ee34e1cfb254ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ff49c1d954725a39cb1a82d7aec366f90e6cb5a212c1c98a3911416efbcacb87", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8da9a0d436a04e599a674866f0bc1654f896eaddaa064e125c713bbd955ece0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "92663605fea62235e345d798be317a67c8b47b7e4caa54688808681df126f201", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b29bfcc5444114f0eece3f4e4e49ddb17626a7a0d1f51581fbd92d9bc890c9a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e4bfb9153b8d025e0a3df8c644d0fd6d2c246728c69bd45d61213b99800eafb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "74c485d4a2707d077040400806a016eb2fa10c0d93bf5d72e361b4ae34aaa005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-original.ppm", + "sha256": "182fd7b16e64d735509dc4bb4a2f71f8b8f68b284a4d2a568b520815624c783f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "873496e312473a4593017485d11639e863c8917f5c6acb6ea5c75b39084deb4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2b2c004f142692c5bdd5050fb3150b450c5f5bd34496d2d92863e8077f335944", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1976cc9fd72dbcb17a7fe1b906e72377f6630a63f08e3f426972976405afa7d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "10a5f08e71a316ee7bb6e4e0f36f4c44594a0800f7315ee4d5bfc128ad3a09c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e73d400f5f3687fd8414e28b802dddab4bc17e0434b0c41274c5b5f294d19220", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91b2ef1b249f19024e007a423f159966c00c2e8f4c474ce43d966acb74c5cf48", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8a86f5b68e9b7e281140bcfb372b9c28805d04f0bbd958486b758bba690ac301", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "716c8a06d2843ecffec70c757a974650e1b0ede11d217f6ad4078f8bcea10835", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "aec21c3a83cb0412a1ac3dfa04a42157c4911f6b0d90c3608910d81fef25f921", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5c86ebfbd4f0ea39cd2083802dde03526fd9666f496620b97d929c03b06a2c30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40176": { @@ -401594,7 +421561,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40176", "family_id": "terrain-40175-40184", "job_id": "terrain-40175-40184", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -401610,6 +421577,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/candidate.json", "sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "8543023fde3b6b84891d01eb451a16fad2addded56c7c2cebe254879b00d2c9f", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.030084+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"40175\\u201340178/4017b/4017c preserve principal rock counts, positions, direction and shadows. Lower40179/4017a join the exact previous40172/40173 into genuine2x2 foliage: annular outer shape, brown clearing and gray/black center feature remain in source regions. More pointed/brighter leaves are disclosed. Cliff entry/corner IDs4017d\\u201340184 retain ground-region boundaries and dark backing.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 f98c2f25a474e99230a8816cf9fc4ce906751bb3468fe746b31711569d047659", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40175", + "40176", + "40177", + "40178" + ], + "sha256": "baf8a618582337dea9958755bd074ecee0a1b107e8bdb5a1bff5601617fdd1a5", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40179", + "4017a", + "4017b", + "4017c" + ], + "sha256": "8af97e923d27551993dc9182cc9a3385ebc7a15a4845f7478ea79acf8bb777e3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4017d", + "4017e", + "4017f", + "40180" + ], + "sha256": "0da99b203d9361afdcefbb09554f5fa2233e119c40b4ae1aaa8ead2e6437743f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40181", + "40182", + "40183", + "40184" + ], + "sha256": "a217bdf6516f93eb9f1e8fbf815e5034b8e6010a94dfc52c5980acb29de4827c", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40175-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0aa5d3c2bfa94a3b5780f2543358d32dea7d1e0fab338173eb5d8dc4ba2867e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fce5b0c52a5c07375e7b8024fd2ca588f3d088a7bb78fd610f4800792af40258", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a9b21fd26f8d4122bf0a0c6fca08455b0f2c447b44fa05b1ad721ba726d2230", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fa59c26521f9c024d932c2ffe7168a951d661c700c7feca073fffd57425818aa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-original.ppm", + "sha256": "282a343dfe124561381ce0b953f1cec731868885e739eca852f90d34a4bb1b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6517863214a17e3d23148b4ecf8a76b983fcc054a29a57016de5c0044fec0701", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "957337b9cbd52d8bff2f5fb70e2155a45a7df7ef0d7cbbdc129c6c798ce83ea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fd0263c80084257e0a7f93375f99c21a5363139cdd45df296e313b328c141f92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "23277e44cdb548031e720e4baea69dca528bd84116ae8f2233c2d43348fa3fd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-original.ppm", + "sha256": "13bfd8b96679f597d574f0595b27fb670417a2aca94d8c368de22d60d26d246c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "557d88897612db5c8586e4a0fd613da184e624a0c15e8d0717a042c482586167", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "554c16a220c02af33c17c862abade23d9ba30b8ece056365a7b363a56683b36f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e126f1292647f8a861cfba270f12185ef0657e1757cf75af7af196c3cc03dc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "86c686822d40526bf80add427720795789fcbff2a7cfb5adc75d9e04af59d292", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-original.ppm", + "sha256": "979d9bccc77d8a54f7a27178a1a6bfe21007edb03bd5fc78cecbb0bc94c20673", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "23ebebde20b9949b061db01f18c5a1eecf471d96c5c058f7e2abd18b3baed259", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a988159f09570a747334ff446aece165dec444bcb68bbb7a47cf1c80d0f584bd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf2e6e5733020a190e73464ceb44ef07d8aa897e588483e8f0e933a6b7cd0ae3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d3f74942ba9e1ee35aad86976773f8cdc3129eed6a1cac35badba032bcbca46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fb41de86fcc764c07ea8a360653f1268e2e6b2d0b8cf2e8201cbc4ce6265952f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0783ab05df05f1dc3596509ff01aac6597d6dd97dea37b7f6aeb8df81db0253a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "033761f83b193348bdf877c3d0b18a01b56eaf257dc817b84e3d8099d8c366bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c5a101874492e6b4193e33ab561d015a9647c81c21d847e96ac5df35ac1b4e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f5f4a69131f1ccb92f9bab73e65dee8624c5fffc419b930fb540c66beb0321", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0cca56783f10f88287ac5780677ae6a286fd3bdf03625be9a47a400f8f912769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85c96cb980ad678f2986943ed4cdd6371375ebfa457e4ced36143acc4a16abc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "29ef10a332c927b7b37aebc455f2ff09abac9d741dce2d464090a87e2e602053", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "40bef7d8b54748e1d7a2699479f3296a567e333b75cbdc0b9a81672f422c3ada", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f8864b5e6d1e427a75bb713c85e3e36c745902b7cd3748b3b590ce260e62c3b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b0669cde458f09abb74261dabfe48cd746b4dca4378ece159317e19cba2d079c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1c6449e26ffdb2085c68600f2241a9dbe0a046e904a55f020a680b6220ae87b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "247892a4eec5e754b1e75600e95bce92423778e95d3aa93582966dc2af0a8c13", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "307cca8dcdeff4e7e29c6da004c552a5a390c8f455c940ad85015784ab44c676", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ae2631cf0e9557c37b7f0e7cd1667a9e41841ae0f0e26a249059c15633dc0a0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0089a7e6524fb6b6dd61e6b895779f446aecfc1f475433d789026cce24da16c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f2b57ad6ee62dcf8617ec64e4fff5bdb5c3f21f79bd3b6e51d93b2a6f27c0c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9381c149b26c515cb867267f203c2e49d8fe09f1ce9c15d98948305a2475ca1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7b0104d96795aa9bc2dab053dbbc69a97de014eb143a41aed2d39ab0d82c8d25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13c6e07a392cf0849ea2638ec922b60ae0779137ab7b4f3045c290a223f8b367", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de884c8dde84b8a799a58611b8a38a847b7ce2e672083c91aa987ab76f7db8a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b224faeea178c3f7bde612f6105db0dc09ad0738b0bcf2f3b5a3b9b6c1c3b0ea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d5d2b5fcdffd8813bc9937ebf0d419e9e6cd74ece4b87f621f6beae740279903", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4321327869426e1dcaa31a7943a0ae1af27f0a913d78be5680ef4d4d44431695", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "60d68af74114d6ec83f6b549a3a22c545fa0468e92cfddf8fb609b1fef3cc625", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7ba09103d7cdaf7f557efc64b20ce741c29ad1af07d87d87518017e90fbbecc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "824a0739065c7471a5dc4d98ca6068784870d1059f1c30c708ba27f67650c9ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "305214fe539963e5e3354660addf3ba2425cef644785c7e73698c944bf8abe99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "97ec1514749eb39695e3d04de0d8841ea60f319713cc255b43a791d9d3fcab38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4c23901aca2608cc6e4c03b31b83de23e924cef5358196a2f3260847ef4add69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d29b2f7c6d934b2040c6f146c3fe1b78f8bd3e438ae4e9ff85acc67a341aed8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5dd4d598fe807ad2a8f291fd93595e494b260c8858af98c5960741e0c7b43ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a32c58da92f7f32e26e30703c86942164cdf3e48f3f29155302f8c73a568673f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e724c789745ff5b797ebc354ce56241ffb3662170a5e1e9e49f5b21f7c4ff023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12ec2879e7b5cac704691c53a3dfe6b10e1e71c90636dd78524a54c3f2c50a11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "66f7b4f49e7eb352f9565efc7d223bea17e49648545092f0b747f3e156048b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0f62020dfa03bd38c3ad4dee9d3238321b076aaf79f6d642cbde22433904dceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "454238a25f2d8c5d862f6d9ffbf5b21fde87b893c7511cc2515d478fb00e9465", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c5dd1fab062c3495d21b5e3bb11b17367c8e52f7130519854b70f3ff72f3fb83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a242ec39d98cd01c90ed133b68e73f5d2bcb7a15e8001b7760d0ea0a38e63420", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ac39a8450e5f3ddd47532b6be1c377f5f9618a2fa433362483717f7bf2252ac7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54fc5534af0340a39c899e044621806248a049d046e8a14643b4a55f9c4bdb79", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bcc7958019ae9e38717fb174782d4d89dba667f952c424eaccb6ddbbe99819fe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a885231ab43a68bfb956ce409c6e4eb1fdfc6d8cd04160cdf1ee34e1cfb254ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ff49c1d954725a39cb1a82d7aec366f90e6cb5a212c1c98a3911416efbcacb87", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8da9a0d436a04e599a674866f0bc1654f896eaddaa064e125c713bbd955ece0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "92663605fea62235e345d798be317a67c8b47b7e4caa54688808681df126f201", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b29bfcc5444114f0eece3f4e4e49ddb17626a7a0d1f51581fbd92d9bc890c9a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e4bfb9153b8d025e0a3df8c644d0fd6d2c246728c69bd45d61213b99800eafb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "74c485d4a2707d077040400806a016eb2fa10c0d93bf5d72e361b4ae34aaa005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-original.ppm", + "sha256": "182fd7b16e64d735509dc4bb4a2f71f8b8f68b284a4d2a568b520815624c783f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "873496e312473a4593017485d11639e863c8917f5c6acb6ea5c75b39084deb4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2b2c004f142692c5bdd5050fb3150b450c5f5bd34496d2d92863e8077f335944", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1976cc9fd72dbcb17a7fe1b906e72377f6630a63f08e3f426972976405afa7d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "10a5f08e71a316ee7bb6e4e0f36f4c44594a0800f7315ee4d5bfc128ad3a09c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e73d400f5f3687fd8414e28b802dddab4bc17e0434b0c41274c5b5f294d19220", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91b2ef1b249f19024e007a423f159966c00c2e8f4c474ce43d966acb74c5cf48", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8a86f5b68e9b7e281140bcfb372b9c28805d04f0bbd958486b758bba690ac301", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "716c8a06d2843ecffec70c757a974650e1b0ede11d217f6ad4078f8bcea10835", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "aec21c3a83cb0412a1ac3dfa04a42157c4911f6b0d90c3608910d81fef25f921", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5c86ebfbd4f0ea39cd2083802dde03526fd9666f496620b97d929c03b06a2c30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40177": { @@ -401631,7 +422068,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40177", "family_id": "terrain-40175-40184", "job_id": "terrain-40175-40184", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -401647,6 +422084,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/candidate.json", "sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "8543023fde3b6b84891d01eb451a16fad2addded56c7c2cebe254879b00d2c9f", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.030084+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"40175\\u201340178/4017b/4017c preserve principal rock counts, positions, direction and shadows. Lower40179/4017a join the exact previous40172/40173 into genuine2x2 foliage: annular outer shape, brown clearing and gray/black center feature remain in source regions. More pointed/brighter leaves are disclosed. Cliff entry/corner IDs4017d\\u201340184 retain ground-region boundaries and dark backing.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 f98c2f25a474e99230a8816cf9fc4ce906751bb3468fe746b31711569d047659", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40175", + "40176", + "40177", + "40178" + ], + "sha256": "baf8a618582337dea9958755bd074ecee0a1b107e8bdb5a1bff5601617fdd1a5", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40179", + "4017a", + "4017b", + "4017c" + ], + "sha256": "8af97e923d27551993dc9182cc9a3385ebc7a15a4845f7478ea79acf8bb777e3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4017d", + "4017e", + "4017f", + "40180" + ], + "sha256": "0da99b203d9361afdcefbb09554f5fa2233e119c40b4ae1aaa8ead2e6437743f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40181", + "40182", + "40183", + "40184" + ], + "sha256": "a217bdf6516f93eb9f1e8fbf815e5034b8e6010a94dfc52c5980acb29de4827c", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40175-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0aa5d3c2bfa94a3b5780f2543358d32dea7d1e0fab338173eb5d8dc4ba2867e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fce5b0c52a5c07375e7b8024fd2ca588f3d088a7bb78fd610f4800792af40258", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a9b21fd26f8d4122bf0a0c6fca08455b0f2c447b44fa05b1ad721ba726d2230", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fa59c26521f9c024d932c2ffe7168a951d661c700c7feca073fffd57425818aa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-original.ppm", + "sha256": "282a343dfe124561381ce0b953f1cec731868885e739eca852f90d34a4bb1b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6517863214a17e3d23148b4ecf8a76b983fcc054a29a57016de5c0044fec0701", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "957337b9cbd52d8bff2f5fb70e2155a45a7df7ef0d7cbbdc129c6c798ce83ea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fd0263c80084257e0a7f93375f99c21a5363139cdd45df296e313b328c141f92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "23277e44cdb548031e720e4baea69dca528bd84116ae8f2233c2d43348fa3fd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-original.ppm", + "sha256": "13bfd8b96679f597d574f0595b27fb670417a2aca94d8c368de22d60d26d246c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "557d88897612db5c8586e4a0fd613da184e624a0c15e8d0717a042c482586167", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "554c16a220c02af33c17c862abade23d9ba30b8ece056365a7b363a56683b36f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e126f1292647f8a861cfba270f12185ef0657e1757cf75af7af196c3cc03dc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "86c686822d40526bf80add427720795789fcbff2a7cfb5adc75d9e04af59d292", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-original.ppm", + "sha256": "979d9bccc77d8a54f7a27178a1a6bfe21007edb03bd5fc78cecbb0bc94c20673", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "23ebebde20b9949b061db01f18c5a1eecf471d96c5c058f7e2abd18b3baed259", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a988159f09570a747334ff446aece165dec444bcb68bbb7a47cf1c80d0f584bd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf2e6e5733020a190e73464ceb44ef07d8aa897e588483e8f0e933a6b7cd0ae3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d3f74942ba9e1ee35aad86976773f8cdc3129eed6a1cac35badba032bcbca46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fb41de86fcc764c07ea8a360653f1268e2e6b2d0b8cf2e8201cbc4ce6265952f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0783ab05df05f1dc3596509ff01aac6597d6dd97dea37b7f6aeb8df81db0253a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "033761f83b193348bdf877c3d0b18a01b56eaf257dc817b84e3d8099d8c366bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c5a101874492e6b4193e33ab561d015a9647c81c21d847e96ac5df35ac1b4e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f5f4a69131f1ccb92f9bab73e65dee8624c5fffc419b930fb540c66beb0321", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0cca56783f10f88287ac5780677ae6a286fd3bdf03625be9a47a400f8f912769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85c96cb980ad678f2986943ed4cdd6371375ebfa457e4ced36143acc4a16abc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "29ef10a332c927b7b37aebc455f2ff09abac9d741dce2d464090a87e2e602053", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "40bef7d8b54748e1d7a2699479f3296a567e333b75cbdc0b9a81672f422c3ada", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f8864b5e6d1e427a75bb713c85e3e36c745902b7cd3748b3b590ce260e62c3b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b0669cde458f09abb74261dabfe48cd746b4dca4378ece159317e19cba2d079c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1c6449e26ffdb2085c68600f2241a9dbe0a046e904a55f020a680b6220ae87b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "247892a4eec5e754b1e75600e95bce92423778e95d3aa93582966dc2af0a8c13", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "307cca8dcdeff4e7e29c6da004c552a5a390c8f455c940ad85015784ab44c676", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ae2631cf0e9557c37b7f0e7cd1667a9e41841ae0f0e26a249059c15633dc0a0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0089a7e6524fb6b6dd61e6b895779f446aecfc1f475433d789026cce24da16c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f2b57ad6ee62dcf8617ec64e4fff5bdb5c3f21f79bd3b6e51d93b2a6f27c0c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9381c149b26c515cb867267f203c2e49d8fe09f1ce9c15d98948305a2475ca1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7b0104d96795aa9bc2dab053dbbc69a97de014eb143a41aed2d39ab0d82c8d25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13c6e07a392cf0849ea2638ec922b60ae0779137ab7b4f3045c290a223f8b367", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de884c8dde84b8a799a58611b8a38a847b7ce2e672083c91aa987ab76f7db8a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b224faeea178c3f7bde612f6105db0dc09ad0738b0bcf2f3b5a3b9b6c1c3b0ea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d5d2b5fcdffd8813bc9937ebf0d419e9e6cd74ece4b87f621f6beae740279903", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4321327869426e1dcaa31a7943a0ae1af27f0a913d78be5680ef4d4d44431695", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "60d68af74114d6ec83f6b549a3a22c545fa0468e92cfddf8fb609b1fef3cc625", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7ba09103d7cdaf7f557efc64b20ce741c29ad1af07d87d87518017e90fbbecc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "824a0739065c7471a5dc4d98ca6068784870d1059f1c30c708ba27f67650c9ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "305214fe539963e5e3354660addf3ba2425cef644785c7e73698c944bf8abe99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "97ec1514749eb39695e3d04de0d8841ea60f319713cc255b43a791d9d3fcab38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4c23901aca2608cc6e4c03b31b83de23e924cef5358196a2f3260847ef4add69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d29b2f7c6d934b2040c6f146c3fe1b78f8bd3e438ae4e9ff85acc67a341aed8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5dd4d598fe807ad2a8f291fd93595e494b260c8858af98c5960741e0c7b43ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a32c58da92f7f32e26e30703c86942164cdf3e48f3f29155302f8c73a568673f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e724c789745ff5b797ebc354ce56241ffb3662170a5e1e9e49f5b21f7c4ff023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12ec2879e7b5cac704691c53a3dfe6b10e1e71c90636dd78524a54c3f2c50a11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "66f7b4f49e7eb352f9565efc7d223bea17e49648545092f0b747f3e156048b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0f62020dfa03bd38c3ad4dee9d3238321b076aaf79f6d642cbde22433904dceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "454238a25f2d8c5d862f6d9ffbf5b21fde87b893c7511cc2515d478fb00e9465", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c5dd1fab062c3495d21b5e3bb11b17367c8e52f7130519854b70f3ff72f3fb83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a242ec39d98cd01c90ed133b68e73f5d2bcb7a15e8001b7760d0ea0a38e63420", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ac39a8450e5f3ddd47532b6be1c377f5f9618a2fa433362483717f7bf2252ac7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54fc5534af0340a39c899e044621806248a049d046e8a14643b4a55f9c4bdb79", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bcc7958019ae9e38717fb174782d4d89dba667f952c424eaccb6ddbbe99819fe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a885231ab43a68bfb956ce409c6e4eb1fdfc6d8cd04160cdf1ee34e1cfb254ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ff49c1d954725a39cb1a82d7aec366f90e6cb5a212c1c98a3911416efbcacb87", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8da9a0d436a04e599a674866f0bc1654f896eaddaa064e125c713bbd955ece0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "92663605fea62235e345d798be317a67c8b47b7e4caa54688808681df126f201", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b29bfcc5444114f0eece3f4e4e49ddb17626a7a0d1f51581fbd92d9bc890c9a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e4bfb9153b8d025e0a3df8c644d0fd6d2c246728c69bd45d61213b99800eafb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "74c485d4a2707d077040400806a016eb2fa10c0d93bf5d72e361b4ae34aaa005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-original.ppm", + "sha256": "182fd7b16e64d735509dc4bb4a2f71f8b8f68b284a4d2a568b520815624c783f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "873496e312473a4593017485d11639e863c8917f5c6acb6ea5c75b39084deb4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2b2c004f142692c5bdd5050fb3150b450c5f5bd34496d2d92863e8077f335944", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1976cc9fd72dbcb17a7fe1b906e72377f6630a63f08e3f426972976405afa7d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "10a5f08e71a316ee7bb6e4e0f36f4c44594a0800f7315ee4d5bfc128ad3a09c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e73d400f5f3687fd8414e28b802dddab4bc17e0434b0c41274c5b5f294d19220", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91b2ef1b249f19024e007a423f159966c00c2e8f4c474ce43d966acb74c5cf48", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8a86f5b68e9b7e281140bcfb372b9c28805d04f0bbd958486b758bba690ac301", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "716c8a06d2843ecffec70c757a974650e1b0ede11d217f6ad4078f8bcea10835", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "aec21c3a83cb0412a1ac3dfa04a42157c4911f6b0d90c3608910d81fef25f921", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5c86ebfbd4f0ea39cd2083802dde03526fd9666f496620b97d929c03b06a2c30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40178": { @@ -401668,7 +422575,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40178", "family_id": "terrain-40175-40184", "job_id": "terrain-40175-40184", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -401684,6 +422591,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/candidate.json", "sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "8543023fde3b6b84891d01eb451a16fad2addded56c7c2cebe254879b00d2c9f", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.030084+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"40175\\u201340178/4017b/4017c preserve principal rock counts, positions, direction and shadows. Lower40179/4017a join the exact previous40172/40173 into genuine2x2 foliage: annular outer shape, brown clearing and gray/black center feature remain in source regions. More pointed/brighter leaves are disclosed. Cliff entry/corner IDs4017d\\u201340184 retain ground-region boundaries and dark backing.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 f98c2f25a474e99230a8816cf9fc4ce906751bb3468fe746b31711569d047659", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40175", + "40176", + "40177", + "40178" + ], + "sha256": "baf8a618582337dea9958755bd074ecee0a1b107e8bdb5a1bff5601617fdd1a5", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40179", + "4017a", + "4017b", + "4017c" + ], + "sha256": "8af97e923d27551993dc9182cc9a3385ebc7a15a4845f7478ea79acf8bb777e3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4017d", + "4017e", + "4017f", + "40180" + ], + "sha256": "0da99b203d9361afdcefbb09554f5fa2233e119c40b4ae1aaa8ead2e6437743f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40181", + "40182", + "40183", + "40184" + ], + "sha256": "a217bdf6516f93eb9f1e8fbf815e5034b8e6010a94dfc52c5980acb29de4827c", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40175-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0aa5d3c2bfa94a3b5780f2543358d32dea7d1e0fab338173eb5d8dc4ba2867e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fce5b0c52a5c07375e7b8024fd2ca588f3d088a7bb78fd610f4800792af40258", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a9b21fd26f8d4122bf0a0c6fca08455b0f2c447b44fa05b1ad721ba726d2230", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fa59c26521f9c024d932c2ffe7168a951d661c700c7feca073fffd57425818aa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-original.ppm", + "sha256": "282a343dfe124561381ce0b953f1cec731868885e739eca852f90d34a4bb1b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6517863214a17e3d23148b4ecf8a76b983fcc054a29a57016de5c0044fec0701", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "957337b9cbd52d8bff2f5fb70e2155a45a7df7ef0d7cbbdc129c6c798ce83ea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fd0263c80084257e0a7f93375f99c21a5363139cdd45df296e313b328c141f92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "23277e44cdb548031e720e4baea69dca528bd84116ae8f2233c2d43348fa3fd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-original.ppm", + "sha256": "13bfd8b96679f597d574f0595b27fb670417a2aca94d8c368de22d60d26d246c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "557d88897612db5c8586e4a0fd613da184e624a0c15e8d0717a042c482586167", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "554c16a220c02af33c17c862abade23d9ba30b8ece056365a7b363a56683b36f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e126f1292647f8a861cfba270f12185ef0657e1757cf75af7af196c3cc03dc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "86c686822d40526bf80add427720795789fcbff2a7cfb5adc75d9e04af59d292", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-original.ppm", + "sha256": "979d9bccc77d8a54f7a27178a1a6bfe21007edb03bd5fc78cecbb0bc94c20673", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "23ebebde20b9949b061db01f18c5a1eecf471d96c5c058f7e2abd18b3baed259", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a988159f09570a747334ff446aece165dec444bcb68bbb7a47cf1c80d0f584bd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf2e6e5733020a190e73464ceb44ef07d8aa897e588483e8f0e933a6b7cd0ae3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d3f74942ba9e1ee35aad86976773f8cdc3129eed6a1cac35badba032bcbca46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fb41de86fcc764c07ea8a360653f1268e2e6b2d0b8cf2e8201cbc4ce6265952f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0783ab05df05f1dc3596509ff01aac6597d6dd97dea37b7f6aeb8df81db0253a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "033761f83b193348bdf877c3d0b18a01b56eaf257dc817b84e3d8099d8c366bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c5a101874492e6b4193e33ab561d015a9647c81c21d847e96ac5df35ac1b4e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f5f4a69131f1ccb92f9bab73e65dee8624c5fffc419b930fb540c66beb0321", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0cca56783f10f88287ac5780677ae6a286fd3bdf03625be9a47a400f8f912769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85c96cb980ad678f2986943ed4cdd6371375ebfa457e4ced36143acc4a16abc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "29ef10a332c927b7b37aebc455f2ff09abac9d741dce2d464090a87e2e602053", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "40bef7d8b54748e1d7a2699479f3296a567e333b75cbdc0b9a81672f422c3ada", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f8864b5e6d1e427a75bb713c85e3e36c745902b7cd3748b3b590ce260e62c3b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b0669cde458f09abb74261dabfe48cd746b4dca4378ece159317e19cba2d079c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1c6449e26ffdb2085c68600f2241a9dbe0a046e904a55f020a680b6220ae87b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "247892a4eec5e754b1e75600e95bce92423778e95d3aa93582966dc2af0a8c13", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "307cca8dcdeff4e7e29c6da004c552a5a390c8f455c940ad85015784ab44c676", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ae2631cf0e9557c37b7f0e7cd1667a9e41841ae0f0e26a249059c15633dc0a0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0089a7e6524fb6b6dd61e6b895779f446aecfc1f475433d789026cce24da16c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f2b57ad6ee62dcf8617ec64e4fff5bdb5c3f21f79bd3b6e51d93b2a6f27c0c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9381c149b26c515cb867267f203c2e49d8fe09f1ce9c15d98948305a2475ca1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7b0104d96795aa9bc2dab053dbbc69a97de014eb143a41aed2d39ab0d82c8d25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13c6e07a392cf0849ea2638ec922b60ae0779137ab7b4f3045c290a223f8b367", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de884c8dde84b8a799a58611b8a38a847b7ce2e672083c91aa987ab76f7db8a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b224faeea178c3f7bde612f6105db0dc09ad0738b0bcf2f3b5a3b9b6c1c3b0ea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d5d2b5fcdffd8813bc9937ebf0d419e9e6cd74ece4b87f621f6beae740279903", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4321327869426e1dcaa31a7943a0ae1af27f0a913d78be5680ef4d4d44431695", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "60d68af74114d6ec83f6b549a3a22c545fa0468e92cfddf8fb609b1fef3cc625", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7ba09103d7cdaf7f557efc64b20ce741c29ad1af07d87d87518017e90fbbecc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "824a0739065c7471a5dc4d98ca6068784870d1059f1c30c708ba27f67650c9ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "305214fe539963e5e3354660addf3ba2425cef644785c7e73698c944bf8abe99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "97ec1514749eb39695e3d04de0d8841ea60f319713cc255b43a791d9d3fcab38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4c23901aca2608cc6e4c03b31b83de23e924cef5358196a2f3260847ef4add69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d29b2f7c6d934b2040c6f146c3fe1b78f8bd3e438ae4e9ff85acc67a341aed8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5dd4d598fe807ad2a8f291fd93595e494b260c8858af98c5960741e0c7b43ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a32c58da92f7f32e26e30703c86942164cdf3e48f3f29155302f8c73a568673f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e724c789745ff5b797ebc354ce56241ffb3662170a5e1e9e49f5b21f7c4ff023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12ec2879e7b5cac704691c53a3dfe6b10e1e71c90636dd78524a54c3f2c50a11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "66f7b4f49e7eb352f9565efc7d223bea17e49648545092f0b747f3e156048b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0f62020dfa03bd38c3ad4dee9d3238321b076aaf79f6d642cbde22433904dceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "454238a25f2d8c5d862f6d9ffbf5b21fde87b893c7511cc2515d478fb00e9465", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c5dd1fab062c3495d21b5e3bb11b17367c8e52f7130519854b70f3ff72f3fb83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a242ec39d98cd01c90ed133b68e73f5d2bcb7a15e8001b7760d0ea0a38e63420", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ac39a8450e5f3ddd47532b6be1c377f5f9618a2fa433362483717f7bf2252ac7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54fc5534af0340a39c899e044621806248a049d046e8a14643b4a55f9c4bdb79", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bcc7958019ae9e38717fb174782d4d89dba667f952c424eaccb6ddbbe99819fe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a885231ab43a68bfb956ce409c6e4eb1fdfc6d8cd04160cdf1ee34e1cfb254ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ff49c1d954725a39cb1a82d7aec366f90e6cb5a212c1c98a3911416efbcacb87", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8da9a0d436a04e599a674866f0bc1654f896eaddaa064e125c713bbd955ece0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "92663605fea62235e345d798be317a67c8b47b7e4caa54688808681df126f201", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b29bfcc5444114f0eece3f4e4e49ddb17626a7a0d1f51581fbd92d9bc890c9a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e4bfb9153b8d025e0a3df8c644d0fd6d2c246728c69bd45d61213b99800eafb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "74c485d4a2707d077040400806a016eb2fa10c0d93bf5d72e361b4ae34aaa005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-original.ppm", + "sha256": "182fd7b16e64d735509dc4bb4a2f71f8b8f68b284a4d2a568b520815624c783f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "873496e312473a4593017485d11639e863c8917f5c6acb6ea5c75b39084deb4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2b2c004f142692c5bdd5050fb3150b450c5f5bd34496d2d92863e8077f335944", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1976cc9fd72dbcb17a7fe1b906e72377f6630a63f08e3f426972976405afa7d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "10a5f08e71a316ee7bb6e4e0f36f4c44594a0800f7315ee4d5bfc128ad3a09c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e73d400f5f3687fd8414e28b802dddab4bc17e0434b0c41274c5b5f294d19220", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91b2ef1b249f19024e007a423f159966c00c2e8f4c474ce43d966acb74c5cf48", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8a86f5b68e9b7e281140bcfb372b9c28805d04f0bbd958486b758bba690ac301", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "716c8a06d2843ecffec70c757a974650e1b0ede11d217f6ad4078f8bcea10835", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "aec21c3a83cb0412a1ac3dfa04a42157c4911f6b0d90c3608910d81fef25f921", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5c86ebfbd4f0ea39cd2083802dde03526fd9666f496620b97d929c03b06a2c30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40179": { @@ -401705,7 +423082,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40179", "family_id": "terrain-40175-40184", "job_id": "terrain-40175-40184", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -401721,6 +423098,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/candidate.json", "sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "8543023fde3b6b84891d01eb451a16fad2addded56c7c2cebe254879b00d2c9f", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.030084+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"40175\\u201340178/4017b/4017c preserve principal rock counts, positions, direction and shadows. Lower40179/4017a join the exact previous40172/40173 into genuine2x2 foliage: annular outer shape, brown clearing and gray/black center feature remain in source regions. More pointed/brighter leaves are disclosed. Cliff entry/corner IDs4017d\\u201340184 retain ground-region boundaries and dark backing.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 f98c2f25a474e99230a8816cf9fc4ce906751bb3468fe746b31711569d047659", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40175", + "40176", + "40177", + "40178" + ], + "sha256": "baf8a618582337dea9958755bd074ecee0a1b107e8bdb5a1bff5601617fdd1a5", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40179", + "4017a", + "4017b", + "4017c" + ], + "sha256": "8af97e923d27551993dc9182cc9a3385ebc7a15a4845f7478ea79acf8bb777e3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4017d", + "4017e", + "4017f", + "40180" + ], + "sha256": "0da99b203d9361afdcefbb09554f5fa2233e119c40b4ae1aaa8ead2e6437743f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40181", + "40182", + "40183", + "40184" + ], + "sha256": "a217bdf6516f93eb9f1e8fbf815e5034b8e6010a94dfc52c5980acb29de4827c", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40175-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0aa5d3c2bfa94a3b5780f2543358d32dea7d1e0fab338173eb5d8dc4ba2867e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fce5b0c52a5c07375e7b8024fd2ca588f3d088a7bb78fd610f4800792af40258", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a9b21fd26f8d4122bf0a0c6fca08455b0f2c447b44fa05b1ad721ba726d2230", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fa59c26521f9c024d932c2ffe7168a951d661c700c7feca073fffd57425818aa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-original.ppm", + "sha256": "282a343dfe124561381ce0b953f1cec731868885e739eca852f90d34a4bb1b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6517863214a17e3d23148b4ecf8a76b983fcc054a29a57016de5c0044fec0701", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "957337b9cbd52d8bff2f5fb70e2155a45a7df7ef0d7cbbdc129c6c798ce83ea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fd0263c80084257e0a7f93375f99c21a5363139cdd45df296e313b328c141f92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "23277e44cdb548031e720e4baea69dca528bd84116ae8f2233c2d43348fa3fd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-original.ppm", + "sha256": "13bfd8b96679f597d574f0595b27fb670417a2aca94d8c368de22d60d26d246c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "557d88897612db5c8586e4a0fd613da184e624a0c15e8d0717a042c482586167", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "554c16a220c02af33c17c862abade23d9ba30b8ece056365a7b363a56683b36f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e126f1292647f8a861cfba270f12185ef0657e1757cf75af7af196c3cc03dc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "86c686822d40526bf80add427720795789fcbff2a7cfb5adc75d9e04af59d292", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-original.ppm", + "sha256": "979d9bccc77d8a54f7a27178a1a6bfe21007edb03bd5fc78cecbb0bc94c20673", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "23ebebde20b9949b061db01f18c5a1eecf471d96c5c058f7e2abd18b3baed259", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a988159f09570a747334ff446aece165dec444bcb68bbb7a47cf1c80d0f584bd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf2e6e5733020a190e73464ceb44ef07d8aa897e588483e8f0e933a6b7cd0ae3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d3f74942ba9e1ee35aad86976773f8cdc3129eed6a1cac35badba032bcbca46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fb41de86fcc764c07ea8a360653f1268e2e6b2d0b8cf2e8201cbc4ce6265952f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0783ab05df05f1dc3596509ff01aac6597d6dd97dea37b7f6aeb8df81db0253a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "033761f83b193348bdf877c3d0b18a01b56eaf257dc817b84e3d8099d8c366bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c5a101874492e6b4193e33ab561d015a9647c81c21d847e96ac5df35ac1b4e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f5f4a69131f1ccb92f9bab73e65dee8624c5fffc419b930fb540c66beb0321", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0cca56783f10f88287ac5780677ae6a286fd3bdf03625be9a47a400f8f912769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85c96cb980ad678f2986943ed4cdd6371375ebfa457e4ced36143acc4a16abc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "29ef10a332c927b7b37aebc455f2ff09abac9d741dce2d464090a87e2e602053", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "40bef7d8b54748e1d7a2699479f3296a567e333b75cbdc0b9a81672f422c3ada", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f8864b5e6d1e427a75bb713c85e3e36c745902b7cd3748b3b590ce260e62c3b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b0669cde458f09abb74261dabfe48cd746b4dca4378ece159317e19cba2d079c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1c6449e26ffdb2085c68600f2241a9dbe0a046e904a55f020a680b6220ae87b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "247892a4eec5e754b1e75600e95bce92423778e95d3aa93582966dc2af0a8c13", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "307cca8dcdeff4e7e29c6da004c552a5a390c8f455c940ad85015784ab44c676", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ae2631cf0e9557c37b7f0e7cd1667a9e41841ae0f0e26a249059c15633dc0a0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0089a7e6524fb6b6dd61e6b895779f446aecfc1f475433d789026cce24da16c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f2b57ad6ee62dcf8617ec64e4fff5bdb5c3f21f79bd3b6e51d93b2a6f27c0c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9381c149b26c515cb867267f203c2e49d8fe09f1ce9c15d98948305a2475ca1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7b0104d96795aa9bc2dab053dbbc69a97de014eb143a41aed2d39ab0d82c8d25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13c6e07a392cf0849ea2638ec922b60ae0779137ab7b4f3045c290a223f8b367", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de884c8dde84b8a799a58611b8a38a847b7ce2e672083c91aa987ab76f7db8a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b224faeea178c3f7bde612f6105db0dc09ad0738b0bcf2f3b5a3b9b6c1c3b0ea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d5d2b5fcdffd8813bc9937ebf0d419e9e6cd74ece4b87f621f6beae740279903", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4321327869426e1dcaa31a7943a0ae1af27f0a913d78be5680ef4d4d44431695", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "60d68af74114d6ec83f6b549a3a22c545fa0468e92cfddf8fb609b1fef3cc625", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7ba09103d7cdaf7f557efc64b20ce741c29ad1af07d87d87518017e90fbbecc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "824a0739065c7471a5dc4d98ca6068784870d1059f1c30c708ba27f67650c9ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "305214fe539963e5e3354660addf3ba2425cef644785c7e73698c944bf8abe99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "97ec1514749eb39695e3d04de0d8841ea60f319713cc255b43a791d9d3fcab38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4c23901aca2608cc6e4c03b31b83de23e924cef5358196a2f3260847ef4add69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d29b2f7c6d934b2040c6f146c3fe1b78f8bd3e438ae4e9ff85acc67a341aed8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5dd4d598fe807ad2a8f291fd93595e494b260c8858af98c5960741e0c7b43ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a32c58da92f7f32e26e30703c86942164cdf3e48f3f29155302f8c73a568673f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e724c789745ff5b797ebc354ce56241ffb3662170a5e1e9e49f5b21f7c4ff023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12ec2879e7b5cac704691c53a3dfe6b10e1e71c90636dd78524a54c3f2c50a11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "66f7b4f49e7eb352f9565efc7d223bea17e49648545092f0b747f3e156048b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0f62020dfa03bd38c3ad4dee9d3238321b076aaf79f6d642cbde22433904dceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "454238a25f2d8c5d862f6d9ffbf5b21fde87b893c7511cc2515d478fb00e9465", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c5dd1fab062c3495d21b5e3bb11b17367c8e52f7130519854b70f3ff72f3fb83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a242ec39d98cd01c90ed133b68e73f5d2bcb7a15e8001b7760d0ea0a38e63420", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ac39a8450e5f3ddd47532b6be1c377f5f9618a2fa433362483717f7bf2252ac7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54fc5534af0340a39c899e044621806248a049d046e8a14643b4a55f9c4bdb79", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bcc7958019ae9e38717fb174782d4d89dba667f952c424eaccb6ddbbe99819fe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a885231ab43a68bfb956ce409c6e4eb1fdfc6d8cd04160cdf1ee34e1cfb254ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ff49c1d954725a39cb1a82d7aec366f90e6cb5a212c1c98a3911416efbcacb87", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8da9a0d436a04e599a674866f0bc1654f896eaddaa064e125c713bbd955ece0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "92663605fea62235e345d798be317a67c8b47b7e4caa54688808681df126f201", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b29bfcc5444114f0eece3f4e4e49ddb17626a7a0d1f51581fbd92d9bc890c9a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e4bfb9153b8d025e0a3df8c644d0fd6d2c246728c69bd45d61213b99800eafb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "74c485d4a2707d077040400806a016eb2fa10c0d93bf5d72e361b4ae34aaa005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-original.ppm", + "sha256": "182fd7b16e64d735509dc4bb4a2f71f8b8f68b284a4d2a568b520815624c783f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "873496e312473a4593017485d11639e863c8917f5c6acb6ea5c75b39084deb4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2b2c004f142692c5bdd5050fb3150b450c5f5bd34496d2d92863e8077f335944", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1976cc9fd72dbcb17a7fe1b906e72377f6630a63f08e3f426972976405afa7d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "10a5f08e71a316ee7bb6e4e0f36f4c44594a0800f7315ee4d5bfc128ad3a09c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e73d400f5f3687fd8414e28b802dddab4bc17e0434b0c41274c5b5f294d19220", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91b2ef1b249f19024e007a423f159966c00c2e8f4c474ce43d966acb74c5cf48", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8a86f5b68e9b7e281140bcfb372b9c28805d04f0bbd958486b758bba690ac301", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "716c8a06d2843ecffec70c757a974650e1b0ede11d217f6ad4078f8bcea10835", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "aec21c3a83cb0412a1ac3dfa04a42157c4911f6b0d90c3608910d81fef25f921", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5c86ebfbd4f0ea39cd2083802dde03526fd9666f496620b97d929c03b06a2c30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4017a": { @@ -401742,7 +423589,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4017a", "family_id": "terrain-40175-40184", "job_id": "terrain-40175-40184", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -401758,6 +423605,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/candidate.json", "sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "8543023fde3b6b84891d01eb451a16fad2addded56c7c2cebe254879b00d2c9f", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.030084+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"40175\\u201340178/4017b/4017c preserve principal rock counts, positions, direction and shadows. Lower40179/4017a join the exact previous40172/40173 into genuine2x2 foliage: annular outer shape, brown clearing and gray/black center feature remain in source regions. More pointed/brighter leaves are disclosed. Cliff entry/corner IDs4017d\\u201340184 retain ground-region boundaries and dark backing.