Files
RustRaptor/data/hd/jobs/terrain-night-hardware2-Original-primary-Source-material-20261019-v1/shared-lineage/different-intrinsic-art/DIFFERENT-NIGHT5-QUALIFIED5-WHOLE-SOURCE-RAW-ALL20-NATIVE-INTRINSIC-WITH-LIMITS.json
T

454 lines
21 KiB
JSON

{
"status": "QUALIFIED_5_WITH_LIMITS_HOLD_0_DIFFERENT_INTRINSIC_ART_ONLY",
"reviewer": "/root/ridge_pair",
"original_artist": "/root/iron_coast_names",
"scope": {
"exact_assets": [
"2054d",
"2054e",
"2057f",
"20581",
"20588"
],
"whole_literal_Originals": 5,
"whole_raw_masters": 2,
"whole_saved_dark_raw_cells_additionally_viewed": 3,
"whole_final_RGB_images": 5,
"whole_native_scales_per_asset": [
1,
2,
3,
4
],
"whole_final_native_bodies": 20,
"whole_SourceNx_controls": 20,
"no_mission_or_join_context_approval": true
},
"physical_review": "Physically viewed all listed complete images. All five 1328x710 native boards contain complete SourceNx and actual rows at integer NN8/4/3/2; body bounds fit within the image. The large dark raw master was also viewed as all three complete existing 724x724 raw-cell images for exact original-detail coverage. No new art, review board or runtime render was created.",
"per_asset": [
{
"asset": "2054d",
"verdict": "QUALIFIED_WITH_LIMITS",
"finding": "QUALIFIED WITH LIMITS. The plain broad upper gray plate, downward triangle and pale tip preserve the Source silhouette. Restrained smooth gray relief; no invented grille or vent geometry.",
"bindings": {
"asset": "2054d",
"Source_sha256": "53c48a3ce6452e2f31378ea19c6c55741fe7ca00f44130c31767691826db7679",
"candidate_sha256": "01629cab282c371a88c1289e2d4bf750869f2f9a171364c25bd4fc7220a8235c",
"QA_sha256": "33a591093fc3f76d99a6d8662577ff2a9f89765757cbd2644c99f5e1b144f378",
"raw_master_sha256": "05a8eb2f0f2423f337d65f50225d65fbbc9a90b067a5b5ea6f17250bf9ecd5c6",
"derived_PNG_sha256": "e767ca64c5621634de4676ec93135ef1338767b594083972177d94b1c1b55260",
"whole_native_board_sha256": "3c0c93f809c144b3ff2c3674429d661536ba4e2bb3e81026a443f5cbd43d7492",
"retained_logical_cells": [],
"scales": [
{
"scale": 1,
"indices": 1024,
"retained_SourceNx_samples": 0,
"functional_SourceNx_samples_exact": 0,
"PPM_and_lossless_PNG_exact": true,
"complete_Source_and_actual_board_rectangles_exact": true
},
{
"scale": 2,
"indices": 4096,
"retained_SourceNx_samples": 0,
"functional_SourceNx_samples_exact": 0,
"PPM_and_lossless_PNG_exact": true,
"complete_Source_and_actual_board_rectangles_exact": true
},
{
"scale": 3,
"indices": 9216,
"retained_SourceNx_samples": 0,
"functional_SourceNx_samples_exact": 0,
"PPM_and_lossless_PNG_exact": true,
"complete_Source_and_actual_board_rectangles_exact": true
},
{
"scale": 4,
"indices": 16384,
"retained_SourceNx_samples": 0,
"functional_SourceNx_samples_exact": 0,
"PPM_and_lossless_PNG_exact": true,
"complete_Source_and_actual_board_rectangles_exact": true
}
],
"Original_black_512_samples": 74656,
"Original_functional_512_samples": 0,
"all_Source_black_and_functional_512_RGB_exact": true,
"these_samples_new_HD_credit": 0
}
},
{
"asset": "2054e",
"verdict": "QUALIFIED_WITH_LIMITS",
