# Complete-original HD review

Current artwork/runtime checkpoint — 17 October 2026: the registered and assembled pack contains **5,413 frames / 3,577 complete sequences**, including **4,300 Terrain pictures**. **340 originals await approval**: 235 Terrain, 71 enemies/ground objects, 33 UI/other and one boss. This count includes held drafts and actual refusals, rather than only never-generated pictures. The append adds intact buildings 20273/20275 and the complete four-frame SHIP23G2 family, 200dd–200e0, in three native sequences and three raw routes (6,724,550 bytes). The four SHIP hybrids retain 98/84/120/118 Original logical cells (420 total); these cells are not newly generated HD. All previous 5,407 bindings and the complete 3,574-header prefix remain exact. Actual data contains **9,359 files / 8,252,150,324 bytes**; actual CLI validates 5,413 frames with zero rejects and 45 mods/one override (`ff0d8164`). Source18 and both Source C+D executables remain unchanged. Finite context/input reviews cover 15 saved building contexts and four genuinely observed living SHIP poses at all native scales; neither group's new IDs occur in the other's saved Source set. Gray steps, partial edges, value/grain differences and low native1 contrast remain qualified; these observations establish no universal placement, visible overlap, full-route/death or seamlessness claim. Three actual 5,413 SDL controls match their frozen controls across 6,220,800 RGB/alpha pixels; none contains the new six pictures, so these fixtures add no target-art approval. The extra S2W7 starter smoke ended in a death cinematic and supplies no passing target-art control. Published 5,407 is `6a3c465d`. Source-C native Windows at the 5,384-frame checkpoint `a073f73f` passed 379 tests with 26 ignored and zero failures; prior API-B evidence remains separate. The 5,407 native Windows run is still pending; 5,413 publication and native Windows execution are also pending. Existing dated Source-update and historical records below retain their scopes.

Preserved 17 October 2026 Source-update checkpoint at 5,384 (historical coverage): Current runtime checkpoint — 17 October 2026: Source C+D is remote-confirmed at `a073f73f`, with **5,384 HD frames / 3,551 sequences** and 369 originals still outstanding. Both executables are rebuilt; 90 Rust / 78 Python tests and three fresh 1080p controls pass, with zero pixel differences from API-B. Source C+D native Windows CI remains pending. Historical 8ada, 386e and API-B material/context/QA evidence below retains its recorded epoch; these bounded runtime checks add no artwork or hybrid approval. See [the coordinator checkpoint](hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md) for current validation and Windows attribution.

Independent review started **2026-10-10**, extended **2026-10-11**. This is an ongoing acceptance record, separate from the generation jobs and registration coordinator. Full completion requires all **5,753 standalone source picture IDs** to have reviewed, registered remasters and their retained rendering paths to work. Candidate images, queue entries, original fallback and a successful PNG decode do not establish completion.

## Inventory checked independently

A strict picture decoder read every one of the 6,449 original catalog entries and checked the recorded byte lengths. Its 5,753 picture IDs, source SHA-256 hashes and logical canvases match the maintained completion ledger and the previous independent Rust pixel audit. **4,768 pictures are outside `sprites/`.** Every picture has `remaster_required: true`; no unused enemy, directional, terrain or miscellaneous picture has been excluded.

The disjoint queues contain 659 jobs and 5,714 source targets in this snapshot. Their union with the 46 registered pictures covers all 5,753 IDs exactly; seven registered dark-player pictures remain in their frozen queue. Every job target's source hash and canvas match the independent inventory. The original unused WORM direction and DSHP picture families remain explicitly required.

All 4,535 terrain pictures remain required, including the 734 destroyed-only IDs absent from intact-map screenshots. Original missions reference 3,483 intact and 736 destroyed IDs, a union of 4,217. The complete target inventory includes the terrain pictures not referenced by those missions.

The **303 AGX delta frames** and **four bitmap fonts** have explicit preservation policies: classic original cinematics and sharply scaled native glyphs. These exceptions are separate from picture coverage and are never counted as HD replacements.

Snapshot ledger SHA-256: `3b024a1a1dd342afabfb0f3829f1933769869f6a8798059826e796b3f7e34fb4`. The ignored evidence is `.reference/hd-full-review/inventory.json`; later ledger updates need a fresh snapshot rather than treating this dated count as current.

## Registered pack reviewed

Manifest SHA-256 `aa2b823acce157f0b49ee2f44bad133cefeca0304905038f004b59b4b6c22835` supplies **46 frames in 16 complete families**. The actual Rust loader decoded each at all four presentation scales, producing 184 correctly sized indexed sprites with no diagnostics. Every source hash, logical canvas and zero origin passed. All seven source/1×/4× contact pages and six separate native-resolution 2×/3× pages were inspected, including every bank pose and every animation frame.

| Reviewed family | Original IDs | Frames | Assessment |
| --- | --- | ---: | --- |
| Light player banking | `1011a–10120` | 7 | Bank ordering, materials, canopy, wing tips and engines remain readable. |
| Dark player banking | `20045–2004b` | 7 | Distinct dark lighting preserves the approved bank geometry and canvas. |
| Ground targets TARGT1/2/3 | `10138–1013a` | 3 | Source orientation and centered mechanism preserved; full opaque canvases intentional. |
| Ground target TARGT6 | `1013d–10141` | 5 | Complete opening/firing sequence aligned on the same square structure. |
| Fighters SHIP01G1 / SHIP27G1 | `102f8`, `10330` | 2 | Source directions, canopy and gunmetal/blue or neutral material cues retained. |
| Industrial boss | `10306` | 1 | Full source footprint and left/right machinery retained. |
| Plasma and enemy-cannon projectiles | `101cf–101d0`, `101d6–101d7` | 4 | Readable indexed projectiles; Plasma's known 1× tail shortening remains documented. |
| Energy flash/rings | `101ae–101b9` | 12 | Complete expansion sequence aligned; known narrower first flash and thin rings remain documented. |
| Forward, Plasma, Dumb Missile, Air Missile equipment | `102b0–102b2`, `102b5`, `102bf` | 5 | Logical inventory canvases retained; loss of original dark opaque outlines remains documented rather than called identical transparency. |

This pack is **partial: 5,707 required pictures still have no registered remaster in this snapshot**. Static fighter approval does not cover other old enemies, bosses, directional variants or terrain. A generated menu background does not count as remastering the original portraits, HUD and retained menu pictures.

Evidence: `.reference/hd-full-review/snapshot-aa2b823a/` contains the exact manifest snapshot, fresh actual Rust 1×–4× indexed outputs, `runtime-qa.json` and every contact-sheet page. The loader library is current for asset decoding and HD loading. Desktop rendering changed after that library was built, so this gallery does not establish those newer runtime routes.

A subsequent registered snapshot, **63 frames**, has manifest SHA-256 `33ec0a782a852ffef36880432d3e8d472f18a39e9a31d545fe47eb0256bb0dfd`. Fresh actual Rust validation passes all 252 scale outputs without diagnostics. Every prior 46 frame's indexed output is byte-identical to the previous reviewed snapshot; the 16 canonical terrain frames and Super Shield pickup match their independently reviewed isolated outputs. The newly added terrain's native 2× and 3× outputs were also inspected. The picture inventory still has **5,690 unregistered targets** at this snapshot. Evidence: `.reference/hd-full-review/snapshot-33ec0a78/review-comparison.json`.

**Palette animation defect found and corrected:** static equipment highlights can select native cycling/fire/flash indices 240–255 despite their original source having none. The PNG source and shape can be valid while the runtime asset flashes unintentionally. The coordinator reported this in Micro Missile/Missile Pods/Mega Bomb candidates and requested an engine correction. Independent pre-fix review found 24 of 63 registered pictures affected across 86 scale outputs. Source-bound palette classes now constrain ordinary art to indices 0–239, water/fire to their own cycling group, and flash masks to exact original labels. Fresh independent post-fix galleries pass **all 63 registered pictures and ten additional equipment frames at scales 1–4 (292 outputs)** with no newly introduced dynamic index. All 24 changed registered frames and all ten equipment frames were visually re-inspected without a shape or readability regression. Evidence: `.reference/hd-full-review/snapshot-63-palette-audit-fixed/` and `equipment-palette-fixed/`.

## Isolated candidate reviews

| Candidate | Candidate JSON SHA-256 | Actual Rust outputs | Status |
| --- | --- | ---: | --- |
| Terrain `10360–1036f` | `ad6062f325e730bdb71d22190ff1589f5d86f6c69c62ed94e8caacfdd9ce955c` | 16 × four scales | All source/1×/4× rows inspected; 48 contexts, 755 cardinal pairs and four native scene captures independently pass. Approved for partial-pack registration. |
| Terrain `2010d–2011c` initial | `74d3a5e8cc32569c849c8baeee3a47d7c265e238c5d00b5f84a98a52198e8527` | 16 × four scales | Rejected: `20111` invented a tree canopy; corrected candidate reviewed below. |
| TARGT5 v2 `1013c` | `e7af1db9fb30f995eaf2c2c360f86c952401bac874087b4f4c462487a9e9ca8a` | One × four scales | Structure preserved and prior orange speckles removed; darker soil needs neighbor review. |
| TARG10 v1 `10161` | `44a2720e6b6164cb96888a024b5fc068c4abe6e331cff54e3389c721890c4eb4` | One × four scales | Cannon pose preserved; orange border speckles and soil color need correction or contextual approval. |
| Super Shield pickup `102d0` | `adf4b4823aee9bade62b755b170bc0393b73d84c02653e51827109016b3d97ea` | One × four scales | Independently approved; golden S glyph, pointed silhouette, transparency and source canvas preserved. |

All five isolated packs passed source hash, canvas, origin, PNG/crop and nonempty indexed validation without diagnostics. That result does not approve their artistry. TARGT5's outer three logical pixels change from source mean RGB 124/76/63 to indexed 1× 74/32/28. TARG10 changes from 104/65/55 to 4× 92/40/30 and introduces bright orange border pixels (1.63% of that band; source zero). These measurements explain the requested ground-neighbor check; they are not universal numeric art gates.

Evidence is under `.reference/hd-full-review/terrain-10360-1036f/`, `terrain-2010d-2011c/`, `held-targt5/`, `held-targ10/` and `equipment-102d0/`. Only source inspection and preview extraction were performed; no candidate pixels or global registration were changed.

## Subsequent complete-family approvals, 2026-10-11

Fresh source-bound Rust galleries and complete sequence inspection approve the following additions. Every frame passes all four scales without loader diagnostics or newly introduced palette indices 240–255. Native 2×/3× views were separately inspected for the new equipment, fighters/bosses and firing player.

| Family | Candidate JSON SHA-256 | Frames | Independent finding |
| --- | --- | ---: | --- |
| Micro Missile pair | `469d467a03864420d21dbe8d70e89ff503b9c241ea791401d179a63003d60711` | 2 | Source glyphs, paired payload and footprint retained. |
| Missile Pods pickup | `7584fc2ec68033e66c75a185f7ea3f5e781a0eab187c64b165879fc12f104bd5` | 1 | Pod arrangement and logical equipment canvas retained. |
| Mega Bomb pickup | `4f9c2542ea6d16ead3a1a571a171afff15b13bcb1d9490ba83602067a0d8c672` | 1 | Source radiation emblem readable; palette defect corrected by the loader. |
| Additional equipment `102d5–102da` | Six hashes retained in `equipment-palette-hold/candidates.json` | 6 | Complete isolated definitions, source material and pickup footprints preserved. |
| Fighter `1030a` | `f98cd3c1b58628f15c506271cc6308007d4fae04618b746c344799c09cb74a98` | 1 | Swept source wings and long nose/tail remain legible at 1×. |
| Fighter `102f9` | `d5c8e2dcf3f91806752e40487c4473168c9fe9fc353e05d52bfb2ee1abe7153f` | 1 | Red industrial upper panels and separated lower angled engines retained. |
| Boss `10308` | `646f5b42172d6be5bb19c39256807f33fdf6e697565bbacf1f5ae07242b59538` | 1 | Curved shoulders and full central machinery preserve source arrangement. |
| Boss `1030f` | `f2043a5722023e57342fedab8b021998fa9234bdce5c09ee47262c02ee2f2915` | 1 | Large mechanical silhouette, center shield and lower pods stay aligned. |
| Boss `10307` | `55e0c67363e7684b66e25393a1cf6bcebacd8cafab4fc3f0c0d91d08a4aaacbf` | 1 | Approved with disclosed dark-perimeter interpretation; three upper towers, center weapon and bottom pods retained. |
| TARGT5 v3 | `629a75b87ef64d01350520207911f2c2a992bb70727913b1b7d489462f820755` | 1 | Earlier soil hold resolved; subdued brown footprint and mechanism preserved. |
| Firing player `2004c–20052` | `8462634f071b1b32b4e6814e0e220c0c6fac59ec202ba2cccfa28e03512e04cf` | 7 | Entire bank sequence approved; corrected straight-frame contour checked explicitly. |
| MiniGun equipment cycle `102b6–102b9` | `4ab17e410808ca03616551fff76f36e5505b16083f2090bd21c443b7b6b91663` | 4 | All four barrel/vent rotation phases preserve source order. |
| Dumb Missile `101ba–101bc` | `c49d40e194870c18d1d70c01c498bc8f327b2ce720017fdf8e4798487d005d72` | 3 | Complete short/long orange exhaust phases; exact logical alpha masks. |
| Pods/Air Missile `101bd–101be` | `f434f793e58fa63ffe46f09bdd0be747e0bb7f6a31558feb6e1e96081c526cba` | 2 | Red nose, paired fins and two blue exhaust phases preserved. |
| Ground Missile `101bf–101c0` | `0eb6ec3fa8d6b8702d82ba3326c19e5b93451901337475452220655aa2780cb2` | 2 | Green projectile material, exact mask and phase geometry retained. |

Boss `10307` has logical alpha IoU 0.8293. Its replacement removes 373 original opaque perimeter pixels (252 very dark) and adds 23; bounds move by at most one logical pixel. The full silhouette remains readable and unclipped, but the alpha contour is an interpretation rather than identical. Evidence: `fighters-bosses-cohort/runtime/10307-alpha-difference.png`. Original collision dimensions remain authoritative.

