Dune/docs/TRUTHTRANCE_MIXED_TRAITOR.md

# Truthtrance current facts and original Traitor declarations

## Mixed aggregate prototype — 26 October 2026

**Prototyped / Partial.** The packet is
`{kind:'mixedTraitorCall',target,battle,territory,mixed}`. Fact/action/AND/OR clauses
use `TraitorActionClaim={call:boolean}`: true Reveal, false Decline. Every action
leaf concerns the same current original revealed native voter decision. The
[scalar contract](TRUTHTRANCE_TRAITOR_DECISIONS.md) still owns public source,
voter/beneficiary, matching physical card, protection and effect timing.
Original pure questions and faction/module start gates stay unchanged.

## Authority and logical meaning

Reuse recorded publisher November2020 FAQp8 AND/OR/current-turn and supplied
Advanced physical39/printed37 compliance/release/unknown authority. The existing
native declaration interval and shared snapshot/witness interpretation remain
provisional under standing14October priority. No dedicated publisher mixed
solver, future matching draw witness or arbitrary promise language is claimed.

Current facts all freeze at the actual answer. Later bribes, Traitor draws and
returns do not reevaluate them. Unknown is false for definite Yes and true for
No; a remaining native obligation must guarantee the aggregate. No negates the
whole expression. Unknown FACT correlations are not inferred.

Every Reveal/Decline action leaf names one boolean decision, so its correlation
is exact. `mixedTraitorRequirement` evaluates the complete compiled tree for
both logical declarations. It returns impossible, one forced choice, or no
restriction when both values guarantee the selected aggregate. Constants and
logical tautologies are terminal immediately; this claims no declaration
receipt. A contradictory action expression can have a guaranteed whole No.
No to a Decline condition can force Reveal. Smaller subclauses never acquire
separate public answers or fixed routes.

Reduction considers both logical values before native eligibility. A presently
unmatched/leaderless/protected actor may only Decline, but a new forced Decline
still binds through later matching-card draws. Eligibility is not used to erase
the future commitment. If no guaranteed answer has an original native completion,
unknown/save/change-question remains available.

## One native decision and receipt

`game/mixed-traitor-question.ts` strictly accepts only one call boolean per leaf.
Outer groups use the shared16-leaf/depth4 grammar and nested fact budget, with
no additional battle-plan node/term caps. Invalid metadata/groups cannot hide
under decisive branches. The original native context must be revealed/current,
with an actual still-unsubmitted voter and exact battle/territory. This includes
native Harkonnen ally voting and retains original Homeworld restrictions.

A forced choice enters `traitorDecisionPromises` through the original binder,
with one optional new event link. Old pure records omit that property and
retain their shape. Validation accepts only a nonempty link when present;
settlement/reconciliation preserve it. Native choice calculation, matching
identity, Kwisatz protection, beneficiary, opposing leader and prior promises
stay authoritative. The mixed helper performs no second native eligibility or
physical card search.

Raw `mixedTraitorQuestions` links original question/answer to the native record.
Actual declaration settles it before effect prevention or synchronous cleanup.
A later canceled effect never undoes a receipt. Native impossibility or ended
unfulfilled source releases pending aggregates; submitted true and false slots
never reopen. New mixed discard signatures retain raw metadata plus the already
signed battle/ledger without changing old pure continuation signatures.

Harkonnen Cunning still draws/returns original physical identities. A live
required Reveal protects its matching identity from voluntary return, including
an answer added during the pending native return. A Decline can return the
matching identity; new draws do not remove its cap. After an actual fulfilled
Reveal, returning that identity does not retract the original receipt/effective
call. Existing parent signatures keep their original exemptions and unrelated
fields; no extra snapshot weakening is added.

## Projection and human controls

Own projection retains only original raw question, whole answer, public turn/
battle/territory and fulfilled/released status. Binding flags, forced choices,
compiled trees and separate frozen facts are not projected. Native own pure
promise rows filter mixed event links for every viewer; private declaration
choices still use the full authoritative ledger.

The shared full editor adds/wraps/nests/switches/removes/collapses groups and
exposes per-leaf Reveal/Decline choices without inspecting card custody or
canReveal. Invalid drafts remain repairable. Raw preview/Ask and target-only
aggregate answer choices connect to the exact current source. Saved answer
callbacks retain owner/question/window/battle/choice-array identity and busy/
source guards. Pure wording and behavior remain.

The mixed panel is status-only and persists after battle cleanup. Original
Reveal/Decline controls use native allowed choices; no duplicate declaration
control or fact reconstruction is added. Four minimal profiles answer and
actually declare legally; strategy/calibration remain deferred.

## Evidence and remaining gates

Helpers: `tests/mixed-traitor-question.test.ts`,
`tests/traitor-decision-promises.test.ts`. Source/journeys:
`tests/fixture-truth-mixed-traitor.ts`, `tests/truth-mixed-traitor-runtime.test.ts`,
`tests/truth-mixed-traitor-harkonnen.test.ts`.
Controlled/shared answer/UI: `tests/truth-mixed-traitor-controls.test.tsx`.
Frozen v2 integration passes **18 files,149/149**, types/lint/build and eleven
original runtime paths with 29 GameTable SSR renders,11 actual answer callbacks
and one editor callback followed by native Ask. Basic26 prefixes add6 for actual
declaration/cleanup, edited true OR, false AND, No-to-Decline requiring Reveal,
call tautology and both unknown polarities; a real bribe3 adds7. Allied72 adds9
for actual Reveal, original Karama cancellation and retained receipt. Cunning77
adds8 for matching protection/safe return/Reveal or matching return/frozen fact/
Decline. Four minimal profiles actually answer and declare legally. Native tests
also exercise the original pre-Cunning76 prefix, real draw/return after Decline,
and fulfilled Reveal followed by a later matching return.

V1 quick checks pass, then the new controls file needs the established Vinext/
CSS test import shim. Loaded controls find a missing history location and an
assertion that omitted the native button arrow. Repairs also make a mixed
Decline's disabled-Reveal explanation reflect its accepted obligation. The two
failing cases pass narrowly, then the complete frozen v2 passes. Proof and
per-file manifest:
`/home/quintine/.local/share/dune/checkpoints/20261026-truth-mixed-traitor-proof-v2/`;
journeys/HTML: adjacent `20261026-truth-mixed-traitor-runtime/`.
This is local engine/SSR/actual-callback evidence, not DOM, hydration, browser,
mobile or deployed acceptance.

The adapters reuse original Basic26 and actual allied Harkonnen72/Cunning77
sources, deriving counts from inherited action arrays. Original setup/deal,
Traitor choices, paid invasions, alliances, plans and draw/return stay genuine.
No extra Truth, played hand/purse/clock/vote/promise is installed. The unmatched
case labels its conserved original-card exchange as controlled rather than a
historical acquisition claim. Two-Truth/prior-ledger histories are not invented.

Unrevealed future-leader questions, other action families, unknown-fact
correlations, broader owned preparations, optional/faction/card/cross-action
compositions and final rules/recovery/privacy/custody/browser/mobile/deployed
acceptance remain required. No complete mode is certified. No saved-game/
database/server/reset/restart/deployment operation is performed by this batch.