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 f98c2f25a474e99230a8816cf9fc4ce906751bb3468fe746b31711569d047659", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40175", + "40176", + "40177", + "40178" + ], + "sha256": "baf8a618582337dea9958755bd074ecee0a1b107e8bdb5a1bff5601617fdd1a5", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40179", + "4017a", + "4017b", + "4017c" + ], + "sha256": "8af97e923d27551993dc9182cc9a3385ebc7a15a4845f7478ea79acf8bb777e3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4017d", + "4017e", + "4017f", + "40180" + ], + "sha256": "0da99b203d9361afdcefbb09554f5fa2233e119c40b4ae1aaa8ead2e6437743f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40181", + "40182", + "40183", + "40184" + ], + "sha256": "a217bdf6516f93eb9f1e8fbf815e5034b8e6010a94dfc52c5980acb29de4827c", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40175-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0aa5d3c2bfa94a3b5780f2543358d32dea7d1e0fab338173eb5d8dc4ba2867e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fce5b0c52a5c07375e7b8024fd2ca588f3d088a7bb78fd610f4800792af40258", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a9b21fd26f8d4122bf0a0c6fca08455b0f2c447b44fa05b1ad721ba726d2230", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fa59c26521f9c024d932c2ffe7168a951d661c700c7feca073fffd57425818aa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-original.ppm", + "sha256": "282a343dfe124561381ce0b953f1cec731868885e739eca852f90d34a4bb1b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6517863214a17e3d23148b4ecf8a76b983fcc054a29a57016de5c0044fec0701", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "957337b9cbd52d8bff2f5fb70e2155a45a7df7ef0d7cbbdc129c6c798ce83ea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fd0263c80084257e0a7f93375f99c21a5363139cdd45df296e313b328c141f92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "23277e44cdb548031e720e4baea69dca528bd84116ae8f2233c2d43348fa3fd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-original.ppm", + "sha256": "13bfd8b96679f597d574f0595b27fb670417a2aca94d8c368de22d60d26d246c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "557d88897612db5c8586e4a0fd613da184e624a0c15e8d0717a042c482586167", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "554c16a220c02af33c17c862abade23d9ba30b8ece056365a7b363a56683b36f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e126f1292647f8a861cfba270f12185ef0657e1757cf75af7af196c3cc03dc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "86c686822d40526bf80add427720795789fcbff2a7cfb5adc75d9e04af59d292", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-original.ppm", + "sha256": "979d9bccc77d8a54f7a27178a1a6bfe21007edb03bd5fc78cecbb0bc94c20673", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "23ebebde20b9949b061db01f18c5a1eecf471d96c5c058f7e2abd18b3baed259", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a988159f09570a747334ff446aece165dec444bcb68bbb7a47cf1c80d0f584bd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf2e6e5733020a190e73464ceb44ef07d8aa897e588483e8f0e933a6b7cd0ae3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d3f74942ba9e1ee35aad86976773f8cdc3129eed6a1cac35badba032bcbca46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fb41de86fcc764c07ea8a360653f1268e2e6b2d0b8cf2e8201cbc4ce6265952f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0783ab05df05f1dc3596509ff01aac6597d6dd97dea37b7f6aeb8df81db0253a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "033761f83b193348bdf877c3d0b18a01b56eaf257dc817b84e3d8099d8c366bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c5a101874492e6b4193e33ab561d015a9647c81c21d847e96ac5df35ac1b4e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f5f4a69131f1ccb92f9bab73e65dee8624c5fffc419b930fb540c66beb0321", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0cca56783f10f88287ac5780677ae6a286fd3bdf03625be9a47a400f8f912769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85c96cb980ad678f2986943ed4cdd6371375ebfa457e4ced36143acc4a16abc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "29ef10a332c927b7b37aebc455f2ff09abac9d741dce2d464090a87e2e602053", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "40bef7d8b54748e1d7a2699479f3296a567e333b75cbdc0b9a81672f422c3ada", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f8864b5e6d1e427a75bb713c85e3e36c745902b7cd3748b3b590ce260e62c3b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b0669cde458f09abb74261dabfe48cd746b4dca4378ece159317e19cba2d079c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1c6449e26ffdb2085c68600f2241a9dbe0a046e904a55f020a680b6220ae87b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "247892a4eec5e754b1e75600e95bce92423778e95d3aa93582966dc2af0a8c13", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "307cca8dcdeff4e7e29c6da004c552a5a390c8f455c940ad85015784ab44c676", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ae2631cf0e9557c37b7f0e7cd1667a9e41841ae0f0e26a249059c15633dc0a0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0089a7e6524fb6b6dd61e6b895779f446aecfc1f475433d789026cce24da16c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f2b57ad6ee62dcf8617ec64e4fff5bdb5c3f21f79bd3b6e51d93b2a6f27c0c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9381c149b26c515cb867267f203c2e49d8fe09f1ce9c15d98948305a2475ca1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7b0104d96795aa9bc2dab053dbbc69a97de014eb143a41aed2d39ab0d82c8d25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13c6e07a392cf0849ea2638ec922b60ae0779137ab7b4f3045c290a223f8b367", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de884c8dde84b8a799a58611b8a38a847b7ce2e672083c91aa987ab76f7db8a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b224faeea178c3f7bde612f6105db0dc09ad0738b0bcf2f3b5a3b9b6c1c3b0ea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d5d2b5fcdffd8813bc9937ebf0d419e9e6cd74ece4b87f621f6beae740279903", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4321327869426e1dcaa31a7943a0ae1af27f0a913d78be5680ef4d4d44431695", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "60d68af74114d6ec83f6b549a3a22c545fa0468e92cfddf8fb609b1fef3cc625", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7ba09103d7cdaf7f557efc64b20ce741c29ad1af07d87d87518017e90fbbecc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "824a0739065c7471a5dc4d98ca6068784870d1059f1c30c708ba27f67650c9ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "305214fe539963e5e3354660addf3ba2425cef644785c7e73698c944bf8abe99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "97ec1514749eb39695e3d04de0d8841ea60f319713cc255b43a791d9d3fcab38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4c23901aca2608cc6e4c03b31b83de23e924cef5358196a2f3260847ef4add69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d29b2f7c6d934b2040c6f146c3fe1b78f8bd3e438ae4e9ff85acc67a341aed8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5dd4d598fe807ad2a8f291fd93595e494b260c8858af98c5960741e0c7b43ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a32c58da92f7f32e26e30703c86942164cdf3e48f3f29155302f8c73a568673f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e724c789745ff5b797ebc354ce56241ffb3662170a5e1e9e49f5b21f7c4ff023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12ec2879e7b5cac704691c53a3dfe6b10e1e71c90636dd78524a54c3f2c50a11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "66f7b4f49e7eb352f9565efc7d223bea17e49648545092f0b747f3e156048b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0f62020dfa03bd38c3ad4dee9d3238321b076aaf79f6d642cbde22433904dceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "454238a25f2d8c5d862f6d9ffbf5b21fde87b893c7511cc2515d478fb00e9465", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c5dd1fab062c3495d21b5e3bb11b17367c8e52f7130519854b70f3ff72f3fb83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a242ec39d98cd01c90ed133b68e73f5d2bcb7a15e8001b7760d0ea0a38e63420", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ac39a8450e5f3ddd47532b6be1c377f5f9618a2fa433362483717f7bf2252ac7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54fc5534af0340a39c899e044621806248a049d046e8a14643b4a55f9c4bdb79", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bcc7958019ae9e38717fb174782d4d89dba667f952c424eaccb6ddbbe99819fe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a885231ab43a68bfb956ce409c6e4eb1fdfc6d8cd04160cdf1ee34e1cfb254ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ff49c1d954725a39cb1a82d7aec366f90e6cb5a212c1c98a3911416efbcacb87", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8da9a0d436a04e599a674866f0bc1654f896eaddaa064e125c713bbd955ece0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "92663605fea62235e345d798be317a67c8b47b7e4caa54688808681df126f201", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b29bfcc5444114f0eece3f4e4e49ddb17626a7a0d1f51581fbd92d9bc890c9a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e4bfb9153b8d025e0a3df8c644d0fd6d2c246728c69bd45d61213b99800eafb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "74c485d4a2707d077040400806a016eb2fa10c0d93bf5d72e361b4ae34aaa005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-original.ppm", + "sha256": "182fd7b16e64d735509dc4bb4a2f71f8b8f68b284a4d2a568b520815624c783f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "873496e312473a4593017485d11639e863c8917f5c6acb6ea5c75b39084deb4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2b2c004f142692c5bdd5050fb3150b450c5f5bd34496d2d92863e8077f335944", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1976cc9fd72dbcb17a7fe1b906e72377f6630a63f08e3f426972976405afa7d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "10a5f08e71a316ee7bb6e4e0f36f4c44594a0800f7315ee4d5bfc128ad3a09c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e73d400f5f3687fd8414e28b802dddab4bc17e0434b0c41274c5b5f294d19220", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91b2ef1b249f19024e007a423f159966c00c2e8f4c474ce43d966acb74c5cf48", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8a86f5b68e9b7e281140bcfb372b9c28805d04f0bbd958486b758bba690ac301", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "716c8a06d2843ecffec70c757a974650e1b0ede11d217f6ad4078f8bcea10835", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "aec21c3a83cb0412a1ac3dfa04a42157c4911f6b0d90c3608910d81fef25f921", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5c86ebfbd4f0ea39cd2083802dde03526fd9666f496620b97d929c03b06a2c30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4017b": { @@ -401779,7 +424096,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4017b", "family_id": "terrain-40175-40184", "job_id": "terrain-40175-40184", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -401795,6 +424112,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/candidate.json", "sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "8543023fde3b6b84891d01eb451a16fad2addded56c7c2cebe254879b00d2c9f", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.030084+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"40175\\u201340178/4017b/4017c preserve principal rock counts, positions, direction and shadows. Lower40179/4017a join the exact previous40172/40173 into genuine2x2 foliage: annular outer shape, brown clearing and gray/black center feature remain in source regions. More pointed/brighter leaves are disclosed. Cliff entry/corner IDs4017d\\u201340184 retain ground-region boundaries and dark backing.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 f98c2f25a474e99230a8816cf9fc4ce906751bb3468fe746b31711569d047659", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40175", + "40176", + "40177", + "40178" + ], + "sha256": "baf8a618582337dea9958755bd074ecee0a1b107e8bdb5a1bff5601617fdd1a5", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40179", + "4017a", + "4017b", + "4017c" + ], + "sha256": "8af97e923d27551993dc9182cc9a3385ebc7a15a4845f7478ea79acf8bb777e3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4017d", + "4017e", + "4017f", + "40180" + ], + "sha256": "0da99b203d9361afdcefbb09554f5fa2233e119c40b4ae1aaa8ead2e6437743f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40181", + "40182", + "40183", + "40184" + ], + "sha256": "a217bdf6516f93eb9f1e8fbf815e5034b8e6010a94dfc52c5980acb29de4827c", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40175-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0aa5d3c2bfa94a3b5780f2543358d32dea7d1e0fab338173eb5d8dc4ba2867e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fce5b0c52a5c07375e7b8024fd2ca588f3d088a7bb78fd610f4800792af40258", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a9b21fd26f8d4122bf0a0c6fca08455b0f2c447b44fa05b1ad721ba726d2230", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fa59c26521f9c024d932c2ffe7168a951d661c700c7feca073fffd57425818aa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-original.ppm", + "sha256": "282a343dfe124561381ce0b953f1cec731868885e739eca852f90d34a4bb1b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6517863214a17e3d23148b4ecf8a76b983fcc054a29a57016de5c0044fec0701", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "957337b9cbd52d8bff2f5fb70e2155a45a7df7ef0d7cbbdc129c6c798ce83ea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fd0263c80084257e0a7f93375f99c21a5363139cdd45df296e313b328c141f92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "23277e44cdb548031e720e4baea69dca528bd84116ae8f2233c2d43348fa3fd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-original.ppm", + "sha256": "13bfd8b96679f597d574f0595b27fb670417a2aca94d8c368de22d60d26d246c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "557d88897612db5c8586e4a0fd613da184e624a0c15e8d0717a042c482586167", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "554c16a220c02af33c17c862abade23d9ba30b8ece056365a7b363a56683b36f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e126f1292647f8a861cfba270f12185ef0657e1757cf75af7af196c3cc03dc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "86c686822d40526bf80add427720795789fcbff2a7cfb5adc75d9e04af59d292", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-original.ppm", + "sha256": "979d9bccc77d8a54f7a27178a1a6bfe21007edb03bd5fc78cecbb0bc94c20673", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "23ebebde20b9949b061db01f18c5a1eecf471d96c5c058f7e2abd18b3baed259", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a988159f09570a747334ff446aece165dec444bcb68bbb7a47cf1c80d0f584bd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf2e6e5733020a190e73464ceb44ef07d8aa897e588483e8f0e933a6b7cd0ae3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d3f74942ba9e1ee35aad86976773f8cdc3129eed6a1cac35badba032bcbca46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fb41de86fcc764c07ea8a360653f1268e2e6b2d0b8cf2e8201cbc4ce6265952f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0783ab05df05f1dc3596509ff01aac6597d6dd97dea37b7f6aeb8df81db0253a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "033761f83b193348bdf877c3d0b18a01b56eaf257dc817b84e3d8099d8c366bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c5a101874492e6b4193e33ab561d015a9647c81c21d847e96ac5df35ac1b4e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f5f4a69131f1ccb92f9bab73e65dee8624c5fffc419b930fb540c66beb0321", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0cca56783f10f88287ac5780677ae6a286fd3bdf03625be9a47a400f8f912769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85c96cb980ad678f2986943ed4cdd6371375ebfa457e4ced36143acc4a16abc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "29ef10a332c927b7b37aebc455f2ff09abac9d741dce2d464090a87e2e602053", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "40bef7d8b54748e1d7a2699479f3296a567e333b75cbdc0b9a81672f422c3ada", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f8864b5e6d1e427a75bb713c85e3e36c745902b7cd3748b3b590ce260e62c3b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b0669cde458f09abb74261dabfe48cd746b4dca4378ece159317e19cba2d079c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1c6449e26ffdb2085c68600f2241a9dbe0a046e904a55f020a680b6220ae87b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "247892a4eec5e754b1e75600e95bce92423778e95d3aa93582966dc2af0a8c13", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "307cca8dcdeff4e7e29c6da004c552a5a390c8f455c940ad85015784ab44c676", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ae2631cf0e9557c37b7f0e7cd1667a9e41841ae0f0e26a249059c15633dc0a0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0089a7e6524fb6b6dd61e6b895779f446aecfc1f475433d789026cce24da16c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f2b57ad6ee62dcf8617ec64e4fff5bdb5c3f21f79bd3b6e51d93b2a6f27c0c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9381c149b26c515cb867267f203c2e49d8fe09f1ce9c15d98948305a2475ca1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7b0104d96795aa9bc2dab053dbbc69a97de014eb143a41aed2d39ab0d82c8d25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13c6e07a392cf0849ea2638ec922b60ae0779137ab7b4f3045c290a223f8b367", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de884c8dde84b8a799a58611b8a38a847b7ce2e672083c91aa987ab76f7db8a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b224faeea178c3f7bde612f6105db0dc09ad0738b0bcf2f3b5a3b9b6c1c3b0ea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d5d2b5fcdffd8813bc9937ebf0d419e9e6cd74ece4b87f621f6beae740279903", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4321327869426e1dcaa31a7943a0ae1af27f0a913d78be5680ef4d4d44431695", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "60d68af74114d6ec83f6b549a3a22c545fa0468e92cfddf8fb609b1fef3cc625", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7ba09103d7cdaf7f557efc64b20ce741c29ad1af07d87d87518017e90fbbecc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "824a0739065c7471a5dc4d98ca6068784870d1059f1c30c708ba27f67650c9ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "305214fe539963e5e3354660addf3ba2425cef644785c7e73698c944bf8abe99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "97ec1514749eb39695e3d04de0d8841ea60f319713cc255b43a791d9d3fcab38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4c23901aca2608cc6e4c03b31b83de23e924cef5358196a2f3260847ef4add69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d29b2f7c6d934b2040c6f146c3fe1b78f8bd3e438ae4e9ff85acc67a341aed8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5dd4d598fe807ad2a8f291fd93595e494b260c8858af98c5960741e0c7b43ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a32c58da92f7f32e26e30703c86942164cdf3e48f3f29155302f8c73a568673f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e724c789745ff5b797ebc354ce56241ffb3662170a5e1e9e49f5b21f7c4ff023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12ec2879e7b5cac704691c53a3dfe6b10e1e71c90636dd78524a54c3f2c50a11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "66f7b4f49e7eb352f9565efc7d223bea17e49648545092f0b747f3e156048b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0f62020dfa03bd38c3ad4dee9d3238321b076aaf79f6d642cbde22433904dceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "454238a25f2d8c5d862f6d9ffbf5b21fde87b893c7511cc2515d478fb00e9465", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c5dd1fab062c3495d21b5e3bb11b17367c8e52f7130519854b70f3ff72f3fb83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a242ec39d98cd01c90ed133b68e73f5d2bcb7a15e8001b7760d0ea0a38e63420", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ac39a8450e5f3ddd47532b6be1c377f5f9618a2fa433362483717f7bf2252ac7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54fc5534af0340a39c899e044621806248a049d046e8a14643b4a55f9c4bdb79", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bcc7958019ae9e38717fb174782d4d89dba667f952c424eaccb6ddbbe99819fe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a885231ab43a68bfb956ce409c6e4eb1fdfc6d8cd04160cdf1ee34e1cfb254ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ff49c1d954725a39cb1a82d7aec366f90e6cb5a212c1c98a3911416efbcacb87", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8da9a0d436a04e599a674866f0bc1654f896eaddaa064e125c713bbd955ece0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "92663605fea62235e345d798be317a67c8b47b7e4caa54688808681df126f201", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b29bfcc5444114f0eece3f4e4e49ddb17626a7a0d1f51581fbd92d9bc890c9a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e4bfb9153b8d025e0a3df8c644d0fd6d2c246728c69bd45d61213b99800eafb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "74c485d4a2707d077040400806a016eb2fa10c0d93bf5d72e361b4ae34aaa005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-original.ppm", + "sha256": "182fd7b16e64d735509dc4bb4a2f71f8b8f68b284a4d2a568b520815624c783f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "873496e312473a4593017485d11639e863c8917f5c6acb6ea5c75b39084deb4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2b2c004f142692c5bdd5050fb3150b450c5f5bd34496d2d92863e8077f335944", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1976cc9fd72dbcb17a7fe1b906e72377f6630a63f08e3f426972976405afa7d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "10a5f08e71a316ee7bb6e4e0f36f4c44594a0800f7315ee4d5bfc128ad3a09c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e73d400f5f3687fd8414e28b802dddab4bc17e0434b0c41274c5b5f294d19220", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91b2ef1b249f19024e007a423f159966c00c2e8f4c474ce43d966acb74c5cf48", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8a86f5b68e9b7e281140bcfb372b9c28805d04f0bbd958486b758bba690ac301", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "716c8a06d2843ecffec70c757a974650e1b0ede11d217f6ad4078f8bcea10835", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "aec21c3a83cb0412a1ac3dfa04a42157c4911f6b0d90c3608910d81fef25f921", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5c86ebfbd4f0ea39cd2083802dde03526fd9666f496620b97d929c03b06a2c30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4017c": { @@ -401816,7 +424603,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4017c", "family_id": "terrain-40175-40184", "job_id": "terrain-40175-40184", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -401832,6 +424619,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/candidate.json", "sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "8543023fde3b6b84891d01eb451a16fad2addded56c7c2cebe254879b00d2c9f", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.030084+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"40175\\u201340178/4017b/4017c preserve principal rock counts, positions, direction and shadows. Lower40179/4017a join the exact previous40172/40173 into genuine2x2 foliage: annular outer shape, brown clearing and gray/black center feature remain in source regions. More pointed/brighter leaves are disclosed. Cliff entry/corner IDs4017d\\u201340184 retain ground-region boundaries and dark backing.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 f98c2f25a474e99230a8816cf9fc4ce906751bb3468fe746b31711569d047659", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40175", + "40176", + "40177", + "40178" + ], + "sha256": "baf8a618582337dea9958755bd074ecee0a1b107e8bdb5a1bff5601617fdd1a5", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40179", + "4017a", + "4017b", + "4017c" + ], + "sha256": "8af97e923d27551993dc9182cc9a3385ebc7a15a4845f7478ea79acf8bb777e3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4017d", + "4017e", + "4017f", + "40180" + ], + "sha256": "0da99b203d9361afdcefbb09554f5fa2233e119c40b4ae1aaa8ead2e6437743f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40181", + "40182", + "40183", + "40184" + ], + "sha256": "a217bdf6516f93eb9f1e8fbf815e5034b8e6010a94dfc52c5980acb29de4827c", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40175-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0aa5d3c2bfa94a3b5780f2543358d32dea7d1e0fab338173eb5d8dc4ba2867e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fce5b0c52a5c07375e7b8024fd2ca588f3d088a7bb78fd610f4800792af40258", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a9b21fd26f8d4122bf0a0c6fca08455b0f2c447b44fa05b1ad721ba726d2230", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fa59c26521f9c024d932c2ffe7168a951d661c700c7feca073fffd57425818aa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-original.ppm", + "sha256": "282a343dfe124561381ce0b953f1cec731868885e739eca852f90d34a4bb1b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6517863214a17e3d23148b4ecf8a76b983fcc054a29a57016de5c0044fec0701", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "957337b9cbd52d8bff2f5fb70e2155a45a7df7ef0d7cbbdc129c6c798ce83ea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fd0263c80084257e0a7f93375f99c21a5363139cdd45df296e313b328c141f92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "23277e44cdb548031e720e4baea69dca528bd84116ae8f2233c2d43348fa3fd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-original.ppm", + "sha256": "13bfd8b96679f597d574f0595b27fb670417a2aca94d8c368de22d60d26d246c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "557d88897612db5c8586e4a0fd613da184e624a0c15e8d0717a042c482586167", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "554c16a220c02af33c17c862abade23d9ba30b8ece056365a7b363a56683b36f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e126f1292647f8a861cfba270f12185ef0657e1757cf75af7af196c3cc03dc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "86c686822d40526bf80add427720795789fcbff2a7cfb5adc75d9e04af59d292", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-original.ppm", + "sha256": "979d9bccc77d8a54f7a27178a1a6bfe21007edb03bd5fc78cecbb0bc94c20673", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "23ebebde20b9949b061db01f18c5a1eecf471d96c5c058f7e2abd18b3baed259", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a988159f09570a747334ff446aece165dec444bcb68bbb7a47cf1c80d0f584bd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf2e6e5733020a190e73464ceb44ef07d8aa897e588483e8f0e933a6b7cd0ae3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d3f74942ba9e1ee35aad86976773f8cdc3129eed6a1cac35badba032bcbca46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fb41de86fcc764c07ea8a360653f1268e2e6b2d0b8cf2e8201cbc4ce6265952f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0783ab05df05f1dc3596509ff01aac6597d6dd97dea37b7f6aeb8df81db0253a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "033761f83b193348bdf877c3d0b18a01b56eaf257dc817b84e3d8099d8c366bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c5a101874492e6b4193e33ab561d015a9647c81c21d847e96ac5df35ac1b4e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f5f4a69131f1ccb92f9bab73e65dee8624c5fffc419b930fb540c66beb0321", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0cca56783f10f88287ac5780677ae6a286fd3bdf03625be9a47a400f8f912769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85c96cb980ad678f2986943ed4cdd6371375ebfa457e4ced36143acc4a16abc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "29ef10a332c927b7b37aebc455f2ff09abac9d741dce2d464090a87e2e602053", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "40bef7d8b54748e1d7a2699479f3296a567e333b75cbdc0b9a81672f422c3ada", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f8864b5e6d1e427a75bb713c85e3e36c745902b7cd3748b3b590ce260e62c3b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b0669cde458f09abb74261dabfe48cd746b4dca4378ece159317e19cba2d079c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1c6449e26ffdb2085c68600f2241a9dbe0a046e904a55f020a680b6220ae87b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "247892a4eec5e754b1e75600e95bce92423778e95d3aa93582966dc2af0a8c13", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "307cca8dcdeff4e7e29c6da004c552a5a390c8f455c940ad85015784ab44c676", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ae2631cf0e9557c37b7f0e7cd1667a9e41841ae0f0e26a249059c15633dc0a0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0089a7e6524fb6b6dd61e6b895779f446aecfc1f475433d789026cce24da16c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f2b57ad6ee62dcf8617ec64e4fff5bdb5c3f21f79bd3b6e51d93b2a6f27c0c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9381c149b26c515cb867267f203c2e49d8fe09f1ce9c15d98948305a2475ca1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7b0104d96795aa9bc2dab053dbbc69a97de014eb143a41aed2d39ab0d82c8d25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13c6e07a392cf0849ea2638ec922b60ae0779137ab7b4f3045c290a223f8b367", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de884c8dde84b8a799a58611b8a38a847b7ce2e672083c91aa987ab76f7db8a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b224faeea178c3f7bde612f6105db0dc09ad0738b0bcf2f3b5a3b9b6c1c3b0ea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d5d2b5fcdffd8813bc9937ebf0d419e9e6cd74ece4b87f621f6beae740279903", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4321327869426e1dcaa31a7943a0ae1af27f0a913d78be5680ef4d4d44431695", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "60d68af74114d6ec83f6b549a3a22c545fa0468e92cfddf8fb609b1fef3cc625", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7ba09103d7cdaf7f557efc64b20ce741c29ad1af07d87d87518017e90fbbecc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "824a0739065c7471a5dc4d98ca6068784870d1059f1c30c708ba27f67650c9ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "305214fe539963e5e3354660addf3ba2425cef644785c7e73698c944bf8abe99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "97ec1514749eb39695e3d04de0d8841ea60f319713cc255b43a791d9d3fcab38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4c23901aca2608cc6e4c03b31b83de23e924cef5358196a2f3260847ef4add69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d29b2f7c6d934b2040c6f146c3fe1b78f8bd3e438ae4e9ff85acc67a341aed8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5dd4d598fe807ad2a8f291fd93595e494b260c8858af98c5960741e0c7b43ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a32c58da92f7f32e26e30703c86942164cdf3e48f3f29155302f8c73a568673f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e724c789745ff5b797ebc354ce56241ffb3662170a5e1e9e49f5b21f7c4ff023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12ec2879e7b5cac704691c53a3dfe6b10e1e71c90636dd78524a54c3f2c50a11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "66f7b4f49e7eb352f9565efc7d223bea17e49648545092f0b747f3e156048b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0f62020dfa03bd38c3ad4dee9d3238321b076aaf79f6d642cbde22433904dceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "454238a25f2d8c5d862f6d9ffbf5b21fde87b893c7511cc2515d478fb00e9465", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c5dd1fab062c3495d21b5e3bb11b17367c8e52f7130519854b70f3ff72f3fb83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a242ec39d98cd01c90ed133b68e73f5d2bcb7a15e8001b7760d0ea0a38e63420", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ac39a8450e5f3ddd47532b6be1c377f5f9618a2fa433362483717f7bf2252ac7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54fc5534af0340a39c899e044621806248a049d046e8a14643b4a55f9c4bdb79", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bcc7958019ae9e38717fb174782d4d89dba667f952c424eaccb6ddbbe99819fe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a885231ab43a68bfb956ce409c6e4eb1fdfc6d8cd04160cdf1ee34e1cfb254ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ff49c1d954725a39cb1a82d7aec366f90e6cb5a212c1c98a3911416efbcacb87", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8da9a0d436a04e599a674866f0bc1654f896eaddaa064e125c713bbd955ece0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "92663605fea62235e345d798be317a67c8b47b7e4caa54688808681df126f201", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b29bfcc5444114f0eece3f4e4e49ddb17626a7a0d1f51581fbd92d9bc890c9a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e4bfb9153b8d025e0a3df8c644d0fd6d2c246728c69bd45d61213b99800eafb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "74c485d4a2707d077040400806a016eb2fa10c0d93bf5d72e361b4ae34aaa005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-original.ppm", + "sha256": "182fd7b16e64d735509dc4bb4a2f71f8b8f68b284a4d2a568b520815624c783f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "873496e312473a4593017485d11639e863c8917f5c6acb6ea5c75b39084deb4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2b2c004f142692c5bdd5050fb3150b450c5f5bd34496d2d92863e8077f335944", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1976cc9fd72dbcb17a7fe1b906e72377f6630a63f08e3f426972976405afa7d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "10a5f08e71a316ee7bb6e4e0f36f4c44594a0800f7315ee4d5bfc128ad3a09c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e73d400f5f3687fd8414e28b802dddab4bc17e0434b0c41274c5b5f294d19220", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91b2ef1b249f19024e007a423f159966c00c2e8f4c474ce43d966acb74c5cf48", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8a86f5b68e9b7e281140bcfb372b9c28805d04f0bbd958486b758bba690ac301", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "716c8a06d2843ecffec70c757a974650e1b0ede11d217f6ad4078f8bcea10835", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "aec21c3a83cb0412a1ac3dfa04a42157c4911f6b0d90c3608910d81fef25f921", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5c86ebfbd4f0ea39cd2083802dde03526fd9666f496620b97d929c03b06a2c30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4017d": { @@ -401853,7 +425110,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4017d", "family_id": "terrain-40175-40184", "job_id": "terrain-40175-40184", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -401869,6 +425126,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/candidate.json", "sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "8543023fde3b6b84891d01eb451a16fad2addded56c7c2cebe254879b00d2c9f", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.030084+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"40175\\u201340178/4017b/4017c preserve principal rock counts, positions, direction and shadows. Lower40179/4017a join the exact previous40172/40173 into genuine2x2 foliage: annular outer shape, brown clearing and gray/black center feature remain in source regions. More pointed/brighter leaves are disclosed. Cliff entry/corner IDs4017d\\u201340184 retain ground-region boundaries and dark backing.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 f98c2f25a474e99230a8816cf9fc4ce906751bb3468fe746b31711569d047659", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40175", + "40176", + "40177", + "40178" + ], + "sha256": "baf8a618582337dea9958755bd074ecee0a1b107e8bdb5a1bff5601617fdd1a5", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40179", + "4017a", + "4017b", + "4017c" + ], + "sha256": "8af97e923d27551993dc9182cc9a3385ebc7a15a4845f7478ea79acf8bb777e3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4017d", + "4017e", + "4017f", + "40180" + ], + "sha256": "0da99b203d9361afdcefbb09554f5fa2233e119c40b4ae1aaa8ead2e6437743f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40181", + "40182", + "40183", + "40184" + ], + "sha256": "a217bdf6516f93eb9f1e8fbf815e5034b8e6010a94dfc52c5980acb29de4827c", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40175-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0aa5d3c2bfa94a3b5780f2543358d32dea7d1e0fab338173eb5d8dc4ba2867e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fce5b0c52a5c07375e7b8024fd2ca588f3d088a7bb78fd610f4800792af40258", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a9b21fd26f8d4122bf0a0c6fca08455b0f2c447b44fa05b1ad721ba726d2230", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fa59c26521f9c024d932c2ffe7168a951d661c700c7feca073fffd57425818aa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-original.ppm", + "sha256": "282a343dfe124561381ce0b953f1cec731868885e739eca852f90d34a4bb1b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6517863214a17e3d23148b4ecf8a76b983fcc054a29a57016de5c0044fec0701", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "957337b9cbd52d8bff2f5fb70e2155a45a7df7ef0d7cbbdc129c6c798ce83ea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fd0263c80084257e0a7f93375f99c21a5363139cdd45df296e313b328c141f92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "23277e44cdb548031e720e4baea69dca528bd84116ae8f2233c2d43348fa3fd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-original.ppm", + "sha256": "13bfd8b96679f597d574f0595b27fb670417a2aca94d8c368de22d60d26d246c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "557d88897612db5c8586e4a0fd613da184e624a0c15e8d0717a042c482586167", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "554c16a220c02af33c17c862abade23d9ba30b8ece056365a7b363a56683b36f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e126f1292647f8a861cfba270f12185ef0657e1757cf75af7af196c3cc03dc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "86c686822d40526bf80add427720795789fcbff2a7cfb5adc75d9e04af59d292", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-original.ppm", + "sha256": "979d9bccc77d8a54f7a27178a1a6bfe21007edb03bd5fc78cecbb0bc94c20673", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "23ebebde20b9949b061db01f18c5a1eecf471d96c5c058f7e2abd18b3baed259", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a988159f09570a747334ff446aece165dec444bcb68bbb7a47cf1c80d0f584bd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf2e6e5733020a190e73464ceb44ef07d8aa897e588483e8f0e933a6b7cd0ae3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d3f74942ba9e1ee35aad86976773f8cdc3129eed6a1cac35badba032bcbca46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fb41de86fcc764c07ea8a360653f1268e2e6b2d0b8cf2e8201cbc4ce6265952f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0783ab05df05f1dc3596509ff01aac6597d6dd97dea37b7f6aeb8df81db0253a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "033761f83b193348bdf877c3d0b18a01b56eaf257dc817b84e3d8099d8c366bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c5a101874492e6b4193e33ab561d015a9647c81c21d847e96ac5df35ac1b4e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f5f4a69131f1ccb92f9bab73e65dee8624c5fffc419b930fb540c66beb0321", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0cca56783f10f88287ac5780677ae6a286fd3bdf03625be9a47a400f8f912769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85c96cb980ad678f2986943ed4cdd6371375ebfa457e4ced36143acc4a16abc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "29ef10a332c927b7b37aebc455f2ff09abac9d741dce2d464090a87e2e602053", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "40bef7d8b54748e1d7a2699479f3296a567e333b75cbdc0b9a81672f422c3ada", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f8864b5e6d1e427a75bb713c85e3e36c745902b7cd3748b3b590ce260e62c3b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b0669cde458f09abb74261dabfe48cd746b4dca4378ece159317e19cba2d079c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1c6449e26ffdb2085c68600f2241a9dbe0a046e904a55f020a680b6220ae87b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "247892a4eec5e754b1e75600e95bce92423778e95d3aa93582966dc2af0a8c13", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "307cca8dcdeff4e7e29c6da004c552a5a390c8f455c940ad85015784ab44c676", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ae2631cf0e9557c37b7f0e7cd1667a9e41841ae0f0e26a249059c15633dc0a0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0089a7e6524fb6b6dd61e6b895779f446aecfc1f475433d789026cce24da16c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f2b57ad6ee62dcf8617ec64e4fff5bdb5c3f21f79bd3b6e51d93b2a6f27c0c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9381c149b26c515cb867267f203c2e49d8fe09f1ce9c15d98948305a2475ca1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7b0104d96795aa9bc2dab053dbbc69a97de014eb143a41aed2d39ab0d82c8d25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13c6e07a392cf0849ea2638ec922b60ae0779137ab7b4f3045c290a223f8b367", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de884c8dde84b8a799a58611b8a38a847b7ce2e672083c91aa987ab76f7db8a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b224faeea178c3f7bde612f6105db0dc09ad0738b0bcf2f3b5a3b9b6c1c3b0ea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d5d2b5fcdffd8813bc9937ebf0d419e9e6cd74ece4b87f621f6beae740279903", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4321327869426e1dcaa31a7943a0ae1af27f0a913d78be5680ef4d4d44431695", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "60d68af74114d6ec83f6b549a3a22c545fa0468e92cfddf8fb609b1fef3cc625", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7ba09103d7cdaf7f557efc64b20ce741c29ad1af07d87d87518017e90fbbecc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "824a0739065c7471a5dc4d98ca6068784870d1059f1c30c708ba27f67650c9ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "305214fe539963e5e3354660addf3ba2425cef644785c7e73698c944bf8abe99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "97ec1514749eb39695e3d04de0d8841ea60f319713cc255b43a791d9d3fcab38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4c23901aca2608cc6e4c03b31b83de23e924cef5358196a2f3260847ef4add69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d29b2f7c6d934b2040c6f146c3fe1b78f8bd3e438ae4e9ff85acc67a341aed8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5dd4d598fe807ad2a8f291fd93595e494b260c8858af98c5960741e0c7b43ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a32c58da92f7f32e26e30703c86942164cdf3e48f3f29155302f8c73a568673f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e724c789745ff5b797ebc354ce56241ffb3662170a5e1e9e49f5b21f7c4ff023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12ec2879e7b5cac704691c53a3dfe6b10e1e71c90636dd78524a54c3f2c50a11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "66f7b4f49e7eb352f9565efc7d223bea17e49648545092f0b747f3e156048b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0f62020dfa03bd38c3ad4dee9d3238321b076aaf79f6d642cbde22433904dceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "454238a25f2d8c5d862f6d9ffbf5b21fde87b893c7511cc2515d478fb00e9465", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c5dd1fab062c3495d21b5e3bb11b17367c8e52f7130519854b70f3ff72f3fb83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a242ec39d98cd01c90ed133b68e73f5d2bcb7a15e8001b7760d0ea0a38e63420", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ac39a8450e5f3ddd47532b6be1c377f5f9618a2fa433362483717f7bf2252ac7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54fc5534af0340a39c899e044621806248a049d046e8a14643b4a55f9c4bdb79", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bcc7958019ae9e38717fb174782d4d89dba667f952c424eaccb6ddbbe99819fe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a885231ab43a68bfb956ce409c6e4eb1fdfc6d8cd04160cdf1ee34e1cfb254ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ff49c1d954725a39cb1a82d7aec366f90e6cb5a212c1c98a3911416efbcacb87", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8da9a0d436a04e599a674866f0bc1654f896eaddaa064e125c713bbd955ece0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "92663605fea62235e345d798be317a67c8b47b7e4caa54688808681df126f201", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b29bfcc5444114f0eece3f4e4e49ddb17626a7a0d1f51581fbd92d9bc890c9a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e4bfb9153b8d025e0a3df8c644d0fd6d2c246728c69bd45d61213b99800eafb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "74c485d4a2707d077040400806a016eb2fa10c0d93bf5d72e361b4ae34aaa005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-original.ppm", + "sha256": "182fd7b16e64d735509dc4bb4a2f71f8b8f68b284a4d2a568b520815624c783f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "873496e312473a4593017485d11639e863c8917f5c6acb6ea5c75b39084deb4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2b2c004f142692c5bdd5050fb3150b450c5f5bd34496d2d92863e8077f335944", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1976cc9fd72dbcb17a7fe1b906e72377f6630a63f08e3f426972976405afa7d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "10a5f08e71a316ee7bb6e4e0f36f4c44594a0800f7315ee4d5bfc128ad3a09c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e73d400f5f3687fd8414e28b802dddab4bc17e0434b0c41274c5b5f294d19220", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91b2ef1b249f19024e007a423f159966c00c2e8f4c474ce43d966acb74c5cf48", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8a86f5b68e9b7e281140bcfb372b9c28805d04f0bbd958486b758bba690ac301", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "716c8a06d2843ecffec70c757a974650e1b0ede11d217f6ad4078f8bcea10835", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "aec21c3a83cb0412a1ac3dfa04a42157c4911f6b0d90c3608910d81fef25f921", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5c86ebfbd4f0ea39cd2083802dde03526fd9666f496620b97d929c03b06a2c30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4017e": { @@ -401890,7 +425617,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4017e", "family_id": "terrain-40175-40184", "job_id": "terrain-40175-40184", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -401906,6 +425633,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/candidate.json", "sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "8543023fde3b6b84891d01eb451a16fad2addded56c7c2cebe254879b00d2c9f", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.030084+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"40175\\u201340178/4017b/4017c preserve principal rock counts, positions, direction and shadows. Lower40179/4017a join the exact previous40172/40173 into genuine2x2 foliage: annular outer shape, brown clearing and gray/black center feature remain in source regions. More pointed/brighter leaves are disclosed. Cliff entry/corner IDs4017d\\u201340184 retain ground-region boundaries and dark backing.