TARGT5's source soil-band RGB is about 124/76/63; v3 is 109/61/50 at 1× and 108/61/50 at 4×, substantially closer than rejected v2's 74/32/28. No bright orange gravel or accidental animated labels remain.

Straight firing frame `2004f` now keeps `(19,8)` opaque and `(11,12)/(11,13)` transparent, with `(11,14)` still opaque. Broad mask scores alone previously missed those contour errors. The seven source/1×/4× rows and native 2×/3× sequence pass independently. FPLAYER's coordinator-owned job wrapper must record its own manifest hash; the hash above identifies the independently reviewed diagnostic proposal and exact same source/artwork.

Evidence is in ignored `.reference/hd-full-review/equipment-palette-fixed/`, `fighters-bosses-cohort/`, `targt5-v3/`, `fplayer-current/`, `dumb-missile-3/` and `new-projectile-equipment/`. These approvals do not imply all items are already globally registered.

## Industrial terrain review, 2026-10-11

The complete 32-picture industrial cohort passes source arrangement and exact indexed loader checks at scales 1–4. Independent visual review inspected all eight source/1×/4× pages and every one of the **51 exact composition pages**: `300ed–300fc` includes 456 cardinal pairs, 96 intact/target contexts and 48 state-partner swaps; `300fd–3010c` includes 404 pairs, 90 contexts and 45 swaps. Wall/roof corners, horizontal/vertical pipes, pit margins, original damage placement, opacity and source palette classes remain correct. Reverse overlay order is identical at every tested scale.

**Runtime texture hold:** repeated narrow grain ridges appear across the plain yard at HD/HD joins and pale strips cross roof surfaces. Exact case 72 visibly adds ridges at presentation x=128 and x=256 absent from the original Scale4x yard. This is a renderer/composition finding; no generated artwork was edited. Both cohorts remain held for a corrected composition proof before calling the terrain seam-free.

Hash-bound candidates: `9524b51b512e6cc02cd5f4f343c6391b022b912b1caf8d19e1cc7201fdd1628a` and `0206f86be19d8ccc3eceeb3893191ac29fb628bfd8df03a919cf07b5e4759bde`. Evidence and every inspected page hash: `.reference/hd-full-review/terrain-set3-cohort/context-review.json`; full original/composed comparison: `case-0072-full-pair.png`.

Foreign destroyed-state partners retain original fallback in these isolated packs. Their swaps prove that composition selects and joins the correct source state; those partners are not accepted HD debris and remain required in their own remaster jobs.

## First terrain family's contextual acceptance

Candidate `10360–1036f` passed independent inspection of all **48 actual 3×3 contexts** and all **755 cardinal pairs** across 24 review pages: 170 HD/HD joins and 585 HD/original joins. Trees, dirt/grass boundaries, adjoining native coastlines, roads, structures and existing destroyed neighbors keep their source arrangement. No tile hole, crossing-material leakage or low-resolution interior edge grid was found. Texture contrast at the temporary HD/original boundary remains visible, so this approval is for the current partial pack and does not establish finished full-map consistency.

Four actual native scene captures show phase 0, phase 31, intact terrain and settled destruction. The engineer's runtime assertions compare cached and fresh composition at every one of 32 scroll phases, preserve simulation/pilot/script/RNG state across draw calls, and invalidate the prepared layer after mod hash or load-order changes. The final release-profile isolated warmed scene averaged 2.969 ms; its prepared 320×268 strip is bounded to 2.62 MiB plus a 64 KiB key and the separate 2 MiB transition lookup. The final native cache proof SHA-256 is `67bf62d4bb82606971d4a4c40aef46642b6f9730e2c9a5f34c2de6d054aa8076`. These scene results are distinct from the PNG gallery check.

This family has **no declared destroyed-state partners**. Its destruction capture exercises another native tile's intact/settled cache transition; it does not approve generated HD debris. Those 734 destroyed-only targets remain required in their own jobs.

Runtime proof SHA-256: `c00e11d26e2a49a6b0f2e156581a7a7b1fc217f922a34e6b70ed7dbd5b95a0de`. Independent evidence is `.reference/hd-full-review/terrain-10360-1036f/context-review.json`, its 24 cardinal pages and three 48-context contact parts. Original native captures are under `.reference/terrain-hd/terrain-10360-1036f/`.

## Corrected second terrain family, 2026-10-11

Candidate SHA-256 `e65fe2737df0f02746cd5024decd6d00e6aeffa0574566e24b7ab803c592e3fb` replaces only `20111` with separately generated `20111-v2.png`; the remaining fifteen raw atlas cells stay unchanged. The invented canopy is gone and its original olive grass/brown dirt arrangement is preserved. All sixteen fresh source/1×/4× rows, **48 refreshed actual contexts** and **519 cardinal pairs** were independently inspected. Neighboring original trees, roads, channels, coastlines and intact/damaged structures retain their arrangement; no material leakage, opacity hole or invented tree was found.

The source artwork is approved, separately from the same compositor texture gate affecting industrial terrain: fine repeated grain bands remain visible at some HD/HD joins. Do not describe this partial terrain as fully seam-free before the composition correction passes. This family has no declared destroyed-state partners and does not approve new HD debris.

The runtime proof JSON hash remains `68726a272d094c520203a303dcb57b755fec8974da48a4b7f6b35e2b2da3af0f` because that older schema records placements rather than artwork digests. The independent review snapshot additionally binds the exact corrected candidate and **every refreshed PNG hash**, avoiding reliance on the unchanged proof JSON alone: `.reference/hd-full-review/terrain-2010d-2011c-corrected/context-proof/proof-snapshot.json`. Its three context and seventeen cardinal pages were all inspected.

## Additional effects approved, 2026-10-11

Complete blue sparks `1019c–101a4` (nine frames; candidate `aaae1833221c1bb2ec7bc93bf03609d89a26bfb822e580e358b9ada6f92a7c8b`) and Death Ray hit `101f1–101f4` (four frames; `56b317e51be2d9c973f6e82f1fd5310a81935b03b468ef3e14e9a3f9717235ed`) pass fresh exact Rust checks at every scale. All source/1×/4× rows and native 2×/3× sequences were inspected. Muted lavender, sparse disconnected fragments, phase order and cross/corner/star shapes stay source-faithful; ray-hit logical alpha masks are exact. No new reserved cycling/flash index is introduced. Evidence: `.reference/hd-full-review/sparks-and-ray-hit/`.

Shield, muzzle, power and explosion families with contour/phase cautions remain separate holds; this approval does not apply to those sibling effects.

## Further effects reviewed, 2026-10-11

Independent review of 43 complete effect frames passes fresh actual Rust 1–4× loading (172 outputs, no new reserved palette class). All eleven source/1×/4× pages and eight native 2×/3× pages were inspected. Three families are approved: Platoon `10213–1021c` ten frames (`b52c4302d8410a66c27e7ebae1ea9fcd93b12753f31fc7ad1c23464d74a49980`), AirBlast `102a0–102af` sixteen (`e4611cd22e202e7a8d2d9a8fc0e3c79f1306258ef21e5825dc4fb0297b9df486`) and PickupGlow `10225–10228` four (`48a26513a296269043c0bce1c4211fb74aa8cb6f66e9df716c338331ddb01e86`). Source fragment positions/green debris, moving hot patches, spoke order, shrinking ring and center holes remain readable. The thinner AirBlast late rim and rounded PickupGlow contours are disclosed interpretations rather than identical alpha. The actual patterned `Canvas::shade` pickup comparison preserves every transparent hole and never paints the generated mask RGB; native logical anchors remain authoritative. Its test is local indexed composition, not a full Host timing/world-neutrality proof.

**MediumAir hold:** `101d8–101e4` thirteen frames (`e833d7e3792b82ba3951bd980055ae42f4dfe1b959ac7f0b890ce33725525e7f`) preserve the early hot-patch ordering, but final `101e2–101e4` rings shrink inward by 1–2 logical pixels and lose 27–38% of original opaque pixels. The last frame shifts its alpha centroid 1.37 pixels right and 0.88 up. The thin HD path visibly sits inside the original at the top/left/bottom; its original outer path, width and gaps require a generated correction before whole-family approval. This is a visible shape finding, not a universal IoU threshold. Evidence: `.reference/hd-full-review/effects-context-cohort/`, including `101e4-logical-difference.png`.

## Large effect cohort and concrete holds, 2026-10-11

All 96 candidate frames across Lightning14, GroundBlast42, SmallAir14 and Flare26 pass fresh actual Rust 1–4× loading (384 outputs), with no new reserved palette class. Every one of the 24 source/1×/4× pages and sixteen native 2×/3× pages was independently inspected. Lightning `1018e–1019b` (`5eb9ba29895acc6ecaca25b3012bc20c9bee1b8818930d97da31d4e22c7d8e6f`) is approved: branch growth/retraction, lower anchor and terminal compact spark remain readable; newly thin continuous branches are slightly cooler blue than the original lavender.

Three complete families remain held for visible source differences:

- GroundBlast42 `10164–1018d` (`9b6060fad4b39b5d9b43e18087eca2ae028be2c7f34886ecd01abec7b1f7ee60`): late smoke and embers are substantially overlit. Occupied-pixel RGB at `10172` changes about 69/27/15→103/48/25, `10174` 49/25/20→78/43/33, and `10176` 35/30/29→68/58/56. Source fragment ordering remains recognizable, but dim late smoke must retain its original fade rather than a new glowing coal treatment.
- SmallAir14 `101fc–10209` (`badd1b4badbfa982c418b9100ca61350d8cd5d31f43429533eaeaf321a875a60`): final `10209` drops the original left-side ring fragments at 1×. Its left bound moves from x=1 to x=7; 23 source opaque pixels become eight. Restore the native fragment positions and enough physical width to survive the supported presentation scales. Earlier phases are coherent.
- Flare26 `10252–1026b` (`b5b7b03d5b4c64f1c2213e54bca11e7a175fb1779488f395fa45f794e554911c`): `10267–10269` fill original transparent center holes with opaque dark/red pixels. At `10268` logical `(16,16)` changes from transparent to black index 0; `10269` gains 46 opaque pixels inside its central 7×7. Exact loaded 4× pixels composed over a checkerboard show scenery being hidden. Restore original center-hole growth and late gaps in generated artwork; a broad mask overlap score misses this problem.

Evidence: `.reference/hd-full-review/effects-large-cohort/independent-review.json` binds every page and candidate hash. `10268-transparent-hole-proof.png` and `10209-logical-difference.png` isolate the transparency and disappearing-fragment findings. The checkerboard is a read-only visualization of exact Rust-loaded masks, not a full Host simulation capture. No candidate pixels were edited; all three holds were sent to the artist and coordinator.

## Original portraits and title logos approved, 2026-10-11

All nine original portraits/ID pictures `10111–10119` and both title logos `10013/10014` pass fresh independent source-bound Rust loading at scales 1–4, with all 44 indexed outputs current and error-free. Every source/1×/4× row and native 2×/3× picture was inspected. Faces, hair, clothing, earrings/eyepatch and slanted ID-card backgrounds retain the original character cues. The English title/subtitle and four Chinese characters preserve their original lettering and spacing, with newly authored metal/stone detail. Alpha contours are interpreted, not identical; original logical canvases and anchors remain authoritative.

Candidate hashes: portraits `bf318311594ef16469922c19047b36dbb98c8b8c38fe3a03f86028729a82781e` (frame binding `c1124bf4fbbd8a79132ffc148bc9f92b18e59c5b49e2c4ddec278d95c5f9776d`), English logo `0c9c021b59bafce53ca9a2f3482b1d632bd97378c3082886ee2422c227de1908`, Chinese logo `723476d5b40c450dc939f9dc31d7d77b087e4c1ee9160481dde7de67a5c32fbe`. Ten static sources gain no reserved palette class. The Chinese source already has 478 fire-class pixels at index 245; its 1× replacement preserves 478 pixels within the allowed 245–249 class rather than introducing a new animation class.

The actual SDL SD/HD four-ID Main-menu comparison was independently viewed and its changed-pixel bounds recomputed: surrounding UI is byte-identical, names/IDs remain readable, and portraits stay inside their menu frame. The five full portraits and both logos remain retained catalog artwork, with no claimed active menu route. Evidence: `.reference/hd-full-review/interface-cohort/` and the owner's `interface-other-10111-10119/runtime-review/live-menu/menu-proof.json`.

The final Stormwall 1280×800 and aspect-correct 1920×1080 actual SDL captures were also inspected: indexed terrain, foreground, HUD and letterbox placement are clean. This contextual check does not resolve the separate original-industrial terrain grain hold or establish original-art completeness.

## Runtime routes and remaining gates

The former original beam/effect routing gaps have dedicated native composition paths. Beam shafts, muzzle/power/impact companions and secondary smoke/sparks/glows preserve original frame IDs and original anchors. Original shadows deliberately retain the original logical masks and collision dimensions.

