Checkpoint 800 independently reviewed HD frames

docs/hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md

@@ -1,54 +1,54 @@
 # HD coordinator checkpoint — 11 October 2026
 
-The reviewed development pack is **697 original picture frames in 276 complete sequences**. The tracked playable snapshot at commit `26ed9cc` contains **340**; only the root assembler refreshes `data/`, `bin/`, `lib/` and `runtime-manifest.json`. Working artwork, prompts and review jobs remain external under `../data/hd/`. These snapshots must remain distinct.
+The reviewed development pack is **800 original picture frames in 340 complete sequences**. The tracked Linux/Windows playable snapshots still contain **340 frames** until the root assembler refreshes them from the private handoff. The development sequence count and runtime frame count are different quantities. Working originals, references, prompts and review jobs remain external under `../data/`; bundled originals and approved runtime artwork are tracked under this repository's `data/`.
 
 ## Verified development coverage
 
 | Category | Registered / original pictures |
 | --- | ---: |
-| Player banking and firing | 21 / 21 |
-| Bosses | 222 / 249 |
-| Enemies and ground objects | 116 / 419 |
-| Projectiles | 45 / 51 |
-| Effects | 91 / 281 |
+| Player banking | 21 / 21 |
+| Bosses | 223 / 249 |
+| Enemies and ground objects | 120 / 419 |
+| Player and enemy projectiles | 45 / 51 |
+| Explosions and effects | 91 / 281 |
 | Equipment and pickups | 47 / 47 |
-| Terrain | 128 / 4,535 |
-| Menus, portraits, HUD and other pictures | 27 / 150 |
-| Total | 697 / 5,753 |
+| Terrain | 208 / 4,535 |
+| Menus, portraits, HUD and other pictures | 45 / 150 |
+| Total | 800 / 5,753 |
 
-The catalog audit reports no source/hash/canvas/ID errors. The refreshed ledger records 677 registered, 20 render-reachable, 1,232 candidate, 1,304 in-progress and 2,520 missing pictures. Candidate status establishes neither artistic approval nor a native scene occurrence. The 5,056-picture backlog stays active, including every unused and damaged ID. The 303 AGX delta frames and four bitmap fonts retain explicit classic-art preservation policies and are not generated-HD counts.
+Catalog audit: all 6,449 entries, 5,753 pictures, zero HD source/hash/canvas/ID errors, **4,953 pictures still awaiting registration**. The refreshed ledger records 780 registered, 20 render-reachable, 1,449 candidate, 1,144 in-progress and 2,360 missing pictures. Candidate status establishes neither artistic approval nor a native scene occurrence. Every unused and damaged ID remains required. The 303 AGX delta frames and four bitmap fonts retain classic-art preservation policies and do not count as generated HD.
 
-## Exact current evidence
+## Exact proof and packaging handoff
 
-`../data/hd/registered-class-review/runtime-697-current/combined-review.json` verifies all **2,788 actual scale outputs** and **3,485 original/scaled PPMs** against independently accepted images byte for byte. All complete new family source/1×/4× pages had coordinator inspection, with separate independent native 2×/3× review. Loader diagnostics are empty and both source-age guards passed.
+`../data/hd/registered-class-review/runtime-800-current/combined-review.json` closes all **3,200 actual scale outputs** and **4,000 original/scaled PPMs**, byte-identical to independently accepted references. Both source-age guards pass and diagnostics are empty. The tested immutable library is `target/hd-review-libraries/f71826f4eec106d59a55c12380ee1437a3cfeddf6f9d145480624ff5e5b8eaa5/libraptor_replica-951a7002da763dc4.rlib`, SHA `f71826f4eec106d59a55c12380ee1437a3cfeddf6f9d145480624ff5e5b8eaa5`, original build timestamp `1791701529935589618`. Its original age and exact bytes survive concurrent Cargo rebuilds; registration rechecks hashes and source age.
 
-The tested immutable library is `target/hd-review-libraries/bc54cb791cb6c17ae65e651491af51831ee9fef33d78000df9904a98c8279876/libraptor_replica-79676ac8bb9ed60d.rlib`, original build timestamp `1791697513165136322`. Its bytes, SHA and original build age are preserved across Cargo rebuilds. Registration rechecks this snapshot and asset/HD source age.
+All 730 ordinary sources introduce no reserved240–255 labels. 67 source-class pictures retain authentic gameplay palette classes. Three standalone opening cards use their authentic static256-color palettes, whose high indices are static colors. Four small pilot portraits retain the complete 400×225 SDL menu proof with byte-identical surrounding UI. Other gallery-only controls/cards do not acquire new live routes from registration.
 
