# HD coordinator checkpoint — 12 October 2026

The reviewed external development pack contains **1,748 original picture frames in701 complete sequences**. Root has copied the exact **1,148-frame / 421-sequence** handoff into shared Linux/Windows runtime data. Root completed and validated both final Stage2 Linux/Windows archives at this exact snapshot; the previous **800-frame / 340-sequence** archives and `964ba93` assembly are historical. Root owns runtime data, binaries, libraries and archives; coordinator owns external development registration and this metadata. Bundled originals and approved runtime art are tracked under this repository's data/. Working originals, prompts, job candidates and review evidence remain external under ../data/.

## Verified development coverage

| Category | Registered / original pictures |
| --- | ---: |
| Player banking | 21 / 21 |
| Bosses | 232 / 249 |
| Enemies and ground objects | 211 / 419 |
| Player and enemy projectiles | 45 / 51 |
| Explosions and effects | 219 / 281 |
| Equipment and pickups | 47 / 47 |
| Terrain | 896 / 4,535 |
| Menus, portraits, HUD and other pictures | 77 / 150 |
| Total | 1,748 / 5,753 |

All6,449 catalog entries and5,753 pictures were audited with zero HD source/hash/canvas/ID errors. **4,005 pictures still await registration**. Current ledger counts are1728 registered,20 render-reachable,2705 candidates,676 in-progress and624 missing. Candidate status is neither artistic approval nor a live occurrence. Unused/destroyed targets remain required;303 AGX delta frames and four bitmap fonts have separate preservation policies.

## Historical Stage2 API 1,148 output proof

../data/hd/registered-class-review/runtime-1148-current/combined-review.json closes **4,592 actual scale outputs / 5,740 original and scaled PPMs**, all byte-identical to independently accepted references. Both source-age guards are false at actual final source invocation and closure; all17 Rust source hashes and mtimes remain exact. Immutable release library `target/hd-review-libraries/636eccd24f56fc08ed25aa3bdf311d0b9e26284f2c95ab5ab6c6df070edc3b7c/libraptor_replica-f076ad67c588e355.rlib`, SHA `636eccd24f56fc08ed25aa3bdf311d0b9e26284f2c95ab5ab6c6df070edc3b7c`, original build time `1791706432981505461`, binds root's final Stage2 optional animation/effect.kind API source. Current development hd.json SHA is `5d6b0010049cf5d9d29612391faa72a35d867968f2ce31d6a8e9622e597e4ed8`; combined review SHA `fffd79b1c1e63b1dc21f92f6f961693e9d483c9a73d027fb3e61c56f71e7d323`. No source flag is inferred solely from unchanged pixels. Root subsequently appended and formatted desktop test code, so this closure now records the exact pre-append source epoch; its historical false guards are not relabeled as current after that edit.

All 1058 ordinary source pictures introduce no reserved240–255 labels. 87 source-class pictures retain authentic gameplay classes; three opening cards use their original static256-color palettes. Exact native/source loading does not establish whole-mission completion, custom-menu reachability, complete assembled-boss joins or new destroyed artwork.

After the historical929 checkpoint, batch-979-approval.json adds **50 frames / eight complete families**, with250 exact accepted PPMs and15 complete coordinator-inspected source/native1/HD4 pages on four boards. The batch contains radar40115–40134/32, four tread/slat/fork families15, TEXTURE10018 and side trims50005/50006. batch-1037-approval.json adds **58 frames / eleven complete families**, with290 exact accepted PPMs and20 complete inspected pages on six boards: Orange9, difficulty4, craft3008f/92/95/98, ground40135–40154/32, restored10310/200a3 and complete400ac–400b2/7. Every candidate, binding, source, peer evidence, raw and current output is bound. The former held boss mains are SHA-named snapshots before exact sibling-byte promotion; all rejected versions remain unchanged.

The radar's nine-cell native object, mast, controls and252 lamp remain source-aligned. Its70 contexts/709 pairs/17 states produce3,316 current compositions; nine radar damage partners stay original fallback. The next two ground shards preserve source crack branches, rock positions and shallow divots through36 contexts/121 pairs and756 compositions; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and there are no state partners. Fine soil density/contrast remains visible against original fallback.

Tank phases, forks and stationary architecture retain source identity with exact3–4x occupied-source coverage. Quantified minor shading variance and lower-scale contour smoothing are accepted. New30098 has one missing nativeRGB4 post corner, restored2–4, with both252/253 labels exactly1/4/9/16. Difficulty portraits retain defining faces and framing; warmer painting and the helmet's central pale mark interpreted as a restrained shallow tab with dark underside are accepted, not described as unchanged hardware. Texture repeats preserve connector and slot topology, while stronger edge contrast and burgundy threshold sensitivity remain explicit.

Boss10310 preserves the right disc, skirt and feet, accepting two RGB4 corners plus isolated gray rim(60,46) lost4x. Boss200a3's y35 bridges and central dark structure are restored allscales, with17 outer contour losses2–4 and small right expansion accepted. EBOSS6 retains the final two pale plates and stationary horizontal central grille/crossed lower floor; the firstsix bindings/24 outputs remain exact. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted, not byte-stationary. These are complete-family gallery decisions with no whole-boss live assembly claim.

Orange9 retains warm ray/fragment/fade character despite stronger4x cell-edge outlines and small adjacent additions. Three alpha16/17/19 exterior specks in101a8 are excluded, while meaningful alpha32 contour pixels are retained. Original alpha, source masks and raw RGB evidence stay distinct. Smoke4 remains held because every actual shaded output equals original nearest-neighbor output, so no visible HD improvement is established.


The batch-1071-approval.json journal adds **34 frames in four complete families** after1037, with136 scale outputs/170 source and rendered PPMs, all byte-identical to peer-reviewed references, and ten complete pages inspected on two boards. The accepted singles300ac/3009d retain central machinery, source frame/post/pod/foot structure and authentic lamps. The two native RGB4 corner losses in3009d are disclosed; every source cell survives2–4 and cue counts are exact1/4/9/16.

Original Set4 jobs9/10,40155–40174, preserve crack routes, rock groups and shallow divots. Standalone40157/4015b corrections exclude prior foreign top connection/crack/rock errors while preserving authentic faint source fragments. Their material density contrast is accepted. The actual160-tile pack retains original lower foliage40179/7a; the separate whole-bush all-HD diagnostic approves neither lower cell. Twenty-two contexts/eighty-two pairs/no states produce544 current compositions; ten unused IDs remain gallery-only. Both lower cells were subsequently independently approved in jobs11/12 and admitted in batch1148; this earlier context-only proof remains unchanged.