Code review of the newly extended HUD, timed currency pickup and light-mask routes confirms they request HD frames at the presentation scale while retaining source logical placement. Light masks call indexed `Canvas::shade` instead of painting RGBA colors. Generic HUD assets keep nearest-neighbor source fallback; bitmap font text remains sharply scaled. Focused runtime fixtures now pass at **1× and 4×**: generic HUD and equipped-weapon icons use supplied HD pixels at the original logical anchor; a sparse red RGBA shield replacement uses its own alpha holes and transforms background index **37→44** through the light table rather than painting its red foreground. World/pilot state remains unchanged. The broader 13 original-rendering checks also pass. A dedicated full `Host::scene` currency fixture now passes at 1×/4× and interpolation α=0/0.5: synthetic native `N$_PIC` stays green in SD while supplied red/blue HD halves appear at the interpolated source anchor, with every pickup pixel and its surrounding black border checked. At 4× the half-step anchor is `(246,410)`. World digest, RNG, pickup countdown/previous-art-position/glow-frame, pilot and clock state remain unchanged; no HD diagnostic appears. This proves route behavior separately from artistic acceptance; no currency remaster is approved by that synthetic test.

Canonical terrain candidate review and actual terrain composition checks are ongoing. Fresh isolated Rust review decoded all 32 tiles in the first two groups at scales 1–4 without diagnostics; all eight paged source/1×/4× contact sheets were inspected. The first group (`10360–1036f`) keeps the broad tree/grass/dirt placements. The second group's original canopy drift is now resolved in its corrected candidate; compositor grain ridges remain a separate presentation gate. Every candidate tile requires independent source geometry review plus neighboring placements, mixed HD/original joins, destroyed states and scroll phases. Opaque alpha-mask overlap alone is trivial and is not an artistic quality gate. Rendering test success adds no artwork coverage.


Opening-credit pictures now have a separate source-palette rendering route: the active card exposes its unfaded POG/CYG palette; supplied HD artwork is quantized using its complete static 256-color palette before the existing cinematic fade. The integration agent reports 19 HD-loader, seven portable-cinematic and two full-Host opening-card fixtures passed, including 1×/4× index 250, start/half/full/end fades, absent/rejected artwork fallback and unchanged world/pilot/RNG plus the 569-tick synthetic cue stream. Two original-data cinematic checks preserve opening 966 ticks and AGX 925 ticks. This is route evidence reported by the implementation owner, separately from independent artistic review; actual opening-card replacements remain unapproved. See `docs/hd-opening-cards.md`. AGX films and bitmap fonts retain their explicit classic policy.

## Open findings

- Full art generation and registration are unfinished; preserve the per-ID checklist through every cohort.
- Generic HD palette quantization is corrected and independently passes all current supplied frames at scales 1–4. Preserve this source-class gate for every future family.
- Firing-player seven-frame sequence is now approved after specific straight-frame contour correction and fresh complete all-scale review. Preserve those source-bound contour checks.
- Generic HUD, lighting-mask and timed-currency routes now pass supplied-art runtime fixtures at 1×/4×, preserving indexed shading and original/interpolated anchors. Review their actual generated artwork separately when candidates arrive.
- **Resolved source hold for terrain `2010d–2011c`: rejected initial picture `20111` invented a tree canopy.** Its original palette contains olive grass and brown dirt only; the remaster adds a bright green canopy at the upper-left covering about 15% of logical pixels. The source hash and opaque alpha-mask overlap pass, demonstrating why those checks do not establish source geometry. The separate v2 correction now passes all source and contextual checks; preserve the original rejected evidence. Coordinator, artist and terrain engineer were notified. Proof: `.reference/hd-full-review/terrain-2010d-2011c/runtime-contact-sheet-002.png` and `20111-original-enlarged.png`.
- First canonical terrain group `10360–1036f` is independently approved. Corrected `20111` no longer invents a canopy and the entire second-family contextual review is complete. Both industrial cohorts remain held for repeated join grain ridges.

This record will be extended as new complete families arrive. Original-derived artwork and review renders remain in ignored `data/` and `.reference/`; authored mod artwork and sounds remain Git-tracked under `RustRaptor/mods/`.


## 2026-10-11 resumed terrain acceptance

The final mirrored-detail compositor is independently approved after all **66** full-corpus gallery pages were viewed, including all **1,706** cases: 1,379 cardinal pairs, 234 intact/target contexts and 93 destroyed-state partner swaps. The seven source/pristine/previous/fixed panels were also inspected. Every gallery digest was recomputed and matches the frozen index. The reviewed `terrain_hd.rs` SHA-256 is `b30b4a65a9e646e9fe106041ad718eebd2740c6c90354267a7b17b770e50ebb0`; the source hashes of `hd.rs`, `assets.rs` and `render.rs` are recorded alongside it in `.reference/hd-full-review/terrain-ridge-final-independent.json`.

Repeated vertical/horizontal grain ridges and pale seam strips are gone. Roof/wall/pipe geometry, broad grass/dirt boundaries and corner placement remain source-coherent. The previous presentation hold is resolved for these exact candidates: `terrain-2010d-2011c` (`e65fe2737df0f02746cd5024decd6d00e6aeffa0574566e24b7ab803c592e3fb`), `terrain-300ed-300fc` (`9524b51b512e6cc02cd5f4f343c6391b022b912b1caf8d19e1cc7201fdd1628a`) and `terrain-300fd-3010c` (`0206f86be19d8ccc3eceeb3893191ac29fb628bfd8df03a919cf07b5e4759bde`). Earlier source-art and complete scale 1–4 reviews remain applicable to their unchanged raw/crop bindings. Registration belongs to the coordinator.

Foreign damaged-state neighbors remain original fallback. Their coarser material patches are visible and add no HD destroyed-art coverage. The first canonical terrain family still has no declared destroyed partner. This approval covers these 48 remastered source pictures and the final composer presentation, not the uncompleted 5,753-picture catalog. The renderer owner's 13 portable checks, corner/grain regression and native 32-phase cache/damage checks are complementary runtime evidence; the visual review does not manufacture a new gameplay/performance result.

Restart checkpoint: `.reference/hd-full-review/restart-checkpoint-2026-10-11.json`. The next independent queue is Flare26 v2, Muzzle4 v4, SmallAir14 v2, Coconut4, then the nine reserved enemy families (35 frames): `10311–10314`, `10334`, `1033d`, `1033e–1033f`, `10340–10343`, `20053`, `20056`, `2006f–2007b`, `20080–20087`. Existing historical effect holds remain attached to their rejected candidate hashes until each new correction is reviewed. Death Ray/Energy equipment is reserved to another reviewer.

Current `render.rs` differs from the frozen corpus due to menu font color/text clipping and a separate cosmetic lightning function drawn after terrain. Root confirmed Canvas scaling, blit, indexed shading and terrain composition are unchanged. The exact current/frozen hashes and this scope are retained in the independent evidence; no terrain acceptance is inferred from unrelated menu tests.


## 2026-10-11 prior cohort journal

The source/enemy/equipment cohort at `.reference/hd-full-review/enemy-equipment-cohort/` was independently inspected completely at original and Rust scales 1–4, with fresh 168 scale outputs for 42 frames. All 42 were approved: Ground Missile pickup v6 (1), Turret (4), Pulse equipment (2), Energy Grab equipment (4), door `10142–10150` (15), bonus `10151` (1), treads `10300–10303` (4), hovercraft `10304–10305` (2), statics `102fa`, `102fd`, `10327`, `10331` (4), `102fe–102ff` (2), corrected TARG10 v3 `10161` (1), and fighters `1032f`, `10309` (2). Exact candidate digests and frozen candidate copies remain in that cohort's `candidates.json` and runtime evidence. Two peripheral single-pixel Energy Grab holes and tiny peripheral fighter holes differ from source, while the primary transparent loops/slots are preserved. Fighter `10309` has brighter copper material (occupied mean RGB 64/47/42→82/58/52), disclosed and accepted independently of the separate bright-soil issue. TARG10 v3 restores subdued brown soil and supersedes its earlier orange-ground hold.

The eight-frame addon `.reference/hd-full-review/soil-and-tiny-projectiles/` also passed every source and actual scale 1–4 view. Corrected ground `1013b` (`23be1ef3cca01b1c6b82b0984cbd07c8817b8c4a3a83edfe5c140828e0f5c9e2`) and `10160` (`90938e509abe1f82c9c7aba48e322697a36947808dc885a538a6b1e17ead8966`) restore quiet rust-brown soil and supersede their old candidates' brightness holds. Forward Guns/MiniGun four 2×2 phases `101c3–101c6` (`1193e3810f7be2063d3e29dfda07b060bd2c232d0df044303577099261140bf2`) preserve each gray/white native mask and phase. Mine two phases `101d1–101d2` (`5da8b059289e3147b433adf1128d86aaf3417e4f1678213ac17e3e6dce8ee204`) preserve pink/burgundy centers and gold corners, with somewhat duller warm patches accepted. No live scene occurrence is claimed by these gallery checks. Coordinator confirmed all 40 addon source/scale PPMs match the independent outputs byte for byte.

Six further complete phases were approved in `.reference/hd-full-review/laser-and-pulse/`: Forward Laser **equipment** `102c8–102cb` (`4d849e980722dd1ddc948d7a7faab98f268c8c97dc112689f3215286f863111b`) retains four rod heights/light indicators and restored opaque backing; Pulse Cannon **projectiles** `10223–10224` (`9c362e95417cc6a7025bd70012890ca9126fa6236c19aa3721b320d9aa5c70ef`) retain exact logical alpha, the muted lavender arches, open centers and native offsets. This does not approve the separately held Forward Laser projectile family.

The independently frozen 215-frame manifest (`69c1f9d46c5e5137b444bcde002f6d0216312b613cacc91c3aaa20f60face5e2`) passes a fresh isolated actual Rust validation of all 860 scale outputs with zero diagnostics and no stale source-loader flag; its source and candidate bindings are in `.reference/hd-full-review/snapshot-215/`. Each active family was independently reviewed in the earlier cohorts. The complete comparison is now finished: all 1,075 original/scale PPMs match prior independently reviewed cohort outputs byte for byte, recorded in `.reference/hd-full-review/snapshot-215/prior-reviewed-byte-comparison.json` (`c5f7bd987e086f5a5edd2a1d3fbf223b651347c5a27107f8841ecdbd025f850c`). This closes the historical215-frame comparison without implying a new whole-pack visual review or relabeling it as the later active manifest. Coordinator reported active coverage 221 after the six later phases, before the new terrain acceptance.

Original player runtime captures at `.reference/secondary-effects/native-player-banking-flames-{sd,hd}.png` and `native-player-family-{0,1,2}-{sd,hd}.png` were independently inspected for complete HD bank families, SD/HD flame phase pairs and firing context. Original anchors, banking alignment, cyan flame phases, localized amber flash and clipping are clean; root's capture test also preserves world digest. The capture was made against the reported 165-frame manifest `3ba076d98f644f39ca6769633f91f83c0b20a9af44036d2afe7905839ddd3310`, so that historical route proof must not silently be relabeled as a later whole-pack capture.

The earlier portrait SDL comparison is historical at its previous menu location. The menu is now logical 400×225 with portrait `(30,45)`; current individual `.reference/ui-all/` captures and `.reference/interface-hd/pilot-menu-400x225/` evidence are the relevant route proof. Pre-existing audit-sheet images are stale. The interface owner independently recomputed the four outside-photo comparisons and reports byte-identical surroundings; current-layout independent viewing by this reviewer remains pending.


## 2026-10-11 effect corrections and Coconut

Independent review of the complete 48-frame combined candidate produced 192 current asset-loader outputs at scales 1–4, with no diagnostics or added reserved indices. All 12 original/1×/4× pages and four native 2×/3× boards were viewed. The broader game-source freshness flag remains true due to unrelated game/menu work, so this is standalone asset/rendered-raster proof, not a new full-Host capture. Full candidate/raw/page bindings and decisions are in `.reference/hd-full-review/effects-corrections-and-coconut/independent-review.json`.

Approved: Muzzle four phases v4 `101c7–101ca` (`bf3d51a434d70a68c42412bf6ad36b88e3e1b0b366f11c1113fbeebac538dd26`), SmallAir fourteen phases v2 `101fc–10209` (`939b87d98431626c0ab9c72685ccd0de48f5259b1fc722a3fedf9e1c96bc2fe8`), and Coconut four phases `1024d–10250` (`153ab82bdab15987be1e92a5779eaa8de4f7386ebf5cec35a60bb399de2c1916`). Muzzle's dim stages now keep source brightness and distinct native bounds. SmallAir's final 23-pixel source mask, bounds and separated left fragments are restored; the other 13 frames' complete source/scale outputs are byte-identical to the earlier reviewed cohort. Coconut retains native offsets, stepped contours, opaque near-black spots and dull tan/burgundy patches, with restrained husk detail.

Flare26 v2 (`ac360b618f5538a06b8989bb79e7282e4720b5811c484a01c1c34c40a0a822d2`) remains held for a **new, separately specified material/coherence issue**, rather than its resolved transparency defect. All scales of `10267–10269` now show original background at center `(16,16)`; source central 7×7 background counts 12/30/46 correspond to HD 1× counts 14/32/46. The other 23 frames' five source/scale PPMs are byte-identical to the preceding reviewed version. However, the three generated corrections use dark-bordered rectangular pixel-cell slabs and brick-like lava grain, visible at 2–4× and in unchanged raw `generated-v2.png`. This abruptly differs from adjacent organically detailed fire/ember phases. The artist has been asked to regenerate only these three with original holes/branches and adjacent remaster style, explicitly excluding beveled/outlined pixel-cell grids and metal/brick material. Earlier rejected hashes and original-hole evidence remain preserved.