-All 644 ordinary sources introduce zero reserved indices240–255; fifty sources retain legitimate gameplay class labels; three standalone opening cards use authentic static256-color palettes. Static-card colors are not gameplay animation classes. Four small pilot portraits have complete current400×225 SDL menu proof, with surrounding UI pixels identical.
+The private approved input is `../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-800-20261011/pack/`. Its exact `hd.json` SHA is `fbf8b6a9af134e263881ce28f002259affbf0636f53d214ea34bbd8c61205f71`. `handoff-manifest.json`, SHA `29821d06c34114101041e50318c5c013a9236e474716a382257d6d252c304b1e`, binds independent private artwork copies, source catalog INDEX, 800 frames/340 sequences, all proof hashes, per-file bytes and limitations. Root alone assembles tracked `data/bin/lib/runtime-manifest.json`; neither OS bundle is updated by the coordinator. Do not extend this frozen snapshot while root copies it. Later candidates stay separate.
 
-Historical full-pack proofs for340 and441 remain preserved. New admission journals are `../data/hd/registered-class-review/batch-630-boss-approval.json` and `batch-697-approval.json`. Per-job coordinator reviews bind exact raw/frame maps, peer evidence and current outputs. The189-boss addition inspected76 primary pages and matched945 PPMs; the67-frame addition inspected21 primary pages and matched335 PPMs. Generated pixels were never edited.
+Admission journals `batch-731-approval.json`, `batch-767-approval.json` and `batch-800-approval.json` retain the 103-frame delta from697. The last33 inspected15 complete source/1×/4× pages and matched165 PPMs. Corrected boss30044 was promoted byte-for-byte from its independently approved sibling, with its former main bytes archived. Earlier DINO6 and SHIP40 promotions retain all failed variants; SHIP40 prepared-v5 was never submitted.
 
-Two approved siblings were promoted byte-for-byte: DINO6 `candidate-iron-coast-2-v6.json` and SHIP40 `candidate-iron-coast-2-v3.json`. Their former held main candidate bytes are archived as `held-main-before-coordinator-promotion-<old-SHA-prefix>.json`; old raw/proof files remain unchanged. SHIP40 prepared-v5 was never submitted and must not be regenerated as a replacement for the accepted sibling.
+Agricultural32 proof covers651 current cases,469 joins and91 real native samples; fine grass/original fallback density contrast is accepted. Its historical Host invocation was unpinned and stays separate. Set4 first32 includes4,644 composition cases,86contexts,31states and1,012directed joins;5unique damage pairs have bothHD art while21directed partners remain original fallback. Terrain103e0 adds1,416cases/64boards/27 original-partner swaps; its9destroyed partners remain original fallback. No whole-map seamless or new destroyed-partner claim is inferred.
 
-The32 new terrain frames103b0–103cf passed all39 current grain-fixed boards and612 cases, covering120 pairs and33 full3×3 contexts at scales1–4. They declare zero state partners and add no new Host-scroll or destroyed-partner claim. Earlier admitted terrain retains its1,426-case and1,706-case contextual proofs. Foreign partners remain original fallback; mixed-detail density is disclosed.
+The metadata correction journal `../data/hd/player-dark/provenance-transparent-flag-corrections-20261011.json` SHA `331456ac7b5451b555afd48eee99dda111c882c1818370e812d7e5499f582fca` changes15 historical opaque-UI flags across6families fromtrue tofalse. Coordinator independently verified actual attempts, all available requests, old/new provenance and unchanged source/candidate/raw/generator bytes. Cursor request JSON absence is explicit; prompt and actual attempt survive. Frozen peer reports and before-byte snapshots stay unchanged. BUTTON1–4 has a separate equivalent four-flag journal in its pending review.
 
-## Ownership and pending work
+## Durable owners and remaining work
 
-The coordinator alone owns development manifest/provenance/audit/ledger. Artists continue original durable job IDs, because queue refreshes omit registered jobs and shift numeric positions. Job bookkeeping can change while candidate/raw/source/render bindings stay frozen; record both metadata hashes honestly. Git commands run in this RustRaptor root, and checkpoints stage only owned paths. Tracked runtime data remains untouched until explicit root assembly.
+Coordinator alone owns external development manifest/provenance/audit/ledger. Artists use original durable job IDs because queue refresh removes registered jobs and shifts indices. No artist may register its own work. Checkpoints stage only owned paths in this Git root; `docs/hd-full-review.md` belongs to its reviewer.
 