The opaque4006e warm center remains held despite coherent gray architecture: the source yellow-inclusive21-cell core becomes13 native cells and about14.19 logical-area cells at4x, with a visibly duller yellow spot. Its job.json inprogress-to-candidate change during peer review came from coordinator hd_job_queue.py bookkeeping in the1037 ledger refresh, not an artist/source change; both byte snapshots and exact unchanged artwork/source pins are preserved. STAG0240088 was subsequently inspected and admitted in batch1148; its earlier approval remained separate from the1071 proof.

## Final pre-Stage2 reviewer closures

The77-frame batch1148 contains six complete job families and21 manifest sequences;10410 contributes sixteen standalone sequences. Coordinator actually inspected all20 complete source/native1/HD4 pages on six unresampled boards and matched all385 source/scaled PPMs to independent accepted references. LargeAirv11 restores the connected inner lip and upper shoulder, accepts its one residual dim endpoint and other enumerated contour differences, and discloses stronger hot grain against smoother phases. STAG0240088 keeps original opaque internal architecture with darker gray/finer metal material. Terrain3011d–3012c retains straight gray remnants, damage routing and authentic warm flecks;10410–1041f retains native intact/damaged building panels, rock groups and stippled crossings. New damaged10410/12/14 sources and full-family state transitions are explicit. Terrain40175–40194 retains slopes/rock offsets/material boundaries and admits the genuine lower bush40179/7a after independent target review. Its cleanv2 raw excludes the preserved rejected gridv1. Six unused IDs remain gallery-only; zero state partners in those two Set4 jobs.

Root's Stage2 API edits and formatting intervened after the initial77 registration checks. The supplementary1148 attempt using d844a5d7 has all5,740 pixels byte-identical to accepted references, but its broad source-age guard correctly reads true. That attempt, its exact source snapshot and comparison remain under runtime-1148-pre-final-stage2-source; they were not relabeled or used as current-source certification. The definitive1148 render rebuilt the final formatted animation/effect.kind API epoch and preserved earlier1071/1037/800 output history. Packaged800 and private1037 copies remain unchanged.

Seven reviewers checkpointed their HD scopes during Stage2 integration; those temporary exclusions have now ended after root completed the release. Historical reviewer-transition evidence remains preserved. Their final exact reports are bound before the transition. Full-family Flare26v8 remains held for10258's five-cell and10266's two-cell transparent holes filled by old bindings, report65648399844683bc4287ce3d5bca5992ccdb602f1f18c5ef5b12eb1dbb13eb1a. Sparkle17v8 remains held for10277's ten-cell alpha-zero opening and10272–76's muted authentic bright ray-tip material, reportde6d412e1647168500778333c277d0823330c9b2d047fd3550ad09dd4bae562d. Artists may generate bounded sibling corrections for those exact two/six frame scopes while preserving other24/11 bindings and the whole frozen history; no self-approval or partial registration.

Terrain3 shard3 remains wholly unadmitted: twelve per-frame judgments are positive, but30112/13/19/1a lose surviving linear gray remnants. Complete shard4's sixteen bindings are separately admitted. The shared independent report755667dfb498724e17a35358d8d01541f51783b061cf26f80684c0d618ad68cb preserves both conclusions without implying joined64 exhaustive seams. Terrain10400's reporte8254870c26cf95c4add0a08ababa03e6108086a33aa2feadf4d3849bfc16a46 accepts fifteen exact bindings with original10406 fallback but holds the whole family on rectangular organic-ground slabs. Its genuine10406 sibling must preserve those fifteen accepted raw/bindings/outputs before complete-family admission. SHIP25 now has separate independent approval but is not included in1148; source-age and current pixel continuity remain required before admission.

## Private approved 1,148 release input

The separate private handoff at ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-1148-20261011/pack/ contains **1,148 frames / 421 complete sequences**, **398 files / 649,901,106 bytes**:396 artwork files plus hd.json/provenance.json. Its handoff-manifest.json SHA is `a701425c73fe671aca1015c4bed78218cde70fd193ff45ab7418031818ad3b31`; pack hd.json SHA is `5d6b0010049cf5d9d29612391faa72a35d867968f2ce31d6a8e9622e597e4ed8`. Original INDEX SHA remains `4ce78e5e638b6603114dd233ceaa41f386c0963ba4aa02ecf88ce0215b096681`. Every source/destination hash matches and every pack file has a private inode. Copied proof includes all5,740 accepted PPM matches, audit, runtime QA, provenance-correction journal and exact final Stage2 production API source epoch. Root copied all398 files into shared runtime data. The coordinator's read-only runtime-1148-copy-verification.json, SHA `7238d482ac7fbf7aa9c00348ab229f0a2722c014ecff5072146c68e213d6afde`, verifies every copied pack hash, 6,848 total data files / 663,083,964 bytes and the unchanged original INDEX. Root owns the current API executables, platform manifests, archive export and Stage2 validation; archive completion is not inferred from this data-copy check. Coordinator has not changed tracked runtime files. Earlier800/1037 private handoffs remain byte-exact.

Root authorized a scoped review-tool repair after Cargo retained two incompatible serde_core feature graphs. Commit `9dba15d` changes only tools/hd_candidate_review.py and its regression test. The helper now compiler-checks Manifest Deserialize/Serialize against the exact frozen game library and freezes the compatible serde_json dependency; dependency-selection.json and runtime QA record the attempted and selected identities. Helper SHA changed from `979558477b61507bf8be587b8f1fc148c3bb5d1f29b58c3b6f6f75aa569d299b` to `ad2ba9c350ecd8d1d59507a69f0a7da8386a3df231d0c9bb639d105b8ced7f80`; old bytes remain under .reference/hd-review-serde-alignment-fix/. A synthetic two-universe rustc regression passes, genuine636 selects compatible89b5 instead of11c796, and a fresh537005 actual SHIP25 gallery passes both source guards with all5 PPMs identical to accepted references. Verification summary SHA is `7976b991b2c47bc9583f9cdbaee60c7b15a512954216f89493a55069ab765de0`. No renderer, policy, raw pixels or production manifests changed.