Independent current-layout portrait review is now complete: all four SD/HD photo crops and one complete Main-menu view were inspected, and all eight capture hashes plus every full-pair difference were independently recomputed. Every changed pixel stays in the screen portrait bounds `(96,184)–(224,312)`; surrounding UI bytes match. The 400×225 canvas at portrait `(30,45)` keeps portraits, pilot text, menu labels and footer readable without clipping. Evidence `.reference/hd-full-review/portrait-current-layout-independent.json` binds exact `fdf2ff0` capture binary `da750499800d33884ddc8ea2beccd3b0339058012525b60805341335d9d28bcb` and unchanged portrait frame binding; it does not claim newer navigation changes were captured.

## 2026-10-11 reserved enemy cohort

The nine reserved enemy families, 35 original pictures, have completed independent original/1×/4× review on all nine pages and native 2×/3× review on all five boards. The isolated actual Rust loader produced 140 outputs with no diagnostics or stale source flags. All candidate and raw artwork hashes remained unchanged; original and HD reserved-palette index counts are zero. Exact candidate/source/raw/output/page bindings and per-family decisions are in `.reference/hd-full-review/enemy03-reserved-35/independent-review.json`.

Approved 33 pictures in eight complete families: `10311–10314`, `10334`, `1033d`, `10340–10343`, `20053`, `20056`, `2006f–2007b`, and `20080–20087`. The rotor sequences retain orientation and native offsets, the machinery keeps recesses and materials, and both complete shutter-to-turret sequences preserve stage progression. The opaque olive/gray/green ground contexts preserve original material regions; this gallery does not prove their terrain joins or live enemy reachability.

The two-frame `1033e–1033f` family remains held at candidate `65966d76a5311858e8c29649f7c0658421a52372689ef6f3d93ddc619659cfc2`. Frame `1033f` has a detached gray vertical strip at actual HD 4× column 0, rows 33–59, also visible at 3×; the original left column is entirely transparent. `.reference/hd-full-review/enemy03-reserved-35/1033f-alpha-detail.png` records the artifact. Its apparently favorable native mask score does not excuse the border artifact. The artist should inspect the unchanged atlas cell boundary and exact source canvas before proposing a correction; no source body pixels should be trimmed to conceal it.

The Git root is now `RustRaptor`; source-art and ignored review evidence paths remain in the parent workspace. This reviewer has staged and committed nothing. The coordinator reports active pack 298 after admitted terrain and independently cross-reviewed boss cohorts, before admission of these 33 enemies and the already approved 22 corrected effects. Coverage remains incomplete against all 5,753 required original pictures.

## 2026-10-11 laser power and endpoint corrections

Seven further complete phases are independently approved: Enemy Laser Power v3 `10245–10248` (`2d5ceba65e0745348119442db9eb2f19bc60a0c07678054e79554e1583deb21e`), Bomb v2 `101d3` (`8225689631f1b65ed4704a6fb0bce65b0130213d41ed8850affd990fdcc232c8`) and Enemy Missile v2 `101d4–101d5` (`69b53e415efc1ac52c927cd13ab72aa7481dc61572a20a3f6d1442b2482e72a4`). The fresh actual Rust loader produced 28 outputs without diagnostics or either stale-source flag. Every native mask is exact, source/native bounding boxes match, original anchors remain, and no reserved palette indices were introduced. All source/1×/4× rows and enlarged exact 2×/3× outputs were viewed.

Laser Power keeps pale broad early cores and darker narrow late phases with fine heat grain. Bomb and Enemy Missile keep red/gray/blue material regions, fin positions and exhaust phase offsets; somewhat darker gray highlights are accepted with readable fine casing detail. Evidence and all raw/candidate/source/output/page hashes are in `.reference/hd-full-review/laser-power-and-endpoint-projectiles/independent-review.json`. This is raster approval, not new live scene or simulation proof.

## 2026-10-11 gold flash and original standalone opening cards

Gold pickup flash `102db–102de` is independently approved at candidate `7c4b3f9bb38ad5ac12fc55da8866a92588fc68bbc78273b11ad54f943ef2b290`. Every phase has an exact native mask/bounds/origin and preserves the large → medium → small/dim → medium sequence. The repeated `102dc`/`102de` originals, raw artwork and every actual scaled output are byte-identical. Complete source/all-scale viewing confirms phase distinction and restrained glow with zero newly animated palette indices.

All three complete original 320×200 opaque cards are independently approved: APOGEE `1002b` (`3475eab74c4a6123f19ce480c4c5288aace2981b7f852eba7929f0d76aa3390f`), CYGNUS `1002d` (`9451cf6d88341ce3a69616c822cc9da2f481b7495dd4b0e0105effbf644efda0`) and TAIWARN `1002f` (`8c609ff0008d2a6a8c9330eb6e14c4ad458abc89cdf7ad09fe9295ba93a10d93`). APOGEE retains its title, complete tagline and planet/swoosh/star composition, with disclosed stronger nebula/star detail. CYGNUS retains exact two-line lettering, slabs, perspective and shadows, with disclosed brighter blue faces and metal grain. TAIWARN retains the original Traditional Chinese title/body/company/closing glyphs and five body line breaks, geometric logo and full-width red rule. The metadata crop removes precisely one pixel per edge of each untouched 1586×992 RGB output; no lettering, logo or planet is clipped.

Each card uses its authentic unfaded POG/CYG/TAI source palette with all 256 static indices allowed. All 64,000 original pixels of each independently decoded source raster match its authenticated prepared source PNG. Every original/native1× pair, complete native2×/3× board and full4× card was viewed; all 15 source/scaled card PPMs match the fresh independent renderer byte for byte. The combined seven-frame pass has 28 outputs, zero diagnostics and no stale source flags. Exact raw/source/palette/candidate/output/page bindings are in `.reference/hd-full-review/gold-and-opening-cards/independent-review.json`.

This is card artwork/raster acceptance, not a new SDL fade/cue proof. The prior engine tests cover APOGEE/CYGNUS still-picture presentation and fades; TAIWARN remains retained catalog art without an active opening cue. Original AGX films remain classic, and this does not change the separate sharp bitmap-font policy.

## 2026-10-11 refreshed complete catalog coverage audit

The independent strict source decoder again checks all 6,449 original INDEX entries and finds exactly 5,753 standalone pictures, including 4,768 outside `sprites/`. Exact source byte lengths, span terminators, source/palette/RGBA hashes, logical canvases and header options match the frozen completion ledger. Every picture still has `remaster_required: true`. All 674 picture-job target memberships preserve those source hashes/canvases and cover all 5,753 IDs; there are no missing, foreign or excluded original picture IDs.

The captured active manifest contains 340 source-bound pictures without duplicate IDs, source mismatch or anchor/canvas drift. Its SHA-256 is `648241ad22ff0863dc3824270d7275cd0184204369349ad0a359a4a08dc32097`; this snapshot is a metadata/coverage audit, not a new whole-pack artistic or live-rendering approval. Candidate stages and registration remain distinct from completion. Evidence `.reference/hd-full-review/catalog-coverage-2026-10-11.json` (`c612c947b0f36be2314698ac4e19f75acdaf8101afa8e025bf4082f35993e9ac`) binds the complete original inventory and all 674 job files.

## 2026-10-11 HUD picture family source-stroke hold

The complete 11-picture HUD family `10005–1000f` remains held at candidate `afdf80893e42db3bd2c2139106d9b5526d2f15e9e7219f08c965f6827cd242c4`. All three source/1×/4× pages and all three enlarged source/all-scale boards were independently viewed after a fresh 44-output actual Rust pass, with no diagnostics, stale flags or newly introduced reserved colors. These are N*_PIC catalog pictures, not the four original bitmap fonts.

Digit 7 `1000c` loses the original bright lower-diagonal pixel `(3,6)` (RGB223/138/24) at native HD1 and gains dark exterior pixel `(1,5)` (RGB89/28/4). This narrows/moves a real source stroke. Its favorable 0.926 native mask overlap does not establish stroke fidelity. The other 10 pictures preserve readable strokes, core holes and row placement, with separately disclosed peripheral dark alpha changes. A targeted genuine correction must restore the native digit7 contour before the complete family can be accepted; the remaining 10 must remain unchanged or be reviewed again. Exact source/raw/page/output/pixel-difference evidence is `.reference/hd-full-review/hud-pictures-11/independent-review.json`. No family approval or active live-route claim is implied.

## 2026-10-11 — Terrain 103b0/103c0 complete current-composer review

Approved exactly the 32 source-bound tiles in `terrain-103b0-103bf` (candidate `5e92494eb43d393b6e471890d0f62b70d1df1d0e3937e9987473b7b9aedf8758`) and `terrain-103c0-103cf` (`3b60736654d48b933215d20ed4b5f5c3ffa58b44705b2dc73e6a0ec65f0551e6`). Both unchanged raw atlases, all eight source/1×/4× pages and eight native 2×/3× pages were visually inspected. Bronze machinery, black recesses, silver pipes, mesh/grate bands, brown soil scars and cyan water boundaries remain source-aligned and readable; authored rivets, casing grain, pebbles and ripples add consistent detail.

The reviewer compiled a private diagnostic helper against the current library and unchanged grain-fixed `terrain_hd.rs` (`b30b4a65a9e646e9fe106041ad718eebd2740c6c90354267a7b17b770e50ebb0`). Every one of 120 declared cardinal pairs and 33 actual 3×3 samples was rendered at all four scales, producing 612 cases. Every replacement applied with no HD diagnostics; whole opacity, per-pixel original palette class and reverse overlay order checks passed. All 39 current full context pages were then visually inspected. Pipe/roof/canal edges and corners remain coherent; the repeated join ridges from the superseded compositor do not recur.

Exact dated acceptance and all 1,384 original/scaled/context PPM hashes are in `.reference/hd-full-review/terrain01-next32/independent-review.json`, SHA256 `ca8730305ce6cf3990ef40c22d30bfff74c28152d16524fc64e7426b92ea4d8a`. Raw hashes are `3950fc29f19b409b8150249c29b01d685e36c30fcf712eb8cee086db651057a2` (b0) and `8c522dec6bf065bee49af637fc2a9da4fd20895b16603e923c1328f673e46471` (c0). Current source component hashes equal those used for rendering. Historical owner probes against older libraries are not the acceptance evidence.

Every target has an empty `state_partners` list: this adds **zero** remastered destroyed partners. Original source scars/fragment pictures are preserved as themselves. Unremastered external neighbors remain lower-detail original fallback and still require their own genuine remasters. This isolated tile/context approval is not a new native Host scrolling, damage, fullscreen or world-neutrality capture. Registration remains coordinator-owned.

## 2026-10-11 — HUD picture family N7 v4 correction accepted

Approved the complete eleven N0–N9/N$_PIC picture family `interface-other-10005-1000f`, exact v4 candidate `a2d85dbca5f76f94eafbe70325f8a2907599fc0ff6aae89e171925d62518034f`. The missing lower N7 stroke in the previous `afdf8089…` candidate is resolved: its native occupied layout now exactly matches the source, the lower step and shortened dark final foot survive all four scales, and the invented `(1,5)` alpha is gone. All eleven originals and actual Rust 1–4× outputs were visually inspected on three complete five-scale boards after a fresh error-free isolated loader run. The row placement, digit strokes and core holes remain readable. These are HUD pictures, not the four preserved classic bitmap fonts.

The brightness difference is deliberately disclosed, not treated as exact RGB preservation: original gold `(3,6)` `223/138/24` becomes copper `158/56/12` at 1×; adjacent `(2,6)` remains gold `231/158/24`. Original shadow `(1,6)` `85/12/4` quantizes to olive `85/81/12` at 1×. The complete native lower diagonal stays opaque and readable, and its higher-scale authored surfaces remain gold-orange with shading consistent with the other numeral remasters. This localized shading variation is acceptable; another regeneration is not required by this review.

The other ten raw/crop/source bindings are unchanged. All fifty of their original and scaled PPMs byte-match the earlier independently reviewed snapshot, including the previously disclosed minor peripheral shadow-alpha changes; core holes remain intact. The untouched new N7 raw PNG was also inspected. Exact source points, source/raw/candidate/runtime page hashes and all 55 PPM hashes are in `.reference/hd-full-review/hud-pictures-11-v4/independent-review.json`, SHA256 `0265bf01fa89e99ac83ef4c413adb82101058386e8ce9db11e8bce7778784298`. This resolves the earlier whole-family artistic hold only for this exact v4 binding. Existing native HUD and currency supplied-art route tests remain separate; no new full Host capture is claimed here.

## 2026-10-11 — Riverbank and crossing terrain 103e0–103ef accepted

Approved the exact sixteen-picture candidate `8d16ab47efc069ab373b80647ff9f680a8338202e562c1dfd6bac49d9bcb6cd7` after viewing the untouched raw atlas, all four source/1×/4× sheets, all four native 2×/3× boards and every one of 64 current context pages. Source coast curves, rock placement, pale banks, moss/grass regions and both steel-sided/wooden crossing orientations remain aligned. Original plank spacing, posts, rails, beams, water gaps, shadows and debris positions survive all four scales; added ripples and ground grain introduce no new canopy, furrows, material crossing or recurring join ridges.

