{ "status": "QUALIFIED_NEW5_FINITE_SEVEN_G2_H5596_STATIC_CONTEXT_ART_NOT_ADMISSION", "reviewer": "/root/terrain_context_review", "artist_and_context_producer": "/root/terrain_repair_plan", "different_from_artist_and_producer": true, "utc": "2026-10-18T22:52:32.109008+00:00", "new_selected": [ "304b7", "304b8", "304cf", "304d5", "304d6" ], "qualified_assets": [ "304b7", "304b8", "304cf", "304d5", "304d6" ], "held_assets": [], "per_asset_material_judgments": { "304b7": "Qualified in its complete3x3 caller and the full9x4 building strip at all native scales. The sparse dark vertical grille remains in the correct right-hand building bay, with the projecting lower block, adjacent gray panel and dark perimeter shadow coherent. Sharper frames have stronger relief; thin bars soften at native1 without becoming an extra opening.", "304b8": "Qualified in its complete3x3 caller and full strip. Exactly three short bars and one dark-red aperture remain recognizable, aligned below the existing damaged upper section and above the lower vented sill. The neighboring right cage and upper/lower projecting horizontal edges still meet their Source structure. Narrow tile/frame shading remains visible, with no new detached panel or aperture.", "304cf": "Qualified in its complete3x3 caller and the full9x5 red motif. The wide left cavity and asymmetric internal rails remain under the existing broken upper column segment. The bottom neighboring ruin keeps its separate short-cavity identity. Stronger gray chips and brighter fine red ground are visible, without displacing the narrow vertical building column.", "304d5": "Qualified in its complete3x3 caller and full motif. The pointed upper cavity, small central shelf and sparse dark interior remain distinct on the right column. The external gray rim, adjoining upper panel and lower ruin stay aligned; more regular bright chipped edges and fine ground contrast are limits.", "304d6": "Qualified in its complete3x3 caller and full motif. The low rubble cluster and hanging upper crosspiece retain a short ruined base below304cf, with the bottom border finishing the left column cleanly. Native1 is soft; larger scales reveal stronger relief and granular background. The base remains distinguishable from the taller neighboring cavities." }, "producer_report": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-newTerrain5-SourceG2-H5596-genuine-seven-context-author-20261019-v1/CLOSED-NEW5-CURRENT-G2-H5596-GENUINE7-CONTEXT-AUTHOR-QUALIFIED.json", "sha256": "328acb7fd2187b34c9391c6ddfde3bb1324663fee8f14c4ddc9e53f69a23d8a6", "size": 4634, "mtime_ns": 1792362784268896019, "mode": 33188 }, "producer_strict": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-newTerrain5-SourceG2-H5596-genuine-seven-context-author-20261019-v1-strict-complete-seven-context-author-closure.json", "sha256": "1cd53dd8e02f14f11188f123427cbec14cb134a529a0e61c051c7889fdbc56f2", "size": 456907, "mtime_ns": 1792362808094346868, "mode": 33188 }, "interface": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-newTerrain5-SourceG2-H5596-genuine-seven-context-author-20261019-v1/FROZEN-AUTHOR-QUALIFIED-NEW5-GENUINE7-CURRENTG2-CONTEXT-PEER-INTERFACE.json", "sha256": "a1fe803e7476bc27a3775bedbf97e2ba0d01dbc038b5cc88a7cec1e76083642b", "size": 30213, "mtime_ns": 1792362807826099973, "mode": 33188 }, "prior_different_intrinsic": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-independent-newTerrain5-SourceG2-whole-intrinsic-review-20261019-v1/QUALIFIED-DIFFERENT-NEWTERRAIN5-TWOFAMILY-SOURCEG2-WHOLE-SOURCE-RAW-ALLNATIVE-INTRINSIC-ART-REVIEW.json", "sha256": "5d26a56dbb80ce485cb328a324283f1f4e4a8f05216d15be79968c02874b9d36", "size": 