Keep HD review stages current and record enemy queue recovery

RustRaptor/tools/hd_job_queue.py

@@ -186,8 +186,8 @@ def contract(family):
         "ownership": "Only this job's target IDs may be proposed. Neighbor/context references and exact-source aliases are reference-only; never claim or overwrite another job's IDs.",
         "raw_output": "Keep raw generated PNG bytes, prompts, source references and provenance. Do not retouch generated RGB/alpha. Atlas/square margin crops are allowed only if they preserve all meaningful visible pixels and original aspect.",
         "full_family": "Review all frames together at logical resolution and indexed 4× with exact Rust Lanczos3 resident→presentation resampling. A good still does not complete an animation family. Record partial candidates and rejections truthfully.",
-        "quality": "Check clipping, alpha halos, banking/animation centers, source bounds, pivots, tiny-projectile readability, palette fades/cycling, material continuity and intended timing. Original ordinary pixels must not gain indices240..255; water/fire/individualblink source classes retain their semantics. Compare original and allscale dynamic-palette counts in runtime-qa.json. Numeric mask metrics support visual review, never replace it.",
-        "terrain": "Use supplied 3×3 neighboring context, all cardinal adjacency sets, repeated tile aliases and intact/destroyed state partners. Preserve coastline/topography crossings, native edge colors and exact reusable tile identity. Review every required adjacent pair, including state changes; full opaque 32×32 terrain canvases are valid. Do not publish context-specific alternate art for one repeated ID. The validated renderer shares adjoining HD edge/corner colors only where original surface class/geometry agrees, and transitions HD/original boundaries towards the joined original layer over two logical pixels; see RustRaptor/docs/hd-terrain.md. Feathering cannot repair shifted coastlines or make a low-resolution grid acceptable; detailed interiors must remain newly authored HD art. Preserve source water indices 240..244, fire 245..249 and single-index glow/flash 250..255; ordinary terrain maps to 0..239." if terrain else None,
+        "quality": "Check clipping, alpha halos, banking/animation centers, source bounds, pivots, tiny-projectile readability, palette fades/cycling, material continuity and intended timing. Near-black original body/backing pixels are occupied artwork, not empty background. For opaque pictures, mask overlap of 1 proves only coverage; compare source material, landmarks and internal geometry separately. Original ordinary pixels must not gain indices240..255; water/fire/individualblink source classes retain their semantics. Compare original and allscale dynamic-palette counts in runtime-qa.json. Numeric mask metrics support visual review, never replace it.",
+        "terrain": "Generate each canonical tile from its own exact source; supplied 3×3 neighbors are separate continuity-review references, not scenery to copy into the target. Check all cardinal adjacency sets, repeated tile aliases and intact/destroyed state partners. Preserve coastline/topography crossings, native edge colors and exact reusable tile identity. Equal-grid atlas crops must preserve each tile's complete logical composition; reject displaced panel boundaries or foreign row strips. Review every required adjacent pair, including state changes; full opaque 32×32 terrain canvases are valid. Do not publish context-specific alternate art for one repeated ID. The validated renderer shares adjoining HD edge/corner colors only where original surface class/geometry agrees, and transitions HD/original boundaries towards the joined original layer over two logical pixels; see RustRaptor/docs/hd-terrain.md. Feathering cannot repair shifted coastlines or make a low-resolution grid acceptable; detailed interiors must remain newly authored HD art. Preserve source water indices 240..244, fire 245..249 and single-index glow/flash 250..255; ordinary terrain maps to 0..239." if terrain else None,
         "renderer": "Registration is separate from render reachability. Require a verified Rust rendering path and record scene/gallery evidence; unsupported terrain/mask/shader semantics remain explicitly pending.",
         "result": "Write candidate.json with job_id, source_sha256 and every proposed target's file/logical dimensions/origin/crop, plus complete sequence metadata and review evidence. Only the coordinator edits global hd.json, completion ledger or provenance.",
     }
@@ -277,10 +277,9 @@ def build(args):
             status = "registered" if source["hd"] else "inprogress" if owner else "missing"
             if not source["hd"] and identity in candidates:
                 status = "candidate"
+                # An old ledger stage cannot override a new hold or lost approval.
                 if coordinator_review and coordinator_review.get("status") == "approved":
                     status = "reviewed"
-                if prior.get("status") == "reviewed" and prior.get("candidate", {}).get("sha256") == candidate_digest:
-                    status = "reviewed"
             renderer = prior.get("renderer", {"availability": "unverified", "evidence": []})
             if source["category"] == "Terrain" and renderer["availability"] in ["unverified", "pipeline_pending"]:
                 if report["terrain"]["runtime_hd_composition_supported"]: