{ "status": "QUALIFIED_DIFFERENT_FIRSTCAMPAIGN_QUARTET_COMPLETE4_ALL16_NATIVE_INTRINSIC_WITH_LIMITS", "reviewer": "/root/grating_pair", "author": "/root/remaining_catalog", "selected": [ "105d3", "105dc", "105dd", "105de" ], "physically_viewed": { "authentic_selected_Source": true, "authentic_fullfamily_Source": true, "untouched_genuine_master": true, "whole_derived512": 4, "whole_SourceNx_and_actual_native_body_readbacks": 32, "native_scales": [ 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "whole_native_actual_frames": 16, "display": "Actual840x1680 author pages at original resolution; whole actual/Source body pixels exact integerNN3, no cropped body approval" }, "candidate": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-firstcampaign105d3-105dc-105dd-105de-Original-primary-quartet-author-20261019-v1/final-reviewed-source-fidelity-pack/candidate.json", "sha256": "f29dc414c16a1f2efa703528c9ab3fad451b269860915bc0916989589a7c6dd0", "size": 2208 }, "literal_QA": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-firstcampaign105d3-105dc-105dd-105de-Original-primary-quartet-author-20261019-v1/actual-once-final-current-SourceG2/runtime-qa.json", "sha256": "5d1ba55b1c130831f3d04d62c447cf97e82541f86dbb4b8861dd9c7c24c10bad", "size": 17133 }, "independent_saved_audit": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-grating-peer-firstcampaign105d3-105de-quartet-intrinsic-review-20261019-v1/READONLY-SOURCE-RAW-DERIVED-INDEXED-PALETTE-ALL32-PAGE-BODIES-AND-RETENTION-AUDIT.json", "sha256": "7de71293f446f574a9ae0c98039b1f5427617c5ae2213bb9fcf0f1228de9a6eb", "size": 50624 }, "producer_author": { "path": "/home/quintine/Projects/RaptorReplica/RustRaptor/.reference/hd-firstcampaign105d3-105dc-105dd-105de-Original-primary-quartet-author-20261019-v1/AUTHOR-QUALIFIED-EXACT-SELECTED-ALL-NATIVE-PORTABLE-READY.json", "sha256": "985e1adb74a0911c9e55e9e1fde2a3a65e9e6749fcf3ecca314c64951131fdf6", "size": 2769 }, "records": [ { "asset": "105d3", "standalone_verdict": "QUALIFIED_APPROVE", "selected_frame_binding": { "frame": 0, "file": "105d3-derived.png", "logical_width": 32, "logical_height": 32, "origin": [ 0, 0 ], "source_sha256": "a9339b020566351e6a6717995c70442c1acba278c154821169a6714681ac2d93", "original_detail_cells": [] }, "source_payload_sha256": "a9339b020566351e6a6717995c70442c1acba278c154821169a6714681ac2d93", "derived_artwork_sha256": "e433b7e50f3cf3066b88d79c7df6676e279bc9e8b64b2c26bd02a135492b69e4", "actual_scales": [ 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "finding": "Gray/rust remnant and yellow cavity retain Source footprint; yellow glints and small ochre contacts remain readable. Gray edges and cavity transitions are softer than crisp SourceNx; fine earth/gray material is restrained.", "retained_Original_generated_detail_credit": 0 }, { "asset": "105dc", "standalone_verdict": "QUALIFIED_APPROVE", "selected_frame_binding": { "frame": 0, "file": "105dc-derived.png", "logical_width": 32, "logical_height": 32, "origin": [ 0, 0 ], "source_sha256": "ac5322698956da028eacacbbd1de6d0eae776e8335e0787522f6d5fb7db35f61", "original_detail_cells": [] }, "source_payload_sha256": "ac5322698956da028eacacbbd1de6d0eae776e8335e0787522f6d5fb7db35f61", "derived_artwork_sha256": "3a8a4282244a5b89425096fde4844472485931781a8759eda8afb7a613d45572", "actual_scales": [ 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "finding": "Original radial hub and arms remain coherent, including the upper-right clipped diagonal brace and curved outeredge. No radialarm was replaced by ordinary texture. Gray/earthgrain is fine and subdued; brace edges soften.", "retained_Original_generated_detail_credit": 0 }, { "asset": "105dd", "standalone_verdict": "QUALIFIED_APPROVE", "selected_frame_binding": { "frame": 0, "file": "105dd-derived.png", "logical_width": 32, "logical_height": 32, "origin": [ 0, 0 ], "source_sha256": "e4b706aa324a92fdd94a573816e139c1751f2f9c4cbcece6e0bfe73f4d2328a1", "original_detail_cells": [ [ 6, 28 ] ] }, "source_payload_sha256": "e4b706aa324a92fdd94a573816e139c1751f2f9c4cbcece6e0bfe73f4d2328a1", "derived_artwork_sha256": "48d26126fcaf0db4843fba3a490f58c8f3a85efb538c1e9c93a3b3227f6b47d8", "actual_scales": [ 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "finding": "Orange control box retains its one dark aperture, two separate checkeredgray fields, leftwater/graycap and clipped red neighbor. Checkers remain visible but softer; protected241owner(6,28) remains Original fidelity, zeroHDcredit.", "retained_Original_generated_detail_credit": 0 }, { "asset": "105de", "standalone_verdict": "QUALIFIED_APPROVE", "selected_frame_binding": { "frame": 0, "file": "105de-derived.png", "logical_width": 32, "logical_height": 32, "origin": [ 0, 0 ], "source_sha256": "d6d3cf3ebeb13acc162f0c8c2b51a576231177b3e26bae3e2bbfcf08f3c7eafe", "original_detail_cells": [] }, "source_payload_sha256": "d6d3cf3ebeb13acc162f0c8c2b51a576231177b3e26bae3e2bbfcf08f3c7eafe", "derived_artwork_sha256": "b1524534e38827409860c090466983aa034da30217bd1e020a7c0c5f2179ca36", "actual_scales": [ 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "finding": "Both authentic red locations retain the openfork/crescent gray gaps and leftclipping. Gaps are not filled into solid discs. Lower ochre contacts, docklegs and watercorner stay recognizable; edges/gray structure are softened.", "retained_Original_generated_detail_credit": 0 } ], "limitations": [ "Gray/structural edges are noticeably softer than crisp SourceNx, with subdued checker/glint/groove boundaries. Native1 averages away much fine detail; fine generated material is modest and strongest in soil/rust/gray regions.", "Small red/ochre parent material crops are magnified; Source-guided low-frequency colors, body geometry, grid and functional/retained pixels receive zero generated-HD detail credit.", "The105dd Sourcepalette241owner remains OriginalNx at allscales; exact protected labels are a functional requirement, not newly generated texture.", "Intrinsic complete-frame approval only; no terrain-neighbor contexts, seams, camera/shimmer, gameplay states or current canonical-header admission are approved here." ], "no_new_generation_cleanup_QA_engine_context_canonical_Git": true, "technical_saved_verdict": "PASS_ALL32_PAGE_BODIES_122880_INDEXED_SAMPLES_PROTECTED_SOURCE_LABELS_AND_44_INPUT_PINS" }