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 f98c2f25a474e99230a8816cf9fc4ce906751bb3468fe746b31711569d047659", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40175", + "40176", + "40177", + "40178" + ], + "sha256": "baf8a618582337dea9958755bd074ecee0a1b107e8bdb5a1bff5601617fdd1a5", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40179", + "4017a", + "4017b", + "4017c" + ], + "sha256": "8af97e923d27551993dc9182cc9a3385ebc7a15a4845f7478ea79acf8bb777e3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4017d", + "4017e", + "4017f", + "40180" + ], + "sha256": "0da99b203d9361afdcefbb09554f5fa2233e119c40b4ae1aaa8ead2e6437743f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40181", + "40182", + "40183", + "40184" + ], + "sha256": "a217bdf6516f93eb9f1e8fbf815e5034b8e6010a94dfc52c5980acb29de4827c", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40175-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0aa5d3c2bfa94a3b5780f2543358d32dea7d1e0fab338173eb5d8dc4ba2867e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fce5b0c52a5c07375e7b8024fd2ca588f3d088a7bb78fd610f4800792af40258", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a9b21fd26f8d4122bf0a0c6fca08455b0f2c447b44fa05b1ad721ba726d2230", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fa59c26521f9c024d932c2ffe7168a951d661c700c7feca073fffd57425818aa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-original.ppm", + "sha256": "282a343dfe124561381ce0b953f1cec731868885e739eca852f90d34a4bb1b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6517863214a17e3d23148b4ecf8a76b983fcc054a29a57016de5c0044fec0701", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "957337b9cbd52d8bff2f5fb70e2155a45a7df7ef0d7cbbdc129c6c798ce83ea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fd0263c80084257e0a7f93375f99c21a5363139cdd45df296e313b328c141f92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "23277e44cdb548031e720e4baea69dca528bd84116ae8f2233c2d43348fa3fd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-original.ppm", + "sha256": "13bfd8b96679f597d574f0595b27fb670417a2aca94d8c368de22d60d26d246c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "557d88897612db5c8586e4a0fd613da184e624a0c15e8d0717a042c482586167", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "554c16a220c02af33c17c862abade23d9ba30b8ece056365a7b363a56683b36f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e126f1292647f8a861cfba270f12185ef0657e1757cf75af7af196c3cc03dc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "86c686822d40526bf80add427720795789fcbff2a7cfb5adc75d9e04af59d292", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-original.ppm", + "sha256": "979d9bccc77d8a54f7a27178a1a6bfe21007edb03bd5fc78cecbb0bc94c20673", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "23ebebde20b9949b061db01f18c5a1eecf471d96c5c058f7e2abd18b3baed259", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a988159f09570a747334ff446aece165dec444bcb68bbb7a47cf1c80d0f584bd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf2e6e5733020a190e73464ceb44ef07d8aa897e588483e8f0e933a6b7cd0ae3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d3f74942ba9e1ee35aad86976773f8cdc3129eed6a1cac35badba032bcbca46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fb41de86fcc764c07ea8a360653f1268e2e6b2d0b8cf2e8201cbc4ce6265952f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0783ab05df05f1dc3596509ff01aac6597d6dd97dea37b7f6aeb8df81db0253a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "033761f83b193348bdf877c3d0b18a01b56eaf257dc817b84e3d8099d8c366bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c5a101874492e6b4193e33ab561d015a9647c81c21d847e96ac5df35ac1b4e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f5f4a69131f1ccb92f9bab73e65dee8624c5fffc419b930fb540c66beb0321", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0cca56783f10f88287ac5780677ae6a286fd3bdf03625be9a47a400f8f912769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85c96cb980ad678f2986943ed4cdd6371375ebfa457e4ced36143acc4a16abc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "29ef10a332c927b7b37aebc455f2ff09abac9d741dce2d464090a87e2e602053", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "40bef7d8b54748e1d7a2699479f3296a567e333b75cbdc0b9a81672f422c3ada", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f8864b5e6d1e427a75bb713c85e3e36c745902b7cd3748b3b590ce260e62c3b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b0669cde458f09abb74261dabfe48cd746b4dca4378ece159317e19cba2d079c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1c6449e26ffdb2085c68600f2241a9dbe0a046e904a55f020a680b6220ae87b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "247892a4eec5e754b1e75600e95bce92423778e95d3aa93582966dc2af0a8c13", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "307cca8dcdeff4e7e29c6da004c552a5a390c8f455c940ad85015784ab44c676", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ae2631cf0e9557c37b7f0e7cd1667a9e41841ae0f0e26a249059c15633dc0a0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0089a7e6524fb6b6dd61e6b895779f446aecfc1f475433d789026cce24da16c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f2b57ad6ee62dcf8617ec64e4fff5bdb5c3f21f79bd3b6e51d93b2a6f27c0c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9381c149b26c515cb867267f203c2e49d8fe09f1ce9c15d98948305a2475ca1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7b0104d96795aa9bc2dab053dbbc69a97de014eb143a41aed2d39ab0d82c8d25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13c6e07a392cf0849ea2638ec922b60ae0779137ab7b4f3045c290a223f8b367", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de884c8dde84b8a799a58611b8a38a847b7ce2e672083c91aa987ab76f7db8a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b224faeea178c3f7bde612f6105db0dc09ad0738b0bcf2f3b5a3b9b6c1c3b0ea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d5d2b5fcdffd8813bc9937ebf0d419e9e6cd74ece4b87f621f6beae740279903", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4321327869426e1dcaa31a7943a0ae1af27f0a913d78be5680ef4d4d44431695", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "60d68af74114d6ec83f6b549a3a22c545fa0468e92cfddf8fb609b1fef3cc625", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7ba09103d7cdaf7f557efc64b20ce741c29ad1af07d87d87518017e90fbbecc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "824a0739065c7471a5dc4d98ca6068784870d1059f1c30c708ba27f67650c9ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "305214fe539963e5e3354660addf3ba2425cef644785c7e73698c944bf8abe99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "97ec1514749eb39695e3d04de0d8841ea60f319713cc255b43a791d9d3fcab38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4c23901aca2608cc6e4c03b31b83de23e924cef5358196a2f3260847ef4add69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d29b2f7c6d934b2040c6f146c3fe1b78f8bd3e438ae4e9ff85acc67a341aed8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5dd4d598fe807ad2a8f291fd93595e494b260c8858af98c5960741e0c7b43ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a32c58da92f7f32e26e30703c86942164cdf3e48f3f29155302f8c73a568673f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e724c789745ff5b797ebc354ce56241ffb3662170a5e1e9e49f5b21f7c4ff023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12ec2879e7b5cac704691c53a3dfe6b10e1e71c90636dd78524a54c3f2c50a11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "66f7b4f49e7eb352f9565efc7d223bea17e49648545092f0b747f3e156048b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0f62020dfa03bd38c3ad4dee9d3238321b076aaf79f6d642cbde22433904dceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "454238a25f2d8c5d862f6d9ffbf5b21fde87b893c7511cc2515d478fb00e9465", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c5dd1fab062c3495d21b5e3bb11b17367c8e52f7130519854b70f3ff72f3fb83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a242ec39d98cd01c90ed133b68e73f5d2bcb7a15e8001b7760d0ea0a38e63420", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ac39a8450e5f3ddd47532b6be1c377f5f9618a2fa433362483717f7bf2252ac7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54fc5534af0340a39c899e044621806248a049d046e8a14643b4a55f9c4bdb79", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bcc7958019ae9e38717fb174782d4d89dba667f952c424eaccb6ddbbe99819fe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a885231ab43a68bfb956ce409c6e4eb1fdfc6d8cd04160cdf1ee34e1cfb254ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ff49c1d954725a39cb1a82d7aec366f90e6cb5a212c1c98a3911416efbcacb87", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8da9a0d436a04e599a674866f0bc1654f896eaddaa064e125c713bbd955ece0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "92663605fea62235e345d798be317a67c8b47b7e4caa54688808681df126f201", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b29bfcc5444114f0eece3f4e4e49ddb17626a7a0d1f51581fbd92d9bc890c9a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e4bfb9153b8d025e0a3df8c644d0fd6d2c246728c69bd45d61213b99800eafb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "74c485d4a2707d077040400806a016eb2fa10c0d93bf5d72e361b4ae34aaa005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-original.ppm", + "sha256": "182fd7b16e64d735509dc4bb4a2f71f8b8f68b284a4d2a568b520815624c783f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "873496e312473a4593017485d11639e863c8917f5c6acb6ea5c75b39084deb4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2b2c004f142692c5bdd5050fb3150b450c5f5bd34496d2d92863e8077f335944", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1976cc9fd72dbcb17a7fe1b906e72377f6630a63f08e3f426972976405afa7d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "10a5f08e71a316ee7bb6e4e0f36f4c44594a0800f7315ee4d5bfc128ad3a09c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e73d400f5f3687fd8414e28b802dddab4bc17e0434b0c41274c5b5f294d19220", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91b2ef1b249f19024e007a423f159966c00c2e8f4c474ce43d966acb74c5cf48", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8a86f5b68e9b7e281140bcfb372b9c28805d04f0bbd958486b758bba690ac301", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "716c8a06d2843ecffec70c757a974650e1b0ede11d217f6ad4078f8bcea10835", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "aec21c3a83cb0412a1ac3dfa04a42157c4911f6b0d90c3608910d81fef25f921", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5c86ebfbd4f0ea39cd2083802dde03526fd9666f496620b97d929c03b06a2c30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4017f": { @@ -401927,7 +426124,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4017f", "family_id": "terrain-40175-40184", "job_id": "terrain-40175-40184", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -401943,6 +426140,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/candidate.json", "sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "8543023fde3b6b84891d01eb451a16fad2addded56c7c2cebe254879b00d2c9f", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.030084+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"40175\\u201340178/4017b/4017c preserve principal rock counts, positions, direction and shadows. Lower40179/4017a join the exact previous40172/40173 into genuine2x2 foliage: annular outer shape, brown clearing and gray/black center feature remain in source regions. More pointed/brighter leaves are disclosed. Cliff entry/corner IDs4017d\\u201340184 retain ground-region boundaries and dark backing.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 f98c2f25a474e99230a8816cf9fc4ce906751bb3468fe746b31711569d047659", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40175", + "40176", + "40177", + "40178" + ], + "sha256": "baf8a618582337dea9958755bd074ecee0a1b107e8bdb5a1bff5601617fdd1a5", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40179", + "4017a", + "4017b", + "4017c" + ], + "sha256": "8af97e923d27551993dc9182cc9a3385ebc7a15a4845f7478ea79acf8bb777e3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4017d", + "4017e", + "4017f", + "40180" + ], + "sha256": "0da99b203d9361afdcefbb09554f5fa2233e119c40b4ae1aaa8ead2e6437743f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40181", + "40182", + "40183", + "40184" + ], + "sha256": "a217bdf6516f93eb9f1e8fbf815e5034b8e6010a94dfc52c5980acb29de4827c", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40175-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0aa5d3c2bfa94a3b5780f2543358d32dea7d1e0fab338173eb5d8dc4ba2867e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fce5b0c52a5c07375e7b8024fd2ca588f3d088a7bb78fd610f4800792af40258", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a9b21fd26f8d4122bf0a0c6fca08455b0f2c447b44fa05b1ad721ba726d2230", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fa59c26521f9c024d932c2ffe7168a951d661c700c7feca073fffd57425818aa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-original.ppm", + "sha256": "282a343dfe124561381ce0b953f1cec731868885e739eca852f90d34a4bb1b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6517863214a17e3d23148b4ecf8a76b983fcc054a29a57016de5c0044fec0701", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "957337b9cbd52d8bff2f5fb70e2155a45a7df7ef0d7cbbdc129c6c798ce83ea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fd0263c80084257e0a7f93375f99c21a5363139cdd45df296e313b328c141f92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "23277e44cdb548031e720e4baea69dca528bd84116ae8f2233c2d43348fa3fd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-original.ppm", + "sha256": "13bfd8b96679f597d574f0595b27fb670417a2aca94d8c368de22d60d26d246c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "557d88897612db5c8586e4a0fd613da184e624a0c15e8d0717a042c482586167", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "554c16a220c02af33c17c862abade23d9ba30b8ece056365a7b363a56683b36f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e126f1292647f8a861cfba270f12185ef0657e1757cf75af7af196c3cc03dc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "86c686822d40526bf80add427720795789fcbff2a7cfb5adc75d9e04af59d292", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-original.ppm", + "sha256": "979d9bccc77d8a54f7a27178a1a6bfe21007edb03bd5fc78cecbb0bc94c20673", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "23ebebde20b9949b061db01f18c5a1eecf471d96c5c058f7e2abd18b3baed259", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a988159f09570a747334ff446aece165dec444bcb68bbb7a47cf1c80d0f584bd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf2e6e5733020a190e73464ceb44ef07d8aa897e588483e8f0e933a6b7cd0ae3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d3f74942ba9e1ee35aad86976773f8cdc3129eed6a1cac35badba032bcbca46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fb41de86fcc764c07ea8a360653f1268e2e6b2d0b8cf2e8201cbc4ce6265952f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0783ab05df05f1dc3596509ff01aac6597d6dd97dea37b7f6aeb8df81db0253a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "033761f83b193348bdf877c3d0b18a01b56eaf257dc817b84e3d8099d8c366bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c5a101874492e6b4193e33ab561d015a9647c81c21d847e96ac5df35ac1b4e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f5f4a69131f1ccb92f9bab73e65dee8624c5fffc419b930fb540c66beb0321", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0cca56783f10f88287ac5780677ae6a286fd3bdf03625be9a47a400f8f912769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85c96cb980ad678f2986943ed4cdd6371375ebfa457e4ced36143acc4a16abc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "29ef10a332c927b7b37aebc455f2ff09abac9d741dce2d464090a87e2e602053", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "40bef7d8b54748e1d7a2699479f3296a567e333b75cbdc0b9a81672f422c3ada", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f8864b5e6d1e427a75bb713c85e3e36c745902b7cd3748b3b590ce260e62c3b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b0669cde458f09abb74261dabfe48cd746b4dca4378ece159317e19cba2d079c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1c6449e26ffdb2085c68600f2241a9dbe0a046e904a55f020a680b6220ae87b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "247892a4eec5e754b1e75600e95bce92423778e95d3aa93582966dc2af0a8c13", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "307cca8dcdeff4e7e29c6da004c552a5a390c8f455c940ad85015784ab44c676", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ae2631cf0e9557c37b7f0e7cd1667a9e41841ae0f0e26a249059c15633dc0a0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0089a7e6524fb6b6dd61e6b895779f446aecfc1f475433d789026cce24da16c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f2b57ad6ee62dcf8617ec64e4fff5bdb5c3f21f79bd3b6e51d93b2a6f27c0c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9381c149b26c515cb867267f203c2e49d8fe09f1ce9c15d98948305a2475ca1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7b0104d96795aa9bc2dab053dbbc69a97de014eb143a41aed2d39ab0d82c8d25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13c6e07a392cf0849ea2638ec922b60ae0779137ab7b4f3045c290a223f8b367", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de884c8dde84b8a799a58611b8a38a847b7ce2e672083c91aa987ab76f7db8a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b224faeea178c3f7bde612f6105db0dc09ad0738b0bcf2f3b5a3b9b6c1c3b0ea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d5d2b5fcdffd8813bc9937ebf0d419e9e6cd74ece4b87f621f6beae740279903", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4321327869426e1dcaa31a7943a0ae1af27f0a913d78be5680ef4d4d44431695", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "60d68af74114d6ec83f6b549a3a22c545fa0468e92cfddf8fb609b1fef3cc625", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7ba09103d7cdaf7f557efc64b20ce741c29ad1af07d87d87518017e90fbbecc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "824a0739065c7471a5dc4d98ca6068784870d1059f1c30c708ba27f67650c9ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "305214fe539963e5e3354660addf3ba2425cef644785c7e73698c944bf8abe99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "97ec1514749eb39695e3d04de0d8841ea60f319713cc255b43a791d9d3fcab38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4c23901aca2608cc6e4c03b31b83de23e924cef5358196a2f3260847ef4add69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d29b2f7c6d934b2040c6f146c3fe1b78f8bd3e438ae4e9ff85acc67a341aed8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5dd4d598fe807ad2a8f291fd93595e494b260c8858af98c5960741e0c7b43ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a32c58da92f7f32e26e30703c86942164cdf3e48f3f29155302f8c73a568673f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e724c789745ff5b797ebc354ce56241ffb3662170a5e1e9e49f5b21f7c4ff023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12ec2879e7b5cac704691c53a3dfe6b10e1e71c90636dd78524a54c3f2c50a11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "66f7b4f49e7eb352f9565efc7d223bea17e49648545092f0b747f3e156048b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0f62020dfa03bd38c3ad4dee9d3238321b076aaf79f6d642cbde22433904dceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "454238a25f2d8c5d862f6d9ffbf5b21fde87b893c7511cc2515d478fb00e9465", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c5dd1fab062c3495d21b5e3bb11b17367c8e52f7130519854b70f3ff72f3fb83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a242ec39d98cd01c90ed133b68e73f5d2bcb7a15e8001b7760d0ea0a38e63420", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ac39a8450e5f3ddd47532b6be1c377f5f9618a2fa433362483717f7bf2252ac7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54fc5534af0340a39c899e044621806248a049d046e8a14643b4a55f9c4bdb79", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bcc7958019ae9e38717fb174782d4d89dba667f952c424eaccb6ddbbe99819fe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a885231ab43a68bfb956ce409c6e4eb1fdfc6d8cd04160cdf1ee34e1cfb254ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ff49c1d954725a39cb1a82d7aec366f90e6cb5a212c1c98a3911416efbcacb87", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8da9a0d436a04e599a674866f0bc1654f896eaddaa064e125c713bbd955ece0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "92663605fea62235e345d798be317a67c8b47b7e4caa54688808681df126f201", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b29bfcc5444114f0eece3f4e4e49ddb17626a7a0d1f51581fbd92d9bc890c9a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e4bfb9153b8d025e0a3df8c644d0fd6d2c246728c69bd45d61213b99800eafb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "74c485d4a2707d077040400806a016eb2fa10c0d93bf5d72e361b4ae34aaa005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-original.ppm", + "sha256": "182fd7b16e64d735509dc4bb4a2f71f8b8f68b284a4d2a568b520815624c783f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "873496e312473a4593017485d11639e863c8917f5c6acb6ea5c75b39084deb4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2b2c004f142692c5bdd5050fb3150b450c5f5bd34496d2d92863e8077f335944", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1976cc9fd72dbcb17a7fe1b906e72377f6630a63f08e3f426972976405afa7d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "10a5f08e71a316ee7bb6e4e0f36f4c44594a0800f7315ee4d5bfc128ad3a09c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e73d400f5f3687fd8414e28b802dddab4bc17e0434b0c41274c5b5f294d19220", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91b2ef1b249f19024e007a423f159966c00c2e8f4c474ce43d966acb74c5cf48", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8a86f5b68e9b7e281140bcfb372b9c28805d04f0bbd958486b758bba690ac301", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "716c8a06d2843ecffec70c757a974650e1b0ede11d217f6ad4078f8bcea10835", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "aec21c3a83cb0412a1ac3dfa04a42157c4911f6b0d90c3608910d81fef25f921", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5c86ebfbd4f0ea39cd2083802dde03526fd9666f496620b97d929c03b06a2c30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40180": { @@ -401964,7 +426631,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40180", "family_id": "terrain-40175-40184", "job_id": "terrain-40175-40184", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -401980,6 +426647,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/candidate.json", "sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "8543023fde3b6b84891d01eb451a16fad2addded56c7c2cebe254879b00d2c9f", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.030084+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"40175\\u201340178/4017b/4017c preserve principal rock counts, positions, direction and shadows. Lower40179/4017a join the exact previous40172/40173 into genuine2x2 foliage: annular outer shape, brown clearing and gray/black center feature remain in source regions. More pointed/brighter leaves are disclosed. Cliff entry/corner IDs4017d\\u201340184 retain ground-region boundaries and dark backing.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 f98c2f25a474e99230a8816cf9fc4ce906751bb3468fe746b31711569d047659", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40175", + "40176", + "40177", + "40178" + ], + "sha256": "baf8a618582337dea9958755bd074ecee0a1b107e8bdb5a1bff5601617fdd1a5", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40179", + "4017a", + "4017b", + "4017c" + ], + "sha256": "8af97e923d27551993dc9182cc9a3385ebc7a15a4845f7478ea79acf8bb777e3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4017d", + "4017e", + "4017f", + "40180" + ], + "sha256": "0da99b203d9361afdcefbb09554f5fa2233e119c40b4ae1aaa8ead2e6437743f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40181", + "40182", + "40183", + "40184" + ], + "sha256": "a217bdf6516f93eb9f1e8fbf815e5034b8e6010a94dfc52c5980acb29de4827c", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40175-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0aa5d3c2bfa94a3b5780f2543358d32dea7d1e0fab338173eb5d8dc4ba2867e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fce5b0c52a5c07375e7b8024fd2ca588f3d088a7bb78fd610f4800792af40258", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a9b21fd26f8d4122bf0a0c6fca08455b0f2c447b44fa05b1ad721ba726d2230", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fa59c26521f9c024d932c2ffe7168a951d661c700c7feca073fffd57425818aa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-original.ppm", + "sha256": "282a343dfe124561381ce0b953f1cec731868885e739eca852f90d34a4bb1b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6517863214a17e3d23148b4ecf8a76b983fcc054a29a57016de5c0044fec0701", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "957337b9cbd52d8bff2f5fb70e2155a45a7df7ef0d7cbbdc129c6c798ce83ea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fd0263c80084257e0a7f93375f99c21a5363139cdd45df296e313b328c141f92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "23277e44cdb548031e720e4baea69dca528bd84116ae8f2233c2d43348fa3fd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-original.ppm", + "sha256": "13bfd8b96679f597d574f0595b27fb670417a2aca94d8c368de22d60d26d246c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "557d88897612db5c8586e4a0fd613da184e624a0c15e8d0717a042c482586167", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "554c16a220c02af33c17c862abade23d9ba30b8ece056365a7b363a56683b36f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e126f1292647f8a861cfba270f12185ef0657e1757cf75af7af196c3cc03dc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "86c686822d40526bf80add427720795789fcbff2a7cfb5adc75d9e04af59d292", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-original.ppm", + "sha256": "979d9bccc77d8a54f7a27178a1a6bfe21007edb03bd5fc78cecbb0bc94c20673", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "23ebebde20b9949b061db01f18c5a1eecf471d96c5c058f7e2abd18b3baed259", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a988159f09570a747334ff446aece165dec444bcb68bbb7a47cf1c80d0f584bd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf2e6e5733020a190e73464ceb44ef07d8aa897e588483e8f0e933a6b7cd0ae3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d3f74942ba9e1ee35aad86976773f8cdc3129eed6a1cac35badba032bcbca46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fb41de86fcc764c07ea8a360653f1268e2e6b2d0b8cf2e8201cbc4ce6265952f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0783ab05df05f1dc3596509ff01aac6597d6dd97dea37b7f6aeb8df81db0253a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "033761f83b193348bdf877c3d0b18a01b56eaf257dc817b84e3d8099d8c366bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c5a101874492e6b4193e33ab561d015a9647c81c21d847e96ac5df35ac1b4e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f5f4a69131f1ccb92f9bab73e65dee8624c5fffc419b930fb540c66beb0321", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0cca56783f10f88287ac5780677ae6a286fd3bdf03625be9a47a400f8f912769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85c96cb980ad678f2986943ed4cdd6371375ebfa457e4ced36143acc4a16abc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "29ef10a332c927b7b37aebc455f2ff09abac9d741dce2d464090a87e2e602053", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "40bef7d8b54748e1d7a2699479f3296a567e333b75cbdc0b9a81672f422c3ada", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f8864b5e6d1e427a75bb713c85e3e36c745902b7cd3748b3b590ce260e62c3b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b0669cde458f09abb74261dabfe48cd746b4dca4378ece159317e19cba2d079c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1c6449e26ffdb2085c68600f2241a9dbe0a046e904a55f020a680b6220ae87b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "247892a4eec5e754b1e75600e95bce92423778e95d3aa93582966dc2af0a8c13", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "307cca8dcdeff4e7e29c6da004c552a5a390c8f455c940ad85015784ab44c676", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ae2631cf0e9557c37b7f0e7cd1667a9e41841ae0f0e26a249059c15633dc0a0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0089a7e6524fb6b6dd61e6b895779f446aecfc1f475433d789026cce24da16c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f2b57ad6ee62dcf8617ec64e4fff5bdb5c3f21f79bd3b6e51d93b2a6f27c0c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9381c149b26c515cb867267f203c2e49d8fe09f1ce9c15d98948305a2475ca1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7b0104d96795aa9bc2dab053dbbc69a97de014eb143a41aed2d39ab0d82c8d25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13c6e07a392cf0849ea2638ec922b60ae0779137ab7b4f3045c290a223f8b367", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de884c8dde84b8a799a58611b8a38a847b7ce2e672083c91aa987ab76f7db8a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b224faeea178c3f7bde612f6105db0dc09ad0738b0bcf2f3b5a3b9b6c1c3b0ea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d5d2b5fcdffd8813bc9937ebf0d419e9e6cd74ece4b87f621f6beae740279903", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4321327869426e1dcaa31a7943a0ae1af27f0a913d78be5680ef4d4d44431695", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "60d68af74114d6ec83f6b549a3a22c545fa0468e92cfddf8fb609b1fef3cc625", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7ba09103d7cdaf7f557efc64b20ce741c29ad1af07d87d87518017e90fbbecc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "824a0739065c7471a5dc4d98ca6068784870d1059f1c30c708ba27f67650c9ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "305214fe539963e5e3354660addf3ba2425cef644785c7e73698c944bf8abe99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "97ec1514749eb39695e3d04de0d8841ea60f319713cc255b43a791d9d3fcab38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4c23901aca2608cc6e4c03b31b83de23e924cef5358196a2f3260847ef4add69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d29b2f7c6d934b2040c6f146c3fe1b78f8bd3e438ae4e9ff85acc67a341aed8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5dd4d598fe807ad2a8f291fd93595e494b260c8858af98c5960741e0c7b43ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a32c58da92f7f32e26e30703c86942164cdf3e48f3f29155302f8c73a568673f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e724c789745ff5b797ebc354ce56241ffb3662170a5e1e9e49f5b21f7c4ff023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12ec2879e7b5cac704691c53a3dfe6b10e1e71c90636dd78524a54c3f2c50a11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "66f7b4f49e7eb352f9565efc7d223bea17e49648545092f0b747f3e156048b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0f62020dfa03bd38c3ad4dee9d3238321b076aaf79f6d642cbde22433904dceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "454238a25f2d8c5d862f6d9ffbf5b21fde87b893c7511cc2515d478fb00e9465", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c5dd1fab062c3495d21b5e3bb11b17367c8e52f7130519854b70f3ff72f3fb83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a242ec39d98cd01c90ed133b68e73f5d2bcb7a15e8001b7760d0ea0a38e63420", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ac39a8450e5f3ddd47532b6be1c377f5f9618a2fa433362483717f7bf2252ac7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54fc5534af0340a39c899e044621806248a049d046e8a14643b4a55f9c4bdb79", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bcc7958019ae9e38717fb174782d4d89dba667f952c424eaccb6ddbbe99819fe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a885231ab43a68bfb956ce409c6e4eb1fdfc6d8cd04160cdf1ee34e1cfb254ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ff49c1d954725a39cb1a82d7aec366f90e6cb5a212c1c98a3911416efbcacb87", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8da9a0d436a04e599a674866f0bc1654f896eaddaa064e125c713bbd955ece0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "92663605fea62235e345d798be317a67c8b47b7e4caa54688808681df126f201", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b29bfcc5444114f0eece3f4e4e49ddb17626a7a0d1f51581fbd92d9bc890c9a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e4bfb9153b8d025e0a3df8c644d0fd6d2c246728c69bd45d61213b99800eafb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "74c485d4a2707d077040400806a016eb2fa10c0d93bf5d72e361b4ae34aaa005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-original.ppm", + "sha256": "182fd7b16e64d735509dc4bb4a2f71f8b8f68b284a4d2a568b520815624c783f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "873496e312473a4593017485d11639e863c8917f5c6acb6ea5c75b39084deb4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2b2c004f142692c5bdd5050fb3150b450c5f5bd34496d2d92863e8077f335944", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1976cc9fd72dbcb17a7fe1b906e72377f6630a63f08e3f426972976405afa7d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "10a5f08e71a316ee7bb6e4e0f36f4c44594a0800f7315ee4d5bfc128ad3a09c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e73d400f5f3687fd8414e28b802dddab4bc17e0434b0c41274c5b5f294d19220", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91b2ef1b249f19024e007a423f159966c00c2e8f4c474ce43d966acb74c5cf48", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8a86f5b68e9b7e281140bcfb372b9c28805d04f0bbd958486b758bba690ac301", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "716c8a06d2843ecffec70c757a974650e1b0ede11d217f6ad4078f8bcea10835", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "aec21c3a83cb0412a1ac3dfa04a42157c4911f6b0d90c3608910d81fef25f921", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5c86ebfbd4f0ea39cd2083802dde03526fd9666f496620b97d929c03b06a2c30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40181": { @@ -402001,7 +427138,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40181", "family_id": "terrain-40175-40184", "job_id": "terrain-40175-40184", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -402017,6 +427154,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/candidate.json", "sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "8543023fde3b6b84891d01eb451a16fad2addded56c7c2cebe254879b00d2c9f", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.030084+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"40175\\u201340178/4017b/4017c preserve principal rock counts, positions, direction and shadows. Lower40179/4017a join the exact previous40172/40173 into genuine2x2 foliage: annular outer shape, brown clearing and gray/black center feature remain in source regions. More pointed/brighter leaves are disclosed. Cliff entry/corner IDs4017d\\u201340184 retain ground-region boundaries and dark backing.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 f98c2f25a474e99230a8816cf9fc4ce906751bb3468fe746b31711569d047659", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40175", + "40176", + "40177", + "40178" + ], + "sha256": "baf8a618582337dea9958755bd074ecee0a1b107e8bdb5a1bff5601617fdd1a5", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40179", + "4017a", + "4017b", + "4017c" + ], + "sha256": "8af97e923d27551993dc9182cc9a3385ebc7a15a4845f7478ea79acf8bb777e3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4017d", + "4017e", + "4017f", + "40180" + ], + "sha256": "0da99b203d9361afdcefbb09554f5fa2233e119c40b4ae1aaa8ead2e6437743f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40181", + "40182", + "40183", + "40184" + ], + "sha256": "a217bdf6516f93eb9f1e8fbf815e5034b8e6010a94dfc52c5980acb29de4827c", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40175-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0aa5d3c2bfa94a3b5780f2543358d32dea7d1e0fab338173eb5d8dc4ba2867e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fce5b0c52a5c07375e7b8024fd2ca588f3d088a7bb78fd610f4800792af40258", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a9b21fd26f8d4122bf0a0c6fca08455b0f2c447b44fa05b1ad721ba726d2230", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fa59c26521f9c024d932c2ffe7168a951d661c700c7feca073fffd57425818aa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-original.ppm", + "sha256": "282a343dfe124561381ce0b953f1cec731868885e739eca852f90d34a4bb1b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6517863214a17e3d23148b4ecf8a76b983fcc054a29a57016de5c0044fec0701", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "957337b9cbd52d8bff2f5fb70e2155a45a7df7ef0d7cbbdc129c6c798ce83ea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fd0263c80084257e0a7f93375f99c21a5363139cdd45df296e313b328c141f92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "23277e44cdb548031e720e4baea69dca528bd84116ae8f2233c2d43348fa3fd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-original.ppm", + "sha256": "13bfd8b96679f597d574f0595b27fb670417a2aca94d8c368de22d60d26d246c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "557d88897612db5c8586e4a0fd613da184e624a0c15e8d0717a042c482586167", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "554c16a220c02af33c17c862abade23d9ba30b8ece056365a7b363a56683b36f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e126f1292647f8a861cfba270f12185ef0657e1757cf75af7af196c3cc03dc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "86c686822d40526bf80add427720795789fcbff2a7cfb5adc75d9e04af59d292", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-original.ppm", + "sha256": "979d9bccc77d8a54f7a27178a1a6bfe21007edb03bd5fc78cecbb0bc94c20673", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "23ebebde20b9949b061db01f18c5a1eecf471d96c5c058f7e2abd18b3baed259", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a988159f09570a747334ff446aece165dec444bcb68bbb7a47cf1c80d0f584bd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf2e6e5733020a190e73464ceb44ef07d8aa897e588483e8f0e933a6b7cd0ae3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d3f74942ba9e1ee35aad86976773f8cdc3129eed6a1cac35badba032bcbca46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fb41de86fcc764c07ea8a360653f1268e2e6b2d0b8cf2e8201cbc4ce6265952f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0783ab05df05f1dc3596509ff01aac6597d6dd97dea37b7f6aeb8df81db0253a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "033761f83b193348bdf877c3d0b18a01b56eaf257dc817b84e3d8099d8c366bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c5a101874492e6b4193e33ab561d015a9647c81c21d847e96ac5df35ac1b4e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f5f4a69131f1ccb92f9bab73e65dee8624c5fffc419b930fb540c66beb0321", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0cca56783f10f88287ac5780677ae6a286fd3bdf03625be9a47a400f8f912769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85c96cb980ad678f2986943ed4cdd6371375ebfa457e4ced36143acc4a16abc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "29ef10a332c927b7b37aebc455f2ff09abac9d741dce2d464090a87e2e602053", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "40bef7d8b54748e1d7a2699479f3296a567e333b75cbdc0b9a81672f422c3ada", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f8864b5e6d1e427a75bb713c85e3e36c745902b7cd3748b3b590ce260e62c3b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b0669cde458f09abb74261dabfe48cd746b4dca4378ece159317e19cba2d079c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1c6449e26ffdb2085c68600f2241a9dbe0a046e904a55f020a680b6220ae87b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "247892a4eec5e754b1e75600e95bce92423778e95d3aa93582966dc2af0a8c13", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "307cca8dcdeff4e7e29c6da004c552a5a390c8f455c940ad85015784ab44c676", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ae2631cf0e9557c37b7f0e7cd1667a9e41841ae0f0e26a249059c15633dc0a0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0089a7e6524fb6b6dd61e6b895779f446aecfc1f475433d789026cce24da16c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f2b57ad6ee62dcf8617ec64e4fff5bdb5c3f21f79bd3b6e51d93b2a6f27c0c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9381c149b26c515cb867267f203c2e49d8fe09f1ce9c15d98948305a2475ca1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7b0104d96795aa9bc2dab053dbbc69a97de014eb143a41aed2d39ab0d82c8d25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13c6e07a392cf0849ea2638ec922b60ae0779137ab7b4f3045c290a223f8b367", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de884c8dde84b8a799a58611b8a38a847b7ce2e672083c91aa987ab76f7db8a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b224faeea178c3f7bde612f6105db0dc09ad0738b0bcf2f3b5a3b9b6c1c3b0ea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d5d2b5fcdffd8813bc9937ebf0d419e9e6cd74ece4b87f621f6beae740279903", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4321327869426e1dcaa31a7943a0ae1af27f0a913d78be5680ef4d4d44431695", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "60d68af74114d6ec83f6b549a3a22c545fa0468e92cfddf8fb609b1fef3cc625", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7ba09103d7cdaf7f557efc64b20ce741c29ad1af07d87d87518017e90fbbecc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "824a0739065c7471a5dc4d98ca6068784870d1059f1c30c708ba27f67650c9ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "305214fe539963e5e3354660addf3ba2425cef644785c7e73698c944bf8abe99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "97ec1514749eb39695e3d04de0d8841ea60f319713cc255b43a791d9d3fcab38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4c23901aca2608cc6e4c03b31b83de23e924cef5358196a2f3260847ef4add69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d29b2f7c6d934b2040c6f146c3fe1b78f8bd3e438ae4e9ff85acc67a341aed8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5dd4d598fe807ad2a8f291fd93595e494b260c8858af98c5960741e0c7b43ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a32c58da92f7f32e26e30703c86942164cdf3e48f3f29155302f8c73a568673f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e724c789745ff5b797ebc354ce56241ffb3662170a5e1e9e49f5b21f7c4ff023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12ec2879e7b5cac704691c53a3dfe6b10e1e71c90636dd78524a54c3f2c50a11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "66f7b4f49e7eb352f9565efc7d223bea17e49648545092f0b747f3e156048b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0f62020dfa03bd38c3ad4dee9d3238321b076aaf79f6d642cbde22433904dceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "454238a25f2d8c5d862f6d9ffbf5b21fde87b893c7511cc2515d478fb00e9465", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c5dd1fab062c3495d21b5e3bb11b17367c8e52f7130519854b70f3ff72f3fb83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a242ec39d98cd01c90ed133b68e73f5d2bcb7a15e8001b7760d0ea0a38e63420", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ac39a8450e5f3ddd47532b6be1c377f5f9618a2fa433362483717f7bf2252ac7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54fc5534af0340a39c899e044621806248a049d046e8a14643b4a55f9c4bdb79", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bcc7958019ae9e38717fb174782d4d89dba667f952c424eaccb6ddbbe99819fe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a885231ab43a68bfb956ce409c6e4eb1fdfc6d8cd04160cdf1ee34e1cfb254ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ff49c1d954725a39cb1a82d7aec366f90e6cb5a212c1c98a3911416efbcacb87", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8da9a0d436a04e599a674866f0bc1654f896eaddaa064e125c713bbd955ece0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "92663605fea62235e345d798be317a67c8b47b7e4caa54688808681df126f201", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b29bfcc5444114f0eece3f4e4e49ddb17626a7a0d1f51581fbd92d9bc890c9a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e4bfb9153b8d025e0a3df8c644d0fd6d2c246728c69bd45d61213b99800eafb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "74c485d4a2707d077040400806a016eb2fa10c0d93bf5d72e361b4ae34aaa005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-original.ppm", + "sha256": "182fd7b16e64d735509dc4bb4a2f71f8b8f68b284a4d2a568b520815624c783f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "873496e312473a4593017485d11639e863c8917f5c6acb6ea5c75b39084deb4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2b2c004f142692c5bdd5050fb3150b450c5f5bd34496d2d92863e8077f335944", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1976cc9fd72dbcb17a7fe1b906e72377f6630a63f08e3f426972976405afa7d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "10a5f08e71a316ee7bb6e4e0f36f4c44594a0800f7315ee4d5bfc128ad3a09c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e73d400f5f3687fd8414e28b802dddab4bc17e0434b0c41274c5b5f294d19220", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91b2ef1b249f19024e007a423f159966c00c2e8f4c474ce43d966acb74c5cf48", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8a86f5b68e9b7e281140bcfb372b9c28805d04f0bbd958486b758bba690ac301", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "716c8a06d2843ecffec70c757a974650e1b0ede11d217f6ad4078f8bcea10835", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "aec21c3a83cb0412a1ac3dfa04a42157c4911f6b0d90c3608910d81fef25f921", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5c86ebfbd4f0ea39cd2083802dde03526fd9666f496620b97d929c03b06a2c30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40182": { @@ -402038,7 +427645,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40182", "family_id": "terrain-40175-40184", "job_id": "terrain-40175-40184", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -402054,6 +427661,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/candidate.json", "sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "8543023fde3b6b84891d01eb451a16fad2addded56c7c2cebe254879b00d2c9f", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.030084+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"40175\\u201340178/4017b/4017c preserve principal rock counts, positions, direction and shadows. Lower40179/4017a join the exact previous40172/40173 into genuine2x2 foliage: annular outer shape, brown clearing and gray/black center feature remain in source regions. More pointed/brighter leaves are disclosed. Cliff entry/corner IDs4017d\\u201340184 retain ground-region boundaries and dark backing.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 f98c2f25a474e99230a8816cf9fc4ce906751bb3468fe746b31711569d047659", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40175", + "40176", + "40177", + "40178" + ], + "sha256": "baf8a618582337dea9958755bd074ecee0a1b107e8bdb5a1bff5601617fdd1a5", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40179", + "4017a", + "4017b", + "4017c" + ], + "sha256": "8af97e923d27551993dc9182cc9a3385ebc7a15a4845f7478ea79acf8bb777e3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4017d", + "4017e", + "4017f", + "40180" + ], + "sha256": "0da99b203d9361afdcefbb09554f5fa2233e119c40b4ae1aaa8ead2e6437743f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40181", + "40182", + "40183", + "40184" + ], + "sha256": "a217bdf6516f93eb9f1e8fbf815e5034b8e6010a94dfc52c5980acb29de4827c", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40175-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0aa5d3c2bfa94a3b5780f2543358d32dea7d1e0fab338173eb5d8dc4ba2867e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fce5b0c52a5c07375e7b8024fd2ca588f3d088a7bb78fd610f4800792af40258", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a9b21fd26f8d4122bf0a0c6fca08455b0f2c447b44fa05b1ad721ba726d2230", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fa59c26521f9c024d932c2ffe7168a951d661c700c7feca073fffd57425818aa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-original.ppm", + "sha256": "282a343dfe124561381ce0b953f1cec731868885e739eca852f90d34a4bb1b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6517863214a17e3d23148b4ecf8a76b983fcc054a29a57016de5c0044fec0701", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "957337b9cbd52d8bff2f5fb70e2155a45a7df7ef0d7cbbdc129c6c798ce83ea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fd0263c80084257e0a7f93375f99c21a5363139cdd45df296e313b328c141f92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "23277e44cdb548031e720e4baea69dca528bd84116ae8f2233c2d43348fa3fd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-original.ppm", + "sha256": "13bfd8b96679f597d574f0595b27fb670417a2aca94d8c368de22d60d26d246c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "557d88897612db5c8586e4a0fd613da184e624a0c15e8d0717a042c482586167", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "554c16a220c02af33c17c862abade23d9ba30b8ece056365a7b363a56683b36f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e126f1292647f8a861cfba270f12185ef0657e1757cf75af7af196c3cc03dc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "86c686822d40526bf80add427720795789fcbff2a7cfb5adc75d9e04af59d292", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-original.ppm", + "sha256": "979d9bccc77d8a54f7a27178a1a6bfe21007edb03bd5fc78cecbb0bc94c20673", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "23ebebde20b9949b061db01f18c5a1eecf471d96c5c058f7e2abd18b3baed259", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a988159f09570a747334ff446aece165dec444bcb68bbb7a47cf1c80d0f584bd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf2e6e5733020a190e73464ceb44ef07d8aa897e588483e8f0e933a6b7cd0ae3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d3f74942ba9e1ee35aad86976773f8cdc3129eed6a1cac35badba032bcbca46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fb41de86fcc764c07ea8a360653f1268e2e6b2d0b8cf2e8201cbc4ce6265952f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0783ab05df05f1dc3596509ff01aac6597d6dd97dea37b7f6aeb8df81db0253a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "033761f83b193348bdf877c3d0b18a01b56eaf257dc817b84e3d8099d8c366bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c5a101874492e6b4193e33ab561d015a9647c81c21d847e96ac5df35ac1b4e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f5f4a69131f1ccb92f9bab73e65dee8624c5fffc419b930fb540c66beb0321", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0cca56783f10f88287ac5780677ae6a286fd3bdf03625be9a47a400f8f912769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85c96cb980ad678f2986943ed4cdd6371375ebfa457e4ced36143acc4a16abc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "29ef10a332c927b7b37aebc455f2ff09abac9d741dce2d464090a87e2e602053", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "40bef7d8b54748e1d7a2699479f3296a567e333b75cbdc0b9a81672f422c3ada", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f8864b5e6d1e427a75bb713c85e3e36c745902b7cd3748b3b590ce260e62c3b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b0669cde458f09abb74261dabfe48cd746b4dca4378ece159317e19cba2d079c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1c6449e26ffdb2085c68600f2241a9dbe0a046e904a55f020a680b6220ae87b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "247892a4eec5e754b1e75600e95bce92423778e95d3aa93582966dc2af0a8c13", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "307cca8dcdeff4e7e29c6da004c552a5a390c8f455c940ad85015784ab44c676", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ae2631cf0e9557c37b7f0e7cd1667a9e41841ae0f0e26a249059c15633dc0a0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0089a7e6524fb6b6dd61e6b895779f446aecfc1f475433d789026cce24da16c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f2b57ad6ee62dcf8617ec64e4fff5bdb5c3f21f79bd3b6e51d93b2a6f27c0c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9381c149b26c515cb867267f203c2e49d8fe09f1ce9c15d98948305a2475ca1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7b0104d96795aa9bc2dab053dbbc69a97de014eb143a41aed2d39ab0d82c8d25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13c6e07a392cf0849ea2638ec922b60ae0779137ab7b4f3045c290a223f8b367", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de884c8dde84b8a799a58611b8a38a847b7ce2e672083c91aa987ab76f7db8a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b224faeea178c3f7bde612f6105db0dc09ad0738b0bcf2f3b5a3b9b6c1c3b0ea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d5d2b5fcdffd8813bc9937ebf0d419e9e6cd74ece4b87f621f6beae740279903", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4321327869426e1dcaa31a7943a0ae1af27f0a913d78be5680ef4d4d44431695", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "60d68af74114d6ec83f6b549a3a22c545fa0468e92cfddf8fb609b1fef3cc625", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7ba09103d7cdaf7f557efc64b20ce741c29ad1af07d87d87518017e90fbbecc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "824a0739065c7471a5dc4d98ca6068784870d1059f1c30c708ba27f67650c9ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "305214fe539963e5e3354660addf3ba2425cef644785c7e73698c944bf8abe99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "97ec1514749eb39695e3d04de0d8841ea60f319713cc255b43a791d9d3fcab38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4c23901aca2608cc6e4c03b31b83de23e924cef5358196a2f3260847ef4add69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d29b2f7c6d934b2040c6f146c3fe1b78f8bd3e438ae4e9ff85acc67a341aed8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5dd4d598fe807ad2a8f291fd93595e494b260c8858af98c5960741e0c7b43ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a32c58da92f7f32e26e30703c86942164cdf3e48f3f29155302f8c73a568673f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e724c789745ff5b797ebc354ce56241ffb3662170a5e1e9e49f5b21f7c4ff023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12ec2879e7b5cac704691c53a3dfe6b10e1e71c90636dd78524a54c3f2c50a11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "66f7b4f49e7eb352f9565efc7d223bea17e49648545092f0b747f3e156048b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0f62020dfa03bd38c3ad4dee9d3238321b076aaf79f6d642cbde22433904dceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "454238a25f2d8c5d862f6d9ffbf5b21fde87b893c7511cc2515d478fb00e9465", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c5dd1fab062c3495d21b5e3bb11b17367c8e52f7130519854b70f3ff72f3fb83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a242ec39d98cd01c90ed133b68e73f5d2bcb7a15e8001b7760d0ea0a38e63420", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ac39a8450e5f3ddd47532b6be1c377f5f9618a2fa433362483717f7bf2252ac7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54fc5534af0340a39c899e044621806248a049d046e8a14643b4a55f9c4bdb79", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bcc7958019ae9e38717fb174782d4d89dba667f952c424eaccb6ddbbe99819fe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a885231ab43a68bfb956ce409c6e4eb1fdfc6d8cd04160cdf1ee34e1cfb254ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ff49c1d954725a39cb1a82d7aec366f90e6cb5a212c1c98a3911416efbcacb87", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8da9a0d436a04e599a674866f0bc1654f896eaddaa064e125c713bbd955ece0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "92663605fea62235e345d798be317a67c8b47b7e4caa54688808681df126f201", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b29bfcc5444114f0eece3f4e4e49ddb17626a7a0d1f51581fbd92d9bc890c9a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e4bfb9153b8d025e0a3df8c644d0fd6d2c246728c69bd45d61213b99800eafb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "74c485d4a2707d077040400806a016eb2fa10c0d93bf5d72e361b4ae34aaa005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-original.ppm", + "sha256": "182fd7b16e64d735509dc4bb4a2f71f8b8f68b284a4d2a568b520815624c783f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "873496e312473a4593017485d11639e863c8917f5c6acb6ea5c75b39084deb4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2b2c004f142692c5bdd5050fb3150b450c5f5bd34496d2d92863e8077f335944", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1976cc9fd72dbcb17a7fe1b906e72377f6630a63f08e3f426972976405afa7d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "10a5f08e71a316ee7bb6e4e0f36f4c44594a0800f7315ee4d5bfc128ad3a09c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e73d400f5f3687fd8414e28b802dddab4bc17e0434b0c41274c5b5f294d19220", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91b2ef1b249f19024e007a423f159966c00c2e8f4c474ce43d966acb74c5cf48", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8a86f5b68e9b7e281140bcfb372b9c28805d04f0bbd958486b758bba690ac301", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "716c8a06d2843ecffec70c757a974650e1b0ede11d217f6ad4078f8bcea10835", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "aec21c3a83cb0412a1ac3dfa04a42157c4911f6b0d90c3608910d81fef25f921", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5c86ebfbd4f0ea39cd2083802dde03526fd9666f496620b97d929c03b06a2c30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40183": { @@ -402075,7 +428152,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40183", "family_id": "terrain-40175-40184", "job_id": "terrain-40175-40184", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -402091,6 +428168,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/candidate.json", "sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "8543023fde3b6b84891d01eb451a16fad2addded56c7c2cebe254879b00d2c9f", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.030084+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"40175\\u201340178/4017b/4017c preserve principal rock counts, positions, direction and shadows. Lower40179/4017a join the exact previous40172/40173 into genuine2x2 foliage: annular outer shape, brown clearing and gray/black center feature remain in source regions. More pointed/brighter leaves are disclosed. Cliff entry/corner IDs4017d\\u201340184 retain ground-region boundaries and dark backing.