The private immutable current-composer corpus covers 283 declared cardinal pairs, 44 actual target 3×3 samples and 27 source-declared damaged-center swaps at scales 1–4: 1,416 cases. Every replacement applied with no diagnostics; whole opacity, original palette classes and reverse overlay order passed. The nine damaged partner pictures (`1050c`, `1050d`, `10510`, `10511`, `1050e`, `1050f`, `104ea`, `104eb`, `104ec`) retain original fallback: **zero damaged partners are remastered by this family**. External original neighbors also remain lower-detail fallback and still require genuine remasters; that visible texture-density difference is disclosed.

Evidence `.reference/hd-full-review/terrain01-103e0-103ef/independent-review.json`, SHA256 `2427f5c4b0d264b71654804c3bfbeee41ea69d424e9a04c7355bdf927031cb7a`, binds all 2912 source/scaled/context PPMs, raw atlas `1de996634c0edcca2e843c70fa11d6722de8760924582b484dd63e0c3285e745`, exact source/canvas/crop records and every viewed context page. Current relevant source hashes match the frozen proof, including grain-fixed composer `b30b4a65a9e646e9fe106041ad718eebd2740c6c90354267a7b17b770e50ebb0`; corpus proof hash is `525a80107a2ef93b671506d09b59aade7f4dc1a5e715991221eba1c49535e964`. Opaque mask overlap is not artistic proof. No new Host scrolling, fullscreen, damage or simulation-neutrality capture is claimed. Registration remains coordinator-owned.

## 2026-10-11 — Eight original UI pictures accepted

Approved five complete frozen families: SYSTEM DAMAGED `10011` v2 (`117d479efc9b40629197076f5e38e6a20c017bd1164df2bbb585bef489e5d61e`), counters `102df–102e0` (`afb2eecafc8c73b4dc00d830b6cd8390e7988533f6b0ffd11e7133a4191ed087`), checkbox OFF/ON `1012d–1012e` (`2eb314ddc9c38a152eabb47210867caa39a32bdd6bcdcecdaedde014e54138bf`), indicator ON/OFF `1012a–1012b` (`09ee9f9239be52063cabae5c5b8fd23c1a205f621b5412c6526ac3e2b1ab6850`) and question `1012c` (`3cda159ce12c3f6dc52ccb1e8eef471ca271aabf756456390da33c36c9099765`). Every untouched raw image, original/1×/4× row and complete native 1–4× board was viewed after a fresh actual Rust 32-output pass with no errors, stale flags or new dynamic palette labels. Exact source/canvas/crop/raw and forty source/scaled PPM hashes are bound by `.reference/hd-full-review/ui-pictures-eight/independent-review.json`, SHA256 `260a6256f99bbbaab606ea01f778defe67e0732e95f3d12c05b0908b37dbf06f`.

SYSTEM DAMAGED v2 restores exact original logical lettering cells and warning spacing; brighter gold/orange bevels preserve readable apertures and dark undersides. Both gold counters preserve their distinct symbols, central recess/lettering and outline shape. At native1 some black outlined cells become olive/brown, while higher scales retain dark readable edges; the disclosed shading change is acceptable. The two indicators preserve a clear bright-red versus dim-burgundy state with a continuous textured lens; the old tiled ON draft remains rejected. The question hook, dark shadow, open core, stepped contour, separate dot and row spacing remain source-faithful, with brighter blue edge detail.

Checkbox acceptance explicitly includes material judgment: OFF preserves its 28-cell gray perimeter and dark empty center, while ON retains the original segmented crossed-stroke positions and grayscale pattern. Brushed metal grain and bevels within source-gray cells remain appropriate and readable at all scales. Native brightness is **not exact**: five source52-gray cells `(0,0)`, `(1,1)`, `(2,2)`, `(4,4)`, `(5,5)` rise above64; `(6,2)` changes from77 to48. These are disclosed shading variations rather than lost/moved source strokes. Whole opacity and mask overlap alone did not establish this approval.

This is isolated artwork/raster review, not a new live menu/HUD capture. The four original bitmap fonts remain under their separate sharp-font policy. The suspected straight-alpha resampling diagnostic remains separately journaled; no loader or alpha policy changed, and this approval binds current actual output. Global admission remains coordinator-owned.

## 2026-10-11 — Shoreline, rock and fence terrain 103f0–103ff accepted

Approved exact complete sixteen-picture candidate `3e7b6f7e4f6355013cb815eb590862a72441bee983fc3145e8a18ab17b52f11f` after viewing all sixteen untouched raw thumbnails, four source/1×/4× sheets, four native 2×/3× boards and every one of 83 current five-column context pages. Original shoreline bays/corners, grass banks, fence rail positions/bends/material widths and four-/six-rock group counts and relative offsets remain aligned. Added brown ground/rock grain and teal ripples preserve source materials without invented canopy, regular furrows, new props, recurring seam ridges or material crossing. Fine checkerboard fence mesh smooths at native 1×; finer dark lattice remains visible at 2×–4×. Authored water-wave frequency/angle varies between tiles, and original fallback neighbors remain visibly lower-detail. These accepted detail differences are disclosed.

The private immutable current-composer proof covers 442 declared cardinal pairs and 48 actual target 3×3 layouts at scales 1–4: **1,960 cases**. All replacements Applied with no diagnostics; whole opacity, original per-pixel palette classes and reverse overlay order passed. All sixteen source state-partner lists are empty: **zero declared and zero remastered damaged partners**. External original machinery/wreck/shoreline neighbors remain separately required remasters; their presence is not destroyed-art coverage. Exact native comparison of three original fallback neighbor regions found 0 changed pixels, resolving misleading thumbnail stripe appearances without modifying artwork.

Evidence `.reference/hd-full-review/terrain01-103f0-103ff/independent-review.json`, SHA256 `35b0871570d1e4f57561b3d80e117371a616feee4a51a7d6090c9fc1eeb88da8`, binds all 4000 source/scaled/context PPM hashes, sixteen raw PNG hashes, source/canvas/crop bindings and all 83 reviewed context-page hashes. Corpus proof SHA256 `8c641364439cd4232e19f0e2991befd9219638731696f3143be7bdfdd55db619` pins immutable library `e8b521c4d9a6f2fdf087668c264487014925df129cdd4fa79959eb15286cf224` and unchanged grain-fixed composer `b30b4a65a9e646e9fe106041ad718eebd2740c6c90354267a7b17b770e50ebb0`; every current relevant source hash still matches. Current job hash `d1a770311acd4a3959b49acfcc9cac93eea90c64157099fd6056edf2edcb9107` differs from the corpus input only by target status/count metadata; all source/context/partner declarations are unchanged. Opaque-mask overlap alone did not establish approval. No new Host scrolling, fullscreen, destruction or simulation-neutrality capture is claimed. Global admission remains coordinator-owned.

## 2026-10-11 — Four complete original tank animation families accepted

Approved the exact fifteen-picture cohort: `30074–30077` (`9eb74fb9566b3ef05a4dc3234298cf9ee5d307d9836bd2c119bab9ef4f44a97d`), `30080–30084` (`1ace4e117a41b4a2790441b94331eb05bc7d66eb711100a0db325d068726758e`), `30085–30088` (`fb0785c9c88080cbee4602e784892ad29a71cdedbb2ded6f579e901e7c3db4dc`) and `3008b–3008c` (`05e1ca21fd8f7d7b02459175b03d963235f2b0eb86612276fffb52e4305ebfe1`). All four untouched raw atlases, every original/native1×/4× row, every native2×/3× row and enlarged whole-family source/4× animation board were independently viewed. Fresh immutable actual Rust decoding produced 60 scale outputs with no HD diagnostics, relevant-loader staleness or new dynamic palette indices. All 75 original/scaled PPMs match the owner’s frozen final evidence byte for byte. Built-in original outputs and repository raw copies have identical authenticated hashes.

The gray/teal tracked machinery keeps its central ladder, dark aperture and four authentic tread phases. The copper four-slat machinery preserves all five original highlight/recess stages, gray side bars and lower split legs; its pale copper bevels are slightly brighter, and source dark bands remain opaque recessed material. The bronze/gray family preserves the central framing, side pods and original fork-length progression (phase0 occupied through row29, later phases through row28). The horizontal red family keeps its original aperture, narrow slot, four gray rake bars, pale marks and distinct two-phase tread patterns. Shared physical/native scale and empty-margin alignment retain every raw alpha≥16 and alpha≥32 pixel without RGB/alpha edits.

Small-scale differences are disclosed: copper loses source black boundary `(3,27)` at1× in all five frames and at2× only `30082/30083`; bronze loses 3/4/2/4 source contour cells at1× and `(21,28)` at2× only `30087/30088`; red loses black `(1,14)` at1×. **Every original source cell survives3× and4×.** Gray/teal loses no whole source cell at any scale, with one added peripheral native cell in each later phase. Partial higher-scale boundary coverage remains recorded separately; native bounds/major limbs are not a crop-only approval.

Original stationary body colors are not byte-identical across authored frames. Independent actual indexed comparison exactly reproduces the owner’s row-based shade-change counts: gray/teal264/333/333 (4/5/4 cells at≥32-channel difference), copper89/124/126/128 (0/0/4/3), bronze171/167/167 (0/1/1), red51 (8). Most changes are small; original stationary logical block means at4× differ by≥32 in only4/6/3 of543 gray/teal cells,0/0/4/3 of341 copper cells,2/1/0 of485 bronze cells, and0 of275 red cells. Full-phase visual review found coherent material/architecture rather than displaced parts. These limited shade variations are accepted and explicitly recorded, not silently treated as original-body invariance.

Exact source/raw/candidate/crop/built-in provenance, all75 PPM hashes, viewed-page hashes, indexed source-class/missing-cell evidence and phase measurements are bound by `.reference/hd-full-review/tank-families-15/independent-review.json`, SHA256 `f6c62881aa1b2c8f035cd588b6d4e11b8b543af4a03a6a56616613afe6be7839`. Immutable library is `e8b521c4d9a6f2fdf087668c264487014925df129cdd4fa79959eb15286cf224`; broader unrelated game-source freshness is true. This is isolated picture/raster acceptance, not a new native Host enemy occurrence, timing, terrain, simulation-neutrality or fullscreen claim. Global registration remains coordinator-owned; root800 handoff is unchanged.

## 2026-10-11 — Terrain 10400–1040f material review: fifteen accepted bindings, complete family held

Finished strict independent review of exact sixteen-picture candidate `921ad8c070b11c9691c121f7f1681422d0a063221fcfca8043f4278a768cd5ef`. All sixteen untouched 1254×1254 built-in raw images were viewed individually, together with every source/native1×/4× row, every enlarged native2×/3× row and all **88** five-column current context pages. Authentic built-in original outputs and repository raw copies are byte-identical; every prompt/request/reference binding is retained. No raw RGB/alpha edits or crops were applied.

The exact bindings for **10400–10405 and 10407–1040f** pass artistic review. Horizontal/vertical gray rims and their original shadow patterns preserve position and width; occupied earth/low-cover regions keep their native dominant cells and organic material. The eight-rock and seven-rock water groups retain original positions, gaps and compound shapes. Machinery preserves corrugation directions, cast shadows and all six components of the five grouped positions in1040d. Corrected1040e-v3 restores the original six-column warm rim at x15–20 around teal center x17–18/y25–26. Its darker rim shading, native1 dimming of small pale components, varied fine water ripple angle/frequency and greater detail density beside original neighbors are accepted and disclosed.

**10406 remains held**, and therefore the complete sixteen-picture family is not approved for registration. Its unchanged raw PNG SHA256 `4df667db387e15cc6a8c5067df4a1fceb6fe56ab4e4d504231e5f6cc4f8f0159` renders the original occupied organic ground as hard rectangular textured soil panels/maze at actual3×–4×. Dominant native color cells remain aligned, but the subpixel material invents structural paving. Full raw and runtime evidence in `10406-material-grid-diagnostic.png`, plus contexts037–040, establishes this independently of mask/opacity scores. The author agrees that the original contains earth and low cover, without evidence for slabs. Sibling10407 was separately inspected at full raw size and enlarged actual4×; its softer irregular boundaries do not exhibit the same panel defect.

The private immutable current-composer corpus exercises 531 declared cardinal pairs, 46 authentic target3×3 layouts and18 source-declared damaged-center swaps at all four scales: **2,380 cases**. Every available replacement Applied without diagnostics; whole opacity, source palette classes and reverse overlay order passed. Damaged partner104f4 for1040a–1040e and10410 for1040f remains original fallback: **zero newly remastered damaged partners and zero destroyed targets**. An additional isolated15-frame pack leaves held10406 original and repeats all2,380 cases. Its18 changed context cases were viewed on four additional five-column pages; all other outputs match the completed88-page corpus. Original fallback and accepted neighbors retain landmarks/material boundaries without recurring compositor ridges.

Final evidence `.reference/hd-full-review/terrain01-10400-1040f/independent-review.json`, SHA256 `e8254870c26cf95c4add0a08ababa03e6108086a33aa2feadf4d3849bfc16a46`, binds exact candidate/source/raw/provenance/library/composer hashes, all88+4 viewed context pages, 4,840 original/source/scaled/context PPMs and the additional4,760 fallback-corpus PPMs. Immutable library SHA256 is `409b38ea7760734201caf6dfbdd1d08c77ed903c18d7d7450dcd964b1a81fc39`; relevant assets, HD, rendering and grain-fixed composer source hashes still match. Composer remains `b30b4a65a9e646e9fe106041ad718eebd2740c6c90354267a7b17b770e50ebb0`. Current job hash `fdc8ca359cb462ba55f1b2a924fb59f5fca12c9f4fc6e9b3196aabfa5f34419e` differs from frozen corpus job only by16 target status fields and status-count metadata; source/context/state declarations remain identical.

