{ "decision_basis": "Personal whole Original/reference/raw/28nativeHD views plus diagnostic comparisons; no numeric-green/index/mask-only approval.", "old3050a_qualification_and_old7_HOLDs_unchanged": true, "reviewer": "/root/iron_coast_2", "rows": [ { "asset": "304fd", "disposition": "QUALIFIED_WITH_LIMITS", "finding": "Whole dark upper/left field, lower-right green ground contact and narrow pale triangular tip remain recognizable. Tip begins at the Original13,17 anchor at native1 and all higher views; the narrow gray continuation follows the existing direction.", "qualifications": [ "Native1 pale tip is softer/narrower in extent than Original; no exact shade/shape claim.", "At2\u20134 the lower gray continuation is brighter and reads farther as pale material than in Original; it is a stronger interpretation of existing gray continuation, not a separately added appendage.", "Fine chips and green grain are stronger; joins remain unreviewed." ] }, { "asset": "30503", "disposition": "QUALIFIED_WITH_LIMITS", "finding": "Connected green ground remains a broad readable upper/left/middle plane around the asymmetric compact brown fork. Gray right/bottom fragments and black separations retain their distinct roles.", "qualifications": [ "Brown fork and gray chips have stronger depth/relief and high-scale highlights.", "Green surface is denser/finer and includes olive/dark shading; native1 smooths the finer texture.", "No precise Original color-cell or edge-join equivalence." ] }, { "asset": "30504", "disposition": "QUALIFIED_WITH_LIMITS", "finding": "Dark left field, separated upper green patch and larger right green region remain readable around the brown remnant and gray fragments at all scales. Green does not collapse to isolated highlights.", "qualifications": [ "Brown and gray fragments have stronger rocky relief and fine highlights.", "Green has brighter/denser small-grain texture; native1 is softer.", "No all-placement or seamless transition claim." ] }, { "asset": "30506", "disposition": "QUALIFIED_WITH_LIMITS", "finding": "Upper-left and lower-left green masses remain connected around the brown fork with clipped edge contacts; the broad right field remains dark charcoal.", "qualifications": [ "Brown remnant and gray fragments carry more relief than Source.", "Dark field gains finer charcoal/gravel texture and green surface is denser; native1 detail compresses.", "Foreign/context exposure remains unreviewed." ] }, { "asset": "30508", "disposition": "QUALIFIED_WITH_LIMITS", "finding": "Small upper-right green corner survives visibly, separate from the jagged gray fingers and large dark center. Gray/dark orientation remains coherent at all four scales.", "qualifications": [ "The corner is quiet at native1; high-scale gray chips are sharper and more raised.", "Dark cavity/ground carries richer fine grain than Original.", "No exact silhouette-sample or contact-join approval from opaque mask counts." ] }, { "asset": "3050b", "disposition": "QUALIFIED_WITH_LIMITS", "finding": "Upper-right green/gray contact remains spatially recognizable against the predominantly quiet dark field. Clipped gray pieces stay separate, with no new object or missing broad dark region.", "qualifications": [ "Brown mottling grows around the Original single235-index brown sample; the new contact is less purely green and native1 is subdued. This is a visible material qualification, not hidden as exact Source equivalence.", "Fine dark grain and stronger small gray fragments remain.", "Green presence counts support saved-body truth only; acceptance follows the whole visual contact, not a palette threshold." ] }, { "asset": "3050c", "disposition": "QUALIFIED_WITH_LIMITS", "finding": "Broad upper green remnant remains a continuous ground region at native1\u20134, with embedded separate gray fragments and a predominantly dark lower field.", "qualifications": [ "Denser green/moss-like fine grain, stronger gray chips and fine charcoal lower texture are authored variations.", "Native1 smooths details and texture-density boundary remains visible.", "Genuine neighboring placements and joins are a later review." ] } ], "status": "QUALIFIED7_HOLD0_INTRINSIC_ONLY" }