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 f98c2f25a474e99230a8816cf9fc4ce906751bb3468fe746b31711569d047659", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40175", + "40176", + "40177", + "40178" + ], + "sha256": "baf8a618582337dea9958755bd074ecee0a1b107e8bdb5a1bff5601617fdd1a5", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40179", + "4017a", + "4017b", + "4017c" + ], + "sha256": "8af97e923d27551993dc9182cc9a3385ebc7a15a4845f7478ea79acf8bb777e3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4017d", + "4017e", + "4017f", + "40180" + ], + "sha256": "0da99b203d9361afdcefbb09554f5fa2233e119c40b4ae1aaa8ead2e6437743f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40181", + "40182", + "40183", + "40184" + ], + "sha256": "a217bdf6516f93eb9f1e8fbf815e5034b8e6010a94dfc52c5980acb29de4827c", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40175-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0aa5d3c2bfa94a3b5780f2543358d32dea7d1e0fab338173eb5d8dc4ba2867e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fce5b0c52a5c07375e7b8024fd2ca588f3d088a7bb78fd610f4800792af40258", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a9b21fd26f8d4122bf0a0c6fca08455b0f2c447b44fa05b1ad721ba726d2230", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fa59c26521f9c024d932c2ffe7168a951d661c700c7feca073fffd57425818aa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-original.ppm", + "sha256": "282a343dfe124561381ce0b953f1cec731868885e739eca852f90d34a4bb1b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6517863214a17e3d23148b4ecf8a76b983fcc054a29a57016de5c0044fec0701", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "957337b9cbd52d8bff2f5fb70e2155a45a7df7ef0d7cbbdc129c6c798ce83ea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fd0263c80084257e0a7f93375f99c21a5363139cdd45df296e313b328c141f92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "23277e44cdb548031e720e4baea69dca528bd84116ae8f2233c2d43348fa3fd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-original.ppm", + "sha256": "13bfd8b96679f597d574f0595b27fb670417a2aca94d8c368de22d60d26d246c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "557d88897612db5c8586e4a0fd613da184e624a0c15e8d0717a042c482586167", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "554c16a220c02af33c17c862abade23d9ba30b8ece056365a7b363a56683b36f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e126f1292647f8a861cfba270f12185ef0657e1757cf75af7af196c3cc03dc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "86c686822d40526bf80add427720795789fcbff2a7cfb5adc75d9e04af59d292", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-original.ppm", + "sha256": "979d9bccc77d8a54f7a27178a1a6bfe21007edb03bd5fc78cecbb0bc94c20673", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "23ebebde20b9949b061db01f18c5a1eecf471d96c5c058f7e2abd18b3baed259", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a988159f09570a747334ff446aece165dec444bcb68bbb7a47cf1c80d0f584bd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf2e6e5733020a190e73464ceb44ef07d8aa897e588483e8f0e933a6b7cd0ae3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d3f74942ba9e1ee35aad86976773f8cdc3129eed6a1cac35badba032bcbca46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fb41de86fcc764c07ea8a360653f1268e2e6b2d0b8cf2e8201cbc4ce6265952f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0783ab05df05f1dc3596509ff01aac6597d6dd97dea37b7f6aeb8df81db0253a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "033761f83b193348bdf877c3d0b18a01b56eaf257dc817b84e3d8099d8c366bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c5a101874492e6b4193e33ab561d015a9647c81c21d847e96ac5df35ac1b4e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f5f4a69131f1ccb92f9bab73e65dee8624c5fffc419b930fb540c66beb0321", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0cca56783f10f88287ac5780677ae6a286fd3bdf03625be9a47a400f8f912769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85c96cb980ad678f2986943ed4cdd6371375ebfa457e4ced36143acc4a16abc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "29ef10a332c927b7b37aebc455f2ff09abac9d741dce2d464090a87e2e602053", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "40bef7d8b54748e1d7a2699479f3296a567e333b75cbdc0b9a81672f422c3ada", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f8864b5e6d1e427a75bb713c85e3e36c745902b7cd3748b3b590ce260e62c3b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b0669cde458f09abb74261dabfe48cd746b4dca4378ece159317e19cba2d079c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1c6449e26ffdb2085c68600f2241a9dbe0a046e904a55f020a680b6220ae87b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "247892a4eec5e754b1e75600e95bce92423778e95d3aa93582966dc2af0a8c13", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "307cca8dcdeff4e7e29c6da004c552a5a390c8f455c940ad85015784ab44c676", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ae2631cf0e9557c37b7f0e7cd1667a9e41841ae0f0e26a249059c15633dc0a0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0089a7e6524fb6b6dd61e6b895779f446aecfc1f475433d789026cce24da16c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f2b57ad6ee62dcf8617ec64e4fff5bdb5c3f21f79bd3b6e51d93b2a6f27c0c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9381c149b26c515cb867267f203c2e49d8fe09f1ce9c15d98948305a2475ca1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7b0104d96795aa9bc2dab053dbbc69a97de014eb143a41aed2d39ab0d82c8d25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13c6e07a392cf0849ea2638ec922b60ae0779137ab7b4f3045c290a223f8b367", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de884c8dde84b8a799a58611b8a38a847b7ce2e672083c91aa987ab76f7db8a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b224faeea178c3f7bde612f6105db0dc09ad0738b0bcf2f3b5a3b9b6c1c3b0ea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d5d2b5fcdffd8813bc9937ebf0d419e9e6cd74ece4b87f621f6beae740279903", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4321327869426e1dcaa31a7943a0ae1af27f0a913d78be5680ef4d4d44431695", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "60d68af74114d6ec83f6b549a3a22c545fa0468e92cfddf8fb609b1fef3cc625", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7ba09103d7cdaf7f557efc64b20ce741c29ad1af07d87d87518017e90fbbecc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "824a0739065c7471a5dc4d98ca6068784870d1059f1c30c708ba27f67650c9ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "305214fe539963e5e3354660addf3ba2425cef644785c7e73698c944bf8abe99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "97ec1514749eb39695e3d04de0d8841ea60f319713cc255b43a791d9d3fcab38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4c23901aca2608cc6e4c03b31b83de23e924cef5358196a2f3260847ef4add69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d29b2f7c6d934b2040c6f146c3fe1b78f8bd3e438ae4e9ff85acc67a341aed8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5dd4d598fe807ad2a8f291fd93595e494b260c8858af98c5960741e0c7b43ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a32c58da92f7f32e26e30703c86942164cdf3e48f3f29155302f8c73a568673f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e724c789745ff5b797ebc354ce56241ffb3662170a5e1e9e49f5b21f7c4ff023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12ec2879e7b5cac704691c53a3dfe6b10e1e71c90636dd78524a54c3f2c50a11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "66f7b4f49e7eb352f9565efc7d223bea17e49648545092f0b747f3e156048b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0f62020dfa03bd38c3ad4dee9d3238321b076aaf79f6d642cbde22433904dceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "454238a25f2d8c5d862f6d9ffbf5b21fde87b893c7511cc2515d478fb00e9465", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c5dd1fab062c3495d21b5e3bb11b17367c8e52f7130519854b70f3ff72f3fb83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a242ec39d98cd01c90ed133b68e73f5d2bcb7a15e8001b7760d0ea0a38e63420", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ac39a8450e5f3ddd47532b6be1c377f5f9618a2fa433362483717f7bf2252ac7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54fc5534af0340a39c899e044621806248a049d046e8a14643b4a55f9c4bdb79", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bcc7958019ae9e38717fb174782d4d89dba667f952c424eaccb6ddbbe99819fe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a885231ab43a68bfb956ce409c6e4eb1fdfc6d8cd04160cdf1ee34e1cfb254ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ff49c1d954725a39cb1a82d7aec366f90e6cb5a212c1c98a3911416efbcacb87", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8da9a0d436a04e599a674866f0bc1654f896eaddaa064e125c713bbd955ece0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "92663605fea62235e345d798be317a67c8b47b7e4caa54688808681df126f201", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b29bfcc5444114f0eece3f4e4e49ddb17626a7a0d1f51581fbd92d9bc890c9a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e4bfb9153b8d025e0a3df8c644d0fd6d2c246728c69bd45d61213b99800eafb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "74c485d4a2707d077040400806a016eb2fa10c0d93bf5d72e361b4ae34aaa005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-original.ppm", + "sha256": "182fd7b16e64d735509dc4bb4a2f71f8b8f68b284a4d2a568b520815624c783f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "873496e312473a4593017485d11639e863c8917f5c6acb6ea5c75b39084deb4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2b2c004f142692c5bdd5050fb3150b450c5f5bd34496d2d92863e8077f335944", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1976cc9fd72dbcb17a7fe1b906e72377f6630a63f08e3f426972976405afa7d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "10a5f08e71a316ee7bb6e4e0f36f4c44594a0800f7315ee4d5bfc128ad3a09c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e73d400f5f3687fd8414e28b802dddab4bc17e0434b0c41274c5b5f294d19220", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91b2ef1b249f19024e007a423f159966c00c2e8f4c474ce43d966acb74c5cf48", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8a86f5b68e9b7e281140bcfb372b9c28805d04f0bbd958486b758bba690ac301", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "716c8a06d2843ecffec70c757a974650e1b0ede11d217f6ad4078f8bcea10835", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "aec21c3a83cb0412a1ac3dfa04a42157c4911f6b0d90c3608910d81fef25f921", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5c86ebfbd4f0ea39cd2083802dde03526fd9666f496620b97d929c03b06a2c30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40184": { @@ -402112,7 +428659,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40184", "family_id": "terrain-40175-40184", "job_id": "terrain-40175-40184", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -402128,6 +428675,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/candidate.json", "sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "ff9ae7dea0ed532bad278d6c1f1432fea7c1a9f85ba7dd9a402ab696bf9ebd89", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "8543023fde3b6b84891d01eb451a16fad2addded56c7c2cebe254879b00d2c9f", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.030084+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40175-40184/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"40175\\u201340178/4017b/4017c preserve principal rock counts, positions, direction and shadows. Lower40179/4017a join the exact previous40172/40173 into genuine2x2 foliage: annular outer shape, brown clearing and gray/black center feature remain in source regions. More pointed/brighter leaves are disclosed. Cliff entry/corner IDs4017d\\u201340184 retain ground-region boundaries and dark backing.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 f98c2f25a474e99230a8816cf9fc4ce906751bb3468fe746b31711569d047659", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40175", + "40176", + "40177", + "40178" + ], + "sha256": "baf8a618582337dea9958755bd074ecee0a1b107e8bdb5a1bff5601617fdd1a5", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40179", + "4017a", + "4017b", + "4017c" + ], + "sha256": "8af97e923d27551993dc9182cc9a3385ebc7a15a4845f7478ea79acf8bb777e3", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4017d", + "4017e", + "4017f", + "40180" + ], + "sha256": "0da99b203d9361afdcefbb09554f5fa2233e119c40b4ae1aaa8ead2e6437743f", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40181", + "40182", + "40183", + "40184" + ], + "sha256": "a217bdf6516f93eb9f1e8fbf815e5034b8e6010a94dfc52c5980acb29de4827c", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40175-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0aa5d3c2bfa94a3b5780f2543358d32dea7d1e0fab338173eb5d8dc4ba2867e1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "fce5b0c52a5c07375e7b8024fd2ca588f3d088a7bb78fd610f4800792af40258", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1a9b21fd26f8d4122bf0a0c6fca08455b0f2c447b44fa05b1ad721ba726d2230", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "fa59c26521f9c024d932c2ffe7168a951d661c700c7feca073fffd57425818aa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40175-original.ppm", + "sha256": "282a343dfe124561381ce0b953f1cec731868885e739eca852f90d34a4bb1b54", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40175-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6517863214a17e3d23148b4ecf8a76b983fcc054a29a57016de5c0044fec0701", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "957337b9cbd52d8bff2f5fb70e2155a45a7df7ef0d7cbbdc129c6c798ce83ea5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "fd0263c80084257e0a7f93375f99c21a5363139cdd45df296e313b328c141f92", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "23277e44cdb548031e720e4baea69dca528bd84116ae8f2233c2d43348fa3fd8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40176-original.ppm", + "sha256": "13bfd8b96679f597d574f0595b27fb670417a2aca94d8c368de22d60d26d246c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40176-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "557d88897612db5c8586e4a0fd613da184e624a0c15e8d0717a042c482586167", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "554c16a220c02af33c17c862abade23d9ba30b8ece056365a7b363a56683b36f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e126f1292647f8a861cfba270f12185ef0657e1757cf75af7af196c3cc03dc4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "86c686822d40526bf80add427720795789fcbff2a7cfb5adc75d9e04af59d292", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40177-original.ppm", + "sha256": "979d9bccc77d8a54f7a27178a1a6bfe21007edb03bd5fc78cecbb0bc94c20673", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40177-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "23ebebde20b9949b061db01f18c5a1eecf471d96c5c058f7e2abd18b3baed259", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a988159f09570a747334ff446aece165dec444bcb68bbb7a47cf1c80d0f584bd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "cf2e6e5733020a190e73464ceb44ef07d8aa897e588483e8f0e933a6b7cd0ae3", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "1d3f74942ba9e1ee35aad86976773f8cdc3129eed6a1cac35badba032bcbca46", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40178-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fb41de86fcc764c07ea8a360653f1268e2e6b2d0b8cf2e8201cbc4ce6265952f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40178-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0783ab05df05f1dc3596509ff01aac6597d6dd97dea37b7f6aeb8df81db0253a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "033761f83b193348bdf877c3d0b18a01b56eaf257dc817b84e3d8099d8c366bf", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "0c5a101874492e6b4193e33ab561d015a9647c81c21d847e96ac5df35ac1b4e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f2f5f4a69131f1ccb92f9bab73e65dee8624c5fffc419b930fb540c66beb0321", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40179-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0cca56783f10f88287ac5780677ae6a286fd3bdf03625be9a47a400f8f912769", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40179-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "85c96cb980ad678f2986943ed4cdd6371375ebfa457e4ced36143acc4a16abc5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "29ef10a332c927b7b37aebc455f2ff09abac9d741dce2d464090a87e2e602053", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "40bef7d8b54748e1d7a2699479f3296a567e333b75cbdc0b9a81672f422c3ada", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f8864b5e6d1e427a75bb713c85e3e36c745902b7cd3748b3b590ce260e62c3b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "b0669cde458f09abb74261dabfe48cd746b4dca4378ece159317e19cba2d079c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "1c6449e26ffdb2085c68600f2241a9dbe0a046e904a55f020a680b6220ae87b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "247892a4eec5e754b1e75600e95bce92423778e95d3aa93582966dc2af0a8c13", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "307cca8dcdeff4e7e29c6da004c552a5a390c8f455c940ad85015784ab44c676", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ae2631cf0e9557c37b7f0e7cd1667a9e41841ae0f0e26a249059c15633dc0a0e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "0089a7e6524fb6b6dd61e6b895779f446aecfc1f475433d789026cce24da16c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "3f2b57ad6ee62dcf8617ec64e4fff5bdb5c3f21f79bd3b6e51d93b2a6f27c0c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "9381c149b26c515cb867267f203c2e49d8fe09f1ce9c15d98948305a2475ca1c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "7b0104d96795aa9bc2dab053dbbc69a97de014eb143a41aed2d39ab0d82c8d25", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "13c6e07a392cf0849ea2638ec922b60ae0779137ab7b4f3045c290a223f8b367", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "de884c8dde84b8a799a58611b8a38a847b7ce2e672083c91aa987ab76f7db8a2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "b224faeea178c3f7bde612f6105db0dc09ad0738b0bcf2f3b5a3b9b6c1c3b0ea", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d5d2b5fcdffd8813bc9937ebf0d419e9e6cd74ece4b87f621f6beae740279903", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "4321327869426e1dcaa31a7943a0ae1af27f0a913d78be5680ef4d4d44431695", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "60d68af74114d6ec83f6b549a3a22c545fa0468e92cfddf8fb609b1fef3cc625", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7ba09103d7cdaf7f557efc64b20ce741c29ad1af07d87d87518017e90fbbecc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "824a0739065c7471a5dc4d98ca6068784870d1059f1c30c708ba27f67650c9ce", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "305214fe539963e5e3354660addf3ba2425cef644785c7e73698c944bf8abe99", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "97ec1514749eb39695e3d04de0d8841ea60f319713cc255b43a791d9d3fcab38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "4c23901aca2608cc6e4c03b31b83de23e924cef5358196a2f3260847ef4add69", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d29b2f7c6d934b2040c6f146c3fe1b78f8bd3e438ae4e9ff85acc67a341aed8c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5dd4d598fe807ad2a8f291fd93595e494b260c8858af98c5960741e0c7b43ea7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a32c58da92f7f32e26e30703c86942164cdf3e48f3f29155302f8c73a568673f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e724c789745ff5b797ebc354ce56241ffb3662170a5e1e9e49f5b21f7c4ff023", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "12ec2879e7b5cac704691c53a3dfe6b10e1e71c90636dd78524a54c3f2c50a11", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4017f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "66f7b4f49e7eb352f9565efc7d223bea17e49648545092f0b747f3e156048b50", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/4017f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0f62020dfa03bd38c3ad4dee9d3238321b076aaf79f6d642cbde22433904dceb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "454238a25f2d8c5d862f6d9ffbf5b21fde87b893c7511cc2515d478fb00e9465", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "c5dd1fab062c3495d21b5e3bb11b17367c8e52f7130519854b70f3ff72f3fb83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a242ec39d98cd01c90ed133b68e73f5d2bcb7a15e8001b7760d0ea0a38e63420", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40180-original.ppm", + "sha256": "ac39a8450e5f3ddd47532b6be1c377f5f9618a2fa433362483717f7bf2252ac7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40180-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "54fc5534af0340a39c899e044621806248a049d046e8a14643b4a55f9c4bdb79", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "bcc7958019ae9e38717fb174782d4d89dba667f952c424eaccb6ddbbe99819fe", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a885231ab43a68bfb956ce409c6e4eb1fdfc6d8cd04160cdf1ee34e1cfb254ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "ff49c1d954725a39cb1a82d7aec366f90e6cb5a212c1c98a3911416efbcacb87", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40181-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e8da9a0d436a04e599a674866f0bc1654f896eaddaa064e125c713bbd955ece0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40181-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "92663605fea62235e345d798be317a67c8b47b7e4caa54688808681df126f201", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "b29bfcc5444114f0eece3f4e4e49ddb17626a7a0d1f51581fbd92d9bc890c9a4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e4bfb9153b8d025e0a3df8c644d0fd6d2c246728c69bd45d61213b99800eafb1", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "74c485d4a2707d077040400806a016eb2fa10c0d93bf5d72e361b4ae34aaa005", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40182-original.ppm", + "sha256": "182fd7b16e64d735509dc4bb4a2f71f8b8f68b284a4d2a568b520815624c783f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40182-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "873496e312473a4593017485d11639e863c8917f5c6acb6ea5c75b39084deb4e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2b2c004f142692c5bdd5050fb3150b450c5f5bd34496d2d92863e8077f335944", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1976cc9fd72dbcb17a7fe1b906e72377f6630a63f08e3f426972976405afa7d6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "10a5f08e71a316ee7bb6e4e0f36f4c44594a0800f7315ee4d5bfc128ad3a09c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40183-original.ppm", + "sha256": "e73d400f5f3687fd8414e28b802dddab4bc17e0434b0c41274c5b5f294d19220", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40183-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "91b2ef1b249f19024e007a423f159966c00c2e8f4c474ce43d966acb74c5cf48", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "8a86f5b68e9b7e281140bcfb372b9c28805d04f0bbd958486b758bba690ac301", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "716c8a06d2843ecffec70c757a974650e1b0ede11d217f6ad4078f8bcea10835", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "aec21c3a83cb0412a1ac3dfa04a42157c4911f6b0d90c3608910d81fef25f921", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40184-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5c86ebfbd4f0ea39cd2083802dde03526fd9666f496620b97d929c03b06a2c30", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40175-40184/runtime/40184-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40185": { @@ -402149,7 +429166,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40185", "family_id": "terrain-40185-40194", "job_id": "terrain-40185-40194", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -402165,6 +429182,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/candidate.json", "sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a0dc3300158ae0d596791a564fce239ebf42829cd04848c5a6cccba5ae7bb03d", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.182491+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"All source cliff wedge/curves, lip/shadow direction and orange-lower/brown-upper ground regions persist. 4018c notch,4018e tapering tilted rock,4018f large bottom-reaching rock,40190/40191 diagonal boundaries,40192/40193 shared oblong boulder and40194 two tilted rocks retain source placement. Cleanv2 has no invented straight quarter-grid lines; changed grain is disclosed.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 706b1a4780e7eaa6594876ffd158ae0cd8e648d0c45c54bc7290e54afc17ae57", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40185", + "40186", + "40187", + "40188" + ], + "sha256": "1b5139822e60551bb982c1686cb4e6a7e10811ee2fd108f3866ed054204bced0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40189", + "4018a", + "4018b", + "4018c" + ], + "sha256": "bb048d2249c27e54cb822893d346885a32b0d293225c54db2a52fd39b7afc04e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4018d", + "4018e", + "4018f", + "40190" + ], + "sha256": "46a2f579b51d9fc7b58a9bb733b2312693da3b2663187af34518a05268f3a9dc", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40191", + "40192", + "40193", + "40194" + ], + "sha256": "4fde949f74ce5d823cfbda462dd530525e91e22d3d5171df11eac25555710289", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40185-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "16e6e9ff46284302e59d2c138c658539b6ea73e178aa68c99d73bed7185f9995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d2df9f081297ce85a911cac24609ba52dea401a88a73594e8992f53fe3df2807", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f09ad009ea8563fc6528beee9c4ecb6fbfd9f49260f1189ad3dbe5e93fe2204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "61b48c823dec16b350d59a0ae6fe05b6c706be706587aac023ab4f372c4fb9c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-original.ppm", + "sha256": "837041d5a64fbe2495e086084e5fd8ad0efde0781c25672b5c6570e6cd5ce75a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0b71bb8c00973c950aa25caaf79819878286a8651c09be6dca4124802f174118", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "892f69d5d7bdcfa445f1c4d9fbb2889995f6a79ed0f54c3f01811d8103514ef7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56757a994d4613fa93a1e4ae3208ab80e0c9c48708867b6ea162efb150bd6d39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "421cb42e828ed02d701cc2667c6a937e2f71575573fece53a34ac74721bb7320", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fecf556bccbe4f03bdeae2f59493a2c86d611157184c118dcc1ef6757f8fcba8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d9c7df53787ac143df89f17ffccde6dbde485e1cb82b519f39b470c63d0d6c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afacc2fbe5b671d6dcaeaa255ad5eeadc9f4b2bfec05082cd55da82a21c90197", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5362165f51b963fb6b76588886604867222c60eb2ec3ab64e72593a7ac4bc5bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0417088410e49670bc963beea7b8be17b6d8b5a3808cb161295ee71f567e6a83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7f3bd65cbae623fc9e1cdeb170c42e29759208852326caec0de23aef842fabc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "415c09ba7701d36fa2955d21005715e16a3cb75a9610d01f09842ae95c52fb76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "085833e696cf6976ce90eed97e2033c4330d8350d885701e630067fda654bcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f48f69d21767674c9bcd9f92f8886b7ab44d6f645327f4b079a01cdd727ee95b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "343c752edac86a2e6e0e98173912e7c54f315451ac7e7e94462158250dee4c57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a446c698739f1fea2129c5d8c8d66b7d3199054720ecf79dc68117af185a31b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "853ad4528bdf6cc3c94aeb8f6b9f965ae488e60d46a392f071f7c120783c6b85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4e094be2afe9756b750cc7f84108865059aca3cef912572aabebf423e280a6d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a8d56618df03e5481079b09cc8f4d7eadf0de2e423419035991fda7294a3f7c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0ed97e74a0ee885127789ab0c0569a7229a47a3d26a61b311bc5bb5eed519107", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7cfc7fc9963ee23b756b1b44fcf24e34733f27f6c697cbde4cdccce711204ead", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e95db65e42e07a4a4d1f32e012ace8e95a2f4edd1ebf1a35276247136fa95963", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6e086bc5888fad9e4cec3d784eed7b829deda94570108d61073bc4303461722f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bc4679e584e87a2356ac172514ecce8c043e2403959494a48ea0fcdcd293910f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d65e253a9a9abd1b44695f1d371be6447b14d7c6280b5a5b84e0ce2445349b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d8363d5f7c1287817a76d7fb381185219bfec0567e439e3e01921c981af0a42e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "95ea257daaa20e7703a0d7c790e8b2749f6abc14635f78d233f3b75ad35cddfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "62e040b11276b2a28fcdc151584da41bbe97e35e04c499d29dbee6b2ace08d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b88cd9285e402e9a44574aa82272aa4f2d1626982f00d356ca81ef4357fd7a4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a891905eec858ea35260e88035f94c7ad01b590b1cdc9d849567d3b76acc76b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8e5422cd0376a74985eb0240671049f1b257c83142ce9e34763f6f9e36c8e03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "74a18fe6657297b4aaed2c0587ee4f5cb4d80a464c6bea1a3b5ea8d2f73df7e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "47efdf58dbc13a2c89f9f01c2c068b7876d75f60bdb8a4f43bf02830d567fecd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f6804bab60508dbf3f99307eb1b44b3d2d37039503bf83b834f44914b6682d26", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f024bc2da5f0dc8abca0cb0532144cf60cf638e07f67d1da174e3c117d4be91d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "77ef5417d0830c673e32a2b36256d261933e0b6bc71072f849ed9a8cdfac3ea6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fe5f2791146275ad9a01fe41c1b6dba758b8b67bfb97eb4ea038c09a9011361f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a55314e3d695c9fc59df25c98448e29d7d19918d95bfef51e789e45551841b1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35db28cf49d178106e419eeaec1426a7cfc7a1a327849fee4a2f842e5c3a28e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5682bf7d3cf99858d5124f44b914998d648c7e1b92ed80a6b95070959547530a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a3aca3dcd595e7a5a20b5e3ddd3e1b2a1c53a1b2e88fc83dc01719c17306d4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35327bd8600e625944b4698f49dc4702987176a385e0d0d579b80e1673069c88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2944b2ee489bb672cef8df8a8ef82fddd58c0a7ad02675706559f2d97f850b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e976afe266b4cd4e96a31a224b30f2e0ffd9d984452e532d986eb1f8998196ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6a8c2e4ab3ec19f9a698b670ee0d28608dcebc30d2a807b09d7003ba05daf175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fc7cea877ce739c24184c84109ec85dd523f12cec75d74e7eb515356dce8ae10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f7a3b0294bfe8bdf1e581f83d343e3fd850f7e7c3fd7d15fcd30446a67aa3c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "53a116251a85cfac95deabca095ca6f2fe9f4b830108f03c8fe18fa6f4639af6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "85628881078612cd7f6c9a492e810045c1b80a14b219086873ad9bd46ce20759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8b995e336a271d1484b2133efac681a5f360ea7e33213a5c5b2d9cecf9b2531", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5921b3c8d539313afe51a73f6b7a752378fc6a9f4ea3f234a1442775275005dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "80a5c3288250087bd0bc6187ac7e7a8c8789dab7842e5399e9dcee665bbb0caa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d0180348d037fa9b80d054f3ea34ff1448cc72fb732bc8f37b21e13e77788a38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e210343958c3eaaf086f7993860ae82806b20d1fc9b4f7c377ebb82aa7dc8ccb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b5084313b23a038e8d360cd58a1140d5551761de3206d7cecd87be89e1a1f306", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8abe2c737ddf84ffa4b7052fa7b520c27e8e3cc175cea8cc3ff33a7da9dd8d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "163fbc1c18f37ab83238440e9fe4437b0df6776806de9b8b80d288e66766abba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ffe141607abc1f1a77196337e46e99b988614f7e3315a89aaba46ddb5e1f85a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e12cb970f1a2c184459efb19d04f36ff86a3b12ca50ffdb2bcec815d536f7dab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "59643c05e20db04f9a5e08c0c47e42419a353e600301620631e9903825eb58cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250b6ae4937cc3b15f8270a4e58c200df6196b1d81dfdb398160acaeadf5bf23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37a02eabacdab34bf65b867efee76e47ff41925982f18b9793445e1fa9aae18b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cac01c201aec508ea2a9dffefc056d7f4cbf3fe0b31b44fcdbdcceb979bc586b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82e7c6e145b2e0e174bb8eb27044ea386592c300e6815efd450ba2befdd54e22", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b24a64fa7032044a02e660854a9b575b68f40873b0e5164ee577e2e5efb8e8e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-original.ppm", + "sha256": "281c53b4f63b17c486a8f33040be35104a7d2eeda1cc739903ebd1d21cfebaa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f61661ed59cd25c5033c519b8274329c6fc4988b37bf5358e49179c6218ae882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db3f643f748332ff908097d353d213dd993d522442637268304d5f5818dbdc2b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e3346559518b4078de56f27cc0ef48fdef545c451c816402bde77b491ecb876", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "52c7828bc9ee7ba7c410dd2acdfa1e106a28debc3ab622fb7a41ff6596c55bf6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4f8e908bd41ecb442e5a535dda5aa468ea6610fae169550e9b5f570bf7ec348c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6e0106cb11b9c0fefa9a1b2657cec2f7a3a5ede57bcbf4c339fc2469e532b608", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "59b3031287b8fc5fa5e0b035eb5797a278519fd7f3eec26931695af4b2772100", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6983135b2c07e6d1fc174539cd4902947636d5dbe3863abf5281b97d2757a36b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "99b318261fbf11732af653226ce69eb758fbbcd36c6339bcaeb99f37ad1a306c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eddfd182df049a93ce41d2b19ee23055c1fd39dd80e6d757b5f75f87ba143b7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40186": { @@ -402186,7 +429673,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40186", "family_id": "terrain-40185-40194", "job_id": "terrain-40185-40194", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -402202,6 +429689,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/candidate.json", "sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a0dc3300158ae0d596791a564fce239ebf42829cd04848c5a6cccba5ae7bb03d", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.182491+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"All source cliff wedge/curves, lip/shadow direction and orange-lower/brown-upper ground regions persist. 4018c notch,4018e tapering tilted rock,4018f large bottom-reaching rock,40190/40191 diagonal boundaries,40192/40193 shared oblong boulder and40194 two tilted rocks retain source placement. Cleanv2 has no invented straight quarter-grid lines; changed grain is disclosed.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 706b1a4780e7eaa6594876ffd158ae0cd8e648d0c45c54bc7290e54afc17ae57", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40185", + "40186", + "40187", + "40188" + ], + "sha256": "1b5139822e60551bb982c1686cb4e6a7e10811ee2fd108f3866ed054204bced0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40189", + "4018a", + "4018b", + "4018c" + ], + "sha256": "bb048d2249c27e54cb822893d346885a32b0d293225c54db2a52fd39b7afc04e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4018d", + "4018e", + "4018f", + "40190" + ], + "sha256": "46a2f579b51d9fc7b58a9bb733b2312693da3b2663187af34518a05268f3a9dc", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40191", + "40192", + "40193", + "40194" + ], + "sha256": "4fde949f74ce5d823cfbda462dd530525e91e22d3d5171df11eac25555710289", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40185-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "16e6e9ff46284302e59d2c138c658539b6ea73e178aa68c99d73bed7185f9995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d2df9f081297ce85a911cac24609ba52dea401a88a73594e8992f53fe3df2807", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f09ad009ea8563fc6528beee9c4ecb6fbfd9f49260f1189ad3dbe5e93fe2204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "61b48c823dec16b350d59a0ae6fe05b6c706be706587aac023ab4f372c4fb9c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-original.ppm", + "sha256": "837041d5a64fbe2495e086084e5fd8ad0efde0781c25672b5c6570e6cd5ce75a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0b71bb8c00973c950aa25caaf79819878286a8651c09be6dca4124802f174118", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "892f69d5d7bdcfa445f1c4d9fbb2889995f6a79ed0f54c3f01811d8103514ef7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56757a994d4613fa93a1e4ae3208ab80e0c9c48708867b6ea162efb150bd6d39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "421cb42e828ed02d701cc2667c6a937e2f71575573fece53a34ac74721bb7320", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fecf556bccbe4f03bdeae2f59493a2c86d611157184c118dcc1ef6757f8fcba8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d9c7df53787ac143df89f17ffccde6dbde485e1cb82b519f39b470c63d0d6c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afacc2fbe5b671d6dcaeaa255ad5eeadc9f4b2bfec05082cd55da82a21c90197", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5362165f51b963fb6b76588886604867222c60eb2ec3ab64e72593a7ac4bc5bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0417088410e49670bc963beea7b8be17b6d8b5a3808cb161295ee71f567e6a83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7f3bd65cbae623fc9e1cdeb170c42e29759208852326caec0de23aef842fabc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "415c09ba7701d36fa2955d21005715e16a3cb75a9610d01f09842ae95c52fb76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "085833e696cf6976ce90eed97e2033c4330d8350d885701e630067fda654bcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f48f69d21767674c9bcd9f92f8886b7ab44d6f645327f4b079a01cdd727ee95b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "343c752edac86a2e6e0e98173912e7c54f315451ac7e7e94462158250dee4c57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a446c698739f1fea2129c5d8c8d66b7d3199054720ecf79dc68117af185a31b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "853ad4528bdf6cc3c94aeb8f6b9f965ae488e60d46a392f071f7c120783c6b85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4e094be2afe9756b750cc7f84108865059aca3cef912572aabebf423e280a6d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a8d56618df03e5481079b09cc8f4d7eadf0de2e423419035991fda7294a3f7c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0ed97e74a0ee885127789ab0c0569a7229a47a3d26a61b311bc5bb5eed519107", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7cfc7fc9963ee23b756b1b44fcf24e34733f27f6c697cbde4cdccce711204ead", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e95db65e42e07a4a4d1f32e012ace8e95a2f4edd1ebf1a35276247136fa95963", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6e086bc5888fad9e4cec3d784eed7b829deda94570108d61073bc4303461722f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bc4679e584e87a2356ac172514ecce8c043e2403959494a48ea0fcdcd293910f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d65e253a9a9abd1b44695f1d371be6447b14d7c6280b5a5b84e0ce2445349b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d8363d5f7c1287817a76d7fb381185219bfec0567e439e3e01921c981af0a42e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "95ea257daaa20e7703a0d7c790e8b2749f6abc14635f78d233f3b75ad35cddfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "62e040b11276b2a28fcdc151584da41bbe97e35e04c499d29dbee6b2ace08d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b88cd9285e402e9a44574aa82272aa4f2d1626982f00d356ca81ef4357fd7a4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a891905eec858ea35260e88035f94c7ad01b590b1cdc9d849567d3b76acc76b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8e5422cd0376a74985eb0240671049f1b257c83142ce9e34763f6f9e36c8e03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "74a18fe6657297b4aaed2c0587ee4f5cb4d80a464c6bea1a3b5ea8d2f73df7e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "47efdf58dbc13a2c89f9f01c2c068b7876d75f60bdb8a4f43bf02830d567fecd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f6804bab60508dbf3f99307eb1b44b3d2d37039503bf83b834f44914b6682d26", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f024bc2da5f0dc8abca0cb0532144cf60cf638e07f67d1da174e3c117d4be91d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "77ef5417d0830c673e32a2b36256d261933e0b6bc71072f849ed9a8cdfac3ea6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fe5f2791146275ad9a01fe41c1b6dba758b8b67bfb97eb4ea038c09a9011361f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a55314e3d695c9fc59df25c98448e29d7d19918d95bfef51e789e45551841b1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35db28cf49d178106e419eeaec1426a7cfc7a1a327849fee4a2f842e5c3a28e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5682bf7d3cf99858d5124f44b914998d648c7e1b92ed80a6b95070959547530a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a3aca3dcd595e7a5a20b5e3ddd3e1b2a1c53a1b2e88fc83dc01719c17306d4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35327bd8600e625944b4698f49dc4702987176a385e0d0d579b80e1673069c88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2944b2ee489bb672cef8df8a8ef82fddd58c0a7ad02675706559f2d97f850b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e976afe266b4cd4e96a31a224b30f2e0ffd9d984452e532d986eb1f8998196ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6a8c2e4ab3ec19f9a698b670ee0d28608dcebc30d2a807b09d7003ba05daf175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fc7cea877ce739c24184c84109ec85dd523f12cec75d74e7eb515356dce8ae10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f7a3b0294bfe8bdf1e581f83d343e3fd850f7e7c3fd7d15fcd30446a67aa3c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "53a116251a85cfac95deabca095ca6f2fe9f4b830108f03c8fe18fa6f4639af6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "85628881078612cd7f6c9a492e810045c1b80a14b219086873ad9bd46ce20759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8b995e336a271d1484b2133efac681a5f360ea7e33213a5c5b2d9cecf9b2531", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5921b3c8d539313afe51a73f6b7a752378fc6a9f4ea3f234a1442775275005dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "80a5c3288250087bd0bc6187ac7e7a8c8789dab7842e5399e9dcee665bbb0caa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d0180348d037fa9b80d054f3ea34ff1448cc72fb732bc8f37b21e13e77788a38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e210343958c3eaaf086f7993860ae82806b20d1fc9b4f7c377ebb82aa7dc8ccb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b5084313b23a038e8d360cd58a1140d5551761de3206d7cecd87be89e1a1f306", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8abe2c737ddf84ffa4b7052fa7b520c27e8e3cc175cea8cc3ff33a7da9dd8d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "163fbc1c18f37ab83238440e9fe4437b0df6776806de9b8b80d288e66766abba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ffe141607abc1f1a77196337e46e99b988614f7e3315a89aaba46ddb5e1f85a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e12cb970f1a2c184459efb19d04f36ff86a3b12ca50ffdb2bcec815d536f7dab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "59643c05e20db04f9a5e08c0c47e42419a353e600301620631e9903825eb58cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250b6ae4937cc3b15f8270a4e58c200df6196b1d81dfdb398160acaeadf5bf23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37a02eabacdab34bf65b867efee76e47ff41925982f18b9793445e1fa9aae18b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cac01c201aec508ea2a9dffefc056d7f4cbf3fe0b31b44fcdbdcceb979bc586b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82e7c6e145b2e0e174bb8eb27044ea386592c300e6815efd450ba2befdd54e22", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b24a64fa7032044a02e660854a9b575b68f40873b0e5164ee577e2e5efb8e8e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-original.ppm", + "sha256": "281c53b4f63b17c486a8f33040be35104a7d2eeda1cc739903ebd1d21cfebaa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f61661ed59cd25c5033c519b8274329c6fc4988b37bf5358e49179c6218ae882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db3f643f748332ff908097d353d213dd993d522442637268304d5f5818dbdc2b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e3346559518b4078de56f27cc0ef48fdef545c451c816402bde77b491ecb876", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "52c7828bc9ee7ba7c410dd2acdfa1e106a28debc3ab622fb7a41ff6596c55bf6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4f8e908bd41ecb442e5a535dda5aa468ea6610fae169550e9b5f570bf7ec348c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6e0106cb11b9c0fefa9a1b2657cec2f7a3a5ede57bcbf4c339fc2469e532b608", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "59b3031287b8fc5fa5e0b035eb5797a278519fd7f3eec26931695af4b2772100", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6983135b2c07e6d1fc174539cd4902947636d5dbe3863abf5281b97d2757a36b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "99b318261fbf11732af653226ce69eb758fbbcd36c6339bcaeb99f37ad1a306c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eddfd182df049a93ce41d2b19ee23055c1fd39dd80e6d757b5f75f87ba143b7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40187": { @@ -402223,7 +430180,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40187", "family_id": "terrain-40185-40194", "job_id": "terrain-40185-40194", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -402239,6 +430196,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/candidate.json", "sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a0dc3300158ae0d596791a564fce239ebf42829cd04848c5a6cccba5ae7bb03d", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.182491+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"All source cliff wedge/curves, lip/shadow direction and orange-lower/brown-upper ground regions persist. 4018c notch,4018e tapering tilted rock,4018f large bottom-reaching rock,40190/40191 diagonal boundaries,40192/40193 shared oblong boulder and40194 two tilted rocks retain source placement. Cleanv2 has no invented straight quarter-grid lines; changed grain is disclosed.