Record 1652 original HD development snapshot and held material scopes

docs/hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md

@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
-# HD coordinator checkpoint — 11 October 2026
+# HD coordinator checkpoint — 12 October 2026
 
-The reviewed external development pack contains **1,465 original picture frames in545 complete sequences**. Root has copied the exact **1,148-frame / 421-sequence** handoff into shared Linux/Windows runtime data. Root completed and validated both final Stage2 Linux/Windows archives at this exact snapshot; the previous **800-frame / 340-sequence** archives and `964ba93` assembly are historical. Root owns runtime data, binaries, libraries and archives; coordinator owns external development registration and this metadata. Bundled originals and approved runtime art are tracked under this repository's data/. Working originals, prompts, job candidates and review evidence remain external under ../data/.
+The reviewed external development pack contains **1,652 original picture frames in605 complete sequences**. Root has copied the exact **1,148-frame / 421-sequence** handoff into shared Linux/Windows runtime data. Root completed and validated both final Stage2 Linux/Windows archives at this exact snapshot; the previous **800-frame / 340-sequence** archives and `964ba93` assembly are historical. Root owns runtime data, binaries, libraries and archives; coordinator owns external development registration and this metadata. Bundled originals and approved runtime art are tracked under this repository's data/. Working originals, prompts, job candidates and review evidence remain external under ../data/.
 
 ## Verified development coverage
 
@@ -12,11 +12,11 @@ The reviewed external development pack contains **1,465 original picture frames
 | Player and enemy projectiles | 45 / 51 |
 | Explosions and effects | 219 / 281 |
 | Equipment and pickups | 47 / 47 |
-| Terrain | 624 / 4,535 |
-| Menus, portraits, HUD and other pictures | 66 / 150 |
-| Total | 1,465 / 5,753 |
+| Terrain | 800 / 4,535 |
+| Menus, portraits, HUD and other pictures | 77 / 150 |
+| Total | 1,652 / 5,753 |
 
-All6,449 catalog entries and5,753 pictures were audited with zero HD source/hash/canvas/ID errors. **4,288 pictures still await registration**. The current ledger contains1445 registered,20 render-reachable,2741 candidates,838 in-progress and709 missing pictures. Candidate status establishes neither artistic approval nor a live occurrence. Unused/destroyed targets remain required;303 native AGX delta frames and four bitmap fonts retain separate preservation policies.
+All6,449 catalog entries and5,753 pictures were audited with zero HD source/hash/canvas/ID errors. **4,101 pictures still await registration**. The current ledger contains1632 registered,20 render-reachable,2778 candidates,683 in-progress and640 missing pictures. Candidate status establishes neither artistic approval nor a live occurrence. Unused/destroyed targets remain required;303 native AGX delta frames and four bitmap fonts retain separate preservation policies.
 
 ## Historical Stage2 API 1,148 output proof
 
@@ -115,22 +115,22 @@ Phase35 comprises complete PLATOON2/6, DMOON/7, TARG1G4/11 and TARG2G4/11. All f
 
 ## Durable owners and outstanding holds
 
-Coordinator alone registers external development artwork and refreshes the audit/ledger. Queue offsets change after admission; use durable original job IDs. Artists never approve/register their own artwork. Only coordinator-owned paths are committed here; docs/hd-full-review.md remains reviewer-owned. Root alone assembles tracked runtime and controls loader/alpha/shader/encoder policy.
+All current independent reviews keep the previously frozen multi-set1465 authority: Terrain1/192, Terrain2/80, Terrain3/96 and Set4/256. Ongoing cohorts do not silently upgrade to the new208/112/176/304 admissions.
 
