Dune/docs/TRUTHTRANCE_TRAVEL_PROMISES.md

# Truthtrance combined shipment and physical movement

## Earlier native phases — 26 October 2026

**Prototyped / Partial.** The same raw question now uses the existing clean
native movement-target envelope in Storm, Spice Blow, Charity, Bidding, Revival
and Shipment and Movement (phases0–5), in both Basic and Advanced. Registered
factions retain their existing selected native-deck and optional-module scope.
This supersedes only the earlier phase5 entry restriction documented below.
No shipment, movement, payment or card action happens merely by answering.

Reuse the existing owned-stage forecast described in
[earlier native movement](TRUTHTRANCE_MOVEMENT_PROMISES.md#native-early-advanced-and-choam-opening--26-october-2026).
Original Charity/normal Revival/current auction liabilities and owned known
preparations remain authoritative. No unknown future card, foreign gift or
favorable future Storm supplies a witness. Prior Revival and bribe obligations
share the same future purse; a final Revival aggregate must retain combined
travel feasibility rather than spend the same spice twice.

An early record starts with its future shipment pending even when the actual
player still has last turn's `shipped` flag. That old physical event never
counts as this answer's progress. Original phase5 initialization remains in
charge of real allowances. Actual current-turn native shipment/ground hooks
record the same distinct receipts and physical maxima; no new event is granted.

A definite answer uniformly reopens only the respondent's concurrent Charity
or legacy Revival readiness, including constant answers. This avoids exposing
a private fact branch through a public Ready difference. Constant answers are
still terminal without action receipts or a private future guide. Ordered
Advanced Revival never reopens an already completed owned turn. A required
owned preparation or optional spending must preserve the last legal route;
mandatory early progress and completed opposing effects can release actual
impossibility rather than trapping the actor. Pending native outcomes retain
priority.

The private guide now offers only an entitled action in the current phase:
Charity, Ready, ordinary Revival, current native bid pass or an owned invoice,
then the existing phase5 transport/movement/card controls. Original cash or
physical Karama payment remains a choice of the actual invoice; exact projected
packets preserve that source. Required native bid/Revival commitments take
priority over passing or Ready in the guide; their native joint completion
retains travel funding. Pending allied auction escrow waits for its actual
foreign payment/income outcome before impossible travel can release. A source-bound paid Box search retains its actual
phase. No future transport is exposed before phase5. Each packet includes
`travelPromisePhase` as well as its event: an old Charity Ready cannot be
replayed as a later Revival Ready. The server and saved callbacks verify the
current source and exact packet. Four minimal profiles use that same path.

New source/control evidence: `tests/fixture-truth-travel-early.ts`,
`tests/truth-travel-early-runtime.test.ts`,
`tests/truth-travel-early-controls.test.tsx`. Separate conserved controlled
`tests/truth-travel-early-revival.test.ts` cases actually declare both original
Truth cards in opposite acceptance orders to reject a shared-purse conflict;
they claim no setup/casualty history. Native
`tests/truth-travel-early-bid.test.ts` uses genuine Harkonnen opening custody to
protect pending bid funding and legal required declarations in both answer
orders.

Frozen verification passes **23 files,197/197**, types/lint/build and three native
runtime journeys with 25 GameTable SSR renders, three actual answer callbacks and
16 guide callbacks. Original owned-Karama Charity53 adds32: real bid2 and current
cash invoice precede Revival and later paid ship2/ground2. Hajr Charity13 adds16:
frozen spice, actual bribe3, paid shipment and two real groups with original Hajr.
Earned post-Storm41 adds24, retaining its true prior shipped flag while the new
future shipment remains pending with empty progress. Every original physical
card inventory remains. Nineteen native and ten early control cases supplement
existing movement/shipment/Revival/funding evidence. Two original Harkonnen
opening-custody bid cases exercise both answer orders; three conserved controlled
Revival cases exercise incompatibility and required actual returns. Four minimal
profiles consume legal current-phase guides.

