{ "reviewed_ns": 1792315424864365883, "reviewer": "/root/ridge_pair", "Source_inputs": [ "Both complete authentic NN512 Original tiles", "Complete first1254x1254 held atlas, especially row2cells3and4", "Complete exact Original-only1024x512 reference sheet" ], "new_raw": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ridgepair-20363-20364-Original-primary-author-20261018-v1/ATLAS-ORIGINAL-PRIMARY-PAIR-RETURNED-UNTOUCHED.png", "sha256": "8c261e3e317bb4e2a268175aa6cc1ddd79e33c35ec3d90e8b1aff0de7293ce5f", "size": 2955687, "mtime_ns": 1792315322547254474 }, "physical_pages": [ { "file": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ridgepair-20363-20364-Original-primary-author-20261018-v1/file-only-whole-native-review-pages/20363-whole-Original-and-actual-all1to4.png", "sha256": "313a30233f3c88a29967ea0e253e436c14adb0153dc5c9d6e924268142e59530", "size": 48711, "mtime_ns": 1792315379151251008 }, "whole_bodies": 5, "native1to4_all_actual_saved": true, "toprow_NN128_display_only": true, "bottomrow_unresampled_saved": true }, { "file": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ridgepair-20363-20364-Original-primary-author-20261018-v1/file-only-whole-native-review-pages/20364-whole-Original-and-actual-all1to4.png", "sha256": "a10d071da60e55335e36967f38b2253364336e044ffe5945f9a812863046bb93", "size": 51209, "mtime_ns": 1792315379171251007 }, "whole_bodies": 5, "native1to4_all_actual_saved": true, "toprow_NN128_display_only": true, "bottomrow_unresampled_saved": true } ], "assets": [ { "asset": "20363", "decision": "QUALIFIED_INTRINSIC_WITH_LIMITS", "finding": "Dark charcoal horizontal corrugations extend continuously across the tile, with fine genuine wear and irregular smudges; held short black vertical brick joints are absent. Complete Source square and dark left/bottom contacts remain recognizable; stronger bevel/highlight qualification retained." }, { "asset": "20364", "decision": "QUALIFIED_INTRINSIC_WITH_LIMITS", "finding": "Paler neutral gray counterpart remains distinctly brighter through all four actual native scales. Continuous fine horizontal ribs and coherent shallow wear replace held segmented plates; no new discrete structural element. Stronger metallic relief and native1 smoothing qualified." } ], "metrics": [ { "asset": "20363", "source": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.1374", "sha256": "1562a0cd7c634e475b969676e47b6e01635d0a98fe9902bbc92dd061eca8c562", "size": 1044, "mtime_ns": 1787663959550573359 }, "source_png": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-2035d-2036c/sources/20363.png", "sha256": "c87dd93a0b932839c1adeae619afc62079b1147ab30d1a74839d9b3424fc7cec", "size": 985, "mtime_ns": 1791704276773441963 }, "native": [ { "role": "original", "file": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ridgepair-20363-20364-Original-primary-author-20261018-v1/actual-once-SourceF-complete2-intrinsic5/20363-original.ppm", "sha256": "1690625faaeee2fb3683bd2df5a0b178b92e993a9ecb966941ad33b6944faab1", "size": 3085, "mtime_ns": 1792315362717252014 }, "dimensions": [ 32, 32 ], "mean_luma": 76.07178203125 }, { "role": "hd-1", "file": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ridgepair-20363-20364-Original-primary-author-20261018-v1/actual-once-SourceF-complete2-intrinsic5/20363-hd-1.ppm", "sha256": "0cff5f38ddae77f3cb325bb6e4ecdf27aeea7df02d374aebb6e4a90a84fdab71", "size": 3085, "mtime_ns": 1792315362718252014 }, "dimensions": [ 32, 32 ], "mean_luma": 71.80368828125 }, { "role": "hd-2", "file": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ridgepair-20363-20364-Original-primary-author-20261018-v1/actual-once-SourceF-complete2-intrinsic5/20363-hd-2.ppm", "sha256": "fa492504e887bc322fb245ec31fae47247fd14112de9e7ee730bc4fc4b943386", "size": 12301, "mtime_ns": 1792315362719252014 }, "dimensions": [ 64, 64 ], "mean_luma": 71.714240625 }, { "role": "hd-3", "file": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ridgepair-20363-20364-Original-primary-author-20261018-v1/actual-once-SourceF-complete2-intrinsic5/20363-hd-3.ppm", "sha256": "307d311cff3028156c68933c0fead09de9a619fd62707917a7b2b11c5b3f630a", "size": 27661, "mtime_ns": 1792315362721252014 }, "dimensions": [ 96, 96 ], "mean_luma": 71.74786877170139 }, { "role": "hd-4", "file": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ridgepair-20363-20364-Original-primary-author-20261018-v1/actual-once-SourceF-complete2-intrinsic5/20363-hd-4.ppm", "sha256": "dba45bc524285fd6c92af0022ceab978203bd924bcb093b7a74300adba307e92", "size": 49167, "mtime_ns": 1792315362724252014 }, "dimensions": [ 128, 128 ], "mean_luma": 71.76506939697265 } ] }, { "asset": "20364", "source": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/misc/unnamed.1375", "sha256": "a27ba631b4579c8f58fd2e9ccc501126042c03dc904820fac47e1cde6d364d91", "size": 1044, "mtime_ns": 1787663959550626979 }, "source_png": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/data/hd/jobs/terrain-2035d-2036c/sources/20364.png", "sha256": "befd51c11856811ed50cf32d8e31325b253cd12f2e4565e72c5739016583cada", "size": 1037, "mtime_ns": 1791704276774459300 }, "native": [ { "role": "original", "file": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ridgepair-20363-20364-Original-primary-author-20261018-v1/actual-once-SourceF-complete2-intrinsic5/20364-original.ppm", "sha256": "163ac33ee5be7435db1687e1a6f5277597de0a714e9f07d95ecc299aef691da4", "size": 3085, "mtime_ns": 1792315362725252014 }, "dimensions": [ 32, 32 ], "mean_luma": 133.4815794921875 }, { "role": "hd-1", "file": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ridgepair-20363-20364-Original-primary-author-20261018-v1/actual-once-SourceF-complete2-intrinsic5/20364-hd-1.ppm", "sha256": "3d92eea2d6318dc53ac77ec252b819107658a933c73935c1ad7dd09b94f69e10", "size": 3085, "mtime_ns": 1792315362726252013 }, "dimensions": [ 32, 32 ], "mean_luma": 132.764365625 }, { "role": "hd-2", "file": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ridgepair-20363-20364-Original-primary-author-20261018-v1/actual-once-SourceF-complete2-intrinsic5/20364-hd-2.ppm", "sha256": "fd524cffd072b00d96615db4174d0588d5e2a57aecd51c0cd76675c521c36ba3", "size": 12301, "mtime_ns": 1792315362727252013 }, "dimensions": [ 64, 64 ], "mean_luma": 132.65341069335938 }, { "role": "hd-3", "file": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ridgepair-20363-20364-Original-primary-author-20261018-v1/actual-once-SourceF-complete2-intrinsic5/20364-hd-3.ppm", "sha256": "a52c8dc58fa1ccd2478e67ded45fcb62dc159a904fe0237ca12bfe8963cbbde7", "size": 27661, "mtime_ns": 1792315362730252013 }, "dimensions": [ 96, 96 ], "mean_luma": 132.58831009114584 }, { "role": "hd-4", "file": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ridgepair-20363-20364-Original-primary-author-20261018-v1/actual-once-SourceF-complete2-intrinsic5/20364-hd-4.ppm", "sha256": "235eeb08c1c96d7ac454cc14ae454f90c030474b5a68483548f707196cf17f15", "size": 49167, "mtime_ns": 1792315362734252013 }, "dimensions": [ 128, 128 ], "mean_luma": 132.54589178466796 } ] } ], "limits": [ "Gallery/native material qualification only; actual terrain neighborhood/state-transition context review remains required before admission.", "Generated ridges have stronger overhead highlight and apparent relief than Source; the small vertical edge bevels and very fine weathering remain visible at native4.", "Native1 is softer and has less irregular Source tonal scuffing; the distinct dark20363 and light20364 horizontal-material identities remain readable.", "No claim of exact per-pixel Original grayscale, exact ridge phase continuity across neighbors, seamless tiling or animation.", "Old first-atlas brick/plate-joint HOLD and actually executed whole16-grid-shift successor HOLD remain literal, separate and unused.", "No cleanup, gain profile, new World, Rust compiler, canonical registry, Git, SDL, gameplay or timing actions were performed." ] }