-- hd_full_review closed original Terrain3 jobs5/6: original5 APPROVE16, whole6 held only3014c darker-source pit drift. All96 planned boards and948 declared cases are bound. It now provides WORMDN8 material/animation advice, then exclusively reviews corrected3014c complete16, followed by WORMRITE8 and WORMLEFT8 advice. None of the worm scopes requests admission.
-- iron_coast_3 approved original Terrain3 jobs7/8/32 with full source/context/state review; all32 are now registered in1465. Original9/10 are its next exclusive scope. Authoritative context remains admitted first48; later unregistered neighbors are separately labeled diagnostics.
-- iron_coast_5 approved original Terrain2 jobs4/5/32 with material limits. Coordinator admitted original4 only and wholly held original5 for six planted-green failures; the old peer verdict is preserved. It exclusively reviews original8/9, then rejudges the six job5 source-green locations.
-- windows_persistence closed original Terrain2 jobs6/7: whole6 held for20161/62/63 planted-source green readability/narrowing, original7 APPROVE16, now registered in1465. It reviews original10/11, then the separate complete job6v4 green correction. First48 are authoritative context; every later unregistered tile stays original or auxiliary context only.
-- iron_coast_2 approved original Set4 job13/16 and jobs15/16/32; all48 plus corrected14 are registered in1465. Its next exclusive scope is original17/18. Original14's held main remains preserved; no partial-family registration occurred.
-- iron_coast_6 approved corrected original14 full16, with other15 binding/output identity and the source-ground macroblock repair bound. It now reserves original Terrain3 jobs11/12. Closed Rotor2 material/low-scale holds and its later failed genuine trials remain separate.
-- terrain_capture_fixture approved complete10430 and10440, including10440's eight authentic wrecks and corrected4c flat face; all32 are registered in1465. It exclusively reviews10450, then queued10460 and10470. Foreign intact/wreck partners remain original fallback; no live Host claim.
-- campaign_release_review has completed/frozen original Set4 jobs31–40 and continues the original queue; original41v1 is held for expanded paths/ruin/embers with separate exact-source corrections. The separate401b4 correction and frozen jobs15/16 retain all provenance/history; corrected job14 is now registered in1465 after iron6 and coordinator review.
-- hd_enemies_01 preserves all prepared enemy families and explicit sibling proposals. DSHP19 reserved-edge omissions,30052 connector failures and the APE service refusal remain held. Rotor's connected phase0 backing strip is original opaque artwork, requiring genuine correction rather than coverage statistics alone.
-- hd_dark_player preserves shop23 diagnostic history and its inherited19 bindings. E7/EB/F6 corrections have improved source masks/shading; monitor tips/mounting/left edge remain held. WORMDN eight phases request material/animation advice, not admission. HANGP rounding, FACESTAT/copyright layout and SCREEN fringe remain separate holds.
-- campaign_integration preserves approved Flare/LargeAir/Sparkle input. Ground42 outlined decay grain/gold-to-olive, Person ivory resampling and smoke visible-enhancement issues remain held; no RGB compensation is allowed to stand in for source artwork.
-- Terrain3 middle and late children continue source-locked production under the shared gate. Middle has223 original bound targets/194 original raws through18, including48 registered5/7/8; its separate3014c correction does not add coverage and301ae remains missing/no-retry. Late has416 complete held targets through62, with selected corrections and rejected variants preserved. Coarse/checker grain, brighter remnants and fallback material rectangles remain unapproved.
+- hd_full_review closed corrected3014c approval, three worm advice scopes, Terrain3 original14/15 approvals and two HELP approvals. It closed Set4 original17v4 as whole-held solely401df desaturated earth, then exclusively reviews original22's two well-fleck repairs as a different peer.
+- iron_coast_3 approved Terrain3 original9/10,16/17 and18/19 with detailed material/state limits. It now reviews late originals37/38 using authentic sources, whole raws and864 genuine cases; all other late drafts remain original fallback.
+- iron_coast_5 approved Terrain2 original8/12/14/15, held original9's water/rib materials and original13's coarse201d6 water, and explicitly superseded its prior six-green job5 acceptance with a material hold. It next reserves original16/17.
+- windows_persistence approved original10, the genuine201b8 hardware sibling, continuous-grass job6v5 and complete classic menu8. It held the earlier green checker and smooth2018d pipe repair; it now exclusively reviews job5's six-green complete sibling. Prior45 gallery regeneration changed only mtimes, and that additive incident remains preserved.
+- iron_coast_2 approved complete Set4 originals18–21 and25/26; original17 atlas edges and22 missing interior gray flecks remain held. It next reserves29/30. iron_coast_6 closed the three damaged singles and Set4 original24 approval/23 atlas-top hold; it now reviews27/28.
+- terrain_capture_fixture approved10450/80/90; it preserved historical10460/70 approvals but explicitly clarified fourteen enlarged-cellular material failures. Whole10460/70 are coordinator-held. It now exclusively reviews frozen104a0.
+- campaign_release_review preserves every accepted/held raw and candidate, author-frozen original43 and later correction history. Only401df warm earth,40237 source-absent atlas line and4022d/40230 well cues have separate exact-source correction reservations; no partial-family admission.
+- hd_terrain_set_1 has208 admitted targets. Frozen104a0 is peer-ready; nine10460 and five10470 fine-material corrections use two early plain-ground/fence probes before the remaining targets. Existing source geometry/colors and other bindings stay fixed.
+- hd_terrain_set_2 has112 admitted targets and90 proposal families/1,437 IDs. Grassv5/hardwarev4 independent approvals, pipe-ribv4 and201d6-waterv3 ready siblings, and job5 peer review remain outside1652. Final2069f/a0 green loss stays hard-held; no blind repeat.
+- Terrain3 middle has128 admitted original targets, including the matching-identity corrected6 sibling without extra coverage. Original14–19 independent approvals await coordinator review; original20 is author-held and production continues from21.301ae remains missing/no-retry. Late37–68 proposes506 distinct targets with514 genuine raws and433 gallery pages, all held pending independent judgment; current actual dependency/source pins are complete and historical omissions/retractions stay preserved.
+- hd_dark_player keeps capped worm-material failures, opaque framing/aspect holds and prepared first-source scene plans separate. MKS/SDL opening ownership and the integer-rounded full-opaque aspect policy remain parent decisions. Two HELP approvals await coordinator review; no extra worm/opaque correction is submitted.
+- hd_enemies_01 preserves all rotor/lamp/tab failures and service refusal history. campaign_integration preserves approved Flare/Sparkle/LargeAir and holds Ground42 decay grain, Person ivory resampling and unchanged shaded smoke. No raw-color, mask, crop or renderer compensation stands in for genuine art.
 
