Checkpoint 52 later HD approvals and shop icon diagnostic

docs/hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md

@@ -59,7 +59,19 @@ Root authorized a scoped review-tool repair after Cargo retained two incompatibl
 
 Corrected complete10400–1040f candidate `2605e5ce6a4b02bbb6b021796e3d010745acf96c379cc23a4e1f1eab297bdaec` is now independently approved by report `7fe17ddcc8e71f75d112f3940b054d9de3091fb4fb9ede7cb198a1be2d57eae2`. Genuine organic10406 resolves the former rectangular-panel hold; fifteen accepted siblings remain exact. All2,380 context cases and4,840 PPMs are bound, with18 changed physical contexts reviewed at all scales. Its636 proof honestly records the later desktop source-age flag as true. This family and approved SHIP25 remain outside the already frozen1,148 handoff pending a later coordinator batch. The historical10406 whole-family hold remains intact.
 
-Flare26v10 remains wholly held at exact candidate `0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3`, report `448d1e14825d5ade5d33a10fbc631c083bbd4dcd19facbacd11ddb3ad31fd2c8`. The corrected10258/66 source holes are clear, but10266 pale pinpoints and1026a/b hotter tails change the source material and late fade. Only those three genuine sibling corrections are reserved; other23 bindings and the whole history remain fixed. Sparkle17v11 is independently approved at candidate `2ba86de91a31034a187bc61adc8f7f3d757f14e0f4e2f9d0f52a3910fdf48d96`, report `c2cafad57d5fbe3e079c8d5aeadd4a4f4073d2a88a943660f5ea6ed1af8ab36e`. Its authentic holes, dark rim and bright tips are restored, with exact isolated corner losses, stronger grain and shade variation explicitly accepted. All85 current PPMs match frozen owner output; other11 bindings/55 outputs remain unchanged. Neither family is registered or included in the frozen1,148 runtime. IOTARG14 is the next exclusive hd_full_review reservation.
+Flare26v10 remains wholly held at exact candidate `0b9c6e789bd275336a59d38005dfb1d66ed6aaa64172c7f384e2767d0d959fd3`, report `448d1e14825d5ade5d33a10fbc631c083bbd4dcd19facbacd11ddb3ad31fd2c8`. The corrected10258/66 source holes are clear, but10266 pale pinpoints and1026a/b hotter tails change the source material and late fade. Only those three genuine sibling corrections are reserved; other23 bindings and the whole history remain fixed. Sparkle17v11 is independently approved at candidate `2ba86de91a31034a187bc61adc8f7f3d757f14e0f4e2f9d0f52a3910fdf48d96`, report `c2cafad57d5fbe3e079c8d5aeadd4a4f4073d2a88a943660f5ea6ed1af8ab36e`. Its authentic holes, dark rim and bright tips are restored, with exact isolated corner losses, stronger grain and shade variation explicitly accepted. All85 current PPMs match frozen owner output; other11 bindings/55 outputs remain unchanged. Neither family is registered or included in the frozen1,148 runtime. IOTARG14 and the four damaged-craft singles have subsequently closed independent review; the next exclusive hd_full_review scope is terrain10420–1042f.
+
+## Later approved artwork outside the release input
+