-- Root owns source/API/menu/package changes, native terrain-capture fixture fixes and Windows persistence work. A new transparent-alpha resampling diagnosis is pending root policy. Do not compensate for it by editing raw art/crops or relaxing freshness checks. If the loader changes, current697 evidence becomes historical for affected outputs; rerender and compare actual pixels, then review every changed family. Fully opaque terrain continuity must also be demonstrated rather than assumed.
-- `hd_full_review` has admitted HUD11 and terrain103b0/c0. It now owns exact frozen terrain103e0–103ef16 and then eight pictureUI frames: corrected10011v2, counters102df/e0, checkboxes1012d/e, indicators1012a/b and question1012c. Those candidates remain frozen; warning holes/spacing and checkbox material need independent judgment.
-- `hd_terrain_render` approved and registered DINO6, projectile EnergyGrab6/EnemyLaser4/Plasma1, and short beam8. It now independently reviews only SHIP35 best-v3 (`candidate-iron-coast-2-v3.json`), with55 source-painted dark losses disclosed. Later v4/v5 proposals are held and do not supersede v3.
-- `iron_coast_2` authorship is frozen; its DINO6 and SHIP40 are registered. It now independently reviews other-artist terrain-set4 first32 (400d5–400f4), with gallery-only400da and material-density limits explicit. Old enemy03 59-family/138-ID and recovered enemy02 45-family/110-ID queues remain frozen.
-- `iron_coast_3` supplied the189-boss peer-approved cohort and UI10010/10012 decisions. It now authors separate source-driven corrections for six boss01 families:10310,200a3,200ba,30044,300a8–ab, and only final400b2 while retaining the first six phases. Its frozen originals remain untouched;200ba source252 remains a distinct alpha-edge hold.
-- `iron_coast_5` independently approved TANK01 four, now registered, and holds four craft families/five frames for source-painted losses. It authors separate200a2 bottom-foot corrections; authentic row39 contains paired side feet with a center gap, so the old shorthand 'short nozzle' must not drive an invented center-barrel extension. v2/v3 still fail bottom extent; a source-only bounded attempt is pending.
-- Boss02/Mole artist evidence stays frozen. Independent boss01 approved65, boss02 approved50 and boss03 approved74 are now registered. Remaining boss holds:10310/200a3/200ba/30044/300a8–ab hull losses;400b2 persistent white plates;30045 wing/backing/struts;200a2 paired bottom feet;300a0 source252 coverage;Mole10352 source253 omission. Mole's separate v4 fixes later loop landmarks but fullfamily remains held. Await root alpha-edge remedy before duplicating palette-only generation.
-- `hd_dark_player` has completed registered equipment47 and HUD11. It owns the frozen UI8 proposals, continues unclaimed small controls and preserves held pointer10128/source-row losses. Corrected SYSTEM DAMAGEDv2 has exact native strokes but still needs independent spacing/material review.
-- `hd_enemies_01` retains original production scope. TANK01 is registered. Frozen craft20099,2009a/b,2009e,200ae remain held for actual high-scale outline/blade/engine/backing losses. TANK02v3 is ready separately with disclosed stationary shading variation. DSHP19 red bands/leg lengths, infantry pose/color, damaged alpha-edge labels and selected contours remain held. APE output-stage refusal is preserved and not automatically retried.
-- `campaign_integration` has registered the completed accepted projectile cohorts. GroundBlast42 remains held despite corrected dark ash phases; other sparse/intermediate paths still need source repair. Flare, person fragments, smoke and short-beam variants with concrete source/material defects remain excluded. Its synthetic actual-Rust alpha-resampling probe is diagnostic evidence, not production approval.
-- `iron_coast_6` independently reviews agricultural set2 families2011d–2013c32. It and its original middle5–36/late37–68 children retain industrial source/material holds. Early joined64 context/state boards distinguish32 registered from32 held and do not infer exhaustive combined approval. Children continue original job IDs with immutable library pins and every changed page reread.
-- Terrain1 keeps103d5/6 bridge-row holds and14-target partial103d0 family; original rejected full-atlas main is not accepted. Terrain2 retains grain-island/support/pipe/water-divider holds despite successful native cache checks. Terrain3 retains overemphasized fragments, faint remnants and invented30361 beams/30362 boundary concerns. Terrain4 retains mixedsoil/vent/material consistency concerns and records unused-first-target native-fixture failures honestly; root owns the fixture remedy.
+- Root owns Windows/Linux binaries, menus, persistence, Lightning API, bundled-runtime assembly and the deferred straight-alpha resampling/source-class alpha-anchor remedy. No renderer/shader/HD loader policy changes occurred in this checkpoint. If a controlled fix changes actual pixels, retain800 as historical and review every changed family before new approval.
+- `hd_full_review` owns frozen terrain103f0–103ff16 independent source/current compositor review. Terrain103e0 and UI8 are now admitted; every classic UI route limit remains explicit.
