{ "status": "QUALIFIED5_INTRINSIC_WITH_LIMITS_NOT_CONTEXT_OR_ADMISSION", "reviewer": "/root/terrain_context_review", "artist_and_preparer": "/root/terrain_repair_plan", "different_from_artist_and_preparer": true, "utc": "2026-10-18T22:09:21.907571+00:00", "qualified_frames": 5, "held_frames": 0, "assets": [ "304b7", "304b8", "304cf", "304d5", "304d6" ], "decisions": [ { "asset": "304b7", "status": "QUALIFIED_COMPLETE1_INTRINSIC_WITH_LIMITS", "qualified_complete1": true, "all4_scales_qualified": true, "complete_native_frames": 1, "native_scales": [ 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "held_frames": 0, "Original_retained_cells": 0, "observations": [ "The complete sparse dark vertical opening, left/right rails and unequal internal crosspieces remain recognizable against the broad gray right-hand panel at every native scale. No additional hole outside the established framed opening was found.", "The generated rails are straighter and more framed, with narrow bright highlights and deeper dark edging. The top/lower crosspieces and unequal hanging bars still communicate the Original sparse pattern; native1 merges some thin detail.", "The gray texture and dark rail treatment sit within the range of the previously qualified304b2/304b3/304b5 native boards. This is a side-by-side material comparison, not an actual terrain join." ] }, { "asset": "304b8", "status": "QUALIFIED_COMPLETE1_INTRINSIC_WITH_LIMITS", "qualified_complete1": true, "all4_scales_qualified": true, "complete_native_frames": 1, "native_scales": [ 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "held_frames": 0, "Original_retained_cells": 0, "observations": [ "Exactly three short horizontal gray bars remain below the single horizontal dark-red aperture at native1,2,3,4. The adjacent long vertical strip, upper recessed edge and lower horizontal sill retain the Original organization. No extra aperture or fourth short bar was found.", "The aperture remains one dark recess with ordinary red/brown illumination patches. It is not a new animated flame effect; all Source and HD indices240..255 are absent.", "Raised bright edges, right-panel shading and the narrow black frame are stronger than Original and slightly stronger than the earlier shallow gray Terrain4 panels. The shapes remain compatible in isolated comparison; genuine neighbor composition is still required." ] }, { "asset": "304cf", "status": "QUALIFIED_COMPLETE1_INTRINSIC_WITH_LIMITS", "qualified_complete1": true, "all4_scales_qualified": true, "complete_native_frames": 1, "native_scales": [ 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "held_frames": 0, "Original_retained_cells": 0, "observations": [ "The wide irregular black cavity, large gray top remnant, lower sill, left internal rails and higher right post preserve the Source damaged-structure identity. The Source asymmetric remnants remain distinct at all scales.", "The broken rim gains small chips and cracks. The upper gray slab stays connected to its rim rather than becoming a separate object, and the maroon/red strips keep the original side arrangement. Native1 softens the sparse internal rails." ] }, { "asset": "304d5", "status": "QUALIFIED_COMPLETE1_INTRINSIC_WITH_LIMITS", "qualified_complete1": true, "all4_scales_qualified": true, "complete_native_frames": 1, "native_scales": [ 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "held_frames": 0, "Original_retained_cells": 0, "observations": [ "The tall sparse cavity, pointed upper break and small central shelf/triangle remain recognizable. The right internal vertical remnant and open lower cavity preserve the Source asymmetry; the opening is not replaced by a new regular grate.", "Gray rim rubble and fine fissures add relief. The more granular bright red ground stays on its authentic side, with the bottom sill and outer footprint still legible. Native1 merges the smallest remnant detail." ] }, { "asset": "304d6", "status": "QUALIFIED_COMPLETE1_INTRINSIC_WITH_LIMITS", "qualified_complete1": true, "all4_scales_qualified": true, "complete_native_frames": 1, "native_scales": [ 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "held_frames": 