This is a partial artistic verdict with exact preserved bindings, **not authorization to admit a partial family**. A genuine10406 correction must preserve the other fifteen raw/source/canvas bindings and exact reviewed scale outputs, then complete a new sixteen-frame sibling and current changed-context review. No new Host occurrence, scrolling, fullscreen, destruction timing or simulation/RNG-neutrality capture is claimed. Registration remains coordinator-owned; the earlier root800 runtime handoff and later development snapshots remain separate from this review.

## 2026-10-11 — Original SHIP25 singleton accepted

Approved exact `1032e` candidate `dc571a8b0c8e025cac4311af9c1806fdfb68e47ac1ac0f19dfb72d685af42291` after inspecting its complete untouched 1254×1254 raw, original source sheet, source/native1×/4× row and enlarged exact native2×/3× outputs. The three gray posts, bronze side pods, upper bronze patch, central recess/ladder, ordinary red wingtips and lower gray block preserve original architecture and material positions. Fine seams, rivets, worn metal grain and locally brighter steel/copper bevels remain coherent. Dark original backing stays opaque material where represented; red tips introduce no flashing palette indices.

Small contour differences are explicitly accepted: opaque source palette31/RGB4 cells `(1,11)` and `(2,12)` disappear at1×/2×, with only `(1,11)` absent at3×. Every one of the422 occupied source cells retains some coverage at4×. Six cells have partial4× coverage: four upper post corners and the two dark tip-edge cells; each of the latter retains1/16 subpixels. Original bounds `(1,1)–(31,24)` and major limbs remain aligned. The exact32:24 crop `[129,252,996,747]` retains every raw alpha≥16 pixel without RGB/alpha edits. This acceptance includes explicit low-scale contour/material judgment, not merely native alpha IoU0.9953.

At the recorded invocation, immutable Rust library SHA256 `0ec6137e0e3261e813b2b863cd96c04da55e07cdf29b5c10b1d112e20f0a3daf` had neither stale-source flag. Independent native decoding verifies every prepared source RGBA pixel, authentic PALETTE_DAT hash and original encoded sprite hash. All five source/scaled PPMs match the frozen owner's gallery byte for byte; independently recomputed missing/partial-cell, source-class and reserved-index evidence also matches. Raw SHA256 `25569f7fbe32797c045628470ba889f647c35883c4929df4bc100312178c65a6` equals the authenticated built-in original. Subsequent Stage2 API/source changes make the broader library epoch historical; admission must separately verify exact output continuity with the current source/build.

Evidence `.reference/hd-full-review/ship25-1032e/independent-review.json`, SHA256 `afa0b45fb0302c681bba5e5cced2309756e633c6b5083ad5f2fb1eb7e6100f32`, binds exact source/raw/crop/provenance/library/PPM/page hashes and all four indexed scale rows. This is isolated picture/raster approval; no live Host occurrence, motion, terrain, sound, collision, simulation/RNG, fullscreen or animation-sequence proof is claimed. Registration remains coordinator-owned.
## 2026-10-11 — Corrected original terrain10400–1040f accepted as a complete sibling

Approved the complete sixteen-frame candidate `2605e5ce6a4b02bbb6b021796e3d010745acf96c379cc23a4e1f1eab297bdaec`. Only10406 artwork changes: untouched genuine built-in raw SHA256 `610644fd57fd16b6d00feb9cef983d379ec0a6ef7a2476db01dc65beb07896ef` replaces the earlier unsupported slab maze with rounded irregular copper-brown earth and dark olive low ground. Full1254×1254 raw and original/native1×–4× outputs were inspected. Original dominant ground cells and the horizontal shadow-to-lit boundary remain aligned; fine grain does not introduce structural paving. The historical10406v1 hold and partial15 report remain intact and apply to their exact old bindings.

Fresh private immutable `636eccd24f56fc08ed25aa3bdf311d0b9e26284f2c95ab5ab6c6df070edc3b7c` renders all2,380 context cases:531 cardinal pairs,46 authentic3×3 scenes and18 original-damaged-state substitutions at each scale1–4. Every2,380 source output and2,308 HD output matches the prior completed88-page corpus byte for byte. Exactly18 physical context cases change at every scale; all eighteen were independently viewed across four source/1×/2×/3×/4× pages. Original structures, shadow boundaries, joins and corners remain coherent without recurring compositor ridges. All fifteen previously accepted sibling bindings/raws and76/80 source/scaled asset PPMs are unchanged; all80 current asset outputs match the frozen owner'sv4 corpus.

The pinned library belongs to source epoch `04885ce95b1884887195684afc583047674cf49018280b6e6aa032571439fa7a`. Relevant loader/render/grain-fixed composer hashes are exact and not stale; the broad newer-game-source flag is honestly true because desktop test code was changed later. This evidence does not relabel636 as a newer complete-game epoch. The first automatic helper invocation selected an incompatible feature/dependency build and failed before rendering; its failure is journaled separately, and a private compile-compatible636/serde pin supplied the actual proof.

Foreign damaged partners104f4 and10410 remain original fallback: **zero newly remastered destroyed partners and zero destroyed targets**. No new Host occurrence, scrolling, fullscreen, gameplay timing, sound or simulation/RNG capture is claimed. Complete-family source/art/composer approval is separate from coordinator admission and the earlier root800 runtime handoff.

Final evidence `.reference/hd-full-review/terrain01-10400-1040f-v4/independent-review.json`, SHA256 `7fe17ddcc8e71f75d112f3940b054d9de3091fb4fb9ede7cb198a1be2d57eae2`, binds exact candidate/source/raw/builtin provenance, source epoch and age flags, fifteen-sibling continuity, all4,840 PPMs and four freshly viewed changed-context pages. Registration remains coordinator-owned.

## 2026-10-11 — Complete original-picture coverage independently recounted

Strict decoding of all6,449 original INDEX records again finds **5,753 required standalone pictures**, including4,768 outside `sprites/`. Every original source hash, authentic palette, decoded RGBA hash, canvas and header option matches the earlier exact inventory. All5,753 remain marked for remastering, and the674 canonical picture jobs collectively cover every required ID. Three additional diagnostic-union job files are explicitly recorded separately; they do not create extra originals or replace canonical ownership. Classic AGX playback and four sharp bitmap fonts remain an explicit preservation policy.

At this immutable metadata snapshot, the development manifest contains **1,148 source-bound frames**, leaving **4,605 required pictures unregistered**. Source hashes, native canvases, anchors, uniqueness and artwork existence were independently checked. This count proves catalog/metadata coverage only; it does not add artistic acceptance, live renderer evidence, runtime packaging or complete-game approval. Evidence `.reference/hd-full-review/catalog-coverage-current-2026-10-11.json`, SHA256 `dfd6e5ca65af0bbea8ceac1865753844ee1486f03d2f27f55a80eb123a7b26d2`.

The desktop source-note boundary is now independently clarified: the prefix before the main `#[cfg(test)]\nmod tests` module hashes to `8bbd655a1a8cc3d417b5dc189298fe72a90d66b42f38c85a61d181884ba85758`; the shorter prefix before the first test helper hashes to `69071073922c512b627571d041fa9ec08d5a6a97eace9cdffcf7a81184ff0920`. Both match Git HEAD byte for byte. The main-module prefix includes two unchanged test helpers and is not labeled pure production. Supplemental evidence `.reference/hd-full-review/terrain01-10400-1040f-v4/desktop-source-note-addendum.json`, SHA256 `bb8bd6792beabad4ff856adf409553105c56123e38fb5149d8878fc53155c815`, resolves the note without rewriting the accepted review or clearing its broad age flag.

## 2026-10-11 — Flare v10 holes resolved; complete family held for late material

Independently reviewed all 26 frames of candidate `0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3`, all five selected untouched raw atlases, seven original/native1–4 pages, native2–3 values, the ordered full sequence and a separate late-brightness comparison. Actual indexed Catalog/HdAssets proof confirms the five-cell10258 and two-cell10266 source holes are now completely clear at every scale. Every74/378 occupied source cell survives. The nine pale cross cells and fine source-colour detail of10258 are restored; its source-cell segmentation is accepted as original geometry with actual fine palette variation.

The complete family remains **held for material/brightness in10266,1026a and1026b**. The new10266 artwork adds pale pinpoints absent from the original dying amber phase: actual4× RGB235/223/142 at `(97,41)` maps to original logical `(24,10)` RGB223/138/24. A darker average body does not remove those invented hot highlights. The two final deep-red phases also become visibly warmer and brighter: actual4× RGB190/69/20 and158/56/12 at `(21,106)` both map to original `(5,26)` RGB85/12/4. This drift is visible at native1× as well. Whole-phase visual judgment is supported by exact samples and luma counts; these numbers are not an arbitrary universal acceptance threshold.

Successful transparency and material corrections are preserved. Historical10267 checker/slab material is resolved into organic ember grain; disclosed10267/68 hole-boundary intrusions, rounded contours, late missing cells and earlier hotspot differences remain explicit caveats. A genuine correction should target only the three blocking frames, retain the other23 bindings and the correct holes/cross, then complete a fresh whole26-frame review. No partial family admission follows. All historical proposals and holds retain their exact original scope.

Fresh canonical-helper proof uses immutable `1a6e8d9eb55b55b9177ce2af848a37b0f62214259073ac3e885195ebb68777e8` with compiler-tested matching serde. Both source-age flags are false and all source hashes remain stable during indexed review. All130 own source/scaled PPMs match the frozen owner's636 v10 corpus;122 match heldv8, including120 outputs of the24 unchanged bindings. Five raw files exactly match authenticated built-in originals; every meaningful alpha≥16 pixel survives its own source-aspect crop. All1,543 owner-frozen files remain unchanged.

Evidence `.reference/hd-full-review/flare26-v10/independent-review.json`, SHA256 `448d1e14825d5ade5d33a10fbc631c083bbd4dcd19facbacd11ddb3ad31fd2c8`, binds every source/raw/crop/provenance, all130PPMs, all actual indexed source cells/holes/classes, complete viewed pages and targeted brightness samples. No production art, candidate, global manifest or Git edits, live Host occurrence, playback cadence, light shader, sound,1080p, collision or simulation/RNG proof is claimed.

## 2026-10-11 — Sparkle v11 accepted as a complete seventeen-frame sibling

Approved the complete `1026c–1027c` candidate `2ba86de91a31034a187bc61adc8f7f3d757f14e0f4e2f9d0f52a3910fdf48d96` after viewing all seventeen originals, all five untouched authenticated raw atlases, every source/native1×–4× row, the ordered whole sequence and a separate corner/ray-tip comparison. Source-centered32×32 canvases, original expansion, radial directions, gray/white hot patches, dark occupied backing, opening rings and separated fading fragments remain coherent. Middle phases have stronger authored fine grain; local gray highlights and darker final debris are accepted shading variations, not exact original color identity. No invented gold/amber glow or new bright terminal blast appears.

The formerly held six phases now restore original bright-ray emphasis and opaque lower backing. For example, `10272(23,19)` changes from the old4× mean38.17/max105 to current223.85/max227 with4/16 occupied samples; native1× still reduces that thin endpoint away. The formerly erased `10273(20,4)` source150-gray now survives every scale, retaining12/16 samples at4×. Previously near-black `10274` lower tips and `10275` left tip recover source-gray contrast. Original ten-cell10277 and28-cell10278 holes remain completely empty at every scale in an independent actual indexed Catalog/HdAssets proof. The earlier10279 two-cell boundary-notch intrusion is retained and explicitly accepted:32/1248 painted hole samples at4×, with76/78 original native hole cells wholly clear. This is not a false all-holes-exact claim.

Contour caveats remain explicit. At4×, `10272` loses the isolated105-gray `(10,20)` side corner; `10273` loses142-gray `(5,10)` and93-gray `(6,15)` side corners; `10277` loses60-gray `(10,2)`, `(27,20)`, `(6,23)`. Native1× losses in those phases are13/9/36 occupied cells. The adjacent left ray tip of10273, lower-left ray of10272 and major dark limbs of10277 remain intact; these limited rounded corners and thin native reductions are accepted after source/local/whole-sequence inspection. Partial high-scale edge coverage, prior small unchanged silhouette differences and stronger local shading are bound in the report rather than silently treated as exact pixels.

Fresh immutable `1a6e8d9eb55b55b9177ce2af848a37b0f62214259073ac3e885195ebb68777e8` and compiler-tested matching serde produced all68 scale outputs without diagnostics. Both source-age flags are false and the entire source snapshot remains stable through final verification. All85 original/scaled PPMs match the frozen owner'sv11 corpus byte for byte;61 match heldv8, including55 outputs of the eleven unchanged bindings. All1,149 owner-frozen files are unchanged. All five raw PNGs equal their authenticated built-in originals, and every meaningful alpha≥16 pixel survives its own exact source-aspect crop.

Final evidence `.reference/hd-full-review/sparkle17-v11/independent-review.json`, SHA256 `c2cafad57d5fbe3e079c8d5aeadd4a4f4073d2a88a943660f5ea6ed1af8ab36e`, binds all source/raw/crop/provenance/library/PPM hashes, complete viewed pages, actual indexed source classes/holes and targeted ray-tip samples. File closure SHA256 is `54042db49fac4aa87cf1364ff4eaad6fd0bec52ee50a3446d16f6eac62bd25e0`. Historical v8 whole-family hold `de6d412e1647168500778333c277d0823330c9b2d047fd3550ad09dd4bae562d` remains unchanged and applies to its exact old sibling. This approval covers complete-family artistic/raster fidelity, without new Host occurrence, playback timing, shade routing,1080p, sound, collision, simulation/RNG, runtime packaging or admission claims. Coordinator owns registration; the closed1,148 runtime handoff is separate.