+The immutable later-approved-52-ready.json journal, SHA `9513c48f9df2555fd246c021ee6eb1faec71c6945d3c4ed15986e14ec84dbec0`, binds **52 frames in eight complete jobs**: SHIP25/1, corrected10400/16, Sparkle17, IOTARG14 and four damaged-craft singles20099/200ae/200b1/200b4. Independent artistic approvals, complete coordinator source/native1/HD4 inspection and exact accepted-output continuity are recorded for each cohort. All260 original/scaled PPMs match their independent accepted references. These frames remain unregistered and outside the immutable1,148 runtime input; possible future1,200 registration and combined proof have not been performed.
+
+IOTARG14 report `ad3b5618793ba5f8833eee9fb763ee0a85bc9e8b5bc19f9323f419505745bbad` accepts authentic shutter heights/order, eight perimeter anchors, the dark cavity/dome and centered six-cell amber footprint in all eight fully-open phases. Darker soil, slight fixed-body shade/grain variance and high-scale color-threshold changes remain explicit. The four-single report `58cdd6213bbb248cd605149828ba9695ee6f4aec0c5e35504ea91e803871de15` accepts source damaged architecture and genuine252/253 lamps with no added dynamic cells. 20099's five native outline losses return at2–4; limited ordinary4x edge partials remain disclosed in all four exact candidates. No paired-damage or live assembled-object claim is inferred.
+
+Each cohort retains its actual invocation source epoch and library. The four singles' fresh default release `da05d6104a484ef9129f755c9c90bb896696d0d2fdbd409314a6392cc992df43`, origin libraptor_replica-f076ad67c588e355.rlib, has both age guards false at invocation and20 exact PPM matches. Their earlier1a6 attempt with broad-age true remains separate. Subsequent root desktop test-module additions make earlier proofs historical again; no old guard is relabeled and no blanket current-source claim is made across these cohorts.
+
+The complete23 shop-icon family remains a frozen diagnostic under correction, not an admission candidate. Coordinator report `f7ffaf5bb08fb91a173b5b03150db7934ecb2a8301577ecedb1ad11a65dd1184` binds115 current original/scaled PPMs identical to the author, all four complete five-scale pages and the full untouched monitor raw. Its actual indexed proof uses library38af886709b5a18061385ae39a8995a87de72f575267fbd3b9e15960b39155f6 and compiler-compatible serde, with both source-age guards false at invocation. Source monitor102f7 row23 contains six separate occupied RGB4 tips at x2/4/9/12/17/19; current art replaces them with two broad metal bars, adding13 fully opaque logical cells at every scale. The occupied x12/y20–23 dark mounting strip is wholly missing at every scale. A genuine local lower-region correction must restore those tips, gaps and strip while preserving the existing screen/body; global crop/shift or dark-color compensation is not a remedy. Other22 full raw material judgments remain pending.
+
+Read-only completion of original Set4 job31's previously uninspected24 contexts/86 pairs/four historical Host captures is preserved in .reference/hd-coordinator-set4-job31-page-completion/completion-review.json, SHA `f0d9ac0b8ba9f7145caff675b0cf588694687e04d5d15bcfcf22ce0e09100613`. All pages were viewed on unresampled boards, and80 fresh sprite PPMs equal the author's historical output. Soil-density squares, smoother crater rims and stronger relief remain pending independent material judgment. There is no new Host/composer replay, job32 approval or registration.
 