-The prior192-frame independent-approval queue is resolved for this batch:176 frames registered in1465 after coordinator inspection and full current continuity; the remaining16 from Terrain2 original5 stay wholly held for six lost planted-green materials. Terrain1 now has192 registered tiles, Terrain2 has80, Terrain3 has96 and Terrain4 has256. Other drafts, exact exclusive reviews and later corrections remain separate; no catalog-complete claim is made.
+The exact registered terrain totals are208/112/176/304,800 overall. The next274 independent approved pictures are outside1652 and require coordinator source/raw/material/current-output review; sixteen original12 targets also have a missing saved-prompt provenance gap requiring parent policy. Their acceptance is not readiness or registration. No catalog-complete or universal seamlessness claim is made.
 
 ## Startup PNG source epoch and current continuity
 
@@ -161,3 +161,16 @@ Terrain2 original5 remains wholly held for20153/54/55/5a/5b/5c green bands. The
 Bookkeeping receipt `26abfbaa34c602652ec648786a21597752372f67526bf050bdca2b498f7d4d34` preserves700 before-refresh metadata files and19 queues. Forty-eight global job.json updates plus one concurrent author claim change only owner/status/count/embedded-review metadata; every source/context/contract is exact. Audit SHA `92478ee534c580ac9d404bcc91641e25a16e170e2f1bb8678d25721c77a8757b` reports1465 registered/4288 remaining/zeroHD errors; ledger SHA `c00f7ba532fe32fa2ecfd22a7898d4f0b2b2be009f5d43279c23ed58412d7175` retains all5753 picture targets and no unused exclusions. The old held Set4 original14 main is a byte-exact SHA-named snapshot before exact accepted sibling promotion; no raw/art/crop changed.
 
