Files
RustRaptor/data/hd/jobs/derived-ship09g2-2009f-200a0-complete2-SourceG2-v2-20261019/proofs/different-intrinsic-ART/QUALIFIED-COMPLETE2-DIFFERENT-INTRINSIC-ART-ALL-NATIVES.json
T

175 lines
9.2 KiB
JSON

{
"status": "QUALIFIED_DIFFERENT_INTRINSIC_ART_COMPLETE2_WITH_LIMITS_CONTEXT_AND_ROOT_PENDING",
"reviewer": "/root/ship_code_review",
"author": "/root/infantry_remaining",
"author_report_sha256": "fe0f564b6cc9cf3f91550f02434bb021c47c5cb99e403192448d8ef8a175cb84",
"producer_seal_sha256": "a21ec85a59f4d73c03cf5d3e7834969b7998f76f5008665a91ad728f566ef940",
"candidate_sha256": "af1e192135108fed6c63b6dbfed72523508134055f1934dafa1a5cd8643def9d",
"actual_QA_sha256": "22686e242cfbbf977abbc28532dd0424511f44fb4706796062a8c0db5d200112",
"actual_indexed_bank_sha256": "b9b9b24c396dc9df3c26751d1da1ee8fc2ab5d5167f58b9652a434ea559f3216",
"physically_viewed": [
{
"path": ".reference/hd-SHIP09G2-actual-all-cyan-derived2-currentG2-author-20261019-v2/presentation-only/2009f-WHOLE-ORIGINAL-AND-ACTUAL-ALL-CYAN-NATIVE1TO4.png",
"sha256": "daf7598db5bddad59056c8d93bf668af6690570214f49a43062cbcb2e06f5a4c",
"scope": "whole saved image at original detail"
},
{
"path": ".reference/hd-SHIP09G2-actual-all-cyan-derived2-currentG2-author-20261019-v2/presentation-only/200a0-WHOLE-ORIGINAL-AND-ACTUAL-ALL-CYAN-NATIVE1TO4.png",
"sha256": "aa15f31fe9e0246c1f6ed5ce1f5113b522acaf63b2222d6f5b62cc5e114e0f69",
"scope": "whole saved image at original detail"
},
{
"path": ".reference/hd-SHIP09G2-actual-wake-derived2-currentG2-author-20261019-v1/presentation-only/2009f-WHOLE-ORIGINAL-AND-ACTUAL-DERIVED-NATIVE1TO4.png",
"sha256": "45a0957b1d0932c3d21fb9de38faa1f5053ce94ba1a69f5b266384957cb12673",
"scope": "whole saved image at original detail"
},
{
"path": ".reference/hd-SHIP09G2-actual-wake-derived2-currentG2-author-20261019-v1/presentation-only/200a0-WHOLE-ORIGINAL-AND-ACTUAL-DERIVED-NATIVE1TO4.png",
"sha256": "20eff64a7e14796978f8ba1095e1a08b370df4ea499b6ee7a67f0ff68961072e",
"scope": "whole saved image at original detail"
},
{
"path": ".reference/hd-SHIP09G2-actual-all-cyan-derived2-currentG2-author-20261019-v2/presentation-only/WHOLE2-ORIGINAL-VS-ACTUAL-ALL-CYAN-DERIVED4.png",
"sha256": "45083ae4d1e961ad4da796f71fbf4bb8c242622ae4979648708fccf2c989a778",
"scope": "whole saved image at original detail"
},
{
"path": ".reference/hd-SHIP09G2-complete2-Original-primary-author-20261019-v1/generated/SHIP09G2-COMPLETE2-PROVIDER-RETURNED-UNTOUCHED.png",
"sha256": "a35f0b3d93afd49f78bc7205463986f2a846491c11defbf16cadadca7dc859c8",
"scope": "whole saved image at original detail"
}
],
"physical_scope": "Both Original72x40 frames, final2 derived native4 masters, every actual final native1..4 enlarged and unscaled on2whole pages; old held native1..4 pages and genuine raw1536x1024 atlas compared. No live or timed context claim.",
"intrinsic_findings": [
"QUAL both phases: left-facing bronze oval mechanical craft, broad tan rails, black recesses and right silver twin-band pod are retained without invented gun/engine/appendage. Plate and gray pod detail read cleanly at native3/4.",
"The prior held pale gray/white highlight crossing cyan rim and internal cyan paint is gone in both phases at every native scale. Preserved actual gray engine/pod remains silver, rather than being recolored cyan.",
"Top/lower rightward wake lines and detached droplets retain two distinct Source phase layouts, transparent margins and natural72x40dimensions. No oversized wake, luminous aura, unwanted backing rectangle or clipping is visible.",
"Native1 is intentionally compact and native2 mildly soft after palette interpolation; native3/4 carry crisp fine material. Two frames align to origin0 with no visible body translation, scale pulse or new appendage in static paired review.",
"Whole raw generation contains bright glow and nearwhite trails; final Source-bounded cyan is visibly muted, with added support treated as functional geometry restoration rather than new generated detail."