Corrected complete10400–1040f candidate `2605e5ce6a4b02bbb6b021796e3d010745acf96c379cc23a4e1f1eab297bdaec` is now independently approved by report `7fe17ddcc8e71f75d112f3940b054d9de3091fb4fb9ede7cb198a1be2d57eae2`. Genuine organic10406 resolves the former rectangular-panel hold; fifteen accepted siblings remain exact. All2,380 context cases and4,840 PPMs are bound, with18 changed physical contexts reviewed at all scales. Its636 proof honestly records the later desktop source-age flag as true. This family and approved SHIP25 remain outside the already frozen1,148 handoff pending a later coordinator batch. The historical10406 whole-family hold remains intact.

Flare26v10 remains wholly held at exact candidate `0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3`, report `448d1e14825d5ade5d33a10fbc631c083bbd4dcd19facbacd11ddb3ad31fd2c8`. The corrected10258/66 source holes are clear, but10266 pale pinpoints and1026a/b hotter tails change the source material and late fade. Only those three genuine sibling corrections are reserved; other23 bindings and the whole history remain fixed. Sparkle17v11 is independently approved at candidate `2ba86de91a31034a187bc61adc8f7f3d757f14e0f4e2f9d0f52a3910fdf48d96`, report `c2cafad57d5fbe3e079c8d5aeadd4a4f4073d2a88a943660f5ea6ed1af8ab36e`. Its authentic holes, dark rim and bright tips are restored, with exact isolated corner losses, stronger grain and shade variation explicitly accepted. All85 current PPMs match frozen owner output; other11 bindings/55 outputs remain unchanged. Neither family is registered or included in the frozen1,148 runtime. IOTARG14, the four damaged-craft singles and complete terrain10420–1042f have subsequently closed independent review. Those five single pictures have also closed exact qualified approval. SHIP04G1/102fb v3 and complete shop23 diagnostic advice have now closed separately. Explicit Flare26v13 subsequently closed complete independent approval and coordinator preparation; its held main/v10 remains unchanged.

## Later approved artwork outside the release input

The immutable later-approved-68-ready.json journal, SHA `fbefe59fe55510be3d6e72180f35879c839a67994632d36589c24d50e6a8f871`, binds **68 frames in nine complete jobs**: SHIP25/1, corrected10400/16, Sparkle17, IOTARG14, four damaged-craft singles20099/200ae/200b1/200b4 and terrain10420–1042f/16. Independent artistic approvals, complete coordinator source/native1/HD4 inspection and exact accepted-output continuity are recorded for each cohort. All 340 original/scaled PPMs match their independently accepted references. These frames remain unregistered and outside the immutable 1,148 runtime input; possible future 1,216 registration and combined proof have not been performed. The preceding52 preparation journal stays byte-exact.

The later-approved-73-ready.json journal, SHA `94a2697fd9d70614f49f28a44b905da178486162471d6187055e6d2cf8df2d1b`, extends that preserved68 input with four explicit enemy-v2 singles and NUMBER10129: **73 frames / fourteen complete jobs / 365 exact accepted PPMs**, all unregistered outside1,148. The five-picture independent report is `8d8101ab8682b85572be70ee942befeccd87a2bc2a099790958b796ba6ad0ba8`; complete coordinator visual inspection is `8e433cf2c869dbfa94d7efb327772672471b7678bb87b1683dec1af77426a424`. An isolated combined73 proof at actual post-Host library `ee1fa1613717bfabbfa2894fee6af2cda933ac2d356b96e544cb16cc5b69e80e` reproduces all365 source/scaled outputs, comparison SHA `db8755d29828effa99fc9c69c56982f3c8f52920297f32ba35c2c3294754b3aa`. Relevant source-age guardfalse/broadtrue is preserved: desktop test bytes changed during invocation, while the observed post-change prefix9552e7d3 and graphics component hashes remain equal. This is isolated graphics continuity, not current full-game/Host certification or a1,221 registration/package handoff. Historical68 and52 journals remain immutable.

The later-approved-74-ready.json journal, SHA `f0826959ddfa4e7cd0e2ad743c20bd88e47d42f9ed1491135f347f48e6fde5c7`, adds the exact SHIP04G1/102fb v3 singleton to preserved73: **74 frames / fifteen complete jobs /370 exact accepted PPMs**. Membership audit `5688edee51ac9168dee8098529d1682ede5a6c8c39a033a3440d77e200f49ae0` verifies unique source IDs and zero overlap with1,148. Independent singleton report `64ce18c689e63cd9522a38bae8a8a3f10b8b42dada642c1c7ab1c3fd6e4e1d48` and coordinator inspection `703d601083ece8cb569e0a627b84ac1de134b4084eed3a0f06e174f385002c25` accept the original blunt wings, central strake, lower wings/tail and occupied dark backing with fine metal grain and three ordinary15/16 edge cells at4x. The entire untouched1254-square raw and complete source/native1/HD4 board were viewed. Comparison `adb8e4d4894a55af0e6828a8e386df0d40691d050b61c8ce459ce42542f16ffd` reproduces all five peer outputs on actual immutable4cad6385/matchedba61, both source guards false and all source hashes stable during invocation. No aggregate74 current-source or combined1,222 proof, registration or runtime handoff is inferred.

The four v2 craft preserve source machinery, bronze/teal/gray regions and dark backing. Tiny200e7 native boundary losses are accepted with all source cells restored at3–4; four200e1 red252/green253 lamps retain exact footprints. NUMBER preserves original746 lettering cells and counter centers, accepting brighter pearlescent lavender/blue and high-scale boundary filling/fringe without falsely claiming transparent-hole byte identity. The complete five-frame source/native1/HD4 board was inspected unresampled at1776x568.

IOTARG14 report `ad3b5618793ba5f8833eee9fb763ee0a85bc9e8b5bc19f9323f419505745bbad` accepts authentic shutter heights/order, eight perimeter anchors, the dark cavity/dome and centered six-cell amber footprint in all eight fully-open phases. Darker soil, slight fixed-body shade/grain variance and high-scale color-threshold changes remain explicit. The four-single report `58cdd6213bbb248cd605149828ba9695ee6f4aec0c5e35504ea91e803871de15` accepts source damaged architecture and genuine252/253 lamps with no added dynamic cells. 20099's five native outline losses return at2–4; limited ordinary4x edge partials remain disclosed in all four exact candidates. No paired-damage or live assembled-object claim is inferred.

