{ "status": "PASS_DIFFERENT_V2_NATIVE_DONOR_REFLECTION_TERRAIN_HELPER_CODE_DELTA_REVIEW", "reviewer": "/root/iron_coast_2", "author": "/root/iron_coast_3", "utc": "2026-10-18T00:56:10.160423+00:00", "helper": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-iron3-declared-material-terrain-retexture-private-helper-20261018-v2/hd_terrain_group_retexture.py", "sha256": "24e3751d26090699f2d8d317ed98f73e05f51f3caa6dc2bf21fc40a109068a27", "bytes": 19852 }, "tests": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-iron3-declared-material-terrain-retexture-private-helper-20261018-v2/test_hd_terrain_group_retexture.py", "sha256": "29870d583d853ef9981c2ee22128a5ddc5aa7ffa10a6726d40ec79992ca78209", "bytes": 18988 }, "API": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-iron3-declared-material-terrain-retexture-private-helper-20261018-v2/FROZEN-PRIVATE-V2-NATIVE-DONOR-REGION-API-AND-SYNTHETIC-TEST-HANDOFF.json", "sha256": "6d6d5ae7888f13c897e5b2768ab4cdc9871695af465c861e79ff73ce18d2025d", "bytes": 6702 }, "author_report": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-iron3-declared-material-terrain-retexture-private-helper-20261018-v2/CLOSED-PRIVATE-V2-NATIVE-DONOR-REFLECTION-DELTA-AUTHOR-REVIEW-NO-REAL-ART.json", "sha256": "b0819a2fba65022511c22e43404cb26376ecdd114197e0cc413a671c18c7a416", "size": 8028, "mtime_ns": 1792284866405034289, "mode": 33188 }, "author_outside_strict": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-iron3-declared-material-terrain-retexture-private-helper-20261018-v2-strict-private-v2-native-donor-delta-closure.json", "sha256": "b6f618243d2b49ecd50941f085a1e6266cdb06e54d4dda32e8556fcb58bc0a90", "bytes": 14119 }, "focused_synthetic_tests": 27, "synthetic_log": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-iron2-declared-group-terrain-V2-donor-delta-independent-code-review-20261018-v1/actual-focused-synthetic27.log", "sha256": "ea7c359fb42208bfa09831d50d01e8aad31712527792a5899de7642d5fe4ee37", "bytes": 4680 }, "independent_checks": 18, "independent_probe_receipt": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-iron2-declared-group-terrain-V2-donor-delta-independent-code-review-20261018-v1/independent-reflect101-and-no-region-full-PNG-compatibility.json", "sha256": "f9c625915ba6880e2f6dbb85fa936578f5a5746015a300d8d244a8875d9d77c1", "bytes": 781 }, "AST_and_membership": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-iron2-declared-group-terrain-V2-donor-delta-independent-code-review-20261018-v1/independent-AST-and-frozen-membership.json", "sha256": "5f4dacdf7f0588ea0fde16efaa0913c804e10e43244b8d8245b073e8d7c63b5d", "bytes": 5000 }, "concrete_open_findings": [], "checks": [ "Exact V1-to-V2 delta changes only validate_recipe/reconstruct/run plus four donor-region/reflection functions and the new method/version; dependency loading, group/parameter guards, readers and atomic publisher AST unchanged.", "Declared regions map only existing group names to strict typed donor rectangles inside the same hash-bound frame crop. Native raw donor position/density and all three RGB channels remain exact before final resizing.", "Independent iterative mirror reference matches reflect101 over negative/positive coordinates, lengths1..9, and six cropped RGB fields including one-pixel donor axes. No repeated-edge convention or pre-enlargement.", "Each group filters its own complete reflected native-density field before final resize; texture modulation is assigned only inside that SourceNx owner mask. Donor-excluded wrong-edge raw changes cannot enter complete regional fields.", "Omitted/empty regions preserve V1 output/base/owner arrays; complete synthetic two-frame PNG payloads are byte-identical to V1. Method/version/diagnostic receipts identify the new tool.", "Both declared .38 gains remain recipe values, not hidden gain boosts. Raw RGB donor equality is an intermediate texture-lineage property, not a promise that final Source-guided output RGB equals raw.", "Existing input hashes, strict asset/path/type guards, Source opaque ordinary validation, all-input recheck and atomic no-replace behavior pass inherited and new tests.", "Normalized execution retains exactly seven fields; detailed lineage records donor RGB SHA, reflected native field SHA, original offset/dimensions and actual position-sample assertion.", "All16 V2 owned files/20 bound input pins match original SHA/size/mtime; V1 whole membership and prior independent PASS remain unchanged." ], "limits": [ "Code/synthetic delta scope only; no actual20390 recipe reconstruction, parent PNG decode, derived asset output, QA, renderer/compiler, World, imagegen, artistic/context judgment or shared edit.", "Reflected repetition/density/phase artifacts can still cause artistic HOLD; this review does not approve donor choices or new art.", "Existing Linux O_NOFOLLOW authoring requirement and no fsync-crash durability guarantee remain unchanged." ], "actual_asset_recipe_calls": 0, "engine_QA_renderer_compiler_World_calls": 0, "shared_writes": false, "pending_own_writer_call_or_lease": false }