0, "Original_retained_cells": 0, "observations": [ "The shorter cavity keeps its high horizontal broken crosspiece, short hanging bits and low central dark rubble cluster. It remains visibly different from304cf and304d5 at all native scales.", "The chipped gray outer frame and the surrounding red ground preserve the Original footprint and bottom border. The low rubble has finer stone texture and greater local contrast; it reads as cavity rubble rather than an added enemy, pickup or glowing effect." ] } ], "actual_families": [ { "family": "family-304b7-304b8", "report": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-stream-304b7-304b8-304cf-304d5-304d6-Source-primary-author-20261019-v1/family-304b7-304b8/CLOSED-NEW-GENUINE-ORIGINAL-PRIMARY-CURRENT-G2-FAMILY-AUTHOR-QUALIFIED.json", "sha256": "7ddd9d202647755f0cba42d4e731f42246ebe1687fcc4873086d5a4f0e97f5a4", "bytes": 4032, "mtime_ns": 1792355683452419845, "mode": 33188 }, "strict": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-stream-304b7-304b8-304cf-304d5-304d6-Source-primary-author-20261019-v1/family-304b7-304b8-strict-author-family-currentG2-intrinsic-closure.json", "sha256": "0edfd83ac6e9e08e4d1461e5190c1d6c6e5801fe1cd8b80180912886294d5137", "bytes": 36485, "mtime_ns": 1792355683461889065, "mode": 33188 }, "interface": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-stream-304b7-304b8-304cf-304d5-304d6-Source-primary-author-20261019-v1/family-304b7-304b8/FROZEN-WHOLE-FAMILY-SOURCE-RAW-ALLNATIVE-CURRENT-G2-PEER-INTERFACE.json", "sha256": "3fe4558120fa156a35449683845b8511194cfcff1e19b5f65cd321a9ee9de2ee", "bytes": 10332, "mtime_ns": 1792355683444215932, "mode": 33188 }, "owned_files": 34, "owned_bytes": 4281737 }, { "family": "family-304cf-304d5-304d6", "report": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-stream-304b7-304b8-304cf-304d5-304d6-Source-primary-author-20261019-v1/family-304cf-304d5-304d6/CLOSED-NEW-GENUINE-ORIGINAL-PRIMARY-CURRENT-G2-FAMILY-AUTHOR-QUALIFIED.json", "sha256": "f24cc720ce3bbec9b7fec650026b0f14dc914062adbd01b38699ddad0980003f", "bytes": 4269, "mtime_ns": 1792355683517608074, "mode": 33188 }, "strict": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-stream-304b7-304b8-304cf-304d5-304d6-Source-primary-author-20261019-v1/family-304cf-304d5-304d6-strict-author-family-currentG2-intrinsic-closure.json", "sha256": "48d92ff3cf21441f85fa62eb2e7be3064f904ad7e12e8361ed07501782bcd062", "bytes": 39179, "mtime_ns": 1792355683527939207, "mode": 33188 }, "interface": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-stream-304b7-304b8-304cf-304d5-304d6-Source-primary-author-20261019-v1/family-304cf-304d5-304d6/FROZEN-WHOLE-FAMILY-SOURCE-RAW-ALLNATIVE-CURRENT-G2-PEER-INTERFACE.json", "sha256": "f5e138fdc57c9317b8f09f8f02f3f5d92d631c3a03009cbe4820a58d4387c06e", "bytes": 13474, "mtime_ns": 1792355683509971867, "mode": 33188 }, "owned_files": 40, "owned_bytes": 4656204 } ], "untouched_raws": [ { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-stream-304b7-304b8-304cf-304d5-304d6-Source-primary-author-20261019-v1/family-304b7-304b8/generated/untouched-genuine-builtin-atlas.png", "sha256": "512a74e6c34b7048364cc85bb53cbc22249b08d35d090d07581515798f18137f", "size": 2986830, "mtime_ns": 1792355380321801681, "mode": 33188 }, { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-stream-304b7-304b8-304cf-304d5-304d6-Source-primary-author-20261019-v1/family-304cf-304d5-304d6/generated/untouched-genuine-builtin-atlas.png", "sha256": "d2d0345d7188df50d7fe3285757d77f1dda345f18d1f73fc24177c3afabf6bff", "size": 2599814, "mtime_ns": 1792355431096798572, "mode": 33188 } ], "physical_review": { "full_raw_atlases_personally_viewed": 2, "raw_dimensions": [ [ 1774, 887 ], [ 1254, 1254 ] ], "all5_whole_Original_bodies_personally_viewed": true, "all5_whole_native1to4_bodies_personally_viewed": true, "unique_Source_and_native_bodies": 25, "whole_native_boards": 5, "pane_bodies_including_exact_integerNN_comparison_views": 50, "whole_board_dimensions": [ 1524, 520 ], "native_scales": [ 