Each cohort retains its actual invocation source epoch and library. The four singles' fresh default release `da05d6104a484ef9129f755c9c90bb896696d0d2fdbd409314a6392cc992df43`, origin libraptor_replica-f076ad67c588e355.rlib, has both age guards false at invocation and20 exact PPM matches. Their earlier1a6 attempt with broad-age true remains separate. Subsequent root desktop test-module additions make earlier proofs historical again; no old guard is relabeled and no blanket current-source claim is made across these cohorts.

Complete terrain10420–1042f approval is report `1e6a874bf088bbbfa7e3fd4283791515a839b9e6f81a88eec11dd61f2cb8c2a1` at candidate `f2d7e3acb9fe53148f3fa58a411e498317ac7b5adf9495bcc5261556817eddb8`. All609 cardinal pairs and48 native scenes were independently viewed; the old sheets' occluded scene rows are excluded, and corrected12 complete-scene sheets are bound instead. Coordinator current80 sprite PPMs are exact at immutable library `ec8f03bf5eaf1fd1d698b7a111cfa5265043ef009f24b4b7a42e8579fb7f9211`, with both source-age flags false at invocation, and all16 full source/native1/HD4 canvases inspected on an unresampled912x1408 board. Comparison SHA `77e58f93c1b661e917b39ecdf2310d607f113f9fd1a45cc17e7ca85c080a2d4d`; inspection SHA `a1a51c690b188b650b840e2e11f04837dc16c7ffe81de3ba0125055d0c158e23`. Paths, stone groups, curved boundaries and corrected organic gravel retain source identity; mixed fallback detail density, zero state partners and no new Host claim remain explicit.

Root then announced a real desktop production correction so enemy and shadow drawing honor mod pinned_art_frame. Every preceding whole-source-age flag and desktop prefix is preserved as its historical epoch; the former8bbd prefix is not asserted as current after this edit. Sprite/terrain loading and the b30 compositor remain unchanged according to root, while new Host certification requires the rebuilt executable and actual source checks. The shared1,148 artwork input stays frozen.

The complete23 shop-icon family remains a frozen diagnostic under correction, not an admission candidate. Coordinator report `f7ffaf5bb08fb91a173b5b03150db7934ecb2a8301577ecedb1ad11a65dd1184` binds115 current original/scaled PPMs identical to the author, all four complete five-scale pages and the full untouched monitor raw. Its actual indexed proof uses library38af886709b5a18061385ae39a8995a87de72f575267fbd3b9e15960b39155f6 and compiler-compatible serde, with both source-age guards false at invocation. Source monitor102f7 row23 contains six separate occupied RGB4 tips at x2/4/9/12/17/19; current art replaces them with two broad metal bars, adding13 fully opaque logical cells at every scale. The occupied x12/y20–23 dark mounting strip is wholly missing at every scale. A genuine local lower-region correction must restore those tips, gaps and strip while preserving the existing screen/body; global crop/shift or dark-color compensation is not a remedy. Independent full23 source/raw/all-scale advice is now complete, report `ce58351c27bc0b96dfa10fc4462d8e56e9bddcf4bb045a1643735910dbde81d4`; no partial or whole-family art approval follows. Exactly102e7 four bottom RGB4 cells,102eb backing at(23,7),102f6 broad matte gray/dark-red material and102f7 tips/mount/corner are reserved for genuine separate sibling corrections. The f6 metal/caps became broadly too bright, with source gray121 becoming native203 and dark-red cap97/8/16 becoming178/48/56. Other19 bindings/crops/provenance remain frozen. Excluded raw alpha16–31 specks in f6/f7 are disclosed; every alpha32 pixel is retained. All23 full raws and complete scale pages were independently viewed, with115 PPMs owner-exact. Later failed monitorv8 remains excluded.

Read-only completion of original Set4 job31's previously uninspected24 contexts/86 pairs/four historical Host captures is preserved in .reference/hd-coordinator-set4-job31-page-completion/completion-review.json, SHA `f0d9ac0b8ba9f7145caff675b0cf588694687e04d5d15bcfcf22ce0e09100613`. All pages were viewed on unresampled boards, and80 fresh sprite PPMs equal the author's historical output. Soil-density squares, smoother crater rims and stronger relief remain pending independent material judgment. There is no new Host/composer replay, job32 approval or registration.

## Private development1,037 input

A separate immutable development input is published at ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-1037-20261011/pack/. Its handoff-manifest.json SHA is `51a857fc9a1e584e00ece4800436e3c9411de5c1fba8a25e527c65d1ee542d4f`; hd.json SHA is `707ab815114579828bcb823cc3e62efa80ea05b54ae83e83dc30c5730cde0e96`. It contains1,037 frames/396 complete sequences,366 distinct files/569,685,991 bytes, with source INDEX, complete source/scale proof and original build identity pinned. Every file is a private copy with verified bytes and a distinct inode; future development mutation cannot change the handoff. This is a preserved historical assembly input, superseded by the separately verified1,148 runtime copy. The original packaged800 handoff remains untouched.

## Frozen Linux/Windows800 history

The separate historical runtime-800-current/combined-review.json remains unchanged:3,200 scales/4,000 accepted PPMs using immutablef71826f4eec106d59a55c12380ee1437a3cfeddf6f9d145480624ff5e5b8eaa5. Historical929,979,1037 and1071 closures remain separate and are not retroactively associated with a newer library. Root's later test-only terrain capture fixes did not alter the production desktop prefix, loader, compositor or shaders.

The private immutable handoff is ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-800-20261011/pack/, pack manifest SHA `fbf8b6a9af134e263881ce28f002259affbf0636f53d214ea34bbd8c61205f71`. handoff-manifest.json SHA `29821d06c34114101041e50318c5c013a9236e474716a382257d6d252c304b1e` binds292 pack files:290 artwork files plus hd.json/provenance.json. Root copied and verified all into tracked data:6,742 files/461,771,350 bytes. Later348 development approvals are not included in that runtime snapshot.