## 2026-10-11 — Original IOTARG hatch/mechanism fourteen-frame family accepted

Approved complete candidate `c9e33f38d56d8e9d73e9ad940c0de619f09076e99114b7cc2ecb7474d479b8d9` for`40036–40043`, binding`f728390e9e8602ac01b0bcca87f7998373afa54486ff0d0653f9b7679609a462`. All fourteen original phases, three unchanged authentic built-in raw atlases, every actual native1×–4× row and the ordered whole sequence were viewed. The square gray frame, eight tan perimeter anchors, lower dark plate, pale frame edges, warning-stripe width/order and opening heights, dark occupied cavity, revealed metal dome and centered amber target remain aligned. Fine worn metal, restrained rivets/cracks and subdued red-brown pebbled earth now have consistent detail across all three source-faithful atlas parts. The historical coarse-material v1 hold remains tied to its old proposal.

The eight fully open phases preserve the original six-cell native amber footprint at centroid`(15.5,18)`. Higher-scale shade/border samples vary: the explicit central warm-color ROI covers5.5 logical units at4× in4003c–40041 and6.5 in40042/43. Earlier ROI counts include warning stripes and are not a semantic core mask. Source yellow/black warning stripes become dimmer olive at1× under current reduction, while2×–4× retain clear stripes and phase spacing. This shading difference is accepted; exact colors and identical high-scale warm-area counts are not claimed.

All802 source cells with identical original RGB throughout the sequence were independently derived. Actual4× adjacent mean absolute RGB-channel variation is4.127–6.818, reproducing the author's measurements exactly. Only4003d→4003e and4003e→4003f have one stationary cell whose logical mean channel difference reaches32; all other transitions have zero. The stationary central bounding-region subset x3–28/y3–28 has zero such cells in all thirteen transitions. Original outer soil mean144.17/102.39/85.99 changes to roughly135/93/78 in the first six remastered phases and131/89/74 in the later eight. These darker earth colors, minor part-boundary difference and varying fine grain are accepted after full-source/phase material review. This is not a claim of exact fixed-body pixels or a timed flicker-free capture.

Whole512×512 opaque source-aspect cell crops retain every visible pixel and native32×32 origin`(0,0)`. Only the final two cells of the contextual third atlas export40042/43; its first four generated reference-only cells are not reused or claimed. All1,024 original cells survive every scale, with no partial/missing cells or gained dynamic palette indices. Opaque coverage supports decoding checks and did not establish artistic acceptance by itself.

Fresh immutable`1a6e8d9eb55b55b9177ce2af848a37b0f62214259073ac3e885195ebb68777e8` with compiler-matched serde has both source-age flags false. All525 author files and the complete source snapshot remain unchanged through final verification. All70 original/scaled PPMs and all56 indexed scale rows match the owner's final a96f4772 build byte for byte. Final evidence`.reference/hd-full-review/iotarg14-v3/independent-review.json`, SHA256`ad3b5618793ba5f8833eee9fb763ee0a85bc9e8b5bc19f9323f419505745bbad`, binds source/raw/builtin/prompt/reference/crop and PPM hashes, full viewed pages, stationary measurements and indexed evidence. Closure SHA256 is`ac90992ee11aba8d42dd1cd1226bb7498a66fe997f744e470d2167c44418d4d3`. No live Host assembly/occurrence, playback cadence, terrain-neighbor seams,1080p, collision, sound, simulation/RNG or runtime-admission claim is added. Coordinator owns registration; the closed1,148 runtime remains separate.

## 2026-10-11 — Four original singletons with exact blink cues accepted

Approved exact singletons `20099` v3 (`070b6120cdf4e024b01fd700da9d54d4d53c5f2b7663f9188595506e4ae6612b`), `200ae` v5 (`0f79891d4129bf287d64d8adc83afc1721644b15f35ae4ef9338776db8397126`), `200b1` v3 (`4707eb1ada07ce628ca164db007bd74ef19d435fa4ebdf2cc70dc2c11085d329`) and `200b4` v2 (`654903cfc56f5545f0f8b6434bbaeb1980f92c96ac8df582d5ded9ad5605b01b`). Every authentic original, full unchanged built-in raw and actual native1×–4× picture was inspected. Original gray/bronze architecture, damage fragments, near-black occupied backing, muted teal inserts, central framing and original orientation remain source-faithful. New fine grain, scratches, seams/rivets and local brighter metal bevels are accepted material variations. These are four independent pictures; no intact/damaged sibling, alternate orientation or whole animation family is implicitly approved.

For20099, native1× loses gray32 `(30,2)` and four RGB4 outer corners `(1,24)`, `(30,24)`, `(2,25)`, `(29,25)`. Every source cell returns at2×–4×; partial edge counts are27/30/30. The top corner has3/16 coverage at4×, while the four dark corners retain4/4/8/6 samples. Source bounds and major forks/pods remain aligned; limited contour smoothing is accepted explicitly. The other three pictures retain all source cells at1×–4×. At4×,200ae has one ordinary dark cell with13/16 coverage,200b1 has two ordinary cells with15/16, and200b4 has three ordinary cells with15/16. Static indices232/237/239 are not falsely described as cycling/flash labels.

Independent actual Catalog/HdAssets source-relative checks verify green253/red252 pairs at original positions:200ae `(1,10)/(31,10)`,200b1 `(2,12)/(30,12)` and200b4 `(1,5)/(23,5)`. Each literal source index retains its entire1/4/9/16-sample footprint across scales1–4, with no extra dynamic cells.20099 introduces no reserved labels. This verifies indexed artwork cues rather than claiming a new live timed blinking capture.

All four source-aspect crops retain every meaningful raw alpha≥16 pixel;200b4 keeps its exact24:16 dimensions. All20 original/scaled PPMs and all16 indexed scale rows match the frozen owners' final evidence. Fresh immutable `1a6e8d9eb55b55b9177ce2af848a37b0f62214259073ac3e885195ebb68777e8` uses compiler-matched serde, with both source-age flags false. All359 owner files and the full source snapshot remain unchanged through final verification; historical holds retain their original exact scope. Evidence`.reference/hd-full-review/enemy-singles-four/independent-review.json`, SHA256 `58cdd6213bbb248cd605149828ba9695ee6f4aec0c5e35504ea91e803871de15`, binds source/raw/builtin/prompt/reference/crop/library/PPM hashes, full viewed pages and original-relative indexed results. Closure SHA256 is `08a367ab750a4958c153754234a2ddf1f11f6a7c9f61cd4a06c0b0e9482439a1`. No new live Host assembly/occurrence, timing,1080p, sound, collision, simulation/RNG, runtime packaging or registration claim is made. Coordinator admission remains separate from the closed1,148 runtime handoff.

## 2026-10-11 — Original terrain10420–1042f complete sixteen accepted

Approved exact complete candidate `f2d7e3acb9fe53148f3fa58a411e498317ac7b5adf9495bcc5261556817eddb8`, binding `ba619dec5d1bfd0182387b6e732b6a5075d35f51d12c1610877c3694b8c41689`. All sixteen literal original pictures, full unchanged built-in1254×1254 raw images and actual native1×–4× outputs were inspected. Selected10424/10426/1042c use genuinev2 replacements; the other thirteen retainv1. Earlier orange/glitter and rectangular gravel-grid drafts remain preserved and excluded. The corrections retain quiet rust-brown earth, gray-brown gravel and pale border stones. Original paired trench bends, inner shadows, diagonal/straight material cuts and pale rock-cluster landmarks remain aligned. New fine irregular grain is source-compatible and introduces no unsupported paving or structure.

Every609 declared cardinal pair and48 authentic native3×3 scene was independently rendered and inspected across all four physical scales:2,628 compositions. Every replacement reportsApplied, reverse overlay order produces identical indexed output, original palette classes are preserved, composed canvases remain opaque and the transition table is bounded at2MiB. All80 source/scaled picture PPMs and all1,314 scale4 context PPMs match the owner's frozen evidence byte for byte. All5,336 own picture/context PPMs were rehashed at acceptance. Native32×32 canvases and `(0,0)` anchors use the full raw without crop or retouch. Opaque-mask coverage is trivial and did not establish artistic acceptance.

The original59 review sheets had a presentation defect in their large3×3 scene rows. Those overlapping/cropped scene rows are explicitly excluded from acceptance. All3,045 cardinal image blocks were independently verified pixel-exact and their59 sheets were fully viewed. Twelve corrected400px-column/416px-row sheets display every48 complete scene without occlusion; all source and actual1×–4× columns on all twelve sheets were fully inspected. Four complete native-family boards were also viewed. The final evidence records this corrected scope without changing the retained earlier sheets.

Fine HD detail meets coarser neighboring original fallback visibly, particularly at2×–4×; this transitional detail-density difference is disclosed and accepted. No join-ridge recurrence or shifted material landmark requiring a hold was found in the complete isolated corpus. Every target has an empty native state-partner list: zero newly HD destroyed targets/partners are claimed. Foreign terrain, machinery, coast and null edge cells remain original fallback in the isolated16 pack. Global combined-HD seams, liveHost rendering, timed scrolling,1080p, simulation/RNG, collision and sound are outside this artwork review.

The actual immutable library is `1a6e8d9eb55b55b9177ce2af848a37b0f62214259073ac3e885195ebb68777e8`, with compiler-matched serde `7a13e07716f46f559cb9acf05c81ce0845e5633dfd3d77e6020e14af31a3a878`. Relevant loader age isfalse; the honest broad game-source age flag istrue. Source snapshots stayed stable during invocation; desktop.rs changed afterward only in the main test-module append, and its prefix before that module remains byte-identical at `8bbd655a1a8cc3d417b5dc189298fe72a90d66b42f38c85a61d181884ba85758`. This prefix includes earlier test helpers and is not described as pure production. Assets, HD loader, rendering and composer pins remain unchanged; composer is `b30b4a65a9e646e9fe106041ad718eebd2740c6c90354267a7b17b770e50ebb0`. No completed1a6 proof is relabeled as the laterda05 build.

Final evidence `.reference/hd-full-review/terrain01-10420-1042f/independent-review.json`, SHA256 `1e6a874bf088bbbfa7e3fd4283791515a839b9e6f81a88eec11dd61f2cb8c2a1`, binds source/raw/prompt/reference/built-in/manifest/library/PPM and every viewed page. All3,654 frozen worker files were rechecked unchanged, and all authentic built-in originals still match selected raws exactly. Closure SHA256 is `869ab5085778f27f2b2a773754116448154ecee4337ed8b61311dd293403d5af`; corrected scene-layout evidence is `32f2f2f5cc2ec38ffe04902dfca3a4297ee71443c87acc469939669ecde47be0`. Coordinator owns admission. This new approval adds no claim to the previously closed1,148 runtime handoff and does not claim complete5,753-picture coverage.

## 2026-10-11 — Four explicit source-driven enemy v2 siblings and NUMBER picture accepted

Approved only the explicit `candidate-v2-final.json` singletons for200e1 (`cc4a8b9e89f850422df760f3d51894e04e587098eafa508fb002670e6237a1d5`),200e4 (`789369cc582168ccc5db18336ca1ee4366be7147c1715e23fdb48b542d7c4da7`),200e7 (`dfd48d87c4e7cfd748fda04e18771e0e20d4297030f32a4b7cf6471bf12d3525`) and200ea (`33787991f15f98691addfd1c4a54dcecc0307eaf8f4849c8bfffedb08c05b08e`). Historical v1 main candidates/raw/proofs remain unchanged. Every original, complete untouched1254×1254 built-in raw and actual native1×–4× picture was independently viewed. The source bronze/teal module pairs, gray heads/ladder/pods, original asymmetric shading, occupied near-black recesses and restored lower tails remain source-faithful. New fine metal grain/seams/rivets and local brighter steel/copper bevels are accepted material differences. No paired variant, multipart assembly or whole animation is implicitly approved.

All739/638/547 occupied source cells of200e1/200e4/200ea survive every scale. Their partial coverage counts at1×/2×/3×/4× are0/0/2/9,0/0/29/39 and0/0/0/0 respectively. For200e7, native1× loses seven RGB4 outer cells `(4,7)`, `(5,8)`, `(6,9)`, `(7,10)`, `(10,26)`, `(11,27)`, `(13,30)` and brown `(22,16)`. Native2× loses only RGB4 `(10,26)`; every609 original occupied cell survives3×/4×. Partial counts are0/33/55/62. The separately boxed source-coordinate board and full-scale pictures show preserved head, short wings, six ordinary amber upper patches, ladder, paired lower pods, hinge and stepped tail. This limited contour smoothing is accepted explicitly; exact silhouettes or full-cell high-scale coverage are not claimed. The restored original right-pod strip x31/y16–24 survives3×/4×.

Actual indexed Catalog/HdAssets checks preserve the four literal source lamps of200e1: green253 at `(0,3)` and `(0,23)`, red252 at `(23,3)` and `(23,23)`. Each retains the entire1/4/9/16-sample footprint, with no additional reserved cells. All other pictures in this cohort introduce zero dynamic palette labels. This is artwork/indexed proof, not a timed live blinking capture.

