Checkpoint 1,037 independently reviewed development HD frames

docs/hd-coordinator-checkpoint.md

@@ -1,58 +1,63 @@
 # HD coordinator checkpoint — 11 October 2026
 
-The reviewed external development pack contains **929 original picture frames in 377 complete sequences**. The committed Linux and Windows playable snapshots remain at **800 frames / 340 sequences**, assembled at `964ba93` from the separate immutable 800-frame handoff. Root owns runtime data, binaries, libraries and archives; coordinator owns external development registration and this metadata. Original references, prompts and review jobs remain external under `../data/`. Bundled originals and approved runtime art are tracked under this repository's `data/`.
+The reviewed external development pack contains **1,037 original picture frames in 396 complete sequences**. The committed Linux and Windows playable snapshots remain **800 frames / 340 sequences**, assembled at `964ba93` from the immutable 800-frame handoff. Root owns runtime data, binaries, libraries and archives; coordinator owns external development registration and this metadata. Bundled originals and approved runtime art are tracked under this repository's data/. Working originals, prompts, job candidates and review evidence remain external under ../data/.
 
 ## Verified development coverage
 
 | Category | Registered / original pictures |
 | --- | ---: |
 | Player banking | 21 / 21 |
-| Bosses | 223 / 249 |
-| Enemies and ground objects | 129 / 419 |
+| Bosses | 232 / 249 |
+| Enemies and ground objects | 148 / 419 |
 | Player and enemy projectiles | 45 / 51 |
-| Explosions and effects | 155 / 281 |
+| Explosions and effects | 164 / 281 |
 | Equipment and pickups | 47 / 47 |
-| Terrain | 256 / 4,535 |
-| Menus, portraits, HUD and other pictures | 53 / 150 |
-| Total | 929 / 5,753 |
+| Terrain | 320 / 4,535 |
+| Menus, portraits, HUD and other pictures | 60 / 150 |
+| Total | 1,037 / 5,753 |
 
-All 6,449 catalog entries and 5,753 pictures were audited, with zero HD source/hash/canvas/ID errors. **4,824 pictures still await registration**. The current ledger contains 909 registered, 20 render-reachable, 1,589 candidate, 1,100 in-progress and 2,135 missing pictures. Candidate status establishes neither approval nor a live scene occurrence. Unused and damaged IDs remain required. The 303 AGX delta frames and four bitmap fonts retain classic-art preservation policies and are separate from generated HD coverage.
+All 6,449 catalog entries and 5,753 pictures were audited with zero HD source/hash/canvas/ID errors. **4,716 pictures still await registration**. The current ledger contains 1,017 registered, 20 render-reachable, 1,657 candidate, 1,084 in-progress and 1,975 missing pictures. Candidate status establishes neither artistic approval nor a live occurrence. Unused and damaged IDs remain required. The 303 AGX delta frames and four bitmap fonts retain their separate classic-art preservation policies.
 
-## Current exact proof
+## Current immutable output proof
 
-`../data/hd/registered-class-review/runtime-929-current/combined-review.json` closes **3,716 actual scale outputs / 4,645 original and scaled PPMs**, all byte-identical to independently accepted references. Both source-age guards are false; diagnostics are empty. The exact immutable library is `target/hd-review-libraries/0ec6137e0e3261e813b2b863cd96c04da55e07cdf29b5c10b1d112e20f0a3daf/libraptor_replica-79676ac8bb9ed60d.rlib`, SHA `0ec6137e0e3261e813b2b863cd96c04da55e07cdf29b5c10b1d112e20f0a3daf`, original build time `1791703254797483881`. The current development `hd.json` SHA is `35897119671889de4391cc0471979338071a3b954cb7f7fbabda1c808f66808a`. Registration checks the library's exact bytes and original build age.
+../data/hd/registered-class-review/runtime-1037-current/combined-review.json closes **4,148 actual scale outputs / 5,185 original and scaled PPMs**, all byte-identical to independently accepted references. Both source-age guards are false; diagnostics are empty. The exact immutable release library is `target/hd-review-libraries/0ec6137e0e3261e813b2b863cd96c04da55e07cdf29b5c10b1d112e20f0a3daf/libraptor_replica-79676ac8bb9ed60d.rlib`, SHA `0ec6137e0e3261e813b2b863cd96c04da55e07cdf29b5c10b1d112e20f0a3daf`, original build time `1791703254797483881`. The current development hd.json SHA is `707ab815114579828bcb823cc3e62efa80ea05b54ae83e83dc30c5730cde0e96`. Combined review SHA is `1a9ef32f37cc2074608d6c9ad65e1387751e912e87d7fc5cd6ffb844f31f246a`. Registration verifies exact library bytes and original build age.
 
