{ "status": "QUALIFIED_COMPLETE3_NEW_DERIVED_INTRINSIC_SOURCE_MATERIAL_AND_MEANINGFUL_HD_DETAIL", "reviewer": "/root/hd_enemies_01", "artist_script_author": "/root/hd_full_review", "qualified_ids": [ "20400", "20403", "20406" ], "held_ids": [], "independent_from_author": true, "review_role": "Saved intrinsic art/source/material/functional reading only, no engine or realcontext production.", "conclusion": "Newcoherent fine/middle material structure is visibly retained at2\u20134 while Source broadolive/darkcharcoal/rim geometry and quiet400right remain compatible. This distinct successor resolves the priorv3HDdetail finding within intrinsic scope. Native1 remains quiet and Source-maskmacrosteps persist.", "rows": [ { "asset": "20400", "independent_artistic_verdict": "QUALIFIED_DERIVED_INTRINSIC_SOURCE_MATERIAL_AND_MEANINGFUL_HD_DETAIL", "artifact_role": "NEW_DERIVED_COHERENT_SCRIPT_RETEXTURE_NOT_UNTOUCHED_GENERATOR_RETURN", "whole512_derived_PNG": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280578904106960, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/actual-coherent-DERIVED-frames-v1/20400-DERIVED-source-guided-material-v1.png", "sha256": "ca5479ef35d84d71ad737dcb55c14443f1796cd7cf8a87b8386e29598913022b", "size": 292432 }, "authentic_Source": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1787663959559952080, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.1531", "sha256": "02ee58837e0189c997e6777cb0cd2e9d66babe48a3252209e20ffb57761e2bba", "size": 1044 }, "native_manifest": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280633133732111, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/private-DERIVED-complete3-native32-pack/hd.json", "sha256": "cd747a0631055397b879934012aa7611e1dc7eecad342b596e1cf29f6167540f", "size": 1552 }, "native_sequence": { "name": "DERIVED Source-guided terrain20400", "base_asset": 132096, "frame_count": 1, "frames": [ { "frame": 0, "file": "20400-DERIVED-source-guided-material-v1.png", "logical_width": 32, "logical_height": 32, "origin": [ 0, 0 ], "source_sha256": "02ee58837e0189c997e6777cb0cd2e9d66babe48a3252209e20ffb57761e2bba" } ] }, "comparison_page": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280660729158052, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/whole-Source-parentHOLD-DERIVED-native1to4/20400-WHOLE-Source-parentHOLD-DERIVED-all-native1to4.png", "sha256": "3ce692f8e8f157ecf3a1367ed6406f10b86c54ba4927d1a6f6083d0f0a07c1f7", "size": 125003 }, "actual_scales": [ { "scale": 1, "actual_PPM": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280633401809954, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/actual-once-SourceF-DERIVED3-intrinsic5/20400-hd-1.ppm", "sha256": "c562f17241df197b4aba08f2eaddf5a011a1e404566d0ab2d0472d6442f966a1", "size": 3085 }, "actual_index_sha256": "a8dbeda310dde790bb4b6c4520fc79c50793eb19a55aed698793a15d2704ffcf", "author_counterfactual_coherent_delta_fraction": 0.189453125, "counterfactual_not_reviewers_artistic_pass_criterion": true }, { "scale": 2, "actual_PPM": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280633402809930, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/actual-once-SourceF-DERIVED3-intrinsic5/20400-hd-2.ppm", "sha256": "2978414e297148462ca9f87753784dc2efc290ffc39c1652568134c779b4a925", "size": 12301 }, "actual_index_sha256": "2fc9076c24cd51fd8923979af10d62d395d0ab5789f5da30f5064c643331c529", "author_counterfactual_coherent_delta_fraction": 0.306640625, "counterfactual_not_reviewers_artistic_pass_criterion": true }, { "scale": 3, "actual_PPM": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280633405809859, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/actual-once-SourceF-DERIVED3-intrinsic5/20400-hd-3.ppm", "sha256": "cd7f0d1e6f42ca52e457343c81f79e9b294b7ffc943bee0e446fb7bb58bbd0c6", "size": 27661 }, "actual_index_sha256": "f0bcdd55dea463fb68a034c25bb5d1656ebc9f9ace7ea7b2c8dec5ba8ef7ddc5", "author_counterfactual_coherent_delta_fraction": 0.3719618055555556, "counterfactual_not_reviewers_artistic_pass_criterion": true }, { "scale": 