{ "status": "INDEPENDENT_QUALIFIED_COMPLETE3_INTRINSIC_MATERIAL_HOLD0_NO_CONTEXT_OR_ADMISSION", "reviewer": "/root/iron_coast_6", "derived_editor": "/root/hd_dark_player", "generated_parent_artist": "/root/hd_enemies_02", "author_report": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-dark-DSHP20G3-complete3-derived-RGB-geometry-cleanup-SourceF-20261018-v1/CLOSED-AUTHOR-QUALIFIED-COMPLETE3-DSHP20G3-DERIVED-RGB-GEOMETRY-CLEANUP-ACTUAL-SOURCEF-NOT-ADMISSION.json", "sha256": "dea900bbb4db8aaa238f4636ec15cf8668f12ccdc7508b819f5b978d72245c26", "size": 12161, "mtime_ns": 1792281062386549998, "mode": 33188 }, "author_strict": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-dark-DSHP20G3-complete3-derived-RGB-geometry-cleanup-SourceF-20261018-v1-strict-complete3-derived-author-SourceF-input-output-closure.json", "sha256": "899c59700a9f6359c09ac14e1c1e97dd61a85e4c721f79e57982a5fb0fc85252", "size": 28834, "mtime_ns": 1792281062417575785, "mode": 33188 }, "peer_interface": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-dark-DSHP20G3-complete3-derived-RGB-geometry-cleanup-SourceF-20261018-v1/COMPLETE3-DERIVED-RAW-SOURCE-OLD-HOLD-ACTUAL1TO4-AND-ANIMATION-PEER-INTERFACE.json", "sha256": "b00d9f015232420e9101c9d6ecc3e74965978a4f024866835ad340edb878d2f2", "size": 22165, "mtime_ns": 1792281061948034959, "mode": 33188 }, "derived_recipe": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-dark-DSHP20G3-complete3-derived-RGB-geometry-cleanup-SourceF-20261018-v1/DSHP20G3-EXPLICIT-DERIVED-RGB-GEOMETRY-CLEANUP-RECIPE-v2.json", "sha256": "6ad7073db0d01c213d71cc1b0c15ef663aa79b714a16074c024bea0bffc4b3d7", "size": 2780, "mtime_ns": 1792280609296359812, "mode": 33188 }, "derived_execution": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-dark-DSHP20G3-complete3-derived-RGB-geometry-cleanup-SourceF-20261018-v1/derived-complete3-coherent-dynamic-regions-v2/normalized-execution.json", "sha256": "280133a7df36155d33e5999ba361b4a8a3172ae73ca840e7e88bfe16c4e86c9a", "size": 922, "mtime_ns": 1792280610149001945, "mode": 33188 }, "actual_SourceF_binding": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-dark-DSHP20G3-complete3-derived-RGB-geometry-cleanup-SourceF-20261018-v1/ACTUAL-MEASURED-SOURCEF-DERIVED-COMPLETE3-QA-EPOCH-AND-FRAME-BINDING.json", "sha256": "cc89e8475adda94ae4b65d92b39d53677443497c43e02e0ca1efba064d085e61", "size": 4463, "mtime_ns": 1792280685591008762, "mode": 33188 }, "complete_family": true, "assets": [ "300a5", "300a6", "300a7" ], "qualified_frames": 3, "held_frames": 0, "per_frame": [ { "asset": "300a5", "decision": "QUALIFIED_INTRINSIC_WHOLE1TO4_MATERIAL_WITH_LIMITS", "finding": "Closed upper cap and dark center plate remain clear. Crisp panel seams, small vent slots, fine bevel/light edges and differentiated shading form continuous mechanical surfaces at3/4. Source-shaped upper prongs and thin lower fingers/notches are restored; brighter lower-chassis panels are deliberate material interpretation, not a new geometry blocker." }, { "asset": "300a6", "decision": "QUALIFIED_INTRINSIC_WHOLE1TO4_MATERIAL_WITH_LIMITS", "finding": "The recessed cap and orange vent rows form a coherent middle phase. Generated vent housings and lower pod surfaces remain continuous without the earlier coarse panel mosaic. Shared chassis is visually steady; softness at1 and limited boundary-color changes remain explicit." }, { "asset": "300a7", "decision": "QUALIFIED_INTRINSIC_WHOLE1TO4_MATERIAL_WITH_LIMITS", "finding": "Round open cap and hollow side ports read distinctly in the final phase, with the same correctly anchored nav lights and underlying chassis. Fine panel/beam relief survives the geometry correction and provides visible HD detail; no new broad clipping, detached part or bulk body displacement is apparent at1\u20134." } ], "main_artistic_finding": "The derived correction preserves coherent generated mechanical RGB forms: panel