{ "actual_game_cleanup_QA_World_render_generation_calls": 0, "actual_readonly_bindings": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ship-10521-water-only-independent-CODE-and-bindings-review-20261019-v1/ACTUAL-READONLY-SOURCE-AND-LINEAGE-BINDINGS.json", "sha256": "765d53cf7781c3c71d65c17ae703adb5905f6f24ac60ebe2577d930762a5874b" }, "author": "/root/targt_full_context", "author_test_rerun": { "elapsed_seconds": 1.262, "errors": 0, "exit_code": 0, "failures": 0, "log": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ship-10521-water-only-independent-CODE-and-bindings-review-20261019-v1/author-tests.stderr", "sha256": "1993958670d3c103605c4f5834623fef16262f6a1c3e4e80a8648ad7bcab9b73" }, "tests": 5 }, "canonical_Git_mutations": 0, "checks": [ "Concrete Source10521PIC/palette bytes match canonical INDEX/PALETTE. True water is everycell of upper16logical rows, ordinary149..159orcycling240..244, and no lowerwater. ScaleNx4/rational724nearest mask is exactly upper362rows.", "Old724RGB is exact pre-held10521mastercrop [0,0,724,724]from2172x724genuine8f890batlas. Exact lower362RGBrows are preserved by source-only ownership assignment; no generated geometry or donor coarsefield is substituted.", "Genuine donor4fa10c1d matches stagedPNG, original untouched master and actual builtin provider savedartifact bytes. Frozen donorcrop0,0,887,887is inbounds; actualrawmetadata/prompts/Originalreference lineage supplied and priorphysicaldonorreview remain separate.", "Independent separableGaussian/convolution oracle matches bounded fineband donor-minusGaussian3,clipplus/minus16,gain.5(maximumRGBresidual8). NormalizedGaussian1waterbase does not bleed lowerdockcoarsecolors into water.", "Independent synthetic full724RGBcomparison proves exact intendedwater output and unchanged lowerhalf; reversing genuine synthetic donor changes onlywater. Constantdonor cannot claim survivingnewHDdetail.", "ProtectedSourcecyclingRGB restoredexact at724rationalmask. Allscale1..4SourceNxprotectedowner union independently recomputed fromtrueSource; metadata must carry that exactunion to finalcandidate.", "Descriptor-walkregularboundedEOFread withnonsymlinkancestors, exactinputSHA, verifiedbufferedmathdependency3284, fixedrecipefield/floatparameters, freshcontainedoutput andpre-writeinputvalidation reviewed. Syntheticrunreceipt recordsactualhelper/input/outputhashes andcorrectderived/notgenerator status." ], "different_from_author": true, "exact_allscale_retained_Source_owner_cells": [ [ 5, 4 ] ], "exact_recipe": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-10521-water-only-quiet-band-remediation-20261019-v1/FROZEN-WATER-ONLY-RECIPE.json", "sha256": "5841dc51a47c2c0490bbf8e8f2ed7ca1c75bc808b94b1e626d07ae11d264c208" }, "findings_requiring_revision": [], "frozen_proposal": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-10521-water-only-quiet-band-remediation-20261019-v1/FROZEN-CODE-RECIPE-BINDINGS-PROPOSAL.json", "sha256": "fcd093cbe23c6e7bd65bc87cc0ef20f1edb0de2fcf10bc516f2469dc54ce5272" }, "helper": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-10521-water-only-quiet-band-remediation-20261019-v1/tools/hd_water_material10521.py", "sha256": "af6e084a626244b25f32ed877353c6f627d1410ad56056623c1280df00be9ec0" }, "independent_test_log": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ship-10521-water-only-independent-CODE-and-bindings-review-20261019-v1/independent-tests.stderr", "sha256": "eced22c2f664b31c0e7f5783d5067262e0eb91d992bbc4fadc012d9e919da62f" }, "independent_test_source": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ship-10521-water-only-independent-CODE-and-bindings-review-20261019-v1/independent_review.py", "sha256": "237de7b5c4543eff2e2201d6777accb25a2dc9e0b66c57e7b5207d69a979e101" }, "independent_tests": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ship-10521-water-only-independent-CODE-and-bindings-review-20261019-v1/INDEPENDENT-6-TESTS-AND-EXACT-ACTUAL-BINDINGS.json", "sha256": "030de387bfadbd1b0dce3ec497999fa1521a0fc9e5681f01ffe3706065565796" }, "inputs_unchanged": true, "reviewed_utc": "2026-10-19T10:02:30.281307+00:00", "reviewer": "/root/ship_portability", "scope_limits": [ "CODEandactualinputbindingqualificationonly, noart/nativepalette/contextapproval. One actualcleanupandfinalG2andfiniteaffectedcontext needseparateexistingRootauthority andsubsequentphysicalreview.", "Nonwaterexactness claim is specifically old724rawRGBrows362..723. Existing HdAssetsLanczosdownsampling may mix values near the water/dockedge; finalnativepixels/Sourceclasssupport/functionalowners andneighborseams must be checked inactualG2/context, not assumed bitidentical fromthisrawclaim.", "Sourcecoarsefield, geometry, protectedcyclingRGB and retainedfunctionalowners receivezeroHDcredit; genuine fineRGBcontribution alone doesnotestablishcleanHDquality.", "Toolmax16MiBinputs/4MpixelPNGdecodeandfixed724outputarebounded. Freshoutputmkdirisnotoverwrite, buthostileconcurrentoutputparentreplacement andOSwritepartialoutput areoutside thisfrozenprivatescope. Helperselfopenreceipt isnot anatomicPythonexecutioncapture; use externalpre/post exacthelperpins.", "Helperdoesnotitselfenforcediskfloor; ownerexecutionwrappermustretainRootcurrentdiskfloorcheck before oneactualrun.", "All frozen source/recipe/input hashes unchanged. Two compactnumeric literal spellings inreviewer-onlytest emitSyntaxWarnings buttestsparsedandexecuted6PASS; nohelper/testproduceredit needed.", "Reviewerperformedonlysyntheticderive/run andreadonlyrealinputdecode/masks. No actualassetcleanup, G2, World, engine/compositor/render, imagegeneration, registrar, canonicalmutation orGitoperation." ], "status": "PASS_DIFFERENT_10521_WATER_ONLY_CODE_AND_EXACT_ACTUAL_BINDINGS", "synthetic_run_calls": 1, "tests": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-10521-water-only-quiet-band-remediation-20261019-v1/tools/test_hd_water_material10521.py", "sha256": "7167c84154a48b1186d95347f47457a4121076658f3e93fea38b5dd2a1009470" } }