4, "actual_PPM": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280633408809787, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/actual-once-SourceF-DERIVED3-intrinsic5/20400-hd-4.ppm", "sha256": "80556db0fd1bab4f1a3509b9f086b13749bd39efb402f871441a841f28b100a6", "size": 49167 }, "actual_index_sha256": "71b849caa1dde4ba64921afd262a4bfd86f92a655c7f84db7bdf66f998a38c06", "author_counterfactual_coherent_delta_fraction": 0.4180908203125, "counterfactual_not_reviewers_artistic_pass_criterion": true } ], "personal_scope": { "whole512_PNG": true, "wholeSource_parentHOLD_new_native1to4_board": true, "panels": 12, "existing_integer_display_only": true }, "findings": { "source_fidelity": "The broad dark-olive/soil footprint and Source-shaped negative spaces remain recognizable; upper/right soil stays comparatively quiet. No new intrinsic geometry/hue blocker across1\u20134.", "meaningful_HD_detail": "At2\u20134 the mottled soil and olive regions retain coherent fine/middle grain with local modulation instead of the priorv3lowpass blur. Whole512 texture reads as ground material rather than amplified random noise.", "qualification": "Native1 is still quiet/Source-led; stepped Source-mask macroboundaries and low-contrast olive areas persist. This is an explicit Source-guided DERIVED material interpretation." } }, { "asset": "20403", "independent_artistic_verdict": "QUALIFIED_DERIVED_INTRINSIC_SOURCE_MATERIAL_AND_MEANINGFUL_HD_DETAIL", "artifact_role": "NEW_DERIVED_COHERENT_SCRIPT_RETEXTURE_NOT_UNTOUCHED_GENERATOR_RETURN", "whole512_derived_PNG": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280578998104727, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/actual-coherent-DERIVED-frames-v1/20403-DERIVED-source-guided-material-v1.png", "sha256": "33305c62843344adb740610057dd7423bb8f8eeec33460e6eb065fe2614fe835", "size": 255126 }, "authentic_Source": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1787663959560153773, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.1534", "sha256": "d5779389a3fc84f260b27f85fa74b13778f528d5978c8a40e577e6570be5f0ea", "size": 1044 }, "native_manifest": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280633133732111, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/private-DERIVED-complete3-native32-pack/hd.json", "sha256": "cd747a0631055397b879934012aa7611e1dc7eecad342b596e1cf29f6167540f", "size": 1552 }, "native_sequence": { "name": "DERIVED Source-guided terrain20403", "base_asset": 132099, "frame_count": 1, "frames": [ { "frame": 0, "file": "20403-DERIVED-source-guided-material-v1.png", "logical_width": 32, "logical_height": 32, "origin": [ 0, 0 ], "source_sha256": "d5779389a3fc84f260b27f85fa74b13778f528d5978c8a40e577e6570be5f0ea" } ] }, "comparison_page": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280660789156620, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/whole-Source-parentHOLD-DERIVED-native1to4/20403-WHOLE-Source-parentHOLD-DERIVED-all-native1to4.png", "sha256": "a91be5301c885982a8b314378794f97608c48c0d37ee1387691ec4b23a018e39", "size": 117227 }, "actual_scales": [ { "scale": 1, "actual_PPM": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280633410809739, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/actual-once-SourceF-DERIVED3-intrinsic5/20403-hd-1.ppm", "sha256": "12b3499d85a45b872ba4355c517ea87427c6741865ca48aaa6b3a560e34a7106", "size": 3085 }, "actual_index_sha256": "27f54b8781b5f63f9ab6fe0de80a6f14fff47fb24ae11dfb4b59795f937399bf", "author_counterfactual_coherent_delta_fraction": 0.1611328125, "counterfactual_not_reviewers_artistic_pass_criterion": true }, { "scale": 2, "actual_PPM": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280633412809692, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/actual-once-SourceF-DERIVED3-intrinsic5/20403-hd-2.ppm", "sha256": "b7479c993b1ea138a09629b03addb92cf498a7db6e269fd4943440f4fa40cdc7", "size": 12301 }, "actual_index_sha256": "6eb94b70a8770ceceea58ce4d3b18872eeb1e532b86e1bcc24cf97d20db3040a", "author_counterfactual_coherent_delta_fraction": 