{ "status": "QUALIFIED_THREE_COMPLETE_FAMILIES_FIVE_FRAMES_HOLD0_INTRINSIC_ONLY", "reviewer": "/root/iron_coast_6", "author": "/root/hd_boss200a2", "author_report": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-next3-enemy-families5-derived-SourceF-20261018/FROZEN-AUTHOR-QUALIFIED-THREE-COMPLETE-ENEMY-FAMILIES-FIVE-DERIVED-FRAMES-SOURCEF.json", "sha256": "a356de0e41a83f4a10970dc101a854cc0ff4e16ebade647f639304315084c025", "size": 37837, "mtime_ns": 1792283097247667970, "mode": 33188 }, "author_strict": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-next3-enemy-families5-derived-SourceF-20261018-strict-frozen-whole-author-closure.json", "sha256": "4f5be1cf91437f9ecc4a959c1ac879c203776b0595e53c5506aed693935a8ab6", "size": 67618, "mtime_ns": 1792283097289621169, "mode": 33188 }, "interface": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-boss-next3-enemy-families5-derived-SourceF-20261018/DIFFERENT-PEER-COMPLETE3-FIVE-FRAME-WHOLE-MATERIAL-INTERFACE.json", "sha256": "d4406ee826cc64c28231711c19364daa09037beca6493179248cc13692346c1a", "size": 22060, "mtime_ns": 1792283097248247065, "mode": 33188 }, "qualified_frames": 5, "held_frames": 0, "per_family": [ { "family": "enemies-200bf-200bf", "assets": [ "200bf" ], "qualified": 1, "held": 0, "decision": "QUALIFIED_COMPLETE_INTRINSIC_MATERIAL_WITH_LIMITS" }, { "family": "enemies-10315-10316", "assets": [ "10315", "10316" ], "qualified": 2, "held": 0, "decision": "QUALIFIED_COMPLETE_INTRINSIC_MATERIAL_WITH_LIMITS" }, { "family": "enemies-1033e-1033f", "assets": [ "1033e", "1033f" ], "qualified": 2, "held": 0, "decision": "QUALIFIED_COMPLETE_INTRINSIC_MATERIAL_WITH_LIMITS" } ], "per_frame": [ { "asset": "200bf", "decision": "QUALIFIED_INTRINSIC_MATERIAL_WITH_LIMITS", "finding": "Generated beveled panels, turquoise circular trim, worn central metal and small hardware add clear continuous form at3/4. The six-wide lower dark shaft is connected and flat in the selected output, unlike the projecting/tapered held silhouette; left-green/right-red navigation samples remain visible. Native1 is soft and the shaft has subtle wear/edge light at larger scales, a qualification rather than a missing-footprint blocker." }, { "asset": "10315", "decision": "QUALIFIED_INTRINSIC_MATERIAL_WITH_LIMITS", "finding": "Continuous silver/turquoise hull plates, inset vent and central round hardware visibly exceed the coarse Original at3/4. The full trailing cyan arcs/streaks return in Source-like placement, while hull/pointed bow retain the phase shape. Bright silver edges/regular plating are an interpretation and the trails intentionally retain coarse Source steps." }, { "asset": "10316", "decision": "QUALIFIED_INTRINSIC_MATERIAL_WITH_LIMITS", "finding": "Second pose retains its distinct trailing streak pattern and Source phase boundary while preserving the same hull construction. Higher-scale bevels and vent/grille detail remain continuous; no gross body jump or new silhouette collapse is seen against the other pose. Native1 is softer/brighter than Original." }, { "asset": "1033e", "decision": "QUALIFIED_INTRINSIC_MATERIAL_WITH_LIMITS", "finding": "Rounded red lens, recessed dark vent, small screws and copper/steel bevels provide meaningful generated form at3/4. Source-like outer-ring placement is preserved and the Source-empty leftmost column stays clear. More regular circular cavities and brighter copper/metal are a sculpted material interpretation." }, { "asset": "1033f", "decision": "QUALIFIED_INTRINSIC_MATERIAL_WITH_LIMITS", "finding": "The complete2 phase changes at the outer ring remain visible without a moving stripe entering the empty left column. Continuous lens/housing finish remains consistent with1033e; the stepped perimeter and native1 soft highlight are visible limits. The dark lower vent is more regular/round than the low-resolution Original shading." } ], "main_finding": "All three families have visible high-resolution form beyond nearest-Original plus grain: generated mechanical panel/hardware relief on200bf, continuous hull/bevel/vent detail onSHIP20G1, and modeled circular lens/vent/copper housing onSHIP37G1. Source-like outlines, trails/phase functions and functional markers remain recognizable in all4 native displays. Positive judgement is whole-body artistic comparison, not passing alpha metrics.", "qualifications": [ "Brighter silver/copper edges, more regular round cavities and refined plating interpret low-resolution Original materials; no exact RGB/art identity claim.", "Native1 merges fine hardware/highlights and is softer than nearest Original. SHIP20 cyan trails and all outer alpha contours keep deliberately stepped Source logical boundaries.", "Derived masks equal SourceNN occupancy at all4; OriginalScaleNx mirror rounds some corners differently. SourceNx is not mislabeled nearest or actual newly executed engine output.", "200bf explicitly rebuilds18 Source-gray shaft cells using declared generated donor detail and Original material support; missing Source-supported regions/trails elsewhere are declared gap fill. These are scripted DERIVED edits of old successful parents, not untouched new generations.", "Two-frame intrinsic phase comparisons do not establish timing, draw order, shadows, caller context, damage/gameplay behavior or genuine scene compatibility.", "Old parent/raw HOLDs and the two initial SHIP37 observed-bounds derivations remain unchanged. Only selected final fullcanvas-v2 SHIP37 outputs are qualified." ], "personal_journal": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-iron6-three-Boss-derived-families-five-SourceF-independent-material-review-20261018/PERSONAL-THREE-COMPLETE-FAMILIES-ALL20-NATIVE-WHOLE-MATERIAL-AND-PHASE-JOURNAL.json", "sha256": "7d065ad5b5065a8e1d73846008110e2a29a7900c065c0f3719678446fbec3512", "size": 3419, "mtime_ns": 1792283316856556901, "mode": 33188 }, "saved_body_authentication": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-iron6-three-Boss-derived-families-five-SourceF-independent-material-review-20261018/INDEPENDENT-SAVED5-SOURCE-INDEX-RGB-ALPHA-RESERVED-60-NATIVE-AND12-WHOLE-BOARD-AUTHENTICATION.json", "sha256": "10077ad87fbc9564eed25c2a665ad901da254af4c0a9b13eca6336cfdc900bdc", "size": 82682, "mtime_ns": 1792283316856220954, "mode": 33188 }, "code_scope": "No cleanup-tool code approval or deterministic-reproduction claim from this material reviewer.", "custody": "Root relayed actual frozen200/23 author handoff and no-pending custody after Boss canonical live task was unavailable. Only metadata was read before that seal. All own notes and consumed inputs remain frozen/no pending writer/call/lease.", "actual_operations": { "engine_helper_QA": 0, "compiler": 0, "World": 0, "imagegen": 0, "image_editing_or_cleanup": 0, "shared_Source_data_docs_Git_registrar_writes": 0 }, "limits": "Intrinsic complete1+complete2+complete2 only; no admission/context/art-history blanket reversal." }