"finding": "QUALIFIED WITH LIMITS only on the two-clamp-notch metadata successor. Bars, ring and downward face remain coherent; the two Source owners (3,16) and (29,16) retain exact SourceNx. Old first-pass notch HOLD remains preserved and is not approved. All four native scales outside those owners are unchanged, and all five 2054d Source/native PPMs remain byte-identical.",
"bindings": {
"asset": "2054e",
"Source_sha256": "a0af561811ac3dc187748135b1572772a8c12c4f4960396fca8eea8920d062ca",
"candidate_sha256": "01629cab282c371a88c1289e2d4bf750869f2f9a171364c25bd4fc7220a8235c",
"QA_sha256": "33a591093fc3f76d99a6d8662577ff2a9f89765757cbd2644c99f5e1b144f378",
"raw_master_sha256": "05a8eb2f0f2423f337d65f50225d65fbbc9a90b067a5b5ea6f17250bf9ecd5c6",
"derived_PNG_sha256": "9721c9cbc3c0727f9a41520bf831976cf6085b357c5c431777747c221934b1e8",
"whole_native_board_sha256": "00236187ecbb3fb4eeaa424b3cc4185d16365feb0702b6020e80fecb7d2c5a70",
"retained_logical_cells": [
[
3,
16
],
[
29,
16
]
],
"scales": [
{
"scale": 1,
"indices": 1024,
"retained_SourceNx_samples": 2,
"functional_SourceNx_samples_exact": 0,
"PPM_and_lossless_PNG_exact": true,
"complete_Source_and_actual_board_rectangles_exact": true
},
{
"scale": 2,
"indices": 4096,
"retained_SourceNx_samples": 8,
"functional_SourceNx_samples_exact": 0,
"PPM_and_lossless_PNG_exact": true,
"complete_Source_and_actual_board_rectangles_exact": true
},
{
"scale": 3,
"indices": 9216,
"retained_SourceNx_samples": 18,
"functional_SourceNx_samples_exact": 0,
"PPM_and_lossless_PNG_exact": true,
"complete_Source_and_actual_board_rectangles_exact": true
},
{
"scale": 4,
"indices": 16384,
"retained_SourceNx_samples": 32,
"functional_SourceNx_samples_exact": 0,
"PPM_and_lossless_PNG_exact": true,
"complete_Source_and_actual_board_rectangles_exact": true
}
],
"Original_black_512_samples": 141776,
"Original_functional_512_samples": 0,
"all_Source_black_and_functional_512_RGB_exact": true,
"these_samples_new_HD_credit": 0
}
},
{
"asset": "2057f",
"verdict": "QUALIFIED_WITH_LIMITS",
"finding": "QUALIFIED WITH LIMITS. Sparse almost-black negative space and faint authentic right/bottom material remain bare. No top/left frame or new hardware silhouette has been transferred from the raw donor.",
"bindings": {
"asset": "2057f",
"Source_sha256": "7de84a5c17d769cbe82296150a8328b05f0e61b1fe65d361f723651b56bcf958",
"candidate_sha256": "b9dfcc645ed1e67e4fe1dddc507e700becaf751442f79e166e2a69855867a041",
"QA_sha256": "61c47f21ed0d98b6bc760685470317fc29361ab28bde38ec59d656fba7493170",
"raw_master_sha256": "2638079a3de2a1aa36a3cfc4637f714f790fb2896aebe3a9cb5cb50a3d01a5c5",
"derived_PNG_sha256": "16c4c596da0bb2d4ad8ac1dd7cd1e91c197b2cd96f16eb98d95d80c613b14501",
"whole_native_board_sha256": "6ee7776c0593bbafa8018871c275edacd882ef350a7697c3bb4b1bd0e33d5fb1",
"retained_logical_cells": [],
"scales": [
{
"scale": 1,
"indices": 1024,
"retained_SourceNx_samples": 0,
"functional_SourceNx_samples_exact": 0,
"PPM_and_lossless_PNG_exact": true,
"complete_Source_and_actual_board_rectangles_exact": true
},
{
"scale": 2,
"indices": 4096,
"retained_SourceNx_samples": 0,
"functional_SourceNx_samples_exact": 0,
"PPM_and_lossless_PNG_exact": true,
"complete_Source_and_actual_board_rectangles_exact": true