 The immutable future input at ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-1465-20261011/pack/ contains1465 frames/545 sequences,534 files/990735382 bytes, all copied to private inodes with exact hashes. Handoff SHA `92cb019a147728e72e966708e0651e094d0a6a2137d8026797bc9be2ea9a1d4d` binds audit/ledger/current proof/source/registration receipts. All6853 packaged bin/lib/data files remain unchanged, before/after inventory SHA `6fc0642c24cae2ba04bab30ab4cd0547d62c965421b1cb49026aa8a48d351653`; runtime remains1148/421 and45 accepted Stage2 mods. No runtime assembly/export or new whole-map/live Host/palette timing/UI-route claim is made. Parent alone coordinates a future runtime snapshot.
+
+
+## Closed1652 outer development registration
+
+Batch1652 registers187 original pictures in15 complete jobs:176 terrain, three damaged-craft singles and eight classic menu words. Approval SHA `fd9bea0bdba0f6d1d7feec5621420834f7f65fa4bb0d26ce76bfb1a5e2610d18` and canonical registration SHA `9d8de971638905c18fb8e11c5b7fae257998ac180691e1e94ae1a4fca8221268` bind every exact candidate, raw, original and independent judgment. Full current comparison SHA `aace2408b3c9d7fe05f4d08b8671f4df6e048f688aa5fed14f020e6e42912128` closes8,260 source/scaled PPMs (6,608 scaled outputs): all7,325 prior1465 outputs and935 new outputs match exactly. Both literal source guards are false, immutable library c0c3 and compiler-compatible Serde ba61 are exact, and all18 recursive source SHA/size/mtime records are stable. Current hd.json SHA `6d07c714205662d65fc16898fb496a43db61bb9e3205b05cec166845fa229443` has605 sequences and every1465 baseline frame binding unchanged. Provenance SHA `7b44e85be8574d327320af13bb141b5d476c2677d54d9aa509d227580e4303be` binds the same actual validation. The104 combined contact pages are hash-bound, not relabeled as freshly viewed.
+
+Coordinator actually reviewed219 proposals with135 full unchanged raw-image views and35 complete source/native1–4 boards;187 selected and32 held. Selected new artwork uses102 distinct raw PNGs. Complete10450 retains four authentic wrecks and selected muted54/5d corrections; Terrain2 originals8/10 retain source compound/coast/water geometry; Terrain3 originals9–12 retain remnants/panels/markers with fine grain/value qualifications. The matching-identity complete3014c correction sibling is registered directly with original15 bindings exact and source-dark pit restored; original held mainf1e1a5b is unchanged. Set4 originals18–20 retain industrial source damage/context identities. Three damaged craft have native source masks and exact reserved light coordinates, with measured darker/lighter gray material and highscale contours disclosed. Menu8 retains source words/gaps/counters/baseline with brighter copper and tiny enumerated dim edges/fringe accepted.
+
+Whole10460/10470 remain unregistered. Additive fixture clarification SHAs `f9ee03e0653f7884ffc8ce8efad0f229e9c7ced6ae5c4fc0b9de130913b8afdc` and `797008b0b4dcbb1d21ee3b1592a68e52d3ea21a6ce70fa1f4f20c5f69745b18e` candidly preserve historical acceptance of enlarged cells and correct overbroad fine-grain wording. Exact fourteen targets10461/63–66/6a–6d and10474/76/77/79/7a require genuine continuous fine material within original source geometry/colors; other seven/eleven siblings stay exact. Geometry/palette numeric passes do not waive material judgment.
+
+Bookkeeping receipt `e807e545bd51dbc379433f571cba466f050e23947b735fd7763c4c6c759d85e8` checks all698 job source/context contracts and preserves720 original/interim metadata files. Thirty-six final payload changes affect derived status/count/owner/review only. A queue refresh accidentally began before audit completion and read old1465; its entire interim state is saved, then one sequential refresh against completed1652 produced1632 registered plus20 reachable,2778 candidates,683 in-progress and640 missing. Byte-identical rewritten job files also changed mtimes, explicitly disclosed to active reviewers. A separate closure assertion mistakenly expected635 sequences; it failed before closure writes and was corrected to605 (the excluded32 targets were standalone sequences). Both exact failed-attempt histories are retained; neither affected art, registration bindings or runtime pixels. Audit SHA `3a90095a51fdfd0748c1ec51cf60c18a42a1812feddc4b243319d4d89b6586c1` reports1652/4101/zero errors; ledger SHA `22b6ee44bee7c7f0392590a0fb4277ee555fec9391d4fbced31b997b3f0b9588` retains all5753 required targets.
+
+Immutable future handoff ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-1652-20261011/pack/ contains1,652 frames/605 sequences,636 files/1263053074 bytes with verified distinct inodes. Handoff SHA `2b89b62f0b673a2fbbff31441307af0fd6bfa9fe89fa33c893a7399acd801556` binds all pack/proof/source/audit/ledger/pending histories. All6,853 packaged bin/lib/data files remain byte-identical, inventory SHA `6fc0642c24cae2ba04bab30ab4cd0547d62c965421b1cb49026aa8a48d351653`; shared runtime remains1,148/421 and45 accepted Stage2 mods. No runtime copy/export, whole-map seam, live Host, palette-time or UI-route proof is inferred. Parent alone coordinates a later runtime snapshot.