0.27880859375, "counterfactual_not_reviewers_artistic_pass_criterion": true }, { "scale": 3, "actual_PPM": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280633415809620, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/actual-once-SourceF-DERIVED3-intrinsic5/20403-hd-3.ppm", "sha256": "6665f682bf5ebe0372de980554bf459bd6233a302dda28112d30e5d9bbef45d1", "size": 27661 }, "actual_index_sha256": "d273a26595ed13ee437f1e5407b117b1192757e91a1f7575a14da73acc389840", "author_counterfactual_coherent_delta_fraction": 0.3448350694444444, "counterfactual_not_reviewers_artistic_pass_criterion": true }, { "scale": 4, "actual_PPM": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280633419809525, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/actual-once-SourceF-DERIVED3-intrinsic5/20403-hd-4.ppm", "sha256": "e64422696b829ce5bfe7f4a94030c0de00c343931d81d16903e97f292a4e523a", "size": 49167 }, "actual_index_sha256": "e56b3e6d1924036455f5ddd4d4170ea40831c8fba7b9f03744a0881bb2dfa4ca", "author_counterfactual_coherent_delta_fraction": 0.38787841796875, "counterfactual_not_reviewers_artistic_pass_criterion": true } ], "personal_scope": { "whole512_PNG": true, "wholeSource_parentHOLD_new_native1to4_board": true, "panels": 12, "existing_integer_display_only": true }, "findings": { "source_fidelity": "Dark charcoal left material, straight vertical brown divider and red/olive right field remain Source-compatible. Rim stays restrained rather than becoming a bright textured frame.", "meaningful_HD_detail": "Clustered charcoal/grit detail is visibly present at2\u20134 with a coherent finer/middle stone structure, resolving the priorv3softblock concern while avoiding the heldparent brightgray tone.", "qualification": "Native1 suppresses much fine texture; at3\u20134 the grain is finer and locally pebbled compared with coarseSource shapes. Neighbor material contrast still needs genuine context review." } }, { "asset": "20406", "independent_artistic_verdict": "QUALIFIED_DERIVED_INTRINSIC_SOURCE_MATERIAL_AND_MEANINGFUL_HD_DETAIL", "artifact_role": "NEW_DERIVED_COHERENT_SCRIPT_RETEXTURE_NOT_UNTOUCHED_GENERATOR_RETURN", "whole512_derived_PNG": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280579086102636, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/actual-coherent-DERIVED-frames-v1/20406-DERIVED-source-guided-material-v1.png", "sha256": "56be74b24d34663feaafb3add8f3fd61b9a7083659fdc109badae7eafb9e0e97", "size": 226907 }, "authentic_Source": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1787663959560340339, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.1537", "sha256": "17b3acb33c17ddf7394984a63a60123a1d16ea98e77d68a350886f2f49cd0e78", "size": 1044 }, "native_manifest": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280633133732111, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/private-DERIVED-complete3-native32-pack/hd.json", "sha256": "cd747a0631055397b879934012aa7611e1dc7eecad342b596e1cf29f6167540f", "size": 1552 }, "native_sequence": { "name": "DERIVED Source-guided terrain20406", "base_asset": 132102, "frame_count": 1, "frames": [ { "frame": 0, "file": "20406-DERIVED-source-guided-material-v1.png", "logical_width": 32, "logical_height": 32, "origin": [ 0, 0 ], "source_sha256": "17b3acb33c17ddf7394984a63a60123a1d16ea98e77d68a350886f2f49cd0e78" } ] }, "comparison_page": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280660849155188, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/whole-Source-parentHOLD-DERIVED-native1to4/20406-WHOLE-Source-parentHOLD-DERIVED-all-native1to4.png", "sha256": "88cab4fa964ada5068c904ebd4514ebca5dbc154141ffae0dcbde018e3bc21b7", "size": 99842 }, "actual_scales": [ { "scale": 1, "actual_PPM": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280633420809501, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/actual-once-SourceF-DERIVED3-intrinsic5/20406-hd-1.ppm", "sha256": "0513e7bb46a068a75f8349d890259fdf5783ac3b2853110087158d61efed8e8a", "size": 3085 }, "actual_index_sha256": "cc3d255c02eb4a8b9b839d741409534a6a76806c5e12bf681570eab4315f4c5f", "author_counterfactual_coherent_delta_fraction": 0.1728515625, "counterfactual_not_reviewers_artistic_pass_criterion": true }, { "scale": 2, "actual_PPM": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280633422809454, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/actual-once-SourceF-DERIVED3-intrinsic5/20406-hd-2.ppm", "sha256": "2b2a76af34e2f31e6d24722baecd08de7112a2049b7b793cd70a170dca9947b4", "size": 12301 }, "actual_index_sha256": "408fdd498e6ab172229590dff9e6954f3c89c596a7af17149a6e56bd8b702128", "author_counterfactual_coherent_delta_fraction": 0.28271484375, "counterfactual_not_reviewers_artistic_pass_criterion": true }, { "scale": 3, "actual_PPM": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280633424809406, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/actual-once-SourceF-DERIVED3-intrinsic5/20406-hd-3.ppm", "sha256": "0661d3f9ce34135360eb35f9f06ea0c73e7779855336cf746d524aa12a4a987a", "size": 27661 }, "actual_index_sha256": "b9c126a4b78b220ff7ef0070f118400112ad395f568f2a204a812f6c6b9777bf", "author_counterfactual_coherent_delta_fraction": 0.3603515625, "counterfactual_not_reviewers_artistic_pass_criterion": true }, { "scale": 4, "actual_PPM": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280633427809334, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/actual-once-SourceF-DERIVED3-intrinsic5/20406-hd-4.ppm", "sha256": "0a8b122dabfafea354e96319b128f923979ad3cb8f4a353a605f3e08dd0a376e", "size": 49167 }, "actual_index_sha256": "1b0f1978f279260c405027a194f15b13e6fd59fbcc2cbdd68f1a3e9843f49108", "author_counterfactual_coherent_delta_fraction": 0.417724609375, "counterfactual_not_reviewers_artistic_pass_criterion": true } ], "personal_scope": { "whole512_PNG": true, "wholeSource_parentHOLD_new_native1to4_board": true, "panels": 12, "existing_integer_display_only": true }, "findings": { "source_fidelity": "The L-shaped brown rim/corner and upper-right soil/olive area remain clear against the dark charcoal surround atall1\u20134. No new wholeframe cue or geometry loss seen.", "meaningful_HD_detail": "The charcoal surround now carries coherent clusteredstone/grain across the large lower/left area, giving an observable HDsurface treatment rather than smoothedSource alone.", "qualification": "Source-shaped corner/rim steps remain, native1 is quiet, and finer stone grain differs from the Source coarsefacets. No joined-neighbor or cornercontact claim is made." } } ], "normalized_actual_execution": { "method": "source-broad-material-guidance-coherent-parent-fine-mid-logtexture-v1", "output_sha256": { "20400": "ca5479ef35d84d71ad737dcb55c14443f1796cd7cf8a87b8386e29598913022b", "20403": "33305c62843344adb740610057dd7423bb8f8eeec33460e6eb065fe2614fe835", "20406": "56be74b24d34663feaafb3add8f3fd61b9a7083659fdc109badae7eafb9e0e97" }, "parent_raw_sha256": [ "70a360ff5c148be181ed9d27ed46e29322a7b54a0f48709d290d1666e3ad70d0" ], "recipe_sha256": "c3c2de1351b23ec3b22559306e235bd5e69fee028911bcfe6f56c77c18ddf82f", "source_sha256": { "20400": "02ee58837e0189c997e6777cb0cd2e9d66babe48a3252209e20ffb57761e2bba", "20403": "d5779389a3fc84f260b27f85fa74b13778f528d5978c8a40e577e6570be5f0ea", "20406": "17b3acb33c17ddf7394984a63a60123a1d16ea98e77d68a350886f2f49cd0e78" }, "status": "success", "tool_sha256": "aeddecececca337983c3f487ff59df1e747e42114ee10ca6e5bc03609f22c449" }, "execution_locator": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280579129365461, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/actual-coherent-DERIVED-frames-v1/DERIVED-LINEAGE-AND-ACTUAL-RECONSTRUCTION-METRICS.json", "sha256": "939eb091d24510b3690ed6848ae408d2f84b33fafe67e12a1b25e85af8d02826", "size": 14077 }, "actual_author_and_technical_authorities": { "author_report": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/CLOSED-ACTUAL-DERIVED3-SOURCE-GUIDED-CLEANUP-SOURCEF-AUTHOR-QUALIFIED3-MATERIAL-HANDOFF.json", "sha256": "1efe011b997ae3e9cfbc01b4f22f5b3fae416867970ad8276510f46da07d5b8f", "size": 80859, "mtime_ns": 1792280769222560994, "mode": 