{ "status": "QUALIFIED3050A_HOLD_OTHER7_COMPLETE8_INTRINSIC_REVIEW", "reviewer": "/root/iron_coast_6", "artist": "/root/hd_terrain_set_1", "author_report": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792291910914642095, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain1-next304fd-3050c-Original8-continuous-material-author-20261018-v1/CLOSED-ACTUAL-ONE-ORIGINAL8-ATLAS-SOURCEF-F8-AUTHOR-ONE-PROPOSAL-SEVEN-HOLDS.json", "sha256": "b2b7e1ca690551978c8f430bc55ff6f7a3a9a8d391b0964da2ca506786131554", "size": 9565 }, "author_strict": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain1-next304fd-3050c-Original8-continuous-material-author-20261018-v1-strict-complete-actual-Original8-atlas-and-SourceF-author-disposition-closure.json", "sha256": "6822b4d75a96326d3b41c952b9575c50bd23a5240ce53ee43969b7946dd29198", "size": 34604, "mtime_ns": 1792291910945869707, "mode": 33188 }, "interface": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792291631387843573, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain1-next304fd-3050c-Original8-continuous-material-author-20261018-v1/ACTUAL-ORIGINAL8-SOURCEF-F8-WHOLE-RAW-NATIVE-PALETTE-PAGE-INTERFACE.json", "sha256": "c54246f40ab326e95c976eded489a39108b6b7d173d50ca5b501904ba419c822", "size": 62283 }, "raw": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792291500849290303, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain1-next304fd-3050c-Original8-continuous-material-author-20261018-v1/ATLAS-ORIGINAL8-RETURNED-UNTOUCHED.png", "sha256": "afc05e2453c5c2e91e64607a82defdef8696f5af4113bdae306fd12b07fe454c", "size": 3415009 }, "native_pack": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792291541368912805, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain1-next304fd-3050c-Original8-continuous-material-author-20261018-v1/private-actualRaw8-complete1-rational-atlas-default-pack/hd.json", "sha256": "fa5ecb6b929d72e37cba054eed41a8737e9220f2b09ffa2b4ffb9f3ba979d2d9", "size": 5137 }, "actual_intrinsic": { "mode": 33188, "mtime_ns": 1792291910430158329, "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain1-next304fd-3050c-Original8-continuous-material-author-20261018-v1/ACTUAL-SOURCEF-F8-SCALAR-INVOCATION-AND-EPOCH-NOT-ART-APPROVAL.json", "sha256": "f633dc6c43d44524789760182103678d1f91e76a511645f35d13f79d8a9cd3f4", "size": 2898 }, "qualified_assets": [ "3050a" ], "held_assets": [ "304fd", "30503", "30504", "30506", "30508", "3050b", "3050c" ], "decisions": [ { "asset": "304fd", "decision": "HOLD", "finding": "The pale fork/tip projects farther up-left and the trailing pale shard descends farther than the Source shape. The gray/green material also becomes a gritty bright fringe. The material texture is real, but it does not excuse the visible pale-geometry displacement." }, { "asset": "30503", "decision": "HOLD", "finding": "The Source has a broad dark-green field around the central brown cavity. Native1 turns much of that field into gray/brown dark rubble; thin bright green threads at3/4 do not retain the same broad green material readability. Brown/root relief is also substantially stronger." }, { "asset": "30504", "decision": "HOLD", "finding": "The right-side brown branching center is retained, but its surrounding dark-green bands turn nearblack/olive-brown at native1. Higher scales show fine green threads while the Source broad green connections remain visually reduced; still a material-role mismatch." }, { "asset": "30506", "decision": "HOLD", "finding": "The Source upper-left and lower green surround is readable as a broad dark-green area. In the new native1 it becomes mostly brown/black around pronounced brown root-like relief, with sparse brighter green filaments higher up. New detail does not preserve the green ground role." }, { "asset": "30508", "decision": "HOLD", "finding": "The small upper-right green corner/contact collapses to dull olive-gray fragments at native1 amid brighter gray chips. The jagged black center remains recognizable and actual3/4 material is detailed, but the Source green corner readability is not retained across all scales." }, { "asset": "3050a", "decision": "QUALIFIED_WITH_LIMITS", "finding": "The upper-left green contact remains plainly readable at native1 and higher scales, and the jagged gray/black floor layout remains recognizable. Actual3/4 show continuous chipped mineral structure and fine grit beyond SourceNN/noise-only finish. Brighter/harder gray exposure, stronger incised relief and native1 softness remain qualifications; genuine neighboring joins/context are still unreviewed." }, { "asset": "3050b", "decision": "HOLD", "finding": "The Source upper-right dark-green patch is broad enough to identify, but the new native1 leaves a gray/brown sliver and nearblack texture in that corner. Higher-scale scattered green specks do not restore the Source material field; the diagonal dark-floor striation is a stronger local interpretation." }, { "asset": "3050c", "decision": "HOLD", "finding": "The Source broad upper green field and gray contacts become an olive-brown/char center at native1 with disconnected bright moss threads at3/4. The gray fragments are more exposed, but the broad green material reading and proportions are materially shifted." } ], "technical_authentication": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-iron6-next304fd-3050c-new-Original8-SourceF-independent-material-review-20261018/INDEPENDENT-EXACT8-SOURCE-FROZEN-EPOCH-40PPM-80-PANE-AUTHENTICATION.json", "sha256": "31f5c233f03d2ae741041cd639b5c4ee15efde0af5a34c4358dcf2c6a641f795", "size": 4523, "mtime_ns": 1792292383841657586, "mode": 33188 }, "personal_journal": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-iron6-next304fd-3050c-new-Original8-SourceF-independent-material-review-20261018/PERSONAL-ALL8-WHOLE-RAW-SOURCE-32-NATIVE-AND-NN-DIAGNOSTIC-DECISIONS.json", "sha256": "2194f201e9a09a056c50293dc2cd72054508027bc1a299eb274265a1b47503f2", "size": 12048, "mtime_ns": 1792292383841940790, "mode": 33188 }, "qualifications": [ "Genuine continuous mineral/brown branching material is visible at native3/4 throughout; technical/artistic material existence does not repair displaced pale geometry or lost green roles.", "3050a qualifies with stronger chipped/exposed gray relief, fine-grit contrast, native1 softness and local green brightness interpretation. It requires its own genuine context and Source-role review before any admission.", "All old V2 holds and unexecuted source-guided proposals remain literal. No first-ever-work claim or whole8 family approval.", "Eight independent static terrain pictures are not an animated family;30504 catalogue-only/no fabricated Original placement.", "Actual SourceF F8 technical PASS and ordinary opaque masks are distinct from the per-frame artistic decisions. No live HD/docs/runtime/source freshness remeasurement during Root publication." ], "custody": "Root relayed actual85-file strict closure/author no_pending record. T1 direct standing custody was requested. All frozen owner and consumed input fullpins are checked unchanged through closure; no pending operation owned by this reviewer.", "actual_operations": { "engine_helper_QA": 0, "compiler": 0, "World": 0, "image_generation_or_cleanup": 0, "shared_Source_HD_data_docs_runtime_Git_registrar_writes": 0 } }