Native Windows third CI38121272504 passed279 tests/0failed/24ignored, exact committedGNU launcher/gameplay/full800/all22mods and a freshMSVC build. Linux/Windows relocated launch, catalog, SDL and audio checks passed. Root documentation proof is fb6574a. Final Windows archive SHA25fca23c5ca95b754cf49fcf24b07d94dec8094863e6750c1898a55d6893cbfe,602433522bytes; Linux SHA0f384c3592a1a6d9302c16769cd8aafb096464fe17150ea1a66b34743fbdc97a. Both archiveCRC/data/runtime/source/doc checks passed. No further packaged art changes are authorized by this development metadata checkpoint.

Metadata-only provenance corrections preserve before-byte snapshots and exact actual attempt/request/prompt authority. All raw/candidate/source/render bindings stay unchanged. Cursor's absent historical request JSON remains disclosed; no retrospective request history was invented. Buoy center252/253 and cyan/water240–244 wording corrections likewise retain prior bytes. BUTTON's four corrected transparency flags were independently verified.

## Final Stage2 release and preserved runtime

Root completed Stage2 acceptance at committed/pushed `51ab388ea0e3cbe111dbe3d65baca5a927bf72d1`. Its release checkpoint is .reference/iron-coast-stage2/release-checkpoint.json; acceptance SHA `3bd05c1abdd730fbdc695ffdb21d6d188aa7477e55080a24978b8451fe9235a0`. Final Linux ZIP SHA is `dc6fcad7736d9f57b8577408f9af06ba913682ed3120068bc2df0ba73cd48a2e`; Windows ZIP SHA is `2c83c00495ddba9fadc0d4e28d9e678f3a50c1e3aaed582285b2afaae9689e4b`. Strict successor checks retain exact binaries, libraries, data, all45 mod bytes and23 final pins. Native Windows run38129755440 succeeded with312 platform-conditional portable tests, saved route, GNU/MSVC export, phase/shadow regressions,34 actual previews, full1148HD/45mods and separate audio validation. Root also completed315 headless and380 desktop release tests.

The temporary reviewer and shared Cargo exclusions have ended. Original HD production and exclusive reviews resume; coordinator may update owned documentation and outer development registrations. Packaged RustRaptor/data1148, runtime manifests/executables and all accepted Stage2 mods remain immutable until root coordinates another runtime snapshot. Artists share the existing four-slot generation gate. No mod art counts toward the original5753 catalog.

## Preserved141-frame preparation and subsequent registration

../data/hd/registered-class-review/later-approved-141-ready.json, SHA `ee561301a1b30a7eaf3f15796dd9bba76d9956a6c49c8aa1921f54ba959ff373`, closed **141 then-unregistered original frames /23 complete jobs /705 accepted PPMs** before the subsequent outer1289 registration. Membership audit SHA `967bfba455559134e2afaa665b81019969801900a6342e6cb8394019badd01d1` proves unique IDs and zero overlap with frozen1148. Earlier74/100/106 journals remain exact. The1289 pack has now been verified and registered externally, with an immutable private input handed to root; no runtime copy/export has been performed.

The preserved74 cohort now has an aggregate current startup probe: all370 accepted PPMs match, report `a6db05524ca6ecff463d36b9cedcddd0665c7f6e7a6de5b098dbbab63f413b10`. Flare26v13 adds130 exact source/scaled outputs, comparison `7a6c9ebe54fa9ec5b91d1f66aee682de8cf274e55dd1693d318107553a54312b`, with all seven full raws and nine complete comparison/phase pages inspected. Corrected66 has no ivory hotspot, exact378-cell footprint/two-cell hole and restrained warmer amber grain; final A/B tails restore original dim brown fade with qualified local peaks and one4x fringe sample. Earlier contour/hole-boundary qualifications remain; whole26 source-cell identity is not claimed.

Static6 adds ADPIC1–4, smalllogo10015 and BASE4006e explicitv4. All six full raws and six complete source/actual1–4 boards were inspected;30 peer PPMs match, comparison `5756039ef486b950b20bc8f0cc55fbb0012af7622dc0ce11d26f223572ff5ad9`, inspection `09d8d34200abc0d85f08960b07ec2b1e035caf9f0b3775b6ac034962ed11bec3`. Source ADPIC counts/layout survive inaccurate prompt history. Brighter logo orange/seven dark edge additions and BASE's darker gray,20/21 warm native footprint plus exact centered yellow highlight are accepted explicitly; no live UI/Host route follows.

Phase35 comprises complete PLATOON2/6, DMOON/7, TARG1G4/11 and TARG2G4/11. All five complete builtin raws, ten complete source/actual1–4 boards and five material-focus panels were inspected. All175 peer PPMs match, comparison `51d2ea38577401dd953ca6198995ca2c032cd9c8142482feda03612aacadba70`, inspection `89f02f7239e3a240567b78f4b09e7310b2564740b952cfbd2790cbbe9d60e2bd`. Six-figure poses, source mechanism order, dark cavities and warm core placement remain faithful. A few PLATOON low-scale edges, darker DMOON intermediate arms, quieter TARG fixed paint, darker early/brighter final shafts and smooth-to-grained part transitions remain accepted differences. TARG2's independently recovered warm classifier is separately bound by addendum `865ee668ba9b7747fe6b7b1e1b69868e89d6565a74284b3ebaaa1d582efabd12`; old reports and all artwork are unchanged.

## Durable owners and outstanding holds

Ongoing independent scopes preserve the exact original1465 context authority: Terrain1/192, Terrain2/80, Terrain3/96, Set4/256. Current admissions240/176/176/304 are not silently substituted.