},
{
"scale": 3,
"indices": 9216,
"retained_SourceNx_samples": 0,
"functional_SourceNx_samples_exact": 0,
"PPM_and_lossless_PNG_exact": true,
"complete_Source_and_actual_board_rectangles_exact": true
},
{
"scale": 4,
"indices": 16384,
"retained_SourceNx_samples": 0,
"functional_SourceNx_samples_exact": 0,
"PPM_and_lossless_PNG_exact": true,
"complete_Source_and_actual_board_rectangles_exact": true
}
],
"Original_black_512_samples": 235824,
"Original_functional_512_samples": 0,
"all_Source_black_and_functional_512_RGB_exact": true,
"these_samples_new_HD_credit": 0
}
},
{
"asset": "20581",
"verdict": "QUALIFIED_WITH_LIMITS",
"finding": "QUALIFIED WITH LIMITS. Olive perimeter blocks, dark center and red functional cues remain legible. All six checked right-contact samples are neutral gray rather than gold, although their final palette values are not all identical to the original single-cell values.",
"bindings": {
"asset": "20581",
"Source_sha256": "18544694589ff0582bc7ac9cdb66f804348035b98e52f860abebef56645990b1",
"candidate_sha256": "b9dfcc645ed1e67e4fe1dddc507e700becaf751442f79e166e2a69855867a041",
"QA_sha256": "61c47f21ed0d98b6bc760685470317fc29361ab28bde38ec59d656fba7493170",
"raw_master_sha256": "2638079a3de2a1aa36a3cfc4637f714f790fb2896aebe3a9cb5cb50a3d01a5c5",
"derived_PNG_sha256": "894c283431cffa99d7537004015ecaad445e5a46b38916c5860d532f68ca5226",
"whole_native_board_sha256": "0b93cd5dfe2d85ce427f35c164d4a47fc37a7dd5dd5a24407b0a171e75e35e9b",
"retained_logical_cells": [
[
4,
15
],
[
16,
4
],
[
16,
27
],
[
27,
15
]
],
"scales": [
{
"scale": 1,
"indices": 1024,
"retained_SourceNx_samples": 4,
"functional_SourceNx_samples_exact": 4,
"PPM_and_lossless_PNG_exact": true,
"complete_Source_and_actual_board_rectangles_exact": true
},
{
"scale": 2,
"indices": 4096,
"retained_SourceNx_samples": 16,
"functional_SourceNx_samples_exact": 16,
"PPM_and_lossless_PNG_exact": true,
"complete_Source_and_actual_board_rectangles_exact": true
},
{
"scale": 3,
"indices": 9216,
"retained_SourceNx_samples": 36,
"functional_SourceNx_samples_exact": 36,
"PPM_and_lossless_PNG_exact": true,
"complete_Source_and_actual_board_rectangles_exact": true
},
{
"scale": 4,
"indices": 16384,
"retained_SourceNx_samples": 64,
"functional_SourceNx_samples_exact": 56,
"PPM_and_lossless_PNG_exact": true,
"complete_Source_and_actual_board_rectangles_exact": true
}
],
"Original_black_512_samples": 151488,
"Original_functional_512_samples": 896,
"all_Source_black_and_functional_512_RGB_exact": true,
"these_samples_new_HD_credit": 0
}
},
{
"asset": "20588",
"verdict": "QUALIFIED_WITH_LIMITS",
"finding": "QUALIFIED WITH LIMITS. Gray/black structure and protected red cues remain coherent. No continuous rusty lower fringe. Precisely two native1 lower-row samples at x=8 and x=24 are dim warm RGB(16,8,4); the other 30 lower-row samples are gray RGB(8,8,8). This review does not claim that every bottom pixel is neutral or independently establish the cause of the two warm samples.",
"bindings": {
"asset": "20588",
"Source_sha256": "1ae18dde9cfd42b3fa3e227afa068a9a485b5cd7b7783d6214b7116a621b8d97",