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "unresampled_bodies_and_integerNN_views": true, "tool_resize": false, "additional_prior_Terrain4_boards_personally_viewed": 4, "total_image_view_calls": 11 }, "prior_Terrain4_comparison": { "interface": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-repair-304b1-304b2-304b3-304b5-Source-primary-shallow-material-complete4-author-20261018-v2/FROZEN-COMPLETE4-FINAL-RAW-SOURCE-NATIVE-AND27-RETAINED-INTERFACE.json", "sha256": "b294c6eec7222e6a2b25dae6b8d5006296c8ca6079f09ef3643125c914c23112", "size": 8310, "mtime_ns": 1792315514434958201, "mode": 33188 }, "boards": [ { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-repair-304b1-304b2-304b3-304b5-Source-primary-shallow-material-complete4-author-20261018-v2/304b1-WHOLE-SOURCENX-PRIOR488E-RETAINED27-ALL-NATIVE-LOSSLESS.png", "sha256": "e1a0f3a485e51247c5f693654b6eed4b983d4d50ad405abd7fc5f70c7201e5dc", "size": 69987, "mtime_ns": 1792315442486247130, "mode": 33188 }, { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-repair-304b1-304b2-304b3-304b5-Source-primary-shallow-material-complete4-author-20261018-v2/whole-allscale-pages/304b2-WHOLE-SOURCE-AND-ACTUAL-NATIVE1TO4-LOSSLESS.png", "sha256": "eb78efb77e0a77d04b902f37660fc0ee3007c4cd42f37b4379a6356c410879f7", "size": 66504, "mtime_ns": 1792315230016260139, "mode": 33188 }, { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-repair-304b1-304b2-304b3-304b5-Source-primary-shallow-material-complete4-author-20261018-v2/whole-allscale-pages/304b3-WHOLE-SOURCE-AND-ACTUAL-NATIVE1TO4-LOSSLESS.png", "sha256": "692023390001f31e5118300f8fc25c2c81243030580d0dfdcb0d84f520d52029", "size": 67347, "mtime_ns": 1792315230093260135, "mode": 33188 }, { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-terrain-repair-304b1-304b2-304b3-304b5-Source-primary-shallow-material-complete4-author-20261018-v2/whole-allscale-pages/304b5-WHOLE-SOURCE-AND-ACTUAL-NATIVE1TO4-LOSSLESS.png", "sha256": "0a2f19aa1e6b87f1a99dc6c9781bcf56a8bf056282a88ce17e700b47c9251a81", "size": 63766, "mtime_ns": 1792315230163260130, "mode": 33188 } ], "scope": "Existing literal SourceF-native and retained27 comparison boards for304b1/304b2/304b3/304b5 viewed as prior material/geometry references only. No new G2 rendering of these neighbors, no fresh context or expanded approval is claimed." }, "saved_readback": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-independent-newTerrain5-SourceG2-whole-intrinsic-review-20261019-v1/PASS-INDEPENDENT-SAVED-SOURCE-AND-ALLNATIVE50-PANE-AUTHENTICATION.json", "sha256": "7b56030816e781f748eeef204123bc17e4bd3ef3356a6a063111b40ebdde7f26", "size": 11166, "mtime_ns": 1792361005252775363, "mode": 33188 }, "technical_summary": { "status": "PASS_SAVED_ONLY_NOT_ART_VERDICT", "native_frames": 5, "native_scales": [ 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "Source_and_HD_samples": 158720, "whole_page_bodies": 50, "producer_files_unchanged": 96, "named_pins_unchanged": 173, "source_epoch": "Actual G2 helper0338/library5b6; exact compile-bound immutable source18", "new_engine": 0, "new_QA": 0, "new_World": 0, "new_generation": 0, "new_pixels": 0 }, "semantics": { "all_Source_and_HD_reserved240_255_counts": 0, "all5_Original_retention_cells": 0, "complete1_definitions_per_asset": true, "new_generation_inventory5_only": true, "unused_C3_lower_right_atlas_cell_not_counted": true, "actual_Source_callers": [ { "asset": "304b7", "settled": "304b7", "mission": "base:sector_3_wave_5", "row": 2, "column": 5, "MAP_asset": "30006", "MAP_byte_offset": 104, "FLATS_asset": "30001", "FLATS_byte_offset": 7760, "flat": 970, "game": 2, "raw_health": -1, "Registry_health": 0, "reward_metadata": 500, "raw_reward": 500 }, { "asset": "304b8", "settled": "304b8", "mission": "base:sector_3_wave_5", "row": 2, "column": 6, "MAP_asset": "30006", "MAP_byte_offset": 108, "FLATS_asset": "30001", "FLATS_byte_offset": 7768, "flat": 971, "game": 2, "raw_health": -1, "Registry_health": 0, "reward_metadata": 500, "raw_reward": 500 }, { "asset": "304cf", "settled": "304cf", "mission": "base:sector_3_wave_7", "row": 2, "column": 1, "MAP_asset": "40003", "MAP_byte_offset": 88, "FLATS_asset": "30001", "FLATS_byte_offset": 7952, "flat": 994, "game": 