-All 846 ordinary source pictures introduce no reserved 240–255 labels. 80 source-class pictures retain authentic gameplay palette classes. Three opening cards use their original static 256-color palettes. Sprite/class checks are scoped to exact source/native rendering and do not infer a whole mission, custom-menu route, complete assembled boss or new destroyed partner.
+All 952 ordinary source pictures introduce no reserved240–255 labels. 82 source-class pictures retain authentic gameplay classes; three opening cards use their original static256-color palettes. Exact native/source loading does not establish whole-mission completion, custom-menu reachability, complete assembled-boss joins or new destroyed artwork.
 
-The admission journal `batch-929-approval.json` binds **129 additional frames / 22 complete families**, every candidate and peer report, all 645 accepted PPM matches and all 42 complete source/native1/HD4 pages inspected on eight unresampled boards. Families include Set4 structures 400f5–40114, terrain103f0–103ff, Power/Impact/Shield/DeathRayPower, MediumAir 13, SmallGround 35, BUTTON 4, buoy 2, cursor 50019, repeating texture 10019, eight fine-metal craft and EAGLE 30073. Exact material/contour caveats remain in peer and coordinator records. No sibling promotion was needed in this batch.
+After the historical929 checkpoint, batch-979-approval.json adds **50 frames / eight complete families**, with250 exact accepted PPMs and15 complete coordinator-inspected source/native1/HD4 pages on four boards. The batch contains radar40115–40134/32, four tread/slat/fork families15, TEXTURE10018 and side trims50005/50006. batch-1037-approval.json adds **58 frames / eleven complete families**, with290 exact accepted PPMs and20 complete inspected pages on six boards: Orange9, difficulty4, craft3008f/92/95/98, ground40135–40154/32, restored10310/200a3 and complete400ac–400b2/7. Every candidate, binding, source, peer evidence, raw and current output is bound. The former held boss mains are SHA-named snapshots before exact sibling-byte promotion; all rejected versions remain unchanged.
 
-Set4 next32 has 70 native contexts / 719 joins / 27 states and 3,392 actual composition checks. Its isolated 64 pack includes 21 unique both-HD damage pairs and four original fallback partners. Terrain 103f0 has 442 pairs / 48 real scenes, 1,960 cases / all 83 boards and no state partners. MediumAir's final local yellow lift is accepted with complete fade intensity falling 37%; tiny peripheral painted-cell losses stay disclosed. SmallGround's first four cell-edge outlines remain warm particle material, with exact warm/brown losses and two adjacent tail additions accepted. Shield has actual patterned shader proof, transparent world centers and occupied-RGB invariance; it adds no foreground paint or live timing assertion. Buoys use cyan/water 240–244 plus blink 252/253, with exact native centers and accepted higher-scale contour differences.
+The radar's nine-cell native object, mast, controls and252 lamp remain source-aligned. Its70 contexts/709 pairs/17 states produce3,316 current compositions; nine radar damage partners stay original fallback. The next two ground shards preserve source crack branches, rock positions and shallow divots through36 contexts/121 pairs and756 compositions; twelve unused IDs remain gallery-only and there are no state partners. Fine soil density/contrast remains visible against original fallback.
 
-## Frozen packaged800 history
+Tank phases, forks and stationary architecture retain source identity with exact3–4x occupied-source coverage. Quantified minor shading variance and lower-scale contour smoothing are accepted. New30098 has one missing nativeRGB4 post corner, restored2–4, with both252/253 labels exactly1/4/9/16. Difficulty portraits retain defining faces and framing; warmer painting and the helmet's central pale mark interpreted as a restrained shallow tab with dark underside are accepted, not described as unchanged hardware. Texture repeats preserve connector and slot topology, while stronger edge contrast and burgundy threshold sensitivity remain explicit.
 