],
"saved_array_proof": {
"verified_producer_files": 28,
"frames": [
{
"asset": "2009f",
"noncyan_RGBA_exact_samples": 11933,
"gray_RGBA_exact_samples": 4573,
"cyan_genuine_eligible_same_phase_tuple_samples": 9069,
"transparent_clear_samples": 25078,
"native1_mask_iou": 0.9932279909706546,
"maximum_donor_logical_distance": 3.9863384338424788,
"missing_fraction": 0.6603815194619032,
"scales": [
{
"scale": 1,
"canvas": [
72,
40
],
"PPM_exact_to_saved_bank": true,
"sha256": "8f886d091c976fe2de9f430db293895760f6ac7f0250d3d72d86d011d2fb4f40"
},
{
"scale": 2,
"canvas": [
144,
80
],
"PPM_exact_to_saved_bank": true,
"sha256": "72acf81c986f823e16753e1e8f1e707e84917dc060193f1ca7d9636980f89130"
},
{
"scale": 3,
"canvas": [
216,
120
],
"PPM_exact_to_saved_bank": true,
"sha256": "dd5336f6ed1b47a0985fd160c5203093009a5ab4305bf4bb05dc37ba58eb790f"
},
{
"scale": 4,
"canvas": [
288,
160
],
"PPM_exact_to_saved_bank": true,
"sha256": "19b01cb4bed30132b749f5f6fa779176d70ec4c4dfda939a34919e41c95f4e70"
}
]
},
{
"asset": "200a0",
"noncyan_RGBA_exact_samples": 11918,
"gray_RGBA_exact_samples": 4573,
"cyan_genuine_eligible_same_phase_tuple_samples": 9000,
"transparent_clear_samples": 25162,
"native1_mask_iou": 0.993202416918429,
"maximum_donor_logical_distance": 2.3954922373042478,
"missing_fraction": 0.5968888888888889,
"scales": [
{
"scale": 1,
"canvas": [
72,
40
],
"PPM_exact_to_saved_bank": true,
"sha256": "801f70c41a0c908eb82df62e0131b2b2c09ea5e8cbf52839a14f131356125d89"
},
{
"scale": 2,
"canvas": [
144,
80
],
"PPM_exact_to_saved_bank": true,
"sha256": "a2f5de17fe70d175b7d187297b8f2ff65bab5c635722b97cacb0769901de0565"
},
{
"scale": 3,
"canvas": [
216,
120
],
"PPM_exact_to_saved_bank": true,
"sha256": "53a57f2fe4640dec6c71817ae85967be507dc93c36d25b60ec2b4ce2a392c687"
},
{
"scale": 4,
"canvas": [
288,
160
],
"PPM_exact_to_saved_bank": true,
"sha256": "804d8073e64f4aea341183ee4b43ea5afc1fa1dd1c1dcabede22f46f952aba5b"
}
]
}
],
"source_and_canvas_alignment": "72x40 both phases; bank Source arrays identical to approved initial bank; origin0 ordered candidate frames.",
"actual_new_cleanup_or_QA": 0
},
"limits": [
"Different intrinsic ART qualification only; genuine context and final Root approval remain pending. No public admission authorized by this receipt.",
"Same-phase genuine RGB retention is verified for unindexed derived PNG cyan tuples. Rust G2 then quantizes cyan RGB into the selected palette; final indexed cyan is not claimed byte-identical to unquantized raw tuples.",
"All11933/11918 noncyan structural derivedRGBA and actualnative4paletteRGBA are exact initialG2projection;4573Source-gray samples perframe remain exact. This is not original unquantizedrawRGB identity.",
"Final alpha is SourceScale4cyan union baselinealpha on noncyanSourceScale4owners; transparentSource clears. WholeSourcealphaidentity is not claimed. Native1maskIoU0.9932279909706546/0.993202416918429.",
"Cyan Source support/partition and bounded donor relocation receive zero newHDdetailcredit;66.04%/59.69%relocation is substantial, boundedmax3.986/2.395logical under5.5/.90/.85.",
"Static wholeframe review does not prove timedanimation/gameplay/movement/shadow/collision/missionreachability. Prior raw/wake-only HOLDs remain unchanged."
],
"findings_requiring_revision": [],
"independent_code_receipt_sha256": "0746450cd1f9fe5086eae05944d51666bb94c67cb11fd22c99f75a0d7cac0451",
"code_and_art_reviews_separate": true,
"new_cleanup_QA_World_calls": 0,
"canonical_git_mutation": 0,
"evidence": {
"verify_saved.py": "8e33343ee0c00a929c8ffc93edfcb0d98e479799f8a285f12db2243735d11bd8",
"SAVED-ARRAYS-PINS-PARTITION-DONORS-PROOF.json": "92487b1e294f6de57e221fb0189f8ea69ada66e1c97d548ac30d34c26bd33e61",
"verify.stdout": "92487b1e294f6de57e221fb0189f8ea69ada66e1c97d548ac30d34c26bd33e61",
"verify.stderr": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"INITIAL-OVERSTRONG-UNQUANTIZED-CYAN-RGB-ASSERTION.stderr": "fa0e89d8a4dcb8126201f267e3242e7bacb264b9baa7e798a2b1105de940e377"
},
"reviewer_fixture_correction": "Initial saved-array assertion incorrectly required all indexednative4cyanRGB to equal raw8bitderivedRGBA. Corrected to asserted structuralRGBA and alpha identities plus palette-index/PPM identity; quantization is explicitly retained. No production change."
}