 ## Private development1,037 input
 
@@ -85,17 +97,17 @@ The terrain-set3 children continue their original HD queues directly. HD artists
 
 Coordinator alone registers external development art and refreshes audit/ledger. Queue offsets change after admission; use original durable job IDs. Artists never approve/register their own artwork. Commit only owned paths; docs/hd-full-review.md remains reviewer-owned. Root alone assembles tracked runtime and controls future loader/alpha/shader/encoder policy. No such production policy changed during1037 closure.
 
-- hd_full_review preserved terrain10400's historical whole-family hold and then approved the complete genuine organic10406 sibling; that16-frame family and separately approved SHIP25 remain pending coordinator admission outside1,148. It closed Flare26v10 with a three-frame material/fade hold and approved complete Sparkle17v11, which also remains outside1,148. Its next exclusive reservation is IOTARG14 while the other seven reviewers serve Stage2.
+- hd_full_review preserved terrain10400's historical whole-family hold and then approved the complete genuine organic10406 sibling. SHIP25, corrected10400, Sparkle17v11, IOTARG14 and four damaged-craft singles now form the52-frame prepared later cohort outside1,148. Flare26v10 retains its three-frame material/fade hold. Its active exclusive reservation is terrain10420–1042f while the other seven reviewers serve Stage2.
 - iron_coast_2 closed and checkpointed independently accepted original Set4 jobs1–12/192frames; no further HD review reservation during its Stage2 mission/boss work. Lower40179/7a is now admitted in the target scope, with prior context-only limits preserved.
 - iron_coast_5 closed Terrain3 shards3/4: four30112/13/19/1a gray-remnant holds in shard3, all16 accepted shard4. It now serves Stage2; no active HD review reservation.
 - windows_persistence closed complete LargeAirv11 approval and STAG0240088 approval. Earlier LargeAirv6/v9, SHIP35 and4006e holds remain exact. Its new Stage2 weapon work is separate from original-catalog HD evidence.
 - terrain_capture_fixture closed all16 terrain10410 frames and verified historical job status/count-only lineage against retained per-frame copies. It now serves Stage2 enemy packages; source/class/shader/scene evidence never implies blanket encounter or liveHost approval.
 - iron_coast_3 preserves admitted10310v4/200a3v4/400acv3 and every failed variant. Its Sparkle17v8 whole hold is complete; no new HD reservation during Stage2. Atlas300a8–abv6 remains held;300a0/200ba alpha-class policy stays root-owned.
 - iron_coast_6 closed the Flare26v8 whole hold, then switched to Stage2. Children continue original middle5–36 and late37–68 HD queues directly under coordinator oversight. Old exact galleries remain pinned; stronger soil/gray/char relief and fallback rectangles remain unapproved.
-- campaign_release_review checkpointed first30 complete Set4 families/480 author-reviewed IDs before Stage2 music work. Job31 has full art and technical proof but uninspected contexts/cardinal/live pages; job32 has only five cross-job crater-quarter proposals. No complete32 or later approval is inferred.
+- campaign_release_review checkpointed first30 complete Set4 families/480 author-reviewed IDs before Stage2 music work. Coordinator has since inspected job31's pending contexts/cardinal/historical live pages without granting artistic approval; job32 still has only five cross-job crater-quarter proposals. No complete32 or later approval is inferred.
 - campaign_integration retains admitted effects and frozen LargeAirv11; Sparkle17v11 is independently approved but unregistered; only Flare10266/1026a/1026b are reserved for further genuine correction after the v10 material/fade hold. Ground gold/alpha, smoke visible-enhancement and other holds remain explicit; no RGB compensation for loader artifacts.
-- hd_enemies_01 retains admitted tanks/singles/STAG02. SHIP25 independent approval is pending coordinator admission; multipart IOTARG/DMOON,4006e warm center, damaged craft/cues and APE refusal stay held. Every failed genuine correction remains preserved.
-- hd_dark_player continues complete23-icon102e1–102f7 production; partial diagnostics are not coverage. HANGP's opaque encoder rounding remains a separate root policy hold. Classic-menu route claims are not inferred through custom Rust menus.
+- hd_enemies_01 retains admitted tanks/singles/STAG02. SHIP25, IOTARG14 and four damaged-craft singles are independently approved and prepared for later admission. Explicit200e4/200e7/200ea candidate-v2-final siblings are frozen awaiting review, without replacing heldv1 mains. DMOON,4006e warm center, other damaged craft/cues and APE refusal stay held. Every failed genuine correction remains preserved.
+- hd_dark_player preserves the complete23-icon102e1–102f7 diagnostic and its confirmed monitor lower-boundary hold; all23 rasters have been viewed, without whole-family raw artwork approval or coverage. HANGP's opaque encoder rounding remains a separate root policy hold. Classic-menu route claims are not inferred through custom Rust menus.
 - Terrain1 has128 registered tiles, Terrain2 has48, Terrain3 has48 and Terrain4 has192. Other completed/partial proposals remain independently held or awaiting exact review. Terrain2's unequal panels/coarse mosaic/foreign rules and Terrain1's bridge row/gap/material issues remain unadmitted.
 
 The original catalog remains incomplete. Continue source-driven production and independent review, then perform exact current output continuity, complete family coordinator inspection and registration for each later batch. No later candidate is packaged or admitted merely because it decodes.