Also approved exact NUMBER_PIC10129 candidate `8d590b22986d28e882d45e486c0deb17959056b0b69794ad071dfe2408ab420d`, binding `b01cfdb645f57c4f9fb4496c3111a61bf2ee413276fbe81e93ff7520ab3dd04e`. The literal historical `1-800-GAME-123` picture retains original stepped serif italic strokes, hyphens, spacing,8/0/A counters,G/M/E openings and final123 across all scales. Fine pearlescent lavender/blue grain and brighter reflections are accepted after full2172×724 raw and actual144×16–576×64 review. All746 original lettering cells survive; native1× alpha is exact. Native4× has only source `(8,12)` index116 at15/16 coverage. New boundary/fringe coverage is disclosed:4× occupied pixels13449 versus ideal scaled-source11936, bounds `(7,11)–(569,57)` versus ideal `(8,12)–(568,56)`. All seven enclosed counter centers remain exact background RGB20/28/38 at1×–4×, while some boundary subpixels fill. Higher-scale transparent holes are not claimed byte-exact. The exact9:1 crop `[80,247,1998,222]` retains every raw alpha≥16 pixel. The original font tables are unchanged; no valid phone number or live menu route is claimed.

All five source-aspect crops retain every meaningful raw alpha≥16 pixel. Authentic encoded source hashes/palette and prepared RGBA were checked against actual Catalog output; every selected raw equals its built-in original byte for byte. All25 source/scaled PPMs and all16 enemy indexed scale rows match frozen owner evidence. Every291 frozen worker file remains unchanged through final closure.

The actual immutable library is `ec8f03bf5eaf1fd1d698b7a111cfa5265043ef009f24b4b7a42e8579fb7f9211`, with compiler-selected compatible serde `ba61a9b6a7f97c994c6fdb2ab5e50915a5d6b456664f31709fd05306d56e48bd`. Both source-age flags were false at the recorded invocations. Root subsequently made real Host enemy/shadow changes to honor pinned_art_frame for mod enemies, so these flags remain historical pre-change observations. Closure records desktop.rs changing from `b9faaac3a3fe81ce3d6e8c0e2d61050b384b8fda4557a297e6555c2850b3aa38` to `7484c09ce6cdc0c0619c66875cd31446a22a14953aba706278714c7fb52504e8`; the prefix before the main test module is now `9552e7d30af666fc47212fae9e793084d9c26e012f51a4694b7f7bde95233d19`. It is not relabeled as the earlier8bbd prefix. Source assets/HD/render/composer pins remain identical. No current whole-game source-age or Host behavior claim is added.

Final evidence `.reference/hd-full-review/enemy-v2-four-number/independent-review.json`, SHA256 `8d8101ab8682b85572be70ee942befeccd87a2bc2a099790958b796ba6ad0ba8`, binds every exact candidate/source/raw/built-in/prompt/reference/crop/library/PPM/page and individual qualified decision. Closure SHA256 is `af4d331bf4a64588a23ea49f3241df84aefa7463bf65908a04c6e483bacb1e95`. No art/global/production changes or registration were performed. Live occurrence, animation cadence,1080p, collision, sound, simulation/RNG, packaging and runtime admission remain outside this isolated picture review. Coordinator admission remains separate from the previously closed1,148 runtime and full5,753-picture completion.

## 2026-10-11 — Source-driven SHIP04G1 v3 singleton accepted

Approved only `enemies-102fb-102fb/candidate-v3-final.json`, SHA256 `56eb2bc0560db8107727d385a2f31eba9a151078e4426e5cf167064c0c78e95a`; the historical heldv2 main remains unchanged. The complete original40×40 source, untouched1254×1254 built-in raw and actual native1×–4× outputs were inspected. The broad blunt upper wings/tips, stepped inner gaps, two upper gray blocks, long gray central strake, lower triangular wings, offset tail and original occupied near-black backing are restored. Bronze/gray planes and asymmetric underside shading remain source-faithful. Fine wear/seams/rivets, local brighter bevels and finer plate subdivisions are accepted after material review; source-cell metal segmentation is supported by this mechanical surface.

All692 original occupied cells survive every scale; native1× mask is exact. Only three ordinary upper-border cells retain15/16 coverage at4×: `(14,1)` index15, `(19,1)` RGB4 and `(26,1)` index8. The exact source-aspect40square crop `[103,103,1048,1048]` keeps every raw alpha≥16 pixel. No dynamic labels are introduced. All five source/scaled PPMs match frozen owner evidence byte for byte.

Evidence `.reference/hd-full-review/ship04g1-and-shop23/singleton/independent-review.json`, SHA256 `64ce18c689e63cd9522a38bae8a8a3f10b8b42dada642c1c7ab1c3fd6e4e1d48`, binds exact source/raw/built-in/prompt/reference/crop, library/serde and all actual raster/indexed evidence. Immutable library is `ee1fa1613717bfabbfa2894fee6af2cda933ac2d356b96e544cb16cc5b69e80e`, with matched serde `ba61a9b6a7f97c994c6fdb2ab5e50915a5d6b456664f31709fd05306d56e48bd`. Relevant source-age isfalse and broad game-source-age is honestlytrue. No flags are relabeled as a newer current whole-game epoch. Root reports the release includes its real Host pinned_art_frame change; this picture review adds no live Host test or route claim. Coordinator admission remains separate.

## 2026-10-11 — Complete23 shop-icon diagnostic advice; four targeted corrections remain

Independently inspected every one of the23 untouched full selected raws, authentic source pictures and actual native1×–4×/native2×–3× outputs of frozen `candidate-corrections23-under-review.json`, SHA256 `db65fc053ad0cb5b7d3b7d98bdf2177be423fecd89c74a7a543701906876ea09`, binding `eff3e7a28814b2d10f79096e05428610e98b7cd4ae6277fe49b57527d9b11cff`. All six complete five-column pages were viewed; no high-scale cell, full raw or source comparison was replaced by alpha-only judgment. All115 source/scaled PPMs match frozen worker evidence, and92 actual indexed outputs introduce no dynamic labels. This is complete diagnostic advice, **not complete or partial artistic approval or admission**. There is no candidate.json for admission.

Three geometry repairs are confirmed.102e7 loses source RGB4 bottom cells `(9,23)`, `(10,23)`, `(13,23)`, `(14,23)` at every scale; these are occupied backing around its blue/green feet.102eb loses original dark index28 boundary cell `(23,7)` at every scale. Selected monitor102f7v3 replaces six separate source row23 RGB4 tips at x2/4/9/12/17/19 with long connected bars: actual native1× occupies x2–10 and13–21. Its original x12/y20–23 mounting/backing is entirely missing at all scales, as is left corner `(0,15)`; `(1,15)` is missing1× and partial later. Private actual Rust indexed grid evidence confirms every source row/tip/mounting index and high-scale footprint. The source screen border, four green rows and lower modules otherwise remain coherent. Later held monitorv8 is explicitly excluded from this frozen review.

Additional material correction is advised for102f6v2. Its broad silver body and red caps become conspicuously brighter/glossier than the original matte-gray/dark-red hierarchy, beyond small local bevels. At original `(6,8)` RGB121/121/121 becomes native1×203/199/199 and4× cell mean196/193.75/193.75. Red cap `(6,2)` changes from97/8/16 to178/48/56. The complete material-detail page supports this source-shade judgment; the numbers are evidence, not a universal brightness threshold. Preserve its three missile/fins/black-band layout and restore quieter source midtones through genuine artwork correction. Four original lower gray cells disappear only1× and return2×–4×;87partial4× edge cells disclose contour narrowing.

The remaining19 pictures have source-compatible material/landmark advice, individually recorded without silent approval. Five brass rounds, gray circular machinery, paired columns/frames, warning bands, red/green missiles, gold/black disk, ribbed cylinder, round metal inset, green/red/gold/blue device, shieldS, energy capsule, cyan module, horizontal cartridge, oblique case, rusty tracked panel and brown/lavender rock retain their original identities. Fine brushed/worn grain and local highlights are qualified explicitly. Low-scale corner losses in102ea/102ed/102f0/102f4 return at higher scales and are distinguished from the all-scale geometry faults above; all exact missing/partial coordinates remain in the report. Current raw red/white/blue fringe is disclosed rather than assumed absent.

All selected crops retain every raw alpha≥32 pixel. The102f6 and102f7 crops discard32 and11 raw pixels respectively at alpha16–31; this does not silently become a claim that allalpha16 survives. Every selected raw remains byte-identical to its authenticated built-in original. All402 frozen selected worker/source/original files remain unchanged through closure. Source/indexed snapshots are stable during their invocation. Only desktop.rs changes after input, from `7484c09ce6cdc0c0619c66875cd31446a22a14953aba706278714c7fb52504e8` to `7a48e4e96ca3a926a4995dac7d31a1dca180b51aff7b682d17415c479ca1f04c`; its main-module prefix remains `9552e7d30af666fc47212fae9e793084d9c26e012f51a4694b7f7bde95233d19`. Assets, HD loader, render and composer pins remain identical. Actual immutable ee1fa161 has relevant-agefalse/broad-age true, retained literally.

Advice evidence `.reference/hd-full-review/ship04g1-and-shop23/shop23/independent-advice.json`, SHA256 `ce58351c27bc0b96dfa10fc4462d8e56e9bddcf4bb045a1643735910dbde81d4`, binds each selected frame/source/raw/builtin/prompt/reference/crop, all115PPMs, full pages, indexed grid and material samples. Shared closure is `e0fb51ba8d8798e61e67bc5fba3fd9c0faac06ec73ab9e0719c9dbd0ccc36968`. No generation, art/candidate/global/production/Git edits or registration were performed. Genuine targeted corrections require a later complete frozen23 proposal and independent review. Live shop/Host occurrence, timing,1080p, simulation/RNG, sound, collision and packaging are not proved. The closed1,148 runtime and complete5,753-picture goal remain separate.

## 2026-10-11 — Complete Flare v13 sibling accepted after late material correction

Approved only explicit `effects-10252-1026b/candidate-v13.json`, SHA256 `b28259e873372b920a327721ab86c1ee1a77cde010825afad648deddb42d7518`, as a complete26-frame sibling. The held main candidate/v10 remain unchanged at their historical hash. Every original source, all seven complete untouched authenticated built-in raw atlases, all source/native1×–4× rows including2×–3×, the ordered whole animation and the source/v10/v13 comparison were independently inspected. Only10266/1026a/1026b bindings change; the other23 bindings and115 source/scaled PPMs remain byte-identical to the earlier reviewed corpus.

The corrected10266 organic amber/brown grain removes the formerly invented ivory pinpoints. All378 source cells, exact bounds and the two-cell source hole survive every scale. Native peak exactly matches original; actual4× RGB239/178/28 at `(97,41)` maps to original `(24,10)` RGB223/138/24. Peak luma180.14 versus147.84 and17 above-source-peak samples out of6048 are accepted restrained amber shading after full phase/material inspection, rather than a universal brightness threshold. Occupied4× mean65.28 versus63.93 remains close to the source. Fine detail varies inside377 logical source cells at4×, with no invented slab geometry or new pale core.

Both final phases now retain the dim source-red fade and every171/52 occupied cell at every scale. Native1× masks/bounds are exact. Their native occupied means18.04/17.64 versus18.00/17.50 and native peak39.24/26.94 restore the source maxima;4× means18.89/18.07 and local peaks48.36/39.24 are accepted quiet red-brown grain. The earlier hot190/69/20 and158/56/12 pixels are gone.1026b has one extra4× boundary sample, disclosed instead of claiming exact high-scale coverage. All meaningful alpha≥16 pixels survive their original-aspect crops; only faintalpha1–7 padding is omitted from the three corrected raws.

The repaired10258 five-cell and10266 two-cell source holes remain completely transparent at every actual scale. Existing qualifications remain visible and explicit: rounded early ignition, native lost thin endpoints, curved rays, local hotter middle patches and source second-pulse expansion.10267/68 holes retain their previously disclosed4× boundary intrusion22/224 and46/816; source hole boundaries are not byte-exact.10268 still loses source `(29,1)` RGB158/56/12 and `(21,8)` RGB89/28/4 at3×–4×.10269 still loses `(29,1)` RGB125/44/8, `(29,9)` RGB89/28/4 and `(31,23)` RGB138/48/12 at3×–4×. These limited outer/notch smoothing differences are accepted after complete source/scale/sequence review. The report does not falsely claim every source cell of all26 phases survives. The original contraction, second pulse, irregular opening, radial limbs and separated final fragments remain coherent.

Actual immutable library `c0c3cfc7d4784afaf60342bf7f02b7db25fcd803c1fdc01faffd027116582338` with compiler-selected compatible serde `ba61a9b6a7f97c994c6fdb2ab5e50915a5d6b456664f31709fd05306d56e48bd` produces104 indexed/scaled outputs without diagnostics or gained dynamic labels. Both source-age flags are false at invocation and closure. The complete source epoch remains unchanged, including the current startup validation changes; historical v10/owner library flags are preserved separately. All130 own PPMs match the frozen owner v13 outputs and every2,710 worker-frozen file remains unchanged. Encoded source graphics/palette and prepared RGBA match actual Catalog output; seven raw files equal their authenticated built-in originals.

Final evidence `.reference/hd-full-review/flare26-v13/independent-review.json`, SHA256 `90e9d9ef7610e87747f75a1004542563c7654e84e075b52e4588ee76ff2c7063`, binds the complete qualified verdict, original/raw/built-in/prompt/reference/crop and library/serde pins, every viewed page,130PPMs and actual indexed classes/holes. Closure SHA256 is `6be5b786e197732c0e74c05a7e610408ef30ca9ce11d1ea6e6cd399eaa34d220`. No candidate/art/global/production/Git edits, registration, live Host occurrence/playback cadence,1080p, shade routing, sound, simulation/RNG, collision or packaging proof is added. Coordinator admission remains separate from the closed1,148 runtime and complete5,753-picture goal; every historical exact hold remains intact.