V1 source feedback finds a controlled ally's Carthag garrison invalidates the
chosen destination, so the escrow case uses the original audit's Basin route.
Actual foreign invoice/income deferral and native required-bid/Revival guide/
funding corrections pass focused regressions. V2 passes types/lint, the full
197-case union and build. Its private smoke driver then auto-settles an owned
invoice before inspecting it. Only that driver changes; corrected runtime v3
advances one native action at a time. `verified-proof.json` explicitly reuses
v2's three passing checks on an identical before/after source snapshot.
Proof and per-file manifest:
`/home/quintine/.local/share/dune/checkpoints/20261026-truth-travel-early-proof-v3/`;
journeys/HTML: adjacent `20261026-truth-travel-early-runtime/`.
This is local engine/SSR/actual-callback evidence, not DOM/hydration/browser/
mobile/deployed acceptance or complete-mode certification.
Other cross-action families, wider owned preparations/module compositions and
final rules/browser/mobile/deployed/recovery/privacy/custody acceptance remain.

## Native travel prototype — 26 October 2026

**Prototyped / Partial.** The question is `{kind:'travel',target,turn,mixed}`.
Travel action leaves are `{kind:'ship'|'move',territory,minimum}` inside the shared
fact/action/AND/OR tree. Current facts are optional; at least one action remains
required. Every original subtree is validated under sixteen logical leaves and
four grouping levels. Old mixed families still require a fact by default.

## Authority and interval

Reuse publisher November2020 FAQp8 game-related yes/no/current-turn/AND/OR and
shipment example, plus supplied Advanced physical39/printed37 compliance,
impossibility and unknown authority. No dedicated printed cross-action planner
is claimed. The existing native owned-action witness interpretation is a
provisional online implementation choice under the standing14October priority.

This first cross-action envelope is the current phase5 native active or unused
waiting turn accepted by the existing movement target rules. Printed factions
and selected native expansion decks use that existing scope; optional modules
retain their separate limits. Earlier phases and arbitrary future card/power/
other-action expressions remain unfinished. Parser rejection is a software
boundary, not a printed rule that those questions cannot be asked.

Shipment leaves concern the one future original reserve-shipment event after
the answer. A shipment already used before answering is false for those future
leaves. Cross-planet/return transport consumes that original opportunity without
becoming a reserve shipment. A skipped or stopped shipment records absence.
Arrival, original fees, physical reserves and native responses remain unchanged.

Movement leaves concern one future actual ordinary physical ground group to a
named destination. The largest group per destination is retained, not a sum of
smaller moves. Original Hajr/Ornithopter and owned preparations may supply more
moves through the existing planner; no entitlement is added. Ambassador moves,
markers and shipments do not contribute movement progress. A shipment may
prepare a later movement while satisfying only its own shipment conditions.

## One whole answer and native feasibility

Current facts freeze at the actual answer. Unknown is false for a definite Yes
and true for No, retaining the earlier guaranteed-aggregate interpretation.
Unknown-fact correlations are not inferred. No negates the whole tree, not each
leaf. A true current fact OR action, or false current fact AND action, can make
the selected answer terminal without a future commitment.

`game/travel-expression-promises.ts` lazily reduces the whole compiled answer
to signed branches, folding actual progress and closed opportunities. Every
shipment leaf shares one event. Native min/cap contradictions are pruned;
alternatives remain available rather than binding one route. Private detached
witnesses translate a branch into existing shipment and movement constraints,
then call the original ground-movement completion search. The real ledgers never
receive that selected branch. Quotes retain original force types, wallets,
movement allowance, routes, owned card preparation and prior native promises.

Actual shipment/ground hooks record receipts; a qualifying whole Yes fulfills
immediately. Whole No remains binding through the respondent's actual turn end.
Ending cannot erase a required action. Spending or consuming the last owned
route is rejected. An opposing completed effect can release a now-impossible
answer; interrupted responses retain original priority.

At the first combined answer, the private order records existing shipment rows
and the native within-movement sequence before the new row. Subsequent real
scalar, whole/mixed movement, shipment and travel answers append their native
ledger index. Joint feasibility reconciles prefixes in that accepted order;
no virtual branch is made permanent. Historical ordering between different
native families before this cutover is not reconstructed. Wider cross-family
revival/payment/alliance/battle composition remains outside this first envelope.