- hd_full_review approved corrected Set4 original17 warm-earth-v5,22 well-fleck-v2 and23 brown-edge-v2; these remain future-only. It now exclusively reviews whole corrected10460 then10470 material siblings as a different peer. Historical coarse-material holds and all inputs remain unchanged.
- iron_coast_2 approved complete Set4 original31/32 and35/36 and now reviews39/40; iron_coast_6 approved33/34 and now reviews37/38. All new holds/qualified approvals are complete-family decisions; later shared quarters remain provenance/original fallback.
- iron_coast_3 approved Terrain3 original14–19 and late37–40; these remain future-only. It now reviews late41/42 after full owner snapshots. Original late37–68 is proposal-complete506targets/514raws, not admitted by production coverage.
- iron_coast_5 approved Terrain2 original14–16,18/19 and21. Original17 coarse water was repaired in a separate now-approved sibling. Original20 remains whole-held for six dark water atlas-divider edges20241/43/45/47/49/4b; an early one-water method check precedes the separate six-source correction. It now reviews originals22/23.
- windows_persistence approved the four corrected64-frame cohort now registered in1748 and the later original17 three-water sibling, outside1748.2018d pipe-ribv4 remains whole-held: all17 fourth-band cells become cyan water at native1. No further blind pipe attempt is reserved.
- terrain_capture_fixture completed10480/90/104a0 approvals;104a0 remains future-only. Final2069f v3 advice is KEEP HELD: genuine source interleaved green/checker footprints became physical outlined stone paving and native green merges into olive/gray. Full13/206a0 remains held; no fourthf/a0 request.
- hd_terrain_set_1 has240 registered pictures. New10460/70 complete material siblings are frozen for the different peer; disjoint104b0 may record partial_source_pass with contexts pending, but every complete-family case must be inspected before freeze. There is no partial acceptance.
- hd_terrain_set_2 has176 registered targets and90 proposal families/1,437 IDs. Exact plantedv2/grassv5/hardwarev4/D6finewaterv3 sibling bytes were promoted with old mains SHA-preserved. Unregistered original25 quality probes stay partial held; smaller atlas divider failure is retained and source-single trials remain bounded. Final13 green/paving stays held.
- Terrain3 middle has128 own registered targets. Original14–19 peer approvals remain pending coordinator review;20/21 are author-held. Original22 production continues;301ae stays missing/no-retry. Source/raw/proof bytes in all peer freezes remain immutable.
- campaign_release_review preserves source/raw/history throughout author-frozen original44 and ongoing45. Source-contour-only repairs402a1/402ab are separate whole16 siblings; no crop/pixel compensation. All current39/40 and37/38 author/shared-parent freezes remain exact.
- Dark-player worm caps, original opaque-scene aspect/border failures, rotor/lamp/tab failures and service refusal history remain held. RITE/LEFT plans and MKS/SDL/opaque policy questions remain separate; no extra worm/opaque execution is implied.

The1748 pending snapshot records546 unique independently approved unregistered pictures, all requiring coordinator complete-source/raw/material/current-output review. Sixteen original12 pictures also have a missing saved-prompt provenance gap requiring parent policy. No generic5753 completion or universal seamlessness claim is made.

## Startup PNG source epoch and current continuity

Root's real assets.rs/modding.rs optimization shares checked_png validation extracted from the existing decoder; root independently compared6682 referenced PNG indexed outputs and passed five rejection/output regressions. Prior API and Host proof epochs retain their literal historical flags. Coordinator's frozen1148 startup proof now reproduces all5740 accepted PPMs, SHA `d07e0228538f562a1338724119af000306db199ef4792d7fd14c31e4b333e447`, on actual4cad6385/ba61 compatible Serde. Both invocation guards are false;17 prior/after top-level source pins are stable and nested OPL3 is separately pinned at closure, without inventing a missing preflight hash. Every398 pack file remains exact across private1148, external registration and packaged runtime, continuity SHA `a786b51a3c56e9b911e21eed6eb6020b45511112c86b926f640230151284bd1b`; original INDEX remains unchanged.

Current later74, Flare26, static6 and phase35 proofs use immutable c0c3cfc7d4784afaf60342bf7f02b7db25fcd803c1fdc01faffd027116582338 with compiler-selected Serde ba61a9b6a7f97c994c6fdb2ab5e50915a5d6b456664f31709fd05306d56e48bd. Both age guards are false and all18 recursive Rust source hashes/mtimes remain exact through each invocation. The complete catalog remains unfinished. Continue source-driven work and exclusive review, then perform combined continuity before later registration; keep packaged1148 and approved Stage2 content frozen.


## Closed1289 outer development registration

Batch1289 registers141 frames/23 complete jobs only after full current6445 accepted source/scaled PPM matches, no diagnostics, both source guards false and all18 recursive source hashes/mtimes stable. Combined proof SHA `9dc65ca9244e9cf6b11b7ebe5f215496f93d625f1e4800f6d2546102491f6ee2`; approval SHA `ffee98a9a086c022df268f1eb41ddab1d57c2dcbc4243528d5b9f2c3ea3b0fb8`; registration SHA `d61b8197c6d357e854fbf3f230d65d6d47414fd5cf0ca0162144b93e8873090d`. Outer hd.json SHA is `a105eb4fc4d851313d1885a5602ced0843d775641218ffa252c2fc0c0f000416`. Its sequence map equals the privately rendered1289 proposal exactly.81 new contact pages are hash-recorded, not falsely described as newly viewed; exact accepted rasters retain the preceding complete visual judgments. No new combined terrain seam, Host assembly, timing or UI-route proof is inferred.

The canonical registration tool required11 explicit accepted siblings to become mains. Their prior mains and coordinator reviews are preserved in exact SHA-named snapshots, with promotion records per job. No generated PNG/crop/explicit sibling changed. The official queue refresh preserves698 pre-refresh metadata files;75 job.json changes are limited to owner/status/count/review metadata. Source/target/native-context/contract declarations remain exact, receipt `dfc14393b7e5408577bf11103e35d071d3ad2046730ffa3fef1d081699ab584d`. Current coverage audit SHA `d06a6035ee3fc95a62ee8379d96a0605ea2ba936361a1b0180445b9eb36e2804` has zero HD errors; ledger SHA `231afe112d21c242b55939efeee7b1ec36644a15744ae27b30d14e39498b79dc` retains source-required5753 scope and no unused-picture exclusions.

The immutable future input is ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-1289-20261011/pack/,1289 frames/474 sequences,467 files/781747237 bytes. Every file has a private inode and verified source/destination hash. Handoff manifest SHA `a61a4063171f9d58ebe3dcfcd7590aa405ce77ca1e32121dba2b65ef886015e6`; proof includes the exact current output closure, approval/registration, ledger/audit and source snapshots. Parent alone controls a later runtime copy/export. Shared RustRaptor/data, packaged manifests/executables/libraries and all45 accepted mods stay at the completed1148 release snapshot.