-The historical full800 proof remains untouched at `runtime-800-current/combined-review.json`, with 3,200 scales / 4,000 accepted PPMs and immutable library `f71826f4eec106d59a55c12380ee1437a3cfeddf6f9d145480624ff5e5b8eaa5`. Root's later test-only native capture fixes did not alter the production renderer, loader, compositor or shaders. The historical proof is not retroactively associated with a newer library.
+Boss10310 preserves the right disc, skirt and feet, accepting two RGB4 corners plus isolated gray rim(60,46) lost4x. Boss200a3's y35 bridges and central dark structure are restored allscales, with17 outer contour losses2–4 and small right expansion accepted. EBOSS6 retains the final two pale plates and stationary horizontal central grille/crossed lower floor; the firstsix bindings/24 outputs remain exact. Final grain/pitch/frame-width differences are accepted, not byte-stationary. These are complete-family gallery decisions with no whole-boss live assembly claim.
 
-The private handoff is `../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-800-20261011/pack/`, manifest SHA `fbf8b6a9af134e263881ce28f002259affbf0636f53d214ea34bbd8c61205f71`. `handoff-manifest.json` SHA `29821d06c34114101041e50318c5c013a9236e474716a382257d6d252c304b1e` binds all 292 pack-file hashes (290 artwork files plus manifest/provenance), source INDEX and limits. Root copied and independently verified every file into tracked runtime data: 6,742 files / 461,771,350 bytes. Linux and Windows packages, relocated launchers, catalog, HD, all 22 mods and actual SDL/audio checks passed. Later 129 development registrations do not change this frozen packaged snapshot.
+Orange9 retains warm ray/fragment/fade character despite stronger4x cell-edge outlines and small adjacent additions. Three alpha16/17/19 exterior specks in101a8 are excluded, while meaningful alpha32 contour pixels are retained. Original alpha, source masks and raw RGB evidence stay distinct. Smoke4 remains held because every actual shaded output equals original nearest-neighbor output, so no visible HD improvement is established.
 
-Earlier admission journals and sibling promotion histories remain intact, including DINO 6, SHIP 40 and corrected 30044. All old held mains/raws and prepared-but-unsubmitted SHIP 40v5 remain preserved. Metadata-only transparent-background corrections keep actual attempts, request/prompt authority, SHA-named old bytes and unchanged raw/candidate bindings. Cursor's missing historical request JSON remains explicit; no retrospective record was invented. Buoy center and cyan/water wording corrections similarly retain before-byte histories. BUTTON's separate four-flag correction was independently verified before admission.
+## Frozen Linux/Windows800 history
 
-## Durable owners and later work
+The separate historical runtime-800-current/combined-review.json remains unchanged:3,200 scales/4,000 accepted PPMs using immutablef71826f4eec106d59a55c12380ee1437a3cfeddf6f9d145480624ff5e5b8eaa5. Historical929 and979 closures remain separate and are not retroactively associated with a newer library. Root's later test-only terrain capture fixes did not alter the production desktop prefix, loader, compositor or shaders.
 
-Coordinator alone edits external development manifest/provenance/audit/ledger. Queue refresh removes registered jobs, so all owners and reviewers follow original durable job IDs rather than live offsets. Artists never register their own work. Git checkpoints stage only owned paths; `docs/hd-full-review.md` belongs to its reviewer.
+The private immutable handoff is ../data/hd/registered-class-review/handoff-800-20261011/pack/, pack manifest SHA `fbf8b6a9af134e263881ce28f002259affbf0636f53d214ea34bbd8c61205f71`. handoff-manifest.json SHA `29821d06c34114101041e50318c5c013a9236e474716a382257d6d252c304b1e` binds292 pack files:290 artwork files plus hd.json/provenance.json. Root copied and verified all into tracked data:6,742 files/461,771,350 bytes. Later237 development approvals are not included in that runtime snapshot.
 