+- `hd_terrain_render` is absent; its remaining reviewer reservations are released, its accepted/held artwork and proofs preserved. `windows_persistence` independently approved DeathRayPower4v2 and held SHIP35 best-v3 for55 opaque losses including both bottom feet. It also approved buoy10162/63 with the disclosed contour and water-class differences. Actual source center labels are252/253, and palette240–244 is cyan/water; both artist wording corrections retain before-byte history.
+- `iron_coast_2` completed independent next32 set4 approval for400f5–40114, with70contexts/719joins/27states/3,392compositions and an exact isolated64 context pack. Four state partners retain fallback; five unused IDs remain gallery-only. Its old enemy queues and all correction variants remain frozen.
+- `iron_coast_3` continues separate measured boss10310/200a3/300a8–ab source-structural corrections. Old missing hull bridges/tips remain held. Only final400b2 may change within a whole seven-frame sibling; the firstsix bindings/24outputs must stay exact. New central panel/floor texture-pop hold is independently recorded. Approved30044 is admitted;200ba/300a0 palette-alpha remedy remains root-owned.
+- `iron_coast_5` independently approved BUTTON4 and four further enemy singles30065/30068/3006b/3006e. Actual30065 has four ordinary amber/orange cells, not two groups counted as two pixels. Its200a2 paired-foot variants remain held for dark bridge/gap errors despite repaired overall bounds; do not blindly regenerate or stretch the canvas.
+- `iron_coast_6` completed effects12: Power4/Impact4 approved, Smoke4 held for visible enhancement because every actual shaded output equals the NN original mask. Its first four enemy singles30055/3005c/3004c/3004f are approved with exact fine-metal/contour disclosures. It independently approved MediumAir13v5 with explicit outer-edge losses and stronger final yellow shading; the phase11→12 normalized intensity still falls about37%. Children retain original terrain-middle5–36 and late37–68 queues with source/material holds and immutable gallery pins.
+- `terrain_capture_fixture` independently approved classic controls/shop/navigation and Shield4's real patterned shader. It now holds the complete400ac–400b2 correction for a source-stable central vent panel and floor changing material. The native capture fixture now selects a real occurrence after unused first IDs; entirely unused shards disclose no occurrence instead of inventing one.
+- `hd_dark_player` has completed equipment47 and HUD11 plus admitted UI controls. BUTTON4 and buoys remain frozen for later admission. Alternate cursor50019 and repeating texture10019 are reserved to iron_coast_5 for independent review. Historical flag and buoy label corrections are metadata-only with before/after history; no raw pixels change.
+- `hd_enemies_01` retains original production scope, precise source-cell loss evidence and blocked art variants. Its new fine-metal singles are independently reviewed separately. DSHP19 bands/leg lengths, infantry poses, damaged labels and selected contours stay held. APE output-stage refusal is preserved and not automatically retried.
+- `campaign_integration` retains proposed Power/Impact/Shield/DeathRayPower approvals, MediumAir13/SmallGround35 review proposals and GroundBlast/Flare/person/Smoke defects. Actual Canvas::shade ignores smoke mask RGB; a source-faithful decoded mask does not demonstrate visible HD enhancement. Do not compensate for root's diagnosed resampling policy with artist color changes.
+- Terrain1 admits96tiles but keeps bridge103d5/6 row/material holds and14-target partial103d0 complete=false;103f0 is frozen for peer review,10400 standalone production continues. Terrain2 admits48 and retains water/soil islands, post-cap scale, semantic rubble and source-material holds. Terrain3 admits32 while invented30361beams,30362rim/material and denser burn/fragment boundaries stay held. Terrain4 first32 is admitted; independently approved next32 is queued and later industrial compounds retain vent/material/soil limits.
 
-Generation remains gated at four submissions: inspect sources/save prompt, acquire → successful start → built-in request → classify/report/release in one execution before model QA. Unknown started calls are reconciled instead of silently retried. No coordinator generation is active.
+At least75 further independently approved frames remain separate from800 pending coordinator current-pixel comparison, complete source/family inspection and registration. The56-frame planned batch has280 exact accepted reference PPMs and fresh isolated probes; four later enemy singles, two buoy phases and thirteen MediumAir phases have separate peer evidence. No later frames are packaged by this handoff.
 
-Continue exact-hash independent acceptance, current immutable probes, full family inspection and output comparison, then dry-run complete-family registration before mutation. Refresh audit and ledger sequentially after admission. A successful loader or opaque mask alone never approves artwork or finishes the catalog.
+Generation uses four shared submissions: inspect source/save prompt, acquire → successful start → built-in request → classify/report/release in one execution before QA. Unknown cells are reconciled before retry. Every concrete source/art hold remains separate from successful loader/class/cache checks. Continue remaining original catalog without a full-HD completion claim.