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 706b1a4780e7eaa6594876ffd158ae0cd8e648d0c45c54bc7290e54afc17ae57", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40185", + "40186", + "40187", + "40188" + ], + "sha256": "1b5139822e60551bb982c1686cb4e6a7e10811ee2fd108f3866ed054204bced0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40189", + "4018a", + "4018b", + "4018c" + ], + "sha256": "bb048d2249c27e54cb822893d346885a32b0d293225c54db2a52fd39b7afc04e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4018d", + "4018e", + "4018f", + "40190" + ], + "sha256": "46a2f579b51d9fc7b58a9bb733b2312693da3b2663187af34518a05268f3a9dc", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40191", + "40192", + "40193", + "40194" + ], + "sha256": "4fde949f74ce5d823cfbda462dd530525e91e22d3d5171df11eac25555710289", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40185-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "16e6e9ff46284302e59d2c138c658539b6ea73e178aa68c99d73bed7185f9995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d2df9f081297ce85a911cac24609ba52dea401a88a73594e8992f53fe3df2807", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f09ad009ea8563fc6528beee9c4ecb6fbfd9f49260f1189ad3dbe5e93fe2204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "61b48c823dec16b350d59a0ae6fe05b6c706be706587aac023ab4f372c4fb9c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-original.ppm", + "sha256": "837041d5a64fbe2495e086084e5fd8ad0efde0781c25672b5c6570e6cd5ce75a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0b71bb8c00973c950aa25caaf79819878286a8651c09be6dca4124802f174118", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "892f69d5d7bdcfa445f1c4d9fbb2889995f6a79ed0f54c3f01811d8103514ef7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56757a994d4613fa93a1e4ae3208ab80e0c9c48708867b6ea162efb150bd6d39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "421cb42e828ed02d701cc2667c6a937e2f71575573fece53a34ac74721bb7320", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fecf556bccbe4f03bdeae2f59493a2c86d611157184c118dcc1ef6757f8fcba8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d9c7df53787ac143df89f17ffccde6dbde485e1cb82b519f39b470c63d0d6c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afacc2fbe5b671d6dcaeaa255ad5eeadc9f4b2bfec05082cd55da82a21c90197", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5362165f51b963fb6b76588886604867222c60eb2ec3ab64e72593a7ac4bc5bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0417088410e49670bc963beea7b8be17b6d8b5a3808cb161295ee71f567e6a83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7f3bd65cbae623fc9e1cdeb170c42e29759208852326caec0de23aef842fabc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "415c09ba7701d36fa2955d21005715e16a3cb75a9610d01f09842ae95c52fb76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "085833e696cf6976ce90eed97e2033c4330d8350d885701e630067fda654bcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f48f69d21767674c9bcd9f92f8886b7ab44d6f645327f4b079a01cdd727ee95b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "343c752edac86a2e6e0e98173912e7c54f315451ac7e7e94462158250dee4c57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a446c698739f1fea2129c5d8c8d66b7d3199054720ecf79dc68117af185a31b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "853ad4528bdf6cc3c94aeb8f6b9f965ae488e60d46a392f071f7c120783c6b85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4e094be2afe9756b750cc7f84108865059aca3cef912572aabebf423e280a6d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a8d56618df03e5481079b09cc8f4d7eadf0de2e423419035991fda7294a3f7c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0ed97e74a0ee885127789ab0c0569a7229a47a3d26a61b311bc5bb5eed519107", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7cfc7fc9963ee23b756b1b44fcf24e34733f27f6c697cbde4cdccce711204ead", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e95db65e42e07a4a4d1f32e012ace8e95a2f4edd1ebf1a35276247136fa95963", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6e086bc5888fad9e4cec3d784eed7b829deda94570108d61073bc4303461722f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bc4679e584e87a2356ac172514ecce8c043e2403959494a48ea0fcdcd293910f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d65e253a9a9abd1b44695f1d371be6447b14d7c6280b5a5b84e0ce2445349b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d8363d5f7c1287817a76d7fb381185219bfec0567e439e3e01921c981af0a42e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "95ea257daaa20e7703a0d7c790e8b2749f6abc14635f78d233f3b75ad35cddfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "62e040b11276b2a28fcdc151584da41bbe97e35e04c499d29dbee6b2ace08d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b88cd9285e402e9a44574aa82272aa4f2d1626982f00d356ca81ef4357fd7a4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a891905eec858ea35260e88035f94c7ad01b590b1cdc9d849567d3b76acc76b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8e5422cd0376a74985eb0240671049f1b257c83142ce9e34763f6f9e36c8e03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "74a18fe6657297b4aaed2c0587ee4f5cb4d80a464c6bea1a3b5ea8d2f73df7e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "47efdf58dbc13a2c89f9f01c2c068b7876d75f60bdb8a4f43bf02830d567fecd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f6804bab60508dbf3f99307eb1b44b3d2d37039503bf83b834f44914b6682d26", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f024bc2da5f0dc8abca0cb0532144cf60cf638e07f67d1da174e3c117d4be91d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "77ef5417d0830c673e32a2b36256d261933e0b6bc71072f849ed9a8cdfac3ea6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fe5f2791146275ad9a01fe41c1b6dba758b8b67bfb97eb4ea038c09a9011361f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a55314e3d695c9fc59df25c98448e29d7d19918d95bfef51e789e45551841b1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35db28cf49d178106e419eeaec1426a7cfc7a1a327849fee4a2f842e5c3a28e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5682bf7d3cf99858d5124f44b914998d648c7e1b92ed80a6b95070959547530a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a3aca3dcd595e7a5a20b5e3ddd3e1b2a1c53a1b2e88fc83dc01719c17306d4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35327bd8600e625944b4698f49dc4702987176a385e0d0d579b80e1673069c88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2944b2ee489bb672cef8df8a8ef82fddd58c0a7ad02675706559f2d97f850b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e976afe266b4cd4e96a31a224b30f2e0ffd9d984452e532d986eb1f8998196ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6a8c2e4ab3ec19f9a698b670ee0d28608dcebc30d2a807b09d7003ba05daf175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fc7cea877ce739c24184c84109ec85dd523f12cec75d74e7eb515356dce8ae10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f7a3b0294bfe8bdf1e581f83d343e3fd850f7e7c3fd7d15fcd30446a67aa3c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "53a116251a85cfac95deabca095ca6f2fe9f4b830108f03c8fe18fa6f4639af6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "85628881078612cd7f6c9a492e810045c1b80a14b219086873ad9bd46ce20759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8b995e336a271d1484b2133efac681a5f360ea7e33213a5c5b2d9cecf9b2531", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5921b3c8d539313afe51a73f6b7a752378fc6a9f4ea3f234a1442775275005dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "80a5c3288250087bd0bc6187ac7e7a8c8789dab7842e5399e9dcee665bbb0caa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d0180348d037fa9b80d054f3ea34ff1448cc72fb732bc8f37b21e13e77788a38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e210343958c3eaaf086f7993860ae82806b20d1fc9b4f7c377ebb82aa7dc8ccb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b5084313b23a038e8d360cd58a1140d5551761de3206d7cecd87be89e1a1f306", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8abe2c737ddf84ffa4b7052fa7b520c27e8e3cc175cea8cc3ff33a7da9dd8d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "163fbc1c18f37ab83238440e9fe4437b0df6776806de9b8b80d288e66766abba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ffe141607abc1f1a77196337e46e99b988614f7e3315a89aaba46ddb5e1f85a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e12cb970f1a2c184459efb19d04f36ff86a3b12ca50ffdb2bcec815d536f7dab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "59643c05e20db04f9a5e08c0c47e42419a353e600301620631e9903825eb58cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250b6ae4937cc3b15f8270a4e58c200df6196b1d81dfdb398160acaeadf5bf23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37a02eabacdab34bf65b867efee76e47ff41925982f18b9793445e1fa9aae18b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cac01c201aec508ea2a9dffefc056d7f4cbf3fe0b31b44fcdbdcceb979bc586b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82e7c6e145b2e0e174bb8eb27044ea386592c300e6815efd450ba2befdd54e22", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b24a64fa7032044a02e660854a9b575b68f40873b0e5164ee577e2e5efb8e8e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-original.ppm", + "sha256": "281c53b4f63b17c486a8f33040be35104a7d2eeda1cc739903ebd1d21cfebaa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f61661ed59cd25c5033c519b8274329c6fc4988b37bf5358e49179c6218ae882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db3f643f748332ff908097d353d213dd993d522442637268304d5f5818dbdc2b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e3346559518b4078de56f27cc0ef48fdef545c451c816402bde77b491ecb876", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "52c7828bc9ee7ba7c410dd2acdfa1e106a28debc3ab622fb7a41ff6596c55bf6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4f8e908bd41ecb442e5a535dda5aa468ea6610fae169550e9b5f570bf7ec348c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6e0106cb11b9c0fefa9a1b2657cec2f7a3a5ede57bcbf4c339fc2469e532b608", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "59b3031287b8fc5fa5e0b035eb5797a278519fd7f3eec26931695af4b2772100", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6983135b2c07e6d1fc174539cd4902947636d5dbe3863abf5281b97d2757a36b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "99b318261fbf11732af653226ce69eb758fbbcd36c6339bcaeb99f37ad1a306c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eddfd182df049a93ce41d2b19ee23055c1fd39dd80e6d757b5f75f87ba143b7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40188": { @@ -402260,7 +430687,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40188", "family_id": "terrain-40185-40194", "job_id": "terrain-40185-40194", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -402276,6 +430703,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/candidate.json", "sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a0dc3300158ae0d596791a564fce239ebf42829cd04848c5a6cccba5ae7bb03d", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.182491+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"All source cliff wedge/curves, lip/shadow direction and orange-lower/brown-upper ground regions persist. 4018c notch,4018e tapering tilted rock,4018f large bottom-reaching rock,40190/40191 diagonal boundaries,40192/40193 shared oblong boulder and40194 two tilted rocks retain source placement. Cleanv2 has no invented straight quarter-grid lines; changed grain is disclosed.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 706b1a4780e7eaa6594876ffd158ae0cd8e648d0c45c54bc7290e54afc17ae57", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40185", + "40186", + "40187", + "40188" + ], + "sha256": "1b5139822e60551bb982c1686cb4e6a7e10811ee2fd108f3866ed054204bced0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40189", + "4018a", + "4018b", + "4018c" + ], + "sha256": "bb048d2249c27e54cb822893d346885a32b0d293225c54db2a52fd39b7afc04e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4018d", + "4018e", + "4018f", + "40190" + ], + "sha256": "46a2f579b51d9fc7b58a9bb733b2312693da3b2663187af34518a05268f3a9dc", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40191", + "40192", + "40193", + "40194" + ], + "sha256": "4fde949f74ce5d823cfbda462dd530525e91e22d3d5171df11eac25555710289", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40185-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "16e6e9ff46284302e59d2c138c658539b6ea73e178aa68c99d73bed7185f9995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d2df9f081297ce85a911cac24609ba52dea401a88a73594e8992f53fe3df2807", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f09ad009ea8563fc6528beee9c4ecb6fbfd9f49260f1189ad3dbe5e93fe2204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "61b48c823dec16b350d59a0ae6fe05b6c706be706587aac023ab4f372c4fb9c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-original.ppm", + "sha256": "837041d5a64fbe2495e086084e5fd8ad0efde0781c25672b5c6570e6cd5ce75a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0b71bb8c00973c950aa25caaf79819878286a8651c09be6dca4124802f174118", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "892f69d5d7bdcfa445f1c4d9fbb2889995f6a79ed0f54c3f01811d8103514ef7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56757a994d4613fa93a1e4ae3208ab80e0c9c48708867b6ea162efb150bd6d39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "421cb42e828ed02d701cc2667c6a937e2f71575573fece53a34ac74721bb7320", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fecf556bccbe4f03bdeae2f59493a2c86d611157184c118dcc1ef6757f8fcba8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d9c7df53787ac143df89f17ffccde6dbde485e1cb82b519f39b470c63d0d6c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afacc2fbe5b671d6dcaeaa255ad5eeadc9f4b2bfec05082cd55da82a21c90197", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5362165f51b963fb6b76588886604867222c60eb2ec3ab64e72593a7ac4bc5bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0417088410e49670bc963beea7b8be17b6d8b5a3808cb161295ee71f567e6a83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7f3bd65cbae623fc9e1cdeb170c42e29759208852326caec0de23aef842fabc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "415c09ba7701d36fa2955d21005715e16a3cb75a9610d01f09842ae95c52fb76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "085833e696cf6976ce90eed97e2033c4330d8350d885701e630067fda654bcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f48f69d21767674c9bcd9f92f8886b7ab44d6f645327f4b079a01cdd727ee95b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "343c752edac86a2e6e0e98173912e7c54f315451ac7e7e94462158250dee4c57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a446c698739f1fea2129c5d8c8d66b7d3199054720ecf79dc68117af185a31b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "853ad4528bdf6cc3c94aeb8f6b9f965ae488e60d46a392f071f7c120783c6b85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4e094be2afe9756b750cc7f84108865059aca3cef912572aabebf423e280a6d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a8d56618df03e5481079b09cc8f4d7eadf0de2e423419035991fda7294a3f7c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0ed97e74a0ee885127789ab0c0569a7229a47a3d26a61b311bc5bb5eed519107", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7cfc7fc9963ee23b756b1b44fcf24e34733f27f6c697cbde4cdccce711204ead", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e95db65e42e07a4a4d1f32e012ace8e95a2f4edd1ebf1a35276247136fa95963", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6e086bc5888fad9e4cec3d784eed7b829deda94570108d61073bc4303461722f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bc4679e584e87a2356ac172514ecce8c043e2403959494a48ea0fcdcd293910f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d65e253a9a9abd1b44695f1d371be6447b14d7c6280b5a5b84e0ce2445349b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d8363d5f7c1287817a76d7fb381185219bfec0567e439e3e01921c981af0a42e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "95ea257daaa20e7703a0d7c790e8b2749f6abc14635f78d233f3b75ad35cddfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "62e040b11276b2a28fcdc151584da41bbe97e35e04c499d29dbee6b2ace08d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b88cd9285e402e9a44574aa82272aa4f2d1626982f00d356ca81ef4357fd7a4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a891905eec858ea35260e88035f94c7ad01b590b1cdc9d849567d3b76acc76b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8e5422cd0376a74985eb0240671049f1b257c83142ce9e34763f6f9e36c8e03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "74a18fe6657297b4aaed2c0587ee4f5cb4d80a464c6bea1a3b5ea8d2f73df7e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "47efdf58dbc13a2c89f9f01c2c068b7876d75f60bdb8a4f43bf02830d567fecd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f6804bab60508dbf3f99307eb1b44b3d2d37039503bf83b834f44914b6682d26", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f024bc2da5f0dc8abca0cb0532144cf60cf638e07f67d1da174e3c117d4be91d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "77ef5417d0830c673e32a2b36256d261933e0b6bc71072f849ed9a8cdfac3ea6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fe5f2791146275ad9a01fe41c1b6dba758b8b67bfb97eb4ea038c09a9011361f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a55314e3d695c9fc59df25c98448e29d7d19918d95bfef51e789e45551841b1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35db28cf49d178106e419eeaec1426a7cfc7a1a327849fee4a2f842e5c3a28e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5682bf7d3cf99858d5124f44b914998d648c7e1b92ed80a6b95070959547530a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a3aca3dcd595e7a5a20b5e3ddd3e1b2a1c53a1b2e88fc83dc01719c17306d4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35327bd8600e625944b4698f49dc4702987176a385e0d0d579b80e1673069c88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2944b2ee489bb672cef8df8a8ef82fddd58c0a7ad02675706559f2d97f850b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e976afe266b4cd4e96a31a224b30f2e0ffd9d984452e532d986eb1f8998196ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6a8c2e4ab3ec19f9a698b670ee0d28608dcebc30d2a807b09d7003ba05daf175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fc7cea877ce739c24184c84109ec85dd523f12cec75d74e7eb515356dce8ae10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f7a3b0294bfe8bdf1e581f83d343e3fd850f7e7c3fd7d15fcd30446a67aa3c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "53a116251a85cfac95deabca095ca6f2fe9f4b830108f03c8fe18fa6f4639af6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "85628881078612cd7f6c9a492e810045c1b80a14b219086873ad9bd46ce20759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8b995e336a271d1484b2133efac681a5f360ea7e33213a5c5b2d9cecf9b2531", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5921b3c8d539313afe51a73f6b7a752378fc6a9f4ea3f234a1442775275005dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "80a5c3288250087bd0bc6187ac7e7a8c8789dab7842e5399e9dcee665bbb0caa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d0180348d037fa9b80d054f3ea34ff1448cc72fb732bc8f37b21e13e77788a38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e210343958c3eaaf086f7993860ae82806b20d1fc9b4f7c377ebb82aa7dc8ccb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b5084313b23a038e8d360cd58a1140d5551761de3206d7cecd87be89e1a1f306", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8abe2c737ddf84ffa4b7052fa7b520c27e8e3cc175cea8cc3ff33a7da9dd8d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "163fbc1c18f37ab83238440e9fe4437b0df6776806de9b8b80d288e66766abba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ffe141607abc1f1a77196337e46e99b988614f7e3315a89aaba46ddb5e1f85a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e12cb970f1a2c184459efb19d04f36ff86a3b12ca50ffdb2bcec815d536f7dab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "59643c05e20db04f9a5e08c0c47e42419a353e600301620631e9903825eb58cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250b6ae4937cc3b15f8270a4e58c200df6196b1d81dfdb398160acaeadf5bf23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37a02eabacdab34bf65b867efee76e47ff41925982f18b9793445e1fa9aae18b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cac01c201aec508ea2a9dffefc056d7f4cbf3fe0b31b44fcdbdcceb979bc586b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82e7c6e145b2e0e174bb8eb27044ea386592c300e6815efd450ba2befdd54e22", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b24a64fa7032044a02e660854a9b575b68f40873b0e5164ee577e2e5efb8e8e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-original.ppm", + "sha256": "281c53b4f63b17c486a8f33040be35104a7d2eeda1cc739903ebd1d21cfebaa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f61661ed59cd25c5033c519b8274329c6fc4988b37bf5358e49179c6218ae882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db3f643f748332ff908097d353d213dd993d522442637268304d5f5818dbdc2b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e3346559518b4078de56f27cc0ef48fdef545c451c816402bde77b491ecb876", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "52c7828bc9ee7ba7c410dd2acdfa1e106a28debc3ab622fb7a41ff6596c55bf6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4f8e908bd41ecb442e5a535dda5aa468ea6610fae169550e9b5f570bf7ec348c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6e0106cb11b9c0fefa9a1b2657cec2f7a3a5ede57bcbf4c339fc2469e532b608", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "59b3031287b8fc5fa5e0b035eb5797a278519fd7f3eec26931695af4b2772100", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6983135b2c07e6d1fc174539cd4902947636d5dbe3863abf5281b97d2757a36b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "99b318261fbf11732af653226ce69eb758fbbcd36c6339bcaeb99f37ad1a306c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eddfd182df049a93ce41d2b19ee23055c1fd39dd80e6d757b5f75f87ba143b7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40189": { @@ -402297,7 +431194,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40189", "family_id": "terrain-40185-40194", "job_id": "terrain-40185-40194", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -402313,6 +431210,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/candidate.json", "sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a0dc3300158ae0d596791a564fce239ebf42829cd04848c5a6cccba5ae7bb03d", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.182491+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"All source cliff wedge/curves, lip/shadow direction and orange-lower/brown-upper ground regions persist. 4018c notch,4018e tapering tilted rock,4018f large bottom-reaching rock,40190/40191 diagonal boundaries,40192/40193 shared oblong boulder and40194 two tilted rocks retain source placement. Cleanv2 has no invented straight quarter-grid lines; changed grain is disclosed.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 706b1a4780e7eaa6594876ffd158ae0cd8e648d0c45c54bc7290e54afc17ae57", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40185", + "40186", + "40187", + "40188" + ], + "sha256": "1b5139822e60551bb982c1686cb4e6a7e10811ee2fd108f3866ed054204bced0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40189", + "4018a", + "4018b", + "4018c" + ], + "sha256": "bb048d2249c27e54cb822893d346885a32b0d293225c54db2a52fd39b7afc04e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4018d", + "4018e", + "4018f", + "40190" + ], + "sha256": "46a2f579b51d9fc7b58a9bb733b2312693da3b2663187af34518a05268f3a9dc", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40191", + "40192", + "40193", + "40194" + ], + "sha256": "4fde949f74ce5d823cfbda462dd530525e91e22d3d5171df11eac25555710289", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40185-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "16e6e9ff46284302e59d2c138c658539b6ea73e178aa68c99d73bed7185f9995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d2df9f081297ce85a911cac24609ba52dea401a88a73594e8992f53fe3df2807", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f09ad009ea8563fc6528beee9c4ecb6fbfd9f49260f1189ad3dbe5e93fe2204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "61b48c823dec16b350d59a0ae6fe05b6c706be706587aac023ab4f372c4fb9c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-original.ppm", + "sha256": "837041d5a64fbe2495e086084e5fd8ad0efde0781c25672b5c6570e6cd5ce75a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0b71bb8c00973c950aa25caaf79819878286a8651c09be6dca4124802f174118", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "892f69d5d7bdcfa445f1c4d9fbb2889995f6a79ed0f54c3f01811d8103514ef7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56757a994d4613fa93a1e4ae3208ab80e0c9c48708867b6ea162efb150bd6d39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "421cb42e828ed02d701cc2667c6a937e2f71575573fece53a34ac74721bb7320", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fecf556bccbe4f03bdeae2f59493a2c86d611157184c118dcc1ef6757f8fcba8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d9c7df53787ac143df89f17ffccde6dbde485e1cb82b519f39b470c63d0d6c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afacc2fbe5b671d6dcaeaa255ad5eeadc9f4b2bfec05082cd55da82a21c90197", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5362165f51b963fb6b76588886604867222c60eb2ec3ab64e72593a7ac4bc5bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0417088410e49670bc963beea7b8be17b6d8b5a3808cb161295ee71f567e6a83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7f3bd65cbae623fc9e1cdeb170c42e29759208852326caec0de23aef842fabc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "415c09ba7701d36fa2955d21005715e16a3cb75a9610d01f09842ae95c52fb76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "085833e696cf6976ce90eed97e2033c4330d8350d885701e630067fda654bcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f48f69d21767674c9bcd9f92f8886b7ab44d6f645327f4b079a01cdd727ee95b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "343c752edac86a2e6e0e98173912e7c54f315451ac7e7e94462158250dee4c57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a446c698739f1fea2129c5d8c8d66b7d3199054720ecf79dc68117af185a31b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "853ad4528bdf6cc3c94aeb8f6b9f965ae488e60d46a392f071f7c120783c6b85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4e094be2afe9756b750cc7f84108865059aca3cef912572aabebf423e280a6d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a8d56618df03e5481079b09cc8f4d7eadf0de2e423419035991fda7294a3f7c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0ed97e74a0ee885127789ab0c0569a7229a47a3d26a61b311bc5bb5eed519107", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7cfc7fc9963ee23b756b1b44fcf24e34733f27f6c697cbde4cdccce711204ead", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e95db65e42e07a4a4d1f32e012ace8e95a2f4edd1ebf1a35276247136fa95963", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6e086bc5888fad9e4cec3d784eed7b829deda94570108d61073bc4303461722f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bc4679e584e87a2356ac172514ecce8c043e2403959494a48ea0fcdcd293910f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d65e253a9a9abd1b44695f1d371be6447b14d7c6280b5a5b84e0ce2445349b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d8363d5f7c1287817a76d7fb381185219bfec0567e439e3e01921c981af0a42e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "95ea257daaa20e7703a0d7c790e8b2749f6abc14635f78d233f3b75ad35cddfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "62e040b11276b2a28fcdc151584da41bbe97e35e04c499d29dbee6b2ace08d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b88cd9285e402e9a44574aa82272aa4f2d1626982f00d356ca81ef4357fd7a4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a891905eec858ea35260e88035f94c7ad01b590b1cdc9d849567d3b76acc76b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8e5422cd0376a74985eb0240671049f1b257c83142ce9e34763f6f9e36c8e03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "74a18fe6657297b4aaed2c0587ee4f5cb4d80a464c6bea1a3b5ea8d2f73df7e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "47efdf58dbc13a2c89f9f01c2c068b7876d75f60bdb8a4f43bf02830d567fecd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f6804bab60508dbf3f99307eb1b44b3d2d37039503bf83b834f44914b6682d26", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f024bc2da5f0dc8abca0cb0532144cf60cf638e07f67d1da174e3c117d4be91d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "77ef5417d0830c673e32a2b36256d261933e0b6bc71072f849ed9a8cdfac3ea6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fe5f2791146275ad9a01fe41c1b6dba758b8b67bfb97eb4ea038c09a9011361f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a55314e3d695c9fc59df25c98448e29d7d19918d95bfef51e789e45551841b1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35db28cf49d178106e419eeaec1426a7cfc7a1a327849fee4a2f842e5c3a28e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5682bf7d3cf99858d5124f44b914998d648c7e1b92ed80a6b95070959547530a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a3aca3dcd595e7a5a20b5e3ddd3e1b2a1c53a1b2e88fc83dc01719c17306d4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35327bd8600e625944b4698f49dc4702987176a385e0d0d579b80e1673069c88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2944b2ee489bb672cef8df8a8ef82fddd58c0a7ad02675706559f2d97f850b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e976afe266b4cd4e96a31a224b30f2e0ffd9d984452e532d986eb1f8998196ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6a8c2e4ab3ec19f9a698b670ee0d28608dcebc30d2a807b09d7003ba05daf175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fc7cea877ce739c24184c84109ec85dd523f12cec75d74e7eb515356dce8ae10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f7a3b0294bfe8bdf1e581f83d343e3fd850f7e7c3fd7d15fcd30446a67aa3c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "53a116251a85cfac95deabca095ca6f2fe9f4b830108f03c8fe18fa6f4639af6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "85628881078612cd7f6c9a492e810045c1b80a14b219086873ad9bd46ce20759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8b995e336a271d1484b2133efac681a5f360ea7e33213a5c5b2d9cecf9b2531", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5921b3c8d539313afe51a73f6b7a752378fc6a9f4ea3f234a1442775275005dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "80a5c3288250087bd0bc6187ac7e7a8c8789dab7842e5399e9dcee665bbb0caa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d0180348d037fa9b80d054f3ea34ff1448cc72fb732bc8f37b21e13e77788a38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e210343958c3eaaf086f7993860ae82806b20d1fc9b4f7c377ebb82aa7dc8ccb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b5084313b23a038e8d360cd58a1140d5551761de3206d7cecd87be89e1a1f306", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8abe2c737ddf84ffa4b7052fa7b520c27e8e3cc175cea8cc3ff33a7da9dd8d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "163fbc1c18f37ab83238440e9fe4437b0df6776806de9b8b80d288e66766abba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ffe141607abc1f1a77196337e46e99b988614f7e3315a89aaba46ddb5e1f85a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e12cb970f1a2c184459efb19d04f36ff86a3b12ca50ffdb2bcec815d536f7dab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "59643c05e20db04f9a5e08c0c47e42419a353e600301620631e9903825eb58cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250b6ae4937cc3b15f8270a4e58c200df6196b1d81dfdb398160acaeadf5bf23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37a02eabacdab34bf65b867efee76e47ff41925982f18b9793445e1fa9aae18b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cac01c201aec508ea2a9dffefc056d7f4cbf3fe0b31b44fcdbdcceb979bc586b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82e7c6e145b2e0e174bb8eb27044ea386592c300e6815efd450ba2befdd54e22", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b24a64fa7032044a02e660854a9b575b68f40873b0e5164ee577e2e5efb8e8e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-original.ppm", + "sha256": "281c53b4f63b17c486a8f33040be35104a7d2eeda1cc739903ebd1d21cfebaa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f61661ed59cd25c5033c519b8274329c6fc4988b37bf5358e49179c6218ae882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db3f643f748332ff908097d353d213dd993d522442637268304d5f5818dbdc2b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e3346559518b4078de56f27cc0ef48fdef545c451c816402bde77b491ecb876", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "52c7828bc9ee7ba7c410dd2acdfa1e106a28debc3ab622fb7a41ff6596c55bf6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4f8e908bd41ecb442e5a535dda5aa468ea6610fae169550e9b5f570bf7ec348c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6e0106cb11b9c0fefa9a1b2657cec2f7a3a5ede57bcbf4c339fc2469e532b608", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "59b3031287b8fc5fa5e0b035eb5797a278519fd7f3eec26931695af4b2772100", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6983135b2c07e6d1fc174539cd4902947636d5dbe3863abf5281b97d2757a36b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "99b318261fbf11732af653226ce69eb758fbbcd36c6339bcaeb99f37ad1a306c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eddfd182df049a93ce41d2b19ee23055c1fd39dd80e6d757b5f75f87ba143b7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4018a": { @@ -402334,7 +431701,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4018a", "family_id": "terrain-40185-40194", "job_id": "terrain-40185-40194", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -402350,6 +431717,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/candidate.json", "sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a0dc3300158ae0d596791a564fce239ebf42829cd04848c5a6cccba5ae7bb03d", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.182491+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"All source cliff wedge/curves, lip/shadow direction and orange-lower/brown-upper ground regions persist. 4018c notch,4018e tapering tilted rock,4018f large bottom-reaching rock,40190/40191 diagonal boundaries,40192/40193 shared oblong boulder and40194 two tilted rocks retain source placement. Cleanv2 has no invented straight quarter-grid lines; changed grain is disclosed.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 706b1a4780e7eaa6594876ffd158ae0cd8e648d0c45c54bc7290e54afc17ae57", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40185", + "40186", + "40187", + "40188" + ], + "sha256": "1b5139822e60551bb982c1686cb4e6a7e10811ee2fd108f3866ed054204bced0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40189", + "4018a", + "4018b", + "4018c" + ], + "sha256": "bb048d2249c27e54cb822893d346885a32b0d293225c54db2a52fd39b7afc04e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4018d", + "4018e", + "4018f", + "40190" + ], + "sha256": "46a2f579b51d9fc7b58a9bb733b2312693da3b2663187af34518a05268f3a9dc", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40191", + "40192", + "40193", + "40194" + ], + "sha256": "4fde949f74ce5d823cfbda462dd530525e91e22d3d5171df11eac25555710289", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40185-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "16e6e9ff46284302e59d2c138c658539b6ea73e178aa68c99d73bed7185f9995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d2df9f081297ce85a911cac24609ba52dea401a88a73594e8992f53fe3df2807", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f09ad009ea8563fc6528beee9c4ecb6fbfd9f49260f1189ad3dbe5e93fe2204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "61b48c823dec16b350d59a0ae6fe05b6c706be706587aac023ab4f372c4fb9c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-original.ppm", + "sha256": "837041d5a64fbe2495e086084e5fd8ad0efde0781c25672b5c6570e6cd5ce75a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0b71bb8c00973c950aa25caaf79819878286a8651c09be6dca4124802f174118", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "892f69d5d7bdcfa445f1c4d9fbb2889995f6a79ed0f54c3f01811d8103514ef7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56757a994d4613fa93a1e4ae3208ab80e0c9c48708867b6ea162efb150bd6d39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "421cb42e828ed02d701cc2667c6a937e2f71575573fece53a34ac74721bb7320", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fecf556bccbe4f03bdeae2f59493a2c86d611157184c118dcc1ef6757f8fcba8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d9c7df53787ac143df89f17ffccde6dbde485e1cb82b519f39b470c63d0d6c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afacc2fbe5b671d6dcaeaa255ad5eeadc9f4b2bfec05082cd55da82a21c90197", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5362165f51b963fb6b76588886604867222c60eb2ec3ab64e72593a7ac4bc5bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0417088410e49670bc963beea7b8be17b6d8b5a3808cb161295ee71f567e6a83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7f3bd65cbae623fc9e1cdeb170c42e29759208852326caec0de23aef842fabc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "415c09ba7701d36fa2955d21005715e16a3cb75a9610d01f09842ae95c52fb76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "085833e696cf6976ce90eed97e2033c4330d8350d885701e630067fda654bcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f48f69d21767674c9bcd9f92f8886b7ab44d6f645327f4b079a01cdd727ee95b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "343c752edac86a2e6e0e98173912e7c54f315451ac7e7e94462158250dee4c57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a446c698739f1fea2129c5d8c8d66b7d3199054720ecf79dc68117af185a31b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "853ad4528bdf6cc3c94aeb8f6b9f965ae488e60d46a392f071f7c120783c6b85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4e094be2afe9756b750cc7f84108865059aca3cef912572aabebf423e280a6d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a8d56618df03e5481079b09cc8f4d7eadf0de2e423419035991fda7294a3f7c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0ed97e74a0ee885127789ab0c0569a7229a47a3d26a61b311bc5bb5eed519107", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7cfc7fc9963ee23b756b1b44fcf24e34733f27f6c697cbde4cdccce711204ead", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e95db65e42e07a4a4d1f32e012ace8e95a2f4edd1ebf1a35276247136fa95963", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6e086bc5888fad9e4cec3d784eed7b829deda94570108d61073bc4303461722f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bc4679e584e87a2356ac172514ecce8c043e2403959494a48ea0fcdcd293910f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d65e253a9a9abd1b44695f1d371be6447b14d7c6280b5a5b84e0ce2445349b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d8363d5f7c1287817a76d7fb381185219bfec0567e439e3e01921c981af0a42e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "95ea257daaa20e7703a0d7c790e8b2749f6abc14635f78d233f3b75ad35cddfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "62e040b11276b2a28fcdc151584da41bbe97e35e04c499d29dbee6b2ace08d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b88cd9285e402e9a44574aa82272aa4f2d1626982f00d356ca81ef4357fd7a4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a891905eec858ea35260e88035f94c7ad01b590b1cdc9d849567d3b76acc76b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8e5422cd0376a74985eb0240671049f1b257c83142ce9e34763f6f9e36c8e03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "74a18fe6657297b4aaed2c0587ee4f5cb4d80a464c6bea1a3b5ea8d2f73df7e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "47efdf58dbc13a2c89f9f01c2c068b7876d75f60bdb8a4f43bf02830d567fecd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f6804bab60508dbf3f99307eb1b44b3d2d37039503bf83b834f44914b6682d26", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f024bc2da5f0dc8abca0cb0532144cf60cf638e07f67d1da174e3c117d4be91d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "77ef5417d0830c673e32a2b36256d261933e0b6bc71072f849ed9a8cdfac3ea6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fe5f2791146275ad9a01fe41c1b6dba758b8b67bfb97eb4ea038c09a9011361f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a55314e3d695c9fc59df25c98448e29d7d19918d95bfef51e789e45551841b1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35db28cf49d178106e419eeaec1426a7cfc7a1a327849fee4a2f842e5c3a28e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5682bf7d3cf99858d5124f44b914998d648c7e1b92ed80a6b95070959547530a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a3aca3dcd595e7a5a20b5e3ddd3e1b2a1c53a1b2e88fc83dc01719c17306d4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35327bd8600e625944b4698f49dc4702987176a385e0d0d579b80e1673069c88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2944b2ee489bb672cef8df8a8ef82fddd58c0a7ad02675706559f2d97f850b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e976afe266b4cd4e96a31a224b30f2e0ffd9d984452e532d986eb1f8998196ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6a8c2e4ab3ec19f9a698b670ee0d28608dcebc30d2a807b09d7003ba05daf175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fc7cea877ce739c24184c84109ec85dd523f12cec75d74e7eb515356dce8ae10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f7a3b0294bfe8bdf1e581f83d343e3fd850f7e7c3fd7d15fcd30446a67aa3c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "53a116251a85cfac95deabca095ca6f2fe9f4b830108f03c8fe18fa6f4639af6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "85628881078612cd7f6c9a492e810045c1b80a14b219086873ad9bd46ce20759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8b995e336a271d1484b2133efac681a5f360ea7e33213a5c5b2d9cecf9b2531", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5921b3c8d539313afe51a73f6b7a752378fc6a9f4ea3f234a1442775275005dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "80a5c3288250087bd0bc6187ac7e7a8c8789dab7842e5399e9dcee665bbb0caa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d0180348d037fa9b80d054f3ea34ff1448cc72fb732bc8f37b21e13e77788a38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e210343958c3eaaf086f7993860ae82806b20d1fc9b4f7c377ebb82aa7dc8ccb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b5084313b23a038e8d360cd58a1140d5551761de3206d7cecd87be89e1a1f306", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8abe2c737ddf84ffa4b7052fa7b520c27e8e3cc175cea8cc3ff33a7da9dd8d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "163fbc1c18f37ab83238440e9fe4437b0df6776806de9b8b80d288e66766abba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ffe141607abc1f1a77196337e46e99b988614f7e3315a89aaba46ddb5e1f85a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e12cb970f1a2c184459efb19d04f36ff86a3b12ca50ffdb2bcec815d536f7dab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "59643c05e20db04f9a5e08c0c47e42419a353e600301620631e9903825eb58cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250b6ae4937cc3b15f8270a4e58c200df6196b1d81dfdb398160acaeadf5bf23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37a02eabacdab34bf65b867efee76e47ff41925982f18b9793445e1fa9aae18b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cac01c201aec508ea2a9dffefc056d7f4cbf3fe0b31b44fcdbdcceb979bc586b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82e7c6e145b2e0e174bb8eb27044ea386592c300e6815efd450ba2befdd54e22", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b24a64fa7032044a02e660854a9b575b68f40873b0e5164ee577e2e5efb8e8e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-original.ppm", + "sha256": "281c53b4f63b17c486a8f33040be35104a7d2eeda1cc739903ebd1d21cfebaa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f61661ed59cd25c5033c519b8274329c6fc4988b37bf5358e49179c6218ae882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db3f643f748332ff908097d353d213dd993d522442637268304d5f5818dbdc2b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e3346559518b4078de56f27cc0ef48fdef545c451c816402bde77b491ecb876", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "52c7828bc9ee7ba7c410dd2acdfa1e106a28debc3ab622fb7a41ff6596c55bf6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4f8e908bd41ecb442e5a535dda5aa468ea6610fae169550e9b5f570bf7ec348c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6e0106cb11b9c0fefa9a1b2657cec2f7a3a5ede57bcbf4c339fc2469e532b608", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "59b3031287b8fc5fa5e0b035eb5797a278519fd7f3eec26931695af4b2772100", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6983135b2c07e6d1fc174539cd4902947636d5dbe3863abf5281b97d2757a36b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "99b318261fbf11732af653226ce69eb758fbbcd36c6339bcaeb99f37ad1a306c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eddfd182df049a93ce41d2b19ee23055c1fd39dd80e6d757b5f75f87ba143b7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4018b": { @@ -402371,7 +432208,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4018b", "family_id": "terrain-40185-40194", "job_id": "terrain-40185-40194", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -402387,6 +432224,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/candidate.json", "sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a0dc3300158ae0d596791a564fce239ebf42829cd04848c5a6cccba5ae7bb03d", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.182491+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"All source cliff wedge/curves, lip/shadow direction and orange-lower/brown-upper ground regions persist. 4018c notch,4018e tapering tilted rock,4018f large bottom-reaching rock,40190/40191 diagonal boundaries,40192/40193 shared oblong boulder and40194 two tilted rocks retain source placement. Cleanv2 has no invented straight quarter-grid lines; changed grain is disclosed.