### Guild-allied Fremen reserve transport follow-up

Bounded read-only review found the joint movement preparation search enumerated
ordinary `ship` but omitted native Fremen `guildShip` from southern reserves.
The native generator now retains that distinct reciprocal-Guild-ally variant;
the witness uses the original Guild tariff and funding split, then dispatches
the actual transport validator. It never substitutes Fremen's free ordinary
reinforcement price. The exact private guide/control also accepts that packet.
Three controlled conserved native cases isolate real transport, subsequent
physical movement, pledged Guild funding, later scalar compatibility and
insufficient funds. They claim no historical setup/alliance acquisition. Native
enumeration and exact guide packet checks also cover that variant. The complete
v4 batch passes after this correction; the earlier v3 proof predates it.

## Connected controls and minimal policies

The shared full editor switches ship/move leaves, destination and minimum,
adds/wraps/nests/removes/collapses groups, and optionally includes current facts.
It reads public vocabulary only. Original raw preview/Ask, private whole-answer
choices and persistent own aggregate history connect through the existing
Truthtrance window. Raw own rows omit compiled/frozen values and route choices.

One private exact guide offers the next native action, with original selection
and costs available for review. Identity, actor, turn, phase, event, busy and
native modal guards prevent stale dispatch. Ordinary manual legal alternatives
remain available. Four minimal profiles answer and consume that same guide;
strategic refinement/calibration remain deferred.

## Evidence and remaining gates

Helpers: `tests/travel-expression-promises.test.ts`,
`tests/mixed-action-question.test.ts`. Source/runtime:
`tests/fixture-truth-travel.ts`, `tests/truth-travel-runtime.test.ts`.
A separate actual Harkonnen two-card opening supplies both original Truths for
`tests/fixture-truth-travel-order.ts` and `tests/truth-travel-order.test.ts`;
its acceptance-order journeys install no extra card or ledger.
Controls: `tests/truth-travel-controls.test.tsx`.
Frozen v4 passes **24 files,237/237**, types/lint/build and six original runtime
paths,21 GameTable SSR renders, six actual answer callbacks/six guide callbacks
and one editor callback followed by native Ask. Active19 adds7 for paid shipment2
and a distinct actual move/own end. Edited OR19 adds6 for manual movement without
shipping. Both No-to-AND routes19 add6 and complete only at own end. Frozen Hajr/
spice facts19 add10 for actual bribe3, shipment2, nonmatching move, physical Hajr
and required second move. Waiting19 adds8 while preserving the original other
owner's turn before the respondent's actual ship/move. Four minimal profiles
actually answer and perform the same native guide. All33 original cards remain.

Ten helper, nine controls and18 native cases supplement existing shipment,
movement and funding coverage. Nine original two-Truth cases use genuine Harkonnen
opening custody and27 native actions (bidding20 plus continuation7), covering both
orders across scalar shipment, scalar movement and whole movement, compatible
whole No and conflicting second-answer rejection while retaining earlier records.
No opposing native release journey is claimed from those sources.

Focused feedback repairs the native shipment event projection, a bot actor lookup
and test assumptions about undrawn cards and redundant valid branches. Frozen
v1 catches JSX composition; v2 catches generic array narrowing. Those are repaired
before the passing v3. Bounded read-only review then identifies the missing
Guild-allied Fremen preparation route described above; native generator, exact
Guild price and guide repairs precede the complete passing v4. Extra evidence:
`tests/movement-shipment-preparation.test.ts` and
`tests/truth-travel-guild-fremen.test.ts`. Proof and per-file manifest:
`/home/quintine/.local/share/dune/checkpoints/20261026-truth-travel-proof-v4/`;
journeys/HTML: adjacent `20261026-truth-travel-runtime/`.
Evidence is local native engine/SSR/actual callbacks, not DOM, hydration, browser,
mobile or deployed acceptance, and certifies no complete mode.

The original Basic base33 source retains its actual selected unopened deal,
Storm/Spice/Charity/Bidding/Revival prefix. Active selects the recorded prefix
immediately before the paid shipment; waiting retains the current owner and
original movement queue. Only one Truthtrance is actually dealt in that source;
the other original physical copy remains undrawn. No extra hand, wallet, force,
clock, promise, answer or event is installed. Controlled helper/view cases are
not represented as historical acquisition evidence.

Earlier phases, other cross-action families, unknown-fact correlations, native
optional-module/expansion/owned-preparation compositions and full rules/recovery/
privacy/custody/browser/mobile/deployed acceptance remain required. No complete
mode is certified. No database, saved-game, server, reset, restart or deployment
operation belongs to this prototype batch.