Subsequent exact peer decisions remain separate: Terrain3 original5 APPROVE16 but whole6 held for3014c red-brown pit drift; original7/8 APPROVE32. Terrain2 original6 whole16 held for20161/62/63 planted-green loss, original7 APPROVE16. Corrected Set4 original14 sibling APPROVE16 preserves15 outputs and removes401b4 macroblocks; original held main remains intact. Rotorv6 still fails connected opaque source backing and another painted blade cell despite improved phase material; a single bounded genuine contrasting-backdrop/background-removal trial is reserved, without manual pixel or loader compensation. WORMDN8 requests material/animation advice only. This paragraph records the historical post1289 queue. Exact original5/7/8, original7 and corrected Set4 original14 were subsequently registered in1465; remaining holds stay outside both releases.


## Closed1465 outer development registration

Batch1465 registers176 terrain frames in11 complete jobs, adding71 manifest sequences to1289 for a total1465/545. Approval SHA `f37ba1764c3c8f3d71c05f2fde211f339c1a531a57b0700e1a1d649866b393b1` and canonical registration SHA `8093a0728ebb253b55d0bbbfbee164bcabd7b55c163c8b001f2a6744cec2d045` follow complete source/raw/native1–4/material/context/state judgments. Full current comparison SHA `4a6b5bebf6f954eb2adff08e890fe91de78f7b7045a30ea41cc0b1c658f7de09` closes all7325 source/scaled PPMs (5860 scaled outputs), both source-age guards false, exact c0c3 library/ba61 Serde and all18 recursive source hashes/mtimes stable. Every1289 frame binding is exact. Current hd.json SHA `7bedf2d9d016d50727f886dd3e0dc627602152007a1ceab7185352e36ea823e8` equals the privately rendered1465 proposal by complete frame bindings.184 combined contact pages are hash-recorded, not claimed freshly viewed; independently accepted source/material judgments remain separately bound.

Coordinator actually inspected68 eligible full untouched raw PNGs and22 complete source/native1–4 boards across176 targets. One additional held job5 raw, two held full boards and two focused green boards were also inspected and excluded. Set4 original13–16/64 keeps cliff/rock/industrial topology, accepted quieter corrected401b4 soil and15 exact siblings. Terrain2 original4/7/32 retains original compound/roof/water/dome/channel geometry, with thinner/brighter rails and ripple/grain/fallback-island differences accepted. Terrain1 10430/40/32 retains original panels/rocks/cues and eight authentic wrecks;1044c-v2 alone removes five unsupported studs. Some native-tone planes remain visibly coarser/quieter than rougher neighboring raws and are accepted explicitly. Terrain3 original5/7/8/48 retains quiet black char/rust, gray fragments, pale cap/cyan footprints and source emerald panels; source-grid30165 remnant steps and richer fine material are qualified, without seamlessness or uniform-detail claims.

Terrain2 original5 remains wholly held for20153/54/55/5a/5b/5c green bands. The full original peer approval remains preserved; coordinator hold SHA `e7006e17489184b91c230ee285de17d33bc4273e2074e84a0ec4718060d9be1c` binds direct native1/4 focus views and the supporting source30/81/44/72/161/70 green counts versus allzero native1. Original6v4,3014c correction and reserved rotor/lamp/tab/monitor failures require separate review; no partial-family admission. The new DSHP20G3 three-phase author geometry hold and pending dark-ship singles likewise remain outside this batch. WORMDN/WORMRITE/WORMLEFT request complete animation/material advice only.

Bookkeeping receipt `26abfbaa34c602652ec648786a21597752372f67526bf050bdca2b498f7d4d34` preserves700 before-refresh metadata files and19 queues. Forty-eight global job.json updates plus one concurrent author claim change only owner/status/count/embedded-review metadata; every source/context/contract is exact. Audit SHA `92478ee534c580ac9d404bcc91641e25a16e170e2f1bb8678d25721c77a8757b` reports1465 registered/4288 remaining/zeroHD errors; ledger SHA `c00f7ba532fe32fa2ecfd22a7898d4f0b2b2be009f5d43279c23ed58412d7175` retains all5753 picture targets and no unused exclusions. The old held Set4 original14 main is a byte-exact SHA-named snapshot before exact accepted sibling promotion; no raw/art/crop changed.

The immutable future input at ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-1465-20261011/pack/ contains1465 frames/545 sequences,534 files/990735382 bytes, all copied to private inodes with exact hashes. Handoff SHA `92cb019a147728e72e966708e0651e094d0a6a2137d8026797bc9be2ea9a1d4d` binds audit/ledger/current proof/source/registration receipts. All6853 packaged bin/lib/data files remain unchanged, before/after inventory SHA `6fc0642c24cae2ba04bab30ab4cd0547d62c965421b1cb49026aa8a48d351653`; runtime remains1148/421 and45 accepted Stage2 mods. No runtime assembly/export or new whole-map/live Host/palette timing/UI-route claim is made. Parent alone coordinates a future runtime snapshot.


## Closed1652 outer development registration

Batch1652 registers187 original pictures in15 complete jobs:176 terrain, three damaged-craft singles and eight classic menu words. Approval SHA `fd9bea0bdba0f6d1d7feec5621420834f7f65fa4bb0d26ce76bfb1a5e2610d18` and canonical registration SHA `9d8de971638905c18fb8e11c5b7fae257998ac180691e1e94ae1a4fca8221268` bind every exact candidate, raw, original and independent judgment. Full current comparison SHA `aace2408b3c9d7fe05f4d08b8671f4df6e048f688aa5fed14f020e6e42912128` closes8,260 source/scaled PPMs (6,608 scaled outputs): all7,325 prior1465 outputs and935 new outputs match exactly. Both literal source guards are false, immutable library c0c3 and compiler-compatible Serde ba61 are exact, and all18 recursive source SHA/size/mtime records are stable. Current hd.json SHA `6d07c714205662d65fc16898fb496a43db61bb9e3205b05cec166845fa229443` has605 sequences and every1465 baseline frame binding unchanged. Provenance SHA `7b44e85be8574d327320af13bb141b5d476c2677d54d9aa509d227580e4303be` binds the same actual validation. The104 combined contact pages are hash-bound, not relabeled as freshly viewed.