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 706b1a4780e7eaa6594876ffd158ae0cd8e648d0c45c54bc7290e54afc17ae57", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40185", + "40186", + "40187", + "40188" + ], + "sha256": "1b5139822e60551bb982c1686cb4e6a7e10811ee2fd108f3866ed054204bced0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40189", + "4018a", + "4018b", + "4018c" + ], + "sha256": "bb048d2249c27e54cb822893d346885a32b0d293225c54db2a52fd39b7afc04e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4018d", + "4018e", + "4018f", + "40190" + ], + "sha256": "46a2f579b51d9fc7b58a9bb733b2312693da3b2663187af34518a05268f3a9dc", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40191", + "40192", + "40193", + "40194" + ], + "sha256": "4fde949f74ce5d823cfbda462dd530525e91e22d3d5171df11eac25555710289", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40185-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "16e6e9ff46284302e59d2c138c658539b6ea73e178aa68c99d73bed7185f9995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d2df9f081297ce85a911cac24609ba52dea401a88a73594e8992f53fe3df2807", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f09ad009ea8563fc6528beee9c4ecb6fbfd9f49260f1189ad3dbe5e93fe2204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "61b48c823dec16b350d59a0ae6fe05b6c706be706587aac023ab4f372c4fb9c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-original.ppm", + "sha256": "837041d5a64fbe2495e086084e5fd8ad0efde0781c25672b5c6570e6cd5ce75a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0b71bb8c00973c950aa25caaf79819878286a8651c09be6dca4124802f174118", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "892f69d5d7bdcfa445f1c4d9fbb2889995f6a79ed0f54c3f01811d8103514ef7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56757a994d4613fa93a1e4ae3208ab80e0c9c48708867b6ea162efb150bd6d39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "421cb42e828ed02d701cc2667c6a937e2f71575573fece53a34ac74721bb7320", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fecf556bccbe4f03bdeae2f59493a2c86d611157184c118dcc1ef6757f8fcba8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d9c7df53787ac143df89f17ffccde6dbde485e1cb82b519f39b470c63d0d6c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afacc2fbe5b671d6dcaeaa255ad5eeadc9f4b2bfec05082cd55da82a21c90197", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5362165f51b963fb6b76588886604867222c60eb2ec3ab64e72593a7ac4bc5bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0417088410e49670bc963beea7b8be17b6d8b5a3808cb161295ee71f567e6a83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7f3bd65cbae623fc9e1cdeb170c42e29759208852326caec0de23aef842fabc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "415c09ba7701d36fa2955d21005715e16a3cb75a9610d01f09842ae95c52fb76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "085833e696cf6976ce90eed97e2033c4330d8350d885701e630067fda654bcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f48f69d21767674c9bcd9f92f8886b7ab44d6f645327f4b079a01cdd727ee95b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "343c752edac86a2e6e0e98173912e7c54f315451ac7e7e94462158250dee4c57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a446c698739f1fea2129c5d8c8d66b7d3199054720ecf79dc68117af185a31b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "853ad4528bdf6cc3c94aeb8f6b9f965ae488e60d46a392f071f7c120783c6b85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4e094be2afe9756b750cc7f84108865059aca3cef912572aabebf423e280a6d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a8d56618df03e5481079b09cc8f4d7eadf0de2e423419035991fda7294a3f7c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0ed97e74a0ee885127789ab0c0569a7229a47a3d26a61b311bc5bb5eed519107", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7cfc7fc9963ee23b756b1b44fcf24e34733f27f6c697cbde4cdccce711204ead", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e95db65e42e07a4a4d1f32e012ace8e95a2f4edd1ebf1a35276247136fa95963", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6e086bc5888fad9e4cec3d784eed7b829deda94570108d61073bc4303461722f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bc4679e584e87a2356ac172514ecce8c043e2403959494a48ea0fcdcd293910f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d65e253a9a9abd1b44695f1d371be6447b14d7c6280b5a5b84e0ce2445349b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d8363d5f7c1287817a76d7fb381185219bfec0567e439e3e01921c981af0a42e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "95ea257daaa20e7703a0d7c790e8b2749f6abc14635f78d233f3b75ad35cddfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "62e040b11276b2a28fcdc151584da41bbe97e35e04c499d29dbee6b2ace08d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b88cd9285e402e9a44574aa82272aa4f2d1626982f00d356ca81ef4357fd7a4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a891905eec858ea35260e88035f94c7ad01b590b1cdc9d849567d3b76acc76b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8e5422cd0376a74985eb0240671049f1b257c83142ce9e34763f6f9e36c8e03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "74a18fe6657297b4aaed2c0587ee4f5cb4d80a464c6bea1a3b5ea8d2f73df7e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "47efdf58dbc13a2c89f9f01c2c068b7876d75f60bdb8a4f43bf02830d567fecd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f6804bab60508dbf3f99307eb1b44b3d2d37039503bf83b834f44914b6682d26", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f024bc2da5f0dc8abca0cb0532144cf60cf638e07f67d1da174e3c117d4be91d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "77ef5417d0830c673e32a2b36256d261933e0b6bc71072f849ed9a8cdfac3ea6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fe5f2791146275ad9a01fe41c1b6dba758b8b67bfb97eb4ea038c09a9011361f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a55314e3d695c9fc59df25c98448e29d7d19918d95bfef51e789e45551841b1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35db28cf49d178106e419eeaec1426a7cfc7a1a327849fee4a2f842e5c3a28e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5682bf7d3cf99858d5124f44b914998d648c7e1b92ed80a6b95070959547530a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a3aca3dcd595e7a5a20b5e3ddd3e1b2a1c53a1b2e88fc83dc01719c17306d4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35327bd8600e625944b4698f49dc4702987176a385e0d0d579b80e1673069c88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2944b2ee489bb672cef8df8a8ef82fddd58c0a7ad02675706559f2d97f850b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e976afe266b4cd4e96a31a224b30f2e0ffd9d984452e532d986eb1f8998196ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6a8c2e4ab3ec19f9a698b670ee0d28608dcebc30d2a807b09d7003ba05daf175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fc7cea877ce739c24184c84109ec85dd523f12cec75d74e7eb515356dce8ae10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f7a3b0294bfe8bdf1e581f83d343e3fd850f7e7c3fd7d15fcd30446a67aa3c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "53a116251a85cfac95deabca095ca6f2fe9f4b830108f03c8fe18fa6f4639af6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "85628881078612cd7f6c9a492e810045c1b80a14b219086873ad9bd46ce20759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8b995e336a271d1484b2133efac681a5f360ea7e33213a5c5b2d9cecf9b2531", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5921b3c8d539313afe51a73f6b7a752378fc6a9f4ea3f234a1442775275005dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "80a5c3288250087bd0bc6187ac7e7a8c8789dab7842e5399e9dcee665bbb0caa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d0180348d037fa9b80d054f3ea34ff1448cc72fb732bc8f37b21e13e77788a38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e210343958c3eaaf086f7993860ae82806b20d1fc9b4f7c377ebb82aa7dc8ccb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b5084313b23a038e8d360cd58a1140d5551761de3206d7cecd87be89e1a1f306", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8abe2c737ddf84ffa4b7052fa7b520c27e8e3cc175cea8cc3ff33a7da9dd8d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "163fbc1c18f37ab83238440e9fe4437b0df6776806de9b8b80d288e66766abba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ffe141607abc1f1a77196337e46e99b988614f7e3315a89aaba46ddb5e1f85a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e12cb970f1a2c184459efb19d04f36ff86a3b12ca50ffdb2bcec815d536f7dab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "59643c05e20db04f9a5e08c0c47e42419a353e600301620631e9903825eb58cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250b6ae4937cc3b15f8270a4e58c200df6196b1d81dfdb398160acaeadf5bf23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37a02eabacdab34bf65b867efee76e47ff41925982f18b9793445e1fa9aae18b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cac01c201aec508ea2a9dffefc056d7f4cbf3fe0b31b44fcdbdcceb979bc586b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82e7c6e145b2e0e174bb8eb27044ea386592c300e6815efd450ba2befdd54e22", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b24a64fa7032044a02e660854a9b575b68f40873b0e5164ee577e2e5efb8e8e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-original.ppm", + "sha256": "281c53b4f63b17c486a8f33040be35104a7d2eeda1cc739903ebd1d21cfebaa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f61661ed59cd25c5033c519b8274329c6fc4988b37bf5358e49179c6218ae882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db3f643f748332ff908097d353d213dd993d522442637268304d5f5818dbdc2b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e3346559518b4078de56f27cc0ef48fdef545c451c816402bde77b491ecb876", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "52c7828bc9ee7ba7c410dd2acdfa1e106a28debc3ab622fb7a41ff6596c55bf6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4f8e908bd41ecb442e5a535dda5aa468ea6610fae169550e9b5f570bf7ec348c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6e0106cb11b9c0fefa9a1b2657cec2f7a3a5ede57bcbf4c339fc2469e532b608", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "59b3031287b8fc5fa5e0b035eb5797a278519fd7f3eec26931695af4b2772100", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6983135b2c07e6d1fc174539cd4902947636d5dbe3863abf5281b97d2757a36b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "99b318261fbf11732af653226ce69eb758fbbcd36c6339bcaeb99f37ad1a306c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eddfd182df049a93ce41d2b19ee23055c1fd39dd80e6d757b5f75f87ba143b7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4018c": { @@ -402408,7 +432715,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4018c", "family_id": "terrain-40185-40194", "job_id": "terrain-40185-40194", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -402424,6 +432731,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/candidate.json", "sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a0dc3300158ae0d596791a564fce239ebf42829cd04848c5a6cccba5ae7bb03d", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.182491+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"All source cliff wedge/curves, lip/shadow direction and orange-lower/brown-upper ground regions persist. 4018c notch,4018e tapering tilted rock,4018f large bottom-reaching rock,40190/40191 diagonal boundaries,40192/40193 shared oblong boulder and40194 two tilted rocks retain source placement. Cleanv2 has no invented straight quarter-grid lines; changed grain is disclosed.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 706b1a4780e7eaa6594876ffd158ae0cd8e648d0c45c54bc7290e54afc17ae57", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40185", + "40186", + "40187", + "40188" + ], + "sha256": "1b5139822e60551bb982c1686cb4e6a7e10811ee2fd108f3866ed054204bced0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40189", + "4018a", + "4018b", + "4018c" + ], + "sha256": "bb048d2249c27e54cb822893d346885a32b0d293225c54db2a52fd39b7afc04e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4018d", + "4018e", + "4018f", + "40190" + ], + "sha256": "46a2f579b51d9fc7b58a9bb733b2312693da3b2663187af34518a05268f3a9dc", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40191", + "40192", + "40193", + "40194" + ], + "sha256": "4fde949f74ce5d823cfbda462dd530525e91e22d3d5171df11eac25555710289", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40185-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "16e6e9ff46284302e59d2c138c658539b6ea73e178aa68c99d73bed7185f9995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d2df9f081297ce85a911cac24609ba52dea401a88a73594e8992f53fe3df2807", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f09ad009ea8563fc6528beee9c4ecb6fbfd9f49260f1189ad3dbe5e93fe2204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "61b48c823dec16b350d59a0ae6fe05b6c706be706587aac023ab4f372c4fb9c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-original.ppm", + "sha256": "837041d5a64fbe2495e086084e5fd8ad0efde0781c25672b5c6570e6cd5ce75a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0b71bb8c00973c950aa25caaf79819878286a8651c09be6dca4124802f174118", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "892f69d5d7bdcfa445f1c4d9fbb2889995f6a79ed0f54c3f01811d8103514ef7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56757a994d4613fa93a1e4ae3208ab80e0c9c48708867b6ea162efb150bd6d39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "421cb42e828ed02d701cc2667c6a937e2f71575573fece53a34ac74721bb7320", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fecf556bccbe4f03bdeae2f59493a2c86d611157184c118dcc1ef6757f8fcba8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d9c7df53787ac143df89f17ffccde6dbde485e1cb82b519f39b470c63d0d6c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afacc2fbe5b671d6dcaeaa255ad5eeadc9f4b2bfec05082cd55da82a21c90197", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5362165f51b963fb6b76588886604867222c60eb2ec3ab64e72593a7ac4bc5bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0417088410e49670bc963beea7b8be17b6d8b5a3808cb161295ee71f567e6a83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7f3bd65cbae623fc9e1cdeb170c42e29759208852326caec0de23aef842fabc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "415c09ba7701d36fa2955d21005715e16a3cb75a9610d01f09842ae95c52fb76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "085833e696cf6976ce90eed97e2033c4330d8350d885701e630067fda654bcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f48f69d21767674c9bcd9f92f8886b7ab44d6f645327f4b079a01cdd727ee95b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "343c752edac86a2e6e0e98173912e7c54f315451ac7e7e94462158250dee4c57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a446c698739f1fea2129c5d8c8d66b7d3199054720ecf79dc68117af185a31b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "853ad4528bdf6cc3c94aeb8f6b9f965ae488e60d46a392f071f7c120783c6b85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4e094be2afe9756b750cc7f84108865059aca3cef912572aabebf423e280a6d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a8d56618df03e5481079b09cc8f4d7eadf0de2e423419035991fda7294a3f7c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0ed97e74a0ee885127789ab0c0569a7229a47a3d26a61b311bc5bb5eed519107", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7cfc7fc9963ee23b756b1b44fcf24e34733f27f6c697cbde4cdccce711204ead", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e95db65e42e07a4a4d1f32e012ace8e95a2f4edd1ebf1a35276247136fa95963", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6e086bc5888fad9e4cec3d784eed7b829deda94570108d61073bc4303461722f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bc4679e584e87a2356ac172514ecce8c043e2403959494a48ea0fcdcd293910f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d65e253a9a9abd1b44695f1d371be6447b14d7c6280b5a5b84e0ce2445349b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d8363d5f7c1287817a76d7fb381185219bfec0567e439e3e01921c981af0a42e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "95ea257daaa20e7703a0d7c790e8b2749f6abc14635f78d233f3b75ad35cddfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "62e040b11276b2a28fcdc151584da41bbe97e35e04c499d29dbee6b2ace08d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b88cd9285e402e9a44574aa82272aa4f2d1626982f00d356ca81ef4357fd7a4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a891905eec858ea35260e88035f94c7ad01b590b1cdc9d849567d3b76acc76b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8e5422cd0376a74985eb0240671049f1b257c83142ce9e34763f6f9e36c8e03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "74a18fe6657297b4aaed2c0587ee4f5cb4d80a464c6bea1a3b5ea8d2f73df7e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "47efdf58dbc13a2c89f9f01c2c068b7876d75f60bdb8a4f43bf02830d567fecd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f6804bab60508dbf3f99307eb1b44b3d2d37039503bf83b834f44914b6682d26", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f024bc2da5f0dc8abca0cb0532144cf60cf638e07f67d1da174e3c117d4be91d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "77ef5417d0830c673e32a2b36256d261933e0b6bc71072f849ed9a8cdfac3ea6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fe5f2791146275ad9a01fe41c1b6dba758b8b67bfb97eb4ea038c09a9011361f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a55314e3d695c9fc59df25c98448e29d7d19918d95bfef51e789e45551841b1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35db28cf49d178106e419eeaec1426a7cfc7a1a327849fee4a2f842e5c3a28e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5682bf7d3cf99858d5124f44b914998d648c7e1b92ed80a6b95070959547530a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a3aca3dcd595e7a5a20b5e3ddd3e1b2a1c53a1b2e88fc83dc01719c17306d4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35327bd8600e625944b4698f49dc4702987176a385e0d0d579b80e1673069c88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2944b2ee489bb672cef8df8a8ef82fddd58c0a7ad02675706559f2d97f850b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e976afe266b4cd4e96a31a224b30f2e0ffd9d984452e532d986eb1f8998196ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6a8c2e4ab3ec19f9a698b670ee0d28608dcebc30d2a807b09d7003ba05daf175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fc7cea877ce739c24184c84109ec85dd523f12cec75d74e7eb515356dce8ae10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f7a3b0294bfe8bdf1e581f83d343e3fd850f7e7c3fd7d15fcd30446a67aa3c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "53a116251a85cfac95deabca095ca6f2fe9f4b830108f03c8fe18fa6f4639af6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "85628881078612cd7f6c9a492e810045c1b80a14b219086873ad9bd46ce20759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8b995e336a271d1484b2133efac681a5f360ea7e33213a5c5b2d9cecf9b2531", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5921b3c8d539313afe51a73f6b7a752378fc6a9f4ea3f234a1442775275005dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "80a5c3288250087bd0bc6187ac7e7a8c8789dab7842e5399e9dcee665bbb0caa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d0180348d037fa9b80d054f3ea34ff1448cc72fb732bc8f37b21e13e77788a38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e210343958c3eaaf086f7993860ae82806b20d1fc9b4f7c377ebb82aa7dc8ccb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b5084313b23a038e8d360cd58a1140d5551761de3206d7cecd87be89e1a1f306", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8abe2c737ddf84ffa4b7052fa7b520c27e8e3cc175cea8cc3ff33a7da9dd8d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "163fbc1c18f37ab83238440e9fe4437b0df6776806de9b8b80d288e66766abba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ffe141607abc1f1a77196337e46e99b988614f7e3315a89aaba46ddb5e1f85a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e12cb970f1a2c184459efb19d04f36ff86a3b12ca50ffdb2bcec815d536f7dab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "59643c05e20db04f9a5e08c0c47e42419a353e600301620631e9903825eb58cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250b6ae4937cc3b15f8270a4e58c200df6196b1d81dfdb398160acaeadf5bf23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37a02eabacdab34bf65b867efee76e47ff41925982f18b9793445e1fa9aae18b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cac01c201aec508ea2a9dffefc056d7f4cbf3fe0b31b44fcdbdcceb979bc586b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82e7c6e145b2e0e174bb8eb27044ea386592c300e6815efd450ba2befdd54e22", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b24a64fa7032044a02e660854a9b575b68f40873b0e5164ee577e2e5efb8e8e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-original.ppm", + "sha256": "281c53b4f63b17c486a8f33040be35104a7d2eeda1cc739903ebd1d21cfebaa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f61661ed59cd25c5033c519b8274329c6fc4988b37bf5358e49179c6218ae882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db3f643f748332ff908097d353d213dd993d522442637268304d5f5818dbdc2b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e3346559518b4078de56f27cc0ef48fdef545c451c816402bde77b491ecb876", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "52c7828bc9ee7ba7c410dd2acdfa1e106a28debc3ab622fb7a41ff6596c55bf6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4f8e908bd41ecb442e5a535dda5aa468ea6610fae169550e9b5f570bf7ec348c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6e0106cb11b9c0fefa9a1b2657cec2f7a3a5ede57bcbf4c339fc2469e532b608", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "59b3031287b8fc5fa5e0b035eb5797a278519fd7f3eec26931695af4b2772100", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6983135b2c07e6d1fc174539cd4902947636d5dbe3863abf5281b97d2757a36b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "99b318261fbf11732af653226ce69eb758fbbcd36c6339bcaeb99f37ad1a306c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eddfd182df049a93ce41d2b19ee23055c1fd39dd80e6d757b5f75f87ba143b7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4018d": { @@ -402445,7 +433222,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4018d", "family_id": "terrain-40185-40194", "job_id": "terrain-40185-40194", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -402461,6 +433238,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/candidate.json", "sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a0dc3300158ae0d596791a564fce239ebf42829cd04848c5a6cccba5ae7bb03d", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.182491+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"All source cliff wedge/curves, lip/shadow direction and orange-lower/brown-upper ground regions persist. 4018c notch,4018e tapering tilted rock,4018f large bottom-reaching rock,40190/40191 diagonal boundaries,40192/40193 shared oblong boulder and40194 two tilted rocks retain source placement. Cleanv2 has no invented straight quarter-grid lines; changed grain is disclosed.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 706b1a4780e7eaa6594876ffd158ae0cd8e648d0c45c54bc7290e54afc17ae57", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40185", + "40186", + "40187", + "40188" + ], + "sha256": "1b5139822e60551bb982c1686cb4e6a7e10811ee2fd108f3866ed054204bced0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40189", + "4018a", + "4018b", + "4018c" + ], + "sha256": "bb048d2249c27e54cb822893d346885a32b0d293225c54db2a52fd39b7afc04e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4018d", + "4018e", + "4018f", + "40190" + ], + "sha256": "46a2f579b51d9fc7b58a9bb733b2312693da3b2663187af34518a05268f3a9dc", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40191", + "40192", + "40193", + "40194" + ], + "sha256": "4fde949f74ce5d823cfbda462dd530525e91e22d3d5171df11eac25555710289", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40185-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "16e6e9ff46284302e59d2c138c658539b6ea73e178aa68c99d73bed7185f9995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d2df9f081297ce85a911cac24609ba52dea401a88a73594e8992f53fe3df2807", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f09ad009ea8563fc6528beee9c4ecb6fbfd9f49260f1189ad3dbe5e93fe2204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "61b48c823dec16b350d59a0ae6fe05b6c706be706587aac023ab4f372c4fb9c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-original.ppm", + "sha256": "837041d5a64fbe2495e086084e5fd8ad0efde0781c25672b5c6570e6cd5ce75a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0b71bb8c00973c950aa25caaf79819878286a8651c09be6dca4124802f174118", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "892f69d5d7bdcfa445f1c4d9fbb2889995f6a79ed0f54c3f01811d8103514ef7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56757a994d4613fa93a1e4ae3208ab80e0c9c48708867b6ea162efb150bd6d39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "421cb42e828ed02d701cc2667c6a937e2f71575573fece53a34ac74721bb7320", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fecf556bccbe4f03bdeae2f59493a2c86d611157184c118dcc1ef6757f8fcba8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d9c7df53787ac143df89f17ffccde6dbde485e1cb82b519f39b470c63d0d6c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afacc2fbe5b671d6dcaeaa255ad5eeadc9f4b2bfec05082cd55da82a21c90197", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5362165f51b963fb6b76588886604867222c60eb2ec3ab64e72593a7ac4bc5bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0417088410e49670bc963beea7b8be17b6d8b5a3808cb161295ee71f567e6a83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7f3bd65cbae623fc9e1cdeb170c42e29759208852326caec0de23aef842fabc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "415c09ba7701d36fa2955d21005715e16a3cb75a9610d01f09842ae95c52fb76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "085833e696cf6976ce90eed97e2033c4330d8350d885701e630067fda654bcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f48f69d21767674c9bcd9f92f8886b7ab44d6f645327f4b079a01cdd727ee95b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "343c752edac86a2e6e0e98173912e7c54f315451ac7e7e94462158250dee4c57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a446c698739f1fea2129c5d8c8d66b7d3199054720ecf79dc68117af185a31b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "853ad4528bdf6cc3c94aeb8f6b9f965ae488e60d46a392f071f7c120783c6b85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4e094be2afe9756b750cc7f84108865059aca3cef912572aabebf423e280a6d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a8d56618df03e5481079b09cc8f4d7eadf0de2e423419035991fda7294a3f7c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0ed97e74a0ee885127789ab0c0569a7229a47a3d26a61b311bc5bb5eed519107", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7cfc7fc9963ee23b756b1b44fcf24e34733f27f6c697cbde4cdccce711204ead", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e95db65e42e07a4a4d1f32e012ace8e95a2f4edd1ebf1a35276247136fa95963", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6e086bc5888fad9e4cec3d784eed7b829deda94570108d61073bc4303461722f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bc4679e584e87a2356ac172514ecce8c043e2403959494a48ea0fcdcd293910f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d65e253a9a9abd1b44695f1d371be6447b14d7c6280b5a5b84e0ce2445349b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d8363d5f7c1287817a76d7fb381185219bfec0567e439e3e01921c981af0a42e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "95ea257daaa20e7703a0d7c790e8b2749f6abc14635f78d233f3b75ad35cddfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "62e040b11276b2a28fcdc151584da41bbe97e35e04c499d29dbee6b2ace08d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b88cd9285e402e9a44574aa82272aa4f2d1626982f00d356ca81ef4357fd7a4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a891905eec858ea35260e88035f94c7ad01b590b1cdc9d849567d3b76acc76b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8e5422cd0376a74985eb0240671049f1b257c83142ce9e34763f6f9e36c8e03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "74a18fe6657297b4aaed2c0587ee4f5cb4d80a464c6bea1a3b5ea8d2f73df7e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "47efdf58dbc13a2c89f9f01c2c068b7876d75f60bdb8a4f43bf02830d567fecd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f6804bab60508dbf3f99307eb1b44b3d2d37039503bf83b834f44914b6682d26", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f024bc2da5f0dc8abca0cb0532144cf60cf638e07f67d1da174e3c117d4be91d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "77ef5417d0830c673e32a2b36256d261933e0b6bc71072f849ed9a8cdfac3ea6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fe5f2791146275ad9a01fe41c1b6dba758b8b67bfb97eb4ea038c09a9011361f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a55314e3d695c9fc59df25c98448e29d7d19918d95bfef51e789e45551841b1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35db28cf49d178106e419eeaec1426a7cfc7a1a327849fee4a2f842e5c3a28e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5682bf7d3cf99858d5124f44b914998d648c7e1b92ed80a6b95070959547530a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a3aca3dcd595e7a5a20b5e3ddd3e1b2a1c53a1b2e88fc83dc01719c17306d4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35327bd8600e625944b4698f49dc4702987176a385e0d0d579b80e1673069c88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2944b2ee489bb672cef8df8a8ef82fddd58c0a7ad02675706559f2d97f850b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e976afe266b4cd4e96a31a224b30f2e0ffd9d984452e532d986eb1f8998196ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6a8c2e4ab3ec19f9a698b670ee0d28608dcebc30d2a807b09d7003ba05daf175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fc7cea877ce739c24184c84109ec85dd523f12cec75d74e7eb515356dce8ae10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f7a3b0294bfe8bdf1e581f83d343e3fd850f7e7c3fd7d15fcd30446a67aa3c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "53a116251a85cfac95deabca095ca6f2fe9f4b830108f03c8fe18fa6f4639af6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "85628881078612cd7f6c9a492e810045c1b80a14b219086873ad9bd46ce20759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8b995e336a271d1484b2133efac681a5f360ea7e33213a5c5b2d9cecf9b2531", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5921b3c8d539313afe51a73f6b7a752378fc6a9f4ea3f234a1442775275005dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "80a5c3288250087bd0bc6187ac7e7a8c8789dab7842e5399e9dcee665bbb0caa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d0180348d037fa9b80d054f3ea34ff1448cc72fb732bc8f37b21e13e77788a38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e210343958c3eaaf086f7993860ae82806b20d1fc9b4f7c377ebb82aa7dc8ccb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b5084313b23a038e8d360cd58a1140d5551761de3206d7cecd87be89e1a1f306", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8abe2c737ddf84ffa4b7052fa7b520c27e8e3cc175cea8cc3ff33a7da9dd8d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "163fbc1c18f37ab83238440e9fe4437b0df6776806de9b8b80d288e66766abba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ffe141607abc1f1a77196337e46e99b988614f7e3315a89aaba46ddb5e1f85a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e12cb970f1a2c184459efb19d04f36ff86a3b12ca50ffdb2bcec815d536f7dab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "59643c05e20db04f9a5e08c0c47e42419a353e600301620631e9903825eb58cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250b6ae4937cc3b15f8270a4e58c200df6196b1d81dfdb398160acaeadf5bf23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37a02eabacdab34bf65b867efee76e47ff41925982f18b9793445e1fa9aae18b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cac01c201aec508ea2a9dffefc056d7f4cbf3fe0b31b44fcdbdcceb979bc586b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82e7c6e145b2e0e174bb8eb27044ea386592c300e6815efd450ba2befdd54e22", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b24a64fa7032044a02e660854a9b575b68f40873b0e5164ee577e2e5efb8e8e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-original.ppm", + "sha256": "281c53b4f63b17c486a8f33040be35104a7d2eeda1cc739903ebd1d21cfebaa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f61661ed59cd25c5033c519b8274329c6fc4988b37bf5358e49179c6218ae882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db3f643f748332ff908097d353d213dd993d522442637268304d5f5818dbdc2b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e3346559518b4078de56f27cc0ef48fdef545c451c816402bde77b491ecb876", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "52c7828bc9ee7ba7c410dd2acdfa1e106a28debc3ab622fb7a41ff6596c55bf6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4f8e908bd41ecb442e5a535dda5aa468ea6610fae169550e9b5f570bf7ec348c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6e0106cb11b9c0fefa9a1b2657cec2f7a3a5ede57bcbf4c339fc2469e532b608", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "59b3031287b8fc5fa5e0b035eb5797a278519fd7f3eec26931695af4b2772100", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6983135b2c07e6d1fc174539cd4902947636d5dbe3863abf5281b97d2757a36b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "99b318261fbf11732af653226ce69eb758fbbcd36c6339bcaeb99f37ad1a306c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eddfd182df049a93ce41d2b19ee23055c1fd39dd80e6d757b5f75f87ba143b7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4018e": { @@ -402482,7 +433729,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4018e", "family_id": "terrain-40185-40194", "job_id": "terrain-40185-40194", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -402498,6 +433745,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/candidate.json", "sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a0dc3300158ae0d596791a564fce239ebf42829cd04848c5a6cccba5ae7bb03d", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.182491+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"All source cliff wedge/curves, lip/shadow direction and orange-lower/brown-upper ground regions persist. 4018c notch,4018e tapering tilted rock,4018f large bottom-reaching rock,40190/40191 diagonal boundaries,40192/40193 shared oblong boulder and40194 two tilted rocks retain source placement. Cleanv2 has no invented straight quarter-grid lines; changed grain is disclosed.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 706b1a4780e7eaa6594876ffd158ae0cd8e648d0c45c54bc7290e54afc17ae57", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40185", + "40186", + "40187", + "40188" + ], + "sha256": "1b5139822e60551bb982c1686cb4e6a7e10811ee2fd108f3866ed054204bced0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40189", + "4018a", + "4018b", + "4018c" + ], + "sha256": "bb048d2249c27e54cb822893d346885a32b0d293225c54db2a52fd39b7afc04e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4018d", + "4018e", + "4018f", + "40190" + ], + "sha256": "46a2f579b51d9fc7b58a9bb733b2312693da3b2663187af34518a05268f3a9dc", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40191", + "40192", + "40193", + "40194" + ], + "sha256": "4fde949f74ce5d823cfbda462dd530525e91e22d3d5171df11eac25555710289", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40185-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "16e6e9ff46284302e59d2c138c658539b6ea73e178aa68c99d73bed7185f9995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d2df9f081297ce85a911cac24609ba52dea401a88a73594e8992f53fe3df2807", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f09ad009ea8563fc6528beee9c4ecb6fbfd9f49260f1189ad3dbe5e93fe2204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "61b48c823dec16b350d59a0ae6fe05b6c706be706587aac023ab4f372c4fb9c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-original.ppm", + "sha256": "837041d5a64fbe2495e086084e5fd8ad0efde0781c25672b5c6570e6cd5ce75a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0b71bb8c00973c950aa25caaf79819878286a8651c09be6dca4124802f174118", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "892f69d5d7bdcfa445f1c4d9fbb2889995f6a79ed0f54c3f01811d8103514ef7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56757a994d4613fa93a1e4ae3208ab80e0c9c48708867b6ea162efb150bd6d39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "421cb42e828ed02d701cc2667c6a937e2f71575573fece53a34ac74721bb7320", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fecf556bccbe4f03bdeae2f59493a2c86d611157184c118dcc1ef6757f8fcba8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d9c7df53787ac143df89f17ffccde6dbde485e1cb82b519f39b470c63d0d6c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afacc2fbe5b671d6dcaeaa255ad5eeadc9f4b2bfec05082cd55da82a21c90197", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5362165f51b963fb6b76588886604867222c60eb2ec3ab64e72593a7ac4bc5bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0417088410e49670bc963beea7b8be17b6d8b5a3808cb161295ee71f567e6a83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7f3bd65cbae623fc9e1cdeb170c42e29759208852326caec0de23aef842fabc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "415c09ba7701d36fa2955d21005715e16a3cb75a9610d01f09842ae95c52fb76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "085833e696cf6976ce90eed97e2033c4330d8350d885701e630067fda654bcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f48f69d21767674c9bcd9f92f8886b7ab44d6f645327f4b079a01cdd727ee95b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "343c752edac86a2e6e0e98173912e7c54f315451ac7e7e94462158250dee4c57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a446c698739f1fea2129c5d8c8d66b7d3199054720ecf79dc68117af185a31b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "853ad4528bdf6cc3c94aeb8f6b9f965ae488e60d46a392f071f7c120783c6b85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4e094be2afe9756b750cc7f84108865059aca3cef912572aabebf423e280a6d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a8d56618df03e5481079b09cc8f4d7eadf0de2e423419035991fda7294a3f7c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0ed97e74a0ee885127789ab0c0569a7229a47a3d26a61b311bc5bb5eed519107", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7cfc7fc9963ee23b756b1b44fcf24e34733f27f6c697cbde4cdccce711204ead", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e95db65e42e07a4a4d1f32e012ace8e95a2f4edd1ebf1a35276247136fa95963", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6e086bc5888fad9e4cec3d784eed7b829deda94570108d61073bc4303461722f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bc4679e584e87a2356ac172514ecce8c043e2403959494a48ea0fcdcd293910f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d65e253a9a9abd1b44695f1d371be6447b14d7c6280b5a5b84e0ce2445349b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d8363d5f7c1287817a76d7fb381185219bfec0567e439e3e01921c981af0a42e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "95ea257daaa20e7703a0d7c790e8b2749f6abc14635f78d233f3b75ad35cddfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "62e040b11276b2a28fcdc151584da41bbe97e35e04c499d29dbee6b2ace08d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b88cd9285e402e9a44574aa82272aa4f2d1626982f00d356ca81ef4357fd7a4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a891905eec858ea35260e88035f94c7ad01b590b1cdc9d849567d3b76acc76b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8e5422cd0376a74985eb0240671049f1b257c83142ce9e34763f6f9e36c8e03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "74a18fe6657297b4aaed2c0587ee4f5cb4d80a464c6bea1a3b5ea8d2f73df7e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "47efdf58dbc13a2c89f9f01c2c068b7876d75f60bdb8a4f43bf02830d567fecd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f6804bab60508dbf3f99307eb1b44b3d2d37039503bf83b834f44914b6682d26", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f024bc2da5f0dc8abca0cb0532144cf60cf638e07f67d1da174e3c117d4be91d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "77ef5417d0830c673e32a2b36256d261933e0b6bc71072f849ed9a8cdfac3ea6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fe5f2791146275ad9a01fe41c1b6dba758b8b67bfb97eb4ea038c09a9011361f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a55314e3d695c9fc59df25c98448e29d7d19918d95bfef51e789e45551841b1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35db28cf49d178106e419eeaec1426a7cfc7a1a327849fee4a2f842e5c3a28e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5682bf7d3cf99858d5124f44b914998d648c7e1b92ed80a6b95070959547530a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a3aca3dcd595e7a5a20b5e3ddd3e1b2a1c53a1b2e88fc83dc01719c17306d4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35327bd8600e625944b4698f49dc4702987176a385e0d0d579b80e1673069c88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2944b2ee489bb672cef8df8a8ef82fddd58c0a7ad02675706559f2d97f850b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e976afe266b4cd4e96a31a224b30f2e0ffd9d984452e532d986eb1f8998196ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6a8c2e4ab3ec19f9a698b670ee0d28608dcebc30d2a807b09d7003ba05daf175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fc7cea877ce739c24184c84109ec85dd523f12cec75d74e7eb515356dce8ae10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f7a3b0294bfe8bdf1e581f83d343e3fd850f7e7c3fd7d15fcd30446a67aa3c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "53a116251a85cfac95deabca095ca6f2fe9f4b830108f03c8fe18fa6f4639af6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "85628881078612cd7f6c9a492e810045c1b80a14b219086873ad9bd46ce20759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8b995e336a271d1484b2133efac681a5f360ea7e33213a5c5b2d9cecf9b2531", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5921b3c8d539313afe51a73f6b7a752378fc6a9f4ea3f234a1442775275005dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "80a5c3288250087bd0bc6187ac7e7a8c8789dab7842e5399e9dcee665bbb0caa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d0180348d037fa9b80d054f3ea34ff1448cc72fb732bc8f37b21e13e77788a38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e210343958c3eaaf086f7993860ae82806b20d1fc9b4f7c377ebb82aa7dc8ccb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b5084313b23a038e8d360cd58a1140d5551761de3206d7cecd87be89e1a1f306", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8abe2c737ddf84ffa4b7052fa7b520c27e8e3cc175cea8cc3ff33a7da9dd8d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "163fbc1c18f37ab83238440e9fe4437b0df6776806de9b8b80d288e66766abba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ffe141607abc1f1a77196337e46e99b988614f7e3315a89aaba46ddb5e1f85a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e12cb970f1a2c184459efb19d04f36ff86a3b12ca50ffdb2bcec815d536f7dab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "59643c05e20db04f9a5e08c0c47e42419a353e600301620631e9903825eb58cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250b6ae4937cc3b15f8270a4e58c200df6196b1d81dfdb398160acaeadf5bf23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37a02eabacdab34bf65b867efee76e47ff41925982f18b9793445e1fa9aae18b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cac01c201aec508ea2a9dffefc056d7f4cbf3fe0b31b44fcdbdcceb979bc586b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82e7c6e145b2e0e174bb8eb27044ea386592c300e6815efd450ba2befdd54e22", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b24a64fa7032044a02e660854a9b575b68f40873b0e5164ee577e2e5efb8e8e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-original.ppm", + "sha256": "281c53b4f63b17c486a8f33040be35104a7d2eeda1cc739903ebd1d21cfebaa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f61661ed59cd25c5033c519b8274329c6fc4988b37bf5358e49179c6218ae882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db3f643f748332ff908097d353d213dd993d522442637268304d5f5818dbdc2b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e3346559518b4078de56f27cc0ef48fdef545c451c816402bde77b491ecb876", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "52c7828bc9ee7ba7c410dd2acdfa1e106a28debc3ab622fb7a41ff6596c55bf6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4f8e908bd41ecb442e5a535dda5aa468ea6610fae169550e9b5f570bf7ec348c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6e0106cb11b9c0fefa9a1b2657cec2f7a3a5ede57bcbf4c339fc2469e532b608", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "59b3031287b8fc5fa5e0b035eb5797a278519fd7f3eec26931695af4b2772100", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6983135b2c07e6d1fc174539cd4902947636d5dbe3863abf5281b97d2757a36b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "99b318261fbf11732af653226ce69eb758fbbcd36c6339bcaeb99f37ad1a306c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eddfd182df049a93ce41d2b19ee23055c1fd39dd80e6d757b5f75f87ba143b7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "4018f": { @@ -402519,7 +434236,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "4018f", "family_id": "terrain-40185-40194", "job_id": "terrain-40185-40194", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -402535,6 +434252,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/candidate.json", "sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a0dc3300158ae0d596791a564fce239ebf42829cd04848c5a6cccba5ae7bb03d", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.182491+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"All source cliff wedge/curves, lip/shadow direction and orange-lower/brown-upper ground regions persist. 4018c notch,4018e tapering tilted rock,4018f large bottom-reaching rock,40190/40191 diagonal boundaries,40192/40193 shared oblong boulder and40194 two tilted rocks retain source placement. Cleanv2 has no invented straight quarter-grid lines; changed grain is disclosed.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 706b1a4780e7eaa6594876ffd158ae0cd8e648d0c45c54bc7290e54afc17ae57", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40185", + "40186", + "40187", + "40188" + ], + "sha256": "1b5139822e60551bb982c1686cb4e6a7e10811ee2fd108f3866ed054204bced0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40189", + "4018a", + "4018b", + "4018c" + ], + "sha256": "bb048d2249c27e54cb822893d346885a32b0d293225c54db2a52fd39b7afc04e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4018d", + "4018e", + "4018f", + "40190" + ], + "sha256": "46a2f579b51d9fc7b58a9bb733b2312693da3b2663187af34518a05268f3a9dc", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40191", + "40192", + "40193", + "40194" + ], + "sha256": "4fde949f74ce5d823cfbda462dd530525e91e22d3d5171df11eac25555710289", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40185-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "16e6e9ff46284302e59d2c138c658539b6ea73e178aa68c99d73bed7185f9995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d2df9f081297ce85a911cac24609ba52dea401a88a73594e8992f53fe3df2807", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f09ad009ea8563fc6528beee9c4ecb6fbfd9f49260f1189ad3dbe5e93fe2204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "61b48c823dec16b350d59a0ae6fe05b6c706be706587aac023ab4f372c4fb9c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-original.ppm", + "sha256": "837041d5a64fbe2495e086084e5fd8ad0efde0781c25672b5c6570e6cd5ce75a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0b71bb8c00973c950aa25caaf79819878286a8651c09be6dca4124802f174118", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "892f69d5d7bdcfa445f1c4d9fbb2889995f6a79ed0f54c3f01811d8103514ef7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56757a994d4613fa93a1e4ae3208ab80e0c9c48708867b6ea162efb150bd6d39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "421cb42e828ed02d701cc2667c6a937e2f71575573fece53a34ac74721bb7320", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fecf556bccbe4f03bdeae2f59493a2c86d611157184c118dcc1ef6757f8fcba8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d9c7df53787ac143df89f17ffccde6dbde485e1cb82b519f39b470c63d0d6c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afacc2fbe5b671d6dcaeaa255ad5eeadc9f4b2bfec05082cd55da82a21c90197", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5362165f51b963fb6b76588886604867222c60eb2ec3ab64e72593a7ac4bc5bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0417088410e49670bc963beea7b8be17b6d8b5a3808cb161295ee71f567e6a83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7f3bd65cbae623fc9e1cdeb170c42e29759208852326caec0de23aef842fabc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "415c09ba7701d36fa2955d21005715e16a3cb75a9610d01f09842ae95c52fb76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "085833e696cf6976ce90eed97e2033c4330d8350d885701e630067fda654bcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f48f69d21767674c9bcd9f92f8886b7ab44d6f645327f4b079a01cdd727ee95b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "343c752edac86a2e6e0e98173912e7c54f315451ac7e7e94462158250dee4c57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a446c698739f1fea2129c5d8c8d66b7d3199054720ecf79dc68117af185a31b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "853ad4528bdf6cc3c94aeb8f6b9f965ae488e60d46a392f071f7c120783c6b85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4e094be2afe9756b750cc7f84108865059aca3cef912572aabebf423e280a6d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a8d56618df03e5481079b09cc8f4d7eadf0de2e423419035991fda7294a3f7c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0ed97e74a0ee885127789ab0c0569a7229a47a3d26a61b311bc5bb5eed519107", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7cfc7fc9963ee23b756b1b44fcf24e34733f27f6c697cbde4cdccce711204ead", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e95db65e42e07a4a4d1f32e012ace8e95a2f4edd1ebf1a35276247136fa95963", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6e086bc5888fad9e4cec3d784eed7b829deda94570108d61073bc4303461722f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bc4679e584e87a2356ac172514ecce8c043e2403959494a48ea0fcdcd293910f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d65e253a9a9abd1b44695f1d371be6447b14d7c6280b5a5b84e0ce2445349b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d8363d5f7c1287817a76d7fb381185219bfec0567e439e3e01921c981af0a42e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "95ea257daaa20e7703a0d7c790e8b2749f6abc14635f78d233f3b75ad35cddfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "62e040b11276b2a28fcdc151584da41bbe97e35e04c499d29dbee6b2ace08d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b88cd9285e402e9a44574aa82272aa4f2d1626982f00d356ca81ef4357fd7a4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a891905eec858ea35260e88035f94c7ad01b590b1cdc9d849567d3b76acc76b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8e5422cd0376a74985eb0240671049f1b257c83142ce9e34763f6f9e36c8e03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "74a18fe6657297b4aaed2c0587ee4f5cb4d80a464c6bea1a3b5ea8d2f73df7e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "47efdf58dbc13a2c89f9f01c2c068b7876d75f60bdb8a4f43bf02830d567fecd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f6804bab60508dbf3f99307eb1b44b3d2d37039503bf83b834f44914b6682d26", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f024bc2da5f0dc8abca0cb0532144cf60cf638e07f67d1da174e3c117d4be91d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "77ef5417d0830c673e32a2b36256d261933e0b6bc71072f849ed9a8cdfac3ea6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fe5f2791146275ad9a01fe41c1b6dba758b8b67bfb97eb4ea038c09a9011361f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a55314e3d695c9fc59df25c98448e29d7d19918d95bfef51e789e45551841b1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35db28cf49d178106e419eeaec1426a7cfc7a1a327849fee4a2f842e5c3a28e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5682bf7d3cf99858d5124f44b914998d648c7e1b92ed80a6b95070959547530a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a3aca3dcd595e7a5a20b5e3ddd3e1b2a1c53a1b2e88fc83dc01719c17306d4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35327bd8600e625944b4698f49dc4702987176a385e0d0d579b80e1673069c88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2944b2ee489bb672cef8df8a8ef82fddd58c0a7ad02675706559f2d97f850b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e976afe266b4cd4e96a31a224b30f2e0ffd9d984452e532d986eb1f8998196ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6a8c2e4ab3ec19f9a698b670ee0d28608dcebc30d2a807b09d7003ba05daf175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fc7cea877ce739c24184c84109ec85dd523f12cec75d74e7eb515356dce8ae10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f7a3b0294bfe8bdf1e581f83d343e3fd850f7e7c3fd7d15fcd30446a67aa3c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "53a116251a85cfac95deabca095ca6f2fe9f4b830108f03c8fe18fa6f4639af6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "85628881078612cd7f6c9a492e810045c1b80a14b219086873ad9bd46ce20759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8b995e336a271d1484b2133efac681a5f360ea7e33213a5c5b2d9cecf9b2531", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5921b3c8d539313afe51a73f6b7a752378fc6a9f4ea3f234a1442775275005dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "80a5c3288250087bd0bc6187ac7e7a8c8789dab7842e5399e9dcee665bbb0caa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d0180348d037fa9b80d054f3ea34ff1448cc72fb732bc8f37b21e13e77788a38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e210343958c3eaaf086f7993860ae82806b20d1fc9b4f7c377ebb82aa7dc8ccb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b5084313b23a038e8d360cd58a1140d5551761de3206d7cecd87be89e1a1f306", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8abe2c737ddf84ffa4b7052fa7b520c27e8e3cc175cea8cc3ff33a7da9dd8d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "163fbc1c18f37ab83238440e9fe4437b0df6776806de9b8b80d288e66766abba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ffe141607abc1f1a77196337e46e99b988614f7e3315a89aaba46ddb5e1f85a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e12cb970f1a2c184459efb19d04f36ff86a3b12ca50ffdb2bcec815d536f7dab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "59643c05e20db04f9a5e08c0c47e42419a353e600301620631e9903825eb58cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250b6ae4937cc3b15f8270a4e58c200df6196b1d81dfdb398160acaeadf5bf23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37a02eabacdab34bf65b867efee76e47ff41925982f18b9793445e1fa9aae18b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cac01c201aec508ea2a9dffefc056d7f4cbf3fe0b31b44fcdbdcceb979bc586b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82e7c6e145b2e0e174bb8eb27044ea386592c300e6815efd450ba2befdd54e22", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b24a64fa7032044a02e660854a9b575b68f40873b0e5164ee577e2e5efb8e8e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-original.ppm", + "sha256": "281c53b4f63b17c486a8f33040be35104a7d2eeda1cc739903ebd1d21cfebaa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f61661ed59cd25c5033c519b8274329c6fc4988b37bf5358e49179c6218ae882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db3f643f748332ff908097d353d213dd993d522442637268304d5f5818dbdc2b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e3346559518b4078de56f27cc0ef48fdef545c451c816402bde77b491ecb876", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "52c7828bc9ee7ba7c410dd2acdfa1e106a28debc3ab622fb7a41ff6596c55bf6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4f8e908bd41ecb442e5a535dda5aa468ea6610fae169550e9b5f570bf7ec348c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6e0106cb11b9c0fefa9a1b2657cec2f7a3a5ede57bcbf4c339fc2469e532b608", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "59b3031287b8fc5fa5e0b035eb5797a278519fd7f3eec26931695af4b2772100", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6983135b2c07e6d1fc174539cd4902947636d5dbe3863abf5281b97d2757a36b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "99b318261fbf11732af653226ce69eb758fbbcd36c6339bcaeb99f37ad1a306c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eddfd182df049a93ce41d2b19ee23055c1fd39dd80e6d757b5f75f87ba143b7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40190": { @@ -402556,7 +434743,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40190", "family_id": "terrain-40185-40194", "job_id": "terrain-40185-40194", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -402572,6 +434759,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/candidate.json", "sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a0dc3300158ae0d596791a564fce239ebf42829cd04848c5a6cccba5ae7bb03d", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.182491+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"All source cliff wedge/curves, lip/shadow direction and orange-lower/brown-upper ground regions persist. 