2, "raw_health": -1, "Registry_health": 0, "reward_metadata": 0, "raw_reward": 0 }, { "asset": "304d5", "settled": "304d5", "mission": "base:sector_3_wave_7", "row": 2, "column": 7, "MAP_asset": "40003", "MAP_byte_offset": 112, "FLATS_asset": "30001", "FLATS_byte_offset": 8000, "flat": 1000, "game": 2, "raw_health": -1, "Registry_health": 0, "reward_metadata": 0, "raw_reward": 0 }, { "asset": "304d6", "settled": "304d6", "mission": "base:sector_3_wave_7", "row": 3, "column": 1, "MAP_asset": "40003", "MAP_byte_offset": 124, "FLATS_asset": "30001", "FLATS_byte_offset": 8008, "flat": 1001, "game": 2, "raw_health": -1, "Registry_health": 0, "reward_metadata": 0, "raw_reward": 0 } ], "all5_direct_static_layout_tiles": true, "Source_raw_health": -1, "Registry_health": 0, "ordinary_red_aperture_not_animated_effect": true }, "producer_limits_verbatim": { "family-304b7-304b8": [ "Edges/frame surfaces are brighter and have stronger relief/highlights than the softly shaded Original. The new material is a remastered interpretation, not pixel-identical geometry or original RGB.", "Native1 reduces fine texture and softens narrow structure/slot detail; all4nativeviews preserve overall Source organization with this limit.", "No genuine currentG2terrain-neighbor composition has yet been rendered; this is intrinsic whole-tile approval only, pending differentpeer and later source-genuine context.", "304b7 generated inner rails/crosspieces are more crisp/regular and framed than Original; Source sparse pattern and dark openings remain recognized.", "304b8 hasexact3shortgraybars physicallyread at1-4 anditsordinarydark-redaperture; raised/shadowed edges are strongerthanSource. No reserved/animatedfireeffect is claimed." ], "family-304cf-304d5-304d6": [ "Edges/frame surfaces are brighter and have stronger relief/highlights than the softly shaded Original. The new material is a remastered interpretation, not pixel-identical geometry or original RGB.", "Native1 reduces fine texture and softens narrow structure/slot detail; all4nativeviews preserve overall Source organization with this limit.", "No genuine currentG2terrain-neighbor composition has yet been rendered; this is intrinsic whole-tile approval only, pending differentpeer and later source-genuine context.", "Red ground is brighter/more granular than Original broad maroon patches. Broken gray rims and cavity remnants show stronger chipped/rubble relief and fine cracks; no exact Original Source interior sample equality is claimed.", "304cf/304d5/304d6 cavity shape/asymmetry, gray remnant placement and ground-side identity remain recognized in all4nativeoutputs; this is no claim that stronger relief is invisible.", "Fourth lower-right2x2cell isunusedgeneratedbackground, not anOriginalasset or countedcompletion." ] }, "material_limits": [ "All five preserve their complete Original organization, but stronger highlights, chipped relief, dark outlines and more regular rails are interpreted HD material. Geometry is not claimed pixel-identical beyond the actual32x32 logical canvas/origin and verified Source binding.", "B2 bar count, one aperture and sparse framed opening were physically assessed across all native scales; zero reserved-index samples alone is not an artistic proof.", "C3 red ground is brighter/finer than broad Original maroon patches. Native1 merges small rails and rubble; native3/4 show stronger cracks and bevels.", "No genuine current-G2 neighboring composition, scrolling, live mission, collision, natural destruction timing, sound, effect or performance was tested. Existing four-neighbor images are comparison references only." ], "recommended_next_step": "The five intrinsically qualified assets may proceed to Root-authorized source-genuine current-G2 terrain-context production and separate context ART review. This is not canonical registration or final release approval.", "operations": { "new_generation": 0, "new_cleanup": 0, "new_art_pixels": 0, "new_intrinsic_QA": 0, "new_composition": 0, "new_World": 0, "new_build": 0, "canonical_writes": 0, "git": 0, "read_only_saved_audit_attempts": 1 }, "no_pending_operation": true }