Coordinator actually reviewed219 proposals with135 full unchanged raw-image views and35 complete source/native1–4 boards;187 selected and32 held. Selected new artwork uses102 distinct raw PNGs. Complete10450 retains four authentic wrecks and selected muted54/5d corrections; Terrain2 originals8/10 retain source compound/coast/water geometry; Terrain3 originals9–12 retain remnants/panels/markers with fine grain/value qualifications. The matching-identity complete3014c correction sibling is registered directly with original15 bindings exact and source-dark pit restored; original held mainf1e1a5b is unchanged. Set4 originals18–20 retain industrial source damage/context identities. Three damaged craft have native source masks and exact reserved light coordinates, with measured darker/lighter gray material and highscale contours disclosed. Menu8 retains source words/gaps/counters/baseline with brighter copper and tiny enumerated dim edges/fringe accepted.

Whole10460/10470 remain unregistered. Additive fixture clarification SHAs `f9ee03e0653f7884ffc8ce8efad0f229e9c7ced6ae5c4fc0b9de130913b8afdc` and `797008b0b4dcbb1d21ee3b1592a68e52d3ea21a6ce70fa1f4f20c5f69745b18e` candidly preserve historical acceptance of enlarged cells and correct overbroad fine-grain wording. Exact fourteen targets10461/63–66/6a–6d and10474/76/77/79/7a require genuine continuous fine material within original source geometry/colors; other seven/eleven siblings stay exact. Geometry/palette numeric passes do not waive material judgment.

Bookkeeping receipt `e807e545bd51dbc379433f571cba466f050e23947b735fd7763c4c6c759d85e8` checks all698 job source/context contracts and preserves720 original/interim metadata files. Thirty-six final payload changes affect derived status/count/owner/review only. A queue refresh accidentally began before audit completion and read old1465; its entire interim state is saved, then one sequential refresh against completed1652 produced1632 registered plus20 reachable,2778 candidates,683 in-progress and640 missing. Byte-identical rewritten job files also changed mtimes, explicitly disclosed to active reviewers. A separate closure assertion mistakenly expected635 sequences; it failed before closure writes and was corrected to605 (the excluded32 targets were standalone sequences). Both exact failed-attempt histories are retained; neither affected art, registration bindings or runtime pixels. Audit SHA `3a90095a51fdfd0748c1ec51cf60c18a42a1812feddc4b243319d4d89b6586c1` reports1652/4101/zero errors; ledger SHA `22b6ee44bee7c7f0392590a0fb4277ee555fec9391d4fbced31b997b3f0b9588` retains all5753 required targets.

Immutable future handoff ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-1652-20261011/pack/ contains1,652 frames/605 sequences,636 files/1263053074 bytes with verified distinct inodes. Handoff SHA `2b89b62f0b673a2fbbff31441307af0fd6bfa9fe89fa33c893a7399acd801556` binds all pack/proof/source/audit/ledger/pending histories. All6,853 packaged bin/lib/data files remain byte-identical, inventory SHA `6fc0642c24cae2ba04bab30ab4cd0547d62c965421b1cb49026aa8a48d351653`; shared runtime remains1,148/421 and45 accepted Stage2 mods. No runtime copy/export, whole-map seam, live Host, palette-time or UI-route proof is inferred. Parent alone coordinates a later runtime snapshot.


## Closed1748 outer development registration

Batch1748 adds96 terrain pictures in six complete families, yielding1,748/5,753 originals in701 sequences and896 terrain pictures. Approval `fc2c4de1ba0263b39c90628f9194f9623e4774c37c2b90bf0a0be7569b5f1e46`, canonical registration `a39194c9e176a29a6283bb2b5e6e931e2046ff666cea04836b986c57c47e4937` and whole actual proof `c5e0a7a97a27f85e2200609be77bbb0f69ad76e046597a883e4728910028bae6` bind every accepted original/raw/candidate/peer judgment. All8,740 source/scaled outputs match:8,260 baseline plus480 new,6,992 scaled. Every1652 baseline frame remains exact. Actual c0c3/compatible ba61 dependencies, both literal false freshness flags and18 recursive source SHA/size/mtime pins remain stable. Current manifest `f74a3dc7a973258d9eb13896b39e78c957710f4ab999d87ffbe415ffbe6de274`, provenance `75c96e18cbb4ed2d0bb7d4783d455617b767f968430f3bc593cb7de9dda7176f`. The110 full-pack contact pages are hash-bound; actual coordinator visual authority is47 full raw canvases and24 complete source/native1–4 boards, plus separate peer full contexts/state proofs.

10480/90 source rail/shore/building/one-wreck geometry is retained with fine continuous material, stronger relief, darker water and original-fallback islands qualified. Planted green row breaks/soil gaps are repaired;20161 continuous grass replaces the checker finish, with39→34 weaker native green samples and all39 green at higher scales qualified.201b8 restores nine broad gray tabbed bodies/square gold plates, native297/81 positions exact, brighter highscale bevel edges qualified.201d6 five3/3/2/3/3 source supports retain narrow center and authentic side stepping; fine water replaces coarse grid with one warm support sample becoming neutral gray and darker/dense cyan ripple differences qualified. Whole families are accepted; no exact RGB or highscale contour identity is claimed.

Canonical registration required four exact approved sibling-byte promotions under their existing parent identities. B/batch-1748-approval-before retains old candidate/coordinator/job bytes in SHA-named copies; all explicit siblings/raw/source/crop/proof bytes remain exact.698 job source/context contracts are checked; only eight derived job payloads changed (six registered parents and two completed/current Terrain3 production jobs). Receipt `9c54e806d6190644920b041b224c7f2275bcf28102e15ea1535158e1ab283946` preserves every old byte. A private wrapper uses unmodified official queue computation/locks/writer but skips identical serialized writes, preserving all690 byte-identical job mtimes. Audit completed before queue derivation; current ledger1728registered+20reachable=1748,2705candidate,676inprogress,624missing. No prior metadata incident is overwritten.

Immutable future input ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-1748-20261012/pack/ has683 files/1,417,761,478 bytes and private inodes; handoff `62fcbf7d286125c065ab374bad3fde39fb3812b62fa057d5ece5d4a3d936ddde`. All636 old1652 handoff files and all6,853 packaged bin/lib/data files remain exact, runtime inventory `6fc0642c24cae2ba04bab30ab4cd0547d62c965421b1cb49026aa8a48d351653`; shared runtime1,148/421 and45 Stage2 mods are unchanged. Parent alone coordinates later runtime copying/build/export. This closes an outer development batch, not the original5753 catalog, live Host, UI routes, palette timing, complete boss assemblies or invisible whole-map seams.