4018c notch,4018e tapering tilted rock,4018f large bottom-reaching rock,40190/40191 diagonal boundaries,40192/40193 shared oblong boulder and40194 two tilted rocks retain source placement. Cleanv2 has no invented straight quarter-grid lines; changed grain is disclosed.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 706b1a4780e7eaa6594876ffd158ae0cd8e648d0c45c54bc7290e54afc17ae57", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40185", + "40186", + "40187", + "40188" + ], + "sha256": "1b5139822e60551bb982c1686cb4e6a7e10811ee2fd108f3866ed054204bced0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40189", + "4018a", + "4018b", + "4018c" + ], + "sha256": "bb048d2249c27e54cb822893d346885a32b0d293225c54db2a52fd39b7afc04e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4018d", + "4018e", + "4018f", + "40190" + ], + "sha256": "46a2f579b51d9fc7b58a9bb733b2312693da3b2663187af34518a05268f3a9dc", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40191", + "40192", + "40193", + "40194" + ], + "sha256": "4fde949f74ce5d823cfbda462dd530525e91e22d3d5171df11eac25555710289", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40185-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "16e6e9ff46284302e59d2c138c658539b6ea73e178aa68c99d73bed7185f9995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d2df9f081297ce85a911cac24609ba52dea401a88a73594e8992f53fe3df2807", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f09ad009ea8563fc6528beee9c4ecb6fbfd9f49260f1189ad3dbe5e93fe2204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "61b48c823dec16b350d59a0ae6fe05b6c706be706587aac023ab4f372c4fb9c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-original.ppm", + "sha256": "837041d5a64fbe2495e086084e5fd8ad0efde0781c25672b5c6570e6cd5ce75a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0b71bb8c00973c950aa25caaf79819878286a8651c09be6dca4124802f174118", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "892f69d5d7bdcfa445f1c4d9fbb2889995f6a79ed0f54c3f01811d8103514ef7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56757a994d4613fa93a1e4ae3208ab80e0c9c48708867b6ea162efb150bd6d39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "421cb42e828ed02d701cc2667c6a937e2f71575573fece53a34ac74721bb7320", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fecf556bccbe4f03bdeae2f59493a2c86d611157184c118dcc1ef6757f8fcba8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d9c7df53787ac143df89f17ffccde6dbde485e1cb82b519f39b470c63d0d6c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afacc2fbe5b671d6dcaeaa255ad5eeadc9f4b2bfec05082cd55da82a21c90197", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5362165f51b963fb6b76588886604867222c60eb2ec3ab64e72593a7ac4bc5bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0417088410e49670bc963beea7b8be17b6d8b5a3808cb161295ee71f567e6a83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7f3bd65cbae623fc9e1cdeb170c42e29759208852326caec0de23aef842fabc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "415c09ba7701d36fa2955d21005715e16a3cb75a9610d01f09842ae95c52fb76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "085833e696cf6976ce90eed97e2033c4330d8350d885701e630067fda654bcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f48f69d21767674c9bcd9f92f8886b7ab44d6f645327f4b079a01cdd727ee95b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "343c752edac86a2e6e0e98173912e7c54f315451ac7e7e94462158250dee4c57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a446c698739f1fea2129c5d8c8d66b7d3199054720ecf79dc68117af185a31b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "853ad4528bdf6cc3c94aeb8f6b9f965ae488e60d46a392f071f7c120783c6b85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4e094be2afe9756b750cc7f84108865059aca3cef912572aabebf423e280a6d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a8d56618df03e5481079b09cc8f4d7eadf0de2e423419035991fda7294a3f7c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0ed97e74a0ee885127789ab0c0569a7229a47a3d26a61b311bc5bb5eed519107", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7cfc7fc9963ee23b756b1b44fcf24e34733f27f6c697cbde4cdccce711204ead", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e95db65e42e07a4a4d1f32e012ace8e95a2f4edd1ebf1a35276247136fa95963", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6e086bc5888fad9e4cec3d784eed7b829deda94570108d61073bc4303461722f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bc4679e584e87a2356ac172514ecce8c043e2403959494a48ea0fcdcd293910f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d65e253a9a9abd1b44695f1d371be6447b14d7c6280b5a5b84e0ce2445349b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d8363d5f7c1287817a76d7fb381185219bfec0567e439e3e01921c981af0a42e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "95ea257daaa20e7703a0d7c790e8b2749f6abc14635f78d233f3b75ad35cddfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "62e040b11276b2a28fcdc151584da41bbe97e35e04c499d29dbee6b2ace08d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b88cd9285e402e9a44574aa82272aa4f2d1626982f00d356ca81ef4357fd7a4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a891905eec858ea35260e88035f94c7ad01b590b1cdc9d849567d3b76acc76b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8e5422cd0376a74985eb0240671049f1b257c83142ce9e34763f6f9e36c8e03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "74a18fe6657297b4aaed2c0587ee4f5cb4d80a464c6bea1a3b5ea8d2f73df7e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "47efdf58dbc13a2c89f9f01c2c068b7876d75f60bdb8a4f43bf02830d567fecd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f6804bab60508dbf3f99307eb1b44b3d2d37039503bf83b834f44914b6682d26", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f024bc2da5f0dc8abca0cb0532144cf60cf638e07f67d1da174e3c117d4be91d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "77ef5417d0830c673e32a2b36256d261933e0b6bc71072f849ed9a8cdfac3ea6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fe5f2791146275ad9a01fe41c1b6dba758b8b67bfb97eb4ea038c09a9011361f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a55314e3d695c9fc59df25c98448e29d7d19918d95bfef51e789e45551841b1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35db28cf49d178106e419eeaec1426a7cfc7a1a327849fee4a2f842e5c3a28e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5682bf7d3cf99858d5124f44b914998d648c7e1b92ed80a6b95070959547530a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a3aca3dcd595e7a5a20b5e3ddd3e1b2a1c53a1b2e88fc83dc01719c17306d4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35327bd8600e625944b4698f49dc4702987176a385e0d0d579b80e1673069c88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2944b2ee489bb672cef8df8a8ef82fddd58c0a7ad02675706559f2d97f850b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e976afe266b4cd4e96a31a224b30f2e0ffd9d984452e532d986eb1f8998196ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6a8c2e4ab3ec19f9a698b670ee0d28608dcebc30d2a807b09d7003ba05daf175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fc7cea877ce739c24184c84109ec85dd523f12cec75d74e7eb515356dce8ae10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f7a3b0294bfe8bdf1e581f83d343e3fd850f7e7c3fd7d15fcd30446a67aa3c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "53a116251a85cfac95deabca095ca6f2fe9f4b830108f03c8fe18fa6f4639af6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "85628881078612cd7f6c9a492e810045c1b80a14b219086873ad9bd46ce20759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8b995e336a271d1484b2133efac681a5f360ea7e33213a5c5b2d9cecf9b2531", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5921b3c8d539313afe51a73f6b7a752378fc6a9f4ea3f234a1442775275005dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "80a5c3288250087bd0bc6187ac7e7a8c8789dab7842e5399e9dcee665bbb0caa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d0180348d037fa9b80d054f3ea34ff1448cc72fb732bc8f37b21e13e77788a38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e210343958c3eaaf086f7993860ae82806b20d1fc9b4f7c377ebb82aa7dc8ccb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b5084313b23a038e8d360cd58a1140d5551761de3206d7cecd87be89e1a1f306", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8abe2c737ddf84ffa4b7052fa7b520c27e8e3cc175cea8cc3ff33a7da9dd8d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "163fbc1c18f37ab83238440e9fe4437b0df6776806de9b8b80d288e66766abba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ffe141607abc1f1a77196337e46e99b988614f7e3315a89aaba46ddb5e1f85a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e12cb970f1a2c184459efb19d04f36ff86a3b12ca50ffdb2bcec815d536f7dab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "59643c05e20db04f9a5e08c0c47e42419a353e600301620631e9903825eb58cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250b6ae4937cc3b15f8270a4e58c200df6196b1d81dfdb398160acaeadf5bf23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37a02eabacdab34bf65b867efee76e47ff41925982f18b9793445e1fa9aae18b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cac01c201aec508ea2a9dffefc056d7f4cbf3fe0b31b44fcdbdcceb979bc586b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82e7c6e145b2e0e174bb8eb27044ea386592c300e6815efd450ba2befdd54e22", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b24a64fa7032044a02e660854a9b575b68f40873b0e5164ee577e2e5efb8e8e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-original.ppm", + "sha256": "281c53b4f63b17c486a8f33040be35104a7d2eeda1cc739903ebd1d21cfebaa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f61661ed59cd25c5033c519b8274329c6fc4988b37bf5358e49179c6218ae882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db3f643f748332ff908097d353d213dd993d522442637268304d5f5818dbdc2b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e3346559518b4078de56f27cc0ef48fdef545c451c816402bde77b491ecb876", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "52c7828bc9ee7ba7c410dd2acdfa1e106a28debc3ab622fb7a41ff6596c55bf6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4f8e908bd41ecb442e5a535dda5aa468ea6610fae169550e9b5f570bf7ec348c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6e0106cb11b9c0fefa9a1b2657cec2f7a3a5ede57bcbf4c339fc2469e532b608", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "59b3031287b8fc5fa5e0b035eb5797a278519fd7f3eec26931695af4b2772100", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6983135b2c07e6d1fc174539cd4902947636d5dbe3863abf5281b97d2757a36b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "99b318261fbf11732af653226ce69eb758fbbcd36c6339bcaeb99f37ad1a306c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eddfd182df049a93ce41d2b19ee23055c1fd39dd80e6d757b5f75f87ba143b7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40191": { @@ -402593,7 +435250,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40191", "family_id": "terrain-40185-40194", "job_id": "terrain-40185-40194", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -402609,6 +435266,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/candidate.json", "sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a0dc3300158ae0d596791a564fce239ebf42829cd04848c5a6cccba5ae7bb03d", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.182491+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"All source cliff wedge/curves, lip/shadow direction and orange-lower/brown-upper ground regions persist. 4018c notch,4018e tapering tilted rock,4018f large bottom-reaching rock,40190/40191 diagonal boundaries,40192/40193 shared oblong boulder and40194 two tilted rocks retain source placement. Cleanv2 has no invented straight quarter-grid lines; changed grain is disclosed.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 706b1a4780e7eaa6594876ffd158ae0cd8e648d0c45c54bc7290e54afc17ae57", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40185", + "40186", + "40187", + "40188" + ], + "sha256": "1b5139822e60551bb982c1686cb4e6a7e10811ee2fd108f3866ed054204bced0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40189", + "4018a", + "4018b", + "4018c" + ], + "sha256": "bb048d2249c27e54cb822893d346885a32b0d293225c54db2a52fd39b7afc04e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4018d", + "4018e", + "4018f", + "40190" + ], + "sha256": "46a2f579b51d9fc7b58a9bb733b2312693da3b2663187af34518a05268f3a9dc", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40191", + "40192", + "40193", + "40194" + ], + "sha256": "4fde949f74ce5d823cfbda462dd530525e91e22d3d5171df11eac25555710289", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40185-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "16e6e9ff46284302e59d2c138c658539b6ea73e178aa68c99d73bed7185f9995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d2df9f081297ce85a911cac24609ba52dea401a88a73594e8992f53fe3df2807", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f09ad009ea8563fc6528beee9c4ecb6fbfd9f49260f1189ad3dbe5e93fe2204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "61b48c823dec16b350d59a0ae6fe05b6c706be706587aac023ab4f372c4fb9c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-original.ppm", + "sha256": "837041d5a64fbe2495e086084e5fd8ad0efde0781c25672b5c6570e6cd5ce75a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0b71bb8c00973c950aa25caaf79819878286a8651c09be6dca4124802f174118", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "892f69d5d7bdcfa445f1c4d9fbb2889995f6a79ed0f54c3f01811d8103514ef7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56757a994d4613fa93a1e4ae3208ab80e0c9c48708867b6ea162efb150bd6d39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "421cb42e828ed02d701cc2667c6a937e2f71575573fece53a34ac74721bb7320", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fecf556bccbe4f03bdeae2f59493a2c86d611157184c118dcc1ef6757f8fcba8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d9c7df53787ac143df89f17ffccde6dbde485e1cb82b519f39b470c63d0d6c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afacc2fbe5b671d6dcaeaa255ad5eeadc9f4b2bfec05082cd55da82a21c90197", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5362165f51b963fb6b76588886604867222c60eb2ec3ab64e72593a7ac4bc5bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0417088410e49670bc963beea7b8be17b6d8b5a3808cb161295ee71f567e6a83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7f3bd65cbae623fc9e1cdeb170c42e29759208852326caec0de23aef842fabc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "415c09ba7701d36fa2955d21005715e16a3cb75a9610d01f09842ae95c52fb76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "085833e696cf6976ce90eed97e2033c4330d8350d885701e630067fda654bcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f48f69d21767674c9bcd9f92f8886b7ab44d6f645327f4b079a01cdd727ee95b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "343c752edac86a2e6e0e98173912e7c54f315451ac7e7e94462158250dee4c57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a446c698739f1fea2129c5d8c8d66b7d3199054720ecf79dc68117af185a31b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "853ad4528bdf6cc3c94aeb8f6b9f965ae488e60d46a392f071f7c120783c6b85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4e094be2afe9756b750cc7f84108865059aca3cef912572aabebf423e280a6d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a8d56618df03e5481079b09cc8f4d7eadf0de2e423419035991fda7294a3f7c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0ed97e74a0ee885127789ab0c0569a7229a47a3d26a61b311bc5bb5eed519107", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7cfc7fc9963ee23b756b1b44fcf24e34733f27f6c697cbde4cdccce711204ead", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e95db65e42e07a4a4d1f32e012ace8e95a2f4edd1ebf1a35276247136fa95963", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6e086bc5888fad9e4cec3d784eed7b829deda94570108d61073bc4303461722f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bc4679e584e87a2356ac172514ecce8c043e2403959494a48ea0fcdcd293910f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d65e253a9a9abd1b44695f1d371be6447b14d7c6280b5a5b84e0ce2445349b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d8363d5f7c1287817a76d7fb381185219bfec0567e439e3e01921c981af0a42e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "95ea257daaa20e7703a0d7c790e8b2749f6abc14635f78d233f3b75ad35cddfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "62e040b11276b2a28fcdc151584da41bbe97e35e04c499d29dbee6b2ace08d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b88cd9285e402e9a44574aa82272aa4f2d1626982f00d356ca81ef4357fd7a4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a891905eec858ea35260e88035f94c7ad01b590b1cdc9d849567d3b76acc76b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8e5422cd0376a74985eb0240671049f1b257c83142ce9e34763f6f9e36c8e03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "74a18fe6657297b4aaed2c0587ee4f5cb4d80a464c6bea1a3b5ea8d2f73df7e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "47efdf58dbc13a2c89f9f01c2c068b7876d75f60bdb8a4f43bf02830d567fecd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f6804bab60508dbf3f99307eb1b44b3d2d37039503bf83b834f44914b6682d26", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f024bc2da5f0dc8abca0cb0532144cf60cf638e07f67d1da174e3c117d4be91d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "77ef5417d0830c673e32a2b36256d261933e0b6bc71072f849ed9a8cdfac3ea6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fe5f2791146275ad9a01fe41c1b6dba758b8b67bfb97eb4ea038c09a9011361f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a55314e3d695c9fc59df25c98448e29d7d19918d95bfef51e789e45551841b1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35db28cf49d178106e419eeaec1426a7cfc7a1a327849fee4a2f842e5c3a28e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5682bf7d3cf99858d5124f44b914998d648c7e1b92ed80a6b95070959547530a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a3aca3dcd595e7a5a20b5e3ddd3e1b2a1c53a1b2e88fc83dc01719c17306d4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35327bd8600e625944b4698f49dc4702987176a385e0d0d579b80e1673069c88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2944b2ee489bb672cef8df8a8ef82fddd58c0a7ad02675706559f2d97f850b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e976afe266b4cd4e96a31a224b30f2e0ffd9d984452e532d986eb1f8998196ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6a8c2e4ab3ec19f9a698b670ee0d28608dcebc30d2a807b09d7003ba05daf175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fc7cea877ce739c24184c84109ec85dd523f12cec75d74e7eb515356dce8ae10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f7a3b0294bfe8bdf1e581f83d343e3fd850f7e7c3fd7d15fcd30446a67aa3c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "53a116251a85cfac95deabca095ca6f2fe9f4b830108f03c8fe18fa6f4639af6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "85628881078612cd7f6c9a492e810045c1b80a14b219086873ad9bd46ce20759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8b995e336a271d1484b2133efac681a5f360ea7e33213a5c5b2d9cecf9b2531", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5921b3c8d539313afe51a73f6b7a752378fc6a9f4ea3f234a1442775275005dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "80a5c3288250087bd0bc6187ac7e7a8c8789dab7842e5399e9dcee665bbb0caa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d0180348d037fa9b80d054f3ea34ff1448cc72fb732bc8f37b21e13e77788a38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e210343958c3eaaf086f7993860ae82806b20d1fc9b4f7c377ebb82aa7dc8ccb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b5084313b23a038e8d360cd58a1140d5551761de3206d7cecd87be89e1a1f306", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8abe2c737ddf84ffa4b7052fa7b520c27e8e3cc175cea8cc3ff33a7da9dd8d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "163fbc1c18f37ab83238440e9fe4437b0df6776806de9b8b80d288e66766abba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ffe141607abc1f1a77196337e46e99b988614f7e3315a89aaba46ddb5e1f85a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e12cb970f1a2c184459efb19d04f36ff86a3b12ca50ffdb2bcec815d536f7dab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "59643c05e20db04f9a5e08c0c47e42419a353e600301620631e9903825eb58cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250b6ae4937cc3b15f8270a4e58c200df6196b1d81dfdb398160acaeadf5bf23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37a02eabacdab34bf65b867efee76e47ff41925982f18b9793445e1fa9aae18b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cac01c201aec508ea2a9dffefc056d7f4cbf3fe0b31b44fcdbdcceb979bc586b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82e7c6e145b2e0e174bb8eb27044ea386592c300e6815efd450ba2befdd54e22", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b24a64fa7032044a02e660854a9b575b68f40873b0e5164ee577e2e5efb8e8e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-original.ppm", + "sha256": "281c53b4f63b17c486a8f33040be35104a7d2eeda1cc739903ebd1d21cfebaa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f61661ed59cd25c5033c519b8274329c6fc4988b37bf5358e49179c6218ae882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db3f643f748332ff908097d353d213dd993d522442637268304d5f5818dbdc2b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e3346559518b4078de56f27cc0ef48fdef545c451c816402bde77b491ecb876", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "52c7828bc9ee7ba7c410dd2acdfa1e106a28debc3ab622fb7a41ff6596c55bf6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4f8e908bd41ecb442e5a535dda5aa468ea6610fae169550e9b5f570bf7ec348c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6e0106cb11b9c0fefa9a1b2657cec2f7a3a5ede57bcbf4c339fc2469e532b608", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "59b3031287b8fc5fa5e0b035eb5797a278519fd7f3eec26931695af4b2772100", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6983135b2c07e6d1fc174539cd4902947636d5dbe3863abf5281b97d2757a36b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "99b318261fbf11732af653226ce69eb758fbbcd36c6339bcaeb99f37ad1a306c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eddfd182df049a93ce41d2b19ee23055c1fd39dd80e6d757b5f75f87ba143b7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40192": { @@ -402630,7 +435757,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40192", "family_id": "terrain-40185-40194", "job_id": "terrain-40185-40194", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -402646,6 +435773,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/candidate.json", "sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a0dc3300158ae0d596791a564fce239ebf42829cd04848c5a6cccba5ae7bb03d", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.182491+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"All source cliff wedge/curves, lip/shadow direction and orange-lower/brown-upper ground regions persist. 4018c notch,4018e tapering tilted rock,4018f large bottom-reaching rock,40190/40191 diagonal boundaries,40192/40193 shared oblong boulder and40194 two tilted rocks retain source placement. Cleanv2 has no invented straight quarter-grid lines; changed grain is disclosed.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 706b1a4780e7eaa6594876ffd158ae0cd8e648d0c45c54bc7290e54afc17ae57", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40185", + "40186", + "40187", + "40188" + ], + "sha256": "1b5139822e60551bb982c1686cb4e6a7e10811ee2fd108f3866ed054204bced0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40189", + "4018a", + "4018b", + "4018c" + ], + "sha256": "bb048d2249c27e54cb822893d346885a32b0d293225c54db2a52fd39b7afc04e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4018d", + "4018e", + "4018f", + "40190" + ], + "sha256": "46a2f579b51d9fc7b58a9bb733b2312693da3b2663187af34518a05268f3a9dc", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40191", + "40192", + "40193", + "40194" + ], + "sha256": "4fde949f74ce5d823cfbda462dd530525e91e22d3d5171df11eac25555710289", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40185-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "16e6e9ff46284302e59d2c138c658539b6ea73e178aa68c99d73bed7185f9995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d2df9f081297ce85a911cac24609ba52dea401a88a73594e8992f53fe3df2807", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f09ad009ea8563fc6528beee9c4ecb6fbfd9f49260f1189ad3dbe5e93fe2204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "61b48c823dec16b350d59a0ae6fe05b6c706be706587aac023ab4f372c4fb9c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-original.ppm", + "sha256": "837041d5a64fbe2495e086084e5fd8ad0efde0781c25672b5c6570e6cd5ce75a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0b71bb8c00973c950aa25caaf79819878286a8651c09be6dca4124802f174118", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "892f69d5d7bdcfa445f1c4d9fbb2889995f6a79ed0f54c3f01811d8103514ef7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56757a994d4613fa93a1e4ae3208ab80e0c9c48708867b6ea162efb150bd6d39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "421cb42e828ed02d701cc2667c6a937e2f71575573fece53a34ac74721bb7320", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fecf556bccbe4f03bdeae2f59493a2c86d611157184c118dcc1ef6757f8fcba8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d9c7df53787ac143df89f17ffccde6dbde485e1cb82b519f39b470c63d0d6c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afacc2fbe5b671d6dcaeaa255ad5eeadc9f4b2bfec05082cd55da82a21c90197", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5362165f51b963fb6b76588886604867222c60eb2ec3ab64e72593a7ac4bc5bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0417088410e49670bc963beea7b8be17b6d8b5a3808cb161295ee71f567e6a83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7f3bd65cbae623fc9e1cdeb170c42e29759208852326caec0de23aef842fabc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "415c09ba7701d36fa2955d21005715e16a3cb75a9610d01f09842ae95c52fb76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "085833e696cf6976ce90eed97e2033c4330d8350d885701e630067fda654bcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f48f69d21767674c9bcd9f92f8886b7ab44d6f645327f4b079a01cdd727ee95b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "343c752edac86a2e6e0e98173912e7c54f315451ac7e7e94462158250dee4c57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a446c698739f1fea2129c5d8c8d66b7d3199054720ecf79dc68117af185a31b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "853ad4528bdf6cc3c94aeb8f6b9f965ae488e60d46a392f071f7c120783c6b85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4e094be2afe9756b750cc7f84108865059aca3cef912572aabebf423e280a6d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a8d56618df03e5481079b09cc8f4d7eadf0de2e423419035991fda7294a3f7c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0ed97e74a0ee885127789ab0c0569a7229a47a3d26a61b311bc5bb5eed519107", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7cfc7fc9963ee23b756b1b44fcf24e34733f27f6c697cbde4cdccce711204ead", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e95db65e42e07a4a4d1f32e012ace8e95a2f4edd1ebf1a35276247136fa95963", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6e086bc5888fad9e4cec3d784eed7b829deda94570108d61073bc4303461722f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bc4679e584e87a2356ac172514ecce8c043e2403959494a48ea0fcdcd293910f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d65e253a9a9abd1b44695f1d371be6447b14d7c6280b5a5b84e0ce2445349b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d8363d5f7c1287817a76d7fb381185219bfec0567e439e3e01921c981af0a42e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "95ea257daaa20e7703a0d7c790e8b2749f6abc14635f78d233f3b75ad35cddfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "62e040b11276b2a28fcdc151584da41bbe97e35e04c499d29dbee6b2ace08d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b88cd9285e402e9a44574aa82272aa4f2d1626982f00d356ca81ef4357fd7a4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a891905eec858ea35260e88035f94c7ad01b590b1cdc9d849567d3b76acc76b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8e5422cd0376a74985eb0240671049f1b257c83142ce9e34763f6f9e36c8e03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "74a18fe6657297b4aaed2c0587ee4f5cb4d80a464c6bea1a3b5ea8d2f73df7e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "47efdf58dbc13a2c89f9f01c2c068b7876d75f60bdb8a4f43bf02830d567fecd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f6804bab60508dbf3f99307eb1b44b3d2d37039503bf83b834f44914b6682d26", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f024bc2da5f0dc8abca0cb0532144cf60cf638e07f67d1da174e3c117d4be91d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "77ef5417d0830c673e32a2b36256d261933e0b6bc71072f849ed9a8cdfac3ea6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fe5f2791146275ad9a01fe41c1b6dba758b8b67bfb97eb4ea038c09a9011361f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a55314e3d695c9fc59df25c98448e29d7d19918d95bfef51e789e45551841b1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35db28cf49d178106e419eeaec1426a7cfc7a1a327849fee4a2f842e5c3a28e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5682bf7d3cf99858d5124f44b914998d648c7e1b92ed80a6b95070959547530a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a3aca3dcd595e7a5a20b5e3ddd3e1b2a1c53a1b2e88fc83dc01719c17306d4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35327bd8600e625944b4698f49dc4702987176a385e0d0d579b80e1673069c88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2944b2ee489bb672cef8df8a8ef82fddd58c0a7ad02675706559f2d97f850b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e976afe266b4cd4e96a31a224b30f2e0ffd9d984452e532d986eb1f8998196ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6a8c2e4ab3ec19f9a698b670ee0d28608dcebc30d2a807b09d7003ba05daf175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fc7cea877ce739c24184c84109ec85dd523f12cec75d74e7eb515356dce8ae10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f7a3b0294bfe8bdf1e581f83d343e3fd850f7e7c3fd7d15fcd30446a67aa3c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "53a116251a85cfac95deabca095ca6f2fe9f4b830108f03c8fe18fa6f4639af6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "85628881078612cd7f6c9a492e810045c1b80a14b219086873ad9bd46ce20759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8b995e336a271d1484b2133efac681a5f360ea7e33213a5c5b2d9cecf9b2531", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5921b3c8d539313afe51a73f6b7a752378fc6a9f4ea3f234a1442775275005dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "80a5c3288250087bd0bc6187ac7e7a8c8789dab7842e5399e9dcee665bbb0caa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d0180348d037fa9b80d054f3ea34ff1448cc72fb732bc8f37b21e13e77788a38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e210343958c3eaaf086f7993860ae82806b20d1fc9b4f7c377ebb82aa7dc8ccb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b5084313b23a038e8d360cd58a1140d5551761de3206d7cecd87be89e1a1f306", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8abe2c737ddf84ffa4b7052fa7b520c27e8e3cc175cea8cc3ff33a7da9dd8d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "163fbc1c18f37ab83238440e9fe4437b0df6776806de9b8b80d288e66766abba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ffe141607abc1f1a77196337e46e99b988614f7e3315a89aaba46ddb5e1f85a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e12cb970f1a2c184459efb19d04f36ff86a3b12ca50ffdb2bcec815d536f7dab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "59643c05e20db04f9a5e08c0c47e42419a353e600301620631e9903825eb58cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250b6ae4937cc3b15f8270a4e58c200df6196b1d81dfdb398160acaeadf5bf23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37a02eabacdab34bf65b867efee76e47ff41925982f18b9793445e1fa9aae18b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cac01c201aec508ea2a9dffefc056d7f4cbf3fe0b31b44fcdbdcceb979bc586b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82e7c6e145b2e0e174bb8eb27044ea386592c300e6815efd450ba2befdd54e22", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b24a64fa7032044a02e660854a9b575b68f40873b0e5164ee577e2e5efb8e8e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-original.ppm", + "sha256": "281c53b4f63b17c486a8f33040be35104a7d2eeda1cc739903ebd1d21cfebaa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f61661ed59cd25c5033c519b8274329c6fc4988b37bf5358e49179c6218ae882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db3f643f748332ff908097d353d213dd993d522442637268304d5f5818dbdc2b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e3346559518b4078de56f27cc0ef48fdef545c451c816402bde77b491ecb876", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "52c7828bc9ee7ba7c410dd2acdfa1e106a28debc3ab622fb7a41ff6596c55bf6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4f8e908bd41ecb442e5a535dda5aa468ea6610fae169550e9b5f570bf7ec348c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6e0106cb11b9c0fefa9a1b2657cec2f7a3a5ede57bcbf4c339fc2469e532b608", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "59b3031287b8fc5fa5e0b035eb5797a278519fd7f3eec26931695af4b2772100", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6983135b2c07e6d1fc174539cd4902947636d5dbe3863abf5281b97d2757a36b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "99b318261fbf11732af653226ce69eb758fbbcd36c6339bcaeb99f37ad1a306c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eddfd182df049a93ce41d2b19ee23055c1fd39dd80e6d757b5f75f87ba143b7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40193": { @@ -402667,7 +436264,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40193", "family_id": "terrain-40185-40194", "job_id": "terrain-40185-40194", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -402683,6 +436280,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/candidate.json", "sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a0dc3300158ae0d596791a564fce239ebf42829cd04848c5a6cccba5ae7bb03d", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.182491+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"All source cliff wedge/curves, lip/shadow direction and orange-lower/brown-upper ground regions persist. 4018c notch,4018e tapering tilted rock,4018f large bottom-reaching rock,40190/40191 diagonal boundaries,40192/40193 shared oblong boulder and40194 two tilted rocks retain source placement. Cleanv2 has no invented straight quarter-grid lines; changed grain is disclosed.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 706b1a4780e7eaa6594876ffd158ae0cd8e648d0c45c54bc7290e54afc17ae57", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40185", + "40186", + "40187", + "40188" + ], + "sha256": "1b5139822e60551bb982c1686cb4e6a7e10811ee2fd108f3866ed054204bced0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40189", + "4018a", + "4018b", + "4018c" + ], + "sha256": "bb048d2249c27e54cb822893d346885a32b0d293225c54db2a52fd39b7afc04e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4018d", + "4018e", + "4018f", + "40190" + ], + "sha256": "46a2f579b51d9fc7b58a9bb733b2312693da3b2663187af34518a05268f3a9dc", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40191", + "40192", + "40193", + "40194" + ], + "sha256": "4fde949f74ce5d823cfbda462dd530525e91e22d3d5171df11eac25555710289", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40185-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "16e6e9ff46284302e59d2c138c658539b6ea73e178aa68c99d73bed7185f9995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d2df9f081297ce85a911cac24609ba52dea401a88a73594e8992f53fe3df2807", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f09ad009ea8563fc6528beee9c4ecb6fbfd9f49260f1189ad3dbe5e93fe2204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "61b48c823dec16b350d59a0ae6fe05b6c706be706587aac023ab4f372c4fb9c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-original.ppm", + "sha256": "837041d5a64fbe2495e086084e5fd8ad0efde0781c25672b5c6570e6cd5ce75a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0b71bb8c00973c950aa25caaf79819878286a8651c09be6dca4124802f174118", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "892f69d5d7bdcfa445f1c4d9fbb2889995f6a79ed0f54c3f01811d8103514ef7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56757a994d4613fa93a1e4ae3208ab80e0c9c48708867b6ea162efb150bd6d39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "421cb42e828ed02d701cc2667c6a937e2f71575573fece53a34ac74721bb7320", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fecf556bccbe4f03bdeae2f59493a2c86d611157184c118dcc1ef6757f8fcba8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d9c7df53787ac143df89f17ffccde6dbde485e1cb82b519f39b470c63d0d6c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afacc2fbe5b671d6dcaeaa255ad5eeadc9f4b2bfec05082cd55da82a21c90197", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5362165f51b963fb6b76588886604867222c60eb2ec3ab64e72593a7ac4bc5bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0417088410e49670bc963beea7b8be17b6d8b5a3808cb161295ee71f567e6a83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7f3bd65cbae623fc9e1cdeb170c42e29759208852326caec0de23aef842fabc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "415c09ba7701d36fa2955d21005715e16a3cb75a9610d01f09842ae95c52fb76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "085833e696cf6976ce90eed97e2033c4330d8350d885701e630067fda654bcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f48f69d21767674c9bcd9f92f8886b7ab44d6f645327f4b079a01cdd727ee95b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "343c752edac86a2e6e0e98173912e7c54f315451ac7e7e94462158250dee4c57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a446c698739f1fea2129c5d8c8d66b7d3199054720ecf79dc68117af185a31b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "853ad4528bdf6cc3c94aeb8f6b9f965ae488e60d46a392f071f7c120783c6b85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4e094be2afe9756b750cc7f84108865059aca3cef912572aabebf423e280a6d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a8d56618df03e5481079b09cc8f4d7eadf0de2e423419035991fda7294a3f7c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0ed97e74a0ee885127789ab0c0569a7229a47a3d26a61b311bc5bb5eed519107", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7cfc7fc9963ee23b756b1b44fcf24e34733f27f6c697cbde4cdccce711204ead", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e95db65e42e07a4a4d1f32e012ace8e95a2f4edd1ebf1a35276247136fa95963", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6e086bc5888fad9e4cec3d784eed7b829deda94570108d61073bc4303461722f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bc4679e584e87a2356ac172514ecce8c043e2403959494a48ea0fcdcd293910f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d65e253a9a9abd1b44695f1d371be6447b14d7c6280b5a5b84e0ce2445349b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d8363d5f7c1287817a76d7fb381185219bfec0567e439e3e01921c981af0a42e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "95ea257daaa20e7703a0d7c790e8b2749f6abc14635f78d233f3b75ad35cddfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "62e040b11276b2a28fcdc151584da41bbe97e35e04c499d29dbee6b2ace08d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b88cd9285e402e9a44574aa82272aa4f2d1626982f00d356ca81ef4357fd7a4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a891905eec858ea35260e88035f94c7ad01b590b1cdc9d849567d3b76acc76b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8e5422cd0376a74985eb0240671049f1b257c83142ce9e34763f6f9e36c8e03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "74a18fe6657297b4aaed2c0587ee4f5cb4d80a464c6bea1a3b5ea8d2f73df7e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "47efdf58dbc13a2c89f9f01c2c068b7876d75f60bdb8a4f43bf02830d567fecd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f6804bab60508dbf3f99307eb1b44b3d2d37039503bf83b834f44914b6682d26", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f024bc2da5f0dc8abca0cb0532144cf60cf638e07f67d1da174e3c117d4be91d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "77ef5417d0830c673e32a2b36256d261933e0b6bc71072f849ed9a8cdfac3ea6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fe5f2791146275ad9a01fe41c1b6dba758b8b67bfb97eb4ea038c09a9011361f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a55314e3d695c9fc59df25c98448e29d7d19918d95bfef51e789e45551841b1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35db28cf49d178106e419eeaec1426a7cfc7a1a327849fee4a2f842e5c3a28e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5682bf7d3cf99858d5124f44b914998d648c7e1b92ed80a6b95070959547530a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a3aca3dcd595e7a5a20b5e3ddd3e1b2a1c53a1b2e88fc83dc01719c17306d4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35327bd8600e625944b4698f49dc4702987176a385e0d0d579b80e1673069c88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2944b2ee489bb672cef8df8a8ef82fddd58c0a7ad02675706559f2d97f850b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e976afe266b4cd4e96a31a224b30f2e0ffd9d984452e532d986eb1f8998196ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6a8c2e4ab3ec19f9a698b670ee0d28608dcebc30d2a807b09d7003ba05daf175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fc7cea877ce739c24184c84109ec85dd523f12cec75d74e7eb515356dce8ae10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f7a3b0294bfe8bdf1e581f83d343e3fd850f7e7c3fd7d15fcd30446a67aa3c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "53a116251a85cfac95deabca095ca6f2fe9f4b830108f03c8fe18fa6f4639af6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "85628881078612cd7f6c9a492e810045c1b80a14b219086873ad9bd46ce20759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8b995e336a271d1484b2133efac681a5f360ea7e33213a5c5b2d9cecf9b2531", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5921b3c8d539313afe51a73f6b7a752378fc6a9f4ea3f234a1442775275005dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "80a5c3288250087bd0bc6187ac7e7a8c8789dab7842e5399e9dcee665bbb0caa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d0180348d037fa9b80d054f3ea34ff1448cc72fb732bc8f37b21e13e77788a38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e210343958c3eaaf086f7993860ae82806b20d1fc9b4f7c377ebb82aa7dc8ccb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b5084313b23a038e8d360cd58a1140d5551761de3206d7cecd87be89e1a1f306", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8abe2c737ddf84ffa4b7052fa7b520c27e8e3cc175cea8cc3ff33a7da9dd8d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "163fbc1c18f37ab83238440e9fe4437b0df6776806de9b8b80d288e66766abba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ffe141607abc1f1a77196337e46e99b988614f7e3315a89aaba46ddb5e1f85a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e12cb970f1a2c184459efb19d04f36ff86a3b12ca50ffdb2bcec815d536f7dab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "59643c05e20db04f9a5e08c0c47e42419a353e600301620631e9903825eb58cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250b6ae4937cc3b15f8270a4e58c200df6196b1d81dfdb398160acaeadf5bf23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37a02eabacdab34bf65b867efee76e47ff41925982f18b9793445e1fa9aae18b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cac01c201aec508ea2a9dffefc056d7f4cbf3fe0b31b44fcdbdcceb979bc586b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82e7c6e145b2e0e174bb8eb27044ea386592c300e6815efd450ba2befdd54e22", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b24a64fa7032044a02e660854a9b575b68f40873b0e5164ee577e2e5efb8e8e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-original.ppm", + "sha256": "281c53b4f63b17c486a8f33040be35104a7d2eeda1cc739903ebd1d21cfebaa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f61661ed59cd25c5033c519b8274329c6fc4988b37bf5358e49179c6218ae882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db3f643f748332ff908097d353d213dd993d522442637268304d5f5818dbdc2b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e3346559518b4078de56f27cc0ef48fdef545c451c816402bde77b491ecb876", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "52c7828bc9ee7ba7c410dd2acdfa1e106a28debc3ab622fb7a41ff6596c55bf6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4f8e908bd41ecb442e5a535dda5aa468ea6610fae169550e9b5f570bf7ec348c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6e0106cb11b9c0fefa9a1b2657cec2f7a3a5ede57bcbf4c339fc2469e532b608", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "59b3031287b8fc5fa5e0b035eb5797a278519fd7f3eec26931695af4b2772100", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6983135b2c07e6d1fc174539cd4902947636d5dbe3863abf5281b97d2757a36b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "99b318261fbf11732af653226ce69eb758fbbcd36c6339bcaeb99f37ad1a306c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eddfd182df049a93ce41d2b19ee23055c1fd39dd80e6d757b5f75f87ba143b7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40194": { @@ -402704,7 +436771,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "40194", "family_id": "terrain-40185-40194", "job_id": "terrain-40185-40194", - "status": "candidate", + "status": "registered", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -402720,6 +436787,476 @@ "manifest": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/candidate.json", "sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" + }, + "coordinator_review": { + "status": "approved", + "candidate_sha256": "e685e7ccdf21460ef8cefc050fb6e08af86c66ad618ff3a81aad7d815690e8ec", + "frame_bindings_sha256": "a0dc3300158ae0d596791a564fce239ebf42829cd04848c5a6cccba5ae7bb03d", + "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-10-11T08:09:40.182491+00:00", + "runtime_qa": "jobs/terrain-40185-40194/coordinator-runtime-current/runtime-qa.json", + "source_and_all_scale_visual_review": "Coordinator actually inspected all twenty complete source/current Rust1x/4x pages on six unresampled boards. LargeAir12v11 retains authentic first flash/rays, expanding bright core, irregular hollow rings, disconnected fading arcs and final fragment distribution. Repaired101eb connected inner lip and101ec upper shoulder preserve the original center-opening geometry; the four-of-five shoulder result and exact residual dim perimeter losses are accepted after independent marked actual2-4 inspection. Stronger hot grain in the two new phases versus smoother earlier paint is accepted and disclosed; no source-identical material or zero contour-loss claim. Opaque STAG0240088 retains its outer rail, clipped stacks, asymmetric dark/gray walls, central inset and lower strut. Fine panel wear/seams/rivets/vents and local brighter bevels with darker mean gray are accepted visually; opacity alone is not fidelity. Terrain3011d-3012c retains original destroyed industrial corners, surviving straight gray frame remnants, dark soot/rubble routing and authentic warm ember positions. Brighter steel/crack/rubble detail and fine gravel against original fallback are accepted; the four held remnant-loss cells in the preceding shard3010d-3011c are excluded. Terrain10410-1041f retains source gray intact/damaged building panels, authentic blast holes, lower dark structural segments, brown wall strips, separate rock groups/count/offsets, rails and stippled crossing fragments. The rough chipped1041f detail and native2/3 palette blockiness remain accepted disclosures, not a claim of continuous invented stonework. New damaged targets10410/12/14 have authentic sources and separately bound whole-family state evidence; foreign partners remain original. Historical job metadata lineage is verified as status/count-only, with exact native declarations unchanged. Terrain40175-40194 retains source rock positions/divots, cliff/coast slopes and orange/brown ground boundaries. Complete lower bush40179/7a is now in this target scope and its organic silhouette/shadow/leaves are accepted with the previously admitted upper pair; prior context-only evidence gave it no approval. The genuine no-grid v2 raw preserves cliff corners and original rock groups; denser fine soil and deeper cliff edge relief remain accepted material interpretation. All six unused IDs remain gallery-only and these two Set4 shards declare zero state partners. No blanket seamless whole-map, liveHost/custom-menu, gameplay timing or assembled-boss claim is inferred. All385 original/current1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte-for-byte, immutable source-age guards clear; held whole families and all prior failed variants remain excluded. {\"source_landmarks\": \"All source cliff wedge/curves, lip/shadow direction and orange-lower/brown-upper ground regions persist. 4018c notch,4018e tapering tilted rock,4018f large bottom-reaching rock,40190/40191 diagonal boundaries,40192/40193 shared oblong boulder and40194 two tilted rocks retain source placement. Cleanv2 has no invented straight quarter-grid lines; changed grain is disclosed.\", \"material\": \"Sharper, denser gravel and more articulated cliff-face relief than original. Native cliff/rock regions remain recognizable; visible soil patches at fallback neighbors are accepted disclosed limits, not seamless-map approval.\", \"coverage_limit\": \"Opaque coverage is only canvas proof; artistic approval is based on authentic fullsource landmarks, allscale views and genuine joins.\", \"holds\": []} [\"HD soil grain is sharper/denser/brighter; visible material patches against original fallback. No seamless or complete HD map claim.\", \"Exactly32 targets approved; other shared raw cells and rejected variants outside approval.\", \"No declared state pairs for these32; original fallback damage and surrounding tiles unchanged, no invented destructibility.\", \"Six unused IDs remain gallery-only, with no native or live placement claim.\", \"Current actual Catalog/Registry/HdAssets/TerrainHd proof, no independent live SDL/Host/cache replay.\", \"Future adjacent HD admissions require renewed contextual/material review.\"] All source and current actual1-4 PPMs match independently visually accepted outputs byte for byte.", + "independent_review": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/independent-verdict.json, SHA256 706b1a4780e7eaa6594876ffd158ae0cd8e648d0c45c54bc7290e54afc17ae57", + "additional_independent_evidence": [ + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/review-index.json", + "sha256": "d26f169bb410ded24f604c88dac40458ec232a9c60a648aa6b7a02ea232d7fd3" + }, + { + "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/artifact-manifest.json", + "sha256": "2c24fbc4947d995e260553b1087c45bb4c19350bbfcaae9c57514da95b7ddceb" + } + ], + "reviewed_pages": [ + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-001.png", + "assets": [ + "40185", + "40186", + "40187", + "40188" + ], + "sha256": "1b5139822e60551bb982c1686cb4e6a7e10811ee2fd108f3866ed054204bced0", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-002.png", + "assets": [ + "40189", + "4018a", + "4018b", + "4018c" + ], + "sha256": "bb048d2249c27e54cb822893d346885a32b0d293225c54db2a52fd39b7afc04e", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-003.png", + "assets": [ + "4018d", + "4018e", + "4018f", + "40190" + ], + "sha256": "46a2f579b51d9fc7b58a9bb733b2312693da3b2663187af34518a05268f3a9dc", + "entire_page_inspected": true + }, + { + "file": "runtime-contact-sheet-004.png", + "assets": [ + "40191", + "40192", + "40193", + "40194" + ], + "sha256": "4fde949f74ce5d823cfbda462dd530525e91e22d3d5171df11eac25555710289", + "entire_page_inspected": true + } + ], + "primary_board_manifest": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/registered-class-review/next1148-boards/boards.json", + "actual_outputs_compared_to_independent_review": [ + { + "file": "40185-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "16e6e9ff46284302e59d2c138c658539b6ea73e178aa68c99d73bed7185f9995", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d2df9f081297ce85a911cac24609ba52dea401a88a73594e8992f53fe3df2807", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5f09ad009ea8563fc6528beee9c4ecb6fbfd9f49260f1189ad3dbe5e93fe2204", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "61b48c823dec16b350d59a0ae6fe05b6c706be706587aac023ab4f372c4fb9c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40185-original.ppm", + "sha256": "837041d5a64fbe2495e086084e5fd8ad0efde0781c25672b5c6570e6cd5ce75a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40185-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "0b71bb8c00973c950aa25caaf79819878286a8651c09be6dca4124802f174118", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "892f69d5d7bdcfa445f1c4d9fbb2889995f6a79ed0f54c3f01811d8103514ef7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "56757a994d4613fa93a1e4ae3208ab80e0c9c48708867b6ea162efb150bd6d39", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "421cb42e828ed02d701cc2667c6a937e2f71575573fece53a34ac74721bb7320", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40186-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fecf556bccbe4f03bdeae2f59493a2c86d611157184c118dcc1ef6757f8fcba8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40186-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "5d9c7df53787ac143df89f17ffccde6dbde485e1cb82b519f39b470c63d0d6c2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "afacc2fbe5b671d6dcaeaa255ad5eeadc9f4b2bfec05082cd55da82a21c90197", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "5362165f51b963fb6b76588886604867222c60eb2ec3ab64e72593a7ac4bc5bc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0417088410e49670bc963beea7b8be17b6d8b5a3808cb161295ee71f567e6a83", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40187-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7f3bd65cbae623fc9e1cdeb170c42e29759208852326caec0de23aef842fabc9", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40187-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "415c09ba7701d36fa2955d21005715e16a3cb75a9610d01f09842ae95c52fb76", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "085833e696cf6976ce90eed97e2033c4330d8350d885701e630067fda654bcfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f48f69d21767674c9bcd9f92f8886b7ab44d6f645327f4b079a01cdd727ee95b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "343c752edac86a2e6e0e98173912e7c54f315451ac7e7e94462158250dee4c57", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40188-original.ppm", + "sha256": "a446c698739f1fea2129c5d8c8d66b7d3199054720ecf79dc68117af185a31b2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40188-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "853ad4528bdf6cc3c94aeb8f6b9f965ae488e60d46a392f071f7c120783c6b85", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "4e094be2afe9756b750cc7f84108865059aca3cef912572aabebf423e280a6d4", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "a8d56618df03e5481079b09cc8f4d7eadf0de2e423419035991fda7294a3f7c7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "0ed97e74a0ee885127789ab0c0569a7229a47a3d26a61b311bc5bb5eed519107", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40189-original.ppm", + "sha256": "7cfc7fc9963ee23b756b1b44fcf24e34733f27f6c697cbde4cdccce711204ead", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40189-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "e95db65e42e07a4a4d1f32e012ace8e95a2f4edd1ebf1a35276247136fa95963", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "6e086bc5888fad9e4cec3d784eed7b829deda94570108d61073bc4303461722f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "bc4679e584e87a2356ac172514ecce8c043e2403959494a48ea0fcdcd293910f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "d65e253a9a9abd1b44695f1d371be6447b14d7c6280b5a5b84e0ce2445349b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018a-original.ppm", + "sha256": "d8363d5f7c1287817a76d7fb381185219bfec0567e439e3e01921c981af0a42e", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018a-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "95ea257daaa20e7703a0d7c790e8b2749f6abc14635f78d233f3b75ad35cddfd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "62e040b11276b2a28fcdc151584da41bbe97e35e04c499d29dbee6b2ace08d17", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "b88cd9285e402e9a44574aa82272aa4f2d1626982f00d356ca81ef4357fd7a4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "a891905eec858ea35260e88035f94c7ad01b590b1cdc9d849567d3b76acc76b8", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018b-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8e5422cd0376a74985eb0240671049f1b257c83142ce9e34763f6f9e36c8e03a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018b-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "74a18fe6657297b4aaed2c0587ee4f5cb4d80a464c6bea1a3b5ea8d2f73df7e5", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "47efdf58dbc13a2c89f9f01c2c068b7876d75f60bdb8a4f43bf02830d567fecd", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "f6804bab60508dbf3f99307eb1b44b3d2d37039503bf83b834f44914b6682d26", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "f024bc2da5f0dc8abca0cb0532144cf60cf638e07f67d1da174e3c117d4be91d", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018c-original.ppm", + "sha256": "77ef5417d0830c673e32a2b36256d261933e0b6bc71072f849ed9a8cdfac3ea6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018c-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "fe5f2791146275ad9a01fe41c1b6dba758b8b67bfb97eb4ea038c09a9011361f", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "a55314e3d695c9fc59df25c98448e29d7d19918d95bfef51e789e45551841b1a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "35db28cf49d178106e419eeaec1426a7cfc7a1a327849fee4a2f842e5c3a28e7", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "5682bf7d3cf99858d5124f44b914998d648c7e1b92ed80a6b95070959547530a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018d-original.ppm", + "sha256": "2a3aca3dcd595e7a5a20b5e3ddd3e1b2a1c53a1b2e88fc83dc01719c17306d4c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018d-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "35327bd8600e625944b4698f49dc4702987176a385e0d0d579b80e1673069c88", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2944b2ee489bb672cef8df8a8ef82fddd58c0a7ad02675706559f2d97f850b9b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e976afe266b4cd4e96a31a224b30f2e0ffd9d984452e532d986eb1f8998196ad", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "6a8c2e4ab3ec19f9a698b670ee0d28608dcebc30d2a807b09d7003ba05daf175", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018e-original.ppm", + "sha256": "fc7cea877ce739c24184c84109ec85dd523f12cec75d74e7eb515356dce8ae10", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018e-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f7a3b0294bfe8bdf1e581f83d343e3fd850f7e7c3fd7d15fcd30446a67aa3c4a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "53a116251a85cfac95deabca095ca6f2fe9f4b830108f03c8fe18fa6f4639af6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "85628881078612cd7f6c9a492e810045c1b80a14b219086873ad9bd46ce20759", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "c8b995e336a271d1484b2133efac681a5f360ea7e33213a5c5b2d9cecf9b2531", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "4018f-original.ppm", + "sha256": "5921b3c8d539313afe51a73f6b7a752378fc6a9f4ea3f234a1442775275005dc", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/4018f-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "80a5c3288250087bd0bc6187ac7e7a8c8789dab7842e5399e9dcee665bbb0caa", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "d0180348d037fa9b80d054f3ea34ff1448cc72fb732bc8f37b21e13e77788a38", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e210343958c3eaaf086f7993860ae82806b20d1fc9b4f7c377ebb82aa7dc8ccb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b5084313b23a038e8d360cd58a1140d5551761de3206d7cecd87be89e1a1f306", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40190-original.ppm", + "sha256": "8abe2c737ddf84ffa4b7052fa7b520c27e8e3cc175cea8cc3ff33a7da9dd8d36", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40190-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "163fbc1c18f37ab83238440e9fe4437b0df6776806de9b8b80d288e66766abba", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "2ffe141607abc1f1a77196337e46e99b988614f7e3315a89aaba46ddb5e1f85a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "e12cb970f1a2c184459efb19d04f36ff86a3b12ca50ffdb2bcec815d536f7dab", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "59643c05e20db04f9a5e08c0c47e42419a353e600301620631e9903825eb58cb", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40191-original.ppm", + "sha256": "250b6ae4937cc3b15f8270a4e58c200df6196b1d81dfdb398160acaeadf5bf23", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40191-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "37a02eabacdab34bf65b867efee76e47ff41925982f18b9793445e1fa9aae18b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "cac01c201aec508ea2a9dffefc056d7f4cbf3fe0b31b44fcdbdcceb979bc586b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "82e7c6e145b2e0e174bb8eb27044ea386592c300e6815efd450ba2befdd54e22", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "b24a64fa7032044a02e660854a9b575b68f40873b0e5164ee577e2e5efb8e8e2", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40192-original.ppm", + "sha256": "281c53b4f63b17c486a8f33040be35104a7d2eeda1cc739903ebd1d21cfebaa0", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40192-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "f61661ed59cd25c5033c519b8274329c6fc4988b37bf5358e49179c6218ae882", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "db3f643f748332ff908097d353d213dd993d522442637268304d5f5818dbdc2b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "1e3346559518b4078de56f27cc0ef48fdef545c451c816402bde77b491ecb876", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "52c7828bc9ee7ba7c410dd2acdfa1e106a28debc3ab622fb7a41ff6596c55bf6", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40193-original.ppm", + "sha256": "4f8e908bd41ecb442e5a535dda5aa468ea6610fae169550e9b5f570bf7ec348c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40193-original.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-1.ppm", + "sha256": "6e0106cb11b9c0fefa9a1b2657cec2f7a3a5ede57bcbf4c339fc2469e532b608", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-1.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-2.ppm", + "sha256": "59b3031287b8fc5fa5e0b035eb5797a278519fd7f3eec26931695af4b2772100", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-2.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-3.ppm", + "sha256": "6983135b2c07e6d1fc174539cd4902947636d5dbe3863abf5281b97d2757a36b", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-3.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-hd-4.ppm", + "sha256": "99b318261fbf11732af653226ce69eb758fbbcd36c6339bcaeb99f37ad1a306c", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-hd-4.ppm" + }, + { + "file": "40194-original.ppm", + "sha256": "eddfd182df049a93ce41d2b19ee23055c1fd39dd80e6d757b5f75f87ba143b7a", + "independent_reference": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/.reference/hd-full-review/iron-coast-2-terrain-set4-cliff-two/terrain-40185-40194/runtime/40194-original.ppm" + } + ], + "native_scene_scope": "Source gallery artwork plus separately bound declared terrain contexts; no new Host/live-route assertion.", + "sibling_promotion": null } }, "40195": { @@ -413397,7 +447934,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402b5", "family_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", "job_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -413408,6 +447945,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-402b5-402c4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "959db7fda95e2bed73727dd9443148585b669e7d62ee728a147030b48fcd6b61", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402b6": { @@ -413429,7 +447971,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402b6", "family_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", "job_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -413440,6 +447982,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-402b5-402c4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "959db7fda95e2bed73727dd9443148585b669e7d62ee728a147030b48fcd6b61", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402b7": { @@ -413461,7 +448008,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402b7", "family_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", "job_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -413472,6 +448019,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-402b5-402c4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "959db7fda95e2bed73727dd9443148585b669e7d62ee728a147030b48fcd6b61", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402b8": { @@ -413493,7 +448045,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402b8", "family_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", "job_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -413504,6 +448056,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-402b5-402c4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "959db7fda95e2bed73727dd9443148585b669e7d62ee728a147030b48fcd6b61", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402b9": { @@ -413525,7 +448082,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402b9", "family_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", "job_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -413536,6 +448093,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-402b5-402c4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "959db7fda95e2bed73727dd9443148585b669e7d62ee728a147030b48fcd6b61", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402ba": { @@ -413557,7 +448119,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402ba", "family_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", "job_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -413568,6 +448130,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-402b5-402c4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "959db7fda95e2bed73727dd9443148585b669e7d62ee728a147030b48fcd6b61", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402bb": { @@ -413589,7 +448156,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402bb", "family_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", "job_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": false, @@ -413600,6 +448167,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-402b5-402c4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "959db7fda95e2bed73727dd9443148585b669e7d62ee728a147030b48fcd6b61", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402bc": { @@ -413621,7 +448193,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402bc", "family_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", "job_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -413632,6 +448204,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-402b5-402c4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "959db7fda95e2bed73727dd9443148585b669e7d62ee728a147030b48fcd6b61", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402bd": { @@ -413653,7 +448230,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402bd", "family_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", "job_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -413664,6 +448241,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-402b5-402c4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "959db7fda95e2bed73727dd9443148585b669e7d62ee728a147030b48fcd6b61", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402be": { @@ -413685,7 +448267,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402be", "family_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", "job_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -413696,6 +448278,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-402b5-402c4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "959db7fda95e2bed73727dd9443148585b669e7d62ee728a147030b48fcd6b61", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402bf": { @@ -413717,7 +448304,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402bf", "family_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", "job_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -413728,6 +448315,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-402b5-402c4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "959db7fda95e2bed73727dd9443148585b669e7d62ee728a147030b48fcd6b61", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402c0": { @@ -413749,7 +448341,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402c0", "family_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", "job_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -413760,6 +448352,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-402b5-402c4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "959db7fda95e2bed73727dd9443148585b669e7d62ee728a147030b48fcd6b61", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402c1": { @@ -413781,7 +448378,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402c1", "family_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", "job_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -413792,6 +448389,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-402b5-402c4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "959db7fda95e2bed73727dd9443148585b669e7d62ee728a147030b48fcd6b61", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402c2": { @@ -413813,7 +448415,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402c2", "family_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", "job_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -413824,6 +448426,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-402b5-402c4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "959db7fda95e2bed73727dd9443148585b669e7d62ee728a147030b48fcd6b61", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402c3": { @@ -413845,7 +448452,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402c3", "family_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", "job_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -413856,6 +448463,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-402b5-402c4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "959db7fda95e2bed73727dd9443148585b669e7d62ee728a147030b48fcd6b61", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402c4": { @@ -413877,7 +448489,7 @@ "canonical_source_asset": "402c4", "family_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", "job_id": "terrain-402b5-402c4", - "status": "inprogress", + "status": "candidate", "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "remaster_required": true, "registry_or_layout_referenced": true, @@ -413888,6 +448500,11 @@ "RustRaptor/tests/hd_terrain.rs", ".reference/terrain-hd/shoreline-draft-context-proof.png" ] + }, + "candidate": { + "manifest": "jobs/terrain-402b5-402c4/candidate.json", + "sha256": "959db7fda95e2bed73727dd9443148585b669e7d62ee728a147030b48fcd6b61", + "validation_scope": "source-bound metadata, target ownership and artwork file presence; artistic/PNG/runtime review is separate" } }, "402c5": { @@ -442374,7 +476991,7 @@ "owner": "/root/campaign_integration", "target_count": 12, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 12 + "registered": 12 }, "job_file": "effects-101e5-101f0/job.json" }, @@ -445950,7 +480567,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "target_count": 1, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 1 + "registered": 1 }, "job_file": "enemies-40088-40088/job.json" }, @@ -446346,7 +480963,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 16 + "registered": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-10410-1041f/job.json" }, @@ -447210,7 +481827,7 @@ "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "inprogress": 16 + "candidate": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-2039d-203ac/job.json" }, @@ -447219,10 +481836,10 @@ "name": "Terrain set 2 shard 43", "category": "Terrain", "kind": "contextual_terrain_shard", - "owner": null, + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "missing": 16 + "candidate": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-203ad-203bc/job.json" }, @@ -447231,10 +481848,10 @@ "name": "Terrain set 2 shard 44", "category": "Terrain", "kind": "contextual_terrain_shard", - "owner": null, + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "missing": 16 + "candidate": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-203bd-203cc/job.json" }, @@ -447243,10 +481860,10 @@ "name": "Terrain set 2 shard 45", "category": "Terrain", "kind": "contextual_terrain_shard", - "owner": null, + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "missing": 16 + "candidate": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-203cd-203dc/job.json" }, @@ -447255,10 +481872,10 @@ "name": "Terrain set 2 shard 46", "category": "Terrain", "kind": "contextual_terrain_shard", - "owner": null, + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "missing": 16 + "inprogress": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-203dd-203ec/job.json" }, @@ -447267,10 +481884,10 @@ "name": "Terrain set 2 shard 47", "category": "Terrain", "kind": "contextual_terrain_shard", - "owner": null, + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "missing": 16 + "inprogress": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-203ed-203fc/job.json" }, @@ -447279,10 +481896,10 @@ "name": "Terrain set 2 shard 48", "category": "Terrain", "kind": "contextual_terrain_shard", - "owner": null, + "owner": "/root/hd_terrain_set_2", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "missing": 16 + "inprogress": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-203fd-2040c/job.json" }, @@ -447834,7 +482451,7 @@ "owner": "iron_coast_6", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 16 + "registered": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-3011d-3012c/job.json" }, @@ -447942,7 +482559,8 @@ "owner": "/root/iron_coast_6/terrain_set3_middle", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "inprogress": 16 + "candidate": 3, + "inprogress": 13 }, "job_file": "terrain-301ad-301bc/job.json" }, @@ -448374,7 +482992,7 @@ "owner": "terrain_set3_late", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "inprogress": 16 + "candidate": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-303ed-303fc/job.json" }, @@ -448734,7 +483352,7 @@ "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 16 + "registered": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-40175-40184/job.json" }, @@ -448746,7 +483364,7 @@ "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "candidate": 16 + "registered": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-40185-40194/job.json" }, @@ -448974,7 +483592,7 @@ "owner": "/root/campaign_release_review", "target_count": 16, "status_counts": { - "inprogress": 16 + "candidate": 16 }, "job_file": "terrain-402b5-402c4/job.json" }, diff --git a/docs/hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md b/docs/hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md index 0999b816..013c6539 100644 --- a/docs/hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md +++ b/docs/hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # HD coordinator checkpoint — 11 October 2026 -The reviewed external development pack contains **1,071 original picture frames in 400 complete sequences**. The committed Linux and Windows playable snapshots remain **800 frames / 340 sequences**, assembled at `964ba93` from the immutable 800-frame handoff. Root owns runtime data, binaries, libraries and archives; coordinator owns external development registration and this metadata. Bundled originals and approved runtime art are tracked under this repository's data/. Working originals, prompts, job candidates and review evidence remain external under ../data/. +The reviewed external development pack contains **1,148 original picture frames in 421 complete sequences**. The committed Linux and Windows playable snapshots remain **800 frames / 340 sequences**, assembled at `964ba93` from the immutable 800-frame handoff. Root owns runtime data, binaries, libraries and archives; coordinator owns external development registration and this metadata. Bundled originals and approved runtime art are tracked under this repository's data/. Working originals, prompts, job candidates and review evidence remain external under ../data/. ## Verified development coverage @@ -8,21 +8,21 @@ The reviewed external development pack contains **1,071 original picture frames | --- | ---: | | Player banking | 21 / 21 | | Bosses | 232 / 249 | -| Enemies and ground objects | 150 / 419 | +| Enemies and ground objects | 151 / 419 | | Player and enemy projectiles | 45 / 51 | -| Explosions and effects | 164 / 281 | +| Explosions and effects | 176 / 281 | | Equipment and pickups | 47 / 47 | -| Terrain | 352 / 4,535 | +| Terrain | 416 / 4,535 | | Menus, portraits, HUD and other pictures | 60 / 150 | -| Total | 1,071 / 5,753 | +| Total | 1,148 / 5,753 | -All 6,449 catalog entries and 5,753 pictures were audited with zero HD source/hash/canvas/ID errors. **4,682 pictures still await registration**. The current ledger contains 1,051 registered, 20 render-reachable, 1,733 candidate, 1,022 in-progress and 1,927 missing pictures. Candidate status establishes neither artistic approval nor a live occurrence. Unused and damaged IDs remain required. The 303 AGX delta frames and four bitmap fonts retain their separate classic-art preservation policies. +All 6,449 catalog entries and 5,753 pictures were audited with zero HD source/hash/canvas/ID errors. **4,605 pictures still await registration**. The current ledger contains 1,128 registered, 20 render-reachable, 1,755 candidate, 1,019 in-progress and 1,831 missing pictures. Candidate status establishes neither artistic approval nor a live occurrence. Unused and damaged IDs remain required. The303 AGX delta frames and four bitmap fonts retain their separate classic-art preservation policies. ## Current immutable output proof -../data/hd/registered-class-review/runtime-1071-current/combined-review.json closes **4,284 actual scale outputs / 5,355 original and scaled PPMs**, all byte-identical to independently accepted references. Both source-age guards are false; diagnostics are empty. The immutable release library is `target/hd-review-libraries/0ec6137e0e3261e813b2b863cd96c04da55e07cdf29b5c10b1d112e20f0a3daf/libraptor_replica-79676ac8bb9ed60d.rlib`, SHA `0ec6137e0e3261e813b2b863cd96c04da55e07cdf29b5c10b1d112e20f0a3daf`, original build time `1791703254797483881`. Current development hd.json SHA is `05f9bb076f31388d34eb13ee05ca53063539548dcb1867fb686dfd3a4cb24445`. Combined review SHA is `8806a5aa651326303d90d18dba8b0d6cdbba65be2e534af14a43cbb40d2c692d`. Registration verifies exact library bytes and original build age. +../data/hd/registered-class-review/runtime-1148-current/combined-review.json closes **4,592 actual scale outputs / 5,740 original and scaled PPMs**, all byte-identical to independently accepted references. Both source-age guards are false at actual final source invocation and closure; all17 Rust source hashes and mtimes remain exact. Immutable release library `target/hd-review-libraries/636eccd24f56fc08ed25aa3bdf311d0b9e26284f2c95ab5ab6c6df070edc3b7c/libraptor_replica-f076ad67c588e355.rlib`, SHA `636eccd24f56fc08ed25aa3bdf311d0b9e26284f2c95ab5ab6c6df070edc3b7c`, original build time `1791706432981505461`, binds root's final Stage2 optional animation/effect.kind API source. Current development hd.json SHA is `5d6b0010049cf5d9d29612391faa72a35d867968f2ce31d6a8e9622e597e4ed8`; combined review SHA `fffd79b1c1e63b1dc21f92f6f961693e9d483c9a73d027fb3e61c56f71e7d323`. No source flag is inferred solely from unchanged pixels. -All 985 ordinary source pictures introduce no reserved240–255 labels. 83 source-class pictures retain authentic gameplay classes; three opening cards use their original static256-color palettes. Exact native/source loading does not establish whole-mission completion, custom-menu reachability, complete assembled-boss joins or new destroyed artwork. +All 1058 ordinary source pictures introduce no reserved240–255 labels. 87 source-class pictures retain authentic gameplay classes; three opening cards use their original static256-color palettes. Exact native/source loading does not establish whole-mission completion, custom-menu reachability, complete assembled-boss joins or new destroyed artwork. After the historical929 checkpoint, batch-979-approval.json adds **50 frames / eight complete families**, with250 exact accepted PPMs and15 complete coordinator-inspected source/native1/HD4 pages on four boards. The batch contains radar40115–40134/32, four tread/slat/fork families15, TEXTURE10018 and side trims50005/50006. batch-1037-approval.json adds **58 frames / eleven complete families**, with290 exact accepted PPMs and20 complete inspected pages on six boards: Orange9, difficulty4, craft3008f/92/95/98, ground40135–40154/32, restored10310/200a3 and complete400ac–400b2/7. Every candidate, binding, source, peer evidence, raw and current output is bound. The former held boss mains are SHA-named snapshots before exact sibling-byte promotion; all rejected versions remain unchanged. @@ -41,15 +41,25 @@ Original Set4 jobs9/10,40155–40174, preserve crack routes, rock groups and sha The opaque4006e warm center remains held despite coherent gray architecture: the source yellow-inclusive21-cell core becomes13 native cells and about14.19 logical-area cells at4x, with a visibly duller yellow spot. Its job.json inprogress-to-candidate change during peer review came from coordinator hd_job_queue.py bookkeeping in the1037 ledger refresh, not an artist/source change; both byte snapshots and exact unchanged artwork/source pins are preserved. STAG0240088 has independent approval but remains separate from1071 until coordinator inspection/admission. +## Final pre-Stage2 reviewer closures + +The77-frame batch1148 contains six complete job families and21 manifest sequences;10410 contributes sixteen standalone sequences. Coordinator actually inspected all20 complete source/native1/HD4 pages on six unresampled boards and matched all385 source/scaled PPMs to independent accepted references. LargeAirv11 restores the connected inner lip and upper shoulder, accepts its one residual dim endpoint and other enumerated contour differences, and discloses stronger hot grain against smoother phases. STAG0240088 keeps original opaque internal architecture with darker gray/finer metal material. Terrain3011d–3012c retains straight gray remnants, damage routing and authentic warm flecks;10410–1041f retains native intact/damaged building panels, rock groups and stippled crossings. New damaged10410/12/14 sources and full-family state transitions are explicit. Terrain40175–40194 retains slopes/rock offsets/material boundaries and admits the genuine lower bush40179/7a after independent target review. Its cleanv2 raw excludes the preserved rejected gridv1. Six unused IDs remain gallery-only; zero state partners in those two Set4 jobs. + +Root's Stage2 API edits and formatting intervened after the initial77 registration checks. The supplementary1148 attempt using d844a5d7 has all5,740 pixels byte-identical to accepted references, but its broad source-age guard correctly reads true. That attempt, its exact source snapshot and comparison remain under runtime-1148-pre-final-stage2-source; they were not relabeled or used as current-source certification. The definitive1148 render rebuilt the final formatted animation/effect.kind API epoch and preserved earlier1071/1037/800 output history. Packaged800 and private1037 copies remain unchanged. + +Seven reviewers have checkpointed their former HD scopes and switched to Stage2; no new HD reservations go to them until Stage2 integration finishes. Their final exact reports are bound before the transition. Full-family Flare26v8 remains held for10258's five-cell and10266's two-cell transparent holes filled by old bindings, report65648399844683bc4287ce3d5bca5992ccdb602f1f18c5ef5b12eb1dbb13eb1a. Sparkle17v8 remains held for10277's ten-cell alpha-zero opening and10272–76's muted authentic bright ray-tip material, reportde6d412e1647168500778333c277d0823330c9b2d047fd3550ad09dd4bae562d. Artists may generate bounded sibling corrections for those exact two/six frame scopes while preserving other24/11 bindings and the whole frozen history; no self-approval or partial registration. + +Terrain3 shard3 remains wholly unadmitted: twelve per-frame judgments are positive, but30112/13/19/1a lose surviving linear gray remnants. Complete shard4's sixteen bindings are separately admitted. The shared independent report755667dfb498724e17a35358d8d01541f51783b061cf26f80684c0d618ad68cb preserves both conclusions without implying joined64 exhaustive seams. Terrain10400's reporte8254870c26cf95c4add0a08ababa03e6108086a33aa2feadf4d3849bfc16a46 accepts fifteen exact bindings with original10406 fallback but holds the whole family on rectangular organic-ground slabs. Its genuine10406 sibling must preserve those fifteen accepted raw/bindings/outputs before complete-family admission. SHIP25 now has separate independent approval but is not included in1148; source-age and current pixel continuity remain required before admission. + ## Private development1,037 input A separate immutable development input is published at ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-1037-20261011/pack/. Its handoff-manifest.json SHA is `51a857fc9a1e584e00ece4800436e3c9411de5c1fba8a25e527c65d1ee542d4f`; hd.json SHA is `707ab815114579828bcb823cc3e62efa80ea05b54ae83e83dc30c5730cde0e96`. It contains1,037 frames/396 complete sequences,366 distinct files/569,685,991 bytes, with source INDEX, complete source/scale proof and original build identity pinned. Every file is a private copy with verified bytes and a distinct inode; future development mutation cannot change the handoff. This is a reviewable future assembly input, not authorization to refresh the existing800 runtime files or archives. The original packaged800 handoff remains untouched. ## Frozen Linux/Windows800 history -The separate historical runtime-800-current/combined-review.json remains unchanged:3,200 scales/4,000 accepted PPMs using immutablef71826f4eec106d59a55c12380ee1437a3cfeddf6f9d145480624ff5e5b8eaa5. Historical929,979 and1037 closures remain separate and are not retroactively associated with a newer library. Root's later test-only terrain capture fixes did not alter the production desktop prefix, loader, compositor or shaders. +The separate historical runtime-800-current/combined-review.json remains unchanged:3,200 scales/4,000 accepted PPMs using immutablef71826f4eec106d59a55c12380ee1437a3cfeddf6f9d145480624ff5e5b8eaa5. Historical929,979,1037 and1071 closures remain separate and are not retroactively associated with a newer library. Root's later test-only terrain capture fixes did not alter the production desktop prefix, loader, compositor or shaders. -The private immutable handoff is ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-800-20261011/pack/, pack manifest SHA `fbf8b6a9af134e263881ce28f002259affbf0636f53d214ea34bbd8c61205f71`. handoff-manifest.json SHA `29821d06c34114101041e50318c5c013a9236e474716a382257d6d252c304b1e` binds292 pack files:290 artwork files plus hd.json/provenance.json. Root copied and verified all into tracked data:6,742 files/461,771,350 bytes. Later271 development approvals are not included in that runtime snapshot. +The private immutable handoff is ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-800-20261011/pack/, pack manifest SHA `fbf8b6a9af134e263881ce28f002259affbf0636f53d214ea34bbd8c61205f71`. handoff-manifest.json SHA `29821d06c34114101041e50318c5c013a9236e474716a382257d6d252c304b1e` binds292 pack files:290 artwork files plus hd.json/provenance.json. Root copied and verified all into tracked data:6,742 files/461,771,350 bytes. Later348 development approvals are not included in that runtime snapshot. Native Windows third CI38121272504 passed279 tests/0failed/24ignored, exact committedGNU launcher/gameplay/full800/all22mods and a freshMSVC build. Linux/Windows relocated launch, catalog, SDL and audio checks passed. Root documentation proof is fb6574a. Final Windows archive SHA25fca23c5ca95b754cf49fcf24b07d94dec8094863e6750c1898a55d6893cbfe,602433522bytes; Linux SHA0f384c3592a1a6d9302c16769cd8aafb096464fe17150ea1a66b34743fbdc97a. Both archiveCRC/data/runtime/source/doc checks passed. No further packaged art changes are authorized by this development metadata checkpoint. @@ -59,22 +69,23 @@ Metadata-only provenance corrections preserve before-byte snapshots and exact ac Root is temporarily assigning iron_coast_2, iron_coast_3, iron_coast_5, iron_coast_6, windows_persistence, terrain_capture_fixture and campaign_release_review to Iron Coast Stage2: eight levels, one or two weapons and authorized API additions. They must checkpoint existing HD review evidence first. No new independent HD review reservations will be assigned to these seven until Stage2 integration finishes. The scopes listed below record their last HD assignments for later resumption, rather than new active review work. -The terrain-set3 children continue their original HD queues directly. HD artists, hd_full_review, hd_dark_player and hd_enemies_01 continue their disjoint original work. Stage2 uses the same four-slot generation gate; its authored mod art is separate from original catalog coverage. Coordinator does not edit Stage2 mods. Runtime800 stays unchanged until root's explicit release update, and the private immutable1037 assembly input remains available. This1071 proof was captured before the reassignment; future API/source changes require honest new library/source-epoch checks and current-output continuity before another admission. +The terrain-set3 children continue their original HD queues directly. HD artists, hd_full_review, hd_dark_player and hd_enemies_01 continue their disjoint original work. Stage2 uses the same four-slot generation gate; its authored mod art is separate from original catalog coverage. Coordinator does not edit Stage2 mods. Runtime800 stays unchanged until root's explicit release update, and the private immutable1037 assembly input remains available. The1071 proof predates the API changes and remains historical. Current1148 closes a separately rebuilt final Stage2 API epoch, while later source changes still require honest new library/source checks and output continuity. ## Durable owners and outstanding holds Coordinator alone registers external development art and refreshes audit/ledger. Queue offsets change after admission; use original durable job IDs. Artists never approve/register their own artwork. Commit only owned paths; docs/hd-full-review.md remains reviewer-owned. Root alone assembles tracked runtime and controls future loader/alpha/shader/encoder policy. No such production policy changed during1037 closure. -- hd_full_review exclusively reviews terrain10400–1040f. Its10406 organic-ground-as-rectangular-slabs material hold is concrete after all88 context pages. Other15 have source-faithful partial judgments with10406 original fallback; no complete16 approval or partial admission. A genuine single-tile organic correction must preserve those fifteen bindings before complete-family and changed-context review. Raw/candidate remain frozen until the review completes. -- iron_coast_2 has independently approved original Set4 jobs1–10/160frames and now reviews original jobs11/12,40175–40194. Additional lower foliage cells40179/7a may appear only in a separately pinned complete-object diagnostic, without admission; the160 reviewed pack retains original fallback there. -- iron_coast_5 now independently reviews iron6's original Terrain3 shards3/4,3010d–3012c/32. Earlier joined64 state diagnostics complement individual exhaustive proof without certifying complete combined seams. Specific gray-remnant/bright-rubble material concerns require artistic judgment. -- windows_persistence holds exact LargeAirv9 for unchanged101eb's connected seven-cell inner lip and101ec's five-cell upper shoulder, with30/14 whole cells absent4x. The newly repairedfirst2/late2 phases are improved/accepted with minor edge caveats, but do not override the full-family hold. It approved300ac/3009d and held4006e for the original warm center. STAG0240088 is independently accepted later; complete LargeAirv11 is now exclusively reserved. -- terrain_capture_fixture completed the nine-frame boss sibling decisions and root's read-only rounding investigation. It now exclusively reviews terrain10410–1041f, including authentic intact/destroyed partners and rough pale fragment material. Its source-class/shader/scene probes do not imply blanket art or live encounter approval. -- iron_coast_3 preserves accepted10310v4/200a3v4/400acv3 plus every failed version. Atlas300a8–abv6 remains held for connected painted side-strip loss and partial source-class coverage.300a0/200ba palette-alpha issues stay root-owned. iron3 now exclusively reviews Sparkle17v8, whose newly reported unchanged10277 center hole requires independent validation. -- iron_coast_6's effects and independent enemy decisions remain bound. Its authored Terrain3 early shards3/4 stay frozen for another reviewer. Children retain original middle5–36 and late37–68 production: large held cohorts have current exact galleries, while physical soil grain, gray/char relief, invented beams/rims and mixed-fallback material concerns remain unapproved. -- campaign_integration preserves admitted Orange9 and earlier complete effects. Separate genuine LargeAir corrections may target only101eb/101ec's exact lost connected structures, retaining the other ten bindings. Flare holes/material, Ground gold/alpha and other contour holds remain explicit; no artist color compensation for loader behavior. -- hd_enemies_01 preserves admitted tanks and singles;300ac/3009d/4006e are frozen for exclusive review,40088 separately unassigned. Multipart IOTARG/DMOON production remains author-only. Damaged craft backing/cues, troop poses and APE refusal remain held. -- hd_dark_player continues the complete23-icon family102e1–102f7; partial single-icon probes are not coverage. HANGP1010b opaque1619x971 remains held by exact-aspect policy pending a separate controlled root decision. No classic-menu route is inferred through current custom Rust menus. -- Terrain1 has112 registered tiles;10400 review,10410 partial production and bridge103d5/6 row/gap/material holds are separate. Terrain2 has48 registered and many complete proposals with post-array/cap/gray machinery, water/ground density and coarse-grid holds. Its202fd–2030c unequal-panel retry stays unbound rather than distorted. Terrain3 has32 registered. Terrain4 has160 registered; later industrial compound/fallback-grain limits remain disclosed. +- hd_full_review completed terrain10400's whole-family hold and fifteen-binding partial proof, then approved SHIP25 separately. It reserves the complete corrected10406 sibling next. It continues original HD review while the other seven reviewers serve Stage2. +- iron_coast_2 closed and checkpointed independently accepted original Set4 jobs1–12/192frames; no further HD review reservation during its Stage2 mission/boss work. Lower40179/7a is now admitted in the target scope, with prior context-only limits preserved. +- iron_coast_5 closed Terrain3 shards3/4: four30112/13/19/1a gray-remnant holds in shard3, all16 accepted shard4. It now serves Stage2; no active HD review reservation. +- windows_persistence closed complete LargeAirv11 approval and STAG0240088 approval. Earlier LargeAirv6/v9, SHIP35 and4006e holds remain exact. Its new Stage2 weapon work is separate from original-catalog HD evidence. +- terrain_capture_fixture closed all16 terrain10410 frames and verified historical job status/count-only lineage against retained per-frame copies. It now serves Stage2 enemy packages; source/class/shader/scene evidence never implies blanket encounter or liveHost approval. +- iron_coast_3 preserves admitted10310v4/200a3v4/400acv3 and every failed variant. Its Sparkle17v8 whole hold is complete; no new HD reservation during Stage2. Atlas300a8–abv6 remains held;300a0/200ba alpha-class policy stays root-owned. +- iron_coast_6 closed the Flare26v8 whole hold, then switched to Stage2. Children continue original middle5–36 and late37–68 HD queues directly under coordinator oversight. Old exact galleries remain pinned; stronger soil/gray/char relief and fallback rectangles remain unapproved. +- campaign_release_review checkpointed first30 complete Set4 families/480 author-reviewed IDs before Stage2 music work. Job31 has full art and technical proof but uninspected contexts/cardinal/live pages; job32 has only five cross-job crater-quarter proposals. No complete32 or later approval is inferred. +- campaign_integration retains admitted effects and frozen LargeAirv11; bounded Flare10258/66 and Sparkle10272–77 genuine siblings are author correction scopes only. Ground gold/alpha, smoke visible-enhancement and other holds remain explicit; no RGB compensation for loader artifacts. +- hd_enemies_01 retains admitted tanks/singles/STAG02. SHIP25 independent approval is pending coordinator admission; multipart IOTARG/DMOON,4006e warm center, damaged craft/cues and APE refusal stay held. Every failed genuine correction remains preserved. +- hd_dark_player continues complete23-icon102e1–102f7 production; partial diagnostics are not coverage. HANGP's opaque encoder rounding remains a separate root policy hold. Classic-menu route claims are not inferred through custom Rust menus. +- Terrain1 has128 registered tiles, Terrain2 has48, Terrain3 has48 and Terrain4 has192. Other completed/partial proposals remain independently held or awaiting exact review. Terrain2's unequal panels/coarse mosaic/foreign rules and Terrain1's bridge row/gap/material issues remain unadmitted. The original catalog remains incomplete. Continue source-driven production and independent review, then perform exact current output continuity, complete family coordinator inspection and registration for each later batch. No later candidate is packaged or admitted merely because it decodes.