33188, "inode": 5537020 }, "author_strict": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018-strict-actual-DERIVED3-author-output-lineage-and-QA-closure.json", "sha256": "08044536957aacaad1ed58a9f8f09ee544653ce0bfac2b84f1ebab6fa45c79e7", "size": 45554, "mtime_ns": 1792280769591552139, "mode": 33188, "inode": 5537021 }, "interface": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/COMPLETE-DERIVED3-WHOLE-NATIVE-AND-FILEONLY-JOIN-RISK-PHYSICAL-INTERFACE.json", "sha256": "a708feb82ff31b5c7adeea097c1183a4948492ed58e6cedf1e1841bec4769980", "size": 58856, "mtime_ns": 1792280661261145352, "mode": 33188, "inode": 5536863 }, "actual_QA": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280633428809311, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/actual-once-SourceF-DERIVED3-intrinsic5/runtime-qa.json", "sha256": "9e12709f3ae9ec13552a79ad4a75923dc4c9a264641157bea847167f0956b1df", "size": 10308 }, "actual_index": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280633433809191, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/actual-once-SourceF-DERIVED3-intrinsic5/actual-indexed-source-and-scales.json", "sha256": "9cd5225d06a2f2b161f5e834334bbbf077a3cf65109ddc38f6ceb6b618ce31e4", "size": 1371220 }, "native_pack": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280633133732111, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/private-DERIVED-complete3-native32-pack/hd.json", "sha256": "cd747a0631055397b879934012aa7611e1dc7eecad342b596e1cf29f6167540f", "size": 1552 }, "epoch": "SourceF38459e0067b17801b3c3c629c22e05dfee98928d451d8c8e0971b63c17288b52/helpera90704f5cba83f7556a8066522097607fcbee816b4e870b2d2284af774c7b790", "private_recipe": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280578036189172, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/ACTUAL-COHERENT-MATERIAL-RETEXTURE-RECIPE-V1.json", "sha256": "c3c2de1351b23ec3b22559306e235bd5e69fee028911bcfe6f56c77c18ddf82f", "size": 6664 }, "private_tool": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792280577870542208, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-full20400-20403-20406-coherent-material-retexture-author-20261018/hd_terrain_cleanup_coherent_retexture.py", "sha256": "aeddecececca337983c3f487ff59df1e747e42114ee10ca6e5bc03609f22c449", "size": 15794 } }, "physical_scope": "Personally read3whole824x1240boards36Source/heldparent/new1\u20134panels and3whole512newPNGs. No edited/cropped/newimages.", "decision_basis": "Visible coherent stone/soil/olive material structure and Source fidelity, not changed-pixel or41percentcounterfactual metric. Author technical counters cited without rerunning their kernel.", "preserved_prior_v3_HOLD": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-enemies20400-20403-20406-DERIVED-v3-independent-artistic-review-20261018/INDEPENDENT-DERIVED3-V3-SOURCE-MATERIAL-COMPATIBILITY-AND-HD-DETAIL-HOLD.json", "sha256": "a2acb8b26cf58cb2901c533bbb1158b78d817e2141154d2bb7583a9b7797fa56", "size": 27412, "mtime_ns": 1792280493686612089, "mode": 33188, "inode": 5536630 }, "scope_limits": [ "The priorv3a2acHOLD remains true for its exactoldPNGs; this positive decision binds only newca5479ef/33305c62/56be74b2 and exactnewlineage939eb091.", "Finer/locally pebbled grain, Source-shaped macroboundaries/steps, lowcontrastolive and native1softness are explicit qualifications.", "File-only riskpreviews are not actualTerrainHd joins and were not used as contextapproval. Genuine Source-context/material contacts remain a separate pending gate.", "No World, engine/helper/QA/compiler/image/sharedSource/data/canonical/Git/docs operation by reviewer.", "No admission or finalsidecar/canonical approval is inferred; the normalizedexecution field above copies this frozen private authorlineage, and any future byteidentical checked-in tool locator is additive only." ], "custody": "Author61owned/59named frozen/no pendingwriter/call/lease directACK bound. All consumed Source/raw/newPNG/header/default/QA/scale/lineage refs exactbeforeafter; ownreviewmetadata frozen/no pendingoperation." }