seams, vents, beam/pod shading, bevels and relief remain visible at native3/4 while Source-shaped silhouette and phase layout are restored. This is a meaningful HD material upgrade beyond merely magnifying Source blocks and adding fine noise. The positive judgement comes from complete-body visual comparison, not mask equality or detail-count metrics.", "whole_family_fidelity": "All three closed/recessed/round cap states, orange vent progression, side-port changes, lower fingers/notches, source-thin support and red/green nav cues remain readable at1\u20134. The old off-cell viewport clipping and expanded bottom outline are corrected in the new explicitly derived canvases; the old raw and its HOLD are not retroactively repaired.", "qualifications": [ "Generated metal has brighter white panels, sharper edges and stronger three-dimensional relief/beam shading than the dim Original. This remains part of the qualified intrinsic interpretation.", "Native1 is softer, but main feature readability is retained; not an assertion of pixel-equal Original material.", "Native3 differs from true SourceScale3 at tiny corners:27/32,33/39,31/36 missing/extra; no broad broken/detached body or missing functional cue was seen.", "Stationary comparison outside changing-part envelopes has small nonzero lower-scale palette differences; no perfect all-scale static pixel identity or zero-flicker claim. Native4 in that named region is exact across phases.", "Only96 functional SourceRGB raw samples are explicitly retained; the artifact is labeled scripted-derived. This is not untouched generator output, a SourceNN reconstruction, or an approval of the cleanup code implementation." ], "saved_authentication": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-iron6-DSHP20G3-derived-RGB-complete3-independent-material-review-20261018/BOUNDED-SAVED-SOURCE-NX-RAW-ALPHA-FUNCTIONAL-LABELS-P6-36-PANE-AND-PHASE-AUTHENTICATION.json", "sha256": "d641b6829698295b4960645fc8c1ac534ecfa38fd608f5a81aa04171dacb5e1a", "size": 11538, "mtime_ns": 1792281328678735457, "mode": 33188 }, "personal_journal": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-iron6-DSHP20G3-derived-RGB-complete3-independent-material-review-20261018/PERSONAL-ALL4-WHOLE-ORDERED-PAGES-FINAL3-RAW-AND-COMPLETE12-NATIVE-MATERIAL-JOURNAL.json", "sha256": "89ddb9f40ae6c84347390dd4e5e6f166da1179ed38f641f0e639237b70d10e1e", "size": 6118, "mtime_ns": 1792281328678959135, "mode": 33188 }, "no_context_or_admission": "Only complete3 intrinsic material and ordered static phase comparison are qualified. Genuine context, Host animation timing/reachability and canonical admission remain separate Root/coordinator work. No frame may claim these from this report.", "history": "Original3ab3 rational output, E02d95e3da9/28cd9828 and my oldE58f80f65/bebdd037 HOLD3 remain unchanged. Dark preliminary v1 mosaic HOLD and actual preflight/synthetic stops stay preserved. OldSourceE epoch not relabeled to SourceFcfabd/a907.", "scope_and_roles": "I6 is different from derived editorDark and original imageartistE02. No renderer/helper/World/compiler/image action, cleanup or shared source/data/registrar/docs/Git write; no code review verdict.", "direct_custody": "Dark direct ACK confirms all66 new files/34actual inputs plus oldE0214/I640 corpora unchanged/no pending operations. Live Source boundary was released after the actual QA; this peer consumes frozen SourceF snapshot/outputs, not a demand for oldlive Source age.", "peer_reader_history": "Preserved initial reviewer-only extra-halo assertion stop; declared rectangles already include1nativehalo, so their direct extents reproduce4049logical samples. No producer/art/QA change or hidden delta exclusion.", "standing_no_mutation": "Own notes plus all actual consumed source/raw/default/candidate/currentSourceF bank/old controls/whole pages/history remain frozen, no pending owned writer/call/lease." }