"candidate_sha256": "b9dfcc645ed1e67e4fe1dddc507e700becaf751442f79e166e2a69855867a041",
"QA_sha256": "61c47f21ed0d98b6bc760685470317fc29361ab28bde38ec59d656fba7493170",
"raw_master_sha256": "2638079a3de2a1aa36a3cfc4637f714f790fb2896aebe3a9cb5cb50a3d01a5c5",
"derived_PNG_sha256": "59c110ffb7da50271dbb377d8d811170dfecb97a3bba9be88ba77f8a2e45302c",
"whole_native_board_sha256": "62a120218fa9f2532d18aa41fe84a42a8ab4013da585337aec91f8f66eb50fd3",
"retained_logical_cells": [
[
8,
1
],
[
8,
30
],
[
24,
1
],
[
24,
30
]
],
"scales": [
{
"scale": 1,
"indices": 1024,
"retained_SourceNx_samples": 4,
"functional_SourceNx_samples_exact": 4,
"PPM_and_lossless_PNG_exact": true,
"complete_Source_and_actual_board_rectangles_exact": true
},
{
"scale": 2,
"indices": 4096,
"retained_SourceNx_samples": 16,
"functional_SourceNx_samples_exact": 16,
"PPM_and_lossless_PNG_exact": true,
"complete_Source_and_actual_board_rectangles_exact": true
},
{
"scale": 3,
"indices": 9216,
"retained_SourceNx_samples": 36,
"functional_SourceNx_samples_exact": 36,
"PPM_and_lossless_PNG_exact": true,
"complete_Source_and_actual_board_rectangles_exact": true
},
{
"scale": 4,
"indices": 16384,
"retained_SourceNx_samples": 64,
"functional_SourceNx_samples_exact": 56,
"PPM_and_lossless_PNG_exact": true,
"complete_Source_and_actual_board_rectangles_exact": true
}
],
"Original_black_512_samples": 65552,
"Original_functional_512_samples": 896,
"all_Source_black_and_functional_512_RGB_exact": true,
"these_samples_new_HD_credit": 0
}
}
],
"checked_saved_proof": {
"path": ".reference/hd-night5-independent-intrinsic-ART-and-native-audit-20261019-v1/PASS-INDEPENDENT-NIGHT5-SAVED-NATIVE-AND-MATERIAL-FIDELITY.json",
"sha256": "547525a1c980f45d86cd78ccb3825429f7babc54af4da8ad0663403d1223d3b9",
"literal_Source_indices": 5120,
"actual_final_native_indices": 153600,
"whole_board_body_rectangles": 40,
"declared_exact_retained_SourceNx_samples": 300,
"notch_successor_changed_native_samples": [
2,
8,
16,
26
],
"notch_successor_changes_outside_two_owners": 0,
"all_20_native_PPM_and_lossless_PNG_pairs_palette_exact": true,
"all_current_18_Rust_Source_hashes_and_G2_library_binding_checked": true
},
"visual_and_credit_limits": [
"This is a Source-geometry-preserving, restrained material treatment with intentionally coarse relief; it is not a claim that the whole tile was newly generated in high resolution.",
"Exact black negative space, functional cycling samples and explicitly Source-retained cells have zero generated-HD credit. Retained high-resolution notch samples follow exact SourceNx; not every sample in the owner footprint is black because ScaleNx can include a genuine adjacent Source value.",
"No new geometric objects were accepted from raw donor art; no cleanup module was executed by this reviewer. Genuine master bindings and producer material/cleanup method are checked through saved outputs and the separate CODE review, not independently re-derived here.",
"All native snapshots are static intrinsic views. Genuine MAP neighbors, seams, mission use, runtime palette phases and canonical admission remain outside this review and require their separate finite context evidence."
