{ "actual_game_cleanup_QA_World_generation_or_registrar_calls": 0, "author": "/root/industrial_remaining", "author_test_rerun": { "command": "python3 -B -m unittest discover -s .reference/hd-302e1-fixed-quiet-floor-CODE-proposal-20261019-v1 -p test_followon302e1_quiet_floor_cleanup.py -v", "elapsed_seconds": 1.453, "errors": 0, "exit_code": 0, "failures": 0, "tests": 36 }, "author_tests": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-302e1-fixed-quiet-floor-CODE-proposal-20261019-v1/test_followon302e1_quiet_floor_cleanup.py", "sha256": "2e283b4cf6e59866186ab9e447dba402c04e518593a4063cc1178ed476aba677" }, "canonical_Git_mutations": 0, "checks": [ "Exact every-byte delta from prior5df17helper is METHOD tag,302e1only fineband sigma3/clip16/strength0.5branch, and truthful perasset receipt. All other functions, buffered descriptor I/O, dependency pinning/compilation, freshoutput/diskguard and Sourcegeometry/retention code unchanged.", "Independent convolution oracle matches sigma3 residual; the genuine RGB residual is bounded to plus/minus8prequantization and no more than8integerRGBdelta on nonclipped synthetic constant Sourcebase. Gray material residual is achromatic.", "Unchanged10370branch is byteexact to priorhelper on same synthetic Source/donor. Synthetic Source ordinarycoloredcue/reserved/black31backing remains exact with noHDcredit.", "Synthetic CLI produces truthful perasset sigma3/clip16/.5receipt,Sourcebase.5and actual executed helper/dependency hashes. The only CLI derivation by reviewer used synthetic data and temporary output.", "Exact actual recipe79bc/candidate5bb1/source0a687/pal1cf6/masterd45469andcrop1155,300,80,80authenticated. Canonical Source/Palette bytes matchINDEX/PALETTE; independent allscale projectedowner union equals seven(7,15..21)candidate cells.", "Actualgenuine30380master/source/crop/ownerbindings byteequal earlier independently reviewed e94f66binding receipt. It is borrowed material explicitly; own held302e1pixelblocked master remains unused." ], "different_from_author": true, "findings_requiring_revision": [], "frozen_proposal": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-302e1-fixed-quiet-floor-CODE-proposal-20261019-v1/FROZEN-QUIET302E1-CODE-AND-ACTUAL-BINDINGS-NOT-EXECUTED.json", "sha256": "a8f80be2f881aed747829dbfeb5fb6270859b119ea6e31317b7198eadc4c72fe" }, "helper": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-302e1-fixed-quiet-floor-CODE-proposal-20261019-v1/followon302e1_quiet_floor_cleanup.py", "sha256": "df2d1a9b84d8f173504ccd36c3f59f411a2f34177ffed7614af8dd37842b4c9d" }, "independent_test_log": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ship-302e1-quiet-floor-independent-CODE-and-bindings-review-20261019-v1/independent-tests.stderr", "sha256": "1721339989563d25698a92c135818e4051626aea7e2bcf2628171866394fc70a" }, "independent_test_source": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ship-302e1-quiet-floor-independent-CODE-and-bindings-review-20261019-v1/independent_review.py", "sha256": "1221132585a2e9c577595f5141fc5050cafb0182983115c957990920490cf49b" }, "independent_tests": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ship-302e1-quiet-floor-independent-CODE-and-bindings-review-20261019-v1/INDEPENDENT-7-TESTS-AND-EXACT-BINDINGS.json", "sha256": "4f2311d2a016e21892bd2d62ce27893ee2f45dd24f69bd34869ed6333eae85ab" }, "inputs_unchanged": true, "preserved_reviewer_syntax_stop": [ { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ship-302e1-quiet-floor-independent-CODE-and-bindings-review-20261019-v1/PRESERVED-FIRST-REVIEWER-SYNTAX-STOP.py", "sha256": "0c5f5428526b0e42a46465e6c25e85db84eeda13d9c5211ce971d0da6b976e1b" }, { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-ship-302e1-quiet-floor-independent-CODE-and-bindings-review-20261019-v1/PRESERVED-FIRST-REVIEWER-SYNTAX-STOP.stderr", "sha256": "47c50628a4c478ec4637897965451e448314ff812e5e9851fec2f79475b6c3d2" } ], "prior_different_CODE": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-publication-review-followon5-different-CODE-and-bindings-20261019-v1/PASS-DIFFERENT-FOLLOWON5-CODE-AND-EXACT-BINDINGS-34PLUS9.json", "sha256": "1649b75edb34ad904a3c2554e71344b04b4610cd090ccbf4eb93d30e12b4af23" }, "reviewed_utc": "2026-10-19T08:24:38.514534+00:00", "reviewer": "/root/ship_portability", "scope_limits": [ "CODE/inputbinding qualification only. Does not approve derived artwork, native1..4fidelity, terrainseams, visiblecleanremaster or gameplay. New actual art/context must be reviewed separately.", "FineRGBsample-countpositive alone is not HDquality. Source supplies geometry/coarse materialfield; copiedcue/black/sourcebase are not genuine new generated detail.", "Frozenhelper/prepost inputhashes qualify this concrete private execution only. Inherited helper self-open receipt and hostile concurrent output-parent replacement/partialwrite limits remain; no generic raceproof/atomic-output guarantee.", "Rootstanding singleactualcleanup/G2 authority belongs to owner. Reviewer did not execute any actualgame derivation, G2, World, generator, compositor, registrar, canonical code/data or Git mutation." ], "status": "PASS_DIFFERENT_FIXED302E1_QUIET_FLOOR_CODE_AND_EXACT_ACTUAL_BINDINGS", "synthetic_CLI_runs": 1 }