-- Root owns runtime assembly/platform code and deferred straight-alpha resampling, source-class alpha-anchor and encoder-rounding policy. No such loader policy changed during 929 closure. Any future actual-pixel change requires a new controlled comparison, preserving 800 / 929 history. HANGP 1010b (1619×971) remains held by strict aspect policy; no clipping, stretching or artist color compensation.
-- `hd_full_review` approved four later tank families / 15 frames, still awaiting coordinator fresh closure. It exclusively reviews terrain 10400–1040f (16 frames) with 531 pairs / 46 real scenes and original damaged partners retained as fallback. Its scoped own-doc commit is `c386550`.
-- `iron_coast_2` independently approved radar jobs 40115–40134 (32 frames), with exact 9-cell radar/native 252 lamp proof. It now reviews ORIGINAL jobs 7/8, 40135–40154. Nine radar damaged partners retain original fallback; no whole-map or new liveHost claim.
-- `iron_coast_5` approved TEXTURE 10018 and side textures 50005/50006, still separate from929. Repeated contexts/connectors and exact seam crops were inspected; stronger highlights and burgundy threshold sensitivity are accepted disclosures. It now exclusively reviews difficulty portraits 1001a–1001d (4 frames).
-- `windows_persistence` held LargeAir 12 v6 for authentic painted ray/arc and fading-ring cells absent at all/higher scales. The48-in-64 original viewport/alpha32 retention passes technically. SHIP35 v3 remains held for 55 occupied losses and both bottom feet. It now reviews new enemy singles 3008f/30092/30095/30098.
-- `terrain_capture_fixture` exclusively reviews iron3's 10310 v4,200a3 v4 and seven-frame 400ac v3 siblings / 9 frames. The former right-disc/skirt, lower bridge and stationary grille/floor holds require different-peer art judgment. Its source-unchanged rounding proposal is future-scoped. Native destroyed/unused fixture fixes have exact selected-source proof and add no blanket artwork approval.
-- `iron_coast_3` preserves those three frozen siblings and every failed variant. Atlas 300a8–ab v6 remains held for painted side-strip loss and partial source-class coverage. Approved 30044 stays frozen; 300a0 / 200ba palette-alpha remedies remain root-owned.
-- `iron_coast_6` independently approved MediumAir 13/SmallGround 35 and the admitted enemy singles. It now exclusively reviews OrangeSparks 9 v3. Terrain children retain original middle 5–36 and late 37–68 scopes; numerous full proposals have geometry/material/fallback holds and exact immutable galleries, not automatic coverage.
-- `hd_dark_player` continues original UI scope, preserving admitted files. Difficulty 4 and side 2 are frozen for peer review/closure. Original HANGP rounding hold remains untouched; no specific classic-control reachability through custom Rust menus is inferred.
-- `hd_enemies_01` continues original disjoint production, preserving admitted nine craft singles and later approved tank 15. Source-cell/phase/cue holds remain explicit for damaged craft, troop poses and earlier outlines. APE refusal evidence is preserved without automatic retry.
-- `campaign_integration` continues disjoint source-driven effects. Orange 9 is reserved to iron6. LargeAir corrections must be separate siblings bound to exact missing painted cells; accepted/held raws and viewport history stay frozen. Smoke 4 has no demonstrated visible HD enhancement because actual shade outputs equal original nearest-neighbor outputs. Ground gold/alpha holds, Flare source-hole/material and remaining geometry failures stay held.
-- Terrain1 registered 112 tiles; 10400 peer review and bridge 103d5/6 row/material holds remain separate. Its14-target partial family stays complete=false. Terrain2 registered 48 and retains post-array footprint, water/soil density and coarse-mosaic/semantic holds. Terrain3 registered 32; invented beams, rim/material and burn-grain transitions remain held. Terrain4 registered 64; radar32 is independently approved later, while industrial compound material and mixed-fallback grain limits remain disclosed.
+Native Windows third CI38121272504 passed279 tests/0failed/24ignored, exact committedGNU launcher/gameplay/full800/all22mods and a freshMSVC build. Linux/Windows relocated launch, catalog, SDL and audio checks passed. Root documentation proof is fb6574a. Final Windows archive SHA25fca23c5ca95b754cf49fcf24b07d94dec8094863e6750c1898a55d6893cbfe,602433522bytes; Linux SHA0f384c3592a1a6d9302c16769cd8aafb096464fe17150ea1a66b34743fbdc97a. Both archiveCRC/data/runtime/source/doc checks passed. No further packaged art changes are authorized by this development metadata checkpoint.
 