],
"physically_viewed_files": [
{
"path": ".reference/hd-iron-names-terrain2054d-2054e-and2057f-20581-20588-Original-primary-author-20261019-v1/Original5-complete-contact-NN10.png",
"sha256": "9bd089d309b4cd1172d49cb2b11bfe29fd545ba38ef242f86727cb1fbf76fda2"
},
{
"path": ".reference/hd-iron-names-terrain2054d-2054e-and2057f-20581-20588-Original-primary-author-20261019-v1/hardware2/returned-untouched-atlas.png",
"sha256": "05a8eb2f0f2423f337d65f50225d65fbbc9a90b067a5b5ea6f17250bf9ecd5c6"
},
{
"path": ".reference/hd-iron-names-terrain2054d-2054e-and2057f-20581-20588-Original-primary-author-20261019-v1/dark3/returned-untouched-atlas.png",
"sha256": "2638079a3de2a1aa36a3cfc4637f714f790fb2896aebe3a9cb5cb50a3d01a5c5"
},
{
"path": ".reference/hd-iron-names-terrain2054d-2054e-and2057f-20581-20588-Original-primary-author-20261019-v1/dark3/2057f-untouched-cell-review-only.png",
"sha256": "d2a60f294c31335174f53cce17d02aa534abb80afd3cab6c7a8f7409dcefd2af"
},
{
"path": ".reference/hd-iron-names-terrain2054d-2054e-and2057f-20581-20588-Original-primary-author-20261019-v1/dark3/20581-untouched-cell-review-only.png",
"sha256": "09543b034656f72e4aafb13eda135e7294064b9b834c0cb6c13899af156a9772"
},
{
"path": ".reference/hd-iron-names-terrain2054d-2054e-and2057f-20581-20588-Original-primary-author-20261019-v1/dark3/20588-untouched-cell-review-only.png",
"sha256": "dbe6cd3fa74ecb80cec211cee14ee077a36f990fc05f7735a5caae68d0381e4b"
},
{
"path": ".reference/hd-iron-names-terrain2054d-2054e-and2057f-20581-20588-Original-primary-author-20261019-v1/hardware2/private-hd/jobs/terrain-night-hardware2-Original-primary-Source-material-20261019-v1/2054d-derived.png",
"sha256": "e767ca64c5621634de4676ec93135ef1338767b594083972177d94b1c1b55260"
},
{
"path": ".reference/hd-iron-names-terrain2054d-2054e-and2057f-20581-20588-Original-primary-author-20261019-v1/hardware2/whole-native-final-review-pages/2054d-complete-SourceNx-and-G2-all4.png",
"sha256": "3c0c93f809c144b3ff2c3674429d661536ba4e2bb3e81026a443f5cbd43d7492"
},
{
"path": ".reference/hd-iron-names-terrain2054d-2054e-and2057f-20581-20588-Original-primary-author-20261019-v1/hardware2/private-hd/jobs/terrain-night-hardware2-Original-primary-Source-material-20261019-v1/2054e-derived.png",
"sha256": "9721c9cbc3c0727f9a41520bf831976cf6085b357c5c431777747c221934b1e8"
},
{
"path": ".reference/hd-iron-names-terrain2054d-2054e-and2057f-20581-20588-Original-primary-author-20261019-v1/hardware2/whole-native-final-review-pages/2054e-complete-SourceNx-and-G2-all4.png",
"sha256": "00236187ecbb3fb4eeaa424b3cc4185d16365feb0702b6020e80fecb7d2c5a70"
},
{
"path": ".reference/hd-iron-names-terrain2054d-2054e-and2057f-20581-20588-Original-primary-author-20261019-v1/dark3/private-hd/jobs/terrain-night-dark3-Original-primary-Source-material-20261019-v1/2057f-derived.png",