19193, "mtime_ns": 1792361361908846489, "mode": 33188 }, "physical_scope": { "all13_saved_pages_personally_viewed": true, "page_pins": [ { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-newTerrain5-SourceG2-H5596-genuine-seven-context-author-20261019-v1/whole-authenticated-context-pages/case00-WHOLE-genuine3x3-Original-baseline-proposed-ALL-NATIVE.png", "sha256": "a58a1d25b6c65290ef94bf8a88ba152a0e5cccac2d6202db86888072b0159a0d", "size": 346521, "mtime_ns": 1792362680039354709, "mode": 33188 }, { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-newTerrain5-SourceG2-H5596-genuine-seven-context-author-20261019-v1/whole-authenticated-context-pages/case01-WHOLE-genuine3x3-Original-baseline-proposed-ALL-NATIVE.png", "sha256": "84b96da9adff891ccf2808fd838b872fab7a4e91349bae0548ca1c4efb4b5189", "size": 348158, "mtime_ns": 1792362680218354698, "mode": 33188 }, { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-newTerrain5-SourceG2-H5596-genuine-seven-context-author-20261019-v1/whole-authenticated-context-pages/case02-WHOLE-genuine3x3-Original-baseline-proposed-ALL-NATIVE.png", "sha256": "ffe3438cf5cb895fa4b35ee72ca010c2e1b8cb66a8fcc7a1b4c6e3ba28ad0705", "size": 420616, "mtime_ns": 1792362680403354687, "mode": 33188 }, { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-newTerrain5-SourceG2-H5596-genuine-seven-context-author-20261019-v1/whole-authenticated-context-pages/case03-WHOLE-genuine3x3-Original-baseline-proposed-ALL-NATIVE.png", "sha256": "da9e353f41d9374064b6b7a7fe71a535366fa068c261de1b8136933f5c525e46", "size": 382690, "mtime_ns": 1792362680590354675, "mode": 33188 }, { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-newTerrain5-SourceG2-H5596-genuine-seven-context-author-20261019-v1/whole-authenticated-context-pages/case04-WHOLE-genuine3x3-Original-baseline-proposed-ALL-NATIVE.png", "sha256": "021a66aa09f5ae8859516aef91530b03c00ce3362b62b917dfa828477a6ccf44", "size": 349075, "mtime_ns": 1792362680764354665, "mode": 33188 }, { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-newTerrain5-SourceG2-H5596-genuine-seven-context-author-20261019-v1/whole-authenticated-context-pages/case05-WHOLE-authentic9x4-native1-all3roles.png", "sha256": "df47ba1388d99b8a2ea34e999d2c9d7f1ea51ac1b5511f3d7af44c29b5f487b5", "size": 85705, "mtime_ns": 1792362680815354662, "mode": 33188 }, { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-newTerrain5-SourceG2-H5596-genuine-seven-context-author-20261019-v1/whole-authenticated-context-pages/case05-WHOLE-authentic9x4-native2-all3roles.png", "sha256": "872d84d80979f408742251b112eca0c594dd68ebb012b49b931841f217aaf4c0", "size": 241514, "mtime_ns": 1792362680894354657, "mode": 33188 }, { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-newTerrain5-SourceG2-H5596-genuine-seven-context-author-20261019-v1/whole-authenticated-context-pages/case05-WHOLE-authentic9x4-native3-all3roles.png", "sha256": "6e92becbc849dea87994485dcb32d07e2efd0f506535abfa244787d909ec675f", "size": 477395, "mtime_ns": 1792362681056354647, "mode": 33188 }, { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-newTerrain5-SourceG2-H5596-genuine-seven-context-author-20261019-v1/whole-authenticated-context-pages/case05-WHOLE-authentic9x4-native4-all3roles.png", "sha256": "b9ae40cee55fa18a73424c2bcfc6808ba988f2192ad288c6db841534955f7e0d", "size": 837285, "mtime_ns": 1792362681341354629, "mode": 33188 }, { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-newTerrain5-SourceG2-H5596-genuine-seven-context-author-20261019-v1/whole-authenticated-context-pages/case06-WHOLE-authentic9x5-native1-all3roles.png", "sha256": "d6143f65bec658d2218665d8d7f64320d349c7ef74c3f83ca96bd02dbf483206", "size": 102474, "mtime_ns": 1792362681403354626, "mode": 33188 }, { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-newTerrain5-SourceG2-H5596-genuine-seven-context-author-20261019-v1/whole-authenticated-context-pages/case06-WHOLE-authentic9x5-native2-all3roles.png", "sha256": "3fff26943144116957604483787e54dfcef481ede1252ab396f2daa06daf7492", "size": 310815, "mtime_ns": 1792362681496354620, "mode": 33188 }, { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-newTerrain5-SourceG2-H5596-genuine-seven-context-author-20261019-v1/whole-authenticated-context-pages/case06-WHOLE-authentic9x5-native3-all3roles.png", "sha256": "e54eb020f1a8f6b52d76f7947ed0c54c18b4dd5fa0800b1bafe1dc97fc79f714", "size": 639582, "mtime_ns": 1792362681691354608, "mode": 33188 }, { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-newTerrain5-SourceG2-H5596-genuine-seven-context-author-20261019-v1/whole-authenticated-context-pages/case06-WHOLE-authentic9x5-native4-all3roles.png", "sha256": "826e3f49c535142710034a6073c23da2602de38bfb07152d087b9b652be1530d", "size": 1130239, "mtime_ns": 1792362682038354587, "mode": 33188 } ], "whole_role_bodies": 84, "native_scales": [ 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "complete3x3_own_caller_windows": 5, "whole_building_strip_tiles": [ 9, 4 ], "whole_red_motif_tiles": [ 9, 5 ], "physical_views": 13, "tool_resize": false, "display": "Saved whole-body pages;3x3native1 is exactNN4 andnative2 exactNN2; remaining3x3native3/4 and all strip/motif bodies unresampled. No crop, reenlargement filtering or recreated image was used." }, "whole_motif_findings": [ "The full building strip reads as one building silhouette: the two grilles, projecting lower blocks, right panel, cages, vents and dark ground shadow retain their original arrangement. The selected right panel three-bar/aperture cues remain readable with the explicit previous-four proposal siblings.", "The full red motif retains its central structure, paired outer ruined columns and open foreground. The C3 cavity variations stay distinguishable; added cracks and chips read as structural rubble, without adding enemies, pickups or new emitted effects.", "Grain, panel contrast and shadow differences already present among installed neighbors remain visible. Stronger B2 outlines and chipped C3 rims make the selected cells more regular/crisp; local gray shading divisions and rectangular red mottling are still discernible. This qualification does not claim perfectly seamless material throughout every map." ], "saved_readback": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-independent-newTerrain5-SourceG2-H5596-seven-context-review-20261019-v1/PASS-INDEPENDENT-G2-H5596-SEVEN-CONTEXT-SAVED-ARRAYS-AND84-BODIES-AUTHENTICATION.json", "sha256": "66d615ae78f167bd8e6b6216b153d6dfa3b192c9b8c9a6bc49c49b8a909941ab", "size": 5183, "mtime_ns": 1792363737024289988, "mode": 33188 }, "technical_summary": { "status": "PASS_READ_ONLY_LITERAL_G2_H5596_CONTEXTS", "producer_strict_members_verified": 1084, "named_immutable_inputs_verified": 179, "maps": 27, "Source_callers": [ { "mission": "base:sector_3_wave_5", "asset": "304b1", "intact": "304b1", "settled": "304b1", "row": 1, "column": 6, "MAP_asset": "30006", "MAP_byte_offset": 72, "flat": 964, "game": 2, "FLATS_asset": "30001", "FLATS_byte_offset": 7712, "health": 0, "raw_health": -1, "reward": 500, "raw_reward": 500 }, { "mission": "base:sector_3_wave_5", "asset": "304b2", "intact": "304b2", "settled": "304b2", "row": 1, "column": 7, "MAP_asset": "30006", "MAP_byte_offset": 76, "flat": 965, "game": 2, "FLATS_asset": "30001", "FLATS_byte_offset": 7720, "health": 0, "raw_health": -1, "reward": 0, "raw_reward": 0 }, { "mission": "base:sector_3_wave_5", "asset": "304b3", "intact": "304b3", "settled": "304b3", "row": 2, "column": 1, "MAP_asset": "30006", "MAP_byte_offset": 88, "flat": 966, "game": 2, "FLATS_asset": "30001", "FLATS_byte_offset": 7728, "health": 0, "raw_health": -1, "reward": 500, "raw_reward": 500 }, { "mission": "base:sector_3_wave_5", "asset": "304b5", "intact": "304b5", "settled": "304b5", "row": 2, "column": 3, "MAP_asset": "30006", "MAP_byte_offset": 96, "flat": 968, "game": 2, "FLATS_asset": "30001", "FLATS_byte_offset": 7744, "health": 0, "raw_health": -1, "reward": 500, "raw_reward": 500 }, { "mission": "base:sector_3_wave_5", "asset": "304b7", "intact": "304b7", "settled": "304b7", "row": 2, "column": 5, "MAP_asset": "30006", "MAP_byte_offset": 104, "flat": 970, "game": 2, "FLATS_asset": "30001", "FLATS_byte_offset": 7760, "health": 0, "raw_health": -1, "reward": 500, "raw_reward": 500 }, { "mission": "base:sector_3_wave_5", "asset": "304b8", "intact": "304b8", "settled": "304b8", "row": 2, "column": 6, "MAP_asset": "30006", "MAP_byte_offset": 108, "flat": 971, "game": 2, "FLATS_asset": "30001", "FLATS_byte_offset": 7768, "health": 0, "raw_health": -1, "reward": 500, "raw_reward": 500 }, { "mission": "base:sector_3_wave_7", "asset": "304cf", "intact": "304cf", "settled": "304cf", "row": 2, "column": 1, "MAP_asset": "40003", "MAP_byte_offset": 88, "flat": 994, "game": 2, "FLATS_asset": "30001", "FLATS_byte_offset": 7952, "health": 0, "raw_health": -1, "reward": 0, "raw_reward": 0 }, { "mission": "base:sector_3_wave_7", "asset": "304d5", "intact": "304d5", "settled": "304d5", "row": 2, "column": 7, "MAP_asset": "40003", "MAP_byte_offset": 112, "flat": 1000, "game": 2, "FLATS_asset": "30001", "FLATS_byte_offset": 8000, "health": 0, "raw_health": -1, "reward": 0, "raw_reward": 0 }, { "mission": "base:sector_3_wave_7", "asset": "304d6", "intact": "304d6", "settled": "304d6", "row": 3, "column": 1, "MAP_asset": "40003", "MAP_byte_offset": 124, "flat": 1001, "game": 2, "FLATS_asset": "30001", "FLATS_byte_offset": 8008, "health": 0, "raw_health": -1, "reward": 0, "raw_reward": 0 } ], "windows": 7, "Source_tiles": 64, "foreign_HD": 55, "proposed9": [ "304b1", "304b2", "304b3", "304b5", "304b7", "304b8", "304cf", "304d5", "304d6" ], "new5": [ "304b7", "304b8", "304cf", "304d5", "304d6" ], "Original_fallbacks": 0, "records": 28, "components": 256, "unique_whole_role_bodies": 84, "pages": 13, "index_class_RGB_samples": 13578240, "totals": { "retained": 2430, "outside": 3121680, "baseline_own": 645120, "foreign_interior": 2469600, "delta": 602376 }, "retained2430_only_prior304b1_Original27_noHDcredit": true, "first_constructor_zero_components_planes_verified": true, "actual_H5596_hd": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-newTerrain5-SourceG2-H5596-genuine-seven-context-author-20261019-v1/private-H5596-baseline/hd.json", "sha256": "82bab648fa338fd4bc73d16859798f7e78e638172d3e4196bd50a0a39d55cfe2", "size": 3032836, "mtime_ns": 1792318079410584313, "mode": 33152 }, "first_attempt_preserved": true, "actual_source": "G2; same literal captured source epoch as producer, no later baseline relabel", "new_engine": 0, "new_World": 0, "new_QA": 0, "new_render": 0, "new_image": 0, "new_cleanup": 0, "canonical": 0, "git": 0 }, "g2_exact_binding": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-independent-newTerrain5-SourceG2-H5596-seven-context-review-20261019-v1/EXACT-G2-LIBRARY-SOURCE18-AND-NAMEONLY-ATTEMPT-BINDING.json", "sha256": "32c005991ec1c7eb01b1cb0d966d585cb215927301edb06de86af90324766f04", "size": 8015, "mtime_ns": 1792363952108909815, "mode": 33188 }, "retained_Original": { "owner": "304b1", "cells": 27, "joined_native_samples": 2430, "Original_not_HD_credit": true, "new5_cells": 0 }, "pixel_epoch": { "actual_source": "SourceG2 library5b6bbd03", "actual_baseline": "immutable captured H5596", "actual_proposal_inputs": [ "304b1", "304b2", "304b3", "304b5", "304b7", "304b8", "304cf", "304d5", "304d6" ], "proposal_includes_previous4": [ "304b1", "304b2", "304b3", "304b5" ], "new5": [ "304b7", "304b8", "304cf", "304d5", "304d6" ], "later_publication_note": "Root states that the prior four are being installed in the next17 batch/H5613 while this independent review proceeds. These images remain the saved H5596 controls with nine explicit proposals; no current H5613 capture, new render or implicit baseline rewrite is claimed. Any portable metadata/finite carry must separately acknowledge the installed four and preserve these literal pixel epochs." }, "actual_producer_execution_counts": { "private_adapter_compile": 1, "constructor_attempts": 2, "successful_full_context_productions": 1, "first_attempt_components": 0, "first_attempt_context_planes": 0, "new_World": 0, "new_engine_build": 0, "new_intrinsic_QA": 0, "new_imagegen": 0, "new_cleanup": 0, "canonical_registration_Git_writes": 0 }, "preserved_producer_stops": [ "Two preflight preparation stops are preserved in producer files.", "First constructor rejected missing top-level name before any component or context plane; its empty folders were independently verified. Same compiled adapter succeeded after adding only the manifest name.", "Producer seal mapping-keyword stop is preserved." ], "producer_limits_verbatim": [ "Finite seven actual static MAP windows, not all map positions or simulation outcomes.", "New five ordinary art have zero Original retention; proposed sibling304b1 retains exact27 lower outlined-slot SourceNx cells with no generated-HD credit.", "H5596 is the current baseline; all nine uninstalled proposed assets are explicit sibling proposal inputs.", "Sharper B2 outlines and stronger chipped C3 relief are accepted with qualification; native1 fine-detail merging and localized ground mottling remain visible.", "Finite static Original MAP terrain only; no World, scrolling, all-map coverage, new enemy interaction or fabricated destruction/state outcomes.", "New5 registration is not implied. Prior4 remain proposed sibling inputs, not installed H5596 baseline." ], "review_limits": [ "Finite static Original MAP data only: all5new direct static callers plus two wider actual motif windows, not every possible screen crop or mission state.", "The five source tiles are fixed layout ruins/panels with rawhealth-1 and registryhealth0. Their appearance does not demonstrate a damage/destruction transition.", "No World, scrolling, gameplay, all-map route, audio, collision or performance run was made by this reviewer.", "This is a context material qualification for new5 with explicit previous4 neighbors. It does not newly count the previous4 as generated completion or count their retained27 Original cells as HD." ], "operations": { "new_generation": 0, "new_cleanup": 0, "new_pixels": 0, "new_composition": 0, "new_World": 0, "new_QA": 0, "new_build": 0, "canonical_writes": 0, "git": 0, "saved_readback_attempts": 1 }, "no_pending_operation": true }