-At least 50 further independently approved frames remain separate from 929: radar 32, tank 15, TEXTURE 10018 and side 2. Every later admission still requires current exact references, coordinator complete family inspection and registration. No later files are packaged by this checkpoint.
+Metadata-only provenance corrections preserve before-byte snapshots and exact actual attempt/request/prompt authority. All raw/candidate/source/render bindings stay unchanged. Cursor's absent historical request JSON remains disclosed; no retrospective request history was invented. Buoy center252/253 and cyan/water240–244 wording corrections likewise retain prior bytes. BUTTON's four corrected transparency flags were independently verified.
 
-Generation uses four shared submissions with inspected source/saved prompts, acquire→successful start→built-in await→classify/report/release in one execution before QA. Unknown cells are reconciled before retries. Continue remaining original catalog without a full-HD completion claim.
+## Durable owners and outstanding holds
+
+Coordinator alone registers external development art and refreshes audit/ledger. Queue offsets change after admission; use original durable job IDs. Artists never approve/register their own artwork. Commit only owned paths; docs/hd-full-review.md remains reviewer-owned. Root alone assembles tracked runtime and controls future loader/alpha/shader/encoder policy. No such production policy changed during1037 closure.
+
+- hd_full_review exclusively reviews terrain10400–1040f. Its current10406 organic-ground-as-rectangular-slabs material hold is concrete; no complete16 approval. Other current contexts are still under full inspection. Raw/candidate remain frozen until the review completes.
+- iron_coast_2 has independently approved original Set4 jobs1–8/128frames and now reviews original jobs9/10,40155–40174. Additional lower foliage cells40179/7a may appear only in a separately pinned complete-object diagnostic, without admission; the160 reviewed pack retains original fallback there.
+- iron_coast_5 now independently reviews iron6's original Terrain3 shards3/4,3010d–3012c/32. Earlier joined64 state diagnostics complement individual exhaustive proof without certifying complete combined seams. Specific gray-remnant/bright-rubble material concerns require artistic judgment.
+- windows_persistence holds exact LargeAirv9 for unchanged101eb's connected seven-cell inner lip and101ec's five-cell upper shoulder, with30/14 whole cells absent4x. The newly repairedfirst2/late2 phases are improved/accepted with minor edge caveats, but do not override the full-family hold. Its new exclusive singles are300ac/3009d/4006e, especially opaque internal gray/warm-center fidelity.
+- terrain_capture_fixture completed the nine-frame boss sibling decisions and root's read-only rounding investigation. Its source-class/shader/scene probes do not imply blanket art or live encounter approval.
+- iron_coast_3 preserves accepted10310v4/200a3v4/400acv3 plus every failed version. Atlas300a8–abv6 remains held for connected painted side-strip loss and partial source-class coverage.300a0/200ba palette-alpha issues stay root-owned.
+- iron_coast_6's effects and independent enemy decisions remain bound. Its authored Terrain3 early shards3/4 stay frozen for another reviewer. Children retain original middle5–36 and late37–68 production: large held cohorts have current exact galleries, while physical soil grain, gray/char relief, invented beams/rims and mixed-fallback material concerns remain unapproved.
+- campaign_integration preserves admitted Orange9 and earlier complete effects. Separate genuine LargeAir corrections may target only101eb/101ec's exact lost connected structures, retaining the other ten bindings. Flare holes/material, Ground gold/alpha and other contour holds remain explicit; no artist color compensation for loader behavior.
+- hd_enemies_01 preserves admitted tanks and singles;300ac/3009d/4006e are frozen for exclusive review,40088 separately unassigned. Multipart IOTARG/DMOON production remains author-only. Damaged craft backing/cues, troop poses and APE refusal remain held.
+- hd_dark_player continues the complete23-icon family102e1–102f7; partial single-icon probes are not coverage. HANGP1010b opaque1619x971 remains held by exact-aspect policy pending a separate controlled root decision. No classic-menu route is inferred through current custom Rust menus.
+- Terrain1 has112 registered tiles;10400 review,10410 partial production and bridge103d5/6 row/gap/material holds are separate. Terrain2 has48 registered and many complete proposals with post-array/cap/gray machinery, water/ground density and coarse-grid holds. Its202fd–2030c unequal-panel retry stays unbound rather than distorted. Terrain3 has32 registered. Terrain4 has128 registered; later industrial compound/fallback-grain limits remain disclosed.
+
+The original catalog remains incomplete. Continue source-driven production and independent review, then perform exact current output continuity, complete family coordinator inspection and registration for each later batch. No later candidate is packaged or admitted merely because it decodes.