"sha256": "16c4c596da0bb2d4ad8ac1dd7cd1e91c197b2cd96f16eb98d95d80c613b14501"
},
{
"path": ".reference/hd-iron-names-terrain2054d-2054e-and2057f-20581-20588-Original-primary-author-20261019-v1/dark3/whole-native-final-review-pages/2057f-complete-SourceNx-and-G2-all4.png",
"sha256": "6ee7776c0593bbafa8018871c275edacd882ef350a7697c3bb4b1bd0e33d5fb1"
},
{
"path": ".reference/hd-iron-names-terrain2054d-2054e-and2057f-20581-20588-Original-primary-author-20261019-v1/dark3/private-hd/jobs/terrain-night-dark3-Original-primary-Source-material-20261019-v1/20581-derived.png",
"sha256": "894c283431cffa99d7537004015ecaad445e5a46b38916c5860d532f68ca5226"
},
{
"path": ".reference/hd-iron-names-terrain2054d-2054e-and2057f-20581-20588-Original-primary-author-20261019-v1/dark3/whole-native-final-review-pages/20581-complete-SourceNx-and-G2-all4.png",
"sha256": "0b93cd5dfe2d85ce427f35c164d4a47fc37a7dd5dd5a24407b0a171e75e35e9b"
},
{
"path": ".reference/hd-iron-names-terrain2054d-2054e-and2057f-20581-20588-Original-primary-author-20261019-v1/dark3/private-hd/jobs/terrain-night-dark3-Original-primary-Source-material-20261019-v1/20588-derived.png",
"sha256": "59c110ffb7da50271dbb377d8d811170dfecb97a3bba9be88ba77f8a2e45302c"
},
{
"path": ".reference/hd-iron-names-terrain2054d-2054e-and2057f-20581-20588-Original-primary-author-20261019-v1/dark3/whole-native-final-review-pages/20588-complete-SourceNx-and-G2-all4.png",
"sha256": "62a120218fa9f2532d18aa41fe84a42a8ab4013da585337aec91f8f66eb50fd3"
}
],
"handoff": {
"path": ".reference/hd-iron-names-terrain2054d-2054e-and2057f-20581-20588-Original-primary-author-20261019-v1/FINAL-NIGHT5-CURRENT-SOURCEG2-INTRINSIC-AUTHOR-HANDOFF.json",
"sha256": "5f305826d53e69508fefc466fbd3cdf5d57b393f338bd984ad6a1971cada3a30"
},
"different_CODE_review_sha256": "3f5a28286fcc7593fb06e198d5b34e2b21ed2f394f0e344c0cb27945387a8920",
"historical_producer_execution_counts": {
"genuine_builtin_imagegen_calls": 2,
"actual_RGB_cleanup_calls": 2,
"actual_initial_SourceG2_calls": 2,
"bounded_ordinary_retention_metadata_successors": 1,
"actual_final_successor_SourceG2_calls": 1,
"new_Cargo_builds": 0,
"World_invocations": 0,
"canonical_or_Git_mutations": 0
},
"new_reviewer_operations": {
"generation": 0,
"RGB_cleanup": 0,
"renderer": 0,
"runtime_QA": 0,
"World": 0,
"engine_build": 0,
"canonical_mutation": 0,
"Git_mutation": 0
},
"own_checker_parse_stop": "The reviewer first saved a checker with an invalid Python identifier beginning in digits; it stopped at parse before any check or runtime operation. That exact failed file is retained. Only the reviewer field identifier was corrected, then the read-only saved-data audit passed; this is not a producer cleanup or QA retry."
}